]ndm|]yZY]|dY|Z{Y{WYY

 YZY{
aZyZ]


|q
|Z] ZZ{{mZY^fe|Y]YZY{

 

{,dY|WYYfzZ|Ze,YZ]Y]ndm
YZY{  ] ] Y~iZe Y ] ] Z] Y Y] Z {Y{ Y{ Y ve Y
,aY{dY|kYzfY^cZveZ|Y0ZZeYY{{ZfY
MZf]ZZ[ZzfYZ]{|]]\ZZ{Y{WYYYa
vY|[ZzfYZZ|]ZY{Y,|Z]YZY{]]cZyZ]{YY
ZuMZ,|Z]ZYZ^{fn|Yd,deY]
   Z 0ZZe ZM my  fY{ Y{ Z ,{] YZY{ cZy Ze
|Z]
Y~iZe{YZeWYYZmeZ]{YWYYZ],ZaeveYY|f]Y{
yY ,Y dY|YYZ]kYzfY{,YZY{]]
Y{WYYYZY{]ndmY,ZZa{dY| ZnY|]
|Z]YY{^]dmeY{ZadZ{sYZY{]]Y~iZe
dY



ZfZve,Y{d|,],Z{Y{,YZY{|ZY

^YfZY{]fd|Z||YZZ

|
]|Y]{yZY]Z]Z]me,qZdaZ{Z{faZY
]|Y]|YZY]ZmY|Yf{f]]  ZMdZrf] |M
]ZZvYZZ^fY{{ZY YZY{]YeZ{Z{iZda
|ZM]yY]meYY,|Z]Y{ZY
] Z ZZ d|YMYe,Y|YYqYfYdYfZZ
Z] Z |Y {^]  ]ZY Y] Y  ] n Y  |Z] ,da ] ]Zf{  Y|Y ] |
Zu{,{YaZf{{|Z]|n|q,d\],,,|
,,,,|f~a{]Y|p,dY{mYZY{]nY]|q
]Z{Y{Y]YY{Y|a,YZY{]Ya^cZve{|ZYZfZ]meZ]
,Mm|Z|M{^,ZZ{YZY{Y{YZ{ZfY|,Z{Y{ZMdmY{Y
zZfY|{m,YZY{cZY]Y|{YeZ,ZZ{ZY{|ZZ]ZY
M]Yv,]neZ]zfYZY{fd{YdZ{ZMY{]YZY{Y{|^edm
{c]YYZY{],Z{Y{{|WYYZZ{{mYZY{]]ZedY{
,|Z]ZY{ZY]ZY0ZZeZMZs]meZ]ZYZ^{fn|d{
|{YveZ{
|Z]ZM]YZY{{YZaZ{Y,aYZnYY|Y]Z]
nZ{Y{|WYY]ndZ{||YykYzfYZmcZ]{YZ]]]Y~iZe{Y
Z{Y{ZMdmZmY]YY{Y{Z{Z{Y{|WYYZ]aY|Z]YZY{]
{fn|d{,YZY{]ZZmn]Z{c]YeZZa{{Y{
{Y|Y[d]|{{md{^]dmZZYWYY]ZYZ^

1 Knowledge Workers
2 Maxim

dY|M|m{e]veY|Y{mc
veY|Y 

{mc

 ] ] Y~iZe {Y Ze Z] Zm | WYY  ]Y~iZe{YZeYZZm{^

YZY{
YZY{]
|Y]YY]MY{ZfYZ{Y{|WYY   ] n dm | |f  | {^
YZY{]n{
YZY{
Y~iZe{YZe|]{YZauY  cZYMmdmZm|{^
YZY{]]
YZY{]]
zf,]YZY{ZZdm|WYY  ]YZY{d{ZZZ{e
]neZ]
ZZZ{
veY|Yc|{Z|m
Y{hZ]|{YZf{{ZM]YZY{dZ{^]Y]ZYd|Y
{Y{Yme{Y{Zfz
cZ]{Y
|Y{y]{ZdYYZZZ{zfZ,Y{fZdYY{d|Y|aZ]
Y|YZY{Y{|Z]Z]ZY]Zd|Y{d||ZY{dY
Z,ZM{{ZZ^{{ZfY{yYf|Z]YfaZ{{Z
ZnMY|Z]ZZ{Zyda|]{fY{{YYZs]f]Ze|Z]}Y{
Z Z|uY ZY ]  ZZ Y Z] {Y{ {m  ZZ  Y|Y Y] {Y|ZfY Z 
Z|uY{Y|eZZ]ZZ]YeZZjY]{Y|Y|uYZ{YZY{
Z|uY  Z Y ] f Z^eY YZY{ Y] ZY |n f { my Z  { ZM my |Z ZM
,,{Y|{mmy
v,YZY{]]ZYY]|Z]e|raZ]Y{ZdZ|ZYZY{



