Taxation
Made Ezy
By CA.Chandrashekhar Shetty.S.
B.com,PGDM,PGDCA, PGDFM, DIM,DISA, LL.B., ACWA, ACS, FCA
Email-id: shettysir@yahoo.com
Tel. No. : 9845336700
INCOME TAX
INTRODUCTION
Tax means an amount paid by a person to Goverrnment (Central, State or local authority) for availing
various benefits provided by such Governments. The benefits may be direct or indirect say infrastructure,
health, education etc. One of the major sources of revenue to the govt. is taxes.
Assessee [Sec. 2(7)] - Assessee means a person who is liable to pay tax or any other sum under this Act,
and includes ;
A person in respect of whom proceedings
have been initiated, either for his own income or for income of others, or for fringe benefits and
includes representative assesses.
Deemed Assesses – Agent of a non-resident.
Assessee in default – Default in TDS.
Sec.3 Previous Year: It means the financial year immediately preceding the assessment year.
Proviso to Sec.3 – Exceptions to the rule that P.Y is a period of 12 months.
(a) When a new business or profession is started in the middle of the year, then the P.Y. shall be from
the date of commencement of business till immediately succeeding 31st March.
(b) When a new source of income arises in the middle if the year, then the P.Y. shall be from the date
of commencement of business till immediately succeeding 31st March.
Ex: 1. Mr. X, has taken a building on rent @ Rs. 10,000 p.m. from 1-4-08. He started pan beeda business
on 1-12-08 to 31-3-09 and hence, rent to be claimed as expenditure is Rs. 40,000.
Ex: 2. Mr. X, owns a House Property since 1975. He purchased another House Property on 24-2-2009.
Both the houses were self occupied. If second house is considered as DLOP, then Annual value should be
computed from 24-2-09 to 31-3-09.
2
Sec. 2(9): Assessment Year: It means the period of 12 months commencing from 1st April every year.
P.Y. is the year in which the assessee earns the income where as A.Y. is the year in which assessee is
expected to compute the income & tax, pay the tax and file Income Tax Return.
Exceptions to the rule that income of previous year is charged to tax in assessment year: In the
following cases income of previous year is charged to tax in the assessment year itself
(a) Sec. 172 – Income from shipping business of a non-resident
(b) Sec. 174 – Income of person leaving India
(c) Sec. 174A – Income of an AOP/BOI, formed for a particular event or purpose
(d) Sec. 175 – Income of persons likely to transfer property to avoid tax
(e) Sec. 176 – Income of a discontinued business
Ex:
1) a) Loan received from a Private Ltd. company, by a shareholder having 12% stake is treated as
deemed dividend u/s 2(22)(e), even though it is a capital receipt. Where as loan taken from a friend is not
included anywhere in the Act, and hence it is not taxable.
1) b) Compensation received for termination of employment is covered u/s 17(3) r/w 17(1) and 15, and
hence taxable subject to 10(10B), even though it is a capital receipt.
2) a) Agricultural income from growing and selling paddy is a revenue receipt. However, Indian
agricultural income is exempt u/s 10(1) whereas other agricultural income is taxable in India.
2) b) Dividend from a domestic co. as well as from a foreign company is a revenue receipt. Sec. 10(34)
exempts the former, whereas the latter is taxable.
Special Income means the income for which, the tax rates are prescribed in the Act itself. Ex: 111A
income, 112 income, lottery income
Normal Income means income other than special income. For normal income, tax rates are prescribed by
the Finance Act every year.
TAX RATES FOR AY 2009-10
Tax rates for individuals / HUF / AOP / BOI / Artificial juridical persons referred to in Sec 2(31)(vii)
Total Income Tax rate
Upto Rs.1,50,000 Nil
Rs.1,50,001 to Rs.3,00,000 10%
Rs.3,00,001 to Rs.5,00,000 20%
Rs.5,00,000 and above 30%
In case of resident women assessees basic exemption limit is Rs.1,80,000/- and in case of resident senior
citizens basic exemption limit is Rs.2,25,000.
Surcharge of 10% on tax payable shall be levied if the total income exceeds Rs.10,00,000. However in
case of artifical juridical person referred to in Sec 2(31)(vii) surcharge of 10% shall be levied irrespective
of total income.
3
Tax rates for firms / domestic companies / local authorities – 30%
Surcharge of 10% on tax payable shall be levied if the total income of a firm / domestic company exceeds
Rs.1,00,00,000/- (No surcharge on income of local authority)
Tax Avoidance – It means reducing the tax burden by taking benefits of loopholes in the law. It is
bending the law without breaking it. It may be legal but not ethical. (Refer case laws below)
Tax Evasion – It means reducing the tax burden through unfair means.
Ex: Omitting sales bills, or excess providing for expenses etc. It is illegal as well as immoral.
General Notes
1) Receipt here means first receipt and not the subsequent receipt / remittance.
Ex: Mr. X earns rs. 12L salary in UK.
Case 1: Such salary is credited to Vijaya Bank in Chickpet. It is the income received in India.
Case 2: Received in HSBC A/c in UK and latter on transferred to Vijaya Bank in Chickpet. It is
the not received in India.
2) Past untaxed profits brought into India shall not be taxable. Since Income tax taxes the income
earned during the P.Y.
3) In case of R&OR/R in India, global income is taxable in India.
4) Non-resident ends up paying tax on income earned in India or received in India.
5) From the view of taxation plan in such manner that assessee becomes non-resident especially for
frequently traveling persons residing outside India.
Person of Indian origin means either the assessee, or his parents or his grand parents have born in
undivided India.
5
Note: 2 Resident but NOR conditions for Individuals & HUF only [Sec. 6(6)].
Individual
BUT AND
NOR OR
Resident Non-resident
NOR OR
6
Ex: HUF, 5 male members, 3 female members, 1 male with 3% management power and all females were
in India. During PY 07-08, karta was in India for 30 days and during earlier 7 years, he was in India for
720 days. Comment.
Ans: Part of the management & control is in India, and hence resident as per Sec. 6(2). Karta satisfied one
of the conditions of 6(6) and hence HUF is Resident but NOR.
The residential status of karta, is irrelevant, while deciding the residential status of HUF. In other words,
in the given case, karta is non-resident as per 6(1). However, application of 6(1) is not required for
determining residential status of HUF. Instead merely apply Sec. 6(2) and 6(6) independently.
Resident NR
Management and control means, defacto control, i.e. the actual control.
Note 2:
Section 56(2)(vi)
Any sum of money Gifts received in kind does not attract this section.
Aggregate of which
per annum From all persons in a P.Y.
Exceeds 50,000 Ex: X gave Rs. 30,000 & Y gave Rs. 30,000 – then,
entire Rs. 60,000 is taxable.
Plan: Defer Y to next year or take 20,000 only. &
defer 10,000 to next year or take 10,000 in kind.
Received by an
individual or HUF Received by anybody other than Individual/HUF is not
taxable.
On or after 1/4/06
Aggregate of whole of
such sum is income
8
& expecting to die shortly. Such a will takes place effect, if and only if he dies because of
illness referred.
4. Received from a local authority referred to in Explanation to Sec. 10(20).
5. Received from a Fund / Institution / Educational Institution / Medical Institution trust referred
in Sec. 10(23C).
6. Received from a trust registered u/s 12AA.
HEADS OF INCOME
As per Sec 14 the incomes earned by an assessee are broadly classified under the following heads:
It is the duty of the assessee to classify incomes under the respective head to ensure benefits, deductions
prescribed in that head are availed / enjoyed by such assessee. If the assessee mis-classifies the income it
is the duty of the assessing officer to classify it under the correct head and grant the deductions and
benefits accordingly.
9
INCOME FROM SALARIES
(CHAPTER IV-A – Sec 15 to Sec 17)
Any income by the employee from the employer is taxable as income from salaries.
3) Arrears of Salary – It means the additional salary received in a financial year towards
service rendered in the past.
Ex: Increase in salary with retrospective effect.
It is taxable in the year of receipt unless taxed earlier on due basis.
The assessee can claim relief under Sec 89 against advance salary and arrears of salary.
6) Salary paid tax-free: Any tax borne by the employer on behalf of the employee shall be
added to salary income of employee, subject to Sec 10(10CC)
As per Sec 10(10CC) any tax borne by the employer relating to non-monetary perquisites provided to
employees is exempt in the hands of the employee.
Therefore tax amount paid by the employer to be added to the employee’s salary is only to the extent of:
10
a) Cash salary say Basic Pay, Dearness Allowance
b) Monetary perquisites say Re-imbursement of medical perquisites.
Income from Salaries
Sec 15
Charging Section Sec 16 Sec 17
Deductions Definitions
Explanation 1 to Sec 15 – Advance salary taxed on receipt basis in a financial year shall not be taxed
again in subsequent financial years on due basis.
Explanation 2 to Sec 15 – Salary earned by a partner from a partnership firm shall not be taken as income
from salary. It will be taxed as income from business or profession [Sec 28(v)]
The above deduction is given irrespective of amount spent by government employee towards
entertainment.
From the above it is clear that the employer and employee relationship can be present, past or future.
RETIREMENT BENEFITS
Provident Fund
Gratuity Commuted Pension Earned Leave
10(11) & 10(12)
Sec 10(10) Sec10(10A) Sec 10(10AA)
Sec 10(11) / 10 (12)
Govt employees
Govt employees covered
covered Central Govt. Govt employees
Central Govt. State Govt covered
State Govt Local Authority Central Govt.
Local Authority Statutory State Govt
corporation
Note: Death cum retirement gratuity, commuted pension and encashment of earned leave received by
government employees at the time of retirement is fully exempt from tax.
13
DEATH CUM RETIREMENT GRATUITY
Government Non-Government
Employees Employees
(Central Govt.,
State Govt. and
Local
Authorities)
Note: When an employee receives gratuity from more than one employer:
a) In the same financial year – Maximum exemption in that year should not exceed Rs.3,50,000/-
b) Received from second employer subsequently – While computing the exemption for gratuity
received from second employer
Statutory Limit = Rs.3,50,000 Less Actual Exemption Given Earlier
14
Problems on Gratuity:
1. Mr. Sri Hari retired from service on 10th Jan 2008. the salary at the time of retirement is as
follows:
Basic pay 6000 p.m., DA Rs. 4000 p.m of which 20% is not taken for retirement benefits
Bonus 10000 p.a., commission 10% of sales achieved by him. Total sales made by him for the
F.Y. ending 31st Dec 2007 is Rs. 600,000. He has rendered service for 29 years, 10 months and he
received gratuity of Rs. 140,000. Compute taxable gratuity if
a) he is an employee of Indian Railway
b) he is covered under Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972
c) he is not covered under Payment of Gratuity Act 1972
His last increment in basic pay of Rs. 500 p.m. was w.e.f. 1st oct 2007
2. Mr. Prakash retired from services on 10th jan.2007, the salary at the time of retirement was as
follows.
