MediacoverageofprotestssurelooksdifferentwhendemonstratorsarewhiteVox
ADVERTISEMENT
@germanrlopez
german.lopez@vox.com
Ryan Bundy, a militia member, talks on the phone at the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge in Oregon.
Associated Press
http://www.vox.com/2016/1/3/10705610/oregonterroristsracismrace
1/14
1/6/2016
MediacoverageofprotestssurelooksdifferentwhendemonstratorsarewhiteVox
It's a big story. This is an armed militia using the threat of violence to
get the federal government to change the law specifically, the
gunmen want the feds to give up publicly managed land to local
ranchers, loggers, and miners. And, yes, they are using the threat of
violence: As Les Zaitz explained ( http://www.oregonlive.com/pacificnorthwestnews/index.ssf/2016/01/drama_in_burns_ends_with_quiet.html) for
the Oregonian, "In phone interviews from inside the occupied building
Saturday night, Ammon Bundy and his brother, Ryan Bundy, said they
are not looking to hurt anyone. But they would not rule out violence if
police tried to remove them, they said."
Yet media outlets don't seem to consider this an alarming story,
instead treating it by and large as a peaceful protest. Here, for
instance, is an Associated Press tweet about the events:
TheAssociatedPress
@AP
Follow
PeacefulprotestinOregonrancherarsoncasefollowedby
buildingtakeoveratnationalwildliferefuge:apne.ws/1R82dGq
11:51PM2Jan2016
358
180
For many on social media, the reaction seems very different from how
the media would react if, say, black or Muslim protesters with guns
took over a government building instead of a predominantly white
group.
2/14
1/6/2016
MediacoverageofprotestssurelooksdifferentwhendemonstratorsarewhiteVox
And here is Fox News's front page, where it's hard to even see the
story right by one about a hoverboard robbery:
http://www.vox.com/2016/1/3/10705610/oregonterroristsracismrace
3/14
1/6/2016
MediacoverageofprotestssurelooksdifferentwhendemonstratorsarewhiteVox
The coverage also generally had little language about the threat of
violence. The AP, for example, characterized the protests as peaceful,
and Fox News called the group in Oregon "armed protesters."
Several people on social media complained that this story was getting
much less or at least a different kind of attention than it would
have gotten if these were mainly black or Muslim protesters. Here's a
sampling of some tweets, which don't encompass the entire
conversation but get to a lot of what people are upset about:
JohnFugelsang
@JohnFugelsang
Follow
Canwepleaseget1Muslimtojointherightwingterroristmilitia
inOregonsoourmediacancoverit?
11:49PM2Jan2016
5,422
5,002
http://www.vox.com/2016/1/3/10705610/oregonterroristsracismrace
4/14
1/6/2016
MediacoverageofprotestssurelooksdifferentwhendemonstratorsarewhiteVox
CDKing
Follow
@thedaleking
What'sthedifferencebetweenaterroristcellandamilitia?
Religionandskincolor.
#OregonUnderAttack
#GOP
12:04PM3Jan2016
1,724
1,617
ThorBenson
@thor_benson
http://www.vox.com/2016/1/3/10705610/oregonterroristsracismrace
Follow
5/14
1/6/2016
MediacoverageofprotestssurelooksdifferentwhendemonstratorsarewhiteVox
@thor_benson
Forthosewhodon'tunderstandwhypeoplesayourcriminal
justicesystemisbroken.#OregonUnderAttack
2:52PM3Jan2016
1,696
1,310
rolandsmartin
@rolandsmartin
Follow
DidImissthecallforthenationalguardinOregon?Irecallthem
inFergusonandBaltimore.#OregonUnderAttack
11:34PM2Jan2016
12,567
11,143
http://www.vox.com/2016/1/3/10705610/oregonterroristsracismrace
6/14
1/6/2016
MediacoverageofprotestssurelooksdifferentwhendemonstratorsarewhiteVox
specifically, police use of force ( http://www.vox.com/cards/policebrutality-shootings-us). Those protests led media outlets not just to
cover the demonstrations as wholly violent, but to suggest that the
protests led to a wave of crime and violence in 2015.
