SUBMITTED BY
Kamran Aziz
M. Hamza
M. Ali Hamza Kamal
Avais Babar Chishti
Proposed Project
1. PROBLEM BACKGROUND
The cooking oil industry is a very large sector in Pakistan. Its status as
a common household FMCG makes it one of the most pertinent of the
products. . However, the practice of cooking oil marketing has not yet
reached a stage where consumers can psychologically associate
themselves with the product. The cooking oil marketing mainly focuses
on the qualities and attributes of the product, rather than the
consumer’s attitudes and perceptions, regarding the product. For
example, many companies promote their products by focusing on the
specific health benefits associated with the product. The management
problem, hence, is understanding the psyche of the consumer
regarding the different brands of cooking oils.
2. MANAGEMENT PROBLEM
To devise an effective positioning strategy and understanding the
attitudes of cooking oil consumer.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
What are the perceived attributes associated with the different brands
of cooking oil?
4. Type of Study:
Firstly, our initial research to find the segmentation in the cooking oil
market would be purely descriptive. As we seek to identify different
consumer segments, the major purpose of descriptive research is to
describe the characteristics of the population. In addition to that, we
also plan to compliment our research with the findings of some
qualitative research conducted through in-depth interviews. In order to
determine the lifestyle of a typical Dalda Cooking Oil customer, we
need to use some judgmental analysis in the form of qualitative
research.
5. Hypothesis
Ho: Dalda, as a cooking oil, is not accepted by the consumer due to its
image as a ghee or banaspati.
Ha: Dalda ,as a cooking oil, is accepted by the consumer despite its
image as a ghee or banaspati.
Ho: Quality is the most important feature affecting the purchase of the
cooking oil
Ha: Quality is the not the most important feature affecting the
purchase of the cooking oil
Ho: People choice of cooking oil is very much affected by the advice
given by credible people such as doctors.
Ha: People choice of cooking oil is not quite affected by the advice
given by credible people such as doctors.
TOTAL 150
8. Sampling Technique:
As we require a specified sample, we would use the non-probability
sample. It will be a stratified sample chosen from the population of
Socioeconomic class B+ and above. We will we collecting information
from those areas of the city that lie in the above mentioned bracket.
9. Field work
The field work will primarily be conducted by our group. However, if the
task seems out of our budgeted time, we have been given the
opportunity to outsource it to the Dalda’s research people. The field
work will require door to door questionnaire filling, short questionnaires
filled by consumers of cooking oils etc.
Not Answered
0%
No
47%
No
Yes Yes
53%
Not Answered
The result shows that half of the people have actually sought the
advice of doctor in their decision about the cooking oil. The other half
will not be taken in our further analysis.
13. Dalda Banaspati * 3. If yes, then did the doctor give any suggession about the
cooking oil? Crosstabulation
Count
3. If yes, then did the doctor give any Tota
suggession about the cooking oil? l
Not
No Yes Applicable
Ye
13. Dalda Banaspati s 0 7 8 15
3. Out of people who visited doctor, how many got any cooking oil
recommended?
Yes
47% Yes
Not Applicable Not Applicable
53%
100% of people who visited doctors were recommended some cooking oil
The result shows that all the people who visited doctor, concerning
their food, had received some advice on their use of cooking oil. This
highlights the importance of doctors’ advice on food and consequently
cooking oil.
13. Dalda Banaspati * 4. If yes, then how regularly do you follow his advice?
Crosstabulation
Count
4. If yes, then how regularly do you follow Tota
his advice? l
V. Not Regularl Rarel
Regularly Applicable y y
13. Dalda Ye
Banaspati s 0 8 5 2 15
V. Regularly
Rarely 0%
13%
V. Regularly
Not Applicable
Not Applicable
54%
Regularly
Regularly Rarely
33%
4. Among the people who got some advice, how many follow the advice ...
V. Regularly
0%
Rarely
29%
V. Regularly
Regularly
Rarely
Regularly
71%
The results show that at least 47% of Dalda Banapati ghee users have
been to Doctor to discuss their food habits. Out of these people who’ve
been to Doctor, all of them got advice regarding cooking oil. And now if
we consider only these people who got some advice from doctor, 71%
follow this advice regularly and 29% rarely follow this advice. This
shows that in total 33% people out of the Dalda cooking oil population
had their decision affected by the doctor’s advice.
