Las Atalayas Del Saber. Legitimación y Jerarquización Del Conocimiento Científico en Colombia (1990-2010)

! " # $
%

! !

! & !

! '

()
&

$

"*
!

!

$ &

!
% !
"
+ ,
- ,

% %
!

-

./ 0 !

*

1! 2

3 4! +
*

1!
"5

%

&! "

!"##$%
&$"$'

!"##$%&$"$'
(
()*

!

" # $ !%
! & $ '
' ($ ' # % %
) %* %' $ '
+ " % &
' ! #
$,
( $

- .
/

-

.
. !
0 1 .
( - % 1
/
- % %
% % % %
- % 2
1 --
1% % 2
3 $$$
4 5
5 " 6 5 7

8&)*93 +)
* !:!& ;!<%;;=>=& % "
5 35-
? !
* &
@ .

31 A>B=C8&)*93 +)
"D 0 & >B=C

5*6.68;2*-.621.;6*78.529.-.-2,8.<=.52+;89>.<<>9*;=2-*
27=.69.<=2?*6.68=2?G,*-*-E**,87=27>*;,87.<=*8+;*1*<=*
,>5627*;5*

5*<=;.<6>3.;.<:>.1*7,;.*-8.56C<9;8/>7-8*68;.762,8;*BG7
%*;*&*=2*7*A-;2*7*

"'-+(."h'
.'"'/,-" "h',(+%"'/,-" "h'
)g-.%("
%('" .+"h'%&)(% "-"&"%
)+(."h'%,+"'-g"('(%(&"

%8@EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8:@WE;<C8:@<E:@8:FDFG@C8I;<C8DF;<IE@Q8:@WE;<C
JK8;F

%8JK<:EFCF>U8J;<C88;D@E@JKI8:@WE;<C:FEF:@D@<EKF:@<EKU=@:F:FDF
GI8>DRK@:8<EC8:FE=@>LI8:@WE;<C:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MF:FCFD9@8EF

:FEF:@D@<EKF

+LGKLI8JPFKI8J=IFEK<I8J<E<C8><E:@8D@<EKF:@<EKU=@:F

JKI8K<>@8J;<>F9@<IEFG8I8C8C<>@K@D8:@WEPA<I8IHL@Q8:@WE;<C
)g-.%(""
%(+'/+'% '"&"'-(
"'-g"(,(+% '%( g%)"-%",&(( '"-"/(
'(%(&"

<C8bJF:@<;8;;<C:FEF:@D@<EKFcPJLJM8:@8D@<EKFJ:FE:<GKL8C<J

C:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MF:FDF8:FEK<:@D@<EKFbKI@;@D<EJ@FE8Cc

CIFC<HLUMF:F;<C8I8:@FE8C@;8;<:FEWD@:8<EC8GIF;L::@WE:@<EKU=@:8

)g-.%("""
)(+.'+"h'(%(+-"/
('("&"'-(,

L<JK@FE8IC8@D@K8:@WE;<CFJDF;<CFJ

"EM<EK8ILE8bI<MFCL:@WE:@<EKU=@:8c

<=<E;<IC8J<G@JK<DFCF>U8JCF:8C<J

('%.,"h'

"%"( +g

5<*+28.<.5*726*5-.;.+*F8-.5,878,262.7=8
:>.27?.<=20*98;:>.<.588;-.7*7A<.58.7<.F*7
I@<;I@:?'@<KQJ:?<

%8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE GIF:<JF ;< :I<8:@WE @II<;L:K@9C< 8 D8EL8C<J P =WIDLC8J
GI<<JK89C<:@;8J <J LEF ;< CFJ 8JG<:KFJ DRJ I<C<M8EK<J ;<EKIF ;< KF;8
:@<E:@8 <J <C =LE;8D<EKF ;< C8 :FEJKIL::@WE ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF :@<EKU=@:F

)F;IU8G<EJ8IJ<<E<CC8:FDFC8:FCLDE8M<IK<9I8CHL<D8EK@<E< L@;88
C8J:@<E:@8J
,@C8:FCLDE8M<IK<9I8C<J;S9@CC8:@<E:@8K@<E;<8<E:FIM8IJ<
8 ;<:8L@IJ8:@WEJF:@8C<JC8:FCLDE8M<IK<9I8CHL<J@IM<G8I8:FDGI<E;I8I <JKF
]:WDF<JK89C<:<IGIR:K@:8JHL<G<ID@K8EHL<C8@EM<JK@>8:@WEJ<P8JF9I<
JLJ :@D@<EKFJ G8I8 ELKI@I <C :L<IGF ;< C8J :@<E:@8J JF:@8C<J JK8 @EHL@<KL;
D< :FE;LAF 8 GC8EK<8I LE8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE JF9I< C8 D8E<I8 :FDF J< ?8

;<K<ID@E8;F C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE :@<EKU=@:8 <E FCFD9@8 <E C8J XCK@D8J ;FJ
;S:8;8J

&RJ 8CCR ;< C8 M<I@=@:8:@WE ;< CFJ ;8KFJ P :@=I8J HL< <M@;<E:@8E LE8
<JKI8K@=@:8:@WEG8IK@:LC8I-.P.7C8J:@<E:@8J:I<FHL<<CGIF9C<D8;<=FE;F
<JKR <E ;<K<ID@E8I :LRC<J ?8E J@;F CFJ J89<I<J :@<EKU=@:FJ @EJK@KL@;FJ <
@EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8;FJ <E EL<JKIF G8UJ
FE <CCF J< <JK89C<:<IU8 EF JFCF <C
?FI@QFEK< ;< A<I8IHLU8J J@EF K8D9@SE CFJ E@M<C<J ;< GF;<I :@<EKU=@:F
FLI;@<L 8 P JJ
HL< ?8E J@;F ;<K<EK8;FJ GFI ;@=<I<EK<J
@EJK@KL:@FE<J ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF P LE@M<IJ@;8;<J :FCFD9@8E8J
C J898E@Q8:@WE 8DGC@8J :8K<>FI@Q8;8J GFI ;@M<IJ8J
=FID8J ;< <O:CLJ@WE P ;<J@>L8C;8; HL< J< ;<J8IIFCC8E <E C8 JF:@<;8;
:FEK<DGFIRE<8C8:L8C<E<CRD9@KF<:FEWD@:FJ<8IK@:LC8GI@FI@K8I@8D<EK<
8 KI8MSJ ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< 9@<E<J @ED8K<I@8C<J 3LB<I=<C;
G8IK@I
;< 8CCU J< K<A<E C8J ;<J@>L8C;8;<J HL< ;8E =FID8 8C ,8695.@>< JF:@8C
:FEK<DGFIRE<F <EK<E;@;F SJK< :FDF ,*92=*52<68 ,8072=2?8 FD@E@F ;< C8
FI>8E@Q8:@WE JF:@8C P <JG8:@F ;< KI8EJ@:@WE <E ;FE;< KFD8E =FID8 C8J
I<C8:@FE<J ;< GF;E@K@MF <JK89C<:<DFEU8 <E C8
GIF;L::@WE C8 J<>I<>8:@WE <E <C 8::<JF P C8 ;<J@>L8C;8; <E C8 8GIFG@8:@WE
;<CFJ9@<E<J@ED8K<I@8C<J

JUGFI<A<DGCF<I8I;@P%8QQ8I8KFD<E:@FE8ELEEL<MFK@GF
;< KI898A8;FI<J 8C :L8C CC8D8E ,8072=*;2*-8 JFE KI898A8;FI<J HL< GIF;L:<E
9@<E<J @ED8K<I@8C<J DL:?8J M<:<J <E :FE;@:@FE<J ;< GI<:8I@<;8;
%8@EM<JK@>8:@WEJLI>@W:FDFKI898AF;<K<J@JG8I8FGK8I8CKUKLCF;<&8>UJK<I<E"EM<JK@>8:@WE<E
)IF9C<D8J ,F:@8C<J FEK<DGFIRE<FJ
%FJ GI@D<IFJ I<JLCK8;FJ ;< <JK8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE =L<IFE
GL9C@:8;FJ <E <C 'XD<IF ;< C8 I<M@JK8 G6*-*< ;< C8 .E@M<IJ@;8; <EKI8C ;< F>FKR MCF98C KFD8E;F :FDF <A< 8E8CUK@:F 8C>LE8J 8:K@M@;8;<J C89FI8C<J ;< >I8E
@DG8:KF K8C<J :FDF C8 <;@:@WE ;< C@9IFJ P I<M@JK8J C8 GIF>I8D8:@WE P
8E@D8:@WEPC8:I<8:@WE;<M@;<FAL<>FJGFIJLG8IK<LD8>8CC@ ?8:<
LE 8ERC@J@J <O?8LJK@MF ;<J;< 8C>LE8J :8K<>FIU8J D8IO@JK8J ;<C GIF:<JF ;<
:FE=@>LI8:@WE ;<C :8G@K8C@JDF :F>E@K@MF <OGC@:RE;FCF :FDF LE GIF:<JF
9@F<:FEWD@:F =@E8CD<EK< /<I:<CCFE< ?8:< LE 8ERC@J@J ;< C8J
I<C8:@FE<JJ8C8I@8C<J;<J;<C8;@M@J@WE@EK<IE8:@FE8C;<CKI898AF:F>E@K@MF<E<C
:8G@K8C@JDF:FEK<DGFIRE<F

JK8JKI8P<:KFI@8J8E8CUK@:8J<@EK<IGI<K8K@M8J;<CFJ8LKFI<JD<E:@FE8;FJEF
:FEJK@KLP<E LE8 bD8CC8c ;< C<:KLI8 ;<J;< ;FE;< J< ;<JGC@<>8 <JK< 8ERC@J@J
J@EFDRJ9@<EJFE<C<D<EKFJ;<:FEKI8JK<<EKI<C8J;@ERD@:8J<E;W><E8JP
C8J J@KL8:@FE<J >CF98C<J J@KL8:@FE<J SJK8J HL< EF J< GL<;<E ;<J:FEF:LI8:@WE ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE
:@<EKU=@:8
C :FEKI8I@F <J8J ;@ERD@:8J DLE;@8C<J :FEK<DGFIRE<8J
@EK<IM@<E<E<ECFI<C8:@FE8;F:FEC8J;<K<ID@E8:@FE<JG8I8C8GIF;L::@WE;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ P <E <C GFJ@:@FE8D@<EKF ;< LE K@GF ;< J89<I<J
JF9I<FKIFJ

%8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ <E FCFD9@8 <JKR <EKI<C8Q8;8 :FE C8J
EL<M8JGIR:K@:8J<:FEWD@:8JPJF:@8C<J;<FI;<E@EK<IE8:@FE8C<E;FE;<CFJ
GI<:<GKFJ ;<C E<FC@9<I8C@JDF ?8E 8=<:K8;F C8J I<C8:@FE<J ?LD8E8J ;<
D8E<I8 :8K<>WI@:8 G<IF ;@=<I<E:@8;8 J<>XE C8J 8JF:@8:@FE<J HL< J<
<JK89C<Q:8E<EKI<C8=<EFD<EFCF>U8<:FEWD@:8PGFCUK@:8
JK8D@I8;8?8:<
EK@<E;F<CRD9@KFGFCUK@:F:FDF<C:FEALEKF;<GIR:K@:8J8::@FE<JP;@J:LIJFJ:FE;L:<EK<J8
C8DFM@C@Q8:@WE;<JLA<KFJ>ILGFJF:FC<:K@MFJJF:@8C<JG8I8C8KI8EJ=@>LI8:@WEF:FEJ<IM8:@WE;<
C8J:FE;@:@FE<J;<<O@JK<E:@8F;<I<C8:@FE<JHL<JFE;<JLGIFG@88=<:K8:@WE<JK8DFM@C@Q8:@WE

LE88GIFO@D8:@WE8C8JFI@<EK8:@FE<JPGFJ@:@FE<J;<JLA<KF<EC8GIF;L::@WE
;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF P <E C8 <JKIL:KLI8:@WE ;< C8J :@<E:@8J 8 G8IK@I ;< CFJ
<E:L8;I<J E8II8K@MFJ P ;< C8J <JKI8K<>@8J ;@J:LIJ@M8J GL<JK8J <E ;@JGLK8
KF;F<CCFM@JKF;<J;<<C8I:?@MF;F:LD<EK8C;<CG<I@F;F;<:C8I8;FK8EKFG8I8
<CRD9@KFGFCUK@:F:FDF<C:@<EKU=@:F
CJ<EK@;F=@E8C;<C8;@J:LJ@WE8GLEK88
I<M@J@K8IC8<OG<I@<E:@8;<C8FI>8E@Q8:@WE;<C8GIF;L::@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ
;<C :8JF :FCFD9@8EF :FDF :FE;@:@WE ;< GFJ@9@C@;8; ?@JKWI@:8 8C K@<DGF HL<
<OGI<J@WE;<8IK@:LC8:@WE8C8J;@ERD@:8J>CF98C<J;<C:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MF

.EF ;< CFJ 8JG<:KFJ 8 GIF9C<D8K@Q8I <J HL< C8 :@<E:@8 8G8I<:< :FDF LE
GIF;L:KF 8:898;F HL< J< :L8EK@=@:8 J@E @DGFIK8I C8J ;@ERD@:8J ;< CFJ
GIF:<JFJ GI<:<;<EK<J
E <J8 D@I8;8 C8J JL9A<K@M@;8;<J ;<J8G8I<:<E ;<C
<JG<:KIF 8E8CUK@:F G8I8 ;8I G8JF 8C ;8KF P C8 :C8J@=@:8:@WE ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE
;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF :@<EKU=@:F I<C<>8 8 LE J<>LE;F GC8EF`:L8E;F J< C8J K@<E<
<E :L<EK8` C8J :FE;@:@FE<J GFCUK@:8J @EJK@KL:@FE8C<J 8:8;SD@:8J P
G<IJFE8C<J HL< @E=CLP<E <E ;@:?8 GIF;L::@WE
<J;< <JK8 G<IJG<:K@M8
<JKIL:KLI8C@JK8 <C :@<EKU=@:F EF <O@JK< <E K8EKF K8C JFCF <O@JK< JL GIF;L::@WE
JL GIF;L:KF C8 K<E;<E:@8 8 I<;L:@I C8 ;<J:I@G:@WE F <OGC@:8:@WE ;<C b<JK8;F
;<C8:@<E:@8c8=8:KFI<J<O:CLJ@M8D<EK<<:FEWD@:FJGFIEF;<:@IGLI8D<EK<
<JK8;UJK@:FJ <E ;FE;< CF bGLIFc J< <EK@<E;< :FDF CF bF9A<K@MFc ><E<I8 LE
M8:UF:FE:<GKL8C<E<C:L8C<C:@<EKU=@:F<Jb898E;FE8;Fc8C8J=L<IQ8J;<C8J
@EJK@KL:@FE<J HL< J< @DGFE<E JF9I< SC
C8 @EM<IJ8 <JG<:@=@:8I <C K@GF ;<
I<C8:@FE<JHL<J<:FEJKILP<E<ECFJ:<EKIFJ<@EJK@KLKFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WEJ@E
<JK89C<:<E<I8 LE I<;L::@FE@JDF HL<
;@=U:@CD<EK< <OGC@:8IU8 C8J KI8EJ=FID8:@FE<J ;< C8 :@<E:@8 DRJ 8CCR ;< C8J
G8IK@:LC8I<J @EK<I8::@FE<J <EKI< @EM<JK@>8;FI<J CC<M8;8J 8 :89F <E CFJ
<E:L<EKIFJ < @EK<I:8D9@FJ 8:8;SD@:FJ P :@<EKU=@:FJ 8JU :FDF C8J

GL<;< 8:FEK<:<EK<JHL<J<;<J8IIFCC8E8KI8MSJ;<C8J
CL:?8JGFCUK@:8JP8;D@E@JKI8K@M8J

%8 :FEAL>8:@WE ;< <JFJ =8:KFI<J JFE CFJ HL< GFJ@9@C@K8E P :FE=@>LI8E C8
:FEJKIL::@WE ;< :@<IK8J 8K8C8P8J :@<EKU=@:8J F:LG8;8J GFI 8HL<CCFJ HL@<E<J
K@<E<E LE8 GFJ@:@WE GI@M@C<>@8;8 ;<J;< ;FE;< GL<;<E FK<8I <C ?FI@QFEK<
8:8;SD@:F<@EK<C<:KL8C<JK8J8K8C8P8J8JLM<QD8I:8EC8J=IFEK<I8J<EKI<
CF HL< J< :FEJ@;<I8 :@<EKU=@:F P EF :@<EKU=@:F C<>UK@DF P EF C<>UK@DF
%FJ
:<EKIFJ ;< GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKF JFE 8KI8M<J8;FJGFILED<:8E@JDF
8IK@:LC8;FI;<C<>@K@D@;8;M@J@9@C@;8;<C:L8CJ<GL<;<I8JKI<8I8G8IK@I;<C8J
<JKI8K<>@8J ;@J:LIJ@M8J HL< <E JL :FEALEKF J< :FEJK@KLP<E <E LE8 FG:@WE
;<EKIF ;< M8I@8J GFJ@9C<J P HL< 8 JL M<Q ><E<I8E :@<IKF K@GF ;< GFCUK@:8J
GX9C@:8J 8CI<;<;FI ;<C K<D8 ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF P ;< C8 :@<E:@8
JK< I<:LIJF
;@J:LIJ@MF J< <JK89C<:< :FE GI<K<EJ@FE<J ;< M<I;8; ;< D8E<I8 HL< J<
:FEJK@KLP<:FDFXE@:FFI;<EGFJ@9C<G8I8<JK89C<:<I:WDF;<9<J<IG<EJ8;8
P <JKIL:KLI8;8 C8 :FEJKIL::@WE ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF
G8IK@I ;< <JKFJ 8JG<:KFJ
><E<I8C<J J< <M@;<E:@8 LE8 K<EJ@WE <EKI< CFJ G8IRD<KIFJ DLE;@8C<J ;< C8
GIF;L::@WE P D<;@:@WE :@<EKU=@:8 P C8J :8I8:K<IUJK@:8J GIFG@8J ;< EL<JKI8
JF:@<;8;:FEJ@;<I8;8J;<J;<EL<JKIFKI8J<>8I?@JKWI@:F

C D<:8E@JDF ;< C<>@K@D8:@WEM@J@9@C@Q8:@WE ;< J89<I<J ;<M@<E< <E C8
@EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8:@WE;<LEK@GF;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ:@<EKU=@:FJHL<J<<JK89C<:<
:FDF :FIFC8I@F ;< C8J :FE;@:@FE<J ;< GFJ@9@C@;8; ;< CFJ @EM<JK@>8;FI<J <E
;FE;<J<GFE<E<EK<EJ@WECFJGIF>I8D8J:@<EKU=@:FJ=I<EK<8CFJ<ELE:@8;FJ
GFCUK@:FJ
E<JK8K<EJ@WE<CGF;<I;<C8:FDLE@;8;:@<EKU=@:8?8J@;FC@D@K8;8
FLI;@<L 8CL;< 8C D@JDF GLEKF ;@:@<E;F CF J@>L@<EK< ^.E 8ERC@J@J HL< KI8K8I8 ;< 8@JC8I LE8
;@D<EJ@WEGLI8D<EK<bGFCUK@:8c<ECFJ:FE=C@:KFJGFIC8;FD@E8:@WE<E<C:8DGF:@<EKU=@:FJ<IU8K8E
I8;@:8CD<EK< =8CJF :FDF JL :FEKI8G8IK< DRJ =I<:L<EK< <C 8ERC@J@J HL< EF :FEJ@;<I8 J@EF C8J
;<K<ID@E8:@FE<JbGLI8JcPGLI8D<EK<@EK<C<:KL8C<J;<CFJ:FE=C@:KFJ:@<EKU=@:FJ_FLI;@<L9

EEL<JKIFG8UJCFJ8ERC@J@JJF9I<C8:@<E:@8PJLJGIF;L:KFJ<JKRE;<=@E@;FJD<KF;FCW>@:8P
:FE:<GKL8CD<EK<GFICFJ@EK<I<J<JGFCUK@:FJ;<HL@<E<J?8:<ECFJ8ERC@J@JLE<A<DGCF:C8IF<J<C
(9J<IM8KFI@F FCFD9@8EF ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8 ;< D8E<I8 HL< <E CFJ <JKL;@FJ P
GL9C@:8:@FE<J JF9I< <C :8DGF :@<EKU=@:F J< M@J@9@C@Q8E C8J GIF;L::@FE<J :@<EKU=@:8J `<E :C8M<
<JK8;UJK@:8`:FDF8I>LD<EKF;FD@E8EK<;<CFJI<JLCK8;FJ;<C8JGFCUK@:8JGX9C@:8J

8 C8 GFK<JK8; ;< C8 ;@=LJ@WE ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE :@<EKU=@:8 8JG<:KF <E <C :L8C
(%"'", `<EK@;8; HL< I<>LC8 C8 8:K@M@;8; :@<EKU=@:8 <E FCFD9@8` ?8
?<:?FSE=8J@J<ECFJXCK@DFJ8VFJ

J< GFJ@:@FE8D@<EKF ;< LEFJ J89<I<J JF9I< FKIFJ `KI8;L:@;F <E CF HL< ?<
;<EFD@E8;F C<>@K@D@;8;M@J@9@C@;8; ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF :@<EKU=@:F` I<JGFE;< 8
LE ?*,2*62.7=8 .92<=.685G02,8 :FDF @E<I:@8 ;< C8 @EJKILD<EK8C@Q8:@WE <E
CUE<8 :FE CFJ ?FI@QFEK<J ;< C8 DF;<IE@Q8:@WE ;<C JK8;F ;<JGC<>8;8 ;<J;<
CFJ 8VFJ <E FCFD9@8 P GIF=LE;@Q8;8 <E C8 ;S:8;8 ;<C ;<C J@>CF
G8J8;F

E C8 GI<J<EK< @EM<JK@>8:@WE J< @EK<IG<C8E CFJ ;@J:LIJFJ HL< ?8E ;8;F
GFJ@9@C@;8; 8 C8 ><E<I8:@WE ;< K@GFJ <JG<:U=@:FJ ;< GFCUK@:8J ;<EKIF ;< C8
GIR:K@:8 :@<EKU=@:8 <E FCFD9@8 P :FDF :FIFC8I@F ;< <CCF J< GC8EK<8 LE8
;@J:LJ@WE 8:<I:8 ;< C8J A<I8IHL@Q8:@FE<J P C8J GIR:K@:8J JF:@8C<J ><E<I8;8J
:FDF :FEJ<:L<E:@8 ;<C <EKI<:ILQ8D@<EKF ;< CFJ :FE;@:@FE8D@<EKFJ
<:FEWD@:FJPC8JK<:EFCF>U8J;<8;D@E@JKI8:@WE;<C:FEF:@D@<EKF LQDRE
<JK89C<:@;8JGFICFJ;@=<I<EK<JFI>8E@JDFJP<EK@;8;<JHL<@EK<IM@<E<E
<E <C ;<J8IIFCCF ;< C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE ;<EKIF ;<C :8DGF :@<EKU=@:F :FCFD9@8EF

%8 @EHL@<KL; :FECC<M8 8 I<M@J@K8I C8 GI8>DRK@:8 ;< CF GFCUK@:F P CFJ J89<I<J
@EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8;FJ<EEL<JKIFG8UJ<JKF:FDFLE8GFIK<:IUK@:F8C8ERC@J@J;<
C8 :FE=@>LI8:@WE ;< C8 <OG<I@<E:@8 :FCFD9@8E8 =I<EK< 8 CFJ =<EWD<EFJ
>CF98C<J HL< ?8E ;<K<ID@E8;F C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ ;<J;< C8
WGK@:8;<CE<FC@9<I8C@JDF

)8I8 89FI;8I <JK8 GIF9C<D8K@Q8:@WE ;< C8 :FEJK@KL:@WE ;<C :8DGF ;<
C<>@K@D@;8;;<C8GIF;L::@WE;<CJ89<I:@<EKU=@:F<EFCFD9@8D<?<J<IM@;F
;< C8J ?<II8D@<EK8J ;< C8 8IHL<FCF>U8 ;< &@:?<C FL:8LCK 8 <E K8EKF
FI@<EK8:@WED<KF;FCW>@:8G8I8:FEJKIL@I<JKIL:KLI8IP89FI;8I <C8I:?@MFEF
:FDF <E:L8;I< :FE:<GKL8C HL< 9LJ:8 EL<MFJ ;<J8IIFCCFJ 8 C8 CLQ ;<
8:FEK<:@D@<EKFJ CF:8C<J
E <JK< J<EK@;F C8 D8E<I8 ;< <DGC<8I C8
8IHL<FCF>U8 :FDF FG:@WE D<KF;FCW>@:8 G8I8 <C KI898AF ;< 8I:?@MF J<
=LE;8D<EKW<EC8L9@:8:@WE<@;<EK@=@:8:@WE;<^=FID8:@FE<J:FE:<GKL8C<J_
^F9A<KFJ_ ^<JKI8K<>@8J_ P ^K@GFJ ;< <ELE:@8:@WE_ G8I8 CL<>F GFE<ICFJ <E
K<EJ@WE 8 KI8MSJ ;< LE8 EL<M8 :F;@=@:8:@WE ;< CFJ ;F:LD<EKFJ <JK8 M<Q
@;<EK@=@:8E;F<C?@CF:FE;L:KFIPCFJ9L:C<J;<CFJ;@J:LIJFJHL<8CFC8I>F;<
;FJ ;S:8;8J :FE=@>LI8IFE C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ <E EL<JKIF G8UJ

%8 GIFG@8 :FEJKIL::@WE ;<C 8I:?@MF @DGC@:W LE <A<I:@:@F ;< @E;8>8:@WE P
9XJHL<;8;<CFJ;F:LD<EKFJI<HL<I@;FJPbJL=@:@<EK<JcG8I8J<>L@I<C:8D@EF
8E8CUK@:F :FE C8 :<IK<Q8 F :L8J@ :<IK<Q8 ;< I<LE@I C8 @E=FID8:@WE
I@>LIFJ8D<EK<
< KF;8J D8E<I8J <C GIFG@F 8I:?@MF 8:KLW :FDF >LU8 <E JL
:FE=@>LI8:@WEGL<J<EF:8J@FE<JC8C<:KLI8;<LE;F:LD<EKF@E<M@K89C<D<EK<
CC<M8988C89XJHL<;8PGFJK<I@FIC<:KLI8;<FKIFHL<CF:FDGC<D<EK898FCF
<OGC@:898
JU C8 KI8;@:@FE8C GIR:K@:8 ;< I<8C@Q8I LE :FIK< * 9;28;2 ;< CFJ
I<>@JKIFJFGI< J<C<::@WE;<C8;F:LD<EK8:@WEG8I8C8@EM<JK@>8:@WE8EK<J;<
89FI;8I <C 8ERC@J@J :FE:<GKL8C EF =L< J<>L@;8 <E <JK< :8JF
C :FEJK8EK<
<EI@HL<:@D@<EKF ;<C 8I:?@MF EF JFCF D< G<ID@K@W 8DGC@8I <C ?FI@QFEK< ;<
8ERC@J@J <J ;<:@I 898I:8I K@GFJ ;< <ELE:@8:@WE HL< EF ?89U8 GI<M@JKF
@E@:@8CD<EK< J@EF HL< K8D9@SE 8V8;@W GIF=LE;@;8; 8 C8J :FEJKIL::@FE<J
:FE:<GKL8C<J ;< CFJ <ELE:@8EK<J <E <C J<EK@;F HL< G<ID@K@W <EKI<K<A@:FJ<:@D<EK8<EKFE:<JJF9I<<C8I:?@MF<E;FE;<J<
<EKI<:ILQ8E
C8J
:8K<>FIU8J
:FE:<GKL8C<J
;<
D8E<I8
EF
C@E<8C
:IFEFCW>@:8D<EK< ?89C8E;F J@EF DRJ 9@<E 8K<E;@<E;F 8 CFJ SE=8J@J P

J@>E8KLI8J <D8E8;FJ ;< CFJ ;@J:LIJFJ <E <JG8:@FJ P K@<DGFJ ;@M<IJFJ

FDF J< D<E:@FEW 8EK<I@FID<EK< LE GI@DL@<EK<J G8C89I8J 8:<I:8 ;<C KI8K8D@<EKF ;<C 8I:?@MF ^C ?@JKFI@8;FI
EF <C@>< ;< DF;F :8JL8C F 8I9@KI8I@F JLJ ;F:LD<EKFJ ;< C8 D8J8 @E;<K<ID@E8;8 < @E<IK< ;<C
8I:?@MFSCJ@>L<<C?@CFJLK@C<@E8G8I<EK<;<C8JJ@>E8KLI8JHL<<O@><E8HLUP8?FI8JLC<:KLI8_
>8D9<E

GI@D<I8 :8K<>FI@Q8:@WE F :F;@=@:8:@WE ;< CFJ <ELE:@8;FJ L9@:8;FJ <E <C

8I:?@MF :FE 98J< <E CFJ :L8KIF <A<J ;< C8 8IHL<FCF>U8 =FL:8LCK@8E8
D<E:@FE8;FJ G8I8 CL<>F ;@I@>@ID< ?8:@8 C8 J<>LE;8 :F;@=@:8:@WE <E ;FE;<
KFDS C8J :8K<>FIU8J :FE:<GKL8C<J <C89FI8;8J K<E@<E;F <E :L<EK8 CFJ
F9A<K@MFJ < ?@GWK<J@J ;< C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE P ;< C8J :L8C<J GL;< 8M@QFI8I <E
DRJ ;<K8CC< C8J EF:@FE<J @;<8J P :FE:<GKL8C@Q8:@FE<J HL< J< <E:FEKI898E
;@JG<IJ8J8CFC8I>F8E:?FPGIF=LE;F;<C8I:?@MF
JK8J<>LE;8:F;@=@:8:@WE
K8D9@SE D< G<ID@K@W FI>8E@Q8I D@ GIFG@8 8I>LD<EK8:@WE P :FE:I<K8I <C
<A<I:@:@F;<<J:I@KLI8<C:L8CJL<C<J<I<CDRJ8E>LJK@FJFP:FDGC@:8;FG8I8
C8D8PFIU8;<CFJ@EM<JK@>8;FI<J

C KI898AF ;< 8I:?@MF P JL ?<ID<ESLK@:8 D8I:8E <E <JK8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE LE8
G<IJG<:K@M8 HL< J< ;<D8I:8 ;< CFJ <JKL;@FJ HL< J< ?8E I<8C@Q8;F <E
FCFD9@8
)FI LE C8;F D< ;@JK8E:@F ;< C8 :L8EK@=@:8:@WE ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE
:@<EKU=@:8 8 G8IK@I ;< CFJ ;8KFJ <JK8;UJK@:FJ J@E LE :IL:< :FE C8J
8GI<:@8:@FE<J<OG<I@<E:@8JK<EJ@FE<JPI<C8:@FE<J;<CFJ8:KFI<J<J;<:@I
8G<C8E;F8C:>DG<IFEF8C,G68G
<A
(P-P(%"'",
GFI FKIF C8;F D< 8C<AF ;< C8J G<IJG<:K@M8J HL< 8GLEK8E 8 C8
:FDGI<EJ@WE ;< C8 :@<E:@8 P ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF :FDF 8IKU=@:<J ;<C ;<J8IIFCCF
8JLD@<E;F8:IUK@:8D<EK<<JK8EF:@WEP;<JC@>RE;FC8;<JL<E:L8;I<JF:@8CP
GFCUK@:F98AFLEGLEKF;<M@JK8/>7,287*52<=*HL<<J<EK<E;@;F;<J;<C898J<
;< C8 78;6*52B*,2G7 :@<EKU=@:8 :=I
RI;<E8J &8C;FE8;F
JK<
K@GF ;< <JKL;@FJ ?8:<E G8IK< ;< 8HL<CCFJ HL< J< ;@JK8E:@8E LE K8EKF ;<
G<IJG<:K@M8Jb:IUK@:8JcCFJ:L8C<J

"EK<EK8E 8GC@:8I CFJ D8I:FJ <C89FI8;FJ GFI ;@M<IJ8J :FII@<EK<J
?<><DWE@:8J 8 E@M<C @EK<IE8:@FE8C 8 CFJ F9A<KFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE <E
DSI@:8 %8K@E8
E 8C>LEFJ :8JFJ C8 8GC@:8:@WE ;< <JKFJ DF;<CFJ
8E8CUK@:FJ J< I<8C@Q8 :FE LE <J=L<IQF ;< 8;8GK8:@WE 8 CFJ :FEK<OKFJ
JF:@8C<J CF HL< ?8 ;8;F CL>8I 8 :@<IKFJ 8ALJK<J :FE:<GKL8C<J P
D<KF;FCW>@:FJ D@<EKI8J HL< <E FKIFJ J< I<8C@Q8 ;< =FID8 DRJ
D<:RE@:8
C>LEFJ <A<DGCFJ ;< <JKF XCK@DF J< ?8E GF;@;F F9J<IM8I
<E <C LJF ;< :FE:<GKFJ K8C<J :FDF <2<=.6* 7*,287*5 -. 2778?*,2G7
<8,2.-*-.<98<=68-.;7*<;.-.<,2.7=E/2,*<058+*52B*-*<=;295.1D52,.
PK8EK8JFKI8JHL<J<8GC@:8E:FEGF:8I<=C<O@WEJF9I<JL8;<:L8:@WE
8CFJF9A<KFJCF:8C<JI<CC8EFP$I<@D<I

C GI<J<EK< K<OKF :FEK@<E< KI<J :8GUKLCFJ
C GI@DFIU8J :FE:<GKL8C<J 8LJ:LCK8E;F
:8;8 LEF ;< CFJ <ELE:@8;FJ HL< ;<K<ID@E8IFE <C HL<?8:<I :@<EKU=@:F
L9@:RE;FCFJ <E ;@=<I<EK<J E@M<C<J 8E8CUK@:FJ ?8JK8 I<:FDGFE<ICFJ <E JL
;<M<E@I;@J:LIJ@MF

E <C 8GUKLCF "" 8E8C@QF CF <OGL<JKF <E <C :8GUKLCF 8EK<I@FI 8 G8IK@I ;< CFJ
<C<D<EKFJ :FE:<GKL8C<J ;< GIFGL<JK8J K<WI@:8J HL< 89FI;8E <C K<D8 ;< C8
:@<E:@8 P C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ <E C8 JF:@<;8; :FEK<DGFIRE<8

HLU 9LJ:F @EK<IG<C8I 8C>LE8J ;< C8J ;<K<ID@E8:@FE<J P ;<J8IIFCCFJ ;< C8
8:K@M@;8; :@<EKU=@:8 ;<I@M8;FJ ;< CFJ <ELE:@8;FJ P I<>LC8:@FE<J GFCUK@:8J
K<E@<E;F:FDFD8KI@QCFJGFJKLC8;FJ;<CFJ<JKL;@FJJF:@8C<JJF9I<C8:@<E:@8
P C8 :IUK@:8 8C :8G@K8C@JDF :F>E@K@MF HL< J< ?8 M<E@;F ;<JGC<>8E;F ;<J;<
?8:<M8I@FJ8VFJ<E;@=<I<EK<JC8K@KL;<J

C 8GUKLCF """ 8>ILG8 C8J I<=C<O@FE<J JLI>@;8J CL<>F ;< ?89<E<I8C G8I8 LE8 ><E<I8:@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ
D<EFJ 9LIF:I8K@Q8;8 P DRJ 89@<IK8 8 C8J GIR:K@:8J EF :FDG<K@K@M8J
JK8
GIFGL<JK8 C8 :L8C ?< ;<EFD@E8;F ,;.*,2G7 ,85*+8;*=2?* -. ,878,262.7=8<

9LJ:8 CC8D8I C8 8K<E:@WE JF9I< CFJ <C<D<EKFJ HL< ;<J;< <C J898:@WE:@<EKU=@:8J<
9LJ:8<EKFE:<JGIFG@:@8IC8<D<E:@8;<EL<M8JGIR:K@:8JHL<EF<JKSE
:<EKI8;8J <E 8JG<:KFJ KS:E@:FJ9LIF:IRK@:FJ F <O:CLJ@M8D<EK< C@>8;FJ 8
G8IRD<KIFJ<:FEFD@:@JK8J

*,2.7,2*A<>9;8->,,2G7-.9.7-.7.70;*76.-2-*-.58<6*;,8<985E=2,8<
D<=8<9>.-.7;.->,2;5*.52627*;5*,868=*6+2D7.<=26>5*;5*A;.8;2.7=*;5*9*;*
<.;?2;6.38;58<27=.;.<.<7*,287*5.<
(IC8E;F8CJFI;8

E J< 89I< G8I8 FCFD9@8 LE8 EL<M8 <K8G8 <E JL ?@JKFI@8 HL<
I<:FE=@>LI8 C8 <:FEFDU8 ;<C G8UJ ;< 8:L<I;F :FE DF;<CFJ E<FC@9<I8C<J
<OKI8EA<IFJ
JK<EL<MF;@I<::@FE8D@<EKF;<C8GFCUK@:8<:FEWD@:88=<:K8IU88
KF;FJ CFJ J<:KFI<J ;< C8 JF:@<;8; :FCFD9@8E8 <EKI< <CCFJ C8 GIF;L::@WE ;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJ
FE C8 @EJK8LI8:@WE ;< C8 8G<IKLI8 <:FEWD@:8 J<
@DGC<D<EK8E KF;8 LE8 J<I@< ;< GIF:<;@D@<EKFJ P D<:8E@JDFJ G8I8 C8
D<;@:@WE P C8 <M8CL8:@WE ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE :@<EKU=@:8 G<IF <JKFJ
GIF:<;@D@<EKFJJ<98J8E<ELE8I8:@FE8C@;8;<:FEWD@:8HL<8;AL;@:8M8CFI
8C :FEF:@D@<EKF ;< C8 D@JD8 D8E<I8 HL< <C :8G@K8C C< 8;AL;@:8 M8CFI 8 C8J
D<I:8E:U8J
JK< DFM@D@<EKF GIF;L:< LE8 EL<M8 I<C8:@WE <EKI< <C
:FEF:@D@<EKF P <C D<I:8;F <E ;FE;< <C GI@D<IF <J JL9JLD@;F GFI <C
J<>LE;F <J ;<:@I <C :FEF:@D@<EKF 8;HL@<I< C8J GIFG@<;8;<J ;< C8J
D<I:8E:U8JPJ<:FEJK@KLP<8JULEbD<I:8;F;<C8J@;<8JcHL<<J@DGLCJ8;F
;<J;< CFJ RD9@KFJ GFCUK@:FJ 8 KI8MSJ ;< C8J I<=FID8J C<>@JC8K@M8J 8 C8

<;L:8:@WE P C8 @DGC<D<EK8:@WE ;< J@JK<D8J ;< D<;@:@WE P ;< :FEKIFC 8 C8J
8:K@M@;8;<J;<:@<E:@8PK<:EFCF>U8

<9< <EK<E;<IJ< <JK< DFM@D@<EKF ;< @EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8:@WE :FDF LE <J=L<IQF
=@E8C;<:FE:<G:@WEC@9<I8C?8:@8C8DF;<IE@Q8:@WE;<CJK8;F@E@:@8;8<EC8
;S:8;8 ;<C ;<C J@>CF G8J8;F
< ?<:?F :FDF CF D<E:@FE8 #@DSE<Q
(:8DGF CFJ KI898AFJ P <JKL;@FJ JF:@8C<J ;< CFJ @EK<C<:KL8C<J <E
FCFD9@8 ;<J;< CFJ XCK@DFJ 8VFJ ^J< ;<;@:8E 8 I<8C@Q8I C8 M@>@C8E:@8 P
<M8E><C@Q8:@WE JF9I< C8 E<:<J@;8; ;< :FDGC<K8I <C GIFP<:KF ;<
DF;<IE@Q8:@WE;<CJK8;F%@9<I8C_<JK<:FEALEKF;<8ERC@J@JJ<:<EKI8<ECF
HL<#@DSE<Q (:8DGF;<EFD@E8.5;.<,*=.-.5<=*-8

FDF8I>LD<EK8<JK<8LKFICFJ<JKL;@FJHL<;<J;<C8J:@<E:@8JJF:@8C<JJ<
;<J8IIFCC8IFE <E C8 ;S:8;8 ;<C ;<C J@>CF G8J8;F JF9I< C8 M@FC<E:@8 P C8
>L<II8 <E FCFD9@8 89FI;8IFE :8K<>FIU8J HL< GI<J<EK8IFE DF;<CFJ
8E8CUK@:FJ ;< C8 b=8CK8c b@E:8G8:@;8;c b;<IILD98D@<EKFc F b;@JCF:8:@WEc ;<C
JK8;F
JK8J G<IJG<:K@M8J J< <E:L8;I8E <E C8 :FE=@>LI8:@WE ;<C JK8;F
%@9<I8C@;<8CLEJK8;FHL<<EFCFD9@8J<>XE<JFJDF;<CFJ<JK8988XE
<E:FEJKIL::@WE

28 <E C8 ;S:8;8 ;< CFJ :FDF J< M<IR 8 :FEK@EL8:@WE J< GIF;L:< LE8
8DGC@80*66*;<;@JGFJ@K@MFJ;@J<V8;FJG8I8HL<C8:@<E:@8PC8K<:EFCF>U8
FG<I<E :FDF G@C8I<J XCK@DFJ <E C8 DF;<IE@Q8:@WE ;<C JK8;F 8JU GL<J C8
FI>8E@Q8:@WE 8;D@E@JKI8:@WE P GIF;L::@WE ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF :@<EKU=@:F <E
FCFD9@8 =L<IFE G<EJ8;8J P ;@J<V8;8J G8I8 :FDGC<K8I ;@:?F F9A<K@MF
@E@:@8;F <E ;S:8;8J 8EK<I@FI<J
E :FEJ<:L<E:@8 J< @EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8IFE P
C<>@K@D8IFE G8I8D<KI@Q8:@FE<J ;< C8 8:K@M@;8; :@<EKU=@:8 :FCFD9@8E8 ;<J;<
D8KI@:<J E<FC@9<I8C<J C8J :L8C<J 8:KL8IFE :FDF GI<J:I@G:@FE<J 8EK< C8
GI<:8I@<;8;;<LEJK8;F<E>L<II8

E <JK< :8GUKLCF GI<J<EKF CFJ <E:L8;I<J E8II8K@MFJ HL< ;@I<::@FE8IFE C8J
GIR:K@:8J @EM<JK@>8K@M8J P :@<EKU=@:8J <E EL<JKIF G8UJ 8 G8IK@I ;< C8J GFCUK@:8J
GX9C@:8JJF9I<:@<E:@8PK<:EFCF>U88JU:FDFC8@DGC<D<EK8:@WE:I<8:@WEF
I<GIF;L::@WE;<;@JGFJ@K@MFJPK<:EFCF>U8J<JG<:U=@:8JG8I8C88;D@E@JKI8:@WE
;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF
)8I8 DFJKI8I <JK< ;<JGC@<>L< ?< 8:L;@;F 8C 8ERC@J@J ;<
:L8KIFE@M<C<J;<8::@WE <C72?.5-2<,>;<2?8I<=<I@;F8CFJ:FE:<GKFJHL<
J< <C89FI8IFE 8CI<;<;FI ;< C8 :@<E:@8 P K<:EFCF>U8 ;<J<89C<J <E EL<JKIF
G8UJ <E ;FE;< J< @EMFCL:I8E C8J EF:@FE<J ;< ;<J8IIFCCF P GIF>I<JF :FDF
D@KFJ;<C8JF:@<;8;:FEK<DGFIRE<8C@>8;FJ8C8:FDG<K@K@M@;8;@EEFM8:@WE
<EK<E;@;8 :FDF <C ;<9LC8:@WE:FDFDSKF;FJF
D<AFI:FDFK<:EFCF>U8J;<8;D@E@JKI8:@WE;<C:FEF:@D@<EKFGFIG8IK<;<CFJ
>F9@<IEFJ :<EKI8C<J <C 72?.5 ;.0>5*=2?8 <E <C :L8C J< <E:L<EKI8E C8J
<JKI8K<>@8J <OGCU:@K8J ;< >F9@<IEF G8I8 C8 ;<K<ID@E8:@WE P ><JK@WE ;< C8
:@<E:@8 P <C 72?.5 -. <>+3.=2?*,2G7 I<=<I@;F 8C GFJ@:@FE8D@<EKF ;< CFJ
JLA<KFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ ;<J;< JLJ GIFG@8J GIR:K@:8J P <ELE:@8;FJ CFJ :L8C<J
G<ID@K<E <JK89C<:8:@WE :@<EKU=@:8 P JLJ 98J<J
JF:@8C<J

!$'$'

.EF;<CFJ<ELE:@8;FJ;@J:LIJ@MFJHL<J<;<JGC<>8IFE:FED8PFI 8DGC@KL;
;<J;< C8 I8:@FE8C@;8; GFCUK@:8 <E EL<JKIF G8UJ =L< <C ;< C8 EF:@WE ;<C
;<J8IIFCCF 8XE EF 8C:8EQ8;F SJK< 8:FDG8V8;F ;<C GIF>I<JF :FDF @;<8C
JF:@8C
JK8 I<=<I<E:@8 8C 8E?<CF GFI J<>L@I LE GIF>I<JF @>L8C 8C ;< FKIFJ
G8UJ<JJ<98J8<EC8:I<<E:@8<ELE<JK8;F;<b@E:FDGC<K@KL;c;<J;<<C:L8C
J< L9@:8IU8E KF;8J C8J ;<JM<EK8A8J <:FEWD@:8J P :LCKLI8C<J =I<EK< 8 FKIFJ

