cccccccccccccccccccccc Perennialism in Education

c

c
c 
ccc cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc
c 
cc cccccccccccccccccccccccccccc
cc
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc
   c!"c#$c
c%cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc
&cc%c
c
c

%c '%c %('c c c c c )c 'c c )c c
*c )%c 'c c Education implies teaching. Teaching implies
knowledge. Knowledge is truth. The truth everywhere is the same. Hence,
education should be everywhere the same.c c Perennialists believe that one
should teach the things that one deems to be of everlasting importance to all
people everywhere.
c
c
˜

   

 


 


 

 

  

   
  
  

       

 
˜
    
    
 
  

  
      
 
     
    
     

   

 



c
˜
c

 c

c c
 cc
c 
c

ccc 
c

c c c  c c c 

c
c c  c c
c

 c
 c  c
c 
c c 
c c
c

 c c
c c
 c  cc c c
  c

ccc
c
˜    

  

   

    
 
   

  
 
   

  
    
 
  





  


 

     
  

 
   
    cc
c


c c  c 
c c c
 c 
c c

c 

c c


c c
c c  c
c
 c  cc 
c

cc cc
c
c



c
c
c
c


 c


c


cc
c c
c  c

c


c  c
c
c
c c
c˜
c 
cc c c
c˜
c 
c
 c c˜
c
c
cc c

c
c

c c c

 c



 c  c
c 
c  c 
c c c  
c 
c  
c c !


c  c
˜
c  
c  c  "c c c c c  c
c

c  c  c c

c
c c

c#cc
c
 c c c
c  c 

c c c  c  cc 
cc
c 
cc
c c  c
c  c c  c  c 

c  
c c 
c  c  c c

 
c c c
 c 

 c c
c  c 

 c c
c

 c c
cc
c
$ 
c cc
c
cccc
 c

c c c
%
c
 c
c

 c c  c c

c c 

c
 c 


c c

&

cc



cc c

c cc
c c  'c

 c  c

c  c  c  c 
c c 
%
c
c 
  c 
 
c  c (
c  c c
 c c

c   c c 
c c 

 c

c c
c c  c  c


 c

c ccc
c

cc
c


c  c  c
c
c c c



 c cc 
c
c c

cc c c


c  cc
c ccc  c
cc
+c+c'c
c
c

c 
c )

