I. INTRODUCTION
The theory and practice of transformer protection has been
mature and comprehensive for many years. But in reality,
transformer protection mis-operations still happen from time
to time. The common reasons of mis-operations are:
Incorrect settings of 87T function
Incorrect settings of transformer overcurrent protection the
setting is either too sensitive or lack of coordination with
adjacent lines or feeders
Inrush current during energization or voltage recovery
CT polarity error in design or construction
False operation of non-electric protection, such as sudden
pressure relays, Buchholz relay, etc.
Relay failure
This paper will focus on the first type of mis-operations. As
the primary protection for large or mid-size transformers, the
87T function is considered to be reliable, sensitive, fast and
selective. Before modern microprocessor relays, the 87T
schemes built upon electromechanical (EM) relays were prone
to human error mainly because of the auxiliary CTs used for
current compensation. Modern digital relays have greatly
simplified the 87T scheme with regards to secondary circuit
design and settings, but setting-related mis-operations still
happen from time to time. This paper presents a few cases that
were caused by incorrect settings of digital 87T relays.
In the first case, the mis-operation was caused by a setting
mistake on differential current compensation. The second case
is about a refurbish project in which the old 87T relay was
replaced but the old circuit was maintained. In that project, the
87T settings of the digital relay were following the relay
manual, but the mis-matching between the old circuit and the
digital relay have created a mistake that was not easy to
identify. The third mis-operation case may or may not be
labeled as user error, since it was the automatic setting of
Winding 2
Ph-A Current
Winding n
Ph-A Current
Filtering and
Phasor Calc.
Filtering and
Phasor Calc.
Filtering and
Phasor Calc.
Magnitude, Phase
angle and zero
sequence
compensation
Magnitude, Phase
angle and zero
sequence
compensation
Magnitude, Phase
angle and zero
sequence
compensation
Maximum magnitude, or
Sum of magnitude, etc.
Differential
Current Iad
Restraint
Current Iar
Id
Ir
Page 1 of 9
IH convert _ B =
IH convert _ C
IH B
TAPH
IH C
=
TAPH
12kV Side
IL ILB
1
ILconvert _ A = A
TAPL
3
ILconvert _ B =
ILconvert _ C =
ILB ILC
1
TAPL
1
TAPL
3
ILC IL A
3
= 2.615 A
400
3 138kV
ILno min al =
50MVA
5
= 4.01A
3 12kV 3000
138kV Bus
Station
Service
138/69/46kV
87T
46kV Bus
69kV Bus
3 factor
Page 2 of 9
W1
100
62.5
138
Wye
Within
zone
0
W2
100
62.5
69
Wye
Within
zone
0
W3
100
35.7
46
Delta
Not Within
zone
-30
Page 3 of 9
From the event record, differential current did exist and was
above the 87T pickup setting. Since all the currents look
normal, the suspicion was on 87T settings that are listed as
follows,
In this case, the primary currents for the relay are IAB, IBC, ICA.
Since an 87T relay will typically compare each phase
individually, the first step is to get the phase currents IA, IB, IC.
To make the calculation intuitive, a number can be assumed
for the primary currents. E.g.,
I A = I CA I AB = 10000 3150o
I B = I AB I BC = 10000 330o
(1)
I C = I BC I CA = 10000 3 90o
Step2. Calculate the secondary currents that flow into the relay
Figure IV.5. Simplified Secondary Circuit for 87T Scheme Generator Branch Current inputs
Per Fig. IV.4, the CT ratio is 20000/5, so the secondary
currents out of the CT are
(2)
Page 4 of 9
W5 W2 W6 W3
87T Relay
W4
W1
WEST AUTO
345/138/13.8kV
(SPARE)
MIDDLE AUTO
345/138/34.5kV
345kV
The event record of the 87T relay is shown in Fig. V.2. From
the record, it was the unrestraint 87T function that operated
and the recorded phasor of differential current Ibd magnitude
was 9.66pu or 48.3 secondary amps. Since the setting of the
unrestraint 87T function was 8.0 pu, the relay operated per
setting. The question is: why did the relay see such high
differential current for an external fault?