YZY{]ndm{Y|ZfYfY|{mY]YfY|mY{ZcZ]Y

Ze{Y{]]Y~iZe{|fY]ZvYZY{]nY]Y]Z]|Z]
dZY]{YYZedZ,]ne|Z{Zu^cZcZ]{YY
Y  ] Zu ] |Z]  cZf Z {ZfY Z Z] Z] fz Z Y]  Y   { ZZ
YZY{]nY]|Z]fY{eZd]ZZ]YZZ]|f{Y{{mYe
,,{Y{YZY{]Y|YdYZZ|{Z,yYcY|Z,,,,dY|
,,,,,,
YZY{]]Y~iZeY
Y,|Y{Y{Yn]{YYZY{]Z|{^|ZnYcZveZe]Z]
me|Z]|Y|{MY{Y{ffc]Zef~ZYYZY{]]Y~iZe
Y{Y|Yadve^cZve{YYZY{]]Y~iZe{YZepZe{
Z]ZMY{|qZZ^cZve{|Z]^Z\ZZd{|v{Y{Zdm{Y
cZve ] me Z] YZY{  ] ] Y~iZe {Y Ze dY | |n Zv e ^ Z|f  
dYY],|]ZZcZve]]MY|]{{ZZef~
|ZfdZrZfenf{ZmycZ^Zv-d
Z,{{cZ^Zv-{{ZZ
Z]]WZZ,ZeY]ZYZ,Z||^Z|{M]eY]cZ^Zv-|^Z
|{ZnYZ{Yq|q|Ye|ZqYfY]]cZ^Zv-fY
,Z{aMYfu,{{]ZZa]ZZtvZnYY]cZ^Zv-{Z]
{ZnYd,Z{Y|ZfYZe]uZ]a{f{
{ZnY[y|qZYY]cZ^Zv-d
Yfu,|eZ{{{]Za]d{ZZZnYY]cZ^Zv-Y~iZe
|ZnYd,ZrZY|ZfY]u|]ZM
|Z]|YfY]cY|edYZdYYY]cZ^Zv-fdZ
]LZeYdmZ|Y||m{Yyc|Y]cZ^Zv-dyM
d]Z ,cZZ^eY , c{Z^e , e -{Y f  { Z] ,Z nfY] cZ^Zv -a d 
ZZfY,{ZYd^i,Yv]d|,]a
Yv]Y{tvYmYdYY]cZ^Zv-ZdY~adX

{Y|ZfYY{Y,d{ZZeY]cZ^Zv-]YZY{{
Y ] dY  Z Y{Y|e { Z] ]|  f ] Y lZf e ] -d^ 
|Z]fY{]ZdY{Z]ay{{z|Z^Z
d,Y,YWZY{yZv{ZY{fuYdZY -YvY 
|Z]Y~iZeZY{]]|YeZy{,,Y{,d],
] |Z]Y|ZZY{,[]]|Y]-Y|YZ]\ZZ^eY 
|Z]fY|{yZv{Y{\Y]fY{Zf{{yZ{Y{cZYZe
|Z]~bZYY{e{YY]\ZZ^eYYZe
ZZnY{Z]WYZ]]|Y]ZZ{ZYZY{Zu{ZYMfY{ 
{|Z]WZYfY|{ZnYfY|]Y{yZdZ|Yf]|Z]{]YM|Z{y
dY{Y{Y{yiZedveYYZY{ZY]ZYZ],YfaZ{
fZdmY{d|ZY]Z]]Y~iZe{Y{Z]YYZY{]]Y~iZe{YY
dY|ZYZM]Y{Y{|YfYn{Za{{YYzcZyZYY
|v,Y|{Y|e,Zed,ZY{,cveY,{,,dmZzcZz
,ZYY,Y|zfY,,ZZda,ZcZZ,Z]ZZ ZcZz
{ZfY,YYZ]ZM,^~Y,l],yY,Z[Zf{Y|e,{f{uY,{Y{Y
ZZ{d,zeZYYZ]ZM,cZY^YZzYZ]Z^eY,dfYYZ