 )c 
c c


c 
c  c 
c 
c 
c

c
c
c
c c  c
c
c 
c
c
c
 
cc
c
c

 c cc
c
c

c  c

c

c
c  c

c

c c
c
c c c
 cc c

 c
c 
 c

c 

c c
c  c  c 
c
 c c
c 
c
c c




c
c c cc
cc

c 
c

 c

cc


c c c  
c c  c 
c   c c c   c  c
c
 c c  c * c ˜ c c +c  c  c

c 
c 

c  c 


c

cc
c 
c  c c
c, c c 
c
c c
c 
c c  c
c 

c  c (c c c 

c c
c c  c
  c ˜
c
c 

c c 
c 
c 

c c c
 c  c 
c c

 c  
c c
c 
c 

c

c 
c  c c 


c c c -

˜ c c -
*  c 

c c
c



c
 c
c


c c
c

c c


c
c c
c
 c  c

c
c

 c

 c
c c  c
c c
cc  c c
c c c

c
 c cc cc
c c
c
,-
#
c
,
-#,c-c
 
c
cc
.cc/#'c-$'0c'c
cc
  
c 
c c
cc
 c
 c c c

c c c
c 
c .c  c c 
c 

c c 

c c 
c  c
c 

/c  c
c

c c 
 c  
c 
c c  c  c 
c +
c
/
c c

c


  c cc 
c
ccc cc


cc c cc c
 cc

cc
c


c c  cc c

c

c c cc

c +c c
/

c c c
c 
c 

c  c 
c c c


c  c c .c c

c  c

c   c  
c 
c c


c c

cc
 c
c
c
c
c1c#'*0cc'c,'%c2'c
c
c0
c c
c
 c
cc c  c c
c c 
cc

c 
c  c * c  
c *
c
c c  c   
c 

c  c c
c  c
c 
c  c    c
c 
 c  

c c
c
c 

c 
c
c  c  c 
 c c  
c 
 c 
c  c  c
c

c  c
  c
c  c
c 
c  c * c ˜ c c .c  
c 
c
c 

 c c 
c c c
c 
c c
 c 

 c  c 
c


c c
ccc c
cc

c c
c
 c

 c. c
c
 cc
c
c
c
c
3c,c,c#*0cc,'c4'c
c
* c ˜ c c
c 
c ! c c
c c c   
c c

c

c c cc
c
c
c c c
c

c c
/

c1
c


c
c   c


c  c c  c  c
c 
c  c   
c c
 c  c
c


c2
c c c cc 
3c c
/

c
  
cc c* c˜ cc cc  c
cc c c 
c c
c

c 
 c c
c
/

c c


c˜ c c c


c

c
c



c c

  c 
c
/

c

c
c


c c  c
cc

c /

c c 
c   c c 
c (c $
c c c 
c
/

cc  c

 c  c
ccc c c  c
c
c c 
c c
 
cc 
 cc c  c c  c 
c c
c 
c


c c
cc
c

c
c$ 
c
cc
c c
c c
c
c c 
c

 c
c c
cc
c 
c.c* c˜ c
c
 c c c 

c c c
c c  c
c 
  c ˜ c  c c c

c  
c c
c c  c
c 

c  c c 

 c c
c˜
c cc c* c˜ cc
cc c  cc
cc c

c

c
c
 4cccc

ccc
 c


c
c ccc

c  c c 

c 
c 

c  c 
c c 
 c  c 
c

c
c
  
c


c
c ccc

c c
c
c
cc  
c


c
c
 c
 c
cc c  cc c

c




cc
 c 

c c
 c
c
0c  c c
c 

c c c
c  c  c
c 

c c 
c



c

c c 

 c
c c 

c c 

 c  c  c $

c


cc  c
cc c
c

c
cc

c
cc c  cc


 c
 
c
c
 cc
/

c c
c

 c c c


cc
c

c c(
c. c 
c c

cc5656ccc1
cc
c 
cc
c1c
0 
cc
c 
c c

c c
  c

c1
cc


c c
c


c c (
c c 78c 
c c 
c
c c 
c c
 
c 
 c


c
c cc cc
c 
c
c  c c  c
cc
c
c

cc
cc 
c c c

cc
 c
cc 
c
 
ccc
9"c
Àc#*c,&'c0cc%c%c
c
c 54'c c c c 

c
c  c

 c 

c


c c
c

 c
 ccc
 c
c c
cc  c
 cc cc ccc
c:
c* 
c+ 'c
 cc 
c c

c -
˜  c  c c  c 

c c 
c c  c 1c  c 
c

c c
 cc
c c

cc
 c 

c  c 
c
c

 c

c c
 cc
c

 c
 c c
c
c
6cc%c c c

c
c c
c:
 c c cc
 c  c 
c


 c 
 c +c 1  c   c c  c

c c

c

c c
c


 c
c c

cc

c c c
 c

 c c
c

c
 c
c


c
c
cc c c  c

c
 c ccc c


c  c
c
 cc  c

cc
c 
c
c c

c c  c c
c  cc c 
c  c
 c
c

-
c-c
 
c

c,c'c)c$*c+ccc+c)c'c'cc
'c,c%++'c6)c'c)c'cc'c6c'$+c

Oecular perennialism

˜
    

  
 

 
  
    



 

  


  


 
Robert Hutchins and Mortimer Adler  
  

 
   


  

 

˜ 
   

  
 
    
     
   
 


 

 
   
 
  
 !

 
"  



 





#
 


 
 
 
  
        

 

 
    


     

 
 
 

 



    
 


  
 
  

   


      
     
      
      



 
$
      
˜





 

 
 $
 


 
   
 
 
 

  

    
 %

     
   
   



   
 


 
&
 


 






 
 




'

  
  
(



 
 
  

 
   
)
 

 
  

˜

  
  (
* 

 



   
 
 

+,˜

 

-)  


  





 




 ,

#
 

 

    
   
 $   
             
        

  


 

    ˜

  


    


 
  
  
     ( 

 


  


  
   

 


  
%

 ˜

 







 
   ) 
  
   

  
 
 ,

" 
 ,   
  

 '
 ˜


 

   . 
 




