Anda di halaman 1dari 181

USER MANUAL

Objectives

This evaluation scheme is based on both ISO 17 025 Standard and on Regional Instrument Centre (RIC) Terms of R
The aim is to measure differences between real practices and requirements.
It has also been developed to help evaluation and identify improvement actions.
This evaluation scheme can be used as a frame for an internal or external audit, or for an autoevaluation.

Background
This tools is useful for every NMHS metrology laboratory and especially for Regional Instrument Centre.
Users must have basic knowledge of quality management and metrology.

Overview
In a general maner, buttons or dynamic user manual allow users to go directly into results.

Evaluation Scheme
This worksheet includes all evaluation items coming from ISO 17 025 and from the RIC Terms of Reference.
It contains three main parts for the evaluation.

Firstly, Chapter 4 and 5 (Management and Technical Requirements) from ISO 17025 and a third part adressing RICs

It is possible to fill only one part and go to results. When you fill Chapter 4 and/or Chapter 5, answers are automatica
If you are accredited, you may fill only the RIC's part.
For each question, the evaluation is done as follows:
- No: nothing
- Rather No: for example draft, under elaboration...
- Rather Yes: written but not validated, not implemented
-Yes: all is written and correct
- n/a: not applicable, the question is out of object
- I don't know: should be clarified later
Answers could be ticked manually or filled by runing the application (Ctrl+W).
Help is obtained by mouse over the red triangle.

Calculation

This sheet has two functions:


- to calculate a score to each answer,
- to weigth answer relatively to their significance.

Radar graphs
This graph allows a simple and synthetic view.
It is also possible to identify improvement actions.
First two parts (chapter 4 and 5) are independant.
Overall results are shown as:
0 < N <40%

Not performing

40% < N < 60%

Need improvments

60% < N < 80%

Satisfactory

80% < N < 100%

Good

Synthesis
This worksheet provides an overview of the results, grouping individual results by topics.
A color code is given from Orange (Not performing) to Green (Good)
A comment area is free for the evaluator to add his remarks.

Non Conforming
At the end, you can get some help to improve your Quality Assurance System.
But this possibility can be used only when the scheme is fully filled.

Bibliography
1 ISO/IEC 17025:2005
General requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories
http://www.iso.org/iso/home.htm

2 Terms of Reference for Regional Instrument Centres


http://www.wmo.int/pages/prog/www/IMOP/instrument-reg-centres.html

3 Cofrac Website
http://www.cofrac.fr

4 Ralisation d'une grille d'valuation ISO 9001 version 2000, simple d'utilisation et associant des outils graphiques,
Jeannal BOURGET, Hassna HAMDOUCH, Rose MORET, Projet d'Intgration, MASTER Management de la Qualit
URL : http://www.utc.fr/mastermq ; Universit de Technologie de Compigne
5 Outil d'autodiagnostic sur la norme ISO 17025, Annunzio GIANNONI, Sofiane HAMITOUCHE, Nathalia MACIEL, Ker
Projet d'Intgration, MASTER Management de la Qualit (MQ), Mastre Spcialis Normalisation, Qualit, Certificati

http://www.utc.fr/master-qualite/public/publications/qualite_et_management/MQ_M2/2009-2010/projets/04_iso_17025/Grille_Autodiagnos

6 Royaume du Maroc
Ministre de l'Industrie, du Commerce et des Nouvelles Technologies
Questionnaire d'valuation pralable une demande d'accrditation
http://www.mcinet.gov.ma/mciweb/QualiteNormalisation/updoc/questionnaire.pdf

V2.1

MANUAL

EVALUATION SCHEME DIRECTOR

Management Requirements

d on Regional Instrument Centre (RIC) Terms of Reference (ToRs).

Technical Requirements
Regional Instrument Centre

ment actions.

external audit, or for an autoevaluation.

cially for Regional Instrument Centre.

go directly into results.

25 and from the RIC Terms of Reference.

s) from ISO 17025 and a third part adressing RICs ToRs.

apter 4 and/or Chapter 5, answers are automaticall inserted in relevant RIC's part.

dual results by topics.

n laboratories

e d'utilisation et associant des outils graphiques,


'Intgration, MASTER Management de la Qualit (MQ), UTC, 2006-2007

NI, Sofiane HAMITOUCHE, Nathalia MACIEL, Kerlany PEREIRA, Jean-Claude TEJONDON,


astre Spcialis Normalisation, Qualit, Certification, Essai (NQCE), UTC, 2009-2010,

Q_M2/2009-2010/projets/04_iso_17025/Grille_Autodiagnostic_ISO17025_gr04_QP10_v4.xls

EVALUATION SCHEME DIRECTORY

Management Requirements

echnical Requirements

Regional Instrument Centre

REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRE EVALUATI


Regional Instrument Centre
Region:
Name:
Address:
Country
Phone./Fax :
Web :
Contact :
Regional Instruments Center with
Full capacities
Basic Capacities

Domains

Number of calibration performed per year and per domain:


Name of Domain

Domain 1
Domain 2
Domain 3
Domain 4
Domain 5
Total number of calibration done:

Total
Number:
Number:
Number:
Number:
Number:

Internal
0
0
0
0
0
0

Name and position of the person responsible for filling out this Questionnaire:
First name:
Family name:
Position:
E-mail:

Adress:

Attached to this questionnaire, please attach (in an electronic way) the following documents for each param
If you are accredited:
- a copy of your accreditation (certification) or a link to the accreditation body web showing your accreditatio
If you are not accredited (or certified):
- the last calibration certificate of your reference standard (for each parameter)
- an example of a calibration certificate issued your RIC.

In both cases (accredited or not) please fill the template worksheet

CENTRE EVALUATION SCHEME

Number of staff per domain


External

Manager

Operator

owing documents for each parameter:

dy web showing your accreditation

Total

Domain
(example)
Pressure

Calibrated item
(example)
Digital Barometer

Mesurande
(example)
Error

Range / Domain
(example)
500 to 1060 hPa

Principle / Reference
(example)
Calibration by comparison
at 23 C 3C / PTE 100 (internal procedure)

Calibration instruments
(Reference Standard, Equipment)
(example)
Quartz barometer DHI RPM 3 A0015
Generator DH type PPC1

Traceability

Best Capability
(example)
8,8 + 5,4.10-5 P

Last standard
calibration date

(example)
01 January 2010

By

(example)
W.M.O. (Switzerland)

REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRE E


Topic

Chapter

4.1 Organization

4.2 Quality System

4.3. Documentation Control

4.4 Review of contracts

4.5 Subcontracting of
calibrations

4.6 Purchasing supplies

4.7 Service to client

4.8. Complaints

4.9 Control of nonconforming


calibration work

4.10 Corrective action

4.11. Preventive action

4.12. Technical records

4.12. Technical records

4.13. Internal audits

4.14. Management review

Chapter

5.2. Personnel

5.3. Accommodation and


environmental conditions

5.4. Calibration methods and


method validations 5.4.1.
General

5.4. Calibration methods and


method validation 5.4.2.
Selection of methods

5.4. Calibration methods and


method validation 5.4.2.
Selection of methods

5.4. Calibration methods and


method validation 5.4.5.
Validation of methods
5.4.6. Estimation of uncertainty
of measurement

