. LAW AND
THE INDIANACADEMYOF INTERNATIONAL
' DIPLoMAcY
I
I
t
\ lJ ELIMINATION AGAINST
OFVIOLENCE
\ J
\
J W O M E NI N I N D I A: M I L E ST OG O
5
t
\*
{
\ J
\ It AkankshaSingh
-\
g
RollNo : L7
-\
t
\ .
{
\{
v
-
(y
\-f
v
--
I
GONTENTS
t (i)
Preface
\.\
(y
-.- """1
f.lntroduction
I '
- \ AgainstWomen(VAW)
Violence
ll. Defining
"""'1
I Againstwomenin Indiansociety
Itl. Violence
""""'2
F
i-l
to EndVAW'
Commitment
lV.India'sInternational
for combatingVAw
/ Legalsafeguards
v. constitutional
""10
..'15
l--t
L
to EndVAW'
Vl. CivicSocietyResponse
"""'24
t \
"25
L- andRecommendations
Vfl. Conclusion
I
L
References.
I i ,
lr-- q u
PREFACE
Violence against women is perhaps the most shameful human rights
UClLI>UD
-^r
d. IIL.I impact of the acts of violence on Indian women. f
Refevant Literature
the Sahitya Akademi library for their cooperation and for the
1 Ak:nkehr
\ a r r ! q r r r \ u r r q
Q Li LnT eY L rL h \I
v
I. INTRODUCTION
health.
coerced pregnancy.
OIdAge:Abuseofwidows,elderabuse'
2OOI census show a decline in sex ratio, in the age group of 0-6
y v e ! v .
birth rate.
virgini*.y is given a hiqh social value. Girls are marr ied of f a1-
drvorced or abandoned
.r d:rrerh1-or
q v g q at the time of marriage is an age-old institution
nrr.tnerf rz under
_yr-_yvr uf/ q. the old Hindu law I a girl was given a parting
of hri dFdroom in whose family the bride and her dowry were to
acccunt their own family needs. The common greed for acquiring
exner-taI i ons were rai sed in the in-Iaws that what is nct given
\ f,
J
\
exner:tat i ons.
v u \ I / v v U u U ! v I r U . Seveaif rz of
U U v U ! J U J v ! torf ure
U v ! U or rIl-treatment inCreased
J
\ tc marry their son and again receive dowry from the new brjde.
I
,j his familv members hrz r l r r r t q" ' -i -n- g in kerosene, gdsoline, or other
t fl-ammable liquid, and sett ing the woman alight. Such incidents
:t a \ / a r \ . 2l - r r i d o t h a t
u v u r y v ! ! v \ will result in COming Of new wealth into the
: family folds
\ ry
BriCe-burning is the term used for such unnatural deaths. Many
t
cases of bride burnings are not reported as such, and the exact
t
nunrber of victims can only be estimated. In 2005, the latest
:
vear in which statistics are available from the National Crime
:
Records Bureau of India, confirmed and rFnr-rrter^l
- v - y v ! u v v r-lowrrz
v v v v ! J cleaf hS
v v u u
\v
including bride burning totaled 1026 .
:
rq
,
r-r4
J
-
,
\.\ 6
it
\.*\
t within the four walls of home. Unfortunately, our wcmen are
L .
*-1
- Perh^ns
l \ , I L r u v J fami'l rz
! u l L t r ! J confl'i r:f - sfress-
v v ! r r r r v u r f u u r v v u / r : r r .f lr r r a l norms and sexual
- inoorr:lifrz
r r r v \ a q q r r u J contribute to wife battering. Fathers and brothers
\-.!
- male self-image as aggressor which has been encouraged and
- - a
-r
r-
wclf-whistles, looks - r A
cl IC
n r r f
ycrr L \C f any woman's life, so much so
- \
.' that it is dismissed as normal . M : n r z .ny "e' 'r . S o n
! r q r r J use words or show
- \
i-
n
v vh
u vqv rrr -v p n o n
. Y
ictureS Of put up col-oured acts, gestures or sounds
- \
t,
\:-
7
molestatron.
are no1- reported in the press or case not filed with the police
q\/mn^thrz is
v]rily-y -I
socialty condemned, ostraci zed and boycotted,
t--^
nas rro ^l
p race In the society, hence the raped women or the
qor-raf
rrrere
T r L - ^ - ^
d- r A. r e many form of rape in India such as: rape in work
nr rna / r
r ao InJ e in domestic environment, rape in police custcdy,
P_Ld.\-C
: l - r r ' l r r ru -rij _n
q v v u v .r
r r Y married Women iS mainly f Or SexUal purpoSe/ namely
inl-r n^n.\'funities
)
uv v_y_yv! u that exist in most backward areas frqn which
n r - \ n nr 1 -r r r ri r i e S
v_y,yv! u qlrr u in India Or abrOad tO whiCh innOCent and pOOr
and the threat to their own life. Living in a foreign land and
i nnor:nt
f
Y r r v !