/ 



  ,
,

Hutchins remarks;
 
   
 
 

0 

 
   


 
  
 
 

 
 
  ˜

    
     '

˜




 

 

1 




   

   


,

   
 

" 
    


    
       

   

 
     
  

 

 
 
 

 
 ˜


 " 
    
 
  

 
    
  





       
   

    

 





  
           
   
   

 

 

  
  
   
 
   
 

 
   
  

 
  
  2  
   

   
     
 





0   
  
 
 
  


 




  


    

         
         
   
   




 

   

" 
 

%
 

   

   

 $
      
    


 
 
     
  
     

  
    

  

 

 



    

 
   



 
   
  
  

      
  3  &


  
  

  


  )   ˜
 
 4
  


 

,   

,   

   

 

      

 
 
        
 

  




 
 &


 


 

˜
 #   
    
 
    )   ,



  


 



% 
 
    
   $  
 
  
           

   
  

 



   
  
  

   


 
  




 
 
 
   
 

   
  

  
 
    
 

 
 
    
 

 







 


  

   
  

   

   

  
  0 

 

 

      


   

 ˜

 


   
 
  
   
 $

  


    
 

 


 ˜
 
 
 


 
       
 


   
   
 




  ˜ (   
#   ˜

  
  
 
   

  
 

   
        

 
 
  
  
   
          
 

Religious perennialism /Theistic perennialism.


  
 
   


 
  
 Thomas
Aquinas
 

 

  &
1 .˜
˜

/

 
 


  

 John Henry Newman 


 





 
  

  ˜
 
   !

 & 
 5 
    6 

  7 *    

   
 

  
" 
  

      
 # )
  


 
 

 
 
(

 




c
˜
c
 c 

 c 


c c c c  c 
c ,
c c (c
2

3c c c  c c 
c c   c .

c
c c
c
 c cc

ccc
c c
 
c  c.c c
c

c


c
 c
c
c

 cc
c c
c
c;