,{]me{,{f{uYdZ,Y]|e,^d]ZZZ]Y{ZZ{ZZ
{Z^e,cZY]f{,cY{ZaWYY,ZZ^{{]zZa,dY,]Y|Y
Y{
] {Z]YZYZ]  cZveY]Z |Y{Z]{ycZve{ Z{Z Y
{Y{{mYe,f{Y{{m,d^]YYZY{{,ZdY,~adX,fdZ-
 ] M {|] ^  d Y{ Z Y ,d {mY{ Z ] i nY]
]nqZe{|Z]YZY{{Y{{mY|M{ZZdYY{,Z
ZYeYZfYY,|{ZnYYYY{f]|YeYZY{dYY|Z]y{Z
Z^cZveZa]]|Z] fY{ ,|  ZM ] ZYZ ze { |Ye  Z Z]
{y Y cZYM m {  v ,|Z]  YZY{ {y e  ] n q Z  e |{

1 Ramirez

Y,veYcZyYYdY|,veY{ZaY,Y{YZY{
|{]Zd{|vYY{^cZve{y]YZY{]]Y~iZeYZeveY{|Z]
|}{Y|YfYnme{YYZeveY{,|Yf{Y{YYY{|qZe
dY|MZYda{YYkYzfYdmfZ]Za{YZY{]]Y~iZeYY
|]y
Z//zZ/Y]LZY|]ZMY|dYf|qZeYZ|]yZM
LZ/YZ//]/||]v]YZd{mZcv,Z|{xZaLZY,ZMYdZM
Z///yY{yY{|Z],LZYZZ{|Z]^Z]|eaYZZZY]y
{/{YY/,{Y{|//v/{Y/{r,ZMY|Z]fY{{mZ]Z]mZyZ
],|]yZM|f|Z|Z]|,|{eY{Y||mZ|M,{Y{dZ
Zf^/LZ/Y{Y|/eZ,d|]ZLZY{Y|eZ]qZ,ZfY{lZf|Z]{Y{{Zze]
/Y{|/Z]/{Y{Zn{ZYYeqYu]Zc]ZyY{ZY|Z]
{eZ]ZZyY{ZYY]meZ]Z|Z]z^Y|YeZ{Y|eZM
/]LZ/Y]]ZeZY],f]{Y|eZ{]LZYYYn|]z]|]yZMY|
|]Zd{|]v,Ze{|Z],ZzYn
]neZe
Z|Z]LZY]ne|]eY]ZfYY|YY],|]yZMY{ZfYe|
Y{ZfY{,Z{]ZY{M|]z]d]Zd]|]yZM,|{Y{te0^
Z/fY/e0ZZY|]yZMqY||eLZYZfyZZ]Z^eY{Z|Yer{
LZ/YYYnY]{ZaZfyZY{f]Z]|Ye^Z{Y|YY],{f{
{{]Z]|Ye|]yZM,|Z]e]Z
{Y{Z{Z
/cY|Z,|eZfyZZ]{Md{]LZYY|{ZZ|{]ne|]^kYzfYZ]v
/yZM,{Y{ZfZfyZ{MY{ZfZveZu{||]f]veY]|Ye
,|/|/{|/uYnc]cY|ZYZm]Y]Z]|{ZnYcY|ZY]Y]ZZ,|]
||]yZcZzZ]||{y LZYc]|Ye
]Ye

1 Cluster variate
2 Taxonomy

/]]YZZMY]Yv,{{Y{ZZy{Y{Y{ZfyZ|eZyZ]
YZdZ^ZcZe]Y{YYZ]{|]yZM{Zu{YYcY|ZZ]|Z{Y{cY|Z
|{Z]y],|Y{^ZM^
KMeansfYe|]y
fY{ {m Y N { Y|Z] Z{Y{
 |ZZ dm Z
  e

 Y ,ZY  Z
n


 ^ZvY

v1, v2 , vc

ZYZ{m|Yan,Z]fY{Yyc{ZnY||Z]
c




U u ik

Q u ik x k v i

i 1 k 1

|]z]
  eZ , n {  R |Z]
 

vi

xk

 Z |Y Z , ]Y {
U eZ ZY{ |Z]
  Zy

 ] ZY ze ,eZ Y  |Z]
   i 1, 2,,c , k 1, 2,, N
{
 ~uiyYkY,ZM

u ik 0

Y

u ik 1

 



