United States Court of Appeals ura ciRcUTT OFFICE OF THE CLERK LYLE W. CAYCE TRL, 504-310-7700 CLERK (600 8, MARSTRI PLACE [NEW ORLEANS, LA’ 70130 May 3, 2010 Ashton R, O’Dwyer, Jr. 6034 St. Charles Avenue New Orleans, LA 70118 RE: _ Judicial Misconduct Complaint Nos. 05-09-90128 and 05-09-90129 Dear Mr. O'Dwyer: Further to your secent email inquiry, please be advised that the Appellate Review Panel of the Judicial Council of the Fifth Judicial Circuit consisted of the following judges who considered ‘your petition for review of Chief Judge Jones’ order dismissing your judicial misconduct ‘complaint against United States District Judges Stanwood R. Duval, Jr. and Ivan LR, Lemelle: Cireuit Judge P. Grady Jolly Chief District Judge Ricardo H. Hinojosa District Judge Eldon B. Fallon District Judge Dee D. Drell District Judge Neil Biggers Please be advised further that copies of your petition for review, the Chief Judge's dismissal order, and your complaints were mailed io the pane! members who voted unanimously to affirm the Chief Judge's order. The judges submitted their ballots by facsimile orby mail tothe tallying judge, Circuit Judge Jerry E. Smith. Very truly yours, LYLE W. CAYCE Clerk Deputy ClerkUnited States Court of Appeals vurra cincurt OFFICE OF THE CLERK LYLE W. CAYCE TD. 504-310-7700 ‘CLERK ‘6008. MAESTRI PLACE NEW ORLEANS, LA’ 70130 May 3, 2010 Ashton R, O'Dwyer, Jr 6034 St. Charles Avenue New Orleans, LA 70118 RE: Judicial Misconduct Complaint Nos. 05-09-90128 and 05-09-90129 Dear Mr, O'Dwyer: Enclosed is a copy of an order entered by the Judicial Council of the Fifth Circuit on your complaint against United States District Judges Stanwood R. Duval, Jr. and Ivan L.R. Lemelle. ‘The law provides for no further review of an unfavorable decision. Very truly yours, LYLE W. Clerk “AYCE, Depiity Clerk Enelosure ce w/encl: Hon. Edith 1. Jones Hon, Stanwood R. Duval Hon. Ivan LR. LemelleU.S. COURT OF APPEALS FILED BEFORE THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL OF THE. MAY 03 2010 FIETH CIRCUIT FIFTH CIRCUIT ~~ LYLE W. CAYCE, CLERK ‘Nos. 05-09-90128 and 05-09-90129 Petition for Review by Ashton R. O’Dwyer, Jt. of the Final Order Filed March 5, 2010, Dismissing Judicial Misconduct Complaint Against United States District Judges Stanwood R. Duval, Jr. and Ivan LR. Lemelle, Under the Judicial Improvements Act of 2002, ORDER An Appellate Review Panel of the Judicial Council of the Fifth Circuit has reviewed the above-captioned petition for review, and all the members of the Panel have voted to affirm the order of Chief Judge Jones, filed March 5, 2010, dismissing the Complaint of Ashton R. O”Dwyer, Jr., against United States District Judges Stanwood R. Duval, Ji, and Ivan LR. Lemelle, under the Judicial Improvements Act of 2002 ‘The Order is therefore AFFIRMED. H-'4 -10 Date Frith States Circuit Judge For Ue Judicial Council of the Fifth Circuit