G8UJ<J HL< ?8E 8C:8EQ8;F C8 b>CFI@8c ;< JLJ K@<DGFJ

)8I8 ;@JD@EL@I <JK8J
;<JM<EK8A8J<C;@J:LIJFGFCUK@:FJ<<E=F:W<EHL<<I8E<:<J8I@F<EGI@D<I8
D<;@;8 8C:8EQ8I <C D@JDF ;<J8IIFCCF :@<EKU=@:F P K<:EFCW>@:F ;< CFJ G8UJ<J
@E;LJKI@8C@Q8;FJ :FE CF :L8C J< ;@JD@EL@IU8E KF;8J C8J 9I<:?8J <E;W><E8J

JU C8 I<JGFEJ89@C@;8; G8I8 C8 bJ8CM8:@WEc F :L8E;F D<EFJ C8
KI8EJ=FID8:@WE E8:@FE8C J< ;<C<>898 <E >I8E G8IK< 8 CFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ <
@EM<JK@>8;FI<JHL@<E<J;<9U8E8GI<E;<I8;FGK8IPI<GIF;L:@ICFJ:FE:<GKFJ
C8JKS:E@:8JPC8JD<KF;FCF>U8J;<JLJ:FC<>8J;<FKIFJG8UJ<J<EK<E;@;8J
:FDF LE :FEALEKF ;< <C89FI8:@FE<J P GIR:K@:8J HL< J<>XE CFJ <ELE:@8;FJ
GFCUK@:FJJ<<E:FEKI898E<ELE<JK8;FDRJ8M8EQ8;FHL<<CGIFG@F

%8@;<8HL<C8:@<E:@8PC8K<:EFCF>U8JFE8C>F8JU:FDFC8G8E8:<8G8I8<C
bJL9;<J8IIFCCFc P C8 JFCL:@WE 8 C8 ;<G<E;<E:@8 I<JG<:KF 8 G8UJ<J ;< FKI8J
C8K@KL;<J J< GL<;< <E:FEKI8I P8 ;<J;< C8 <OGFJ@:@WE ;< DFK@MFJ G8I8 C8
8GIF98:@WE;<C8%<P;< I<8C@Q8;8 GFI CFJ &@E@JKIFJ ;< !8:@<E;8P
IS;@KF )X9C@:F P ;< ;L:8:@WE ;< 8HLSC <EKFE:<J
%8 JL9:FD@J@WE ;< C8
RD8I8 ;< +<GI<J<EK8EK<J HL< <JKL;@W ;@:?8 <OGFJ@:@WE 8M8CW CFJ
:FE:<GKFJHL<8CCUJ<GI<J<EK8IFE

%8 JL9:FD@J@WE <JKL;@W C8 <OGFJ@:@WE ;< DFK@MFJ ?<:?8 GFI CFJ
J<VFI<J&@E@JKIFJP:FDG8IK<C8JI8QFE<JHL<CFJ8E@D8E8GI<J<EK8I
C8GIFGL<JK8
CC8JJ<GL<;<EJ@EK<K@Q8I<E?8:<I;<C8@<E:@8P;<C8
-<:EFCF>U8EFP8<C<D<EKFJ8C<8KFI@FJJ@EF=8:KFI<J<JKI8KS>@:FJG8I8
<C ;<J8IIFCCF ;<C G8UJ <E KF;FJ CFJ :8DGFJ RD8I8 ;<
+<GI<J<EK8EK<J

%8 @;<8 ;< C8 :@<E:@8 :FDF ^=8:KFI <JKI8KS>@:F ;<C ;<J8IIFCCF <E KF;FJ CFJ
:8DGFJ_ J< =LE;8D<EK8 <E <C ;@J:LIJF ;<C 8KI8JF ><E<I8;F GFI C8
;<G<E;<E:@8 EF JFCF <:FEWD@:8 J@EF K8D9@SE :LCKLI8C <E <JK< J<EK@;F C8
:I<<E:@8J<<E=F:8<EHL<C8:@<E:@8PC8K<:EFCF>U8EFJFCFEFJJ8:8IU8E;<C

JL9;<J8IIFCCF J@EF HL< K8D9@SE EFJ MFCM<IU8 DRJ 8M8EQ8;FJ P D<EFJ

;<G<E;@<EK<J:LCKLI8CD<EK<?89C8E;F

L8E;F J< 89FI;8 C8 GIF9C<DRK@:8 <:FEWD@:8 JF:@8C P 8XE :LCKLI8C
;<C G8UJ =I<:L<EK<D<EKEFJ ;< GI<F:LG8:@WE <C =<EWD<EF ;< C8 ;<G<E;<E:@8 45
.EG8UJ<J;<G<E;@<EK<<:FEWD@:8D<EK<:L8E;FEFGL<;<GI<J:@E;@I
;<CJ<:KFI<OK<IEFJ@EHL<JL8G8I8KFGIF;L:K@MFJ<M<8:FDGIFD<K@;F
8 =FE;F
%8 ;<G<E;<E:@8 <:FEWD@:8 8 JL M<Q <J I<JLCK8EK< ;< C8
;<G<E;<E:@8 K<:EFCW>@:8 P LE8 P FKI8 <JKRE 8 C8 98J< ;< C8
;<G<E;<E:@8:LCKLI8CRD8I8;<+<GI<J<EK8EK<J P

%8 EF:@WE ;<C 8KI8JF P <C D@KF ;<C GIF>I<JF ?8E J@;F LE8 :FEJK8EK< <E <C
;@J:LIJF GFCUK@:F JF9I< C8 :@<E:@8 P C8 K<:EFCF>U8 <C J<EK@;F ;< C8 :@<E:@8
;<J;< C8 GFCUK@:8 J< :<EKI8 <E C8 E<:<J@;8; ;< 8C:8EQ8I <C GIF>I<JF
M@E:LC8E;F CFJ F9A<K@MFJ ;< C8 C89FI :@<EKU=@:8 8 C8 :FE:<G:@WE ;<J8IIFCC@JK8
:FEK<DGFIRE<8
JK8G<IJG<:K@M8?8I<:FII@;FCFJ<ELE:@8;FJ;<CFJ;<98K<J
G8I8 C8 =FIDLC8:@WE ;< GFCUK@:8J GX9C@:8J G8I8 <C =FD<EKF ;< C8 :@<E:@8 P C8
K<:EFCF>U8

%FJ GFE<EK<J :FDG8IK@DFJ UEK<>I8D<EK< C8J I8QFE<E 4J@:5 ;<
:FEM<E@<E:@8 <OGL<JK8J <E C8 <OGFJ@:@WE ;< DFK@MFJ ;<C GIFP<:KF ;<
C@8J G8I8 <C ;<J8IIFCCF K<:EFCW>@:F P C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE <E
FCFD9@8:FDFLE=8:KFI;<K<ID@E8EK<G8I8J8C@I;<C8KI8JFP8IK@:LC8I
C8<:FEFDU8E8:@FE8C<E<C:FEK<OKF;<CDLE;FDF;<IEFRD8I8;<
+<GI<J<EK8EK<JJG

E <JK< <EKI8D8;F ;< <ELE:@8;FJ GFCUK@:FJ J< :FE=@>LI8 8C :FEF:@D@<EKF
:FDF @EJKILD<EKF <JG<:@8C@Q8;F G8I8 C8 GIF;L:K@M@;8; P <C 8C:8E:< ;<C
GIF>I<JF

E C8J <:FEFDU8J DF;<IE8J C8 XE@:8 =FID8 ;< CF>I8I C8
:FDG<K@K@M@;8; >CF98C 8 C8I>F GC8QF <J HL< <C :FEF:@D@<EKF ;@E8D@:<
CFJ =8:KFI<J GIF;L:K@MFJ <E =FID8J I<C<M8EK<J G8I8 C8 ><E<I8:@WE ;<
@E>I<JF M8CFI 8>I<>8;F
JU J< >8I8EK@Q8 C8 M@89@C@;8; P I<EK89@C@;8;
;< C8 <JKIL:KLI8 GIF;L:K@M8 KF;8 M<Q HL< C8 GIF;L::@WE
KI8EJ=FID8:@WE
8;8GK8:@WE
KI8EJD@J@WE
<
@EEFM8:@WE
;<C
:FEF:@D@<EKF GIF;L:< <O:<C<EK<J ;@M@;<E;FJ

FE KF;F C8J =8CC8J ;<C
D<I:8;F :FEKI@9LP<E 8 HL< CFJ E@M<C<J ;< @EM<IJ@WE <E -" EF J<8E
CFJ WGK@DFJ GIF9C<D8 HL< J< F9J<IM8 :FE I@>FI <E G8UJ<J :FDF
FCFD9@8RD8I8;<+<GI<J<EK8EK<JJG

&RJ 8CCR ;<C =FIK8C<:@D@<EKF ;< C8 :@<E:@8 P C8 ><E<I8:@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ
:FDF :FEKI@9L:@WE 8 C8 I<;L::@WE ;< C8J 9I<:?8J JF:@8C<J J< ><JK@FE8 LE8
:@<E:@8 <E=F:8;8 <E CFJ @;<8C<J ;<C D<I:8;F <E FKI8J G8C89I8J J< GFJKLC8
LE8 FEKFCF>U8 <:FEFD@:@JK8 ;< C8 :@<E:@8 <E ;FE;< J< <EKI<:ILQ8E CFJ
F9A<K@MFJ ;< C8 :@<E:@8 P ;<C D<I:8;F :FE <C GIFGWJ@KF ;< CC<M8I 8 :89F C8
KI8EJ@:@WE @EM<JK@>8:@WE GIF;L:K@M@;8; GIF>I<JF
JK8 @EK<II<C8:@WE D<;@8;8
GFI<CD<I:8;F<J<CF9A<K@MF?8:@8<C:L8C8GLEK8ECFJ@EJKILD<EKFJGFCUK@:FJ
;@J<V8;FJG8I8C8><JK@WE;<C8:@<E:@8<EFCFD9@8<JKFJ<?8:<<OGCU:@KF
:L8E;F <E C8 GFE<E:@8 G8I8 J<>LE;F ;<98K< ;< C8 RD8I8 ;<
+<GI<J<EK8EK<JG8I8C88GIF98:@WE;<C8%@:F

"E;LJKI@8C<JP<DGI<J8I@FJGL<;<E:FEKI@9L@I8CGIF>I<JF;<C8@EM<JK@>8:@WE<EC8JLE@M<IJ@;8;<JP
:<EKIFJ ;< <EJ<V8EQ8 K<:EFCW>@:8 ;<C G8UJ_ (%"'", JG
%8 8EK<I@FI :@K8 <J LE
:C8IF <A<DGCF ;< :WDF <C ;@J:LIJF <JK89C<:< LE8 I<C8:@WE ;@I<:K8 <EKI< C8 LE@M<IJ@;8; :FDF
GIF;L:KFI8 ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ 8 KI8MSJ ;< C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE <E :@<E:@8 P C8 K<:EFCF>U8 <C @;<8C ;<
;<J8IIFCCF I<GI<J<EK8;F <E CFJ G8UJ<J @E;LJKI@8C@Q8;FJ P <C D@KF ;<C GIF>I<JF :FDF GIFD<J8 8
:LDGC@IGFID<;@8:@WE;<C8;@M@E8GIF;L:K@M@;8;:@<EKU=@:8

CFJ F9A<K@MFJ ;< <JK89C<:8C G8I8 C8 :FE=FID8:@WE ;< LE8
,F:@<;8; ;<C FEF:@D@<EKF <E <C G8UJ 8GFP8;F <E LE8 A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE ;< C8
:@<E:@8 C8 K<:EFCF>U8 P C8 @EEFM8:@WE -" G8I8 <C CF>IF ;<C ;<J8IIFCCF
<:FEWD@:F P JF:@8C RD8I8 ;< +<GI<J<EK8EK<J JG
%8 EF:@WE ;<
^JF:@<;8;;<C:FEF:@D@<EKF_`C8:L8CELE:8J<;<=@E<<OGCU:@K8D<EK<<ECFJ
;<98K<JK8EJFCFJ<<EK@<E;<:FDF<C=@ED@JDF;<EL<JKI8SGF:8Ì<D@K<8
LE8A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE;<CFJJ89<I<JP;<C8GIFG@88:K@M@;8;:@<EKU=@:8<E;FE;<
J<<JK89C<:<E:FDF;<J<89C<JPGI@FI@K8I@FJ8HL<CCFJHL<K@<E<ELE@DG8:KF
;@I<:KFJF9I<<CD<I:8;F:8G@K8C@JK8
%8@;<8HL<<JKR;<KIRJ;<<JK<K@GF;<
<ELE:@8;FJ<JHL<J@E:FEF:@D@<EKFEF?8P;<J8IIFCCF

/@M@DFJ <E LE8 SGF:8 <E C8 HL< <C :FEF:@D@<EKF P JLJ DXCK@GC<J
8GC@:8:@FE<J J< ?8E :FEM<IK@;F <E <C<D<EKFJ :<EKI8C<J ;<C ;<J8IIFCCF
;< C8 JF:@<;8;
%8 :@<E:@8 <EK<E;@;8 :FDF LE8 =FID8 ;< 8;HL@I@I
:FEF:@D@<EKFJFI@<EK8;FJ8:FDGI<E;<I<OGC@:8IPKI8EJ=FID8IK8EKF
8C J<I ?LD8EF :FDF 8C <EKFIEF HL< ?89@K8 ?8 ;<A8;F ;< J<I LE8
8:K@M@;8;;<@EK<ISJXE@:8D<EK<G8I8CFJ:@<EKU=@:FJ

%8 :@<E:@8 <J LE =8:KFI ;< :I<:@D@<EKF <:FEWD@:F
<9@;8D<EK<
FI@<EK8;8 J< KI8;L:< <E ;<J8IIFCCF P 9@<E<JK8I G8I8 CFJ GL<9CFJ
(%"'", JG

]*LS JL:<;< <EKFE:<J :FE C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE HL< EF <JKRE
M@E:LC8;8J ;@I<:K8D<EK< :FE CFJ GIF:<JFJ ;< GIF;L::@WE <:FEWD@:8 ]*LS
JL:<;<:FEC8J@EM<JK@>8:@FE<JJF:@8C<JHL<K@<E<EGFIF9A<KF:L8CHL@<IFKI8
^J:C8IFHL<C8J8:KL8:@FE<JGFCUK@:8JG8IK<E;<CI<:FEF:@D@<EKFHL<C8JF:@<;8;<EJL:FEALEKF
P JLJ CU;<I<J C< ?8:<E 8 CFJ K<D8J HL< :FEJ@;<I8E :IL:@8C<J
E <JK< J<EK@;F C8 GFCUK@:8 8HLU
<OGL<JK8J<<I@><:FDFG@C8IG8I8GFK<E:@8I8FCFD9@8:FDFLE8bJF:@<;8;;<C:FEF:@D@<EKFcP
8JU GF;<I :8G@K8C@Q8I CFJ I<:LIJFJ @EJK@KL:@FE8C<J @EK<C<:KL8C<J P E8KLI8C<J HL< GFJ<< G8I8
JFCL:@FE8IJLJGIF9C<D8J
45C;<J8IIFCCF;<LE8JF:@<;8;;<C:FEF:@D@<EKF@DGC@:8LE:8D9@F
:L8C@K8K@MF<E<CLJFP8GC@:8:@WE;<C8@E=FID8:@WEG8I8C8><E<I8:@WE;<EL<MFJ:FEF:@D@<EKFJ<C
:L8C ;<9< <JK8I 98J8;8 <E C8 <;L:8:@WE P <C 8GI<E;@Q8A<
%8 ><E<I8:@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKF P JLJ
DXCK@GC<J 8GC@:8:@FE<J JFE <C<D<EKFJ :<EKI8C<J G8I8 <C ;<J8IIFCCF <:FEWD@:F P JF:@8C ;< C8J
JF:@<;8;<J:FEK<DGFIRE<8JPJFE9RJ@:FJG8I8I<JGFE;<I8CFJI<HL<I@D@<EKFJPE<:<J@;8;<J;<
C8JF:@<;8;_(%"'",8P

:FJ8 D<EFJ =FIK8C<:I<JF F::@;<EK8C <J;< C8 G<IJG<:K@M8 <OGL<JK8 <JK8J
@EM<JK@>8:@FE<J EF J<IU8E GFCUK@:8D<EK< C<>UK@D8J G8I8 JW FKIF K@GF ;<
EF:@WEHL<@>L8CD<EK<I<;<=@E@IU8C88:K@M@;8;@EM<JK@>8K@M8<EJLJF9A<K@MFJ
<JK8EF:@WEHL<J<8JLD@W:FDFLECL>8I:FDXE;<EKIF;<C8:@<E:@8<JC8
@EEFM8:@WE

@:?8 EF:@WE ;< @EEFM8:@WE :F9IW LE8 =L<IQ8 @DGFIK8EK< <E CFJ F9A<K@MFJ
D@J@FE8C<J;<(%"'",8CGLEKFHL<<JK8GI@FI@;8;CFCC<MW8@DGLCJ8I
C8 :FDG<K@K@M@;8; ;<C J<:KFI GIF;L:K@MF :FDF LE8 8:K@M@;8; :<EKI8C DRJ HL<
GIFDFM<IP=FIK8C<:<IC88:K@M@;8;:@<EKU=@:8

,< ;<JK8:8 LE <J=L<IQF @DGFIK8EK< <E <C 8GFPF 8 GIFP<:KFJ ;<
@EEFM8:@WEP;<J8IIFCCF<DGI<J8I@8C45E<JK8;@ERD@:8J<I<=C<A8C8
@DGFIK8E:@8 FKFI>8;8 8C RD9@KF ;< C8 @EEFM8:@WE P ;<J8IIFCCF
K<:EFCW>@:F<E(%"'",
OGI<J@FE<J;<<JK8;@ERD@:8=L<IFE
C88G<IKLI8;<C8,L9;@I<::@WE;<"EEFM8:@WE-<:EFCW>@:8P<J8IIFCCF
DGI<J8I@8C <C =FIK8C<:@D@<EKF ;<C :FDGFE<EK< ;< @EEFM8:@WE
<E <C )IF>I8D8 (%"'", " """ <K8G8 C8 JL9J:I@G:@WE ;<
:FEM<E@FJ :FE <C ,' <C "" P <C FE;F '8:@FE8C ;< 8I8EKU8J C8
8G8I@:@WE ;< EL<M8J DF;8C@;8;<J ;< =@E8E:@8:@WE :FDF C8
:F=@E8E:@8:@WEP<C:8G@K8C;<I@<J>F(%"'", P

C @>L8C HL< C8 EF:@WE 9@E8I@8 GIF>I<JF;<J8IIFCCF C8 :<EKI8C@;8; ;< C8
@EEFM8:@WE P <C =FD<EKF <DGI<J8I@8C JF9I< C8 8:K@M@;8; :@<EKU=@:8 <

E<CG<I@F;F:FDGI<E;@;F<EKIU8 :FE:<EKI898 <E GIFP<:KFJ ;< @EEFM8:@WE P ;<J8IIFCCF K<:EFCW>@:F <E
GIFP<:KFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE<E:@<E:@8PK<:EFCF>U8 <EI<:LIJFJ?LD8EFJ<E;@MLC>8:@WE
:FDLE@:8:@WEPGFGLC8I@Q8:@WE;<C8:@<E:@8<E8;D@E@JKI8:@WE;<CJ@JK<D8<EGIFP<:KFJ
;< J@JK<D8J ;< @E=FID8:@WE <E :<EKIFJ ;< ;<J8IIFCCF K<:EFCW>@:F P <E 8GFPF 8 C8
:FDLE@;8; :@<EKU=@:8 I<>@FE8C
<C KFK8C ;< @EM<IJ@WE <E GIFP<:KFJ ;< @EEFM8:@WE =L<IFE
;<JK@E8;FJ8<DGI<J8JP:<EKIFJK<:EFCW>@:FJ8:<EKIFJ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WEEFLE@M<IJ@K8I@FJ
8LE@M<IJ@;8;<JGX9C@:8JP8LE@M<IJ@;8;<JGI@M8;8J(%"'", P

@EM<JK@>8K@M8 <E C8 ;@J:LIJ@M@;8; GFCUK@:8 K8D9@SE <JKLMF GI<J<EK< 8 CF C8I>F
;<CG<I@F;F8E8C@Q8;F
JUGFI<A<DGCFC8D8KI@Q;<GIF;L:KFJP8:K@M@;8;<J
;<:@<E:@8K<:EFCF>U8<@EEFM8:@WE<C89FI8;8<E<C;F:LD<EKF;<
;<C FEJ<AF '8:@FE8C ;< )FCUK@:8 :FEWD@:8 P ,F:@8C ('), M@E:LC8;F
8C <G8IK8D<EKF '8:@FE8C ;< )C8E<8:@WE ') GI<J<EK8 8::@FE<J
:FE:I<K8JG8I8<C@DGLCJF;<C8@EEFM8:@WEP;<@EM<JK@>8:@FE<J<E<CJ<:KFI
GIF;L:K@MF G<IF EF D<E:@FE8 8::@FE<J G8I8 <C =FD<EKF ;< @EM<JK@>8:@FE<J
C@>8;8J 8 C8J :@<E:@8J JF:@8C<J C8J :L8C<J =*6+2D7 ?8:<E G8IK< ;<C RD9@KF
:@<EKU=@:F ') P
)<IF DRJ 8XE J< @EKIF;L:< C8 EF:@WE ;<
^@EEFM8:@WE JF:@8C_ G8I8 GFE8:@WE <E :@<E:@8J JF:@8C<J P ?LD8E8J K@<E< LE G8G<C M@K8C
<E=FD<EK8IC8:8G8:@;8;;<:FEM@M<E:@8PCF>I8ILE:FEJ<EJFJF:@8C
CF JL=@:@<EK<D<EK< JWC@;F G8I8 HL< J< :I<<E C8J 98J<J ;< LE EL<MF
G8:KFJF:@8C
)8I8I<JGFE;<I8CFJ8EK<I@FI<J;<J8=UFJJ<I<HL@<I<HL<
C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE J< I<C8:@FE< :FE GIF:<JFJ ;< @EEFM8:@WE JF:@8C
FI@<EK8;FJ 8 ;<J8IIFCC8I <JKIL:KLI8J F 8II<>CFJ @EJK@KL:@FE8C<J DRJ
<=@:@<EK<J P <HL@K8K@MFJ 8JU :FDF D8I:FJ EFID8K@MFJ HL< I<=C<A<E CFJ
:8D9@FJ HL< J< <JKRE @EKIF;L:@<E;F <E 8JG<:KFJ K8C<J :FDF C8J
EL<M8J=FID8JHL<<JKRKFD8E;F<CG8G<C;<CJK8;FPJLJDF;FJ;<
8::@WE<EC8JF:@<;8;:FCFD9@8E8(%"'", JG

%8^@EEFM8:@WEJF:@8C_]GL<;<<EK<E;<IJ<:FDFLEE@M<CGI@D8I@FFC@D@K8;F
;<C8JKI8EJ=FID8:@FE<JJF:@8C<J]<JLE8EF:@WEHL<EF9LJ:8KI8EJ>I<;@I
<C<=*=>:>8,@<J8JU]<EKFE:<J<CG8G<C;<C8J:@<E:@8JJF:@8C<JJ<C@D@K88
C<>@K@D8I CF <JK89C<:@;F 8 G8IK@I ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ HL< I<GIF;LQ:8E `
b@EEFMRE;FC8Jc` C8J :FE;@:@FE<J JF:@8C<J <O@JK<EK<JE C8 <C89FI8:@WE ;<
%88J@D@C8:@WEPI<GIF;L::@WE;<<JK8J@E;<=@E@:@FE<JGFIG8IK<;<CFJGIFG@FJ:@<EKU=@:FJGFE<<E
<M@;<E:@8C88LJ<E:@8;<GFJKLI8J:IUK@:8JP;<I<=C<O@M@;8;=I<EK<8CFJ:FE:<GKFJ<C89FI8;FJ<E

;<K<ID@E8:@FE<J P ;< @E ;<=@E@:@FE<J JF9I< C8 :@<E:@8 I<8C@Q8;8 ;<J;< LE

CL>8I ;< <ELE:@8:@WE EF :@<EKU=@:F J< K@<E;< 8 G8J8I GFI 8CKF 8 I8QWE ;< C8
GI<DLI8F<C;<J:FEF:@D@<EKF:FE:<GKFJHL<JFE:<EKI8C<JG8I8C8JC89FI<J
;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE CF :L8C <J GIF9C<DRK@:F P DRJ 8XE :L8E;F <J8J @E
;<=@E@:@FE<JP;<K<ID@E8:@FE<JJ<<JK89C<:<E:FDFLE:FEALEKF;<EFID8JP
;< J@>E8KLI8J ;< FI;<E ALIU;@:F HL< <JK89C<:<E LE D8I:F <E <C J<EK@;F ;<
<ED8I:8:@WEC@D@K8:@WEC<>8C;<8::@WE

G8IK@I ;< <JK8J b<ED8I:8:@FE<Jc C8J LE@M<IJ@;8;<J P CFJ :<EKIFJ ;<
@EM<JK@>8:@WE JFE M@E:LC8;FJ ;@J:LIJ@M8 P GI8>DRK@:8D<EK< 8 GIR:K@:8J HL<
;<J9FI;8EJLIFC;<><E<I8;FI<J;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ<EK8EKF9@<E<JJF:@8C<J
G8I8 :LDGC@I :FE 8:K@M@;8;<J 8;@:@FE8C<J GIFP<:K8;8J ;<J;< CFJ G8IRD<KIFJ
<DGI<J8I@8C<J ;< 8::@WE
JU JL:<;@W GFI <A<DGCF :FE <C ;@J:LIJF ;< C8
:FDG<K@K@M@;8;@EEFM8:@WEHL<=L<@EF:LC8;F8C8JLE@M<IJ@;8;<JG8I8HL<J<
;<JGC<>8I8;<EKIF;<JLJ8:K@M@;8;<JD@J@FE8C<J

<C ,'P- 4,@JK<D8 '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U85 J< ;<I@MW <E
<C ,@JK<D8 '8:@FE8C ;< "EEFM8:@WE `,'"` :FE <C F9A<KF ;<
@DGC<D<EK8I LE8 <JKI8K<>@8 ;< ;<J8IIFCCF <DGI<J8I@8C FI@<EK8;8 8 C8

FKI8J C8K@KL;<J CFJ :L8C<J J< 8JLD<E :FDF <C<D<EKFJ ;< M<I;8; HL< ;<9<E >L@8I C8 8:K@M@;8;
:@<EKU=@:8
JK8 @II<=C<O@M@;8; P I<G<K@:@WE ;< EF:@FE<J J@E :FEK<E@;F 8G8I<:< <E C8J 8::@FE<J P
;@J:LIJFJ ;< CFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ GFI <A<DGCF G8I8;WA@:8D<EK< C8 :@K8 ;< (%"'", <OGL<JK8
8EK<I@FID<EK<JF9I<^@EEFM8:@WEJF:@8C_=L<I<G<K@;8K<OKL8CD<EK<J@EI<=<I<E:@88C>LE8 8VFJ
;<JGLSJ <E <C ;@J:LIJF ;< <EKI<>8 ;<C GI<D@F 8C DSI@KF :@<EKU=@:F <C ;@J:LIJF :FDGC<KF GL<;<
C<<IJ<<E?KKGI<J
LE@8E;<J
<;L
:FM@<N
G?G M@<N
G?G

E <C :L<I;F '\ ;< ;<C FEJ<AF '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8 J< 8;FGK8E C8J
;<=@E@:@FE<J;<^@EEFM8:@WE_^GIFP<:KF;<@EEFM8:@WE_P^GIFP<:KFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE:@<EKU=@:8P
K<:EFCW>@:8_;<CFJ&8EL8C<J;<(JCFPI8J:8KK@D8EL8C<JHL<JLI>@<IFE8G8IK@I
;<C8J:FE;@:@FE<JPE<:<J@;8;<J;<C=FD<EKF:@<EKU=@:FG8I8LIFG8M<IIKU:LCF \;<C:L<I;F
'\;<
%8:FEJ<:L<E:@8;<<JK88;FG:@WE8:IUK@:8<JHL<JLI><E;<=@E@:@FE<JK8LKFCW>@:8J
HL< <E I<8C@;8; ;<A8E J<I@FJ M8:UFJ :FE:<GKL8C<J GFI <A<DGCF C8 ;<=@E@:@WE ;< GIFP<:KF ;<
@EEFM8:@WE^CGIFP<:KF;<@EEFM8:@WEJ<;<=@E@IU8<EKFE:<J:FDF<C:FEALEKF;<8:K@M@;8;<J;<
@EEFM8:@WE:@<EKU=@:8JK<:EFCW>@:8JGIF;L:K@M8JFI>8E@Q8:@FE8C<J=@E8E:@<I8JP:FD<I:@8C<JHL<
I<8CD<EK< :FE;L:<E 8 C8 @DGC<D<EK8:@WE ;< @EEFM8:@FE<J_ IKU:LCF \ ;<C :L<I;F '\ ;<

C>FJ@D@C8IF:LII<:FEC8;<=@E@:@WE;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE9RJ@:8P8GC@:8;8C8:L8C=L<KFD8;8
;<C &8EL8C ;< I8J:8K@ ^C GI<J<EK< &8EL8C J< I<;8:KW GFI P G8I8 CFJ <OG<IKFJ ;< CFJ <JK8;FJ
D@<D9IFJHL<I<:F><EPGL9C@:8ECFJ;8KFJE8:@FE8C<JI<C8K@MFJ8C8"PI<D@K<E8C8(CFJ
I<JLCK8;FJ;<C8J<E:L<JK8J;<"_(

><E<I8:@WE ;< EL<MFJ GIF;L:KFJ P GIF:<JFJ 8 C8 8;8GK8:@WE

K<:EFCW>@:8 8 C8 :8G8:@K8:@WE 8M8EQ8;8 ;< KI898A8;FI<J P 8 C8
8;FG:@WE ;< :8D9@FJ <E C8 :LCKLI8 <DGI<J8I@8C
%F 8EK<I@FI :FE <C
GIFGWJ@KF ;< 27,;.6.7=*; 5* 9;8->,=2?2-*- A ,869.=2=2?2-*- -. 5*<
.69;.<*<A-.5<.,=8;9;8->,=2?87*,287*5<EJL:FEALEKF')
C8J:LIJ@M8JJFEDU8J

4C5 GI@E:@G8C F9A<K@MF 4;<C ,@JK<D8 '8:@FE8C ;< "EEFM8:@WE5 <J
GIFDFM@:F<E<CG8UJ
!8:<EG8IK<
;<SCCFJ8:KFI<JPLJL8I@FJ;<C8@EEFM8:@WEC8JI<;<J;<@EEFM8:@WE
G8I8 <C 8GI<E;@Q8A< CFJ GIF>I8D8J <JKI8KS>@:FJ <E RI<8J P J<:KFI<J
JF:@8C<J F GIF;L:K@MFJ ;< 27/;*.<=;>,=>;* 27<=2=>,287*5 9*;* 5*
27?.<=20*,2G7 P C8 GI<JK8:@WE ;< J<IM@:@FJ K<:EFCW>@:FJ P CFJ
@EJKILD<EKFJ ;< fE8E:@8D@<EKF ;< C8 @EEFM8:@WE (P-
C8J:LIJ@M8JJFEDU8J

JK8J ;FJ :@K8J J< :FDGC<D<EK8E P DL<JKI8E :WDF C8 @EEFM8:@WE `KSID@EF
HL< J< @;<EK@=@:8 GC<E8D<EK< :FE <C =8MFI<:@D@<EKF ;<C J<:KFI <DGI<J8I@8C`
<J C@>8;8 8 CFJ GIF:<JFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ 8 KI8MSJ ;< ^CFJ 8:KFI<J ;<
@E=I8<JKIL:KLI8 @EJK@KL:@FE8C G8I8 C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE_ <E ;FE;< CFJ D@<D9IFJ
;< LE@M<IJ@;8;<J P :<EKIFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE ;<9<E 8IK@:LC8I JLJ 8:K@M@;8;<J
;@I<:K8 < @E;@I<:K8D<EK< 8C @E:I<D<EKF ;< C8 GIF;L:K@M@;8; P :FDG<K@K@M@;8;
;<C J<:KFI GIF;L:K@MF E8:@FE8C
)<IF EF JFCF <JF <C ,@JK<D8 '8:@FE8C ;<
"EEFM8:@WE =L< :I<8;F <OGCU:@K8D<EK< G8I8 8GIFM<:?8I C8 8G<IKLI8
<:FEWD@:8;<DF;FHL<C8JLE@M<IJ@;8;<JP:<EKIFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE;<9U8E
8GFP8IP:FEJFC@;8I;@:?FDFM@D@<EKF<E<CJ@JK<D8<:FEWD@:F;<CG8UJ

M@;<EK<D<EK<<C8GFPF8C8@EEFM8:@WE?8J@;F;<J;<C8;S:8;8;<C<C<580*7<JK8K8CG8I8
;<C@D@K8I <C 8GFPF 8 C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J :@<EKU=@:8J
-8EKF 8JU HL< GFI <A<DGCF <E <C G<I@F;F
<C D8PFI GFI:<EK8A< ;< C8 @EM<IJ@WE KFK8C ;< (%"'", <E :@<E:@8 P K<:EFCF>U8 =L<
;<JK@E8;F 8 GIFP<:KFJ ;< @EEFM8:@WE P ;<J8IIFCCF K<:EFCW>@:F J<>L@;F ;< C8 @EM<IJ@WE <E
GIFP<:KFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE<E:@<E:@8PK<:EFCF>U8(%"'", `@>LI8'\

45LE:FDGFE<EK<@DGFIK8EK<;<C)IF>I8D84G8I8C8E;F><E@Q8:@WE
;< C8 @<E:@8 P C8 -<:EFCF>U85 <JK8IR FI@<EK8;F 8 ;<J8IIFCC8I P
:FEJFC@;8I LE ,@JK<D8 '8:@FE8C ;< "EEFM8:@WE <E <C HL< J< 8J<>LI<
LE8 D8PFI I<C8:@WE <EKI< LE@M<IJ@;8;<J P :<EKIFJ ;< ;<J8IIFCCF
K<:EFCW>@:F GFI LE C8;F P C8J <DGI<J8J ;<C J<:KFI @E;LJKI@8C P
8>IU:FC8GFI<CFKIF
JK8J8:K@M@;8;<J<JKRE<E:8D@E8;8J88GFP8IC8
DF;<IE@Q8:@WE ;<C J<:KFI <DGI<J8I@8C P 8 ;8IC< C8J ?<II8D@<EK8J
E<:<J8I@8J G8I8 <E=I<EK8I C8 8G<IKLI8 <:FEWD@:8 P CFJ D8PFI<J
I<HL<I@D@<EKFJ ;< :FDG<K@K@M@;8; HL< ;@:?F J<:KFI :FE=IFEK8
(%"'", JG

)<IF <C 8:FEK<:@D@<EKF ;<=@E@K@MF ;< ;FE;< <D@W @II<M<IJ@9C<D<EK< <C
<EKI<:ILQ8D@<EKF ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF :@<EKU=@:F P ;< C8 @EEFM8:@WE :FDF
G8IRD<KIF ;< C<>@K@D8:@WE =L< C8 :I<8:@WE ;<C ,@JK<D8 '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8
-<:EFCF>U8<"EEFM8:@WE,'-"<E<C:L8CJ<J<CCWPJ<EFID8C@QW`98AF<C
8M8C ALIU;@:F @II<;L:K@9C< < @E:L<JK@FE89C< ;< C8 =@ID8 GI<J@;<E:@8C` <C
=8MFI<:@D@<EKF <DGI<J8I@8C ;<EKIF ;< C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J D@J@FE8C<J ;< C8J
LE@M<IJ@;8;<J

G8IK@I ;< C8 M@><E:@8 ;< C8 GI<J<EK< %U8 8C HL< J< I<=@<I< <C <:I<KF ;< J<
;<EFD@E8IR,@JK<D8'8:@FE8C;<@<E:@8-<:EFCF>U8<"EEFM8:@WE`
,'-"`:FE<C=@E;<@EK<>I8IC8J8:K@M@;8;<J:@<EKU=@:8JK<:EFCW>@:8JP
;< @EEFM8:@WE 98AF LE D8I:F ;FE;< <DGI<J8J JK8;F P 8:8;<D@8
@EK<I8:KX<E <E =LE:@WE ;< CFJ =@E<J ;< C8 GI<J<EK< CU8 HL< ><E<I< I@HL<Q8 P HL<
=8MFI<Q:8 <C ;<J8IIFCCF <DGI<J8I@8C ;< C8 E8:@WE <J LE J@JK<D8
KI@<JK8D<EK8I@F <E ;FE;< KF;FJ K@<E<E :8J@ C8J D@JD8J =LE:@FE<J HL< ?8E

J@;F<JK89C<:@;8J;<J;<LECL>8I;<<ELE:@8:@WEGI<<D@E<EK<D<EK<GFCUK@:F
G8I8 G<I=@C8I 8 C8J LE@M<IJ@;8;<J P :<EKIFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE :FDF
@EJK@KL:@FE<J;<@EK<ISJ<:FEWD@:F

& ' &
% !' "

%8;S:8;8;<C;<CJ@>CFG8J8;FGL<;<J<I:8K8CF>8;8:FDFC8;S:8;8;<
C8EFID8C@Q8:@WE;<C8:@<E:@8F;S:8;8;<C8I8QWE:@<EKU=@:8<JKF;<9@;F8
HL< ;<J;< J< @EK<EJ@=@:8 GFI G8IK< ;<C >F9@<IEF :FCFD9@8EF C8
@EK<E:@WE ;< @EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8I <C :FEF:@D@<EKF <JG<:@8C@Q8;F GIF;L:@;F GFI
@EM<JK@>8;FI<J P :@<EKU=@:FJ ;< KF;8J C8J RI<8J P ;@J:@GC@E8J
28 <E J<
GIF;L:<<CGI@D<I8EK<:<;<EK<;<<JK<GIFGWJ@KF:L8E;F;LI8EK<<C>F9@<IEF
;</@I>@C@F8I:FJ<@EJK8C8C8&@J@WE;<@<E:@8P-<:EFCF>U8:FE<CF9A<K@MF
;< Î<M@J8I <C <JK8;F ;<C 8IK< <E C8 D8K<I@8 GIFGFE8E@Q8:@WE
@EJK@KL:@FE8C P GIFGFI:@FE8I LE D8I:F EFID8K@MF G8I8 <C ;<J8IIFCCF ;< <JKFJ
KWG@:FJ_')
C@E=FID<<EKI<>8;FGFI<JK8&@J@WE<E PC8
<OG<;@:@WE ;< C8 %U8,'P-<C:L8C<=<:K@M8D<EK<J<
:I<W<E 98AF<C<:I<KF;<

JU @E@:@8 <E EL<JKIF G8UJ LE8 :FEK@EL8 <OG<;@:@WE ;< ;F:LD<EKFJ
EFID8K@MFJ P :FE <CCFJ C8 :I<8:@WE ;< <EK<J DSKF;FJ P J@JK<D8J G8I8
I<>LC8I D<;@I P <M8CL8I C8 8:K@M@;8; :@<EKU=@:8 P K<:EFCW>@:8
JK8
EFID8K@M@;8;ALEKF:FECFJJ@JK<D8J@DGC<D<EK8;FJ:FEJK@KLP<E;FJK@GFJ;<
;@JGFJ@K@MFJ HL<J<:FDGC<D<EK8EGFILEC8;FCFJ-2<98<2=2?8<-2<,>;<2?8<
HLUD<I<D@KF8C8;<=@E@:@WE;<^;@JGFJ@K@MF_?<:?8GFIFL:8LCK<ELE8<EKI<M@JK8;<
^%F HL< KI8KF ;< @E;@:8I :FE <JK< EFD9I< <J <E GI@D8I LE :FEALEKF I<JL<CK8D<EK<
?<K<IF>SE<F HL< @E:CLP< ;@J:LIJFJ @EJK@KL:@FE<J @EJK8C8:@FE<J 8IHL@K<:KWE@:8J ;<:@J@FE<J
I<>C8D<EK8I@8J C<P<J D<;@;8J 8;D@E@JKI8K@M8J <ELE:@8;FJ :@<EKU=@:FJ GIFGFJ@:@FE<J =@CFJW=@:8J

;<JGC<>8;FJ <E :8;8 LE8 ;< C8J GFCUK@:8J GX9C@:8J I<JFCL:@FE<J 8:L<I;FJ
;<:I<KFJPC<P<JJF9I<:@<E:@8PK<:EFCF>U8GFIFKIFC8;FCFJ-2<98<2=2?8<-.
;.0>5*,2G7 :FE:<EKI8;FJ <E DSKF;FJ <EK<J GIF>I8D8J P J@JK<D8J :LPF
F9A<K@MF<J<A<I:<I8C>XEK@GF;<:FEKIFC;<EKIF;<:L8CHL@<I8;<CFJGIF:<JFJ
HL< ?8:<E G8IK< ;< C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE :@<EKU=@:8 P GIF;L::@WE
K<:EFCW>@:8
C:FEALEKF;<CFJ;@JGFJ@K@MFJD<E:@FE8;FJCFJ?<;<EFD@E8;F
=.,78580E*< -. *-6272<=;*,2G7 -.5 ,878,262.7=8
GFI :L8EKF J< GIF;LAF
;<J;< C8 @EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8:@WE ;< LE8 bK<:EFCF>@Q8:@WEc ALIU;@:8 P
I<>LC8K@M8HL<@E=CLPW;@I<:K8D<EK<<EC8J8:K@M@;8;<J:@<EKU=@:8J8G8IK@I;<C8
@DGC<D<EK8:@WE ;< JF=@JK@:8;FJ @EJKILD<EKFJ P D<KF;FCF>U8J G8I8 JL
D<;@:@WE<M8CL8:@WE F 9@<E D<;@8EK< C8 @EKIF;L::@WE F :I<8:@WE ;<
,87,.9=>*52B*,287.<
<ECFJ;@J:LIJFJHL<;<=@E@<IFEP;<C@D@K8IFE<CKI898AF
:F>E@K@MF

C ><ID<E ;< <JK8J K<:EFCF>U8J GL<;< J@:8 ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF J< <JG<:@=@:8 :FE C8 :I<8:@WE ;<
CFJ FE:< FEJ<AFJ '8:@FE8C<J ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8 :FDF

DFI8C<J =@C8EKIWG@:8J 9I<M<D<EK< CF ;@:?F P K8D9@SE CF EF ;@:?F SJKFJ JFE CFJ <C<D<EKFJ ;<C
;@JGFJ@K@MF
C;@JGFJ@K@MFD@JDF<JC8I<;HL<J<<JK89C<:<<EKI<<JKFJ<C<D<EKFJ_M8D9<E
<E"EK<IE<K

C :FE:<GKF ;< ^K<:EFCF>U8J ;< C8 8;D@E@JKI8:@WE_ <J LK@C@Q8;F GFI ,8E;IF #@DSE<Q (:8DGF
G8I8?8:<II<=<I<E:@88C8J8::@FE<JD<:8E@JDFJPGIF:<;@D@<EKFJ;@J<V8;FJ;<J;<LERD9@KF
;<GF;<I<JG<:U=@:FG8I8<C:FEKIFCP><JK@WE;<J@KL8:@FE<JJF:@8C<JP;<C8J8:KL8:@FE<J;<CFJ
JLA<KFJHL<?8:<EG8IK<;<SJK8J#@DSE<Q (:8DGF

HLU J< <EK@<E;<E C8J :FE:<GKL8C@Q8:@FE<J <E <C J<EK@;F HL< FL:8LCK ;8 8 C8 =FID8:@WE ;<
:FE:<GKFJ <J ;<:@I C8J I<C8:@FE<J HL< J< <E:L<EKI8E <E CFJ ;@J:LIJFJ JF9I< C8 GIF;L::@WE ;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJCF:L8C:FEJK@KLP<LE8I<;;<<ELE:@8;FJ?<:?88EWE@D8D<EK<<EC8;<=@E@:@WEP
<OGC@:@K8:@WE ;< CFJ HL<?8:<I<J 8IKUJK@:FJ GFCUK@:FJ :@<EKU=@:FJ <K:
;< LE8 SGF:8
E G8C89I8J
;< FL:8LCK ^J< KI8K8 ;< =@A8I 8JU :WDF GL<;<E CFJ <C<D<EKFJ I<:LII<EK<J ;< CFJ <ELE:@8;FJ
I<8G8I<:8E8I <E <OK<EJ@WE F <E ;<K<ID@E8:@WE MFCM@:8J 8;HL@I@I <E ;<JHL@K< EL<MFJ :FEK<E@;FJ
J<DREK@:FJ:FEJK@KL@I<EKI<<CCFJFI>8E@Q8:@FE<JG8I:@8C<J
JKFJ<JHL<D8JG<ID@K<E;<J:I@9@IEF
C8J C<P<J ;< :FEJKIL::@WE @EK<IE8 ;< CFJ :FE:<GKFJ EF JL >SE<J@J GIF>I<J@M8 < @E;@M@;L8C <E <C
<JGUI@KL;<LE?FD9I<J@EFJL;@JG<IJ@WE8EWE@D88KI8MSJ;<K<OKFJC@9IFJPF9I8J_8

JKFJJFE FEJ<AF;<C)IF>I8D8'8:@FE8C;<@<E:@8P-<:EFCF>U8;<C8,8CL;FEJ<AF
;<C )IF>I8D8 '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8J RJ@:8J FEJ<AF ;<C )IF>I8D8 '8:@FE8C ;<

