Anda di halaman 1dari 51

The Gender Agenda: Making HIV Responses Work for Key Affected Women and Girls Workshop Report

21-22 September 2012 Bangkok, Thailand

ABOUT UNZIP THE LIPS


UNZIP is a group of individuals and organisations working for the rights and meaningful participation of key affected women and girls in the context of HIV and its intersections with other gender issues in Asia and the Pacific It is intended to offer a safe and inclusive space for dialogue for multiple stakeholders. It is a platform that grew out of the organizing of the 10th ICAAP and was being galvanised by 7Sisters together with supporting partners and activists across the region to articulate the needs of KAWG. With the support of several engaged institutions and individuals, coordinated by the Asia Pacific Alliance for Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights (APA) as a temporary legal agent, together with the Asia Pacific Council of AIDS Service Organizations (APCASO) and the Asia Pacific Resource and Research Centre for Women (ARROW), a workshop was organised to engage and mobilise support from other organisations and individuals who share our commitment to making the voices of women and girls, particularly those most at risk and most affected by HIV, heard in national and regional AIDS responses. Supporting Partners

Visit our website to find out more information and access resources:

www.unzipthelips.org
CONTACT US If you have stories, resources or other information to share with the community, please email us at unzip@unzipthelips.org To find out more about becoming a supporting partner of Unzip the Lips, please write to partners@unzipthelips.org

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Unzip the Lips platform launched an advocacy Workshop on 21-22 September, 2012 in Bangkok, Thailand to strengthen the capacity of civil society organisations (CSO) who work in the Asia Pacific region to more effectively address the needs of key affected women and girls (KAWG) in the context of HIV and its intersections with other gender issues. Specifically, the workshop aimed to: increase the understanding on and mobilise support for the issues of key affected women and girls among national and regional HIV and AIDS networks develop policy recommendations by community and civil society organisations on key affected women and girls, including on intimate partner transmission of HIV map out potential advocacy strategy opportunities where advocates can deliver key messages and call attention to current critical issues affecting key affected women and girls, including at the UN Regional Consultation on HIV and KAWG in the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) region, as well as at various national, regional, and global events in 20122013 strengthen civil society participation at various national, region, and global policymaking forums and events in 2012-2013. Civil society representatives from across the Asia Pacific region joined the advocacy discussion around the theme The Gender Agenda: Making HIV Responses Work for Key Affected Women and Girls. Countries represented included Australia, Cambodia, India, Indonesia, Lao PDR, Malaysia, Myanmar, Philippines, Thailand, and Vietnam. The workshop was part of an activity for 2012 of the Unzip the Lips, a platform for articulating the needs of key affected women and girls in the Asia and Pacific region. To date, this is an informal discussion space with the support of several engaged institutions and individuals. The workshop was coordinated by the Asia Pacific Alliance for Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights (APA) together with the Asia Pacific Council of AIDS Service Organizations (APCASO) and the Asia Pacific

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

Resource and Research Centre for Women (ARROW) and hoped to engage and mobilise support from other organisations and individuals who share their commitment to making the voices of women and girls, particularly those most at risk and most affected by HIV, heard in national and regional AIDS responses. Process / methodology To ensure that the workshop is an enabling space to surface and talk about the issues of key affected women and girls, APA, APCASO and ARROW had an intensive series of online preparatory meetings. With importance equally put on both content and processes, the workshop was designed to have as much involvement from different constituenciesfrom developing the content and programme, to facilitating and resourcing sessionsas possible. Most significant outcomes The participants evaluated the workshop as having mainly achieved its objectives overall. As a result of the workshop, Unzip now has, among others: (i) a wider base of supporters from the region, (ii) clarity and consensus on the definition of who are key affected women and girls., (iii) clarity and consensus on the definition of intimate partner transmission, (iv) a clearer understanding of cross-cutting as well as community-specific issues of key affected women and girls, (v) a clearer idea of how to move forward as a network both in terms of advocacy and governance, and (vi) a fresh set of Temporary Advisory Committee (TAC) members who will coordinate and facilitate joint actions and decision-making from the group for the networks future.

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ACRONYMS WORKSHOP REPORT 1. INTRODUCTION 2. THE WORKSHOP
2.1 A Voice for Women and Girls: Opening Remarks 2.2 Who are Key Affected Women and Girls? 2.3 A Community Dialogue on Intimate Partner Transmission 2.4 Advocacy Strategising and KAWG Messaging 2.5 Getting to Know ASEAN 2.6 UNZIP Strategy: The Way Forward

3. RECOMMENDATIONS ANNEXES Annex Annex Annex Annex Annex Annex Annex A: Agenda B: Participants List C: Keynote Speeches D: Workshop Resources E: Workshop Evaluation Report F: Unzip the Lip Advocacy Events Mapping G: Our Call to ASEAN

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

Acknowledgements
On behalf of the Unzip the Lips platform, the Asia Pacific Alliance for Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights (APA) is grateful to the Joint Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS) and The ASEAN Foundation for their generous financial contribution to the project Setting Priorities for Key Affected Women and Girls in Asia Pacific and Intersections with HIV: Civil Society-Led Strategies for UNZIP the Lips, which this workshop was part of. With additional support from the Japanese Government, we are thankful we were able to bring the UNZIP message to more stakeholders. This effort has been conducted with support from the Regional UN Interagency Task Team (IATT) on Women, Girls, Gender Equality, whose representatives consist of the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS), the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA), the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF), and The United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women (UN Women). Our thanks and appreciation likewise goes to all those who have contributed to making the Workshop a success: all participants, speakers, and panelists, meeting organisers and facilitators and development partners. Lastly, we wish to acknowledge people who have, from the beginning, supported Unzip the Lips, believed passionately in its cause and generously contributed their valuable time, minds and energies to keep it going: Rachel Arinii Judhistari, Vince Crisostomo, Frieda Lee, Dean Lewis, Kirenjit Kaur, Rose Koenders, Rodelyn Marte, Katy Pullen, and Jane Wilson.

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

ACRONYMS
ACW AICHR ASEAN ATFOA CSO HIV/AIDS ICAAP IPT GBV KAWG KAP Laos PDR MSM PLHIV PUD SOGI SRHR STI UN UNAIDS UNDP UNESCAP UNESCO UNFPA UNICEF UN Women VCCT ASEAN Committee on Women ASEAN Intergovernmental Commission on Human Rights Association of Southeast Asian Nations ASEAN Task Force on AIDS Civil Society Organisations Human Immunodeficiency Virus infection / Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome International Congress in AIDS in the Asia and the Pacific Intimate Partner Transmission Gender-based violence Key Affected Women and Girls Key Affected Populations Lao Peoples Democratic Republic Men who have sex with men People Living with HIV/AIDS People who Use Drugs Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights Sexual Transmitted Infections United Nations Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS United Nations Development Programme United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization United Nations Population Fund United Nations Children's Fund United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women Voluntary and Confidential Counseling and Testing

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

WORKSHOP REPORT
1. INTRODUCTION

The Unzip the Lips platform launched an advocacy Workshop on 21-22 September, 2012 in Bangkok, Thailand to strengthen the capacity of civil society organisations (CSO) who work in the Asia Pacific region to more effectively address the needs of key affected women and girls (KAWG) in the context of HIV and its intersections with other gender issues. Civil society representatives from across the Asia Pacific region joined the advocacy discussion on The Gender Agenda: Making HIV Responses Work for Key Affected Women and Girls. Countries represented included Australia, Cambodia, India, Indonesia, Lao PDR, Malaysia, Myanmar, Philippines, Thailand, and Vietnam. Unzip the Lips is an informal group of individuals and organisations who are galvanised by the opportunity to provide a voice for key affected groups of women and girls in the HIV epidemic in the region of Asia and the Pacific. The Unzip the Lips platform was formed prior to the 10th International Congress in AIDS in the Asia and the Pacific (ICAAP10) in Busan, the Republic of Korea, in August 2011. Various events to advance the gender agenda have taken place, including a gender side event at the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (UNESCAP) High Level Intergovernmental Meeting (HLM) on the Assessment of Progress against Commitments in the Political Declaration on HIV/AIDS and the MDGs, held in February 2012. The goals of this event were to advocate for national and regional leadership and commitment for effective strategies and interventions for addressing HIV/AIDS related gender inequalities, with a focus on key affected women and girls; and to identify and discuss good practices and models for addressing the needs and rights of key affected women and girls for HIV prevention, treatment and care services. Thus, in the context of the growing momentum in the Asia Pacific region, this Workshop sought to facilitate advocacy dialogue on issues related to KAWG and define a collaborative approach to ensure future policy responses are sensitive to KAWG. The workshop objectives were as follows: To increase the understanding on and mobilise support for the issues of key affected women and girls among national and regional HIV and AIDS networks To develop policy recommendations by community and civil society organisations on key affected women and girls, including on intimate partner transmission of HIV To map out potential advocacy strategy opportunities where advocates can deliver key messages and call attention to current critical issues affecting key affected women and girls, including at the UN Regional Consultation on HIV and KAWG in the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN)

