LEADERSHIP
TEAM
www.CitrusResearch.org | Citrograph Magazine
Learn More
Not all uses are registered in all states. Check local recommendations.
Bayer CropScience LP, 2 TW Alexander Drive, Research Triangle Park, NC 27709. Always read and follow label instructions. Bayer, the Bayer Cross, and Alion are
registered trademarks of Bayer. Alion is not registered in all states. For additional product information, call toll-free 1-866-99-BAYER (1-866-992-2937) or visit our
website at www.BayerCropScience.us.
CR0614ALIONNA074V00R0
www.CitrusResearch.org | Citrograph Magazine
PUBLICATION OFFICE
12
Eric Cribbs
www.cribbsproject.com
graphics@citrographmag.com
(559) 308-6277
Co-Publisher / Project Manager
Carolina M. Evangelo
www.evangelocommunications.com
cevangelo@citrographmag.com
(209) 777-8995
ADVERTISING
Theresa Machado-Waymire
tmwaymire@citrographmag.com
(209) 761-4444
Carolina M. Evangelo
cevangelo@citrographmag.com
(209) 777-8995
Advertising, business and
production inquiries - call, email
or write us at:
Cribbsproject
121 E. Main Street, Suite #204
Visalia, Calif. 93291
Phone: (559) 308-6277
Fax: (866) 936-4303
graphics@citrographmag.com
18
2016
24
IN THIS ISSUE
8 CHAIRMANS VIEW
RICHARD BENNETT
40
M EE T CR B S NE W
L E A D E R S H IP
TEAM
On The Cover:
ENSURE A SUSTAINABLE
CALIFORNIA CITRUS INDUSTRY FOR
THE BENEFIT OF GROWERS BY
PRIORITIZING, INVESTING IN AND
PROMOTING SOUND SCIENCE.
Member Expires
Kevin Olsen
2017
Etienne Rabe
2018
John Konda
2018
Keith Watkins
2018
Jeff Steen
2018
Richard Bennett
2018
Justin Brown
2018
Public Member
Member Expires
Vacant
2018
CALENDAR OF
EVENTS 2016
January 13
CPDPP Board Meeting, Visalia/Exeter,
California. For more information, contact
CDFA at (916) 403-6652.
January 27
Annual UC Riverside Citrus Day,
Riverside, California. Up-to-date research
information, field tours and variety
tasting.
January 28
CRB Board Meeting, Riverside, California.
For more information, contact the CRB at
(559) 738-0246.
February 9-11
World Ag Expo, International Agri-Center,
Tulare, California. For more information,
visit www.worldagexpo.com.
March 3
California Citrus Mutual Citrus Showcase,
Visalia Convention Center, Visalia,
California. For more information, contact
California Citrus Mutual at
(559) 592-3790.
March 9
CPDPP Board Meeting,
Riverside / San Bernardino, California.
For more information, contact CDFA at
(916) 403-6652.
Citrus Research Board | 217 N. Encina St., Visalia, CA 93291 | PO Box 230, Visalia, CA 93279
(559) 738-0246 | FAX (559) 738-0607 | E-Mail Info@citrusresearch.org | www.citrusresearch.org
CHAIRMANS VIEW
BY RICHARD BENNETT
OUR #1 GOAL:
CONTROLLING HLB
The Ultimate and Only Objective
Richard Bennett
1.
2.
HLB SUMMIT
1.
2.
3.
10
3.
4.
11
From left to right, CRB Secretary/Treasurer Toby Maitland-Lewis, Chairman Richard Bennett, President Gary Schulz and Vice-Chairman Dan Dreyer.
his past September, the Citrus Research Board (CRB) instituted some key leadership changes. First,
after a lengthy and thorough search, we hired a new president for the organization. Shortly thereafter,
at the Boards annual meeting, new executive officers were elected.
We are pleased to introduce Gary Schulz as the CRBs president. Gary has an impressive resum that
seems tailor-made for his new responsibilities of leading the agency through the challenging period
we now face. He is a senior executive with an extensive, focused background in member-driven nonprofit and quasi-governmental agricultural business organizations. Having demonstrated his ability to
12
Wnderful
trees
start with
Wnderful
roots.
Large selection
of scion/rootstock
Insect-excluding
state-of-the-art nursery
USDA/CDFA certified
and inspected
PC13955_WC_Nursery_TradeAd_F.indd 1
13
11/18/15 4:30 PM
INDUSTRY VIEWS
MOJTABA MOHAMMADI
14
FLORIDA EXPERIENCE
BIOLOGICAL CONTROL
15
PUBLIC AWARENESS
16
BIOLOGICAL CONTROL
FLORIDA EXPERIENCE
Weve learned a lot from the HLB situation in Florida. One of the
most important lessons for us early on was the role of human
transportation in the spread of psyllids and disease. This
lesson led directly to steps being taken in California, including
the establishment of quarantines, to ensure that people
are not moving around infested or infected plant material.
Similarly, regulations were put in place in California to make
sure that nursery plants are not sources of HLB spread. I am
fairly confident that these measures (although theyve proven
burdensome for certain people and industries) are at least
part of the reason that the pace of the ACP and HLB situation
in California has to date been very different from Florida.
FLORIDA EXPERIENCE
Call The
Agri-Business
Insurance Specialists
Farms - Ranches
Crops
Packing Houses
Nursery
Land Developers
Produce Brokers
Tree Trimmers
Chemical Applicators
Pump & Well
559-594-5500
nielseninsurance.net
17
18
19
20
TITLE
Pagliaccia
Vidalakis
Leveau
Thomson
Thomson
Louzada
Moore
Ramadugu
Zale
Vidalakis
Roose
Guinard
Jin
Slupsky
Chen
Cilia
Stansly
Ng
Coaker
Godfrey
Cilia
Rolshausen/Leveau
Thomson
McCollum
Falk
Lin
Sumerlin
New
Proposals
5100-153
Real
Time
PCR
co-detecHon
of
Candidatus
Liberibacter
species
and
Spiroplasma
citri
5100-154
Citrus
dwarng
of
commercial
varieHes
using
TsnRNAs
5100-155
Citrus
rhizobiomes
and
tree
producHvity
in
response
to
soil
manipulaHons
Con0nuing
Projects
5200-141
The
development
of
novel
Blood
and
Cara
cara
like
citrus
varieHes
5200-142
UHlizaHon
of
founder
lines
for
improved
citrus
biotechnology
via
RMCE
5200-144
Development
of
consumer-friendly
transgenic
citrus
plants
with
potenHal
broad
spectrum
resistance
5200-146
Rapid
cycling
plant
breeding
in
citrus
5200-147
EvaluaHon
of
hybrids
of
citrus
and
citrus
relaHves
for
huanglongbing
(HLB)
tolerance/resistance
5200-148
MicropropagaHon
of
mature
citrus
in
temporary
immersion
bioreactors
5200-149
Streamlining
the
introducHon
of
licensed
citrus
varieHes
into
California:
A
case
study
-
Florida
5200-201
CORE:
integrated
citrus
breeding
and
evaluaHon
for
California
New
Proposals
5200-150
OpHmizing
sensory
quality
and
consumer
acceptance
of
citrus
fruit
through
horHcultural
pracHces
Con0nuing
Projects
5300-131
IdenHcaHon
and
characterizaHon
of
HLB-induced
small
RNAs
and
mRNAs
5300-150
Biomarkers
for
detecHon
of
Liberibacter
infecHon
in
citrus
trees
through
1H-NMR
based
metabolomics
A
phage/prophage-based
PCR
system
for
sensiHve
and
specic
detecHon
of
Candidatus
Liberibacter
asiaHcus
and
Spiroplasma
citri
5300-151
Using
mass
spectrometry
technologies
to
develop
novel
management
strategies
for
citrus
insect
vector-borne
pathogens
5300-155
5300-156
The
citrus
greening
bibliographical
database
5300-158
ConstrucHon
of
the
cloned
infecHous
cDNA
of
Citrus
tristeza
virus
(California
isolate)
5300-160
IdenHfying
and
characterizing
citrus
targets
from
Candidatus
Liberibacter
asiaHcus
5300-161
Infrastructure
support
for
research
on
detecHon
and
management
of
HLB
and
ACP
5300-163
Not
all
psyllids
are
created
equal:
Why
do
some
transmit
Liberibacter
and
others
do
not?