FI>8E@JDFJ HL< ?8:<E G8IK< @EK<>I8C ;<C ,@JK<D8 '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8 P
-<:EFCF>U8 :8;8 FEJ<AF <JK8IU8 <E:8I>8;F ;< FI@<EK8I P 8J<JFI8I CFJ
C@E<8D@<EKFJ G8I8 C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ <E RI<8J <JG<:U=@:8J ;<C
J89I8D8J '8:@FE8C<J ;<
@<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8 ') JG
E <C 8VF J< I<>C8D<EK8IFE
<JKFJ FEJ<AFJ FKFI>8E;F C8 I<JGFEJ89@C@;8; ;< JL :I<8:@WE 8
(%"'", <:I<KF ;< G<IF ;<EKIF ;< JLJ =LE:@FE<J
><E<I8C<JJ<<JG<:@=@:8IFEC8J;<^;@I@>@I8J<JFI8IP:FFI;@E8IC8JGFCUK@:8J
<JKI8K<>@8J < @EJKILD<EKFJ_ ;< :8;8 LEF ;< CFJ )IF>I8D8J '8:@FE8C<J
<:I<KF ;< IKU:LCF
JU GL<J J< GL<;< ;<:@I HL< KF;8 C8
98J<GI8>DRK@:8;<J;<C8:L8CJ<:FEJKILP<IFECFJ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ;@J:LIJ@MFJP
;< I<>LC8:@WE J< <E:L<EKI8 <E C8 :C8J@=@:8:@WE ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF I<8C@Q8;8
;<J;<LECL>8I;<<ELE:@8:@WEGFCUK@:F

LI8EK< CFJ GI@D<IFJ 8VFJ ;< :FEJKIL::@WE ;< <JK8J K<:EFCF>U8J ALIU;@:8J P
8;D@E@JKI8K@M8J <C @EK<ISJ <JK898 GL<JKF <E C8 <JKIL:KLI8:@WE ;< CF HL<
GF;IU8DFJ CC8D8I <C 8E;8D@8A< G8I8 C8 C<>@K@D8:@WE ;< CFJ GIF:<JFJ P
GIF:<;@D@<EKFJ ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ
E <C :8JF
:FE:I<KF;<CFJ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ;@J:LIJ@MFJ;<J;<C8=FIDLC8:@WE;<C8%<P<E
?8JK8 M8I@FJ;<:I<KFJ=L<IFE<JK89C<:@;FJ:FE<J<=@E
C>LEFJ;<

"EM<JK@>8:@FE<J<EEU8P&@E<IU8FEJ<AF;<C)IF>I8D8'8:@FE8C;<@<E:@8P-<:EFCF>U8
>IFG<:L8I@8 FEJ<AF ;<C )IF>I8D8 '8:@FE8C ;< <J8IIFCCF -<:EFCW>@:F "E;LJKI@8C P 8C@;8;
FEJ<AF ;<C )IF>I8D8 '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8 ;<C &8I FEJ<AF ;<C )IF>I8D8
'8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8J ,F:@8C<J P !LD8E8J FEJ<AF ;<C )IF>I8D8 '8:@FE8C ;< JKL;@FJ
@<EKU=@:FJ <E ;L:8:@WE FEJ<AF ;<C )IF>I8D8 '8:@FE8C ;< @FK<:EFCF>U8 FEJ<AF ;<C
)IF>I8D8 '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8J ;<C &<;@F D9@<EKI8D8
'8:@FE8C ;< C<:KIWE@:8 "E=FIDRK@:8 P -<C<:FDLE@:8:@FE<J M8;FI<J P
<DGI<J8I@FJ
8AF JL ;@I<::@WE J< KI8Q8IFE CFJ GC8E<J <JKI8KS>@:FJ ;< CFJ FE:< GIF>I8D8J
C
GI@D<IF ;< <JKFJ <A<I:@:@FJ KLMF CL>8I <EKI<E 8 LE8 :FC<::@WE ;< FE:<
C@9IFJHL<=L<IFE;@JKI@9L@;FJ8C8J9@9C@FK<:8J;<KF;8JC8JLE@M<IJ@;8;<J;<CG8UJ
CJ<>LE;FJ<
I<8C@QW<EKI< P_(P-

JK8J :C8J@=@:8:@FE<J J< :FDGC<D<EK8E :FE FKI8J DRJ <JG<:@8C@Q8;8J HL< K@<E<E <=<:KFJ
;@I<:KFJJF9I<C8J8:K@M@;8;<J;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE<E:8;8RI<8;<:FEF:@D@<EKF
JUGFI<A<DGCFC8
:C8J@=@:8:@WE;<C:FEF:@D@<EKF;<C8J:@<E:@8JJF:@8C<JP?LD8E8JJ<>XEC8.',(J<:FDGFE<
;< ;@J:@GC@E8JHL<8JLM<QJ<;@M@;<E<E JL9;@J:@GC@E8JM<I(P-PJJ

CFJ 8JG<:KFJ JF9I<J8C@<EK<J ;< CFJ ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ ;@J:LIJ@MFJ :I<8;FJ ;LI8EK<

<JK<G<I@F;FJFECFJJ@>L@<EK<J

FID8J;<8JF:@8:@WEG8I8C8I<8C@Q8:@WE;<8:K@M@;8;<J:@<EKU=@:8JP<C
;<J8IIFCCF;<GIFP<:KFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE<:I<KF;<

GFPFJ =@E8E:@<IFJ G8I8 C8 =FID8:@WE ;< @EM<JK@>8;FI<J <E <C <OK<I@FI
<:I<KF;<

I<8:@WE ;<C FEJ<AF '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8 P
I<FI>8E@Q8:@WE;<(%"'",<:I<KF;<

&F;8C@;8;<J;<:FEKI8KFJG8I8<C=FD<EKF;<C8@EM<JK@>8:@WE:@<EKU=@:8
<:I<KF ;<

+<<JKIL:KLI8:@WE ;<C "EJK@KLKF FCFD9@8EF G8I8 <C <J8IIFCCF ;< C8
@<E:@8 P C8 -<:EFCF>U8 I8E:@J:F #FJS ;< 8C;8J (%"'",
<:I<KF;<

)8I8C<C8D<EK< 8 <JK8 =FID8:@WE ;@J:LIJ@M8 ;<J8IIFCC8;8 G8I8 C8 C<>@K@D8:@WE
;< C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ J< <JK89C<:@<IFE CFJ ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ ;<
I<>LC8:@WE ;< CFJ :L8C<J <C ,@JK<D8 '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8
,'P- J< <E:L<EKI8 <EKI< CFJ DRJ @DGFIK8EK<J GFI JL FI>8E@Q8:@WE P GFI
JLF9A<K@MF;<:<EKI8C@Q8IC8><JK@WE;<C8:@<E:@8<EEL<JKIFG8UJ

M@F C8 :I<8:@WE GIFG@8D<EK< ;@:?8 ;<C ,@JK<D8 :FE C8
GIFDLC>8:@WE;<C<:I<KF%<P5%2<=.6* *,287*5-.2.7,2*A
&.,78580E* .< >7 <2<=.6* *+2.;=8 78 .@,5>A.7=. -.5 ,>*5 /8;6*7
9*;=. =8-8< 58< 9;80;*6*< .<=;*=.02*< A *,=2?2-*-.< -. ,2.7,2* A
=.,78580E* 27-.9.7-2.7=.6.7=. -. 5* 27<=2=>,2G7 9H+52,* 8 9;2?*-* 8
-.5*9.;<87*:>.58<-.<*;;855.
%8;<=@E@:@WEK@<E<M8I@FJ<C<D<EKFJ
HL< D<I<:<E ;<JK8:8IJ< <J LE J@JK<D8 ;< 8:K@M@;8;<J EF ;<
@EJK@KL:@FE<J EF JFE C8J @EJK@KL:@FE<J K8C<J F :L8C<J F C8J G<IJFE8J
=LC8E8 P D<E>8E8 C8J HL< =FID8E G8IK< ;<C J@JK<D8 EF J< I<HL@<I<E
<JK8KLKFJ E@ :8IESJ J< I<HL@<I< ?8:U8J<?8:<G8IK<;<C,@JK<D8J@J<;<A8
;<8:KL8IJ<J8C<;<SC
'F<JLEJ@JK<D89LIF:IRK@:FJ@EFLEFG8I8
FI>8E@Q8IC88::@WE
J89@<IKFPEF<O:CLP<EK<
'8;@<GL<;<;<:@IHL<
:@<IKFK@GF;<8:K@M@;8;<J;<:@<E:@8PK<:EFCF>U8JFEDRJ;<J<89C<JP
GFI CF K8EKF ;<9<E <JK8I <E SC P HL< FKI8J JFE @E;<J<89C<J P ;<9<E
<O:CL@IJ<
C D@JDF K@<DGF J< ;<:C8IW C8 F9C@>8:@WE ;<C JK8;F ;<
8GFP8IC8:@<E:@8PC8K<:EFCF>U8@E;<G<E;@<EK<D<EK<;<C8@EJK@KL:@WE
GX9C@:8FGI@M8;8HL<C8J;<J8IIFCC<<J;<:@IJLF9C@>8:@WE<J8GFP8I
<C KI898AF G8I8 :FEF:@;FGFI<CFEJ<AF'8:@FE8C;<@<E:@8P-<:EFCF>U8
8;J:I@KF 8 C8 )I<J@;<E:@8 ;< C8 +<GX9C@:8
< <JK< FEJ<AF ?8:<E
G8IK< <C )I<J@;<EK< <C @I<:KFI ;<C <G8IK8D<EKF '8:@FE8C ;<
)C8E<8:@WE`')`:L8KIFD@E@JKIFJ:L8KIFI<:KFI<J;<LE@M<IJ@;8;<J
;FJ @EM<JK@>8;FI<J ;FJ <DGI<J8I@FJ P LE I<GI<J<EK8EK< ;< C8J
I<>@FE<J
,L=LE:@WE<J><E<I8IC8GFCUK@:8;<:@<E:@8PK<:EFCF>U8<E
KF;8 C8 E8:@WE P :FFI;@E8I CFJ <J=L<IQFJ
8AF <JK< <J:<E8I@F J< ?8E
GC8EK<8;FC8JGFCUK@:8J;<=@E8E:@8:@WE;<C8@EM<JK@>8:@WEHL<CC<M8IFE
8LE:I<:@D@<EKF<ECFJI<:LIJFJG8I8;@:?8J8:K@M@;8;<J8D<;@8;FJ
;<C8;S:8;8;<CEFM<EK8(P- P

E CFJ <ELE:@8;FJ ;@J:LIJ@MFJ J< ;@:< ;< <JK< ,@JK<D8 HL< <J ^89@<IKF <
@E:CLP<EK<_ G<IF <E JL D@JD8 ;<J:I@G:@WE FI>8E@Q8K@M8 J< <JK89C<:<
:C8I8D<EK< HL< <J 8CK8D<EK< :<EKI8C@Q8;F P HL< JU <JKR :FE=FID8;F GFI
@EJK@KL:@FE<J ;< D8E<I8 K8C HL< C8 ;<J:I@G:@WE LE K8EKF @;UC@:8 HL< J<
GI<J<EK8 :FII<JGFE;@<EK< 8 LE ^J@JK<D8 ;< 8::@FE<J_ <J K8E JFCF LE8
;<=@E@:@WEGIFG8>8E;UJK@:8DRJHL<LE8I<8C@;8;:FE:I<K8

)FIFKIFC8;F:FEC8@EKIF;L::@WE;<C8^@EEFM8:@WE_:FDF:FE:<GKL8C@Q8:@WE
HL<;<9<FI9@K8I8CI<;<;FI;<C8:@<E:@8J<<JK89C<:@WK8D9@SE8D<;@8;FJ
;<C8;S:8;8;<CFKIF;@JGFJ@K@MF<E:8I>8;F;<@DGC<D<EK8I8::@FE<JHL<
:FE;LA<I8E8<JK89C<:<IMUE:LCFJ<JKI<:?FJP=FID8C<J<EKI<<JK<:FE:<GKFP
C8@EM<JK@>8:@WE:@<EKU=@:8

,@JK<D8'8:@FE8C;<"EEFM8:@WE`,'"`@EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8;FGFI;<:@J@WE
;<CFEJ<AF'8:@FE8C;<@<E:@8P-<:EFCF>U8<EALC@F;<
JLE
DF;<CF :FC<:K@MF < @EK<I8:K@MF ;< 8GI<E;@Q8A< ;< 8:LDLC8:@WE P
8GIFG@8:@WE;<C:FEF:@D@<EKF<E<CHL<@EK<IM@<E<E;@M<IJFJ8><EK<J
:FDGIFD<K@;FJ :FE <C ;<J8IIFCCF K<:EFCW>@:F P :FE C8 GIF;L::@WE P
:FD<I:@8C@Q8:@WE ;< 9@<E<J P J<IM@:@FJ ;<EKIF ;< LE GIF:<JF ;<
9XJHL<;8 G<ID8E<EK< GFI C8 :FDG<K@K@M@;8; JFJK<E@9C@:F <E <C
G8UJ
!8:<E G8IK< ;< SC CFJ 8:KFI<J P LJL8I@FJ ;< C8 @EEFM8:@WE C8J
I<;<J ;< @EEFM8:@WE G8I8 <C 8GI<E;@Q8A< CFJ GIF>I8D8J <JKI8KS>@:FJ
<E RI<8J P J<:KFI<J JF:@8C<J F GIF;L:K@MFJ ;< @E=I8<JKIL:KLI8
@EJK@KL:@FE8C G8I8 C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE P C8 GI<JK8:@WE ;< J<IM@:@FJ
K<:EFCW>@:FJ P CFJ @EJKILD<EKFJ ;< =@E8E:@8D@<EKF ;< C8 @EEFM8:@WE
(P-

%L<>F ;< @DGC<D<EK8I ;@:?FJ ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ J< 8:FGC8IFE KS:E@:8J P
K<:EFCF>U8J <E:8D@E8;8J 8 C8 D<;@:@WE P <M8CL8:@WE ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE
:@<EKU=@:8J@E<D98I>F ;@:?8<M8CL8:@WE=L<G<EJ8;8J@DGC<D<EK<:FDFLE
D<:8E@JDF G8I8 I<>LC8I <C KI898AF :F>E@K@MF P G8I8 <C :FEKIFC ;< C8
GIF;L::@WE :@<EKU=@:8 D8J EF :FDF LE GIF:<;@D@<EKF HL< ;S :L<EK8 ;< CFJ
8JG<:KFJ JLJ:<GK@9C<J ;< D<AFI8D@<EKF
E <JK< J<EK@;F LE8 ;< C8J
K<:EFCF>U8J HL< J< ;<J8IIFCCW ;LI8EK< C8 ;S:8;8 ;<C =L< C8 :@<E:@FD<KIU8
:FDF ;@JGFJ@K@MF ;< A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE HL< J< ;<JGC<>W IRG@;8D<EK< <E KF;8J

C8J8:K@M@;8;<J;<@EM<JK@>8:@WEPJ<GFJ@:@FEW:FDFC8=FID8GI@M@C<>@8;8P
C<>UK@D8 ;< <M8CL8:@WE :@<EKU=@:8
%8 @EKIF;L::@WE ;< CFJ G8IRD<KIFJ
:@<E:@FDSKI@:FJ P 9@9C@FDSKI@:FJ 8 C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J GIFG@8J ;<C KI898AF
:@<EKU=@:F J< <M@;<E:@8 <E LE8 ;< C8J I<:FD<E;8:@FE<J I<8C@Q8;8J GFI C8
CC8D8;8&@J@WE;<J89@FJ<EJL@E=FID<

M8CL8I<C;<J8IIFCCF:@<EKU=@:F
FE<C=@E;<D<;@I<C8;<C8EKF;<CG8UJ
<E <JK< :8DGF < @;<EK@=@:8I CFJ GI@E:@G8C<J GIF9C<D8J G<E;@<EK<J <C
FEJ<AF '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8 <JK89C<:<IR LE J@JK<D8
G<ID8E<EK<;<<M8CL8:@WE:FE98J<<E@E;@:8;FI<J;<GIF;L:K@M@;8;
:8C@;8; < @DG8:KF
JK< J@JK<D8 ;< @E;@:8;FI<J :FDGI<E;< CFJ ;<
@EJLDFJ P ;< I<JLCK8;FJ < @E:CL@IR <EKI< FKIFJ <C EXD<IF ;<
@EM<JK@>8;FI<J :FCFD9@8EFJ ;< GL9C@:8:@FE<J :@<EKU=@:8J ;< :@K8J
9@9C@F>IR=@:8J ;< G8K<EK<J P ;< K<J@J <O@KFJ8D<EK< K<ID@E8;8J
(%"'", JG

)F:FJ 8VFJ ;<JGLSJ J< @EJK@KL:@FE8C@QW C8 :@<E:@FD<KIU8 <JK89C<:@SE;FC8
:FDF C8 D@J@WE ;<C (9J<IM8KFI@F FCFD9@8EF ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8
(P- 8JUJ<GC8EK<W<EJLJ<JK8KLKFJ8GIF98;FJ<E

C (,+/-(+"( K@<E< :FDF D@J@WE =FIK8C<:8:@WE P <C <J8IIFCCF @<EKU=@:F P -<:EFCW>@:F ;<C G8UJ
D<;@8EK< C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< @E=FID8:@WE < @E;@:8;FI<J :FEKI@9L@I 8C
:FEF:@D@<EKF:L8EK@K8K@MFP:L8C@K8K@MF;<C,@JK<D8'8:@FE8C;<@<E:@8
P -<:EFCF>U8 D<;@8EK< JL I<GI<J<EK8:@WE GFE;<I8;8 P 8GFP8I CFJ
GIF:<JFJ <JKI8KS>@:FJ ;< GC8E@=@:8:@WE P KFD8 ;< ;<:@J@FE<J 8 KI8MSJ
ERC@J@J;<K8CC8;FJa;<J;<WGK@:8J;@M<EK<Ja;<CFJJ@JK<D8J;<@E;<O8:@WEP:C8J@=@:8:@WE
K8C<J:FDFC8:@<E:@FD<KIU8PC89@9C@FD<KIU8PJL8GC@:8:@WE<EFCFD9@8J<GL<;<E:FEJLCK8I
WD<QP&8C;FE8;F<JG<:U=@:8D<EK<CFJ:8GUKLCFJ"1P1;<<JK<XCK@DF

C(P-J<?8<E:8I>8;F;<I<8C@Q8IC8JD<;@:@FE<J:FII<JGFE;@<EK<J8C8GIF;L::@WE:@<EKU=@:8
<EEL<JKIFG8UJ:FE<C=@E;<^:FEKI@9L@I8C8?FDF><E<@Q8:@WE PEFID8C@Q8:@WE;<C8@E=FID8:@WE
><E<I8;8 GFI <EK<J E8:@FE8C<J < @EK<IE8:@FE8C<J GIF;L:KFI<J ;< @E=FID8:@WE GI@D8I@8 <E CFJ
:8DGFJ;<C8@EM<JK@>8:@WE:@<EKU=@:8PK<:EFCW>@:8_(P-IK
\ELD

;< LE8 @EK<IGI<K8:@WE @EK<>I8C ;< C8 ;@ERD@:8 ;< C8 @<E:@8 P C8
-<:EFCF>U8 <E <C G8UJ P ;< JL GFJ@:@FE8D@<EKF 8 E@M<C I<>@FE8C P
DLE;@8C(P-IK
\

)8I8
:FDGC<D<EK8I
P
<JG<:@8C@Q8I
<JK8
8:K@M@;8;
:@<E:@FDSKI@:8
@EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8;8 D@J@FE8CD<EKU8 J<
@DGC<D<EKW K8D9@SE C8 9@9C@FD<KIU8 :FDF <JKI8K<>@8 <OGCU:@K8 G8I8 C8
FI@<EK8:@WE;<C8JGFCUK@:8JJF9I<:@<E:@8

%8:8EK@;8;PC8:8C@;8;;<C8GIF;L::@WE:@<EKU=@:8;<LEG8UJGL<;<E
8E8C@Q8IJ<GFID<;@F;<@E;@:8;FI<J9@9C@FDSKI@:FJXK@C<JG8I8FI@<EK8I
C8J;<:@J@FE<J<E<C:8DGF;<C8GFCUK@:8:@<EKU=@:8
JKFJ@E;@:8;FI<J
J< :FEJKILP<E 8 G8IK@I ;< @E=FID8:@WE :FEK<E@;8 <E 98J<J ;< ;8KFJ
9@9C@F>IR=@:8JF,<IM@:@FJ;<"E;<O8:@WEP+<JLD<E`,"+,`
(P-

%FJ=LE:@FE8I@FJ;<C8J<EK@;8;<JPFI>8E@JDFJG8I8C8><JK@WE;<C8:@<E:@8
J< 98J8E <E C8 <JK8;UJK@:8 :FDF .<=;*=.02* HL< G<ID@K< ?8:8:@WE <E K8EKF GIF;L:KFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ
%F HL< ?8:< <E
XCK@D8J C8 :@<E:@FD<KIU8 <J JLJ:@K8I HL< C8 <M8CL8:@WE ;< CFJ GIF:<JFJ
:@<EKU=@:FJ HL<;< I<;L:@;8 8 C8 :L8EK@=@:8:@WE ;< CFJ I<JLCK8;FJ <EK<E;@;FJ
SJKFJ:FDFGIF;L:KFJ;<CJ89<I:@<EKU=@:F

JK8J<JKI8K<>@8J<JK8;UJK@:8JJ<<E=F:8E<O:CLJ@M8D<EK<<EC8D<;@:@WE;<
CFJ GIF;L:KFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ <C@D@E8E;F ;< JLJ @EK<I<J<J C8J KI8P<:KFI@8J

)8I8 <C (9J<IM8KFI@F FCFD9@8EF ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8 CFJ GIF;L:KFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ <JKRE
I<GI<J<EK8;FJ <E ^CFJ 8IKU:LCFJ :FDGC<KFJ 8IKU:LCFJ :FIKFJ C@9IFJ I<JLCK8;F ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE
C@9IFJ GL9C@:8;FJ :8GUKLCFJ ;< C@9IF JF=KN8I< G@CFKFJ GIFP<:KFJ GIFKFK@GFJ EFID8J ;@J<VFJ
@E;LJKI@8C<JK<J@J;<D8<JKIU8P;F:KFI8;F_(P-

D<KF;FCW>@:8J ><E<I8E;F 8JU LE8 A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE ;< :<EKIFJ < @EJK@KL:@FE<J

;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE 8 G8IK@I ;< C8 :L8EK@=@:8:@WE ;< JLJ GIF;L::@FE<J
%8
;<JM<EK8A8;<<JK<J@JK<D8EFJ<L9@:8K8EKF<E<C?<:?F;<CC<M8II<>@JKIFP
:FEK89@C@Q8I C8 :8EK@;8; ;< GIF;L:KFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ J@EF <E CF HL< <JKF ;<
><E<I8 C8 A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE :@<EKU=@:8 JF:@8C P <:FEWD@:8 ;< :<EKIFJ
@EJK@KL:@FE<J P ?8JK8 ;< @EM<JK@>8;FI<J 8 G8IK@I ;< JL M@J@9@C@;8; <E CFJ
J@JK<D8J;<@E;<O8:@WE

C 8IKU:LCF :@<EKUf:F :FEJK@KLP< <C GI@E:@G8C D<:8E@JDF ;<
:FDLE@:8:@WE ;< C8 :@<E:@8 DF;<IE8 GFI CF HL< ?8 CF>I8;F :FEJKIL@I
<JKIL:KLI8JJF:@8C<J:FDGC<A8J8JL8CI<;<;FIHL<8J<>LI8EC8M8C@;<Q
G<IK@E<E:@8PI<C<M8E:@8<EC8:FDLE@;8;:@<EKUf:8;FE;<J<@EJ:I@9<

%8J <JKIL:KLI8J JF:@8C<J :FDF CFJ :FD@KSJ <;@KFI@8C<J :FD@KSJ
:@<EKUf:FJ ;< J<C<::@WE P :FD@KSJ ;< G8I<J <M8CL8;FI<J :<IK@=@:8E C8J
:8C@;8;<J :@<EKUf:8J P <;@KFI@8C<J E<:<J8I@8J G8I8 <C I<:FEF:@D@<EKF
;< C8J :FDLE@:8:@FE<J <E C8J :FDLE@;8;<J :@<EKUf:8J
JK< K@GF ;<
J<C<::@WE P I<:FEF:@D@<EKF EF JFCF J< ;8 <E <C E@M<C ;< =L<EK<J
GI@D8I@8J ;< @E=FID8:@WE :FDF C8J I<M@JK8J J@EF HL< ?8:< G8IK< ;<
C8J GIR:K@:8J :FDLE<J ;< =L<EK<J J<:LE;8I@8J ;< @E=FID8:@WE :FDF
JFE CFJ ,"+,
%8 M@J@9@C@;8; ;< LE8 :FDLE@:8:@WE :@<EKUf:8 GL<;<
8J@D@C8IJ< 8 C8 ;@D<EJ@WE P GI<JK@>@F ;<C :FEALEKF ;< <JKIL:KLI8J
JF:@8C<JHL<J<DFM@C@Q8EG8I8;8I:L<EK8;<<CC8<EFKI8JG8C89I8J
C8 M@J@9@C@;8; GL<;< <EK<E;<IJ< :FDF <C :FEALEKF ;< FI>8E@Q8:@FE<J
I<:FEF:@;8J JF:@8CD<EK< ;FE;< :@I:LC8 LE 8IKU:LCF :@<EKUf:F
)8I8
:FEJKIL@I @E;@:8;FI<J ;< :@I:LC8:@WE ;< CFJ 8IKU:LCFJ @;<EK@=@:8;FJ GFI
JLJ I<=<I<E:@8J <E C8J 98J<J ;< M% P
ILG% LK@C@Q8DFJ C8
@E=FID8:@WE;<I<M@JK8J@EK<>I8;8J<EC8J98J<J;< ,"+,HL<?8E
J@;F<DGC<8;FJ<E<CGIF:<JF;<8J@>E8:@WE;<GLEK8A<JJ8C8I@8C<J;<
@EM<JK@>8;FI<J 8JF:@8;FJ 8 @EJK@KL:@FE<J GX9C@:8J <E <C G8UJ
:8C@=@:8E;F CFJ 8IKU:LCFJ J<>XE <C >I8;F ;< :@I:LC8:@WE ;< C8J I<M@JK8J
;FE;< ?8E J@;F GL9C@:8;FJ
JK< >I8;F ;< :@I:LC8:@WE ;< C8J I<M@JK8J

PGFI<OK<EJ@WE;<CFJ8IKU:LCFJJ<<EK@<E;<8HLU:FDF<CEXD<IF;<
,"+,;FE;<?8EJ@;F@EK<>I8;8J(P-

%8 9XJHL<;8 ;< C8 M@J@9@C@;8; ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE :@<EKU=@:8 J< 98J8 <E C8
@E:CLJ@WE;<CFJ8IKU:LCFJ<EC8JI<M@JK8JSJK<K<ID@E8GFI:FEM<IK@IJ<<E<C=@E
;< LE8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE P EF <E LE M8CFI 8>I<>8;F CF :L8C ><E<I8
KI8EJ=FID8:@FE<J<EC8JGIR:K@:8J;<CFJ@EM<JK@>8;FI<J?8:@<E;FAL<>F8C8
CW>@:8 ;< M@J@9@C@Q8:@WE ;<C J@JK<D8
%8 <J:I@KLI8 ;< LE 8IKU:LCF J< :FEM@<IK<
<EKFE:<J <E <C =@E ;< C8J @EM<JK@>8:@FE<J GL<J <C J@JK<D8 EF <JK@DLC8 E@
<M8CX8 KI8P<:KFI@8J JFCF GIF;L:K@M@;8; P JL GFJ@:@FE8D@<EKF <E <C D<I:8;F
;<C8JGL9C@:8:@FE<J

CD@JDFK@<DGFFKIFJ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ;<I<>LC8:@WEFI@<EK8IFELE8K<E;<E:@88
C8 ?FDF><E<@Q8:@WE ;< C8J GIR:K@:8J ;F:<EK<J :@<EKU=@:8J < @EM<JK@>8K@M8J
98J8;8<EC8@EJK8LI8:@WE;<LEb;<9<IJ<Ic@;<8CG8I8LED<AFI8D@<EKF;<C8
:8C@;8; P D8PFI G<IK@E<E:@8 ;< ;@:?8J GIR:K@:8J
J <C :8JF ;<C ,@JK<D8 ;<
J<>LI8D@<EKF ;< C8 8C@;8; ;< C8 ;L:8:@WE ,LG<I@FI ,, <C :L8C
<JKR :FE=FID8;F GFI <C I<>@JKIF :8C@=@:8;F F9C@>8KFI@F G8I8 KF;FJ CFJ
GIF>I8D8J;<<;L:8:@WEJLG<I@FIPC88:I<;@K8:@WE;<:8C@;8;FG:@FE8CG8I8
GIF>I8D8J<@EJK@KL:@FE<J;<<;L:8:@WEJLG<I@FI<E;FE;<J<;<JGC@<>8LE8
K<E;<E:@8 8 C8 ?FDF><E@Q8:@WE ;< GIF:<;@D@<EKFJ GFI <A<DGCF C8
8:I<;@K8:@WE ÊF K@<E< <E :L<EK8 C8 :8C@;8; ;< CFJ I<JLCK8;FJ ;<C GIF:<JF
<;L:8K@MF J@EF <C :LDGC@D@<EKF ;< :FE;@:@FE<J ?FDF>SE<8J ;<
=LE:@FE8D@<EKF4
5_ WD<QP<C@JG

)FIFKIFC8;FCFJJ@JK<D8J
;< D<;@:@WE P :C8J@=@:8:@WE ;< CFJ >ILGFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE HL< I<8C@Q8
(%"'", ;<J;< 8 KI8MSJ ;< :FEMF:8KFI@8J 89@<IK8J :FEJK@KLP<E
;@JGFJ@K@MFJ ;< I<>LC8:@WE <E <C J<EK@;F HL< D<;@8EK< C8 =FID8:@WE ;<
:FE:<GKL8C@Q8:@FE<J J< <JK89C<:< C8 A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE ;< ;@:?FJ >ILGFJ
K<E@<E;F :FDF 98J< JL :<I:8EU8 F C<A8EU8 8 CFJ GIF;L:KFJ @;<8C<J ;<=@E@;FJ
)8I8LE8ERC@J@JI@>LIFJF;<C,,MS8J< WD<QP<C@J

GFI <C GIFG@F (%"'",

LI8EK< CFJ GI@D<IFJ 8VFJ <JK< ;@JGFJ@K@MF
FG<IW:FDFLE@EJKILD<EKF;<A<I8IHL@Q8:@WEPM@J@9@C@Q8:@WE;<CFJ>ILGFJ;<
@EM<JK@>8:@WEG<IF;LI8EK<CFJ8VFJGFJK<I@FI<JJ<<JK89C<:@WK8D9@SE:FDF
LEK@GF;<:<IK@=@:8:@WEHL<G<ID@K<8CFJ@EM<JK@>8;FI<J8::<;<I8CFJ8GFPFJ
=@E8E:@<IFJ FKFI>8;FJ GFI <C JK8;F ><E<I8E;F <C :UI:LCF GIF;L:K@M@;8;
=@E8E:@8:@WE GIF;L:K@M@;8; J< GL<;< 8::<;ILGFJP8:FEJFC@;8;FJLE8:FE=@ID8:@WEbF=@:@8Cc;< C8 GFJ@:@WE;FD@E8EK<
D8PFI I<:FEF:@D@<EKF P GI<JK@>@F J<>XE <C ^:8G@K8C :@<EKU=@:F_ 8:LDLC8;F
;< C8 SC@K< :@<EKU=@:8 ;<EKIF ;<C :8DGF :@<EKU=@:F P <E <J< J<EK@;F LE8
I<GIF;L::@WE8G8IK@I;<C88=@ID8:@WE;<<J8A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE

)8I8 I<=FIQ8I C8 A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE ;< CFJ >ILGFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE J<
EFID8C@Q8IFE C8J :C8J@=@:8:@FE<J ;< CFJ D@JDFJ ;< 8:L<I;F :FE JL

J@DGFIK8EK<J<V8C8IHL<<CGI@D<IDF;<CF=FID8C;<:C8J@=@:8:@WEJ<;@J<VW<E P;<8CCU
<E 8;<C8EK< J< ?8E <JK89C<:@;F :8D9@FJ K8C M<Q <C DRJ J@>E@=@:8K@MF =L< @EKIF;L:@;F <E <C 8VF
<C:L8C:FEJ@JK@W<EI<<DGC8Q8I8CFJG8I<J<M8CL8;FI<JG8I8C8J<C<::@WEP:C8J@=@:8:@WE;<
CFJ >ILGFJ GFI LE J@JK<D8 8LKFDRK@:F 98J8;F <E LE UE;@:< ;< D<;@:@WE GFI ;<:@C<J
(%"'",9G

JK<AL<>F;<I<GIF;L::@WE?8:<M@J@9C<C8;@=<I<E:@8<EKI<CFHL<FLI;@<L8GG
PJJ

CC8D8 GF;@F :@<EKU=@:F C@>8;F 8
LE8@EJK@KL:@FE8C@;8;@EK<C<:KL8C
EKF;F:8JFC8;@=<I<E:@8:@WEEFE@<>8C8UEK@D8I<C8:@WE<EKI<
8D9FJ >ILGFJ F K@GFJ ;< @EJK@KL:@FE8C@;8; <E C8 :FE=@>LI8:@WE ;<C :8DGF :@<EKU=@:F :FCFD9@8EF
:FDFGL<;<M<IJ<8KI8MSJ;<CF8HLU<OGL<JKF

^C EL<MF <J:8C8=WE ;< >ILGFJ :FCFD9@8EFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE <E :@<E:@8 K<:EFCF>U8 <
@EEFM8:@WE:FEJK8;<:@E:F:8K<>FIU8J
A
.E>ILGFJFC8D<EK<GL<;<8::<;<I8LE8
:8K<>FIU8J@:LDGC<:FEC8;<=@E@:@WE;<>ILGF45,<8::<;<8:8;8:8K<>FIU8:LDGC@<E;F:FECFJ
J@>L@<EK<JI<HL@J@KFJ

8K<>FIU8 -<EL8C 8
P 8C D<EFJ 8VFJ ;<
<O@JK<E:@8

P 8C D<EFJ 8VFJ ;<
<O@JK<E:@8

P 8C D<EFJ 8VFJ ;<
<O@JK<E:@8

P 8C D<EFJ 8VFJ ;<
<O@JK<E:@8

GIF;L:K@M@;8; 8 G8IK@I ;< LE J@JK<D8 8LKFDRK@:F <J ;<:@I 8 G8IK@I ;< LE
UE;@:< ;< D<;@:@WE GFI ;<:@C<J <JK< J@JK<D8 ;< :C8J@=@:8:@WE GI@M@C<>@8 C8
GL9C@:8:@WE ;< 8IKU:LCFJ G8I8 C8 F9K<E:@WE ;< GLEKFJ P 8JU 8J:<E;E@K@MF
8;HL@I@W LE8 K<C<FCF>U8 ;< C8 GIF;L::@WEGL9C@:8:@WE DRJ 8CCR ;< JL GFJ@9C<
:FEKI@9L:@WE8C8><E<I8:@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJG8I8C8JKI8EJ=FID8:@FE<J;<
CFJ :8DGFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ P JF:@8C<J GFI FKIF C8;F CFJ >ILGFJ P :<EKIFJ ;<
@EM<JK@>8:@WE <EKI8IFE <E <C G8EFI8D8 GFCUK@:F 8;D@E@JKI8K@MF ;< C8 E8:@WE 8
G8IK@I;<CFJI<:LIJFJ8J@>E8;FJ8JL=FD<EKFF:FEJFC@;8:@WE^FE<C=@E;<
;8IC< LE8 D8PFI :8G8:@;8; FG<I8K@M8 P <JK89@C@;8; <:FEWD@:8 8 CFJ :<EKIFJ
;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE J< LK@C@Q8IRE CFJ @E:<EK@MFJ KI@9LK8I@FJ <O@JK<EK<J G8I8
=FD<EK8I C8 :FEJK@KL:@WE ;< =FE;FJ ;< :8G@K8C ;< ;@:?FJ @EJK@KLKFJ
<E;FND<EKJ_ ') JG
,@E <D98I>F :FDF G8IK< ;<C 8::<JF 8
CFJ I<:LIJFJ (%"'", J< 8KI@9LP< <C GF;@K@D@;8; 8 CFJ >ILGFJ P :<EKIFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE
=LE;8D<EK8;F CFJ :I@K<I@FJ ;< :8C@;8; P G<IK@E<E:@8 J@E <C I<:FEF:@D@<EKF
FKFI>8;FGFI(%"'",CFJ>ILGFJEFGL<;<E8::<;<I8C8=@E8E:@8:@WE
<JK8K8CM<I(%"'",+<JFCL:@WE;<

8K<>FIU8-<E<ILEUE;@:<%,2.7=285D8PFI8
P8CD<EFJ 8VF;<<O@JK<E:@8
_
(%"'",9

^,<@;<EK@=@:8<C ILGF;<"EM<JK@>8:@WE:FDF<C'X:C<FF.E@;8;RJ@:8;<C,@JK<D8'8:@FE8C
;<@<E:@8P-<:EFCF>U8G8I8C8><E<I8:@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKF8KI8MSJ;<C8@EM<JK@>8:@WE
G8IK@I
;< J< ?8 ;<J8IIFCC8;F LE8 GFCUK@:8 ;< 8GFPF <JG<:@8C P :FEK@ELF 8 <JK8J LE@;8;<J ;<
@EM<JK@>8:@WE
JK8 GFCUK@:8 :FEK<DGC8 <C ;<J8IIFCCF ;< <JKI8K<>@8J G8I8 GIFDFMILGFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WEHL<FG<I8E<E<CG8UJ8JU:FDFC8
:I<8:@WE ;< EL<MFJ >ILGFJ
FC:@<E:@8J :FD<EQW 8 ?8:ILGFJ P :<EKIFJ <E
PI<8C@QW:@E:F;<<CC8J<EC8XCK@D8;S:8;8;<CJ@>CFG8J8;F:FE<CGIFGWJ@KF;<@;<EK@=@:8I
CFJ >ILGFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE HL< KI898A898E <E <C G8UJ P <E 8C>LE8J ;< <CC8J FKFI>W <JKUDLCFJ
<:FEWD@:FJG8I8JL=FIK8C<:@D@<EKF
8;8LE8J<:FEJK@KLPW<ELE8M8E:<?8:@8<C:FEF:@D@<EKF
;< C8 8:K@M@;8; P ;< CFJ I<JLCK8;FJ ;< CFJ >ILGFJ P :<EKIFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE ;<C G8UJ
E <C 8VF
J<I<8C@QWC8J<>LE;8:FEMF:8KFI@88>ILGFJP:<EKIFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE:FE<CGIFGWJ@KF;<
FKFI>8I <JKUDLCFJ <:FEWD@:FJ G8I8 JL =FIK8C<:@D@<EKF
E <JK8 F:8J@WE =L<IFE 8GFP8;FJ
>ILGFJP:<EKIFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE
E<C8VF J<GI<J<EK8IFE >ILGFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE
;<CFJ:L8C<JJ<8GFPW8PJ<GI<J<EK8IFE:<EKIFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE;<CFJ:L8C<JJ<8GFPW
8
E J< <J:8C8=FE8IFE >ILGFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE P :<EKIFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE_
(%"'",9P

%8 A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE ;< >ILGFJ P :<EKIFJ :FDF GLEKF ;< G8IK@;8 G8I8 C8
8;D@E@JKI8:@WE ;< CFJ I<:LIJFJ GFI G8IK< ;<C JK8;F 898I:8 EF JFCF C8J
J@>E8KLI8J JF9I< CFJ JLA<KFJ J@EF K8D9@SE C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J ;< CFJ D@JDFJ
I<GI<J<EK8;FJ <E CFJ GIFP<:KFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE C<>UK@DFJ <JKF GF;IU8
:FEJ@;<I8IJ<:FDF<C8E;8D@8A<:FE:<GKL8C;<C8=@E8E:@8:@WE<JK8K8C

)IFP<:KFJ ;< :8IR:K@:F
,FE CFJ GIFP<:KFJ
I<C8:@FE8;FJ:FEC8@EM<JK@>8:@WE:@<EKUf:8FC88GIFG@8:@WEGX9C@:8;<
C8 :@<E:@8 P C8 K<:EFCF>U8
)IFP<:KFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE :@<EKUf:8 JFE
8HL<CCFJ HL< J< I<=@<I<E 8 LE :FEALEKF 8IK@:LC8;F P :F?<I<EK< ;<
8:K@M@;8;<JFI@<EK8;8J88C:8EQ8ILEFFM8I@FJF9A<K@MFJI<C8:@FE8;FJ
:FEC8><E<I8:@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFP:LP8GIF>I8D8:@WE<E<CK@<DGF
I<JGFE;< 8 LE :IFEF>I8D8 :FE LE8 ;LI8:@WE C@D@K8;8
%FJ GIFP<:KFJ
;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE :@<EKUf:8 ;<9<E J<>L@I LE8 D<KF;FCF>U8 HL<
:FEK<DGC< LE <HL@GF ;< G<IJFE8J @;WE<8J P FKIFJ I<:LIJFJ
:L8EK@=@:8;FJ <E =FID8 ;< GI<JLGL<JKF P GI<M<8 <C CF>IF ;<
;<K<ID@E8;FJ I<JLCK8;FJ J@E :FEKI8M<E@I C8J EFID8J P 9L<E8J
GIR:K@:8J <JK89C<:@;8J
%FJ GIFP<:KFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE J< I<C8:@FE8E
:FEC8><E<I8:@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ@8CJ<II<8C@Q8;FJJ<F9K@<E<LE
:FEF:@D@<EKF JF9I< 8C D<EFJ LE 8JG<:KF ;< C8 K<DRK@:8 KI8K8;8 HL<
CC<>L<DRJ8CCR;<CHL<?L9@<I8GF;@;F8;HL@I@IJ<<ELEGI@E:@G@F<EC8
9@9C@F>I8=U8 <JG<:@8C@Q8;8 F <E <C J89<I :FC<:K@MF ;< CFJ <JG<:@8C@JK8J
<E<CK<D8
)FI8;8GK8:@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ<<EK@<E;<C88GC@:8:@WE
F LK@C@Q8:@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKF LE@M<IJ8C 8 GIF9C<D8J G8IK@:LC8I<J
:FEK<DGC8;FJGFI<CGIFP<:KF<ELE8=FID8HL<EF?8P8J@;F?<:?8
8EK<J G8I8 <J< K@GF ;< GIF9C<D8J < @EMFCL:I< C8 I<JFCL:@WE ;<
@E:<IK@;LD9I<J HL< I<HL@<I<E LE <J=L<IQF JLG<I@FI 8C HL< GL<;<
9I@E;8IC8:FEJLCK8;<C8C@K<I8KLI8<JG<:@8C@Q8;8F<CKI898AFEFID8C;<
<JG<:@8C@JK8J <E <C RI<8 <E 8LJ<E:@8 ;< LE GIFP<:KF ;< <EM8;LI8
J@D@C8I F JLG<I@FI 8C GC8EK<8;F 'P- :L<I;F '\ ;< IK

\

%8J K<:EFCF>U8J ;< 8;D@E@JKI8:@WE ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF :@<E:@FD<KIU8

9@9C@FD<KIU8 DF;<CFJ ;< :C8J@=@:8:@WE J@JK<D8J ;< ><JK@WE :FEKIFC P
<M8CL8:@WE @DGC<D<EK8;8J ;<J;< CL>8I<J ;< <ELE:@8:@WE :FE:I<KFJ
FI>8E@JDFJ P <EK@;8;<J >L9<IE8D<EK8C<J 8:KL8IFE :FDF @EJKILD<EKFJ
<OGCU:@KFJG8I8C8;<C@D@K8:@WE;<C:FEF:@D@<EKF:@<EKU=@:FHL<J<:FEJ@;<I8IU8
C<>UK@DF ;<J<89C<E<I8:@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJJ<<JK89C<:@WP
EFID8C@QW 8 G8IK@I ;< :I@K<I@FJ GIFG@FJ ;< C8J @EK<E:@FE<J D@KFJ ;<J<FJ P
GLEKFJ;<M@JK8;<HL@<E<J?8:<EGFCUK@:898AFG<IJG<:K@M8J<:FEFD@:@JK8JP
EF;<HL@<E<J?8:<E:@<E:@8

E <C J@>L@<EK< 8G8IK8;F DFJKI8IS 8C>LE8J ;< C8J 8::@FE<J :FE:I<K8J HL<
<D8E8IFE;<<JKFJ;@J:LIJFJP8::@FE<J@DGC<D<EK8;8J;<J;<CFJGI@D<IFJ
8VFJ ;< C8 ;S:8;8 ;<C ;<C J@>CF G8J8;F ;S:8;8 <E C8 :L8C :FDF J< ?8
M@JKF ?L9F LE ;<JGC@<>L< ;< C8J K<:EFCF>U8J FI>8E@Q8:@FE8C<J
@EJKILD<EK8C<J ;@J:LIJ@M8J D<KF;FCW>@:8J <E <C J<EK@;F 8HLU <OGL<JKF
;@JGL<JK8J G8I8 8;D@E@JKI8I C8 GIF;L::@WE ;@MLC>8:@WE P 8GIFG@8:@WE ;< CFJ
:FEF:@D@<EKFJ:@<EKU=@:FJ

' # !$'

