Columbia’s coffee market has grown by leaps and bounds in the last two decades, as evidenced
by the amount of coffee that consumers purchase both by the cup and by the bean. The number Z-Best owner Zakir Twaddle has been roasting his own coffee since the 1980s. He officially
of coffee houses has multiplied, from locally owned shops like Lakota and the Dunn Brothers launched his own business in 1995 with a $5000 loan, a popcorn popper and a few bags of cof-
to chains like Starbucks and Kaldi’s. The amount of coffee that customers buy off the shelves, fee beans. In Zakir’s words, his favorite part of his job is roasting the coffee by hand and hear-
from supermarkets to specialty shops, also has increased — especially in light of the recession. ing people tell him that they truly enjoy his product.
Note that Columbia coffee drinkers are not limited to college campuses by any stretch. Across Zakir runs Z-Best out of a remodeled shed outside his home in Sturgeon, Mo., about ten
the board, more and more residents seem to be incorporating a caffeinated java fix into their minutes north of Columbia. He now owns a custom $20,000 roaster capable of roasting 100
daily lives. pounds of coffee per hour if necessary. Currently, however, Zakir only roasts about 100 pounds
For Z-Best Coffee, the good news is that tremendous opportunity abounds for a quality cof- a week.
fee roaster to grab a foothold in the marketplace. As our primary research proves, Columbia Z-Best is a bare-bones operation with minimal operating expenses. After roasting the beans,
residents who try Z-Best almost always have positive things to say about it. Despite the ripe Zakir delivers freshly made coffee on a weekly basis to area businesses that include Hy-Vee,
market, however, Z-Best faces several challenges. Not enough people are familiar with Z-Best Clover’s Natural Foods, Abigail’s, Sycamore, Flat Branch Pub & Brewing and Uprise Bakery.
or even know that it exists. In addition, Z-Best is limited by its budget compared to most coffee Zakir’s wife, Patricia, maintains their website: www.zbestcoffee.com.
sellers in the area.
Z-Best primarily serves the Columbia market but also takes orders online. At present, how-
The overall goals of our public relations plan, therefore, are to promote brand awareness in ever, online sales generate only 2 percent of Z-Best’s revenue. Hy-Vee and Clover’s Natural
the local community and to build an online presence. If more people are exposed to Z-Best, Market account for 90 percent of sales.
they’ll be more inclined to purchase it in the future. That said, our objectives are to increase
brand recognition of Z-Best by 20 percent and to increase the amount of online traffic by 25 Business saw a downturn following the recession. Though sales did increase by 15 percent in
percent within a six-month time period. the last year, it’s still nowhere near the 300 pounds of coffee per week that Zakir was selling
four years ago. He now sells 150 to 200 pounds, but needs to sell 500 pounds in order to turn a
Based on our research, we recommend the following strategies: profit. He does $5,000 to $6,000 in sales each month, but needs to double or triple that figure to
be profitable.
• Promote Z-Best “by the pound” by expanding the number of retailers in which Aside from a few articles around 2007, not much has been written about Z-Best in the local
the coffee is sold media. Zakir spends little on advertising and most of his business seems to come by word-of-
• Promote Z-Best “by the cup” by co-sponsoring coffee tastings at local venues mouth or from personal relationships with business owners.
• Generate favorable media coverage
• Create easier navigation for the website
• Build presence on social media marketing sites
Weaknesses Threats
• Z-Best is not Fair Trade Certified: Fair Trade is an issue for many coffee buyers, as more participants • Economy: Profits for Z-Best tend to fluctuate with the economy. With less money in their pock-
than expected brought up the issue during our survey. In theory, Fair Trade is based on a partnership between etbooks, coffee buyers might be more inclined to purchase generic coffee brands.
producers and wholesalers that ensures sustainability and fair trading conditions, including health and safety
standards as well as an agreement not to use forced or child labor. According to Zakir, however, there is debate • Competition: Z-Best Coffee’s biggest competitors are Lakota and Dunn Brothers, both local cof-
as to whether Fair Trade Certified products indeed live up to their expectations, to the point that Zakir has fee shops situated in Columbia. Zakir has also struggled against high-end national imports. With no
removed Fair Trade from consideration of his business plan. storefront business, Lakota and Dunn Brothers have the upper hand.
