A Thesis
Presented to
The Faculty of the Department of Physical Sciences
College of Science
Polytechnic University of the Philippines
Sta. Mesa, Manila
In Partial Fulfillment
Of the Requirements for the Degree
Bachelor of Science in Chemistry
By
March 2016
Acknowledgement
The researchers thank all who in one way or another contributed in the
completion of this thesis. First, we would like to give thanks to God for giving us
the knowledge, wisdom, protection and understanding throughout the study.
We also express our sincere gratitude to our advisor, Prof. Christian Jay B.
Cambiador for his continuous support of our research, for his patience, motivation,
enthusiasm and immense knowledge. His guidance helped us throughout our
research and writing of this thesis.
Moreover, we would like to thank the Oral Defense Panel, Prof. Jose Mari
M. Felicita, Prof. Melody Clerigo, Dr. Lorna T. Enerva, Mr. Mark Kristian Cabello,
Ms. Ann Selma Morata, Ms. Grace Ann Samson and Mr. Sherwin Escayo for their
constructive criticism and recommendations to improve our study.
The researchers also express their appreciation for the contribution of Julian
Victor Beldeniza, a Mechanical Engineering student, for the betterment of this
study.
To our beloved classmate and friends in the BS Chemistry family, we deeply
appreciate the stimulating discussions and the moral support that you shared to
us.
Most importantly, none of this could have happened without our family. We
would like to thank our parents who continuously offered their prayers and support
for us throughout the duration of our research. This research stands as a testament
to their unconditional love and encouragement.
iii
Abstract
Combustion flames contain strong emissions from excited radical species
produced by the combustion process. The monitoring and characterization of such
emissions is important for an in-depth understanding for the elemental analysis of
metal ions especially alkali, alkaline earth, and transition metals. This study
includes the fabrication of an improvised Flame Emission Spectrometer and testing
of the instruments system linearity. This paper also incorporates Digital ImageBased analysis of emitted radiation and reproducibility of the acquired results.
Methodology for this research is comprised of the design and assembly of the said
instrument, standard preparation to be used for the experimentation proper,
accuracy, precision, bias and recovery test of the instrument. The data from the
instrument were obtained using the Amadeus Spectrometer and its corresponding
Quantum Software. The data for the standards were then analyzed for its linearity
and regression, while the instrument was tested for its limit of detection and limit
of quantification. The said instrument was able to provide an accepted analysis for
the quantification of intensities of common metal ions while being much less
expensive, heavy, and bulky than comparable commercial instruments.
Keywords: emission spectroscopy, system linearity.
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
TITLE PAGE . i
APPROVAL SHEET ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT . iii
ABSTRACT iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS ...v
LIST OF FIGURES ix
LIST OF TABLES ..x
CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION .1
1.1. Statement of the Problem .2
1.2. Objectives of the Study .....2
1.3. Scope and Limitations 2
1.4. Significance of the Study .. 3
1.5. Outline ..... 4
1.6. Definition of Terms . 5
CHAPTER II BACKGROUND AND REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE .. 6
vi
vii
Recommendation ... 45
References .. 47
APPENDICES .... 51
Appendix A .. 52
Appendix B .. 64
Appendix C .. 81
Appendix D .. 84
Appendix E .. 86
Appendix F .. 88
viii
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1.
Figure 2.
Figure 3.
Figure 4.
Figure 5.
Figure 6.
Figure 7.
Figure 8.
Figure 9.
Figure 10.
Figure 11.
Figure 12.
ix
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1.
1.1
1.2
1.3
2 10 ppm Na+
Table 2.
K+ FES Analysis
2.1
2.2
20 100 ppm K+
2.3
2 10 ppm K+
Table 3.
3.1
3.2
3.3
Table 4.
Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION
One of the most common procedures used to characterize a sample is
through elemental analysis. It is useful in most areas of human endeavor and is
commonly applied to samples of importance in geology, toxicology, forensic
science, prospecting, health, nanotechnology, materials science, industrial
process control, semiconductor processing, automobile manufacturing, and
others. Because of its wide range of application and importance, a broad suite of
methods for elemental analysis has been devised. These methods range from
long-established procedures such as those based on precipitation and titration to
more modern ones that rely as much on physical principles as on chemistry
(Hieftie, 2000). A common of method of Atomic Emission Spectroscopy is the
Flame Emission Spectroscopy. In flame emission spectroscopy, the flame
provides a means of converting analytes in a solution to atoms in the vapor phase
freed of their chemical surroundings. These free atoms are then transformed into
excited electronic states by one of two methods: absorption of additional thermal
energy from the flame or absorption of radiant energy from an external source of
radiation. The energy from the flame also supplies the energy necessary to move
the electrons of the free atoms from the ground state to excited states. The
intensity of radiation emitted by these excited atoms returning to the ground state
provides the basis for analytical determinations in FES.
1.1
Methods that will be involved for the accuracy and precision of the said
instrument.
1.2
propane mixed fuel based flame emission spectrometer. Specific objectives of the
study involve the quantitative and qualitative analysis of selected Alkali and
Alkaline Earth Metals, specifically Na, K, Sr and Ba via FES and test for system
linearity of the said instrument using known standards.