ccc
 c c 
 c 
c
c ˜

c c c 
 c 
c c 
 c


c
ccc
c&
 c
c c
c

 cc
 c2
 c

cc(
 c,c!c
3c
c˜
 c+
cc c
c


 c c
c *c c c  c
c 
 c 
c  c 
c c

cc
c

--#
cc
,- 
c
c
-$cc*''c'c
c
˜
c


 c 


c  c c c 
c 

c  c c c 
c
  c
c
c
c


c, cc
c c c c,
cc
cc
c c

c /

c 

c c
c


c  c

  c  
c /

c c
c


c  c.c
c


 c/

cc cc 
c
c c


c
 c cc
c 
c c c
c 
c c
c 
 cc
c/

c
c,
c˜
c


c c,
cc/

c.c
c

 c


 c c
,
c c

c  c (c (c  c 
c c
/

c  c  c c


 c .
c $c +(
c c 
c 
c
c  c   'c

 c
c
c
c
c#!%c'cc*cc

c
˜
c  c  c
c


 c c c 
c c 0c
c 
c c
c
 cc

c c
c$ 
cc
cc
c

 c
c

cc
 c  c

 cc  c*

c
c c
c  c
c c
cc
 c
c
 c
c c
ccc
c c
 cc
c
˜
c


 c  c c

c c  c c c  c 

c

c c c c


c
c ˜ c
c c 
% c  c
c


c  c
  c c 
c ,
c ˜
c


 c

c c 
c c  c
 c c   c c 

 c ˜
c c


 c c c c  c
c

c 


c 1
c c  c 
&
 c
c  
c 

c  c 
 c 1
c
c

c  c
c

c cccc
cc

c

c
c

c c

c ,
c c c c  c c  c 
c c 

c 
c   c c
c
  
c˜
c c


 c

c c 

c c
 c ,
c c(cc c
c c
c c
c

cc 

cc
c
c'$c'c c)%$"c
c


 c 

c
c  c  

 c c c 
 

 c  c  c c 
c
c 
 c c c

c
/



c  c c c
c c  c

c c
c c
c


 ccc

c c  c  c

cc c

c


c c c  c

 cc
c
˜

c 
 

 c  c 

c c
c


 c c  
c 
c  c  c
 c  c 
c 

c c 

c .c
c c


 c  c c 
c c
 c 
c c   c .c
c

 c


 c

c c 
c c


c c c  c c
c 
  
c  c 

 c   c c 
c c c
$ 
c   c c c   c  c c c c 
c
c 


 c  c 

 c

c c c 
c
/
c c c  c
 c 
c
c c
c

c c

 cc+(
cc
c c
c
 c $  c

c c
 c c <"c


c#c
, c
ccc
c

 c


 c
c
cc
c˜ c

c
c c c 
ccccc
 
c c 

c
c c
&

c
c
c


 cc999c  c c
c
/



c c
c


cc c%
c

c c

c
cc
c
˜c %
c 

c c 



 c  c c ˜ c c 
c c c
c  c 
c  c

c 
c 
 c 
c  9c   c 
c
c
 "c
c c
c

c=c  ccc
cc  c  cc>c
c

 cc
c
˜cc c
c


 c


c c
c

c c˜c

c  c  c


c  c  c 
c  
c  c 

c c  c
cc c

c$ 
c c 

 cc c cc c
c
cc


"cc
cc 
c  c



c
ccc
c 
cc

/

c c cc  c


c  c
c 
c c c 

cc c
c 
c
 c 
c 

c"c*
c

cc 
c&   c c
c
 c  c
c


 c 
c  c 
c c c c 

 c 

c 

 c c 

c c




 cc cc c
c  c˜
c

 c


 cc

c  c  cc c
 c c
ccc
c
 c c  c˜
c
c
c
c 
c   c c c 
c 
c c
c 
c  c .c
/

c
c

/

c  c (c c 


c c  c 


c
c 
c c
 c  c
c

/

c c(c
cc* c˜ ccc
c*c˜
c
c
7$c'c
c
c'c,c
c
cc ˜
c


 c


c  c cc
c  c c
cc cc
 c


cc
c

c
cc
c 
cc
c cc
c
 
c  c
 c
 c
c c
cc  c  cc

 c. cc
c
c c


 cc


c
cc
c c c
*
c
c


 c  c c

c
c c 
c  c 
 c c
c


 c c  c ˜ c


c c c c


 c
c c+c
c c

c1cccc4c c

c

c 
c

c
c c  c cc c


c
/

 c˜
c


 c


c  c

c
c
 c c  c
c
 

 cc  c
c

  
c c

c
 c
c 
c
 

 c  c  c
ccc
c
c
 

 c  c ccc c  

 cc
c  c c  c



c c  c


c c  c &
 c ˜ c 

c  c  

 c c 


c c

c  

 c   c 


c 
c c
/



c  c  

 c 
c
c 
c* c 

 c 

cc
c
  c

 c
cc c

 c  c   c 

c 
c c 
 c c 
 c c  c 
c



c  c
c
/


 c 

c ˜ c c  c 
c  c
c  c 
c

4c cc
c c
c  c
c c
cc
c

cc
c
.cc'c!%c '"cc
c
 × c c c
c c 

c c
c
c c
c c 
c
c & c c 

c c  
c  c 
c c
c c 
c c
c 
c
 c c
c˜
cc cc
c c 
cc'c  c, c
c
c cc cc
c c c  4c cc

