7hruhpd: + (Q (Q (+ ( (Q Q Q

$5+,0('( V 1UPDLLXQLH
$6835$381&7(/25),;(
$/(81(,)81&é,,5($/(
&(=$5-2, $

)LHI5→5RIXQF LHFRQWLQX [∈5úL$⊂59RPIRORVLXUP WRDUHOH
QRWD LL 2 +[ I {\∈5∃Q∈1DVWIHOvQFkWIQ[ \`
2 −[ I {\∈5∃Q∈1DVWIHOvQFkWIQ\ [`
2[I 2 +[ I∪ 2 −[ I)L[I {\∈5I\ \}
;
{\ ∈5 ∃XQúLU^[Q`[Q ∈;?^\`úLOLP[Q \`FXDOWHFXYLQWH;

HVWHPXO LPHDSXQFWHORUGHDFXPXODUHDOHOXL;
'DF I HVWH IXQF LH /LSVFKLW] GH FRQVWDQW N ∈ DWXQFL OHPD FRQ
WUDF LHLDOXL%DQDFKVSXQHF )L[IDUHH[DFWXQHOHPHQWúLSHQWUXRULFH[ ∈5
2 +[ I
)L[IÌQDFHDVW QRW YRPSUH]HQWDXQUH]XOWDWRDUHFXPVLPLODUSHQ
WUXRIXQF LHFRQWLQX DUELWUDU GHVSUHFDUHúWLPF DUHFHOSX LQXQSXQFWIL[
7HRUHPD )LHI5 →5RIXQF LHFRQWLQX DVWIHOvQFkW)L[I ≠úLILH
D∈)L[I
D'DF [!DúLI[![DWXQFL
2 [− I
∩)L[I≠∅
D
'DF ∀[!DDYHPD[I[DWXQFL
∀[!D 2 [+ I
∩)L[I≠∅
E'DF [DúLI[[DWXQFL

2 [− I
∩)L[I≠∅
E
'DF ∀[D[I[DDWXQFLSHQWUX∀[D

2 [+ I
∩)L[I≠∅

'(021675$ ,( 9RP GHPRQVWUD QXPDL D úL D

SHQWUX F E úL E
VXQW
FRPSOHWVLPLODUH
D )LH α VXS)L[I ∩ >D [@ 2EVHUY P PDL vQWkL F α ∈ )L[I

ÌQWUDGHY U SHQWUX RULFH Q ∈ 1 α ± QX HVWH PDMRUDQW SHQWUX PXO LPHD
Q
)L[I ∩>D [@ GHRDUHFH α HVWH FHO PDL PLF PDMRUDQW DO DFHOHL PXO LPL 'HFL

H[LVW DQ ∈ )L[I ∩ >D [@ DQ ∈  α − α $WXQFL OLP DQ α úL IDQ DQ

 Q 

7UHFkQGODOLPLW vQDFHDVW XOWLP UHOD LHRE LQHPIα αúLGHFLα∈)L[I
3HQWUXF I[±[ ≠SHQWUXRULFH[ ∈α[@úLI[!GLQFRQWLQXLWDWHD
OXLIUH]XOW F I[![∀[∈α[@9RPDU WDF α∈ 2 −[ I

9RPGHILQLXQúLU^[Q`Q≥DVWIHOvQFkW α[Q ≤[Q±I[Q [Q±úLOLP[Q

α2GDW FRQVWUXLWXQDVWIHOGHúLUGLQUHOD LDGHUHFXUHQ UH]XOW F IQ[Q

[úLGHFL[Q∈ 2 −[ LDUGLQOLP[Q αGHGXFHPF α∈ 2 −[ I

&RQVWUXF LDúLUXOXL^[Q`VHIDFHDVWIHOGHILQLPPDLvQWkL[)XQF LDJ[

I[ ± [ HVWH FRQWLQX úL Jα α ± [ J[ I[ ± [ ! úL GHFL

∃[∈α[FXJ[ úLGHFLI[ [
3UHVXSXQHPF DPFRQVWUXLW[[«[QDVWIHOvQFkWI[Q [Q±úLα[N
[N±N Q úLYRPFRQVWUXL[Q
)XQF LDJ[ I[±[QHVWHFRQWLQX úLJαJ[Q [Q±±[Q!úLGH
DLFL GHGXFHP F H[LVW [Q ∈ α [Q DVWIHO vQFkW I[Q [Q $FHDVWD vQFKHLH
FRQVWUXF LD úLUXOXL {[Q` 0DL U PkQH GH DU WDW F OLP [Q α 3ULQ FRQVWUXF LH
^[Q}HVWHGHVFUHVF WRUúLP UJLQLWGHFLFRQYHUJHQW
)LH " OLP[Q$WXQFL α ≤ "[LDUGLQI[Q [Q±GHGXFHPF I" "
$PREVHUYDWvQV PDLVXVF SHQWUX[∈α[I[![úLGHFL" α
D
)LH[!DDUELWUDU'HILQLPúLUXO {[Q`Q≥SULQUHOD LDGHUHFXUHQ [Q
I[QQ ≥$WXQFLD[Q[QúL[Q IQ['HFL^[Q`HVWHFRQYHUJHQWúL
[Q ∈ 2 +[ I /D IHO FD vQ GHPRQVWUD LD SXQFWXOXL D GHGXFHP F OLP [Q D úL
GHFLD∈ 2 +[ I
∩)L[I

8UP WRDUHOHH[HPSOHLOXVWUHD] QHFHVLWDWHDFRQGL LLORUWHRUHPHL

I[ ±[∀[∈5$WXQFL2[I ^[±[`SHQWUX[≠úL2I ^

− [ [ ∈ > −@
I[  $WXQFL2I 2±I ^O±}

− [ [ ∈ −∞ − @ ∪ > ∞
 
2I [ −  SHQWUX|[|!úL2[I [ − [ −  SHQWUX|[|O
 
 [ [  [
− [ − [ ∈ −∞ − @
I[  $WXQFL SHQWUX [ ≠ 2[I HVWH LQILQLW
− [ [ ∈ > − ∞
GDU∉2[I
$WXQFLFkQGFRQGL LLOHWHRUHPHLQXVXQWVDWLVI FXWHSXWHPvQF
RE LQHXQUH]XOWDWSDU LDO

3URSR]L LD )LHDFEWUHLQXPHUHUHDOH'DF I>DE@→>DE@HVWH
R IXQF LH FRQWLQX DVWIHO vQFkW )L[I )L[I ^F` úL GDF
I | >D F@ úL I | >F E@ VXQW PRQRWRQH DWXQFL ∀ [ ∈ >D E@ ? ^F}
F∈ 2 [′ I
'(021675$ ,(9RPGLVWLQJHWUHLFD]XUL
&D]XOI|>FE@HVWHFUHVF WRDUH$WXQFL∀[!FI[!F'HRDUHFHI[±[≠
≠SHQWUX[ ≠FGHGXFHPF ∀[ ∈FE@I[![VDX ∀[ ∈FE@I[[
ÌQSULPDVLWXD LHFRQFOX]LDSURSR]L LHLUH]XOW ODIHOFDvQSXQFWXODDOWHRUH
PHLLDUvQFHDGHDGRXDVLWXD LHDSOLF PSXQFWXOD

&D]XOI|>DF@HVWHGHVFUHVF WRDUH$FHVWFD]VHWUDWHD] ODIHOFDúL&D]XO
&D]XOI | >D E@HVWHGHVFUHVF WRDUHÌQDFHVWFD]FRQVLGHU PIXQF LDJ[
I[$WXQFLJQ IQúLGHDLFLGHGXFHP2[J ⊂2[I3HGHDOW SDUWH
)L[J ^F`úLJHVWHFUHVF WRDUH0DLU PkQHDFXPGRDUV DSOLF P&D]XO
VDXIXQF LHLJ
2'(021675$é,(
(/(0(17$5à$5(/$é,(,
/8,'855$1'(
,&'5 *+,&(6&8

)LH XQ SDWUXODWHU LQVFULSWLELO vQ FHUFXO 2 5 úL FLUFXPVFULSWLELO FHUFXOXL
,U5HOD LDOXL'XUUDQGHDILUP F GLVWDQ DGLQWUHFHQWUHOHFHORUGRX FHUFXUL
HVWHGDW GH $
2, 5U± U 5 + U
D
GHFLHVWHH[SULPDELO QXPDLFXDMXWRUXOUD]H %
ORU
G
'HPRQVWUD LDSRDWHILJ VLW vQH[FHOHQWD
PRQRJUDILH >@ SDJ LDU SHQWUX DFHDVWD E
VHIRORVHúWHRIRUP SDUWLFXODU DFHOHEUHLWH
RUHPHGHvQFKLGHUHDOXL-93RQFHOHW
ÌQDFHVWDUWLFROG PRGHPRQVWUD LHHOH ' &
F
PHQWDU DFHVWXLUHPDUFDELOUH]XOWDW0DLvQWkL
vQV YRPWUDWDGRX FKHVWLXQLSULYLQGSDWUXOD
WHUHOH LQVFULSWLELOH VDXúL FLUFXPVFULSWLELOH
)LJ
HYLGHQ LLQG R VHDP GH UH]XOWDWH GH FDUH
DYHPQHYRLHvQGHPRQVWUD LH

)LHQXPHUHOHUHDOHDEFGSR]LWLYH
ÌQWUHEDUHD ÌQFHFRQGL LXQLQXPHUHOHDEFGSRWILOXQJLPLOHODWXULORU
XQXLSDWUXODWHULQVFULSWLELO"$FHVWSDWUXODWHUHVWHXQLFGHWHUPL
QDW"
3HQWUXDU VSXQGHFRQVLGHU PSDWUXODWHUXO$%&'vQFDUH$% D%& E
&' F'$ GSHFDUHvOSUHVXSXQHPLQVFULSWLELOILJ
$WXQFLFRV$ ±FRV&úLDSOLFkQGWHRUHPDFRVLQXVXULORUDYHP
%' DG±DGFRV$ EFEFFRV$
5H]XOW F
D + G − E − F
FRV $ =
DG + EF
3XQkQGFRQGL LD
D + G − E − F

DG + EF
vQPRGHYLGHQWQXSXWHPDYHDFRV$ UH]XOW GXEODLQHJDOLWDWH
±DGEFDG±E±FDGEF
HFKLYDOHQW FXVLVWHPXO
D + G − E − F > _ E − F _ < D + G
DGLF
 E + F − D − G > _ D − G _ < E + F
 
$FHVWXOWLPUH]XOWDWVHSRDWHVFULHúLVXEIRUPD
− D − G < E − F < D + G

− E − F < D − G < E + F

FHHDFHUHYLQHODLQHJDOLW LOHVLPXOWDQH
D < E + F + G
E < D + F + G


F < D + E + G

G < D + E + F
$FHVWHD VXQW FRQGL LLOH F XWDWH SDWUX QXPHUH UHDOH SR]LWLYH SRW IL OXQ
JLPLOHODWXULORUXQXLSDWUXODWHULQVFULSWLELOGDF RULFDUHGLQWUHHOHHVWHPDL
PLFGHFkWVXPDFHORUODOWH
2 GDW VDWLVI FXWH DFHVWH FHULQ H SDWUXODWHUXO UHVSHFWLY HVWH XQLF GHWHU
PLQDWGHRDUHFHFRQIRUPUH]XOWDWXOXLXQJKLXULOHVDOHVXQWXQLFGHWHUPLQDWH
FXDMXWRUXOFHORUSDWUXQXPHUH

2%6(59$ ,,
6HGHPRQVWUHD] YH]LGHSLOG >@F DULDDFHVWXLSDWUXODWHUHVWHHJDO FX
6 = S − D S − E S − F S − G
S VHPLSHULPHWUXOSDWUXODWHUXOXLLDUUD]DFHUFXOXLFLUFXPVFULVDUHOXQJLPHD
DE + FG DF + EG DG + EF
5=
6
LQkQGVHDPDGHGHGXFHPF
$ S − DS − G $ S − FS − G
VLQ = FRV =
DG + EF DG + EF
úLDSRL
6
VLQ $ =
DG + EF
ÌQWUHEDUHD ÌQFHFRQGL LXQLQXPHUHOHDEFGSRWILOXQJLPLOHODWXULORU
XQXLSDWUXODWHUFLUFXPVFULSWLELO"$FHVWDHVWHXQLFGHWHUPLQDW"
3UHFXPvQFD]XOSULPHLvQWUHE ULSUHVXSXQHPSUREOHPDUH]ROYDW ILJ
&RQVLGHUkQGFDvQILJXU SXQFWHOHGHWDQJHQ FXFHUFXODOHODWXULORUSDWUXODWH
UXOXLQRW P
[ $0 $4\ %0 %1 $ D 0
%
] &1 &3W '3 '4
$WXQFLD [\E \]F ]W G
G W[GHXQGHUH]XOW F
DF EG 4 1
$FHDVWD HVWH FRQGL LD QHFHVDU FD QXPHUHOH ,
DEFGV ILHOXQJLPLOHODWXULORUXQXLSDWUXODWHU E
FLUFXPVFULSWLELO(DHVWHúLVXILFLHQW FHHDFHVH
GHPRQVWUHD] SULQ UHGXFHUH OD DEVXUG &RQGL LD ' F &
3
VWDELOLW QH DUDW F SDWUXODWHUXO QX HVWH XQLF
GHWHUPLQDWSULQFHOHSDWUXQXPHUH )LJ
2%6(59$ ,,
ÌQPRGHYLGHQWDYHP
S DF EG
&HQWUXO,DOFHUFXOXLvQVFULVvQSDWUXODWHUXO$%&'ILLQGSXQFWXOGHFRQ
FXUHQ DOELVHFWRDUHORUXQJKLXULORUSDWUXODWHUXOXLDYHP
U ,0 ,1 ,3 ,4
$WXQFL DULD 6 D SDWUXODWHUXOXL ILLQG HJDO FX VXPD DULLORU WULXQJKLXULORU $,%
%,&&,'',$UH]XOW F HVWHDGHY UDW HJDOLWDWHD
6 SU

'DF QXPHUHOHDEFGVDWLVIDFFHULQ HOHFDSDWUXODWHUXOV ILHVLPXOWDQ
LQVFULSWLELO úL FLUFXPVFULSWLELO DWXQFL FRQIRUP FHORU VWDELOLWH HO HVWH XQLF GH
WHUPLQDW LQkQGVHDPDGHúLGHDULDDFHVWXLSDWUXODWHUHVWH
6 = DEFG
5HOD LD OXL 'XUUDQGH GHPRQVWUD LH 9RP IRORVL UH]XOWDWHOH PHQ LRQDWH
DQWHULRUSUHFXP úLSXWHUHDSXQFWXOXLID GHFHUFÌQDFHVW VFRS UHDPLQWLPF
GDF VHG XQFHUF&25LDU0HVWHXQSXQFWVLWXDWODGLVWDQ DGID GHFHQ
WUXO2DWXQFLSXWHUHDSXQFWXOXL0ID GHFHUFXO&HVWHQXP UXO
ρ0 G±5
'DF RGUHDSW YDULDELO SULP0LQWHUVHFWHD] FHUFXOvQ$úL%DWXQFLHVWH
DGHY UDW HJDOLWDWHD $
|ρ0| 0$⋅0%
ÌQDLQWHGHDGDGHPRQVWUD LDSXQHPvQHYLGHQ úL
XQDOWUH]XOWDWSUHOLPLQDU
)LHWULXQJKLXO$%&úL$
SXQFWXOvQFDUHELVHFWRD
UHDLQWHULRDU DXQJKLXOXL$LQWHUVHFWHD] GLQQRXFHU
FXOFLUFXPVFULVWULXQJKLXOXLILJ
% &
$SOLFkQG vQ SDWUXODWHUXO $%$
& WHRUHPD OXL
3WROHPHXDYHP$$
⋅%& $%⋅$
&$&⋅$
%
$

$
úLFXP%& 5VLQ$$
% $
& 5VLQ UH]XOW
)LJ
$% + $&
$$
%
$ (
FRV D
$ E
3HQWUX D GHPRQVWUD UHOD LD OXL 'XUUDQGH U
&
SUHVXSXQHP F SDWUXODWHUXO $%&' HVWH vQ
,
VFULVvQFHUFXO25úLFLUFXPVFULVFHUFXOXL
, U 'DF ELVHFWRDUHD $, LQWHUVHFWHD] D [
GRXD RDU FHUFXO FLUFXPVFULV vQ $
ILJ G 2 $
DWXQFLLQWURGXFkQGSXWHUHDSXQFWXOXL,ID GH F

DFHVWDDYHP
,$⋅,$
|ρ,| |2,±5| 5±2,
GHFL
'
2, 5±,$⋅,$

)LJ
'LQWULXQJKLXO$,%DYHP
$ %
$% $((% U  FWJ + FWJ 

 

$QDORJ
$ '
$' = U  FWJ + FWJ 

 
úLDWXQFLFRQIRUPYRPRE LQH
U $ % '
$$
=  FWJ + FWJ + FWJ 

$ 
FRV

%+ ' 
VLQ
  
U  $ =
 U  $ 
VDX $$ =

 FWJ +  FWJ + 
$ % ' $ % '
FRV  VLQ VLQ  FRV  VLQ VLQ 
   
 
 
GHFL $$
= U  
 VLQ $ FRV $ VLQ % VLQ ' 
+

 

3HGHDOW SDUWHGLQWULXQJKLXO$,(DYHP
U
$, =
$
VLQ

U
UH]XOW F ,$
= $$
− $, =
$ % '
FRV VLQ VLQ

U
3ULQXUPDUH ,$ ⋅ ,$
=
% '
VLQ $ ⋅ VLQ ⋅ VLQ

'DU LQkQGVHDP GHUH]XOWDWHOHúLRE LQHP
% ' 6
VLQ $ ⋅ VLQ ⋅ VLQ =
(DG + EF )(DE + FG )
U (DG + EF )(DE + FG )
GHFL,$ ⋅ ,$
=
6
VDXDYkQGvQYHGHUH
N
,$ ⋅ ,$
=
S
XQGHN DGEFDEFG
'DU N = D EG + DFG + DE F + EF G = EG D + F + DF E + G
( ) ( )

úLFXPGLQDYHP
D + F = S − DF E + G = S − EG
XOWLPDHJDOLWDWHGHYLQH
N = S (DF + EG )− DEFG
1RWkQG[ DFEGúL LQkQGVHDPDGHúLUH]XOW
N = S [ − 6 = S [ − U
( )
LDUGHYLQH
[
,$ ⋅ ,$
= − U

