2010 - 1431
:
:
:
.
:
:
: :
:
) ( 214 ) (479 )( 67
) (412 ) ( 214 ) ( 202.
:
.
:
-
.
.
.
:
. )( .
. .
. .
)( .
.
.
.
.
.
STUDY ABSTRACT
Study Title: The role of Training Requirements identification in the quality of the staff development in the
passports corps in Qassim Region A screening survey in the staff operating in Qassim Region corps.
Student: Abdul Majeed Bin Sulaiman Al Jarbou
Advisor : Dr. Ibrahim Bin Abdullah Al Mahi
Research Problem: The study problem is represented in the following query: What is the role of identifying
the training requirements in the quality of staff development programs in Qassim Region passports corps.
Study Population (Sample): The study samples consist of the officers and noncommissioned officers
operating in Qassim Region passports corps amounting (471) out of them (65) officers and (412)
noncommissioned officers. (214) questionnaire sheets were distributed, and (202) valid sheets were received.
Research Methodology:
The researcher utilized the descriptive analytical approach in the study and used the questionnaire as a tool
for this study.
Main Results:
- The study samples do not agree that there are scientific methods used in identifying the training
needs of employees at Qassim Region Passports.
- The study samples do not agree that there are scientific standards used in identifying the training
needs of employees at Qassim Region Passports.
- The study samples do not agree that identifying the training needs contributes in the quality of
employees development programs at Qassim Region Passports.
- The study samples agree that there are hindrances that limit identifying the training needs of
employees at Qassim Region Passports, including:
o Absence of clear & definite mechanisms (e.g. forms) for the identification of the training
needs
o Lack of evaluation of the previous training limits the identification of training needs.
o Shortage of qualified human resources for identification of training needs.
.
Main Recommendations:
- Create clear & definite mechanisms (e.g. forms) for the identification of the training requirements in
Qassim Region passports corps.
- It is deemed necessary to evaluate the results of the proceeding training and benefit from them in the
identification of the training requirements.
- Attract the qualified human cadres for operation in the identification of the training requirements in
Qassim Region passports Corps.
- Conduct extensive studies on how to identify the training requirements.
- It is deemed necessary to reformulate the job descriptions to include all the tasks assigned to the
subordinates.
- Encourage the officials to devote concern to the identification of the actual training requirements.
- It is necessary to clarify the purpose of the training process in the passports of Qassim Region passports
corps.
- Encourage the staff operating in Qassim Region passports corps to co-operate in providing the required
information upon the identification of the training requirements.
.
) ( .
.
) (
.
.
.
/
.
/ /
.
11
12
13
-1
13
-2
15
-3
16
-4
17
19
-1
20
-2
22
-3
23
-4
25
-5
31
-6
33
-7
34
-8
36
-9
37
39
-1
39
-2
40
-3
42
-4
44
-5
45
48
58
58
58
59
60
68
68
71
73
77
101
102
104
110
111
119
62
62
63
64
65
65
66
67
73
10
74
11
75
12
75
13
76
14
15
76
77
16
81
17
86
18
90
19
20
(TEST
21
94
95
(TEST
97
22
23
98
99
120
128
130
. . . . . . -
-1-
:
.
) 2005 .(1
-2-
) 2010 .( 161
) 1420 .(301 - 300
.
.
-3-
:
.
) 1989 .(13 12
"
" ) 1412 .(215
-4-
"
" ) 1418 (52
"
" ) 2004 .(5
:
-5-
:
.1
.2
.3
.4
.5
:
-1
.
-2
.
-3
.
-4
.
-5
.
-6-
)(:
.
)(:
-7-
:
.
:
.
:
)1431 /1430(
:
.
-8-
-1:
) 2000( "
" .18
) 2003( "
" .95
)1996( "
" .5
:
.
-2 :
) 2004( "
" 239
-9-
:
.
-3
:
.
- 10 -
:
:
- 11 -
:
:
: :
: : .
: :
- -
.
: :
.
: :
.
- 12 -
:
:
) 1990 .(220
) 2002 .(2
-1 :
.