Y{Y{eiy]kY|f{{

|Z
 {M]YY|]z]Z
 eZ
|Z]
 ZYZeZ{{]eZZy

Y
N

0 u ik N
k 1

i 1, 2, , c



u
i 1

ik

k 1, 2, , N



{Y{ey]Ze,Y
c



Y{
 Z U Z]Y|Z
 {M]Y{Y{{Z
 eZ|]z]
 Z
 eZ{YZy

{
 {ZnYYZ
 YYn

|]z]
 eZ, Q Z
 

v , v , vc
U U  1 2
]meZ] Q Z
 
|Z]
 K-Means,{e

{Y{{mfzZ{Z
 ]YZ]]Y{

Y|eZ^K-Means|]y

{YZ
 ]Zd
 Z

v
|[ZzfY{Ze]YZM
 |Ye
 ,ZjY]|{eY i 1, 2, , c  i YZ
 

Ye

|{eY|]z]
 eZZYZ],{Y{ZfyYU ]Z^Y{|{Z




1
u ik
0

if d x k , vi min j i d x k , v j
otherwise



|5]Z^ZvYYYZ


vi

u
k 1
N

ik

k 1

xk
ik



|Z]ZY]Z
 eYeMZ,|e|Y|Za] Q yZ|
 Y|aY{YZZeZY
{YeZ,ZjY]{ZZYZY{{mZfyZYe|]z]
 Z
 eZY{ZfYZ]

|Z] c 3 Z]]Y]Zy

{Y|e,ZnY{dY|{ZnY N 8 YY]|]
1 0 0 1 0 1 0 1
U 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0

dY|e

1, 4, 6, 8 ZYYyYdY{YyY]Z]|eYy,{

|{
 aY



5, 7 |ZZ]ZYy,{ 2, 3 ZYZy{
KMedoidsfYe|]y

Z
  {ZnY { 
  ZY f Y ] Y{b] K-medoids|]y

 fY te ] M Y ^
|Z] f Y fyY iPe dveY{Y{
  Z Y   Y ,Y]Z] -|
  f  { ZZe ,Zy

 Y Y
 {
  Y  | Y {Y{ YZZ ,Y { f]  ]|
  Y iPe dve  YZ
  ,ZM
|
 ZZ]]d],Zu|Z]e|
ZY n )(  ]  {] \e ZM  ,
YY{
 eYZ

x 1 x 2 , x N

med x 1 , x 2 , , x N

,|Z]\e

,u {Y|Y ] ] Z

x 1, x 2 , , x N n|{Y{

 ,Z

x N /2 x N /21 / 2 Z] {] |Yy ]Y] Z ,|Z] k N Y[ x N 1/2 Z] {] |Yy ]Y] Z ,|Z] { N

YY|

x1

|,ZjY]dY{|Yzf]Z{Y{
 {{mfyY],nfdY||{M]

YZ{Y~]iPenfdZ]
 |[vca{Y{

x1

,Y]Z]|Z]Z{Y{
 ]Ye
 Z]{]
|]{

Zu{fue||{ZYY{y|,Z

x 1, x 2 , , x N {Y{nZ

|{Yme{d{]Y|{Y{
 ZZd
 caZ{Y{Ye
 ]{Y|e
,  { dY d Y{ ] me Z]| u Y   |
 e Z Y|  |Z] fY{ me
Y{dY{Y|aYu

 Z`q
]Z
 dY{{YdZ]Z{{Y{nZ
|Z]
 ca{Y{{m
dYZ
 ]PY]]Ym,Z{Y{Z{Z]Ye
 



min i

x k x i x k med

k 1

k 1



|z]
 {^]Y|]y

|,|]YeY]|{
 ZYZmed,]Y{
{
 fc]yc{ZnYZ]Zf|]Ze,|]nZ{Y{
 Y]]
c



Q u ik x k vi
i 1 k 1

u ik x k j v ij
i 1 k 1 j 1



ZY
  |Z] |fy

 0Z |Ye
  Z
 ] |M Y |Z
  Zy

 Y Y ] Y Z ,]Ze Y  fZ
Y
  |]y

 Z
 e Z
  Y ,Y { {Y{ {m Z
 ] |M  Y Y [ZfmY  ]  {
Z{]Z {|]y

Z]  ,PAMZmedoid u|]z]
  ZY ZM
  Y { { ]  |Z]