c 
cc
c c   c c
c c c 

c ˜
c c c c 
c  
c c c
 
c cc

 c c
c

 c˜
c

 c


 c c
 c

cc
/ c2
cc cc

 c c
c

 3c 

cc


c 
c c
c
cc c c
 c

cc,c
c
c 
c cc
c
c cc ccc
c c
c
c


c c c cc
c c c
 cc c
/ c

cc  cc c

c
c
c
cc
c

c c 
cccc
c

c c
c 
c"c
c
1cc'c+c ''"c
c
× ccc
c c

cc c
c
c c
 c
$
c c 
c c 
  c 
c 
c 

c c  c 

c c  c



c+c
c c
c
 
4c
c

c c
c c c
c
c
c

 c c

 c c  c c


cc 

c
 

 c˜
c  c   c

c
c c

 c cc  c
cc



ccc c

 c  c
c


c c
c
c

 c
c
%c'c
c
,

c c 
c 
c

 c
c 
c
 c  c 
c


 c
c
c c


c˜
c  c cc %
ccc c
c
c
c c
c  c cccccc
c
cc

c
ccc

c

c
c c
 c c c 
cccc ˜
cc cc
 c
c
cc c

cccc
c
.c 

 c
c c  c
 c c c

c  c  
 c 
c

 c c
c
 c
c c$

c% c˜

c
c 
c
c


 c c c

c c c
c ˜
c c c c
 c 
c  c 
c


 c c

c
c  c  c
c  c c cc
c c
c cc c
c c

 c

cc c 
cc

 c
c
 
c c  
cc
c 
c


c c
/

cc  c˜
c



c c

c
c
c˜ c

c 
c
c
 c  c 
c c
c ) )c  c c
c 

c


c c  c c  c
c &c  c
c  c c 

c c 

c


cc
cc

 c c cc
c&c c
c c c

c
c
 c c
c c  c   c
 c  
 c 
c 
c  c c
 c 
c
c
 c cc
c 
cc
 c c
  c c c


 c c 
c  c c   c  c 
4c c c
c



c c cc c)
c 
 )cc

c
%c'c=cc
c
 c
 c
c 
cc c
 c=c
c
c c
c
c
c cc
c
cc 
cc

c, c& c  c
c

c<c˜
c
c
c



 c c

c

 cc
 c
 
c c
cc c
c 
 c

c˜
c
c


 c c  c 
c
c 

c  c 


c
c 

 c
˜
c c

c c
c 
 c c
cc
cc
c
c

c
 c
c 
 c
/

c cc
c
c

c c
c

 c c c

c c
c
,ccc
c
˜
c

 c


 c

c
c cc

c c
c
cc

 cc
 c
c c c
c

 c, cc c c c
c


cc
cc
c

c  c
c c c
 c˜
c
c

 c c c c c 
c 
 c ˜
c

 c


 c



c  c
c  c  c 


c  
 c c
c  c  c 
c c  c

c
c cc  c  cc

 c˜ c
cc c  c
c 
c c  
c c  c c 


c  c 
c c  c  c  c



c  c 
"c
 c  c  c c c 
c  c  c 
c


c cc
c
c 
c
 cc c
c

 c


 cc
c



c cc
c  "cc cc c c  c
c c
 c c
c

c  c
c cc
c
cc ˜
c 


c  c

c c c c 
c  c 

c  c 

c c 
c

c c  
 c c c 
 c 

c c ˜
c

c c c

 
c



 
ccc

 ccc c  c c c

 c˜
c
c c
cc c

 c

cccc
c
c c * c  c 
c
 c


c  
 c c 

c 
c


c  c 
c  c  c c c  
c &
 
c 
 c  c

c
)
c )c c  
 c c 
c 
c 

c c 

c 
c c
c* c c c c c
cc 

c

c
c
,c%c/c
c
˜
c  
 c c 

c c c  c 
c  c


c c ˜ c c


c, c
c 

cc cc
 c
c c c
c 

 c c
c
 c c

c c 


c  c ˜
c  c

c  c
c 

c
c c 
c


c cc
 c c  c
 c˜ c
c  c c
cc 
c
 c
c c

c c 
c&
 c c
c cc% c
˜ cc
c&
 c cc
 ccc˜
c  c c
c
c 
c c c  
 c 
%
c c 
c 
c   c 

c

/

c
% c c c cc
 cc

c c
c

c˜
c
 c  c c c 
c c c
c  
 c

c c c   c 
c


 c
 c c 

c c  c 


c  c




c c 


c ,c

c c

c 

c 

c  c
/

c
c  
 c 


c c
c 
 c c
c  
c #c 
c 
c c c ˜
c c


 c 




c c

c cc
c 
cc

%
c
c

c c c
ccc c
 c
c
c c
c 
 c
c
'c/c
c
c,

c?c 
 c 
 cc
c
c

  c c c
c

c 
c c c c c 
c
c  c 
c  c c 
 c c 
c c  c c
  c+
c
c 

c c


c˜
c
c


c c
c c$
c
 c
/
cc ?c c

c c c

 cc

c

c
,

c
c
c c
c c
c c1

c 
c  c
c
c
c
c c c
cc cc
c  c c
 c
c
c* 
 c  c 
c  c c c 


 c c   c c 

c
˜

c
c c

c 
 c


c
c
 
c  cc
c cc

cc

c!

cc
ccc

 c c
cc
cc c  cc

c

c c 
c c 
c

c0
c c  cc
* 
 c  c c c  c
c  
c 

 c

c c

 c
 c

c  
 c 

c
c 

c c 

c
c c 
 c
c c
 
c &
 
c *
 

c c 
c  c  c  c
c 
c  c c  
 c
 c


c  c 
c 
 c c ˜
c c c




c ˜
c


ccc

cc c
c
c cc  c
c 
 cc

c c
c c
c  
c c c
c *>
c c 


c c
c
 c c


 c  c c >
c 
 c c

c
c 
c c
 c
 c&
 c
c
c
 c

c
 c

c* cc cc
  cc

 cc

c* 
 c c


c
c 
cc
c

c
c
,c,c/cc
c
˜
c

c c
c


 c c c 
 c 
c  c  c




ccc

c c
 cc cc
c
c c
c
c c  
 c ˜
c

c  c 
c
c  c c c  c
c  c



c  c
c  
 c c 
c 1
c  c 

c c c 


 c

c
/
c
cc c
c 
 cc
c c

c
c


c
c
 c  
cc
c
˜ c

c c

c 
ccc
c

c c 
c
c


c

 c 
  c -c c c c *
c
c

c c c c
c  
 c c

c
ccc

c
c c
 c 
c

c 

c 
c c
cc
c

c
c 
 cc
cc c

cc
c



 c c c  
c
c
c c 

c c c c
 c  c
c  
 c c 


c c
c
&
 c
ccc c c c>
c c c
c

c cc
c c
c
c
c 
 c
c cc  c>
cc

cc
c  
c+  cc 
c
c c
c

cc

c c
ccc c c c
c 
 c cc c

c c

c
c


 


   
     
 


   

  .


