www.elsevier.com/locate/foodres
Abstract
Frozen storage of mechanically deboned silver carp (Hypophthalmichthys molitrix) mince for 180 days resulted in a signi®cant
(P40.05) decrease in myo®brillar proteins. In contrast, peroxide value (PV), free fatty acids (FFA) and total volatile base nitrogen
(TVBN) contents increased signi®cantly (P4 0.05) throughout the storage period. The kamaboko forming ability and the sensory
scores of the silver carp mince decreased signi®cantly (P40.05) during the storage period. Texture of the mince was signi®cantly (P
4 0.001) correlated with the decrease in the myo®brillar proteins (salt-soluble proteins), jelly strength and folding test grades; and
increase in expressible water percentage, PV, FFA and TVBN content. Based on `texture' of the mince, the product was acceptable
for 180 days at ÿ18 C. # 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Silver carp; Keeping quality; Frozen storage; Protein denaturation; Lipid deterioration
2. Materials & methods and the solubility index derived from the formula:SSN/
WSN6.25. Peroxide value (PV) and free fatty acids
2.1. Sample preparation (FFA) were determined according to Jacobs (1958) and
Takagi, Hayashi and Itabashi (1984), respectively, using
Fresh silver carp (H. molitrix), purchased from a pri- chloroform extract of lipids prepared from ®sh mince.
vate ®sh farmer near Shimoga, Karnataka state, were The total plate count was estimated by the spread plate
washed in chilled water and transported to the proces- technique as described by Speck (1976). The analyses
sing hall in insulated box containing ice in the ratio of were conducted in triplicate from the randomly selected
1:1 (®sh:ice), during night hours. The ®shes were thor- 500 g sample (frozen) block.
oughly washed and dressed to remove scales, head and
viscera. They were washed once again in chilled water 2.3. Sensory analysis
and ®lleted. Fish ®llets were deboned using mechanical
deboner (model S-3, Toyoseikon Kaisha Ltd., Japan) Sensory evaluation of raw ®sh mince was conducted in
containing 6.5 mm perforation separating disk. Fish mince an open laboratory. The mince was thawed and served on
was prepared by mechanical mincer (model M-3, Toyosei- white enamel trays to 10 panelists familiar with sensory
kon Kaisha Ltd., Japan) initially with 5 mm holes mincer evaluation of similar products. Panelists scored the pro-
plate (15 cm diamter) and later with 2 mm holes mincer duct for appearance, odour and texture based on a 9-
plate. point hedonic scale (1, dislike extremely; 2, dislike very
Samples (500 g) of mince were packed in polythene much, 3; dislike moderately; 4, dislike slightly; 5, neither
bags, arranged in galvanised iron trays and immediately like nor dislike; 6, like slightly; 7, like moderately; 8, like
frozen at ÿ28 C in a coil freezer for 48 h and packed in very much; 9, like extremely).
master cartons of three-ply corrugated paper board
(Coramandel Cartons & Containers Pvt. Ltd. Auto- 2.4. Testing the kamaboko forming ability of mince
nagar, Visakhapatnam-530 012, India) and stored at
ÿ18 C. Samples were drawn at random immediately 2.4.1. Sample preparation
after mincing (fresh), immediately after freezing and at The minced meat was mixed with 3% salt and ground in
30 days interval during frozen storage, for the measure- a silent cutter (mixer) supplied by Toyoseikon Kaisha Ltd.,
ment of the changes in lipids, proteins and sensory Japan for 5 min. The mince was further ground into paste
qualities, besides testing for the kamaboko forming with the addition of 3% starch at 10 C for 30 min. About
ability. 100 g of ground ®sh paste was packed in a vinylidine
chloride ®lm (250 mm long, 48 mm diameter and 200
2.2. Chemical analysis guage thickness) without air pockets. After sealing the
ends, it was boiled at 90 C for 30±40 min in hot water. The
Total protein (TN6.25) was determined by the product was then cooled in ice cold water (2 C) for 20 min,
microkjeldahl method of AOAC (1984) using Tecator and left at room temperature for 12±24 h before analysis.
1007 digestion system and Kjeltec 1002 distilling unit.
