Problem: pipe 3, SCH 40, L=3m. Calculate moments and forces at restraints?

When node B, C, G are not modeled as bend (elbow):

-

The result as per structural analysis:

The result as per Ceasar II:

Point
A
B
C
D

Node
10
20
30
40

Point
E
G
H

Node
50
60
70

RESTRAINTS REPORT: Loads On Restraints

CASE 1 (SUS) W+F1

NODE

FX N.

FY N.

FZ N.

10
50
70

0
0
0

-734
-2084
-497

0
0
0

MX
N.m.
0
0
0

MY
N.m.
0
0
0

MZ
N.m.
0
0
0

Rigid +Y
Rigid +Y
Rigid +Y

GLOBAL ELEMENT FORCES EXTENDED REPORT: Forces on Elements

CASE 1 (SUS) W+F1

10
20

Axial
Force
N.
0
-0

Shear
Force
N.
734
71

Bending
Moment
N.m.
0
2415

Torsion
Moment
N.m.
0
0

20
30

71
260

0
0

2415
2415

30
40

0
-0

260
591

40
50

0
-0

50
60

FX N.

FY N.

FZ N.

MX
N.m.

MY
N.m.

MZ
N.m.

-0
0

734
-71

-0
0

0
2415

0
-0

0
0

0
-0

-0
0

71
260

-0
0

-2415
2415

0
-0

-0
0

2415
1138

0
-0

-0
0

-260
591

-0
0

-2415
1138

0
-0

-0
0

1255
1421

1138
870

0
-0

-0
0

-1255
1421

-0
0

-1138
-870

0
-0

-0
0

0
-0

663
497

870
0

0
-0

-0
0

663
-497

-0
0

870
0

0
0

-0
0

60
0
70
0
They are same.

497
497

0
0

0
-0

0
0

497
497

0
-0

0
-0

-0
0

-0
0

NODE

When node B, C, G are modeled as bend (elbow):

The result as per Ceasar II is quite different.
RESTRAINTS REPORT: Loads On Restraints

CASE 1 (SUS) W+F1

NODE

FX N.

FY N.

FZ N.

10
50
70

0
0
0

-730
-2071
-497

0
0
0

MX
N.m.
0
0
0

MY
N.m.
0
0
0

MZ
N.m.
0
0
0

Rigid +Y
Rigid +Y
Rigid +Y

GLOBAL ELEMENT FORCES EXTENDED REPORT: Forces on Elements

CASE 1 (SUS) W+F1

10
18

Axial
Force
N.
0
-0

18
19

-0
-50

80
50

2384
2390

0
-0

0
-0

80
-70

0
0

-2384
2390

0
-0

-0
-0

19
20

50
-60

50
0

2390
2392

0
-0

0
-0

70
-60

0
-0

-2390
2392

0
-0

-0
0

20
28

60
246

0
0

2392
2392

0
-0

0
-0

60
246

-0
0

-2392
2392

0
-0

0
-0

28
29

-246
181

0
181

2392
2383

0
-0

-0
0

-246
256

-0
0

-2392
2383

0
-0

0
-0

29
30

-181
0

181
266

2383
2362

0
0

0
-0

-256
266

0
-0

-2383
2362

0
-0

0
-0

30
40

0
-0

266
585

2362
1135

-0
0

-0
0

-266
585

-0
0

-2362
1135

0
-0

0
-0

40
50

0
-0

1249
1414

1135
862

-0
0

-0
0

-1249
1414

-0
0

-1135
-862

0
-0

0
-0

50
58

0
-0

657
504

862
57

-0
0

-0
0

657
-504

-0
0

862
-57

0
-0

0
-0

58
59

-0
0

504
494

57
0

-0
-23

-0
0

504
-494

0
-0

57
-16

0
0

0
17

59
60

-0
0

494
484

0
56

23
0

-0
0

494
-484

0
-0

16
0

-0
-0

-17
56

60
70

0
0

484
497

56
0

-0
0

0
0

484
497

-0
0

-0
0

0
-0

-56
-0

NODE

Shear Bending Torsion

Force Moment Moment
N.
N.m.
N.m.
730
0
0
80
2384
-0

FX N.

FY N.

FZ N.

MX
N.m.

MY
N.m.

MZ
N.m.

-0
0

730
-80

-0
0

-0
2384

0
-0

-0
0