Basic pay- Rs. 12,000 p.m, DA- 6,000 p.m., Commission 3,000 P.m., Special allowance 4,000
p.m. Increment in basic pay Rs. 1000 p.m was from 1st may 2006. He has rendered service for 28
years 6 months 27 days. From the previous employer he has received Rs. 50000 of which Rs.
10,000 was taxed. Gratuity received Rs. 4,20,000. Total sales made by the employee for the
financial year ending 3st dec 2006 is Rs. 6,00,000. Compute taxable gratuity if
a) an employee of income tax Department
b) covered by Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972
c) not covered by Payment of Gratuity Act
Pension is a periodic payment received by an employee after retirement. It is fully taxable as salary in the
hands of employee. Family pension means pension earned / received by the members of the deceased. It is
taxed as income from other sources.
Commutation of pension means surrendering the right to receive a periodic pension against a lump sum
consideration. Pension can be commuted wholly or partly. Commutation of pension is exempted u/s
10(10A).
Pension is always taxable irrespective of whether the assessee is a government employee or a
non-government employee or irrespective of whether it is received while in service or after service.
Government here means Central Government, State Government, local authority and statutory
corporation.
(Pension is taxable under the head ‘salaries’ where as family pension is taxable under other sources)
However, commutation of pension received at the time of retirement is exempt as per provisions of Sec
10(10A). Commutation means surrendering the right to receive periodic pension against a lump sum
consideration.
Exemption is as under:
15
A. In receipt
Full value of commuted pension of gratuity:the commuted value of pension
means expressing B. Doesinnot receive
terms of 100%
Exemption= 1/3 x full value of gratuity:
commuted pensionSummary: Exemption= 1/2 x full
value of commuted pension
PROBLEM:
Q. Mr. Vivek retired from service on 1st Jan 2008 . he is eligible for pension of 6000 p.m. he commuted
2/3rd of pension on 1st march 2008 and received 300,000. Compute taxable amount of pension if
a) he receives gratuity
b) does not receive gratuity
2) In the above example if employee retired on 15 June, 2007 & was eligible for 9000 p.m.
Earned leave means leave granted but not availed or taken by the employee. The employee can encash
such leave not taken. This is called encashment of earned leave.
Encashment of earned leave received while in service is fully taxable (both for government and for non-
government). However encashment of earned leave received at the time of retirement is exempt as per the
provisions of Sec 10(10A).
Note:
1) Salary = Basic Pay + Dearness Allowance (if taken for retirement benefit) + Commission based
on fixed percentage of turnover.
2) Average salary means average of salary of 10 months immediately preceding the date of retirement (i.e.
including month of retirement unlike in case of gratuity)
16
3) While computing 30 days p.a., only complete years have to be considered.
4) If the employee receives encashment of earned leave from more than 1 employer then the above
exemption shall be restricted to the limit prescribed above (i.e. in totality)
5) If an exemption has been claimed during earlier years towards encashment of earned leave then,
statutory limit has to be reduced by such exemption.
[ For HRA u/s 10(13A), Gratuity not covered under PGA, 1972, Encashment of earned leave u/s
10(10AA), Contribution to RPF, VRS computations:
Salary = Basic Pay + Dearness Allowance, if taken for retirement benefit + commission based on
Fixed percentage of turnover.
For Gratuity covered under PGA, 1972:
Salary = Basic Pay + All kinds of Dearness allowance ]
Problems:
Q. Mrs. Shanthi retires from service on 30th nov 2007 after rendering service for 28 years. She
received Rs. 75,000 as encashment of earned leave. Leave granted as per company policy 20 days.
Earned leave was 12 months. Salary at the time of retirement was as under:
Basic pay: 4000 p.m. , DA 1200 p.m., commission 5% on sales ( sales for the last 12 months
effected by her is Rs. 900,000)
Last increment in basic pay of Rs. 2000 p.m.was w.e.f. 10th oct 2006
Compute taxable earned leave
Q. Mrs. Shruthi retired from service on 30th nov 2007 after rendering service for a period of 28 years
in ABC Pvt. Ltd. She received Rs. 75,000 towards encashment of earned leave.
Leave granted as per company policy was 45 days. Her earned leave is 12 months.
Salary details are as follows:
Basic pay Rs. 4000 p.m. , DA- 1200 P.m., commission 5% on sales ( sales for the last 12 months
effected by her is 9,00,000) last increment in basic pay of Rs.2000 p.m. was w.e.f. 10th oct 2006 )
Compute taxable earned leave
Q. In the above question if leave is taken by the employee is 12 months, then what is the answer?
Q. Mr.A retired from service on 28th feb 2008 after rendering service for a period of 30 years. He has
Taken a leave of 12 months during the tenure of his service. Salary at the time of retirement was:
Basic pay-8000 p.m., DA- 60% of basic pay of which 60% is taken for retirement benefits,
commission Rs. 2000 p.m.
Amount received at the time of retirement :
a) gratuity- Rs. 140,000
b) earned leave salary- 312,000
c) commuted pension- 180,000( 75% commuted)
compute taxable gratuity, earned leave and commuted pension for A.Y. 2008-09 if:
• leave granted as per company policy-20days
• leave granted as per company policy-40 days
17
Tax Treatment of Provident Fund (PF)
18
REFUND
Contribution Interest
Allowances
House rent allowance (HRA) is a fixed sum of allowance given to an employee to meet rental expenses.
Least of the following is exempt (for both government and non – government employees):
a) Actual HRA received
b) Rent paid less 10% of salary
c) 40% of salary [50% of the salary in case the accommodation (and not the place of employment) is in
Bombay, Calcutta, Chennai and Delhi]
e.g. Job in Mumbai, house in Pune – 40%
Note:
1) Salary = Basic Pay + Dearness allowance, if taken for retirement benefit (or considered for
retirement benefit or forms part of salary) + Commission based on fixed percentage
19
of turnover
2) Conditions for claiming exemption u/s 10(13A)
(i) Accommodation occupied by the assessee should not be owned by him.
(ii) Assessee should have actually incurred rental expenditure on accommodation occupied by
him during the previous year.
3) If there is a change in component of HRA computation ( say rent paid is different during two parts
or assessee works for two different employers during a year ) then HRA computations have to be
done separately.
4) Rule 2A r/w Sec 10(13A) states that HRA exemption should be given for the relevant period.
Relevant period means the period during which accommodation is occupied by the assessee.
20
Problems on special allowamce:
1. Mr. R received transport allowance of rs 1500 p.m.
Case:1- amount spent: Nil
Taxable amount:
Transport allowance received 1500
Less: amount prescribed by law 800
Taxable amount 700
2. Children education allowance :amount received : Rs.1000 p.m. per child for 3 children
Amount received(1000x12x3) 36000
Less: amount prescribed under law(100x12x2) 2400
Taxable amount 33600
3. children hostel allowance: amount received Rs.1000 p.m. for 3 children
amount received(1000x12) 12000
less: amount prescribed under law(300x12x3) 7200
amount taxable: 4800
4. children hostel allowance: amount received : Rs.600 p.m. for 3 children
amount received(600x12) 7200
less: amount exempted(200x12x2) 4800
taxable amount 2400
Sec 17(2)(i) Sec 17(2)(ii) Sec 17(2)(iii) Sec 17(2)(iv) Sec 17(2)(v) Sec 17(2)(vi)
Rent free Concessional Amenity/benefit to a Employees Employer Any other
accommodation Rent free specified employee obligation met contributing fringe benefits,
(RFA) accommodation Refer note: 1 by employer to a fund to (other than
Ex:Employees effect provided in
Proviso:ESOP (refer life insurance assurance chapter XII-H),
note 2) premium, on the life as may be
income tax of assessee prescribed
Explanation: use of borne by or contract (refer note 4)
company’s vehicle employer. of annuity
(refer note 3) Also refer sec
10(10CC)
21
NOTES:
1) Specified employee means :
a) director employee
b) an employee having substantial interest in the company, i.e. holding 20% or more of the
voting
power
c) an employee whose monetary income under the head salary after deductions under section
16
exceeds Rs. 50000 p.a.
EX: basic pay : 4000 p.m. , RFA valued at 160,000, DA-3000 p.a. deduction u/s 16(iii)-2000/-
The following three perquisites are taxable only in the hands of specified employees:
facility of sweeper, watchman,gardener, etc. – Rule 3(3)
facility of gas, electricity, or any other mode of power—Rule 3(4)
education facility—Rule 3(5)
Following are the only three fringe benefits covered under this category.
a) Interest free or concessional loan to employees
b) Use of employer’s moveable assets by the employees
c) Transfer of assets by employer to employee either free of cost or at concessional rate
4) Medical Perquisites:
Medical allowances are fully taxable. However medical perquisites are exempt as under:
Ex: Basic pay 140,000, DA -50,000, medical expenses-50,000 ( permitted by RBI Rs. 45000), traveling
expenses Rs. 110,000, income from other sources –Rs. 20,000
Soln:
GTI (before including traveling expenses)
Basic pay 140,000
DA 50,000
Medical expenses incurred 50,000
Less: permitted by RBI 45,000 5,000
195,000
income from other sources 20,000
GTI 215,000
Since GTI before including traveling expenses exceeds Rs. 200,000, entire traveling expenses is taxable
Statement of total income:
Basic pay 140,000
DA 50,000
Traveling expenses 110,000
Taxable medical expenses 5,000
Taxable salary income 305,000
23
Income from other sources 20,000
GTI 325,000
Note:
Medical perquisites can be availed by employee or any of his/her family members. Family for this purpose
and sec 10(5) means:
Spouse of individual
Any two children, parents, brothers, sisters
Wholly or mainly dependant on the individual
Rule 3 is applicable for any benefit derived by any employee or any member of his household by reason of such
employment. In other words all these perquisites are taxable only in the hands of employees.
When a director, non-employee is provided with a RFA, Rule 3 is not applicable. Further such RFA may not be
taxable in the hands of director, since there is no computation provision given in law. When computation fails,
taxation also fails. – held in B.C. Srinivas Shetty Vs. CIT (SC)
Own source:
Perq = Cost of such education in a similar institution in same or near by locality. If such cost does not exceed
Rs.100 p.m. per child, then there will not be any perquisites. (no restriction on number of children for IT purpose)
24
Valuation Of RFA/ CRFA
Sec 17(2) (i),(ii) read with rule 3(1)
II. Hotel
I. Government
Non- Accommodation
employee
Government (Government /
Perq = X+Y-Z
employee Non -Government)
Here X means
15% of salary
OR
If population is If Actual rent
exceeding 25 L If population is WIL
population
as per 2001 >10L but ≤25L
is ≤10L
census 15% of 10% of
7.5% of
salary salary
salary
NOTE 1:- Hotel accommodation may be for I or II. Further there is no Y here.