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

region, as well as at various national, regional, and global events in 20122013 To strengthen civil society participation at various national, region, and global policymaking forums and events in 2012-2013. This report seeks to provide a summary of the key action items and outcomes from the Unzip the Lips Workshop. The report contains live links to websites, news articles, and presentations from the Workshop. We hope that through the collective energy and collaboration of all the supporting partners, this report can serve as a tool for increased civil society capacity and participation to support the needs of key affected women and girls in the Asia Pacific region.

Photo Credit: Rodelyn Marte

2.

THE WORKSHOP

2.1 A Voice for Women and Girls: Key Note Speeches


The opening remarks set the tone for the Workshop, highlighting the disproportionately higher levels of HIV infection for women and girls in the Asia Pacific region. Women and girls needs are often overlooked and neglected when policymakers design effective HIV responses. They deserve more opportunities to increase their individual capacity and allow them to speak out about their rights to health, equality, and dignity. Oldri Mukuan of YouthLEAD provided an inspiring opening speech documenting how the face of the HIV epidemic continues to reflect the high burden on women, specifically young
Photo Credit: Rodelyn Marte Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

women. Young women are particularly vulnerable to HIV, accounting for 64% of new infections among young people worldwide. Too often, these young womens voices go unheard, and they lose out on important opportunities to promote their rights or push for policies that ensure the realisation of their rights. She stressed the need for strong policy commitments and greater dedicated effort from the government, from the United Nations (UN) multilateral agencies and all development partners to ensure that program interventions and budget allocations target key affected women and girls, including young women living with HIV.

We are here to make our voices heard. Oldri Mukuan


Susan Paxton, representing the Asia Pacific Network of People Living with HIV (APN+) addressed the group to advocate for ways that civil society could move forward the gender agenda within the HIV response context. Women and girls are more vulnerable to HIV due to the deeply rooted gender inequalities that exist in our society, often manifesting in discrimination, abuse, stigma and gender-based violence (GBV). Unfortunately, these Photo Credit: Rodelyn Marte instances of human rights violations often go unnoticed, leaving women and girls vulnerable and unable to protect their own health and rights. However, there are programs, such as Stepping Stones which uses a participatory, rights-based approach to explore how gender issues influence behavior. Efforts such as these are important in opening up the dialogue space for gender equality. Overall, there needs to be greater attention to mobilising resources and building the leadership of and advocacy skills for women, especially young women, to speak out and advocate for themselves and their peers. With the effort of a platform like Unzip the Lips, it is no longer acceptable that womens rights are ignored or that women are denied access to health services due to their HIV status. Now is the time to hold governments accountable to uphold the rights of women and girls, to treat all women with dignity and respect, and ensure their lives are free from abuse, discrimination, and exploitation. The full text from the opening remarks can be accessed in Annex C: Key Note Speeches.

2.2 Who are Key Affected Women and Girls?

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

10

Within the context of the Asia Pacific region, five panelists presented specific challenges for key affected women and girls, highlighting the needs of sex workers, transsexuals, women and girls who use drugs, and women and girls who are HIV positive. Anastacia Ryan, from the Global Network of Sex Worker Projects, presented five main issues and problems facing sex workers, which undermine access to HIV prevention, treatment, care, and support. First, ongoing stigma and discrimination by society and health workers places sex workers at an increased risk of violence. Second, many countries criminalise some part of sex work in the absence of an enabling legal and policy environment. Third, sex workers have little to no access to sexual and reproductive health services and no support system exists for HIV positive women. Fourth, sex workers suffer violence from their intimate partners, as well as government actors like police officers. Fifth, there is a lack of meaningful participation from sex worker communities in HIV prevention campaigns. Campaigns that neglect to involve and coordinate with sex workers can results in bad policies, and even worse, failed programs. Baby Rivona, of the Indonesia Positive Womens Network, discussed how there could be no AIDS free generation without the inclusion of women and girls. In the last six years, there has been a significant rise of HIV prevalence in female populations. In particular, women often do not understand how to advocate for their sexual and reproductive health and rights (SRHR), lack comprehensive health information, suffer from unequal power relationships, and lack meaningful participation in policy

Photo Credit: Rodelyn Marte

discussions. Additionally, for women who are HIV positive, they face a double stigma of being a woman and living with HIV. To improve this situation, awareness among policymakers must be raised, so that commitments to ensuring the rights of women and girls are recognised. Manis Chen, of the PT Foundation, stated that the main challenge for transsexual women in Malaysia was lack of legal recognition. Many transsexual women have no access to hormone replacement therapy, have trouble securing employment, and suffer from religious discrimination and intolerance. Many transsexual women lack community support systems, which can lead to a lack of self-acceptance, identity confusion, and low self-esteem. Building greater understanding on gender and sexuality within the wider community could have significant results in empowering transsexual women and

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

11

decreasing the stigma they face. Efforts to change the legal status for transsexual women is being pursued, and if achieved, would be a landmark legal case in Malaysia. Yvonne Sibuea, from the Asian Network of People who Use Drugs (ANPUD), presented the increasing trend of women that use stimulant drugs in the Asia Pacific region. Many women and young girls use drugs to

young girls to ensure they have the proper knowledge about these drugs. Alexa Johns, of the Asia Pacific Alliance for Sexual and Reproductive Rights (APA), presented the results from an e-consultation that collected feedback on which strategies should be prioritised to address the needs of KAWG in HIV and AIDS programmes. Respondents included networks of people living with HIV (PLHIV), people who use drugs (PUD), sex workers, transgender, and community based organisations. Many respondents noted a lack of common understanding on what populations constituted KAWG in the Asia Pacific region. The lack of access to basic human rights and health services often increased women and girls vulnerability to HIV. Respondents also noted that a funding gap prevented the full realisation of women and girls rights, as there was no financial support for womens leadership and little resources for research and development for womens programmes. Future HIV policies and programmes should meaningfully engage KAWG populations and invest in strengthening their leadership at the national, regional, and global levels. For young KAWG, an even greater focus needs to ensure increased awareness about safe sex, STIs and ensure access to comprehensive sexuality education. Efforts to strengthen the linkages between HIV and other health efforts, such as sexual and reproductive health programs and services, will ensure greater impact of policies and programmes.