u l l u
nf
v the laws of the land, oT even the address of the
h\ 9
ry
\I un known .
t/
h..-\ reformer Raja Ram Mohan Roy during the British rule. But rt
t
- -
still occurs occasionally, mostly in the rural areas. The last
I
\.r clearly documented case was that of Roop Kanwar. However there
J
are claims that other more recent deaths have also been cases of
t
\ry 10
gfrrs and can create health, social, and economic
a
v
costs for the
matters pertaining
t to ending violence against women. These are:
-a TNTERNATIONAL
f
CO\ZENAI{T ON CIVrL AIVD POLITICAL
I R T G H T S ,( T C C P R ), 1 9 6 6
) of r^rrr-r]_ or-1- i an
5-,rt-lLUUL_LUrl. aS are requrred by his status as a rntnor / on
,
11
i nr-orn.)r:1_
ss
l v - - y the nri nr-inl c of
. y r r r r v r l / r v v ! non diSCriminatiOn whiCh States
not vrolate any right, and must take positive action to prornote
]u _r r h
v
a n rnfoction
I/! v Lv from abuse and neglect. The State has the
\^ Jl - lr - l -ri -^ L- f v o
L .ri ' ^r^' to protect children f rom all f orms of maltreatment
whefher
V Y f I U U I I V ! brz fhe
- J U I I V n^renfs
. L J * ' V I I U U
or
V ! brz others.
V f Article 32 deals with the
derre'l onmenf
\-.tsvu-L\ryrllsrlu/ - fL ov set
J\-L- minimUm
ttt-LlI_Lr.il.L,tILL acfeq
C'vE,J for
I\JI F m n - l o r z m e n f - aC -.l 'I l.l ,1t
grlLIJJ\JJrrL\-1.r.(./ 1L l -, n vc)^1rIr+-a
rg9LrIO.Lc
^ r ' - r ;^ - +L r i\ r^r r^
\rrrrrva of the State to make every effort to prevent the
rcnrodrrr-i-irre
- - " y ! v v q v u r v v riohts
r - Y r l u J of
v ! women ancl faroefs
v v v r r L v r l u r r v u q ! Y v u J culture and tradrtion
)
)
t2
)
AS rnfluential forces shaping gender role s and fami I y
t
rel-ations.
)
The convention guarantees women equal rights with men in atl
)
qnharoq nf life, including education, effiployment, health care/
t
aCult franchise, and marriage. It affirms women's right to
)
*: -r -y. rql rr' !i vr o, -r -,l . ) a n g e o r retain their nationality and the nationality
)
of their children. By accepting the Convention, the states
t
ccrnmrt themselves to undertake a series of measures to end
t
discrimination against women in all forms. These steps include:
t
. incorporating the principle of equality of men and women ln
t
their legal system and abolishing all discrimination.
)
. establishing tribunals and other public institutions to
,
ensure the effective protection of women against discrimination.
!
,
. ensuring elimination of all acts of discrimination against
)
vvvrllvu
rJ -rrtr z
\^7rlmar'r persons/
1 organLzations or enterprises.
t
Countries that have acceded to the convention are legallv bound
)
tc put its provisions into practice . They are also bound to
t
submit national reports, dt least once every four years on
t
the measures they have taken to comply with their treaty
,
obligations. The Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination
t
Against Women was established to review reports which all
)
\ signatory countries to the Convention must submit on women's
)
a status.
,
h,,-
1 L ! - -r .^L L r-L- irdg.^ l1
i-r-r +- s are a f undamental part of all human rights . The
]
J
A
J
13
- ^ ^ 1 1 4 r : + -i n p i n
V L q U A V I I I I I such
J q v f I f ields
! ! U I \ . I J aS
( I J economrc and socia I
g \ - \ J I I , V - L L L I \ - o . T I I , { D U U I c l I c l e r r e lo n m e n f -
L - I E V C I \ J y l [ . v , , U /
girl-chitd.
; , d r -L \ r r
nr r.{_ ^tr
all human rights. It streSsed that "population and
n r a + -a r - +i- ^ n
_ Y -
" U V V U ! V r a of women' s human riqht s." This document also
d- ^u1 "r- -li r e v e i r L e r r to f women's human rights. Section 106 (q) states
to recognLze and care for girls and women of all ages who
respect for women and for their rights, monitoring action and
L d r \ r 1 r 9 r- ir^ r+ L e r n a l
f r ' 1 . - i ^ ^
disciplinary actions against violations of the
up in:
(a) The State shall not discriminate agai-nst any cit LZen on
any of them.
(c) Nothing in this article shall prevent the State from makinq
employment
(1) The State shall strive to promote the welfare of the people
the State
(a) that the citLZeDS, men and women equally, have the
(d) that there is equal pay for equal work for both men
and women;
women, and the tender age of children are not abused and
The State shall make provision for securing j ust and humane
by thi s Act .
l r
b--
a
18
nunishable
I J U I I ! J l I q V M v I
r ^ r 1. i_ h s ' i m n l e
U t 1 J l r l l y r u imnrisonment
l r t t l r which ' mav extend
' . . - _ I to ft-fteen
simnle i m n r .r iJ q
*...yr \ , r ll n
r l tm
" r - . i ^ } - lm
t s rer nu t w r r r ( - l r
-\/ extend
ttd)/ to three months and shall
that the marriage was not a child marriage . Puni shment for
r^\r/-\rYrn1_o
JJIUIII\JLU
lL- hI aI C marriage or permits it to be solemnrzed, or
l _h a ryr r-r,r .r ^. r,i . .ng menace of the social evil of dowry, which makes not
nn l rz ]_hc
v r r ! J u r r v actual act of giving or taking dowry an offense
19
tho
u11U Srrnrome Court
U Ul'/! V. has laid down that the dowry demand for a
PRE\ZENTTON)ACT
Misuse) Act was passed in the year 7994 for the purpose of
n r F \ r p n l -i n o m i s u s e
_ y r - v v r r u
of prenatal diagnostic techniques by clinics
f o e t Lr Lrf ,sJ
r\--l\.- hrz
jJJ rL TrJsI I liVn c r cli-Ah
\lrO.9LI\JD
^ fL i- L^L . +L - Ee\ \r- l-' t h nicttte-
IIIYLrs/ is made an offenSe
bailable.
recli.ster any case under this act. It can be arqued that the
-^,-r-^-- - I
IU(.-TLUDDO-L CannOt be a mild legiSlatiOn. UnleSS the people are
n o r q . . ' nq
y v ! u i n the work places or other institutions, to prevent
ways.
2l
- h ^ r A ^ r ' i I O r rL^C
o.IJy-LUlJI
^ h - 1 r Li I^g gD in
Jrr SuCh
DL,r\-ll r rr rr !lueJ s
r aoainSt
qvur the offender.
IJErtO-I
As
l r J reoa rcis
! V Y q ! V U nri rraf e
_ y - - v q U V
e m n ' l o r z m e n 1 _ , ' su u,vfl e
v r l r y ! v J r L L v f r u / un s should
u r r \ be taken to incl-ude
r -r. r - - - m n n r
rrd.LctJJ.il.tutiL ShOUld have the OptiOn tO Seek their Own tranSf er
r r r ri r - l oI i n e s . T h e c o m m i t t e e
\-.J s r \sv should be headed by a woman and not
D O M E S T T CV T O L E N C E A C T , 2 0 0 5
Thre Domestic Violence Act covers women who have been Ii vrng
lirrincr
! r v r r r Y in
r l l a
u relatjonshin
! v ! q u ! v r r u r a l l
- y
not
r r v u in the
g r r v nature
r r s 9 q ! v of marai:cre
dlly
€ ^*-r,e
IctttclIc rl cel dlLal v tc i v e tL o\ J file
IIIE a
c. Comnla.n
i f
\-\JlrLyro.rllL
^^-j^^f
d9dIII>L the
] 1 r . \ ta
_vJJ
_ r - r _i n n order by the Magistrate to prevent further
ent itled under the Act to monetary rel ief and compensation
+L - L1l . U' - ^c-t tr ' -L -"t-J C^\ .rl with respect to medical examination, legal aid,
^-€^
J d I C
^}-^r*er
J I , I C I L I etc.Under the Act, dhV actroffiission or commissron
-or
conduct of the respondent shall constitute domestic violence
l-.^-l 1 _1 - - -ef
in case it harms or rnj ures or endangers the l . lu c t - L L l l , ) O L = ar .f | _ r z I
23
j _n orzar]
h
rro
u rr vhJr z c^ rn
r l \y / \r --\ _
. )/ rnr \dl Lr. rr \r/ -\ -f rv ^v rrl h
s uor rfghr o r nhrzqir-:l
yrrJJr\Jcrr \n_ r/ r rm
t LaE n j -c ) _ L :l
lIe l L\_/ lL_1 h- t o
c; cAf \. j r9 .I IrCr Vi C \ . - {
person.
Before this Act came into force , the law necessitated the
even making a dowry demand has been brought into the framework
of domestic violence.
mofhers. I f u ! U l Sisters
J ! U u v I U and
q f I V children
V I I I I V ! v l a aS
s U well.
v Y v I ! . It
I u seeks
J v v l \ J f o
U v nro\/ide
y r v v
relationships.
24
( A m e n d m e n t) A c t was passed.
]L .vn I . ia h f
r r v r l u
.j
r n Karvi, Uttar Pradesh, raising the whole issue of
. Women's groups have also been using legal means including PIL
)<
Over the last few decades, violence against women has become one
section of the society are concerned about the issue and legal
reforms are being made against women oppression. But the rate
nf rlr.-'rraas made in
. y r - Y ! v u this area is hardly noticeable when one
Even the women themselves also are not able to reali ze this
n r^1-on1_ -inn
y - " u v v u ! v r r Of
v ! W
v v vOl Lm el nI
L U :af,a
q Y q inst all forms of violence. Such a policy
i n n a r , ^ . ' art r- 3 t i o n
_ y w y v u q of acts of torture, including rape and
srzstem should
U ] I V I be built on the solid foundation of equality,
-i aq
system to identify gender discriminaLion and qrrrrnroq1_
- * Y Y v u u
romorl
! u r L L U V ! U J .
: ! r ov
u ri r n
r u: rv' lv Y ou aq r l r r r - a u v The need for establishing short stay shefters
1r -_n
\ _ . r \r -j ros r rv asl r v Pn n o: r. Ll al gngrLr r: a1 _ L ca facifities within the overburdened health
:]_ nrin.i y r r v ! ! u
1.y level. Violence affected women should be qiven
political parties
\
Extension of Literacy Programmes: To make the
\ women aware of
their rights and responsibilities, they
v
should be given proper
7
29
its widest reach and large influencing power can play a major
- ^ . i - - + . j o n1 Is' >
\-rr9O.tI-LLA.LI\, w
W \o
- / Lrr k
! I rir n
Y o for
r\-,/l- c J e r r e l n n m e n j _car lnl \ ,c{ l n
\-r\-VEI\JVItLgIIL rofer:tion of the
IJI\-./Lg\,
gender violence.
* * * * * * * * * * * ) k * * * *
30
REFERENCES
Bhan,Ashok, "Violence
Against women and Criminal Justrce
Systefr," Kashmir Uni\/prqirtr T , ^ wR e v i e w , vol.1O, no.10 (2003)
!;
l "
Thornhill,R.
Bioloqical Bases of
and palmer T., A l/aturaL
Sexual- Coercion,
Iristory
Communafisinq
and de Alwis,
women's sexuaLity
Malathi
in
(eds).
south
Embodied violence:
\
l!/
Dasgupta, Monica; chenrL.c. and Krishnan, womenrs lleaJth in
- India, Oxford University press, ( 1 9 9 8)
\
Gopalan and Shiva (eds ) . l/a tional- prof ile on Women, Heayth
-a and
v
D e v e l o p m e n t , V H A I a n d W H O, (2 000 )
v
h\
Bhatti, R. S."Socio-cultural dynamics of wife batterLnq," in
t
\\ Scod, €d . , Viof ence Aoai nef D t T n m s pAl ,r i h a n t . publishers, Jaipur,
D
(1990)
\q
\-/
*.\
T> Campbell, J. C . , "women's responses to sexual abuse in intimate
- q relaticnships I IreaJth Care f or women rnternational, (19s 9 )
>
f-\
,U
a
31
India, (2005)
(2000)
Bare Acts
(2006)
Act, 7gg4, universal Law Publishing co. Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi,
(2006)
32
Internet Sources
Seiferf-R.
v v r r v ! u / t \ . War and Rape: Analyticaf Approaches, Women's
h t t p : / / w w w .u n i c e f . orglsowc96pk/sexviot . htm (a c c e s s e d 2 5 J u n e 2 0 0 1 )
h t t p : / / w w w .u n i f e m , o l _ e ( a c c e s s e d : 26 June 2001 )
o f w o m e n , h t L p ; / / w w w .a m n e s t V u s € . e L q ( a c c e s s e d 2 6 J u n e 2 0 0 1 )
r + l t # + +'tT+ + #
1f ]t 1T lt lt 1T 1T