CLARAZ]

Zmedoid YYn

  ] Z{Y{
  { {m ZfyZ Z Y dY cZ^ PAM fY { Y |Y

Z Y   ,Zmedoid Y  n  Z] ]Y {|fY{Y{
  Z e
  YY{YZy

 ,Zmedoid
{
 eY,Zu|]y

d{Y{MY YZe
 {
 |]
 medoidMuY{Y{

 e ~ y|Y{ e  y  ]  Z{Y{
   Zmedoid Z {mZZ
  n ^Zv
Zf Zmedoid |Z ZM
  Z]  ,Z Y Yz{ n  Z] Y {y Z ,PAM{ {Y{ Z  medoid
1Partitioning Around Medoids
2Clustering Large Applications

{
 cZn]ZmZmedoid YzY{Y{
 ],Z
 ]Yu {|
 ZM,{

n Y|Y ] me Z]dY{ |Yy Y ] Y|]y

 {^] ,Zn]Zm  dY M ] |M q ZnY {
q{Y{Zn

Z]]Y{PAM|{
 Z,]nelZf{]|YyYZd
 {|vZ]Y,{Y{
Zn

|]y

]yY{Y{
 ,0j-|{
 Z{yYY]y{Zy

 {Y|e
cZ^ ]{]  { Y ZM
  Yz] Ze Z{Y{
 Ze Y {ZfYZn]  dY fZ eY]
  PAM ,e]
  {Y{
ZnY Y
  ,CLARA |Z CLARA Y  Y{
 
  {Y{ n Y d Y { ,{
n Y  |q , Y {| Y|a Y Zmedoid  { ZY ~  Y PAM b  |{

{
 WYYmyY]|]y

f]kYzfY{Y{
|fme]Z
 d{YY{MfzYYK-medoidsfY|Z]fY{me

|Y
|Z]
 {Y{nYY
 {]e]Z
 [
{Y{ Y  | Y{ kYzfY |MuY Z { Y  Y dZ]
 {Y{ ZYY cZ^Zv ] fY Y

ZMZm

|YmY,|ZMdmZ{c]ZYZ^{fn|Yd{veY
Y-|[v YZY{Y,teZ]{],0ZZYY{dM{,Y|ZZe
|Z]cZyYY{
Z]Y~iZe{YYZ],ZZ{YYZe Z
|Z]ZYWZ]t|{Z,{YYZs
^ZveYZY{Y|WYYZeZ],{mZZZ
YYZfY,{ZnYdm{{]0ZZYZ^{fn|Ynmy  
|Z]Y{
YY-{Y,|Z]zdYY{Y|u{[ZY{Y|e],ZMZm
ZMZmY]v\ZmY,|ZYcZy]meZ]ZYZ^{fn|Yd
|Z]{ZZY||YZZZ,ZZZ,veM{ZMZm|[ZzfY

1Interpretability
2 The full range of Knowledge Worker

{Y{vev]dZ{ZMY{||{e|Yd{Za]
{,|Z]Z^fYZ|{Y{xZaZa{]{ZfY{{Z|{Z{Y|e]meZ]|
dYMve{ZMY{|n
{Y|ZZYZ^{fn|Yd{,Z{Y{Z^Yd{|vd]aY{
]Y~iZeYkYzfY{ZY{{y|Z]\Y],Zv{|Ze{]YZY{]]Y~iZe
Z{{YcZY,Za^uZZ]|ZZd|Z]eYY~,dZ{,|Z]y{]
{kYzfYYZY{]ndm
|]y
YY{MYmY]dY{,|ZYMYY|]y]^{cZve]meZ]

Y]|ZY|dY|Z{Y{ZffYY]|]y||YyfyY{a]
|]yZfYYy]Z]WYZ]meZ]dY|{ZfYMYcZvejY{,|Z]Z{Y{YYkYzfY
|q^{ KmedoidsKmeans fY{YveY{,v{eZfYf]
WYZ,vefY{Y[ZzfYddyY{aYyZM]Y{Y{dY|{ZfY|teZMdYZMYmY
WZ]YZYY{KmeansfYdY{]fY{YYYyZM{{ZfYf]Y{]fY{YZ]
{{Y-dY{Y{ZfyY{y]Z{Y{cZZ{Y{ZfYmeYf]|Z]Z]{]
,{|c]cZYdZ{]{] KmeansfZZedZu KmedoidsfYdY|{Y{Z
|{YZM{YYZ{Y{|Ye