While the moisture content was determined by the 2.4.2. Analysis
standard hot air oven (100 C for 18 h) method of The jelly strength of the paste product was measured
AOAC , crude ash was determined by heating an incin- by means of Okada gellometer (Saitama Keki Seisa Kuso
erated sample in a mue furnace (550 C for 10 h) and Co. Ltd., Tokyo, Japan) as described by Suzuki (1981).
values expressed on wet weight basis (AOAC). Total The folding test and expressible water measurements
lipids from the minced meat sample was extracted by were also carried out as per the procedure of Okada,
the procedure of Bligh and Dyer (1959) using chloro- described by Suzuki.
form. Total volatile base nitrogen (TVBN) was estimated
by the method of Beatty and Gibbons (1937). The non- 2.5. Statistical analysis
protein nitrogen content in the TCA extract (20%) of
minced meat was determined by the microkjeldahl All the results expressed are the mean of three or
method. The pH of minced meat was recorded using com- more measurements except the sensory scores for
bined electrode pH meter (Vidya Sagar Reddy & Srikar, appearance, odour and texture which are the mean of
1991). hedonic scores as assessed by 10 panelists. Simple cor-
The salt soluble nitrogen (SSN) and water soluble relation was used to relate the mean texture scores with
nitrogen (WSN) contents were extracted from the mince FFA, PV, TVBN & SSP. A linear regression plot of
as per the procedure described by Dyer, French and mean sensory scores for texture and storage period was
Snow (1950) and Srikar and Vidya Sagar Reddy (1991), used to determine the shelf-life. ANOVA and Student t
respectively. The soluble nitrogen contents in the test were used to ®nd the signi®cance of dierence
extracts were estimated by the microkjeldahl method between the storage periods.
D. Siddaiah et al. / Food Research International 34 (2001) 47±53 49
Table 1
Characteristics of fresh silver carp mince and yield percentage at various stages of processing
1. Physical characteristics
(a) Average total length (cm) 40.81(1.63) 12
(b) Average total weight (gm) 875.00(48) 12
2. Biochemical characteristics
(a) Moisture (%) 80.97(1.18) 4
(b) Total protein (%) 16.68(0.42) 4
(c) Total lipid (%) 1.42(0.08) 4
(d) Ash (%) 1.21(0.04) 4
(e) pH 6.50(0.0) 3
(f) Salt soluble proteins (% of total proteins) 64.04(1.16) 3
(g) Water soluble proteins (% of total proteins) 27.26(0.69) 3
(h) Total volatile base nitrogen (mg/100g meat) 1.60(0.35) 3
(i) Non-protein nitrogen (mg/100g meat) 386.36(7.42) 3
(j) Peroxide value (mmoles of O2/Kg fat) 15.32(1.27) 3
(k) Free fatty acids (% of total lipid as oleic acid) 6.58(1.10) 3
3. Microbiological characteristics
(a) Total plate count (colony forming units/g meat) 2.45104 3
4. Stage of processing Yield percentage
(a) Whole ®sh to dressed ®sh 59.28 2
(b) Whole ®sh to picked meat 25.37 2
(c) Whole ®sh to minced meat 24.62 2
(d) Dressed ®sh to picked meat 42.81 2
(e) Dressed ®sh to minced meat 42.53 2
(f) Picked meat to minced meat 97.01 2
50 D. Siddaiah et al. / Food Research International 34 (2001) 47±53
Fig. 1. Changes in the salt soluble proteins (SSP), water soluble proteins (WSP), peroxide value (PV), free fatty acids (FFA) and total volatile base
nitrogen (TVBN) contents of silver carp mince during frozen storage.
1995). In the present study, TVBN was around 30 mg/100 The jelly strength and folding test grades decreased
g meat, when the samples were liked slightly by panelists signi®cantly (P40.05) during the frozen storage (Fig. 4).
indicating beginning of spoilage and signi®cantly In contrast, the expressible water percentage increased
(P40.001) correlated with the `odour' of the mince (Table signi®cantly (P40.05) throughout the storage period.
2). However, TVBN levels are dependent on the species of Prabhu, Shamasunder, Krishnamurthy and Chan-
®sh and the storage temperature of the product (Park, drasekhar (1986) observed signi®cant decrease in the
Chai, Ahn & Yang, 1981). kamaboko forming ability of the ®sh sausage prepared
The sensory attributes, viz., appearance, odour and from lesser sardine mince. Based on the kamaboko
texture of raw silver carp mince decreased signi®cantly forming ability of the frozen stored mince, the product
(P40.05) during the storage (Fig. 2). While the appear- was acceptable for 90 days. The corresponding jelly
ance and odour of the product was acceptable through- strength, expressible water percentage and folding test
out the storage period, the product was rated poor based grades were 240.9 g cm, 15.32% and `B', respectively.