"
" ) 2002 .(13
- 13 -
) 2001( "
" 27
) (2000 "
" . 8
) 2003( "
" .19
) 2002( "
" 5
:
-
. - .
- 14 -
-2 :
.
) 1999( " :
-
" . 16 - 14
) 2001( " :
-
" . 11
) 1989( " :
-
- 15 -
" . 10 9
-3 :
.
:
-
- 16 -
.
-
) 2003 .(25
-4 :
.
)1997( :
- 17 -
-1 .
-2
.
-3
" 159
) 2003( "
" .30
- 18 -
:
:
..
) 2004( " :
.1 .
.2 .
.3 .
.4 .
.5 .
.6 .
- 19 -
-1 :
) 1999 .(42 41
) 1997( "
" .66
) (1992 "
" .31
) 1995( "
" .112
)2002( "
" .97
- 20 -
) 2003( "
" .49
) 2007( "
" .29
)1999( "
"
.43
) 2002( "
" .213
.
- 21 -
-2 :
.
:
-
) 2004 .(265
- 22 -
-3 :
.
:
- :
:
. . -
- :
.
.
- 23 -
- :
- :
" ) 1992 (123
) 1989( " :
:
.
:
.
- 24 -
:
" .31
:
: .
: . : . : .
:
) . 1986 (77
-4 :
.
- 25 -
)( :
:
.
:
- :
) 1996 :(81
:
) 2003 (62
:
- 26 -
)
1996 .(82
:
) 1996 .(84
:
) 1996 (84
:
.
:
) 1992 (43
- 27 -
- ) (:
.
) ) 1989(
"
" .51
) 1996( " :
-
: .
: .
: .
:
.
:
"
.87
- 28 -
:
: .
:
.
:
.
:
.
:
) 1992
(37
- :
.
- 29 -
) 1999( "
:.52
:
.
:
.
:
.
:
.
:
- 30 -
.
:
.
:
.
:
.
:
) 1999 .(53
-5 :
.
:
- 31 -
- :
:
-
:
.
:
.
- :
:
-
:
.
:
.
:
.
- 32 -
:
) 2007 .(185 183
-6 :
:
-
:
.
:
.
:
.
:
.
:
- 33 -
:
) .1991 25
.(26
-7 :
:
-
:
) 1996 .(89
:
) 2003 .(72
:
- 34 -
:
) 2003 .(73
-
:
) 1996 .(90
:
)
1997 (73
:
) 1997 .(40
:
) 2003
.(73
- 35 -
:
) 2003 .(73
: :
)
1997 (74
-8 :
:
-
: .
: .
:
.
: .
- 36 -
:
-
:
.
:
.
: .
-
: .
)1990 , .(99 97
-9 :
.
:
-
.
- 37 -
) 1986 .(81
- 38 -
:
-1 :
.
) :1993 (77
-
- .
- .
- .
- .
- . .
. - .
- .
- 39 -
-2
216331402/9/15
4/31402/7/15
1403/7/1
/2042 1403/7/13
.
- 40 -
- 41 -
-3 :
1343
.
1348 3441348/11/17
1353/10/20
178 .
1356 12/3/57 1356/8/12.
1358 12/3/171358/1/19
.
35941396/3/29
- 42 -
5711380/11/5
)
( 1371
) ( 1337/2/17
1371/9/11 1391 /90
1391/10/24
1393/1392.
) 1393( 1001 -91391/11/10 .
1393 1195 1393/5/10
.
1395 894 1395/7/27
/1039 1395/10/9
/360
1395/12/12
- 43 -
-4 :
.
.
.
- 44 -
.
) 2005 .(23
-5
10
11
12
13
14
15
- 45 -
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
- 46 -
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
- 47 -
: :
:
) 2009( " .
) (92 ).(118
:
-1
) (1.96 ) .(3
. ) , (2,17 )(1,70
.
-2
) (1.89 ) (12.60
.
- 48 -
:
.
.
) 1428( "
.
) (97.
:
-1
.
-2
.
- 49 -
-3
.
:
-1
.
-2
.
-3
:
.
.
- 50 -
:
.1 :
) (%72.3
) (% 71 .