C E@M<C ;@J:LIJ@MF <OGC@:@K8;F <E <OGFJ@:@FE<J GFE<E:@8J ;F:LD<EKFJ
EFID8J P C<>@JC8:@FE<J P <C E@M<C GI8>DRK@:F <E <C :L8C CFJ ;@J:LIJFJ J<
:FDGC<D<EK8E :FE C8J 8::@FE<J JFE @DGFIK8EK<J G<IF EF JFE JL=@:@<EK<J
G8I8 <JK89C<:LC8:@FE<J JF9I< <C J89F9@<IEFJ `
G8I8C<C8D<EK< 8 CFJ ;@J:LIJFJ P ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ` LE8 J<I@< ;< <JKI8K<>@8J HL<
9LJ:898E FI>8E@Q8I EFID8C@Q8I P C<>@K@D8I GFI LE C8;F CFJ GIF:<JFJ P

GIF:<;@D@<EKFJG8I8C8GIF;L::@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJPKF;8JC8J8:K@M@;8;<J
HL<I<JLCK898E;<J<89C<J<E<C<A<I:@:@F;<C8@EM<JK@>8:@WE:@<EKU=@:8PGFI
FKIF C8;F C8J :FE;@:@FE<J G8I8 8::<;@8J J< FI@>@E8IFE LE8 J<I@< ;< 8:FEK<:@D@<EKFJ HL< ;<I@M8IFE <E
8::@FE<J K8C<J :FDF A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE < @EM@J@9@C@Q8:@WE ;< J89<I<J
;<K<ID@E8:@FE<J P J@>E8KLI8J >L9<IE8D<EK8C<J JF9I< C8 :@<E:@8
;<G<E;<E:@8 =@E8E:@<I8 <E C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE P ><JK@WE ;< C8
:@<E:@8 ;<J;< <C RD9@KF GFCUK@:F K<D8J <JKFJ 8 CFJ :L8C<J D< I<=<I@IS 8
:FEK@EL8:@WE

FDF:FIFC8I@F;<C8J<JKI8K<>@8J;<J8IIFCC8;8JP;<CFJF9A<K@MFJ@DGL<JKFJ
G8I8 C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ ;<J;< C8 CW>@:8 9@E8I@8 ;< CFJ :8DGFJ
GFCUK@:F <:FEWD@:F C8 @EM@J@9@C@Q8:@WE ;< J89<I<J <EKIW 8 FG<I8I
GI@E:@G8CD<EK<8KI8MSJ;<CFJ8GFPFJG8I8C8=@E8E:@8:@WE;<@EM<JK@>8:@FE<J
<EC8J:@<E:@8JP<EC8JRI<8J;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJHL<C8J:FDGFE<E
JUGFI
<A<DGCF 8 D<;@8;FJ ;< C8 ;S:8;8 ;<C <E C8J :@<E:@8J JF:@8C<J J<
<JK89C<:@W :FDF LEF ;< CFJ F9A<K@MFJ GFI G8IK< ;<C JK8;F 8GFP8I C8
@EM<JK@>8:@WE

JF9I< K<D8J <JKI8KS>@:FJ G8I8 <C ;<J8IIFCCF JF:@8C P <:FEWD@:F ;<C
G8UJ:FDF<C8ERC@J@J;<CFJ=8:KFI<JHL<@E:@;<EJF9I<C8GF9I<Q8<C
=LE:@FE8D@<EKF ;< C8 <:FEFDU8 C8J EL<M8J =FID8J ;< 8::@WE P ;<
@EK<IM<E:@WE ;<C JK8;F C8 I<C8:@WE <EKI< <JK< XCK@DF P C8 JF:@<;8;
:@M@CC8>F9<IE89@C@;8;CFJD<:8E@JDFJ;<G8IK@:@G8:@WE:@L;8;8E8<C
:FEF:@D@<EKF ;< EL<JKI8 ?@JKFI@8 P EL<JKI8 ?<K<IF><E<@;8; SKE@:8 P
:LCKLI8C') JG

<EKIF ;< CFJ F9A<K@MFJ J<V8C8;FJ EF J< <E:L<EKI8E K<D8J K8C<J :FDF <C
8GFPF 8 C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE JF9I8:@FE<J JF9I<
C8JC<E>L8JKI8;@:@FE8C<J<JKL;@FJJF:@8C<JJF9I<C8:@<E:@8PE@HLS;<:@I;<

C8J @EM<JK@>8:@FE<J 8CI<;<;FI ;< C8 ?@JKFI@8 ;<C 8IK@:FJ
G8I8 <C ;<J8IIFCCF JF:@8C P <:FEWD@:F ;<C G8UJ_ <E ;FE;< CF <JKI8KS>@:F <J
;<=@E@;F
;<J;<
<C
;@J:LIJF
>L9<IE8D<EK8C
8
G8IK@I
;<C
D@KF

GIF>I<JF;<J8IIFCCF <OGL<JKF <E <C GI@D@:FJ C@D@K8 C8J FG:@FE<J ;< 8::<JF 8C 8GFPF
=@E8E:@<IF <JK8K8C 8 8HL<CCFJ @EM<JK@>8;FI<J :LPFJ @EK<I<J<J JFE ;@JK@EKFJ
><E<I8E;F LE8 <O:CLJ@WE -. /*,=8 ;<C ,@JK<D8 '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8 P
-<:EFCF>U8

%8<O:CLJ@WE=@E8E:@<I8<EKI<C8J:@<E:@8JJ<8DGC@W;@J:LIJ@M8D<EK<:L8E;F
CLJKIFJ DRJ K8I;< 98AF C8 %L@<EK<ÎK@:LC8IP <EI@HL<:<IC8
@EM<JK@>8:@WE <C ;<J8IIFCCF :@<EKU=@:F K<:EFCW>@:F P C8 @EEFM8:@WE :FE <C
J<:KFIGI@M8;F<E<JG<:@8C<CJ<:KFIGIF;L:K@MF_%8I

JK<F9A<K@MFJ<GC8EK<8;<D8E<I88:IUK@:8PJ@E<JG<:@=@:8I:FEHLS
=@E8C@;8;J<HL@<I<8IK@:LC8IC8@EM<JK@>8:@WE8CJ<:KFIGI@M8;F
&RJ8XE
]:FE HLS F9A<KF J< 9LJ:8 <EI@HL<:<E<I8C C8
@EM<JK@>8:@WE :FE <C J<:KFI GI@M8;F ]J<IR HL< GFI <A<DGCF CFJ
GI@E:@G@FJ ;< C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE JF:@8C GL<;<E I<;L:@IJ< 8 LE8 SK@:8
GIF;L:K@M8 LQDRE

%8 ALJK@=@:8:@WE ;< C8 @E:FIGFI8:@WE ;<C J<:KFI GIF;L:K@MF :FDF LEF ;< CFJ
8:KFI<J@DGFIK8EK<JG8I8<CJ@JK<D8;<8GFPF=@E8E:@<IF;<CJK8;FJ<98J8

LI8EK<<CG<I@F;F (%"'",=@E8E:@W GIFP<:KFJ;<C)IF>I8D8'8:@FE8C;<
@<E:@8J ,F:@8C<J :FE LE DFEKF ;<

D@CCFE<J ;< G<JFJ D@<EKI8J HL< <E <C )IF>I8D8
'8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8J RJ@:8J =@E8E:@W GIFP<:KFJ :FE LE DFEKF ;<

D@CCFE<J ;<
G<JFJ<J;<:@IHL<:8;8GIFP<:KF;<C8JCC8D8;8J:@<E:@8J9RJ@:8J=@E8E:@8;FGFI(%"'",
;LGC@:898 <C DFEKF I<:@9@;F G8I8 CFJ GIFP<:KFJ ;< :@<E:@8J JF:@8C<J MLD<EKFJ ;< K@GF JF:@FCW>@:F HL< 8M8C8E F GFI CF D<EFJ EF
:L<JK@FE8E C8J KI8EJ=FID8:@FE<J GIF;L:@;8J ;<J;< <C :8G@K8C@JDF
:FEK<DGFIRE<F

%FJ GIF=LE;FJ GIF:<JFJ ;< KI8EJ=FID8:@WE HL< M@M< <C DLE;F ?8E
;<J<D9F:8;F <E :8D9@FJ =LE;8D<EK8C<J <E C8 I<C8:@WE <EKI< CFJ
GI@E:@G8C<J J<:KFI<J ;< C8 JF:@<;8; P <EKI< <JKFJ XCK@DFJ P C8
<:FEFDU8
< <JK8J KI8EJ=FID8:@FE<J M8C< C8 G<E8 D<E:@FE8I CFJ
:8D9@FJHL<@E:@;<E<E<C98C8E:<<EKI<CFJD8I:FJI<>LC8KFI@FJP<C
D<I:8;F CFJ :8D9@FJ <E C8 E8KLI8C<Q8 D@JD8 ;< K8C<J D8I:FJ
I<>LC8KFI@FJCFJ:8D9@FJ<EC8J=FID8J;<8::@WEP;<@EK<IM<E:@WE;<C
JK8;F P <E C8 I<C8:@WE <EKI< <JK< XCK@DF P C8 JF:@<;8; :@M@C
%FJ
:8D9@FJ<EC8<JKIL:KLI8;<C8GIF;L::@WE:FDFG8IK<;<CGIF:<JF;<
I<<JKIL:KLI8:@WE :FDG<K@K@M8 <JKRE ><E<I8E;F GI<>LEK8J 9RJ@:8J
JF9I< :WDF ;@M@;@IJ< <C :FJKF ;< ;@:?FJ 8ALJK<J <EKI< <C :8G@K8C P <C
KI898AF
(%"'", JG

*L<;8:C8IFHL<G8I8CFJ><JKFI<J<JK8K8C<J;<C8:@<E:@8C8I8:@FE8C@;8;;<
JL><JK@WEJ<;<=@E<GI@E:@G8CD<EK<GFILEGIF9C<D8;<:8G@K8CP;<:WDF<C
KI898AF :F>E@K@MF ;<9< <JK8I 8C J<IM@:@F ;<C :8G@K8C ;< D8E<I8 HL< C8
=@E8E:@8:@WE J< <E=FHL< GI<:@J8D<EK< <E <C J<:KFI GI@M8;F
%8 @;<8 ;<
<JK89C<:<JK@WE ;< C8 :@<E:@8 GFI <A<DGCF LE8 ;< C8J
<JKI8K<>@8J ;< C8 )FCUK@:8 '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8 G8I8 <C G<I@F;F
<J<E=RK@:88CI<JG<:KF

I<8I:FE;@:@FE<J;<:FDG<K@K@M@;8;<E<CJ<:KFIGIF;L:K@MFE8:@FE8C
GFI D<;@F ;< GFCUK@:8J J<:KFI@8C<J 8:K@M8J HL< :FEK<DGC<E C8
K<:EFCF>U8 :FDF =8:KFI :IL:@8C G8I8 8C ;<J8IIFCCF ;< M<EK8A8J

%8J ;@=<I<EK<J DF;8C@;8;<J ;< =@E8E:@8:@WE <JK89C<:@;8J G8I8 <C ,@JK<D8 '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8
-<:EFCF>U8<"EEFM8:@WEJ<GL<;<E:FEJLCK8I<E(%"'",9P

:FDG8I8K@M8J 8;HL@I@;8J
FE <JK< GIFGWJ@KF J< CC<M8IR 8 :89F LE8
8>I<J@M8 GFCUK@:8 <E:8D@E8;8 8 ;<J8IIFCC8I I<;<J ;< @EEFM8:@WE HL<
M@E:LC<E<CJ<:KFIGIF;L:K@MF:FE:<EKIFJK<:EFCW>@:FJLE@M<IJ@;8;<JP
FKI8J @EJK@KL:@FE<J ;< ><E<I8:@WE P ;@=LJ@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKF ')
JG

%8^8>I<J@M8GFCUK@:8_?8:<<OGCU:@KF<C@EK<ISJ<E<JK89C<:<ILE8:@<E:@8G8I8
C8 GIF;L:K@M@;8; F9A<K@MF HL< <JKR GFI <E:@D8 ;< C8 ><E<I8:@WE ;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJG8I8<C<EI@HL<:@D@<EKF;<CFJJ89<I<JJF:@8C<J<JKF8G<E8J
J< D<E:@FE8 <E <C D@JDF ;F:LD<EKF :@K8;F
%8 GIF;L:K@M@;8; <J <C EL<MF
.=18< @E:FIGFI8;F 8 C8J GIR:K@:8J :@<EKU=@:8J ;< 8CCU J< ;<JGI<E;<E P J<
<OGC@:8E CFJ ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ :I<8;FJ G8I8 D<;@I CFJ I<JLCK8;FJ EF <E JL
:8C@;8; P 8GFIK<J 8 CFJ :8DGFJ ;< :FEF:@D@<EKF P ;@J:@GC@E8J J@EF <E JL
:8EK@;8; P :FEKI@9L:@WE 8 C8J ;<D8E;8J ;< CFJ J<:KFI<J <:FEWD@:FJ
E8:@FE8C<J
.E8 ;< C8J :FE:CLJ@FE<J `HL< J<>LI8D<EK< P8 ?8 J@;F
@;<EK@=@:8;8 GFI <C C<:KFI` <J HL< C8 GI@FI@;8; ;< C8 GFCUK@:8 JF9I< :@<E:@8 P
K<:EFCF>U8 ?8 J@;F :FDF J< ?8 M@JKF 8 CF C8I>F ;< CFJ ;F:LD<EKFJ
<JK89C<:8;FI<JP:@<EKU=@:FJ;<CG8UJ

G<J8I ;< HL< <E <C FI;<E ;<C ;@J:LIJF GFCUK@:F JF9I< C8 :@<E:@8 P <E C8J
8::@FE<J<DGI<E;@;8J;<J;<<C>F9@<IEF:<EKI8CG8I8C8><JK@WE;<C8:@<E:@8
J< GFE>8E <E J<>LE;8 CUE<8 <JFJ @EK<I<J<J P ;<D8E;8J ;< CFJ
@EM<JK@>8;FI<J@EM@J@9@C@QRE;FCFJ<JKFEFHL@<I<;<:@IHL<EF?8P8E<O@JK@;F
F HL< EF ?8P8E CF>I8;F >8E8I 8C>LEFJ <JG8:@FJ ;< 8::@WE 8 KI8MSJ ;< LE8
JL9A<K@M8:@WE :@<EKU=@:8 HL< <E F:8J@FE<J IFDG< :FE CFJ :FE;@:@FE8D@<EKFJ
;FD@E8EK<J P HL< CF>I8 GFJ@:@FE8I <C GIFG@F CL>8I ;< <ELE:@8:@WE :@<EKU=@:F

,F9I<<JKFJ8JG<:KFJD<I<=<I@IS<E<CJ@>L@<EK<8G8IK8;F

!8:<EG8IK<;<<JKFJ;@JGFJ@K@MFJC8:@<E:@FD<KIU8C89@9C@FD<KIU8C8:C8J@=@:8:@WE;<CFJ>ILGFJ
;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE CFJ J@JK<D8J ;< @E;<O8:@WE P CFJ <J:8C8=FE8D@<EKFJ J<>XE C8J GL9C@:8:@FE<J
I<8C@Q8;8J

! !# &

CG8EFI8D8><E<I8C;<C8:@<E:@8<EFCFD9@8HL<;8@EMRC@;FJ@J<<O:CLP<
;<SCC8<D<E:@8;<<ELE:@8;FJPGIR:K@:8J;<J;<<CCL>8I:@<EKU=@:FP;<
JLJ@EK<ID<;@8:@FE<J<EC8:FE=@>LI8:@WE;<C8GIF;L::@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ

E <C 8ERC@J@J ;<C 8I:?@MF ;F:LD<EK8C J< <E:FEKI8IFE <M@;<E:@8J ;< HL< 8
G<J8I ;< C8 ?<><DFEU8 ;<C ;@J:LIJF GFCUK@:F <E C8 ;<K<ID@E8:@WE P KFD8 ;<
;<:@J@FE<J G8I8 C8 ><JK@WE ;< C8 :@<E:@8 ?8E <O@JK@;F K8D9@SE GFK<E:@8J
G<IJG<:K@M8J P 8::@FE<J HL< =8MFI<:<E <C KI898AF :F>E@K@MF P ;<DRJ
8:K@M@;8;<J ;< CFJ @EM<JK@>8;FI<J P8 J<8 <D8E8;8J ;<J;< CF GFCUK@:F
GIFG@8D<EK<;@:?F;<J;<LECL>8I<JKI@:K8D<EK<:@<EKU=@:FF;<J;<LECL>8I
;<<ELE:@8:@WE8D9@>LFF8D9@M8C<EK<

E GI@D8I J< ;<9< ;<JK8:8I LE :FEALEKF ;< JL:<JFJ HL< ?<
;<EFD@E8;F ^8G<IKLI8 :@<EKU=@:8_ GL<JKF HL< <E J< ;<:I<KW HL< C8
8:K@M@;8;;<GIF;L::@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ:@<EKU=@:FJGF;U8J<II<8C@Q8;8GFI
:L8CHL@<I<EK@;8;FG<IJFE8E8KLI8C@EK<I<J8;8<E<CCFD<;@8EK<C8DF;8C@;8;
;<8JF:@8:@WE:FEC8'8:@WEFJLJ<EK@;8;<J;<J:<EKI8C@Q8;8J<:I<KF
;<
)L<;<;<:@IJ<HL<

C8 I<>LC8:@WE JF9I< C8 8JF:@8:@WE G8I8 C8 I<8C@Q8:@WE ;< GIFP<:KFJ ;<
@EM<JK@>8:@WE 89I< C8 GFJ@9@C@;8; ;< :I<8I EL<M8J 8JF:@8:@FE<J P
:FEM<E@FJG8I8C8GIF;L::@WE:@<EKU=@:8G<IFK8D9@SEG<ID@K<I<8C@Q8I
8:K@M@;8;<J :@<EKU=@:8J 8 8HL<CCFJ JLA<KFJ HL< bKI8;@:@FE8CD<EK<c EF
K<EU8E<OG<I@<E:@8<E<JK<:8DGF
JK8b8G<IKLI8:@<EKU=@:8cK<EU8LE8

JK< XCK@DF <J <C :8JF ;<C (9J<IM8KFI@F FCFD9@8EF ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8 (P- <C :L8C
<JKR :FE=FID8;F GFI D@<D9IFJ ;<C J<:KFI >L9<IE8D<EK8C P 8:8;SD@:F HL< I<8C@Q8E
<EKI<:ILQ8D@<EKFJ :FE:<GKL8C<J P J@>E8KLI8J <EKI< C8 I8:@FE8C@;8; GFCUK@:8 ;<K<ID@E8;8 GFI CF
<OGL<JKF <E CFJ 8G8IK8;FJ 8EK<I@FI<J P C8 C89FI :@<EKU=@:8 <JG<:@=@:8;8 <E C8J D<KF;FCF>U8J ;<
D<;@:@WE LK@C@Q8;8J
,< GL<;< ;<:@I HL< CFJ D@<D9IFJ ;<C (P- =CL:KX8E <EKI< JLJ J89<I<J
GIF=<J@FE8C<JPJL;<M<E@I:FDF=LE:@FE8I@FJGX9C@:FJ8CJ<IM@:@F;<CKI898AF:F>E@K@MF;<CG8UJ

:C8I8@EK<EJ@WE;<M@E:LC8I8CJ<:KFI<DGI<J8I@8C:FEC8GIF;L::@WE;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJ ;< D8E<I8 HL< C8J <DGI<J8J 8GIFM<:?8IFE <JK< IFC
G8I8=@E8E:@8IPG8KIF:@E8I@EM<JK@>8:@FE<J;<JLJ@EK<I<J<J LQDRE

JK< 8:FEK<:@D@<EKF =L< :8J@ @ED<;@8K8D<EK< I< M8C@;8;F D<;@8EK< <C
<:I<KF;< <E<C:L8CJ<;<=@E@W8C,@JK<D8'8:@FE8C;<@<E:@8P
-<:EFCF>U8

C ,@JK<D8 '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8 J< FI>8E@Q8 <E
GIF>I8D8J ;< :@<E:@8 P K<:EFCF>U8
,< <EK@<E;< GFI )IF>I8D8 ;<
@<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8 LE RD9@KF ;< GI<F:LG8:@FE<J :@<EKU=@:8J P
K<:EFCW>@:8J
<JKIL:KLI8;F
GFI
F9A<K@MFJ
D<K8J
P
K8I<8J
=LE;8D<EK8C<J HL< J< D8K<I@8C@Q8 <E GIFP<:KF P FKI8J 8:K@M@;8;<J

:FDGC<D<EK8I@8J HL< I<8C@Q8IRE <EK@;8;<J GX9C@:8J F GI@M8;8J
FI>8E@Q8:@FE<J:FDLE@K8I@8JFG<IJFE8JE8KLI8C<JIKU:LCF\

%8 8G<IKLI8 :@<EKU=@:8 D<E:@FE8;8 K8D9@SE ?@QF G8IKU:@G< D<;@8EK< C8 MU8
ALIU;@:8 8 C8J <EK@;8;<J ;< C8 E8:@WE HL< :FDF <EK<J >L9<IE8D<EK8C<J
KI8;@:@FE8CD<EK<EFG8IK@:@G898E<E8:K@M@;8;<J;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE:@<EKU=@:8<E
KF;8J C8J RI<8J ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ 8JU J< <JK@GLCW <E <C
<:I<KF ;<

%8'8:@WEPJLJ<EK@;8;<J;<J:<EKI8C@Q8;8JGF;IRE:<C<9I8I:FEKI8KFJ
HL< K<E>8E GFI F9A<KF C8 GI<JK8:@WE ;< J<IM@:@FJ :@<EKU=@:FJ F
K<:EFCW>@:FJ :FDF 8J<JFIU8J KS:E@:8J F :@<EKU=@:8J <M8CL8:@WE ;<
GIFP<:KFJ;<:@<E:@8FK<:EFCF>U8I<E;@:@WE;<:FE:<GKFJ:@<EKU=@:FJF
K<:EFCW>@:FJ GL9C@:@;8; ;< 8:K@M@;8;<J :@<EKU=@:8J F K<:EFCW>@:8J
@DGC8EK8:@WE P FG<I8:@WE ;< J@JK<D8J ;< @E=FID8:@WE P J<IM@:@FJ ;<
GIF:<J8D@<EKF ;< ;8KFJ ;< :@<E:@8 F K<:EFCF>U8 8><E:@8D@<EKF ;<
8;L8E8J ;< <HL@GFJ E<:<J8I@FJ G8I8 <C ;<J8IIFCCF ;< C8 :@<E:@8 F C8

K<:EFCF>U8 D8EK<E@D@<EKF P I<G8I8:@WE ;< D8HL@E8I@8 <HL@GFJ

@EJK8C8:@FE<J P J@D@C8I<J 8=<:KFJ 8C ;<J8IIFCCF ;< 8:K@M@;8;<J ;<
:@<E:@8 F K<:EFCF>U8 P ;@8>I8D8:@WE <;@:@WE :F<;@:@WE @DGI<J@WE
GL9C@:8:@WE P ;@JKI@9L:@WE ;< C@9IFJ I<M@JK8J =FCC<KFJ P J@D@C8I<J ;<
:@<E:@8FK<:EFCF>U8
JKFJXCK@DFJEF<O@>@IRE<CKIRD@K<GI<M@JKF<E<C
<:I<KF;< IKU:LCF \

JK8 <EKI8;8 ;< CFJ FI>8E@JDFJ E8:@FE8C<J 8C :8DGF :@<EKU=@:F <J LE8
EFID8C@Q8:@WEHL<;<M@EF<ELE8C<>@K@D8:@WE=FIQ8;8;<C8G8IK@:@G8:@WE;<
<JFJ FI>8E@JDFJ 8 C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J ;< GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ P8 HL<
J< ?8:< 8 G8IK@I ;<C GF;@JC8K@MF P EF ;<J;< C8 KI8;@:@WE 8:8;SD@:8 F
:@<EKU=@:8FLI;@<LP8

%8 @EK<E:@FE8C@;8; ;< <JK8 8G<IKLI8 :@<EKU=@:8 <I8 8DGC@8I C8 F=<IK8 ;<
GIFP<:KFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WEI<8C@Q8;FJ<E<CG8UJ:FE<C=@E;<CF>I8I<JKUDLCFJ
<:FEWD@:FJG8I8<CJ<:KFIGIF;L:K@MF<@E;LJKI@8C<E<JK<GI@D<IDFD<EKFC8
@;<8 <I8 @E:FIGFI8I 8 EL<MFJ 8:KFI<J <E C8J <J=<I8J ;< C8 :@<E:@8 P ;< C8
K<:EFCF>U8 J@E @DGFIK8I JL ;<J:FEF:@D@<EKF F GF:8 <OG<I@<E:@8 <E C8
<G@JK<DFCF>U8 <E C8J D<KF;FCF>U8J P <E C8J KS:E@:8J ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE
:@<EKU=@:8 <J ;<:@I @E:FIGFI8I EL<MFJ 8:KFI<J J@E LE .=18< :@<EKU=@:F
GIFG@8D<EK<;@:?F

GI@E:@G@FJ ;< J< <OG@;@<IFE CFJ ;<:I<KFJ HL< :I<8IFE <C
,@JK<D8'8:@FE8C;<@<E:@8P-<:EFCF>U8:FE<C:L8CJ<?8CF>I8;F
@EK<>I8I <J=L<IQFJ 8EK<I@FID<EK< 8@JC8;FJ < @EMFCL:I8I 8 KF;FJ CFJ
J<:KFI<J;<CJK8;F<E<C@DGLCJFPC8:FE;L::@WE;<<JK88:K@M@;8;

-8D9@SE J< <JK@DLCW C8 LE@WE ;< <J=L<IQFJ <EKI< CFJ J<:KFI<J
8:8;SD@:FPGIF;L:K@MFG8I88GFP8IC8I<:FEM<IJ@WE@E;LJKI@8CPJ<C<
;@FG@JFC<>8C8C88JF:@8:@WE<EKI<<CJ<:KFIGX9C@:FP<CGI@M8;FG8I8

;<J8IIFCC8I GIFP<:KFJ :FEALEKFJ <E <JK8 RI<8 (%"'",

JG

#LEKF :FE <JK8J 8JF:@8:@FE<J GIFG@:@8;8J GFI <C ;@J:LIJF GFCUK@:F P
C<>@K@D8;8J GFI CFJ ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ ALIU;@:FJ ;<9< K<E<IJ< <E :L<EK8 C8
G<IJG<:K@M8 <:FEWD@:8 HL< J< GFJ@:@FE8 <E C8J 8I>LD<EK8:@FE<J JF9I< C8J
8:K@M@;8;<J :@<EKU=@:8J P HL< 8G8I<:< :FEJ@>E8;8 :FDF <C<D<EKF :<EKI8C
;<EKIF;<C88::@WE8;D@E@JKI8K@M8;<CJ89<I
@:?8:<EKI8C@;8;<:FEWD@:8<E
C88;D@E@JKI8:@WE;<C:FEF:@D@<EKFJ<?@QF<M@;<EK<:L8E;F;<J;<C8I8QWE
:@<EKU=@:8 J< CC8DW C8 8K<E:@WE JF9I< C8 E<:<J@;8; ;< @DGC<D<EK8I LE8
GFCUK@:8HL<I<M<IJ8I8C8J@KL8:@WE;<CFJGIF=<JFI<JHL<:FDFGIF=<J@FE8C<J
EF>FQ8E;<:FE;@:@FE<JWGK@D8JG8I8<C;<J8IIFCCF;<JLJC89FI<J

)8I8 CF>I8I <C :8D9@F <;L:8K@MF GIFGFE<DFJ HL< <C ,I
)I<J@;<EK<
8JLD8 K8D9@SE G<IJFE8CD<EK< <C C@;<I8Q>F ;< C8 EL<M8 GFCUK@:8
<;L:8K@M8
E <CC8 J< GI<JK8IR LE8 8K<E:@WE :FE:<EKI8;8 8 C8
<;L:8:@WEGI<<J:FC8IP9RJ@:8G8I8<C ;<C8GF9C8:@WE;<8
8VFJ :FE 8CKUJ@D8 :8C@;8; P =FD<EKF 8 C8J @EEFM8:@FE<J <E=F:8;8 8C
:LCK@MF;<C8MF:8:@WE;<:8;8LEF;<C8:I<8K@M@;8;PCFJM8CFI<J;<
C8 :FEM@M<E:@8
)8I8 <CCF ;<9<IR MFCM<IJ< 8 C8 AFIE8;8 :FDGC<K8 ;<
F:?F ?FI8J P 8EK< KF;F =FID8I :FE J<I@<;8; I<DLE<I8I
8;<:L8;8D<EKE@f:8I JF:@8CD<EK< 8 CFJ ;F:<EK<J ;< C8
<;L:8:@WE9RJ@:8(%"'", JG

,@D@C8I<J ;<D8E;8J J< GI<J<EK8E G8I8 <C :8JF ;< CFJ D@<D9IFJ ;< CFJ
:<EKIFJ P >ILGFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE 8HLU J< <E=8K@Q8 JF9I< C8 E<:<J@;8; ;<
D<AFI8I C8J :FE;@:@FE<J =@E8E:@<I8J :FDF LE8 ;< C8J I<:FD<E;8:@FE<J
?<:?8J<EJLDFD<EKFGFIC8b&@J@WE;<,89@FJc

FIK8C<:ILGFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE <O@JK<EK<J
@:?FJ
:<EKIFJ P >ILGFJ ;<9<IRE I<:@9@I =FE;FJ G8I8 JL D<AFI8D@<EKF

@EJK@KL:@FE8C;<D8E<I8HL<GL<;8E@E:I<D<EK8IJL=LE:@WE=FID8;FI8
P JL 8:K@M@;8; @EM<JK@>8K@M8
J E<:<J8I@F ;FK8ICFJ :FE C89FI8KFI@FJ
9@<E<HL@G8;FJ:FEG<IJFE8C;<8GFPF:FE9@9C@FK<:8J8:KL8C@Q8;8JP
:FE I<;<J ;< :FDLE@:8:@WE DF;<IE8J G8I8 :FII<F <C<:KIWE@:F P
:FEJLCK8J898E:FJ;<;8KFJ@EK<IE8:@FE8C<J
%8J8:K@M@;8;<J;<<JKFJ
:<EKIFJP>ILGFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE;<9<IREFI>8E@Q8IJ<<EKSID@EFJ;<
)IF>I8D8J ;< <J8IIFCCF @<EKU=@:F P -<:EFCW>@:F <JKF XCK@DF =8:@C@K8
C8=FID8:@WE;<I<;<J;<@EM<JK@>8;FI<JHL<KI898A8EJF9I<LED@JDF
K<D8 F JF9I< K<D8J J@D@C8I<J <E ;@=<I<EK<J I<>@FE<J ;<C G8UJ
(%"'", JG

FDF J< F9J<IM8 <C CL>8I ;< <ELE:@8:@WE :@<EKU=@:F DRJ 8CCR ;<C GFCUK@:F
><E<I8 GIFGL<JK8J HL< J< 8:<I:8E 8 C8J ;@=<I<EK<J ;@D<EJ@FE<J @DGC@:8;8J
<E C8J C89FI<J @EM<JK@>8K@M8J P :@<EKU=@:8J 8C>LE8J ;< C8J I<:FD<E;8:@FE<J
?<:?8J8CJ<:KFIGFCUK@:FKI8J:@<E;<EC8GI<F:LG8:@WEGFIC8:L8EK@=@:8:@WEC8
D<;@:@WE P :FEKIFC ;< I<JLCK8;FJ P IFDG<E C8 CW>@:8 ;< C8 :FDG<K@K@M@;8;

JK<?<:?F<JDLP@DGFIK8EK<GFIHL<8;<DRJ;<I<:8C:8IC8@DGFIK8E:@8;<
CFJ GIF:<JFJ P C8 E<:<J@;8; ;< @DGC<D<EK8I :FE;@:@FE<J WGK@D8J G8I8 HL<
C8J@EM<JK@>8:@FE<J:@<EKU=@:8JI<8CD<EK<GL<;8E:FEKI@9L@I8C8><E<I8:@WE;<
EL<MF :FEF:@D@<EKF J< <DG@<Q8E 8 =8MFI<:<I GIF:<JFJ ;< JL9A<K@M8:@WE
:@<EKU=@:8HL<HL@<9I8EC8:CRJ@:8;@:FKFDU8:@<E:@8JF:@<;8;

C ?<:?F ;< 8KI8M<J8I <JK8 =IFEK<I8 `<IIWE<8D<EK< :FE:<9@;8` <EKI< CFJ
D8I:FJ :@<EKU=@:FJ P C8J :FE;@:@FE<J ?LD8E8J JF:@8C<J GJ@:FCW>@:8J
<:FEWD@:8J:LCKLI8C<JP:F>E@K@M8JHL<GIF;L:<E;@:?FJD8I:FJ:FEJK@KLP<
LE8 =FIK8C<Q8 <G@JK<DFCW>@:8 GFI G8IK< ;< HL@<E<J G@<EJ8E C8 :@<E:@8 <E
FCFD9@8
.E8;<C8JGI@D<I8J@;<8JHL<J<<OGC@:@KW8CI<JG<:KFD<E:@FE8
HL<^C8:FEJKIL::@WEP<CLJF;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJFEGIF:<JFJJF:@8C<JP:FDF
K8C K@<E<E =LE;8D<EKF P :FE:I<:@WE <E LE8 :LCKLI8 <JG<:@=@:8_
(%"'",8
LEHL<C8:WE@:8PGF;IU8DFJ;<:@IK8I;U8<JK8

8=@ID8:@WE89I<C8GL<IK8G8I8G<EJ8IP><JK@FE8IC8:@<E:@8DRJ8CCR;<LE8
:FE:<G:@WEGLI8D<EK<K<:E@:@JK8P9LIF:IRK@:8

,< ;<9< ;<JK8:8I HL< 8HLU J< ;8 LE G8JF :FEKLE;<EK< G8I8 @EK<>I8I C8
8:K@M@;8; ?LD8E8 ;<EKIF ;<C GIF:<JF ;< :I<8:@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ <E C8
><JK@WE GX9C@:8 ;<J;< <JK< RD9@KF C8 :@<E:@8 P C8 K<:EFCF>U8 J< bDL<JKI8Ec
<E JL :FE:I<:@WE
E <JK< J<EK@;F <C KI898AF :F>E@K@MF ;<A8 ;< JE8KLI8 ;<J;< LE =898< <OW><EF <J
JL=@:@<EK< G8I8 ;<JGC<>8I C8 GFK<E:@8 :I<8;FI8 ;< HL@<E<J <A<I:<E ;@:?8
C89FIPDRJ8XE:FDGI<E;<IJL;<M<E@IJF:@8C

)8I8=@E8C@Q8I<JK<:8GUKLCFJ<GL<;<:FE:CL@IHL<C8JKI8EJ=FID8:@FE<J;<C8
D8E<I8 ;< <A<I:FI@Q8:@FE<JC8EQ8;8J;<EKIF;<LEFI;<E;<M<I;8;HL<
@DGC@:8 CW>@:8J DRJ 8CCR ;< C8J :@<EKU=@:8J P C8 I<GIF;L::@WE ;< LE .=18<
:8G@K8C@JK8
C;@J:LIJFGFCUK@:FJF9I<C8:@<E:@8?88:8G8I8;FC8D8PFIG8IK<
;< CFJ ;<98K<J GX9C@:FJ SJK< J< ?8 GFJ@:@FE8;F :FDF <C I<=<I<EK< DRJ
@DGFIK8EK<;<J;<<C:L8CJ<GL<;<G<EJ8I<CHL<?8:<I:@<EKU=@:F

C;FD@E@F:FE:<GKL8C;<C8><JK@WE;<C8:@<E:@8:FDFJ<?8M@JKFG8IK<;<
C8:I<<E:@8<EHL<<DLC8I<C;<J8IIFCCF;<CEFIK<DLE;@8C<J<CXE@:F:8D@EF
GFJ@9C< G8I8 D<AFI8I C8J :FE;@:@FE<J JF:@8C<J P <:FEWD@:8J ;<C G8UJ
JK8
G<IJG<:K@M8 LCKI8 ;<J8IIFCC@JK8 F9EL9@C8 <C G<EJ8D@<EKF :IUK@:F ;< CFJ 9852,A
6*4.;<;<D8E<I8HL<J<8JLD<E:FE:<GKFJP:8K<>FIU8J;<FKI8JC8K@KL;<J
J@E GIF=LE;@Q8I F @EK<IG<C8I JL ><E<8CF>U8 JL J<EK@;F GFCUK@:F P JL @EK<ISJ
<:FEWD@:F
E <JK< GLEKF J< ?8:<E <M@;<EK<J CFJ :FEJK8EK<J :8D9@FJ P

8D9@>Y<;8;<J <E C8 ;<=@E@:@WE ;< C@E<8D@<EKFJ GIFG@FJ P EF <OKI8EA<IFJ
G8I8C8:FEJFC@;8:@WE;<C8J:@<E:@8J<E<CG8UJ

JK<HL@<9I<?8><E<I8;F8C>LE8J8D9@>Y<;8;<J<EC8EFID8K@M@;8;CF:L8C
I<;LE;8 <E C8 KI8EJ=@>LI8:@WE ;< C8J JL9A<K@M@;8;<J :@<EKU=@:8J <E <C J<EK@;F
HL<CFJ@EM<JK@>8;FI<JK@<E<EHL<8=IFEK8IF8JLD@IEL<MFJI<KFJ=@E8E:@<IFJ
KS:E@:FJ P 9LIF:IRK@:FJ HL< J< 8:LDLC8E <E JL G8G<C ;< ><E<I8;FI<J ;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJ
<<JK8D8E<I8<C:FEF:@D@<EKF8EK<J<EK<E;@;F:FDF9@<E
JF:@8C8?FI8<J:FEM<IK@;F<E<C<A<8IK@:LC8;FIG8I8<C=FIK8C<:@D@<EKF;<CFJ
;<J@>E@FJ GI@M8;FJ I<GI<J<EK8;FJ <E CFJ @EK<I<J<J @E;LJKI@8C<J P
<DGI<J8I@8C<J

%8 I8:@FE8C@;8; <:FEWD@:8 ;<C D<I:8;F :8G@K8C@JK8 J< :FEM@<IK< <E <C :LIJF
I<:KFI ;< C8 :@<E:@8 <E CFJ FIU><E<J D@JDFJ ;< C8 :FE:<GKL8C@Q8:@WE HL<
<D<;<C;@J:LIJFGFCUK@:FJF9I<C8:@<E:@8PC8K<:EFCF>U8J<<JG<:@=@:8<C
@EK<ISJ?8:@8C8:FEJKIL::@WE;<LEDF;<CF;<><JK@WEP;<8;D@E@JKI8:@WE;<C
:FEF:@D@<EKF KFK8CD<EK< C@>8;F 8 CFJ ;<J@>E@FJ ;<C E<FC@9<I8C@JDF
,<
I<=L<IQ8<EKFE:<JLE8.92<=.6.J@>E8;8GFI<C:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MFHL<J<
=LE;8D<EK8 <E C8 M@J@WE KI8J:<E;<EK8C ;<C ?<:?F <:FEWD@:F
)<IF <J
E<:<J8I@F ;<:@I HL< K8C :FDF J< GL;F F9J<IM8I 8C J<>L@I CFJ I8JKIFJ ;< CFJ
<ELE:@8;FJ8CFC8I>F;<C8I:?@MF<C:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MFEF<J<CbK<CWE;<
=FE;FcHL<<OGC@:8C8JGFCUK@:8J;<:@<E:@8PK<:EFCF>U8J@EF8C:FEKI8I@FJFE

A<DGCF ;< <CCF JFE CFJ :FEJK8EK<J I<;@I<::@FE8D@<EKFJ ;< C8 :FDG<K<E:@8 G8I8 C8 ;@J:LJ@WE P
8J@>E8:@WE;<I<:LIJFJ8C,'-"I<8C@Q8;FJ;LI8EK<<CG<I@F;F8E8C@Q8;FC8:L8CG8JWGFID8EFJ
;<C &@E@JK<I@F ;< ;L:8:@WE '8:@FE8C GFI <C <G8IK8D<EKF '8:@FE8C ;< )C8E<8:@WE GFI <C
FEJ<AF'8:@FE8C;<)FCUK@:8:FEWD@:8P,F:@8C('),PGFI(%"'",

^)8I8-8I;<KF;F<EC8<:FEFDU8DF;<IE8<JKRD8I:8;F:FE<CJ<CCF;<C8KI8J:<E;<E:@8PCF
J8>I8;F
FDFJ<GI<>LEK898'@<KQJ:?<8GIFGWJ@KF;<C8:@<E:@8b])FIHLSEFJFKIFJK8D9@SE
JFDFJG@8;FJFJKF;8MU8c_%8KFLIP%SG@E8P

<JK8JGFCUK@:8JC8JHL<<OGC@:8EP;<=@E<EC8:FE=FID8:@WEF:FE=@>LI8:@WE;<C
:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MF<EFCFD9@8

J @DGFIK8EK< I<J8CK8I HL< C8 :@<E:@FD<KIU8 <E K8EKF <JKI8K<>@8 D<K8
:@<EKU=@:8 :FE=@>LIW LE >ILGF ;< :FE:<GKFJ ;<=@E@:@FE<J JF9I< CFJ K@GFJ ;<
@EM<JK@>8:@WE CFJ @EM<JK@>8;FI<J CFJ GIFP<:KFJ P CFJ GIF;L:KFJ GLJF <E
K<EJ@WE ;@=<I<EK<J F9A<KFJ C8 @E;<O8:@WE :FDF b@;<8Cc :@<EKU=@:F C8
=@E8E:@8:@WE 8 G8IK@I ;< C8 GIF;L:K@M@;8; GI<M@8 :<EKI8C@;8; ;< C8 @EEFM8:@WE
JF9I< C8 :8C@;8; <K:
<JK89C<:@W ;@=<I<EK<J K@GFJ ;< <ELE:@8:@WE GFI
<A<DGCF 8C FKFI>8I 8 :8;8 >ILGF ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE LE CL>8I <JG<:U=@:F <E <C
:8DGF :@<EKU=@:F 8 KI8MSJ ;< C8 :C8J@=@:8:@WE F ;<J:C8J@=@:8:@WE P 8;FGKW
<JKI8K<>@8J DLP :FE:I<K8J <E <C :8DGF ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ
:@<EKU=@:FJ C8 <JK8;UJK@:8 :FDF FG:@WE P =LE;8D<EKF ;< C8 GFJ@K@M@;8;
D@JD8

%8 GL<IK8 8E8CUK@:8 HL< HL@<IF 89I@I ;8 C8 GFJ@9@C@;8; ;< :FDGI<E;I<E <E=F:8I JLJ
F9A<K@MFJ ?8:@8 C8 ><E<I8:@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ HL< J<8E :@<EKU=@:8 P
JF:@8CD<EK< I<C<M8EK<J P 8JU GF;8K@M8JDRJ8LKWEFD8J:FELE8I<J@>E@=@:8:@WE;<JLJ<EK@;FGFCUK@:F
P :FE LE8 EL<M8 I8:@FE8C@;8; HL< GI<:@J< JL I<C8:@WE :FE <C :8DGF
<:FEWD@:F

HLU;<9F;<:@IHL<D@:FE:<G:@WE;<C:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MF:FDFK<CWE;<=FE;F<OGC@:8K@MF;<
CFJ GIF:<JFJ ;< :FE=@>LI8:@WE ;< C8 :@<E:@8 =L< LEF ;< CFJ GLEKFJ ;< @E@:@F <E <C 8ERC@J@J ;<C
:8DGF:@<EKU=@:F<EFCFD9@8
,@E<D98I>F>I8:@8J8CFJ:FD<EK8I@FJPC8J:FEM<IJ8:@FE<J:FE
,8E;IF#@DSE<Q (:8DGF<JK8G<IJG<:K@M8<I8@EJL=@:@<EK<G8I8<OGC@:8IC8JGIR:K@:8J:@<EKU=@:8JP
<E KF;F :8JF ;898 GFI ?<:?F LE8 EF:@WE =FIRE<8 HL< <I8 <EK<E;@;8 :FDF LE8 M<I;8;
@E:L<JK@FE89C< F GFI CF D<EFJ C<>UK@D8 P HL< <E <J< :8JF EF <I8 E<:<J8I@F :L<JK@FE8IC8
<J:L;I@V8IC8
,FCF :FE <C <A<I:@:@F ;< 8ERC@J@J ;<C 8I:?@MF GL;< <E:FEKI8I P <EK<E;W <E FCFD9@8 ;<J;< G8I8 ?8:E@K@MF<JGIF;L:KF;<<J8.92<=.6.:FEJKIL@;8PEF
LE8b:FJ8;8;8cHL<<ED8I:8P<OGC@:8GFIJUD@JD8CFJRD9@KFJ;<CJ89<I:@<EKU=@:F

*,2.7,2*-.5<2058))1*;.7>7,2*-8*=8-*9;.=.7<2G7/258<G/2,*
A1*9*<*-8*<.;>70;*77.08,28
)8LC<P<I89<E;

.EF;<CFJ<C<D<EKFJ8E8CUK@:FJ:<EKI8C<J;<C8GI<J<EK<@EM<JK@>8:@WE<JC8
K<EJ@WE <EKI< C8J GIR:K@:8J :@<EKU=@:8J P C8J J@>E8KLI8J ;<C ;@J:LIJF GFCUK@:F
G8I8 C8 ;<K<ID@E8:@WE ;< ;@:?8J 8::@FE<J
E FCFD9@8 `:FDF J< <OGC@:@KW
<E <C :8GUKLCF 8EK<I@FI` <C FI;<E ;<C ;@J:LIJF JF9I< <JK< K<D8 ?8 <JK8;F
=L<IK<D<EK<C@>8;F8C8JK<E;<E:@8J@EK<IE8:@FE8C<J;<M@E:LC8ICFJGIF:<JFJ
P 8:K@M@;8;<J ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE :@<EKU=@:8 8 C8J CW>@:8J ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE ;<
9@<E<J D8K<I@8C<J
FE KF;FJ <JKFJ <C<D<EKFJ J< ?8 :FE=@>LI8;F LE8
@II<M<IJ@9C< ;@JGLK8 <EKI< =L<IQ8J ;< C8J ;@D<EJ@FE<J :@<EKU=@:8 GFCUK@:8 P
<:FEWD@:8 <JK8J =L<IQ8J DRJ HL< J<E;<J;<JLJ;<JGC@<>L<J
<JG<:U=@:FJ 8 LE8 I<FI>8E@Q8:@WE JF:@8C HL< 8C>LEFJ 8LKFI<J ?8E
;<EFD@E8;F ,*92=*52<68 ,8072=2?8
E <JK< :8GUKLCF ?8IS LE I<:FII@;F GFI
8C>LEFJ ;< JLJ GC8EK<8D@<EKFJ ><E<I8C<J K<E@<E;F :FDF 98J< 8E8CUK@:8 <C
+<:FI;<DFJHL<<C8ERC@J@J;<CGI@D<I:8GUKLCFJ<;<JGC<>W<ECFJE@M<C<J;<8::@WE;@J:LIJ@MF
GI8>DRK@:FI<>LC8K@MFP;<JL9A<K@M8:@WE
E:8;8LEF;<<JKFJE@M<C<J8G8I<:U8ECFJ8><EK<JF
bI<GI<J<EK8EK<Jc;<C8:@<E:@8C8<:FEFDU8PC8GFCUK@:8:FED8PFIFD<EFII<C<M8E:@8PM@J@9@C@;8;
J<>XECFJ@EK<I<J<JPC8J=L<IQ8JDFM@C@Q8;8J;<J;<JLJG8IK@:LC8I<JCL>8I<J;<<ELE:@8:@WE

8I:?@MF :FEJKIL@;F G8I8 C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE <E <JK< J<EK@;F M8C< ;<:@I HL< CFJ
GIFG@FJ 8:FEK<:@D@<EKFJ F:LII@;FJ ;LI8EK< <C G<I@F;F <JKL;@8;F 8:KL8IRE
:FDF >LU8 8E8CUK@:8 G8I8 :FDGI<E;LI8:@WE ;<C :8G@K8C@JDF
:F>E@K@MF<EFCFD9@8
CI<:FII@;FHL<HL@<IFGC8EK<8I8HLUKFD8:FDF<A<
<C<EKI<:ILQ8D@<EKF<EKI<CFJE@M<C<J;<8::@WE;<J:I@KFJ8EK<I@FID<EK<PC8J
:FE:<GKL8C@Q8:@FE<J 8CI<;<;FI ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ <E C8J
JF:@<;8;<J:FEK<DGFIRE<8J

,< ;<9< I<:8C:8I LE8 M<Q DRJ HL< EF :FEJ@;<IF <C :8G@K8C@JDF :F>E@K@MF
:FDF C8 b<OGC@:8:@WE :FEK<OKL8Cc ;< C8J GFCUK@:8J ;< :@<E:@8 P K<:EFCF>U8 ;<C
G8UJ J@EF HL< 8C :FEKI8I@F J<>XE CF L9@:8;F <E <C 8ERC@J@J ;<C 8I:?@MF C8
;@D<EJ@WE GFCUK@:8 ÀLEKF :FE FKIFJ <C<D<EKFJ ;< FI;<E <:FEWD@:F P
:@<EKU=@:F` <OGC@:8 ;<=@EE@K@MF <E FCFD9@8
EK@<E;F <C
:8G@K8C@JDF :F>E@K@MF :FDF LE8 KI8D8 HL< J< :FEJKILP< ;<J;< DXCK@GC<J
<J:<E8I@FJ?@JKWI@:FJPHL<;<M@<E<<E8:FEK<:@D@<EKFKI@;@D<EJ@FE8C8XE<E
KI8EJ@:@WE P EF :FDF LE GI<:<GKF JF:@8C ;8;F HL< J< 8JLD< ;<J;< CFJ
:REFE<J<G@JK<DFCW>@:FJ;<C8J:@<E:@8JJF:@8C<J:FEK<DGFIRE<8J

.E8 ?85>7=*- -. ?.;-*- K8C F=I<:<IU8 LE8 G<IJG<:K@M8 I<;L::@FE@JK8 ;<C
:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MF8C<O:CL@I;<C8ERC@J@JJLJ:FE<O@FE<J=<EFD<EFCW>@:8J
:FDF:FEJ<:L<E:@8J<I<;L:@IU8C8GIF;L::@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ:@<EKU=@:FJ8
LE8 FEKFCF>U8 :FEJL<KL;@E8I@8 <E K8EKF ISGC@:8 F DLCK@GC@:8:@WE ;< C8J
:FEM<E:@FE<J8E8CUK@:8J<E9F>8

,F9I< C8 8;FG:@WE ;< :@<IK8J K<FIU8J GFI G8IK< ;< CFJ @EM<JK@>8;FI<J ?I@JK@8E L:?J ;@:< CF
J@>L@<EK<^LEHL<C8JK<FIU8JJF:@8C<JJFE:FDGC<A8J<EJUD@JD8J<J:F><ILE:FE:<GKF:C8M<
J@>E@=@:8 ?8:<I SE=8J@J <E :@<IKFJ =8:KFI<J HL< J< :FEJ@;<I8E ;< G8IK@:LC8I @DGFIK8E:@8 P
;<J:I@9@ICFJ <E K8EKF HL< @E=CL<E:@8J =LE;8D<EK8C<J HL< ;8E =FID8 P :8D9@8E C8 JF:@<;8;_
L:?J
J GI<:@J8D<EK< GFI C8 ;<:@J@WE ;< ?8:E@K@MFJ@E
<D98I>FSJK8J<8JLD<EF:FDF<OGC@:8:@WE;8;8HL<;8=FID88C8JF:@<;8;J@EF:FDF;<M<E@I
;< C8J 8JF:@8:@FE<J <:FEWD@:8J GFCUK@:8J P :@<EKU=@:8J 8:FEK<:@D@<EKF KI@;@D<EJ@FE8C HL< <J
I<;<=@E@;F 8 D<;@;8 HL< CFJ KI<J <C<D<EKFJ 9RJ@:FJ <:FEFDU8 GFCUK@:8 P :@<E:@8 K<A<E EL<M8J
8JF:@8:@FE<J

) *#!" !

