PARTIES: Plaintiff: Harvey Defenant: !acey CAUSE OF ACTION: "#ecific #erformance $n%unction to re"train t&e to'n of (in)"ton from ta*in) conveyance DEFENSE(s): PROCEDURAL HISTORY: +rial court i"mi""e t&e action on t&e )roun t&at t&e a)reement i not i"clo"e a conclue contract, t&e -.C of Jam rever"e, D a##eale to t&e Juicial Committee of t&e Privy Council FACTS: Harvey 'ante a #iece of lan o'ne .y !acey (/um#er Hall Pen) P "ent a tele)ram 0 12ill you "ell u" /um#er Hall Pen3 +ele)ra#& lo'e"t ca"& #rice 0 an"'er #ai4 D "ai 955 #oun" Harvey "ent .ac* 0 'e a)ree ISSUE(s): 2a" t&ere a contract3 RULES OF LAW: 6o conclue contract HOLDING: 7ever"e an t&e %u)ment of t&e trial court re"tore REASONING: 6o conclue contract 1 "t tele)ram a"*" t'o 8ue"tion": 1. 2illin)ne"" of D to "ell 2. 9o'e"t #rice +&e 1tele)ra#&4 i" are""e to t&e "econ 8ue"tion only 0 not t&e fir"t D re#lie to t&e "econ 8ue"tion only 0 lo'e"t #rice 3 r tele)ram treat" t&e an"'er of D a" an unconitional offer 1. 6ot .inin) in any re"#ect: e;ce#t to t&e e;tent of it" term 0 lo'e"t #rice D i not acce#t 0 if &e &a "ent .ac* a tele)ram "ayin) 1ye"4 t&en &e 'oul &ave com#lete t&e contract P "ay" acce#tance to t&e 1 "t 8ue"t. i" im#lie .ut mere lo'e"t #rice oe" not im#ly contract to "ell