• Lack of awareness: Again only a small percentage of coffee buyers are aware of Z-Best. Many who drink • Chain restaurants: At one time, Z-Best was sold by the cup in dozens of local restaurants. But
it either know Zakir personally or shop regularly at specialty shops where it’s sold. many of them closed up shop in the last decade, especially as corporate chains moved in, bringing
with them their own distributors and having no need for local producers.
• Lack of advertising: Z-Best Coffee does not advertise at present, though in the past Zakir posted ads at
Hollywood Theatres and in the Add Sheet. The product is largely sold by word-of-mouth and a few under- • Local media: As Fair Trade became a hot topic, Z-Best was taken to task by the Columbia Mis-
writing spots on KBIA, Columbia’s National Public Radio affiliate. Zakir also contributes to their membership sourian for not buying Fair Trade Certified coffee beans, resulting in a frayed relationship. The Co-
drives. lumbia Business Times, meanwhile, wrote an in-depth feature on Zakir’s business that was pleasant
• Poor product placement: At local stores where Z-Best is sold, the product is consistently placed on the enough; and the Columbia Tribune mentioned Z-Best in a related article about a family that ate only
bottom shelf, making it hard to spot for customers who don’t already know it’s there. from local producers for a week as part of the Localvore Challenge. The fact that all of them have
previously written stories on Z-Best decreases the chances of them doing so now, though the odds
are not insurmountable.
• When Lakota opened in 1992, it was only one of two places that sold coffee in downtown Co- Primary Research
lumbia. Fifteen years later, there were five other shops all within five blocks: Panera Bread, Star-
In order to gain insight into the coffee-buying habits of consumers, we gathered data through a coffee
bucks, Kaldis, The Underground Café and the Coffee Zone. Also downtown are Kayotea Tea Room,
tasting set up at Clover’s Natural Foods. As participants tried Z-Best coffee, we asked them if they’d be
Sven’s Kafe and Café Berlin.
willing to take a survey as well. Questions involved consumers’ favorite brands, what qualities in coffee
• In 2008, however, the Coffee Ground shut down. According to media reports, Lakota and are most important, and their degree of familiarity with our client.
Kaldi’s are stuggling as well.
• One element of Lakota that drives customer loyalty, however, is the in-house roasting, which Survey statistics
exposes the business district to the rich scent. Of the 19 people who took our survey:
• 26 percent spend less than 5$ and five percent spend $10-$20
“We’re selling quite a bit of our bulk coffee,” said Lakota owner Skip DuCha- • 68 percent of our participants spend between $5 to $10 a week on coffee
rme. “It seems like people are making more of it at home.” • 89 percent buy coffee from grocery stores or supermarkets, followed by a close 58 per
cent who buy from coffee shops (participants could choose more than one answer)
• Root Cellar opened in 2002 as a small grocery and specializes in locally grown products.
• Taste/quality, price and Fair Trade are ranked as the top three factors when purchasing
coffee
“I’m the middleman between farmer and consumer,” said co-owner Kimberly • 63 percent had heard of Z-best coffee, mostly from Clover’s or by word-of-mouth
Griffin. “When a person buys food from that comes from 3,000 miles away,
• 26 percent of participants buy Z-best coffee on a regular basis. Other coffees mentioned
even if it’s certified organic, you still can’t know what the growing practices
include Yuban and Folgers
truly are. It’s different when you know the farmers and buy directly from
them.”
• The need for smaller, centrally located groceries like Clover’s Natural Foods is likely to grow,
according to the Columbia Business Times. This news bodes well for local producers like Z-Best. Responses
About 25 people participated in our taste test, of which 24 reported favorable results. Comments in-
cluded: “Delicious”; “Very tasty, rich and creamy”; “Very flavorful”; and “Excellent with a robust flavor.”
“The number of coffee shops has really exploded in Columbia,” said Ariel, a Only one person was dissatisfied, claiming the taste was too strong and bitter (see Graph 1).
sales associates at Clover’s. “I remember when there was just a handful, and
then Barnes & Noble opened one in the mall. People definitely take it serious-
ly. There’s a whole culture around it.”
Primary Audiences
Coffee drinkers who buy their coffee by the bean are our primary audience. These are the true
coffee drinkers who value taste and quality. Z-best is not cost-competitive with the lower-end
brands, but it is cost-competitive among premium coffees. The target market can be further di-
vided into two groups: those who buy their coffee in stores and those willing to buy coffee online.