ffYnfmeZ{Y{ZfYYY|{]me{Y|{Z

K-MeansfYe|]y

1 Missed data
2 Outliers

Yd],|Z]|]y]]ZfYe{Z]afYK-MeansfY

fYYdY|{ZfYZYZ^{fn|Yd{ZZY{{YY|]yY]M
{|]YZfYZae|ZMY{ZfYY]{{ZfY{|Z{Y{ZMY]{]Za

[ZzfYZ]|{ZfYZy{Y|ef{YndmYYZYY|]yY]Z]
Y] yZ]Z{Y{ZZYnyMu{ |[ZzfY{Y[Ymf]y
dY|{Y{Z{YY{|YmY||{ZfY|]yf{n


YY]|{Y{cYf{K-MeansfY

ddYfY{|]Y{Z|^e,Z{Y{zYadY|{Y{Z{Z
{ZZe,YYY~|f{Y{ZfYZ]|Z]Y{ZdZ{{ K-Means fY{M
fY K-MeansfYMYa||^e{|{Z]|Y~|Z{Y{z{{mY
YY]{f]Z]y{Y|e,YY]|{Y{|]eM]ZYZytvYadY
nY]dY|{Y{YY]dyM{yZ]ZZYn{dY|{Y{
]|ZnYZ]ZYZeYadY|Z]Z{Y{ZeZc]|ZZ]yZ
]meZ],|ZY]yY|ZulZf{ZYYe]y[ZzfYZ]Zy
dYY]ZeyYYYa

1 ClusterNumberEvaluator
2 ClusterCentroidEvaluator

]\ee]|Z]ZZ{ZZY{{YYeYmZZyY|ZyY
YY|Z]Y|{Y|ef{Y{YY|zfY|{ZYveY|Md|]^lZfZY
YyY{{m{YY{Y{Y]Z^eY{]fZyZeYyY{{f{u
YZ]YYZ|Z]Zy{]{dZf]YY{Y|Zez
ZyZe]ZYfYY{yY{Y{yYZ]0Zf^]ZZY|Y{^a{
|Z]YfYY{yY{ZY|Z]fY{]]{ZY~iZe|Z]ZY-|Z]{m
ZMZ]ZWZYeYZ{]ZZY[m{0YjYyYYZY{|Zy[
YZ]dY{ZYZY{YyY{{m{YY\ZmYfZ{uYeZ]]meZ]{Y|Z]
fZ{{f{uY|{Z|Y{Y{yfZ{uY yYa0Zf^dZY{m
y Y ZY {Y| fZ{ {f{  u Y Y ZM dZ ] iZe {YY Z d Z  YZY{ e
]ZZ]ZY|Z]Z]ZeYf]YY{|d^~Y{Y|r
eZ]YyYYZY{|Z]{YY{]YfY|{Z|Z]yYme
{f{uZ]{ZZ^eY{Y|Y{y]ZZ{dY]Y|Y,~adXu
fY{WZ]dYZuY{fY{{y]{ZY|Y|hZ]{Y{YZY{efZ{
|Z]
YZe|Z]ZeZ]Z]YZY{e|]{yY |Z  yk
ZZY{ZYYYY{ZMf]{]ZyY{cveY|Ya|Z]{nZM
{YMf]YY{yYYZY{|Y{Y{ZfyY{y]YzeZYYY{ZfYf]|Z]
{YYZ]ZZ]^eY|Y{y]Zu{dd{YeZ]Y|f{yZZnYu
ZYMYZu{,{ycZ]neY{ZfYZ]|Y{f]Z]Z]neZ]YZY{|{Z{]
|Z]ZnY]dd{Z]Y{yZ{]Y{y]
{ZcZZZeZ]Y,|Z]YZY{{Y|ef]|]{yY |Z  y{
{f{uYdZf]ZY|Y{ZZ{da]|YfYZY{YdYY{y]ZZ