3HGHDOW SDUWHGLQDYHP
5 6 = N[ = S [ − U [
( )
FHHDFHFRQIRUPQHG HFXD LD
[ − U [ − 5 U =
DF UHLVLQJXU U G FLQ FRQYHQDELO HVWH
( )
[ = U + U U + 5
$WXQFLGHYLQH
,$ ⋅ ,$
= U 5 + U − U
UH]XOWDWXOFDUHvQORFXLWvQQHG UHOD LDOXL'XUUDQGH

%LEOLRJUDILH
>@ 'U JKLFHVFX ,& $VXSUD XQRU SUREOHPH SULYLQG SDWUXODWHUXO
LQVFULSWLELO*0
>@ 0LKDOFD'&KL HVFX,&KLUL 0*HRPHWULDSDWUXODWHUXOXLWHR
UHPHúLSUREOHPH7HRUD%XFXUHúWL

ì,585,)$5(<
FRQIGU9,&725$ /(;$1'588QLY%XFXUHúWL
SURI1,&8/$,(0$5,1*2ù21,8ùF1U%XFXUHúWL

'HILQL LH 'DF Q HVWH QXP U QDWXUDO QHQXO DWXQFL SULQ úLU )DUH\ GH
RUGLQQVHvQ HOHJHúLUXOPXO LPHD)QDWXWXURUIUDF LLORURUGL
QDUH VXEXQLWDUH LUHGXFWLELOH FX QXPLWRUXO FHO PXOW HJDO FX Q
VFULVHvQRUGLQHFUHVF WRDUH

$VWIHOúLUXULOH)DUH\SHQWUXQ VXQW
     
) =   ) =   ) =  
     
   
) =   ) =  
   
7HRUHP K O
)LH úL GRX IUDF LLLUHGXFWLELOHFRQVHFXWLYHGLQ)Q
)DUH\&DXFK\ N P
$WXQFLNO±KP
'(021675$ ,(
¦3ULQLQGXF LHGXS Q ≥&D]XULOH ≤Q ≤YHULILF GLUHFW)LHDFXP
D K O
∉ )Q FX D E ([LVW DWXQFL úL FRQVHFXWLYH vQ )Q DVWIHO vQFkW
E N P
K D O
< < 6 REVHUY P F VLVWHPXO GH HFXD LL OLQLDUH vQ λ úL µ
N E P
µK + λO = D
DUHVROX LLvQWUHJLGHRDUHFHKP±KO ±FRQIRUPLSRWH]HLGHLQ
µN + λP = E

K D O
GXF LHúLDQXPH λ DN±EK!úL µ EO±DP!GHRDUHFH < < 5H
N E P
K D µK + λO O
FLSURFSHQWUXRULFH λ µ ∈1 λ + µ > DYHP ≤ = ≤ GHRDUH
N E µN + λP P
FH K (µO + λP ) ≤ N (µK + λO ) úLµKλOP≤µNλPOÌQDGHY U
K (µN + λP )− N(µK + λO ) = λ (KP − NO) = −λ ≤
úL (µK + λO )P − (µN + λP )O = µ(KP − NO) = −µ ≤
6HPDLREVHUY F λúL µVXQWUHODWLYSULPHGDF úLQXPDLGDF DúLEVXQW
UHODWLYSULPH

D µK K
3HQWUXλ VHRE LQH = = FDUHHVWHUHGXV GRDUSHQWUXµ
E µN N
D
6HRE LQHD KúLE NFHHDFHFRQWUDYLQHvQV IDSWXOXLF ∉ )Q $VWIHOVD
E
D K D O 
DU WDW F PXO LPHD  (D E ) = úL < <  FRLQFLGH FX PXO LPHD
 E N E P 
 µK + λO
λ µ ≥ (λ µ ) =  &HDPDLPLF YDORDUHSHQWUXEHVWHNPFDUHVH

 µN + λP


D
RE LQH SHQWUX λ µ 3ULQ XUPDUH SHQWUX D DYHD ∈ )Q + − )Q WUHEXLH FD
E
D K+O K+O
Q NP ELDUD KOGHXQGH = QXPLP PHGLDQ
E N+P N+P
K O
WDIUDF LLORU úL
N P
K K+O O
5H]XOW F < < VXQW FRQVHFXWLYH vQ )Q (VWH XúRU GH SUREDW
N N+P P
DFXP FRQGL LD GLQ FRQFOX]LD WHRUHPHL K ON ± N PK ON P ±
K O
±PKO'HRDUHFHvQFD]XOFkQG úL VXQWFRQVHFXWLYHFKLDUvQ)QFRQ
N P
FOX]LDHVWHHYLGHQW UH]XOW F GHPRQVWUD LDWHRUHPHLVHSRDWHIDFHSULQLQGXF LH
GXS Q≥
,QWHUSUHWDUH JHRPHWULF 2 IUXPRDV LQWHUSUHWDUH JHRPHWULF D úLUXULORU
)DUH\VHDIO vQ>@SDJúLHVWHDWULEXLW OXL/HVWHU5)RUG
6 FRQVLGHU PRD[ DQXPHUHORU2[3HQWUXRULFHQXP UUD LRQDOúLSXQFW
S
\ DOD[HL2[ GHVHQ PXQFHUFGHGL
T

DPHWUX WDQJHQWD[HL
T
D 'DF & &% U úL &
&%UVXQWFHUFXULOHFRUHVSXQ]
D F
WRDUH QXPHUHORU úL DWXQFL HOH
2 E G
D D+F F [ VXQWWDQJHQWHGDF úLQXPDLGDF vQ

E E+G G WUHJLLDGúLEFVXQWFRQVHFXWLYL$VWIHO
D F
)LJ GDF úL VXQW WHUPHQL FRQVHFX
E G

WLYL vQWUXQ úLU )DUH\ )Q DWXQFL \
FHUFXULOHGHILQLWHPDLVXVVXQWWDQ
JHQWHH[WHULRU
ÌQWUDGHY U GRX FHUFXUL &
&%UúL& &%UVXQWWDQ %
JHQWH GDF úL QXPDL GDF DUH ORF &
$
UHOD LD%& UUÌQFD]XOQRVWUX
SHGHRSDUWHDYHP 2
D  F  D  D F [
%  &  $ 
 E E   G G   E G  E G
)LJ
  F D
$% = ⋅  −  $& = −
E G  G E
úLFRQIRUPWHRUHPHLOXL3LWDJRUD
F D  

%& =  −  +  − 
 G E   G E 
LDUSHGHDOW SDUWHFRQIRUPGHILQLULLFHUFXULORU

U + U = +
E G
5HOD LD%& UUHVWHHFKLYDOHQW FXDG±EF
2 GHPRQVWUD LH FRPSOHW QHFHVLW DQDOL]DUHD WXWXURU FD]XULORU SRVLELOH vQ
FDUH VH SRW VLWXD FHL SDWUX vQWUHJL )LJXUD FRUHVSXQGH SUHVXSXQHULL E G úL
D F
<
E G
D F
E 'DF GRX FHUFXUL FRUHVSXQ]kQG IUDF LLORU úL VXQW WDQJHQWH
E G
D+F D F
DWXQFLFHUFXOFRUHVSXQ] WRUQXP UXOXL PHGLDQWDIUDF LLORU úL YD
E+G E G
ILWDQJHQWSULPHORUGRX FHUFXULYH]LILJXUD
ÌQWUDGHY UGLQUHOD LDEF±DG UH]XOW DWkWEGF±DFG FkWúL
DFF±EGG GHFLFRQIRUPREVHUYD LHLDQWHULRDUHFHUFXOPHGLDQWHVWH
WDQJHQWFHORUODOWHGRX
2%6(59$ ,,
D'LQGHPRQVWUD LHUH]XOW F IUDF LLOHGLQ)Q±)QVXQWPHGLDQWHOHIUDF
LLORUFRQVHFXWLYHGLQ)Q
K O
E'DF úL VXQWFRQVHFXWLYHvQ)QDWXQFLNP≥Q
N P

D F D F
F )LH úL WHUPHQL FRQVHFXWLYL vQ )Q LDU γ ∈   'DF
E G E G
D D+F
DWXQFLDYHP
E E+G
<γ<
D D+F D
< γ− <
E E + G E E(E + G ) E(Q + )
− = ≤
D+F F
LDUGDF < γ < DWXQFL
E+G G
F F D+F
< −γ< −
G G E + G G (E + G ) E(Q + )
= ≤
6HRE LQHDVWIHOXUP WRUXO

O
&RURODU 'DF HVWHRIUDF LHLUHGXFWLELO FXP!QDWXQFLH[LVW
P
K
FXN≤QDVWIHOvQFkW O − K ≤ HJDOLWDWHDDYkQGORF
N P N (Q + )N
SHQWUXQ P

K
&RURODU 'DF γ ∈5?4úLQ ∈1 DWXQFLH[LVW FXN ≤QDVWIHOvQ
N
FkW − K <
N N
&DDSOLFD LHSUH]HQW PXUP WRDUHD

7HRUHP 'DF Q≥$∈=LDUQ_$DWXQFLH[LVW VW∈1DVWIHO
vQFkWQ VW
'(021675$ ,( 6 QRW P 1 = Q < Q &RQIRUP FRURODUXOXL H[LVW R
[ ]
U
IUDF LH DVWIHOvQFkW $ − U <
LDUV15H]XOW F
V Q V (1 + )V
Q Q
$V − QU < Q
1 + [ Q ]+ <
=
1RWkQGW $V±UQDYHP
W + V = ($V − UQ ) + V = V $ + − $VUQ + U Q

( )
GHXQGHQGLYLGH W + V 3HGHDOW SDUWH

< W + V < ( Q ) + ( Q ) = Q

DVWIHOvQFkW Q = V + W
'HUHPDUFDWF VúLWVXQWUHODWLYSULPHDFHDVWDUH]XOWkQGGLQUHOD LD
$ +
= V − $VU + U Q
Q
2DOW DSOLFD LHHVWHGDW GHXUP WRDUHD
K
7HRUHP 'DF γ ∈5?4DWXQFLH[LVW RLQILQLWDWHGHQXPHUH ∈ 4
N
K
DVWIHOvQFkW − <
N N
'(021675$ ,(6 REVHUY PPDLvQWkLF HVWHVXILFLHQWV FRQVLGHU PFD
]XOFkQG γ ∈ÌQDGHY URULFH γ ∈5VHSRDWHUHSUH]HQWDXQLFVXEIRUPD
γ = [γ ]+ γ ′ XQGH >γ@ ∈ = HVWH SDUWHD vQWUHDJ D OXL γ >γ@ ≤ γ >γ@ LDU
K
γ
∈ HVWH SDUWHD IUDF LRQDU D OXL γ 'DF γ ′ − < DWXQFL
N N
K + [γ ] K
= γ − [γ ]− < DVWIHO vQFkW HVWH VXILFLHQW V SURE P FRQFOX]LD
N N N
γ−
SHQWUXQXP UXOγ

D F D F
)LHQ!úLV SUHVXSXQHPF vQ)QDYHP < γ < LDU VXQWFRQVH
E G E G
FXWLYH
7HRUHPDYDILGHPRQVWUDW GDF DU W PF DUHORFXQDGLQLQHJDOLW LOH
D F
γ − < VDX − γ <
E E G G
D F
ÌQWUDGHY U SUHVXSXQkQG FRQWUDULXO DP DYHD γ − ≥ úL − γ ≥
E E G G
F D E +G
F D
GHXQGHRE LQHP − ≥ 'HRDUHFH − = UH]XOW
G E E G
G E EG
E + G (E − G )

≥ GHXQGHE G$FHDVWD QXHSRVLELOSHQWUXQ ≥
E G EG E G
− =
DG±EF ±DULPSOLFDE G

)LH DFXP ε > úL Q ∈ 1 DVWIHO FD Q > 'HRDUHFH GLIHUHQ D GLQWUH GRL
ε

WHUPHQLFRQVHFXWLYLGLQ)QHVWHPDL PLF VDXHJDO FX < ε GLQFHOHGHPDL
Q

K K K
VXVUH]XOW F J VLP ∈4DVWIHOvQFkW γ − < ε úL γ − < &RQVLGH
N N N N
UkQGXQúLU (ε P )P FX ε P > úL ε P → HFODUF VHSXQvQHYLGHQ RLQILQLWD
WHGHQXPHUHUD LRQDOHFH VDWLVIDFFRQGL LDGLQHQXQ 2vPEXQ W LUHDDFHVWXL
UH]XOWDWHVWHGDW GHXUP WRDUHD
7HRUHP D 'DF γ ∈ 5?4 LDU F ≤ XQQXP U UHDO SR]LWLY DWXQFL
K
+XUZLW]
K
H[LVW LQILQLWDWHGHQXPHUH ∈4DVWIHOvQFkW − <
N N FN
E'DF vQV F > DWXQFLH[LVW QXPHUHLUD LRQDOHγSHQ
K
WUX FDUH LQHJDOLWDWHD − < DUH ORF GRDU SHQWUX XQ QX
N FN
K
P UILQLWGHQXPHUH ∈4
N
'(021675$ ,( +LQFLQ &D úL vQ FD]XO WHRUHPHL DQWHULRDUH
REVHUY P F HVWH VXILFLHQW V SURE P FRQFOX]LD SHQWUX γ ∈ 6 SUHVXSX
K K′
QHP F úL VXQW WHUPHQL )DUH\ FRQVHFXWLYL GLQ )Q Q ! DVWIHO vQFkW
N N′
K K′ + N
( ) ( − N
)
< γ < 3XWHPSUHVXSXQHF ILH N ′ > ILH N ′ < QXSX
N N′
WHPDYHDHJDOLWDWHSHQWUXF ∉ 4
ÌQWUDGHY UGDF
( − )N < N ′ < ( + )N DWXQFL

+
N + N
> ⋅ PD[ N N

( )

K K′
úLSXWHPvQORFXL)QFX)PXQGHP NN
LDUXQXOGLQQXPHUHOH FXPH
N N′
K + K′
GLDQWDORU GHRDUHFHFRQIRUPWHRUHPHL
N + N′
N (K + K ′)− K(N + N ′) = (N + N ′)K ′ − (K + K ′)N ′ =
N′ + −
$VWIHOGDF ω = DWXQFL ω > VDX ω < ÌQDPEHOHVLWXD
N
LLDYHP
+ ω− > ⋅ ω −

   +  − 
GDWILLQGF +  − =  ω−  ω −  >
 ω  ω ⋅ω 

  
3ULQXUPDUH
   
 +  >
N N  ⋅ N  ω  ωN
 +
 =
DVWIHOvQFkW
K   K
 K
K  
 +


N   N
 N
N NN
N ω N N 
γ −  +  − γ = − = = <

 
 +

N ω N N 

<
K K

úLGHFLDYHP γ − < VDX − γ < GHXQGH
N ⋅N
N
⋅ N
K K

N ⋅N N
⋅ N

+
> −
5H]XOW F XQXOGLQLQWHUYDOHOHGHVFKLVH
K K   K
K

 + VDX 
N N N ⋅ N
N


−
⋅N 

 
YDFRQ LQHSXQFWXOγ
ÌQFRQWLQXDUHVHIRORVHúWHDFHODúLDUJXPHQWFDvQILQDOXOWHRUHPHL
+
E)LH F > úLV FRQVLGHU PQXP UXOLUD LRQDO γ = $FHVWDHVWH

FXQRVFXWVXEQXPHOHGHQXP UXOGHDXUúLVHQRWHD] GHRELFHLFXϕ9RPDU WD
K
F SHQWUXDFHVWQXP UH[LVW GRDUXQQXP UILQLWGHIUDF LL VDWLVI FkQGLQHJD
N
OLWDWHD
K
ϕ− <
N FN

)LH F = XQGHα3UHVXSXQHPF
α
K +

N ⋅ N
− <
$FHDVW LQHJDOLWDWHRSXWHPVFULHVXEIRUPDXQHLHJDOLW L

K +

N ⋅ N
− =
XQGH < α 'HDLFLRE LQHPF

N ⋅N
K−
⋅N
= +
VDXGXS ULGLFDUHDODS WUDWvQDPELLPHPEUL

K − KN − N = +
N
&XPKúLNVXQWQXPHUHQDWXUDOHH[SUHVLDK±KN±NQXVHSRDWHDQXODH[FHS
WkQG FD]XO K N 'DU N ≠ úL SULQ XUPDUH K − KN − N ≥ &XP
|θ|αDYHP

α
≤ +
N N N
≤ + < α +
α
VDX N <
( − α )
K
$VWIHOQXPLWRUXOIUDF LHL VDWLVI FkQGLQHJDOLWDWHDWUHEXLHV VDWLVID
N
F úLLQHJDOLWDWHD'DUαHVWHIL[DWúLGHFLNQXSRDWHOXDGHFkWXQQXP UILQLW
GH YDORUL 'LQ UH]XOW F úL K SRDWH OXD GRDU XQQXP U ILQLW GH YDORUL 3ULQ
XUPDUHGDF F > DWXQFLLQHJDOLWDWHDHVWHDGHY UDW GRDUSHQWUXXQQX
K
P UILQLWGHIUDF LL &XDFHDVWDWHRUHPDHVWHGHPRQVWUDW
N
ÌQ FRQWLQXDUH YRP IRORVL WHRUHPD SHQWUX D SURED XQ IDSW GHVFRSHULW GH
)HUPDWQXPHUHOHSULPHGHIRUPDNVHSRWUHSUH]HQWDFDVXP
GHGRX S WUDWHGHQXPHUHvQWUHJL5HDPLQWLPF SULQD ≡EPRGSVHQRWHD]
UHOD LD³SGLYLGHD±E´
7HRUHP 'DF SHVWHQXP USULPDWXQFLDYHP
:LOVRQ

(S − ) + ≡ PRG S
'(021675$ ,('DF S DWXQFLDYHP ≡PRG'DF S
DWXQFLDYHP ≡PRGGHFLWHRUHPDHVWHDGHY UDW vQDFHVWH
FD]XUL
6 SUHVXSXQHPDFXPF S≥,GHHDGHPRQVWUD LHLFRQVW vQDJUXSDIDFWRULL
GLQS±vQSHUHFKLDOF URUSURGXVV ILHFRQJUXHQWFXPRGXORS