.2
: ) (%78
) (%77 ) (%75
) (% 75 ).(%72.6
.3
: ) (%70.3
) (%70 ) (%69.7
).(%69.3
:
.1
.
.2
.
.3
- 51 -
.
.
-1
-2
- 52 -
-3
-4
-5
:
.
.
)1423( "
" .
86
.
:
-1
.
-2
.
- 53 -
:
.
.
- )1423( "
" .
.
.
:
-1
, ,
.
,
.
-2
,
,
.
- 54 -
-3
,
.
-4 .
:
.
,
.
- 55 -
- 57 -
:
)(
.
:
) 1427( "
" .75
:
) (479 ) (67 ) (412 )
1429(.
- 58 -
:
)X2.N.P(1-P
= N
)D 2 .(N-1)+X.P(1-P
: n : N . .
: D )(0.05 =D
: P )(0.50 = P
: X2 % 95 )= X2
(3.841
((3.481) (477)(0.5) (0.5
=214
= N
2
) (214 ) (
% 44,7 ) (479
) (202 .
:
250
38
202
.
- 59 -
:
.1 :
""
,
:
(1 .
(2 .
)
( :
(1
) (7.
(2
) (11.
(3
) (8.
(4
) (9.
- 60 -
):
(.
: ) (5 ) (4 ) (3 )(2
) (1 .
) (Closed Ques onnai re
.
-2 :
)
1995 (429 "
" ) 2001 .(179
:
:
) (15 )
.(2
) (2 .
:
)
(
:
- 61 -
)(1
201
0.6478
) (0.6478
%70
.
)
( :
:
)(2
1
2
3
4
0.6122
0.5383
0.6248
0.6260
0.3558
0.5526
0.3116
0.3078
**0.567
**0.747
**0.508
**0.514
201
201
201
201
5
6
7
-
0.6535
0.6166
0.5932
-
0.2040
0.3476
0.4347
-
**0.421
**0.584
**0.599
-
201
201
201
-
** 0.01
* :
.
)
(
) (5
- 62 -
) (0.6535 ) (0.6468
.
) (2
)
(
0.01 0.2040 .0.5526
)
( :
)(3
179
11
0.7369
) (0.7369
.
)
(:
:
- 63 -
)(4
1
2
3
4
5
6
0.7170
0.7290
0.7245
0.6899
0.7060
0.6925
0.3900
0.2997
0.3316
0.5615
0.4613
0.5453
**0.551
**0.403
**0.464
**0.702
**0.608
**0.673
179
179
179
179
179
179
7
8
9
10
11
-
0.7163
0.7167
0.7457
0.7306
0.7199
-
0.3958
0.3910
0.1132
0.2816
0.3707
-
**0.533
**0.501
**0.250
**0.426
**0.517
-
179
179
179
179
179
-
** 0.01
* :
.
)
(
) (9
) (0.7457 ) (0.7369
.
) (4
)
(
0.01 0.1132
.0.5615
)
( :
- 64 -
)(5
198
0.8484
)
( ) (0.8484
.
)
(:
)(6
1
2
3
4
0.8463
0.8243
0.8308
0.8267
0.4780
0.6342
0.5821
0.6223
**0.579
**0.752
**0.706
**0.717
198
198
198
198
5
6
7
8
0.8241
0.8175
0.8389
0.8339
0.6347
0.6982
0.5136
0.5553
**0.757
**0.794
**0.658
**0.691
198
198
198
198
** 0.01
* :
.
)
(
.
- 65 -
) (6
)
(
0.01 0.4780 .0.6982
)
( :
)(7
199
0.6920
)
(
)(0.6920 .
)
(:
:
- 66 -
)(8
1
2
3
4
5
0.6511
0.6452
0.6558
0.6556
0.6608
0.4375
0.4801
0.4508
0.4187
0.3953
**0.608
**0.619
**0.576
**0.580
**0.557
199
199
199
199
199
6
7
8
9
-
0.7145
0.6576
0.6678
0.6837
-
0.1200
0.4123
0.3610
0.3036
-
**0.328
**0.562
**0.543
**0.512
-
199
199
199
199
-
** 0.01
* :
.