Photo Credit: Rodelyn Marte

maintain a certain body image and improve their self-esteem. Additionally, peer effects are strong, as a woman is more likely to use drugs if her partner uses drugs. There are many problems associated with drug use that specifically are detrimental to women, such as having irregular periods, changes in sexual feelings and mood swings, reduced effectiveness of contraception, interference with breastfeeding, and complications during pregnancy and childbirth. Furthermore, the use of stimulant drugs is one of the main factors associated with unprotected sexual intercourse, leading to increased rates of sexual transmitted infections (STIs), including HIV, among women who use drugs. Often excluded from discussions on harm reduction and HIV prevention education, greater attention should be placed on reaching these women and

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

12

The panelists highlighted a number of important issues affecting key affected women and girls. The following discussion centered on the fact that women, compared to men, are much more vulnerable to HIV transmission, which is even more true for some women and girls who engage in risky behavior or have a partner who engages in risky behavior. The following definition of KAWG was agreed upon by the Workshop participants as a gender-sensitive definition that recognises the specific vulnerability of women and girls by including communities whose needs are neglected and marginalised in the current HIV response.
HIV and Key Affected Women and Girls Womens rights and gender equality for all are imperative to an effective HIV response. We recognise that key affected women and girls include: women and girls who are living with HIV, female sex workers, women and girls who use drugs, transgender women and girls, mobile and migrant women, female prisoners, women with disabilities, women in serodiscordant relationships as well as intimate female partners of men who engage in behaviors that put them at a higher risk of HIV infection

2.3 A Community Dialogue on Intimate Partner Transmission


The Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS) defines intimate partner transmission (IPT) of HIV as transmission of HIV to women from their long-term male partners who inject drugs, have sex with other men or are clients of sex workers (UNAIDS, HIV Transmission in Intimate Partner Relationships in Asia). Much of the discussion focused on the intentional meaning of terms in the definition, such as whether Photo Credit: Rodelyn Marte long-term fully captured the difference between intimate partners and sexual partners, or if that was necessary to distinguish. Participants agreed that the current IPT definition has two main shortcomings: (1) it places a lot of emphasis on prevention of HIV, and thus leaves out women and girls already living with HIV and (2) it neglects addressing consent issues, shared decision-making and power dynamics. Future efforts to

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

13

promote IPT should occur within the context of a SRHR-based framework, which shares common ground with the Unzip the Lips platform. Why should we care about IPT among KAWG? In the Asia Pacific region, women and girls are left out of the HIV responses and very few programmes are available to meet their needs. The promotion of womens rights, through the empowerment of these populations, will help communities to change the gender and cultural norms that are pervasive in society and demote women. All women, not only those who are HIV positive, should have the right to make their own choices, have a right to express their sexual rights, and protect their bodily integrity. What are the key factors affecting IPT among KAWG? The power dynamic between people in a relationship often affects the ability for women to negotiate condom use. Social, cultural, and religious norms can also encourage traditional gender roles, which prevents an open discussion about sexuality. This can lead to low or limited available SRHR information, and such lack of knowledge can prevent knowledge about an individuals HIV status or their partners HIV status. In addition to these cultural barriers, participants agreed that trust issues and trust building can also significantly influence power dynamics, making negotiations more complicated and difficult. What are the key strategies to prevent IPT among KAWG? More emphasis needs to be placed on creating an enabling environment that goes beyond just women and girls, and includes their partners and the wider community in discussing sexuality and sexual rights, demystifying marriage, and breaking taboos about relationships. Specific focus should target young people with comprehensive sexuality education (that includes a focus on gender) in school curriculum and out-of-school settings

Photo Credit: Rodelyn Marte

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

14

2.4 Advocacy Strategising and KAWG Messaging


Six main themes emerged during the discussions around defining KAWG and discussing intimate partner transmission. Thus, to more effectively address the needs of KAWG, Workshop participants worked in small groups to focus on concrete action that can create opportunities for key affected women and girls. Participants discussed specific barriers related to their theme, and developed three recommendations and policy asks to improve programs for women and girls who are most impacted by HIV policies. Theme 1: Leadership development, mobilisation, and networking The major problems in achieving this theme was low individual capacity and competency to stay at certain job positions, including a language barriers, low institutional capacity and inability to sustain networks, and traditional gender roles that prevented women from being hired for leadership positions. To change the current environment, improved training, increased funding, and better communication is necessary. Women mentors can help build a better pool of leaders and help inspire future leaders to take on the role of a leader. The top recommendations are: 1. Donor agencies and UN bodies and government need to fully fund regional and national level networks 2. ASEAN, ESCAPE and governments need to change laws and policies to protect human rights of

Photo Credit: Rodelyn Marte

KAPs/PLHIV and address gender inequity 3. Governments need to ensure meaningful involvement of KAWG in all decision-making processes that affect KAWG and have representation of their community in the government system Theme 2: Meaningful participation & involvement of KAWG Too often, there is tokenistic involvement of KAWG, leading to a womens lack of confidence in being involved, especially when there is a male-dominated decision-making process. An even greater barrier exists for positive KAWG who are not guaranteed that their HIV status will be kept confidential. Improved community empowerment, ownership, and community mobilisation can help change the cultural and social norms that prevent KAWG from fully realising

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

15

their participatory involvement. The top recommendations are: 1. To have consultation procedures in place for any policy that will affect the community 2. To have laws and harmonised policies that all support and not work against the health of KAWG including the contradiction between law enforcement and harm reduction 3. To ensure sustainability of

framework. The top recommendations are: 1. UN bodies, government policymakers, and legislators need to repeal the laws and policies that criminalise (any aspect of) sex work, drug use, men who have sex with men (MSM) and transmission of HIV 2. UN bodies, government policymakers, and legislators need to repeal all policies of mandatory testing (in antenatal clinics, of migrant workers, and for employment) and promote voluntary confidential counseling and testing (VCCT) 3. Government needs to develop policies that promote voluntary HIV testing, voluntary sterilisation, abortion, etc. Theme 4: Barriers to accessing health services Many countries have substantial barriers that prevent women from accessing health services. For instance, in Myanmar and Lao PDR, there is no contraceptive service for youth. In some countries, in cases of rape, no female police or social worker are available to assist the children during the investigation. Even more challenging is that health services are often only available for the native population, and non-native people living with HIV are sent back to their home countries. The member countries of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) should support cross-border projects and ensure collaboration to address the major health and social issues within the region. The top recommendations are:

Photo Credit: Rodelyn Marte

community programs and national budgets Theme 3: Human rights, policy and legal environment Punitive laws and policies that violate a womans right to access sexual and reproductive health is the biggest barrier for this theme. The lack of enabling environment also increases the vulnerability of KAWG. More opportunities for face-to-face dialogue between government policymakers and KAWG populations could help promote a better legal and policy environment. Further a stronger evidence base will make policy messages more effective in advocating for a rights-based

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

16

1. To ensure that civil society organisations and representatives can participate in ASEAN process 2. To have an integrated health access and information system in ASEAN 3. To ensure that ASEAN government follow international conventions that promote human rights Theme 5: Gender-based violence (GBV) including sexual violence and harassment There are no legal support mechanisms to address genderbased violence and sexual violence. Greater gender-sensitive laws need to be passed to protect KAWG from violence, harassment, and abuse. Media can play an influential role in changing the societal attitude towards improved treatment of KAWG. The top recommendations are: 1. Governments need to provide education and information to KAWG to inform and raise awareness on rights to protect them from violence 2. Governments and UN agencies need to address the need to integrate GBV, including sexual violence and sexual harassment into HIV and AIDS response including program, health services and legal services 3. Governments and all stakeholders need to ensure that KAWG have full participation and leadership in planning and implementing, monitoring and evaluation of policies and practices to combat and prevention of sexual violence and other forms of violence
Photo Credit: Rodelyn Marte

Theme 6: Gender norms and gender inequalities and power dynamics and sexuality The legal and policy environment is slightly enabling in terms of addressing gender issues and empowerment of women and girls. But many countries still criminalise people on the basis of sexual orientation and gender identity (SOGI). In addition, religious and cultural forces continue to dictate, define, and impose beliefs and dogma that are harmful and discriminatory to women, demonising sexuality and womens sexual empowerment. The top recommendations are: 1. ASEAN and national governments need to increase budget allocations to address gender and sexuality issues (e.g. to fund appropriate services or to change laws that privilege men or disempower women) 2. ASEAN and national governments need to have gender transformative, sex-positive education should be integrated/ in the curriculum of the public school system at all levels 3. ASEAN and national governments need to support KAWG/civil society organisations/community engagement in the response

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

17

2.5 Getting to Know ASEAN


Yuyun Wahyuningrum of the Human Rights Working Group (HRWG) Indonesia provided an overview and background primer about ASEAN. Noting the history of the regional mechanism, the establishment of the ASEAN community, and highlighting relevant operational documents, she highlighted various advocacy entry points for civil society. Using her own experience in working with ASEAN, she encouraged advocates to promote gender and human rights issues for meaningful engagement with ASEAN policymakers. Nina Somera, of the Asia Pacific Forum on Women Law and Development (APWLD) reflected on her experience and lessons learned in working with the Womens Caucus, ASEAN Intergovernmental Commission on Human Rights (AICHR) and the ASEAN Committee on Women (ACW). Describing key areas of work, such as violence against women, migration, and economic participation, highlighted opportunities for regular consultation and collaboration with civil society. Given that there are numerous stakeholders involved in influencing the ASEAN process and how challenging it is for civil society to have meaningful participation, she recommended identifying and pursuing common positions with civil society networks to ensure messages are heard. Nuanpan Thamanovanish, of the ASEAN Youth Movement, discussed the importance of ensuring that ASEAN address non-traditional security elements, such as health issues that affect services and people. Speaking from experience, she highlighted her organisations efforts to build youth participation and strengthen marginalised youth groups through increased networking and advocacy.

