The World Reflected Critique Criteria

Advanced

Proficient

10- 9

Student
completes the
self and peer
reflection
activity,
providing a
detailed written
explanation of
their own work
discussing
artistic decisions
and process.
Provides an
insightful
response to their
peers artwork.
Student
participates in
the critique
discussion giving
thoughtful
responses, using
descriptive
adjectives and
asking
meaningful
questions.

Student
completes the
self and peer
reflection
activity,
providing a basic
written
explanation of
their own work
and a basic
response to their
peers artwork.

Student
participates in
the critique
discussion using
basic art
language and
common
adjectives.

Working
Toward
Proficiency
7
Student
completes the
self and peer
reflection
activity with
little
explanation of
their artwork or
response to
peers artwork.

Student rarely
participates in
the critique
discussion with
simple
comments
about what
they like.

Not
Proficient
6
Student does
not complete
the self and
peer reflection
activity.

Student does
not
participate.

/20