)
(
) (6 )(0.7145
) (0.6920
..
) (8
) (
0.01
0.1200 .0.4801
- 67 -
:
) (250
) (202
) (15
1431/1430.
) (spss .
Sta s cal
- 68 -
2.61 3.40 )( .
3.41 4.20 )( .
4.21 5.00 ) (
.
:
-1
.
- 2 )( " " Weighted Mean
.
-3 " " Mean
) (
.
-4 " "Standard Devia on
.
.
- 69 -
-5 .
-6 )( ) (Independent Sample T-test
.
-7 ) (
.
- 70 -
.
.
- 71 -
)
( :
(1
(2
(3
(4
(5
- 72 -
:
)
(.
:
)(9
64
24
66
40
8
31.7
11.9
32.7
19.8
4.0
202
%100
) (9 ) (66 %32.7
) (64 %31.7
) (40 %19.8
) (24 %11.9
) (8 %4.0
.
- 73 -
)(10
2
13
9
25
13
5
6
25
31
44
29
1.0
6.4
4.5
12.4
6.4
2.5
3.0
12.4
15.3
21.8
14.4
202
%100
) (10 ) (44
%21.8
) (31 %15.3
) (29 %14.4
) (25 %12.4
) (13 %6.4
) (13 %6.4
) (9 %4.5
) (6 %3.0
) (5 %2.5 ) (2
%1.0 .
- 74 -
)(11
67
135
33.2
66.8
202
%100
) (11 ) (135
%66.8
) (67 %33.2 .
)(12
5
5 10
10 15
15 20
20
5
46
66
62
18
5
2.5
22.8
32.7
30.7
8.9
2.5
202
%100
) (12 ) (66
%32.7 10 15
) (62 %30.7
15 20
) (46 %22.8
5 10 ) (18 %8.9
20 ) (5
%2.5 5 )(5
- 75 -
%2.5
.
)(13
67
135
33.2
66.8
202
%100
)(14
72
61
42
17
10
35.6
30.2
20.8
8.4
5.0
202
%100
) (14 ) (72
%35.6
) (61 %30.2
) (42 %20.8
) (17 %8.4
.
- 76 -
) (10 %5.0
.
:
" :
"
:
)(15
39
30
47
1.0
14.9
23.3
41.6
29
44
94
35
14.4
21.8
46.5
17.3
42
113
37
0.5
4.0
20.9
56.2
18.4
12
32
109
48
0.5
5.9
15.8
54.0
23.0
20
133
40
4.5
9.9
65.8
19.8
40
96
63
1.5
19.8
47.5
31.2
35
100
65
84
19.3
2.37
0.990
87.356
**0.000
2.33
0.927
52.218
**0.000
2.12
0.765
196.189
**0.000
2.05
0.824
178.050
**0.000
1.99
0.691
189.485
**0.000
1.92
- 77 -
1.87
0.752
0.722
90.950
104.020
**0.000
**0.000
6
7
1.0
17.3
49.5
32.2
2.09
0.462
** 0.01
) 2.09 (5 )
1.86 (2.60
.
0.01 .
) 1.87 (2.37
) (
) (2 6 4 1 7 5 3
:
- 78 -
.1 ) (3 " "
) 1.87
(5
.
.2 ) (5 "
"
) 1.92 (5
.
.3 ) (7 "
"
) 1.99 (5
.
.4 ) (1 "
"
) 2.05 (5
.
- 79 -
.5 ) (4 "
"
) 2.12 (5
.
.6 ) (6
"
) 2.33 (5
.
.7 ) (2 "
"
) 2.37 (5
.