5.4.7. Control of data

5.5. Equipment

5.6. Measurement traceability


5.6.1. General

5.6. Measurement traceability

5.8. Handling of
calibration items

5.8. Handling of
calibration items

5.9. Assuring the quality of


calibration results

5.10. Reporting the results

5.10.9. Amendments to
calibration certificates

Term Of Reference

(a) A RIC must have, or have


access to, the necessary
facilities and laboratory
equipment to perform the
functions necessary for the
calibration of meteorological
and related environmental
instruments;

(b) A RIC must maintain a set


of meteorological standard
instruments and establish
traceability of its own
measurement standards and
measuring instruments to the
SI;

(c) A RIC must have qualified


managerial and technical staff
with necessary experience in
fulfilling its functions;

(c) A RIC must have qualified


managerial and technical staff
with necessary experience in
fulfilling its functions;

(d) A RIC must develop its


individual technical procedures
for calibration of
meteorological and related
environmental instruments
using calibration equipment
employed by the RIC;

(e) A RIC must develop its


individual quality assurance
procedures;

(f) A RIC must participate in, or


organize inter-laboratory
comparisons of standard
calibration instruments and
methods;
(g) A RIC must, as appropriate,
utilize the resources and
capabilities of the Region to
the best interest of the Region;

(h) A RIC must, as far as


possible, apply international
standards applicable for
calibration laboratories, such
as ISO 17 025;

(i) A recognized authority must


assess a RIC, at least every five
years, to verify its capabilities
and performance;

(i) A recognized authority must


assess a RIC, at least every five
years, to verify its capabilities
and performance;

(j) A RIC must assist Members


of the Region in calibrating
their national meteorological
standards and related
environmental monitoring
instruments;

(k) A RIC must participate in or


organize, WMO and/or regional
instrument intercomparisons,
following relevant CIMO
recommendations;

(l) According to relevant


recommendations on the WMO
Quality Management
Framework a RIC must
contribute positively to
Members regarding quality of
measurements;

(m) A RIC must advise


Members on inquiries
regarding instrument
performance, maintenance and
the availability of relevant
guidance materials;

(n) A RIC must actively


participate in, or assist in the
organization of regional
workshops on meteorological
and related environmental
instruments;
(o) The RIC must cooperate
with other RICs in
standardization of
meteorological and related
environmental measurements;

(p) A RIC must regularly inform


Members and report, on an
annual basis, to the president
of the Regional Association
and to the WMO Secretariat on
services offered to Members
and activities done;

REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRE EVALUATION SCHE


Questions

Chapter 4: Management Requirements


Is the RIC's position clearly defined in the parent organisation structure?
Are RIC relationships with other services defined?
Are RIC and maintenance services clearly separated?
Are there policies and procedures relating to the protection of its clients confidential information?
Are there organigrams describing internal RIC organization?
Are responsibility, authority and interrelationships of all personnel specified?
Has a member of staff been appointed as quality manager?
Have deputies been appointed for key personnel?
Do you have Quality Assurance procedures (Quality Manual)?
Is the quality manual appropriate to the scope of the RIC activities?
The date of the last update is?
Are objectives of RIC clearly documented (for instance in the quality policy statement)?
Does the quality manual include the structure of the documentation and the responsibilities of technical staff
and quality managers?
Are there procedures to control documents?
Are there instructions or procedure dealing with the review and approval of documents?
Are updates and modifications clearly identified in all documents?
Are the latest versions of documents promptly available?
Are all documents, included external sources, controlled?

Are the procedures for the review of requests and contracts established?
Are reviews and discussions with clients maintained?
Are you subcontracting some of your calibration works?
Are selecting criteria clearly defined?
Is the client advised of the subcontract?
Is a policy for purchasing supplies expressed?
Are the purchasing procedures written and validated?
Are the conformity criteria used for materials acceptance clearly defined, especially for materials used in
calibration works?
Is the evaluation of critical material suppliers performed?
Do you have a procedure or dispositions concerning relationship with your clients?
Are clients allowed to be present during your calibration work?
Is the confidentiality of clients ensured during all the process?
Do you have a policy for the resolution of clients' complaints?
Do you have procedure(s) for the resolution of clients' complaints?
Do you have a policy for the resolution of nonconforming work?
Do you have a procedure dealing with nonconforming calibration work?
In case of nonconforming work, is the responsibility for authorizing the resumption of work defined?
Are dispositions taken in case of nonconforming calibration report?
Have you established a policy for implementing corrective actions when nonconforming work has been
identified?
Have you established a procedure(s) for implementing corrective action when nonconforming work has
been identified?
Are corrective actions monitored to ensure effectiveness?
Have you established procedure(s) for preventive actions?
Have you established procedure(s) for the control of quality and technical records?

Is the retention time of quality and technical records clearly established?


Are all records kept securely?
Are internal audits of RIC conducted periodically?
Have you established a procedure to schedule internal audits?
The period of internal audits is
All elements of the RIC quality system are covered by audits?
Have you established a schedule for quality system review?
Have you establish a procedure to organize quality system review?
The periodicity of such review is?
Are the decided actions recorded and reviewed regularly?

Chapter 5: Technical requirements


Have you established a policy for training of personnel?
Do you ensure that personnel are qualified to perform calibration work?
Is every job described in the quality system from managerial to technical staff?
Have you described competency and responsibility of every technical staff?
Does the RIC have all facilities to perform calibration work for the expressed capabilities?
Are environmental conditions controlled and recorded?
Are measures taken for housekeeping of laboratory areas?
Do you have special dispositions dealing with neighboring areas (for instance storage) ?
Do you have manuals for the use of all equipments used in calibration work?
Has the laboratory established instructions on the use and operation of all relevant equipment?
Is the client informed by the laboratory of the method used for calibration?

Has a member of staff been appointed as technical manager (or equivalent), which is in charge particularly
of method selection and validation?
Has the laboratory validated its calibration methods?
Are clients' needs in term of performance and accuracy clearly defined?
Or are your capabilities in term of range, steps and accuracy clearly defined?
Do you apply a procedure to estimate the uncertainty of all calibration measurement covered by quality
system?
Are calculations and data transfers systematically under control or checked?
Have you developed and validated special software for calibration work?
Have you established a procedure(s) for data protection?
Does the RIC have all equipment to perform calibration work for each claimed parameter?
Is the required accuracy specified for all equipment (reference standards in particular)?
Is every equipment (reference standard, particularly) uniquely identified?
Have you established records for all equipments?
Have you established instructions dealing with defective equipment or software?
Do you have special procedure(s) for equipment going out of your direct control?
Have you established a progamme for the calibration of reference standards and associated systems?
Have you established a procedure(s) for the calibration of reference standards and associated systems?
Can the RIC give real proofs of traceability to SI units for all reference standards and associated
equipments?
Do the calibration certificates of reference standards contain measurement results, including the
measurement uncertainty and/or a statement of compliance?
Have you performed regular checks to maintain confidence in the calibration status of reference?
Have you established a procedure(s) for handling, transport, storage and use of your reference standards?
Are you using equipments which are not able to ensure traceability to SI units?
(please add comments)
Have you established a procedure(s) for the transportation, receipt, storage of instruments to be calibrated?

Have you established instructions for identifying such items?


Have you established a procedure(s) for monitoring the validity of your calibrations?
Are all relevant information and data reported in the calibration certificate given to the client after calibration
work?
If needed, are calibration data, which are obtained before and after adjustment or reparation, reported?
Are you able to give opinion or interpretation to satisfy client requirements?
Are you able to give a compliance or non-compliance opinion?
Are compliance criteria reported in the calibration report?
Have you established instructions dealing with amendments of a calibration certificate?

REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRE


Does the RIC have all facilities to perform calibration work for the expressed capabilities?
Are environmental conditions controlled and recorded?
Are measures taken for housekeeping of laboratory areas?
Does the RIC have all equipment to perform calibration work for each claimed parameter?
Required accuracy is specified for all equipment (reference standards in particular)?
Is every equipment (reference standard, particularly) uniquely identified?
Have you established instructions dealing with defective equipment or software?
Have you established a programme for the calibration of reference standards and associated systems?
Can the RIC give real proofs of traceability to SI units for all reference standards and associated
equipments?
Are there organigram describing internal RIC organization?
Are responsibility, authority and interrelationships of all personnel specified?
Have you establish a policy for training of personnel?

Do you ensure that personnel are qualified to perform calibration work?


Is every job described in the quality system from managerial to technical staff?
Have you described competency and responsibility of every technical staff?
Have the laboratory established instructions on the use and operation of all relevant equipment?

Is the client informed by the laboratory of the method used for calibration?

Have you established a procedure(s) dealing with uncertainty associated with calibration results?
Has a member of staff been appointed as technical manager (or equivalent), which is in charge particularly
of method selection and validation?
Do you have any Quality Assurance procedures (Quality Manual)?
Are objectives of RIC clearly documented (for instance in the quality policy statement)?
Do the quality procedures include the structure of the documentation and responsibilities of technical and
quality managers?
Have you organized or participated in an interlaboratory comparison?
Have results of intercomparison been published (for instance on WMO or RIC Web)?

Does the RIC have contact or meetings with other Members of the Region?

Is a member of staff responsible of RIC quality assurance?

Are RIC and maintenance service clearly separated?


Does the RIC apply international standards, such as ISO 17 025?
Is the laboratory certified or accredited against ISO 9001 or ISO 17025 standard?
Have you established a procedure to schedule internal audits?

The period of internal audits is


Have you been audited or evaluated within the last five years by a recognized authority?
Have you external clients (external to organisation)?

Do you have Members (NMHSs) of the Region as client?

Have you received any demand concerning the calibration of national standards of Members of the Region
(NMHSs)?

Did you organize or participate in a WMO comparison campaign?

Have you calibrated instruments (transfer standards or other sensors) for other Region Member(s) within
the last five years?

Have you collaborated within instrument domain with other Region Member(s) within the last five years?

Have you received demands dealing with instrument domain coming from other Region Members?

Have you received demands of Region Members dealing with instrumental documentation?

Have you contributed to the training of staff on instruments in the Region (workshop, trainee)?

Have you participated in or organized workshop on metrology or instruments?

Have you had contact(s) with other RICs within the last five years?

Do you inform regularly Members, president of the Region and WMO Secretariat, about your activities as
RIC?

Have you a specialized web-site on your RIC activities?

ATION SCHEME
Answers

Comments

YES

NO

I don't know

YES

NO

I don't know

YES

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Not
valid

Draft

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

<1year

~1 year >>1year

No
MQ

I don't know

YES

Not
valid

NO

I don't know

YES

Draft

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Yes

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

<1year

~1 year >>1year

No
audit

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

<1year

~1 year

>>1year

No
audit

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather

YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather

YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather

YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

n/a

YES

Rather

YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

n/a

n/a

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

n/a

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather

YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

YES

I don't know

YES

Rather

YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather

YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather

YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather

YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather

YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather

Not

NO

I don't know

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

YES

YES

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

YES

YES

YES

ISO
17025
YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

Rather
YES
ISO 9001

Rather
YES

NO

I don't know

NO

I don't know

NO

I don't know

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

<2 y

YES

YES

~2 y

>>2 y

Never

I don't know

NO

I don't know

NO

I don't know

YES

NO

I don't know

YES

NO

I don't know

YES

YES

NO

YES

YES

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

Rather
Not

Rather
Not

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

I don't know

NO

I don't know

NO

I don't know

NO

I don't know

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

YES

YES

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

<1year

~1 year

>>1year

Never

I don't know

YES

Rather
YES

Rather
Not

NO

I don't know

Requirements

4.1 Organization

4.1 Organization

4.1 Organization

4.1 Organization

4.1 Organization

4.1 Organization

4.1 Organization

4.1 Organization

4.2 Quality System

4.2 Quality System

4.2 Quality System

4.2 Quality System

4.2 Quality System

4.3. Documentation Control

4.3. Documentation Control

4.3. Documentation Control

4.3. Documentation Control

4.3. Documentation Control

4.4 Review of contracts

4.4 Review of contracts

4.5 Subcontracting of calibrations

4.5 Subcontracting of calibrations

4.5 Subcontracting of calibrations

4.6 Purchasing supplies

4.6 Purchasing supplies

4.6 Purchasing supplies

4.6 Purchasing supplies

4.7 Service to client

4.7 Service to client

4.7 Service to client

4.8. Complaints

4.8. Complaints

4.9 Control of nonconforming calibration work

4.9 Control of nonconforming calibration work

4.9 Control of nonconforming calibration work

4.9 Control of nonconforming calibration work

4.10 Corrective action

4.10 Corrective action

4.10 Corrective action

4.11. Preventive action

4.12. Technical records

4.12. Technical records

4.12. Technical records

4.13. Internal audits

4.13. Internal audits

4.13. Internal audits

4.13. Internal audits

4.14. Management review

4.14. Management review

4.14. Management review

4.14. Management review

5.2. Personnel

5.2. Personnel

5.2. Personnel

5.2. Personnel

5.3. Accomodation and environmental conditions

5.3. Accomodation and environmental conditions

5.3. Accomodation and environmental conditions

5.3. Accomodation and environmental conditions

5.4. Calibration methods and method validations

5.4. Calibration methods and method validations

5.4. Calibration methods and method validations

5.4. Calibration methods and method validations

5.4.5. Validation of methods

5.4.5. Validation of methods

5.4.6. Estimation of uncertainty of measurement

5.4.7. Control of data

5.4.7. Control of data

5.4.7. Control of data

5.5. Equipment

5.5. Equipment

5.5. Equipment

5.5. Equipment

5.5. Equipment

5.5. Equipment

5.6. Measurement traceability

5.6. Measurement traceability

5.6. Measurement traceability

5.6. Measurement traceability

5.6. Measurement traceability

5.6. Measurement traceability

5.6. Measurement traceability

5.8. Handling

5.8. Handling

5.9. Assuring the quality

5.10. Reporting the results

5.10. Reporting the results

5.10. Reporting the results

5.10. Reporting the results

5.10. Reporting the results

5.10.9. Amendments to calibration certificates

(a) A RIC must have the necessary facilities and


laboratory equipment

(a) A RIC must have the necessary facilities and


laboratory equipment

(a) A RIC must have the necessary facilities and


laboratory equipment

(b) A RIC must maintain a set of meteorological standard


instruments

(b) A RIC must maintain a set of meteorological standard


instruments

(b) A RIC must maintain a set of meteorological standard


instruments

(b) A RIC must maintain a set of meteorological standard


instruments

(b) A RIC must maintain a set of meteorological standard


instruments

(b) A RIC must maintain a set of meteorological standard


instruments

(c) A RIC must have qualified managerial and technical


staff

(c) A RIC must have qualified managerial and technical


staff

(c) A RIC must have qualified managerial and technical


staff

(c) A RIC must have qualified managerial and technical


staff

(c) A RIC must have qualified managerial and technical


staff

(c) A RIC must have qualified managerial and technical


staff

(d) A RIC must develop its individual technical


procedures for calibration

(d) A RIC must develop its individual technical


procedures for calibration

(d) A RIC must develop its individual technical


procedures for calibration

(e) A RIC must develop its individual quality assurance


procedures

(e) A RIC must develop its individual quality assurance


procedures

(e) A RIC must develop its individual quality assurance


procedures

(e) A RIC must develop its individual quality assurance


procedures

(f) A RIC must participate in, or organize inter-laboratory


comparisons

(f) A RIC must participate in, or organize inter-laboratory


comparisons

(g) A RIC must, as appropriate, utilize the resources and


capabilities of the Region

(h) A RIC must apply international standards applicable


for calibration laboratories

(h) A RIC must apply international standards applicable


for calibration laboratories

(h) A RIC must apply international standards applicable


for calibration laboratories

(h) A RIC must apply international standards applicable


for calibration laboratories

(i) A recognized authority must assess a RIC

(i) A recognized authority must assess a RIC

(i) A recognized authority must assess a RIC

(j) A RIC must assist Members of the Region in


calibrating their national meteorological standards

(j) A RIC must assist Members of the Region in


calibrating their national meteorological standards

(j) A RIC must assist Members of the Region in


calibrating their national meteorological standards

(k) A RIC must participate in or organize, WMO and/or


regional instrument intercomparisons

(l) According to relevant recommendations on the WMO


Quality Management Framework a RIC must contribute
positively to Members

(l) According to relevant recommendations on the WMO


Quality Management Framework a RIC must contribute
positively to Members

(m) A RIC must advise Members on inquiries regarding


instrument performance

(m) A RIC must advise Members on inquiries regarding


instrument performance

(n) A RIC must actively participate in, or assist in the


organization of regional workshops on meteorological

(n) A RIC must actively participate in, or assist in the


organization of regional workshops on meteorological

(o) The RIC must cooperate with other RICs in


standardization of meteorological

(p) A RIC must regularly inform Members and report to


the president of the Regional Association and to the
WMO Secretariat

(p) A RIC must regularly inform Members and report to


the president of the Regional Association and to the
WMO Secretariat

Global

CALCULATION GRID

QUESTIONS

Chapter 4: Management Requirements

Is the RIC's position clearly defined in the parent organisation structure?

Are RIC relationships with other services defined?

Are RIC and maintenance services clearly separated?

Are there policies and procedures relating to the protection of its clients confidential
information?

Are there organigrams describing internal RIC organization?

Are responsibility, authority and interrelationships of all personnel specified?

Has a member of staff been appointed as quality manager?

Have deputies been appointed for key personnel?

Do you have Quality Assurance procedures (Quality Manual)?

Is the quality manual appropriate to the scope of the RIC activities?

The date of the last update is?

Are objectives of RIC clearly documented (for instance in the quality policy statement)?

Does the quality manual include the structure of the documentation and the
responsibilities of technical staff and quality managers?

Are there procedures to control documents?

Are there instructions or procedure dealing with the review and approval of documents?

Are updates and modifications clearly identified in all documents?

Are the latest versions of documents promptly available?

Are all documents, included external sources, controlled?

Are the procedures for the review of requests and contracts established?

Are reviews and discussions with clients maintained?

Are you subcontracting some of your calibration works?

Are selecting criteria clearly defined?

Is the client advised of the subcontract?

Is a policy for purchasing supplies expressed?

Are the purchasing procedures written and validated?

Are the conformity criteria used for materials acceptance clearly defined, especially for
materials used in calibration works?

Is the evaluation of critical material suppliers performed?

Do you have a procedure or dispositions concerning relationship with your clients?

Are clients allowed to be present during your calibration work?

Is the confidentiality of clients ensured during all the process?

Do you have a policy for the resolution of clients' complaints?

Do you have procedure(s) for the resolution of clients' complaints?

Do you have a policy for the resolution of nonconforming work?

Do you have a procedure dealing with nonconforming calibration work?

In case of nonconforming work, is the responsibility for authorizing the resumption of


work defined?

Are dispositions taken in case of nonconforming calibration report?

Have you established a policy for implementing corrective actions when nonconforming
work has been identified?

Have you established a procedure(s) for implementing corrective action when


nonconforming work has been identified?

Are corrective actions monitored to ensure effectiveness?

Have you established procedure(s) for preventive actions?

Have you established procedure(s) for the control of quality and technical records?

Is the retention time of quality and technical records clearly established?

Are all records kept securely?

Are internal audits of RIC conducted periodically?

Have you established a procedure to schedule internal audits?

The period of internal audits is

All elements of the RIC quality system are covered by audits?

Have you established a schedule for quality system review?

Have you establish a procedure to organize quality system review?

The periodicity of such review is?

Are the decided actions recorded and reviewed regularly?

Chapter 5: Technical requirements

Have you established a policy for training of personnel?

Do you ensure that personnel are qualified to perform calibration work?

Is every job described in the quality system from managerial to technical staff?

Have you described competency and responsibility of every technical staff?

Does the RIC have all facilities to perform calibration work for the expressed
capabilities?

Are environmental conditions controlled and recorded?

Are measures taken for housekeeping of laboratory areas?

Do you have special dispositions dealing with neighboring areas (for instance
storage) ?

Do you have manuals for the use of all equipments used in calibration work?

Has the laboratory established instructions on the use and operation of all relevant
equipment?

Is the client informed by the laboratory of the method used for calibration?

Has a member of staff been appointed as technical manager (or equivalent), which is in
charge particularly of method selection and validation?

Has the laboratory validated its calibration methods?

Are clients' needs in term of performance and accuracy clearly defined?


Or are your capabilities in term of range, steps and accuracy clearly defined?

Do you apply a procedure to estimate the uncertainty of all calibration measurement


covered by quality system?

Are calculations and data transfers systematically under control or checked?

Have you developed and validated special software for calibration work?

Have you established a procedure(s) for data protection?

Does the RIC have all equipment to perform calibration work for each claimed
parameter?

Is the required accuracy specified for all equipment (reference standards in particular)?

Is every equipment (reference standard, particularly) uniquely identified?

Have you established records for all equipments?

Have you established instructions dealing with defective equipment or software?

Do you have special procedure(s) for equipment going out of your direct control?

Have you established a progamme for the calibration of reference standards and
associated systems?

Have you established a procedure(s) for the calibration of reference standards and
associated systems?

Can the RIC give real proofs of traceability to SI units for all reference standards and
associated equipments?

Do the calibration certificates of reference standards contain measurement results,


including the measurement uncertainty and/or a statement of compliance?

Have you performed regular checks to maintain confidence in the calibration status of
reference?

Have you established a procedure(s) for handling, transport, storage and use of your
reference standards?

Are you using equipments which are not able to ensure traceability to SI units?
(please add comments)

Have you established a procedure(s) for the transportation, receipt, storage of


instruments to be calibrated?

Have you established instructions for identifying such items?

Have you established a procedure(s) for monitoring the validity of your calibrations?

Are all relevant information and data reported in the calibration certificate given to the
client after calibration work?

If needed, are calibration data, which are obtained before and after adjustment or
reparation, reported?

Are you able to give opinion or interpretation to satisfy client requirements?

Are you able to give a compliance or non-compliance opinion?

Are compliance criteria reported in the calibration report?

Have you established instructions dealing with amendments of a calibration certificate?

REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRE

Does the RIC have all facilities to perform calibration work for the expressed
capabilities?

Are environmental conditions controlled and recorded?

Are measures taken for housekeeping of laboratory areas?

Does the RIC have all equipment to perform calibration work for each claimed
parameter?

Required accuracy is specified for all equipment (reference standards in particular)?

Is every equipment (reference standard, particularly) uniquely identified?

Have you established instructions dealing with defective equipment or software?

Have you established a programme for the calibration of reference standards and
associated systems?

Can the RIC give real proofs of traceability to SI units for all reference standards and
associated equipments?

Are there organigram describing internal RIC organization?

Are responsibility, authority and interrelationships of all personnel specified?

Have you establish a policy for training of personnel?

Do you ensure that personnel are qualified to perform calibration work?

Is every job described in the quality system from managerial to technical staff?

Have you described competency and responsibility of every technical staff?

Have the laboratory established instructions on the use and operation of all relevant
equipment?

Is the client informed by the laboratory of the method used for calibration?

Have you established a procedure(s) dealing with uncertainty associated with


calibration results?

Has a member of staff been appointed as technical manager (or equivalent), which is in
charge particularly of method selection and validation?

Do you have any Quality Assurance procedures (Quality Manual)?

Are objectives of RIC clearly documented (for instance in the quality policy statement)?

Do the quality procedures include the structure of the documentation and


responsibilities of technical and quality managers?

Have you organized or participated in an interlaboratory comparison?

Have results of intercomparison been published (for instance on WMO or RIC Web)?

Does the RIC have contact or meetings with other Members of the Region?

Is a member of staff responsible of RIC quality assurance?

Are RIC and maintenance service clearly separated?

Does the RIC apply international standards, such as ISO 17 025?

Is the laboratory certified or accredited against ISO 9001 or ISO 17025 standard?

Have you established a procedure to schedule internal audits?

The period of internal audits is

Have you been audited or evaluated within the last five years by a recognized
authority?

Have you external clients (external to organisation)?

Do you have Members (NMHSs) of the Region as client?

Have you received any demand concerning the calibration of national standards of
Members of the Region (NMHSs)?

Did you organize or participate in a WMO comparison campaign?

Have you calibrated instruments (transfer standards or other sensors) for other Region
Member(s) within the last five years?

Have you collaborated within instrument domain with other Region Member(s) within
the last five years?

Have you received demands dealing with instrument domain coming from other Region
Members?

Have you received demands of Region Members dealing with instrumental


documentation?

Have you contributed to the training of staff on instruments in the Region (workshop,
trainee)?

Have you participated in or organized workshop on metrology or instruments?

Have you had contact(s) with other RICs within the last five years?

Do you inform regularly Members, president of the Region and WMO Secretariat, about
your activities as RIC?

Have you a specialized web-site on your RIC activities?

weighted answer

weight

Mark (%) per line

Mark (%)
per chapter

99.5

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

1.5

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0%

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

Note du ss
chapitre/100

87

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

103

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

1.5

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0.00

0%

0%

0%

0%

0.00

1.5

0%

Chapter 4: Management Requirements

0%
Chapter Sheet
4.1 Organization

4.2 Quality
System

4.3. Documentation
Control

4.4 Review of
contracts

0%

0%

0%

0%

Management

Documentation

Customers

Suppliers

0%

0%

0%

0%

Synthesis

0%

Chapitre 5: Technical requirements

Chapter Sheet
5.2. Personnel

5.3.
Accomodation
and
environmental
conditions

5.4. Calibration
methods and
method validations

5.5. Equipment

0%

0%

0%

0%

Man Power

Mother Nature

Method

Machine
(Equipment)

Synthesis

0%

0%

0%

0%

0%
Tableau par sous-chapitre
(a) A RIC must
have the
necessary
facilities and
laboratory
equipment

(b) A RIC must


maintain a set of
meteorological
standard
instruments

(c) A RIC must


have qualified
managerial and
technical staff

(d) A RIC must


develop its
individual technical
procedures for
calibration

0%

0%

0%

0%

Method

Mind Power

Tableau par thme


Machine
(Equipment)

Man Power

0%

0%

0%

0%

0%

4.5
Subcontracting
of calibrations

4.6 Purchasing
supplies

4.7 Service to
client

4.8. Complaints

4.9 Control of
nonconforming
calibration work

0%

0%

0%

0%

0%

Improvment

0%

5.6.
Measurement
traceability

5.8. Handling

5.9. Assuring the


quality

5.10. Reporting
the results

0%

0%

0%

0%

Measurement
(Traceability)

Material
(Input/Output)

0%

0%

(e) A RIC must


(f) A RIC must
develop its
participate in, or
individual quality organize interassurance
laboratory
procedures
comparisons

0%

0%

(g) A RIC must,


as appropriate,
utilize the
resources and
capabilities of
the Region

(h) A RIC must


apply
international
standards
applicable for
calibration
laboratories

(i) A recognized
authority must
assess a RIC

0%

0%

0%

4.10 Corrective
action

4.11. Preventive
action

4.12. Technical
records

4.13. Internal
audits

4.14.
Management
review

0%

0%

0%

0%

0%

(l) According to
relevant
(n) A RIC must
(j) A RIC must
recommendation
(k) A RIC must
(m) A RIC must
actively
assist Members
s on the WMO
participate in or
advise Members participate in, or
of the Region in
Quality
organize, WMO
on inquiries
assist in the
calibrating their
Management
and/or regional
regarding
organization of
national
Framework a
instrument
instrument
regional
meteorological
RIC must
intercomparisons
performance
workshops on
standards
contribute
meteorological
positively to
Members

0%

0%

0%

0%

0%

(o) The RIC


must cooperate
with other RICs
in
standardization
of meteorological

(p) A RIC must


regularly inform
Members and
report to the
president of the
Regional
Association and
to the WMO
Secretariat

0%

0%

RIC:
Date:
Comments :

Chapter
RIC
4
5

RIC
Machine (Equipment)

Man Power

Method

Mind Power

SYNTHESIS

Topic

Score (%)

RIC
0%

Management requirements

0%

Technical requirements

0%

Global Score

0%

0%
(a) A RIC must have the necessary facilities and laboratory
equipment
(b) A RIC must maintain a set of meteorological standard
instruments

(c) A RIC must have qualified managerial and technical staff


(g) A RIC must, as appropriate, utilize the resources and capabilities
of the Region

(d) A RIC must develop its individual technical procedures for


calibration
(e) A RIC must develop its individual quality assurance procedures
(h) A RIC must apply international standards applicable for
calibration laboratories
(i) A recognized authority must assess a RIC

(f) A RIC must participate in, or organize inter-laboratory


comparisons

0%
0%

0%
0%

0%
0%
0%
0%

0%

(j) A RIC must assist Members of the Region in calibrating their


national meteorological standards
(k) A RIC must participate in or organize, WMO and/or regional
instrument intercomparisons
(l) According to relevant recommendations on the WMO Quality
Management Framework a RIC must contribute positively to
Members
(m) A RIC must advise Members on inquiries regarding instrument
performance
(n) A RIC must actively participate in, or assist in the organization
of regional workshops on meteorological
(o) The RIC must cooperate with other RICs in standardization of
meteorological
(p) A RIC must regularly inform Members and report to the president
of the Regional Association and to the WMO Secretariat

0%
0%

0%
0%
0%
0%

0%

Global

#REF!

#REF!

#REF!

#REF!

#REF!

#REF!

Caption:
0 < N <40%

Not performing

40% < N < 60%

Need improvments

60% < N < 80%

Satisfactory

80% < N < 100% Good

Global Results

RIC
100%
75%
50%
0%25%
0%
0%0%
Technical requirements

Management requirements

Chapter 4 Results

Management
100%
75%
Improvment

50%
25%
0%
0% 0%
0%
0%0%

Suppliers

Please, to validate the graph click the


button

Documentation

Customers

Chapter 5 Results

Man Power
100%
75%
50%
25%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%

Material (Input/Output)

Measurement (Traceability)

Mother Nature

Method
Machine (Equipment)

Please, to validate the graph click the


button

RIC Results

Machine (Equipment)
100%
75%
50%

Mind Power

25%
0%
0%0%0%
0%

Method

Please, to validate the graph click the


button

Man Power

Regional Instrument Centre


Region:
Name:
Address:
Country
Phone./Fax :
Web :
Contact :
Regional Instruments Center with
Full capacities
Basic Capacities

ITEMS BELOW MUST BE IMPROVED

Topic

4.1 Organization

4.1 Organization

4.1 Organization
4.1 Organization
4.2 Quality System
4.2 Quality System
4.2 Quality System
4.3. Documentation Control

4.3. Documentation Control


4.3. Documentation Control

4.4 Review of contracts

4.6 Purchasing supplies

Domains

4.6 Purchasing supplies

4.6 Purchasing supplies


4.7 Service to client

4.7 Service to client


4.8. Complaints

4.8. Complaints

4.9 Control of nonconforming calibration work

4.9 Control of nonconforming calibration work

4.9 Control of nonconforming calibration work


4.9 Control of nonconforming calibration work

4.10 Corrective action


4.10 Corrective action
4.10 Corrective action

4.11. Preventive action


4.12. Technical records
4.12. Technical records
4.14. Management review
4.14. Management review

5.2. Personnel
5.2. Personnel

5.2. Personnel
5.2. Personnel
5.3. Accomodation and environmental conditions

5.3. Accomodation and environmental conditions

5.3. Accomodation and environmental conditions


5.4. Calibration methods and method validations

5.4. Calibration methods and method validations


5.4. Calibration methods and method validations

5.4.7. Control of data


5.4.7. Control of data
5.5. Equipment
5.5. Equipment
5.5. Equipment
5.5. Equipment
5.5. Equipment
5.5. Equipment
5.6. Measurement traceability

5.6. Measurement traceability


5.6. Measurement traceability
5.6. Measurement traceability
5.8. Handling
5.8. Handling

5.9. Assuring the quality


5.10. Reporting the results
5.10. Reporting the results

(a) A RIC must have the necessary facilities and laboratory equipm
(a) A RIC must have the necessary facilities and laboratory equipm

(b) A RIC must maintain a set of meteorological standard instrume


(b) A RIC must maintain a set of meteorological standard instrume

(b) A RIC must maintain a set of meteorological standard instrume


(b) A RIC must maintain a set of meteorological standard instrume
(b) A RIC must maintain a set of meteorological standard instrume

(b) A RIC must maintain a set of meteorological standard instrume

(c) A RIC must have qualified managerial and technical staff


(c) A RIC must have qualified managerial and technical staff

(c) A RIC must have qualified managerial and technical staff


(c) A RIC must have qualified managerial and technical staff
(c) A RIC must have qualified managerial and technical staff

(d) A RIC must develop its individual technical procedures for calib
(d) A RIC must develop its individual technical procedures for calib
(d) A RIC must develop its individual technical procedures for calib
(e) A RIC must develop its individual quality assurance procedures
(e) A RIC must develop its individual quality assurance procedures
(e) A RIC must develop its individual quality assurance procedures
(f) A RIC must participate in, or organize inter-laboratory comparis
(h) A RIC must apply international standards applicable for calibrat

(h) A RIC must apply international standards applicable for calibrat


(h) A RIC must apply international standards applicable for calibrat
(i) A recognized authority must assess a RIC
(j) A RIC must assist Members of the Region in calibrating their na

(j) A RIC must assist Members of the Region in calibrating their na

(l) According to relevant recommendations on the WMO Quality M


(l) According to relevant recommendations on the WMO Quality M

(m) A RIC must advise Members on inquiries regarding instrument


(n) A RIC must actively participate in, or assist in the organizati
(o) The RIC must cooperate with other RICs in standardization of
(p) A RIC must regularly inform Members and report to the preside

REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRE EVALUATION SCHEME

Question
Chapter 4: Management Requirements

Are RIC relationships with other services defined?

Are there policies and procedures relating to the protection of its clients confidential information?

Are responsibility, authority and interrelationships of all personnel specified?


Has a member of staff been appointed as quality manager?
Do you have Quality Assurance procedures (Quality Manual)?
Is the quality manual appropriate to the scope of the RIC activities?
Are objectives of RIC clearly documented (for instance in the quality policy statement)?
Are there procedures to control documents?

Are there instructions or procedure dealing with the review and approval of documents?
Are the latest versions of documents promptly available?

Are the procedures for the review of requests and contracts established?

Is a policy for purchasing supplies expressed?

Are the purchasing procedures written and validated?

Are the evaluation of critical material suppliers performed?


Do you have a procedure or dispositions concerning relationship with your clients?

Is the confidentiality of clients ensured during all the process?


Do you have a policy for the resolution of clients' complaints?

Do you have procedure(s) for the resolution of clients' complaints?

Do you have a policy for the resolution of nonconforming work?

Do you have a procedure dealing with nonconforming calibration work?

In case of nonconforming work, is the responsibility for authorizing the resumption of work defined?
Are dispositions taken in case of nonconforming calibration report?

Have you established a policy for implementing corrective actions when nonconforming work has been identified?
Have you established a procedure(s) for implementing corrective action when nonconforming work has been identified?
Are corrective actions monitored to ensure effectiveness?

Have you established procedure(s) for preventive actions?


Have you established procedure(s) for the control of quality and technical records?
Is the retention time of quality and technical records clearly established?
Have you established a schedule for quality system review?
Have you establish a procedure to organize quality system review?

Chapitre 5: Technical requirements


Have you established a policy for training of personnel?
Do you ensure that personnel is qualified to perform calibration work?

Is every job described in the quality system from managerial to technical staff?
Have you described competency and responsibility of every technical staff?
Does the RIC have all facilities to perform calibration work for the expressed capabilities?

Are environmental conditions controlled and recorded?

Do you have special dispositions dealing with neighbouring areas (for instance storage) ?
Has the laboratory established instructions on the use and operation of all relevant equipment?

Is the client informed by the laboratory of the method used for calibration?
Has a member of staff been appointed as technical manager (or equivalent), which is in charge particularly of method sele

Have you developed and validated special software for calibration work?
Have you established a procedure(s) for data protection?
Does the RIC have all equipment to perform calibration work for each claimed parameter?
Is the required accuracy specified for all equipment (reference standards in particular)?
Is every equipment (reference standard, particularly) uniquely identified?
Have you established records for each equipment?
Have you established instructions dealing with defective equipment or software?
Do you have special procedure(s) for equipment going out of your direct control?
Have you established a progamme for the calibration of reference standards and associated systems?

Have you established a procedure(s) for the calibration of reference standards and associated systems?
Can the RIC give real proofs of traceability to SI units for all reference standards and associated equipments?
Have you performed regular checks to maintain confidence in the calibration status of reference?
Have you established a procedure(s) for the transportation, receipt, storage of instruments to be calibrated?
Have you established instructions for identifying such items?

Have you established a procedure(s) for monitoring the validity of your calibrations?
Are all relevant information and data reported in the calibration certificate given to the client after calibration work?
If needed, are calibration data, which are obtained before and after adjustment or reparation, reported?

REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRE

Does the RIC have all facilities to perform calibration work for the expressed capabilities?
Are environmental conditions controlled and recorded?

Does the RIC have all equipment to perform calibration work for each claimed parameter?
Required accuracy is specified for all equipment (reference standards in particular)?

Is every equipment (reference standard, particularly) uniquely identified?


Have you established instructions dealing with defective equipment or software?
Have you established a programme for the calibration of reference standards and associated systems?

Can the RIC give real proofs of traceability to SI units for all reference standards and associated equipments?

Are responsibility, authority and interrelationships of all personnel specified?


Have you establish a policy for training of personnel?

Do you ensure that personnel is qualified to perform calibration work?


Is every job described in the quality system from managerial to technical staff?
Have you described competency and responsibility of every technical staff?

Have the laboratory established instructions on the use and operation of all relevant equipment?
Is the client informed by the laboratory of the method used for calibration?
Have you established a procedure(s) dealing with uncertainty associated with calibration results?
Has a member of staff been appointed as technical manager (or equivalent), which is in charge particularly of method sele
Do you have any Quality Assurance procedures (Quality Manual)?
Are objectives of RIC clearly documented (for instance in the quality policy statement)?
Have you organized or participated in an interlaboratory comparison?
Is a member of staff responsible of RIC quality assurance?

Does the RIC apply international standards, such as ISO 17 025?


Are the laboratory certified or accredited against ISO 9001 or ISO 17025 standard?
Have you been audited or evaluated within the last five years by a recognised authority?
Do you have Members (NMHSs) of the Region as client?

Have you received any demand concerning the calibration of national standards of Members of the Region (NMHSs)?

Have you calibrated instruments (transfer standards or other sensors) for other Region Member(s) within the last five yea
Have you collaborated within instrument domain with other Region Member(s) within the last five years?

Have you received demands dealing with instrument domain coming from other Region Members?
Have you participated in or organised workshop on metrology or instruments?
Have you had contact(s) with other RICs within the last five years?
Do you inform regularly Members, president of the Region and WMO Secretariat, about your activities as RIC?

Your answer

Yes

Help
4.1.5 The laboratory shall
e) define the organization and management structure of the
laboratory, its place in any parent organization and the
relationships...
4.1.5 The laboratory shall have policies and procedures to
ensure the protection of its clients confidental information...

Yes
4.1.5 The laboratory shall specify the responsability,
authority and interrelationships of all personnel...
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

4.1.5 The laboratory shall appoint a member of staff as quality manager who shall have authority for
4.2.2 The laboratory's quality system policies and objectives shall be defined in a quality manual...
4.2.1 The laboratoy shall establish, implement and maintain a quality system appropriate to the scope o
4.2.2 The averall objectives shall be documented in a quality policy statement...
4.3.1 The laboratory shall establish and maintain procedures to control all documents...

Yes

4.3.2 All documents shall be reviewed and approved


Do not used old or not approuved documents.
Reviewed does not mean revised.
4.3.2.2 The procedure(s) adopted shall ensure that
An electronic way is possible..

Yes

4.4.1 The laboratory shall establish procedures for the review


of contracts...
This part concerns all clients included internal, other members
even when the service is free of charge.

n/a

4.6.1 The laboratory shall have a policy and procedure(s) for


purchasing supplies...
Purchasing can be subcontract to a specific department.

Yes

4.6.1 The laboratory shall have a policy and procedure(s) for


purchasing supplies...
n/a

n/a
Yes

4.6.4 The laboratory shall evaluate suppliers of critical


consumables...
But you can also evaluate the others suppliers...
4.7 The laboratory shall affords clients or their representatives cooperation to clarify the client's request
4.7 that the laboratory ensures confidentiality to other
clients.

Rather Yes
Rather Yes

4.8 The laboratory shall have a policy and procedures for the resolution of complaints...

Rather Yes

4.8 The laboratory shall have a policy and procedures for the
resolution of complaints...
Internal or external. Delay, nonconforming work
Policy defines actions.
Procedure defines how to act.

Yes

4.9.1 The laboratory shall have a policy and procedures that


shall be implemented when any aspect of the calibration work
do not conform...
Work were done as it shall be?
Policy defines actions.
Procedure defines how to act.

Rather Yes

4.9.1 The laboratory shall have a policy and procedures that


shall be implemented when any aspect of the calibration work
do not conform...
Work were done as it shall be?
Policy defines actions.
Procedure defines how to act.

Yes
Yes

4.9.1 The policy and procedures shall ensure that the


responsabilities are designated...
Note Identification of nonconforming work can occur at various
places within the quality system and technical operations...
5.10.9 Material amendments to calibration certificate after issue shall be made only in the form of a furt

Yes
Yes
Rather Not

4.10.1 The laboratory shall establish a policy and


procedurefor implementing corrective action when
nonconforming workhave been identified.
Policy defines actions.
Procedure defines how to act.
4.10.1 The laboratory shall ...designate appropriate authorities for implementing corrective action when
4.10.4 The laboratory shall monitor the results to ensure that corrective actions taken have been effecti

Rather Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

4.11.1 Needed improvements shall be identified...


4.11.2 Procedures for preventive actions shall include the
initiation...
4.12.1 The laboratory shall establish and maintain procedures for identificationof quality and technica
4.12.1.2 Retentions times of records shall be establish.
4.14.1 The laboratory's executive management shall periodically conduct a review of the laboratory's
4.14.1 In accordance with a predetermined schedule and procedure, the laboratory's executive manage

Rather Yes
Yes

4.14.2 Findings from management reviews and the actions that arasie from them shall be recorded...
5.2 The laboratory management shall ensure the competence of all who operateand sign calibration

Yes
Rather Yes
Yes

5.2.4 The laboratory shall maintain current job descriptions for


managerial, technical and key support personnel involved in
calibrations
Note At least, responsabilities, competences and
responsabilities shall be defined.
5.2.5 The management shall authorize specific personnel to perform particularcalibrationThe lab
5.3 Laboratory facilities for calibration..; shall be such as to facilitate calibrations.

Yes

5.3.1 That laboratory shall ensure that the environmental


conditions do not invalidate the results of any measurement.
5.3.2 The laboratory shall monitor, control and records
environmental conditions ...

Rather Not
Rather Yes

5.3.3 There shall be effective separation between


neighbouring areas
5.3.4 Access to and use of areas affecting the quality of the
calibrations shall be controlled ...
5.4.1 The laboratory shall have instructions on the use and operation of all relevant equipment...

Yes
No

5.4.2 The laboratory shall use calibrations methods which


meet the needs of the clients
The laboratory shall inform the client
Even an internal client.
5.4.2 the laboratory shall select appropriate methods...

Rather Yes
Rather Yes
Yes
Yes
Rather Yes
Yes
Rather Yes
Rather Not
Yes

5.4.7.2 When computer or automated equipment are used for


the acquisition, the laboratory shall ensure that
Not necessary, calibration can be performed only manually.
But even an Excelsheet must be validated.
5.4.7.2 When computer or automated equipment are used for the acquisition, the laboratory shall ensu
5.5.1 The laboratory shall be furnished with all items of measurement for the correct performance of the
5.5.2 Equipment and its sofware use for calibration shall be capable of achieving the accuracy requiere
5.5.4 Each item of equipment used for calibration shall be uniquely identified.
5.5.5 Records shall be maintained of each item of equipment...
5.5.7 Equipment that has been subjected to overloadingshall be taken out of service. It shall beclea
5.5.9 When equipment goes outside the direct control of the laboratory ...
5.6.1 the laboratory shall have an established progamme and procedure for the calibration of its equ

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Rather Yes

5.6.1 the laboratory shall have an established progamme


and procedure for the calibration of its equipment.
Programme defines when
Prodedure defines how.
5.6.2.1.1 For calibration laboratories, the programme for calibration of equipment shall be designed an
5.6.3.3 Checks needed to maintain confidence in the calibration status of reference shall be carried o
5.8.1 The laboratory shall have procedures for the transportation, receiptof calibration items, to prote
5.8.2 The laboratory shall have a system for identifying calibration items...

Rather Not
Yes
n/a

5.9 The laboratory shall have quality control procedures for


monitoring the validity of calibrations undertaken
For instance interlaboratory comparisons.
5.10.1 The results of each calibration, or series of calibrations carried out by the laboratory shall be rep
5.10.4.3 When an instrument for calibration has been adjusted or repaired, the calibration results befor

Yes
Yes

5.3.1 The laboratory shall ensure that the environmental


conditions do not invalidate the results of any measurement.
5.3.2 The laboratory shall monitor, control and records
environmental conditions ...
5.3.5 Measures shall be taken to ensure good housekeeping in the laboratory...

Yes
Yes

5.5.2 Equipment and its sofware use for calibration shall be


capable of achieving the accuracy requiered
Especially when you buy a new equipment
5.5.4 Each item of equipment used for calibration shall be uniquely identified.
5.5.7 Equipment that has been subjected to overloading
shall be taken out of service. It shall beclearly labelled

Rather Yes
Rather Yes
Yes

5.6.1 the laboratory shall have an established progamme and procedure for the calibration of its equ
5.6.2.1.1 For calibration laboratories, the programme for calibration of equipment shall be designed an

Yes

4.1.5 The laboratory shall specify the responsability, authority


and interrelationships of all personnel...
It is dealing with internal RIC organization.

Yes
Rather Yes

5.2.2 The laboratory shall have a policy and procedures for


identifying training needs and providing traininng of
personnel
Policy defines what.
Procedure defines how.
5.2 The laboratory management shall ensure the competence of all who operateand sign calibration

Yes
Yes
Rather Yes

5.2.4 The laboratory shall maintain current job descriptions for


managerial, technical and key support personnel involved in
calibrations
Note At least, responsabilities, competences and
responsabilities shall be defined.
5.2.5 The management shall authorize specific personnel to perform particularcalibrationThe lab
5.4.1 The laboratory shall have instructions on the use and operation of all relevant equipment...

Rather Yes
Yes
Rather Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

5.4.2 The laboratory shall use calibrations methods which


meet the needs of the clients
The laboratory shall inform the client
Even an internal client.
5.4.6.1 A calibration laboratoryshall have and shall apply a procedure to estimate the uncertainty of m
5.4.2 the laboratory shall select appropriate methods...
4.2.2 The laboratory's quality system policies and objectives shall be defined in a quality manual...
4.2.2 The averall objectives shall be documented in a quality policy statement...
Sum up of chapter 4.2.3 et 4.2.4 concerning quality manual includes.
5.6.2.1.2 Participation in a suitable programme of interlaboratory comparisons is required when poss
4.1.4 If the laboratory is part of an organization, the responsabilities of key personnel shall be defin

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

If accredited (certified) attach a copy of your accreditation(s) or


certification or a link to certification or accreditation organism
If you are both accredited and certified, tick manually the two
check boxes (out of application)
4.13.1 The laboratory shall periodically, and in accordance with a predetermined schedule and procedu
Have you external clients such as other governemental agencies, private companies...?
Have you NMHS of the Region as client?

No

5.6.2.1.2 Participation in a suitable programme of


interlaboratory comparisons is required when possible
This paragraph can be generalised to every kind of sensor and
not only laboratory instruments.
This item appies only on full capability RIC

Yes
Rather Not

5.6.2.1.1 For calibration laboratories, the programme for


calibration of equipment shall be designed and operated to
ensure are traceable to SI units.
Are some Region Members traceable via your RIC?
Could be any collaboration dealing with instrument domain.
Any inquiries regarding instrument such as performance,
performed tests, maintenance.

No
No
Rather Yes
Rather Not

Workshop are useful to disseminate the metrology.


Working together to improve the skill of each other.
A report must be send to RA and WMO every year.

o shall have authority for ensuring that the quality system is followed at all times.
n a quality manual...
appropriate to the scope of its activities...

clarify the client's request...

e only in the form of a further document...

ng corrective action when nonconforming workhave been identified


s taken have been effective.

nof quality and technical records...

review of the laboratory's quality system.


atory's executive management shall periodically conduct a review of the laboratory's quality system..

em shall be recorded...
ateand sign calibration certificates.

larcalibrationThe laboratory shall maintain records of the relevant autorisation(s)

elevant equipment...

the laboratory shall ensure thatprocedures are established and implemented for protecting the data...
orrect performance of the calibrations...
ng the accuracy requiered...

f service. It shall beclearly labelled...

r the calibration of its equipment.

ment shall be designed and operated to ensure are traceable to SI units....


rence shall be carried out...
calibration items, to protect the integrity...

he laboratory shall be reported accurately, clearly, unambiguously and objectively...


e calibration results before shall be reported.

r the calibration of its equipment.


ment shall be designed and operated to ensure are traceable to SI units.

ateand sign calibration certificates.

larcalibrationThe laboratory shall maintain records of the relevant autorisation(s)


elevant equipment...

mate the uncertainty of measurement for all calibrations...

n a quality manual...

ns is required when possible


personnel shall be defined in order to identify potential conflicts of interest.

ed schedule and procedure, conduct internal audits of its activities...

Anda mungkin juga menyukai