PERHITUNGAN MOMEN DENGAN METODE CROSS

Titik
Batang
Faktor Distribusi
Momen Primer
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi
Induksi
Distribusi

A
AB
0.00000
-1.67708
0.00000
0.97003
0.00000
0.13160
0.00000
-0.06478
0.00000
0.02478
0.00000
-0.01220
0.00000
0.00466
0.00000
-0.00230
0.00000
0.00088
0.00000
-0.00043
0.00000
0.00017
0.00000
-0.00008
0.00000
0.00003
0.00000
-0.00002
0.00000
0.00001
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000

BA
0.55556
2.11458
1.94007
0.00000
0.26319
0.00000
-0.12957
0.00000
0.04955
0.00000
-0.02439
0.00000
0.00933
0.00000
-0.00459
0.00000
0.00176
0.00000
-0.00086
0.00000
0.00033
0.00000
-0.00016
0.00000
0.00006
0.00000
-0.00003
0.00000
0.00001
0.00000
-0.00001
0.00000
0.00000

BC
0.44444
-5.60667
1.55202
-0.47375
0.21055
0.23322
-0.10365
-0.08919
0.03964
0.04391
-0.01951
-0.01679
0.00746
0.00827
-0.00367
-0.00316
0.00141
0.00156
-0.00069
-0.00060
0.00026
0.00029
-0.00013
-0.00011
0.00005
0.00006
-0.00002
-0.00002
0.00001
0.00001
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000

CB
0.44444
5.12667
-0.94749
0.77601
0.46644
0.10528
-0.17839
-0.05183
0.08782
0.01982
-0.03359
-0.00976
0.01653
0.00373
-0.00632
-0.00184
0.00311
0.00070
-0.00119
-0.00035
0.00059
0.00013
-0.00022
-0.00007
0.00011
0.00002
-0.00004
-0.00001
0.00002
0.00000
-0.00001
0.00000
0.00000

CD
0.55556
-2.99479
-1.18439
-1.82552
0.58307
0.29610
-0.22299
-0.14577
0.10977
0.05575
-0.04198
-0.02744
0.02067
0.01050
-0.00790
-0.00517
0.00389
0.00198
-0.00149
-0.00097
0.00073
0.00037
-0.00028
-0.00018
0.00014
0.00007
-0.00005
-0.00003
0.00003
0.00001
-0.00001
-0.00001
0.00000

D
DC
1.00000
3.65104
-3.65104
-0.59219
0.59219
0.29153
-0.29153
-0.11149
0.11149
0.05489
-0.05489
-0.02099
0.02099
0.01033
-0.01033
-0.00395
0.00395
0.00195
-0.00195
-0.00074
0.00074
0.00037
-0.00037
-0.00014
0.00014
0.00007
-0.00007
-0.00003
0.00003
0.00001
-0.00001
0.00000
0.00000

Jumlah

-0.62474

4.21926

-4.21926

5.37591

-5.37591

0.00000

Cross
-0.62474
4.21926
-4.21926
5.37591
-5.37591
0.00000

KR ( % )
0.00138
0.00036
0.00083
0.00006
0.00027
0.00000

Perbandingan Hasil Perhitungan :