" :
"
- 80 -
)
(
:
- 81 -
)(16
11
10
15
7.5
12
83
41.7
57
35
17.6
46
52
26.1
61
14
7.0
21
6.1
28.9
23.4
31.0
10.7
20
10.2
14
31
15.7
41
47
23.9
37
86
43.7
87
13
6.6
23
6.9
20.3
18.3
43.1
11.4
28
45
101
24
1.5
13.9
22.4
50.2
11.9
35
41
92
31
0.5
17.5
20.5
46.0
15.5
19
42
105
26
4.0
9.5
21.0
52.5
13.0
12
6.0
2
25
12.5
21
33
16.5
51
88
44.0
103
42
21.0
24
1.0
10.4
25.4
51.2
11.9
6
3.0
1
12
6.1
7
44
22.2
30
82
41.4
123
54
27.3
40
0.5
3.5
14.9
61.3
19.9
** 0.01
- 82 -
3.17
1.114
83.387
**0.000
2.89
1.124
48.457
**0.000
2.79
1.108
85.614
**0.000
2.68
1.128
78.792
**0.000
2.43
0.925
137.184
**0.000
2.42
0.968
108.300
**0.000
2.39
0.966
147.250
**0.000
2.39
1.128
84.150
**0.000
2.37
0.863
153.005
**0.000
2.16
0.994
98.869
**0.000
10
2.03
0.731
238.776
**0.000
11
2.52
0.529
) 2.52 (5 ) 1.86
(2.60
)1428 (
.
0.01 .
) 2.03 (3.17
) /(
) (4 11 6 1
:
- 83 -
.1 ) (1 " "
) 3.17 (5
.
.2 ) (6 " "
) 2.89 (5
.
.3 ) (11 " "
) 2.79 (5
.
.4 ) (4 "
"
) 2.68 (5
.
) (10 2 7 5 3 8 9
:
- 84 -
.1 ) (9 "
"
) 2.03 (5
.
.2 ) (8 "
) 2.16 (5
.
.3 ) (3 "
"
) 2.37 (5
.
.4 ) (5 " "
) 2.39 (5
.
.5 ) (7 " "
) 2.39 (5
- 85 -
.
.6 ) (2 "
"
) 2.42 (5
.
.7 ) (10 "
"
) 2.43 (5
.
" :
"
:
- 86 -
)(17
58
27
94
20
0.5
13.5
29.0
47.0
10.0
2.48
0.868
133.250
**0.000
12
71
97
21
0.5
5.9
35.1
48.0
10.4
17
52
113
18
2.38
0.772
170.178
**0.000
1.0
8.4
25.7
55.9
8.9
2.37
0.801
196.267
**0.000
43
25
105
27
1.0
12.4
21.3
52.0
13.4
2.36
0.899
150.277
**0.000
11
58
115
16
5.5
29.0
57.0
8.0
57
112
23
1.0
4.0
28.2
55.4
11.4
11
39
119
31
1.0
5.4
19.3
58.9
15.3
10
31
128
31
1.0
5.0
15.3
63.4
15.3
** 0.01
- 87 -
2.32
2.28
2.18
0.700
0.755
0.790
2.13
0.762
2.31
0.563
139.320
203.693
213.050
253.693
**0.000
**0.000
**0.000
**0.000
)2.31
(5 ) 1.86 (2.60
.
0.01 .
) 2.13 (2.48
) (
) (5 3 2 1 4 6 7 8
:
.1 ) (8 " "
) 2.13 (5
.
- 88 -
.2 ) (7 " "
) 2.18 (5
.
.3 ) (6 " "
) 2.28
(5
.
.4 ) (4 " "
) 2.32
(5
.
.5 ) (1 "
"
) 2.36 (5
.
.6 ) (2 "
"
) 2.37 (5
- 89 -
.
.7 ) (3" "
) 2.38
(5
.
.8 ) (5 "
"
) 2.48 (5
.
" :
"
:
- 90 -
)(18
)(
2
1.0
105
79
10
52.2
39.3
5.0
2.5
62
114
30.8
56.7
4.5
4.5
3.5
69
93
24
34.3
46.3
11.9
4.5
3.0
77
83
14
21
38.5
41.5
7.0
10.5
2.5
49
89
44
16
24.4
44.3
21.9
8.0
1.5
62
56
60
21
30.8
27.9
29.9
10.4
1.0
37
83
50
25
18.6
41.7
25.1
12.6
2.0
27
83
46
31
14
13.4
41.3
22.9
15.4
7.0
35
39
52
58
17
17.4
19.4
25.9
28.9
8.5
4.39
- 91 -
231.711
**0.000
4.07
0.919
223.154
4.04
0.956
149.821
**0.000
4.03
1.051
137.000
**0.000
3.82
0.942
110.517
**0.000
3.77
1.033
73.254
**0.000
3.39
** 0.01
0.781
**0.000
3.62
0.992
1.113
3.08
1.232
3.80
0.541
87.407
69.920
25.443
**0.000
**0.000
**0.000
) 3.80
(5 ) 3.41 (4.20
.