13. Dalda Banaspati * 6. In your opinion, how compatible are the clothes worn
now a days with the moral code? Crosstabulation
Count
6. In your opinion, how compatible are the
clothes worn now a days with the moral code?
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Not Answered
13. Dalda Banaspati Yes 1 1 0 3 2 0 6 2
6. How compatible are the clothes worn now a days compatible with societal moral
code
4
Series2
3
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
7. Do you exercise
Not Answered
7%
Yes
13%
No
Yes
Not Answered
No
80%
This clearly shows that the consumer of Dalda cooking oil is not very
conscious about their health, as 80% do not exercise at all.
13. Dalda Banaspati * 8. If yes, then how regularly do you
exercise? Crosstabulation
Count
8. If yes, then how
regularly do you exercise? Total
Not Not
1 Applicab Answer
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 0 le ed
13. Dalda Banaspati Yes 1 0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 10 1 15
All
33%
Me
Me
46% Childeren
Not Answered
Parents
Husband n' Wife
All
Husband n' Wife
7%
Parents Childeren
7% 7%
Not Answered
0%
The results shows that the decision is made by the housewife herself
half of the time or it is collectively done. This shows the importance of
targeting housewife as the potential buyer and also the management
of Dalda should consider the fact that a good chunk of their consumer
makes the decision collectively, therefore they need to promote a
family outlook of their Brand.
13. Dalda Banaspati * 10. Rate the following according to their importance
Crosstabulation
Count (Quality).
10. Rate the following according to their
importance Total
Not
1 2 4 5 Answered
13. Dalda Banaspati Yes 0 0 1 14 0 15
Ratings of Quality
16
14
12
10
8 Series2
0
1 2 3 4
The results clearly show that the most important thing affecting the
purchasing pattern of a Dalda cooking oil consumer is the Quality of
the product.
13. Dalda Banaspati * 10. Rate the following according to their importance
Crosstabulation
Count (Price)
10. Rate the following according to
their importance Total
Not
1 2 3 4 5 Answered
13. Dalda Banaspati Yes 1 0 5 7 1 1 15
Ratings of Price
4 Series1
0
1 2 3 4 5 Not Answered
This shows that price is the second most important decision affecting
the purchase of cooking oil.
13. Dalda Banaspati * 10. Rate the following according to their importance
Crosstabulation
Count (BRAND)
10. Rate the following according to
their importance Total
Not
1 2 3 4 5 Answered
13. Dalda Banaspati Yes 3 1 3 7 0 1 15
Ratings of Company Name
4 Series1
0
1 2 3 4 5 Not Answered
The company name also plays a good role in deciding the purchase of
cooking oil. A good percentile of people chose it to be the second most
important factor in their purchasing decision.
13. Dalda Banaspati * 10. Rate the following according to their importance
Crosstabulation
Count (Prize
Schemes)
10. Rate the following according to
their importance Total
Not
1 2 3 4 5 Answered
13. Dalda Banaspati Yes 5 5 4 0 0 1 15
3 Series2
0
1 2 3 4 5
This did not affect, much, the purchasing decision of the cooking oil,
although some people actually were influenced by this decision.
13. Dalda Banaspati * 10. Rate the following according to their importance
Crosstabulation
Count
10. Rate the following according to
their importance Total
Not
1 2 3 4 5 7 Answered
13. Dalda Banaspati Yes 5 7 1 1 0 0 1 15
Ratings of Discount Schemes
4 Series2
0
1 2 3 4 5 6
4 Series2
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Sometimes In,
Sometimes Out
33%
Mostly In
33%
Not Answered
6%
No
Yes
38% Yes
No Not Answered
56%
Most of the Rafhan Consumers have not been to a doctor, for their
advice about food. Only 38% have been to the doctor in total.
13. Rafhan Cooking Oil * 3. If yes, then did the doctor give any suggession
about the cooking oil? Crosstabulation
Count
3. If yes, then did the doctor give
any suggession about the cooking
oil? Total
No Yes Not Applicable
13. Rafhan Cooking Oil Yes 1 5 10 16
3. If yes, then did doctor give any suggestion about cooking oil?
No
6%
Yes
31%
No
Yes
Not Applicable
Not Applicable
63%
3. Out of people who visited doctor, how many got any cooking oil
recommended?