 
 

   
 
/   
 


      
 #  
   
  

    



 
    
 ˜

 
   
 




  



 
 

  

 




 
  



  

     
 

 
   

 


   

 
  % 
  
 
 
   




  

 
 
 
 
 



 




 

 





 






 
 





  

%

 


 


 

 

 
 
 
   

     
  
 #  
      
   

 
   
 


 
   
 

    

 
c
#c/






 
   

 
 #


  
 


 

  ˜

 


  
 
 #



  
  
 
       
  
 '
 #
 

 
 

 
   
 
      
    
  
        
 c
c
c 

 c c )$  c 
c
c

 c c c  
 c  c <)c
$ cc

 cc  
c
c 
c c
c
 cc  c c  c c


 "c cc˜
c

 c
c
c
 c c
cc
c
c
cc
cc

 c cc
cc
c
c
c c
c
 cc c

c
 c
c
.c
c


 c

c
c cc

c c&
 c
c#c 
c
 c
c 

 cc 
c c
c
 c ˜
c c


 c

%
c
c  c c

c

c 
c
c
  c
 c c
c
c.c
c

 c


 c

c c c c   4c
c c 
c 
c 

c  c c 

c
c
c
cc 
 c


 c  c 

c c + 
c 
c 
c  c
 
c  c c :
 c 1
c 
c a
 
  
c 1c c

 c c  c c c 
c 
 c c  c
c c ˜
c 
c

c

c c
  cc
c c c  cc

c c

%
4c
c
 c  4c  c  c
 c 0c c c c c  c  c
c

c  c
c c )