Coffee drinkers who buy their coffee in stores make up the bulk of Z-Best’s business, as 90
percent of revenue comes from Hy-Vee and Clover’s. But this market needs to be maintained and
expanded. Many potential buyers might skip over Z-Best while perusing the aisles if they don’t
see it at first glance due to poor product placement. Recall that 37 percent of those surveyed had
not heard of Z-Best coffee. If we increase customer awareness of Z-Best or convince stores to
routinely place Z-Best on the top shelves rather than the bottom, sales could increase as well.
Coffee drinkers who buy coffee online also value taste and quality, perhaps even more so than
store buyers if they’re willing to seek out certain brands via the Internet. With only 2 percent of
Z-Best’s revenue coming from online purchases, Web purchases represent a virtually untapped
market. These customers are tech-savvy and best reached through online social media, such as
Facebook, Twitter or niche blogs devoted to specialty coffees.
Secondary Audiences
Local businesses willing to co-sponsor events such as coffee tastings offer another means to pro-
mote the brand. These small business owners recognize that Z-Best is a high-quality product with
local appeal. To gain their support, we must stress that co-sponsoring events is mutually benefi-
cial, as the net result is bringing more customers into their store.
The local media can be utilized to boost awareness of upcoming events, such as coffee tastings
or a vendor booth at the Farmer’s Market. The Columbia Business Times is often favorable to this
sort of coverage. When news releases are sent out, Z-Best can follow-up by phone and/or e-mail
to answer questions about the product. For other local media outlets, such as the Columbia Mis-
sourian, Columbia Tribune, or KOMU, it will be tougher to convince them to do in-depth feature
stories. But regional/national publications might be interested. For example: Tea & Coffee Trade
Journal, Fresh Cup Magazine, or Midwest Living.
Z-Best tastes great and is one-of-kind. The combination of exotic beans imported from Overall Goal: Increase brand awareness
South America and Africa which are then custom-roasted right here in mid-Missouri makes
for a very unique experience. The caffeine “buzz” is more pleasant than mainstream brands,
much like sipping Grey Goose versus well vodka. Once customers try Z-Best, it’s hard to go Objective 1: Promote Z-Best in Columbia and increase brand recognition
back to low-end or generic coffees, and our own teammates can attest to that. by 20 percent
Z-Best offers organic and locally roasted coffee. Both our primary and secondary
research reveals that customers value products that are grown within the community using Strategy 1: Promote Z-Best coffee “by-the-pound” to local coffee drinkers
natural ingredients. Concerns range from sustainable agriculture to pesticide-risk reduction. Rationale: Based on our secondary research, we found a significant increase in homemade cof-
Z-Best should always promote itself as an eco-friendly local business in order to generate fee consumption during the last two years. Due to the economic downturn, more consumers
consumer interest. are purchasing their coffee from grocery stores and supermarkets. Z-Best has an advantage in
this market, given its local following at prominent retailers like Hy-Vee and Clovers.
Overall evaluation of Objective #1: Conduct a second survey in six months to gauge the Despite having regained some traction in the last year, as evidenced both in the
difference in the number of participants who have either tried Z-Best or recognize the brand increased demand for the product and repairing the relationship with Uprise Bakery,
name. we believe this is only the beginning for Z-Best. Zakir is in a great position to expand
his business and elevate the Z-Best brand to a household name for Columbia and mid-
Evaluation of Tactic #1: If Zakir opts to set up a booth at the Farmer’s Market this sum- Missouri residents.
mer, success will be measured by the number of samples given out compared to the num-
ber of purchases made. If enough coffee is sold for Zakir to break even, we consider that a On a personal level, we have enjoyed getting to know Zakir and find his enthusiasm
success. In the case of Root Cellar, persuading the owners to allow Zakir to conduct a coffee to be contagious. He’s a great PR tool in himself, and surely other business owners
taste is a success in itself. If they decide to carry his coffee afterward, that’s a bonus. and coffee drinkers will feel the same.
Evaluation of Tactic #2: As to the potential of a Wake Up to Z-Best Breakfast! at Uprise After much research and thought, we have the following recommendations:
Bakery, a turnout of at least 30 customers would be a success as well as a reason to continue
hosting future events. 1. Host events in the community. There’s no greater PR than face-to-face com-
munication. Zakir has a very compelling personality and should use it as much as
Evaluation of Tactic #3: In this case, merely writing and sending press releases is not possible to promote his product. Free samples and coffee tastings will go a long
enough. To be a success, at least one publication has to devote some page space to an upcom- way to endearing customers as they experience Z-Best.
ing Z-Best event.
