BMW automobiles
arian Lenin
WW Group is «prominent European maker of prestige automobiles. separations so ince
ai, sftware prods nd racial eansces: ths case dels ony wih te group's atoncches
4 ftareaueed and sold oer ane milon vais unr tse brands: BMW, by far the lpecs
reaurchof he Bish ion smal automobile tom the 1960s end the Rats oye, of whitey
3tod be ‘Phantom’ mode 2068 Foowing the faire to grow mart share and tm rang et
"by acauing the Bsn group Rover, the Group in the ea 20000 adopted an agers tat
erga wth Tha est as teach org nba of mods arash pea ey
and a robust poly of mat development. ;
automobile industry in sconomy expeenced 2 shrp downturn in 20,
nid 2000s ‘which sted wet into 2003 when some Sgn.
scclenton were experened espe inte US
5 sutomobies were produced inthe late economy, Equity pes had fen ust! lt
rity but the automa industry became 2003 this coupled mith goopelital tno,
Scant employer snd an economic force concn about ol sapple, nde tote
ter he Second World War, when national tainty about the economic and pallial en
Uesbegentoberebul. Wh theendof the ments. la this cht ales i oot
Indust podction and manpower that makes atound the wottd decline, wih,
ed he wa efor ete deployed orebld
cures and provide peop mith the con
Soods that were not valle
{he war. Autamable production
tay prominent in the US, but
ope ter Ata especialy Japan,
‘ually important force. By
por ofthe 20h century, the
Tne inustey wa lob ture
Stomoble production wae con
‘Vin Give companies - General
Tord, Daimler Chyler, Toyota
‘sagen face Exhibit
Inber of envionment cecum
atfected the ingyen
Sof the 2s century The globalQD = eorana nt
1 00
cine in the atomobe art in US was pac:
sia severe
“re mid 19905 atomodile producers
score to impowe engineering 2nd uaity of
‘Shes es toe to competitor aang oF
Ten ceca to ah op with competion, but
‘yeas ater these wn wey eto ientine
‘Sedncbis produced by many ofthe major com
eee pcretoe in the st er years the 218
eae puja inthe atom Inds 38 =
Stepped ap pie competion. A betty ove
‘Ries at round 30 pr cent in the oe is
‘BPtnaat at's fot f meal chased ite money,
‘Bhnng Tom prc or Incentives ~ most the
fem ate nseance, 0 per cen terest on
tine purchase = the pevalent means to space
ei hare om compen. However managers
vr aly aware that competing on pice mas Dot
nell fo anyone in See medi fem, 2
Aepvesd the pofiably ofthe whole Sada:
tomers expecatonr would become 2 very
ewer buts t Ineesing prices Matt, The
Fest was that ae wel a lng sea cm
ic sod them at ower pice the consequent
pression of potabiywos ely to afte
ely te ae ating fos pressing We cost
ti womowing a niga scenario. Ts mas UE
‘pcly ih repartee USAS ig OE,
Ford, GM and DaimierChyslet
the ger Buropean a companies a aso
ura rau depres emand ahd ovesi7eY,
teh Vtiragen's ros ling by 4 pe en
the vecon quae of 2003, Fat was abo ENG
Cathe ve ar compari in 208
emg) aa
co ver
[ron er vest
| poimeciraior 288 sass
Te eat 1530
ohne seo a8
ard to gt ou fa serious css by resusing
he company ad renewing the Gull mode ange
‘er te puitance of the CED who had ued
Sa tne fortes of Pre, te re ner.
Soca te ey ae all out on Fa’ ances of
‘changes in the basis of competitive
‘advantage
‘Byte ml 2000 he ca mates ws teeming wih
Po gatity ene, but consumers fond Wey fe
eth ang beeen many of te svable
Tees a models Quality was no fonger an se
iehe indo most models were well ui Da
‘Sms for example, the ql of US ato
tee: had improve 24 per cent fom the Be
‘Joun Tegap Baween te best and worst US
Tens ch a 212 dfn pet 10 wees
Eifooe:nesranomed 053 defects?