5300-164
A
microbiota-based
approach
to
citrus
tree
health
5300-165
Development
of
mature
budwood
transformaHon
technology
Use
of
digital
PCR
for
improved
early
detecHon
of
Candidatus
Liberibacter
asiaHcus
infecHon
in
citrus
and
ACP
5300-168
New
Proposals
5300-169
ArHcial
microRNA-based
targeHng
of
the
Asian
citrus
psyllid
for
HLB
management
5300-170
Develop
a
novel
target-basis
of
anH-virulence
strategy
for
controlling
HLB
5300-171
Photosynthate-responsive
polymeric
nano-carriers
for
phloem-specic
delivery
in
the
treatment
of
HLB
Gupta
Kandelous
Ma
PRINCIPAL
INVESTIGATOR
Con0nuing
Projects
5100-146
Novel
therapy
of
high-priority
citrus
diseases
5100-150
OpHmizaHon
of
water
and
nitrate
applicaHon
eciency
for
citrus
trees
5100-152
IdenHcaHon
of
key
components
in
HLB
using
eectors
as
probes
(co-sponsor
with
CRDF)
NUMBER
UC
Davis
USDA-ARS
University
of
Florida
UC
Riverside
UC
Davis
USDA-ARS
Boyce
Thompson
InsHtute
University
of
Florida
UC
Riverside
UC
Davis
UC
Davis
Boyce
Thompson
InsHtute
UC
Riverside
&
UC
Davis
USDA
USDA-ARS
UC Davis
USDA-ARS
USDA-ARS
Texas
A&M
University
of
Florida
UC
Riverside
University
of
Florida
UC
Riverside
UC
Riverside
UC
Riverside
UC
Riverside
UC
Davis
Los
Alamos
UC
Davis
UC
Riverside
AFFILIATION
$
85,000
$
72,424
$
117,128
$
146,406
$
116,437
NCE*
$
183,713
$
18,114
$
94,365
$
106,974
$
100,864
$
146,275
$
151,653
$
2,504
$
42,500
$
101,114
$
129,202
$
115,106
$
110,469
$
103,712
$
73,333
$
22,872
$
5,000
$
627,307
$
21,000
$
6,535
$
86,276
$
67,500
$
108,059
$
22,290
BOARD
APPROVED
BUDGET
21
Adaskaveg
Adaskaveg
Adaskaveg
Walse
Xiao
Walse
Con0nuing
Projects
5400-103
EvaluaHon
of
new
post-harvest
treatments
to
reduce
post-harvest
decays
in
packinghouse
operaHons
5400-119
Disease
forecasHng
and
management
of
Septoria
spot
of
citrus
5400-148
Epidemiology
and
management
of
Phytophthora
diseases
of
citrus
in
California
5400-149
Breaking
criHcal
pest-related
trade
barriers
for
California
citrus
exports
5400-150
Control
of
post-harvest
diseases
of
citrus
Sub-Award
5050-010
Vargas
Stouthamer
TBD
Stouthamer
&
Hoddle
New
Proposals
5500-208
Eects
of
ACP
cover
sprays
against
fruit
ies
(TephriHdae)
and
their
natural
enemies
Sub-Awards
5500-196
Biological
control
of
Asian
citrus
psyllid
in
California
(CPDPP)
6310
Contract
rearing
of
Tamarixia
6320/6321 Development
of
mass-rearing
methods
for
the
parasitoid,
Tamarixia
radiata,
to
support
classical
biological
control
NCE* represents a No Cost Extension where funds for project comple:on were approved in the previous scal year.
Morse
Qureshi
Hoddle
Hoddle
Stouthamer
Qureshi
Stelinski
Grapon-Cardwell
Con0nuing
Projects
5500-189
OpHmizing
chemical
control
of
Asian
citrus
psyllid
in
California
5500-189E Development
of
an
Asian
citrus
psyllid
(ACP)
management
plan
for
organic
citrus
5500-191
Host
specicity
tesHng
of
Diaphorencyrtus
aligarhensis
5500-194
Release
and
monitoring
of
Tamarixia
radiata
and
phenology
of
Asian
citrus
psyllid
in
Southern
California
5500-197
Impact
of
resident
predator
species
on
control
of
Asian
citrus
psyllid
populaHons
5500-205
Toxicity
of
syntheHc
and
organic
insecHcides
to
Tamarixia
radiata,
ecto-parasitoid
of
Asian
citrus
psyllid
5500-206
Development
of
new
trapping
and
control
methods
for
ACP
based
on
complex
citrus
lure
blends
5500-501
CORE:
IPM
program
Breaking criHcal pest-related trade barriers for California citrus exports (TASC)
Gomwald
Slupsky
Willey
Sub-Awards
5300-154
Risk-based
decision
making
in
the
management
of
huanglongbing
(CPDPP)
5300-162
DetecHon
of
Candidatus
Liberibacter
in
citrus
in
Hacienda
Heights
and
other
areas
of
California
(CPDPP)
5050-041
Using
the
internet
to
train
citrus
hobbyists
to
order
budwood
from
CCPP
and
not
to
spread
HLB
(CPDPP)
Cilia
Rolshausen/Leveau
Thomson
McCollum
Falk
Lin
Sumerlin
Schneider
Godfrey
Yokomi
LeVesque
McCollum
Not
all
psyllids
are
created
equal:
Why
do
some
transmit
Liberibacter
and
others
do
not?
A
microbiota-based
approach
to
citrus
tree
health
Development
of
mature
budwood
transformaHon
technology
Use
of
digital
PCR
for
improved
early
detecHon
of
Candidatus
Liberibacter
asiaHcus
infecHon
in
citrus
and
ACP
New
Proposals
5300-169
ArHcial
microRNA-based
targeHng
of
the
Asian
citrus
psyllid
for
HLB
management
5300-170
Develop
a
novel
target-basis
of
anH-virulence
strategy
for
controlling
HLB
5300-171
Photosynthate-responsive
polymeric
nano-carriers
for
phloem-specic
delivery
in
the
treatment
of
HLB
Development
of
PCR-based
diagnosHc
tools
for
detecHon
and
dierenHaHon
of
citrus
leprosis-associated
viruses
5300-172
5300-173
Eect
of
mixed
infecHons
of
plant
pathogens
on
detecHon
of
HLB
using
two
early
detecHon
methods
5300-174
Establish
a
system
to
infect
and
maintain
Nico:ana
benthamiana
and
citrus
with
the
recombinant
CTV
5300-175
EDT
experiment
5300-176
Flush
&
Nypmh
experiment
5300-163
5300-164
5300-165
5300-168
UC
Riverside
TBD
UC
Riverside
USDA-ARS
UC
Riverside
University
of
Florida
UC
Riverside
UC
Riverside
UC
Riverside
University
of
Florida
University
of
Florida
UC
Riverside
USDA-ARS
UC
Riverside
UC
Riverside
UC
Riverside
USDA-ARS
USDA-ARS
USDA-ARS
UC
Davis
Fruitmentor
UC
Davis
USDA-ARS
University
of
Florida
USDA-ARS,
FDWSRU
UC
Davis
USDA-ARS
CRB
USDA-ARS
$
181,745
$
250,000
$
248,404
$
30,000
$
116,660
$
66,565
$
206,407
$
231,358
NCE*
$
69,642
$
100,740
$
420,155
$
444,235
$
61,000
$
53,000
$
134,000
$
40,576
$
73,557
$
180,601
$
55,773
$
20,000
$
85,000
$
72,424
$
117,128
$
56,428
$
214,737
$
94,950
$
254,619
$
113,000
$
146,275
$
151,653
$
2,504
$
42,500
TOTAL $
6,702,284
MEET YOUR
BOARD MEMBERS
Ivy Leventhal
The Citrus Research Board (CRB) is governed by 21 dedicated volunteers from a wide variety of backgrounds and
geographical areas of the California citrus industry. Fifteen of the Board members represent northern California; three
are from southern and coastal California; two represent the desert area; and there is one public member.