25
NOTE 2:- Y means perquisites value of furnishing say furniture, air conditioner, TV, refrigerator etc, if any
provided.
Condition 1
Condition 2
Note: 5. More than one accommodation given on transfer:-When an accommodation is given in the new place
of posting, while retaining accommodation at old place of posting.
OR RFA of
RFA of RFA of RFA of
House 2 House 2 R
House 1 House 1 Q
2
WEL
Say P
Taxable perquisites = P+Q+R
Note 6:-
26
Accommodation includes a house, flat, farm house or part thereof or accommodation in a hotel or motel, service
apartment, guest house, caravan, mobile home, or other floating structure.
Hotel includes licensed accommodation in the nature of motel, service apartment or guest house.
Interest rates shall be prescribed by SBI applicable as on 1st April of the relevant P.Y. The rates applicable for
A.Y. 2009-10 are:
27
- Above 15 yrs but upto 25 years 10.75%
II) Use of moveable assets (other than computers and laptops) belonging to employer, by the employee:
Perquisites = Y; i.e.,
a) when such asset is owned by the employer 10 of original cost; or
b) when the assets are taken on hire, such actual hire charges
Note: moveable item do not include vehicles
III)Transfer/ sale of any assets by the employer to employee
Perquisite is computed as under:
Original cost of asset XXX
Less depreciation as per prescribed rates XXX
(Refer note 1)
Book value XXX
Less: sale value (amount received from employee) XXX
Perquisites XXX
Note1:
Depreciation rates for this purpose:
computers and electronic items:- 50% of WDV
motor car:- 20% of WDV
other assets :- 10% p.a. for every completed year of usage under SLM
Eg: Furn – 10L; used for 4 yrs 11 months; Depreciation = 4L
Note 2:
Electronic items does not include TVs, Refrigerators, micro- owens, washing machines, AC, etc. electronics
items include digital diaries, printers, etc
General note: when asset is more than 10 years old there won’t be any perquisite.
Sec 10(10B) : Exemption towards Retrenchment compensation
Least of the following is exempted u/s 10(10B)
28
1) Actual compensation received XXX
2) amount prescribed U/S 25(F) of Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 XXX
3) statutory limit 5,00,000
Retrenchment compensation means amount received by the employee at the time of premature termination
(income as per Sec 17(3))
Salary = Basic pay + DA( if taken for retirement benefits) + commission based on fixed % on turnover
executed by employee
29
Problems
30
Rs.1,500 p.m; (vi) Educational facility for 2 children provided free of cost. The school is
owned and maintained by the company. (vii) Interest free loan of Rs.5,00,000 repayable
within 7 years given on 1.10.2008 for purchase of a house. No repayment was made
during the year. (viii) Interest free loan for purchase of computer Rs.50,000 given 1.1.2007.
No repayment was made during the year. (ix) Corporate membership of a club. The initial
fee of Rs.1,00,000 was paid by the company. Ullas paid the bills for his use of club facilities.
You are required to compute the income of Ullas under Salaries in respect of AY 2009-10.
Suitable assumptions may be made, wherever necessary.
31
INCOME FROM HOUSE PROPERTY
[Sections 22 to 27]
The rental income of a house property is chargeable to tax under the ‘Income from House Property’.
(Profit on sale of building is taxable under the head ‘Capital Gains’). House Property for this purpose
means any building which has the characteristic features of a building. It includes residential building,
commercial building, cinema theatres etc.
Income from house property is the only head of income which is taxed on notional basis i.e. taxed even
there is no income.
Ex: Mr.X owns three houses and uses all the three for self-occupation. In this case two house properties
are deemed to be let out and hence taxed accordingly.
Exceptions to the rule that the rental income of the building is taxable under the head
House Property:-
1. Income from sub letting – Income from Other Sources since assessee is not the owner.
2. Composite Rent – When a building has been let out along with the furniture, then such letting out
is called composite letting.
a) As per section 56(2) when the rent is inseparable then entire rent is taxable under other
sources.
b) As per CIT vs Shambhu Investments Pvt. Ltd., (S.C.) (2003) such inseparable composite
rent is taxable under House Property.
However, if the composite rent is separable then the rent relating to the building is taxed under
House Property and rent relating to furniture is taxed under the head Business or Other
Sources.
Ex.1: Mr. A lets out building along with furniture for Rs. 12000 – for building Rs.10000, furniture
Rs.2000. In this House Property income is Rs.10000 and Business / Other Sources income is Rs.2000.
32
Ex.2: In the above example if rent is inseparable Rs.12000 is taxable under House Property.
3. When a building has been let out to Employees/Directors – Income from Business.
4. Building let out for Bank or Post Office, Courier Agency etc., wherein letting out is incidental and
subservient to the business – Income from Business.
Section 27 – Owner
In the following cases even the persons other than registered owners shall be deemed to be the owners.
1) Transfer of property without adequate consideration to spouse without having an agreement to live
apart or to a minor child not being a married daughter – Transferor shall be the deemed owner.
2) Holder of an impartible estate shall be the deemed owner.
3) Disputed Ownership – Assessing officer shall decide the ownership of the property depending upon
the facts and circumstances of the case. Ex: Mukesh and Anil disputing for a property. Assessing
officer decides Mukesh the owner of the property.
Case 1: The Court decides Mukesh is the owner :- Assessment done hitherto shall be continued as it is.
Case 2: The Court later decides Anil is the owner – Assessment done on Mukesh shall be reversed
and fresh assessment shall be done in the name of Anil.
4) Allotment of houses of Company / AOP Co-operative society to its members under a house building
scheme of such institution
5) The person in possession of the property shall be the deemed owner in case of part performance of a
contract referred in Sec 53A of Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
6) In case of lease for a period not less than 12 months lessee shall be the deemed owner. However, it
should be not be a month to month lease or lease period should not exceed one year.
Sec 23 (2) – The annual value of one house or part of the house used for self occupation or which could
not be occupied for the reasons of employment or business / profession elsewhere shall be nil.
33
Sec 23 (3) – Conditions for Sec 23(2) property – To claim annual value as nil the following two
conditions should be satisfied:
a) Property is not actually let out during the year AND
b) No other benefit is derived from such property.
Sec 23(4) – Deemed Let Out Property (DLOP) – If the assessee own or has more than 23(2) properties
then:
a) Annual value of one property at the option of the assessee shall be taken as nil
b) Annual value of the other properties (i.e. DLOP) is computed as
per Sec 23(1)(a)
Points to be noted:
1) If the property is deemed to be let out then Sec 23(1)(b) and Sec 23(1)(c) shall not arise. A property
shall be deemed to be let out if and only if it is actually not let out even for part of the year.
2) Fair Rental Value (FRV) means rental value of a similar house in a similar locality or near by locality
OR municipal value, whichever is higher.
3) FRV cannot exceed the standard rental value
Note:
1) Only if (e) > (d) vacancy allowance has to be considered. (Otherwise it is ignored)
2) Annual value of the property cannot exceed standard rent as per Rent Control Act. (Sheila Kaushish
vs. CIT). However, if actual rent received is the highest figure then the same should be taken as
annual value.
1) Sec 24(a) – Standard deduction @ 30% of NAV – Only for LOP and DLOP.
2) Sec 24(b) – Interest on capital or loan borrowed for acquisition, construction, renewal, repairs and
reconstruction in respect of
a) LOP / DLOP – Any amount is allowed
b) SOP – Deduction is as follows:
(i) Normal deduction upto Rs.30,000/-
(ii) Special deduction upto Rs.1,50,000/- (Refer Note 1 below)
34
Explanation – Pre-Construction Period (Refer Note 2 below)
Note:
1) Interest deduction upto Rs.1,50,000/-. It is available only for acquisition and construction. However,
the following conditions must be satisfied:
a) The loan should have been taken on or after 01.04.1999 and construction should have been
completed within 3 years from the end of the financial year in which loan is borrowed.
b) For claiming deduction the interest certificate giving details of interest amount, principal
outstanding etc. has to be attached along with return of income.
2) Pre-Construction Period Interest – Pre-Construction Period interest is allowed in 5 equal annual
instalments commencing from the year of completion. PCP means the period commencing from date
of the loan till the complete repayment of loan or immediately preceding March 31st of the year of
completion, whichever is earlier.
3) Penal interest on interest is not allowed u/s 24.
4) Loan can be taken from friends and relatives also
5) Unpaid purchase price is considered as loan
6) Interest is allowed on accrual basis and not on cash basis.
Points to be noted:
1) Annual value of partly self-occupied and partly vacant property (one property)
35
2) Annual value of partly self-occupied and partly let out (one property)
Treated as DLOP
for entire period Annual Value of Annual Value of
SOP is Nil LOP to be taken at
25%
36
Chapter IV-D - Profits and Gains from Business or Profession
As per Sec 2(13) "Business includes trade, commerce or manufacture or any adventure or concern in the
nature of trade, commerce or manufacture". Normally to constitute a business there should be a series of
transactions. However, in certain cases even a single transaction can constitute a business. Ex: Joint
venture for export. Further the motive of the enterprise is irrelevant i.e. whether profit motive or non -
profit motive of the enterprise. It is still chargeable under Chapter IV D.
As per Sec 2 (36) "Profession includes vocation". It means application of skill, Knowledge
Eg: Medicine, Chartered Accountant, Lawyers, Actors etc.
The provisions of this head of income are same for business as well as profession.
1. Specific Deduction
Sec 30 – Rent, rate, repairs, insurance of building
Revenue expenditure on repair (current repair), rent, insurance etc.
Sec 31 – Repairs and insurance of machinery, plant and furniture
Revenue expenditure on repair, insurance etc. on these assets are allowed
as deduction.
Sec 32 – Depreciation
32(1)(i) SLM
32(1)(ii) WDV
32(1)(iia) Additional Depreciation
32(1)(iii) Terminal Depreciation
37
32(2) Carry forward of unabsorbed loss / allowance – Depreciation allowance
can be adjusted against any income in first year as well as subsequent
years and can be carried forward for any number of years.
Methods of Depreciation:
Straight Line Method
Written Down Value Method
In the year of sale of asset, covered under this type of depreciation, the tax treatment is as under (For
profit / loss on sale)
i) When Sale value is less than book value – Sec 32(1)(iii)
Loss is treated as terminal depreciation if and only if written off in the books of Account. (Loss = Book
value – Sale value)
ii) When sale value is greater than book value
Sale Value – Original cost = Short Term Capital Gain u/s 50A.
(Sale Value or Original Cost, whichever is less) – Book Value;
This is Balance in charge (business income) u/s 41(2).