Page 5 of 9
CT ratio
Rated MVA
Nominal
voltage(kV)
Transformer
Winding
Conn.
Grounding
W2
400
675
138
W3
800
62
34.5
W4
800
675
345
W5
600
675
138
W6
800
143.7
13.8
Wye
Wye
Delta
Wye
Wye
Delta
Within
zone
Within
zone
Within
zone
Within
zone
Withi
n zone
Not Within
zone
-30
Angle with
regards to
Wnd1
Automatic Selection
8.0 pu ( 40A secondary)
The CTs and connections were verified after the event. From
the event record, there was no sign of CT saturation even
though some current were relatively high. There was not
apparent mistake with the relay settings either.
To analyze the event, the relay internal 87T calculations were
reproduced on the MathCAD sheet. Then an issue emerged
during this exercise. This type of relay has a setting called
Reference Winding Selection. Any CT inputs can be
selected as the setting. But by default, the setting is
Automatic Selection. Since Automatic is such a magic
word, no one would ever want to change this default setting
prior to this event. According to the relay manual, the
reference winding is used to determine the compensation
factor. When Automatic Selection is used, the relay will
select the reference winding that gives the minimum Imargin,
which is defined by
CT _ Pr imary[ w]
I m arg in [ w] =
, where w=1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
I rated [ w]
In this case, the rated current and the margin current for each
current input are listed in the following table,
Winding
1
2
3
4
5
6
1129.6
2824.0
1037.6
1129.6
2824.0
6012
Irated
1.771
1.416
1.157
1.771
1.416
0.665
Imargin
Since the Imargin[6] is the smallest, the winding 6 input for the
relay is used as reference per Automatic Selection setting.
Once the reference winding is defined, the magnitude
compensation factor M for each winding is calculated per
following equation,
I primary [ w] Vno min al [ w]
, where w=1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
M [ w] =
I primary [ wref ] Vno min al [ wref ]
Winding
M
W1
400
675
345
1
12.5
2
10.0
3
0.75
4
12.5
5
10.0
6
1.0
I Aconv [ w] = I A [ w] M [ w] AngCompA [ w]
I Bconv [ w] = I B [ w] M [ w] AngCompB [ w]
I Cconv [ w] = I C [ w] M [ w] AngCompC [ w]
where the AngComp X [ w] represents the phase compensation.
Page 6 of 9
W1
400
100
138.0 kV
Wye
Within zone
0
Slope 1
Break 1
30%
1.25 pu
CT ratio
Rated MVA
Nominal voltage
Transformer Winding Connection
Grounding
Angle with regards to Wnd1
Percent
Differential
Pickup
0.099 pu
W2
1200
100
19.5 kV
Delta
Not Within zone
-330
Slope 2
Break 2
80%
3.0 pu
138kV Bus#2
138kV Bus#1
138kV Bus#3
138kV Bus#4
400/5
YnD11,
100MVA
YnD11,
100MVA
(Spare)
YnD11,
100MVA
87T
1200/5
19.5kV
19.5kV
SVC#1
SVC#2
Page 7 of 9
CT ratio
Rated MVA
Nominal voltage
87T Pickup
Slope 1
Break 1
Break 2
Slope 2
Inrush Inhibit Function
Inrush Inhibit Mode
Inrush Inhibit Level
W1
W2
400
600
70
70
345.0
19.5 kV
kV
0.05 pu
30%
1.53 pu
7.66 pu
75%
Adaptive 2nd
2-out-of-3
15%
REFERENCE
[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
Yiyan Xue received his B.Eng. from Zhejiang University in 1993 and M.Sc.
from the University of Guelph in 2007. He is currently an Engineer Principal
in American Electric Power (AEP), working on protection and control
standards, relay settings, fault analysis, simulation studies, etc. Before joining
AEP in 2008, he had worked in GE for 3 years, in ABB for 10 years and in
GEC-ALSTHOM for 1 year. Yiyan Xue is a senior member of IEEE and a
Professional Engineer registered in the state of Ohio.
Zachary P. Campbell received his B.S.E.E. degree from the University of
Akron, in Akron, Ohio, in 2008, and his M.Sc. degree from The Ohio State
University, in Columbus, Ohio, in 2012. He has been an engineer at
American Electric Power (AEP) since 2008, working in various capacities
within protective relaying departments including field services and
engineering. Zak is a member of IEEE, CIGRE and is a registered
professional engineer in the state of Ohio.
Sudhakar Chidurala received his B.Eng. from Osmania University in 1989
and Master of Technology from REC, Kakatiya University in 1999. He is
currently a Protection and Control Engineer in AEP. Before joining AEP in
2007, he had worked 3 years in Hydro One Inc., Canada and 13 years in AP
Transmission Corp., India at various capacities in Protection and Control
Engineering. Sudhakar is active Senior Member of IEEE, MIE of India and is
registered professional engineer in the state of Oklahoma and Texas.
Charles Jones received his BSEE from West Virginia University in 1982 and
MEEE from the University of Idaho in 2011. He is currently a Staff Engineer
at American Electric Power, working on protection and control standards,
relay setting templates, fault analysis, etc. He has been with American Electric
Power for 30 years. Charles Jones is a member of IEEE and a Professional
Engineer registered in the state of West Virginia and Ohio.
Page 9 of 9
MVA 1000000 V A
pu 1
1. Relay Settings
nWnd := 3
Number of windings:
62.5MVA
Snom := 62.5MVA
35.7MVA
138kV
Vnorm := 69kV
46kV
ReferenceWinding := 0
500A
CT prim := 500A
500A
"Y"
Connection := "Y"
"D"
"Within Zone"
Grounding := "Within Zone"
"Not Within Zone"
0
AngWrtW1 := 0
30
CTsec := 5A
Pickup := 0.2
Slope1 := 40%
Break1 := 2.0
Slope2 := 100%
2. CT Ratio Check
CT ratio
100
CTR :=
= 100
CTsec
100
CT prim
Snom
Inorm_prim :=
Vnorm
261
= 523 A
3
448
Break2 := 15.0
2.615
Inorm_prim
Inorm_sec :=
= 5.23 A
CTR
4.481
Tthe selection of CT ratio should make the secondary nominal current 1~5A for each winding.
3. Magnitude Compensation Factors
1.912
CTprim
Imargin :=
= 0.956
Inorm_prim 1.116
( (
ReferenceWinding otherwise
The magnitude compensation factors (M) are used to convert each winding current before the differential
and restraint current are calculated
2
CT prim Vnorm
= 1
M :=
Vnorm
CTprim
RefW 1
RefW 1 0.667
If the setting of Reference Winding is "Automatic Selection", the winding cooresponding to the smallest Margin
Factor will be selected by the relay as the reference winding. If you see a overly high M factor, please set the
reference winding manually instead of using "Automatic Selection".
3. Phase Compensation Reference
i :=
n 0
while Connectionn = "Y"
n n + 1
n
i=2
RefAngle := AngWrtW1i = 30
30
AngWrtRef := RefAngle AngWrtW1 = 30
0
4. Fault Analysis
175.85 283.2
IAFprim := 83.6 103.37 A
80.52 84.01
IAFprim
IAF :=
CTR
112.84 64.45
IBFprim := 102.95 204.83 A
592.83 286.92
112.9 145.43
ICFprim := 119.15 341.61 A
236.57 318.7
IBFprim
IBF :=
CTR
ICFprim
ICF :=
CTR
IAp0gnd :=
IAp30lag :=
IAF ICF
IBp0gnd :=
IBp30lag :=
ICp30lag :=
3
IAp30lead :=
ICp0gnd :=
IAF IBF
IBp30lead :=
IBF ICF
ICp30lead :=
ICF IAF
IAW ( n) := s
IBW ( n) := s
ICW ( n) := s
IAp30lead n if AngWrtRef n = 30
IAp30lagn if AngWrtRef n = 30
s Mn CTsec 1
IBp30leadn if AngWrtRef n = 30
IBp30lagn if AngWrtRef n = 30
s Mn CTsec 1
ICp30leadn if AngWrtRef n = 30
ICp30lagn if AngWrtRef n = 30
s Mn CTsec 1
ii := 0 .. nWnd 1
IAXii := IAW ( ii)
nWnd 1
IdA :=
IAXk
IdB :=
k=0
IBXk
IdC :=
ICXk
k=0
k=0
nWnd 1
nWnd 1
IdB = 0.316
IdC = 0.325
IrA = 0.62
IrB = 0.79
Pickup
vx1 := Slope1
Break1
Break2
vx :=
IrC = 0.34
Pickup
Pickup
vy1 :=
Break1 Slope1
Break2 Slope2
vy :=
87T Characteristic
vy
IdA
IdB
IdC
xlimit 3
ylimit 3
The TxCTC setting represents one of the following matrixes. The CTC(12) produces no phase shift, but it
removes the zero-sequence components.
2 1 1
1
CTC12 := 1 2 1
3
1 1 2
1 1 0
1
CTC1 :=
0 1 1
3
1 0 1
D lags Y by 30
1 0 1
1
CTC11 :=
1 1 0
3
0 1 1
D leads Y by 30
1. Relay Settings
MVA_ := 1500
ICOM := "Y"
Windings:S,T,U,W
CTRS := 600
CTCONS := Y
TSCTC := CTC12
VTERMS := 765
CTRT := 600
CTCONT := Y
TTCTC := CTC12
VTERMT := 765
CTRU := 6928
CTCONU := D
TUCTC := CTC1
VTERMU := 26
CTRW := 7000
CTCONW := Y
TWCTC := CTC1
VTERMW := 26
CTRX := 1
CTCONX := Y
TXCTC := CTC1
VTERMX := 1
O87P := 0.3
U87P := 16
SLP1 := 25%
SLP2 := 60%
DIOPR := 1.2
DIRTR := 1.2
E87HB := "N"
E87HR := "Y"
PCT2 := 20%
PCT4 := 20%
PCT5 := 35%
S87QP := 1.0
SLPQ1 := 100
S87QD := 100
In order to compensate for the differential current due to CT ratios and transformer ratio, the relay will calculate the
scaling factor, namely TAPn, for each winding current. The calculation method is,
TAPS :=
TAPT :=
TAPU :=
TAPW :=
TAPX :=
MVA_ 1000
3 VTERMS CTRS
CTCONS = 1.89
MVA_ 1000
3 VTERMT CTRT
CTCONT = 1.89
MVA_ 1000
3 VTERMU CTRU
CTCONU = 8.33
MVA_ 1000
3 VTERMW CTRW
MVA_ 1000
3 VTERMX CTRX
CTCONW = 4.76
CTCONX = 866025.4
For each winding, enter the A, B, C phase current from top to bottom.
237 44
IFS := 274.8 280.7
311.3 163.2
527.8 36.9
IFT := 504.8 278.7
480.9 155
13641.4 186.6
IFU := 13590.2 68
13915.6 307.5
951.5 328.9
IFW := 997.3 207
963 87.4
0 0
IFX := 0 0
0 0
87T Calculation
ISC := TSCTC
IFS CTCONS
CTRS TAPS
IWC := TWCTC
IFW CTCONW
CTRW TAPW
ITC := TTCTC
IFT CTCONT
CTRT TAPT
IXC := TXCTC
IFX CTCONX
CTRX TAPX
0.234 + 0.177i
DiffSEL := ISC + ITC + IUC + IWC + IXC = 0.042 0.296i
0.276 + 0.118i
IUC := TUCTC
IFU CTCONU
CTRU TAPU
O87P
vx1 :=
SLP1
xlimit
O87P
vy1 := O87P
xlimit SLP1
O87P
vx2 := SLP2
xlimit
O87P
xlimit SLP2
vy2 :=
87T Characteristic
87T Settings:
O87P = 0.3 pu
SLP1 = 25 %
SLP2 = 60 %
Fault Quantity Calc:
DiffA
DiffA = 0.29 pu
DiffB 3
DiffB = 0.3 pu
DiffC
DiffC = 0.3 pu
vy1
vy2 2
ResA = 1.11 pu
ResB = 1.14 pu
ResC = 1.14 pu
xlimit 5
0
ylimit 5