Periodically, we will introduce you to several of your representatives so that you can learn more about these hardworking Board members who volunteer significant portions of their time for the betterment of the citrus community. In
this issue, youll meet three of the most recent appointees.
Greg Galloway has served on the
Board since 2014 and represents
District One. During the past year,
he has served on a number of
committees Communications,
Production Efficiency, Research
Development and Implementation,
Pest Management and NonVectored Disease and Post-Harvest.
My experience on the Board so
far has been interesting, amusing,
confusing and at times overwhelming, Galloway said. I have come
to realize how little I know and how truly open I am to new ideas
and concepts. Our industry has many exceptionally bright people
working on a tremendous number of research projects. These
scientists are compassionate about their work, while patient with
those of less intelligence. I feel blessed to be allowed into their sand
box.
Our industry is being bombarded with many challenges, he
continued. Trade partners are placing quality demands that require
significant production and processing adjustments. Neighboring
growing regions are experiencing the wrath of a crippling, perhaps
apocalyptic disease. We are on high alert regarding the invasive
nature of this disease and have spread a very wide research net.
22
Leffingwell_Ad.pdf
I think the greatest issue for all of us in the citrus industry is the
threat of HLB, Perricone said. Its not going to be an easy fight,
but I think we will be able to beat this thing out if we all work
together.
The San Juan Capistrano native who now lives in Temecula is a
relative newcomer to the California citrus industry. For the past
several years, he has served as the operations manager for Pauma
Ranches in Pauma Valley, responsible for citrus and avocado
acreage and staff.
Perricone and his wife have one son. When not working or fulfilling
his CRB Board duties, the D.A.R.E. America volunteer enjoys the
fast sport of roller hockey and spending time with his family.
The newest over-all Board
member, representing District
One and elected in 2015, is Keith
Watkins. As Vice President of
Farming and Field Operations
for Bee Sweet Citrus in Fowler,
he is charged with overseeing
approximately 10,000 acres
and is responsible for land
acquisition, investor relations
and financial oversight. His son,
Matthew, works with him on Bee
Sweets farming operations, which has allowed Watkins the time
to serve as a vice president of the Cawelo Water District and a past
president of the Tulare County Farm Bureau, as well as volunteer
on the CRB Board.
In this latter capacity, the Visalia native is a member of the
Pest Control Committee, which dovetails with his interest in
addressing the current major threats facing the industry. HLB
and ACP are dark clouds hanging over us, Watkins said. I want
to help concentrate the CRB in a direction that will focus all of
the research currently being conducted to come up with answers
to those two problems. We need to ensure that the scientists are
talking to each other and building on each others work.
A veteran of more than two decades in the California citrus
industry and an alumnus of the California Agricultural Leadership
Foundation, Watkins stated, We should be focusing on the CRBs
financial responsibility by utilizing the growers money to invest in
areas that will provide good returns to the growers.
When not at work or volunteering in his industry and community,
the married father of three enjoys traveling and family time.
Ivy Leventhal is the managing editor of Citrograph.
6/7/13
2:50 PM
TREES NOT
PERFORMING LIKE
THEY SHOULD?
Small Size?
Low Yield?
Poor Packouts?
Proprietary Foliar Sprays
Custom Blended Fertilizer
All Lines of Crop Protection
Organic Products
PhD Citrus Agronomist on Staff
FINGWELL
F
E
L
SALES CO. INC
AG
Providing Quality
Service to Growers
Since 1920
Ivanhoe - Lindsay - Terra Bella
559.562.4946
www.leffingwellag.com
www.CitrusResearch.org | Citrograph Magazine
23
HLB DETECTIONS
IN SAN GABRIEL
Where are we now?
24
25
HLB quarantine map in Southern California, including the single 2012 Hacienda Heights detection and the 10 San Gabriel finds in the summer of 2015.
26
With the strategy set by the citrus industry and immediate response by CDFA
survey and treatment crews, no other San Gabriel samples have been confirmed
for HLB at the time of this printing.
This is a wake-up call for all growers, particularly those in Southern California.
Growers should be participating in an area-wide management program to control
ACP populations in commercial groves. With HLB in California, ACP management
becomes even more crucial. Review the best management practices at www.
citrusinsider.org/resources, and employ them in your groves. Also, see the flyer
on page 28. The Citrus Pest and Disease Prevention Program (CPDPP) and CDFA
encourage growers to regularly survey their own groves for signs of ACP and HLB.
CPDPP will continue to trap for ACP in commercial groves throughout the state.
REDUCE YOUR
ENERGY COSTS
Operate your business with a
fixed energy cost from the solar
power produced on site. On
average, agribusinesses that
use solar can reduce energy
costs by 84 percent a year.
Villa Park Orchards Association 1.15MW DC
IN THE BACKYARD
Through CPDPPs support, CDFA survey and treatment crews will remain vigilant
in looking for HLB and treating for the Asian citrus psyllid in residential areas. CDFA
in partnership with the USDA, local agricultural commissioners and the citrus
industry continues to pursue a strategy of controlling the spread of Asian citrus
psyllids while the Citrus Research Board and other researchers work to find a cure
for the disease.
Visalia Citrus Packing Group 813.6 kW DC
BY THE NUMBERS
Total ACP samples collected from San Gabriel, including
expansion areas: 1,504
Total plant samples collected from San Gabriel, including
expansion areas: 6,735
LoBue Citrus 492.2 kW DC
References:
www.citrusinsider.org/resources
http://www.cdfa.ca.gov/phpps/acp
Victoria Hornbaker is with the Citrus Pest and Disease Prevention Program,
where she serves as citrus program manager. Lucita Kumagai is with the Plant
Pest Diagnostics Branch at the California Department of Food and Agriculture,
where she serves as senior plant pathologist.
Power Ahead
1-888-705-5055
www.ColdwellSolar.com
Established in 1986, CA Lic# 969149
Source: Coldwell Solar, Inc. solar power system partners
27
Asian citrus psyllids are brown, aphidlike insects that feed on the leaves
and stems of citrus trees.
We must all do our part to protect our trees, our industry, and our way of life.
28
CitrusInsider.org
29
Figure 1A
30
Figure 1B
Figure 1. HLB infection symptoms: (A) Leaf mottling symptom on a Hamlin
orange leaf indicative of carbohydrate disruption; (B) HLB-induced fruit drop
in eight-year old Hamlin orange trees on Swingle citrumelo rootstock trees in
October 2015.
31
Figure 2A
Figure 2B
Figure 2. A. Average propagules of Phytophthora nicotianae in rhizosphere soil samples collected in Florida groves between January 2008 and October 2015
(YTD). B. Average dry weight of fibrous roots in soil samples collected between January 2013 and October 2015 (YTD) (data courtesy of J. B. Taylor, Syngenta
Crop Protection).
32
Figure 3. Valencia orange trees on Carrizo citrange rootstock trees before (A) and after (B) 2.5 years of water acidification in a grove irrigated with water high
in bicarbonates. Note more fully expanded leaves and absence of dead twigs in top of the tree canopy after acidification.
References
Graham, J.H., Johnson, E.G., Gottwald, T.R., and Irey, M.S. 2013.
Presymptomatic fibrous root decline in citrus trees caused by
huanglongbing and potential interaction with Phytophthora
spp. Plant Dis. 97:1195-1199.
Johnson, E.G., Wu, J., Bright, D.B. and Graham, J.H. 2014.
Association of Candidatus Liberibacter asiaticus root
infection, but not plugging with root loss on huanglongbingaffected trees prior to appearance of foliar symptoms. Plant
Pathol. 63:290-298.
Glossary
Root exudation: Roots of higher plants release
organic compounds (sugars, amino acids, lipids,
vitamins, etc.) that may serve as chemical attractants
or repellents to a particular microbial community in
rhizosphere.
Propagule: Fungal spores or bacterial cells that
transmit a disease.
Rhizosphere: Zone (few mm in thickness)
surrounding the plant root system where plant,
microorganisms and soil come together influencing
root chemistry and biology.
Tree phenology: Plant life cycle events that are
influenced by seasonal variations in climate and
elevation.
33
Many research projects are in progress in Florida, California and elsewhere looking for
long-term solutions to huanglongbing (also known as citrus greening or HLB). In the
interim, area-wide, coordinated chemical control of the Asian citrus psyllid (ACP) is critical
to slowing the spread of HLB in California.
One danger of aggressive ACP chemical control, however, is that resistance can develop
in the psyllids to some of the more effective and persistent classes of chemistries such as
neonicotinoids and pyrethroids (Tiwari et al. 2011, 2012, 2013). We are reporting here on
baseline ACP resistance monitoring designed to determine the susceptibility of a California
ACP population with minimal past exposure to 12 pesticides that will be used for control in
future years.
34
Figure 2. Lindsay Robinson aspirates about 20 adult ACP into each vial just
before a baseline resistance micro-applicator test.
Figure 3. A small drop of liquid agar is poured on the bottom of a Petri dish
and allowed to solidify prior to placing part of a clean citrus leaf.
35
Figure 4. Three Petri dishes were set up per treatment; these are the acetone controls prior to introduction of about 20 micro-applicator-treated ACP from each
collection vial.
36
Figure 6. A 0.8 l droplet of pesticide in acetone is applied to each ACP adult with a micro-applicator while they are still knocked out with carbon dioxide. The
ACP adult is removed from the micro-applicator syringe tip with a small paint brush.
Figure 7. Dead ACP adults on the leaf in a Petri dish when the bioassay is evaluated 24 hours after micro-applicator treatment.
37
38
Acknowledgements
Table 1. Baseline susceptibility of Asian citrus psyllid adults to 12 insecticides listed by class of chemistry.
Table 1. Baseline susceptibility of Asian citrus psyllid adults to 12 insecticides listed by class of chemistry.
ACP Field
use rate
converted to
Ratio of
1,000*
LD95 to
field use
mg AI/litere
ratef
689.1
87.0
1,687.5
14.9
179.8
130.3
4.3 oz/a
30.2
126.3
7 fl oz/a
150.7
18.1
5.5 oz/a
51.5
18.7
5.75 fl oz/a
53.8
146.6
131.1
439.4
6 oz/a
56.2
43.8
4.25 fl oz/a
13.9
171.1
27 fl oz/a
165.6
41.4
4.5 fl oz/a
17.5
106.6
Typical
ACP field
use rate
Chisquare
statistic Slope SE
insect)
0.1716
6.0917 0.4096
32.2114 a 30.4832-33.9718
59.9828 a
0.4607
4.9094 0.3857
34.7369 a 32.2420-37.4984
75.1332 a
66.0530-88.8990
0.1973
4.2610 0.4286
10.3481 a 9.3399-11.5586
25.1703 a
20.8504-32.9151 6 pts/a
0.8716
5.0234 0.2744
15.0516 b 14.2124-15.9941
31.9907 a
28.8779-36.1855
251
0.7529
2.1990 0.2313
4.1845 a
3.3012-5.5469
23.4234 a
15.1553-44.1153 16 fl oz/a
302
0.4637
4.5397 0.4456
7.6217 b
6.8886-8.4483
17.5543 a
14.8621-22.1481
2-27-13; 3-13-13
394
0.2889
1.8723 0.2000
0.5044 a
0.3688-0.6429
3.8133 a
2.8392-5.7455
8-12-14; 8-28-14
609
0.2302
2.8376 0.2071
1.0716 b
0.9764-1.1777
4.0709 a
3.3606-5.2209
8-15-12; 9-26-12;
10-10-12
565
0.1067
2.5470 0.2165
0.6181 a
0.5449-0.7086
2.7342 b
2.0953-3.9257
245
0.7033
5.6308 0.6922
0.7270 a
0.6555-0.8053
1.4244 a
1.2169-1.8093
0.2905
4.6172 0.4255
0.4234 a
0.3899-0.4612
0.9616 a
0.8252-1.1880
0.6549
5.9113 0.6075
0.3382 a
0.3504-0.4145
0.7248 a
0.6403-0.8624
0.2212
4.1400 0.2826
3.1617 a
2.8722-3.4624
7.8919 a
6.9625-9.2009
0.8370
5.8523 0.6248
3.4192 a
3.1254-3.7240
6.5312 a
5.7362-7.8553
0.3959
2.8398 0.1763
15.1775
13.7792-16.6333
57.6000
49.4197-69.5275 14 fl oz/a
0.9544
3.5879 0.3157
0.8561 a
0.7556-0.9799
2.4603 a
1.9863-3.2843
0.2280
3.7880 0.2726
0.9720 a
0.9025-1.0504
2.6416 a
2.2712-3.2108
0.1377
2.7986 0.2262
0.6157 a
0.5352-0.7049
2.3830 a
1.9248-3.1477
0.7538
4.1526 0.6214
1.4750 b
1.2979-1.7861
3.6720 a
2.7200-6.2713
0.1102
4.0289 0.3676
2.6759 a
2.3916-2.9824
6.8508 a
5.7954-8.5838
0.1640
5.4498 0.4475
2.5559 a
2.3747-2.7364
5.1211 a
4.6137-5.8671
0.2577
2.3040 0.2815
0.3602 a
0.2857-0.4282
1.8642 a
0.1303-2.7977
0.2684
2.8436 0.3081
0.3294 a
0.2808-0.3781
1.2478 a
0.9919-1.7434
IRAC
a
Pesticide
common
name
Pesticide
trade
name
(company)
Class
Class 1A (carbamates)
Carzol 92 SP
chlorpyrifos, Round 2
Class 3A (pyrethroids)
Danitol 2.4 EC
fenpropathrin
(Valent)
fenpropathrin, Round 2
zeta-cypermethrin Mustang 1.4 EC
(FMC)
zeta-cypermethrin, Round 2
Class 4A (Neonicotinoids)
imidacloprid
(Bayer)
imidacloprid, Round 2
10-24-12; 1-9-13
8-7-13
7-17-13
LD50
(ng AI/
c
LD95
(ng AI/
95% Ci
insect)
95% Ci
Insecticide Resistance Action Committee class (www.irac-online.org); pesticides in the same class have similar modes of action and thus, cross resistance within the class is likely.
N = total number of insects tested at various bioassay rates, excluding control insects.
LD50 or LD90 values for a particular pesticide followed by the same letter are not signficantly different in Round 1 vs. Round 2 tests based on overlap of 95% CI values.
To convert the listed Typical ACP field use rate to mg AI/liter, we assumed field use of 200 GPA spray volume.
Data in this column are the ratio of 1,000 * LD95 in ng AI applied to each insect (in the 0.8 l droplet) to the field pesticide use rate in units of mg AI per liter assuming application at 200 GPA.
Technical material received late so no Round 1 test was done with Sivanto; field use rate ratio is based on the Round 2 LC95.
Literature
Tiwari, S., R.S. Mann, M.E. Rogers and L.L. Stelinski. 2011.
Insecticide resistance in field populations of Asian citrus
psyllid in Florida. Pest Management Science 67: 1258-1268.
Tiwari, S., L.L. Stelinski and M.E. Rogers. 2012. Biochemical
basis of organophosphate and carbamate resistance in Asian
citrus psyllid. Journal of Economic Entomology 105(2): 540-548.
Tiwari, S., N. Killiny and L.L. Stelinski. 2013. Dynamic insecticide
susceptibility changes in Florida populations of Diaphorina
citri (Hemiptera: Psyllidae). Journal of Economic Entomology
106(1): 393-399.
www.CitrusResearch.org | Citrograph Magazine
39
An experiment with 18 RITA bioreactors to propagate mature Valencia and Carrizo plants.
MATURE CITRUS
PROPAGATION IN RITA
BIOREACTORS
SUMMARY
This project seeks to find a way to propagate mature citrus rapidly, as an alternative
to budding or tissue culture on solid media, while maintaining maturity traits for early
flowering and fruit production. We are utilizing RITA (Rcipient Immersion Temporaire
Automatique) bioreactors to propagate mature citrus, and altering the composition of
the nutrient media and plant growth regulators to generate shoots and roots. Afterwards
the propagated plants will be analyzed at the molecular level and with biotechnological
instrumentation to ensure the maintenance of maturity and genetic integrity.
40
Figure 2. The initial steps of mature citrus propagation in bioreactors. A) Budstick was surface-sterilized, cut into pieces and plated onto solid media in Petri
dishes. B) Valencia shoots initiated from stem cuttings.
41
Figure 3. Mature citrus shoot growth after excision from stem cuttings. A) Failure of shoot growth in solid medium after excision from the stem cuttings.
Activated charcoal is added to the medium to absorb inhibitory compounds. B) Excised shoots thrive on a carrot nurse tissue culture.
The bioreactor is similar to a hydroponics system in that both use liquid media. However, unlike hydroponics, the bioreactor is
sterile; the plant material has been surface-sterilized; and entire plantlets, embryos or plant tissues are temporarily immersed
in the liquid culture medium for short time periods every few hours. RITA has been shown to reduce the time for propagation,
reduce expenses and improve the quality of the propagules. It was used to propagate cedar, and yields were increased four- to
six-fold in half the time compared to plant propagation in tissue culture on solid media. In addition, plants produced with the
RITA system were hardier and better acclimated.
To be commercially viable, mass propagation of citrus should ensure the genetic fidelity of the mature donor plant. We are
testing and optimizing certain parameters, such as types and sizes of citrus cuttings, the nutrient and growth regulator
composition of the liquid media and the duration and frequency of plant immersion in liquid media.
Figure 4. Bioreactor-grown Carrizo shoots. A) Carrizo shoots in the bioreactor. B) Primary Carrizo shoots with developing axillary shoots.
Our protocol consists of surface sterilization of mature stems (or budsticks), aseptic cutting of the stems into pieces and plating
them on solid nutrient media composed of different plant growth regulators conducive to shoot production (Figures 2A and
2B). It is relatively easy to generate shoots of mature citrus directly from the stem cuttings, but it is difficult to grow after excision
from the stem cutting. Mature shoots appear to produce a high level of ethylene, a gaseous plant growth regulator involved in
plant senescence and fruit ripening, which might cause shoot death. Activated charcoal is used in tissue culture in an attempt
to absorb inhibitory compounds (Figure 3A). Therefore, mature citrus tissue culture is not conducive to plant production in
vitro, because the excised shoots fail to grow and root in culture. In our standard protocol, shoots must be micro-grafted onto
citrus rootstock to survive, which is not always successful. To understand why the shoots die when excised from stem cuttings,
we micro-grafted them onto carrot nurse tissue where they appear more green and vigorous (Figure 3B). Therefore, it appears
that the citrus shoots feed directly from the primary stem cutting and not from the culture medium, or perhaps some growth
regulators are produced in the primary stem cuttings necessary for shoot survival. This research will improve the composition
of the basal culture medium for mature citrus propagation.
Our preliminary results in bioreactors suggest that shoot size and quality are increased compared to growth on solid medium
(Figure 4A and 4B). Currently, we are testing different basal media and growth regulators to optimize shoot growth and
multiplication from axillary buds. The data collected from these experiments will be the percentage of cuttings with shoots, the
42
43
Figure 5. Rooting mature scion and rootstock. Rooted Valencia (left) and Carrizo (right) after the
application of growth regulators in the medium.
Yosvanis Acanda of Vigo, Spain, is a Ph.D. candidate and a senior biologist at the University of Florida, Institute of Food and
Agricultural Sciences (IFAS), Citrus Research and Education Center (CREC). Janice Zale Ph.D. is the Mature Citrus Facility
Coordinator at the University of Florida, IFAS, CREC.
www.citrusboys.com
44
45
Figure 1. This project is centered on coupling genetics to proteomics to reveal how the HLB biological players interact at the molecular level during Candidatus
Liberibacter asiaticus (CLas) transmission by the Asian citrus psyllid (ACP), Diaphorina citri. The ACP is the CLas vector, and it harbors other bacteria, called
symbionts, that are beneficial to it. The two primary ACP symbionts include Candidatus Carsonella rudii DC, a putative nutritional symbiont, and Candidatus
Profftella armature, a putative defensive symbiont. Profftella is an ACP-specific symbiont and not found in any other insect species studied to date. This
feature makes the interaction between the ACP and Profftella a prime target for ACP control, because the risks for harm to beneficial insects would be minimal
or none.
Our preliminary data show that Profftella cells inside the ACP respond to CLas acquisition by the insect vector. CLas infects citrus trees, and the ACP vector
carries the bacterium from tree to tree. CLas harbors a virus called phage, and the roles of the phage in transmission are unknown. The host plants also have an
effect on transmission in ways that are just beginning to be understood.
46
PROJECT SUMMARY
The Asian citrus psyllid (ACP), Diaphorina citri Kuwayama, is an economically important pest of citrus and
a vector of Candidatus Liberibacter asiaticus (CLas).1 CLas is a phloem-limited, gram-negative, fastidious
bacterium that is implicated in causing the most serious disease of citrus, huanglongbing (also known as HLB
or citrus greening disease). ACP and HLB have spread to most citrus growing regions worldwide. The disease
threatens the future of Floridas annual $9 billion industry1.
The need for novel and effective HLB management strategies is urgent, as the HLB-associated Liberibacter and
vector are spreading beyond Florida. The urgent need for control strategies was affirmed in July 2015 with the
discovery of 10 infected trees in San Gabriel, California, marking the first confirmed report of HLB in the state
since a single infected tree was discovered in Hacienda Heights in 2012. HLB management options currently
are limited to ineffective strategies to control ACP vectors and early disease detection, and the disease is a
death sentence for an infected citrus tree. Control of CLas transmission by the ACP represents a promising new
control strategy.
Our new project is focused on comparing populations of the ACP that vary in their ability to transmit CLas. This
will enable us to understand the molecular interactions that occur during CLas transmission. These interactions
are challenging to study because there are many organisms interacting with one another (Figure 1).
In this article, we briefly describe each of the biological players and our overall experimental approach. Finally,
we explain how our results may be used to help the growers in California and elsewhere to better manage the
disease. Our team is well poised to achieve our objectives and to translate knowledge into novel management
strategies for the citrus industry. Our preliminary data already have led to the identification of potential targets
for ACP control using para-transgenic and ribonucleic acid (RNA) interference technologies being developed in
other laboratories.
47
Bacteriophage. At least some isolates of CLas harbor bacteriainfecting viruses called bacteriophages. Although they are
presumed to remain inactive in the ACP, bacteriophage may
increase the virulence of CLas or may even be used as a suicide
switch to kill CLas.
Host plants of the ACP and CLas. The host plants are also
other players. Some plants in the Rutaceae are hosts of both
CLas and the ACP, while others are hosts for the ACP only.
In HLB-susceptible citrus varieties, the ACP can efficiently
acquire CLas. In infected Murraya spp., a citrus relative, CLas
titers are much lower than in citrus; and the ACP acquires four
orders of magnitude less CLas from infected Murraya than
from CLas-infected citrus.9 Understanding how each of the
players interacts with the others is a critical part of learning
how to efficiently manage the disease and to prevent CLas
transmission. The molecular approach our team is utilizing
will enable us to understand novel ways to prevent CLas from
using the ACP to go commit its next crime.
EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH
CM
MY
CY
CMY
48
Figure 2. Excised leaf assay for CLas transmission studies. (A) Polypropylene tube for caging psyllids with excised citrus leaf (el). The petiole is inserted into a
microcentrifuge tube (mt) full of water, with Parafilm wrapped around the top of this tube. The caging tube is covered with a piece of fine-mesh screen cloth
under the screw cap, with the flip-top part of the cap removed for ventilation. (B) Caging tubes in a tube-rack (from Ammar et al. 2013).
49
Acknowledgements
References
50
51
COMPLEX CITRUS
LURES TO TRAP AND
CONTROL ACP
SUMMARY
Monitoring of Asian citrus psyllid (ACP), Diaphorina citri, remains critical in California, given
that there is still an effort to quarantine ACP or at least keep it at minimal population
densities. Currently, unbaited yellow sticky traps are the main method for monitoring
psyllid populations, and they are used widely in California. However, the tactic is not
satisfactory without long-range attractants. Although some volatile attractants for ACP
have been developed that do improve effectiveness of monitoring traps, progress has been
slow in implementing such technologies practically. We have worked toward developing
a more potent synthetic lure to improve monitoring and the possibility for effective new
management tactics, such as attract-and-kill devices or disruption of host finding.
52
53
54
References
55
56
Figure 1. Schematic diagram of the landing pad within the Founder Line genome. The attP recognition site is a unique DNA sequence that the recombinase
enzyme Bxb1 uses for DNA integration. The Res recognition site is a unique DNA sequence that the recombinase enzyme CinH uses for DNA excision. Acting
together, these two enzymes can swap out the original DNA between these recognition sites and replace it with new beneficial DNA. The DSRed visual marker
allows one to see the transgenics, while the codA and nptII genes allow for chemical selection of tissue containing the newly inserted DNA.
57
Figure 4. Transgenic citrus lines being produced from mature tissue from Limoneira 8A and Tango cultivars. Green shoots demonstrate tissue competent for
transformation and transgenic production. When the shoots have grown bigger, they will be grafted to rootstock and transferred to the greenhouse for
further molecular evaluation.
58
Glossary
Transgene: Any gene brought into the genome by
means other than traditional breeding.
Recombinase: Enzymes that are capable of cutting
and pasting DNA without the gain or loss of genetic
material. Further, these enzymes recognize and
only manipulate very specific short DNA sequences
(recognition sites), which can be added to larger
DNA molecules (genome) for the cutting and pasting
process.
559-592-2304
Stronger Roots
make Super
Citrus Trees
SUPERCITRUS TREES
Container grown in
insect resistant structures
Unique pot design grows
massive root system
Delivered in special sock
for easy handling
All faciities
certified
by USDA
NOW
NOW TAKING
TAKING ORDERS
ORDERS FOR
FOR 2017
2017
www.citrustreesource.com
59
Figure 1. Young graft-inoculated navel orange trees were used to detect CLas over time. Midrib tissue from young and mature leaves and feeder root tissue
were sampled for DNA to detect CLas and monitor its spatial and temporal distribution using real-time qPCR on a monthly basis. For proteomic analysis, phloem
proteins were extracted from stem tissue to monitor changes in host proteins in response to HLB infection.
CITRUS DISEASE
RESPONSE TO HLB
INFECTION
SUMMARY
The second year of this Citrus Research Board-funded research project focused on studying the in planta
distribution of Candidatus Liberibacter asiaticus (CLas), the huanglongbing (HLB)-associated bacterium, and
citrus responses to HLB infection. Using graft-inoculated navel trees, we found CLas to be in greater titer and
more evenly distributed in feeder roots than in young and mature leaves over time using quantitative real-time
polymerase chain reaction (qPCR). Through mass spectrometry, we also identified citrus proteins that were
differentially expressed during infection. These proteins have the potential to serve as markers for HLB, as well
as targets that can be manipulated for disease control. By understanding how CLas manipulates its host, better
management strategies can be implemented.
60
5
4
3
Feeder
Root
Young
Leaves
Mature Leaves
1
0
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Months
post
gra7
inocula;on
RESULTS
INTRODUCTION
61
Figure 3. Protein extraction from stem tissue in navel orange. Bark containing phloem tissue was peeled off from the stems, excised into small strips, placed into
a small tube and centrifuged to extract the sap. Sap proteins were analyzed and compared to the control plant.
30
28
26
Selected Literature:
24
22
20
Figure 4. Expression of various proteases in phloem sap of navel orange graft-inoculated with CLas.
Citrus defense genes (e.g., subtilisin protease, cysteine proteinases 1 and 2, aspartate proteases 1 and
2) were expressed significantly higher in HLB-infected plants than those in the non-inoculated control
plants. The Y-axis shows the relative expression of different host genes . Asterisks indicate significant
differences between infected and non-infected trees.
62
Early
Vegetative
YaraMila
15 - 15 - 15
Growth/
Flush
20% of
total N
CN-9 / Tropicote
20% of
total K2O
Fruit
fill
Post
harvest
30% of
total N /
15% of
total K2O
YaraVita
Fruit
set
20% of
total N /
10% of
total K2O
YaraLiva
Flowering
30% of
total N
30% of
total K2O
25% of
total K2O
63
DEVELOPMENT OF
LOW-SEEDED CITRUS BY
MUTATION BREEDING
64
65
Figure 2. UCR 10K, 13D and 13E trial sites showing adjacent citrus blocks that might serve as pollen sources. 13D and 13E have many fertile citrus varieties.
Image: Google Earth, March 9, 2011.
STATUS REPORT
66
Figure 3. Porterville rootstock trial site showing adjacent plantings that can serve as pollen sources. Image: Google Earth, June 15, 2011.
TRIAL SITES
67
DATA COLLECTION
METHODS
Figure 4. Number of Tango fruit with various seed counts in 4,224 fruit from fruit quality samples and
19,941 fruit cut in the field. Data collected from 1998 to 2015.
RESULTS
Figure 5. Seed content of Tango fruit in five trials at UCR measured from field-cut fruit between 2004
and 2015. Year effect (*) indicates statistically significant differences between years in the percentage
of fruit from the same field having zero or one seed per fruit compared to fruit having more than one
seed. For UCR 10K, the test included fruit with zero compared to one or more seeds, because the number
of fruit with more than one seed was very low. The significance test is indicated above the most recent
year sampled. The average number of fruit in each sample was 1,078, and the range was 130 to 2,590.
Mother signifies the original Tango from which budwood was collected that eventually was released.
The symbol ns denotes not significantly different.
68
Figure 6. Seed content of Tango fruit in six trials measured from field-cut fruit between 2007 and 2012.
Year effect (*) indicates statistically significant differences between 2012 and 2013 samples from the
Porterville trial in the percentage of fruit having zero or one seed per fruit compared to fruit having
more than one seed. The average number of fruit in each sample was 693, and the range was 142 to
1,432.
69
CONCLUSIONS
Tango trees nearly always produce fruit with fewer than two
seeds, with the majority of fruit being seedless over a wide
range of sites and years. Sites with high pollen pressure, such
as those adjacent to large plantings of varieties that produce
copious amounts of viable pollen (pummelos, Minneola and
Clementines are examples) are likely to produce fruit with
higher seed counts, with averages of about one seed per
fruit in the worst years. (We have not determined whether
or not the proximity to lemons affect seed content of Tango.)
In such situations, young trees are more likely to have higher
seed counts because bees are more likely to bring pollen
from outside the block when trees are small and have fewer
flowers. On the other hand, solid block plantings (similar to
most commercial plantings) and those isolated from strong
pollen sources may have very low seed counts with 95 percent
or more of fruit being seedless.
Acknowledgements
www.Youngs-Nursery.com
70
71
NOVEL THERAPY
OF HIGH-PRIORITY
CITRUS DISEASES
SUMMARY
Huanglongbing (HLB), citrus canker and citrus variegated chlorosis (CVC) are three high-priority citrus diseases,
all caused by a single category (Gram-negative) of bacteria. Any approach that could kill the causative bacteria
when they first infect the tree would be very useful, and the same approach may be able to prevent all three
diseases.
In this project, we lay the foundation of one such approach. We show that the design and delivery of a protein
chimera clears both HLB-associated Candidatus Liberibacter asiaticus (CLas) and canker-causing Xanthomonas
citri subsp. citri (Xcc) and blocks disease symptom development. This chimera has two functional domains
derived from citrus. One domain (called the recognition domain) targets the specific membrane features
conserved in these three bacteria, whereas the other domain (called the lysis domain) creates membrane pores
72
INTRODUCTION
PROGRESS TO DATE
73
Figure 2. Transgenic citrus (Carrizo) expressing the Thionin1-D4E1 chimera shows protection against both citrus canker and HLB (Collaborator: Ed Stover, USDAARS, Ft. Pierce, Florida). Transgenic citrus expressing the Thionin1-D4E1 chimera is protected after Xcc challenge (A, left panel), whereas nontransgenic citrus
is not (A, right panel). Transgenic citrus shows protection against HLB, (B, left panel) whereas nontransgenic citrus does not (B, right panel). All the citrus trees
were grafted with Liberibacter-infected rough lemon.