)c c )  
)c   c  c
c 

c

c  c c
cc
c

c c

c c
c
c
.c c


 c
c

cccc  c
 c+ c
c
/

c

%
c
c 
 
c  c c 
c
 c c c c 
c
  c
c  c c
c.c+ c 

cc
c
 c c
c


c c
c
  c cc 
c c  c c
c
c c
 c
 c
cc
c c

c c
c

cc c
c 
c
c c

c
c "ccc c
c


 c

ccc

c c

%
c


c 
 c 
 
c 

c c  c c
c 
c 
c  c
 c
c

c 
c cc
cc
cc
 c
c
c

 c

c c

c 
 c
c 
c
c c cc


cc
 c
c c c˜
c c c

cc cc
c
 c c
c

 cc

 c
c

 cc c

c  c

c
c
c c
c

c c c
  cc

c
c 
 
c  c c 
 c c 
c c 4c  c c c
c


c c 
/cc 
cc
c

%c  c
c 
c 
c

c
ccc

c c

c
c 

c 

 c
 c  c
c


c c   c 
  c
 c 
c

c

c

 c

%
c  c  c 
 c c
 c 
c  c   c  c c c 
c 

c c c c 
c 
 c


c c  
c
  cc
 c cc
c
$ c
c
/

c  c
c c  c   c  c


 c



c 
c

%
c 

c c 
 c
 c  c 
c 
c
c
c 
c  c  
 c $
c c 

c c   c 
c c c
 c


 c
 c c
c 

c

c  c 

c  c
c c


 c 

%
c  c   c
c


 c c 
c c
c
c

 c  c  
c 0c  c
c


 c  c 

c
c

c
c
cccc2
c
c cc 
3cc
cc
c&
 c

c c
cc
c

 c˜
c
ccc&
 c
c  c cc  c



c c  
c cc 
c
c- cc
c
c


c
c
 c c
c c

c
% ccc

cc
c
cc c

 c

c  c 
 c
c
 c c

cc%c
c(
 c,c˜

c
c
c
 
ccc  ?c

 c 
cc
c  c

 c


c
cc
 c
  c
c
 c cc
c
c

c
cc

 c
 c
c 
c
c
 
c
c
c
 
c c

c

c 
 c2c

3c


c  c c cc
c c

c 
c cc c
c 
 ?c


ccc
c
c 
c  c


 c  c 
 c +c 1  c + 
c

c 
c


c
c
c cc
 c

cc
cc
c
 c

c˜

c
c
cc  c
c

c
 c

c
c 
c  c

c
 c c 
c cc
c  c c
c 
c
c cc
 c c 
c cc


c ˜
c 
c 


c  c 
c c 
c


c 
"c c c

  c 
c ccc  
c

c˜ cc  cc
c c
c  c



c c
c
 c0
c c  ccc

cc+(
ccc c



c
cc c
"cc
c
 c c

c+ c c

c  c

c
 cc c

cc  c
c
c c
 cc
c
c˜
c c c
c  c
 cc&
 c  cc c >
c
 c
c ?c



#c  c 
c  c 
 c  c


c
c 
c cc

c˜
c c c
c
cc c
c c

cc c c
c1
cccc
cc
ccc c c

c ˜ c
c  c 
c c 
c c c

c  c   c =c c 
c
 c
c
c˜
c 

ccc
  c
c
'c'cc+76*ccccc
c
˜
 c

c c


cc c1c
c c
c
c
c c 

c c 
c 



c ˜ c   c  c
c 

 c c
c

 c
 ccc  
c
 c˜
c
cc 
cc
 c  c 
c  
c  
 ?c  c c
c 

c ˜
c
 
 c 
 
 c  c c 
c

%
=c
c 
 c c  c

 
cc c
ccc


c c

cc
c


 c c  c&
 c
c c
c
c

c c
cc
˜
c

c  c 

c
 c 

  
c 
c 

c  c c
c

 c ˜
c 
c
 c  c  c
c


c  c 
c

c


cc
c 

 c c
c cc
 c  c  cc 

c
 c  c  
c
c

c c
c 
c 
c  c c
 c
c  c  c
c 
 c c  c 
 
c

c  c c


c * c c 



 c ?c 
 c  c  c c c  
c c ˜
c
 c



c c

cc
c

c˜
cc  c 
4c
c
c 

c

cc cc>
c 
c  c  c 
c 
c 
  c cc>
cc
cc

c c cc  cc
c


c

ccc
c cc


 c

2
 
 
  # ˜  
 

    
  
 

  
  

 
  
 
  0

c —
RA— ARTO
8
-
 4 
c

9 


  

' 

2PH —OPHY.
8:

 



9#   

 
 
;1

 
 


"OPRNATRA— TH—Yc
c
%c+c,$c

  

   
 

    
  


     ˜

 
 
 
 
       
 


 ˜  
 
 
   
   
 

  
  
 
     1   
    
 

  


 