]|{ZlZf-|Y{YyY{,ZZ{ZYZY{f]Y]meZ]|Y{{yfZ{
{Y{yY{YZY{]]Y~iZeYY{^Y{y]WZa
ZvYZZ{{YY e{YZ]|Y{Z Ze ]yY{{mYZY{ |Z  y
ZY{{YZY{Y|Z]Z{Z,Yf{|Z]Z]ZY{|
,YZY{Y{{mZ[Zf{Y|e]meZ]|Z]ZffY{WZ]ZZda|Yy{f{
YfZ{yZf]Y|Y{Y{ZfyY{y]yYZY{{YYYZYeZ]
|Y{^~Y{d]ZeZY{^l],{YYYYY|r|Y{Y{ZfyY{y]YZZ
yYYZY{|ZzeYYZ]Yu|u{|fZZ{ZYYYY{{YYYY|r
uYdZfdZfYYZY|Y{Y{ZfyY{y]Yda]|Yf]
fr{y]Y|YfYY{yYYZY{|Y{y]ZZ{fZ{{f{
|ZuYZZ{YdY
dYY]vZY]ZyY],{|]yY|ZulZf
YZY{]]Y~iZeY{rdZf]fY{d]]eZ]y
|fY{f^dZZZ]ZfZved{
f]Zu{d{df],ZYMfY{,{YYZ]]ne]eZ]Z]]y
dYyYaZ]]Y]yYzeZYYY{ZfYY
Y{ZZY{{YYdYMYZuyY{||{cZyZe f] y 
|Z]f]YY{Z^ey
dZfjyY{{mYZY{Y|}cZyZe]meZ]WZa]y
,{y]Y|YYfr{Y{YZY{]]Y~iZeY{Z]WZ]f^
|Z]WZa]YY{yYdYMYZucZyZe,dYf

]meZ]|Y{Y{ZfyY{y]Yda]|YfyY{YY ]eWZa y 

Y~iZeYYpY|fY{y]WZa]Y|fZ]ZZ{ZcZZf]
|Y{ZdZ{yfZ{{f{uYZe|dZZM{YZY{]]
K-MedoidsfYe|]y
cZWmZY]|Z]|]y|dY|Z{Y{{{{]ZafY,K-MedoidsfY

|Ye{Y{Z]Y{|YZ{Y{dZ{ZYefYY,^{fYY{{|}
Y|,dY{|WYY{|Z]Z{Y{|^eYY{|]ZY]Z],|Z]{]ZaZ]
ZZZM{Y|ecZWm}Z]Zymyedy{Y{ZfYZ]{ZnY|]ycZ{Z|{
v\ZmY,|{ZfYZMYZyYnY]^ZfYY{ZfYZ]Y{{
YaK-MedoidsfY|Z]Y]YmY||YmY[ZzfY{fYY]]y{Y|e
{Yedy{dyZdmZ{Y{~udm{MYafYZ{Y{z
eZy{Y{ZY]|^e|]Ze]YZy{,edy{]cZY|{YY^
dY|{Y{Z]cZWm{{Z{ZMedy{


YY]|{Y{cYf{K-MedoidsfY
{ZMlZff]{Y]Yy {Y|edZ{|YY]dyM{,edy{my
dYY]Zy{ZZ{YYevY{|{ZveY]ZM|

 na y |Z  Zq y |Z   y |Z  { y |Z  Y y

{y|Z y|Z fy|Z fy|Z y|Z
dY|WYY{|WYYYYedZ{fy{|Z


]yZ]K-MedoidsfYYZuedy{

dYY]]yZ]K-MedoidsfYe|]yYZulZf
dY|[ZzfYZfY]dZuY{cveY

eY~iZe{Y{YfZ{{f{uYdZYZY{efZ{{f{uY

dY|[ZzfYfY
|]Ze]lZf]ZYY]YY]dZu,fYYZ]]y[ZzfYY

|Y||]eZy{]y]Y~iZeY,yZ]|]ydZuf][ZzfY]meZ]

|YfY{ZY|]y{YY{|v{Y|eZefYYY{ZfYZ]