.E8 ;< C8J @;<8J HL< 8:KL8CD<EK< J< <I@><E <E 8DGC@FJ <JG8:@FJ ;< C8
I<=C<O@WE 8:8;SD@:8 <J C8 @EJK8LI8:@WE F 8 M<:<J 8;M<E@D@<EKF ;< C8
CC8D8;8 <8,2.-*- -.5 ,878,262.7=8 <E C8J JF:@<;8;<J F::@;<EK8C<J :FDF
=FID8 :FEK<DGFIRE<8 ;< C8J I<C8:@FE<J ;< GIF;L::@WE < @EK<I:8D9@F ;<
9@<E<JD8K<I@8C<J<@ED8K<I@8C<JJ@E<D98I>F<JK8@;<8<JKIL:KLI8;8GFIC8J
:@<E:@8JJF:@8C<J;<9<J<II<M@J@K8;88C8CLQ;<CFJ8:FEK<:@D@<EKFJGIFG@FJ
P;<C8GI8>DRK@:8J@E>LC8I<ECFHL<J<I<:FEF:<:FDFC8:FE=@>LI8:@WE;<C
:8DGF;<C8GIF;L::@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ
JKF:FE<C=@E;<@EK<IG<C8IEF
JFCFC8:FE:<GKL8C@Q8:@WEJF9I<CFJ8:FEK<:@D@<EKFJJF:@8C<J8:F>@;8GFICFJ
@EM<JK@>8;FI<J P G<EJ8;FI<J ;< EL<JKI8J C8K@KL;<J J@EF K8D9@SE CFJ
=LE;8D<EKFJ @;<FCW>@:FJ ;< C8 8::@WE GFCUK@:8 <E <C ;@I<::@FE8D@<EKF P
:FE=@>LI8:@WE;<C:8DGF:@<EKU=@:F

)8I8 <CCF D< ?< 98J8;F <E C8 <OG<I@<E:@8 :FCFD9@8E8 EF :FDF GLEKF ;<
I<=<I<E:@8 <D9C<DRK@:F J@EF DRJ 9@<E :FDF =IFEK<I8 GIFM@J@FE8C ;< C8
I<=C<O@WE <E <C J<EK@;F HL< J< I<:FII< C8 J@E>LC8I@;8; ;<C :8JF 8:FDG8V8;8
;< :FE<O@FE<J >CF98C<J HL< <E:L8;I8E C8 GIF;L::@WE :FEK<DGFIRE<8 ;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJ

.E8ERC@J@J:IUK@:F;<<JK8EF:@WEGL<;<<E:FEKI8IJ<<E<C8IKU:LCF;<8ICFJ/8C;<II8D8
HL@<E?8:<LEI<:FII@;F;<J;<@E@:@FJ;<CJ@>CF1"1G8I8;8I:L<EK8;<:WDF<C:FEF:@D@<EKF?8
J@;FF9A<KF;<;@JGLK8P;<;<=@E@:@WE;<CFJ@EK<I<J<JGFCUK@:FJ@E;<G<E;@<EK<D<EK<;<JL=FID8
FI>8E@Q8K@M8
C F9A<K@MF :<EKI8C ;<C KI898AF ;< /8C;<II8D8 <J @EK<IG<C8I CFJ I<;L::@FE@JDFJ <E
KFIEF8C:FE:<GKF;<<8,2.-*--.5*27/8;6*,2G7;<J;<C8JGIR:K@:8JGFCUK@:8JP;@J:LIJ@M8J

HLU <J XK@C I<D@K@IJ< 8 C8 GFJKLI8 ;< ILEF %8KFLI I<JG<:KF 8C 8ERC@J@J ;< C8J 8JF:@8:@FE<J
J<>XE C8 =FID8:@WE ;< >ILGFJ
,FJK@<E< %8KFLI HL< CF HL< J< <EK@<E;< :FDXED<EK< GFI
bJF:@<;8;c EF ;<9< 8E8C@Q8IJ< ;<J;< LE8 G<IJG<:K@M8 bD@:IFc F bD8:IFc J@EF HL< J< ;<9< G8IK@I
;< C8J ^:FEKIFM<IJ@8J_ JLI>@;8J ;<J;< CFJ GIFM@J@FE8C<J >ILGFJ P ;<J;< 8CCU I8JKI<8I C8J
;@=<I<EK<J:FE<O@FE<JHL<<JFJ>ILGFJ<JK89C<:<E:FEFKIFK@GF;<8JF:@8:@FE<JJ@E@DGFIK8ILE8
EF:@WE;@D<EJ@FE8C;<CFD@:IFFCFD8:IFPJJ

%8 EF:@WE DUK@:8 ;< bGIF>I<JFc 89FI;8;8 <E <C :8GUKLCF 8EK<I@FI 9LJ:8 JL
D8K<I@8C@Q8:@WE 8 G8IK@I ;<C <E:L8;I< E8II8K@MF ;< C8 bJF:@<;8; ;<C
:FEF:@D@<EKFc<C:L8C8G8I<:<:FDFLECL>8I:FDXE<ECFJ;<98K<JGX9C@:FJ
P GI@M8;FJ HL< J< CC<M8IFE 8 :89F G8I8 G<EJ8I <C IFC GFI :@<IKF :8J@
<O:CLJ@M8D<EK< =LE:@FE8C ;< C8 :@<E:@8 <E C8 JF:@<;8;
JK< =8982
<D<EK< ;< C8J :@<E:@8J JF:@8C<J ?8 J@;F E8KLI8C@Q8;F ;<EKIF ;< CFJ
;@J:LIJFJ K<:EF:IRK@:FJ 8C GLEKF ;< M8:@8ICF ;< :FEK<E@;F F :L8E;F D<EFJ
;<J<EK@;F:FEK<OKL8C

E <C I<:FII@;F GFI <C 8I:?@MF :FEJKIL@;F J< GL;F MU88GLEK88LE8EF:@WE;<bJF:@<;8;;<C
:FEF:@D@<EKFcHL<ELE:8<J8E8C@Q8;8<E<C:FEK<OKF<E<C:L8CJ<<ELE:@8
<C @;<8C ;<C GIF>I<JF <JKR D8I:8;F GFI CC<>8I 8 JE@=@:8 I<8CD<EK< bGF;<Ic CC<>8I 8 JU8
%8EF:@WE;<b:@<E:@8G8I8<C;<J8IIFCCFP<CGIF>I<JFc
J<<E:L<EKI88CFC8I>F;<C;@J:LIJF<JJ@J<HL@<I<LE8?85>7=*--.?.;-*-
;<JGC<>8;8:FDFG8E8:<8G8I8<CJL9;<J8IIFCCF;<CG8UJ

%8 ;@J:LIJ@M@;8; GFCUK@:8 <E KFIEF 8 C8 :@<E:@8 P K<:EFCF>U8 <E=F:8;8 <E
@EJK@KL@I LE8 bJF:@<;8; ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKFc <E C8 :L8C <C :FEF:@D@<EKF <J
JL9JLD@;FGFIC8CW>@:8;<CD<I:8;FG8I8<C=FD<EKF;<CJ<:KFIGIF;L:K@MF
J< D8K<I@8C@QW 8 KI8MSJ ;< LE8 J<I@< ;< ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ 98AF C8 =FID8 ;<
bJ@JK<D8Jc <E CFJ :L8C<J C8 KFD8 ;< ;<:@J@FE<J C8 8;D@E@JKI8:@WE P C8
C<>@K@D8:@WE ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ <JKLMF DRJ <E <C :8DGF
GFCUK@:FHL<<E<CGIFG@F:8DGF:@<EKU=@:F
JKFJJ@JK<D8JJ<<EK@<E;<E:FDF
;@JGFJ@K@MFJ;<I<>LC8:@WE;<C8GIF;L::@WE;<CFJ:FEF:@D@<EKFJ:@<EKU=@:FJ

C :FE:<GKF ;< =8982 CF ?8 KI898A8;F +LK? 0F;8B P ?8:< I<=<I<E:@8 8 8I>LD<EK8:@FE<J F
:8K<>FI@Q8:@FE<J ;<C ;@J:LIJF HL< JFE @E;@JG<EJ89C<J G8I8 ?@C8I C8 GIFG@8 <ELE:@8:@WE
JK8J
:8K<>FI@Q8:@FE<JJ<?8:<E:FDLE<J?8JK8GFJ@:@FE8IJ<:FDFbM<I;8;c<E<CRD9@KFGX9C@:FGFI
K8CI8QWEEFJ<:L<JK@FE8EFJ<G8J8EGFI8CKF<EK8EKF<M@;<E:@8JHL<EFI<HL@<I<EALJK@=@:8:@WEE@
@EK<IG<C8:@WE
/<IGFI<A<DGCF0F;8B P8>8I

;@JGFJ@K@MFJHL<<E;<=@E@K@M8:FE=@>LI8IFE<C:8DGF:@<EKU=@:FG8I8=FIK8C<:8:@WE
J <E ;@:?F :FEK<OKF
<E <C :L8C J< ;<9<E <EK<E;@8J ;< :FDG<K@K@M@;8; P
A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE :FDF C8 :@<E:@FD<KIU8 C8 9@9C@FD<KIU8 P C8 :C8J@=@:8:@WE ;<
>ILGFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE

%F 8EK<I@FI ;<A8 MU8 <E FCFD9@8 J< ?8E
<;@=@:8;F JF9I< C8 98J< ;< GFCUK@:8J :LPF FI;<E ;<C ;@J:LIJF 8GLEK8 8 C8
<JK8E;8I@Q8:@WE ;< GIF:<;@D@<EKFJ C8 :L8EK@=@:8:@WE ;< CFJ GIF;L:KFJ P C8
A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE ;< CFJ >ILGFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE
JKF :FDF J< ?8 M@JKF
I<JGFE;< 8 LE8 CW>@:8 ;<C D<I:8;F <E ;FE;< <C :FEF:@D@<EKF <EKI8 <E <C
AL<>F;<C:8G@K8C:FDFD<I:8E:U8@EK8E>@9C<;<8CKFM8CFI<EFKI8JG8C89I8J
C8GFCUK@:8JF9I<:@<E:@8PK<:EFCF>U8:FEJK@KL@;8;<J;<C8;S:8;8;<C;<C
J@>CFG8J8;F=L<C8GI@E:@G8C6.-2*,2G7G8I8C8:FE=@>LI8:@WE;<C:8G@K8C@JDF
:F>E@K@MF<EFCFD9@8

JUGL<JC8GIF;L::@WE:FEK<DGFIRE<8;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJJ<CC<M88:89F8
KI8MSJ;<C8C<>@K@D8:@WE;<C:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MF<C:L8CFG<I8D<;@8EK<CFJ
GIF:<;@D@<EKFJ <JK89C<:@;FJ @EJK@KL:@FE8C P >L9<IE8D<EK8CD<EK< G8I8 CC<M8I
8:89FC8J8:K@M@;8;<J:@<EKU=@:8J:FELESE=8J@J<JG<:@8C<ECFJD<:8E@JDFJ
G8I8 CF>I8I <C GFJ@:@FE8D@<EKF ;< :@<IKFJ GIF;L:KFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ 8GFPRE;FJ<
<E ;@J:LIJFJ ;<C ;<J8IIFCCF <C GIF>I<JF P C8 @EEFM8:@WE
C GIFGWJ@KF ;< C8
:@<E:@8 <E EL<JKIF G8UJ J< ?8 :FE=@>LI8;F :FDF LE 8JLEKF ;< <JKI8K<>@8
GFCUK@:8 <E C8 M@J@9@C@Q8:@WE ;<C J89<I <E ;FE;< <C D<I:8;F 8:KX8 :FDF AL<Q
G8I:@8C P ;<=@E@K@MF G8I8 <JK89C<:<I CFJ C@E<8D@<EKFJ P CFJ @EK<I<J<J HL< J<
;<9<E 89FI;8I JF:@8C P :@<EKU=@:8D<EK< <E C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ

)8I8 %8KFLI CFJ D<;@8;FI<J 8 ;@=<I<E:@8 ;< CFJ @EK<ID<;@8I@FJ ^KI8EJ=FID8E KI8;L:<E
;@JKFIJ@FE8E P DF;@=@:8E <C J@>E@=@:8;F F CFJ <C<D<EKFJ HL< J< JLGFE< HL< ;<9<E KI8EJ=FID8I_

,< ;@:< HL< C8 GFCUK@:8 =L< LE8 D<;@8;FI8 GFIHL< SJK8 DF;@=@:W <C J<EK@;F ;< C8
GIF;L::@WE:@<EKU=@:88J@>ERE;FC<EL<MFJIFC<JPF9A<K@MFJHL< =L<IFE8JF:@8;FJ8C8J;@ERD@:8J
;<CD<I:8;F

8AFC8S>@;8;@J:LIJ@M8;<C8bJF:@<;8;;<C:FEF:@D@<EKFcJ<@DGC<D<EK8IFE
;@M<IJFJ ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ HL< 8J<>LI8IFE C8 @E:CLJ@WE P :FEKIFC ;< KF;FJ CFJ
@EM<JK@>8;FI<JP>ILGFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WEFGFICFD<EFJ;<KF;FJ8HL<CCFJ
HL< HL@J@<I8E 8G8I<:8J P G8I<J P 8EK< C8
JF:@<;8; <E ><E<I8C
JK< GIF:<JF ;< C<>@K@D8:@WE ;<C J89I8:@8J 8 C8J
KI8EJ=FID8:@FE<J:8G@K8C@JK8JHL<M<EU8EF:LII@<E;F<E<CDLE;FF::@;<EK8C
<E;FE;<C8JLE@M<IJ@;8;<JPCFJ:<EKIFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE<DG<Q8IFE8J<I<C
<G@:<EKIF ;< C8 <:FEFDU8 DLE;@8C P 8JU =L<IFE GFJ@:@FE8;FJ :FDF
GIF;L:KFI<J GI@M@C<>@8;FJ ;< 9@<E<J @ED8K<I@8C<J 98AF C8 =FID8 ;<
:FEF:@D@<EKF<JG<:@8C@Q8;FPJ89<I:@<EKU=@:F

< <JK8 D8E<I8 C8J <JKI8K<>@8J CC<M8;8J 8 :89F <E EL<JKIF G8UJ G8I8 C8
C<>@K@D8:@WE ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE :@<EKU=@:8 8G8I<:@<IFE 8EK< CFJ FAFJ ;< CFJ
@EM<JK@>8;FI<J:FDF8C>FE8KLI8CP7.,.<*;28G8I8<C;<J8IIFCCF;<C8:@<E:@8
<J ;<:@I G8I8 8C:8EQ8I CFJ DF;<CFJ ;< ;<J8IIFCCF :@<EKU=@:F ;< CFJ G8UJ<J
@E;LJKI@8C@Q8;FJ
JK< I<C8KF J< JLJK<EKW 8 JL M<Q <E <C 8E;8D@8A<
@EJK@KL:@FE8C <JK89C<:@;F G8I8 CC<M8I 8 :89F C8 8;D@E@JKI8:@WE ;< C8 :@<E:@8 P
:LPFF9A<K@MF=L<<JK89C<:<IC8J8K8C8P8J;<CJ89<ID<;@8EK<C8@EKIF;L::@WE
;< J@JK<D8J <OKI8EA<IFJ J@E I<:FEF:<I JLJ 8:@<IKFJ P ;<J8:@<IKFJ P J@E
8E8C@Q8I C8J @DGC@:8:@FE<J G8I8 C8 :@<E:@8 :FCFD9@8E8
%FJ ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ
@DGC<D<EK8;FJ<EEL<JKIFG8UJ;<J:I@KFJ<E<C:8GUKLCF8EK<I@FI;8E:L<EK8
;< <J< DFM@D@<EKF ;< <DLC8:@WE HL< ><E<IW LE8 J@DGC@=@:8:@WE ;< C8J
<G@JK<DFCF>U8J :@<EKU=@:8J P LE8 ?FDF><E<@Q8:@WE ;< C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J ;<
@EM<JK@>8:@WE <JK89C<:@<E;F LE DF;<CF XE@:F G8I8 C8 GIF;L::@WE ;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJ
)8I8;WA@:8D<EK< 8 G8IK@I ;< C8 ;S:8;8 ;< K8D9@SE J<
?89U8 GIF;L:@;F <JK< <=<:KF ;< J@DGC@=@:8:@WE P ?FDF><E<@Q8:@WE <E CFJ
G8UJ<J;<CEFIK<K8C:FDFCFI<C8K8+@:?8I;0?@KC<P

FE LE8 DF;8C@;8; HL< K8C M<Q J<8 KUG@:8 ;< :L8CHL@8E@Q8:@WE @EK<C<:KL8C P JF:@8C P GFI CF K8EKF
9LJ:898E @DGFE8:@WE0?@KC@:F8EK<<CI<C8KF;<C
b8;M<E@D@<EKFc ;< C8 JF:@<;8; ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF I<C8KF HL< J< @;<EK@=@:898
:FE <C GIF:<JF ;< @EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8:@WE ;< CFJ :8DGFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ 8;<C8EK8;F
GFICFJG8UJ<J@E;LJKI@8C@Q8;FJ;<J;<;S:8;8J8EK<I@FI<JG<IFHL<EFGF;U8
:FII<JGFE;<IJ<:FEC8J@KL8:@WE;<EL<JKI8JC8K@KL;<J

)8I8 IFDGDRK@:F ;<
J<>L@D@<EKF P I8JKI<F 8 C8J :FE;@:@FE<J GFCUK@:8J >L9<IE8D<EK8C<J P
8;D@E@JKI8K@M8JHL<:FE;LA<IFE8C8@DGC<D<EK8:@WE8;FG:@WE;<CFJDF;<CFJ
<OKI8EA<IFJHL< ><E<I8IFE I<C8:@FE<J @EK<I@EJK@KL:@FE8C<J 98J8;8J DRJ <E
CFJ GI@E:@G@FJ ;<C E<FC@9<I8C@JDF HL< <E C8 2-.* ;< C8 ;<DF:IRK@:8 JF:@<;8;
;<C:FEF:@D@<EKF

" ) *

%8GIFGL<JK8:FE:<GKL8C;<J;<C8:L8CJ<?8:FEJKIL@;FC88I>LD<EK8:@WE<E
<JK<KI898AF9LJ:8?8:<ILE8@EK<IG<C8:@WE8CG8G<CHL<?8AL>8;F<CJK8;F
:FCFD9@8EF:FDFJLA<KF;<;<K<ID@E8:@WE;<C8:@<E:@8PJL><JK@WE;<J;<<C
RD9@KF <JKI@:K8D<EK< GFCUK@:F
JKFJ 8JG<:KFJ ?8E J@;F ;<K<ID@E8EK<J G8I8

.E 8ERC@J@J JF:@FCW>@:F ;< CFJ J@JK<D8J ;< :FEF:@D@<EKF ;< G8UJ<J :FDF JK8;FJ .E@;FJ
"E>C8K<II8C<D8E@8P#8GWEGL<;<<E:FEKI8IJ<<E0?@KCE@K@MF G<IF <J @DGFIK8EK< I<J8CK8I HL< <JK< :8G@K8C@JDF
<JK89C<:@;F GFI CFJ >ILGFJ GFCUK@:FJ P <:FEWD@:FJ JLI>< >I8:@8J 8 C8J
;@JK@EK8J8JF:@8:@FE<J<EKI<C8:@<E:@8P<CD<I:8;FHL<J<@EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8IFE
:FE @EK<IM<E:@WE ;< C8J K<:EFCF>U8J ;< 8;D@E@JKI8:@WE ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF
@DGC<D<EK8;8J

E<JK<J<EK@;FC8K<J@JGIFGL<JK8<JHL<<C:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MFEFCC<>W8C
G8UJ GFI JL 8::@WE 8LKWEFD8 :FDF LE8 JFD9I8 HL< M8 <OK<E;@SE;FJ<
G8LC8K@E8D<EK< J@EF GFI 8::@WE :FE:I<K8 ;< @E;@M@;LFJ P >ILGFJ HL<
DFM@C@Q8IFE :@<IK8J K<EJ@FE<J <EKI< CFJ GIF:<;@D@<EKFJ P C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J
:@<EKU=@:8JGFILEC8;FPCFJ@EK<I<J<J;<CJ<:KFIGIF;L:K@MF <DGI<J8I@8CGFI
<CFKIFC8;F
%FHL<?<@EK<EK8;F:FE<JK8@EM<JK@>8:@WE<JJ<>L@ICFJI8JKIFJ
;<C ;@J:LIJF 8:<I:8 ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ P C8J GIR:K@:8J
><E<I8;8J 8CCU :FDF LE <EC8:< <EKI< C8J :FJ8J ;@:?8J CFJ ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ
;<JGC<>8;FJPCFJ=CLAFJ;<C<OK<I@FIHL<=L<IFE@DGC<D<EK8;FJ <E<CGIFG@F
:8DGF ;< C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE :@<EKU=@:8 =CLAFJ K8C<J :FDF C8 :@<E:@FD<KIU8 P C8
G8LG<I@Q8:@WE ;< C8 GIF=<J@WE ;F:<EK< MLIWCFHL<;<EFD@E8DFJ:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MF<C:L8C8
G8IK@I ;< EL<M8J 8JF:@8:@FE<J J< KI8EJ=FID8 ><E<I8E;F 8 JL M<Q EL<M8J
JL9A<K@M8:@FE<J:@<EKU=@:8J
%8?@GWK<J@JGC8EK<8<EKFE:<JHL<<C:8G@K8C@JDF
:F>E@K@MF DRJ HL< LE :FE:<GKF 89JKI8:KF ;< C8 <:FEFDU8 GFCUK@:8 <J LE
8:FEK<:@D@<EKF :FE LE8 ><E<8CF>U8 GIFG@8 I8JKI<89C< <E EL<JKIF G8UJ 8
KI8MSJ;<C8KIU8;8;@J:LIJFJ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ=CLAFJ

JK8 G<IJG<:K@M8 GI8>DRK@:8 JF9I< <C :8G@K8C@JDF :F>E@K@MF <OGC@:8 JL
><E<8CF>U8 <E EL<JKIF G8UJ P ;<=@E< :WDF FG<I8E C8 GIF;L::@WE ;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJPJLJI8J>FJK<C<FCW>@:FJ<J;<:@I<OGC@:8<CG8G<C8KI@9L@;F8

C8 :@<E:@8 P CFJ @EK<I<J<J GL<JKFJ <E <CC8 GFI CFJ >ILGFJ <:FEWD@:FJ P
GFCUK@:FJ
%8 :L<JK@WE <EKFE:<J <J I8JKI<8I <C K@GF ;< GIR:K@:8J P ;<
8JF:@8:@FE<J HL< J< ><E<I8E <EKI< CFJ GFCUK@:FJ CFJ <DGI<J8I@FJ P CFJ
:@<EKU=@:FJ J<>L@I JLJ I<C8:@FE<J P C8J ILGKLI8J G8I8 ;8I :L<EK8 ;< C8J
J@>E8KLI8J P ;< C8J GIR:K@:8J ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE :@<EKU=@:8 J@E G8IK@I F ;8I
GI@FI@;8;E<:<J8I@8D<EK<8LE:FEK<OKFbD@:IFcFbD8:IFc

)FIFKIFC8;F<J:FEM<E@<EK<J<V8C8IHL<<EK<E;<I<C:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MF
EF :FDF LE K<CWE ;< =FE;F HL< <OGC@:8 P b:FEK<OKL8C@Q8c C8 GIF;L::@WE ;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJJ@EF:FDFLE8J<I@<;<8:FEK<:@D@<EKFJHL<JFE<OGC@:8;FJ
FGFICFD<EFJ;<J:I@KFJ8KI8MSJ;<C8J8JF:@8:@FE<JGI<:<;<EK<JK@<E<LE8
@EK<E:@FE8C@;8;HL<EF<J=FIKL@K8
,<KI8K8;<b;8IML<CK8c8C8J<OGC@:8:@FE<J
<JKIL:KLI8C@JK8JHL<GFE<E<C:8G@K8C@JDF:FDF<C:FEK<OKFPC8:@<E:@8:FDF
JL;<M<E@I
HLUC8D@I8;8<J;@=<I<EK<GL<JJFEC8JGIR:K@:8J ;@J:LIJ@M8JP
JLJ I<8C@Q8:@FE<J C8J HL< :FEJK@KLP<E LE8 I<; ;<J;< C8 :L8C J< :@D<EK8 <C
:8G@K8C@JDF :FEK<DGFIRE<F <C :8G@K8C@JDF EF <J <C :FEK<OKF ;< <OGC@:8:@WE
J@EF DRJ 9@<E C8 <OGC@:8:@WE D@JD8 ;< CFJ WI;<E<J <E C8 GIF;L::@WE ;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJ

<EKIF ;< CFJ <ELE:@8;FJ GFCUK@:FJ J< ?8 D<E:@FE8;F :FEK@EL8D<EK< C8
E<:<J@;8;;<?8:<I;<FCFD9@8LE8JF:@<;8;;<C:FEF:@D@<EKFJ<8G<C88
J<>L@I<CDF;<CF;<CFJbG8UJ<J;<J8IIFCC8;FJcG8I8<JK89C<:<ILE8JF:@<;8;
ALJK8
)<IF <JK8 <ELE:@8:@WE GFCUK@:8 ;< C8 JF:@<;8; ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF ?8
F9M@8;FJ@JK<DRK@:8D<EK<C8JI<=C<O@FE<J8:8;SD@:8JJF9I<<CK<D8<EKI<
FKI8J :FJ8J GFIHL< <J DRJ :FII<:KF `GFCUK@:8D<EK< ?89C8E;F` ;<:@I

!8:@8 <J< D@JDF J<EK@;F 8GLEK8 C8 F9J<IM8:@WE ;< %8KFLI JF9I< C8 ;@M@J@WE <EKI< :@<E:@8 P
JF:@<;8; ^!<DFJ ;< J<>L@I C8 GIF;L::@WE J@DLCKRE<8 ;< LE cK<OKFc P LE b:FEK<OKFc
E FKI8J
G8C89I8J :L8CHL@8DFJ <EKI< JF:@<;8; GFI LE C8;F P :FEK<E@;F :@<EKU=@:F P
KS:E@:FGFIFKIF<JE<:<J8I@8D<EK<8I9@KI8I@8_%8KFLI

.E <A<DGCF ;< C8J I<:@<EK<J I<=C<O@FE<J 8:8;SD@:8J 8C I<JG<:KF GL<;<E <E:FEKI8IJ< <E <C
EXD<IF;<C8I<M@JK8 G6*-*<;<C"EJK@KLKF;<JKL;@FJ,F:@8C<JFEK<DGFIRE<FJ",(;<
C8 .E@M<IJ@;8; <EKI8C :LPF DFEF>IR=@:F <J ^,F:@<;8; ;< C8 @E=FID8:@WE P <C :FEF:@D@<EKF
;<98K<J:IUK@:FJ_

GX9C@:8D<EK< HL< J< HL@<I< LE8 JF:@<;8; ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF P EF C8
@DGC<D<EK8:@WE ;< LE8 CW>@:8 8:FI;< :FE CFJ GI@E:@G@FJ ;<C :8G@K8C@JDF
:FEK<DGFIRE<F
FDFCFD<E:@FE8E+F;IU>L<QP,RE:?<Q

^8G@K8C@JDF :F>E@K@MF_ HL@<I< J@:8 ;< C8J <K@HL<K8J JF:@FCW>@:8J 8C LJF LE8 JL<IK< ;<
:FIK8=IUFJ ;< LE8 GIR:K@:8 K<WI@:8 C8I>F K@<DGF ><C@=@:8;8
FDF
:FE:<GKF GFCUK@:F J<V8C8 D<EFJ C8 @E<CL:K89C< KI8EJ=FID8:@WE ;< LE
DF;<CF K<WI@:F :FDF C8 ^GL<JK8 8 KI898A8I_ `<E <J< J<EK@;F HL<
@E;@:8 C8 :F8::@WE P <C JFD<K@D@<EKF 8 LE8 I<C8:@WE J8C8I@8C` ;< LE8
EL<M8:FEJK<C8:@WE<OG8EJ@M8;<J89<I<JP:FEF:@D@<EKFJ

JU GL<J J< LK@C@QW C8 @;<8 ;< JF:@<;8; ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF :FDF <JKI8K<>@8
GFCUK@:8 G8I8 :FE=@>LI8I C8 C<>@K@D8:@WE ;<C J89LIW LE DF;<CF ;< GIF;L::@WE ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF J@EF HL<
G8I8C<C8 P :FDGC<D<EK8I@8D<EK< ?L9F LE8 KI8EJ=@>LI8:@WE ;< C8J
JL9A<K@M@;8;<J:@<EKU=@:8J;<D8E<I8HL<<C<A<I:@:@F;<8;D@E@JKI8:@WE;<C8
GIF;L::@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJEFGIFMF:WD8PFI<JK<EJ@FE<J<EKI<GFCUK@:FJP
:@<EKU=@:FJGL<JSJKFJ=L<IFE^<EIFC8;FJ_`G8I8LJ8ILE:FE:<GKF;<%8KFLI
`<ECFJ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ;<C8:L8EK@=@:8:@WEPD<;@:@WE;<JLGIF;L::@WE

%8 GIR:K@:8 :@<EKU=@:8 J< I<;<=@E@W 8 C8 CLQ ;< <JK8J J@>E8KLI8J GFCUK@:8J P
<:FEWD@:8J><E<I8E;F<EDL:?FJ:<EKIFJ>ILGFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WEP<ECFJ
@EM<JK@>8;FI<J D@JDFJ LE EL<MF <E=FHL< ;< C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J G8I8 8JU GF;<E C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J
:FK@;@8E8J C8J :L8C<J 8 JL M<Q ;<=@E<E P :FE=@>LI8E C8 :@<E:@8 :FDF K8C
^%FJ <JKL;@FJ ;< C8
:@<E:@8 EF J< ;<=@E<E GFI C8 <OK<EJ@WE ;< C8J <OGC@:8:@FE<J JF:@8C<J ;< C8 :@<E:@8 J@EF GFI <C
SE=8J@J <E CFJ <DGC8Q8D@<EKFJ CF:8C@Q8;FJ D8K<I@8C<J P DLE;8EFJ <E ;FE;< J< GI8:K@:8E C8J
:@<E:@8J_%8KFLI

C :FEALEKF P C8 8JF:@8:@WE ;< CFJ EL<MFJ :FEKIFC<J <A<I:@;FJ 8 C8 GIR:K@:8
:@<EKU=@:8<EI8QWE;<C:8G@K8CGL<;<EJ<I<EK<E;@;FJ:FDFLE8+28.,8786E*
K8CP:FDFCFGC8EK<8LD8>8CC@

C:FE:<GKF;<9@F<:FEFDU8EFJI<D@K<8LE8:IUK@:8;<C8JI<C8:@FE<J
;< GF;@;8J 8 C8 <OGIFG@8:@WE ;< M8CFI
@F<:FEFDU8 <J 8JU C8
G8C89I8 :FE C8 HL< @E;@:8DFJ C8 :IUK@:8 ;< C8J I<C8:@FE<J JF:@8C<J
GI<J<EK<J<E<C:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MF

J GI<:@J8D<EK< <C 8ERC@J@J :IUK@:F ;< C8 GIR:K@:8 ;@J:LIJ@M8 P ;< JL
<=<:KL8:@WE<EC8C<>@K@D8:@WE;<CJ89<I:@<EKU=@:FCFHL<J<?8@EK<EK8;F8HLU
<JKF ;<J;< CFJ 8:FEK<:@D@<EKFJ <:FEWD@:FJ P GFCUK@:FJ @E@:@8;FJ <E C8
;S:8;8 ;<C ;<C J@>CF G8J8;F ;S:8;8 <E C8 :L8C ?L9F DFM@D@<EKFJ
@EJK@KL:@FE8C<JHL<KI8EJ=FID8IFEC8GIF;L::@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJPGIF;LAF
:FDF:FIFC8I@FC8=FID8:@WE;<CKI898AF:F>E@K@MF8:KL8C
-<E@<E;F<E:L<EK8
CF 8EK<I@FI J< ?8 HL<I@;F 8M@QFI8I <C J<EK@;F ;< C8 @EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8:@WE
8:8<:@;8 P JL GIFP<:KF ;< M@J@9@C@Q8:@WE@EM@J@9@C@Q8:@WE ;< J89<I<J
HLU <J
G<IK@E<EK< <C GIFELE:@8D@<EKF ;<C D@JDF LD8>8CC@ I<JG<:KF 8C :8G@K8C@JDF
:F>E@K@MF

%8J@DGC<F9J<IM8:@WE<DGUI@:8;<C8<MFCL:@WE?@JKWI@:8EFJDL<JKI8
:WDFC8;@ERD@:88C8I>FGC8QF;<C:8G@K8C@JDFM@<E<D8I:8;8EFJFCF
GFI LE DF;<CF @EDLK89C< ;< <:FEFDU8 ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF J@EF DRJ
9@<E GFI ;@=<I<EK<J I<>LC8:@FE<J P GFI ;@M<IJFJ I<>UD<E<J ;<
GIF;L::@WE ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF
JKFJ XCK@DFJ J< ;<J8IIFCC8E JF9I< C8
98J<;<C8KI8EJ=FID8:@WE;<C8J=FID8J@EJK@KL:@FE8C<JHL<`J<>XEC8
<J:L<C8 ;< C8 I<>LC8:@WE` :8I8:K<I@Q8E C8 ?@JKFI@8 ;<C :8G@K8C@JDF P
;<K<ID@E8EJL:8G8:@;8;G8I8I<GIF;L:@IJ<8KI8MSJ;<LE8@E:<J8EK<
D<K8DFI=FJ@J;<C8JI<C8:@FE<JJF:@8C<J=LE;8D<EK8C<J

JUGL<J:FDFJ<D<E:@FEWGR>@E8J8KIRJ<E<JK<<JKL;@FEF?8PLE=F:FF
<G@:<EKIF 8E8CUK@:F CF:8CDLE;@8C D@:IFD8:IF HL< ;<=@E8 P ;<K<ID@E< C8J
I<C8:@FE<J:@<EKU=@:8JPJF:@8C<J
JKFGFIHL<J@CFJI<>UD<E<J;<GIF;L::@WE
;<C:FEF:@D@<EKFJ<;<J8IIFCC8E8G8IK@I;<C8J;@JK@EK8J=FID8J@EJK@KL:@FE8C<J
HL< C8J GFJ@9@C@K8E <EKFE:<J C8J K<:EFCF>U8J ;< C8 8;D@E@JKI8:@WE ;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJ
;@JGFJ@K@MFJ
ALIU;@:FJ
;@J:LIJ@MFJ
P
=@E8E:@<IFJ
@EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8;8J;<J;<C8J<JKI8K<>@8J;<>F9@<IEFJFE 6.-2*-8;*<;<C8
:FE=FID8:@WE;<C:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MF<EFCFD9@8PEF8C:FEKI8I@F

!&"'!'
&

28J<?8D<E:@FE8;FC8:FDGFJ@:@WEKI@;@D<EJ@FE8C;<C:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MF
<E ;FE;< :FE=CLP<E C8 GFCUK@:8 C8 <:FEFDU8 P C8 :@<E:@8
G8IK@I ;< <JK8
KIU8;8 @EJ<G8I89C< J< ?8 :FE=@>LI8;F C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ
:@<EKU=@:FJ <E C8 JF:@<;8; :FEK<DGFIRE<8
E C8 8:KL8C =FID8 ;< 8JF:@8:@WE
;< <JKFJ KI<J <C<D<EKFJ C8 GFCUK@:8 P C8 <:FEFDU8 ?8E :F9I8;F D8PFI
GIFK8>FE@JDF8JUCFJFJK@<E<E< I<@==P&8C;FE8;F

45 J< ;<9< 8:<GK8I HL< C8 J<C<::@WE ;< GIF9C<D8J P GFJ@9C<J
JFCL:@FE<J K<:EF:@<EKU=@:8J JFE ;<:@J@FE<J 8;D@E@JKI8K@M8J <E
:FEK<OKFJ8;D@E@JKI8K@MFJHL<EFJFEKFD8;8JGFI:@<EKU=@:FJJ@EFGFI
GFCUK@:FJP;@I<:K@MFJ:FIGFI8K@MFJ< I<@==P&8C;FE8;F

,@E<D98I>F<JK8:FE:<G:@WE;<C8GIF;L::@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ:@<EKU=@:FJ
HL<J<G<I=@C898AFLE8I8:@FE8C@;8;<:FEWD@:8?8:<GIF9C<DRK@:8JLGIFG@8
=LE;8D<EK8:@WEGFCUK@:8
%8:IUK@:8HL<GI<J<EKF<E<JK<8G8IK8;FK@<E<:FDF
G@JF <G@JK<DFCW>@:F CFJ 8GFIK<J ;<C JF:@WCF>F 89I@<C -8I;< GI@E:@G8CD<EK<
<E C8 MFQ ;< KI<J G<EJ8;FI<J :FEK<DGFIRE<FJ &8LI@Q@F %8QQ8I8KF /@E:<EK
EKFE@E%SG@E8PPILEF%8KFLI

C G<EJ8D@<EKF ;< -8I;< J< :FE=@>LI8 8 G8IK@I ;< C8J DWE8;8J C8J :L8C<J
JFE <EK@;8;<J DFC<:LC8I<J HL< <E JL DLCK@GC@:@;8; ;< I<C8:@FE<J
:FEJK@KLP<E<C<8,2><CFHL<J<IU8<CDLE;FJF:@8C8G8IK@I;<C8@EM<E:@WEP
C8 @D@K8:@WE %8QQ8I8KF
JK8 G<IJG<:K@M8 K@<E< LE 8GFIK<
:FE:<GKL8C@DGFIK8EK<8C:FEJ@;<I8IHL<C8JDWE8;8J^G<ID@K<E:FE:<9@IC8
8:K@M@;8; EF :FDF GIF;L::@WE J@EF :FDF :I<8:@WE P <=<:KL8:@WE ;< CFJ
DLE;FJ J@>L@<E;F C8 CW>@:8 ;<C 8:FEK<:@D@<EKF 45_ %8QQ8I8KF

28 ;< <EKI8;8 -8I;< ;8 LE >@IF 8 C8 :L<JK@WE ;< CF HL< ?FP ;<EFD@E8DFJ
8><E:@8D@<EKF GL<J C8J JL9A<K@M@;8;<J J< ;<=@E<E EF GFI C8 CW>@:8 ;< C8
GIF;L::@WE J@EF GFI <C 8:FEK<:@D@<EKF HL< <J :I<8:@WE P <=<:KL8:@WE ;<
GFJ@9C<J
%FJ8><E:@8D@<EKFJJ<;<=@E<E<EKFE:<JGFIC8:I<8:@WE;<J;<C8
;@=<I<E:@8 EF GFI C8 GIF;L::@WE GI<:FE:<9@;8
)8I8 <C :8JF HL< <JK8DFJ
8E8C@Q8E;F <JK8 @;<8 <J ;< >I8E @EK<ISJ GFIHL< :8D9@8 <C J<EK@;F ;<C
:FEF:@D@<EKF:@<EKU=@:FP8EFJ<KI8K8;<bGIF;L::@WE@E;@M@;L8C@JK8cJ@EF;<
b:I<8:@WE :FC89FI8K@M8c ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ
&@<EKI8J HL< G8I8 C8 8:K@M@;8;
:@<EKU=@:898J8;8<EC8GIF;L::@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ<C@EK<ISJJ<:<EKI8<EC8
:L8EK@=@:8:@WEA<I8IHL@Q8;8G8I8C8:I<8:@WE:FC89FI8K@M8;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJCF
@DGFIK8EK< <J C8 KI8EJ=FID8:@WE ;< C8J JL9A<K@M@;8;<J DWE8;8J =UJ@:8J
E8KLI8C<JF?LD8E8JPC88=<:K8:@WED@JD8;<C@EK<C<:KFP;<CFJJ<EK@;FJ