Ex: Original Cost of asset – Rs.10 lacs. Book Value – Rs.3 lacs
The asset is sold for:
(i) Rs.2,00,000
Soln: Rs.1,00,000 can be claimed as terminal depreciation
under Sec 32(1)(iii) provided same is written off in the books
(ii) Rs.5,00,000 (Sale Value < Original Cost)
Soln: Profit = Rs.5 Lac – Rs.3 Lac = Rs.2 Lac. This is considered
as balance – in – charge u/s 41(2) and taxed as business income
(iii) Rs.12,00,000
Soln: Profit = Rs.12 Lac – Rs.3 Lac = Rs.9 Lac
A. Rs.12 Lac – Rs.10 Lac = Rs.2 Lac. This is the Short Term
Capital Gain u/s 50A.
B. Rs.10 Lac or Rs.12 Lac WEL
i.e. Rs.10 Lac – Rs.3 Lac = Rs.7 Lac. This is the Balance
in Charge (Recovery of depreciation).
Note: 1) SLM method of depreciation is not applicable for entities engaged in mere
distribution of power (Eg: KPTCL).
2) Sec 32(1)(i) and Sec 50A are applicable to tangible as well as intangible assets whereas Sec 32(1)(iii)
and Sec 41(2) are applicable only to tangible assets.
38
2. Written Down Value Method
i) Depreciation under this method is charged on basis of block of asset concept.
ii) As per Sec 2(11) Block of assets means “tangible assets namely building, machinery, furniture and
plant OR intangible assets AND having same rate of depreciation.”
Intangible assets include know-how, patents, trademarks, copyright, license, franchise or any other asset
of similar nature.
Normally for all intangible assets only one block of asset (since the rate of depreciation is equal).
However under each category of tangible assets there may be various blocks of assets.
iii) Depreciation is calculated based on WDV as on 31st March of the previous year.
iv) As per 43(6) WDV is computed as under:
WDV as on 1st April of PY XXX
Add: Actual cost of additions during the year XXX
Less: Sale value on sale/Insurance money received
on destruction of asset XXX
Sec 35ABB – Expenditure on obtaining tele-communication license – It is allowed equally over license
period commencing from the year of commencement of business.
Sec 35D – Preliminary expenses only for Indian Company or Non-corporate resident assessee. Deduction
per year = 1/5th of preliminary expenses
Preliminary expenses allowed is Actual amount OR 5% of cost of the project WEL.
However in case of Indian Companies higher of Cost of the project and capital employed is considered for
ascertaining the 5% criteria.
Notes:
1. Preliminary expenses include expenditure on feasibility study, preparation of project
report, MOA, AOA, legal fees etc.
2. Cost of the project includes cost of fixed assets as on last day of PY in which business
is commenced.
3. Capital employed = Issued Share Capital + Debentures + Long Term Borrowing as on
last day of PY in which business is commenced.
Long term borrowings also include creditors for Fixed Asset imported from abroad,
wherein the credit period exceeding 7 years.
40
Sec 35 DD – Expenditure on amalgamation / de-merger – Deduction is 1/5 th of such expenses (only for
companies)
Sec 35DDA – Expenditure incurred on VRS compensation – Deduction is 1/5th of such expenditure. It is
applicable only to Indian Companies and any person, not being a company, resident in India.
Sec 37(2B) – Any advertisement in a journal, pamphlet, tract, souvenir, belonging to a political party shall
not be allowed.
36(1)(ia) – Insurance premium on the cattle belonging to the members of federal milk co operative society
paid by the society (Deduction to society)
36(1)(ib) – Health insurance premia paid by employer, by way of A/c Payee cheque, on health of
employees.
36(1)(iii) – Interest on borrowed capital – It is allowed as a deduction. Any interest on capital borrowed
till the date asset is put to use cannot be claimed as a deduction as that amount is capitalised. (only for
extension of business)
36(1)(iiia) – Discount on zero coupon bonds which are primarily infrastructure bonds is allowed pro-rata
over the life of the bond.
36(1)(vi) – Deduction towards Animals other than stock-in-trade – Deduction is allowed in the year of
death of animals or in the year in which it becomes permanently useless.
41
Deduction = Cost of animals – Sale value of Carcasses.
36(1)(vii) – Bad debt is allowed as a deduction, provided conditions u/s 36(2) are satisfied. It does not
include RBD.
36(1)(viii) – Deduction is for a specified entity for eligible business computed under head Profits &
Gains of Business or Profession.
– Deduction = Special Reserve created or 20% of the profit of such business WEL.
No deduction when the balance in such reserve exceeds twice paid up capital & General reserve.
36(1)(x) – Omitted.
36(1)(xi) – Omitted.
36(1)(xii) – Any expenditure incurred by corporation or body corporate for meeting the objects of such
entity.
36(1)(xiii) – Banking Cash Transaction Tax is allowed.
36(1)(xiv) – Contribution towards Exchange risk administration fund – Credit guarantee fund trust for
small industry.
36(1)(xv) – Securities Transaction Tax w.e.f. 1.4.08 (STT)
36(1)(xvi) – Commodity Transaction Tax w.e.f. AY 2009-10 (CTT)
Treatment of bad debts recovered – Sec 41(4) – It should be treated as business income to the extent
allowed earlier.
Ex: Bad debts in the year 2002-03 – 10 Lacs. Allowed by ITO – Rs.7 lacs. Bad debts recovered – 5 lacs
Income u/s 41(4) is 5 lacs – 3 lacs (disallowed earlier) = 2 lacs.
42
Sec 40(a) – Amounts not deductible
The following amount shall not be deducted while computing business income.
(i)Any interest, royalty, technical fees etc payable outside India or in India to a non-resident (Other
than a Company or foreign company) on which no TDS is made or after deducting the TDS has not
been remitted to the government.
(ia) Any interest, rent, commission, brokerage, technical fees, professional fees, contract amount etc
payable to a resident in India, for which no TDS is made or after deducting the TDS has not been
remitted to the government.
Note: Salary paid to a resident in India even without TDS is allowed as deduction.
(ib) Security transaction tax. (AY – 2009-10 allowed)
(ic) FBT
(ii) Any amount of income tax or any other sum charged under this Act..
(iia) Wealth Tax
(iii) Salary payable
Outside India (resident or non-resident)
To a non-resident, without TDS (in India)
(iv) Any payment out of PF or any other employee welfare fund unless effective TDS arrangement
has been made.
(v) Tax referred u/s 10(10CC) i.e. tax paid by employer on non-monetary perquisites.
Note: In Point No. (1) and (2) above, the amount shall be allowed in the subsequent year if TDS
condition is satisfied in subsequent years.
Sec 40A(3) – Payment made in excess of Rs.20,000 otherwise than by account payee cheque or Demand
Draft – 100% of such expenditure is disallowed.
Sec 40A(7) – Provision for gratuity is disallowed. However the following amounts shall be allowed:
a) Gratuity actually paid during the year.
b) Provision that has become payable during current financial year.
43
Note: Employer’s contribution should be paid before the due date u/s 139(1), if paid
subsequently allowed in that year. Employees contribution should be paid within the due date
under relevant Act. If it is paid after the due date, it is never allowed.
(iii) Bonus or commission as referred in Sec 36(1)(ii).
(iv) Any interest on loan or borrowings from Public Financial Institution, SFC, State Industrial
Investment Corporation.
(v) Any interest payable on loans/advances taken from a scheduled bank.
(vi) Any amount payable by employer towards earned leave.
If any of the above mentioned items are paid after due date then the same shall be allowed in
such year of payment.
Eg: Bonus debited to P&L A/c of 07-08-10L(A Ltd)
Bonus paid Rs 3L on 10.3.08, Rs 5L on 15.9.08, 2L on 14.2.2008;
Rs 8L is allowed for FY 07-08 & Rs 2L for FY 08-09
Deduction of interest, salary etc allowed u/s 40(b). Share of profit is exempt in the hands of partner u/s
10(2A)
PFAOP – If any of the condition prescribed in sec 184 are not satisfied.
Sec 40(ba) – no deduction is allowed towards interest, salary etc paid to partner of PFAOP. Further, share
of profit received by a partner of PFAOP is not exempt u/s 10(2A).
Sec 40(b) – Deduction towards interest & salary to the partners of PFAS :
Interest :
1. it should be mentioned in the deed
2. interest allowed is interest as per deed or 12% p.a., WEL.
3. this interest is applicable on any amount given by the partner (capital or loan).
Remuneration to partners
1. It should be mentioned in the deed.
2. It is allowed only to the working partners. Working partner means a partner who is actively
engaged in the affairs of the firm.
3. Remuneration allowed is amount prescribed in deed or amount prescribed in Sec 40(b) whichever
is less.
Non-Professional Firm
a) Book Profit upto 1st Rs.75,000 – Remuneration allowed is 90% of book profit or Rs.50,000
whichever is higher.
b) On next Rs.75,000 – 60% of book profit
c) On balance of book profit – 40% of book profit.
Professional Firm
Substitute Rs.1,00,000 in place of Rs.75,000 in the above format
45
Sec 44AB – Tax Audit:
(a) Business – Turnover / Gross receipts in the current previous year exceed Rs.40
lacs
(b) Profession – Gross receipts exceed Rs.10 lac in current previous year.
(c) Presumptive Tax - 44AD, 44AE, 44AF, 44BB, 44BBB and claiming lower
income than prescribed.
In all the 3 cases, assessees have to get their accounts audited by a CA and submit the report
within the specified date i.e. 31st October of AY.
If there is a default under this section the penalty is 0.5% of turnover or Rs.1lac which ever is less.
Audit report has to submitted in Form No. 3CA or 3CB along with statement of particulars in
Form No. 3CD.
Presumptive Taxation – Sec 44AD, Sec 44AE and Sec 44AF.
In the above sections law presumes certain minimum incomes.
Sec 44AD – Profits and gains from civil construction including works contract
1. Income = Turnover or Gross receipts x 8%
2. 44AD is applicable if and only if turnover does not exceed Rs.40 lacs.
Sec 44AE – Profits and gains from goods carriage vehicles
1. For heavy goods vehicle Rs.3,500 per month or part of the month
Other vehicles – Rs.3,150 per month or part of the month
2. Assessee should not own more than 10 vehicles at any time during the previous year.
3. Asset taken on hire purchase or installment are deemed to be owned.
Gross receipts may be over Rs.40 lakhs
Sec 44AF – Profits and gains of retail business
Minimum income = Turnover x 5%.
Turnover should not exceed Rs.40 lacs.
It should be pure retail business.
Problems:
1 P & L A/c of ABC & Co. for year ending 31.3.09 :
To general expenses 2,000,000 By gross profit 3,000,000
To depreciation 500,000 By dividend received 400,000
To donation 1,500,000 By Net loss 2,610,000
To interest to partners at 18% p.a.
