Anda di halaman 1dari 43

Predication and Its Importance in Islamic

History Narration Criticism


Prof.Dr. Abdullah Khalaf Al Hammad
1-It has to study the predication and know the narrators
circumstances in the historic literatures. And to be sure of
their abilities and resourcefulness in transferring the events,
before judging on the narration if true or weak, in help of
the men and classes translations.
2-The concentration on the criticism of the historic novel
according to the western criticism rules of the historic
novels , represent only o ne aspect of the European historic
search that free predication series, and this does not apply
on the Islamic history, because of the predication series in
most of the historic narrations.
3-Modern and ancient various studies proved not the
possibility for the implementation process of defects and
modifications for the narrators with complete conditions for
the historic novels that not deal with legal aspects.
4- The ,necessity of enclosing new subjects in history sections
,dealing with history term, narration criticism rules, and
practicing the students on implement it on Islamic history
narrations.
91

92

: :

93



: :
: :

))) (1

: (().(2

: )( :

).(3
: :

: :

).(4

)( )(

) (5
) (1 ) 395( :
) 1979( 3 105

) 711( 1 ) .( 3 .220
) (2 ) 733(

:. 2 )
1406( .30-29

) (3 3105 3 .220
) (4 )852( 1
) (1989.24

) (5 3 ) 1997( .33

94

) ( :
: - :

)) : (() (1
)(
)(.

) ().(2

) (1 )256( :
3 ) 1987( 1 .52

) (2 )1176(
: ) (

.2

95

) (1

)) :

: (() (2 :
)) (() (3

)) :

(().(4

)) :


) (1
)498( .

)748( 1 ) .( 4 1233
.1234

) (2 1
) 1979( .201

) (3 )463(
:. ) 1402( 2.200
) (4 ) 405(
: 2 ) 1977( .40

96


(().(1

)( :

))


(().(2


))

...
- ) ( ) (
) (1 )463( :
) .( .40
) (2 : 2 ) 1984(
.64

97

...
-


(().(1

))

((

) (2

))


) (

(().(3

)) :


) (1 1 ) 1986(
.119-118

) (2 ) 1372(
24 2.210

) (3 2 .210

98

(().(1

).(2


) (1 )310( 1
) 1407( 1.13
) (2 1 )
2007( ) .(39-38 32

99


) (
) ().(1

-1
.

-2

-3

.

.
.

) (1 6 ) 1985( .68

100


) (1

) (2

))
) (1 )808( 1
) 2007( .47
) (2 )1076(
) (1992 1 .87

101

...

(().(1

).(2

) (1 1 ) 1992(
.10
) (2 )
2003( .64

102

)(1

-1 :

).(2

))

(() (3
.

) (1 )806(
) .( .1
) (2 .71
) (3 .97

103

-2 :

).(1

)) : (() (2

)) :
:

: :
) (1 )643(
: ) 1977( 104
)911(

: 2 )
.( 2.368

) (2 )463( :
) .(

.119

104

: : :
: :


(().(1

) ( )( )

( ) (


).(2

) (1 .119
) (2 4
) 1417( .144

105

).(1

).(2

) (1 1 ) 1986( .182
) (2 .189

106

:
-1 :

) : ( )301( ) (
)351( ) ( )430( )

( )463( )

( )630( ) (
)748( ) (
)852(.


.
-2 :

) (

)261( )( )354(

107

) ( )385( )

( )748(.

-3 :
:

) ( )256( ) (

)259( ) (
)264( ) ( )303( )

( )354( ) (
)365( ) ( )748( )

( )852(

-4 :

)(

)181( )( )233( )(
) 234( )( )241( ) (
)256( ) ( )277( ) (

)279(.
:

)(

108

).(1

: ) (

)230( )( )240(

) (
)245( ) ( )333(.

) : (

)288( ) ( )463( ) (

)571(

(
.

) ( ) (

) (1 1 ) 1999(
.235

109

))


(().(1

:
).(2


) ( )) :



) (1 .14
) (2 )
( 1 ) 1999(

.210-209

110


(( ) (1

:
.

) (2

)(

)(

) (1 )771( :
5 ) 1990( .71
) (2 : )
1967( .134-128

111

-1 :

) (1

-2 ).(2

-3
:

)) )(

(().(3

-4

)) :

(().(4

) (1 )261( :
) .( 1.2

) (2 ) 1304( :
3 ) 1407( .57

) (3 ) 748( :
) .( 1.16

) (4 .113

112

-5 ).(1

-6 ) (2
.

-7
) () (3

) (1 ) 273( :
) .( 2.792
) (2 .114
) (3 .80

113

-1 )) :
(().(1

-2
.

-3 :


.

-4

.