3HQWUXRULFHL ∈^«S±`DYHPLS úLDSOLFkQGDOJRULWPXOOXL
(XFOLG v+U J VLP XQ XQLF L
∈ ^«S ± ` DVWIHO FD L⋅L
≡
≡PRGSÌQWUDGHY ULúLSILLQGUHODWLYSULPHH[LVW L
úLTvQWUHJLDVWIHOvQFkW
L⋅L
S⋅T )DSWXOF L
SRDWHILDOHVvQL
∈^«S±`úLF HVWHXQLFGH
WHUPLQDW GH DFHDVW SURSULHWDWH DG XJDW OD FRQGL LD L⋅L
≡ PRG S vO O V P
VSUHYHULILFDUHFLWLWRUXOXL
(XúRUGHREVHUYDWF DYHPL L
GDF úLQXPDLGDF L ≡PRGSDGLF
GDF L VDXL S±5H]XOW F vQSURGXVXO⋅⋅«⋅S±IDFWRULLSRWILJUX
SD LvQSHUHFKLDVWIHOvQFkWSURGXVXOFRPSRQHQWHORUXQHLSHUHFKLV ILHFRQJUXHQW
FXPRGXORSGHDLFLGHFXUJkQG⋅⋅«⋅S±≡PRGSúLvQILQDO
⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ (S − )⋅ (S − ) ≡ S − ≡ −(PRG S )
úLDVWIHOWHRUHPDHVWHGHPRQVWUDW
&RURODU )LHSXQQXP USULP$WXQFLFRQJUXHQ D[ ≡PRGS
DUHVROX LLGDF úLQXPDLGDF S VDXGDF S≡PRG
'(021675$ ,('DF S DYHPVROX LD[
)LHSXQQXP USULPLPSDU&RQIRUPWHRUHPHLOXL:LOVRQDYHPS±
≡PRGS'DUSXWHPVFULH
(S −)= ⋅ ⋅⋅ S − ⋅  S + ⋅⋅ (S − M)⋅⋅ (S − )(S −)

  
6 REVHUY PF JUXSkQGIDFWRUXO³M´GLQSULPDSDUDQWH] FXIDFWRUXO³S±M´GLQ
S −
FHDGHDGRXDSDUDQWH] SXWHPVFULHS − ∏ MS − M ÌQV DYHPMS−M≡
M=
≡−M PRGSGHFL

S− S−
 S− 
S−  
∏ MS − M = ∏(− M) (PRGS) = (− )
M= M=

⋅  M (PRG S)
∏
 M= 
 
S −
$VWIHO GDF S ≡ PRG DWXQFL (− ) = úL FRQJUXHQ D [ + ≡ (PRG S )
S −

DUHFDVROX LHSH [ = ∏ M
M=
'DF SHVWHSULPS≠úLS ≡/ PRGDWXQFLS≡PRG)LHGHFLSDVW

IHO vQFkW S ≡ PRG 6 SUHVXSXQHP F SHQWUX XQ vQWUHJ [ DYHP [ ≡
S −
≡±PRGS$WXQFLGDWILLQGF HVWHLPSDU

S − S −
[ S − = [ ≡ (− ) ≡ −(PRG S )
( )
3HGHDOW SDUWHFXP S /_ [ FRQIRUPPLFLLWHRUHPHDOXL)HUPDWYH]L>@SDJ
DYHP [ S − ≡ (PRG S )$FHDVW FRQWUDGLF LHDUDW F vQDFHVWFD]FRQ
JUXHQ D [ ≡ (PRG S )QXDUHVROX LL

127(,6725,&(

-2+1)$5(<
)DUH\ D IRVW XQ JHRORJ FDUH vQ D WULPLV OD UHYLVWD
3KLORVRSKLFDO 0DJD]LQH XQ DUWLFRO GH SDUDJUDIH LQWLWXODW 2Q D FXULRXV
SURSHUW\RIYXOJDUIUDFWLRQV$VXSUDXQHLSURSULHW LDIUDF LLORURUGLQDUH
ÌQSULPXOSDUDJUDI)DUH\VSXQHF H[DPLQkQGWDEHOHOHGHIUDF LL]HFLPDOHD
REVHUYDW³RSURSULHWDWHFXULRDV ´
ÌQDOGRLOHDSDUDJUDIHOGHILQHúWHFHHDFHD]LQXPLP³úLU)DUH\´úLHQXQ
DFHD³SURSULHWDWHFXULRDV ´
8Q³úLU)DUH\´VHFYHQ )DUH\VHGHILQHúWHDVWIHOSHQWUXXQQXP UQDWX
UDOQIL[DWFRQVLGHU PWRDWHQXPHUHOHUD LRQDOHGLQWUHúLH[SULPDWHFDIUDF LL
LUHGXFWLELOHFXQXPLWRUXOFHOPXOWHJDOFXQvQRUGLQHFUHVF WRDUH$WXQFL³SUR
SULHWDWHDFXULRDV ´HVWHDFHHDF ILHFDUHWHUPHQWGLQúLUVHFYHQ HVWHHJDOFX
IUDF LDFHDUHFDQXP U WRUVXPDQXP U WRULORULDUFDQXPLWRUVXPDQXPLWRULORU
FHORUGRLWHUPHQLFHvQFDGUHD] SHW
ÌQSDUDJUDIXOWUHLGLQDUWLFROXOOXL)DUH\HVWHGDWXQH[HPSOX(OFRQVLGHU
Q $WXQFLVHULD)DUH\FRUHVSXQ] WRDUHHVWH
 
) =  
 
+
)DUH\LOXVWUHD] ³SURSULHWDWHDFXULRDV ´FXH[HPSOXO =
+
ÌQSDUDJUDIXOILQDO)DUH\VSXQHF QXúWLHGDF DFHVWHIDSWHDXPDLIRVWWLS
ULWHGHIDSWIXVHVHWLS ULWFHYDSULQUHFXQRDúWHF QXGH LQHGHPRQVWUD LD
SHQWUXFD]XOJHQHUDOúLDúWHDSW RSLQLDYUHXQXLFLWLWRUPDWHPDWLFLDQ«
8QXOGLQWUHFLWLWRULDIRVW&DXFK\FDUHDGHPRQVWUDWSURSULHWD
WHDFXULRDV WHRUHPDSUH]HQWXODUWLFROvQDOV X([HUFLVHVGHPDWKpPDWLTXH
GLQDFHODúLDQ

180 58/'($85
3ULQW LHWXUDGHDXUVHF LXQHDGHDXUVHvQ HOHJHvPS U LUHDXQXLVHJPHQW
DDVWIHOFDSDUWHDPDLPDUHEV ILHPHGLHSURSRU LRQDO vQWUHvQWUHJVHJPHQWXOD
úLSDUWHDPDLPLF D±EDGLF DVWIHOvQFkWV DYHPSURSRU LD
D E

E D−E
=
'HDLFLVHRE LQHUHOD LD D − DE − E =

D D

VDX   − − =
E E
D
1RWkQG = [ VHRE LQHHFXD LD
E
[ − [ − =
+
GLQFDUHUH]XOW [ =

5HOD LDVHPDLSRDWHVFULHúLDVWIHO
[ +
[= [ = + VDX [ = +
[ [
+

+

+
+
'HFL[VHSRDWHRE LQHVXEIRUPDXQHLIUDF LLFRQWLQXHYH]L>@FDS,VDX

>@SDJDOHF UHLUHGXVHVXQW úDPGXQGH

«VXQWQXPHUHOHOXL)LERQDFFLGHILQLWHSULQ[
[ «[Q [ Q+ + [ Q Q∈1YH]LúL>@SDJúL>@SDJ
*HRPHWULFW LHWXUDGHDXUDXQXLVHJPHQW$%VHRE LQHDVWIHOSHSHUSHQ
GLFXODUDvQ%SH$%VHLDSXQFWXO(DVWIHO (
$%
vQFkW %( = 3H$(VHLD'DVWIHOvQFkW
'
(' (% DSRL VH LD & SH $% DVWIHO vQFkW
$& $'
$% $& $ %
$WXQFLYRPDYHD &
$& %&
=
7HUPHQXOGHVHF LXQHGHDXUDIRVWLQWURGXVGH/HRQDUGRGD9LQFL
3ULQFLSLLOHVHF LXQLLGHDXUVDXDOHSURSRU LLORUDSURSLDWHHLDXVWDWODED]D
UHDOL] ULLPXOWRURSHUHDOHDUWHLXQLYHUVDOHvQVSHFLDORSHUHOHDUKLWHFWXULLDQWLFKL

W LL úL 5HQDúWHULL GH H[HPSOX &DSHOD 3D]]L GLQ )ORUHQ D GH DUKLWHFWXO
%UXQHOOHVFKL
7 LHWXUDGHDXUDSDUHSHQWUXSULPDGDW vQFDUWHDD,,DGLQ(OHPHQWHOHOXL
(XFOLG XQGH VH G FRQVWUXF LD JHRPHWULF HFKLYDOHQW UH]ROY ULL HFXD LHL GH
JUDGXODOGRLOHDGHIRUPD
[ (D + [ ) = D
(XFOLGDSOLF VHF LXQHDGHDXUSHQWUXFRQVWUXF LDSROLJRDQHORUUHJXODWHFX
úLODWXULF U LOH,9úL;,9SUHFXPúLvQJHRPHWULDvQVSD LXSHQWUXFRQVWUXL
UHDSROLHGUHORUUHJXODWHFXúLGHODWXUL
1XH[LVW vQGRLDO F VHF LXQHDGHDXUDIRVWFXQRVFXW úLvQDLQWHDOXL(X
FOLG
ÌQ(XURSD(YXOXL0HGLXVHF LXQHDGHDXUDIRVWFXQRVFXW GLQWUDGXFHULOH
DUDEHDOH(OHPHQWHORUOXL(XFOLG
7UDGXF WRUXO úL FRPHQWDWRUXO OXL (XFOLG - &DPSDQR GLQ 1RYDUD VHF DO
;,,,OHDDDG XJDWODFDUWHD;,,,GLQ(OHPHQWHRSURSR]L LHFRQ LQkQGGHPRQ
VWUDUHD DULWPHWLF D LQFRPHQVXUDELOLW LL VHJPHQWXOXL úL D FHORU GRX S U L FH
FRQVWLWXLHVHF LXQHDGHDXU
ÌQVHFROHOHDO;9OHDúLDO;9,OHDLQWHUHVXOID GHVHF LXQHDGHDXUDFUHV
FXWSULQWUHVDYDQ LúLDUWLúWLPDLDOHVGDWRULW DSOLFD LLORUDWkWvQJHRPHWULHFkWúL
vQDUW úLvQVSHFLDOvQDUKLWHFWXU
/XFD3DFLROLYH]L>@SDJDGHGLFDWVHF LXQLLGHDXUWUDWD
WXO 'HVSUH VHF LXQHD GLYLQ FDUH HVWH LOXVWUDW FX GHVHQHOH SULHWHQXOXL
V X/RQDUGRGD9LQFLGHVSUHVHF LXQHDGHDXUDVFULVvQWUROXFUDUHODvQFHSXWXO
DFWLYLW LLVDOHúL.HSOHU

%LEOLRJUDILH
>@ &KDQGUDVHFNNKDUDQ.,QWURGXFHUHvQWHRULDDQDOLWLF DQXPHUH
ORU 6SULQJHU 9HUODJ WUDG OE UXV (G 0LU 0RVFRYD

>@ 0DWLOD&*K\ND)LORVRILDúLPLVWLFDQXP UXOXL(GLWXUD8QLYHUV
HQFLFORSHGLF%XFXUHúWL
>@ 6XGDQ *DEULHO ± *HRPHWUL]DUHD IUDF LLORU FRQWLQXH (GLWXUD
7HKQLF
>@ & &KLWHú * &RQVWDQWLQHVFX 5 ,OLH úD 0DWHPDWLFD 0DQXDO
SHQWUXFODVDD;D(GLWXUD6LJPD
>@ 6WHUH ,DQXú 0DUFHO HQD 0DULQ 1LFRODH 0DWHPDWLFD PDQXDO
SHQWUXFODVDD;D(GLWXUD&RULQW

>@ &1 VW VHVFX&1L 0'XPLWUHVFX16RDUH'1L HVFX'
53RSHVFX0DWHPDWLFDPDQXDOSHQWUXFODVDD;D(GLWXUD'L
GDFWLF úL3HGDJRJLF
>@ 9LFWRU $OH[DQGUX 1LFXODLH 0DULQ *RúRQLX (OHPHQWH GH WHRULD
QXPHUHORU,(GLWXUD8QLYHUVLW LL%XFXUHúWL
>@ - + &RQZD\ 5 . *X\ 7KH %RRN RI 1XPEHUV 6SULQJHU
9HUODJ1<
&80$75$*(0,17(5(68/
(/(9,/253(1758
',6&,3/,1$0$7(0$7,&à
SURI$,'$35('$

ÌQWRWGHDXQD DX H[LVWDW úL YRU H[LVWD SURIHVRUL GH PDWHPDWLF FH VXQW FRQ
YLQúLF DSUHGDHVWHRDUW 6 QHJkQGLPGHH[HPSOXODPDWHPDWLFLDQXOSHGD
JRJ*HRUJH3yO\DFDUHvQOXFUDUHDVD³'HVFRSHULUHDvQPDWHPDWLF ´vQWUHSULQGH
XQVWXGLXDVXSUDSURFHGHHORUúLPHWRGHORUGHUH]ROYDUHDSUREOHPHORUGHPDWH
PDWLF
'HVLJXUvQFRQGL LLOHvQFDUHDYHPGHSDUFXUVRSURJUDP vQF VXILFLHQWGH
vQF UFDW SULPDJULM «HVWHSUHGDUHDvQWUHJLLPDWHULLLDUvQOLPLWDWLPSXOXLU
PDVQHPDLJkQGLPúLODPHWRGHOHIRORVLWHvQDFHVWVFRS1XWUHEXLHV XLW PvQ
V F UROXO SULPRUGLDO DO PDWHPDWLFLL vQ úFRDO HVWH V GH]YROWH JkQGLUHD
HOHYLORU$VWIHOVXQWSX LQHúDQVHFDXQHOHYFDUHQXHVWHUHFHSWLYODPDWHPDWLF
V HYROXH]HFDXQLQGLYLGFDSDELOGHDQDOL] úLVLQWH] ODQLYHOXOFHUXWGHVRFLH
WDWHDDFWXDO
1RL SURIHVRULL FXQRVFkQG DFHDVW UHDOLWDWH DYHP UHVSRQVDELOLWDWHD GH DL
FXFHULSHHOHYLSULQVWUDWHJLLELQHSXVHODSXQFW
&kWHYDGLQSXQFWHOHGHVSULMLQGHPQHGHDYXWvQYHGHUHVXQW
DVSHFWXOV OLLGHFODV vQWURVDO GHFODV SDYRD]DW OXPLQRDV FXUD
W GLVSR]L LDHOHYXOXLGHDJkQGLHRSWLP
FOLPDWXOLQVWDXUDWGHSURIHVRU±DSURSLDWGHVWLQV±HVWHLPSRUWDQWSHQ
WUXVWLPXODUHDFUHDWLYLW LLHOHYLORU
FRRSWDUHD HOHYLORU vQ FRQIHF LRQDUHD PDWHULDOXOXL GLGDFWLF XWLOL]DELO OD
RUHOHGHPDWHPDWLF SODQúHFRUSXULJHRPHWULFH
XWLOL]DUHD XQRU PHWRGH DFWLYH GH SUHGDUH vQY DUHD SULQ GHVFRSHULUH
F XWDUHDGHLSRWH]HHFKLYDOHQWHHWF6HVWLPXOHD] FUHDWLYLWDWHDHOHYL
ORUúLVHRIHU DFHVWRUDPRPHQWHGHVDWLVIDF LH

HOHYXOWUHEXLHV ILHFRQYLQVGHF WUHSURIHVRUF PDWHPDWLFDHVWHLQWH
UHVDQW SURIHVRUXO WUHEXLH V L RIHUH HOHYXOXL PRWLYD LH $FHDVWD VH
SRDWHUHDOL]DúLSULQHPR LRQDUHDFODVHLSULQOXFUXULVXUSULQ] WRDUH6
G PXQ H[HPSOX⋅ ± −
DSOLFD LHI FXW GXS SUH]HQWDUHDIRUPHORUGHFDOFXOSUHVFXUWDW$VWIHO
SURIHVRUXOWUHEXLHV GHDPXOW DWHQ LHDOHJHULLIRUPXO ULLúLSUH]HQW
ULLDGHFYDWHDSUREOHPHLSHFDUHRSURSXQH

(VWHGHFLXWLO
V VH ODVH HOHYXOXL OLEHUWDWHD GH D LQWXL FKLDU GDF QX H FDSDELO V GH
PRQVWUH]HvQvQWUHJLPHDGHY UXOLQWXLW
V VHSDUFXUJ ID]DGHH[SORUDUHúLID]DGHDVLPLODUH$PEHOHID]HXUP
UHVF V FRUHOH]H SUREOHPD vQ FDX] FX OXPHD vQFRQMXU WRDUH úL FX DOWH
FXQRúWLQ HSULPDvQDLQWHGHUH]ROYDUHDIRUPDO DGRXDGXS
FXUVXULOH RS LRQDOH OD QLYHOXO GLVFLSOLQHL PDWHPDWLFH SUHFXP úL RS LR
QDOHOH LQWHUGLVFLSOLQDUH $FHVWH RUH GH PDWHPDWLF GLVWUDFWLY FOV 9
9,GHDSOLFD LLOHHFXD LLORUvQúWLLQ HOHQDWXULLFOVD9,,DSUHFXPúL
DOWHSRVLELOLW LDWUDJHOHYLLGRYHGLQGXOHF PDWHPDWLFDQXHVWHRGLV
WUDF LHLQXWLO PDWHPDWLFDVHUYHúWHDPFLWDWGLQ*ULJRUH0RLVLO
GHSLVWDUHDHOHYLORUFXSRWHQ LDOFUHDWLYVXSHULRUFXDMXWRUXOWHVWHORUVSHFL
DOHVDXvQSURFHVXOGHvQY PkQWPDLDOHVGDF XWLOL] PPHWRGHDFWLYH
DFWLYLWDWHD vQ DIDU GH FODV SRDWH FXOWLYD LQWHUHVXO úL FUHDWLYLWDWHD vQ
VSHFLDOvQFDGUXOFHUFXULORUGHPDWHPDWLF
GDF GRULPHOHYLFUHDWLYLWUHEXLHV ILPSURIHVRULFUHDWLYL

'(635(75(,352%/(0(
&(/(%5(
7ULVHFêLDXQJKLXOXL
'XSOLFDUHDFXEXOXL
&YDGUDWXUDFHUFXOXL
SURI,/,(3(75(,$0%25

XUPDUHGLQQXP UXOSUHFHGHQW

$P Y ]XW GHMD FXP VH SRDWH RE LQH WULVHF LD XQJKLXOXL FX DMXWRUXO
WULVHFWRDUHL OXL /RQJFKDPSV ÌQ FRQWLQXDUH YRP SUH]HQWD XQ QRX SURFHGHX FX
DMXWRUXOWULVHFWRDUHLOXL0DF/DXULQÌQVLVWHPXOGHFRRUGRQDWH[2\VHFRQVLGHU
FHUFXOFXFHQWUXOvQ$GHUD] 2$ UWDQJHQWvQ2D[HL2\3HVHFDQWDPRELO
23VHFRQVLGHU SXQFWHOH0úL1DVWIHOvQFkW20 31XQGH1HVWHSXQFWXOGH
LQWHUVHF LHDOPHGLDWRDUHLVHJPHQWXOXL2$ UFXVHFDQWD23/RFXOJHRPHWULF
DOSXQFWXOXL0HVWHWULVHFWRDUHDGHILQLW GH&0DF/DXULQ(FXD LDFDUWH
]LDQ DWULVHFWRDUHLHVWH
+ U[
) [ \ = [ [ + \ − U \ − [ = I [ = ±
( ) ( ) ([