A 180,000.00
B 90,000.00
C 240,000.00 510,000
To salary
A 200,000.00
B 1,000,000
C 300,000.00 1,500,000
46
6,010,000 6,010,000
Adjustments :
i) Depreciation u/s 32 - 3,00,000
B/f depreciation loss 1 L & Business loss-2L
ii) Commission received - 3,00,000 directly credited to partners capital.
Compute income of firm & partners & tax.
iii)FD Interest 3L
2 Mr.Gautham is a Chartered Accountant practising at Mangalore. The following is the
analysis of his Receipts and Payments Account for the year ending 31.03.2006:
Receipts Amount Payments Amount
To Balance b /d 9,500 By Salaries 64,000
To Professional Income 190,000 By Rent 12,000
To House Rent for 8 months 32,000 By Telephone Expenses 5,500
To Share of Income from HUF 6,250 By Professional Expenses 3,000
To share of profit from firm 11,000 By Motor Car Expenses 7,500
To LIC policy matured 77,750 By Misc. Office Expenses 1,500
with bonus By Purchase of Car 80,000
By Advance Income-tax 12,500
By Personal Expenses 42,400
By Entertainment Expenses 17,000
By House Property Expenses
- Municipal Taxes 6,000
- Repairs 2,500
- Insurance 2,000
- Collection Charges 600
By Balance c /d 70,000
326,500 326,500
Compute Mr.Gautham's Gross Total Income after taking into account, the following:
a) Value of benefits received from clients during the course of profession is Rs.5,000/-.
b) Allowable rate of depreciation on motor car is 15%.
c) Municipal value of house property is Rs.42,000. The house was self-occupied for
residence for 4 months during the year.
d) Salary outstanding – 6000/-
e) 40% of the car is used for personal expenses.
CAPITAL GAINS
Chapter IV – E (Sec 45 – Sec 55A)
Any profits or gains arising on transfer of a capital asset is chargeable to tax under the head Capital Gains,
unless specifically exempt u/s 54 to 54H.
Capital Gain = Transfer [Sec 2(47)] + Capital Asset [Sec 2(14)]
48
TYPES OF CAPITAL ASSETS
1) Short Term Capital Asset (STCA – Sec 2(42A))
It means any capital asset held by the assessee for not more than 36 months immediately preceding the
date of its transfer. (i.e. <= 36 months)
However, in the following cases, 12 months is considered instead of 36 months
(i) Shares (listed or unlisted).
(ii) Other listed securities.
(iii) Units of UTI or Mutual fund as specified in 10(23D).
(iv) Zero coupon bonds (w.e.f. AY 2006-07)
Note 1: In the case of LTCA, cost of acquisition and improvement have to be indexed, i.e. to give the
benefit of inflation and change in the time value of money.
49
Indexed cost = cost of acquisition/improvement X cost inflation index of year of transfer
cost inflation index of year of acquisition/improvement
Note 2: In case of assets acquired before 1.4.1981, the assessee has the option to choose either the actual
cost or fair value as on 1.4.1981 (whichever is higher).
All improvements before 1.4.1981 should be completely ignored (incurred by assessee or previous
owner)
Eg:
Balance Sheet
Share capital 8L Land 10L
P&L A/c 4L Building 8L
CRR 1L Machinery 4L
Debentures 6L Stock 3L
Creditors 5L Debtors 1L
O/S Expenses 3L Preliminary expenses 1L
27L 27L
Net worth:
Assets: Land 10L
Building 7L
Machinery 3L
Stock 3L
Debtors 1L
(a) 24L
Less: Liabilities
Debentures 6L
Creditors 5L
O/S Expenses 3L
(b) 14L
Net worth (a) – (b) 10L
Therefore, LTCG = sale (22L) – Net worth (10L) = 12L
Sec 50C: COMPUTATION OF CAPITAL GAIN ON SALE LAND OR BUILDING OR BOTH AND
IMPACT OF STAMP VALUATION
Applicable only for sale of land or building or both.
Sale value shall be
(1) Actual sale value or stamp valuation, whichever is higher.
(2) Whichever is higher in (1) or valuation as per valuation officer (if referred by assessee), whichever is
less (but minimum is actual sale value).
Eg1: Cost of land – 10L; Actual sale value – 15L; Stamp valuation (a) 12L (b) 20L;
FMV – Rs.17L.
Solution:
(a) 15L or 12L, WEH = Rs.15L
Less: cost Rs.10L
51
STCG Rs.5L
Eg2: In the above Eg1, if reference is made to valuation officer, what is sale value
If value is (a) 18L (b) 22L (c) 12L
LONG-TERM (Special)
Sec 112 – Listed equity shares/units of equity oriented funds subject to STT; Exempt u/s10(38).
Others – Note – 2
Note – 1:
STCG on sale of listed equity shares or units of an equity oriented fund. It is taxed at 10% subject to
following conditions:
(a) Sale is on or after 1.10.2004
(b) Such transaction is subject to STT.
(c) If other income is below taxable limit (Rs.1,50,000) then the deficit shall be taken out of
such CG [Applicable only for resident individual or HUF]
(d) No deduction under Chapter VI-A (including Sec 80C) against this income or tax.
Note – 2:
Other long-term Capital Gains are taxed at flat rate of 20%
(a) Resident individual/HUF can use LTCG for adjusting deficit arising on account of other b
income being below taxable (same as 111-A above)
(b) Chapter VI-A deductions cannot be given.
52
(c) Incase of transfer of listed securities including equity shares [if not covered u/s 10(38)], the
following option is given:
(i) Tax @ 20% after indexing the cost or
(ii) Tax @ 10% without indexation.
Note: While computing GTI, the income to be taken is always after indexation. Only while computing
tax, the above option should be exercised.
Note: The relaxation, exemption etc are for shares, listed securities etc. If listed securities are sold without
undergoing STT then exemption u/s10(38) is not available.
Sec 54: Exemption in respect of LTCG arising on transfer of residential house property and investment in
residential house property.
(a) Applicable only for individuals or HUF.
(b) Asset transferred should be LTCA, being residential house property.
(c) The assessee should invest LTCG in a residential house property. There is no restriction on
number of house properties to be invested.(However law uses the word ‘a house property’)
(d) Amount of exemption is LTCG or amount invested, whichever is less.
(e) Period of investment:
Sec 54B: Exemption in respect of capital gain on the transfer of urban agricultural land used for
agriculture
(a) Applicable only for individuals.
53
(b)The asset transferred should be agricultural land (ST or LT)
(c) Such agricultural land should have been used for agricultural purposes in the 2 years immediately
preceding the date of transfer either by himself or by his parents.
(d)Amount to be invested is CG.
(e) Exemption = amount invested or CG, whichever is less.
(f) Time limit for investment: The assessee should invest such capital gain within 2 yrs from the date
of transfer in another agricultural land, urban or rural.
Note: Other provisions of CGAS / default provisions (Refer Sec 54).
Sec 54D: Exemption in respect of capital gain on compulsory acquisition of Land & Buildings forming
part of industrial undertaking
(a) Applicable for all kinds of assessees.
(b) The capital asset transferred may be LT or ST.
(c) Capital asset acquired should be (i) Land (ii) Building (iii) Right in land or building.
(d) Such capital asset should form part of an industrial undertaking belonging to assessee.
(e) Such capital asset should have been used by assessee for the purpose of business of the
undertaking for 2 yrs immediately preceding the date of transfer.
(f) The asset should have been acquired by way of compulsory acquisition under any law.
(g) Amount to be invested is capital gain.
(h) Investment should be in another land or building or any right in such land or building, forming
part of another industrial undertaking (building can either be purchased or constructed).
(i) Time limit: Time limit for investments is within 3 yrs from the date of transfer.
(j) Capital Gain = amount invested or CG, WEL.
Note: For CGAS and transfer of new asset within 3 yrs, refer Sec 54.
Sec 54F: Exemption in respect of LTCG on transfer of LTCA other than residential HP & invested in
residential HP
(a) Applicable for individual and HUF.
(b) Asset transferred should be a LTCA other than residential HP. Therefore, if a commercial HP is
transferred Sec 54F is applicable.
(c) The investment should be made in residential HP.
(d) The investment should be Net Sale Consideration (NSC).
(e) Time limit for investment – same as Sec 54.
(f) Capital Gain exempted is:
(i) If investment is greater than or equal to NSC, entire capital gain is exempt.
(ii) If investment is less than NSC, then exemption is proportionate amount
i.e. Exemption = Total CG X Investment
NSC
(g) The assessee should not own more than one house property other than one purchased for Sec
54F on the date of transfer. In other words, the maximum number of house properties that an
assessee can own on date of transfer is 2. i.e. one house property (existing) + one purchased
within 1 year before date of transfer as per provisions of Sec 54F.
Note: For CGAS and transfer of new asset within 3 yrs, refer Sec 54.
Sec 54G: Exemption in respect of capital gain on transfer of asset in the course of shifting of industrial
undertaking from urban area
(a) Applicable for all assessees.
54
(b) Capital asset may be LT or ST.
(c) Capital asset should be: (i) Machinery (ii) Plant (iii) Building (iv) Any right in building (v)
Land.
It does not cover rights in P&M etc (only in building). It also does not cover furniture & fittings.
(d) Such capital asset should be used for purpose of industrial undertaking.
(e) The capital gain arises on transfer of above said capital asset in the course of shifting an
industrial undertaking. Eg: land is sold since industrial undertaking is getting shifted from
urban area.
(f) The industrial undertaking should be shifted from urban area to any area other than urban area.
(It can be shifted to semi-urban area also).
(g) The assessee should invest CG.
(h) The investment should be made in another machinery, plant, building (purchase/construction)
or land. Exemption shall also be given towards expenses incidental to shifting.
(i) Time limit for investment: Within 1 year before date of transfer or within 3 yrs after date of
transfer.
Note: For CGAS and transfer of new asset within 3 yrs, refer Sec 54.
Sec 54EC: Exemption in respect of LTCG on transfer of any asset & investment in certain bonds
(a) The asset transferred should be LTCA (including residential HP, jewellery, and agricultural
land).
(b) The investment to be made is CG.
(c) Investment should be made in the long-term specified assets i.e. any bond redeemable after 3
years issued by:
NHAI – National Highway Authority of India.
RECL – Rural Electrification Corporation Ltd.
(d) Time limit for investment: Within 6 months from the date of transfer.
(e) Exemption = CG or Amount invested, WEL.
(f) Withdrawal of exemption: If any time within 3 years from the date of acquisition of such
specified asset. The said asset is either transferred or converted into money in any other mode
or any loan or advance is taken on the security of such specified asset then, CG exempted
earlier shall be taxed as LTCG.
Note: Provisions of CGAS is not applicable for Sec 54EC & 54ED.
Maximum investment is Rs 50 Lakhs w.e.f 1.4.07
Sec 54H: Extension of time limit for acquiring new asset or depositing or investing amount of capital
gains
Where transfer of a capital asset u/s 54, 54B, 54D, 54EC, 54F is by way of compulsory acquisition and the
compensation is not received as on the date of transfer then, the time limit shall commence from the date
of receipt of compensation and not from the date of transfer. (Also refer Sec 45(5)).