))
((

) (2

)) :

((

)(3

)) (().(4

) (1 )902( 1
) 1402( 3.4

) (2 ) 543(
: 4 ) 2007( .166
) (3 .167
) (4 .118

114

)) :


(().(1

)) : (()(2

-1 :
.

-2 :
.

-3
)( .

-1 .

-2 .

-3
.

) (1 .66
) (2
)833( 1 ) 2006(
1.237

115

( )) :

(().(1

) (

))

(() (2 :
))

(().(3

)) :
) (1 ) 794(
:. 1 )
1998( 3.342
) (2 .68
) (3 .80

116

:
:

) (1

(().(2

) (1 : . 2
) 1972( 1.131

) (2 .46-45

117

)(
)(.

) (1

)( )) :
)( )(.(2)((.

)( )( )(

) (1 ) 129
.(14

) (2 .23

118

) ( )146(

).(1

) ( ) 147 158( )) :

(() (2 )) : ...

(().(3

) ( ) 157( )) :

(() (4 ) (585

132) (5

) (1 )327(
1 ) 1952( 7270
) 742( :

1 ) 1980( 25 .250

) (2 )748(
) .( 13 .231

) (3 ) 852( 3
) 1986( 4.386

) (4 ) 322( :
1 ) 1984( 4.18
) (5
) 1410( .487

119

) ( )170(

)) (()) (( ))

(().(1

) ( )207( )) :

(().(2
) ( )212( ).(3

) ( )225(

) (4
).(5

) ( )262( ))

(() (6 )) :

) (1 12 326 2.255
) (2 )463( )
.( 14.52

) (3 8 468 3
.282

) (4 4.253
) (5 ) .(18
) (6 3 .361

120

(().(1

))

(() (2


).(3

) (1 11.208

) (2
) .( .6
) (3 6 ) 2005(
1.20

121

)) :
(().(1

() () (2

-1



) (3 :
)) (().(4

-2 ) ( :

) (1 291 1
.298

) (2 .133
) (3 .34-33
) (4 )852( 1 )
1406( 1 .262

122

-3

-4

) (1
.

-5 :
) (2


).(3

-6
)110( )) :

) (1 ) ( .50
) (2 )) : ((
2 ) 1999( .202

) (3 1.39

123

: ((

) (1

-7

:


).(2

-8



).(3

)
) (1 .122
) (2 1 )
2007( .14

) (3 .16

124

).(1


).(2


) (1 ) 852( 1
) 2003( 7 .279
) (2. .
1 ) 1985( .13-12

125



) (

) (
) (2933

) (
) (1 .

) (1 1
) 1999( .7-6

126


127

.
.

-1 )327(
1 ) 1952(.

-2
) 794( :.

1 ) 1998(.

-3
)833( 1

) 2006(.

-4 )643(

: )
1977(.

-5 ) 543(
: 4 )
.(2007

128

-6 )733(
:. 2

) 1406(.

-7 ) 852( 3
) 1986(.

-8 )852(
1 ) .(1989

-9 )852( 1
) 1406(.

-10 )852(
1 ) 2003(.

-11 )808(
1 ) 2007(.

-12 )395(

: )
1979(.

-13 )273( :
) .(.

-14 )711( 1
) .(.

-15 )256(
: 3 ) 1987(.

-16 )405(
: 2 )
1977(.

129

-17 )1076(
) .(1992

-18 )463(
) .(.

-19 )463(
:. )
1402(.

-20 )463(
:

) .(.

-21 )463(
:
) .(.

-22 )748(
1 ) .(.

-23 )748(
) .(.

-24 )748(
: ) .(.

-25 )771(

: 5 )
1990(.

-26 )902(
1 ) 1402(.

130

-27 )911(
: 2

) .(.

-28 )310(
1 ) 1407(.

-29 )806(
) .(.

-30 )322( :
1 ) 1984(.

-31 ) 1304(

: 3 )
1407(.

-32 1 )
1992(.

-33 ) 742(
: 1
) 1980(.

-34 )261(
: ) .(.

-35 )1176(
: )

(.

-1 2
) 1972(.

131

-2 )
( 1
) 1999(.

-3 4
) 1417(.

-4 :
) 1967(.

-5 1
) 2007(.

-6 .
1 ) 1985(.

-7 1
) 1999(.

-8 6 )
1985(.

-9 2 )
1984(.

-10 1
) 1999(.

-11 2
) 1999(.

-12 1 ) .(1986

-13 3 )
1997(.

132

-14
) 2003(.

-15 1
) 1986(.

-16 6
) 2005(.

-17

)
.(.

-18 1
) 2007(.

-19 1
) 1979(.

-20
) 1410(.

) 1372( 24.2

133