For one, there were several instances in which victims of police
shootings and Black Lives Matter protesters even largely peaceful
ones were called thugs or other racially charged language. This is a
problem that CNN ( http://gawker.com/just-call-them-niggersexasperated-cnn-guest-tells-e-1700812536), the New York Times (
http://www.vox.com/xpress/2014/8/25/6066343/new-york-timesmichael-brown-no-angel), and Fox News (
http://mediamatters.org/research/2015/10/26/from-hate-group-tonazis-fox-news-ramps-up-thei/206424) all ran into.
But it went further. After a police officer was shot and killed in Texas,
investigators in the case specifically said (
http://www.vox.com/2015/9/1/9239643/black-lives-matter-fox-news)
they had no idea what the motive of the shooter was. But that didn't
stop Fox News from repeatedly pinning the blame on Black Lives
Matter protesters, whom pundits blamed for fostering distrust and
even hatred toward police: Fox News's Elisabeth Hasselbeck
wondered aloud on air why Black Lives Matter isn't considered a "hate
group." Bill O'Reilly was more blunt, concluding the movement was
indeed a "hate group." And Megyn Kelly characterized the movement
as violent and anti-police in another segment.
http://www.vox.com/2016/1/3/10705610/oregonterroristsracismrace
7/14
1/6/2016
MediacoverageofprotestssurelooksdifferentwhendemonstratorsarewhiteVox
mabReward=CTM&action=click&pgtype=Homepage®ion=CColumn&module=Recommendation
CNN ( http://www.cnn.com/2015/06/02/us/crime-in-america/), USA
Today ( http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2015/07/09/us-citieshomicide-surge-2015/29879091/), and NPR (
http://www.npr.org/2015/07/01/418555852/nationwide-crime-spikehas-lawenforcement-retooling-their-approach) ran stories about a
supposed increase in murders and crimes in 2015, usually suggesting
that protests against police were one factor. In a reference to the
original Black Lives Matter protests in Ferguson, Missouri (
http://www.vox.com/cards/mike-brown-protests-ferguson-missouri),
this became known as the "Ferguson effect" the idea that protests
against police had demoralized police and emboldened criminals,
leading to more crime.
While murder rates are significantly up in some US cities, crime is not (
http://www.vox.com/policy-andpolitics/2015/11/19/9758276/ferguson-effect-crime-wave).
Throughout the year, criminologists also repeatedly cautioned (
http://www.vox.com/2015/9/8/9273139/murder-rates-rising-sharply)
that there's no evidence of a nationwide wave of violence; they've also
said ( http://www.vox.com/2015/9/8/9273139/murder-rates-risinghttp://www.vox.com/2016/1/3/10705610/oregonterroristsracismrace
8/14
1/6/2016
MediacoverageofprotestssurelooksdifferentwhendemonstratorsarewhiteVox
said ( http://www.vox.com/2015/9/8/9273139/murder-rates-rising-
sharply) that there's no evidence that the Black Lives Matter protests
have anything to do with a potential rise in violence. But that didn't
stop the widespread media narratives of a "Ferguson effect."
Asked about the discrepancies, CNN law enforcement analyst Art
Roderick suggested ( http://www.rawstory.com/2016/01/cnnanalyst-white-militiamen-arent-a-threat-like-black-protestersbecause-theyre-not-looting-anything/) that the differences make
sense because the Oregon protesters are in a largely empty rural area
and "they're not destroying property, they're not looting anything."
http://www.vox.com/2016/1/3/10705610/oregonterroristsracismrace
9/14
1/6/2016
MediacoverageofprotestssurelooksdifferentwhendemonstratorsarewhiteVox
GoBrooklyn
@GoBrooklyn
Follow
@APWhenwhitepeoplewithgunstakeoverafederalbuilding
andthreatenthelivesoffedemployees,it'sapeacefulprotest.
12:02AM3Jan2016
93
120
10/14
1/6/2016
MediacoverageofprotestssurelooksdifferentwhendemonstratorsarewhiteVox
http://www.vox.com/2016/1/3/10705610/oregonterroristsracismrace
11/14
1/6/2016
MediacoverageofprotestssurelooksdifferentwhendemonstratorsarewhiteVox
Joe Posner/Vox
http://www.vox.com/2016/1/3/10705610/oregonterroristsracismrace
12/14