Y{ZfYY]{^|Y|qK-MedoidsfYe|]yYZulZf,|}{YZe]meZ]
||Yy{ZfYK-MeansfYlZfY|]f{{|Zf

~yN]Z

Ray, P.K. and Sahu, S. (1989), The measurement and evaluation of white-collar productivity,International Journal
of Operations & Production Management, Vol. 9 No. 4, pp. 28-48.
2. Schroeder, R., Anderson, J. and Scudder, G. (1985), Measurement of white collar productivity,International
Journal of Operations & Production Management, Vol. 5 No. 2, pp. 25-33.
3. Ahmed, P.K., Lim, K.K. and Zairi, M. (1999), Measurement practice for knowledgemanagement, Journal of
Workplace Learning: Employee Counselling Today, Vol. 11No. 8, pp. 304-11.
4. Yuri W. Ramrez, David A. Nembhard, (2004) "Measuring knowledge worker productivity: A taxonomy",
Journal of Intellectual Capital, Vol. 5 Iss: 4, pp.602 - 628
5. Tjosvold, D. (1986), Working Together to Get Things Done: Managing for OrganizationalProductivity,
Lexington Books, Lexington, MA.
6. Drucker, P. (1999), Knowledge-worker productivity: the biggest challenge, CaliforniaManagement Review, Vol.
41 No. 2, pp. 79-85.
7. Davis, T. (1991), Information technology and white-collar productivity, Academy ofManagement Executive,
Vol. 5 No. 1, pp. 55-68.
8. Helton, R. (1988), The best work method of knowledge worker assessment, IndustrialManagement, Vol. 30 No.
5, pp. 19-22.
9. Drucker, P.F. (1993b), Professionals productivity, Across the Board, November/December,Vol. 30, p. 50.
10. Mary E. Guy, Janice R. Hitchcock, (2000) "If apples were oranges: the public/nonprofit/business nexus in Peter
Druckers work", Journal of Management History (Archive), Vol. 6 Iss: 1, pp.30 47
11. Drucker, P. (1968), The Practice of Management, Pan, London.
12. Klassen, K.J., Russell, R.M. and Chrisman, J.J. (1998), Efficiency and productivity measures forhigh contact
services, Service Industries Journal, Vol. 18 No. 4, pp. 1-19.
13. Coates, J. (1986), Three models for white collar productivity improvement, IndustrialManagement, Vol. 28 No. 2,
pp. 7-14.
14. Drucker, P. (1959), The Landmarks of Tomorrow, Harper & Row, New York, NY.
15. http://www.wikipedia.org/
 
17. Davenport, T. (2002), Can you boost knowledge works impact on the bottom line?,Management Update, Vol. 7
No. 11, pp. 3-5.
18. Davenport, T. and Prusak, L. (2000), Working Knowledge: How Organizations Manage WhatThey Know,
Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA.
19. Jablonski, M. and Kunze, K. (1990), Hours at work: a new base for BLS productivity statistics,Monthly Labor
Review, Vol. 113 No. 2, p. 17.
20. Bridges, B.M. (1992), Using operational audit to measure white collar productivity, paperpresented at Productivity
and Quality Improvement in Government Conference, February.
21. Thomas, B.E. and Baron, J.P. (1994), Evaluating knowledge worker productivity: literaturereview, Interim Report,
No. FF-94/27, USACERL, pp. 1-27,
22. Sink, S. (1985), Productivity Management: Planning, Measurement and Evaluation, Control andImprovement,
John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY.
23. Brisley, C.L. and Fielder, W.F.F. Jr (1983), Unmeasurable output of knowledge/office workerscan and must be
measured, Industrial Engineering, Vol. 15 No. 7, pp. 42-7.
24. Fitz-Enz, J. (1986), White-collar effectiveness: Part I: the employees side, Management Review,Vol. 75 No. 5,
pp. 52-5.
25. Pepitone, J.S. (2002), A case for humaneering, IIE Solutions, Vol. 34 No. 5, pp. 39-44.
26. Nickols, F. (2000), What is in the world of work and working: some implications of the shift toknowledge work,
Butterworth-Heinemann Yearbook of Knowledge Management, pp. 1-7,
27. Drucker, P. (1994), Adventures of a Bystander, Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick, NJ.
28. Dove, R. (1998), The knowledge worker, Automotive Manufacturing & Production, Vol. 110No. 6, pp. 26-8.
29. Drucker, P. (1999), Knowledge-worker productivity: the biggest challenge, CaliforniaManagement Review, Vol.
41 No. 2, pp. 79-85.
30. Thompson, P., Warhurst, C. and Callaghan, G. (2001), Ignorant theory and knowledgeableworkers: interrogating the
connections between knowledge, skills and services, Journal ofManagement Studies, Vol. 38 No. 7, pp. 923-43.
31. Ramirez Rodriguez, Yuri W., PhD, Defining measures for the intensity of knowledge work in tasks and workers, THE
UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN - MADISON, 2006
 

 

SPSS  
35. RapidMiner 4.6 User GuideOperator ReferenceDeveloper Tutorialhttp://www.rapidminer.com/
1.