on the tough texture attained during storage. Toughness Although, minced meat has potential application in the
attained during frozen storage of the mince is mainly preparation of value added products like ®sh sticks, ®sh
due to the decreased solubility of protein as a result of cakes, ®sh balls, ®sh ®ngers, ®sh sausage, etc., products
aggregation (Vidya Sagar Reddy & Srikar, 1991). of prime quality are obtained when the mince retains its
According to Rodger, Weddle and Craig (1980), sensory native protein structure, without undergoing signi®cant
quality ``texture of meat'' is one of the important attri- denaturation and aggregation. Although oxidative and
bute on which protein denaturation has profound eect. hydrolysed products do have a bearing on the taste and
Textural changes among ®sh and ®shery products are odour of the paste products, these can be masked dur-
associated with toughening events in myotomal tissue ing the product preparation. On the other hand, in the
(Shenouda, 1980) and are related to the denaturation of preparation of paste products especially emulsion type
myo®brillar proteins and low density of Z lines, which products where protein functionality is of great sig-
occur during post mortem glycolysis (Dunajski, 1979). ni®cance, texture plays a major role and the products
Further, as FFA and PV formed during storage cause should not become tough or rubbery.
textural alterations by complexing with proteins (Mai & The results of the present investigation indicate that
Kinsella, 1980), the mean texture scores were used to although frozen silver carp mince (raw) was in accep-
calculate the shelf-life. On correlating the mean sensory table condition up to 180 days, emulsion type of paste
scores for texture of the mince with storage period (Fig. 3), products could be prepared from the mince stored up to
the product was in acceptable condition for 180 days. 90 days only when the product is stored at ÿ18 C.
Signi®cant decrease in texture scores have been Determination of the contents of FFA, PV, SSP, TVBN
observed by Rodger et al. (1980), Vidya Sagar Reddy and testing the kamaboko forming ability of the mince
and Srikar (1991) Verma, Srikar, Sudhakara and Sarma are useful in assessing the quality of frozen stored silver
(1995) and Vidya Sagar Reddy, Srikar, Ravikiran, Jiten carp mince. The present investigation indicates that
Sharma and Khuntia (1997). production and freezing of silver carp mince could oer
52 D. Siddaiah et al. / Food Research International 34 (2001) 47±53
References
AOAC (Association of Ocial Analytical Chemists) (1984). Ocial
method of analysis (14th ed.). Washington, DC: Association of O-
cial Analytical Chemists.
Beatty, S. A., & Gibbons, N. E. (1937). The measurement of spoilage
in ®sh. Journal of Biological Board of Canada, 3(1), 77±91.
Bligh, E. G., & Dyer, W. J. (1959). A rapid method of total lipid
extraction and puri®cation. Canadian Journal of Biochemistry &
Physiology, 37(8), 911±917.
Boerrenson, T., Knudsen, L. B., & Neilsen, J. (1985). Determination
of sarcoplasmic proteins during frozen storage of ®sh. Refrigeration
Science Technology, 60, 92±96.
Chakrabarti, R. (1984). Changes in the muscle of three Indian major
carps during frozen storage. Fishery Technology, 21(2), 91±93.
Connell, J. J. (1975). Control of ®sh quality. Surrey, UK: Fishing News
(Books) Ltd.
Daley, L. H., & Deng, J. C. (1978). Determining the optimal ranges of
factors aecting the sensory acceptability of a minced mullet sau-
sage. Journal of Food Science, 43, 1497±1500.
Dunajski, E. (1979). Texture of ®sh muscle. Journal of Texture Studies,
10, 301±306.
Dyer, W. J., French, H. V., & Snow, J. M. (1950). Protein in ®sh
muscle. 1. Extraction of protein fraction in fresh ®sh. Journal of the
Fisheries Research Board of Canada, 7, 585±593.
Herzberg, A., & Pasteur, R. (1981). Proximate composition and pre-
liminary data on freshness determination of silver carp (Hypoph-
thalmichthys molitrix, val). Bamidegh, 33(3), 87±99.
Jacobs, M. B. (1958). The chemical analysis of foods and food products
(pp. 393±394). New York: Krieger Publishing Co., Inc.
Kimura, K., & Kiamakura, S. (1934). Detection of the onset of
decomposition in ®sh meat as shown by content of ammonia. Pro-
ceedings of 5th Paci®c Science Congress, 5, 3709±3712.
Kussi, T., Nikkila, O. E., & Savolainen, K. (1975). Formation of
malonaldehyde in frozen Baltic herring and its in¯uence on the
changes in protein. Zeitschrift fuÈr Lebenssmittel-Unters und-for-
chung, 159, 285±287.
Mai, J., & Kinsella, J. E. (1980). Composition of lipids and proteins of
deboned, minced and ®lleted white sucker (Catostomus commersoni).
Journal of Food Biochemistry, 3(4), 229±239.
Park, Y. H., Chai, S. A., Ahn, C. W., & Yang, Y. K. (1981). Changes
in contents of amines in the dark ¯eshed ®sh meat during processing
and storage 2: Formation of DMA and TMA in salted and dried
mackerel, pike and spanish mackerel. Bulletin of Korean Fisheries
Society, 14, 7±14.