Photo Credit: Rodelyn Marte

Moi Lee Liow, of the Asia Pacific Council of AIDS Service Organisations (APCASO), discussed her perspective of being a civil society observer to the ASEAN Task Force on AIDS (ATFOA). To date, civil society organisations have been very passive and have provided subdued inputs, often approaching HIV as a gender-neutral issue. However, much more can be done to improve the status of women and girls issues in the ATFOA discussions. Ensuring womens groups are represented and are more proactive at the national level is the first step to obtaining progressive language and successful engagement.

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

18

2.6 UNZIP Strategy: The Way Forward


To ensure common ground and promote collaboration, all participants engaged in an advocacy mapping exercise to think about where each individual or organisation could leverage their time and talents to putting women and girls on the agenda in 2012 until 2015. The full advocacy mapping can be viewed in Annex F: Unzip the Lips Advocacy Event Mapping. This document can be used for upcoming strategic Photo Credit: Rodelyn Marte advocacy opportunities to both deliver key messages and call greater attention to the specific needs of key affected women and girls. Events such as the International Congress on AIDS in Asia and the Pacific (ICAAP) occurring in 2013 have the promising potential where Unzip the Lips can coordinate a joint advocacy effort. Furthermore, organisations who are presenting or attending conferences are able to offer up free booth space for promotion of materials and key messages. Given that the Unzip the Lips platform is a loose group of organisations, the group has historically operated without any formal structure. Most participants agreed to continue with having a platform that will remain a broad coalition of volunteer membership, where people can join freely and any member can easily promote the mission of the group. Many representatives needed to internally discuss the level of participation they could commit to the effort. In the meantime, participants agreed to form a Temporary Advisory Committee on a voluntary basis, comprised of: Anandi Yuvaraj (ICW-AP), Anastacia Ryna (NSWP), Chompoo Supecha (ForSOGI), Dean Lewis (ANPUD), Jet Riparip (IHAA), Oldri Mukuan (YouthLEAD), Rachel Arinii Judhistari (ARROW), Rodelyn Marte (APCASO), and Rose Koenders (APA). Additionally, many regional organisations were also able to offer in-kind donations and support, such as meeting conference space, provision of logistics or supplies, translation of materials, and technical support via email. Decisions regarding communications, fundraising, and definition of roles and responsibilities were tabled for future decision-making conversations with the core group of partner organisations.

Thank you for making sure women stay on the HIV agenda! Anonymous

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

19

3.

WORKSHOP RECOMMENDATIONS TO ASEAN POLICYMAKERS

On 24-25 September 2012, ASEAN delegates from the ATFOA and ACW gathered together for a Consultative Meeting on HIV and Key Affected Women and Girls: Reducing Intimate Partner Transmission of HIV in ASEAN in Luang Prabang, Lao PDR. Ten representatives of the workshop in Bangkok joined this meeting and represented the voice of key affected women and girls on behalf of the UNZIP the Lips Platform . They called for scaling up action and resources for policies and programs that address the rights of women and girls in the context of HIV and AIDS. ASEAN countries have signed international conventions and ASEAN Declaration of Commitment. Through several interventions and presentations, UNZIP members congratulated ASEAN on the ASEAN Declaration of Commitment: Getting to Zero new HIV Infections, zero discrimination, zero aids-related death. Especially paragraph 17f where ASEAN countries commit towards zero new HIV infections through encouraging and support the active involvement of key affected populations and vulnerable groups. Unzip the Lips applauded ASEAN in its commitment to ensure that national prevention strategies comprehensively address communities at higher risk, of HIV infection such as people who use drugs, sex workers, and men having sex with men, including transgender people. And expressed their pride that this sub region has taken up this important leadership role.
Photo Credit: YouthLEAD

The UNZIP platform members also highlighted that ASEAN Member states have pledged to eliminate gender inequalities and gender-based abuse and violence especially by promoting the rights of women and girls, strengthening national social and child protection systems, empowering women and young people to protect themselves from HIV and have access to health services, including, sexual and reproductive health as well as full access to comprehensive information and education. And stressed that these are crucial strategies in ending Intimate Partner Transmission of HIV infections.

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

20

The following text was delivered to ASEAN delegates by civil society advocates at the a Consultative Meeting on HIV and Key Affected Women and Girls: Reducing Intimate Partner Transmission of HIV in ASEAN in Luang Prabang, Lao PDR. See Annex G: Our Call to ASEAN for the final document. OUR CALL TO ASEAN We want to live in a world where these commitments are realised, where programs and funds and resources are reaching us, key affected women and girls, ensuring that we can live in dignity and enjoy our human rights. We are worried and deeply concerned that gender, women empowerment, and womens rights are lost in the HIV response. We, key affected women and girls are able to help ASEAN countries realise these commitments. To do so, we call on ASEAN member states to: To reduce Intimate Partner Transmission by scaling up programs that support work with Key Affected Communities; that guarantee the sexual and reproductive rights of women and girls; and that end gender based violence against women and girls. To scale up action and resources for policies and programs that address the rights of women and girls in the context of HIV and AIDS To strengthen all laws and policies to protect the human rights of key affected women and girls, including women and girls living with HIV. Ensure an enabling environment by decriminalising all sex work, drug use, same-sex behavior and relationships and transmission of HIV. To remove barriers to women and girls access to non-judgmental gender sensitive health and legal services. To address stigma and discrimination in health care settings for key affected women and girls including ending forced sterilisation, forced abortion and compulsory HIV testing among women and girls. Ensuring access to comprehensive gender and sexuality education for girls and boys for both in and out of school. Invest in women and girls leadership and guarantee the sustainability of community organisations and groups working for key affected communities through core funding support

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

21

ANNEXES
ANNEX A: Workshop Agenda
DAY 1 Friday September 21st
Time 9:00-9:30 Session and Format Welcome from UNZIP Organising Team Opening Remarks by Susan Paxton (APN+) and Oldri Mukuan (YouthLEAD) 9:30-10:30 Introductions, Expectations and How to Work Together Objective is to introduce facilitators and participants and set out a clear roadmap of how the workshop will proceed Energiser Morning Break Introduction Video on Key Affected Women and Girls (5-10 minutes) Overview of definition, key issues and recommendations on key affected women and girls in HIV and AIDS programs - Panel Presentation Objective is to let key affected communities speak out on gender issues and the challenges that women and girls are facing in their respective communities and to develop a discourse on KAWGs which will set the tone for the meeting. Moderator: Anandi Yuvaraj (ICW-AP) Panelists (10 min each) Alexandra Johns (APA) Anastacia Ryan (NSWP) Baby Rivona (IPPI) Manis Chen (PT Foundation) Yvonne Sibuea(ANPUD) 11:4512:45 Brainstorm key categories and priority issues - Floor Discussion Q and A (1 hour) Objective is to share more issues of participants concerning KAWG to be taken forward to the afternoon session Q & A, sharing from participants on gender issues in respective communities 12:4513:45 13:4514:45 Lunch and submeeting Voluntary group will cluster issues into categories Community Dialogue on IPT - Large Group Discussion (1 hour) Objective is to have an open discussion and develop a community perspective on IPT for the Regional Consultation with ASEAN

10:3010:45 10:4511:45

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

22

14:4515:00 15:0015:15 15:1516:45

Moderator: Khut Th Hi Oanh Afternoon Break Energiser Power Walk Advocacy Strategising and Messaging Group work (90 min) Objective is to have a more in depth discussion about the gender issues identified in the morning and the barriers communities are facing in their work. Participants will develop solutions into an advocacy objectives / policy asks. Wrap-up and Meeting Close