Amos inevitably, te dsingusing elements
an tetomen! hole factor had Beco ES
{24 and apes as demonseate by thet at
‘Bipasha piven aeton whe Wok’ of
tha automates had bulk powesal brands
(pte a at ater han losing aretha
“Tu ranaation made design he fst weoRO.
in te Gg for saet share a the feature that
Tanbed stones’ attention. Nataly, boo:
Fak up deg st aor plank of teeMon
iyeeomen |_Msscnsttceprent |__Panbmsnmert |_ Lay sgnan
Sc tat ey pepo a aa er a
“tegy and spe hunt for op eel designs
he promised rewards wees enough ete
{st aes who were then proved wth Ish
ightch dgn aborts nd at studios Ts
"stegy was tfodden by companies aco pie
na vetude type range,
owes, pursing quality and appeal indesign
os ptng pressure on companer outs 50
' brand bling and management, which was
‘en smote demanding and ith hat cen
Sul. had become ees tha x brand dently
5 one of the most affective ways to be mote
empetive ina indastry where mee and more
‘cs came to the mathee Ba simple sve
‘ng mas not enough. In the US camaets ha
fet more than $80bo (= €41bn) on martin
alent to $2,900 fr every at sid Yet tele
imbined US market shite hd fen by mre
a4 per cent amounting toa 3150 os
Etc branding esablshes emotional con-
‘tons betwen castomers on one Hea pro
{5 salen, other wes on the the & pe
ample of sucesul banding was Toyota
veyed te preepon of hgh uaity and ue
Dnomy, creting’ the emotion connections
of relisbty and smart environmental amaenss
BMV conveyed the image of he alimate dng
‘machin’ een t thow cusses ho bog
‘osels with small engines and automatic want
‘sion, saya Seis. The reson fortis was that
every model ase a sea general peptone
‘motional connections generated by the othe
band 6 well some Species relat to the
model in queston. The common theme ofthe
‘rand confer even #9 the lest specie
‘model certain aura Tas proces fd towed 9
long way ftom te concept of product ra,
lor example Ford Mode
“This snot to sy that the product wa ani
portant. Research condicted in 2003" demon
Sate tat consumers, bed oa tek et 20d
Indect expecence, meanired diferent Bab
Peformance agunst two overarching ier
Froductexeetence and con of ownership. The
Searchers ao sed thatthe eative mage
(oF product exealence and low ct of omnes
Sintdetermines 4 band’s value propostion in the
marketpice’ The brands that at poston In
3 come rea of the competitive space sult
Daiculary fom competition and tee prot
"ect Te psltons reported in Exh 2 tend
‘0 berather sabe over te
BMW Group
Origine
Nas sablished during the Fist Would Wat
‘manufacture engine in 148 the company nos
sill Gemany’ leading manufac of to
‘gine. Subsequently vee to hat
23000 were is Tain pods automobiles sot
‘otreycles. By then BMW wat one of Germanys
Ingest and most ces companies, But BMP
‘ox 10 sustained sucess war aonb one ad
In 2000 the hodzon wasnt lon. The grasps
‘xtviles were conceited. tmost excep
on two produc ange: high-performaner soos
automobiles and motoryels The foc of tit
‘eon automebies.
‘The march te success
‘the en ofthe Second World Wa, oth ae
lnes market ands capil equipment were
der setoas teat. The demand for aer- engines
Geusay having lst the war, had copoly
Spear and HS main toy was now ne
Soult aeruption zoe. These whist ona
‘Wes Geemany expentenced an esnomic tac,
SW stg. Uncertain it etn the cs
Pay concentrated on automobile prcsion
Dat without focus products sanging fom
‘ull babble as, ule under lence lage
moun in 1959 BSW faced bankupicy, when
"found power shareholder Canna
‘0 could see the company’s leet stents
yond the cumen feuter The tuning pent
ein 1961, when it launched the BM 1500,
‘hich "soon established the BMW setomotg
"and as one wth a reputation for engineering
tn the 2st century, the scarce rsures that
‘is ntuence atonal competitiveness hey
the sls displayed bythe workforce One of
feminys istincive national cues was a
‘HRY auaied labour fre tat could be wed
'.Scanan manufactures a3 suse of compe
advantage: Mat of such advantage Went
Bite atometies TAT
Companies hat, ke BAW, managed to bald &
ception of valuable diferences th nds of
the bers
It was lfc to singe ou 3 specie tesoure
that undespinnet BMWs sce was ster 3
sete of factors and the way they combined to
‘usa ts competitiveness. BNA automo
Poweriulselable and taro, but not ace
‘only so, BMW's chology had ben sovance,
butt exceptionally innovative er compare,
for example, wit Ctuoen ie somobile, were
‘onvestonly designed snd tionally syle,
they were expensive, ren conietng te hgh
level of speciation oe by test model with
‘etal margins comparatively high, The company
ad gly conto Is dsrbtion nctwork, to
"eb of and management communication
ad ater sevice. eg low to the buyer
had ao atlomed them to segment he mat
flctiey for example, BMW tunebite have
‘een postoned dfrsty and pried iferenty
In the vious national markets BMW aso exer
ot a fim conta on the supply an and Sea
Ings and aston mth supers, who osy
had mainsined a ong station With the com
‘any. That combination, a sytem of peo
{hat gave the company advantage in ts ehonen
Segment a reputation for prodit ualty and 2
‘and which mmedaey ents the a ond
‘spiations ois eustomes, by them 1990 ad
but MW into one ofthe most pole nate
‘mobile manufac inthe word
The BMW brand abo aequied a distinctive
dently as a symbol for young fuer Eos
‘ean profesional most dives peeved high
Peformance saloon tomsbles ts symone
With MU. They had been able cts
their proton around an easy 10 summarise
{heme The ulmte diving snare Estey
Troyanosermade ote in 200 When a person
lt nto a BNA showaom, the question nt
“Which model do want I, “Hom much BW
can fn
[BMW's postion in 2008
In 2009, Rayeriche Motonen Wee (BM), the
1B0up tat owns he prestigious BNW brand war
‘ne of Europe’ tp automakers BNW atoms
soe hey hy a naDiommpeee oRneus,
ee lr!
sccounte fr about three quate ofthe group's
Ses. The company’s operations slo inl
motores, software anda growing fant
services sion. The tmoverof the Group in
2108 was over €41.53bn (= 27 Sn), down 21 pet
‘ent over 2002 mostly due othe engin ofthe €
fone he USS (counting this eee, the growth
in veverue over 2002 would have been 42 pet
ent. Gross margins, of € 2, were down 2.6 pet
‘ent om 28 per ent of 200, 2 eeton of te
"owing expenature tn prodct and make deve
‘pment. The group produced sn annual Srp of
320m, 36 percent lomer than 200 the die
nce was mosy du to change inthe elation
forex proven.
“Test esuls nee even more wearable con
sidered In the ght ofthe generally downwats
{tend in the aotomodie ncaty's potty
‘BMW sutomebile io 2003 employed over
104000 worker In plants in Dingling, Munich
and Regensburg in Germany, Spartan the
1s, Rossy South atc, Oxia in the Und
‘in China, They produced over milion BBO
Min and Ralls Roye eas OF these, 928000 wee
MV automo, up 16 percent on 2002
fact BMW had achieved some smackably
rogesive agreements eth the woke’ unons,
and wes operating Some ofthe mos lee and
‘oducve plants In the sstometie indstiy. &
scraptartatemengec
usr areca tae
Sraencieta a ee ae
Sccuratnemenae ne
Srnwrimeaate es
Seon rat encanta
Scanners
SEeraneest a sate
smmercnetean ciare‘Automobiles delivered by the BMW Group in 2008 (1,000 units)
ee Pe Se SP
LOO LE LE ff
China wout te soured eal scoring to CEO
The markets
‘heimin makes for BM automobiles have bes
Were Europe, the USA, Japan and the Pace
‘os, with the mutts of Geran a he US
Secon for almost hal the ttl car sl
lngotot martes have also been the fs ing
Ukand the lian, French ae Japenee mares
Sales i the USA tarket have ben partly
Sues as they grew by over 8 yr cet onthe
Devious year to 277,000, bes the biggest
fark for the group and overtaking te Leas
and forte fis me. At the ed of 2008, the
| giteok for 2008 by group management ant
| ads observers wat upbeat, This ew wats
Parc by the sacs launch ofthe new Sey
{Be onoliston in Eatope and Aa ofthe BAW
24 and he nsodueon othe BMW XS. The new
Seis and the BROW 6 Svs cbt were
2 launched early im 2004 By far the ost
ul model ete the MIN the eres sad
"FT 2820,
‘he Sstres, but the other models wer ako in
Signcant demand, inthe Chinese ates tere
‘os gong demand for he higher end mod! of
the range specially foe Zee and Seren”
anit 4 shows the deals of automate
stein 2008,
The future
In the ay 20005, the sz of the company and
the tange of mode continued to Be chur
for concen. Inthe mid 1980 they had taeled
‘oth problems by taking ove Rover of the UR.
However, the venture dd nt wk snd ems 04
sexy end fie years ater, wen the had oe the
Bese company forthe um of £10 (#830, The
Quandt family had put presre on the Groups
‘manages 0 slop Rover's haemorthagi loses
fstimated they were In the region of 00m per
Yat. The CEO, B. Pcheiny,tesgned afer t
‘Horm meting withthe sarsolders Miberg
‘he new CEO, had to det wit the mesy seq
on and dispose of They vtained the MINTBMW's top ten markets
0 Fon
USA Gemsry UK fay aapan Fnce Span Cine Gebun Aten
brand a sold Land Rover, preouly pt ofthe
Rover Group, to Fo
“Te aur 35 We as ausing the os of reat
eal of money and of publ as, ad aie et the
{.0up with two problems sll unread. They
‘ete sl ede more than 9 niche player, come
Ding witha nant of modes Alo hi ie
‘es sll modest when compared with that ofthe
tig ive and lef them vulnerable to Soqtston it
the Quant amily wee to decide to dose of
Suc smcunt of heir hes
1 2002 Helm Fan, sel pi, had
‘become the new Groups CHO, and sated at
gy of intra! growth trough make and pd
{SE development tn 2003, BMW was planning to
rch 3 te model eer thee months thigh
10 205, providing ange af premium automobiles
thar ranged om the Mia tothe Rol Royce
“Te am wast alse sles by 40 pet cet yea for
the nest Ste year, and to aleve of Ite
lon veces, Mercegertens woud then become
number two produe of premium car, and BMW's
Tong term ambison of being number one ould
‘efi ele”
To achleve the gets nad sete the con
puny was pushing hard inthe US and. Asan
‘arkets to ind buyers forthe highend modes
‘that they ha ound fiat os inthe at
Saturated European matt, Dials in desing
‘nts labour cost contol nthe European pole
Climate nad aio led BMW to expand i pre
om faites in the US, where the Spartan
Plant was not unning tl potent, and Cs
here a well quaied labour force cont mich ss
than i the West! Twas an ambos plan ht
i Seems, a wel br giving the group peter
Prominence and poftabliy would so efecto)
ure the probe of sine to aeqlstion=
ut the strategy was not without se Te
smcerconneced fates eed to BA ed
‘nt ofall ncesing the output atthe eve
planned by the company, could theaten the wey
feason for BOWS gent aces aston, bt single,
theme summarised by the line the utmate
‘ving machine. They nd been able 10 expo
this brand ientty very poftabiyand sal
wherever thet nie coud be found. Tes 899
doube thatthe brand could be extended ad tat
{Be theme woul tl ecg and tne
out go without easing damage was 2 mate of
‘pecan, How would the Inch oe
Be pereived by buyer, and perspective Duvetofthe high-end BMW marl? Would hel pec
‘on ofthe value of he BN brand be neg
-Mcced? elated to his tether wa ao the
"isk that any model potoned in he penny of
4 more expensive mode could cannile ITor
‘ample could the seer thde! cannibal the
See?
‘Secondly, ineesing the production of aller
«could have the elle ef edcing the histo
ally high mains enjoyea by BMW (ce Exh 3
‘Moving ite Smale crs sneant ering the lowes
‘args that were typcl of thse the se,
ments. Bat compton in thew segment ee
olume products with lower costs then BR
Would BRC be abet ep pie premtums lg
enough to maintain their Potty lee? The
Premium pice automate marke ting oe ot
"he few potable ones, ws ncensingy roe,
‘ore models cme oat ad new ene nag
‘loathe te. The real ws tht pie ens
pelo, whieh started when Lens had terse
the US market in the mid 19905 nas xing pce
Im sac a competi climate, the presure
fon to save cos Dy sharing’ components and
Bw aaometies TAY
pisos amongst mods, fr example beween
Sere aod 13. However, this sharing col Tend
to 2 fattening ofthe fees of the dient
‘models thas enourging the tania of
the more expense mode”
‘Ahi concer was that of uty, With pes
sre on costs, thers of aly apes was nd
toincresse, The conaquences of quay deere ie
‘the pei segments canbe very heyy as BAW
Jeamed wien customers fund ty fc to
se the De they ha isle tn the Pai
[xpanding producion ‘th increasing cones
lng out of manutactring process cnt ake
uty contol more aici than It had Been
hen aan of modes made BMWs epee
vl.
IH. Fake was mang ove any ofthese con
20s; edi nt sow a he Aa cunt of
‘ret Conference on 17 Man 200, when hes
Sota tomes etn as we
‘iene bog pes