Poets & Writers

Practice Imagining Change

IOPEN the creative writing courses I teach with this vow: “I’ve seen far too many workshops become an indoctrination into an instructor’s taste—a semester-long exhortation to love what the instructor loves and to hate what he does too—and I am going to do my best to avoid that.” The statement is meant to protect students from the shame I felt when, in the first semester of an MFA program in fiction, I listened as the director mocked a writer whose books my parents, my sister, and I all loved.

I absorbed the verdict as truth even though the disdain felt like snobbery: I would never tell someone they were wrong to love what they loved. It wasn’t that I wanted to please my professor—I’d already voiced my dissatisfactions with his course. What I wanted was to master the social mores of a culture that, in some unconscious and unexamined sense, I’d entered the MFA program to join: the culture of the tastemaking class.

It wasn’t despite but because of the shame I experienced that the first creative writing courses I taught reproduced the canon of that program almost exactly. I wanted to shield my students from the embarrassing ignorance I’d discovered in myself; I thought they should know what “good taste” entailed. A pedagogy course had introduced me to the problem of education as acculturation—a means of assimilating students into the dominant culture of a powerful class—but I discussed acculturation only with students in my composition courses, not in my creative writing workshops. I wasn’t yet paying attention to the connection between the problematic constructs of “bad grammar” and “bad taste.” I was still a student of “good taste” myself.

I’ve seen far too many workshops become an indoctrination into an instructor’s taste—a semester-long exhortation to love what the instructor loves and to hate what he does too—and I am going to do my best to avoid that.

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Poets & Writers

Poets & Writers17 min read
Recent Winners
Karisma Price of New Orleans won the 2023 Stanley Kunitz Memorial Prize for “The Art of London Firearms.” She received $1,000, and her poem was published in the September/October 2023 issue of American Poetry Review. The editors judged. The annual aw
Poets & Writers2 min read
Submission Calendar
AMERICAN POETRY REVIEW Stanley Kunitz Memorial Prize DIAGRAM/NEW MICHIGAN PRESS Chapbook Contest  LEEWAY FOUNDATION  Transformation Awards LOST HORSE PRESS Idaho Prize for Poetry NATIONAL BOOK FOUNDATION National Book Awards  PITTSBURG STATE UNIVERSI
Poets & Writers6 min read
The Contest You Didn’t Enter
FEW literary honors inspire as many mixed emotions as “best” lists. These festivities are still primarily annual, still primarily relegated to Q4, but in recent times the promotional bonanza seems to have exploded, both in terms of the number of lis

Related Books & Audiobooks