2. Build an online presence. With an intern onboard, building the Z-Best brand
Overall evaluation of Objective #2: We would measure the increase in Z-Best’s online on the Web should be a relatively simple process. Don’t underestimate the power
presence by conducting an informal study of his various arenas — website, social media, etc. of social media to promote awareness and drive traffic to the website.
— again following a six-month period.
3. Promote Z-Best as an organic and locally roasted product. Based on our re-
Evaluation of Tactic #4: The effect of the revamped website can easily be measured by search, many customers would rather buy homegrown coffee from small business
the number of hits. We place the bar at five to 10 hits per week. One option is to use Google owners than go to chains like Starbucks or Kaldi’s. This is what separates Z-Best
Analytics to measure website traffic and trends. from most of the competition.
Evaluation of Tactic #5: Setting up Twitter and LinkedIn accounts as well as posting to
blogs, forums and the Facebook fan page is only the first step. The real measure is in two-
way communication. If Z-Best is averaging 10 to 15 responses per week across all forms of
social media following a six-month period, then he can officially claim online presence.
Nearly all our tactics can be achieved at minimal cost, especially if Z-Best brings on an unpaid
intern to plan events and build an online presence using social media. The largest expenses
are setting up a booth at the Farmer’s Market and co-sponsoring a taste testing.Everything
else is under $20.
TACTIC COST TIME
Business cards (250 color cards from FedEx Office) $20 2 hours
Z-Best Coffee... 18
Monthly E-mail Newsletter
by Brian Jarvis
First a heartfelt thanks to the enthused customer who took it on his/herself to launch a Face-
book page in our honor. With 36 fans already onboard, we hope to see more visitors leave
comments, post photographs and other fun stuff. Look to see all of our upcoming events posted
there as well.
An even warmer thanks to Uprise Bakery, who, after a yearlong hiatus, has begun to sell Z-Best
again thanks to popular demand. At well under $2 for a large, it’s about the cheapest (and of the
course the best) cup to be found on MU’s campus.
With May on the horizon, look to find us at the Farmer’s Market doling out free samples and
selling our latest flavors by the bean. We’ll even have a custom grinder on-site. Have two or
three free samples if you like — we’re well aware of the wake-up juice you might need to trek
through the market first thing on a Saturday morning.
Details have not yet been finalized, but we’re thinking of offering free tours of our roasting
facilities right here in Sturgeon for those brave enough to make the trip. Naturally a few iced
coffees afterward might be in order afterward to survive the summer heat. Something to keep in
mind as you make your weekend plans…
In beans we trust,
Zakir Twaddle
Z-Best Coffee... 20
Pitch Letter to Root Cellar
by James Coston
My name is Zakir Twaddle and I’m the owner of Z-Best Coffee, a small business located in
Sturgeon just 10 miles north of Columbia. Since our start in 1995, we’ve developed some-
thing of a niche in the Columbia market. I roast my coffee by hand and then deliver it in
person to local businesses.
I’m reaching out to see if Root Cellar would be interested in letting me host a coffee tasting.
I’d be happy to take care of all the planning and expenses. If it brings in customers to your
store, it would be a win-win for both of us. I’m confident I could deliver at least 30 people for
a weekend breakfast tasting.
Why Root Cellar? We know that you only sell the best products produced within our home
state of Missouri. For Z-Best, it’s all about quality — and from what I’ve seen, that holds true
for Root Cellar as well. I’d be happy to send you a complimentary sample of my coffee so you
can try for yourself. If you take a liking to it, we can discuss the possibility of carrying it on
your shelves.
What do you think? I’ll plan to follow up later this week. I can be reached at (573) 875-5605.
Warm regards,
Zakir Twaddle
Z-Best Coffee...22
Event Brief
by Ashanya Indralingam
Event Rationale
Wake Up to Z-Best Breakfast! is the first in a series of events aimed to build brand recognition and
promote Z-Best. Targeted toward by-the-cup drinkers who frequent coffee shops, the event will re-
introduce Z-Best to the Uprise Bakery and capitalize on its taste and quality.
Event Summary
7 a.m. The event kicks off the moment the café opens. A posterboard at the entrance will inform pa-
trons that any purchase at the bakery comes with a free cup of Z-Best. Customers can choose their
blend.
8 a.m. Zakir will give a short introduction to Z-Best’s background and history. Local luminar-
ies such as former Mayor Darwin Hindman can chip in with their thoughts. Customers are free to
mingle and ask questions.