No
17%
No
Yes
Yes
83%
Out of those 38% who sought advice about food, a very high 83% got
advice about the cooking oil. This again signifies the importance of
Healthy food and good cooking oil.
13. Rafhan Cooking Oil * 4. If yes, then how regularly do you follow his advice?
Crosstabulation
Count
4. If yes, then how regularly do you follow his Tota
advice? l
V. Not Regularl Rarel
Regularly Applicable y y
13. Rafhan Cooking
Oil Yes 1 11 2 2 16
Rarely V. Regularly
13% 6%
Regularly
13% V. Regularly
Not Applicable
Regularly
Rarely
Not Applicable
68%
V. Regularly
20%
Rarely
40% V. Regularly
Regularly
Rarely
Regularly
40%
How compatible are the clothes worn now a days with the moral code?
4
Series1
3
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Not
Answered
No
44%
No
Yes Yes
56%
This shows that more than half of the Rafhan consumers do actually
exercise and are health conscious.
13. Rafhan Cooking Oil * 8. If yes, then how regularly do you exercise?
Crosstabulation
Count
8. If yes, then how regularly do you
exercise?
Not
1 Not Answer
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 Applicable ed
13. Rafhan Cooking 1
Oil Yes 0 1 0 1 2 0 1 1 1 0 2 7 0 6
How regularly do you exercise?
4 Series1
All
38%
Me
Me Childeren
50% Not Answered
Parents
Husband n' Wife
All
5
Series1
4
0
Me Childeren Not Answered Parents Husband n' Wife All
The results show that the housewife is the main factor making the
purchasing decision. In many cases of rafhan cooking oil, all the family
members also pitch in their choice of cooking oil. The unique point here
is that housewife makes the decision or at least contributes to the
decision in 94% (50%+38+6+) of the instances.
????
13. Rafhan Cooking Oil * 10. Rate the following according to their importance
Crosstabulation
Count (Quality)
10. Rate the following according to their Tota
importance l
Not
1 2 4 5 Answered
13. Rafhan Cooking Oil Yes 0 1 3 12 0 16
Ratings of Quality
14
12
10
8
Series1
6
0
1 2 3 4 5 Not Answered
3 Series2
0
1 2 3 4 5
4
Series2
3
0
1 2 3 4 5
10
9
8
7
6
5 Series2
4
3
2
1
0
1 2 3 4 5
Prize schemes are not considered to be a very strong factor and the
consumers are not very much affected by the presence of such prize
schemes.
13. Rafhan Cooking Oil * 10. Rate the following according to their importance
Crosstabulation
Count
10. Rate the following according to
their importance Total
Not
Answere
1 2 3 4 5 7 d
13. Rafhan Cooking Oil Yes 5 6 4 1 0 0 0 16
4
Series2
3
0
1 2 3 4 5 6
12
10
6 Series2
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Only Out
0%
Only In Mostly Out
13% 0%
Only Out
Mostly Out
Sometimes In, Sometimes Out
Sometimes In, Mostly In
Mostly In
31% Sometimes Out Only In
56%
Not Answered
Yes 0%
23%
No
Yes
Not Answered
No
77%
Most of the people have never consulted the doctor on their food
habits, and therefore, the effectiveness of Doctors’ advice on the
buying decision is already made less important by this fact.
13. Soya Supreme * 3. If yes, then did the doctor give any suggession about the
cooking oil? Crosstabulation
Count
3. If yes, then did the doctor give any
suggession about the cooking oil? Total
No Yes Not Applicable
13. Soya Supreme Yes 2 5 23 30
No
7%
Yes
17%
No
Yes
Not Applicable
Not Applicable
76%
The graph for only recommended people is not applicable here because very small
people portion of soya supreme consumers went to doctor
30
25
20
15 Series1
10
0
V. Regularly Not Applicable Regularly Rarely
here also the graph for people who follow advice is not required coz very few people
5
Series2
4
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
The graph shows a very diversified trend, and it will be safe to assume
that the consumer of Soya supreme, is very diverse in their mindset of
the current attire. Therefore, we cannot make any concrete statement
about the dressing preferences of the soya supreme consumers.
