Penyelesaian:

a) Northwest Corner Rule

Project A
Plant 1

x11

Plant 2

x21

Plant 3

x31

Project
Requirements

10
12
9
40

Project B
4

x12

x22

x32
50

Project C
11

x13

x23

x33

Plant
Capacities
70
50
30

60

70
50
30
40

50

60

40

30
50
30

50

60

40

30

50
30

20

60

40

30

20

30
30

40

30
20

60
30

30

40

30
20

60
30

30

Solusi:

x11=40 ; x12=30 ; x22=20 ; x23=30 ; x33=30

Total biaya = 40(10)+30(4)+20(5)+30(8)+30(6) = 1040 (dalam $)

b) Modified Distrbution Method (MODI Method)

Project A
Plant 1

x11

Plant 2

x21

Plant 3

x31

Project
Requirements

10
12
9

Project B

12
9

50
-

40

12
9

50
-

40

12
9

12
9
-

11

30

20
50
30

30

20
50
-

11

30

30

20
20
-

50

50

30

70

60

10

11

50

30

20

10

x33

Plant
Capacities

60

x23

10

20

x32

11

x13

50
10

x22

40

x12

Project C

11

30

30

Solusi:

x11=20 ; x12=50 ; x21=20 ; x23=30 ; x33=30

Total biaya = 20.(10)+50.(4)+20.(12)+ 30.(8)+ 30.(6)= 1060(dalam $)

c) Vogels Approximation Method (VAM)

Project A
Plant 1

x11

Plant 2

x21

Plant 3

x31

Project
Requirements

10
12
9

Project B
4

x12

x22

x32

40

Project C

10
12
9

50
-

11

x13

11

6
60

10-9=1

5-4=1

8-6=2

12

4
5

11
8

50

40

10

10-9=1

8-6=2

10
12

50

11

50

10

40

10-9=1

11-6=5

10
20

12
9

50
-

30

60

50

50

x33

40

10

70

x23

50

Plant
Capacities

4
5
7

50
10

11
8
6

20

10-4=6

50

8-5=3

30

7-6=1

20

11-10=1

12-8=4

30

9-6=3

20

11-10=1

20

9-6=3

20

20

10-9=1

10

20

12

20

50

11

50

10

Solusi:

X11=20 ; x12=50 ; x23=50 ; x31=20 ; x33=10

Total biaya = 20.(10)+50.(4)+50.(8)+ 20.(9)+ 10.(6) = 1040 (dalam $)

Yang C belum dijawab..