0.01 .
) 3.08 (4.39
) /
(
) (3 "
)( " ) 4.39
(5 )(
.
- 92 -
) (4 6 7 1 5 2
:
.1 ) (2 "
"
) 4.07 (5
.
.2 ) (5"
" )4.04
(5
.
.3 ) (1 " "
) 4.03 (5
.
.4 ) (7 "
"
) 3.82 (5
.
- 93 -
.5 ) (6 "
" )3.77
(5
.
.6 ) (4" "
) 3.62 (5
.
)8
(9 :
.1 ) (8 "
"
) 3.39 (5
.
.2 ) (9 "
"
) 3.08 (5
.
- 94 -
" :
"
: :
" " ) One
(Way ANOVA
:
)(19
" " ) (One Way ANOVA
1.379
0.345
41.101
192
0.214
42.480
196
0.141
0.035
55.116
192
0.287
55.258
196
1.832
0.458
61.811
192
0.322
63.643
196
0.796
0.199
56.923
191
0.298
57.719
195
1.611
0.173
0.123
1.423
0.668
0.974
0.228
0.615
0.05 )
,
- 95 -
(
10 20
.
: :
"
" ) (Independent Samples T-TEST
:
)(20
" " ) (Independent Samples T-TEST
67
135
2.1855
2.0471
0.52342
0.42367
1.880
0.063
67
135
2.5814
2.4878
0.53081
0.52665
1.187
0.237
67
135
66
135
2.4246
2.2549
3.7997
3.8036
* 0.05
- 96 -
0.63500
0.51773
0.40940
0.59596
2.031
0.049
*0.044
0.961
0.05
)
(
.
0.05
)
(
.
: :
"
" ) (Independent Samples T-TEST
:
- 97 -
)(21
" " ) (Independent Samples T-TEST
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
67
2.1791
0.52125
1.753
135
2.0503
0.42599
67
2.5707
0.53320
2.4931
0.52633
0.982
135
67
2.4190
135
66
0.055
0.51803
3.8182
0.41557
3.7946
0.59373
0.290
135
0.327
0.63598
1.928
2.2577
0.082
0.772
0.05 )
(
.
- 98 -
:
"
" ) (One Way ANOVA
:
)(22
" " ) (One Way ANOVA
1.214
0.303
41.779
197
0.212
42.993
201
0.911
0.228
55.244
197
0.280
56.155
201
1.602
0.401
62.217
197
0.316
63.819
201
1.136
0.284
57.352
196
0.293
58.488
200
1.431
0.225
0.812
1.268
0.970
0.519
0.284
0.425
0.05 )
- 99 -
(
.
: :
" "
) (One Way ANOVA
:
)(23
" " ) (One Way ANOVA
1.067
0.356
40.466
190
0.213
41.532
193
0.743
0.248
53.408
190
0.281
54.151
193
1.813
0.604
61.129
190
0.322
62.942
193
0.010
0.003
56.227
189
0.297
56.237
192
- 100 -
1.670
0.881
1.878
0.011
0.175
0.452
0.135
0.998
0.05 )
(
.
- 101 -
. - .
- 102 -
:
.
.
)
( :
- 103 -
(1
(2
(3
(4
(5
.
.
.
.
- 104 -
:
:
) (66 %32.7
.
) (44 %21.8
.
) (135 %66.8
.
) (66 %32.7
10 15
.
) (135 %66.8
) (72 %30.2
.
- 105 -
:
" :
"
.
:
.1 .
.2 .
.3 .
.4 .
.5
.
.6
.
.7 .
" :
"
.
- 106 -
:
.1 .
.2 .
.3 .
.4 .
:
.1 .
.2 .
.3 .
.4 .
.5 .
.6 .