)
(U − [ )
6WXGLLQGYDULD LDIXQF LHLYH]L>@SDJVHRE LQHJUDILFXOXUP
WRU \
(
P
3
7
1
α [
& % 2 ' $ [
0
P

6HFRQVLGHU WULXQJKLXO7%2vQFDUH2% ±UúL2& ±U'DF QRW P
7%& αDWXQFL
72&
7%& α3HQWUXDWULVHFWDXQJKLXO7%& αGX
FHPGLQRULJLQHVHFDQWD27'DF 7HVWHSHWULVHFWRDUHDWXQFL
72& α
2DOW SUREOHP ODIHOGHFHOHEU ODFDUHPDWHPDWLFLHQLLJUHFLQXDXSXWXW
IRORVLULJODúLFRPSDVXOHVWH

3UREOHPDGHOLF VDXDGXSOLF ULLFXEXOXL
$FHDVWD HVWH OHJDW GH XUP WRDUHD OHJHQG ÌQ $WHQD EkQWXLD OD YUHPHD
DFHHDRFLXP FXPSOLW /RFXLWRULLRUDúXOXLQHúWLLQGFXPV VFDSHGHPROLP
DXKRW UkWV FRQVXOWHRUDFROXOGLQ'HOILGLQLQVXOD'HORV5 VSXQVXODIRVWGDW
FKLDUGH]HXO$SROORFDUHFHUHDV VHGXEOH]HDOWDUXOGLQWHPSOXOFRQVDFUDWOXL
&XP DOWDUXO DYHD IRUPD XQXL FXE DWHQLHQLL ODX VWULFDW úL DX FRQVWUXLW DOWXO FX
ODWXUDGHGRX RULPDLPDUH'DUFLXPDDFRQWLQXDWV VHFHUHYLH LOHRPHQHúWL
$WXQFLDWHQLHQLLVDXDGUHVDWGLQQRXRUDFROXOXLúLGHGDWDDFHDVWDU VSXQVXOD
IRVWXOXLWRU³6WXGLD LPDLELQHJHRPHWULD´*kQGLQGODvQ HOHVXODFHVWRUFXYLQWH
DWHQLHQLLúLDXGDWVHDPDF DOWDUXOFRQVWUXLWGHHLQXHUDGHGRX RULPDLPDUH
GHFkWFHOYHFKLFLGHRSWRULPDLPDUH(LDXvQFHUFDWV UHSDUHJUHúHDODF XWkQG
ODWXUDFXEXOXLDOF UXLYROXPV ILHGHGRX RULPDLPDUHGHFkWDOXQXLFXEGDW
ÌQV RULFkWDXvQFHUFDWJUHFLLQXDXSXWXWJ VLRFRQVWUXF LHFXULJODúLFRPSD
VXOGLQFDUHV UH]XOWHOXQJLPHDPXFKLHLFXEXOXLF XWDW&DúLvQFD]XOWULVHF LHL
XQJKLXOXL DX IRVW J VLWH VROX LL DOH SUREOHPHL FX DMXWRUXO DOWRU FXUEH GHFkW DOH
GUHSWHLúLFHUFXOXL'DUDWXQFLHOHDXIRVWUHVSLQVH
3ULPDVROX LHGHDFHVWJHQDGLF PHFDQLF DIRVWVWDELOLW GHF WUH+LSRFUDW
GLQ&KLRVDOWHOHDXIRVWGHVFRSHULWHGH$UKLWDVGLQ7DUHQWHDSRLGHGLVFLSROXO
DFHVWXLD (XGR[ GLQ &QLGH úL vQ ILQH GH HOHYXO OXL (XGR[ DQXPH 0HQHGLPXV
VHF ,9 vHQ ùL vQ DFHVW FD] H[SOLFD LD LPSRVLELOLW LL FRQVWUXF LHL FX ULJOD úL
FRPSDVXODSXWXWILvQ HOHDV GHDELDvQVHFDO;9,,,OHDRGDW FXLQWURGXFHUHD
PHWRGHORUDOJHEULFHQRLGHFHUFHWDUHDJHRPHWULHL

&YDGUDWXUDFHUFXOXL
(VWHDWUHLDSUREOHP LPSRVLELOGHUH]ROYDWFXULJODúLFRPSDVXO(VWHYRUED
GH FRQVWUXLW ODWXUD S WUDWXOXL D F UXL DULH V ILH H[DFW HJDO FX D XQXL FHUF GDW
,PSRVLELOLWDWHD FYDGUDWXULL FHUFXOXL FX ULJOD úL FRPSDVXO D IRVW VWDELOLW DELD
DFXPDQL
1LFL R SUREOHP QX D SDVLRQDW SH JHRPHWULL JUHFL DúD GH PXOW FD DFHDVWD
ÌQF GLQúFRDODOXL3LWDJRUDVDvQFHUFDWV LVHJ VHDVF RVROX LHGDUUH]XOWDWHOH
QXVHPDLFXQRVF6HVSXQHF $QD[DJRUDDUILVFULVRFDUWHGHVSUHFYDGUDWXUD
FHUFXOXLvQWLPSXOSHWUHFXWGHHOvQvQFKLVRDUHF FLGHúLSULHWHQFX3HULFOHDWH
QLHQLL ODX FRQGDPQDW OD vQFKLVRDUH ILLQGF OD FXUVXULOH VDOH GH DVWURQRPLH HO
VXV LQHD F 6RDUHOH HVWH R PDUH SLDWU LQFDQGHVFHQW LDU /XQD QX DUH OXPLQ
SURSULHFLRUHIOHFW SHDFHHDD6RDUHOXL1XVHúWLHFXPDUH]ROYDW$QD[DJRUD

DFHDVW SUREOHP F FLFDUWHDOXLQXPDLH[LVW vQVFKLPEQHDXU PDVDOWHVROX
LLSURSXVHGH+LSRFUDWGLQ&KLRVGH'LQRVWUDWGH$QWLIRQúLGHDO LL
6 QHRSULPODVROX LDSURSXV GH$QWLIRQF FLGRYHGHúWHLQWXL LHJHRPH
WULF $QWLIRQDFRQVLGHUDWXQWULXQJKLHFKLODWHUDOvQVFULVvQFHUFúLLDGXEODWvQ
PRGVXFFHVLYQXP UXOODWXULORUGLQvQGLQvQúDPGÌQIHOXODFHVWD
ODWXULOH VH vQPXO HVF DILUPD $QWLIRQ úL GHYLQ DúD GH PLFL vQFkW SROLJRQXO VH
FRQIXQG FXFHUFXO$úDGDUODXUPDXUPHLFHUFXOHVWHXQSROLJRQúLFXPRULFH
SROLJRQVHSRDWHWUDQVIRUPDvQWUXQS WUDWvQVHDPQ F VHSRDWHIDFHFYDGUDWXUD
FHUFXOXL
3URFHGHXOLPDJLQDWGH$QWLIRQHVWHDFHODFHVHIRORVHúWHD]LvQPRGRELúQX
LW ÌQV SH YUHPHD DFHHD HO D IRVW DVSUX FULWLFDW úL UHVSLQV FD ILLQG XQ VRILVP
GHRDUHFH PDWHPDWLFLHQLLGHDWXQFLVXV LQHDXF ROLQLHGUHDSW QXHVWHIRUPDW
GLQSXQFWHFLRULFkWGHPLF DUGHYHQLHDU PkQHOLQLHGUHDSW DGLF S VWUHD]
FHOH GRX H[WUHPLW L úL GHFL SROLJRQXO vQVFULV QX VH SRDWH WUDQVIRUPD vQWUXQ
FHUFF FLODWXULOHOXLRULFkWDUILHOHWDLHFHUFXOPHUHXvQGRX SXQFWH/ VkQGOD
RSDUWHVXEWLOLW LOHJHRPHWULHLFDUHDYHDXV VHUH]ROYHvQYLLWRUJHRPHWULLJUHFL
DX FRQWLQXDW V FHUFHWH]H SURSULHW LOH OLQLLORU IUkQWH úL DOH FHORU FXUEH úL V VH
EXFXUHGHUH]XOWDWHOHRE LQXWH

%LEOLRJUDILH
>@ &0LKX,3,DPERU&XUEHSODQH(GLWXUD7HKQLF
>@ *KHRUJKH ùW $QGRQLH 9DULD PDWKHPDWLFD (GLWXUD 7LQHUHWXOXL

>@ )ORULFD7&kPSDQ3ULQWUHOLQLLúLVXSUDIH H(GLWXUD,RQ&UHDQ
J
>@ )ORULFD7&kPSDQ3RYHVWLULGHVSUHSUREOHPHFHOHEUH(G$OED
WURV
>@ ..ROPDQ,VWRULDPDWHPDWLFLLvQDQWLFKLWDWH(GLWXUDùWLLQ LILF

$6835$81(,
352%/(0(
SURI35('$75$,$1
/LFHXO7HRUHWLFÄ$ /(;$1'589/$+8 ³

/DHWDSDMXGH HDQ GLQDQXODROLPSLDGHLGHPDWHPDWLF DSDUHXUP
WRDUHDSUREOHP
)LHI5→5RIXQF LHFXSURSULHW LOH
DI[I\≤I[\∀[\∈5
E∃0!DVWIHOvQFkW|I[|≤0[∀[∈5
6 VHDUDWHF
I ([ Q )
L GDF SHQWUX XQ úLU [QQ≥ DYHP OLP [ Q = ∞ úL OLP = O
Q→∞ Q→∞ [Q
I[
DWXQFL ≤ O ∀[!
[
I[
LLH[LVW OLP
Q→∞ [
ÌQ HVWHGDW XUP WRDUHDVROX LHSHQWUXSXQFWXODOGRLOHD

³LL 3UHVXSXQHP SULQ UHGXFHUH OD DEVXUG F DYHP GRX úLUXUL ([ Q )Q ≥ úL
(\ Q )Q ≥ FX QOLP
→∞
[Q OLP \ Q = ∞ DVWIHOvQFkW
Q→∞
I ([ Q ) I (\ Q )
OLP = O úL OLP = O FX O < O
Q→∞ [Q Q → ∞ \Q
I \
$WXQFL FRQIRUP FX L DYHP ≤ O ∀ \ ! UH]XOW F vQ YHFLQ WDWHD
\
 O + O I (\ Q )
O + O  DOXLOQXH[LVW QLFLXQWHUPHQGHIRUPD FHHDFHHVWH

 \Q


I [
IDOVúLGHFLO ODGLF H[LVW OLP ´
[ →∞ [
'HPRQVWUD LDHVWHJUHúLW VDXFHOSX LQLQFRPSOHW

3HQWUX R IXQF LH I 5 → 5 H[LVW OLP I [ úL HVWH HJDO FX O GDF
[ →∞
∀ ([ Q )Q ≥ ⊂ 5H[LVW OLPI ([Q ) úLHVWHHJDO FXO

Q→∞

ÌQDFHDVW GHPRQVWUD LHVDDU WDWF GDF SUHVXSXQHPF H[LVW GRX úLUXUL
I ([ Q ) I (\ Q )
([ Q )Q ≥ úL (\ Q )Q ≥ FXOLPLWD∞DVWIHOvQFkW QOLP
→∞ [
≠ OLP
Q →∞ \
VHDMXQJHODR
Q Q
FRQWUDGLF LH
I ([ Q )
'HPRQVWUD LDHVWHLQFRPSOHW GHRDUHFHQXVDDU WDWF H[LVW OLP úL
Q →∞ [
Q
I (\ Q )
OLP
Q→∞ \
Q
ÌQFHOHFHXUPHD] G PRVROX LHDFHVWHLSUREOHPH
I[ I [
LL)LH $ = VXS < ∞ GLQE ⇒ ≤ $ ∀[ ∈5úLSHQWUX ∀ ε!
[∈5 + [ [
∃[εDVWIHOvQFkW
ε I ([ ε )
$− <
[ε
I [
$U W PF OLP = $ ⇔ ∀ε > ∃δ ε DVWIHOvQFkW
[ →∞ [
I [ I [
∀ [ > δ ε ⇒ $ − ε < < $ + ε 6XILFLHQW $ − ε <
[ [
[ [
)LH [ > [ ε úLILH Uε[ =   ⇒ Uε[ ≤ < Uε[ +
[
 ε [ ε
1RW P 5 ε[ = [ − Uε[ [ ε ⇒ 5 ε[ ∈ [ [ ε )úL [ = 5 ε[ + Uε[ [ ε

Uε[ ∈ 1⇒ DUε[ I [ ≤ I Uε[ [ $YHP
( )
I [ I Uε[ [ ε
( + 5 ) U I ([
[ [
)+ I (5 ε[ ) = Uε[ ⋅ [ ε I ([ ε ) I 5 ε[
( )

[ [ [ Uε[ [ ε + 5 ε[ [ ε Uε[ [ ε + 5 ε[
ε ε ε
= ≥ ⋅ +
Uε[ [ ε
[→∞ [ ε IL[DW⇒ Uε[ → ∞ ⇒ → 5 ε ∈ [ [ ε ) ⇒
Uε[ [ ε + 5 ε[ [ → ∞
5 ε[ [ [
⇒≤ →
[
< [ ε [ = ε [
Uε [ ε + 5 ε Uε [ ε + 5 ε
[ [ →∞
Uε[ [ ε 5 ε[
'DU
Uε[ [ ε + 5 ε[ Uε[ [ ε + 5 ε[
= −

I 5 ε[
( ) 05 ε[ Uε[ I ([ ε )+ I 5 ε[
( ) I ([ ε )
⇒
Uε[ [ ε 5 ε[ Uε [ ε + 5 ε [ [ε
≤ [ [
→ ⇒ →
+
ε Uε[ I ([ ε )+ I 5 ε[ I ([ ε ) ε
( )
⇒ ∃δ ε
Dv − < ⇒
[ [ε
< −
Uε[ I ([ ε )+ I 5 ε[
( ) I ([ ε ) ε U [ I ([ ε )+ I 5 ε[ I ([ ε ) ε
( )
⇒ ∃δ ε
Dv − < ε <
[ [ε [ [ε
⇒ → −
Uε[ I ([ ε )+ I 5 ε[( ) I ([ ε ) ε
∀ [ > δ
ε ⇒ − ∀[ > δ
ε
[ [ε
>
I [ I ([ ε ) ε
'LQúL⇒ − ∀ [ > δ
ε
[ [ε
>
I [ I ([ ε ) ε
'LQúL⇒ − > $ − − = $±εSHQWUX
ε ε
[ [ε
>
I [ I [
∀ [ > δ ε = PD[ (δ
ε δ

ε ) ⇒ > $ − ε ⇒ > $ − ε ∀ [ > δ ε THG
[ [
I [ I [
L'LQLLGHRDUHFH OLP = VXS úL
[ →∞ [ [∈5 + [
I ([ Q ) I[ I [
OLP = " ⇒ VXS ≤ " ∀[∈5
Q →∞ [ [ [
="⇒
Q [∈5 +

%LEOLRJUDILH
>@ ,RDQ 7RPHVFX FRRUG 3UREOHPH GDWH OD ROLPSLDGHOH GH PDWH
PDWLF SHQWUXOLFHH(GLWXUDùWLLQ LILF
>@ &RQVWDQWLQ3RSD9LRUHO+LULú0LKDLO0HJDQ,QWURGXFHUHvQDQD
OL]DPDWHPDWLF (GLWXUD)DFOD

'(635(ì,585,5(&85(17(
'(),1,7(,03/,&,7
SURI90$5,1$

ÌQXOWLPLLDQLDXIRVWSURSXVHODH[DPHQHúLFRQFXUVXULSUREOHPHvQFDUH
DSDULPSOLFLWúLUXULUHFXUHQWH9RPWUDWDXQLWDUXQHOHGLQWUHDFHVWHSUREOHPH
([HPSOXO )LH[QU G FLQDUHDO DHFXD LHL[Q[±Q ∀Q ∈1
6 VH DUDWH F úLUXO ([ Q )Q ≥ HVWH FRQYHUJHQW úL V VH FDOFXOH]H
OLP [ Q
Q→∞

62/8 ,( )LH I 5 → 5 I[ [ Q[ ± Q GHULYDELO úL I
[ [ Q
'HFL I
[ ! ∀ [ ∈ 5 'HGXFHP F HFXD LD I[ GHRDUHFH I HVWH VWULFW
FUHVF WRDUHúLI ±QI !DUHRVLQJXU VROX LHSHFDUHRQRW P
FX[QúLGHFL[Q∈DGLF úLUXO ([ Q )Q ≥ HVWHP UJLQLW
3HQWUXPRQRWRQLHVFULHPvQWkLFHUHOD LHYHULILF [Q
[ Q + + (Q + )[ Q + − Q + = VDX [ Q + = Q + − Q[Q

GDU I ([ Q + ) = [ Q + Q[ Q + − Q = Q + − (Q + )[ Q + + Q[ Q + − Q = − [ Q + úL FXP

[QUH]XOW I ([ Q + ) > 2E LQHPVLWXD LD
[ [Q
I[ ±Q
'LQ I ([ Q + ) > GHGXFHP F [Q HVWH OD GUHDSWD OXL [Q I HVWH FRQWLQX úL
S VWUHD] VHPQFRQVWDQWSHLQWHUYDOHOHSHFDUHQXVHDQXOHD]
'HFL [ Q < [ Q + úLDPGHPRQVWUDWF ([ Q )Q ≥ HVWHFRQYHUJHQW

([LVW / = OLP [ Q 6FULLQGUHOD LDSHFDUHRYHULILF [QDVWIHO [ Q = − [Q
Q →∞ Q
úLWUHFkQGODOLPLW RE LQHP / = − ⋅ / úLGHFL / = OLP [ Q =
Q →∞
([HPSOXO 6H G HFXD LD [ + Q [ + = Q ∈ 1 6 VH DUDWH F

HFXD LDDUHRVLQJXU U G FLQ [QúLUXO ([ Q )Q ≥ HVWHFRQYHUJHQW
úLV VHDIOH OLP [ Q
Q→∞

62/8 ,()LHIXQF LDI5→5I[ [Q[FDUHHVWHGHULYDELO
'HRDUHFH I
[ = [ + Q > I!úLI±HFXD LDDUHRXQLF VROX LH
[Q∈±úLGHFLúLUXO ([ Q )Q ≥ HVWHP UJLQLW
5HOD LD SH FDUH R YHULILF [Q HVWH [ Q + + (Q + ) [ Q + + = VDX

[ Q + = − − (Q + ) [ Q + 3HGHDOW SDUWHGLQ I ([ Q + ) = [ Q + + Q [ Q + +

= − − Q [ Q + + Q[ Q + + [Q + + Q [ Q + + = − (Q + )[ Q + > GHGX

( )
FHPF [QHVWHODGUHDSWDOXL[QGHFL [ Q < [ Q + úLUXO ([ Q )Q ≥ ILLQGFUHVF WRU

6FULLQGUHOD LDSHFDUHRYHULILF [QDVWIHO [ Q + [ Q + = úLWUHFkQG
Q Q
ODOLPLW RE LQHP OLP [ Q =
Q→∞
([HPSOXO (FXD LD [ Q + OQ[ = ∀Q ∈1 DUHRVLQJXU U G FLQ [Q

V VHDUDWHF úLUXO ([ Q )Q ≥ HVWHFRQYHUJHQW OLP [ Q = "
Q→∞

62/8 ,()LHIXQF LDI5 o5I[ [QOQ[FX I
[ = Q[ Q − +
>
[
&XP OLP I [ = −∞ úLI!UH]XOW F HFXD LDDGPLWHRVLQJXU U G FLQ [QúL
[ →
[ >
DQXPH[Q∈)LJXUkQGDYHPVLWXD LD

[Q [Q
I[ ±∞
(FXD LDSHFDUHRYHULILF [QHVWH [ QQ ++ + OQ [ Q + = GHFL

OQ [ Q + = − [ QQ ++ I ([ Q + ) = [ QQ + + OQ [ Q + = [ QQ + − [ QQ ++ = [ QQ + ( − [ Q + ) > úL GHFL
[Q[QUH]XOW ([ Q )Q ≥ FRQYHUJHQWúLGHFLH[LVW " OLP [Q HYLGHQW"∈>@
Q→∞
'DF "UH]XOW OLP [ Q = 7UHFkQGODOLPLW RE LQHP

Q→∞
OLP ([ QQ + OQ [ Q = ⇔ OQ " = FRQWUDGLF LHFX"úLGHFL"

)
Q→∞
([HPSOXO (FXD LD [ Q + [ Q − + + [ − = DUHRVLQJXU VROX LHSR]L

WLY [Q6 VHDUDWHF úLUXO ([ Q )Q ≥ HVWHFRQYHUJHQWúLV VHDIOH
OLP [ Q
Q→∞

62/8 ,( )LH IXQF LD I >∞ → 5 I[ [ Q + [ Q − + + [ − FX
I
[ = Q[ Q − + + > GHFL I HVWH VWULFW FUHVF WRDUH úL FXP I ±
I Q±!H[LVW RXQLF VROX LH[Q∈2E LQHPVLWXD LD
[ [Q∞
I[ ±Q−
'DU I ([ Q− ) = [ QQ− + [ QQ−− + + [ Q− − = [ QQ− + = [ QQ − > úL GHFL [ Q ∈ ( [ Q − )
( )
FDUHQHDUDW F úLUXOHVWHGHVFUHVF WRU'HRDUHFH[Q∈úLUXOHVWHúLP UJLQLW
GHFLFRQYHUJHQW
6FULLQGUHOD LDGHUHFXUHQ DOWIHO [ Q + [ Q − + + [ + − = úLvQPXO LQG
FX[±RE LQHP [ Q + − − ([ − ) = VDX [ = + [ Q + 'HFL[QYHULILF UHOD

LD [ Q = + [ QQ + úLWUHFkQGODOLPLW RE LQHP OLP [ Q = + OLP [ QQ + úLGHFL
Q→∞ Q →∞

OLP [ Q =
Q →∞
([HPSOXO (FXD LD [H [ = Q DUHRVROX LHSR]LWLY XQLF [QV VHVWXGLH
]HFRQYHUJHQ DúLUXOXL[QúLV VHFDOFXOH]H OLP [ Q
Q→∞
62/8 ,()LHIXQF LDI>∞→5 I [ = [H[ − Q FX I

[ = [H [ + H [ >
'HRDUHFHI ±QúL OLP I [ = +∞ UH]XOW F HFXD LDDUHRXQLF VROX LH
Q→∞
[Q!(YLGHQW [ Q +H [ Q +
= Q + úLGHFL I ([ Q + ) = [ Q +H [ Q + − Q = Q±Q !
!úLGHFL [ Q < [ Q +
3UHVXSXQHPF [QHVWHP UJLQLWFXPI H±QSHQWUXQ ≥SRWSUH
VXSXQH[Q∈1GHFL[QFRQYHUJHQWúLGHFLH[LVW " = OLP [ Q 7UHFkQGODOLPL
Q →∞
W vQ UHOD LD [ Q H [Q

= Q RE LQHP HH = ∞ FHHD FH HVWH IDOV úL GHFL úLUXO ([ Q )Q ≥
H
HVWHQHP UJLQLWÌQILQDO OLP [ Q = +∞

Q→∞
Q
([HPSOXO 6 VH DUDWH F HFXD LD H [ = [ DUH R XQLF VROX LH SR]LWLY
[
[Q6 VHVWXGLH]HFRQYHUJHQ DúLUXULORU[QúL Q
Q

Q
62/8 ,( )LH IXQF LD I ∞ → 5 I [ = H [ − [ FX OLP I [ = +∞
[ →
I Q = H − Q < SW Q ≥ RE LQHPF HFXD LDDUHRVROX LHXQLF [Q∈QF FL
I = H Q − >
[ [QQ∞
I[ ±∞!
Q +
5HOD LD YHULILFDW GH [Q HVWH H [ Q + − [ Q + = $WXQFL [ Q < [ Q + úLUXO

([ Q )Q≥ ILLQGFUHVF WRU
Q
3UHVXSXQHP F úLUXO ([ Q )Q ≥ HVWH P UJLQLW $WXQFL OLP = +∞ úL
Q→∞ [Q
Q
OLP H [Q
= OLP [ Q LPSOLF OLP [ Q = ∞ DEVXUG'HFLúLUXO ([ Q )Q ≥ HVWHQHP UJL
Q→∞ Q→∞ Q →∞
Q
[Q
QLWRE LQkQG OLP [ Q = ∞ $WXQFL OLP H [Q
= ∞ FDUHLPSOLF OLP =
Q→∞ Q → Q→∞ Q
3à75$7(/(ì,&8%85,/(
8125180(5(1$785$/(
'0% 7,1( 8*,85*,8

3RUQLQGGHODIRUPXOHOHGHFDOFXOSUHVFXUWDW
DE DDEE
DE DDEDEE
YRPVWDELOLRPRGDOLWDWHVLPSO GHRE LQHUHDS WUDWHORUúLFXEXULORUXQRUQXPH
UHGHRDQXPLW IRUP
)LHQ∈1 &RQVLGHUkQGvQUHOD LDD QE RE LQHP
Q

Q⋅Q

+

+ =

Q − Q Q Q − Q −
DGLF

=

Q − Q − Q −
ÌQSDUWLFXODUSHQWUXQ GHGXFHPF

=

'HDVHPHQHDGDF vQOX PD E RE LQHPQ

Q Q⋅Q

Q − Q − Q −
úLGHFLvQSDUWLFXODUUH]XOW

=

6 FRQVLGHU PvQUHOD LDD QE ±úLRE LQHP

Q± Q±⋅Q

−

=

Q Q − Q Q − Q −
'DF vQFRQVLGHU PD QE ±RE LQHP
« Q± Q±⋅Q

− ⋅

=

Q − Q Q − Q −
ÌQSDUWLFXODURE LQHP

=

úLUHVSHFWLY

=

ÌQFRQWLQXDUHOXkQGvQD QE∈{±}RE LQHP
QE QE⋅Q⋅E⋅QE Q±⋅Q⋅Q±
DGLF RE LQHPUHVSHFWLY
Q Q⋅Q⋅Q
úL Q± Q±⋅Q⋅Q±
3ULQXUPDUHGLQGHGXFHP

+

+

+ =

Q − Q Q Q Q − Q − Q −
ÌQSDUWLFXODUUH]XOW F

=

'HDVHPHQHDGLQRE LQHP

=
−
+
−

Q Q Q Q Q − Q − Q
ÌQSDUWLFXODUSHQWUXQ RE LQHP

=

%LEOLRJUDILH
>@%$.RUGHPVNL&XEXULúLS WUDWHFXULRDVHDOHXQRUQXPHUH
0DWHPDWLNDYúFROHQUSDJ

'(35,1/80(
$'81$7(e
SURI(5,.$/8&,$68+$<

ÌQWURWLJDLHvQFDSRGDW FKLIWHOHILHFDUHWUHEXLH LQXW PLQXWHSHR
SDUWHúLPLQXWHSHFHDODOW &DUHHVWHWLPSXOPLQLPvQFDUHSRWILSU MLWH
FKLIWHOH"
5GHPLQXWH
'XS FHFKLIWHOHDXIRVW LQXWHPLQXWHVHvQWRUFúLVHVFRWSHR
IDUIXULHSXQkQGXVHFKLIWHOHQHSU MLWHvQORFFDUHVH LQvQF PLQXWH
'XS DFHHDVHVFRWFHOHSU MLWHVHvQWRUFFHOHúLVHPDLSXQFHOHGHSH
IDUIXULH
8QDXWREX]PHUJHSHRúRVHDGLQRUDúXO$VSUHRUDúXO%FXYLWH] FRQVWDQW
úLODILHFDUHPLQVHvQFUXFLúHD] FXDXWREX]HFDUHPHUJGHOD%VSUH$FX
DFHHDúLYLWH] &kWHDXWREX]HVRVHVFvQ$WLPSGHRRU
5DXWREX]H
'DF DXWREX]XODUVWDSHORFDUYHGHDGLQVHQVFRQWUDUXQDXWREX]OD
PLQXWH
'RLHOHYL$úL%MRDF XUP WRUXOMRFDXvQID RJU PDG GHGHFKLEUL
WXULúLDXYRLHV LDSHUkQGFHOSX LQXQE FHOPXOWEH HRGDW ÌQFHSH
$ &kúWLJ FHO FDUH LD XOWLPXO E 6 VH DIOH FDUH FkúWLJ FX VLJXUDQ úL
FXPWUHEXLHV MRDFH
5 3UHVXSXQHPF EH HOHVXQWQXPHURWDWH8OWLPXOE SHFDUHWUHEXLHV OLD
$vQDLQWHV FkúWLJHWUHEXLHV DLE QXP UXO± 'LQDFHVWHD
VF ]kQGPHUHXRE LQHPQXPHUHOHSHFDUHWUHEXLHV OHVSXQ $%ILLQG
REOLJDWV VHvQFDGUH]HvQHOH
$
%
$LDXOWLPXOE
'DF %LDPDLSX LQGH$YDOXDPDLPXOWHEH HGHFkW$
8QYDSRUFDUHPHUJHSHXQUkXSDUFXUJHvQVHQVXOFXUHQWXOXLDSHLNP
SH RU 9LWH]D DSHL HVWH GH NP SH RU &k L NLORPHWUL SDUFXUJH YDSRUXO
vQWURRU GDF PHUJHvPSRWULYDFXUHQWXOXLDSHL"
5NP
9YDSRU ± NPK
9vPSRWULYDDSHL ± NPK

$6835$(&8$é,(,/8,3(//
3(758ù$/(;$1'5(6&8

)LHHFXD LD [ − \ = 6 DU W PF DFHDVW HFXD LHDUHRLQILQLWDWH
GHVROX LLvQQXPHUHvQWUHJL3HQWUXDFHDVWDV IDFHPRVHULHGHREVHUYD LL
ÌQWUDGHY UVHFRQVWDW LPHGLDWF [WUHEXLHV ILHQXP ULPSDU$úDGDUOX P
[ ]]∈=ÌQORFXLPvQúLRE LQHP (] + ) − \ = ⇔

⇔ ] + ] − \ = ⇔ ] (] + ) = \ GHDLFLUH]XOW \QXP USDU

] (] + )
)LH\ X$WXQFL X = HFXD LHHFKLYDOHQW FX

2EVHUYkQGFXDWHQ LHHFXD LDJ VLPFkWHYDVROX LLSDUWLFXODUH$FHVWHDVXQW
(] X ) = (±)⇒ ([ = \ = )
(] X ) = (±)⇒ ([ = \ = )
(] X ) = ( ( ⋅ ) )HWF
6HPDLSRDWHFRQVWDWDF X = [ \ FHHDFHFRQGXFHOD] \ [ \
\ [\$úDGDURE LQHPSHF LHXULVWLFHLQIRUPD LDFDUHGHYLQHWHRUHP vQ
PRPHQWXOvQFDUHRYRPúLGHPRQVWUD
7HRUHP 'DF ]XHVWHRVROX LHDHFXD LHLFXVROX LD[\
FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH SHQWUX HFXD LD DWXQFL R DOW VROX LH YD IL
X = [ \
 ] = \

GDW GHVLVWHPXO 
 [ = \
+
 \ = [ \

3URFHVXO HVWH LWHUDWLY DGLF VROX LD SDUWLFXODU (X ] [ \ ) JHQHUHD]

VROX LD (X ] [ \ )FDUHJHQHUHD] ODUkQGXOV XVROX LD (X ] [ \ ) HWF
ÌQFD]XOHFXD LHLVROX LDQHQXO JHQHUHD] SULQIRUPXOHOH
VROX LD DFHDVWD JHQHUHD] OD UkQGXO HL VROX LD ⋅
⋅⋅⋅
6 WUHFHP OD GHPRQVWUDUHD WHRUHPHL ÌQWUDGHY U V SUHVXSXQHP F VLVWH
PXO (X ] [ \ ) HVWH R VROX LH PL[W D HFXD LLORU úL 6 DU W P F úL
VLVWHPXO (X ] [ \ )GDWGHIRUPXOHOHHVWHRVROX LHDHFXD LLORUúL

$úDGDU [ − \ = \ + − ([ \ ) =

( )
\ + \ + − [ \ = \ \ + − [ + = GHRDUHFH [ − \ = THG
( )

2'(021675$é,(35,1
,1'8&é,(3(1758
,1(*$/,7$7($0(',,/25
7,78=921$58

6FRSXODFHVWHLQRWHHVWHGHDGDRQRX GHPRQVWUD LHSUREDELOLQHGLW SHQ
WUXFHOHEUDLQHJDOLWDWHDPHGLLORU
9RPGHPRQVWUDPDLvQWkLF SHQWUXRULFHDE ∈5úLP ∈1P!HVWH
DGHY UDW LQHJDOLWDWHD
D + P P E ≥ (P + )P + DE
FDUHHVWHXQFD]SDUWLFXODUDOLQHJDOLW LLGLQSUREOHPDGLQ*D]HWD0DWH
PDWLF QUSURSXV GHDXWRUXODFHVWRUUkQGXUL
1RWkQG D = [ P + E = \ P (P +) LQHJDOLWDWHDGHYLQH
[ P + + P ⋅ \ P + ≥ (P + )[\ P
FDUHSULQvPS U LUHOD[\ DPSUHVXSXV[\ ≠FD]XULOHFkQGFHOSX LQ[
P
[
VDX\ VHYHULILF LPHGLDWúLFXQRWD LD = W GHYLQH W P + P ≥ P + DGLF
\ W
WP+ − (P +)⋅ W + P ≥
$YHPVXFFHVLY W P +
− (P + )W + P = W P +
− W − P (W − ) =
W (W − ) W
( P −
+ + W + − P (W − ) = (W − ) W + W P − + + W + W − P =
) ( P
)
(W − )(W − + W − + + W
P P −
− + W − ) = (W − )>(W − )(W + + )+
P −
+ (W − )(W P − + + )+ + (W − )(W + )+ (W − )@ = (W − ) 4(W ) XQGH 4W HVWH XQ

SROLQRPGHYDULDELODSR]LWLY WúLFDUHDUHWR LFRHILFLHQ LLSR]LWLYLDGLF 4W!

!úLLQHJDOLWDWHDHVWHDGHY UDW
6 WUHFHPDFXPODGHPRQVWUDUHDSULQLQGXF LHDLQHJDOLW LL
D + D + + D Q ≥ Q Q DD D Q
DGHY UDW RULFDUHDUILQXPHUHOHUHDOHSR]LWLYH D D D Q XQGHQ∈1
3HQWUXQ úLQ LQHJDOLWDWHDHVWHDGHY UDW 6 SUHVXSXQHPF LQH
JDOLWDWHDHVWHDGHY UDW úLV GHPRQVWU PF
D + D + + D Q + D Q + ≥ (Q + )Q + DD D Q D Q +
)RORVLQGLSRWH]DGHLQGXF LHúLLQHJDOLWDWHDRE LQHP
D + D + + D Q + D Q + ≥ D + Q Q D D Q D Q + ≥ (Q + )Q + D D D Q D Q +
&RQIRUP SULQFLSLXOXL LQGXF LHL UH]XOW F LQHJDOLWDWHD HVWH DGHY UDW
RULFDUHDUILQXPHUHOHUHDOHSR]LWLYH D D D Q úLQ∈1

352%/(0(5(=2/9$7(

3UREOHPD9QU
6HFRQVLGHU QXP UXOQDWXUDO$ PQPQ∈1ùWLLQGF $HV
WHPXOWLSOXGHúLP NN∈1DIOD LUHVWXOvPS U LULLOXLQOD
6ROX LHILLQGPXOWLSOXGHúLUHVWXOvPS U LULLOXLPODHVWHUH]XO
W F Q SS∈1vQWUXFkW$HVWHPXOWLSOXGH
$úDGDUUHVWXOvPS U LULLOXLQODHVWH
*KHRUJKH*LXUJLX
3UREOHPD9,QU
* VL LFHOPDLPLFQXP UQDWXUDOGHIRUPD $ = D ⋅ E ⋅ F XQGHDEF∈
∈1 úWLLQGF $DUHFXGLYL]RULPDLPXOWGHFkW$

6ROX LH 1XP UXO GLYL]RULORU QXP UXOXL $ ILLQG (D + )(E + )(F + ) úL L
QkQGFRQWGHFRQGL LDGLQHQXQ DYHP
$ = D + ⋅ E ⋅ F úLH[LVW HJDOLWDWHD
(D + )(E + )(F + ) = (D + )(E + )(F + )+
(D + )(E + )(F + )− (D + )(E + )(F + ) =
(E + )(F + )⋅ (D + − D − ) =
(E + )(F + ) = ⇒ E = F =
$HVWHFHOPDLPLFQXP UQDWXUDOvQFRQGL LLOHGDWHGDF D LDUQXP UXO
F XWDWHVWH
*KHRUJKH*LXUJLX
3UREOHPD9,,QU
)LH $ = + + + + (Q − ) − Q 'HPRQVWUD LF $HVWHGLYL]LELOFX
SHQWUXRULFHQ∈1
6ROX LH6HSRDWHVFULHQ +
+
+ úLRE LQHP
Q WHUPHQL
$ = − + − + − + + (Q − ) −
[ ]

( ) ( ) ( )
'LIHUHQ HOHGLQSDUDQWH]HVXQWGHIRUPD (Q −) − XQGHQ∈1

$YHP (Q − ) − = Q (Q − )([SUHVLDQQ±XQGHQ ∈1 HVWHSUR

GXVXODGRX QXPHUHQDWXUDOHFRQVHFXWLYHGHFLVHGLYLGHFX
5H]XOW F SURGXVXOQQ±Q ∈1 VHGLYLGHFXGHFLúLQXP UXO$VH
GLYLGHFXGHRDUHFHHVWHRVXP GHQXPHUHGLYL]LELOHFX
SURI2YLGLX*DEULHO'LQX

3UREOHPD,;QU

'DF I5 →5úL I ([ ) + ⋅ I   = [ ∀[∈5 V VHGHWHUPLQHI[
[
 
6ROX LH I ([)+ ⋅ I   = [ ⇒ I   + ⋅ I ([) = ∀[∈5 + GHFL
[ [ [
  
I ([ ) + I   =  [ +  úLDWXQFLGLQHQXQ RE LQHPF
[  [ 
  
⋅ I   +  [ +  = [ ∀[∈5 + ⇔
[  [ 
    
⇔ I   = [ −  [ +  =  [ −  ⇒
[  [   [ 
      − [

⇒ I   =  [ −  ⇒ I ([ ) =  − [  =
 [   [   [  [
3UREOHPD;QU
6 VHGHWHUPLQH [ORJ + ORJ + ORJ ]

6ROX LH6HYHULILF LPHGLDWF < ORJ < < ORJ < < ORJ <

'HFL + + < ORJ + ORJ + ORJ < + + ⇔

⇔ < ORJ + ORJ + ORJ < GHXQGHGHGXFHPF [ORJ + ORJ + ORJ ]

3UREOHPD,;QU
) U DWUHFHQXPHUHOHúLvQED]DV VHDIOHFkWHFLIUHYRUDYHD
FHOHGRX QXPHUHvQDFHDVW ED]
SURI,OLH'LDFRQX&OXM1DSRFD
6ROX LH&XP = = < < = = úL

= = < < = = UH]XOW F FHOHGRX QXPHUH

YRUDYHDUHVSHFWLYFLIUHvQVLVWHPXOELQDU
3UREOHPD;QU
6 VHUH]ROYHvQPXO LPHDQXPHUHORUUHDOHHFXD LD
[ − \−]
+ \ −] − [
+ ] −[−\
=

SURI,OLH'LDFRQX&OXM1DSRFD

6ROX LDDXWRUXOXL$SOLFkQGLQHJDOLWDWHDPHGLLORURE LQHP

[ + \ + ] − [ − \ − ] +
( )
+ + ≥ ⋅
[ −\−] \ −] −[ ] −[ −\ [ + \ + ] − [ − \ −]

=

[
([ −) + (\ −) + (] −) ]
= ≥ =
5H]XOW LPHGLDWF DYHPHJDOLWDWHQXPDLGDF [ \ ]
3UREOHPD;QU
+
5H]ROYD LHFXD LD DUFVLQ [ + DUFFRV [ =

π
6ROX LH$YHP[∈>±@$SOLFLQHJDOLWDWHDPHGLLORU
DUFVLQ [ + DUFFRV [ ≥ ⋅ DUFVLQ [ +DUFFRV [ 'DU D + E ≥

(D + E) ⇒

⇒ DUFVLQ [ + DUFFRV [ ≥
(DUFVLQ [ + DUFFRV [ )

+
&XP DUFVLQ [ + DUFFRV [ = ∀[∈>±@RE LQHP DUFVLQ [ + DUFFRV [ ≥

π
π

ÌQLQHJDOLW LOHIRORVLWHHJDOLWDWHDDUHORFGDF úLQXPDLGDF
 DUFFRV [ = DUFVLQ [

⇒[=
DUFVLQ [ = DUFFRV [

SURI0DULDQ*KL &RQVWDQ D
3UREOHPD;QU
)LH SDWUXODWHUXO 00 0 0 GLQ SODQXO α 6 VH DIOH ORFXO JHRPHWULF DO
SXQFWHORU0GLQVSD LXFXSURSULHWDWHD
00 − 00 = 00 − 00 = 00 − 00 = 00 − 00
6ROX LH'LQ 00 − 00 = 00 − 00 ⇒ 00 = 00 + 00
$QDORJ 00 = 00 + 00 úLGHFL 00 = 00
$VHP Q WRU VH DUDW F 00 = 00 úL vQORFXLQG vQ UHOD LD GLQ HQXQ XO
SUREOHPHL⇒ 00 = 00 00 = 00
'HFL0DSDU LQHSODQHORUPHGLDWRDUHDOHFHORUODWXULDOHSDWUXODWHUXOXLÌQ
FRQFOX]LH ORFXO JHRPHWULF HVWH GUHDSWD SHUSHQGLFXODU SH SODQXO α vQ FHQWUXO
FHUFXOXLFLUFXPVFULVSDWUXODWHUXOXLGDF DFHVWSDWUXODWHUHVWHLQVFULSWLELOLDUGD
F SDWUXODWHUXOQXHVWHLQVFULSWLELOORFXOJHRPHWULFHVWHPXO LPHDYLG
0HWRGD,,6HúWLHF ORFXOJHRPHWULFDOSXQFWXOXL0GLQVSD LXFXSURSULH
WDWHD 00 − 00 = N N ∈ 5 HVWH XQ SODQ SHUSHQGLFXODU SH VHJPHQWXO

00 &HOH SODQH SHUSHQGLFXODUH SH ODWXULOH SDWUXODWHUXOXL VXQW FRQFXUHQWH
GXS RGUHDSW G⊥αGDF úLQXPDLGDF SDWUXODWHUXOHVWHLQVFULSWLELO
SURI0DULDQ*KL &RQVWDQ D
3UREOHPD;,,QU
)LH $+$ XQLQHOFX ≠úL($PXO LPHDHQGRIRUPLVPHORUJUXSXOXL
$'HILQLPDGXQDUHDúLFRPSXQHUHDHQGRPRUILVPHORUSULQ
(I + J ) [ = I [ + J [ (I $ J ) [ = I (J [ )∀IJ∈($∀[∈$
6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HF
DGDF (( $+$) HVWHXQFRUSL]RPRUIFXFRUSXO4DWXQFL$HVWHXQFRUS
L]RPRUIFXFRUSXO4
E GDF (( $ +$) HVWH XQ FRUS L]RPRUI FX FRUSXO =S S SULP DWXQFL $
HVWHXQFRUSL]RPRUIFXFRUSXO=S
0DUFHO HQD
6ROX LH6HDUDW LPHGLDWF ³´úL³ $ ´VXQWRSHUD LLDOJHEULFHSHPXO LPHD
($ úL F (($+$) HVWH XQ LQHO 3HQWUX ILHFDUH D ∈ $ DSOLFD LLOH
ID$→$ID[ D[úLJD$→$JD[ [DVXQWHQGRPRUILVPH
DOHJUXSXOXL$GHFLIDJD∈($
ÌQSOXVDSOLFD LLOH ϕ$ →($ ϕD IDúL ψ$ →($ ψD JDVXQW
PRUILVPHXQLWDUHLQMHFWLYHGHLQHOH
$FHDVWD DUDW F LQHOXO (( $ +$) LQFOXGH GRX VXELQHOH L]RPRUIH FX
($+$) úLDQXPH (,P ϕ+$)úL (,P ψ+$)
D 3UHVXSXQHP F (( $ +$) HVWH XQ FRUS L]RPRUI FX FRUSXO 4 $WXQFL
SHQWUX RULFH D ∈ $ D ≠ HQGRPRUILVPXO ID HVWH LQYHUVDELO vQ PRQRLGXO
(( $$) GHFLHVWHELMHFWLY
5H]XOW F H[LVW D
∈$DVWIHOvQFkW I D D
= DGLF DD
/DIHOHQGR
PRUILVPXOJDHVWHLQYHUVDELOvQ (( $ $) GHFLHVWHELMHFWLYSULQXUPDUHH[LVW
D
∈$DVWIHOvQFkWJDD
DGLF D
D $úDGDUDHVWHLQYHUVDELOODVWkQJDúL
ODGUHDSWDvQ$GHFLHVWHLQYHUVDELO&XPD ∈$D ≠DIRVWDUELWUDUUH]XOW F
LQHOXO$HVWHXQFRUS
'HRDUHFH $ ≅ ,P ϕ UH]XOW F (,P ϕ+$ ) HVWH XQ FRUS LQFOXV vQ FRUSXO
(( $+$) &XP($ ≅4LDU4QXLQFOXGHDOWHFRUSXULDIDU GHHOvQVXúLUH
]XOW ,P ϕ = ( $ ≅ 4 GHFL ,P ϕ ≅ 4 úLGHFL$≅4WRDWHL]RPRUILVPHOHVXQW
GHFRUSXUL
E&DúLODDGHRDUHFH (( $ +$) HVWHXQFRUSUH]XOW F ($+$ ) HVWHXQ
FRUS úL DWXQFL (,P ϕ+$ ) HVWH XQ FRUS LQFOXV vQ (( $ +$) 'HRDUHFH ($ ≅

≅=SúL=SQXLQFOXGHDOWHFRUSXULvQDIDU GHHOvQVXúLUH]XOW ,Pϕ ($≅=S
GHFL,Pϕ≅=SúLGHDLFL$≅=SWRDWHL]RPRUILVPHOHVXQWGHFRUSXUL
3UREOHPD;QU
)LHI5→I5 ∞FDUHYHULILF SHQWUX∀[∈5UHOD LD
I [ + I [ = − [
$U WD LF IHVWHLQYHUVDELO
&DOFXOD L I − [
90DWURVHQFR
6ROX LH1RW P J[ = [ + [ (+∞) → (+∞)

) [ = − [ 5 → ∞ 'H DLFL UH]XOW J(I [ ) = I [ + I [ VDX

(J $ I ) [ = ) [ ∀[∈5
'HRDUHFH ) HVWH LQMHFWLY UH]XOW I LQMHFWLY ÌPSUHXQ FX LSRWH]D I5
∞UH]XOW IELMHFWLY DGLF LQYHUVDELO
5H]XOW J $ I = ) ⇒ J = ) $ I − ⇒ ) − $ J = I −
&XP ) − [ = − ORJ [ ⇒ I − [ = − ORJ [ + [
( )
3UREOHPD;,,QU
E
D)LHIXQF LLOHIJ>DE@ →5LQWHJUDELOHFX ∫ I [ J [ G[ ≠ úLNXQ
D
QXP UUHDOSR]LWLYIL[DW6 VHDUDWHF H[LVW F∈DEDVWIHOvQFkW
F E
∫ I [ J [ G[ = N ∫ I [ J [ G[
D F
E
E'DF I>DE@ →5HVWHLQWHJUDELO úL I [ G[ ≠ DWXQFLSHQWUXRULFH
∫
D
Q∈1 H[LVW QXPHUHOH [ [ [ Q ∈ (D E )DVWIHOvQFkW
[ [ E
∫ I [ G[ = ∫ I [ G[ = = ∫ I [ G[
D [ [Q
'%XúQHDJúL&0DQJUD
6ROX LHD&RQVLGHU PIXQF LLOHϕψúL)>DE@→5GHILQLWHDVWIHO
W E
ϕ W = I [ J [ G[ ψ W = I [ J [ G úL ) W = ϕ W − Nψ W
∫ ∫
D W
6HREVHUY FXXúXULQ F
ϕψúL)VXQWFRQWLQXHSH>DE@

ϕD ψE

E
ϕE⋅ψD  I [ J [ G[  >


D
∫ 

'DU)D⋅)E ±NψD⋅ϕEGHRDUHFHN!úLGLQDYHP ϕE⋅ψD!
! GHFL GLQSURSULHWDWHD OXL 'DUERX[ SHQWUX IXQF LD ) UH]XOW F ∃ F ∈ D E
F E
DVWIHOvQFkW)F ⇒ϕF NψF⇒ I [ J [ G[ = N I [ J [ G[
∫ ∫
D F

E LQkQGFRQWGHDIDFHPJ úL N = RE LQHP
Q
[

E
∫ I [ G[ = ∫I [ G[ XQGH[∈DE
D
Q[

Q
E E
6HREVHUY F I [ G[ =
∫ I [ G[ ≠ UH]XOW F SXWHPIRORVLGLQQRX
∫
[
Q + D

SXQFWXODDOSUREOHPHLSHQWUXLQWHUYDOXO>[E@J úL N = úLRE LQHP
Q −
[

E
∫ I [ G[ = I [ G[ XQGH[∈[E
∫
[
Q − [

3URFHGHXOFRQWLQX ODIHOúLRE LQHP

[ E
∫ I [G[ = ∫ I [G[ XQGH[∈[E
[ Q − [
úDPGÌQILQDO
[Q E
∫ I [ G[ = ∫ I [ G[ XQGH[Q∈[QE
[ Q − [Q
'LQ UHOD LLOH « Q UH]XOW F H[LVW SXQFWHOH
[ [ [ Q ∈ (D E )DVWIHOvQFkW
[ [

E E
I [ G[ = I [ G[ = = I [ G[ = I [ G[

∫
D
∫
[
∫
[
Q + D∫

35(*à7,5($
2/,03,$'(/25ì&2/$5(

352%/(0('(*,01$=,8

2** VL LFHOPDLPLFS WUDWSHUIHFW
DPDLPDUHGHFkW
EPDLPDUHGHFkW
6 VHDUDWHF GDF DPDIODWFHOPDLPLFS WUDWSHUIHFWPDLPDUHGHFkWQ
SXWHPDIODFHOPDLPLFS WUDWSHUIHFWPDLPDUHGHFkWQSULQPD[LPvQPXO
LUL
7UDLDQ3UHGD

2*6 VHGHWHUPLQHDEF ∈^`úLPQS ∈^«`úWL
LQGF
D E F
D + + =

P Q S
E + + =

,OLH'LDFRQX&OXM1DSRFD

2*8QXLWULXQJKL$%&RDUHFDUHvLDVRFLHPXQWULSOHWGHSXQFWH/01
%/ &0 $1
QRWDW3N$%&DVWIHOvQFkW/ ∈%&0 ∈$&1 ∈$%úL N
/& 0$ 1%
= =
6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HF 3N (3W ($%&)) = 3W (3N ($%&))
%RJGDQ,RQL úL7LWX=YRQDUX%XFXUHúWL

2*ÌQWULXQJKLXOGUHSWXQJKLF$%&$ °FX$'vQ O LPHDGLQ$
GXFHPELVHFWRDUHOH >$( >$)DOHXQJKLXULORU&$'UHVSHFWLY%$'( ∈&'
DULD ($%& )
)∈'%6 VHDUDWHF ≥ +
DULD ($() )

2*6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HF HFXD LD
[ − [ =
QXDUHVROX LL[\∈1[1
'DPLDQ&RQVWDQWLQ

2*6 VHUH]ROYHvQ1 [1 HFXD LD
([ + \ ) [ + \ + [ + \ − =
( )( )
3$OH[DQGUHVFX

2*6 VHGHWHUPLQHIXQF LDI5→5 I [ = D[ + E[ + F DVWIHOvQFkW
I [ + \ = I [ + I \ + [\ ∀[\∈=

2* 'DF [ ∈ 5 DVWIHO vQFkW [ − [ + [ − = V VH DUDWH F
 
[ ∈  
 
'DQ1HGHLDQX

352%/(0('(/,&(8

2/6HFRQVLGHU QXPHUHOHSR]LWLYH[[«[QQ ≥SUHFXPúLQX
PHUHOHDEGHDVHPHQHDSR]LWLYH6 VHDUDWHF
E  E   E   E
Q
 D +  D +  D +  ≥  D + Q 

 [  [   [Q   V
XQGHV [[«[Q
,&'U JKLFHVFX

2/ )LH QXPHUHOH UHDOH D D D Q (Q > ) DVWIHO vQFkW SHQWUX RULFDUH
Q±GLQWUHHOHVXPDORUHVWHPDLPDUHGHFkWQXP UXOU PDV6 VHDUDWHF
D D D Q D + D + + D Q
+ + ≥
− D + D + + D Q D − D + + D Q D + D + − D Q Q−
+
,&'U JKLFHVFX

2/7ULXQJKLXO$%&HVWHHFKLODWHUDOGDF úLQXPDLGDF
D + E + F = S 5U
$XUHO'RERúDQ/XJRM

2/3HQWUXILHFDUHQXP UQDWXUDO[ILH6[VXPDFLIUHORUOXL['HPRQ
VWUD LF H[LVW RPXO LPHLQILQLW GHQXPHUHQDWXUDOHQRWDW FX0FXSURSULHW
LOH
D∀[∈0 6 [ + 6 [ = 6 [
( )

E ∀[ ∈0DYkQGQFLIUHQ ∈1Q ≥DQ±DFLIU DOXL[[[IRU
PHD] RSURJUHVLHDULWPHWLF
*DEULHO'RVSLQHVFXHOHY2QHúWL

2/6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HF RULFDUHDUILQXPHUHOHUHDOHVWULFWSR]LWLYH[
[«[QQ!HVWHDGHY UDW LQHJDOLWDWHD
 Q 
 [L  Q
∑
Q  L =  [ L ∑
 L ≠ M  ≤ Q L =
∑
 Q  Q
M=
 [L  ∑ [L ∑
 L =  L =
 L≠ M 
2JHQHUDOL]DUHDSUREOHPHL2GLQ*0

Q
2/)LH α L ≥ L = Q FX ∑α L = úL D L M > M = P L = Q $WXQFL
L =
Q P P Q
αL
D L M ∑∏ (D )
  M α L
∏∑
L =

 M=


≥
M= L =
L
 

3$OH[DQGUHVFX65 GXOHVFX

2/)LHSDWUXODWHUXOFRQYH[$%&'úLFHUFXULOHGHGLDPHWUH&'$'
1RW PFXWGOXQJLPHDWDQJHQWHLFRPXQH$QDORJRE LQHPWDWEWF6 VHDUDWHF
W D + W E + W F + W G = () + ($% + &' ) ⇔ $%&'HVWHFLUFXPVFULSWLELO

( )
XQGH(úL)VXQWPLMORDFHOHGLDJRQDOHORU$&úL%'
$QGUHL&KLWHúHOHY%XFXUHúWL

352%/(0(352386(

&/$6(/(,±,9
ÌQWURFODV VXQWHOHYLúLE QFL'DF VDUDúH]DFkWHHOHYLvQEDQF
HOHYLDUU PkQHvQSLFLRDUHLDUGDF VDUDúH]DFkWHvQEDQF QDUDYHDORF
&k LHOHYLúLFkWHE QFLVXQW"
vQY9LUJLQLD&LRDE 6ODWLQD
6 VH GHWHUPLQH QXP UXO $ = [\]W úWLLQG F VXQW vQGHSOLQLWH VLPXOWDQ
FRQGL LLOH
D6XPDFLIUHORUQXP UXOXL$HVWH
E)LHFDUHFLIU HVWHFXPDLPDUHGHFkWFHDDQWHULRDU
vQY7XGRUL D'RLQD6W QFXOHVFX
3URGXVXODGRX QXPHUHQDWXUDOHHVWH'DF VHP UHúWHGHvQPXO LWXO
FXSURGXVXOGHYLQH6 VHDIOHFHOHGRX QXPHUH
8QQXP UDGXQDWFXVIHUWXOV XHVWHHJDOFX&DUHHVWHQXP UXO"
,RQX DUHQXFL2DQDDUHúLHDQXFLGDUPDLSX LQHGHFkW5DUHúLDU5D
UHúDUHWRWDWkWHDQXFLFkWHDUH2DQDúL,RQX ODXQORF&kWHQXFLDUSXWHDDYHDvQ
WRWDOFHLWUHLFRSLL"
vQY%RGHD5RGLFD7XUGD
'HWHUPLQD LQXPHUHOHQDWXUDOHQDVWIHOvQFkWQXPHUHOH $ = − ( + Q )
úL% Q±V ILHQDWXUDOHLDU$%
vQY'LQX*KHRUJKL D
)LHDEFQXPHUHQDWXUDOHDVWIHOvQFkWDE úLDE±F
$IOD LYDORDUHDQXP UXOXLDEF
vQY'LQX*KHRUJKL D

&/$6$$9$
9$U WD LF QXH[LVW QXPHUHQDWXUDOHFDUHvPS U LWHODV GHDUHVWXO
úLvPS U LWHODV GHDUHVWXO
*K&ULVWHVFX
9&kWHQXPHUHGHIRUPD D D VXQWGLYL]LELOHFX"
*K&ULVWHVFX
9D6 VHDUDWHF 6HVWHQXP UQDWXUDOS WUDWSHUIHFWúWLLQGF 6UHSUH
]LQW VXPDGLYL]RULORUQXP UXOXL

1
E6LPSOLILFD LIUDF LD XQGH1UHSUH]LQW QXP UXOGLYL]RULORUQXP UX
6
OXL
*K*LXUJLX'HM
90HGLDDULWPHWLF DQXPHUHHVWHùWLLQGF PHGLDDULWPHWLF D
GLQWUHHOHHVWHV VHDIOHPHGLDDULWPHWLF DFHORUODOWHGRX QXPHUH
9,YDQ
93URGXVXODGRX QXPHUHQDWXUDOHGLIHULWHGHHVWHLDUFPPGF
DOORUHVWH$IOD LFHOHGRX QXPHUH
3RSD2OJD%XFXUHúWL
9 2 SRSXOD LH GH EDFWHULL VH GXEOHD] OD ILHFDUH RU 'H FkWH RUL VD
PXOWLSOLFDWODRUH"
3RSWHDQ$QGUHHDHOHY %XFXUHúWL
9$QDHVWHPDLPDUHGHFkW3DXOFDUHHVWHPDLPDUHGHFkW0DULD(YDHV
WHPDLPDUHGHFkW3DXO,RDQDHVWHPDLPLF GHFkW$QDúLPDLPDUHGHFkW(YD
&DUHHVWHFHOGHDOWUHLOHDvQRUGLQHDYkUVWHL"
3RSWHDQ$QGUHHDHOHY %XFXUHúWL

&/$6$$9,$
9, ùWLLQG F QXPHUHOH [ \ \ ] [ ] VXQW GLUHFW SURSRU LRQDOH FX
QXPHUHOHúLLDU[\] V VHDUDWHF [\]
*K&ULVWHVFX
9,3XQFWHOH$2&VXQWFROLQLDUHÌQDFHODúLVHPLSODQVHGXFVHPLGUHS
WHOH>2%úL>2'SHUSHQGLFXODUHDVWIHOvQFkW>2'HVWHLQWHULRDU XQJKLXOXL$2%
'DF >2(HVWHvQVHPLSODQXORSXVFX>2%P
(2& °úLGDF VHPLGUHS
WHOH>20úL>21VXQWELVHFWRDUHOHXQJKLXULORU%2&úL$2(DU WD LF SXQFWHOH
021VXQWFROLQLDUH
*K&ULVWHVFX

9, 1XPHUHOH D E F VXQW GLUHFW SURSRU LRQDOH FX QXPHUHOH úL

ùWLLQGF DEF V VHFDOFXOH]H D + E − F
9,YDQ
9,ÌQWULXQJKLXO$%&ELVHFWRDUHD>$'DXQJKLXOXL$' ∈%&vQWkO
QHúWH SDUDOHOD SULQ & OD $% vQ ( 'HPRQVWUD L F ∆$&( HVWH LVRVFHO 'DF
P
%$& °DIOD LP VXULOHXQJKLXULORU∆$&(
9,YDQ
D
9,'DF = DIOD L[GLQUHOD LD
E

E − D ([ − )

D + E
⋅ =
$GLúRU1LVWRU

&/$6$$9,,$
D D + E −
9,,6 VHGHWHUPLQHQXP UXO úWLLQGF
E E
=
0*k
9,,)LHWULXQJKLXO$%&úLSXQFWHOH'( ∈%&DVWIHOvQFkW%' '(
(&3ULQ'úL(GXFHPSDUDOHOHODODWXULOH$%UHVSHFWLY$&6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HF
SXQFWXOGHLQWHUVHF LHDOSDUDOHOHORUHVWHFHQWUXOGHJUHXWDWHDOWULXQJKLXOXL$%&
&ULVWLQD,FKLP
9,,6HG WULXQJKLXOGUHSWXQJKLF$%&FXP
% °$& FPúL
$% FP6HSUHOXQJHúWH>%&@FX>&'@DVWIHOvQFkW>%&@ >&'@úL>$%@FX
>%(@DVWIHOvQFkW>%(@ >$%@
D$IOD LDULD∆$('
E$U WD LF >$'@ >'(@
9,YDQ
9,,&DOFXOD LPHGLLOHDULWPHWLF JHRPHWULF úLDUPRQLF DQXPHUHORU[

úL\XQGH [ = + ⋅ − \ = ⋅ ⋅ ⋅
−

2UGRQD LFUHVF WRUYDORULOHFHORUWUHLPHGLLRE LQXWH

&ULVWLQD*RGHDQX
9,,D&DOFXOD LSULPHOHGRX FLIUHDOHQXP UXOXL
E&DOFXOD LSULPHOHGRX FLIUHDOHQXP UXOXL
00DWURVHQFR
9,,6 VHDUDWHF (Q + )(Q + ) ∈5±4
0DULD0DWURVHQFR
9,,$U WD LF Q + Q + ∈5?4∀Q∈1
'RLQD0DULD1LVWRU
9,,6HG ( [ = [ (− ) [∈=
[
D* VL L[∈=SHQWUXFDUH (([ +) + (([ −) =

E&DOFXOD L ( + ( + + (
F6 VHDIOH[∈=DVWIHOvQFkW ( + ( + + ( [ =
*K&ULVWHVFX

&/$6$$9,,,$
9,,,)LH9$%&'RSLUDPLG SDWUXODWHU UHJXODW FXYkUIXOvQ93XQFWH
OH01345úL6VXQWPLMORDFHOHVHJPHQWHORU>9$@>9%@>9&@>9'@>%&@
úLUHVSHFWLY>$'@
D$U WD LF 01__$%13__$%&013__$%&92⊂965
E'DF >$%@ >95@FDOFXOD LP
9634
F'DF vQSOXV 92 = 2HVWHFHQWUXOS WUDWXOXL$%&'FDOFXOD LDULD
∆9$&úLGLVWDQ DGHODSXQFWXO6ODSODQXO9%&
*K&ULVWHVFX
9,,,5RPEXO$%&'FXP
$ °úLG$%&' FPVHURWHúWHvQ
MXUXOGLDJRQDOHL$&RE LQkQGXVHFRUSXO&úLvQMXUXOODWXULL$'RE LQkQGXVH
FRUSXO&&RPSDUD LYROXPHOHFHORUGRX FRUSXUL
&ULVWLQD*RGHDQX
9,,,'HWHUPLQD LED]HOHGHQXPHUD LHFRQVHFXWLYH[úL\úWLLQGF
[ + \ =
*KHRUJKH*LXUJLX'HM
9,,,6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HF SHQWUXRULFHQ∈5)QQXVHVLPSOLILF SULQ
Q − Q − Q +
) Q =
Q − Q + Q − Q +
'DPLDQ&RQVWDQWLQHOHY/LFHXOGH,QIRUPDWLF %XFXUHúWL
9,,, 6 VH GHWHUPLQH QXPHUHOH UHDOH D úL E DVWIHO FD VLVWHPXO
D [ − D\ = − D
V DGPLW QXPDLVROX LD[ \
E[ + ( − E )\ = + D

0&KLUL

&/$6$$,;$
,;6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HF QXH[LVW QLFLRSHUHFKHDEDE ∈1 DVWIHO
vQFkWHFXD LLOH [ + D[ = E úL [ + E[ = D V DGPLW U G FLQLvQWUHJL
0&KLUL
,;6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HLGHQWLWDWHD
VLQ(D + E ) − VLQ(D − F )FRV(D + F ) − VLQ(E + F ) =
D−E E−F
VLQ(D + E )VLQ − VLQ(E + F )VLQ

,OLH3HWUH,DPERU

,;'HWHUPLQD LYDORULOHOXL[SHQWUXFDUH
 [[ ]   [[ ]
 + {[} +  + {[} = [

   
XQGH>@HVWHSDUWHDvQWUHDJ LDU^`SDUWHDIUDF LRQDU
SURI$XUHO'RERúDQ/XJRM

,;)LHI5 →5 (I $ I ) [ = + [ − [ ∀[ ∈5$U WD LF H[LVW

FHOSX LQXQ[∈5DVWIHOvQFkWI[ [
,;'DF Q∈1Q≥V VHUH]ROYHHFXD LD
[[ ] + [ + N  = ⋅ [Q[ ]+
Q −
∑ N =  Q
'0% WLQH X*LXUJLX
,; )LH D E F WUHL QXPHUH QDWXUDOH SULPH DVWIHO vQFkW HFXD LD
D[ − E[ + F = DUHU G FLQLOHIUDF LRQDUH6 VHDUDWHF
(FXD LD D[ − E[ + F = DUHRVLQJXU U G FLQ vQWUHDJ
&HO SX LQ XQXO GLQ QXPHUHOH D úL F HVWH HJDO FX úL FHO SX LQ XQXO GLQ
E −
QXPHUHOHE±úL HVWHQXP USULP

1LFRODH3DSDFX6ORER]LD
,;)LH&&GRX FHUFXULRUWRJRQDOHúL0XQXOGLQSXQFWHOHGHLQWHUVHF
LH7UHLGUHSWHYDULDELOHFHWUHFSULQ0WDLHFHUFXULOH&úL&vQSXQFWHOH$%
&'UHVSHFWLY()1RW P3 $& ∩%)4 $( ∩%'6 VHDUDWHF 34 ⊥
$%
SURI$90LKDL
,; 6 VH GHWHUPLQH WRDWH WULSOHWHOH GH QXPHUH VWULFW SR]LWLYH D E F FX
SURSULHW LOH
LDEF
LL∃[∈5 DVWIHOvQFkW
(D[ + E) + (E[ + F ) + (F[ + D ) − = [

F[ + E[ + D D[ + F[ + E E[ + D[ + F

[ + [ +

'RVSLQHVFX*DEULHOHOHY2QHúWL
,;3HODWXULOH%&&$úL$%DOHWULXQJKLXOXL$%&FRQVLGHU PSXQFWHOH
%' &( $)
'(UHVSHFWLY)DVWIHOvQFkW )LH0XQSXQFWVLWXDWSHVHJPHQ
'& ($ )%
= =
WXO()úLQRW P1 $0∩%&
D6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HF $0 01GDF úLQXPDLGDF $)≡)%VDX)0≡0(

E'DF $0HVWHPHGLDQ vQWULXQJKLXO$()DWXQFLSXQFWXO1HVWHL]RWR
PLFXOSXQFWXOXL'VLPHWULFXOOXL'ID GHPLMORFXOODWXULL%&
,;6 VHUH]ROYHHFXD LD [[ ] = [ [ ]
9ODG0DULQD
&/$6$$;$
;6 VHUH]ROYHHFXD LD [ + [ = [ ([ + )
0&KLUL úL03LWLFDUL
;6 VHUH]ROYHHFXD LD + + + + = [ + [ + + [
[ [ [ [
;6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HF H[LVW RLQILQLWDWHGHSHUHFKL[\ ∈1 ×1
DVWIHOvQFkW [ = + \
'0% WLQH X*LXUJLX
;'HWHUPLQD LIXQF LLOHI1 →1 FDUHYHULILF FRQGL LLOH
Q
N + Q (Q + )
D ∑ ∀Q∈1
I N I N I Q
=
N = + +
EHFXD LDI[ DUHFHOSX LQRVROX LHvQQXPHUHQDWXUDOH
1LFRODH3DSDFX6ORER]LD
;)LH013456PLMORDFHOHPXFKLLORU%&$'$%&'$&%'

DOHWHWUDHGUXOXL$%&'6 VHDUDWHF 9 $%&' ≤ 01 ⋅ 34 ⋅ 56

65 GXOHVFX
Q
; )LH DD«DQ ∈ & FX |DM| M = Q ∑D M = úL ∑D D M N =
M= ≤ M< N ≤ Q
$WXQFL
Q
L ∑ ]−D
M=
M ≥ Q ∀Q∈&
LL ∑ ] −D M ⋅ ] − D N ≥ & Q
≤ M< N ≤ Q
65 GXOHVFX3$OH[DQGUHVFX
;ùLUXO {E Q }Q ≥ HVWHGHILQLWSULQUHOD LD + EQ − = + ⋅ EQ − − SHQWUX
E Q −
RULFHQXP UQDWXUDOQQ ≥úLE ≠6HFHUHV VHJ VHDVF SULPXOWHUPHQDO

úLUXOXLGDF H[LVW S∈1S≥DVWIHOvQFkW

 Q  S −
 E N  ⋅ = ORJ  + ( −
 6 VHDIOHDSRLE
E
)
 
∑
 N =  S  
*DEULHO'RVSLQHVFXHOHY2QHúWL
;6 VHUH]ROYHvQ5HFXD LD [ + [
[ (− [ )
= [ +
'0% WLQH X*LXUJLX
; )LH QXPHUHOH D = + E = − úL Q ∈1 Q ! 1RW P FX
6 Q = D Q + E Q úL7Q DQ±EQ6 VHDUDWHF
6Q = 6Q − − 6Q −
7 = 6 + 7
,OLH3HWUH,DPERU

&/$6$$;,$
;,6HG úLUXO (D Q )Q ≥ FXSURSULHWDWHDF (Q + ) D Q + − Q D Q = Q N ∀Q∈

∈1 N ∈16 VHGHWHUPLQHNPD[LPSHQWUXFDUHH[LVW OLP D Q úLHVWHILQLW

Q→∞
DSRLV VHDIOHOLPLWD
SURI$XUHO'RERúDQ
Q

;,'DF [ Q = ∑ WJ Q + N V VHFDOFXOH]H OLP Q([ Q − OQ )
Q →∞
N =
'0% WLQH X*LXUJLX
Q
;, 6H úWLH F úLUXO DQQ≥ DQ ±πOQ Q VLQ HVWH FRQYHUJHQW FX
π
N =
∑ Q
OLP D Q = D ∈56 VHFDOFXOH]H OLP Q (D Q − D )
Q →∞ Q→∞
'0% WLQH X*LXUJLX
;,)LH (D Q )Q ≥ (E Q )Q ≥ GRX úLUXULGHQXPHUHUHDOHDVWIHOvQFkWEQHVWH
FRQYHUJHQWúLvQSOXV D Q + − D Q ≤ E Q + − E Q ∀Q ∈16 VHDUDWHF DQQ≥DUH
OLPLW vQ 5
6RULQ5 GXOHVFX
;,6 VHGHWHUPLQHIXQF LDI5 →±FRQWLQX vQWUXQSXQFWúLFDUH
I [ + I \
vQGHSOLQHúWHFRQGL LD I ([ + \ ) =
+ I [ I \
6RULQ5 GXOHVFX

;,'HWHUPLQD LIXQF LDLQGHILQLWGHULYDELO I5→5úWLLQGF I
[
∀[ ∈5I
I
úLI ±DSRLFDOFXOD L I − úL I − XQGHI

( ) ( )
HVWHLQYHUVDIXQF LHLI
Q −
$ N
;,)LHGDWúLUXO [ Q = (− ) Q≥
N − Q
N =
∑ (N + )
D6 VHDUDWHF úLUXOHVWHP UJLQLW
E 6 VH VWXGLH]H FRQYHUJHQ D úLUXOXL úL vQ FD] DILUPDWLY V VH GHWHUPLQH
OLP [ Q
Q→∞
3RSD$UWKXU0DULXV
;,)LHIJ5 →5FRQWLQXHDVWIHOvQFkW J(I ([ )) = [ $WXQFLIúLJVXQW
ELMHFWLYH

&/$6$$;,,$
;,,)LHD!3H* ∞VHLQWURGXFHOHJHDGHFRPSR]L LH
[ ∗ \ = ORJD [( D − )( D − )+ ]
[ \
$U WD LF
L*HVWHSDUWHVWDELO vQUDSRUWFX³ ´
LL* HVWHJUXSDEHOLDQ
( )
LLLIXQF LDI5→5 I [ = ORJD D [ + HVWHL]RPRUILVPGHJUXSXUL
$XUHO'RERúDQ
;,,'DF DEF∈ 5 + LDUI>D@ →5HVWHRIXQF LHGHULYDELO FXGH
∗
I [ − I
[
D
ULYDWDFRQWLQX V VHFDOFXOH]H ∫ EH G[

[
+ FI [
'0% WLQH X*LXUJLX
;,,)LHIJ>@→5FXSURSULHW LOH
LIJVXQWGHULYDELOHFXGHULYDWDFRQWLQX
LLI I
$WXQFL

D I
[ G[ ≥
∫

∫ [J
[ − J

[ ⋅ I [ G[
]

E(JDOLWDWHDGHODDDUHORFGDF úLQXPDLGDF I

;,,)LHI>DE@ →5DE ∈@RIXQF LHFRQWLQX &DOFXOD LOLPLWD
E
úLUXOXL (D Q )Q ≥ XQGH D Q = [ Q I [ G[
∫
D
'LQX2YLGLX*DEULHO
π
+ FRV [

;,,6 VHFDOFXOH]H G[ XQGHDE∈ 5 +
∗
∫ DH

[
+ E( + FRV [ − VLQ [ )
'0% WLQH X*LXUJLX
;,,)LHDEGRX QXPHUHUHDOHDE!6 VHDUDWHF H[LVW XQVLQJXU
QXP UUHDOP!FDUHYHULILF LQHJDOLWDWHD D P OQ E + P OQ D ≤ (D + E )OQ E
( )
3RSD$UWKXU0DULXV/LFHXO,QWHUQD LRQDO
0$*$=,10$7(0$7,&

0DUHDPDMRULWDWHDDGMHFWLYHORUQXSRVHG FDOLWDWHDSHFDUHRLQGLF DGMHF
WLYXOURúXQXHVWHURúXWRWXúLXQHOHRSRVHG GHH[HPSOXDGMHFWLYXODGMHF
WLYDO6 QXPLPDGMHFWLYHOHGHSULPXOIHOKHWHURORJLFHLDUSHFHOHGHDOGRL
OHDIHO±KRPRORJLFH+HWHURORJLFHVWHXQDGMHFWLY'HFDUHIHO":H\O

3URIHVRUXO6 SUHVXSXQHPF vQSUREOHP [HVWHQXP UXORLORU
(OHYXO'DUGRPQXOHSURIHVRUV SUHVXSXQHPF [QXHVWHQXP UXORLORU
ÌQWUHEDWILLQGSURIHVRUXO:LWWJHQVWHLQGDF DFHDVW JOXP QXDUHFXPYDXQ
DGkQFVHQVILORVRILFDFHVWDDU VSXQVF DUH

5HSXWD LDXQXLPDWHPDWLFLDQVHED]HD] SHQXP UXOGHGHPRQVWUD LLQHUHX
úLWHSHFDUHOHDI FXW0XQFDGHSLRQLHUDWHVWHGLILFLO $6%HVLFRYLWFK

('DUZLQFRQVLGHU F GLQWLPSvQWLPSWUHEXLHV HIHFWX PH[SHULPHQWHOH
FHOHPDLQHEXQHúWLGLQHOHQXUH]XOW DSURDSHQLFLRGDW QLPLFGDUGDF L]
EXWHVFUH]XOWDWHOHVXQWXOXLWRDUH
'DUZLQFkQWDODWURPERQSHQWUXODOHOHOHVDOH5H]XOWDWXODFHVWHLH[SHULHQ HD
IRVWQHJDWLY

/HXOúLRPXO8QOHXúLXQRPvQFKLúLvQWURDUHQ DXYLWH]HPD[LPHHJDOH
&HVWUDWHJLHWUHEXLHV IRORVHDVF OHXOSHQWUXDILVLJXUGHRVS XOV X"
([WUDVHGLQOXFUDUHD9DULHW LPDWHPDWLFHGH-(/LWWOHZRRG

'28 352%/(0(',675$&7,9(

n ÌQILJXUDGHPDLMRVVHFHUHXQLUHDSULQOLQLLFRQWLQXHDGUHSWXQJKLXULORU
QXPHURWDWHODIHOFXFXúLFXI U FDOLQLLOHWUDVDWHV DLE LQWHU
VHF LLúLI U V LHúLPGLQFKHQDUXOPDUH

o-RFXOGLYL]RULORU3URIHVRUXOVFULHSHWDEO XQQXP UQDWXUDOPDLPDUH
VDXHJDOFX-RFXOVHMRDF vQFROHJLLGHEDQF 3ULPXOMXF WRUVSXQHXQGL
YL]RUDOQXP UXOXLVFULVSHWDEO úLDSRLDOGRLOHDXQGLYL]RUFDUHQXHVWHPXOWL
SOXDOQXP UXOXLVSXVGHSULPXOMXF WRUúDPGUHVSHFWkQGXVHUHJXODF QLFL
XQMXF WRUQXSRDWHVSXQHXQQXP UFDUHV ILHPXOWLSOXDOXQXLQXP UVSXVDQ
WHULRU3LHUGHMXF WRUXOFDUHVSXQHSULPXOQXP UXO([HPSOX3HWDEO DSDUH
QXP UXO
3ULPXOMXF WRU
$OGRLOHDMXF WRU
$SLHUGXWDOGRLOHDMXF WRU
SURI9LFWRU9DFDULX
7$/21'(&21&856

5HGDF LD UHYLVWHL Ä$5+,0('( ´ RUJDQL]HD] SHULRGLF SHQWUX HOHYLL
UH]ROYLWRULGHSUREOHPHFRQFXUVXULGRWDWHFXXUP WRDUHOHSUHPLL
3UHPLXO,OHL
3UHPLXO,,OHL
3UHPLXO,,,OHLúL
0HQ LXQHFRQVWkQGvQDERQDPHQWHDQXDOH
7DORQXOGHFRQFXUVVHYDWULPLWHvQSOLFXOFXSUREOHPHUH]ROYDWH
&RQFXUVXOXLVHYDGHVI úXUDSHGDWDGHRFWRPEULHDSULOLHDFvQ%XFXUHúWL
&kúWLJ WRULLWUDJHULORUYRUILSXEOLFD LvQQXP UXOGLQOXQDQRLHPEULHDOUH
YLVWHL

58%5,&$5(=2/9,725,/25
'(352%/(0(

%XFXUHúWL/LFHXO*HRUJH&RúEXF6XK LDQX0RQLFDFOV9,0LKDLO
5DXOHD FOV 9, 7UDQGDILUHVFX ,ULQD FOV 9, 5RWDUX /DULVD FOV 9,,
ùHUEDQ &RUQHOLD 6LPRQD FOV 9,, RURSRF &RUQHOLD 2DQD FOV 9,,
*KHDXú2WLOLDFOV9,,+X DQX$OH[DQGUXFOV9,,ùFRDODJH
QHUDO QU+kUúWRDJ 0DUWKD&ULVWLQDFOV9,/LFHXO1,RUJD/HS U
$QD0DULDFOV9,,
&kPSXOXQJ0XVFHOùFRDOD6I,DFRE$OEXOHVFX2OJD'LDQDFOV9
3LFX*KHRUJKH'DQLHOùFRDOD1D 2SUHD,RUJXOHVFX0RJDUX*HRUJLDQD
'HQLVDFOV91HJRL$OH[DQGUD(OHQDFOV9
'HMùFRDODQU'DQFLX,RDQDFOV9,7 WDU)ORULQ$OH[DQGUX
0DUFKLú$QGUHHDFOV9,3XJQD5DUHúFOV9,,6LJKHDUW X,XOLDFOV
9,-XOD$QGUHLFOV9,,3XUGHD*HRUJLDQFOV9,%DQGH&ULVWLQD
$OH[DQGUD FOV 9,, 3HWUHDQ 'DQLHOD 2DQD FOV 9, 0DUWRQ *DEULHO
9DVLOHFOV9,,% ODQ$QFD0DULDFOV90LFOHD$QD(PDQXHODFOV
9 %HUHQGH 6HUJLX 2YLGLX FOV 9,, %RWLú 6RULQ FOV 9,, 5L
PRYHF],RDQ0LKDLFOV9,&ULúDQ&LSULDQFOV9,%RUD$QGUDGDFOV
9,,0DJGDú*DEULHOD$GULDQDFOV9&ULVWHD9ODGFOV9,&kU
SHOHDQ5DUHúFOV9&ROHJLXO1D LRQDO$QGUHL0XUHúDQ'DQD5XVXFOV
9,,,,QRFDQ/LQGDFOV9$OH[DQGUX5R[DQDFOV9,%HOGHDQ%LDQFD
FOV9
/XJRM /LFHXO ,XOLD +DVGHX 3HWUX HVFX %RJGDQ FOV 9,,
3URWRSRSHVFX& OLQFOV96XE LUH5R[DQD'HQLVDFOV9

180(/(ù,35(180(/((/(98/8, BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

ù&2$/$$'5(6$ù&2/,,7(/()21 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
&/$6$BBBBBBBBB-8'( 8/BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB25$ù8/ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
7(/()218/(/(98/8,$'5(6$(/(98/8,BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

7hruhpd: + (Q (Q (+ ( (Q Q Q

Diunggah oleh

Informasi Dokumen

Judul Asli

Hak Cipta

Format Tersedia

Bagikan dokumen Ini

Bagikan atau Tanam Dokumen

Opsi Berbagi

Apakah menurut Anda dokumen ini bermanfaat?

Apakah konten ini tidak pantas?

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia

7hruhpd: + (Q (Q (+ ( (Q Q Q

Diunggah oleh

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia

$5+,0('( V 1UPDLLXQLH

'(021675$ ,( 9RP GHPRQVWUD QXPDL D úL D

α2GDW FRQVWUXLWXQDVWIHOGHúLUGLQUHOD LDGHUHFXUHQ UH]XOW F I Q [Q

I [ ± [ HVWH FRQWLQX úL J α α ± [   J [ I [ ± [ !  úL GHFL

8UP WRDUHOHH[HPSOHLOXVWUHD] QHFHVLWDWHDFRQGL LLORUWHRUHPHL

 I [ ±[∀[∈5$WXQFL2[ I ^[±[`SHQWUX[≠úL2 I ^ 

6HRE LQHDVWIHOXUP WRUXO

&DDSOLFD LHSUH]HQW PXUP WRDUHD

DG±EF ±DULPSOLFDE G  

XQGH  < α 'HDLFLRE LQHPF

VDXGXS ULGLFDUHDODS WUDWvQDPELLPHPEUL

(S −)= ⋅ ⋅⋅ S − ⋅  S + ⋅⋅ (S − M)⋅⋅ (S − )(S −) 

≡−M PRGS GHFL

'DF SHVWHSULPS≠úLS ≡/  PRG DWXQFLS≡ PRG )LHGHFLSDVW

'HDLFLVHRE LQHUHOD LD D  − DE − E  = 

ÌQ HVWHGDW XUP WRDUHDVROX LHSHQWUXSXQFWXODOGRLOHD

'HPRQVWUD LDHVWHJUHúLW VDXFHOSX LQLQFRPSOHW 

∀ ([ Q )Q ≥ ⊂ 5H[LVW OLPI ([Q ) úLHVWHHJDO FXO

1RW P 5 ε[ = [ − Uε[ [ ε ⇒ 5 ε[ ∈ [ [ ε )úL [ = 5 ε[ + Uε[ [ ε 

GDU I ([ Q + ) = [ Q +  Q[ Q + − Q = Q +  − (Q + )[ Q + + Q[ Q + − Q =  − [ Q + úL FXP

([HPSOXO 6H G HFXD LD [  + Q  [ +  =   Q ∈ 1  6 VH DUDWH F

[ Q + = − − (Q + ) [ Q + 3HGHDOW SDUWHGLQ I ([ Q + ) = [ Q + + Q  [ Q + + 

= − − Q  [ Q + + Q[ Q + + [Q +  + Q  [ Q + +  = − (Q + )[ Q + >  GHGX

([HPSOXO (FXD LD [ Q + OQ[ =   ∀Q ∈1 DUHRVLQJXU U G FLQ [Q

DQXPH[Q∈  )LJXUkQGDYHPVLWXD LD

(FXD LDSHFDUHRYHULILF [QHVWH [ QQ ++ + OQ [ Q + =  GHFL

'DF "UH]XOW OLP [ Q =  7UHFkQGODOLPLW RE LQHP

OLP ([ QQ + OQ [ Q =  ⇔ OQ " =  FRQWUDGLF LHFX"úLGHFL" 

([HPSOXO (FXD LD [ Q + [ Q − +  + [ −  =  DUHRVLQJXU VROX LHSR]L

62/8 ,()LHIXQF LDI>∞ →5 I [ = [H[ − Q FX I

W vQ UHOD LD [ Q H [Q

HVWHQHP UJLQLWÌQILQDO OLP [ Q = +∞ 

5HOD LD YHULILFDW GH [Q HVWH H [ Q + − [ Q + =   $WXQFL [ Q < [ Q + úLUXO

  

   

⇔ ]  + ] −  \  =  ⇔ ] (] + ) = \  GHDLFLUH]XOW \QXP USDU

3URFHVXO HVWH LWHUDWLY DGLF VROX LD SDUWLFXODU (X   ]   [   \  ) JHQHUHD]

SROLQRPGHYDULDELODSR]LWLY WúLFDUHDUHWR LFRHILFLHQ LLSR]LWLYLDGLF 4 W !

$YHP (Q − ) −  = Q (Q − )([SUHVLDQ Q± XQGHQ ∈1 HVWHSUR

DUFVLQ [ + DUFFRV [ ≥  ⋅ DUFVLQ [ +DUFFRV [ 'DU D  + E  ≥

) [ =  − [  5 →  ∞  'H DLFL UH]XOW J(I [ ) = I  [ + I  [ VDX

3URFHGHXOFRQWLQX ODIHOúLRE LQHP

2UGRQD LFUHVF WRUYDORULOHFHORUWUHLPHGLLRE LQXWH

D * VL L[∈=SHQWUXFDUH (([ +) + (([ −) = 

RULFHQXP UQDWXUDOQQ ≥úLE ≠6HFHUHV VHJ VHDVF SULPXOWHUPHQDO

∈1 N ∈16 VHGHWHUPLQHNPD[LPSHQWUXFDUHH[LVW OLP D Q úLHVWHILQLW 

&/$6$BBBBBBBBB-8'( 8/BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB25$ù8/ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

Anda mungkin juga menyukai

$5+,0('( V 1UPDLLXQLH

'(021675$ ,( 9RP GHPRQVWUD QXPDL D úL D

α2GDW FRQVWUXLWXQDVWIHOGHúLUGLQUHOD LDGHUHFXUHQ UH]XOW F IQ[Q

I[ ± [ HVWH FRQWLQX úL Jα α ± [ J[ I[ ± [ ! úL GHFL

8UP WRDUHOHH[HPSOHLOXVWUHD] QHFHVLWDWHDFRQGL LLORUWHRUHPHL

I[ ±[∀[∈5$WXQFL2[I ^[±[`SHQWUX[≠úL2I ^

&DDSOLFD LHSUH]HQW PXUP WRDUHD

DG±EF ±DULPSOLFDE G

XQGH < α 'HDLFLRE LQHPF

VDXGXS ULGLFDUHDODS WUDWvQDPELLPHPEUL

(S −)= ⋅ ⋅⋅ S − ⋅  S + ⋅⋅ (S − M)⋅⋅ (S − )(S −)

≡−M PRGSGHFL

'DF SHVWHSULPS≠úLS ≡/ PRGDWXQFLS≡PRG)LHGHFLSDVW

'HDLFLVHRE LQHUHOD LD D − DE − E =

ÌQ HVWHGDW XUP WRDUHDVROX LHSHQWUXSXQFWXODOGRLOHD

'HPRQVWUD LDHVWHJUHúLW VDXFHOSX LQLQFRPSOHW

∀ ([ Q )Q ≥ ⊂ 5H[LVW OLPI ([Q ) úLHVWHHJDO FXO

1RW P 5 ε[ = [ − Uε[ [ ε ⇒ 5 ε[ ∈ [ [ ε )úL [ = 5 ε[ + Uε[ [ ε

GDU I ([ Q + ) = [ Q + Q[ Q + − Q = Q + − (Q + )[ Q + + Q[ Q + − Q = − [ Q + úL FXP

([HPSOXO 6H G HFXD LD [ + Q [ + = Q ∈ 1 6 VH DUDWH F

[ Q + = − − (Q + ) [ Q + 3HGHDOW SDUWHGLQ I ([ Q + ) = [ Q + + Q [ Q + +

= − − Q [ Q + + Q[ Q + + [Q + + Q [ Q + + = − (Q + )[ Q + > GHGX

([HPSOXO (FXD LD [ Q + OQ[ = ∀Q ∈1 DUHRVLQJXU U G FLQ [Q

DQXPH[Q∈)LJXUkQGDYHPVLWXD LD

(FXD LDSHFDUHRYHULILF [QHVWH [ QQ ++ + OQ [ Q + = GHFL

'DF "UH]XOW OLP [ Q = 7UHFkQGODOLPLW RE LQHP

OLP ([ QQ + OQ [ Q = ⇔ OQ " = FRQWUDGLF LHFX"úLGHFL"

([HPSOXO (FXD LD [ Q + [ Q − + + [ − = DUHRVLQJXU VROX LHSR]L

62/8 ,()LHIXQF LDI>∞→5 I [ = [H[ − Q FX I

HVWHQHP UJLQLWÌQILQDO OLP [ Q = +∞

5HOD LD YHULILFDW GH [Q HVWH H [ Q + − [ Q + = $WXQFL [ Q < [ Q + úLUXO

⇔ ] + ] − \ = ⇔ ] (] + ) = \ GHDLFLUH]XOW \QXP USDU

3URFHVXO HVWH LWHUDWLY DGLF VROX LD SDUWLFXODU (X ] [ \ ) JHQHUHD]

SROLQRPGHYDULDELODSR]LWLY WúLFDUHDUHWR LFRHILFLHQ LLSR]LWLYLDGLF 4W!

$YHP (Q − ) − = Q (Q − )([SUHVLDQQ±XQGHQ ∈1 HVWHSUR

DUFVLQ [ + DUFFRV [ ≥ ⋅ DUFVLQ [ +DUFFRV [ 'DU D + E ≥

) [ = − [ 5 → ∞ 'H DLFL UH]XOW J(I [ ) = I [ + I [ VDX

2UGRQD LFUHVF WRUYDORULOHFHORUWUHLPHGLLRE LQXWH

D* VL L[∈=SHQWUXFDUH (([ +) + (([ −) =

RULFHQXP UQDWXUDOQQ ≥úLE ≠6HFHUHV VHJ VHDVF SULPXOWHUPHQDO

∈1 N ∈16 VHGHWHUPLQHNPD[LPSHQWUXFDUHH[LVW OLP D Q úLHVWHILQLW