1.3
instrument, test for system linearity using a known set of standards and for the
determination and analysis of the emission lines of selected Group 1A and 2A
metal ions such as Li, Na, K, Ca, Sr, and Ba. This research extend its analysis for
selected transition and post-transition metals with distinguishable spectral lines
such as Cr and Cu. The said instrument was limited in determining the emission
spectra of the mentioned metal ions. An optical fiber (detector) along with an
appropriate software (Ocean Optics Quantum software) was used to project the
2
1.4
alkaline earth metals without compromising the reliability and the validity of the
generated results. The instrument would also be notable for the inexpensiveness
and convenience of its fuel source since the employed propane-butane gas
mixture or LPG can be easily accessed in the market. Ultimately, the instrument
would be able to educate the universitys undergraduate students with the basic
principles of Flame Emission Spectrometry with minimal financial hindrance and
also provide them with one of the most established forms of instrumental analysis.
1.5
Outline
The outlines of this research were as follows: The following chapter contains
a brief review of the background study and related literatures applied in this study.
Theory involving the principles of atomic emission and absorption spectroscopy
were discussed, as well as various information from related studies of professional
researchers regarding this study. The next chapter describes the experimental
setup and the components used or suggested for the flame and the engine part
respectively. Preparation of standard solutions was also elaborated in this chapter.
Thereafter, implementation of the simulations was described, as well as the
methods for the experiments. The remaining chapters involved the tabulation and
discussion of result, conclusion, recommendation and listing of the acquired
references. Timeline review and budget proposed for this study was also
presented and discussed.
1.6
Definition of Terms
Background
This study focuses on one of the most widely used collection of physical-
such interferences are blank interference (i.e. Spectral Interference), and Analyte
interference (Physical and/or Chemical interference). Flame temperature is also
an important factor that determines the efficiency of atomization. The relative
number of excited and unexcited atoms also depends on flame temperature.
2.2
EMR with matter, the energy of a photon can be related to its wavelength and
frequency:
Where h is the Plancks constant which has a value of 6.626 x10-34 Js.
Spectroscopy can be generally defined as the interactions of matter and
radiation. These interactions can be used to quantitatively and qualitatively
understand the sample of interest. Spectroscopic analyses in analytical chemistry
dwell on the concept of electromagnetic radiation. It consists of measurements
based on electromagnetic radiation including light. Such techniques can be
classified based on what type of radiation is produced or used, according to the
electromagnetic spectrum (Skoog et. al, 2014). According to S. Thompson and J.
Staleys Foundations of Spectroscopy (n.d.), the two most commonly used
approaches in spectroscopic analyses are emission and absorption spectroscopy.
When matter is excited through the introduction of energy (e.g. thermal, radiant,
nuclear or electrical), it emits electromagnetic radiation as it reverts back to its
original state. The spectrum or range of the emitted radiation from an energized
substance is called an emission spectrum. According to Harvey (2000), the
intensity of the emission line is proportional to the number of atoms N* in the excited
state given by the equation:
Where gi and g0 are statistical factors that account for the number of
equivalent
energy levels for the excited state and ground state respectively, Ei is the energy
of the excited state relative to that of the ground state (E0 = 0), k is Boltzmanns
constant equal to1.3807 1023 J/K, and T is the temperature in Kelvin. From
here we can observe that excited states with lower energies have larger
populations, therefore giving the most intense emission lines.
10
11
progressed. This is what made AES a resilient technique that has undergone
several defining changes but still relies on its most fundamental principles.
2.2.3 Flame Emission Spectroscopy
The principle of Flame Emission can date back to 1556 where Georgius
Agricola wrote in his De Re Metallica about the color of fumes from various types
of ores (Schrenk, 1986). Although the very first observations of atomic emission
can date even back to the discovery of fire in the prehistoric era, Agricolas work
is one of the earliest known records that introduce the role of flame in substance
identification, especially in metals. And that this breakthrough marks the start of
the utilization of flame in chemical analysis especially in Atomic Spectroscopy.
Aside from Newtons study about the solar spectrum including nature of light and
its colors, another notable early account was in 1752 by Thomas Melville who
observed distinguishable color changes in a flame that was incorporated with sea
salt and other substances. Further accounts helped solidify the foundations of what
would now be known as Flame Emission Spectrometry (FES, a.k.a. flame
photometry). Additionally, further description of the spectral features of the solar
spectrum was conducted in 1802 by Wollaston, who distinguished dark lines in a
photographic image of the solar spectrum. These lines were studied in detail by
Fraunhofer in 1817 who labeled them with letters of the alphabet starting from the
red end of the spectrum (Skoog et. al, 2014). Also, it was W.H. Fox Talbot in 1834
that iterated the promising potential of flame emission spectrometry as an
analytical tool (Schrenck, 1986).
13
14
Figure 5. Notable milestones in the development of FES represented by the bar at the top. The
darker shades represent a higher level of activity in the particular period.
Further development in the late 1800s was very minimal. During this period
the flames used were generated only from either natural gas or alcohol lamps, and
utilizing air as an oxidant. The flames yielded by these sources were stable and
reproducible yet allowed only the analysis of easily excited elements due to its
relatively low temperature. It was until 1928 when Lundegrdh utilized an airacetylene burner which provided a considerably stable flame but with a higher
temperature than those generated by the previously used sources, and marked
the modern period for FES. He was able to produce sufficient data for twenty-four
elements namely Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs, Ca, Sr, Tl, Mn, Cu, Ag, Cr, Fe, Ni, Ba, Er, Mg,
Pb, Pd, Ra, Y, Au, Cd, and Nd. (Schrenk, 1986). This was due to the principle that
the intensity of the emission is directly proportional to the population of the atoms
in the excited state. Although the acetylene flame burner provided a hotter flame,
15
the butane flame gives off a better signal (Neel, Crespo, Perret, Cherubini, Bakker;
2014).
Figure 6. Temperature of flame generated from different sources in relation to number of excited
population
16
17
18
Spectral Lines of common Alkali and Alkaline Earth Metals (Na, Ca)
The sodium spectrum is dominated by a line of 589 nm wavelength, coming
from the transition from the 3p state to the 3s state.
Figure 9. Flame spectrum of sodium. Scale: wavelength in nm. (Data from: Sansonetti and Martin,
Handbook of Basic Atomic Spectroscopic Data)
If there are more than one electron in the outermost shell, there are many
more possibilities of electronic transitions and the spectra accordingly become
more involved.
Figure 10. Flame spectrum of Calcium. (Only the stronger lines are shown.) Scale: wavelength in nm.
19
the study confirm the model's discriminating power in isolating each analyte's
information from a single digital image, even with spectral interference.
This study will be able to provide an insight to the researchers on how to
employ an alternative method of detection for the emission spectra of metal ions
which offers a simple and economically viable alternative to the conventional FES.
21
Introduction
This chapter discusses the methodology that was used in this study. The
first section describes the modification and fabrication of the instrument, followed
by development of a method for analyzing metal ions. The third part describes the
preparation of the standard solutions that were subjected in the analysis.
Subsequent sections explicate the conducted experiments and analysis to
investigate the efficiency, accuracy, precision and system linearity of the fabricated
instrument.
This research was conducted based on the methodology. This methodology
plays an important role in implementing this research study accordingly. The
details of the methodology are explained in detailed in this chapter.
3.2
22
Figure 12. Schematic Diagram of the modified AAS for the fabrication of FES
24
Flame generation. The outlet of the nebulizer was guided to the air inlet of the
burner. The compressed air nebulizing the sample was adjusted to the highest
possible velocity before resulting in a dimming of the flame. The used air was from
an air compressor instrument.
Flame analysis. The analysis was carried out in a room with minimal light
interference to avoid stray light from reaching the detector. A fiber optic probe (1.8
meter, flame resistant) was directed 1 inch horizontally away to the widest part of
the flame transmitting the light to a USB powered spectrometer (Amadeus
Spectrometer, 350850 nm range, 3 nm resolution). The optical signal was sent
through a USB port to a Windows computer with the appropriate software (Ocean
Optics Quantum software) from where it can be projected live on screen. Emission
Spectra results will then be analyze for their peak intensities.
3.3
images, and was connected by a universal serial bus (USB) to an Intel I3 2.3GHz
Laptop computer (PC). The camera captures at a rate of 30 frames per s, with 5.0
Mega Pixels Dynamic Images. The atomizer/emitter module of a flame emission
spectrometer was coupled to the camera, and the combined system was used to
generate and record the image of the flame. The recorded images were then
transferred to the laptop computer for the image analysis. The treatment of the
captured digital images were done in the basis of RGB color system by means of
using an image analysis software: Microsoft Paint Tools, Color Picker.
25
3.4
from the Universitys Laboratory. For powdered standards, the researchers oven
dried the powdered reagents for about 120 degrees Celsius for 180 minutes to
eliminate moisture present in the powdered reagents before subjecting it in the
preparation of standard solutions.
For 1000 ppm Sodium Chloride stock solution.
2.542 g of sodium chloride was dissolved with enough de-ionized water and
then transferred into a 1000 ml volumetric flask and diluted to mark.
For 1000 ppm Potassium Chloride stock solution.
1.907 g of potassium chloride was dissolved with enough de-ionized water
and then transferred into a 1000 ml volumetric flask and diluted to mark.
For 1000 ppm Strontium Chloride stock solution.
1.405 g of strontium chloride was dissolved with enough de-ionized water
and then transferred into a 1000 ml volumetric flask and diluted to mark.
For 1000 ppm Barium Chloride stock solution.
1.7785 g of barium chloride was dissolved with enough de-ionized water
and then transferred into a 1000 ml volumetric flask and diluted to mark.
For 1000 ppm Copper Sulfate stock solution.
2.511 g of copper sulfate was dissolved with enough de-ionized water and
diluted to mark into a 1000 ml volumetric flask.
The standard solutions used in this research covers a set of range of
concentration from a relatively higher concentration (200 to 1000 ppm range) to a
26
27
28
3.6
29
Conceptual Framework
Start
Fabrication of the
Instrument
Method
Development of
the Instrument
Precision,
Accuracy,
Correction for Bias
and Recovery Test
Write Up
End
30
interference. The room is also provided with a fully functional fire extinguisher in
case fire hazard occurs. In case of emergency, notify all safety personnel and
remove all sources of heat and ignition immediately.
For the calibration curve of standards ranging from 100 to 1000 ppm NaCl,
the pressure flow of the air compressor is controlled and maintained at level 4
(regardless of the amount of pressure that the air compressor provide) and the fuel
output of the burner is regulated at level 2. The optical detector is clamped to an
iron stand and focused horizontally at least 1 inch away from the burner and
pointed slightly above the hottest region of the flame (middle part of the flame). In
addition, the data was obtained using Quantum Software through a point and click
scheme. Once a stable flame was obtained, the tip of the projected peak was
identified by the researchers and a screenshot was taken in order to corroborate
the findings acquired.
However, for the calibration curve of 20 to 100 ppm NaCl and the entire
calibration range of KCl standards, we adjusted the pressure flow of the air
compressor down to level 3. This is because of the instability of the flame at higher
pressures especially when analyzing standards of relatively low concentration.
Adjustment of pressure flow changes the intensity reading of the fiber optics, but
as long as the pressure level output for a given calibration range is consistent all
31
throughout the duration of the analysis, it will still yield an intensity that corresponds
to the given concentration.
4.2
FES Analysis
I. Na+ Analysis
a. 200 to 1000 ppm
Table 1.1 Respective intensities of various standard solutions for triplicate trials together with the
obtained R Squared Value, LoD, LoQ and Percentage Recovery.
61730 1467
800
50845 1549
600
40500 2053
400
30628 1330
200
20216 819.8
R-Squared Value:
0.9997
LoD (mg/L):
20
LoQ (mg/L):
61
% Recovery:
95.2 %
The results obtained from the average of triplicate trials for concentrations
200 to 1000 ppm exhibits a linear behavior with a regression coefficient of 0.9998
and a percentage recovery of 95.2%.
32
b. 20 to 100 ppm
Table 1.2 Respective intensities of various standard solutions for triplicate trials together with the
obtained R Squared Value, LoD, LoQ and Percentage Recovery.
Concentration (mg/L)
LoD (mg/L):
1.2
100
6835 20.00
LoQ (mg/L):
3.7
80
5680 0.5800
% Recovery:
102.2 %
60
4475 142.5
40
3285 70.44
20
2059 46.70
The results obtained from the average of triplicate trials for concentrations
20 to 100 ppm exhibits a linear behavior with a regression coefficient of 0.99995
and a percentage recovery of 102.2%.
c. 2 to 10 ppm
Table 1.3 Respective intensities of various standard solutions for triplicate trials together with the
obtained R Squared Value, LoD, LoQ and Percentage Recovery.
Concentration (mg/L)
10
2021 94.06
1811 51.87
1615 5.77
1406 32.51
1224 71.23
33
LoD (mg/L):
0.29
LoQ (mg/L):
0.88
% Recovery:
95.2 %
II. K+ Analysis
a. 200 to 100 ppm
Table 2.1 Respective intensities of various standard solutions for triplicate trials together with the
obtained R Squared Value, LoD, LoQ and Percentage Recovery.
1000
32099 51.00
800
28262 690.5
600
24361 332.0
400
19844 211.4
200
16064 219.4
R-Squared Value:
0.9992
LoD (mg/L):
36
LoQ (mg/L):
110
% Recovery:
105.5 %
The average of triplicate trials for 200 to 1000 ppm of KCl yielded a linear
calibration plot with a regression coefficient of 0.9996 and a percentage recovery
of 105.5%. Calculation of percentage recovery was done by employing an
analytical technique called spike method.
34
b. 20 to 100 ppm
Table 2.2 Respective intensities of various standard solutions for triplicate trials together with
the obtained R Squared Value, LoD, LoQ and Percentage Recovery.
LoD (mg/L):
4.0
100
10182 563.5
LoQ (mg/L):
12
80
8346 153.1
% Recovery:
97.1 %
60
6571 265.8
40
4745 109.7
20
3214 228.1
R-Squared Value:
0.9999
Concentration (mg/L)
LoD (mg/L):
0.14
10
1509 6.000
LoQ (mg/L):
0.41
1360 41.00
% Recovery:
101.8 %
1208 23.07
1066 16.64
912 10.00
35
function, the calibration curve was baseline corrected in order to approximate the
intensity of a blank sample. The Linest feature was carried out in order to verify the
regression and slope of the line and determine the standard deviation of each data.
The Significance F- Values from the F-test were also determined in order to verify
if the regression was just a merely a chance occurrence (other supporting
statistical data are included in Appendix A). For this parameter the accepted values
are less than or equal to 0.05. The values obtained from the analysis of each set
of data were found to be substantially less than 0.05, which validates the statistical
significance of the obtained results. The P-value on the other hand was determined
in order to validate if the values of the Y- intercept or the X variable are merely a
result of chance. The considerably low P-values from the obtained statistical
treatment depict the reliability and the likelihood that the results did not occur by
chance.
From the statistical output acquired, the researchers were able to calculate
the Limit of Detection (LoD), and Limit of Quantification (LoQ) for each set of data.
The LoD represents the lowest possible concentration that can be detected by the
instrument while the LoQ is the lowest possible concentration that can not only be
detected but is also viable for statistical treatment. The researchers managed to
obtain relatively low concentration values for the LoD and LoQ for each set of data.
Such recovery test was carried out by using measurements of the standards used
which were not included for the determination of the mean. This was done by
selecting the mean intensity of a certain concentration within each range of
standards and determining the resulting intensity when a sample or in this case, a
37
synthetic sample is spiked. The percent recovery was then calculated for each of
the concentration ranges. A percent recovery of about 100% 10 % for each range
demonstrates a substantial recovery and renders the validity of the results.
4.4
method known as Digital Image-Based FES. This analytical technique relies on the
principle of RGB values of pixels from images captured and projected digitally on
an LCD screen. For this purpose, the researchers used a smartphone camera
(Model: MyPhone A848i Duo) to capture images of the flame while running
standard solutions of varying concentrations of a specific metal salt. The captured
images were then transferred to a computer and analyzed for their respective RGB
values. This was carried out by selecting a representative pixel from the flame
image in quintuplicate and using the Color Picker feature of Microsoft Paint.
38
I. Sr2+ Analysis
a. 200 to 1000 ppm Green Values
Table 3.1 Respective intensities of various standard solutions for triplicate trials together with
the obtained R Squared Value, LoD, LoQ and Percentage Recovery.
1000
54.4 2.70
800
25
LoQ (mg/L):
75
% Recovery:
102.6 %
44.6 2.30
600
36.0 0.71
400
26.8 2.39
200
LoD (mg/L):
18.0 1.22
LoD (mg/L):
1.6
107.8 2.170
LoQ (mg/L):
4.8
60
87.2 3.270
% Recovery:
105 %
40
66.4 3.440
20
44.8 1.920
100
128.0 2.550
80
39
For the analysis of 20 to 100 ppm SrCl2, the Red values were taken and
plot against each of its corresponding concentration. These values were found to
be of linear behavior with a linear regression value of 0.9999 and a recovery
percentage of 105% was obtained from the calibration curve via spike method.
c. a. 20 to 100 ppm - Green + Red Values
Table 3.3 Respective intensities of various standard solutions for triplicate trials together with the
obtained R Squared Value, LoD, LoQ and Percentage Recovery.
100
145.4 38.87
80
124.0 33.38
60
106.2 27.08
40
84.4 21.06
20
64.8 14.21
0.14
LoQ (mg/L):
0.41
% Recovery:
101.8 %
40
1000
146.25 2.070
800
0.9995
LoD (mg/L):
28
LoQ (mg/L):
84
% Recovery:
92.5 %
133.75 1.340
600
123.00 1.670
400
111.00 2.700
200
R-Squared Value:
98.75 1.640
For the analysis of 200 to 1000 ppm BaCl2, the mean Red were taken and
plot against each of its corresponding concentration. These values were found to
be of linear behavior with a linear regression value of 0.99975 and recovery
percentage of 92.5% was obtained via spike method.
4.5
method known as Digital Image-Based FES. This analytical technique relies on the
principle of RGB values of pixels from images captured and projected digitally on
an LCD screen. For this purpose, the researchers used a smartphone camera
(Model: MyPhone A848i Duo) to capture images of the flame while running
standard solutions of varying concentrations of a specific metal salt. The captured
images were then transferred to a computer and analyzed for their respective RGB
41
values. This was carried out by selecting a representative pixel from the flame
image in quintuplicate and using the Color Picker feature of Microsoft Paint. These
values were subjected to linear regression analysis in order to determine which of
the Red, Green and Blue values would exhibit a linear behavior with respect to the
concentration. Afterwards, in-depth analysis using the Linest and Analysis Toolpak
feature of MS Excel was carried out to determine the Linear Regression, Standard
Deviation, and the Significance F and P-Values for each set of data.
The calibration curve for each set of test concentration were found to have
linear regression values approximately very close to 1, which exhibits the direct
relation of the intensity with respect to the concentration. Likewise, the Significance
F and P values were also determined in order to validate the statistical reliability of
the obtained output (other supporting statistical data are included in Appendix A).
The researchers were able to obtain Significance F and P-values which are notably
less than 0.05 which depicts the likelihood that the regression and the x variable
and the y-intercept values are not obtained by chance. In a similar manner, the
LoD and LoQ for each set of data were determined and found to be of substantially
low concentration values. Ultimately, a recovery test was carried out in a similar
manner for the data obtained for each of the concentration ranges. Likewise the
researchers were able to acquire an approximately 100% 10 % percent recovery
for each of the ranges, illustrating the considerable trueness of the generated
results.
42
Fiber Optic Probe - 1.8 meter, flame resistant, capable of detecting light at
350-850 nm range.
Fuel Source
Burner Assembly
Adjustments: Horizontal g
Operating Modes
43
44
the flame images of varying concentrations of Sr2+ and Ba2+ standard solutions.
This illustrates the direct relationship of RGB Values of the image and the
concentration of the solution being analyzed.
Recommendation
Side View
Top View
Figure 5. Proposed room plan for the viable storage of the fabricated FES.
45
Figure 5 exhibits the proposed room plan for the viable storage, utilization
and maintenance of the fabricated FES. Ideally, the room should be fully airconditioned, contains a fume hood/exhaust fan and has a functional fire
extinguisher. Also, the room should be most likely free from wind interference and
contains minimal light interference as much as possible.
The researchers suggest utilizing a compressed air tank with the aid of an
air compressor in order to regulate and maintain a constant pressure flow all
throughout the analysis.
To minimize the time consumed for the assembly of the instrument, the
researchers recommend providing an air compressor and a fiber optic detector
(Amadeus Spectrometer) that will solely be used for the operation of the
instrument.
For financially abled future research involving the fabricated FES, the
researchers advise the use of Acetylene Fuel in place of the Propane-Butane LPG
mixture to be able to expand the scope of analysis of metal ions beyond the group
I and II metals.
46
References
1. Hieftie, G. M. (2000) Atomic Emission Spectroscopy: It Lasts and Lasts and
Lasts. Journal of Chemical Education. Vol. 77. Retrieved from
http://JChem.Ed.chem.wisc.edu.
2. Flame Supplement. (n.d.). Tel Aviv University Homepage. Retrieved June
18, 2015, from www.tau.ac.il/~chemlaba/Files/Flame supplement.pdf
3. Skoog, D. A.; West, D. M.; Holler, F. J.; Crouch, S. R. (2014) Fundamentals
of Analytical Chemistry, 9th Edition. Brooks/Cole, Cengage Learning.
4. D. A. Skoog, D. M. West, F. J. Holler, and S. R. Crouch. (2000) Analytical
Chemistry: An Introduction, 7th ed., Chapter 23, pp. 594-631. Brooks/Cole,
Cengage Learning.
5. Atomic Emission. (n.d.). University of Kentucky Homepage Retrieved
August 02, 2015, from www.chem.uky.edu/courses/che226/Labs/040Atomic_Emission.pdf
6. 1000ppm ATOMIC ABSORPTION standards. (n.d.). Delloyds Lab Tech
Homepage.
Retrieved
March
09,
2016,
from
http://delloyd.50megs.com/1000ppm.html
7. Goodney, D. E. (1982) Determination of Sodium in Salt Substitute by Flame
Emission Spectroscopy. Journal of Chemical Education. Willamette
University. Volume 59, Number 10.
8. Lyra, W. S.; de Almeida, L. F.; Cunha, F. A.; Diniz, P. H.; Martins, V. L.; de
Araujo, M. C. (2014) Determination of sodium and calcium in powder milk
47
Flame
Emission
Spectrometer
for
Classroom
August
28,
2015,
from
https://www.itp.unihannover.de/~zawischa/ITP/atoms.html
14. Instrument Calibration. (2013) UC Davis ChemWiki Homepage. Retrieved
August
28,
2015,
from
http://chemwiki.ucdavis.edu/AnalyticalChemistry/DataAnalysis/Instrument_
Calibrationoveraregime#Howtorevealandavoiderrorsintheinstruments
15. Youden, W. J. (1984) Experimentation and Measurement.
16. Skoog, DA. Holler, FJ. Crouch, SR. (2007) Principles of Instrumental
Analysis, 6th Ed. Brooks/Cole, Cengage Learning.
48
09,
2016
from
http://www.excelfunctions.net/Excel-Linest-
Function.html.
24. A Quick Guide to Using Excel 2007s Regression Analysis Tool. (n.d.).
Duke Universitys Fuqua School of Business Homepage. Retrieved March,
09,
2016,
from
https://faculty.fuqua.duke.edu/~pecklund/ExcelReview/Use%20Excel%202
007%20Regression.pdf
49
25. Perret, D.; et. al. (2015) Camping Burner-Based Flame Emission
Spectrometer for Classroom Demonstrations. Department of Inorganic and
Analytical Chemistry, University of Geneva.
50
APPENDICES
51
APPENDIX A
Summary of Statistical
Evidence and Supporting Data
52
APPENDIX A
SUMMARY OF STATISTICAL EVIDENCE AND SUPPORTING DATA OBTAINED
FOR EACH SET OF CONCENTRATION RANGE FOR FES ANALYSIS
The following tables were the statistical values obtained from the treatment of given data
from FES Analysis using MS Excel Functions. Residual values were also obtained from
the analysis of results.
STATISTICAL OUTPUT
R-squared Value
0.9999
Standard deviation
22.36
Slope P-value
3.96E-07
Slope-intercept P-value
3.60E-05
Significance F
3.96E-07
95.2 %
Percentage Recovery
102.2 %
LoD (mg/L)
20.23
LoD (mg/L)
1.24
LoQ (mg/L)
61.32
LoQ (mg/L)
3.74
R-squared Value
0.9997
Standard deviation
316.53
Slope P-value
1.74E-06
Slope-intercept P-value
7.38.E-05
Significance F
1.74E-06
Percentage Recovery
STATISTICAL OUTPUT
STATISTICAL OUTPUT
R-squared Value
0.9992
Standard deviation
221.66
Slope P-value
9.91E-06
Slope-intercept P-value
1.40E-05
Significance F
9.91E-06
95.2 %
Percentage Recovery
105.5 %
LoD (mg/L)
0.29
LoD (mg/L)
36.13
LoQ (mg/L)
0.88
LoQ (mg/L)
109.50
R-squared Value
0.9995
Standard deviation
8.84
Slope P-value
5.22E-06
Slope-intercept P-value
1.45E-06
Significance F
5.22E-06
Percentage Recovery
53
STATISTICAL OUTPUT
R-squared Value
0.9989
Standard deviation
106.26
Slope P-value
1.34E-05
Slope-intercept P-value
1.05E-03
Significance F
1.34E-05
Percentage Recovery
97.1 %
LoD (mg/L)
4.00
LoQ (mg/L)
12.12
STATISTICAL OUTPUT
R-squared Value
0.9999
Standard deviation
3.06
Slope P-value
5.30 E-07
Slope-intercept P-value
1.42E-07
Significance F
5.30E-07
Percentage Recovery
101.8 %
LoD (mg/L)
0.14
LoQ (mg/L)
0.41
54
Mean
252
56
60
251
57
60
255
50
60
255
54
60
254
55
62
80 ppm
R
G
B
Mean
255
48
66
255
43
65
255
45
67
255
42
62
253
45
59
60 ppm
R
G
B
254.60
44.60
63.80
Mean
252
35
62
254
36
63
255
36
58
254
36
62
255
37
62
40 ppm
R
G
B
253.40
54.40
60.40
254.00
36.00
61.40
Mean
251
25
65
253
28
65
247
27
62
254
24
62
253
30
59
20 ppm
251.60
26.80
62.60
Mean
R
G
177
20
179
17
153
18
151
18
166
17
165.20
18.00
75
77
74
71
75
74.40
Table A.7 RGB Values obtained from the Image analysis of standard solutions 200 to 1000 ppm
SrCl2.
55
Mean
129
130
124
130
127
128.00
19
19
12
18
19
17.40
66
72
70
74
71
70.60
80 ppm
Mean
110
109
105
106
109
107.80
20
16
12
17
16
16.20
72
73
69
73
73
72.00
60 ppm
Mean
92
87
86
88
83
87.20
18
22
17
18
20
19.00
69
76
71
72
75
72.60
40 ppm
Mean
71
64
69
63
65
66.40
21
13
21
20
15
18.00
74
72
73
76
68
72.60
20 ppm
Mean
47
42
45
44
46
44.80
19
18
21
20
22
20.00
68
70
73
72
74
71.40
Table A.8 RGB Values obtained from the Image analysis of standard solutions 20 to 100 ppm
SrCl2.
56
Mean
146
147
145
147
142
146.25
137
138
132
133
132
135.00
120
121
113
122
120
119.00
800 ppm
Mean
134
134
135
132
132
113.75
120
122
117
116
116
118.75
109
106
107
101
103
105.75
600 ppm
Mean
125
123
121
123
121
123.00
112
113
114
112
111
112.75
104
111
108
110
109
108.25
400 ppm
Mean
110
111
108
115
113
111.0
95
96
94
99
99
96.00
90
90
94
99
99
93.25
200 ppm
Mean
98
98
98
101
101
98.75
85
85
82
85
85
84.25
86
99
96
101
95
95.50
Table A.9 RGB Values obtained from the Image analysis of standard solutions 20 to 100 ppm
BaCl2
57
STATISTICAL OUTPUT
R-squared Value
0.9996
R-squared Value
0.9998
Standard deviation
0.34
Standard deviation
0.50
Slope P-Value
3.20E-06
Slope P-Value
8.16E-07
1.28E-04
1.27E-04
Significance F
3.20E-06
Significance F
8.16E-07
Percentage Recovery
102.6 %
Percentage Recovery
105 %
LoD (mg/L)
24.80
LoD (mg/L)
1.57
LoQ (mg/L)
75.14
LoQ (mg/L)
4.76
STATISTICAL OUTPUT
R-squared Value
0.9993
R-squared Value
0.9995
Standard deviation
1.04
Standard deviation
0.50
Slope P-Value
8.30E-06
Slope P-Value
4.50E-06
2.74E-05
4.03E-07
Significance F
8.30E-06
Significance F
4.50E-06
Percentage Recovery
93.2 %
Percentage Recovery
92.5 %
LoD
3.41
LoD (mg/L)
27.76
LoQ
10.32
LoQ (mg/L)
84.11
58
y = 59.735x + 882.7
R = 0.9999
Mean Intensity
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Concentration (mg/L)
Figure A.1 Calibration curve of NaCl standard solution ranging from 20 ppm to 100 ppm.
Mean Intensity
60000
y = 51.623x + 9810.3
R = 0.9997
50000
40000
30000
20000
10000
0
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
Concentration (mg/L)
Figure A.2 Calibration curve of NaCl standard solution ranging from 200 ppm to 1000 ppm.
59
Mean Intensity
2000
y = 99.95x + 1015.7
R = 0.9995
1500
1000
500
0
0
10
12
Concentration (mg/L)
Figure A.3 Calibration curve of NaCl standard solution ranging from 2 ppm to 10 ppm.
30000
Mean Intensity
25000
20000
15000
10000
5000
0
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
Concentration (mg/L)
Figure A.4 Calibration curve of KCl standard solution ranging from 200 ppm to 1000 ppm.
60
10000
y = 87.685x + 1350.5
R = 0.999
Mean Intensity
8000
6000
4000
2000
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Concentration (mg/L)
Figure A.5 Calibration curve of KCl standard solution ranging from 20 ppm to 100 ppm.
y = 74.4x + 764.6
R = 0.9999
Mean Intensity
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
0
10
Concentration (mg/L)
Figure A.6 Calibration curve of KCl standard solution ranging from 2 ppm to 10 ppm.
61
12
50
40
y = 0.0453x + 8.78
R = 0.9996
30
20
10
0
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
Concentration (mg/L)
Figure A.7 Calibration curve of SrCl2 standard solution vs. Mean Green Values ranging from
200 ppm to 1000 ppm.
140
120
y = 1.039x + 24.5
R = 0.9998
100
80
60
40
20
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Concentration (mg/L)
Figure A.8 Calibration curve of SrCl2 standard solution vs. Mean Red values ranging from 20 ppm
to 100 ppm.
62
160
140
120
y = 1.004x + 44.72
R = 0.9993
100
80
60
40
20
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Concentration (mg/L)
Figure A.9 Calibration curve of SrCl2 standard solution vs. Mean Red + Mean Green values
ranging from 20 ppm to 100 ppm.
y = 0.0589x + 87.225
R = 0.9995
120.00
100.00
80.00
60.00
40.00
20.00
0.00
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
Concentration (mg/L)
Figure A.10 Calibration curve of SrCl2 standard solution vs. Mean Red + Mean Green values
ranging from 20 ppm to 100 ppm
63
APPENDIX B
Spreadsheet Functions
64
APPENDIX B
SPREADSHEET FUNCTIONS
[known_x's]
as
65
theknown_y's
array;
(or
FALSE
[stats]
the constant
normally;
is
treated
TRUE
DO return
statistics.
additional
regression
I.e. Return the array of values mn, mn1, ... , b and also return the additional
regression statistics listed in the table
below.
66
The array of statistics returned from the Excel Linest function has the following
form:
mn
mn-1
...
m1
sen
sen-1
...
se1
seb
r2
sey
df
ssreg
ssresid
sei
seb
r2
sey
df
ssreg
ssresid
68
The curly brackets around this function show that it has been entered as an array
formula.
Cells D1 and E1 give the values of the slope, m as 1.88452381, and the yintercept, b as 2.419642857. Therefore, the equation for the line of best fit through
the given points is:
y = 1.88452381 x + 2.419642857
The remaining cells in the range D2 - E5 give the following additional statistics for
this curve:
69
70
6. Open Excel and confirm that the Data Analysis dialog is available.
Steps to Follow When Running a Regression with Excel
1. Rearrange the Data as Necessary.
With Excels regression tool the independent X variables you use in your
analysis must be located together in the worksheet. There must be no blank
columns or columns with non-relevant data interrupting the range of X variables.
The dependent Y variable need not be located adjacent to the X variables, but all
Y variable values must be in a single range. These location specifications are
required by Excels built-in regression tool.
For the data in our sample, the data need not be rearranged. The X
variables are together in Columns F through K and the Y variable values are all in
Column E.
Figure B.3 Sample X and Y Data for Regression Analysis.
72
Excel opens its Data Analysis dialog. Scroll down and find the
Regression option. Click OK.
73
74
- Specify Unit Sales as the Input Y Range. Include the column header cell (the
cell that holds the text Unit Sales) in your range specification.
- Specify the range of data in Columns F through K as the Input X Range. Include
only one row of column headers with your range specification (that is, include only
the labels directly above the data).
- In the Regression dialog box make sure the Labels box is checked. With this
option checked Excel will recognize that the first cell in each column of data is a
data label.
- Direct Excel to put its results on a new worksheet by choosing the option New
Worksheet Ply.
- For outputs, select Residuals, and Standardized Residuals.
75
With data ranges and choices specified, your dialog should now look like the one
below.
Figure B.8 Filled dialog box from the Regression Analysis function.
76
Widen the columns on the new worksheet in order to see all the text results
properly. A quick way to do this is to select the blank square at the intersection of
the row numbers and column headers (to select the entire worksheet), and then
double-click the dividing line between any two column headers. Excel widens each
column so the widest entry in that column displays completely.
77
Excel labels the output areas SUMMARY OUTPUT, ANOVA, and RESIDUAL
OUTPUT.
78
In the image shown above, the sample standard and the sample used was
the original standard solution included in the calibration range, the only difference
was that the intensity for the sample standard was obtained from the mean of all
its acquired intensity while the intensity of the sample was obtained from the
intensity of excess trials that were not included in the mean intensity of the sample.
Intensity of the spiked sample was also obtain from the excess trials.
79
The concentration of the sample standard, spiked sample and sample were
calculated using the linear regression equation that can be obtained from a
calibration plot. Recovered analyte is then obtained by subtracting the calculated
concentration of sample from the concentration of spiked sample.
Recovery factor can now be calculated using the following equation:
80
APPENDIX C
Documentation
81
EXPERIMENTAL SETUP
Detector Setup
SrCl2 Flame
APPENDIX D
Budget Plan
84
APPENDIX D
BUDGET PLAN
Description
Propane-Butane
Tank
Price (Peso)
Mixed
Fuel
P 1,300
P 2000
Reagents/Chemicals
P 500
Transportation
P 200
Other
P 500
Total:
85
P 4,800
APPENDIX E
Gantt chart of Activities
86
APPENDIX E
GANTT CHART OF ACTIVITIES
Activities
1. Formulation
the topic
May
June
July
Aug.
of
2. Planning Period
3. Preparation for
the title defense
4. Title defense
5. Gathering
of
Materials,
Preparation for
Experimentation
Proper
6. Experimentation
7. Analysis of data
8. Preparation for
the final defense
9. Final defense
10. Revision of the
manuscript
11. Bookbinding
87
Sept.
Feb. Mar.
APPENDIX F
Curriculum Vitae
88
Personal Information
Date of Birth
Place of Birth
Mandaluyong City
Citizenship
Filipino
Gender
Male
Height
56
Educational Background
Tertiary:
Secondary:
Training
On-The-Job Training:
89
Personal Information
Date of Birth
August 3, 1995
Place of Birth
Quezon City
Citizenship
Filipino
Gender
Male
Height
55
Educational Background
Tertiary:
Secondary:
Primary:
Training
On-The-Job Training:
90
Personal Information
Date of Birth
Place of Birth
Cebu City
Citizenship
Filipino
Gender
Male
Height
510
Educational Background
Tertiary:
Secondary:
Primary:
Training
On-The-Job Training:
91