.7 .
" :
"
.
- 107 -
" :
"
.
"
)( ".
:
.1 .
.2 .
.3 .
.4 .
.5 .
.6 .
:
.1 .
.2 .
- 108 -
" :
"
0.05 )
,
( .
0.05 )
( .
0.05 )
(
.
0.05 )
- 109 -
( .
0.05 )
( .
0.05 )
( .
- 110 -
:
-
)(
.
- 111 -
- 112 -
)2004( : .
) 1997( :
.
) 1991( :
.
) 1990( :
.
) 1990( :
.
)1994( :
) ( .
, .
: , ,
1423:.
) 1989(
.
) 1998(
1418/8/17 15 .
- 113 -
)1989(
.
) 1986(
) (10 ).(1
)1997( :
.
) (1995
:
) (4 )(3
1991 ) (
) . (1 2 31
)1995(
:
) (4 ).(3
)1995( : .
) 1995( :
.
) 2005(
: .
)1993(
) (45 ).(13
- 114 -
)1992(
:
.
)1990(
: .
) 1994( :
.
)1991( : .
)1999( : .
)1994(
: .
) 1993( : .
, )1990( " . " , , :
, ) , (41 ). (12
) 1997( : .
) 2003(
: .
) 1998( :
:
) (13 ). (26
- 115 -
, )1423(
, ,
) 1992(
) (5 ).(10
) 1989( )(46
) (1 2 .
) 2001(
:
.
)1998( : .
) 2010( :
.
)1989( :
) (3 ). (5
) 2003(
: .
)2005(
: .
)1997(
: .
- 116 -
)1992( :
.
)2001( . : .
) (1402 :
.
) 2001(
.
) (1995 :
.
)1992( :
.
)1420(
: .
) 2000(
:
.
, )2002(
, , :
.
)1992(
: .
- 117 -
) 2004(
: .
)2002( 1
: .
)2003(
12 -9 1424 .
)2009(
: .
)1996( : .
2005 ) ( .
)1428(
:
.
) 1993( :
.
) 2002(
) (7 ). (5
)1995( :
.
- 118 -
) 2001( : :
.
)2005(
:
.
) 1993(
.
)1992( : .
)1999(
: .
) 1996( :
.
)1986( :
.
)1423(
) (17 )(33
: .
- 119 -
:
:
)2009(
) 1428(
) 2005(
, )2003( "
,
)1423(
,
)1423(
, )2002( "
.
.
- 56 -
- 119 -
) ( 1
- 120 -
- 121 -
) (
1430 1431-
- 122 -
- 123 -
.
:
-1
-2
-3
-4
-5
] , , , , [
- 124 -
: :
)
( :
:
)
( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) (
-2 :
) ))
- )
- )
( ) ( - )
(-
- )
( - )
- 3 :
- 5
- 5 10)
10 ) 15 - 20
( - 15 20 )
(
(
5 :
)
( -
- )
- .....................
-6 :
- ) (
) (
) ( ) (
- 125 -
) (
: :
:
.
)
..................
( :
- 126 -
- 127 -
:
.
)
( :
10
11
12 ...................
- 128 -
:
.
) ( :
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9 ........................
- 129 -
:
.
) ( :
)(
4
5
6
7
8
10
...................
,,,,,,,,,
- 130 -
) ( 2
- 131 -
..
..
..
. .
. .
. .
10 .
11 .
12 .
13 .
14 .
15 .
- 132 -
)(3
- 133 -
:
.
) (P
.
- 134 -
: :
) ( :
-1 :
)
( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) (
-2 :
-
( - )
( - )
) ( -
( - )
( -
( -
- 3 :
- 5
- 5 10
( - 15 20
10 ) 15 - 20
5 :
)
( -
- )
- .....................
-6 :
- ) (
) ( ) (
) ( ) (
- 135 -
: :
:
.
) ( P :
........................................
- 136 -
:
.
) ( P :
10
11
12
..............................
- 137 -
:
.
) ( P :
...................
- 138 -
:
.
) ( P :
1
2
3
)(
5
6
7
8
9
10
................................
,,,,,,,,,
- 139 -