8:30-11:30 a.m. Z-Best brands will be available for purchase. Customers can also sign-up to receive
the Z-Best monthly newsletter via e-mail. Zakir can distribute his business cards that list his website
and social media links.
Z-Best is a small business that specializes in premium coffee sold wholesale. Although Z-Best is
hand-delivered to retailers around mid-Missouri, the product can be shipped anywhere in the
Sample Tactic 4 country.
Address:
Z-Best Coffee
17205 North Hwy NN
Sturgeon, MO 65284
Locally Owned and Custom Roasted Z-Best Coffee Joining Columbia’s Farmers Market
COLUMBIA, Mo. – Z-Best Coffee Co. LLC is proud to announce that it will open a booth at the
Columbia Farmer’s Market starting Saturday, May 1, 2010.
This marks the first time Z-Best Coffee will be showcased at the Farmer’s Market. Owner and
proprietor Zakir Twaddle will be on hand giving out free samples and selling the latest flavors
by the bean. Twaddle will also have a grinder so that beans can be ground on-site.
“Being part of the Columbia Farmer’s Market is a great opportunity for Z-Best,” said Twaddle.
“We love being out in the community meeting people and being able to offer them a one-of-a-
kind product that is roasted right here in mid-Missouri.”
Z-Best Coffee offers more than 15 varieties of beans that come from Central and South America,
Africa, and Indonesia. The company ships orders all over the country as well as delivers coffee
locally to businesses such as Clover’s Natural Market, Hy-Vee, Gerbes and the Uprise Bakery.
Z-Best Coffee will be available on Saturdays at the Farmer’s Market as well as Mondays and
Wednesdays throughout the summer.
Z-Best Coffee... 29
Timeline
You can purchase Z-Best in person at the Farmer’s Market, at local businesses in Columbia, or
online at www.zbestcoffee.com.
Immediate
Zakir Twaddle launched Z-Best Coffee Co. in 1996. It is locally owned and operated out • Start recruiting and hire an unpaid intern
of Sturgeon, Mo. The company is registered in the state of Missouri and licensed for both
wholesale and retail sales. To see a list of products, local businesses selling Z-Best, or to pur- • Create a Facebook page
chase coffee, visit www.zbestcoffee.com. • Create a Twitter feed and LinkedIn profile
• Update the Z-Best website
The Columbia Farmers Market showcases more than 70 local farmers, producers, and arti-
sans. It is located at the Activity & Recreation Center on the corner of Clinkscales and Ash • Pitch story ideas to niche magazines and local media stories
streets. You can go to www.columbiafarmersmarket.org for an updated listing of hours and
operations, as they change throughout the year. May 2010
• Promote upcoming events at the Farmers Market, Root Cellar, and Uprise Bakery
June 2010
• Host first of two Farmer’s Market vending booths
July 2010
• Host a coffee tasting at Root Cellar
August 2010
• Host the second Farmer’s Market vending booths
September 2010
• Host Wake Up to a Z-Best Breakfast! before a Mizzou home football game
____________
Gender? M or F
Student? Y or N
6. How willing are you to try a new coffee?
1. How often do you drink coffee?
• Very willing
• More than two cups daily • Somewhat
• At least 1-2 cups daily • Never
• A few times a week
• Once in a while 7. How do you receive your news? Circle as many as you want.
4. What are the most important things about your coffee? Again you may _________
circle more than one.
• Taste/quality
• Price
• Convenience
• Grown organically/ healthy beans
• Grown locally, not imported or sold at a chain
• Grown by certified Fair Trade farmers
2. Garcia, J.P. “Coffee Culture in Columbia.” Columbia Missourian. Jan. 11, 2010.
4. Christian, L. “The neighborhood grocery: Looking to the past for a greener future.” Co-
lumbia Business Times. Dec. 23, 2009.
5. Cook, M. “Business Profile: Z-Best’s Owner Beans with Pride over Success of His Cof-
fee.” Columbia Business Times. July 28, 2007.
7. “Boost Sales During a Recession: The Growing Importance of Qualified Online Sales
Leads.” www.MSDynamicsWorld.com.
8. Cole, Henry S. “Preserving the Rural Tier by Creating Economic Opportunity: Part 1.”
Prince George’s County Rural Tier Watch. Jan. 27, 2007. www://livableruraltier.blogspot.
com
Z-Best Coffee... 34