55
GIST OF EXEMPTIONS
(a) 54B, 54D and 54G - Short term / Long term (Others Long term) (Bombay Delhi Goa)
(b) 54, 54F - Individual / HUF
54B - Only Individuals (Applicability)
(c) Investment - Capital Gains in all except Net Sale Consideration in 54F
(d) Exemption - Capital Gains or Investment w.e.t (except 54F where there is
proportionate exemption)
(e) Time Limit - (I) 54 / 54F - within 1 year before or within 2 years for purchase (construction
– 3 years)
(ii) 54B - 2 years
(iii) 54D - within 3 years
(iv) 54G/GA - within 1 year before or within 3 yrs after
(v) 54EC - 6 months.
(f) CGAS - all except 54EC
(g) New asset not to transfer within 3 years in all
(h) one to one correlation 54, 54B, 54D and 54G.
56
(vi) Apart from the incomes given in Sec 56(2), the following incomes are always taxed under
other sources.
(a) Family pension
(b) Salary of M.P.
(c) Honorarium
(d) Royalties
(e) Copyrights, technical know-how etc if not taxed u/s 28.
(f) Bank interest etc.
It means including in one’s income, the income of other person. Basic intention of clubbing is to reduce
tax evasions, except in special cases such as Sec 64(1A).
(i) If the marriage of parent does not subsist, then clubbing shall be made in the hands of such
parent who is maintaining child.
(ii) If the parents are not alive, clubbing is made in the hands of guardian. (not specifically
provided in law)
In the case of (a), (b) and (c) above, minor child himself shall be the assessee and parent/guardian shall be
deemed u/s 2(7).
DEEMED INCOMES
Sec 68 to 69D
Sec 68: Cash Credit
If any amount is found credited in the books of the assessee and no explanation is given by him about the
same or explanation is unsatisfactory then, such amount shall be taxed as cash credit.
Sec 69: Unexplained Investment
Investments found with the assessee but not recorded in the books are deemed income.
58
Sec 69A: Unexplained money, jewellery, bullion etc.
Same as Sec 69.
Sec 69B: Investments, jewellery, bullions etc. partly disclosed in the books
Deemed income – to the extent not disclosed in the books.
Sec 69C: Unexplained Expenditure
If the assessee offers no explanation or unsatisfactory explanation about the expenditure incurred then, the
same shall be deemed to be income. No deduction shall be allowed against such income under any head
of income.
Sec 69D: Amount borrowed or repaid in Hundi
Hundi means Bill of Exchange in vernacular language. It is taxable either at the time of borrower or at the
time of repayment (including interest).
Sec 74A: Losses from the activity of owning and maintaining race horse.
Only for 4 subsequent years and can be adjusted only against such income.
Sec 78: Change in constitution of firm & carry forward incase of succession
(i) Change in constitution of the firm: The firm cannot carry forward loss relatable to share of
retired/deceased partner.
(ii) Succession: If any person carrying business/profession has been succeeded in such capacity by
another person otherwise than by inheritance. No losses can be carried by the successor.
Sec 79: Carry forward or set-off of losses incase of company in which public are not substantially interested
Carry forward of losses unless shareholders holding atleast 51% of the voting power share continued to be
shareholders even on the last day of the P.Y. in which carry forward or set-off is to be claimed. However,
this is not applicable if change in shareholding takes place because of death of the shareholder or transfer
of shares by way of gift to any relative.
Chapter VI A Deductions
80C (1) Actual amount paid towards Life Insurance Upto Rs.1,00,000
Policy Premium
60
(2) Contribution to Public Provident Fund
(3) Investments in National Savings Certificates
(4) Subscription to any approved units of mutual fund
referred to in Sec
10(23D)
(5) Contribution by an employee to a recognised
provident fund
(6) Contribution by an employee to an
super
annuation fund
(7) Contribution to Unit Linked Insurance Plan, 1971
(8) Payment made as tuition fees to any university,
college or school or other educational institution
situated in India for the purpose of full time
education in respect of any two children of the
assessee.
(9) Repayment of loan taken from Government
Approved Institution or Specified Employer or any
Board or a Corporation or any other body
established under Central or State Act or a
notified Institution, borrowed for the purpose of
purchase or construction of residential house.
Any expenditure incurred towards stamp duty,
registration charges for purchase of the house is
also eligible.
(10) Amount Contributed towards a contract for
deferred annuity.
(11) Contribution to 10 / 15 year account under Post
Office Savings Bank (Cumulative Time
Deposit) Rules,
1959
w.e.f AY 08-09 Bonds of NABARDS
w.e.f AY 07-08 FD in a scheduled bank for
a period of 5 years
80CCC Annuity or Pension Fund (LIC or other Insurer) Upto Rs.1,00,000
.
80CCD Central Government Pension Scheme a) Employer's Contribution
10% of salary or actual
amount paid by the employee
b) 10% of salary or actual
amount contributed by
61
Central Government.
[Salary = Basic Pay + DA (If
taken for retirement benefit)
Note: According to Sec 80CCE, aggregate of deductions under Sec 80C, Sec 80CCC and
Sec 80CCD is limited to Rs.1,00,000
80D Medical Insurance Premium paid by cheque only Senior Citizen - Rs.20,000
(w.e.f AY 08-
09, paid by
any mode of
payment other Others - Rs.15,000
than by cash)
62
II. With Limit Donations
(A) Eligible for 100% deduction
a) Contribution to Indian Olympic Association
b) Contribution to Government or Local Authority
for family planning.
(B) Eligible for 50% deduction
a) Contribution to Government or Local Authority
for purpose other family planning.
b) Contribution to religious and charitable trust
The various provisions relating to TDS are covered under Chapter XVII-B of Income Tax Act, 1961.
TDS refers to tax deducted at source by the payer at the prescribed rate at the time of accrual or payment
of certain incomes to the payee.
The following are the objectives of TDS:
63
a) To collect income tax at the earliest opportunity
b) To provide information about the tax – payer (i.e. the person from whom tax is deducted)
Rates of TDS
Different rates of TDS are provided under respective sections for various payments made. Only in case of
salary payment, the employer shall apply the income tax rates applicable for individual assessee. In
addition to TDS rates, surcharge shall be applied as follows:
Rate of
Su
Status of the Payee rch
arg
e
Individual, HUF, AOP, BOI where total amount paid or credited under relevant TDS
Nil
provisions does not exceed Rs.10,00,000/-
Individual, HUF, AOP, BOI where total amount paid or credited under relevant TDS
10%
provisions exceeds Rs.10,00,000/-
Firms and Domestic Companies where total amount paid or credited under relevant TDS
Nil
provisions does not exceed Rs.1 crore
Firms and Domestic Companies where total amount paid or credited under relevant TDS
10%
provisions exceeds Rs.1 crore
Foreign Companies 2.5%
Items covered under TDS provisions are exhaustive in nature and not indicative.
65
Agreement u/s 90A
Payment to offshore fund
At the time of credit or
196B income from mutual fund 10% Nil payment whichever is earlier
units
Payment of income on
At the time of credit or
196C foreign currency bonds or 10% Nil payment whichever is earlier
shares of Indian Company
At the time of credit or payment
196D Payment of income to FIIS on securities 20% Nil whichever is earlier
* Rate of TDS
a) Upto 31.05.2007
15% plus applicable surcharge and cess if the payee is an individual or HUF and at the rate of 20%
plus applicable surcharge and cess if the payee is any other person.
b) From 01.06.2007
Rate of
Asset Payee
TDS
(i) For use of any machinery or plant or
Any Payee 10%
Equipment
(ii) For use of any land or building (including
factory building), land appurtenant to a
Individual or HUF 15%
building (including factory) or furniture or
fittings
(iii) For use of any land or building (including A person other than
factory building), land appurtenant to a building an individual or 20%
(including factory) or furniture or fittings HUF
Sec. 116
66
The following are the classes of income tax authorities:
i) The Central Board of Direst Taxes
ii) Directors General of Income-tax or Chief Commissioners of Income – tax
iii) Directors of Income-tax or Commissioners of Income-tax or Commissioners of Income-tax(Appeals)
iv) Additional Directors of Income-tax or Additional Commisioners of Income-tax or Additional
Commisioners of Income-tax (Appeals)
v) Joint Directors or Joint Comissioners of Income-tax
vi) Deputy Directors of Income-tax or Deputy Commissioners of Income-tax
vii) Assistant Directors of Income-tax or Assistant Commissioners of Income-tax
viii) Income-tax officers
ix) Tax Recovery Officers
x) Inspectors of Income-tax
ASSESSMENT
1. Section 139(1):
1) Who should file ROI?
• Company/firm, or
• Other persons whose total income exceeds basic exemption limit( total
income = total income before deductions under sec 10A/10B/10BA or Chapter VIA)
2. Section 139(1A): filing of bulk return of income by salaried employee to their employer:- such
employer shall furnish return of income within due date
3. Section 139(1B):
• Filing of returns in e-form is equivalent to return filed u/s 139(1)
• E-form includes floppy, magnetic cartridge, CD-ROM
o Where regular books are maintained and P&L a/c and Balance sheet / personal
account are not furnished.
68
o Audit report (if audited) is not filed
o Where regular books of account are not maintained and a statement of available
particulars is not furnished
• AO may intimate defect and the assessee should rectify the defect within 15 days.
71
SERVICE TAX
Taxes are mainly of two types:
a) Direct Tax
b) Indirect Tax.
Indirect tax is a tax wherein the incidence and impact of tax is on two different persons.
The main contributories to indirect tax revenue are sales tax / VAT, service tax, central excise duty,
luxury tax etc.
Sales Tax is in existence for collection of taxes on sale of goods for several decades, but the government’s
eye was also on services being rendered as service sector’s contribution to India’s GDP was substantial.
To tax these services, a committee was formed which was headed by Dr. Raja J Chelliah. Based on the
committee’s recommendations, service tax was introduced through the Finance Act 1994 (There is no
separate Act for service tax unlike other taxation laws like income tax, wealth tax etc.)
72
Finance Trade Notices
Acts Notifications Orders
Circulars or Office
letters (Instructions) Rules
The Act applies to whole of India except the state of Jammu & Kashmir. The levy applies to taxable
services provided or to be provided.
If the service is provided in Jammu & Kashmir Service Tax is not applicable.
If the service is provided from Jammu & Kashmir to any other part of India, the service will be liable to
Service Tax.
Hence, for the applicability of Service Tax, location of service provided is relevant.
Levy of Service Tax extends to services rendered in designated areas in the continental shelf and
exclusive economic zone. The Exclusive Economic Zone extends upto 200 nautical miles inside the sea
from base line.