16:4517:00

DAY 2 Saturday September 22nd


Time 8:45-9:00 9:00 10:00 10:0010:15 10:1511.45 Session and Format Welcome and Agenda of Day 2 Report Outs - Panel Session (1 hour) moderated by Dean Lewis (ANPUD) Objective is to share information and advocacy messages / asks from each of the small working group sessions of Day 1 Morning Break Getting to Know ASEAN, the ASEAN ATFOA and ASEAN Asian Committee on Women (ACW) - Panel Presentation with Q&A (60-90 min) Objective is to familiarise participants with ASEAN, the ASEAN structure and the key advocacy entry points Moderator: Malu Marin (Action for Health Initiatives (ACHIEVE), Inc.) Panelists: 11:4512:30 Moi Lee (APCASO) Yuyun Wahyuningrum - Human Rights Working Group (HRWG) Nuanpan Thamanovanish - ASEAN Youth Movement Nina Somera - APWLD / Women Caucus Member

Strategy preparation for the CSO presentation at the UN IPT Regional Consultation Meeting - Large Group Discussion (1 hour) Objective is developing effective advocacy messages targeted at ASEAN to be presented at the Regional Consultation on HIV and KAWG in the ASEAN region. Lunch

12:3013:30

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

23

13:3015:00

UNZIP Strategy Discussion (90 min) The Way Forward Objective is to develop a roadmap with opportunities for putting women and girls on the agenda. To define the future for the UNZIP work, including noting key milestones (like ICAAP 2013 or Women Deliver, Beyond 2015 consultations/discussions) and other activities which would be appropriate advocacy opportunities to target Afternoon Break UNZIP Strategy Discussion (90 min) How to Work Together Objective is to discuss how the participants would like to work together, including a discussion of how and what UNZIP will look like - UN partners of the IATT on HIV, women and gender equality are invited to join the session.

15:0015:30 15:3017:00

17:0017:30

Closing and Evaluation

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

24

ANNEX B: List of Participants


Name 1. Alexandra Johns 2. Anandi Yuvaraj 3. Anastacia Ryan 4. Baby Rivona 5. Brahm Press 6. Brianna Harrison 7. Chompoo Supecha Baotip 8. Dalish Prum Organisation Asia Pacific Alliance (APA) International Community of Women Living with HIV/AIDS Asia Pacific (ICW-AP) Global Network of Sex Worker Projects (NSWP) Indonesia Positive Womens Network (IPPI) Coordination of Action Research on AIDS and Mobility (CARAM Asia) UNAIDS Asia Pacific RST For Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation Rights Project (For-SOGI) Women of APN+ (WAPN)/Cambodian Community of Women Living with HIV/AIDS (CCW) Asian Network of People who Use Drugs (ANPUD) Lao Positive Health Association (LaoPHA) Consultant, UN Women Health Policy Initiative / WAPN+ International HIV/AIDS Alliance Asia Pacific Region Asia Pacific Alliance (APA) Youth Voices Count/Thai Transgender Alliances Asia Pacific Network of Sex Workers (APNSW) / 7Sisters Center for Supporting Community Development Initiatives (SCDI) Association of People Living with HIV/AIDS (APL+) Action for Health Initiatives (ACHIEVE) Philippines/CARAM PT Foundation Asia Pacific Council of AIDS Service Organisations (APCASO) Migrant Action Programme Foundation (MAP Foundation) Asia Pacific Forum on Women Law and Development (APWLD) ASEAN Youth Movement (AYM) YouthLEAD Country Thailand India Thailand Indonesia Thailand Thailand Thailand Cambodia

9. Dean Lewis 10. 11. 12. 13. Douang Khamvongsa Frieda Lee Jeanne Darch Truong Jet Riparip

Thailand Lao PDR Australia Vietnam Thailand Thailand Thailand Thailand Vietnam Lao PDR Philippines Malaysia Malaysia Thailand Thailand Thailand Indonesia

14. Kate Tibone 15. Kath Kangpiboon 16. Khartini Slamah 17. Khut Th Hi Oanh 18. Kinoy Phondeth 19. Malu Marin 20. Manis Chen 21. Moi Lee Liow 22. Namishin Jate 23. Nina Somera

24. Nuanpan Thamanovanish


25. Oldri Mukuan

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

25

26. Phonexay Sithirajvongsa 27. Rachel Arinii Judhistari 28. Rodelyn (RD) Marte 29. Rose Koenders 30. Sarah Zaidi 31. Seangpanya Phanthamith (Nith) 32. Sunee Talawat 33. Susan Paxton 34. Thaw Zin Aye 35. Vanphanom Sychereun 36. Vilasini Seevanathan 37. Yalda Jafari 38. Yuyun Wahyuningrum 39. Yvonne Sibuea

CARE International Asian Pacific Resource and Research Centre for Women (ARROW) Asia Pacific Council of AIDS Service Organisations (APCASO) Asia Pacific Alliance (APA) International Treatment Preparedness Coalition - Cancelled Lao National Network of People Living with HIV (LPN+) Raks Thai Foundation Consultant, Asia Pacific Network of People Living with HIV/AIDS (APN+) YouthLEAD University of Social Science Laos IPPF East and South East Asia and Oceania Region (ESEAOR) - Cancelled UNESCO Human Rights Working Group (HRWG) Indonesia Asian Network of People who Use Drugs (ANPUD)

Lao PDR Malaysia Malaysia Thailand Thailand Laos Thailand Australia Thailand Lao PDR Malaysia Thailand Indonesia Indonesia

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

26

ANNEX C: Keynote Speeches


Opening Remarks by: Oldri Mukuan, YouthLEAD Good morning everyone! It is indeed a great honour and pleasure for as a young woman living with HIV to welcome all of you to Unzip the lips workshop The Gender Agenda: Making HIV Responses Work for Key Affected Women and Girls. I would like to thank the organizers of the event, and all my fellow civil society members in leading the way forward! Especially the network I am from Youth LEAD, the Asia Pacific Network of Young Key Affected Populations. We are very glad to work collectively to strengthen national and regional HIV responses that more effectively address the needs and rights of key affected women and girls including those of women and girls living with HIV, in Asia and the Pacific. In our region, the region most affected by HIV, the face of the epidemic continues to be that of a woman and in particular, a young girl. We have spoken about this repeatedly and we have made calls for exerted efforts and accelerated action, but the one thing that has remained resilient over the past 30 years of the epidemic is the disproportionally higher level of infection among women and girls. Young women are particularly vulnerable to HIV, accounting for 64% of infections among young people worldwide. I like to share my experiences regarding Indonesian situation for young Key Affected women, especially YWLHIV. As a young women living with HIV, i'm very lucky to have the opportunity to work in the National WLHIV network. I have had opportunity to get capacity building trainings, speak up to promote women and young women living with HIV right in policy making level. But, I also realize that there are many young women who don't have opportunities like me. We should really take into consideration for the women and girls and do something to address this situation: provide more space and opportunity for Young women KAP to increase they capacity and speak up about their right. We should definitely focus on addressing the importance of investing on Young Women from KAP. Looking at how we can advocate to push the government, UN Agencies, international development partners to make commitments, have specific program intervention and budget allocation for Young Women KAP included YWLHIV. The key point should be to invest on young people. Recognizing the need for targeted programs and actions on this, I, as a young women would like to put across the message that;

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

27

We are here to make our voices heard. We are here to make sure to recognize that women and girls who work as sex workers, use drugs and transgendered are most-at-risk and their needs are neglected. We are here to talk about the right to confidentiality and fully informed consent. We are here also talking about the right of access to appropriate health care services that will enable women to go safely through pregnancy and childbirth and provide couples with the best chance of having a healthy infant. We are talking about the right to health, to education, to employment. And let me say this: How you find out your HIV status and how your status is used should not violate your human rights. Freedom from discrimination, abuse and exploitation, the right to participate in decisions that affect your life, and to privacy are fundamental human rights standards. Everyone has the right to live in dignity. These basic rights apply to all people, including women and girls living with HIV/AIDS and young key affected women and girls. Yet, while human rights are the same for all people, the circumstances in which people find themselves are different. For new generations, we must encourage the capacity building of young women from key affected populations. The full and equal participation and leadership of women is no longer an option. It is important to involve us more meaningfully in advocacy and designing programme and policy-making levels. It is urgent and a necessity if we are to achieve the transformational change needed at all levels and spheres of society for sustainable development. This is a crucial platform where we can really strive towards addressing the needs of the women and girls, and working collectively we can really make a difference in the HIV response. With these messages in our mind, lets make the best of the time we have at this workshop. Also before I end, please join me in saluting the work of all the women present here for their dedication, hard work, commitment and passion to make this a reality. Lets not forget the men who are present here as well, as they are also an important partner in this process. Please give a round of applause. Thank you

