Name:__________________ Period:_________________

Peer Editing Sheet

Papers Author:

What is the Main Idea of this paragraph?

What 3 details are used to support the main idea?

1. Yes

No

Does the topic sentence have a main idea supported by 3 details?

2. Yes No Does the sentence after the topic sentence relate to the first detail listed in the topic sentence? 3. Yes 4. Yes No No Is there a conclusion sentence? Is the paragraph 5-8 sentences? Do any of the details sentences not support the main argument ? If no,

5. Yes No explain:

Name at least 3 strong parts of this paragraph:

Name at least 3 weak parts of this paragraph:

If the author changed only 1 thing, what should it be?

If this paragraph was turned in now, how many points out of 25 would you expect it to get?