%8 8::@WE ;< C8 DWE8;8 :FE:@<IE< <E GI@D8I 8C J<EK@I
:KL8I
J@>E@=@:8DF;@=@:8IC8D8E<I8;<J<EK@IALEKFJJ<>XEC8JDF;8C@;8;<J
;<C88::@WELE@C8K<I8CFI<:UGIF:8
I<8IP<=<:KL8IDLE;FJJ@>E@=@:8
8:KL8IGI@D<IFJF9I<C8J:I<<E:@8JPCFJ;<J<FJJF9I<C8JMFCLEK8;<J
PC8J@EK<C@><E:@8J<J;<:@IJF9I<CFJ8=<:KFJ%8QQ8I8KF

'F<JLEGLEKFD<EFI<CHL<J<8:898;<<ELE:@8IGFIHL<GI<:@J8D<EK<;<
8CCU G8IK< C8 :IUK@:8 8 C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ <E <C :8G@K8C@JDF
:F>E@K@MF
@:<%8QQ8I8KF^%8<OGI<J@WEPC8:FEJK@KL:@WE;<C8JD8E<I8J;<

J<EK@I <E CL>8I ;< ;<G<E;<I ;<C DF;F ;< GIF;L::@WE JFE GI<M@8J 8C
=LE:@FE8D@<EKF ;< C8 <:FEFDU8_
%8J JL9A<K@M@;8;<J P CFJ
:FEF:@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ <E K8EKF 8=<:K8:@WE ;< C8J DWE8;8J EF GL<;<E
J<IJL9JLD@;FJ8CFI;<E;<C8GIF;L::@WE:8G@K8C@JK8GFIHL<<CCFJ<O:<;<EC8
CW>@:8 DFE<K8I@8 J@E <D98I>F <E C8 JF:@<;8; :FEK<DGFIRE<8 J< ?8
<JK89C<:@;FLEK@GF;<8JF:@8:@WE<E;FE;<C8?<><DFEU8;<C8<:FEFDU8?8
:FFGK8;F<J8JJL9A<K@M@;8;<J P:FEF:@D@<EKFJG8I8CC<M8ICFJ8CGC8EF;<C8
:L8EK@=@:8:@WE P ;< C8 :FDG<K@K@M@;8; ;<C :8G@K8C GFI <E:@D8 ;< C8
:FFI;@E8:@WEPC8:FFG<I8:@WE;<C8J:I<<E:@8JPCFJ;<J<FJ

-8I;<GIFGFE<C8<M8CL8:@WEFM8CFI8:@WE;<C8J;FJ=L<IQ8JHL<:FDGFE<E
C8JDWE8;8JC8:I<<E:@8P<C;<J<F
)8I8<CCF<JG<:@=@:8KI<JDF;8C@;8;<J
F :8K<>FIU8J ;< M8CFI <C ?*58;?.;-*- <C ?*58;>=252-*- P <C ?*58;+.55.B*
-8I;< :@K8;F GFI %8KFLI P %<G@E8P
C GI@D<IF J< I<=@<I< 8 CFJ
:FEF:@D@<EKFJ < @;<8J <C J<>LE;F 8 CFJ 9@<E<J D8K<I@8C<J C@9IFJ :8IIFJ
M<JK@D<EK8<K:
<CM8CFI 9<CC<Q8?8:<I<=<I<E:@88C8J:I<8:@FE<J8IKUJK@:8J

JK8JKI<J:8K<>FIU8J<JG<:@=@:8ELEK@GF;<:L8EK@=@:8:@WE;@=<I<E:@8;8GL<J
G8I8 -8I;< C8 GIF9C<DRK@:8 EF <J C8 :L8EK@=@:8:@WE ;< C8 <:FEFDU8 J@EF 8C
:FEKI8I@FHL<EFJ<?8:L8EK@=@:8;FCFJL=@:@<EK<DRJ<O8:K8D<EK<HL<<JK8
:L8EK@=@:8:@WE J< ?8 ?<:?F :FE 98J< <E LE8 JFC8 D<;@;8 C8 DFE<K8I@8
!<
8?UJ<>XE-8I;<<C<IIFI;<C8<:FEFDU8KFD8I:FDF^D<;@;86.-2-*_C8
%8 EF:@WE ;< JL9A<K@M@;8; <E -8I;< EF FGFE< <C @E;@M@;LF 8 C8 JF:@<;8; <J DRJ 9@<E LE8
:FEK@EL@;8; 27=.;9<2,85G02,* ;< DWE8;8J HL< EF <JKR ;<K<ID@E8;8 GFI :FEK<OKFJ F <JKIL:KLI8J
JF:@8C<JJ@EFGFI:I<<E:@8JP;<J<FJ^%8JL9A<K@M@;8;;<J@>E8 J@<DGI<C8E8KLI8C<Q8:FEK8>@FJ8
;<CFJ;<J<FJPC8J:I<<E:@8JHL<J8CK8E;<LE@E;@M@;LF8FKIFJ@EELE:8G8J8I`<JK<<J<CGLEKF
<J<E:@8C` GFI C8 @EK<ID<;@8:@WE ;< LE :FEK<OKF F ;< LE8 <JKIL:KLI8 JF:@8C_ %8KFLI P %SG@E8P

ÊD@M@J@WECFJ;FJ<JK8;FJ;<C8CD8FDRJ9@<EC8J;FJ=L<IQ8J;<C8CD8CC8D8;8J:I<<E:@8
P;<J<F;<;FE;<;<I@M8EC8*/2;6*,2G7PC8?85>7=*-GI<J<EK8E<J<:8IR:K<I<D@E<EK<P;@JK@EK@MF
4;<EL<JKIFJ<JK8;FJ@EK<IEFJ5_-8I;<

^FEM@<E< GL<J ;@JK@E>L@I :FE :L@;8;F ;FJ K@GFJ ;< D<;@;8J C8 HL< :8GK8IU8 <C <JK8;F I<8C
HL<GF;IU8CC8D8IJ<C8D<;@;86.-2-*G8I8;@JK@E>L@IC8;<C8HL<=FID8K<8<CDLE;FJF:@8CHL<
GF;IU8CC8D8IJ<C8D<;@;86.7<>;*7=.
JK8;@JK@E:@WEG<ID@K<8;M<IK@IHL<<O@JK<EDL:?FJFKIFJ
@EJKILD<EKFJ ;@JGFE@9C<J G8I8 ?8:<I M<I;8;<I8D<EK< :L8EK@=@:89C< C8 <:FEFDU8_ %8KFLI P

DFE<;8 P 8GC@:8I <JK< @EJKILD<EKF :FE C8 F9A<K@M@;8; P =I@8C;8; HL< <CCF
@DGC@:88C8:L8EK@=@:8:@WE;<=L<IQ8J<EK<I8D<EK<JL9A<K@M8J:FDFCFJFEC8
:I<<E:@8P<C;<J<F

%8QQ8I8KFI<KFD8<JK8@;<8G8I8J<V8C8IHL<CFJGIF:<JFJ;<8GIFG@8:@WE;<
CFJ J89<I<J EF JFE <HL@G8I89C<J 8 CFJ GIF:<JFJ ;< 8GIFG@8:@WE ;< C8J
I@HL<Q8J^CFJDF;FJ;<GIF;L::@WEJF:@8C@Q8:@WEP8GIFG@8:@WE;<CJ89<IP
;< C8 :LCKLI8 JFE I<8CD<EK< ;@=<I<EK<J ;< CFJ DF;FJ ;< GIF;L::@WE
JF:@8C@Q8:@WE P 8GIFG@8:@WE ;< C8J I@HL<Q8J_ %8QQ8I8KF
CF
C8I>F ;< <JK< K<OKF J< ?8 DFJKI8;F :WDF C8 CW>@:8 ;< D<I:8;F ?8
;@I<::@FE8;F C8 8:K@M@;8; :@<EKU=@:8 ;<J;< C8J XCK@D8J ;S:8;8J P ?<DFJ
CC<>8;F8?FI88:FDGI<E;<IGFIHLS<JK8:FE:<G:@WE;<C8:@<E:@8EFJFCF<J
;<J=8MFI89C< G8I8 CFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ J@EF K8D9@SE <HLUMF:8 ;<J;< <C GLEKF ;<
M@JK8 GFCUK@:F
C >I8E 8GFIK< ;< -8I;< <E <JK< J<EK@;F =L< ;8IC< LE >@IF
:FE:<GKL8C 8 C8 <:FEFDU8 GFCUK@:8 P :I<8I EL<M8J :8K<>FIU8J G8I8 <C ?*58;

%8D<EK89C<D<EK< CFJ :FE:<GKFJ ;< -8I;< JLJ C@9IFJ P SC D@JDF =L<IFE
I<C<>8;FJ 8 LE J<>LE;F GC8EF ;<EKIF ;< C8 JF:@FCF>U8 G<IF 8?FI8
I<:FEF:<DFJ JL @DGFIK8E:@8 G8I8 :FDGI<E;U8 ;< C8 :@<E:@8 <E
K8EKFKI898AF:F>E@K@MF

%FJ ?*58;.<?.;-*- JFE ;< <JG<:@8C @EK<ISJ 8HLU GL<J G8I8 -8I;< SJKFJ J<
I<=@<I<E 8C :FEF:@D@<EKF
C <HLUMF:F HL< J<V8C8 -8I;< <J HL< CFJ M8CFI<J
M<I;8; JFE :FEJ@;<I8;FJ 8C E@M<C ;< C8J D<I:8E:U8J JL GIF;L::@WE
@EK<I:8D9@FP:FEJLDFJFE@EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8;FJ:FDFJ@;<9@<E<JD8K<I@8C<J
J< KI8K8J<E
JKF <J CF HL< ?8 JL:<;@;F :FDF J< DFJKIW <E <C :8GUKLCF
8EK<I@FI:FEC8GFCUK@:8;<:@<E:@8PK<:EFCF>U8<EFCFD9@8LE8GFCUK@:8HL<

%SG@E8P
%8@;<8;<-8I;<<JHL<C8J8:K@M@;8;<JHL<;<J<E:8;<E8EC8J:I<<E:@8JPCFJ
;<J<FJJ<8ED<;@9C<J:FE:8K<>FIU8JD<EJLI8EK<JPEF:FEC8D<;@;8><E<I8C;<C8<:FEFDU8

8JLD@W CFJ :FEF:@D@<EKFJ M8CFI<J M<I;8; :FDF D<I:8E:U8J M8CFI<J

LK@C@;8;

%8 <:FEFDU8 KI8K8 <=<:K@M8D<EK< <JKFJ 9@<E<J 4CFJ :FEF:@D@<EKFJ5
:FDF I@HL<Q8 <:FEWD@:8 :FEJ@;<IRE;FCFJ :FDF M8CFI<J LK@C@;8; 8C
@>L8C HL< <C I<JKF G<IF J<>XE -8I;< CFJ :FEF:@D@<EKFJ GFJ<<E LE
DF;F ;< GIF;L::@WE HL< EF GL<;< I<;L:@IJ< 8 ^C8 ;@M@J@WE ;<C
KI898AF_LEDF;F;<^JF:@8C@Q8:@WE_P;<^:FDLE@:8:@WEJF:@8C_HL<
EF GL<;< <JK8I FI>8E@Q8;F GFI <C D<I:8;F P GFI <C @EK<I:8D9@F JF
G<E8 ;< ;<JE8KLI8C@Q8I C8 GIF;L::@WE P <C :FEJLDF ;< <JKFJ M8CFI<J
%8QQ8I8KF

%8 :@<E:@FD<KIU8 C8 9@9C@FD<KIU8 P KF;FJ CFJ J@JK<D8J ;< D<;@:@WE P ;<
:C8J@=@:8:@WE ;< >ILGFJ <JKRE ;@J<V8;FJ 98AF <J< <IIFI GIUJK@EF ;< C8
<:FEFDU8KF;8J<J8J?<II8D@<EK8JJ<<E=F:8E<E<CGIF;L:KF D<I:8E:U8EF
<E C8 GFK<E:@8 ;< C8J :I<<E:@8J P ;<J<FJ ;< JLJ 8LKFI<J J< C@D@K8E 8
:L8EK@=@:8I <C bHLSc G<IF EF <C b:WDFc C8 JLGL<JK8 F9A<K@M@;8; CC<MW 8 CFJ
<:FEFD@JK8J ;< C8 :@<E:@8 8 9FII8I ;<C 8ERC@J@J 8 CFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ P 8 CFJ
KI898A8;FI<J :F>E@K@MFJ M@J@9@C@Q8E;F XE@:8D<EK< JL GIF;L::@WE :FDF CF
M<I;8;<IF

XE:L8E;F4CFJ<:FEFD@JK8J5;<9@<IFE:FEJ@;<I8I<CC8;FGJ@:FCW>@:F
;< CFJ =<EWD<EFJ HL< <JKL;@898E CFJ DWM@C<J ;<C KI898A8;FI P C8J
E<:<J@;8;<J ;<C :FEJLD@;FI GFI <A<DGCF :FE:@9@<IFE LE :FI8QWE
?LD8EF K8E J@DGC@=@:8;F K8E <JHL<DRK@:F GFI 8JU ;<:@ICF LE 8CD8
?LD8E8 K8E DLK@C8;8 HL< <J< DUE@DF ;< GJ@:FCF>U8 @E;@JG<EJ89C<

^< <JK< DF;F <E <C :8G@K8C@JDF KF;8J C8J =FID8J ;< GIF;L::@WE @E:CLJF C8J DRJ
@E:FDG8I89C<JG8J8E:8;8M<QDRJ8J<I<M8CL8;8J<E;@E<IFG<IF:8;8M<Q<ED<EFID<;@;8
CFJ:FEF:@D@<EKFJJ<GI<JK8E8<JK<K@GF;<M8CFI8:@WE_%8QQ8I8KF P

-8I;< <J:I@9@W LE8 9<CC8 @;<8 <E ;FE;< ;<JK8:8 <JK< 8JG<:KF FCM@;8;F GFI C8 :@<E:@FD<KIU8
JF9I<:WDFJ<I<8C@Q8C8:@<E:@8^8;8:@<EKU=@:FKI898A88G8IK<;<CFJ;<DRJ8LEHL<LK@C@Q8JLJ
KI898AFJ>I8:@8J8JLC<E>L8:FDXESCGFE<JLK<DG<I8D<EKFJL8CD8<EC8J@EM<JK@>8:@FE<J8
C8J:L8C<JJ<C@9I8KF;F<ESC<J:8I8:K<IUJK@:F<@E;@M@;L8C_

K<EU8 <C 8JG<:KF ;< LE J@DGC< GFJKLC8;F ;<JK@E8;F 8 JFJK<E<FDSKI@:F;<JLJ;<;L::@FE<J-8I;<:@K8;FGFI%8KFLIP
%SG@E8P

J 8JU :FDF <E C8 C<>@K@D8:@WE ;< CFJ :FEF:@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ CFJ
@EM<JK@>8;FI<J JFE J@DGC@=@:8;FJ 8 CFJ I<JLCK8;FJ ;< JLJ GIFP<:KFJ JLJ
:I<<E:@8J P ;<J<FJ JLJ 27=.;.<.< *9*<287*-8< =L<IFE E<>8;FJ <E LE
SOK8J@J;<<IIWE<8F9A<K@M@;8;

JUC8D<;@:@WEP:L8EK@=@:8:@WEHL<?8?<:?FC8:@<E:@FD<KIU8EFG<ID@K<LE
8ERC@J@J<O?8LJK@MFJF9I<C8D8E<I8:FDFJ<:FEJKILP<<C:FEF:@D@<EKFJFCF
G<ID@K< M@JL8C@Q8I <C bGIF;L:KFc =@E8C G<IF EF <C GIF:<JF P CFJ <C<D<EKFJ
@EJK@KL:@FE<J < @E;@M@;LFJ @EK<IM@E@<EK<J <E ;@:?8 :FEJKIL::@WE
J< K@GF ;<
8ERC@J@J EF G<ID@K< M8;FI<J=@E8E:@8;FI<J<JKL;@8EK<J<K:
JUCF<ELE:@8)89CF$I<@D8;FI<J ?L9F P ?8P :LREK8 GC8K8
>8JK8IFE P >8JK8E <EKI< FKI8J :FJ8J
)<IF GFI DRJ HL<
;<J8IIFCC<DFJ GIFC@AFJ P :L@;8;FJFJ D<:8E@JDFJ <JK8;UJK@:FJ G8I8
D<;@I C8 :8EK@;8; ;< 8IKU:LCFJ HL< GL9C@:8E CFJ @EM<JK@>8;FI<J F CFJ
>ILGFJ JFCF K<E;I<DFJ LE 8::<JF =@:K@:@F 8 C8 bGIF;L::@WEc ;< C8
:@<E:@8
)FI <A<DGCF J@ 9LJ:8DFJ C8 :8EK@;8; ;< 8IKU:LCFJ HL< J<
GL9C@:8IFE JF9I< LE K<D8 ;<K<ID@E8;F <JF EF EFJ ;@:<
89JFCLK8D<EK< E8;8 8:<I:8 ;< HL@SE<J G8IK@:@G8IFE <E ;@:?8J
@EM<JK@>8:@FE<J:FEHLS=FE;FJ=L<IFEJFCM<EK8;8JPCFDRJ:IL:@8C

)8I8-8I;<CFJ@EK<I<J<J8G8J@FE8;FJJFEK8EKFFDRJ@DGFIK8EK<JG8I8<C8ERC@J@JJF:@FCW>@:F
HL<8HL<CC8J:CRJ@:8J:8K<>FIU8J;<^<JKIL:KLI8_^:FEK<OKF_^JF:@<;8;_<K:
%FJL9A<K@MFDRJ
<O8:K8D<EK< CF @EK@:F <J G8I8 -8I;< <C <C<D<EKF =LE;8D<EK8C G8I8 C8 <O@JK<E:@8 ;<
CFJ :FC<:K@MFJ
JU CF ;<A8 M=>;* ^C
8DFI <E <=<:KF <J C8 =L<EK< @EM@J@9C< < @E8>FK89C< ;< <JK8 :FIK<JU8 ;< EL<MF >SE<IF
%8 :8G@K8C
@DGFIK8E:@8HL<?8KFD8;FC8J<OKI8V8J=FID8JHL<?8I<M<JK@;FC8J@E<JG<I8;8J8CKLI8J8HL<
J< ?8 <C<M8;F :FEJK@KLP<E HL@QRJ <C :8IR:KE@=@:8K@MF ;< EL<JKI8 :@M@C@Q8:@WE_ -8I;<

HL@SELJWFGF;IU8LJ8I<C:FEF:@D@<EKF;<CHL<J<?89C845

%8C<::@WEHL<EFJ?8;<A8;F-8I;<<JHL<C8:@<E:@8J<;<9<:L8EK@=@:8IJU
G<IF J< ;<9< ?8:<E<I8 LE8 KI8EJ=@>LI8:@WE ;< C8 8:K@M@;8; :@<EKU=@:8 P
;<JC<>@K@D8 C8 @EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8:@WE P A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE ;< CFJ :FEF:@D@<EKFJ
:@<EKU=@:FJ ;<JGC<>8;8J <E C8 :FE=@>LI8:@WE ;<C :8G@K8C@JDF :F>E@K@MF ;<
D8E<I8HL<C8J8K8C8P8J;<CJ89<I=L<IFE:FEJKIL@;8JPGFJ@:@FE8;8J98AFLE
@EK<ISJ HL< C<AFJ ;< =8MFI<:8E@Q8:@WE :8G@K8C@JK8 ;< EL<JKIF
K@<DGF

E<CJ@>L@<EK<:8GUKLCF89FI;8IS<JK8:FE:CLJ@WE><E<I8CPC8LK@C@Q8IS:FDF
b<O:LJ8cG8I8GC8EK<8ILE88CK<IE8K@M88C88:KL8C><JK@WE;<C8:@<E:@8P;<C8
GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ C8 GIFGL<JK8 <J <EK<E;8K@M8 :FDF LE GFK<EK< 8:FEK<:@D@<EKF <E C8
KI8EJ=@>LI8:@WE ;< JL9A<K@M@;8;<J P EF :FDF LE8 :L<JK@WE ;< GIF;L::@WE
D<I:8EK@C ;< C<>@K@D8:@WE ;< @EK<I<J<J E<FC@9<I8C<J P ;< A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE
:@<EKU=@:8
E FKI8J G8C89I8J C8 GIFGL<JK8 9LJ:8 @EK<IG<C8I C8 D8E<I8 :FDF
J< :FEJK@KLP<E 8:KL8CD<EK< C8J 8K8C8P8J ;<C J89<E
FEKFCW>@:FEFGFIJLC<>@K@D@;8;<G@JK<DFCW>@:8

7./.,=8J78.<5*@E<JK89@C@;8;;<CF?<K<IF>SE<F58:>.1*1.,18*<86+;8<8*5
>72?.;<8
89I@<C-8I;<

E CFJ :8GUKLCFJ 8EK<I@FI<J J< 89FI;W C8 :L<JK@WE ;< C8 C<>@K@D8:@WE ;< C8
GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ ;<J;< ;FJ <EKI8;8J GI@D<IF ;<J;< C8
GI8>DRK@:8 ;<C :8DGF :@<EKU=@:F ;<J:I@K8 8 KI8MSJ ;< CFJ :L8KIF E@M<C<J
8E8CUK@:FJ ;@J:LIJ@MF GI8>DRK@:F I<>LC8K@MF P ;< JL9A<K@M8:@WE 89FI;8;FJ
<E <C 8GUKLCF " J<>LE;F ;<J;< C8 @EK<IG<C8:@WE ;< 8C>LE8J
8I>LD<EK8:@FE<J:FE:<GKL8C<JI<=<I<EK<J8CG8G<C;<CFJJ89<I<J:@<EKU=@:FJ
<E C8 JF:@<;8; :FEK<DGFIRE<8 :L<JK@WE 8E8C@Q8;8 <E <C 8GUKLCF ""
E
<JK< :8GUKLCF J< K<E;IRE <E :FEJ@;<I8:@WE C8J ;FJ <EKI8;8J D<E:@FE8;8J
G8I8 GC8EK<8I LE8 GIFGL<JK8 ><E<I8C JF9I< CFJ :I@K<I@FJ HL< J< GF;IU8E

%8 =FID8 <OGFJ@K@M8 ;< <JK< C@9IF J< 8;FGKW ;< D8E<I8 ;<C@9<I8;8 J< 9LJ:898 IFDG<E<I8C@Q8;8 8I>LD<EK8:@WE :LP8 FI>8E@Q8:@WE G8IK< ;< C8 I<M@J@WE @EK<IG<C8:@WE P
8;FG:@WE ;< D8I:FJ K<WI@:FJ F :FE:<GKL8C<J G8I8 CL<>F ALJK@=@:8I :FE 98J< <E <JFJ :FE:<GKFJ
8;FGK8;FJ LE8 J<I@< ;< F9J<IM8:@FE<J HL< J< M<E GI<:@J8D<EK< b<ED8I:8;8Jc <E LE :L<IGF
:FE:<GKL8C HL< J< JLGFE< C8J <OGC@:8
< <JK8 D8E<I8 C8J :FEJKIL::@FE<J :FE:<GKL8C<J JFE
<DGC<8;8J :FDF <C K<CWE ;< =FE;F HL< <JKR GL<JKF G8I8 JLGL<JK8D<EK< GF;<I M<I CFJ
8:FEK<:@D@<EKFJ :FE LE8 GIF=LE;@;8; D8PFI G<IF <E I<8C@;8; JFE LE8 <O:LJ8 HL< J@IM< G8I8
8:FDF;8ICFJ?<:?FJ8JLJGI<:<GKFJFG<FI8XEJFE<CK<CWEHL<J@IM<:FDFbLK@C<IU8;<:FI8K@M8c
G8I8C8F9I8<EJL:FEALEKFG<IFHL<<EJUD@JDFGF:F8GFIK88C8D@JD8
)FI<C:FEKI8I@F8HLU
J<G8IK@WGFI<C8ERC@J@J;<CFJ8:FEK<:@D@<EKFJ?8:@<E;FJ<>L@D@<EKF;<C8JGIR:K@:8J;@J:LIJ@M8J
P ;< C8J 8::@FE<J :FE:I<K8J G8I8 CL<>F JU @EK<IG<C8I <J8J GIR:K@:8J P 8::@FE<J :FE 8C>LE8J
<C89FI8:@FE<J K<WI@:8J HL< J< ?8E ;<J8IIFCC8;F JF9I< <C K<D8 ;< DF;F HL< CFJ :FE:<GKFJ
89FI;8;FJ K@<E<E LE IFC J<:LE;8I@F G<IF I<8CD<EK< @DGFIK8EK< GFI :L8EKF G<ID@K<E :FDGI<E;<E<I8:@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ:@<EKU=@:FJK<E@<E;F<E:L<EK8C8
I<=C<O@WE JF9I< C8 =FID8 <E HL< J< :FE=@>LIW <C :8DGF :@<EKU=@:F <E C8J
XCK@D8J;FJ;S:8;8J<EEL<JKIFG8UJ<EKI8;8>EFJ<FCW>@:8G8I8C<C8D<EK<
8 CFJ 8ERC@J@J :FE:<GKL8C<J 89FI;8;FJ <E <C :8GUKLCF 8EK<I@FI <EKI8;8
<G@JK<DFCW>@:8

< C8 GI@D<I8 <EKI8;8 J< :FE:CLPW HL< <C :8DGF ;< C<>@K@D8:@WE ;< C8
GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ <E EL<JKIF G8UJ <JKR 8KI8M<J8;F GFI C8
M@J@9@C@;8;;<CFJ:@<EKU=@:FJGFI<E:@D8;<CFJ8JG<:KFJ<G@JK<DFCW>@:FJ<J
;<:@I <E C8 :FE=@>LI8:@WE ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE ;< J89<I<J :@<EKU=@:FJ CF DRJ
@DGFIK8EK<?8J@;F8;HL@I@IPD8EK<E<IM@J@9@C@;8;GIF;L:K@M8<JKFGFI<E:@D8
;<C8I<=C<O@WEPCFJ;<98K<J8:<I:8;<CbG8I8HLSc;<C8:@<E:@8;<JLJLJFJ
P JLJ 8GFIK<J 8 C8 KI8EJ=FID8:@WE ;< :FC<:K@M@;8;<J
C GIF9C<D8 J< ?8
GL<JKF JF9I< C8 @EJKILD<EK8C@Q8:@WE ;<C :8DGF DRJ HL< JF9I< JL
<G@JK<DFCF>@Q8:@WEJ@J<D<G<ID@K<<CKSID@EF
%FJGIF:<JFJP;@JGFJ@K@MFJ
@DGC<D<EK8;FJF:I<8;FJ8GLEK8IFEJ@<DGI<8:FE=@>LI8I`;<J;<;@J:LIJFJ
HL<8G<C898E8C8CW>@:8E<FC@9<I8C`<C:8DGF;<C<>@K@D@;8;M@J@9@C@Q8:@WE;<
C8GIF;L::@WE;<CJ89<I:@<EKU=@:F;<A8E;F<ELEJ<>LE;FGC8EF<C;<J8IIFCCF
;< C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE :@<EKU=@:8 <E K8EKF KI898AF :F>E@K@MF P <E K8EKF GFK<E:@8
JL9A<K@M8 G8I8 C8 :I<8:@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ ,869;86.=2-8< :FE
CFJ;@M<IJFJJ<:KFI<J;<C8JF:@<;8;:FCFD9@8E8
JUGL<JC8GIF;L::@WE;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ <J LE :8DGF C<>@K@D8;F ;<J;< C8 :L8EK@=@:8:@WE
D<I:8EK@C<JLE:8DGFHL<:<EKI8JL:I<:@D@<EKFPM@J@9@C@;8;<ELE8JG<:KF
;< C8 :@<E:@8 HL< C@D@K8 JL =FIK8C<:@D@<EKF <G@JKSD@:F GFI :L8EKF :<I:8 <E
>I8E D<;@;8 C8 M8CFI8:@WE ;< JL HL<?8:LE;8<EKI8;8J<:FE:CLPWHL<C8CW>@:8:FEC8:L8CJ<:FE=@>LIWC8
C<>@K@D@;8; ;< CFJ J89<I<J :@<EKU=@:FJ ;LI8EK< C8J XCK@D8J ;FJ ;S:8;8J <E
EL<JKIFG8UJJ<=LE;8D<EKW<ELE8G<IJG<:K@M8;<C8:@<E:@8HL<;<J;<C8

;@J:LIJ@M@;8; GFCUK@:8 GIFG@:@W C8 :FE=@>LI8:@WE ;<C :8G@K8C@JDF :F>E@K@MF

<DLC8E;FCFJJ@JK<D8J;<:@<E:@8K<:EFCF>U8<@EEFM8:@WE;<FKI8JC8K@KL;<J

JK8 ;<:@J@WE ><E<IW LE J@JK<D8 <E <C :L8C CFJ @EM<JK@>8;FI<J <E K8EKF
JLA<KFJ =L<IFE @EM@J@9@C@Q8;FJ LE J@JK<D8 HL< ;<J:FEF:< C8J :FDGC<A8J
I<C8:@FE<J98J8;8J<E@EK<I<J<JG8J@FE<J:I<<E:@8JP;<J<FJ:FDFKF;8J
C8J I<C8:@FE<J ?LD8E8J <E C8J :L8C<J G8IK@:@G8E CFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ ;LI8EK< CFJ
GIF:<JFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE P ;< :I<8:@WE :@<EKU=@:8
%8 :FEJ<:L<E:@8 DRJ
M@J@9C<=L<HL<<C=FIK8C<:@D@<EKF;<CJ@JK<D8KLMFLE:8IR:K<I8IK@=@:@8CFJFCF
;< =8:?8;8 <E <C J<EK@;F HL< J< GIFG@:@W C8 :FDG<K<E:@8 <EKI< G8I<J G8I8
8;HL@I@I M@J@9@C@;8; 8 KI8MSJ ;< C8J GL9C@:8:@FE<J G<IF <E I<8C@;8; CFJ
GIF:<JFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE P C8 =L<IQ8 <G@JK<DFCW>@:8 ;< C8J ;@J:@GC@E8J
HL<;8IFE <E LE J<>LE;F GC8EF P ;<9@C@K8;8J GFI CFJ ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ ;< :FEKIFC
HL<?8:U8EG8IK<;<C88;D@E@JKI8:@WE;<C:FEF:@D@<EKF
JUJ<?@G8:@WEGI<M@8J8C?<:?F;<GL9C@:8I<CI<JLCK8;F;<LE
<JKL;@F:@<EKU=@:F

C I<JG<:KF )89CF $I<@D<I ;@:< HL< ^,@ JLGFE<DFJ HL< CFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ JFE
8LKWEFDFJ ;< KF;8J C8J FKI8J I<C8:@FE<J JF:@8C<J <JF EFJ @DG<;@IR
:FDGI<E;U8J;<8;D@E@JKI8:@WE;<C:FEF:@D@<EKF@DGC<D<EK8;8J;<J;<C8
;S:8;8;< 8KI8MSJ;<CFJJ@JK<D8J;<:@<E:@8PK<:EFCF>U8;<J:I@KFJ
<E<C8GUKLCF";<<JK<C@9IFJ<98J8E<ELEDF;<CF;<J<>L@D@<EKF:FEKIFC
P <M8CL8:@WE HL< 8;AL;@:8E 8 CFJ :FEF:@D@<EKFJ P J89<I<J :@<EKU=@:FJ
?*58;.<?.;-*- C8J GIFG@<;8;<J ;< C8J D<I:8E:U8J ?*58;.<>=252-*-
GIFG@:@8E;F LE ?FI@QFEK< 8E8CUK@:F ;< C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J :@<EKU=@:8J P ;<
@EM<JK@>8:@WE 98JK8EK< C@D@K8;F <C ;<98K< GX9C@:F JF9I< CFJ 8JG<:KFJ ;< C8
:@<E:@8 J< C@D@KW 8 :FE:<GKL8C@Q8I JF9I< CFJ I<JLCK8;FJ G<IF EF JF9I< CFJ

GIF:<JFJ
< D8E<I8 HL< KF;F <C ;<J8IIFCCF P :FE=@>LI8:@WE LCK<I@FI ;<C
:8DGF :@<EKU=@:F P JL C<>@K@D8:@WE J< =LE;8D<EK8E <E LE <IIFI
<G@JK<DFCW>@:F P D<KF;FCW>@:F @E:@K8;F GFI C8 :<EKI8C@;8; ;< C8 CW>@:8 ;< C8
<:FEFDU8;<D<I:8;F<EC8:L<JK@WE:@<EKU=@:8<JKFJ8JG<:KFJ:FE=@>LI8IFE
<C :8G@K8C@JDF :F>E@K@MF <E EL<JKIF G8UJ <E K8EKF 8:FEK<:@D@<EKF JF:@8C K8C
:FDFJ<GLEKL8C@QW<E<C8GUKLCF""

E <JK< :8GUKLCF J< GI<J<EK8E CFJ GI@E:@G@FJ ><E<I8C<J ;< LE8 8GL<JK8
8CK<IE8K@M8 8C DF;<CF 8:KL8C G8I8 <A<I:<E<I8C<J G<IF EF GFI <CCF J< ;<9< ;<J@JK@I <E C8 :FEJKIL::@WE ;<
LE8 ,2.7,2* 9;892* :FDF CF GC8EK<W (IC8E;F 8CJ FI;8 P <E <JK<
:8JF <E C8 :FEJKIL::@WE ;< LE DF;<CF GIFG@F G8I8 C8 GIF;L::@WE P
<M8CL8:@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ
'F <J LE8 :L<JK@WE D<EFI 8GFJK8I
GFI LE8 KI8EJ=FID8:@WE ;<C 8:KL8C DF;F ;< <A<I:@:FJ P D<KF;FCW>@:FJ GIFDFM@;FJ GFI CFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ <
@EM<JK@>8;FI<J;<EL<JKI8I<>@WEG<ID@K@<E;FJL;<J8IIFCCF<E;W><EFPEFJL
C@D@K8:@WE8G8IK@I;<<JHL<D8J;<<M8CL8:@WEA<I8IHL@Q8:@WE@EK<IE8:@FE8C<J

E CFJ J@>L@<EK<J 8G8IK8;FJ J< GC8EK<8E C8J @;<8J ><E<I8C<J G8I8 C8
:FEJKIL::@WE ;< LE EL<MF DF;<CF <JK8J @;<8J JFE <C <:F ;< CFJ
GC8EK<8D@<EKFJ I<8C@Q8;FJ ;<J;< ?8:< M8I@8J ;S:8;8J GFI G<EJ8;FI<J ;<
;@M<IJ8 I8UQ 8:8;SD@:8 P ><F>IR=@:8 JLJ 8GFIK<J JFE C8 GFK<E:@8 HL< >LU8
<JK8GIFGL<JK8

! '

"EK<IG<C8I ;FJ 98J<J =LE;8D<EK8C<J HL< :8I8:K<I@Q8E C8 GIF;L::@WE ;<
:FEF:@D@<EKFJ:@<EKU=@:FJ<EEL<JKIFG8UJ<JKF<JC8C<>@K@D8:@WE8G8IK@I;<
C8I8:@FE8C@;8;;<D<I:8;FPC8A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE;<8:L<I;F:FEC8GIF;L::@WE
D8K<I@8C;<CFJ@EM<JK@>8;FI<JJ@>E@=@:8GC8EK<8ILEEL<MFK@GF;<I<C8:@FE<J
G8I8C8><E<I8:@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ:@<EKU=@:FJLEEL<MFK@GF;<I<C8:@FE<J
<E C8J :L8C<J C8 GFCUK@:8 P C8 <:FEFDU8 EF J<8E <C <G@:<EKIF <E C8J
;<K<ID@E8:@FE<J:@<EKU=@:8JCF:L8CEFHL@<I<;<:@IHL<<JFJRD9@KFJ;<98E
;<J8G8I<:8IJ< ;<C <JG<:KIF :@<EKU=@:F
%F HL< J< GC8EK<8 <J
KI8EJ=FID8I <C DF;<CF 8:KL8C G8I8 <C ;<J8IIFCCF ;< C8 8:K@M@;8; :@<EKU=@:8
:FE=@>LI8;F8G8IK@I;<C8:I<<E:@8:FDXE;<GFCUK@:FJP8;D@E@JKI8;FI<J;<C
:FEF:@D@<EKF HL< J< ;<9< J<>L@I <C D@JDF :8D@EF ;< CFJ G8UJ<J
@E;LJKI@8C@Q8;FJ G8I8 8C:8EQ8I JLJ D@JDFJ CF>IFJ <JK< G<EJ8D@<EKF CF
:L<JK@FE8)89CF$I<@D<I;<C8J@>L@<EK<D8E<I8

LI8EK< DL:?F K@<DGF C8J M@J@FE<J :FEM<E:@FE8C<J ;< C8J GFCUK@:8J
:@<EKU=@:8J :FEJ@;<I8IFE HL< <I8 JL=@:@<EK< =FID8I LE8 bD8J8 :IUK@:8c
;<:@<EKU=@:FJLE8bD8EF;<F9I8c:@<EKU=@:8P;FK8IC8;<LE8:8EK@;8;
DUE@D8;<I<:LIJFJ
JU;8;FJ<JFJI<:LIJFJP<CK@<DGFE<:<J8I@F`
M8I@8J;S:8;8J`C8:@<E:@8<ECFJG8UJ<J<E;<J8IIFCCF=LE:@FE8IU8;<C
D@JDFDF;FHL<<E<CI<JKF;<CDLE;F

!FP <E FCFD9@8 ;FJ ;S:8;8J ;<JGLSJ ;< C8 @DGC<D<EK8:@WE ;<C DF;<CF
J<V8C8;F C8J G8C89I8J ;< $I<@DL9<IE8D<EK8C ;< J<>L@I <C :8D@EF ;< CFJ G8UJ<J @E;LJKI@8C@Q8;FJ <E C8
:FE=@>LI8:@WE;<C:8DGF:@<EKU=@:FE8:@FE8C<JC8I<GI<J<EK8:@WE;<C8JC<P<J;<C8@D@K8:@WEHL<
-8I;< ;<=@E@W <E <C J@>CF 1"1
C 8:KF ;< C8 @D@K8:@WE ;@:< -8I;< <JKR ;<K<ID@E8;F GFI C8J
:I<<E:@8J P CFJ ;<J<FJ HL< 8 JL M<Q JFE C8J =L<IQ8J HL< DFM@C@Q8E 8 CFJ ?FD9I<J 8E@D8C<J P
?8JK8C8JGC8EK8J;@E8D@Q8E;F<CDLE;FJF:@8C8E@D8CPM<><K8C-8I;<JK@WE P <M8CL8:@WE ;< C8 GIF;L::@WE :@<EKU=@:8 <JKR
;<K<ID@E8;8 GFI C8 ?<><DFEU8 ;< CFJ ;@J:LIJFJ HL< <JK89C<:<E :FDF
C<>UK@D8 P CW>@:8 <O:CLJ@M8D<EK< 8 CFJ G8IRD<KIFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ ;< CFJ G8UJ<J
@E;LJKI@8C@Q8;FJ
)<IF <JK8 @D@K8:@WE ;<9<IU8 J@M<IJ8;8
EG8C89I8J;<-8I;<

8 @EM<EK8;F F @D@K8;F 58 @D@K8;F <J J@<DGI< LE8 @;<8 F LE HL<IL8 ;< C8J FI8:@FE<J ;< LE8 I<C@>@WE ;< C8J
8;D@E@JKI8:@FE<J ;< LE JK8;F ;< CFJ 8IKU:LCFJ ;< LE :W;@>F ;< CFJ
;<9<I<J ;< LE8 DFI8C ;< CFJ KI898AFJ ;< LE8 @E;LJKI@8 ;< CFJ
GIF:<;@D@<EKFJ;<LE8IK< 9

EJUEK<J@JCFHL<J<?8<JK8;F@D@K8E;F;<J;<?8:<;FJ;S:8;8JEF<JE@
J@HL@<I8 C8 GIF;L::@WE :@<EKU=@:8 :FDF K8C <J ;<:@I JL ./.,=>*,2G7 J@EF C8
2-.* HL< C8 GFCUK@:8 :@<EKU=@:8 b:FDGIWc 8:<I:8 ;< C8 D<AFI D8E<I8 ;< ?8:8E@JDFJ@EK<IE8:@FE8C<J

C8 @D@K8:@WE J< ;8 >I8:@8J 8 C8 @EK<IM<E:@WE ;< ;@:?8J =L<IQ8J <E <C ?FD9I< GIFG8>RE;FJ<
G8LC8K@E8D<EK<?8JK8@E=CL@I<EKF;8LE8JF:@<;8;
CC<:KFIGL<;<:FEJLCK8ILE9I<M<8ERC@J@J;<
<JKFJ :FE:<GKFJ K8I;<8EFJ I<=<I@;FJ 8 CFJ GIF:<JFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE JF:@8C :FEK<DGFIRE<FJ <E
LQDRE

-8C<J<C:8JF;<C8(I>8E@Q8:@WEG8I8C8FFG<I8:@WEP<C<J8IIFCCF:FEWD@:F(P<C
8E:F&LE;@8C&HL@<E<J<EJL@E=FID<;< JF9I<C8<;L:8:@WEJLG<I@FI<EFCFD9@8;8E
JL 9<E<GCR:@KF 8 C8J GFCUK@:8J @DGC<D<EK8;8J <E EL<JKIF G8UJ ;<J<JK@D8E;F C8J :FEJ<:L<E:@8J
CF:8C<JHL<<CCFGL<;<><E<I8I:FDFGFI<A<DGCFC8GI@M8K@Q8:@WE;<C8<;L:8:@WEJLG<I@FI
@:<E
C8(P<C8E:F&LE;@8CCFJ@>L@<EK<^%FJGI@E:@G8C<J<C<D<EKFJ;<C8I<=FID848C8%<P5
JFE:FII<:KFJG<IF?8J@;F;@=U:@C8C:8EQ8ILE:FEJ<EJFJF9I<<C:FEK<E@;F<O8:KF;<CFJ:8D9@FJ

O@JK<8:L<I;FJF9I<C8E<:<J@;8;;<<OG8EJ@WEP=L<9@<EI<:@9@;F<C:FDGIFD@JF;<8LD<EK8I
CFJ =FE;FJ GX9C@:FJ 45
%8 FGFJ@:@WE 8 C8 <;L:8:@WE :FE RE@DF ;< CL:IF 8:8G8IW CFJ K@KLC8I<J
G<IF<EFG@E@WE;<C<HL@GF;<I<M@J@WE<I8EPJFEDRJ@DGFIK8EK<JFKIFJ8JG<:KFJ;<C8I<=FID8
GIFGL<JK8_
'WK<J< <C :8IR:KLD<EK8:@WE 8C @E@:@F ;< C8 :@K8
:L8E;F :8C@=@:8 ;< b:FII<:KFJc CFJ <C<D<EKFJ ;< C8 I<=FID8 ;< D8E<I8 HL< C8 ( P <C 8E:F
&LE;@8C DRJ HL< FI>8E@JDFJ ;< <M8CL8:@WE P I<:FD<E;8:@WE JF9I< C8J GFCUK@:8J E8:@FE8C<J

%8 @DGFJ@:@WE @D@K8:@WE ;< LE DF;<CF ;FD@E8EK< G8I8 <A<I:@WE C8K@EF8D<I@:8E8 J< ?8 <JK89C<:@;F :FDF LE8
<OK<EJ@WE ;<C D@KF ;<C GIF>I<JF <E ;FE;< <C ;@J:LIJF GFCUK@:F 8JF:@8 C8
:@<E:@8@EK<IE8:@FE8C:FDFC8XE@:8GFJ@9C<G<IF<EI<8C@;8;

45 <C :8IR:K<I ;<D8J@8;F @EKILJ@MF ;<C DF;<CF ;FD@E8EK<
b@EK<IE8:@FE8CcGL<;<?8:<IG<I;<I;<M@JK8C8J@;<8JJF9I<HLS:C8J<
;<:@<E:@8FHLSD<;@FJG8I8HLS=@E<JJ<IU8ECFJDRJXK@C<JG8I8CFJ
GIF9C<D8J ;< 4DSI@:8 %8K@E85
E C8 G<IJG<:K@M8 ;< LE8 :@<E:@8
b@EK<IE8:@FE8Cc J@E =IFEK<I8J C8 G<I@=<I@8 ;<A8 ;< K<ECF98C

E :8D9@F <E C8 G<IJG<:K@M8 ;< C8 ?@JKFI@8 ;< C8 :@<E:@8
C8K@EF8D<I@:8E8 J< F9J<IM8 HL< SJK8 EF =LE:@FE8 <O8:K8D<EK< :FDF
C8J :FIGFI8:@FE<J DLCK@E8:@FE8C<J ;< C8 "P J@EF HL< ?8P KF;8 LE8
>8D8 ;< :FEKI@9L:@FE<J CF:8C@Q8;8J D8PFI<J P D<EFI<J 8C DFJ8@:F
;< C8 :@<E:@8 P HL< C8 G<I@=<I@8 GL<;< J<I DRJ @EEFM8;FI8 HL< CFJ
:<EKIFJ GL<J SJKFJ K@<E<E @EM<IJ@FE<J DLP =L<IK<J HL< :FEJ<IM8I
/<JJLI@

<J;<<JK8WGK@:8<C8ERC@J@J;<CFJ;@J:LIJFJGFCUK@:FJ;<J;<CFJ:L8C<JJ<
:FEJKILPW C8 GFCUK@:8 :@<EKU=@:8 <E FCFD9@8 DL<JKI8 HL< <C ?FI@QFEK< ;<
8::@WE J@<DGI< =L< <JK89C<:@;F GFI CFJ DF;<CFJ <OKI8EA<IFJ ;<J8K<E;@<E;F
MU8J 8CK<IE8K@M8J ;< =FIK8C<:@D@<EKF ;< C8 :@<E:@8 98J8;F <E <OG<I@<E:@8J P
;<J8IIFCCFJ :FE :8IR:K<EF
G8IK@I ;< <J8 J@KL8:@WE J< ?8:<
GI<GFE;<I8EK< LE <A<I:@:@F ;< ;./5.@2?2-*- :FE C8 G8IK@:@G8:@WE :FEALEK8 ;<

8:KX8E :FDF FI>8E@JDFJ ;< M<<;LIU8
-8D9@SE CC8D8 C8 8K<E:@WE HL< <C b<HL@GF ;< I<M@J@WEc
FKFI>L< GF:8 @DGFIK8E:@8 8C K<D8 ;< C8 <;L:8:@WE :FE RE@DF ;< CL:IF J@E <D98I>F <J8
8=@ID8:@WEK@<E<J<EK@;F8C:FDGI<E;<IHL<C8K<E;<E:@8DLE;@8C<J;<:@IC8<O@><E:@8;<<JKFJP
FKIFJ FI>8E@JDFJ DLCK@C8K<I8C<J <J =FIK8C<:<I<E:@8J
LE@M<IJ@K8I@8J G8I8 C8 8;D@E@JKI8:@WE <DGI<J8I@8C ;< C8 <;L:8:@WE
JU GL<J C8 <;L:8:@WE :FE
RE@DF;<CL:IFEF<JLEGIF9C<D8G8I8C8(P<C8E:F&LE;@8CGFIHL<<J8<JC8K<E;<E:@8
HL< ?8E GIFDFM@;F ;<J;< ?8:< LE G8I ;< ;S:8;8J 8C GLEKF ;< E8KLI8C@Q8I <E <C ;@J:LIJF ;@:?8
;@I<:KI@Q
)8I8LE8ERC@J@J;<<JK8K<E;<E:@8M<I;L 8:KFIPP.E@M<IJ@;8;'WD8;8

GFCUK@:FJ :@<EKU=@:FJ P AWM<E<J @EM<JK@>8;FI<J <E ;FE;< J< <JK89C<Q:8E

:LRC<J?8EJ@;FCFJ<=<:KFJ;<C8262=*,2G7;<CFJDF;<CFJ?8JK8?FPPJ@<J
GIL;<EK< :FEK@EL8I GFI C8 D@JD8 MU8 F ,;.*; FKI8 8CK<IE8K@M8
)8I8 CF>I8I
<JKF J< ;<9< :<EKI8I <C 8ERC@J@J EF CFJ I<JLCK8;FJ <JK8;UJK@:FJ ;< C8
:@<E:@FD<KIU8 P8 I<8C@Q8;FJ GFI <C (P- J@EF <E C8 8=<:K8:@WE P <E C8J
@DGC@:8:@FE<J;<C8JGFCUK@:8J@DGC<D<EK8;8J<ECFJ:L8KIFE@M<C<J;<8::@WE
8E8C@Q8;FJ<E<CGI@D<I:8GUKLCF;<<JK<C@9IF<JKF<J <CE@M<C;@J:LIJ@MF
<CE@M<CGI8>DRK@:F<CE@M<CI<>LC8K@MFP<CE@M<C;<JL9A<K@M8:@WE

%8 I<=C<O@M@;8; P C8 @EK<IG<C8:@WE ;<C DF;<CF 8:KL8C JFE @DGFIK8EK<J P
E<:<J8I@FJG8I8<JK89C<:<ILEDF;<CF;<=FD<EKF8C8:@<E:@8HL<I<8CD<EK<
8GFIK< 9<E<=@:@FJ 8 C8 <:FEFDU8 CF:8C :FE 98J< <E :I@K<I@FJ JFC@;8I@FJ P EF
:FDG<K@K@MFJ :FDF JL:<;< 8:KL8CD<EK<
,<>L@I <C DF;<CF @D@K8;F ;<J;<
?8:<8VFJ:FECC<M88G<ID8E<:<I<EC8JG<I@=<I@8J;<C8:@<E:@8DLE;@8C
G<I@=<I@8J HL< CFJ D@JDFJ DF;<CFJ J< <E:8I>8E ;< :FEJK@KL@I P D8EK<E<I

8AF<JKFJDF;<CFJG8I8<A<I:<IC88:K@M@;8;:@<EKU=@:8JFCFCFJG8UJ<JHL<J<
:FEJFC@;8E <E <C :8DGF :@<EKU=@:F K@<E<E <JK8KLJ :@<EKU=@:F <J LE :UI:LCF
M@:@FJF P <O:CLP<EK< <E ;FE;< C8J =IFEK<I8J ;< C8 :@<E:@8 P C8 <:FEFDU8 J<
;@CLP<E G8I8 ;8I G8JF 8 CF HL< J< ?8 ;<EFD@E8;F b<:FEFDU8J ;<C
:FEF:@D@<EKFc 8JU CF <ELE:@8E `@DGX;@:8D<EK<` C8 ( P <C 8E:F
&LE;@8C

45 K8D9@SE <J @DGFIK8EK< <EK<E;L@IR
98JRE;FJ<<E>I8ED<;@;8<ECFJI<:LIJFJE8KLI8C<JC88>I@:LCKLI8P
C8J @E;LJKI@8J ;< K<:EFCF>U8 D<EFJ 8M8EQ8;8 D@<EKI8J HL< JLJ
@EJK@KL:@FE<J;<<;L:8:@WEJLG<I@FI<E:FEALEKFJ<>L@IREJ@<E;F<E
C F9A<K@MF ;< <J< <A<I:@:@F ;< I<=C<O@M@;8; J<IU8 ;<K<ID@E8I :LRC<J JFE C8J ,;..7,2*LU8EC88GIFG@8:@WEP<A<:L:@WE;<CFJDF;<CFJ:@<EK@=@:FJ@DGC<D<EK8;FJ<E
EL<JKIFG8UJ;<J;<?8:<DRJ;<8VFJ

<C D<AFI ;< CFJ :8JFJ 9L<EFJ :<EKIFJ G8I8 C8 <;L:8:@WE ><E<I8C P
GIF=<J@FE8C G<IF EF J< :FEM<IK@IRE <E @EJK@KL:@FE<J ;<;@:8;8J 8 C8
@EM<JK@>8:@WE(8E:F&LE;@8C

&RJ :FEKLE;<EK<J EF GL<;<E JFE8E JFCF <O@JK< LE8 :@<E:@8 :FII<:K8 P <J 8HL<CC8 HL< <OK@<E;< C8J
GIR:K@:8J @EM<JK@>8K@M8J ?8:@8 C8 :FEJFC@;8:@WE ;< C8 CC8D8;8 <:FEFDU8 ;<C
:FEF:@D@<EKF :L8CHL@8:@WE HL< <JKS GFI =L<I8 ;< ;@:?FJ
:REFE<JJ<IRJ@<DGI<G8I8C8(P<C8E:F&LE;@8CLE8@EM<JK@>8:@WE
;< J<>LE;8 :C8J< LE8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE @E=<I@FI P :FDF :FIFC8I@F J@E
@DGFIK8E:@8G8I8<CJ@JK<D8@EK<IE8:@FE8C;<GIF;L::@WE:@<EKU=@:8

,@<CDF;<CF?<><DWE@:F;<?8:<I:@<E:@8EFJI<C<>8;<J;<<CGI@E:@G@F8LE
J<>LE;F GC8EF ]GFI HLS J<>L@I @D@K8E;F JLJ GI@E:@G@FJ P D<KF;FCF>U8J
]G8I8HLS@EK<EK8I:FDGC8:<I8CFJ><JKFI<J;<;@:?FDF;<CFJ@>L@<E;F<><
G8KIFE<J ]EF J<IU8 DRJ ;@>EF P 8GIFG@8;F :I<8I 7>.<=;8< GIFG@FJ
G8KIFE<J %8 I<=C<O@WE HL< ;<9<DFJ GIFG@:@8I ;<9< <JK8I <E:8D@E8;8 8
JFG<J8I C8J M<EK8A8J P ;<JM<EK8A8J HL< C8 8;FG:@WE ;< CFJ DF;<CFJ
<OKI8EA<IFJ ?8 ><E<I8;F <E CFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ < @EM<JK@>8;FI<J ;< EL<JKIF G8UJ
<E K8EKF KI898A8;FI<J :F>E@K@MFJ P <E K8EKF J<I<J ?LD8EFJ <E FKI8J
G8C89I8J8E8C@Q8IHLSK8E9<E<=@:@FJF?8J@;FC8@DGC<D<EK8:@WE@D@K8:@WE;<
<JFJDF;<CFJG8I8<C;<J8IIFCCF;<EL<JKI8:@<E:@8PG8I8C8:8C@;8;;<M@;8
;<CFJ:@<EKU=@:FJ
JUJ<?8:<@DGI<J:@E;@9C<C8GI<>LEK8=FIDLC8;8GFI8CJ
FI;8

]*LS GF;<DFJ 8GI<E;<;WE HL< GI<K<E;< I<;L:@IEFJ 8 IF9FKJ P
J<IM@;FI<J ;< DF;<CFJ <OKI8VFJ G<IF HL< EFJ :FEJLD< 8C D@JDF

K@<DGF;<@E8E@:@WEGFIHL<:?LG8:FDFJ8E>L@AL<C8EL<JKIFJI<:LIJFJ
;<KF;8:C8J<HL<JFEDL:?FJ!<II<I8P%WG<Q:FDGJ

J?FI8P8;<GC8EK<8IEFJJ<I@8PD<KW;@:8D<EK<LEDF;<CFHL<I<8CD<EK<
=8MFI<Q:8 CFJ ;<J8IIFCCFJ D<KF;FCW>@:FJ P <G@JK<DFCW>@:FJ ;< EL<JKI8J
C8K@KL;<JGL<J:FDFK8D9@SECFGC8EK<W:<IK<I8D<EK<8CJFI;8
^(:@<E:@8
I<9<C;< EL<M8 :FEJKIL:K@M8 F :@<E:@8 ;< J<>LE;8 :C8J< @D@K8K@M8 P
;<J8;8GK8;8_!<II<I8P%WG<Q:FDGJ

" !)"!' &*

.E8 M<I;8;<I8 bI<MFCL:@WE :@<EKU=@:8c <E EL<JKIF G8UJ P <E EL<JKI8 I<>@WE
J@>E@=@:8IU8 KI8EJ>I<;@I CFJ G8IRD<KIFJ ;< C8 :@<E:@8 8:KL8C ><E<I8E;F
J@JK<D8J;<GIF;L::@WEP<M8CL8:@WEI<8CD<EK<8LKSEK@:FJP8LKWEFDFJ
)FI
LE C8;F LE J@JK<D8 8LKSEK@:F K<E;IU8 HL< <JK89C<:<E8J;<@EM<JK@>8;FI<J>ILGFJP
:<EKIFJ;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE
)FIFKIFC8;FC88LKFEFDU8<JK8IU8I<GI<J<EK8;8<E
JL@E;<G<E;<E:@8;<CFJJ@JK<D8J;<GIF;L::@WEPD<;@:@WE<OKI8EA<IFJF<E
GI@E:@G@F<JK89C<:<I@E;<G<E;<E:@8<EKI<C8J:C8J@=@:8:@FE<JA<I8IHL@Q8:@FE<J
;<;@:?FJJ@JK<D8JPC8KFD8;<;<:@J@FE<JGFCUK@:8J
%8I<MFCL:@WE:@<EKU=@:8
<JGFJ@9C<<EKFE:<JJFCF8G8IK@I;<C8KI8EJ=@>LI8:@WE;<CFJ8G8J@FE8;FJ
@EK<I<J<J D<I:8EK@C<J P <:FEWD@:FJ ;< CFJ 9852,A 6*4.;< ?8:@8 CFJ
@>L8CD<EK<8G8J@FE8;FJ@EK<I<J<J:@<EKU=@:FJP<G@JK<DFCW>@:FJ

%8 @EM<E:@WE ;< LE EL<MF DF;<CF G8I8 EL<JKIF G8UJ ;<9< 8JLD@IJ< :FDF
LE8 M<I;8;<I8 <>+?.;<2G7 <EK<E;@;8 :FDF ^8HL<CC8 :FE;@:@WE F J@KL8:@WE
HL<I<=C<A8C8J@E:FE>IL<E:@8J@EK<IE8J;<LE8FI;<EJF:@8C;<J:L9@<IK8JGFI
D@<D9IFJ ;< <JK< <E LE G<I@F;F ?@JKWI@:F ;<K<ID@E8;F 8 C8 CLQ ;< EL<M8J
D<K8J bLKFGU8c HL< LE8 JF:@<;8; HL@<I< 8C:8EQ8I_ !<II<I8 P %WG<Q
:FDGJ

JK8 <JKI8K<>@8 ;< :8D9@F <C89FI8;8 GFI 8CJ FI;8
;<J;< <E JL C@9IF * <>+?.;<2G7 .7 8586+2* :FEK@<E< M8I@FJ
<C<D<EKFJ HL< D<I<:<E 8K<E:@WE 8 C8 CLQ ;< CFJ @EK<I<J<J HL< 8HLU EFJ
:FEMF:8E
C J<>L@I C8 :@K8 @ED<;@8K8D<EK< 8EK<I@FI GF;<DFJ ;<:@I HL< C8
;.?85>,2G7 ,2.7=E/2,* `HL< K8D9@SE GF;IU8DFJ CC8D8I 8?FI8 <>+?.;<2G7
,2.7=E/2,*
`J<C<>@K@D8PDRJ8XEJ<?8:<E<:<J8I@8GFI;@M<IJ8JI8QFE<J

%FJ ;<J8K@EFJ ;<C DF;<CF 8:KL8CD<EK< @EJK8LI8;F <E FCFD9@8 JFE
:FEJ<:L<E:@8 ;< C8 ;<J:FEK<OKL8C@Q8:@WE C8 @DGIFM@J8:@WE P C8 =8CK8
;<:FEJ<EJF<EC8GFCUK@:8:@<EKU=@:8

@:?8 =8CK8 ;< :FEJ<EJF 8 JL M<Q F9<;<:< 8 C8 <O:<J@M8
9LIF:I8K@Q8:@WE P :<EKI8C@JDF ;< C8 @EJK@KL:@WE <E:8I>8;8 ;< ;<=@E@I
:FEKIFC8I P 8;D@E@JKI8I C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J :@<EKU=@:8J
JKF GIF;LAF LE
8@JC8D@<EKF><E<I8C;<CFJ:@<EKU=@:FJ<EC8KFD8;<;<:@J@FE<JJF9I<
JL GIFG@8 MF:8:@WE P JF9I< C8J 8:K@M@;8;<J HL< I<8C@Q8E
:FK@;@8E8D<EK<<EJLJKI898AFJ

%8 8;FG:@WE ;< LE DF;<CF ;<J:FEK<OKL8C@Q8;F @DGC@:8 C8
@EM@J@9@C@Q8:@WE P <C ;<J:FEF:@D@<EKF @EK<E:@FE8;F ;< CFJ GIF:<JFJ
:@<EKU=@:FJ<E;W><EFJ<EXCK@D8J<JC8E<>8:@WE8C8GFJ@9@C@;8;;<
G8IRD<KIFJGIFG@FJG8I8C8<M8CL8:@WE:@<EKU=@:8E8:@FE8C

%FJ :8D9@FJ P 8;8GK8:@FE<J 8C DF;<CF P8 @EJK8LI8;F GIFM@<E<E ;<
MF:<J <OK<IE8J :FEJLCKFIU8J D@J@FE<J F I<:FD<E;8:@FE<J ;<
<EK@;8;<J:FDF<C8E:F&LE;@8C<C)'.PC8(HL<8:KX8E
98AF<C@EK<ISJ;<CGFJ@:@FE8D@<EKF;<C8<:FEFDU8@EK<IE8:@FE8C

JK8J :8I8:K<IUJK@:8J ;<C DF;<CF 8:KL8C JFE JL=@:@<EK<J G8I8 I<GC8EK<8I C8
FI>8E@Q8:@WE ;< C8 :@<E:@8 <E EL<JKIF G8UJ P C<>UK@D8J G8I8 ><E<I8I LE8
I<MFCL:@WE:@<EKU=@:8<E<CJ<EK@;FFKFI>8;F8<JK<KSID@EFGFI8CJFI;8
%8
I8QWE DRJ :FEKLE;<EK< G8I8 ><E<I8I <JK8 KI8EJ=FID8:@WE <J G@<EJF PF <C
)8I8 J<I DRJ GI<:@JF CF HL< J< GIFGFE< <J LE8 bI<MFCL:@WE ;<C :8DGF ;< GIF;L::@WE P
8;D@E@JKI8:@WE ;< C8 :@<E:@8c G<IF G8I8 =8:@C@;8; ;< C8 C<:KLI8 P G8I8 CC8D8I C8 8K<E:@WE JF9I< <C
:CRJ@:FKSID@EFJ@<DGI<J<J@DGC@=@:8IR8CKSID@EFbI<MFCL:@WE:@<EKU=@:8c
8ERC@J@J GF:F GIF=LE;F ;<C DF;<CF @DGC8EK8;F GFI G8IK< CFJ <EK<J
8;D@E@JKI8K@MFJP;<:FEKIFC;<C8:@<E:@8
,@DGC<D<EK<J<?8G8J8;FGFI8CKF
HL<

45 CFJ GIF;L:KFJ ;< C8 :@<E:@8 JFE :FEJKIL::@FE<J :FEK<OKL8CD<EK<
<JG<:U=@:8JHL<CC<M8EC8JD8I:8J;<C8:FEK@E><E:@8J@KL8:@FE8CP;<
C8 <JKIL:KLI8 ;< @EK<I<J<J ;<C GIF:<JF GFI <C :L8C JFE ><E<I8;FJ P
HL< EF GL<;<E J<I :FDGI<E;@;FJ 8;<:L8;8D<EK< J@E LE 8ERC@J@J ;<
JL:FEJKIL::@WE$EFIIP

%8 KI8EJ=FID8:@WE ;<C 8:KL8C DF;<CF HL< 8HLU J< GIFGFE< 9LJ:8
GI<:@J8D<EK<:FEK<OKL8C@Q8IC8GIF;L::@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ:@<EKU=@:FJG<IF
JF9I< KF;F :FDGI<E;U8J < @E@:@8K@M8J HL< J<
=FIDLC8E <E CFJ RD9@KFJ CF:8C<J ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE D<KF;FCF>U8J HL< JFE
<O:CL@;8J GFI CFJ G8IRD<KIFJ @DGL<JKFJ GFI (%"'",
%8 XE@:8
D8E<I8 ;< JLG<I8I <J< K@GF ;< <O:CLJ@FE<J <J 8 KI8MSJ ;< LE8 GIF=LE;8
I<MFCL:@WE <E C8 FI>8E@Q8:@WE ;< C8 :@<E:@8 HL< J<8 :FEJ<EJL8;8 P
:FC89FI8K@M8 HL< M8P8 DRJ 8CCR ;< CFJ DRI><E<J ;< C8 >CF98C@Q8:@WE
:8G@K8C@JK8P;<C8;@M@J@WE@EK<IE8:@FE8C;<CKI898AF:F>E@K@MFPHL<I<JGFE;8
8CFJ@EK<I<J<JGX9C@:FJ;<KF;8JC8JI<>@FE<J;<CG8UJ
)FIFKIFC8;FEFJ<
KI8K8J@DGC<D<EK<;<HL<CFJ@EM<JK@>8;FI<JP:@<EKU=@:FJK<E>8EC8FG:@WE;<
8:<GK8I F EF LE8J EFID8J D<KF;FCW>@:8J P HL< ^C8 :FDG<K<E:@8 <EKI< CFJ
@EM<JK@>8;FI<J GFI 8C:8EQ8I <C SO@KF GIF=<J@FE8C >8I8EK@Q8 HL< K<E;<IRE 8
<C<>@IEFID8J;<:8C@;8;<G@JKSD@:898JK8EK<8CK8J_:FDF@E><EL8D<EK<CF
?8G<EJ8;F#<JXJ38DFI8GL<J:FDFJ<M@F<E<C8GUKLCF";<
<JK<C@9IF<C:8DGF;<C<>@K@D@;8;;<C8GIF;L::@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJEFJ<
:FE=@>LI8 8 G8IK@I ;< C8 <C<>@9@C@;8; ;< EFID8J D<KF;FCW>@:8J P <G@JKSD@:8J
GFIG8IK<;<CFJ:@<EKU=@:FJJL;@JGFJ@:@WE<JDRJ9@<ELE8JLEKF;<@EK<ISJ
<:FEWD@:FD<;@8;FGFI<C;@J:LIJFGFCUK@:F<E;FE;<C8G8IK@:@G8:@WE;<CFJ
@EM<JK@>8;FI<J <E C8 KFD8 ;< ;<:@J@FE<J <J DUE@D8 P ;< KF;8J D8E<I8J
<:C@GJ8;8GFI<C;FD@E@F<OK<IEF;<CGF;<IGFCUK@:F<E:L8EKF8C8C<>@JC8:@WE
J<I<=@<I<

"EM<EK8I LE8 I<MFCL:@WE :@<EKU=@:8 EF <J LE :FEKI8J<EK@;F :L8E;F C8J
:FE;@:@FE<J <E C8J :L8C<J J< ;<J8IIFCC8E CFJ KI898AFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ EF
:FEKI@9LP<E :FDF J< <JG<I898 8 C8J GIF=<J@FE<J E@ 8 C8J :FDLE@;8;<J
CF:8C<J
,< ?8:< <M@;<EK< <EKFE:<J C8 E<:<J@;8; ;< C<>@K@D8I LE8 EL<M8
FI>8E@Q8:@WE ;< C8 :@<E:@8 8 KI8MSJ ;< D<:8E@JDFJ P 8::@FE<J ;<
KI8EJ=FID8:@WE 8 E@M<C E8:@FE8C K<E@<E;F <E :L<EK8 C8J <O@><E:@8J CF:8C<J
8JU :FDF CFJ ;@=<I<EK<J :8DGFJ ;<C J89@:8JPC8JKI8;@:@FE<J<G@JK<DFCW>@:8J

.E8FI>8E@Q8:@WEI<MFCL:@FE8I@8;<C8:@<E:@8;<9<8J@D@JDF:8I8:K<I@Q8IJ<
GFI GIFDFM@:FJ <D<EK<J :FDF
GFJ@9@C@;8;;<LE8><E:@8D@<EKF:@<EKU=@:F:FEKI8I@F8C8I<GIF;L::@WE;<CFJ
DF;<CFJ:FEJKIL@;FJ;<J;<C8J<G@JK<DFCF>U8J?<><DWE@:8J<JG<:@8CD<EK<
<LIF:<EKI@JK8J
E <JK< J<EK@;F LE8 I<MFCL:@WE :@<EKU=@:8 ;<9<IU8 :FEK<E@:8J <EK<E;@;8J SJK8J :FDF GIR:K@:8J
:@<EKU=@:8J HL< CC<M8E 8 :89F LE8 ILGKLI8 :FE C8 CW>@:8 ;< D<;@:@WE
<M8CL8:@WE;FD@E8EK<
.EKI898AF;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE>L@8;FGFICC<M8I8CCUD@K<
C8J:I<<E:@8J ;<J<FJ:@<EKU=@:FJDRJHL<GFIC8E<:<J@;8;;<C8GL9C@:8:@WE
<JKI8K@=@:8:@WE JF:@8C ;<J8IIFCC8 LE8 ;@JGFJ@:@WE :IUK@:8 DRJ 89@<IK8 P 8C
D@JDF K@<DGF LE <E:L8;I< D<KW;@:F D<EFJ IU>@;F
%8 8G<IKLI8 ?8:@8 C8
@EEFM8:@WE D<KF;FCW>@:8 <J :@<IK8D<EK< LE8 ILGKLI8 I8;@:8C :FE C8
K<E;<E:@8KI8;@:@FE8CGL<J:FE<CC8J<9LJ:8LE8EL<M88JF:@8:@WE<EKI<CFJ
GIF:<JFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE P C8 SK@:8 :@<EKU=@:8 @E;<G<E;@<EK<D<EK< LE8
I<C8:@WE;<JC@>8;8;<CFJ:REFE<J<JK89C<:@;FJGFICFJJ@JK<D8J;<:@<E:@8
K<:EFCF>U8<@EEFM8:@WE@DGC<D<EK8;FJ;S:8;8J8KIRJ

L8E;F 8HLU ?89C8DFJ ;< b@EEFM8:@WE D<KF;FCW>@:8c J< ;<9< 8J@D@C8I <C
GI@D<I KSID@EF ;<J;< LE GLEKF ;< M@JK8 K8I;<8EF <J ;<:@I C8 @EEFM8:@WE
<EK<E;@;8 :FDF @E@:@8K@M8 <O@KFJ8 :FDF @EM<E:@WE KI8EJ=FID8;FI8
)8I8
-8I;< C8 @EM<E:@WE DRJ HL< LE J@DGC< 8:KF <J LE8 =L<IQ8 ;<K<ID@E8EK8I C8J FKI8J 8 C8 E<:<J@;8; ;< ;<J<8I HL<I@:8 <J LE8 =L<IQ8 HL<
@EM<EK8 EL<M8J D8E<I8J ;< <A<I:<E:@8D@<EKF:@<EKU=@:F8
KI8MSJ;<D<KF;FCF>U8J:I<8K@M8JHL<@IILDG8E<CJK8KLHLF8:KL8C<JLE8:KF
I<MFCL:@FE8I@F HL< J@E ;L;8 KI8EJ=FID8IR K8D9@SE C8J JL9A<K@M@;8;<J
:@<EKU=@:8J
E <JKF J< :FE;<EJ8 C8 D<E:@FE8;8 @EEFM8:@WE D<KF;FCW>@:8
@EM<E:@WE K<WI@:8 G8I8 KI8EJ=FID8I C8 :@<E:@8 @EM<E:@WE GIR:K@:8 G8I8
KI8EJ=FID8I 8C :@<EKU=@:F
JKF HL@<I< ;<:@I HL< <J E<:<J8I@F KI8EJ=FID8I `8
KI8MSJ ;< 8><E:@8D@<EKFJ I<MFCL:@FE8I@FJ` CFJ <JHL<D8J :@<EKU=@:FJ
8:KL8C<J

?FI8 9@<E ];< HLS J< KI8K8 C8 @EEFM8:@WE D<KF;FCW>@:8 <E :L8EKF 8C
DSKF;F<EL<MF-8I;<EFJ8:<I:88LE8GFJ@9C<I<JGL<JK8;<EKIF;<CFJ
KSID@EFJ HL< J< ?8E M<E@;F GC8EK<8E;F ^.E8 FI>8E@Q8:@WE ;<C KI898AF
:@<EKU=@:F HL< I<>C8D<EK8I8 C<>@JC8K@M8D<EK< C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE <OG<I@D<EK8C F
C8 D<;@8:@WE =@CFJW=@:8 ;8IU8 I<JLCK8;FJ C8D<EK89C<J_ :@K8;F GFI %8QQ8I8KF

%F HL< GC8EK<W -8I;< ?8:< P8 DRJ ;< 8VFJ GL<;<
<EK<E;<IJ< :FDF <C @E@:@F ;< C8 :IUK@:8 8 C8 <JK8E;8I@Q8:@WE ;< CFJ
GIF:<;@D@<EKFJ:@<EKU=@:FJ8J@D@JDF:FDFLEK<DGI8EFCC8D8;F;<8K<E:@WE
JF9I<C8EFID8C@Q8:@WE;<C8FI>8E@Q8:@WE:@<EKU=@:8:FDF:8DGF;FD@E8EK<

%8 :@K8 ?8:< G8IK< ;<C C@9IF "<A,185802. .,87862:>. GL9C@:8;F GFI GI@D<I8 M<Q <E <E
)8I@J

;< GF;@K@D8:@WE ;< JLJ I<JLCK8;FJ

%8 I<>C8D<EK8:@WE CF :L8C
J@>E@=@:8 C8 <JK8E;8I@Q8:@WE ;< CFJ GIF:<;@D@<EKFJ ;< C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE
:@<EKU=@:8 :@<IK8D<EK< C@D@K8E C8 =L<IQ8 :I<8K@M8 <EK@SE;8J< C8J :I<<E:@8J P
CFJ;<J<FJ;<CFJ@EM<JK@>8;FI<JGFI:L8EKF:FEC8@DGFJ@:@WE@E=I8EHL<89C<
;<C :8DGF C<>@JC8K@MF J< ;<:@;< HLS P :WDF J< ;<9<E CC<M8I 8 :89F CFJ
GIF:<;@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ <E KF;FJ CFJ :8JFJ
,<>XE -8I;< <JKF ;8IU8
I<JLCK8;FJC8D<EK89C<J]C<;@FC8?@JKFI@8;<C8:@<E:@8C8I8QWE

%FHL<JU<JJ<>LIF<JHL<;@:?8I<>C8D<EK8:@WEC<>@JC8K@M8GIF;LAFEFJFCF
C8 EFID8C@Q8:@WE J@EF K8D9@SE C8 E8KLI8C@Q8:@WE ;< LE DF;<CF :@<EKU=@:F
E8:@;F <E C8J <OG<I@<E:@8J <LIFG<8 P <JK8;FLE@;<EJ< ;< ?8:@FE<J ><F>IR=@:8J KLM@DFJ HL< @;<EK@=@:8IEFJ
E
<J< J<EK@;F C8 @EK<IE8:@FE8C@Q8:@WE ;<C DF;<CF ;<:I<KW HL< <J8 <J C8 XE@:8
MU8 G8I8 GF;@K@D@;8; K8EKF 8JU HL< C8 :@<E:@FD<KIU8 P C8 9@9C@FD<KIU8 8:KX8E :FDF
8LKSEK@:FJM<<;FI<J;<;@:?8C<>@K@D@;8;
FEKF;F<JKFMFCM@<E;F8-8I;<
CFJ @EM<JK@>8;FI<J ;<9<E FCM@;8IJ< ;< JLJ G8J@FE<J :I<<E:@8J P ;<J<FJ
:@<EKU=@:8J G8I8 :LDGC@I :FE CFJ ;<J@>E@FJ K<WI@:FJ P D<KF;FCW>@:FJ ;< LE8
:@<E:@8 @DGIFG@8
C GIFG@F -8I;< ;<J8IIFCCW <C :FE:<GKF ;< ^@E=CL<E:@8J
<OKI8CW>@:8J_<ECFJGIF:<JFJ;<@D@K8:@WEG8I8CC8D8IC88K<E:@WEJF9I<<JK8
J@KL8:@WE<EC8M@;8JF:@8C

FEJ@;<I8;8 98AF :L8CHL@<I8 ;< JLJ 8JG<:KFJ C8 M@;8 JF:@8C 8C
GIFCFE>8IJ< =.;627* /*=*56.7=. .7 5* /8;6*,2G7 -. >7* /G;6>5* <J
;<:@I <E <C KI@LE=F DRJ :FDGC<KF ;<C ,87/8;62<68 <8+;. 5* /*7=*<E*
27-2?2->*5
%8 C<E>L8 C8 I<C@>@WE C8 GFCUK@:8 C8 >L<II8 <C ;<I<:?F C8
8IHL@K<:KLI8 C8 DXJ@:8 C8 G@EKLI8 C8 GF<JU8 C8 :FIK<JU8 <K:
;8E
FI@><E8LE:FE=FID@JDFK8EKFDRJG<I=<:KF8LE8=WIDLC8K8EKFDRJ
<O@><EK< P K@IRE@:8 :L8EKF DRJ K@<DGF ?8E ;LI8;F P DRJ

G<I=<:K8D<EK< J< ?8E ;<J<EML<CKF 9 C8J :LIJ@M8J JFE

DU8J

JKF <J CF HL< ?8 JL:<;@;F :FE EL<JKI8 :@<E:@8 J< ?8 :I<8;F LE8 =WIDLC8
K@IRE@:8 <LIF <JK8;FLE@;<EJ< HL< J< ?8 GIFCFE>8;F >I8:@8J 8 <J<
:FE=FID@JDF K8EKF GFCUK@:F :FDF K<WI@:F P D<KF;FCW>@:F CF :L8C ?8
;<J<D9F:8;F <E C8 =8K8C@;8; ;< EL<JKI8 .92<=.6.
-8I;< <J :8K<>WI@:F 8C
GC8EK<8IC8;@=<I<E:@8:FDFLEF;<CFJ8JG<:KFJ:<EKI8C<JG8I8<C8M8E:<;<
C8 :@<E:@8 ^45 :8;8 @EM<JK@>8;FI K@<E< JL DSKF;F GIFG@F @E;@M@;L8C P :8J@
@EKI8EJD@J@9C<P;<C:FE:LIJF;<<JKFJDSKF;FJ;@M<IJFJ;<JL:FE=C@:KF8
D<EL;FI<JLCK8<C8M8E:<;<C8:@<E:@8_ 9
,@>L@<E;FC8JCUE<8J
;< -8I;< CF HL< J< ?8 GC8EK<8;F 8HLU <J HL< EF GL<;< ?89SE<J@J :FEK<OKL8C

GC8EK<8;8GFI8CJFI;8!<II<I8P%WG<Q PJJ

J@EFK8D9@SEC8J
:I<<E:@8JP;<J<FJ;<CFJ:@<EKU=@:FJ

C J@>L@<EK< 8G8IK8;F ;<J8IIFCC8 C8 @;<8 ;< C8 E<:<J@;8; ;< ;<=<E;@FJ8
D@C@K8I:FDFCF?@QFLIFG8;LI8EK<C8:FEHL@JK8FGFIC8C<>@JC8:@WEGFCUK@:F
<:FEWD@:8:FDFCF?8:<E8:KL8CD<EK<LIFG8PJK8;FJ.E@;FJ

%8<E;F>SE<J@J:FEK<OKL8C^JFJK@<E<HL<C8JI<8C@;8;<J9RJ@:8JF9J<IM89C<JM8E:FE;@:@FE8;8J
8C<EKFIEFM@K8C8KI8MSJ;<CGIF:<JF;<C8JF:@8C@Q8:@WECF:L8C@E;L:<8C8:I<8K@M@;8;FI>RE@:88C
8GI<:@F P I<JG<KF GFI C8J I8U:<J :LCKLI8C<J P GFI C8J :8I8:K<IUJK@:8J <JG<:U=@:8J ;<C 8D9@<EK<
E8KLI8CPJF:@8C;<CFJGL<9CFJ45_!<II<I8P%WG<Q

&

L<JK@FE8I :IUK@:8D<EK< C8 GFJ@:@WE ;FD@E8EK< ;< CFJ DF;<CFJ <OKI8EA<IFJ P
;8I G8JF 8 LE8 I<MFCL:@WE :@<EKU=@:8 ;<9<E J<E:@8D@<EKFJ :@D<EK8;FJ
;<J;< LE8 @;<8 =L<IQ8 HL< C8J JLJK<EK@WEC8K@EF8D<I@:8E8J<I<:FE=@>LI<E8
C8 CLQ ;< EL<JKI8J GIFG@8J KI8;@:@FE<J ;8E;F CL>8I EF JWCF 8 CFJ J89<I<J
:@<EKU=@:FJJ@EFK8D9@SE8CFJ:FEF:@D@<EKFJKI8;@:@FE8C<JP:FDLE@K8I@FJ
E
C8 :FEALE:@WE <EKI< <C J89<I :@<EKU=@:F P <C KI8;@:@FE8C J< :FEJKILP< C8
GFJ@9@C@;8; ;< LE :FEF:@D@<EKF I<8CD<EK< :FC89FI8K@MF GFI :L8EKF C8
J<EJ@9@C@;8;PC8<OG<I@<E:@8;<JLA<KFJ@E;@M@;L8C<JP:FC<:K@MFJJ<:FEJK@KLP<
<E<C<G@:<EKIF;<CFJGIF:<;@D@<EKFJE<:<J8I@FJG8I8C8:I<8:@WE;<J89<I<J
DXCK@GC<J ;<J;< <JK8 :FE:<G:@WE C8 :FDGFJ@:@WE ;< LE8 D<KF;FCF>U8 JWCF
GL<;<;8IJ<98AFCFJG8IRD<KIFJ;<C8JGIFG@8JI<C8:@FE<J:FEJKIL@;8J<EKI<
KF;FJ:@<EKU=@:FJPEF:@<EKU=@:FJ

-FD8E;F:FDFGLEKF;<G8IK@;8<JK<:FEALEKF;<I<C8:@FE<J<J@EE<>89C<C8
E<:<J@;8;;<;<=<E;<IC8J:FEJKIL::@FE<JHL<;<<CC8J;<I@M<EGFE@<E;F<E
G<IJG<:K@M8 P <E :L<JK@WE EF JWCF CFJ ;FD@E@FJ :@<EKU=@:FJ <OKI8EA<IFJ J@EF

^)FI .92<=.6. J< <EK@<E;< ;< ?<:?F <C :FEALEKF ;< C8J I<C8:@FE<J HL< GL<;<E LE@I <E LE8
SGF:8 ;<K<ID@E8;8 C8J GIR:K@:8J ;@J:LIJ@M8J HL< ;8E CL>8I 8 LE8J =@>LI8J <G@JK<DFCW>@:8J 8
LE8J:@<E:@8J<M<EKL8CD<EK<8LEFJJ@JK<D8J=FID8C@Q8;FJ<CDF;FJ<>XE<C:L8C<E:8;8LE8
;< <J8J =FID8:@FE<J ;@J:LIJ@M8J J< J@KX8E P J< FG<I8E CFJ G8JFJ 8 C8 <G@JK<DFCF>@Q8:@WE 8 C8
:@<EK@=@:@;8; 8 C8 =FID8C@Q8:@WE C8 I<G8IK@:@WE ;< <JFJ LD9I8C<J HL< GL<;<E <EKI8I <E
:F@E:@;<E:@8 <JK8I JL9FI;@E8;FJ CFJ LEFJ 8 CFJ FKIFJ F <JK8I ;<J=8J8;FJ <E <C K@<DGF C8J
I<C8:@FE<J C8K<I8C<J HL< GL<;<E <O@JK@I <EKI< LE8J =@>LI8J <G@JK<DFCW>@:8J F LE8J :@<E:@8J <E C8
D<;@;8<EHL<;<G<E;<E<EGIR:K@:8J;@J:LIJ@M8J:FEK@>L8JG<IF;@JK@EK8J_FL:8LCK8
P
EFKI8G8IK<I<@K<I8FL:8LCKÊLE8:LCKLI8P<ELEDFD<EKF;8;FJJWCF?8PJ@<DGI<
LE8<G@JK<D<HL<;<=@E<C8J:FE;@:@FE<J;<GFJ@9@C@;8;;<KF;FJ89<IJ<8HL<J<D8E@=@<JK<<E
LE8 K<FIU8 F HL< HL<;< J@C<E:@FJ8D<EK< @EM<JK@;8 <E LE8 GIR:K@:8_ 9
.E8 .92<=.6.
<J ;<J;< <JK< GLEKF ;< M@JK8 KF;8J 8HL<CC8J I<C8:@FE<J < @EK<I:8D9@FJ ;@J:LIJ@MFJ ;< GF;<I
J@D9WC@:FJ <K:
HL< @EK<IM@<E<E P 8=<:K8E <E C8J :FEJKIL::@FE<J ;<C J89<I JFE GIF:<;@D@<EKFJ
G<IFK8D9@SEJ<EJ@9@C@;8;<JHL<J<?8:<EGFJ@9C<J<E<CFI;<E;<<JG8:@FJPK@<DGFJDXCK@GC<J
G<IF :FE:I<KFJ P8 J<8 GFI C8 8::@WE ;@I<:K8 GI<J<E:@8C@;8; F GFI C8 8::@WE 8 ;@JK8E:@8
M@IKL8C@;8;

K8D9@SE C8J 8K8C8P8J ;<C J89<I GFJ@:@FE8;8J <E EL<JKIFJ GIFG@FJ :8DGFJ
<G@JKSD@:FJ
<<JK8D8E<I8J<<A<I:<LE;F9C<b9C@E;8A<c:FEKI8CFJGFJ@9C<J
<G@JK<D@:@;@FJ GFI LE C8;F :FEKI8 <C :FCFE@8C@JDF @EK<C<:KL8C GIFG@:@8;F 8
KI8MSJ C8 I<G<K@:@WE ;< DF;<CFJ <OKI8EA<IFJ GFI FKIF C8;F :FEKI8 C8
A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE ;<C J89<DWE@:8 G8I8 C8
JFCL:@WE;<GIF9C<D8JP:FE=C@:KFJ;<P<EC8JF:@<;8;

<=<E;<IC8J<G@JK<DFCF>U8JCF:8C<JJ@>E@=@:889I@ICFJGIF:<JFJ;<:I<8:@WEP
;<@EM<JK@>8:@WE8CFJ:FEF:@D@<EKFJ;<C8J:FDLE@;8;<JEF:@<EKU=@:8J
JKF
K@<E<@DGC@:8:@FE<J@DGFIK8EK<JG8I8C8LE@M<IJ@;8;
EGI@D<ICL>8IJ@>E@=@:8
I<:FEF:<I C8 I<C8:@WE A<IRIHL@:8 P <O:CLP<EK< HL< ?8 K<E@;F C8 LE@M<IJ@;8;
:FECFJFKIFJK@GFJ;<:FEF:@D@<EKFGI<J<EK<J<EC8JF:@<;8;GL<J:FDFCF
D<E:@FEW F8M<EKLI8 ;< ,FLJ8 ,8EKFJ ?@JKWI@:8D<EK< <CC8 ?8 J@;F LE8 ;<
C8J@EJK@KL:@FE<J8IKU=@:<J;<C^<G@JK<D@:@;@F:FD<K@;F<EEFD9I<;<C8:@<E:@8
DF;<IE8 :FEKI8 CFJ J89<I<J CF:8C<J C<>FJ @E;U><E8J GFGLC8I<J_

EJ<>LE;FCL>8IJ<;<9<KI8EJ=FID8I;@:?8I<C8:@WE<O:CLP<EK<<EC8
:L8C ^JFE CFJ @EM<JK@>8;FI<J HL@<E<J ;<K<ID@E8E CFJ GIF9C<D8J :@<EKU=@:FJ
HL<;<9<EI<JFCM<IJ<;<=@E<EC8JI<C<M8E:@8JP<JK89C<:<EC8JD<KF;FCF>U8J
P CFJ I@KDFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE_ 2+E-
JKF <J CF HL< <C GIFG@F ,8EKFJ
;<=@E@W :FDF ^:FEF:@D@<EKF GCLI@LE@M<IJ@K8I@F_ LE :FEF:@D@<EKF <E
;FE;< C8 LE@M<IJ@;8; JLJ @EJK@KL:@FE<J P D@<D9IFJ ><E<I8 GIR:K@:8J ;<
@EM<JK@>8:@WE <E I<C8:@WE :FE JL :FEK<OKF <E;F>SE<J@J :FEK<OKL8C ;< 8CJ
FI;8 P JLG<I8 C8 @D@K8:@WE ;< CFJ DF;<CFJ <LIF <JK8;FLE@;<EJ<J
GI<;FD@E8EK<J<E<C:8DGF;<C<>@K@D8:@WE;<EL<JKIFJJ89<I<J:@<EKU=@:FJ

<J;<<JK8GIFGL<JK8CFJ:8DGFJ<G@JKSD@:FJJ<;<9<E:FEJKIL@I<EKFE:<J
:FE98J<<EC8JI<=<I<E:@8J8GFIK8;8JGFI<C:FEK<OKFCF:8CI<C8:@WE<EKI<<C
?FD9I<PC8E8KLI8C<Q8<E<JG8:@FJ><F>IR=@:FJ<JG<:U=@:FJ;<D8E<I8HL<
C8 8G<IKLI8 ?8:@8 FKIFJ :8DGFJ :LCKLI8C<JJ<8E LE8 :FE;@:@WE @E<OFI89C<

G8I8 C8 :I<8:@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ
JKF HL@<I< ;<:@I HL< C8 :I<8:@WE
:FC89FI8K@M8 ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ :FEK@<E< C8J J@>L@<EK<J ;@D<EJ@FE<J
><E<I8:@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFDRJ8CCR;<CFJIU>@;FJG8KIFE<J@EK<IE8:@FE8C<J
;@RCF>F:FEFKIFJ:8DGFJ:LCKLI8C<JPKI8EJ=FID8:@WE;<C8JI<C8:@FE<J
A<IRIHL@:8J P <O:CLP<EK<J <EKI< :FEF:@D@<EKF :@<EKU=@:F P :FEF:@D@<EKF
KI8;@:@FE8C

JK8J ;@D<EJ@FE<J <E :FEALEKF :FEJK@KLP<E C8 <EKI8;8 8 C8 :I<8:@WE
:FC89FI8K@M8 ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ GIFGL<JK8 9;*@285G02,* D<;@8EK< C8 :L8C J<
GFE<;<I<C@<M<8HL<CCFHL<-8I;<CC8DW^:<I<9IF:FC<:K@MF_PHL<8C8M<Q
9LJ:8 ;<JA<I8IHL@Q8I <C :FEF:@D@<EKF 8 KI8MSJ ;< C8 M@E:LC8:@WE ;<
D<KF;FCF>U8J @EEFM8;FI8J <E <C J<EK@;F ;< IFDG<DWE@:F P ;< C8 :FE=@>LI8:@WE ;< EL<M8J JL9A<K@M@;8;<J :@<EKU=@:8J
8CI<;<;FI ;< LE8 J<EJ@9@C@;8; ?8:@8 <C <EKFIEF <EK<E;@;F SJK< :FDF <C
<JG8:@F;<@EK<I8::@WE<EKI<DWE8;8JJF:@8C<JPE8KLI8C<J