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

28

Susan Paxton, Consultant, Asia Pacific Network of People Living with HIV/AIDS (APN+) TIME TO UPHOLD OUR RIGHTS Susan Paxton, PhD

UNZIP the Lips, Bangkok, 21 September 2012 Thank you very much for inviting me to address this important forum on how to strengthen the advocacy around the needs and rights of key affected women and girls in the response to HIV. We are a very diverse group of women and men who are gathered for these two days to examine how we can support each other regardless of HIV status, age, profession, whatever - to move forward the gender agenda within the HIV response. I believe HIV highlights the deeply-rooted gender inequity that exists in our society in a way that nothing before has ever done: Gender inequity makes women and girls more vulnerable to HIV in the first place, and women living with HIV face more discrimination than men do. Gender-based violence and poverty lead many women and girls to contract HIV and once they are positive they face even more violence. Although HIV is now a manageable condition, for some women it is still a death sentence - because of the stigma, not the virus. Two weeks ago in Dallas, Texas, Cicely Bolden was killed by her partner when she disclosed that she was HIVpositive. How often do you think this may have happened to women in our region and gone undocumented? The Asia Pacific Network of People living with HIV has recorded many instances of discrimination, abuse and rights violations of women living with HIV: women are beaten by their partners after their diagnosis; women are thrown out of their homes by their in-laws and lose custody of their children; women with HIV are refused treatment and health care; women are neglected during delivery because of their HIV status. Most women living with HIV still face discrimination in the health sector. I'm among them. Over the past twenty years of living with HIV I have been denied emergency medical care and whenever I interact with health care professionals outside the HIV sector, I am invariably asked, "How did you catch HIV?". I am used to the question, but it still makes me angry. If I answer, will that affect how they treat me? If HIV is now manageable and we are told we can lead "normal" lives, why are women and girls diagnosed with HIV strongly discouraged from having children? Maternal health nurses often scold positive women who get pregnant with comments like, "How dare you?". In several countries in Asia and Africa, women

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

29

with HIV have documented coerced sterilisation. How many men are asked to get sterilised because they are HIV positive? And where are the contraceptive choices that should be available to all women to stop the one in three unwanted pregnancies that women have in the first place? Why are condoms almost the only option promoted among women with HIV? Why do we not have more contraceptives under women's control? The response towards HIV in relation to key affected women and girls, from UN bodies and government, tends to focus almost entirely on us as reproductive vessels to bring forth the next generation. In an effort to prevent mother-to-child transmission of HIV, governments are now talking about rolling out WHO's Option B+, which is testing all women during pregnancy and putting women who test HIV-positive onto ARVs immediately. What happens to us as people and as mothers in this process is largely disregarded. These programs do not take into account: the lack of confirmatory test results; responses from partners or in-laws to the HIV result; what happens to the quality of life of any other children if the woman is thrown out of home; whether the woman will even continue to attend the health care centre after her diagnosis - because we well know that many HIV-positive women and girls avoid health care settings because of the discrimination they face if they are known to be HIV-positive - we know that women are abused, segregated and abandoned within the health care system and this discourages women from using these services. People in authority have adopted this medical solution to vertical HIV transmission, and rapidly moved to implement it without laying down some of the basic groundwork needed to protect women's rights and health. Disconcertingly, alongside increased efforts to save babies lives there is decreased funding and support to networks of women living with HIV at every level. Women and girls living with HIV can meaningfully inform programs. We have a unique perspective. We know how programs failed us. We care most about saving our babies. We know what is needed and how to do it but we are not given sufficient platform to address our issues. It is a woman living with HIV, Alice Welbourn, who designed the "Stepping Stones" program that now operates in over 100 countries. This program uses a participatory, rights-based approach to explore how gender issues influence behaviour. The program has been highly successful in reducing gender-based violence and HIV-related stigma. Why is there so little interest or support to get this program rolled out across our region?

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

30

In parts of Africa, mothers living with HIV are now trained as "mentor mothers" and employed within the public health sector. They meet with pregnant women who test positive, disclose their status and offer support and information to guide them through their pregnancy. These projects record increased CD4 testing, ARV initiation, HIV disclosure, and infant testing. They also reduce the stigma that women feel on diagnosis and break down discriminatory attitudes and practices within the public health sector. How can we encourage public health authorities in our region to adopt similar programs? In Namibia, Africa, three women with HIV recently took their government to court and actually won the case in relation to coerced sterilisation. In Kenya there are similar moves afoot to challenge coerced sterilisation of positive women. When might such a case to be brought forward in Asia or the Pacific region? How can we mobilise support to advocate for the rights of key affected women and girls in an environment that is controlled by men? They don't bleed and they don't reproduce; they have a very different perspective to that of women and very often they just don't get it. Even within our networks of people living with HIV, women often struggle to bring their issues to the forefront because the boards of nearly all of these networks are dominated by men. On the rare occasion when a woman is asked to participate at the decisionmaking table, it is hard to be a lone voice on a committee comprised mainly of doctors and public health professionals - particularly in our region where the role of women is expected to be one of subservience and silence. So how do we support and mentor these women to do the best job they can? How do we ensure that women with HIV gain the skills and confidence to run vibrant, ambitious networks like IPPI, the national network of women living with HIV in Indonesia to take hold of the issues and speak out and advocate for their peers on all relevant policy making bodies? These are the questions that we might strive to answer over the next two days. I hope we can develop plans on how to mobilise resources and how to build the leadership and advocacy skills of women to speak out for themselves and their peers. It is no longer acceptable that key affected women's and girls' rights are ignored. It is no longer acceptable that young women are refused contraceptive options. It is no longer acceptable that women have unwanted pregnancies and coerced sterilisations. It is no longer acceptable that women with HIV are denied their rights to health, safety, housing, and family. All governments in our region have signed the Convention for the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination Against Women. It is time to map out a plan to draw government attention to how it is failing women living with HIV and key affected

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

31

women and girls. It is time to make our governments accountable to uphold our rights, regardless of our status and treat all women with dignity and respect. Thank you.

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

32

ANNEX D: Workshop Resources


Presentations and resources from the meeting are also available for download on the Unzip the Lips website [www.unzipthelips.org] under UNZIP WORKSHOP. Day 1 Panel Presentation: Overview of definition, key issues and recommendations on key affected women and girls in HIV and AIDS programs. o o o o o Issues and Problems Facing Sex Workers Anastacia Ryan, Global Network of Sex Worker Projects (NSWP) Women Drug Use and the Risk of HIV Transmission Yvonne Sibuea, Asian Network of People who Use Drugs (ANPUD) Transsexual Women in Malaysia Manis Chen, PT Foundation AIDS Free Generation? NOT Without Women and Girls Baby Rivona, Indonesia Positive Womens Network (IPPI) Addressing the Needs and Rights of KAWG in Asia and the Pacific Alexa Johns, Asia Pacific Alliance (APA) Day 2 Panel Presentation: Getting to Know ASEAN, the ASEAN ATFOA and ASEAN Asian Committee on Women (ACW) o Understanding ASEAN Its Way of Working Structure & Engagement with Civil Society - Yuyun Wahyuningrum, Human Rights Working Group (HRWG) o The Gender Agenda Making HIV Responses Work for Key Affected Women and Girls - Moi Lee Liow, Asia Pacific Council of AIDS Service Organisations (APCASO) o Engaging ASEAN Some Reflections from the Womens Caucus Nina Somera, Asia Pacific Forum on Women Law and Development (APWLD) o ASEAN A journey of thousand miles begins with a single step Nuanpan Thamanovanish, ASEAN Youth Forum

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

33

Annex E: Workshop Evaluation Report


PARTICIPANTS WRITTEN EVALUATION

1. To what extent do you think were each of the workshop objectives achieved? 4 Completely achieved 3 Mostly achieved 4 1. To increase the understanding on and mobilise support for the issues of key affected women and girls among national and regional HIV and AIDS networks. 2. To develop policy recommendations by community and civil society organisations on key affected women and girls, including on intimate partner transmission of HIV 3. To map out potential advocacy strategy opportunities where advocates can deliver key messages and call attention to current critical issues affecting key affected women and girls, including at the UN Regional Consultation on HIV and KAWG in the ASEAN region, as well as at various national, regional, and global events in 2012-2013 4. To strengthen civil society participation at various national, regional and global policymaking forums and events in 2012-2013 2 Mostly not achieved 3 2 1 0 1 Completely not achieved Total votes 23 Other comments?