c
c
cccccccccc,

c
c 
c ccc  cc

c
cc
c
c



c

c 
c c
 c  c 
c c
c 
c c c 
c ˜ c 
c  c
 
c
c c
c c
 c

 
c c
c
c c
c

?c
 c
cc cc
c c 
cc
c
 c c

c
c
˜
c 
c  c
 c c
c


 c c 
c c 
 c 

c
c c
c c  c
c 

 c  c
c 

c 

 c c
c &
 c

c*
c
c c cc c

c c
c
cc c
c


 c

cc

 c c
c c

c c
c 
 c c
c˜
c


 c 
c

c
c 

c
c 
c c 
 
c c

c
c
 
 c  
c
c c c  c  c 
c
c c   c  c
c


c 0
c
 
c 

c 
  c c
c


 c 
c

% c c
cc c
c

 c


 c
  c c
c

 c
c
c$ c

c c c
cc  ccc


c
c cc
c  c c


ccc
c
<c!c


 cc
% c
c cc
c
c


c ˜
 c  c  c 
c 
c c
c )
 c c 
 )c

c c 

c  c 

c 
c 
c c 
c
c 
c 
 c c c
c
 c  
 c ˜
c  c  c
 c  c  c 
c 
c  c
 cc
c

cc 
c c c
 c
c
c

 c  %
c
c  c  c  c 

c  c   c  c

 c  c 
c

c 
 c cc

 c
c c
c

c
c 
c
 c c

cc
/
c c

c

c
c

 c c  
 c  c  c
c  c  c c 
 c 

c


 c
c
c

cc
/ cc
 
c c
c
c


 c
 c  cc

c

c
c

cc


c
c


c  
 c c

c

c c * c 
c c  c c

c c


cc
 
c
 c c  ?c c 

c

c
c
#''c+c'cc
˜
c


 c


c
ccc c
c c
c
c c
c 


c c

c ˜
c c 
c c 
c c 
 
c 
 c


cc cc
cc cc
c c

c


 cc
c 

 c

 c ˜
c c 
c c c
c c c c c 
c 
c
c 
c  c
  c c
/
c c c c 
c c  c c
c 
c 

c  c
c


4cc cc 
c
c
c


 cc 
c c


c cc cc
c c 
 c

c c   c
c c 
c 

c ˜
c c


 c c 
 c 
 c  c
c


 c 
c c 

c c
c c

 c c
c  cc
c
 c˜
c
c c 
c
 
c cc cc 
c
c
c c c 
c
cc
c c

c
 c c  c


c
c


 c
c c
c˜ c  cc 
cc
c 
cccc

c
c

 
c
c  c 

c


 c

c 
c 
c 
c


c c&
 c cc 
c c c
 c

c c

cc 
 c

c c c  ccc
c
%
cc
cc
c cc
  c c 
 c  c =c  c c  
c 0c
c 
c c

c 
c c
 c   c 
c c 

c c c c c c

 c


c
c
.c6'c,c
c
$


c
c
 c c 
c˜ cc
c ccc


c


c
c c $ 
c  
c ˜ <"c ˜
c


 c 
c c   c 

 c
cc c
c  cc c 
cc 

c c

c 
c

c c c c

c 

c 
c c 
c 
c c 

c c ˜ c
c 
c
c

c  c 
c
 c c c 
c 
c 

c 
c  c
c   c
c
c  c
c
 c c c 
c 

c 

c

c c c


 c


 c
c
 c c  c  c  c 
c 
&

c
c


 c
 c 
c  
c c
c
c
c
c
c 
c
c  c 
c


 c c  c 
c
c
cc0



cc.
cc×
ccc!

c c

c
c


 
c
c c c
c

 cc  c c
c


 cc
c
1c
cc%'c
c

c c
c
 c c

cc c
cc  c 
c  c
c


 c

c 

c c c 

c  c 
c  c c
/
c
c


 c ˜ c
c


 c
c



 c 
c  c˜
c  c


c c c

 c c  c 

c c 
 c  c 
c c
c
  cc
cc c
c  cc
ccc

 c  c
c  c
c 
c, c
c
c  c  c
c  c c
cc  c
c  c
  
c 
 "c c 
c  c c c
c  c  c  c 
c
  c0
ccc


c c
c(
c
c c 
c c c

'c

 c c

 cc
 c  c

 c

c
c


c c c

c %
c c ˜
c c


 c c
c 
c c c 
  c 
c



c c
c 
 c   c  c
c   c -


c
c c c
 c
c c  cc
c
 c 
c c
c
 cc
c 

 cc c

cc c

cc˜ c
c

3c)%$c'cc%cc'+cc
c
.c c
 c c 
c  c 

c c c
c c  
 c c
 c c  
 c  
c c
 c c 
c  c 

c c
c 
/ c 
 c

  c c 
c 

c
/

c c  

 c  c c + 'c  c
@

c c c 
c c  
 c c c
c c  
 4c c  c  c c
c
  c c
cc c
 "c
c

Àc'cc'c
c
cc
c
 c
c
c


 c

cc
c


c


c cccc c& c c
c  cc c
cc

c c

c c
cccc˜
c 
cc
c c
c


 c c

c
c
c

cc c c
c c
 c 
cccc
c  c c
 c
/
c
c
c
c
cc
c
cc'c'*cc*c6c c %$c'c'cc$''8c'c
*c 6c c c $c +c c 8/%c 8/6%c +c
'c %c '8c +c 'c c c $c +c c %c *%$c 8/&c
%cc$c+c%c6'cc%c%'*ccc+c8$c'cc
$c c c c %c 6c c c 8'c )c c '&c &$c
*ccc'cc+%c'cc6'c+cc'c%cc+cc
c
c

+'c
c

c + 
c c !


c  c
c  
c  c  "c  

c  c
 c- c*
c c
c* c c c. . c
c c
c #c:
 c c c
c5ABCc
c

,
c˜

c 

c c cc c


 
c-
cD#c
!
c
c5AE6c
c

, 
c×!c.c 


cc˜
c 
cc cc
c
-
cD#c1

cFcc
c5AE7c
c


c c ,c  c *  c  

c $
 c + 
#c $
 c


c
c5ABAc
c

+(
c $c ˜
c  
c  c  c  "c  

c  c
 c- c*
c c
c* c c c.   c
c cc
 #c:
 c c c
c5ABCc
c

+ c ×
"c ˜  c 
c c  "c +
c  


c  c
 c - c *
c c
c * c  c  c . . c 
c
 cc #c:
 c c c
c5AEEc
c

+
c Gc 

c  

c c
c 
c * c 
c +#c


c
c5A65cc