Momen
AB
BA
BC
CB
CD
DC

Slope Deflection
-0.62473
4.21928
-4.21923
5.37591
-5.37589
0.00000

PERHITUNGAN DENGAN METODE CROSS

Titik

Batang

AB

B
BA

Faktor Distribusi
Momen Primer

0.4054

0.3243

0.2703

2.2083

-2.0625

-4

-0.405701754

-0.785472973

-0.628378378

-0.523648649

-0.392736486 -0.162280702

-0.202850877

-0.314189189

-0.261824324

-0.811403509

-0.324561404

0.206703414

0.082681366

0.103351707

0.162280702

0.082236842

0.065789474

0.054824561

0.314189189

0.103351707

0.081140351

0.041118421

0.041340683

0.051675853

0.157094595

0.032894737

0.027412281

-0.064346722

-0.025738689

-0.032173361 -0.041340683

-0.084636668

-0.067709335

-0.056424445

-0.032894737

-0.032173361

-0.020670341

-0.042318334 -0.012869344

-0.016086681

-0.016447368

-0.033854667

-0.028212223

0.033151934

0.013260774

0.016575967

0.012869344

0.013189479

0.010551583

0.008792986

0.033854667

0.016575967

0.006434672

0.00659474

0.006630387

0.008287984

0.016927334

0.005275792

0.004396493

-0.006857585

-0.002743034

-0.003428793 -0.006630387

-0.010222426

-0.008177941

-0.006814951

-0.005275792

-0.003428793

-0.003315193

-0.005111213 -0.001371517

-0.001714396

-0.002637896

-0.00408897

-0.003407475

0.004434951

0.00177398

0.002217475

0.001371517

0.001764443

0.001411554

0.001176295

0.00408897

0.0022

0.000685759

0.000882221

0.00088699

0.001108738

0.002044485

0.000705777

0.000588148

Distribusi

-0.000825253

-0.000330101

-0.000412626

-0.00088699

-0.001278334

-0.001022667

-0.000852222

-0.000705777

-0.000412626

-0.000443495

-0.000639167 -0.000165051

-0.000206313

-0.000352889

-0.000511333

-0.000426111

Distribusi

0.000569822

0.000227929

0.000284911

0.000165051

0.000226703

0.000181363

0.000151136

0.000511333

0.000284911

8.25253E-05

0.000113352

0.000113964

0.000142456

0.000255667

9.06814E-05

7.55678E-05

Distribusi
Induksi

-0.000103093

-4.12373E-05

-5.15466E-05 -0.000113964

-0.000161401

-0.000129121

-0.000107601

-9.06814E-05

-5.15466E-05

-5.69822E-05

-8.07005E-05 -2.06186E-05

-2.57733E-05

-4.53407E-05

-6.45604E-05

-5.38003E-05

Distribusi
Induksi

7.24646E-05

2.89858E-05

3.62323E-05

2.06186E-05

2.883E-05

2.3064E-05

1.922E-05

6.45604E-05

3.62323E-05

1.03093E-05

1.4415E-05

1.44929E-05

1.81161E-05

3.22802E-05

1.1532E-05

9.60999E-06

-1.30128E-05

-5.20512E-06

-6.5064E-06 -1.44929E-05

-2.04309E-05

-1.63448E-05

-1.36206E-05

-1.1532E-05

0.347364879

-1.305283255

-0.191579031

-3.00649683

-0.470605881

3.47710271

-4.261441835

Distribusi
Jumlah

F
FD

0.2632

-0.405701754

Induksi

Induksi

E
ED

Distribusi

Induksi

DF

0.2105

Distribusi
Induksi

DE

0.5263

Distribusi
Induksi

DB

-0.6667

Distribusi
Induksi

CB

Distribusi
Induksi

BD

0.6667

Distribusi
Induksi

BC

1.496862287

Perbandingan Hasil Perhitungan :

Momen

Slope Deflection

Cross

KR ( % )

AB

0.34736269

0.347364879

0.000629676

BA

-1.305274617

-1.305283255

0.000661813

BC

-0.1915823852

-0.191579031

0.001750544

BD

1.496857002

1.496862287

0.000353069

CB

DB

-3.00649670

-3.00649683

4.32124E-06

DE

-0.470606827

-0.470605881

0.000200945

DF

3.477103526

3.477102710

2.34662E-05

ED

FD

-4.261448237

-4.261441835

0.000150239

PERHITUNGAN MOMEN DENGAN METODE CROSS

Akibat Beban Luar

Titik
Batang
Faktor Distribusi
Momen Primer

A
AB
0
-3.55556
-1.002998737

-0.018078512

-0.001232626

-8.40427E-05

Jumlah

-4.57795

B
BA
0.45455
3.11111
-2.00600

-0.03616

-0.00247

-0.00017

1.06649

C
BC
0.54545
1.30208
-2.40720
0.07955

CB

CD

0.5
-2.86458
-1.20360
0.15909

-0.04339
0.00542

-0.02169
0.01085

-0.00296
0.00037

-0.00148
0.00074

-0.00020
2.52128E-05

-0.00010
5.04256E-05

-1.06630

-3.92073

0.5
3.75
0.15909
0
0.01085
0
0.00074
0
5.04256E-05
0
3.92073

Akibat Goyangan
Titik
Batang
Faktor Distribusi
Momen Primer

A
AB
0
-0.083333333
-0.021969697

-0.028770661

-0.001961636

-0.000133748

Jumlah

-0.13617

B
BA
0.45455
-0.08333
-0.04394

-0.05754

-0.00392

-0.00027

-0.18900

C
BC
0.54545
0.18
-0.05273
0.12659

CB
0.5
-0.18
-0.02636
0.25318

-0.06905
0.00863

-0.03452
0.01726

-0.00471
0.00059

-0.00235
0.00118

-0.00032
0.00004

-0.00016
0.00008

0.18904

0.02830

CD
0.5
-0.3
0.25318
0.00000
0.01726
0.00000
0.00118
0.00000
0.00008
0.00000
-0.02830

CROSS

D
DC
0
-3.75
0.079545455
0
0.005423554
0
0.000369788
0
2.52128E-05
0
-3.66464

D
DC
0
-0.3
0.12659
0
0.00863
0
0.00059
0
4.01244E-05
0
-0.16415