Service provided within the territorial waters will be liable to Service Tax, as levy of Service Tax extends
to whole of India except Jammu & Kashmir and India includes territorial waters. Indian territorial waters
extends upto 12 nautical miles from the Indian land mass.
The rate of service tax prescribed by section 66 is 12% + Cess on service tax is 3% w.e.f. 11.05.2007. i.e
2% Education Cess and 1% Secondary Higher Education Cess. Section 65(105) provides that taxable
service shall not only include service provided but also the “service to be provided”. Thus,
a) The charge is on the services provided or to be provided
b) The services provided or to be provided must be the one which is covered in Sec 65(105)
73
c) The rate of tax is 12%
d) The measure of tax is on “Value of Taxable Services” provided which is defined in section 67.
The unit of special economic zone has been approved by the Development Commissioner or
Board of Approvals, as the case may be, to establish the unit in the special economic zone
The developer or unit of special economic zone shall maintain proper account of receipt and
utilization of the said taxable services.
74
(c) Exemption to goods and materials sold by service provider to recipient of service
– Notification No. 12/2003 ST, dated 20.06.03
W.e.f 1.07.03 so much of the value of all the taxable services, as is equal to the value of goods and
materials sold by the service provider to the recipient of service has been exempt from the service tax
leviable thereon subject to the condition that there is documentary proof specifically indicating the value
of the said goods and materials.
However, the said exemption shall apply only in such cases where:
No credit of duty paid on such goods and materials sold has been taken under the provisions of
the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 or
Where such credit has been taken by the service provider on such goods and materials, such
service provider has paid the amount equal to such credit availed before the sale of such goods and
materials.
(d) Exemption for small service providers – Notification No. 6/2005 ST dated 01.03.05:
Service tax is fully exempt in respect of the taxable services of aggregate value not exceeding
Rs.4,00,000 (Rs.8,00,000 from FY 2007-08 & Rs.10,00,000 from FY 2008-09) in any financial year.
Consideration Consideration
Consideration partly Consideration not
wholly in money inclusive of ST
in terms of money ascertainable payable
75
d) Money includes any currency, cheque, promissory note, letter of credit, draft, pay order,
travellers cheque, money order, postal remittance and other similar instruments but does not include
that is held for its numismatic value.
e) Gross amount charged includes payment by cheque, credit card, deduction from account
and any form of payment by issue of credit notes or debit noted and book adjustment.
Note: Subject to the provisions mentioned above, the value of taxable services shall be determined in
such manner as may be prescribed.
1,00,000
Option1 :
Send separately a Option 2:
debit note of 1,00,000 is presumed
Rs 1,00,000 to be cum-tax
(inclusive).
- FY 2010-11
o Amount billed – 10,00,000
o Amount received – 7,00,000
No SSP eligibility since billed amount exceeded 10,00,000. However, there is no tax since he has
eligibility in preceding year & amount received in CY is less than 10,00,000
- FY 2011-12
o Billed amount – 12,00,000
o Amount received – 4,00,000
Service Tax on entire 4,00,000 i.e from 1,00,000
76
2010-11 7,00,000 9,00,000 Nil
Building
V Used for self occupation
IV Let out to employees for residence
III
II Let out for business
I
Service Tax is applicable for I & II i.e building used by occupier for commercial purpose.
77
Taxable services and the specified person / class of person who are liable to pay service tax thereon as per
Rule 2(1)(d) of Service Tax Rules, 1994 are:
a) In relation to general insurance business, the person liable to pay service tax is the insurer or re-
insurer, as the case may be, providing such service.
b) In relation to insurance auxiliary service provided by an insurance agent, the perso liable to pay
ST is the person carrying on general insurance business or the life insurance business as the case
may be, in India.
c) In relation to taxable service provided or to be provided by any person from a country other than
India and received by any person in India, the person liable to pay ST is the recipient of such
service.
d) In relation to taxable service provided by a goods transport agency, where the consignor or
consignee of goods is:
Any factory registered under or governed by Factories Act, 1948;
Any company formed or registered under Companies Act, 1956;
Any corporation established by or under any law;
Any society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 or under any law
corresponding to that Act in force in any part of India;
Any co-operative society established by or under any law;
Any dealer of excisable goods, whois registered under the central excise act, 1944 or the
rules made thereunder; or
Any body corporate established, or a partnership fir registered, by or under any law,
the person liable for paying ST is any person who pays or is liable to pay freight either himself or
through his agent for the transportation of such goods by road in a goods carriage i.e. recipient of
services.
e) In relation to business auxiliary service of distribution of mutual fund by a mutual fund distributor
or an agent, as the case be, the person liable for paying ST is mutual fund or asset management
company, as the case may be, receiving such service.
f) In relation to sponsorship service provided to body corporate or firm, the person liable to pay ST
is the body corporate or firm, as the case may be, who receives such sponsors service.
The service provider charges service tax in his bill raised on his client as and when the service is
provided. However, the service tax is payable to the government only when the value of taxable services
is ‘received’.
Thus, if a chartered accountant raises a bill for outstanding services say, on 15th December, 2007 for
Rs.1,12,360/- (including service tax of Rs.12,360/-) and the client pays his bill only in February 2008, the
liability to pay service tax to the government would arise only in February 2008. This alleviates the major
grievance of the service providers who otherwise would be required to pay service tax on amounts not
received or not likely to be received.
Section 67(1) (iii) and Service Tax (Determination of value) Rules, 2006 (as inserted w.e.f. 19.04.2006)
make provisions for valuation even when consideration is not ascertainable.
However, these provisions apply only when there is consideration.
78
If there is no consideration i.e. in case of free service, section 67 and Service Tax (Determination of
Value) Rules, 2006 cannot apply. Therefore, service tax is not applicable in such cases.
79
In such cases of adjustment, the asseessee is required to file details in respect of such suo motu
adjustments done by him at the time of filing ST returns. The return form ST-3 also provides for
enclosure for documentary evidence for adjustment of such excess ST paid.
It is to be noted that adjustment of excess payment of ST is not allowed per se, say due to clerical mistake
etc. in such cases, the asseessee has to claim the refund of excess tax paid.
MANNER OF PAYMENT OF SERVICE TAX
Service tax has to be paid to the credit of the Central Government in Form GAR-7 challan (yellow colour)
in the specified branches of the designated bank. The list of such Banks and Branches is available in every
Commissionerate of Central Excise. Different heads of accounts have been specified for different taxable
service by the Government under which payment has to be made.
While making the payment of service tax to the credit of Central Government, head of account
should be correctly and properly indicated under major and minor heads and sub-heads to avoid
misclassification. In the challan, account head of education cess should be shown separately.
A multiple service provider (a service provider rendering more than one taxable service) can use
single GAR-7 challan for payment of service tax on different services.
Where an amount is collected in excess of the service tax assessed or determined, the person who liable to
pay such amount shall, in addition to the amount, be liable to pay interest. Interest shall also be payable by
a person who has collected any amount, which is not required to be collected as service tax.
The interest shall be payable at the rate of 13% per annum from the first day of the month succeeding the month in which the
amount should have been paid till the date of payment of such amount.
Quarterly once
By an individual or a proprietary firm or a
Payable by the 5th of the month immediately
partnership firm
following the said quarter
Monthly once
In other cases (company and HUF) Payable by the 5th of the month immediately
following the said calendar month
The service tax return, in form ST-3 should be filed on half yearly basis by the 25 th of the month
following the particular half year. The due dates on this basis are tabulated as under:
80
HALF YEAR DUE DATE
1st April to 30th September 25th October
1st October to 30th March 25th April
When the due date falls on public holiday: Incase the due date of the filing of return i.e., either 25 th
October or 25th April falls on public holiday, the assessee can file the return on the immediately
succeeding working day.
NIL RETURN:
Even if no service has been provided during a half year and no service tax is payable; the assessee has to
file a nil return within the prescribed time limit.
E-FILING
E-filing is a facility for the electronic filing of service tax returns by the assessee from his office,
residence or any other place of choice, through the Internet, by using a computer. The assessee
can go to the e-filing site ‘Home Page’ by typing the address http://servicetaxefiling.nic.in in the
address bar of the browser.
E-filing of returns is an assessee facilitation measure of the department in continuation of its
modernization and simplification program. It is an alternative to the manual filing of returns. This facility
is available to all service providers.
Definition:
“Practicing Chartered Accountant” means a person who is member of the Institute of Chartered
Accountants of India and is holding a certificate of practice granted under the provisions of the Chartered
Accountants Act, 1949 and includes any concern engaged in rendering services in the field of chartered
accountancy.
Scope of taxable services shall include any service provided or to be provided to a client by a practicing
chartered accountant in his professional capacity, in any manner.
‘Policy holder’ includes a person to whom the whole of interest of policy holder in the policy is assigned
once and for all, but does not include an assignee thereof whose interest in the policy is defeasible or is
for the time being subject to any condition [Sec 2(2) of the Insurance Act, 1938].
‘Insurer’ means any person carrying on the general insurance business and includes re-insurer.
82
Scope: The service shall include any service provided to a policyholder or any person, by an insurer,
including re-insurer carrying on general insurance business in relation to general business.
Service tax is payable only on the total amount of the premium charged by the insurer carrying on general
insurance business.
W.e.f. 11.07.2003 the taxable service provided by the insurer, carrying on general insurance business, to a
policyholder in relation to General insurance business provided under the Universal Health Insurance
Scheme is exempt from the service tax leviable thereon.
CONVETION SERVICES
Scope: The service shall include any service provided or to be provided to a client, by any person in
relation to holding of any convention in any manner.
Points to be noted:
a) Stage shows, music concerts, sports events are not considered as convention since these events
provide some type of amusement, entertainment or recreation
b) Hotels and event management companies holding seminars are liable for service tax in respect of
the charges levied towards holding of such seminars. Service can be providing rooms / halls for
the convention or providing other facilities such as video conferencing, OHPs, speakers,
microphones etc. apart from providing space for holding a convention.
c) Services provided by mandap keeper may appear similar to convention services but there is a
subtle distinction between the type of events (official, social or business in case of mandap keeper
as opposed to a formal meeting in case of convention service).
However, a mandap keeper already paying service tax is not liable to pay service tax again under
the category of convention services and vice-versa.
d) In case of service provider providing catering service along with convention services and catering
charges are included in the gross amount of the bill, an abatement of 40% is allowed on the gross
amount charged in the bill.
However, abatement will not be available in the following cases:
(i) The cenvat credit of duty paid on inputs or capital goods or the cenvat credit of service
tax on input services, used for providing such taxable service, has been taken under
Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004.
(ii) The service provider has availed the benefit under the Notification No.12 / 2003 ST,
dated 20.06.2003.
Scope:
The service shall include any service provided or to be provided to any person, by a rent-a-cab operator in
relation to renting of a cab.