74
hypothesis that the same chimeric proteins can protect citrus plants
against multiple bacterial diseases. Testing of transgenic plants
expressing LBP-Thionin2 chimeric protein for disease resistance is
currently underway in greenhouse.
The second goal of our project was to design nanocapsules
(Figure 310,11) containing the AMPs listed above and deliver them into
citrus plants to combat HLB infection.
We have determined that in planta delivery of nanocapsules will
require a large-scale amount of CTV capsid protein, which we will
obtain by isolating and purifying the protein from the CTV virions.
CONCLUSION
References
Figure 3. Design of two types of lipid-based nanocapsules carrying a small molecule or protein therapeutic agent. A lipid-based inner shell (hydrophobic
interior) contains inhibitory therapeutic agents (A, left panel). An outer shell of Citrus tristeza virus (CTV) capsid protein is used to specifically deliver the
therapeutic agents into the citrus phloem tissue (A, right panel). Inner shell with liposome (hydrophilic interior) contains inhibitory therapeutic agents (B, left
panel). An outer shell of CTV capsid protein is used to specifically deliver the inhibitory therapeutic agents into the citrus phloem tissue (B, right panel).
Glossary
Gram-negative bacteria: Bacteria are divided into
two distinct groups of Gram-negative and Grampositive based on their cell wall architecture. Gramnegative bacteria have an outer membrane with
thinner cell walls and do not retain the crystal violet
stain as opposed to Gram-positive bacteria.
Protein chimera: Chimeric or fusion proteins are
engineered through the joining of two or more
specific genes. The latter are eventually translated
into corresponding proteins, each having a different
functional property or domain to serve a particular
purpose.
In planta: Inside plant cell or tissue
9. Xu, Q. et al. 2013. The draft genome of sweet orange (Citrus sinensis).
Nature Genetics 45(1):59-66.
11. Huynh, N.T., Passirani, C., Saulnie, P. and Benoit, J.P. 2009. Lipid
nanocapsules: A new platform for nanomedicine. International
Journal of Pharmaceutics 379:201209.
75
SUMMARY
As California prepares for a potential showdown with huanglongbing (HLB), contemporary strategies that
use low inputs, yet produce high-value control, are needed to manage the disease. With biotechnology, we
can develop Citrus tristeza virus (CTV) into a tool for the protection or treatment of citrus trees. Specifically,
our goal is to engineer an infectious complementary (c)DNA clone of a mild California strain of CTV that
can be developed for the control of HLB (and other disease-causing agents of citrus). Here, we performed
a systematic analysis of the nucleotide variability located at the genome ends of California CTV strains with
76
OBJECTIVES
77
VARIABILITY IN
GENOME ENDS OF
CTV POPULATIONS
Figure 2. Nucleotide (nt) variations at 5 end of cDNA clones of CTV strain T30-CA. Only nt variants at
frequencies greater than 20 percent among all the clones sequenced are shown. Numbers at the top of
each bar represent the number of clones with nt sequence shown at the base of that bar over the total
number of clones sequenced. Consensus (conserved) or common nucleotides (nts) are shown in black
letters, variant nts are in red.
VARIABILITY AT
GENOME ENDS OF
T30-CA
3. Nucleotide variations at 3 end of cDNA clones of CTV strain T30-CA. Only nt variants at
The consensus (conserved) RNA Figure
frequencies greater than 10 percent among all the clones sequenced are shown. Numbers at the top of
sequence at the 5 end of selected each bar represent the number of clones with the nt sequence shown at the base of that bar over the
T30 sequences retrieved from the total number of clones sequenced. Consensus (conserved) or common nts are shown in black letters;
variant nts are in red.
NCBI GenBank database is AAUUUC.
Sequencing of the (+)-strand DNA and
the (-)-strand DNA revealed that the consensus AATTTC (in many other nt variants (data not shown) but the ones shown
DNA, Uracil is replaced by Thymine) sequence was present in in Figure 2 were the most common.
many of the clones sequenced (Figure 2). In several cloned
sequences, one or more extra (variant) nts were observed The 3 end of the T30-CA strain genome contained fewer nt
upstream of this consensus sequence (Figure 2). There were variants than its 5 end. Data obtained from the sequencing
of the (+)-strand DNA and the (-)-strand DNA revealed that
78
Figure 4. Nucleotide variations at 5 end of cDNA clones of CTV strain T36-CA. Only nt variants at frequencies greater than 10 percent among all the clones
sequenced are shown. Numbers at the top of each bar represent the number of clones with the nt sequence shown at the base of that bar over the total
number of clones sequenced. Consensus (conserved) or common nts are shown in black letters; variant nts are in red. Nucleotide sequences that are similar to
the Group 1 consensus sequence, AATTTCTCAAA, and the Group 2 consensus sequence, AATTTCACAAA, are indicated.
79
Figure 5. Nucleotide variations at 3 end of cDNA clones of CTV strain T36-CA. Numbers at the top of each bar represent the number of clones with the nt
sequence shown at the base of that bar over the total number of clones sequenced. Consensus (conserved) nts are written in black letters; variant nts are in red.
Acknowledgements
We thank the Citrus Research Board for funding this research.
James Ng, Ph.D., associate professor of Plant Pathology,
and Angel Chen, Ph.D., assistant specialist, are from the
Department of Plant Pathology and Microbiology at the
University of California, Riverside. Raymond Yokomi,
Ph.D., is a plant pathologist at USDA-Agricultural Research
Service, Parlier, California.
80
References
1. Lee, R.F. and Bar-Joseph, M. 2003. Graft-transmissible
diseases of citrus. p. 607-639. In: G. Loebenstein and G.
Thottappilly (eds.), Virus and Virus-like Diseases of Major Crops
in Developing Countries. Kluwer Academic Publishers, the
Netherlands.
2. Ng, J.C.K. and Zhou, J.S. 2015. Insect vector-plant virus
interactions associated with non-circulative, semi-persistent
transmission: current perspectives and future challenges.
Current Opinion in Virology 15:48-55.
3. Ambrs, S., El-Mohtar, C., Ruiz-Ruiz, S., Pea, L., Guerri, J.,
Dawson, W.O. and Moreno, P. 2011. Agroinoculation of Citrus
tristeza virus causes systemic infection and symptoms in the
presumed nonhost Nicotiana benthamiana. Molecular PlantMicrobe Interactions 24:1119-1131.
4. Tatineni, S., Gowda, S., Boyko, V.P., Albiach-Marti, M.R.,
Mawassi, M., Navas-Castillo, J., Karasev, A.V., Dolja, V., Hilf, M.E.,
Lewandowski, D.J., Moreno, P., Bar-Joseph, M., Garnsey, S.M.
and W.O. Dawson. 1999. An engineered closterovirus RNA
replicon and analysis of heterologous terminal sequences for
replication. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
USA 96:7433-7438.
Glossary
Infectious complementary (c)DNA clone Many
plant viruses, including CTV, use RNA (as opposed
to DNA) as their genetic material. This RNA can be
converted into DNA, which is complementary to
the RNA (hence the name complementary DNA),
and inserted (cloned) into a piece of autonomously
replicating DNA (called a cloning plasmid) that
exists outside a bacteriums DNA chromosome to
produce many copies of the inserted cDNA. When it
is introduced into a suitable plant, this cloned cDNA
is deemed infectious when it replicates and moves
throughout the plant.