5 16 2 21.7% 69.6% 11.5%

8 14 34.8% 60.2%

1 4.3%

23

4 16 3 17.4% 69.6% 13.0%

23

5 14 21.7% 60.9%

2 8.7%

22

One vote : 2.5 One comment: not yet achievable

Comments: - Translator for local languages needed - perhaps too many objectives - all objectives felt meaningfully achieved

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

34

2. How would you rate your level of satisfaction with the following aspects of the workshop? 4 Completely satisfied 3 Mostly satisfied 2 Mostly unsatisfied 1 Completely unsatisfied 1 0 total 22

a. Workshop programme design Comments: -like the interactive aspects, some activities needed more instructions - it is a great workshop where agencies/individuals come together for KAWG - The workshop program is ok for me, full contents for discussion - Program design is fantastic - was not here on the first day b. Effectiveness of the workshop in encouraging participation from people Comments: -consider language English only -too many people talking before lunch on Day 2 -small group work is increasing participation - English barrier to understand -ok c. Participants level of participation Comments: - language barriers make less participation by non-english speakers - reps from each country quite full d. Effectiveness of methodologies used Comments: - talking Day 2 morning hard to take it all in - the methodologies used are great e. Facilitation of the workshop Comments: -need to slow down when explain or facilitate sessions f. Presentations Comments: -varied - all speakers give us new ideas for advocacy

4 3 2 9 12 1 40.9% 54.5% 4.5%

9 11 3 0 39.1% 47.8% 13.0%

23

7 9 5 0 33.3% 42.9% 20.8%

21

5 15 1 23.8% 71.4% 4.8%

21

8 12 3 0 34.8% 52.2% 13.0%

23

6 12 3 0 28.6% 27.1% 14.3%

21

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

35

strategies and issues - great presentations with strong messages Interesting and good opening g. Communication and coordination of workshop organisers with participants before the workshop Comments: h. Programme-related preparations for the workshop Comments: - attended only on 2nd day i. Logistics/administrative arrangements for the workshop Comments: - attended only on 2nd day j. The workshop, overall Comments: - I am pleased with the workshop - ok k. Are you feeling familiar with UNZIP the LIPS? Comments: - Yes! - yes! - Yes - No - Yes - Yes!! - Yes, I knew since launched at ICAAP10 - It is the first time for me, but it is great to share with other participants. I will share unzip the lips with others in my country - Yes - Yes, I have - Yes - Yes, been involved for one other workshop - yes - Of course - Yup - Yess - Yes! 8 10 4 0 36.4% 45.5% 18.1% 22

8 12 1 38.1% 57.1% 4.8%

21

9 45%

10 50%

1 5.0%

20

7 14 1 31.8% 63.6% 4.5%

22

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

36

l. Are you interested to be part or be more active with UNZIP? Comments: - YES! - Yes! - Yes - Yes - Yes - Yes, of course! - Yes because unzip is very useful to bring all womens issue to be heard - Yes, would love to get involved more and have updates of Unzip activities - Yes, as needed - Yes - Yup - Yess - Yes - Yes. Yet that is subject to approval from my employer - Thank you very much for Unzip, APA team to support and make a good workshop! - yes

Other comments: Require English-Lao translation thank you very much for making sure women stay on the HIV agenda thank you so much, a good space to speak out Felt meaningfully involved and included as a KAP. Thank you

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

37

ANNEX F: Unzip the Lip Advocacy Events Mapping


GLOBAL LEVEL MAPPING
September-December 2012 Known Activities APNSW Key Affected Populations (KAP) Working Group Meeting Global Fund to Fight AIDS, TB and Malaria (GFATM) Board Meeting Global Youth Forum ICPD +20 Stop Gender Based Violence (GBV) on Youth 2012 GFATM Strategic Investment Framework (SIF) Meeting UN Post-2015 Task Force Launch Wish List of Activities N/A January-December 2013 Known Activities The 57th UN Commission on the Status of Women (CSW) Details Details Geneva, Switzerland October 2012 Geneva, Switzerland 14-15 November 2012 Twenty-Eighth Board Meeting Bali, Indonesia 4-6 December 2012 Bangkok, Thailand Serving as a focal point to influence the Framework through a gender lens Contact Person Khartini Slamah, APNSW/7Sisters Rachel Arinii Judhistari, ARROW Rachel Arinii Judhistari, ARROW Contact Person Rachel Arinii Judhistari, ARROW Rachel Arinii Judhistari, ARROW Other collaborators? APA Baby Rivona, IPPI APA Oldri Mukuan, Thaw Zin Aye, YouthLEAD

Others interested?

Details New York, NY USA 4-15 March 2013

Contact Person APA

Other collaborators?

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

38

The 46th Commission on Population and Development (CPD) The 3rd Global Women Deliver Conference

Harm Reduction, International Conference 2013 The 7th International AIDS Society (IAS) Conference on HIV Pathogenesis, Treatment and Prevention (IAS 2013) Planning a regional policy paper Prioritize SRHR in the post-2015 framework or the next MDGs

Priority Theme: Elimination and prevention of all forms of violence against women and girls Review Theme: The equal sharing of responsibilities between women and men, including caregiving in the context of HIV/AIDS New York, NY USA 22-26 April 2013 Theme: New trends in migration: demographic aspects Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia 28-30 May 2013 Invest in Girls, It Pays! APA plans on a session with a focus on MDG5 IHAA will attend Women Deliver and present a regional policy paper on women and children Vilnius, Lithuania 9-12 June 2013 Kuala, Lumpur 30 June 3 July 2013 Topic is not specific yet Monitor and engage in national, regional, and global events and consultations regarding a new

APA

APA

Susan Paxton will help out in developing abstract presentations for positive women

Baby Rivona, IPPI

IHAA APA

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

39

framework Serve as a member of the Committee Advisory Group (CAG) Human Rights Consultancy ICPD +20 Womens Rights Consultancy, ICPD +20 All events related to the ICPD +20 review Wish List of Activities Track on Key Populations (KPs) at International HIV/AIDS Scientific Management 2013 A 5-minute slot on a Roadmap for women-related events/abstracts at the Committee Advisory Group (CAG) More funding for programs/projects for positive women The International Campaign Stop Trans Pathologization 2013 Write a policy paper focused on Key Affected Women and Girls (KAWGs)/Key Populations (KPs) Paper on the Human Rights focused on female and young IDUs January-December 2014 Known Activities Details Anandi Yuvaraj, ICW-AP Rachel Arinii Judhistari, ARROW Rachel Arinii Judhistari, ARROW APA Others interested? APA

Contact Person Anandi Yuvaraj, ICW-AP

IHAA IHAA

Details

Contact Person

Other collaborators?

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

40

XX International AIDS Conference (AIDS 2014)

Melbourne, Australia

Wish List of Activities Co-chair the Community Program for the IAC 2014 Co-chair for positive womens track at the IAC 2014 Womens Track at the IAC 2014 More positive women scholarships at the IAC 2014 January-December 2015 Known Activities Celebrate the first Transgender Secretary General of the UN, who shuts down UNAIDS and says We have reached ZERO! Wish List of Activities N/A

Details

Contact Person Khartini Slamah, APNSW

Baby Rivona, IPPI Oldri Mukuan, Thaw Zin Aye, YouthLEAD Manis Chen, PT Foundation APA Anandi Yuvaraj, ICWAP Others interested? APA Anandi Yuvaraj, ICWAP APA APA

Details

Contact Person Khartini Slamah, APNSW

Other collaborators? APA

Details

Contact Person

Others interested?