Note: In case of rent-a-cab operator abatement of 60 % is allowed on the gross amount charged in the bill.
Abatement is not available in the following cases:
a) The credit of duty paid on inputs or capital goods has not been availed
b) Exemption has not been availed for the cost of material used in providing services.
RENTING OF IMMOVABLE PROPERTY SERVICE
‘Immovable property’ means building and its parts, the land incidental to the use of such building, the
common or shared areas and facilities. In the case of a building located in a complex or industrial estate, it
also includes common areas and facilities relating thereto, within such complex or estate. It excludes:
a) Vacant land solely used for agriculture, aqualculture, farming, forestry, animal husbandry, mining
purposes, education, sports, circus, entertainment and parking purposes.
b) Building used solely for residential purposes and buildings used for the purposes of
accommodation, including hotels, hostels, boarding houses, holiday accommodation, tents and
camping facilities.
Scope: The taxable service shall include service provide or to be provided to any person, by any other
person in relation to renting of immovable property for use in the course or fur therance business or
commerce.
84
insulation, sound insulation, fire proofing or water proofing, lift and escalator, fire escape
staircases or elevators; or
(b) construction of new building or a civil structure or part thereof, or of a pipeline or conduit,
primarily for the purpose of commerce or industry; or
(c) construction of a new residential complex or part thereof; or
(d) completion and finishing services, repair, alteration, renovation or restoration of, or similar
services, in relation to (b) or (c); or
(e) turnkey projects including engineering, procurement and construction or commissioning
(EPC) projects
Scope: The taxable service shall include service provided or to be provided to any person, by any other
person in relation to the execution of a works contract excluding works contract in respect of roads,
airports, railways, transport terminals, bridges, tunnels and dams.
Note: There is a composition scheme for the service providers involved in the execution of works
contract. The scheme gives an option to the assessee to pay 2% of the total value of the works contract as
service tax. Assessees opting for the composition scheme would not be entitled to avail cenvat credit of
capital gods, input and input services required for use in the works contract. The assesses who do not opt
for this scheme would pay service tax on the taxable value of the works contract which is relatable to the
services provided in the execution of a works contract. Such value would be determined on actual basis
based on the records maintained by the assessee.
SPECIAL PROVISIONS FOR PAYMENT OF SERVICE TAX IN CASE OF AIR TRAVEL AGENT
The person liable for paying service tax in relation to the services provided by an air travel agent has an option
to pay an amount calculated at the rate of:
a) 0.6% of the basic fare in the case of domestic bookings
b) 1.2% of basic fare in the case of international bookings
of passage for travel by air, during the calendar month or quarter, as the case may be, towards the discharge of
his service tax liability instead of service tax @ 12%.
The option once exercised applies uniformly in respect of all bookings of passage for travel by air made by
him and cannot be changes during a financial year under any circumstances
The expression ‘basic fare’ means that part of the air fare on which commission is normally paid to air travel
agent by the airline
Problems
1) Ajay Ltd. has agreed to render services to Mr. Guru. The following are the chronological events:
Contract for services entered into on 31.8.2006
Advance received in September, 2006 towards all services 60,000
Total value of services, billed in February, 2007 2,10,000
85
Above includes non-taxable services of 70,000
Balance amount is received in March, 2007
When does the liability to pay service tax arise and for what amount? Contract contains clear
details of services; consideration and service tax are charged separately, as mutually agreed
upon.
Soln:
The liability to pay service tax arises at the time of receipt of advance in September, 2006 and
at the time of receipt of balance consideration in March 2007. Service tax is payable as soon
as any advance is received as the taxable service includes “service to be provided” and
payments received, before during or after the provision of taxable services form part of the
gross amount charged for the taxable services. Further, the liability to pay service tax arises
only upon the receipt of the value of taxable services and not when the bill is raised.
Advance portion
Advance received towards all services in September, 2006 = 60,000
Amount billed for taxable services = 2,10,000 – 70,000 = 1,40,000
Advance received towards taxable services = 60,000 x (1,40,000/ 2,10,000) = 40,000
Service tax @ 12% (since, service tax is charged separately) = 40,000 x 12% = 4,800
Education Cess @ 2% = 96
Total service tax liability = 4,896
In this case, the due date for payment of service tax will be 5th October, 2006.
Balance portion
.Balance amount received in March 2007 = 2,10,000 – Rs.60,000 = 1,50,000
Amount received towards taxable services = 1,50,000 x (1,40,000/2,10,000) = 1,00,000
Service tax @ 12% = 1,00,000 x 12% = 12,000
Education Cess @ 2% = 240
Total service tax liability = 12,240
In this case, the due date for payment of service tax will be 31st March, 2007.
2) MN Ltd. has entered into a contract with OP Ltd. on 31.05.2006 for rendering services. The contract contains
clear details of services. Consideration and service tax are charged separately. The following information is also
available:
(i) Advance received in June 2006 from OP Ltd. towards all services Rs.1,20,000
(ii) Total value of services billed to OP Ltd. in August 2006 Rs.4,20,000
(iii) Non-taxable services billed to OP Ltd.(included in (ii) above) Rs.1,40,000
Balance consideration for services is received in December 2006.
(i) How many times does the liability to pay service tax arise in such a case and when?
(ii) What is the service tax liability in each case?
(ii) What are the due dates for payment of service tax in each case?
Soln:
(i)The liability to pay service tax arises twice in such a case. The liability to pay service tax arises first when the
advance is received as:
(i) the taxable service includes ‘service to be provided’ and
(ii) payments received, before during or after the provision of taxable services form part of the gross .
86
The liability to pay service tax arises again when the balance consideration is received. It may be noted that the
liability to pay service tax arises only upon the receipt of the value of taxable services and not when the bill is
raised.
(ii) Contract contains clear break up of taxable and other services. So advance received should also be bifurcated.
(a) Advance portion Rs.
Advance received in June 2006 = 1,20,000
Amount billed for taxable services = 4,20,000 – 1,40,000 = 2,80,000
Advance received towards taxable services = 1,20,000 x (2,80,000/4,20,000) = 80,000
Service tax @ 12% (since service tax is charged separately) = 80,000 x 12% = 9,600
Education cess @ 2% = 9,600 x 2% = 192
Total service tax liability 9792
(iii) In case of a company, service tax for a calendar month is payable by the 5th of the month immediately
following the said calendar month. Therefore, the due date for payment of service tax in respect of receipt of
advance is 05.07.2006. The due date for payment of service tax in respect of receipt of balance consideration is
05.01.2007.
3) PQ Ltd. gives the following particulars relating to the services provided to various clients by them
for the half-year ended on 30.09.07:
(i) Total bills raised for Rs. 9,50,000 out of which bill for Rs. 50,000 was raised on an approved
International Organisation and payments of bills for Rs. 1,50,000 were not received till 30.09.07.
(ii) Amount of Rs. 70,000 was received as an advance from MNO Ltd. on 25.09.07 to whom the
services were to be provided in October’07.
You are required to work out the:
(a) taxable value of services
(b) amount of service tax payable
Soln:
Computation of taxable value of services provided by the PQ Ltd. for the half year ending on 30.09.2007:
Total bills raised 9,50,000
Less: Bill raised on an approved International organisation (note 1) 50,000
Less: Bills for which payment has not been realized (note 2) 1,50,000 2,00,000
7,50,000
Add: Advance received for the services to be provided in October ’07 (note 3) 70,000
Taxable value of services 8,20,000
87
Notes:
1. Services provided to approved International Organisation are exempt from the service tax vide Notification No.
16/2002 ST dated 02.08.2002.
2. Service tax is payable only on the value of taxable services received [Rule 6(1) of Service Tax Rules, 1994].
3. Service tax is payable on advance received for taxable services (Section 67 of the Finance Act, 1994).
In other words the various taxes paid on inputs purchased will be allowed as a credit.
As VAT is less distortive and more revenue-productive, it has been spreading all over the world.
VAT
Collected at
Multi-point Tax Provision for set-off
different stages
on for tax at the previous
of sales
Value addition stage
88
(i) A’s cost of imported materials (from other states) 10,000
(A will deposit rs.1250 duty on the above. Since, this is not a state VAT 1,250
it will form a cost of input)
In the above illustration it is assumed that set off of VAT paid on imported goods from outside countries
or other states is not allowed.
VARIANTS OF VAT:
VAT has three variants, viz.,
Gross product
Income variant Consumption variant
variant
Allows deductions
for taxes on all Allows for deductions Allows for deduction
purchases of raw on purchase of raw on all business
materials & materials and purchases including
components, but no components as well as capital assets.
deduction is allowed depreciation on capital
for taxes on capital goods.
inputs.
89
These variants can be further distinguished according to their method of calculation, viz., Addition
method & Subtraction method. Subtraction method could be further divided into: (a) Direct, (b)
Intermediate, and (c) Indirect subtraction method.
There are several methods to calculate the ‘Value Added’ to the goods for levy of tax. The three
commonly used methods are:
(a) Addition Method
(b) Invoice Method
(c) Subtraction Method
Addition Method:
This method aggregates all the factor payments including profits to arrive at the total value addition on
which the rate is applied to calculate the tax.
Subtraction Method:
While the above stated Invoice or Tax-Credit method is the most common method of VAT, another
method to determine the liability of a taxable person is the cost subtraction method, which is also a simple
method. Under this method, the tax is charged only on the value added at each stage of the sale of goods.
Since, the total value of goods sold is not taken into account, the question of grant of claim for set off of
or tax credit does not arise.
90
Effect on retail price : VAT does not have any inflationary impact as it merely replaces the existing
equal Sales tax. With the introduction of VAT, the tax impact on the raw materials is to be totally
eliminated. Therefore, there may not be any increase in prices.
Demerits:
There are varying rates and some goods are out of VAT. Composition schemes and exemption.
Composition schemes and exemption schemes are also available. Thus 100% benefit of VAT is not
gained because there are varying VAT rates and some goods are out of VAT system.
It will be difficult to put the purchases from other states at par with the state purchases.
The accounting costs will increase. The burden of this increase may not be commensurate with the
benefit to traders and small firms.
It would increase the working capital requirements and interest burden on the same.
VAT tends to be regressive: Being a consumption tax, the burden of tax is the same for the poor as
well the rich. Any consumption tax is bound to suffer from this weakness.
(Specified Administration cost to the state can increase significantly.
Rate + Y) -
Z 1. Compute the invoice value to be charged and amount of tax payable under VAT by a dealer who
had purchased goods for Rs 120000 and after adding for expenses of 10,000/- and of profit Rs
15000/- had sold out the same. The rate of VAT on purchases and sales is 12.5%.
Solution:
Computation of invoice value
Particulars Rs
Cost of Goods Purchased 120000
Add: Additional expenses 10000
Add: Profit Share 15000
Total Invoice Value 145000
91