,< <EK@<E;< 8?FI8 :8;8 LEF ;< CFJ KSID@EFJ ;< C8 GIFGL<JK8 ,;.*,2G7
,85*+8;*=2?*-.,878,262.7=8<
EGI@D<ICL>8Ib:I<8:@WEc;<9<<EK<E;<IJ<
;<J;<LE8CW>@:8FGL<JK88:FDFJ<?8:FE:<9@;FC8:@<E:@8<EC8JXCK@D8J
;S:8;8J <J ;<:@I DRJ 8CCR ;< JL CW>@:8 E<K8D<EK< <:FEWD@:8 <E ;FE;< CF
HL< @DGFIK8 <J GIF;L:@I :FEF:@D@<EKFJ G8I8 MFCM<ICFJ D<I:8E:U8J G8I8

EK<E;<IC8:@<E:@8:FDFLE8=FID8:LCKLI8C<EKI<FKI8J/<JJLI@ J@>E@=@:8<JK89C<:<I

HL< C8 :@<E:@8 EF <JKR E@ GFI =L<I8 E@ GFI <E:@D8 ;< CFJ ;<J8IIFCCFJ P I<GI<J<EK8:@FE<J ;< LE8
:FC<:K@M@;8;
FDF;@:</<JJLI@^J@J<8:<GK8HL<C8:@<E:@8<JLE8=FID8:@WE:LCKLI8C<EKFE:<J
:FDF:L8CHL@<IFKI8:LCKLI8<CC8K<E;IRLE8;@D<EJ@WEEFID8K@M8PLE8:F>E@K@M845%FJ?<:?FJ
;<C8:@<E:@8J@<DGI<K@<E<E M8CFI<J8;?<I@;FJ8<CCFJHL<CFJ @EM@JK<E;<J@>E@=@:8;FJF:@8CPEF
D<I8D<EK<CW>@:F_

89I@<C-8I;<<EK<E;U8C8JF:@<;8;PKF;88::@WEJF:@8C:FDFLE8:FFG<I8:@WE<EKI<:<I<9IFJ
8JU GL<J C8 JF:@<;8; DRJ HL< LE8 JLD8KFI@8;< @E;@M@;LFJ ;<9< :FEJ@;<I8IJ< :FDF LE :<I<9IF
:FC<:K@MF:FDGL<JKFGFILE8:8EK@;8;@E=@E@K<J@D8C;<DWE8;8JHL<@EK<I8:KX8E<EKI<JU
FE<JK8
@;<8 -8I;< IFDG< :FE C8 ;@M@J@WE ;< C8 =@CFJF=U8 DF;<IE8 <EKI< JLA<KFF9A<KF GL<J P8 EF J<
<EK@<E;<CFJF:@8C8G8IK@I;<<JK8FEKFCF>U89@E8I@8J@EFHL<JLA<KFPF9A<KF<JKRE@ED<IJFJ;<EKIF
;<CD@JDFDLE;FDFER;@:F<ELE:FEJK8EK<@EK<I:8D9@FJ@EHL<LEFJ<FGFE>8FJL9FI;@E<8C
FKIFM<I-8I;<

:FD<I:@8C@Q8ICFJ:FDFJ<<OGC@:@KW<E<CGI@D<I:8GUKLCF
EJ<>LE;FCL>8IP
<EJ@EKFEU8:FECF<OGI<J8;F8EK<I@FID<EK<C8G8C89I8b:FC89FI8K@M8cI<D@K<
8C88::@WE;<I<FI>8E@Q8ICFJGIF:<;@D@<EKFJG8I8C8C<>@K@D8:@WEM8C@;8:@WE
P <M8CL8:@WE ;< CFJ :FEF:@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ DRJ 8CCR ;< JL GIF;L:K@M@;8;
<E C8 CW>@:8 :8G@K8C@JK8 <E C8 :L8C CFJ @EM<JK@>8;FI<J J< :<EKI8E <E C8
:FDG<K@K@M@;8; GFI C8 GL9C@:8:@WE P <E <C I8EB@E> @EK<IE8:@FE8C C8 GIFGL<JK8
8GLEK88><E<I8ILE.=18<;<:FC89FI8:@WEEF;<:FDG<K@K@M@;8;
EK<I:8ICFJb:FEF:@D@<EKFJcJFE<EK<E;@;FJ8HLU:FDF<C:FEALEKF;<J89<I<J
:@<EKU=@:FJ KI8;@:@FE8C<J @E;U><E8J P GFGLC8I<J HL< J< ;.,86+27*7:FE <C
=@E ;< ;8I JFCL:@FE<J GIR:K@:8J 8 GIF9C<D8J :FEK<DGFIRE<FJ P GFJ@9@C@K8I
I<=C<O@FE<J 8E8CUK@:8J JF9I< C8J GIF9C<D8K@Q8:@FE<J ;< LE8 F M8I@8J
:FDLE@;8;<J:FEF:@D@<EKFJG8I8C8KI8EJ=FID8:@WEEF:FEF:@D@<EKFJG8I8
C8:@K8:@WE

JK8GIFGL<JK8GL<;<FEFJ<I=8:K@9C<GL<J;<G<E;<:FDF:8J@KF;FCFHL<
898I:858<8,2*5;<C:FEALEKF;<KFD8;<MFCLEK8;<J;<:@J@FE<JP8::@FE<J
HL<KI8J:@<E;<ECF@E;@M@;L8C
,L8::@WEKI8EJ=FID8;FI8;<G<E;<8JLM<Q;<
C8 KI8EJ=FID8:@WE ;<C 8E;8D@8A< :@<EKU=@:F 8:KL8C ;<J;< CFJ ;@J:LIJFJ
GFCUK@:FJ 98J8;FJ <E D@KFJ P :FE:<G:@FE<J <:FEFD@:@JK8J ?8JK8 C8
:<EKI8C@;8; ;<C D<I:8;F ;< GL9C@:8:@WE :FEJK@KL@;F :FDF :FIFC8I@F ;< C8J
<JKI8K<>@8J:@<E:@FDSKI@:8JP9@9C@FDSKI@:8JG8I8C8M8C@;8:@WEPC<>@K@D8:@WE
@EK<IE8:@FE8C ;<C J89<E<I8IR LE8J
JL9A<K@M@;8;<J :@<EKU=@:8J <E 8IDFEU8 :FE CFJ DXCK@GC<J GIF9C<D8J
:FEK<DGFIRE<FJP<J88IDFE@Q8:@WE<EKI<C8:@<E:@8PJL<EKFIEF><E<I8IR
:I<FPFJF:@<;8;<JDRJGIF:C@M<J8C8ALJK@:@8JF:@8CHL<8C8KI8EJ=<I<E:@8

^+<:FD9@E8I J@>E@=@:8 DF;@=@:8I C8 I<C8:@WE <EKI< CFJ ;@=<I<EK<J <C<D<EKFJ ;< DF;F HL< J<
GIF;LQ:8 LE I<JLCK8;F J<D@WK@:F P =LE:@FE8C ;@JK@EKF ;<C HL< ;<I@M898 ;< C8 :FD9@E8:@WE
GI<:<;<EK<_ <I8I;@
E <C :FEK<OKF <E <C HL< J< GC8EK<8 <JK< :FE:<GKF P :FDF CF
GC8EK<S <E FKI8 F:8J@WE ^J< <EK@<E;< C8 I<:FD9@E8:@WE <E C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE JF:@8C :FDF C8
@EK<I8::@WE <EKI< C8J GFK<E:@8J DFER;@:8J HL< GFE<E <E K<EJ@WE JLJ :I<<E:@8J P ;<J<FJ <E C8
GIF;L::@WE:FC<:K@M8;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ<JK8CL:?8;<=L<IQ8J:I<8EL<MFJ8:<IMFJP89I<EL<M8J
GFJ@9@C@;8;<J<E<C:8DGF:@<EKUf:F_ LQDRE EFK8

;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ P K<:EFCW>@:FJ :FC<:K@M@;8;<J :@<EKU=@:8J

J<EJ@9C<J 8 JLJ :FDLE@;8;<J DRJ HL< 8 JLJ GX9C@:FJ P :FE;@:@FE<J
C89FI8C<J :@<EKU=@:8J <E I<C8:@WE :FE CFJ J<EK@D@<EKFJ 8G8J@FE8;FJ ;< CFJ
@EM<JK@>8;FI<J EF :FE CFJ ;< :8G@K8C@JK8J P <DGI<J8I@FJ
J ;<J;< <JK<
-.<.8 HL< J< GIFGFE< KI8EJ=FID8I C8J 8K8C8P8J ;<C J89<E
8:KL8CD<EK< <E <C :8DGF :@<EKU=@:F P CFJ <C<D<EKFJ HL< ;@<IFE FI@><E 8 JL
:FEJKIL::@WE
)<IF<JK8<JK8EJFCFLE8GIFGL<JK8;<DL:?8JGFJ@9C<J

C CC8D8;F GFI LE8 KI8EJ=FID8:@WE JF:@8C :FDGIFD@JF @II<=LK89C< ;< C8J
:@<E:@8JJL<E8:FDFLE?@DEF<EKFE8;FGFIC8JMF:<JHL<I<:FEF:<EPHL<
?8EG8;<:@;FCFJ;<J@>E@FJ;<C8@EALJK@:@8C8<O:CLJ@WEPC8 I<GI<J@WE
,FCF
8HL<CCFJHL<;<LE8LFKI8D8E<I8?8EJ@;F9<E<=@:@8I@FJ;<C<=*=><:>8J<
J@C<E:@8EP8JLM<QJ<?8:<ECFJJFI;FJ8;@:?FCC8D8;F

,FDFJ EFJFKIFJ @EM<JK@>8;FI<J P 8:8;SD@:FJ :FGIFK8>FE@JK8J ;< <J8
KI8EJ=FID8:@WE
WDF<E8I9FC8IJL98E;<I8<JLE8@EHL@<KL;;<8EK8VFHL<
EF J@E QFQF9I8 CFJ @EM<JK@>8;FI<J ?<DFJ K<E@;F HL< <E=I<EK8I I<:FII@<E;F
;@M<IJFJ C89<I@EKFJ HL< G8I<:@<I8E I<:FEJKIL@IJ< 8 JU D@JDFJ :FE :8;8
8M8E:< <=<:KL8;F
E <J< :8DGF C89<IUEK@:F <=<:K@M8D<EK< 8 M<:<J J<
G@<I;< <C ?FI@QFEK< 8 K8C GLEKF HL< C8 :@<E:@8 M8C>8 ;<:@I CFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ
I<GIF;L:@DFJ F 8:<GK8DFJ HL<;8D<EK< C8J :FE;@:@FE<J ;< @EALJK@:@8 P
<O:CLJ@WE:FEKI8C8J:L8C<J;<9<IU8DFJKI898A8I
%8:FDGC<A@;8;;<CC89<I@EKF
<J K8C HL< ?8 ><E<I8;F 8J@D@JDF <O:CLJ@FE<J <E <C GIFG@F K<II<EF ;< C8
:@<E:@8 :FE CF :L8C J< GL<;< :FE=@ID8I HL< <C :8DGF :@<EKU=@:F EF <JKR GFI
<E:@D8E@GFI=L<I8E@DRJ8CCR;<C8JF:@<;8;C8:@<E:@8K8D9@SE.<<8,2*5

EKFE:<JJ@C8:@D8;<C8:@<E:@8<JC8KI8EJ=FID8:@WEJF:@8CSJK8<E:L8EKF
K8C ;<9<IU8 KI8EJ=FID8IJ< 8 JU D@JD8 GI@D<IF 8 D<EFJ HL< J< :FEJ@;<I<
HL< K8C P :FDF <JKR :FE=@>LI8;8 8:KL8CD<EK< <JKR 9@<E
"E;L;89C<D<EK< CF
<OGL<JKF <E <JK< C@9IF <J <C I<KI8KF ;< C8 :I<<E:@8 FGL<JK8 C8 8:KL8C
:FE=@>LI8:@WE ;<C :8DGF :@<EKU=@:F <E FCFD9@8 ?8 ><E<I8;F <=<:KFJ
:FEKI8I@FJ 8 CFJ ;<J<FJ ;< KI8EJ=FID8:@WE GFI K8C I8QWE ;@:?F :8DGF ;<9<
J<I;..7<*6+5*-8
FE<JK8@;<8:FDF>LU8:FE=CLP<IFEC8JI<=C<O@FE<JHL<
898I:8IFECFJKI<J:8GUKLCFJGI<:<;<EK<J
CC89<I@EKFI<:FII@;F<E<JK<:8JF

KI8KW;<;8I:C8I@;8;JF9I<CFJG8J8;@QFJ;< <C8E;8D@8A<HL<;8=FID8P
J<EK@;F8C8:@<E:@8PK<:EFCF>U8<EFCFD9@8CFJFIU><E<JP:FEJFC@;8:@WE
;<C:8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MFPJF9I<C8JCUE<8J><E<I8C<JG8I8GIFP<:K8ILE8
I<MFCL:@WE:@<EKU=@:8

J@D@JDF<J@DGFIK8EK<D<E:@FE8IHL<<CI<:FII@;F?<:?FGLJF;<I<C@<M<C8
G<IJG<:K@M8;F9C<;<J;<;<EKIFP;<J;<=L<I8<E<CJ<EK@;FHL<<CGLEKF;<
M@JK8 8KI8M<JW CFJ ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ HL< =LE;8D<EK8E EL<JKIF :8DGF :@<EKU=@:F
G<IF8;<DRJCFJ@EK<IG<CW8G8IK@I;<:FE:<GKFJPI<=C<O@FE<JGI<:<;<EK<JP
GIFG@8J :FDF LE :C8IF <A<DGCF ;< C8 GFJ@9@C@;8; ;< <O@JK<E:@8 ;<C :<I<9IF
:FC<:K@MFK8I;<8EF

%8:FE:CLJ@WEHL<;8<JHL<8G<E8JJ<?8?<:?FLEGI@D<II<:FII@;FGFI<C
C89<I@EKF<J@DGI<J:@E;@9C<8;<DRJ;<I<:FII<ICFPI<:FEF:<ICF<J:L;I@V8I
JLJ <=<:KFJ DRJ UE=@DFJ <JKF <J C8 8=<:K8:@WE HL< ?8 ><E<I8;F <E
:@<EKU=@:FJ < @EM<JK@>8;FI<J ;LI8EK< <JK8J XCK@D8J ;FJ ;S:8;8J GL<J :FDF
;@:< <C KUKLCF ;< LEF ;< CFJ C@9IFJ ;< )89CF $I<@DF ;< 89I@I C8J GL<IK8J ;<C C89<I@EKF HL<;8 C8
@DG<I@FJ8E<:<J@;8;;<:FEF:<I<E;<K8CC<P<E9F:8;<CFJGIFG@FJJLA<KFJ
:@<EKU=@:FJ<@EM<JK@>8;FI<JJLJ<OG<I@<E:@8JPM@M<E:@8J<EI<C8:@WE:FECFJ
;FD@E@FJ ;< ;@:?F :8DGF
JK8 J@E E@E>LE8 ;L;8 <J C8 J@>L@<EK< K8I<8 8
I<8C@Q8I

>8D9<E @FI>@F
%207*=>;*;.;>6%8+;..56D=8-8L<EFJ@I<J
;I@8E8!@;8C>F

6666666666 J#>D .< >7 -2<98<2=2?8 FEJLCK8;F <E *8<68<2<
?KKG:8FJDFJ@J
8:I8:@8
E<KG

I<CC8EF EKFE@F P $I<@D<E<I8Cc <E
I<CC8EFEKFE@FP$I<@D<I)89CF;@I<:KFI<J<=>-28<8,2*5-.5*,2.7,2*A
5*=.,78580E*-.<-.6D;2,**=27*F>FKR

,@>CF;<C!FD9I<;@KFI<J

<I8I;@I8E:F2/8
*/C+;2,*-.5*27/.52,2-*- >.?*</8;6*<-.
=;*+*38A68?262.7=8058+*5&8;I@;-I8=@:8EK<J;<JL<VFJ

CFE;<8L(C@M@<I.=*5
*92=*52<68,8072=2?89;892.-*-27=.5.,=>*5A
,;.*,2G7,85.,=2?*
&8;I@;-I8=@:8EK<J;<JL<VFJ

FLI;@<L )@<II<
5 8/2,28 -. ,2.7=E/2,8 2.7,2* -. 5* ,2.7,2* A
;./5.@2?2-*-8I:<CFE8E8>I8D8

66666666668
868*,*-.62,><
L<EFJ@I<J,@>CF11";@KFI<J

66666666669
8<><8<<8,2*5.<-.5*,2.7,2*L<EFJ@I<J'L<M8
/@J@WE

LE>< &8I@F
* ;.5*,2G7 .7=;. 5* <8,28580E* A 5* /258<8/E* &8;I@;
;@KFI@8C

RI;<E8J #
&

* 7>.?* .,8786E* -.5 ,878,262.7=8 F>FKR
;@:@FE<J#LIU;@:8J LJK8MF"9RV<Q

(%"'",
8586+2**5/258-.5*898;=>72-*-&868
,8EK8=S
;<F>FKR-<I:<I&LE;F;@KFI<JM<IJ@WE<ECUE<8

6666666666
2.7,2* A <8,2.-*- 8586+2* /;.7=. *5 ;.=8 -.5 =.;,.;
625.728 %2<=.6* *,287*5 -. 2.7,2* A &.,78580E* ,878,262.7=8 9*;* .5
-.<*;;8558,8EK8=S;<F>FKRFC:@<E:@8J

6666666666
6*7.;*< -. 0.7.;*; ,878,262.7=8 .7 8586+2*
*<8<<.5.,,287*-8<98;58<";80;*6*< *,287*5.<-. 2.7,2*

&.,78580E*.778?*,2G7F>FKR(%"'",

66666666668
8586+2*,87<=;>A.A<2.6+;*/>=>;8"85E=2,*7*,287*5
-./86.7=8*5*27?.<=20*,2G7A*5*2778?*,2G78,>6.7=89*;*-2<,><2G7
F>FKR

6666666666 9
8-.58 -. 6.-2,2G7 -. 0;>98< -. 27?.<=20*,2G7
=.,785G02,*8-.2778?*,2G7VF
F>FKR

<
I<@== C<O@J P &8C;FE8;F hJ:8I

bdGIFG@8:@WE =L<IK<e ;<C
:FEF:@D@<EKF LE8 GIFGL<JK8 G8I8 :FEJKIL@I GFCUK@:8J @E:CLJ@M8J ;< :@<E:@8

K<:EFCF>U8<@EEFM8:@WE<EDSI@:8%8K@E8c<EI<CC8EFEKFE@FP$I<@D-28<8,2*5-.5*,2.7,2*A5*=.,78580E*-.<-.6D;2,*
*=27*F>FKR

,@>CF;<C!FD9I<;@KFI<J

;L 8:KFIP P .E@M<IJ@;8; 'WD8;8 :FDGJ

* '72?.;<2-*- .7
,87/52,=8 *9=>;*< A />0*< .7 .5 6.;,*-8 058+*5 -.5 <*+.; &8;I@;
-I8=@:8EK<J;<,L<VFJ

8CJ FI;8 (IC8E;F
2.7,2* 9;892* A ,85872*52<68 27=.5.,=>*5
F>FKR(M<A8'<>I8

FL:8LCK &@:?<C 8
* *;:>.8580E* -.5 <*+.;
&SO@:F ,@>CF 11"
;@KFI<J

66666666669
*<9*5*+;*<A5*<,8<*<&SO@:F,@>CF11";@KFI<J

L:?J?I@JK@8E
b.E8:FEKI@9L:@WE8C8:IUK@:8;<C8<:FEFDU8GFCUK@:8
;<C :8G@K8C@JDF @E=FID8:@FE8C KI8EJE8:@FE8Cc <E G6*-*< '\
F>FKR
",( .GG

LD8>8CC@ E;I<8
28.,8786E* A ,*92=*52<68 ,8072=2?8 *,2* >7
7>.?868-.58-.*,>6>5*,2G7&8;I@;-I8=@:8EK<J;<JL<VFJ

WD<Q /U:KFI &8EL<C P <C@J #FI>< b,@JK<D8 ;< 8J<>LI8D@<EKF ;<
C8 :8C@;8; ;< <;L:8:@WE JLG<I@FI :FEJ@;<I8:@FE<J JF9I< C8 8:I<;@K8:@WE <E
FCFD9@8c <E $.?2<=* 8586+2*7* -. %8,28580E* /FC
'\
F>FKR
.E@M<IJ@;8;'8:@FE8C;<FCFD9@8GG

WD<Q 2LI@ #8:B
b)FCUK@:8 :@<EKU=@:8 :FCFD9@8E8 P 9@9C@FDSKI@:8
LJFJc <E G6*-*< '\ F>FKR .E@M<IJ@;8; <EKI8C ` ",( GG

LQDRE -FM8I SJ8I

bC ;@J=I8Q ;< C8 :FDG<K@K@M@;8; P C8
GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ <E <C :8G@K8C@JDF :F>E@K@MFc <E $.?2<=*

8586+2*7*-.%8,28580E*'\
F>FKR.E@M<IJ@;8;'8:@FE8C;<FCFD9@8
GG

6666666666
b!FDF><E<@;8; P DLCK@GC@:@;8; <E C8 @EM<JK@>8:@WE
JF:@8Cc<E G6*-*<'\
F>FKR.E@M<IJ@;8;<EKI8C`",(GG

6666666666
b%8JK<:EFCF>U8J;<C88;D@E@JKI8:@WE;<:FEF:@D@<EKFJ
<E FCFD9@8c <E .68;2*< -.5 ( 870;.<8 7=.;7*,287*5 -. 5* $.- -.
7?.<=20*,2G7 A 8,.7,2* .7 778?*,2G7 &.,785G02,* $& &8E@Q8C<J
FCFD9@8 8C ;< 89I@C ;<
&8E@Q8C<J .E@M<IJ@;8;
'8:@FE8C.E@M<IJ@;8;;<&8E@Q8C<J

6666666666
b%8 :FE=@>LI8:@WE ;<C :8DGF ;< C<>@K@D@;8; ;< C8
GIF;L::@WE ;<C J89FKR
.E@M<IJ@;8;<EKI8C`",(GG

!<II<I8 '@:FCRJ P %WG<Q %FI<E8 :FDGJ

2.7,2* ,869;862<8 A
,*6+28 <8,2*5 &.@=8< -. !;5*7-8 *5< 8;-* L<EFJ @I<J C FC<:K@MF
%8EQ8JP%<KI8J OK<EJ@WE%@9IFJ

#@DSE<Q (:8DGF ,8E;IF
* *-6272<=;*,2G7 -. 58< ./.,=8< -. 5*
>.;;* ,868 =.,78580E* -. 8+2.;78 >7* 62;*-* 98<=52+.;*5 *5 87/52,=8
;6*-8 .7 8586+2*

-<J@J F:KFI8C )IF>8D8 ;< JKL;@FJ
)FCUK@:FJ 8:LCK8; %8K@EF8D<I@:8E8 ;< @<E:@8J ,F:@8C<J %,(
:L8;FI

$I<@D7 <.; 1>6*78 * ,2.7,2*
+*385*5>9*L<EFJ@I<J,@>CF11";@KFI<J

$EFII<K@E8$8I@E
*/*+;2,*,2G7-.5,878,262.7=8'7.7<*A8<8+;.
.5 ,*;C,=.; ,87<=;>,=2?2<=* A ,87=.@=>*5 -. 5* ,2.7,2* <IE8C .E@M<IJ@;8;
'8:@FE8C;<*L@CD<J

%8KFLI ILEF
b%8 K<:EFCF>U8 <J C8 JF:@<;8; ?<:?8 G8I8 HL< ;LI<c
<EFDTE<:?&
P-@I8;F
:FDGJ
%8,28580E*<26D=;2,*7<*A8<<8+;.
,2.7,2*=.,78580E*A<8,2.-*-8I:<CFE8 <;@J8

666666666
*.<9.;*7B*-."*7-8;*7<*A8<<8+;.5*;.*52-*--.
58<.<=>-28<-.5*,2.7,2*8I:<CFE8 <;@J8

6666666666
$..7<*6+5*; 58 <8,2*5 >7* 27=;8->,,2G7 * 5* =.8;E* -.5
*,=8;.-L<EFJ@I<J&8E8EK@8C

%8KFLI ILEF P %SG@E8P /

* .,8786E* ,2.7,2* -. 58< 27=.;.<.<
*9*<287*-8< 7=;8->,,2G7 * 5* *7=;898580E* .,87G62,* -. *+;2.5 &*;-.

L<EFJ@I<J&8E8EK@8C

%8QQ8I8KF &8LI@Q@F
b-I8;@:@WE :LCKLI8C <LIFG<8 P EL<M8J =FID8J ;<
GIF;L::@WE P ;< KI8EJD@J@WE ;<C J89<Ic <E (C@M@*5 A ,;.*,2G7 ,85.,=2?*
&8;I@;
-I8=@:8EK<J;<JL<VFJGG

6666666666
"8;>7*985E=2,*6.78;,87=.,262.7=8A985E=2,*.75*<
<8,2.-*-.<-.,87=;85&8;I@;-I8=@:8EK<J;<,L<VFJ

&8C;FE8;F 8ICFJ ;L8I;F
&%" 2.7,2* A =.,78580E* ,868
985E=2,*<9H+52,*<A<8,2*5.<F>FKR.E@M<IJ@;8;OK<IE8;F;<FCFD9@8

&<AU8&8I:F+8XC
->,*,2G7.<.75*<058+*52B*,2G7.<7=;..5
9.7<*62.7=8H72,8A5*7>.?*,;E=2,*F>FKR

;@:@FE<J<J;<98AF

(9J<IM8KFI@F FCFD9@8EF ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8 ` (P-

7-2,*-8;.<-.,2.7,2*A=.,78580E*8586+2*
F>FKR(P-

6666666666
7-2,*-8;.< -. ,2.7,2* A =.,78580E* 8586+2*

F>FKR(P-

(I>8E@Q8:@WEG8I8C8FFG<I8:@WEP<J8IIFCCF:FEWD@:FJ`(

*7>*5 -. ;*<,*=2 ";89>.<=* -. 8;6* ";C,=2,* 9*;* 7,>.<=*< -.
7?.<=20*,2G7 A .<*;;8558 @9.;26.7=*5 JG8V8 LE;8:@WE JG8VFC8 G8I8
C8@<E:@8PC8-<:EFCF>U82-

( P 8E:F &LE;@8C
?*5>*,287.< -. "85E=2,*< *,287*5.< -.
->,*,2G7 * ->,*,2G7 %>9.;28; .7 8586+2* )8I@J (8E:F
&LE;@8C

+F;IU>L<QDD8EL<CP,RE:?<Q+8XC
b)IWCF>F
EKI<<C:8G@K8C@JDF
:F>E@K@MFP<CFDDFE=8I<c<EFLK8E>2
&
<K8C
*92=*52<68,8072=2?8
9;892.-*-27=.5.,=>*5A,;.*,2G7,85.,=2?*&8;I@;-I8=@:8EK<J;<JL<VFJ

,8EKFJ F8M<EKLI8 ;< ,FLJ8
.<,85872B*; .5 <*+.; ;.27?.7=*; .5
98-.;&FEK<M@;<F;@:@FE<J-I@C:<

6666666666
b%8 LE@M<IJ@;8; <E <C J@>CF 11"
)8I8 LE8 I<=FID8
;<DF:IRK@:8P<D8E:@G8;FI8;<C8LE@M<IJ@;8;c<E+8DUI<Q+<ES:FFI;

&;*7</8;6*; 5* >72?.;<2-*- 9*;* =;*7</8;6*; 5* <8,2.-*- *L@KF ,<:I<K8IU8
'8:@FE8C;<;L:8:@WE,LG<I@FI@<E:@8-<:EFCF>U8<"EEFM8:@WE

-8I;<
89I@<C
;*06.7=8 -. 12<=8;2* />=>;* 8I:<CFE8 ;@:@FE<J
9I8O8J

6666666666
87*-8580E*A<8,28580E*
L<EFJ@I<J8:KLJ

6666666666 8
;..7,2*<-.<.8<<8,2.-*-.<L<EFJ@I<J8:KLJ

6666666666 9
*< 5.A.< -. 5* 262=*,2G7 A * <8,28580E* &8;I@;
<EKIF ;< "EM<JK@>8:@FE<J ,F:@FCW>@:8J P ><E:@8 JK8K8C FC<KUE (=@:@8C ;<C
JK8;F

/8C;<II8D8 8ICFJ ;L8I;F
b,F:@<;8; ;< C8 @E=FID8:@WE
?<><DFEU8 I<;L::@FE@JDF K<:EFCW>@:F P I<J@JK<E:@8Jc <E G6*-*< '\

F>FKR",( .GG

/<I:<CCFE<8ICF
b8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MFPDF;<CFJ;<I<>LC8:@WE;<
C8I<C8:@WEJ8C8I@8C
C>LE8J<EJ<V8EQ8J;<CDFM@D@<EKF8EK@ )c<E;L
8:KFIP P .E@M<IJ@;8; 'WD8;8 :FDGJ

* '72?.;<2-*- .7 ,87/52,=8
*9=>;*< A />0*< .7 .5 6.;,*-8 058+*5 -.5 <*+.; &8;I@; -I8=@:8EK<J ;<
JL<VFJGG

/<JJLI@!<9<
!27?.7=*68<8.;;*68<*,2.7,2*,8682-.*/>.;B*
.76D;2,**=27*<IE8C.E@M<IJ@;8;'8:@FE8C;<*L@CD<J

0?@KC<P+@:?8I;
*8;0*72B*,2G727=.5.,=>*5A<8,2*5-.5*<,2.7,2*<
<IE8C.E@M<IJ@;8;'8:@FE8C;<*L@CD<J

0F;8B +LK?
b%8 ?@JKFI@8 <E :FEJKIL::@WE %8 :FEJKIL::@WE ;< C8
?@JKFI@8
%8 d0<?ID8:?K 8C<D8E8e <E CFJ I<:L<I;FJ :FC<:K@MFJ < @E;@M@;L8C<J
;< LJKI@8c <E 2<,>;<8 %8,2.-*- /FC

'LD

GG

?KKGNNN
;@JJF:
FI><;@:@FE<JME , 0F;8B
?KDC

8>8I">FI
b&8982@EI@K@:8C@J:FLIJ<E8CPJ@Jc<E8-B"*9.;<27
";*06*=2,<
/FCLD<

"JJL<

GG

?KKGM<IJ@K8
D<K8GI<JJ
:FD:FEK<EK0 %

38DFI8#<JXJ
2.7,2*9H+52,*,2.7,2*9;2?*-*$./5.@287.<<8+;.5*
9;8->,,2G7-.5<*+.;,2.7=E/2,8&SO@:FFE;F;<LCKLI8:FEWD@:8

3LB<I=<C;&8I@8EF
b8G@K8C@JDF:F>E@K@MFKI898AF@E=FID8:@FE8CPLE
GF:F;<DXJ@:8c<E G6*-*<'\F>FKR",( .GG

FEJ<AF '8:@FE8C ;< @<E:@8 P -<:EFCF>U8
:L<I;F '\ ;<
b)FI <C :L8C J< 8;FGK8E ;<=@E@:@FE<J :I@K<I@FJ P GIF:<;@D@<EKFJ G8I8 C8
:8C@=@:8:@WE ;< CFJ GIFP<:KFJ :FDF ;< :8IR:K@:F F ;<
@EEFM8:@WE G8I8 CFJ <=<:KFJ GI<M@JKFJ <E <C 8IKU:LCF ;<C <JK8KLKF
-I@9LK8I@Fc

6666666666
:L<I;F '\ ;< b)FI <C :L8C J< 8;FGK8E LE8J
;<=@E@:@FE<Jc

<:I<KF;<
b)FI<C:L8CJ<;@:K8EEFID8JJF9I<8JF:@8:@FE<JG8I8
8:K@M@;8;<J :@<EKU=@:8J P K<:EFCW>@:8J GIFP<:KFJ ;< @EM<JK@>8:@WE P :I<8:@WE
;<K<:EFCF>U8Jc

<:I<KF ;<

b)FI <C :L8C J< I<>C8D<EK8E CFJ M@8A<J ;< <JKL;@F 8C
<OK<I@FI;<CFJ@EM<JK@>8;FI<JE8:@FE8C<J
c

<:I<KF;<
b)FI<C:L8CJ<:I<8<CFEJ<AF'8:@FE8C;<@<E:@8P
-<:EFCF>U8 J< I<FI>8E@Q8 <C "EJK@KLKF FCFD9@8EF G8I8 <C <J8IIFCCF ;< C8
@<E:@8PC8-<:EFCF>U8 FC:@<E:@8JPJ<;@:K8EFKI8J;@JGFJ@:@FE<Jc

<:I<KF ;<
b)FI<C:L8CJ<I<>LC8EC8JDF;8C@;8;<J<JG<:U=@:8J;<
:FEKI8KFJ;<=FD<EKF;<8:K@M@;8;<J:@<EKU=@:8JPK<:EFCW>@:8Jc

<:I<KF;<
b)FI<C:L8CJ<8GIL<98<C:L<I;FEXD<IF ;<
HL< <JK89C<:< C8 <JKIL:KLI8 @EK<IE8 ;<C "EJK@KLKF FCFD9@8EF G8I8 <C
<J8IIFCCF ;< C8 @<E:@8 P C8 -<:EFCF>U8 dI8E:@J:F #FJS ;< 8C;8Je
FC:@<E:@8JPJ<;<K<ID@E8EC8J=LE:@FE<J;<JLJ;<G<E;<E:@8Jc

<G8IK8D<EKF '8:@FE8C ;< )C8E<8:@WE ')
F:LD<EKF ('),

)FCUK@:8'8:@FE8C;<@<E:@8P-<:EFCF>U8

6666666666
F:LD<EKF ('),
)FCUK@:8 '8:@FE8C ;<
@<E:@8P-<:EFCF>U8

<G8IK8D<EKF'8:@FE8C;<)C8E<8:@WE`')

(2<2G78586+2*
.7=.7*;28>7-*6.7=*;.5,;.,262.7=8A.5-.<*;;8558<8,2*5.75*,2.7,2*
5*=.,78580E*A5*2778?*,2G7

6666666666
F:LD<EKF ('),
)FCUK@:8 '8:@FE8C ;<
FDG<K@K@M@;8;P)IF;L:K@M@;8;

RD8I8;<+<GI<J<EK8EK<J
)FE<E:@8G8I8GI@D<I;<98K<8CGIFP<:KF
;<%<PEXD<IF b)FI<C:L8CJ<;@:K8E;@JGFJ@:@FE<JG8I8<C=FD<EKF;<
C8 "EM<JK@>8:@WE @<EKU=@:8 P <C <J8IIFCCF -<:EFCW>@:F P J< FKFI>8E LE8J

=8:LCK8;<J<OKI8FI;@E8I@8Jc

6666666666
)FE<E:@8 G8I8 J<>LE;F ;<98K< 8C GIFP<:KF ;< CU8<"EEFM8:@WE<EFCFD9@8PJ<;@:K8EFKI8J
;@JGFJ@:@FE<Jc

(%"'",
+<JFCL:@WE"EK<IE8'\;< b)FIC8:L8CJ<
I<>LC8CFI<C8K@MF8CI<:FEF:@D@<EKF;<CFJ<EKIFJ;<"EM<JK@>8:@WE
<EKIFJ
;< <J8IIFCCF -<:EFCW>@:F P <EKIFJ P
ILGFJ ;< "EM<JK@>8:@WE ;<
"EJK@KL:@FE<J ;< ;L:8:@WE ,LG<I@FI G8I8 CFJ <=<:KFJ GI<M@JKFJ <E CFJ
8IKU:LCFJ P;<C8%<P;<C;<;@:@<D9I<;<c

%U8 < "EEFM8:@WE <E FCFD9@8 P J<
;@:K8EFKI8J;@JGFJ@:@FE<Jc

(9J<IM8KFI@FFCFD9@8EF;<@<E:@8P-<:EFCF>U8`(P-
JK8KLKFJ

Buy your books fast and straightforward online - at one of worlds

fastest growing online book stores! Environmentally sound due to
Print-on-Demand technologies.
Buy your books online at
www.get-morebooks.com
Compre sus libros rpido y directo en internet, en una de las
libreras en lnea con mayor crecimiento en el mundo! Produccin
que protege el medio ambiente a travs de las tecnologas de
impresin bajo demanda.
Compre sus libros online en
www.morebooks.es
VDM Verlagsservicegesellschaft mbH
Heinrich-Bcking-Str. 6-8
D - 66121 Saarbrcken
Telefon: +49 681 3720 174

Telefax: +49 681 3720 1749
info@vdm-vsg.de
www.vdm-vsg.de

Las Atalayas Del Saber. Legitimación y Jerarquización Del Conocimiento Científico en Colombia (1990-2010)

Diunggah oleh

Informasi Dokumen

Judul Asli

Hak Cipta

Format Tersedia

Bagikan dokumen Ini

Bagikan atau Tanam Dokumen

Opsi Berbagi

Apakah menurut Anda dokumen ini bermanfaat?

Apakah konten ini tidak pantas?

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia

Las Atalayas Del Saber. Legitimación y Jerarquización Del Conocimiento Científico en Colombia (1990-2010)

Diunggah oleh

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia



  &     

. /  0 !

CFLE;<8L .= *5   ;<J8IIFCC8E ;<J;< ;@=<I<EK<J =F:FJ C8J

:IFEFCW>@:8D<EK< ?89C8E;F J@EF DRJ 9@<E 8K<E;@<E;F 8 CFJ SE=8J@J P

GI@D<I8 :8K<>FI@Q8:@WE F :F;@=@:8:@WE ;< CFJ <ELE:@8;FJ L9@:8;FJ <E <C

G8UJ<J HL< ?8E 8C:8EQ8;F C8 b>CFI@8c ;< JLJ K@<DGFJ

JL9;<J8IIFCCF J@EF HL< K8D9@SE EFJ MFCM<IU8 DRJ 8M8EQ8;FJ P D<EFJ

:FEF:@D@<EKF GIF;L:< <O:<C<EK<J ;@M@;<E;FJ

E<CG<I@F;F:FDGI<E;@;F<EKI< P C8@EM<IJ@WEKFK8C;<(%"'",<E:@<E:@8P

;<K<ID@E8:@FE<J P ;< @E ;<=@E@:@FE<J JF9I< C8 :@<E:@8 I<8C@Q8;8 ;<J;< LE

><E<I8:@WE ;< EL<MFJ GIF;L:KFJ P GIF:<JFJ 8 C8 8;8GK8:@WE

CFJ 8JG<:KFJ JF9I<J8C@<EK<J ;< CFJ ;@JGFJ@K@MFJ ;@J:LIJ@MFJ :I<8;FJ ;LI8EK<

@EJK@KL:@FE8C@Q8;8 D@J@FE8CD<EK< P EFID8C@Q8;8 :FDF LE8 ;< C8J GFCUK@:8J

D<KF;FCW>@:8J ><E<I8E;F 8JU LE8 A<I8IHL@Q8:@WE ;< :<EKIFJ < @EJK@KL:@FE<J

ILG% LK@C@Q8DFJ C8

5_ WD<QP<C@J G

GFI <C GIFG@F (%"'",

%8J K<:EFCF>U8J ;< 8;D@E@JKI8:@WE ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF :@<E:@FD<KIU8

=LE;8D<EK8C<J HL< J< D8K<I@8C@Q8 <E GIFP<:KF P FKI8J 8:K@M@;8;<J

K<:EFCF>U8 D8EK<E@D@<EKF P I<G8I8:@WE ;< D8HL@E8I@8 <HL@GFJ

;<J8IIFCC8I GIFP<:KFJ :FEALEKFJ <E <JK8 RI<8 (%"'", 

<JK89C<:<I LE8 GIF;L::@WE ;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ 98AF CFJ G8IRD<KIFJ ;<C

8JLD@W CFJ :FEF:@D@<EKFJ M8CFI<J M<I;8; :FDF D<I:8E:U8J M8CFI<J

;@J:LIJ@M@;8; GFCUK@:8 GIFG@:@W C8 :FE=@>LI8:@WE ;<C :8G@K8C@JDF :F>E@K@MF

 !  '

GFCUK@:FJ :@<EKU=@:FJ P AWM<E<J @EM<JK@>8;FI<J <E ;FE;< J< <JK89C<Q:8E

;< GF;<I <E C8 C<>@K@D8:@WE ;< JLJ I<JLCK8;FJ

G<I=<:K8D<EK< J< ?8E ;<J<EML<CKF  9   C8J :LIJ@M8J JFE

GC8EK<8;8GFI8CJFI;8!<II<I8P%WG<Q  PJJ

C8 8G<IKLI8 ?8:@8 FKIFJ :8DGFJ :LCKLI8C<JJ<8E LE8 :FE;@:@WE @E<OFI89C<

EK<E;<IC8:@<E:@8:FDFLE8=FID8:LCKLI8C<EKI<FKI8J/<JJLI@  J@>E@=@:8<JK89C<:<I

;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ P K<:EFCW>@:FJ :FC<:K@M@;8;<J :@<EKU=@:8J

  *<8<<.5.,,287*-8<98;58<";80;*6*< *,287*5.<-. 2.7,2*

I<@== C<O@J P &8C;FE8;F hJ:8I  

:FEF:@D@<EKF LE8 GIFGL<JK8 G8I8 :FEJKIL@I GFCUK@:8J @E:CLJ@M8J ;< :@<E:@8

;L 8:KFIP P .E@M<IJ@;8; 'WD8;8 :FDGJ

;< LJKI@8c <E 2<,>;<8 %8,2.-*- /FC

<:I<KF  ;< 

C8 "EM<JK@>8:@WE @<EKU=@:8 P <C <J8IIFCCF -<:EFCW>@:F P J< FKFI>8E LE8J

ILGFJ ;< "EM<JK@>8:@WE ;<

Buy your books fast and straightforward online - at one of worlds

Buy your books online at

Compre sus libros online en

Telefon: +49 681 3720 174

Anda mungkin juga menyukai

&

./ 0 !

CFLE;<8L .= *5 ;<J8IIFCC8E ;<J;< ;@=<I<EK<J =F:FJ C8J

:IFEFCW>@:8D<EK< ?89C8E;F J@EF DRJ 9@<E 8K<E;@<E;F 8 CFJ SE=8J@J P

JL9;<J8IIFCCF J@EF HL< K8D9@SE EFJ MFCM<IU8 DRJ 8M8EQ8;FJ P D<EFJ

E<CG<I@F;F:FDGI<E;@;F<EKI< P C8@EM<IJ@WEKFK8C;<(%"'",<E:@<E:@8P

><E<I8:@WE ;< EL<MFJ GIF;L:KFJ P GIF:<JFJ 8 C8 8;8GK8:@WE

ILG% LK@C@Q8DFJ C8

5_ WD<QP<C@JG

GFI <C GIFG@F (%"'",

%8J K<:EFCF>U8J ;< 8;D@E@JKI8:@WE ;<C :FEF:@D@<EKF :@<E:@FD<KIU8

=LE;8D<EK8C<J HL< J< D8K<I@8C@Q8 <E GIFP<:KF P FKI8J 8:K@M@;8;<J

K<:EFCF>U8 D8EK<E@D@<EKF P I<G8I8:@WE ;< D8HL@E8I@8 <HL@GFJ

;<J8IIFCC8I GIFP<:KFJ :FEALEKFJ <E <JK8 RI<8 (%"'",

8JLD@W CFJ :FEF:@D@<EKFJ M8CFI<J M<I;8; :FDF D<I:8E:U8J M8CFI<J

;@J:LIJ@M@;8; GFCUK@:8 GIFG@:@W C8 :FE=@>LI8:@WE ;<C :8G@K8C@JDF :F>E@K@MF

! '

GFCUK@:FJ :@<EKU=@:FJ P AWM<E<J @EM<JK@>8;FI<J <E ;FE;< J< <JK89C<Q:8E

G<I=<:K8D<EK< J< ?8E ;<J<EML<CKF 9 C8J :LIJ@M8J JFE

GC8EK<8;8GFI8CJFI;8!<II<I8P%WG<Q PJJ

C8 8G<IKLI8 ?8:@8 FKIFJ :8DGFJ :LCKLI8C<JJ<8E LE8 :FE;@:@WE @E<OFI89C<

EK<E;<IC8:@<E:@8:FDFLE8=FID8:LCKLI8C<EKI<FKI8J/<JJLI@ J@>E@=@:8<JK89C<:<I

;< :FEF:@D@<EKFJ :@<EKU=@:FJ P K<:EFCW>@:FJ :FC<:K@M@;8;<J :@<EKU=@:8J

<8<<.5.,,287-8<98;58<";80;6< ,2875.<-. 2.7,2*

I<@== C<O@J P &8C;FE8;F hJ:8I

:FEF:@D@<EKF LE8 GIFGL<JK8 G8I8 :FEJKIL@I GFCUK@:8J @E:CLJ@M8J ;< :@<E:@8

;L 8:KFIP P .E@M<IJ@;8; 'WD8;8 :FDGJ

;< LJKI@8c <E 2<,>;<8 %8,2.-*- /FC

<:I<KF ;<

C8 "EM<JK@>8:@WE @<EKU=@:8 P <C <J8IIFCCF -<:EFCW>@:F P J< FKFI>8E LE8J