13. Soya Supreme * 7. Do you exercise? Crosstabulation
Count
7. Do you
exercise? Total
Not
No Yes Answered
13. Soya Supreme Yes 12 18 0 30
No
40%
No
Yes Yes
60%
12
10
6 Series1
0
ed
e
bl
pp 0
0
er
1
a
l ic
w
ns
A
tA
ot
o
N
N
Everyone
30%
Me
43% Me
Childeren
Not Answered
Parents
Husband n' Wife Husband n' Wife
7%
Everyone
Childeren
Parents 0%
20% Not Answered
0%
14
12
10
8
Series1
6
0
Me Childeren Not Answered Parents Husband n' Wife Everyone
The house wife plays the pivotal role in the purchasing decision
however, everyone’s advice is also sought. The relative percentage of
children, surprisingly, is none. This might also be due to the fact that
majority of the women consuming Soya are in their late twenties.
13. Soya Supreme * 10. Rate the following according to their importance
Crosstabulation
Count
10. Rate the following according to their
importance
1 2 4 5 Not Answered
13. Soya Supreme Yes 0 0 2 28 0
Ratings of Quality
30
25
20
15 Series2
10
0
1 2 3 4 5
Ratings of Price
14
12
10
8
Series2
6
0
1 2 3 4 5
14
12
10
8
Series1
6
0
1 2 3 4 5 Not Answered
18
16
14
12
10
Series2
8
0
1 2 3 4 5
Prize schemes are not a very popular factor affecting the purchasing
decision. People do not think of it highly when it comes to making the
decision about the purchase of the cooking oil.
13. Soya Supreme * 10. Rate the following according to their importance
Crosstabulation
Count
10. Rate the following according to
their importance Total
Not
Answere
1 2 3 4 5 7 d
13. Soya Supreme Yes 11 10 4 3 1 0 1 30
Ratings of Discounts
12
10
6 Series2
0
1 2 3 4 5 6
Discount schemes like Prize scheme do not count for much either when
it comes to the purchasing of the product.
13. Soya Supreme * 11. When buying cooking oil, nothing is more important than
the quality Crosstabulation
Count
11. When buying cooking oil, nothing is more
important than the quality
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
13. Soya Supreme Yes 18 7 2 2 1 0 0
20
18
16
14
12
10 Series2
8
6
4
2
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Only Out
0%
Only In
Mostly Out
10%
7%
Only Out
Mostly Out
Sometimes In, Sometimes Out
Mostly In Mostly In
33% Only In
Sometimes In, Sometimes
Out
50%
INTERPRETATION
The results show that at least 38% of Dalda users have been to Doctor
for consulting on their food habits. Out of those who’ve been to Doctor
38% did actually receive some advice. Out of these 40%, 4% follow
their Doctor’s advice very regularly, 31% follow it regularly and 4%
rarely.
Q6. In your opinion, how compatible are the clothes worn now a days
with the moral code? (1=very compatible, 7=completely incompatible)
Not
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Answered
3 1 2 6 2 0 12 0
Weighted Average = 4.96
Figure 4
Q8. If yes, then how regularly do you exercise? (1=very irregular,
10=very regular)
Not
Not Answer
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Applicable ed
0 0 1 1 3 4 3 1 2 2 0 8 1
Weighted average = 3.6
INTERPRETATION
Quality
1 2 3 4
Not 5
Answer
ed
1 1 0 1 23 0
Weighted average = 4.69
Price
Not
Answer
1 2 3 4 5 ed
1 1 13 10 1 0
Weighted average = 3.34
Brand
Not
Answer
1 2 3 4 5 ed
6 0 8 12 0 0
Weighted average = 3.0
Prize Scheme
Not
Answer
1 2 3 4 5 ed
11 11 2 0 2 0
Weighted average = 1.88
Discounts
Not
Answer
1 2 3 4 5 7 ed
6 12 5 3 0 0 0
Weighted average = 2.19
Q.10 Rate the following according to their importance:
(5=most important, 1=least important)
INTERPRETATION
The most important aspect for a Dalda consumer is the quality (an
average score of 4.69 out of 5). Other important aspect, along with
their average scores, in decreasing order of their importance are price
3.34/5, Brand 3.0/5, Discounts 1.8/5 and Prize Scheme 1.88/5.
Though these results clearly suggest that the most important aspect is
indeed Quality, there could well be a natural tendency for all the
respondents to choose quality as the most important factor.
INTERPRETATION
Most Dalda oil consumers believe that Quality is more important than
any other factor when buying a cooking oil (16 respondents considered
it to be the most important factor out of a sample of 30)
INTERPRETATION
INTERPRETATION
The results show that at least 40% of HABIB users have been to Doctor
for consulting on their food habits. Out of those who’ve been to Doctor
40% did actually receive some advice. Out of these 40%, 7% follow
their Doctor’s advice very regularly, 27% follow it regularly and 7%
rarely.
Q6. In your opinion, how compatible are the clothes worn now a days
with the moral code? (1=very compatible, 7=not compatible)
Not
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Answered
7 1 1 7 0 1 12 1
INTERPRETATION
INTERPRETATION
Quality
1 2 4 5 Not
3 Answer
ed
0 1 0 6 22 1
Weighted average = 4.53
Price
Not
Answer
1 2 3 4 5 ed
0 2 13 9 4 2
Weighted average = 3.3
Brand
Not
Answer
1 2 3 4 5 ed
3 0 10 9 6 2
Weighted average = 3.3
Prize Scheme
Not
Answer
1 2 3 4 5 ed
11 12 3 0 2 2
Weighted average = 1.8
Discounts
Not
Answer
1 2 3 4 5 ed
11 12 2 2 1 2
Weighted average = 1.8
INTERPRETATION
The most important aspect for a Habib consumer is the quality (an
average score of 4.53 out of 5). Other important aspect, along with
their average scores, in decreasing order of their importance are price
3.3/5, Brand 3.3/5, Prize Scheme 1.8/5 and Discounts 1.8/5.
Though these results clearly suggest that the most important aspect is
indeed Quality, there could well be a tendency for all the respondents
to choose quality as the most important factor.
Q.11 When buying cooking oil, nothing is more important than the
quality?
(1=very true, 7=very false)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
19 4 5 2 0 0 0
Weighted average = 1.67
INTERPRETATION
Most Habib oil consumers believe that Quality is more important than
any other factor when buying a cooking oil (19 respondents considered
it to be the most important factor out of a sample of 30 while no
respondent giving it low scores of 5, 6 or 7 on the scale above)
INTERPRETATION
35
30
25
20
Series1
15
10
5
0
E
IL
E
AN
NS
TA
B
FI
HE
V
EM
O
BI
SU
LI
AN
FH
SO
NG
IG
HA
PR
RA
PL
A
ES
T
KI
SU
SE
PA
RG
O
YA
AS
BO
SO
AN
A
LD
B
DA
A
LD
DA
Q14 TO Q17
14. What does word "Dalda" reminds
you of?
Cooking Oil 64
10
Banaspati Ghee 0
Vegetable Oil 18
Not Answered 2
Not Answered
1%
Vegetable Oil
10%
Cooking Oil
35%
Cooking Oil
Banaspati Ghee
Vegetable Oil
Not Answered
Banaspati Ghee
54%
4
Least Successful 0
6
Second Most Successful 0
7
Most Successful 8
Not Answered 6
Not Answered
3%
Least Successful
22%
Least Successful
Most Successful Second Most Successful
42% Most Successful
Not Answered
3
Least Successful 8
5
Second Most Successful 0
8
Most Successful 8
Not Answered 8
Perceptions about Dalda Banaspati Ghee
Not Answered
4%
Least Successful
21%
Least Successful
Second Most Successful
Most Successful
Most Successful
Not Answered
48%
11
Least Successful 0
Second Most Successful 42
Most Successful 18
Not Answered 14
Not Answered
8%
Most Successful
10%
Least Successful
Second Most Successful
Most Successful
Second Most Not Answered
Successful Least Successful
23% 59%
Therefore, the analysis from the Q14 and 15 highlights our hypothesis,
that Dalda as a cooking oil is not entirely accepted by its consumer due
to its strong image as a Banaspati ghee.
16. Have you ever used Dalda
Cooking Oil?
No 42
Yes 142
No
23%
No
Yes
Yes
77%
Luckily, most of the people we interviewed had used Dalda cooking oil,
which provided us ample sample size to move to our semantic
differential question above measuring consumer’s attitudes towards
Dalda cooking oil, on a variety of Dimensions.
Limitations
There were several limitations to our research. The major limitations to
this research are as follows: