CYAF 380: WIKI Assignment Peer Review Rubric

Age-Group Wiki
Instructions: You will review the Wiki website of all of the members of your group. Follow the link to their site and review the material. You will be
giving them feedback based on the rubric below. The point system is simplified, but the criteria is all the same except for the peer review points that
you will get when your final project is graded. You should focus more on giving comments than the points, so be sure to include as much constructive
information as possible. The feedback should help your peers improve their grade. Once you have filled out the rubric for each of your peers, save it
with both of your names on the top of the form where indicated. Name the document with their name so you can keep track of it before emailing it
back to them.

General Criteria

A = +4

B = +3

C = +2

D = +1

Philosophy of Family

Section covers your overall

philosophy of the role families play
in your future career. Your
explanations are thorough and
clear.

Section somewhat covers your

overall philosophy of the role
families play in your future career.
Your explanations are somewhat
thorough and clear.

Section does not clearly cover

your overall philosophy of the
Section is not clear or thorough,
role families play in your future
incomplete in explaining and
career. Your explanations are
content.
unclear and not thorough
enough.

Families and Your

Career

Outline of how your career

involves family is thorough and
thoughtful.

Outline of how your career

involves family is somewhat
thorough and thoughtful.

Outline of how your career

Outline of how your career involves
involves family is not thorough
family is incomplete or missing.
or thoughtful.

Arising Issues

Arising issues and how you will

address them is included, including
descriptions of how you see the
family in terms of challenges and
solutions.

Arising issues and how you will

address them is included, but only
somewhat complete, including
some descriptions of how you see
the family in terms of challenges
and solutions.

Arising issues and how you will

address them is barely
included, but incomplete,
including vague descriptions of
how you see the family in
terms of challenges and
solutions.

Arising issues and how you will

address them is not included and
descriptions of how you see the
family in terms of challenges and
solutions are missing.

Graphics & Visual

Appeal

Website is somewhat interesting,

Website is interesting, stimulating
stimulating and keeps the reader's
and keeps the reader's attention.
attention at times. Graphics and
Graphics and text are related to
text are somewhat related to
concepts shared.
concepts shared.

Website is somewhat
uninteresting, not as
stimulating and difficult to
keep the reader's attention.
Graphics and text are unrelated
to concepts shared.

Website is uninteresting, not

stimulating and does not keep the
reader's attention. Graphics and
text are completely unrelated to
concepts shared.

Organizational Pattern

Word Choice &

Sentence Structure

Strong, interesting; clear

beginning/middle/end.

Organized; clear
beginning/middle/end.

Somewhat organized; attempt No attempt at organization; lacks

at beginning/middle/end
clear beginning/middle/end.

Fresh/vigorous; contributes to
unique voice. Sentence structure is
correct & varied. Paragraph
structure is smooth and transitions
are clear between each.

Vivid/interesting; attempt to
establish a unique voice. Sentence
structure is correct, but lacks
variety. Paragraph structure is
somewhat smooth and transitions
are fairly clear between each.

Appropriate but not specifi or

vidid; weak voice. Sentence
structure incorrect and lacks
variety. Paragraph structure is
not smooth and transitions are
unclear between each.

A = +4

B = +3

C = +2

General Criteria

Creativity
Site Resources

On time & Complete

Unusually creative insight in the

information within the site.

Somewhat creative insight into the Fairly creative insight into the
information within the wiki.
wiki information.

Most but not all resources are

Each resource used is cited within
cited within the text and within a
the text and within a bibliography.
bibliography.
Wiki was completed on time and Wiki was completed with almost
all requirements for the
all requirements for the
assignment were complete at that assignments complete at that
time.
time.

Score Tally:

_____ x4 =

Total:
Comments:

/36

Revised: Moser, January 2015

_____ x 3 = _____

Only a few of the resources

sited within the text and/or as
part of a bibliography.
Wiki was completed with some
of the requirements for the
assignments complete at that
time.

_____ x 2 = _____

Simple/vague; appears to lack a

unique voice. Sentence structure
contains frequent errors & lacks
variety. Paragraph structure is
fragmented and the transitions do
not make any sense.
D = +1
Very little creative insight within the
wiki information.
No resources sited for entries.
Wiki was not completed on time
and very few of the requirements
were complete at that time.

_____ x 1 = _____

Peer Review Completed For:______________________________

By:____________________________________________________

Comments: