B. Lepski, University of Alberta, Z. Bassiouni, Louisiana State University, J.M. Wolcott, FIA
Solutions
Copyright 1998, Sodoty of Petroleum Engineers, Inc.
This paper was preparad for presentaron at the 1998 SPE/DOE Improved Oil
Recovery Symposium held in Tulsa, Oklahoma, 19-22 April 1998.
This paper was selected for presentation by an SPE Program Committee
following review of information contained in an abstrae! submitted by the
author(s). Contents of the paper, as presented, have not been reviewed by the
Sodety of Petroleum Engineers and are subject to correction by the author(s)
The material, as presented, does not necassarily reflect any position of the
Society of Petroleum Engineers, its officers, or members, Papers presented at
SPE meetings are subject to publication review by Editorial Committees of the
Society of Petroleum Engineers, Electronic reproduction, distribution, or storage
of any part of this paper for commercia! purposes without the written consent of
the Society of Petroleum Engineers is prohibited. Pormission to reproduce in
print is restricted to an abstract of not more than 300 words; illustrations may
not be copied, The abstract must contain conspicuous acknowledgment of
where and by whom the paper was presented. Write Libraran, SPE, P.O. Box
833836, Richardson, TX 75083-3836, U.S.A., fax 01-972-952-9435.
Abstract
Corefloods and field investigations confirmed that
incremental oil can be recovered from dipping waterdrive reservoirs using gravity assisted gas injection
processes such as Double Displacement Process
(DDP), and Second Contact Water Displacement
(SCWD). Transparent cell experiments support the
presumption of film flow of water-displacementresidual oil and the dependeney of these methods
efficiency on fluid distribution within the pore space.
The ability of oil to form a film is quantitatively
expressed by the spreading coefficient defined in terms
of interfacial and surface tensions of the phases
involved.
The drop volume and pendant drop techniques
were adapted to provide rapid and convenient methods
for the measurement of IFT at high-pressure and high
temperature conditions. The interfacial and surface
tensin properties of several fluid systems were
investigated.
IFT measurements of systems used in the corefloods support the belief that a positive spreading
coefficient is needed for an efficient recovety of
residual oil. IFT measurements proved also that
injection of nitrogen is more beneficial than methane to
the creation of an oil film that Controls incremental oil
recovery efficiency.
The simplicity of the adapted IFT setup, combined
with its ability to perform a large number of
measurements, may result in the development of an
empirical screening criteria needed in the selection of
reservoirs suitable for DDP and SCWD processes.
Introduction
The Double Displacement Process (DDP) involves updip gas injection in a water-invaded oil zone in order to
mobilize and produce incremental oil 1. The incremental
oil results from the difference in residual oil saturation
in the presence of water as compared to that in the
presence of gas. Gravity stable displacement causes the
formation of an oil bank which collects oil as it
migrates downward in the reservoir towards the
producing well. A simplified schematic of a DDP
candidate reservoir is shown in Fig. 1. Under favorable
reservoir conditions, incremental oil on the order of
40% of the initial oil-in-place may be recovered using
DDP. The schematic of the reservoir subjected to DDP
is shown in Fig. 2. When conditions are favorable, the
duration of the DDP may be shortened by introducing
Second Contact Water Displacement (SCWD). SCWD
is an extensin of the DDP and in principie gas
injection is followed with down-dip water invasin,
preferentially from a strong water aquifer. Schematic
illustrating the SCWD is shown in Fig. 3.
In order to recover water-displacement-residual
oil, we must restore its effective permeability. By
~
0
@og ~
)
Con"
Where:
S'o w = final spreading coefficient of oil over water,
mN/m awg = water - gas interfacial tensin, mN/m
cr0g = oil - gas interfacial tensin, mN/m cxow = oil
- water interfacial tensin, mN/m.
When S'uw is positive, oil tends to spread on water
and form a continuous film. When S'(l is negative, oil
does not spread on water.
Several investigators reported that highest oil
recoveries in water-wet media were observed for
positive S'ow fluid system11,12. Lower oil recoveries in
oil-wet media were attributed to capillary retention
forces. There was no detectable difference between
positive and negative S'o/w fluid systems in oil-wet
experiments11. Both drainage and imbibition oil relative
permeabilities were higher for positive- spreading
coefficient12.
The spreading coefficient is the key to the
feasibility of the DDP. Representative vales of
interfacial tensin between each pair of fluids involved
are needed to estmate the spreading coefficient.
10
Interfacial Tensin
and J.M.
Pendant
Drop.
B. LEPSKI, Z. BASSIOUNI,
WOLCOTT
(2)
y=0.12836-0.75775+1.7713^-0.54253
(3)
R0 = 4/[2(0.9987+0.1971/2-0.0734^ 2-QM/3j)]
(4)
methane. A Through Window Ruska PVT Cell Model 2329800-00 (Fig. 6) and Ruska Constant Temperature Air Bath
Model 2320 were adapted to IFT measurements. High
pressure, positive displacement pump was used for fluid
injections. Recombined oil was injected via a transfer vessel
with distilled water as driving fluid. The transfer vessel used
for IFT measurements has a capacity of 250 cc. Transfer
vessel was heated in the air bath together with PVT Cell.
The system upper pressure and temperature limits are 5000
psi and 350 F. These ranges cover conditions common to
candidate reservoirs. A schematic of the setup used for IFT
measurements is shown in Fig. 7.
In order to perform the measurement with sufficient
accuracy and simplicity, the pendant drop formed in the
PVT Cell was filmed using a video camera equipped with a
set of additional close-ups. The video camera was capable
of magnication up to 16X using optical zoom and 160X
using digital zoom. Magnifcation scale used for
measurements varied from 12 to 15 X. The image produced
by this optical system was free from noticeable optical
distortions. The video camera signal was taped on VCR
using a high-grade tape to improve the quality of still
images. Selected frames containing images of the drop were
later transferred to a Computer using the Frame Capture
software. Frame Capture software provided resolution up to
1500x1125. Drop dimensions were later measured using
Jandel SigmaScan measuring software. A typical pendant
drop as displayed by the SigmaScan software is shown in
Fig. 8.
For pendant drop IFT measurements, the high pressure
Ruska PVT Cell was adapted to accommodate a detachable
capillary. In our case, a 22 gauge (2.0955 mm OD) syringe
needle, which was cut and polished to obtain a fat top was
used. The capillary mount was made from a standard
surgical Steel syringe connector cut out from the syringe
and screwed on a piece of 1/8 stainless Steel tubing fitted
with a standard 1/8 Swagelok connector. One of the PVT
Cell endcaps was adapted to accommodate a 1/8 standard
Swagelok connector, which served as an inlet for measured
Where:
Ap = measured fluid density difference,
kg/m3 g = gravitational constant, m/s2 4=
mximum drop diameter, m S = shape
factor, S = d/de, as shown in Fig. 4.
An IFT measurement using Drop Volume method is
made by pumping the light phase into the dense phase at
constant flow rate. Drops form at the tip of the specially
designed capillary, Fig. 5, and IFT is calculated using Eq. 5.
cr, = [ Vl/mp(pH-pL)g]/(nd)
Where:
pH = density of the heavy phase, kg/m3 pL
= density of the light phase, kg/m3 Vdmp =
volume of the drop, m3 g = acceleration of
gravity, m/s2 d = inside diameter of the tip,
m
To avoid necessary corrections due to liquid that can
wet and accumulate on the tip, a very sharp tip is used17.
In case of hydrocarbon mixtures, surface tensin can be
also calculated based on the composition of the mixture at
given pressure and temperature18. Empirical correlations to
calclate surface tensin of oil exist19. There is no widely
accepted method of calculating water-hydrocarbon gas and
water-oil interfacial tensions. Methods proposed to estmate
gas-water IFT and oil-water IFT, are rather inaccurate 20,21.
The effect of dissolved solids in water in both cases is
unknown22.
Interfacial
Tensin
Reservoir Conditions
Measurements
Under
39659
39659 fluids.
SCREENING
OF OIL
ASSISTED
GAS
The schematic of the capillary
housing
is RESERVOIRS
shown in FOR GRAVITY
rather than
dozens
ofINJECTION
drops provide some beneflts for
Fig. 9.
measurements where time is a factor such as those involving
The size of the capillary was similar to the sizes
strong surfactant solutions. Since only the volume of the
typically used for IFT measurements performed by the oil
drop is required for IFT calculation, assuming the drop to be
industry2 . The selection of the capillary size and resulting
spherical only the diameter of the drop need be measured.
drop size was also determined by the size of the window of
Distances were calibrated using OD of the capilllary tip.
the Ruska PVT cell (6.35 mm wide). Depending on the
This simplifled method can be further refined using
measured fluid system density difference, the capillary was
sophisticated volume calculation considering the actual
mounted in the top or in the bottom of the PVT cell as
shape of the drop. An example of drop volume processing is
shown in Fig. 10. Since the drop had to be visible, the
shown in Fig. 12.
continuous phase had to be transparent.
If gas is bubbled through the liquid at ambient pressure,
Pendant drops were formed by injecting the
the bubble rapidly expands after it leaves the capillary,
discontinuous phase at a very slow, constant injection rate,
yielding invalid measurement. At higher pressure, the
(lcc/hr) to avoid IFT changes due to aging time differences.
pressure required to overcome the gas-liquid interface is
The videotape frames containing an image of the hanging
rather negligible compared to the bubble pressure, thus the
drops were captured, saved as bitmaps and later
bubble forms a regular spherical-like shape similar to that of
downloaded into the measurement software.
a liquid drop in a liquid-liquid system. A high-pressure gas
The measurements were performed using the
bubble is shown in Fig. 13.
uncalibrated pixel option to speed up processing. Distance
A difficulty in using the drop volume method for
calibrations and IFT calculations were later performed using
liquid/gas IFT (i.e., surface tensin measurements) arises,
spreadsheet Computer application. Distances were
however, from the wettability of the capillary tip in the
calibrated using the outer diameter (OD) of the capillary.
presence of gas. In the presence of gas, liquid is strongly
The OD was measured within 0.00 lmm accuracy using a
attracted to the tip, which causes liquid to climb over the tip.
micrometer.
Drop volume IFT measurements were made by
Analysis of Interfacial Tensin Measurements
pumping the light phase into the dense phase at a slow
Interfacial Tensin (IFT) measurements were performed to
constant flow rate. Drops formed at the tip of the specially
calclate spreading coefficient for fluid systems used in
designed capillary, and the volume of the drop was
corefloods experiments24,25. Measurements used for
calculated from the injection rate and the number of drops
spreading coefficient calculations were performed using
formed within a specifc time period.
pendant drop method. An average of five independently
The drop volume IFT measurements were performed
calculated vales of IFT based on five independently
using the same setup as for the Pendant Drop measurements
processed drops were used to calclate IFT at each pressure
with the positive displacement pomp used for liquid
and temperature settings.
injection. A helical-shaped spiral of about 40 cc was used
Densities of liquids for different pressure and
instead of the 250 cc transfer vessel used in the Pendant
temperature settings were calculated using standard fluid
Drop study to minimize flow rate instabilities due to
correlations26. Gas densities were interpolated from
temperature fluctuations. Since the drop size was small, in
published tables27 assuming linear distribution between
the range of 3050 |iL, fluid volume changes were able to
known pressure and temperature points. IFT experimental
cause flow rate fluctuations when large volumes of liquid
setup was checked against published vales of IFT and
were" involved. Again, distilled, degassed water was used
surface tensin at ambient conditions. Surface tensions were
as driving fluid with the 50K ppm KC1 brine used as buffer
measured for pur water, heptane and dichloromethane in
between measured sample and driving fluid. Injection rates
presence of air at 26.4 C and compared with published
varied from 1 cc/hr to 4 cc/hr depending on the size of the
vales28. Interfacial Tensin was measured for heptane/water
drop. In order to seal the tip at elevated temperature, the
and dichloromethane/water systems and also compared with
manufacturis leaking Teflon fltting was replaced with a
published vales17. In all cases, experimental vales obtained
standard 1/16 Swagelok steel fitting screwed on the top of
with pendant drop setup were within 5% range from the
1/16-1/8 nipple. This arrangement provided metal to
published vales. A comparison of measured and published
metal seal between the nipple and the capillary. The nipple
vales is given in Fig.
was then mounted in the Ruska PVT cell using standard
14. The summary of IFT measurements performed for
1/8 connector.
experimental coreflood fluid systems is given in
Capillary tip design is critical to the precisin and
Table 1. The resulting spreading coefficient vales
simplicity of Drop Volume methods. The tip has to be very
are given in Fig. 15.
sharp so the drop is attached to a well-defined circle rather
In
addition
to spreading coefficient measurements,
than to the rim. The design of the tip is shown in Fig. 11. In
surface
tensin
measurements
of 50 K ppm NaCl brine in
our study the Krtiss 0.254 mm ID and 1.5596 mm OD tip
presence
of
methane
and
nitrogen
were also conducted.
was used.
Selected
pressure
settings
were
1500,
2000, 2500, 3000,
An IFT calculation method using image processing is
3500 psia and temperature settings of 52.5, 66.8, 78.8, 95.4,
proposed. The ability to measure IFT based on several drops
11
10
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
39659
39659
8.
9.
OF OIL RESERVOIRS
1996 SPE Annual SCREENING
Technical Conference
and FOR GRAVITY
14. ASSISTED
Padday, GAS
J.F.: INJECTION
Surface Tensin, Surface and
Exhibition, Denver, CO, October 6-9.
Colloid Science, John Wiley & Sons, New York
(1969).
6. Bensaid, F.: Effects of Dip Angle, Absolute
Permeability and Relative Permeability on the
15. Ambwani D.S., Tomilson Jr, F.: "Pendant Drop
Technique for Measuring Liquid Boundary
Double Displacement Process, Thesis, LSU,
Tensin, Surface and Colloid Science, John Wiley
Baton Rouge, 1995.
& Sons, New York (1979) 93.
7. Kantzas, A., Chatzis, I., Dullien, F. A. L.:
16. Herd, M.D., Lassahn, G.D., Thomas C.P., Bala
"Enhanced Oil Recovery by Inert Gas Injection",
G.A.:"Interfacial
Tensions
of
Microbial
paper SPE/DOE No. 17379 presented at the
Surfactants Determined by Real-Time Video
SPE/DOE Enhanced Oil Recovery Symposium in
Imaging of Pendant Drops", SPE/DOE No. 24206
Tulsa, Oklahoma, April 17-20, 1988.
presented at the SPE/DOE Eight Symposium on
Chatzis, I., Kantzas, A., Dullien, F. A. L.:
"On
Enhanced Oil Recovery in Tulsa, Oklahoma, April
the
22-24, 1992.
Investigation
of
Gravity-Assisted
Inert
Gas
17. Gilman, L.B.: "A Review of Instruments for Static
and Dynamic Surface and Interfacial Tensin
Injection
Measurement", Presented at the AOCS Annual
Using Micromodels, Long Berea Sandstone Cores, and
Meeting and Expo, Anaheim, CA April 27, 1993.
Computer-Assisted Tomography", paper SPE No.
18284 presented at the 63rd SPE Annual Technical
18. Katz, D.L., Monroe, R.R., and Trainer, R.R.:
Conference and Exibition in Houston, TX, October 2-5
Surface Tensin of Crude Oils Containing
1988.
Dissolved Gases, Pet. Tech. (Sept. 1943) 1-10.
Oren, P. E., Billiotte, J., Pinczewski,
W.
19. Baker, O., Swerdloff, W.: Calculation of Surface
V.:
Tensin, Oil and Gas Journal, Nov 21, 1955-Jan
"Mobilization of Waterflood Residual Oil
by
9, 1956.
Gas
Production
Optimization
Using
11
Water/Gas ST
Fresh
Water- 30 K ppm KCI Brine- 30 K ppm KCI
Dead
Oil- Dead Oil- Nitrogen Brine-Live OllNitrogen
Methane
55.32
50.21
54.17
0t/Water IFT
27.84
23.98
28.03
Oil/Gas ST
15.41
15.41
10.77
Measurement/
Fluid System
Fig. 4.
Pendant
Drop IFT Measurement Method (after Ref. 15).
Heavy Phase, pH
i
Vdrop
(PH"PL)9
Separation Forc
a7td
Adherence forc
Positiva
DlsplK*mnt Pump
(Ugtrar Llquid)
.0154 mm
11 4S42AM MAR
21
1997;
1.5596 mm
Fig. 8. Example of
SigmaScan Pendant
Drop Image
Processing.
80.0
Published Measured
* 29.5
I 19.5 19 5
20.1 -
0.0 -
IIII
Bubble in Water.
Pressure
Temparature dag C
Fig. 16. Comparison of Nitrogen and Methane IFT for 1500 psia.
70 -
l'
F
T
m
Temperature
deg C
Fig. 17. Comparison of Nitrogen and Methane IFT for 3500 psia.
4000
Fig. 18. Drop Volume and Pendant Drop IFT Measurements for 96 C (Mean Vales).
Fig. 19. Drop Volume and Pendant Drop IFT Measurements for 66 C (Mean Vales).
Fig. 20. Pendant Drop vs. Drop Volume IFT Vales Crossplot for 1500-3500 psia.