Prabhu, R. M., Shamasunder, B. A., Krishnamurthy, B. V., & Chan-
drasekhar, T. C. (1986). Suitability of lesser sardine, (Sardinella
Fig. 4. Changes in kamaboko forming ability (jelly strength, expressible gibbosa) meat for the preparation of ®sh sausage. In M. Mohan
water and folding test grades) of silver carp mince stored at ÿ18 C. Joseph, The ®rst indian ®sheries forum, Asian Fisheries Society (pp.
57±95). Mangalore: Indian branch.
Rodger, G. W., Weddle, R. B., & Craig, P. (1980). Eect of time,
temperature, raw material types, processing and use of cryo-protec-
tive agents on mince quality. In J. J. Connell, Advances in ®sh sci-
a potential means of processing fresh water ®sh. Further ence and technology (pp. 199±217). London: Fishing News Books
work is needed on the improvement of stability of silver Ltd.
carp mince during storage. Shenouda, S. Y. K. (1980). Theories of protein denaturation during
frozen storage of ®sh ¯esh. Advances in Food Research, 26, 275±311.
Siddaiah, D., Vidya Sagar Reddy, G., & Raju, C. V. (1999). Eect of
cryoprotectants on the keeping quality of silver carp (Hypophthal-
michthys molitrix) mince during frozen storage. Environment and
Acknowledgements Ecology, 17(2), 359±365.
Sikorski, Z. E., Olley, J., & Kostuch, S. (1976). Protein changes in
frozen ®sh. CRC Critical Reviews of Food Science and Nutrition,
The authors express their gratitude to Professor H.
8(1), 97±129.
Seshappa, and Associate Professors Sri H. Bhandary Speck, M. L. (1976). Compendium of methods for the microbiological
and Sri N.S. Sudhakara, of College of Fisheries for their examination of foods. New York: American Public Health Associa-
keen interest in the investigation. tion.
D. Siddaiah et al. / Food Research International 34 (2001) 47±53 53
Srikar, L. N., Seshadari, H. S., & Fazal, A. A. (1989). Changes in Eect of frozen storage on lipid freshness parameters and some
lipids and proteins of marine cat ®sh, (Tachysurus dussumieri) dur- functional properties of oil sardine (Sardinella longiceps) mince.
ing frozen storage. International Journal of Food Science and Tech- Food Research International, 28, 87±90.
nology, 24, 653±658. Vidya Sagar Reddy, G., & Srikar, L. N. (1991). Preprocessing ice sto-
Srikar, L. N., & Vidya Sagar Reddy, G. (1991). Protein solubility and rage eect on functional properties of ®sh mince proteins. Journal of
emulsifying capacity in frozen stored ®sh mince. Journal of Science Food Science, 56(4), 965±968.
of Food and Agriculture, 55, 447±453. Vidya Sagar Reddy, G., Srikar, L. N., Khuntia, B. K., & Vinay
Suzuki, T. (1981). Fish and krill proteins; Processing technology. Bark- Kumar, N. (1995). Eect of preprocess storage in ice on the chemi-
ing, UK: Applied Science Publishers. cal characteristics of ®sh mince. Journal of Food Science and Tech-
Takagi, T., Hayashi, K., & Itabashi, Y. (1984). Toxic eect of free nology, 32, 315±319.
unsaturated fatty acids in mouse assay of diarrlutic shell®sh toxin Vidya Sagar Reddy, G., Srikar, L. N., Ravikiran, K., Jiten Sarma, &
by intraperitoneal injection. Bulletin of the Japanese Society of Sci- Khuntia, B. K. (1997). Keeping quality of frozen stored pink perch
enti®c Fisheries, 50, 1413±1418. mince. Environment and Ecology, 15(3), 497±502.
Tokunaga, T. (1974). The eect of decomposition products of tri- Vidya Sagar Reddy, G., & Srikar, L. N. (1996). Eect of preprocess
methylamine oxide on the quality of frozen Alaska Pollack ®llet. storage on the lipid changes of Japanese thread®n bream (Nemip-
Bulletin of Japaneese Society of Scienti®c Fisheries, 40(2), 167±174. terus japonicus) mince during frozen storage. Asian Fisheries Sci-
Uchiyama, H., & Ehira, S. (1974). Relation between freshness and ence, 9, 109±114.
acid soluble nucleotides in aseptic cod and yellow tail muscles Webb, N. B., Hardy, E. R., Giddings, G., & Howell, A. J. (1976).
during ice storage. Bulletin of Tokai Refrigeration Fisheries Research In¯uence of mechanical separation upon proximate composition,
Laboratory, 78, 23±32. functional properties and textural characteristics of frozen Atlantic
Verma, J. K., Srikar, L. N., Sudhakara, N. S., & Sarma, J. (1995). croaker muscle tissue. Journal of Food Science, 41, 1277±1281.