RNA silencing/interference This is an all-natural
gene-inactivation system that allows organisms,
including plants and animals, to regulate their biological
processes, such those involved in development and
in defense against viruses. With biotechnology, RNAi
can be used to inactivate the genes of virtually any
organism that has the RNAi mechanism.
www.CitrusResearch.org | Citrograph Magazine
81
DEVELOPMENT OF AN ACP
MANAGEMENT PLAN FOR
ORGANIC CITRUS
Jawwad A. Qureshi and Philip A. Stansly
SUMMARY
Control of the Asian citrus psyllid (ACP), which is the vector for the phloem-limited bacterium Candidatus
Liberibacter asiaticus (CLas) that is associated with huanglongbing (HLB or greening disease) in all habitats
including organic citrus is critical for area-wide management of this vector-disease complex and sustainable
citrus production. Organic citrus is produced in California, as well as in Florida and Texas.
We evaluated the impact of three separate organic programs organic insecticides applied alone (Program
1) or with horticultural mineral oil (Program 2) and insecticidal soap (Program 3) compared with one
conventional program on populations of ACP and beneficial insects in bearing citrus trees during dormant
and growing seasons in southwest Florida. During the dormant winter season, Pyganic alone or with 435 oil
or M-pede applied in November, December and January, and Danitol applied in November and January all
82
provided significant reduction in ACP through the first week of March. This was when ACP adult numbers
started to escalate with the organic programs while still held to the 0.1 per tap threshold in the conventional
program. Pyganic with M-pede performed better than with 435 oil and both performed better than Pyganic
alone. ACP reduction from Pyganic with M-pede was similar to Danitol through the first week of March after
which only the Danitol residual was effective. A total of six applications for the organic programs and five in
the conventional program were made during the growing season. Organic Programs 2 and 3 rotated organic
insecticides with 435 oil or M-pede resulting in a 50 percent reduction in the use of organic insecticides while
providing better control than Program 1 with organic insecticides only.
However, ACP was reduced more in the conventional program. Reduction to 0.1 adults per tap sample was
observed after the treatments of Closer and Aza-Direct plus M-pede in March, Micromite and Azera plus
M-pede in April, and Entrust plus 435 oil and Imidan in May. Lacewings, spiders, ants and ladybeetles were
observed in all treatments that also may have contributed to ACP reduction. Green lacewings were most
abundant. Ladybeetles known for significant predation on ACP were rare, reflecting the negative impact of
increased use of broad-spectrum insecticides to control ACP since the advent of HLB.
Tamarixia radiata was released in all programs, but more were recovered from ACP nymphs in the trees from
the organic program compared to the conventional program. Significant effects of organic insecticides with
435 oil or M-pede on ACP indicate potential use in all citrus, including where conventional products may
not be appropriate. In the coming cycle, we will be repeating and extending these studies to confirm results,
include additional products and evaluate on ACP, other pests and beneficial insects.
BACKGROUND
Photo 2: A female Tamarixia radiata laying egg on an ACP nymph. (Photo by J. Lotz).
83
Table 1. Insecticides, rates, manufacturer and timing of spray applications in organic and conventional programs made using final spray volume
of 100 gallons per acre.
84
as citrus leafminer (CLM) and aphids. Therefore, applying broadspectrum insecticides prior to flush reaps the maximum benefit
in suppressing adult ACP while conserving key beneficial insects.
Citrus trees go through periods of dormancy during cold or dry
weather, producing little or no new growth. Adult ACP living
on these trees need to wait for new growth to emerge and lay
eggs. Insecticidal sprays made during winter, before bud break,
in Florida are commonly known as dormant sprays. The aim is to
reduce psyllid entry into spring flush and, therefore, subsequent
reproduction during the growing season. Generally, broadspectrum pyrethroids and organophosphates are preferred in
winter followed by selective insecticide chemistries, microbials
and horticultural spray oil during the growing season. Such
programs to manage ACP in conventional citrus are now common
in Florida and are being adopted in California and Texas.
In this project, we are focused on developing holistic ACP
management programs for organic citrus, which is grown more in
California than any other state. Findings will be useful for organic
growers to manage ACP in their groves and contribute to its areawide management by reducing the spread to conventional citrus
and other habitats. Organic products also will be suitable for
conventional citrus growers as selective options to avoid excessive
use of non-selective insecticides, to limit pesticide resistance and
harm to beneficial insects. Conservation of naturally-occurring
populations of beneficial insects and augmentation of T. radiata
will be useful for ACP control across habitats. In contrast, synthetic
chemicals are expensive and not always welcomed in residential
areas that may be suitable for organic products.
RESEARCH OBJECTIVES
DESIGN, TREATMENTS
AND SAMPLING
PROCEDURES
Photo 3. Durand Wayland AF100-32 air blast speed sprayer (Photo by J. Qureshi).
85
Photo 4. Demonstration of the stem tap sampling method and resulting adult psyllids (Photo by P.
Stansly).
86
2.0
1.8
1.6
1.4
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
Untreated
Pyganic
5.0
EC
(17
oz/ac)
Pyganic
5.0
EC
(17
oz/ac)
+
435
oil
(2%)
Pyganic
5.0
EC
(17
oz/ac)
+
M-pede
(2%)
Danitol
2.4
EC
(16
oz/ac)
3/3/15
Sampling
date
Figure 1. Density estimates of ACP populations (mean SE) in organic and conventional control programs in a Valencia orange block. Pyganic alone and with M-pede
or 435 oil was applied on November 11, December 10, January 12, and Danitol on November 11 and January 12. Arrows indicate spray applications except with
asterisk when Danitol was not sprayed.
RESEARCH FINDINGS
87
1.2
Untreated
Organic
insec=cide
Organic
insec=cide
with
435
oil
Organic
insec=cide
with
M-pede
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
Lacewings
Spiders
Ants
Predatory
group
Lady beetles
Figure 2. Populations of different predatory groups of beneficial insects (mean SE) in the organic and conventional control programs in a Valencia orange block.
Aza-Direct alone and with 435 oil or M-pede and Closer alone
sprayed on March 10 provided a significant reduction in ACP
adults through March 24 averaging 75 percent, 71 percent,
92 percent and 97 percent, respectively. Only Aza-Direct
plus M-pede and Closer reduced adults to 0.1 per tap sample.
Application of Grandevo, 435 oil, M-pede and Movento all made
alone on April 1 provided 54 percent, 69 percent, 69 percent
and 82 percent reductions, respectively, but did not reduce
adults to the desired threshold. Follow-up applications of Azera
alone and with 435 oil or M-pede and Micromite alone made on
April 14 provided adult reductions of 41 percent, 69 percent, 82
percent and 83 percent, respectively, through May 5.
Only Azera plus M-pede and Micromite reduced adults to
0.1 per tap sample on May 5. Reductions of 45 percent, 77
percent, 68 percent and 99 percent were observed for about
two weeks with microbial insecticide Venerate, 435 oil,
M-pede and Imidan all applied alone on May 8, respectively;
but only Imidan held ACP at 0.1 per tap sample. Application
made on May 27 of Entrust alone and with 435 oil or M-pede
provided reductions of 53 percent, 84 percent and 72 percent,
respectively, for about three weeks. Although no application
was made in the conventional program on May 27, an
average reduction of 87 percent and 0.1 adults per tap sample
indicated a prolonged effect from Imidan applied on May 8.
Applications made in July are being evaluated.
Biological Control
Green lacewings were the most abundant predator in all
treatments (Photo 6). They attack ACP, CLM, aphids, thrips,
whiteflies and several other pests. Ladybeetles known for
significant predation on ACP were rare (Figure 2). Cycloneda
sanguinea (Photo 7) and Olla v-nigrum (Photo 8) were the
species most commonly observed. Ladybeetle numbers in
Florida have dropped significantly due to the increase in the
use of insecticidal sprays after the advent of HLB.
88
Acknowledgements
Photo 6. Green lacewing predator of ACP and other pests (Photo by the University of Florida)
Photo 8. Larva and adult of Olla v-nigrum feeding on ACP nymphs (Photo by P. Stansly)
89
90
sales@duartenursery.com
Available
Spring 2016
experienced horticulturists
Clonal
Containerized
Clean
CLEAN CITRUS
559.977.7282
Ed Needham
Available
Spring 2016
In vitro avocado
Clonal
Multiple Varieties on
Toro Canyon
Micropropagated
Toro Canyon Rootstock
AVOCADOS
Clonal Rootstock