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

41

REGIONAL LEVEL MAPPING


September-December 2012 Known Activities Regional Workshop on Greater Mekong Sub-region (GMS) Countries Reproductive Health laws, policies & reproductive health services for women and female migrant workers ASEAN Civil Society Conference (ACSC) / ASEAN Peoples Forum (APF) 2012 Details 23-28 September 2012 Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, Thailand, Vietnam Cambodia 13-16 November 2012 APNSW is organising a sex workers meeting during the summit Contact Person Raks Thai Other collaborators? APA

APNSW

Meeting of Regional Networks on the Strategic Investment Framework (SIF) Come up with recommendation on reproductive health rights (RHR) for ASEAN Regional Conference with male, youth and HIV/AIDS networks towards the prevention of GBV in ASEAN (workplan of ACW) Wish List of Activities Ensure that ACHIEVE significantly

7 Sisters APCASO Raks Thai Malu Marin, ACHIEVE Philippines/CARAM

Philippines 15-16 November 2012 ACHIEVE is part of the Core Group for ACW Details

Manis Chen, PT Foundation Khut Th Hi Oanh, SCDI Susan Paxton happy to help the women to develop their presentations if needed APA Anastacia Ryan, APNSW APA

Contact Person Malu Marin, ACHIEVE

Others interested?

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

42

influences the agenda/presentations at ASEAN Attend or influence the Asia-Europe Meeting Summit (ASEM) 9 January-December 2013 Known Activities ASEAN Civil Society Conference (ACSC) / ASEAN Peoples Forum (APF) 2013 International Congress on AIDS in Asia and the Pacific (ICAAP 2013)

Phillipines/CARAM Vientiane, Laos 5-6 November 2012 Details Brunei Darussalam Tentatively March/April 2013

Contact Person

MDG Regional Review UNESCAP Session on Population Regional policy paper International HIV/AIDS Alliance

Bangkok, Thailand 18-23 November 2013 Brahm Press (CARAM) is on the community committee Positive women are co-chairs and at least 15 positive women attend IPPI is sharing VAW films IPPI is sharing SRHR module on WLHIV YouthLEAD is sharing/presenting a GBV study on YKAP APN+ is an Advisory Group member - needs to strengthen Topic is not decided yet

Rachel Arinii Judhistari, ARROW IHAA IHAA

Other collaborators? APA Manis Chen, PT Foundation Khut Th Hi Oanh, SCDI APA Manis Chen, PT Foundation RD Marte, APCASO Malu Marin, ACHIEVE Phillipines/CARAM IPPI Rachel Arinii Judhistari, ARROW RD Marte, APCASO Anandi Yuvaraj, ICWAP Susan Paxton APA

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

43

meeting in Asia-Pacific Wish List of Activities Organize pink dot activity in Thailand Organize a workshop on positive women advocacy at the regional level for the ICAAP meeting Organize a workshop about women sexuality especially lesbian and bisexual issues on HIV and rights Joint effort with UNZIP on KAWG HIV/AIDS policy change is specific for women and girls Advocacy plan/workshop to accessing health care for KAWG At ICAAP, organize a cross-cutting panel session on migrants and women at ICAAP At ICAAP, make sure that there is specific support for KAWG and women and youth people living with HIV/AIDS At ICAAP, ensure more participation of women who use drugs, such as ensure scholarships At ICAAP, set up a womens forum and womens track At ICAAP, ensure gender equity for positive womens scholarships

Details

Contact Person Lao NGOs

Others interested? RD Marte, APCASO APA YouthLEAD APA APA Frieda Lee

APA Khut Th Hi Oanh, SCDI

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

44

At ICAAP, have a positive womens co-chair

YouthLEAD

January-December 2014 Known Activities ASEAN Civil Society Conference (ACSC) / ASEAN Peoples Forum (APF) 2014 The 7th Asia Pacific Conference on Reproductive and Sexual Health and Rights (APCRSHR) Wish List of Activities N/A January-December 2015 Known Activities N/A Wish List of Activities N/A

Details Yangon, Myanmar Tentatively March/April 2014 Manila, Philippines Details Details Details

Contact Person Contact Person Contact Person Contact Person

Other collaborators? APA Khut Th Hi Oanh, SCDI APA Khut Th Hi Oanh, SCDI Others interested? Other collaborators? Others interested?

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

45

NATIONAL LEVEL MAPPING


September-December 2012 Known Activities 1st National MSM & TG meeting 2012 WLHIV involved at evaluation of UNAIDS Operational plan on women and girls Support the development of sex workers organisations Support the establishment of national and local network of sex workers Support the establishment of national and local network of drug users and make sure issues of female drug users are included in their agenda Expand program on sexual partners Plan, organize, and work with Youth Key Affected Populations (YKAP) to ensure new generational leadership and conduct trainings in Indonesia, Myanmar, Philippines, and Sri Lanka Wish List of Activities Prioritize the participation of KAWG within the YKAP work Meaningful participation of KAWG to ensure implementation of National Details Thailand Indonesia Vietnam UNZIP to help with regional networking and capacity building Contact Person All Thailand NGOs All Indonesian NGOs Other collaborators? SCDI

All Vietnamese NGOs

Vietnam UNZIP to help promote the intervention of experience sharing Capacity building in Indonesia, Myanmar, Philippines, and Sri Lanka Details Indonesia

All Vietnamese NGOs YouthLEAD

SCDI

Contact Person YouthLEAD All Indonesian NGOs

Others interested? APA

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

46

Action Plan for women in girls 20122014 January-December 2013 Known Activities Support TG women to ensure a network and that they have a voice WLHIV involved at evaluation of UNAIDS Operational plan on women and girls Wish List of Activities Data/demographic research on Transsexual in Malaysia. Meaningful participation of KAWG to ensure implementation of National Action Plan for women in girls 20122014 Set up positive women networks countrywide Sex worker network formed Strategy of PLHIV network by 2013 January-December 2014 Known Activities Submit a proposal for Thai positive womens advocacy Women and KAWG issues will be

Details Vietnam UNZIP to help with capacity building, exposure, and networking Indonesia Details With this data, it will be easier to talk to politicians/governments/policymak ers about our issues and concerns Indonesia

Contact Person Other collaborators? All Vietnamese NGOs SCDI All Indonesian NGOs Others interested?

Contact Person Manis Chen, PT Foundation All Indonesian NGOs

APA

Details

Lao representatives

Manis Chen, PT Foundation

Contact Person All Thai NGOs

Other collaborators? APA

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

47

mentioned and solutions Wish List of Activities Study on gender-based violence for women and girls Study on KAWG response to HIV Women living with HIV will have more opportunity to participant in national and international events January-December 2015 Known Activities Strategic plan on women and girls is identified and included into national strategies on gender, HIV, and health agendas Wish List of Activities N/A Details Contact Person Others interested?

Details

Contact Person

Other collaborators?

Details

Contact Person

Others interested?

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

48

Consultative Meeting on HIV and Key Affected Women and Girls: Reducing Initmate Partner Transmission of HIV in ASEAN 24-25 September 2012 Phousi Hotel, Luang Prabang, Lao PDR

CALL TO ASEAN
Annex G: Our Call to ASEAN

www.unzipthelips.org
Who are Key Affected Women and Girls?
We recognize that key affected women and girls include: women and girls who are living with HIV, female sex workers, women and girls who use drugs, transgender women and girls, mobile and migrant women, female prisoners, women with disabilities, women in serodiscordant relationships as well as intimate female partners of men who engage in behaviors that put them at a higher risk of HIV infection.
49

Who are Unzip the Lips?


UNZIP the Lips is a platform of individuals and organisations working for the rights and meaningful participation of key affected women and girls in the context of HIV and its intersections with other gender issues in the Asia Pacific region. Unzip the Lips is intended to offer a safe and inclusive space for dialogue for multiple stakeholders. In this space we hope to engage and mobilise support from other organisations and individuals and of ASEAN here today - who share our commitment to making the voices of women and girls, particularly those most at risk and most affected by HIV, heard in national and regional AIDS responses.

ASEANs Commitments
ASEAN countries have signed international conventions and ASEAN Declaration of Commitment. We congratulate ASEAN on the ASEAN Declaration of Commitment: Getting to Zero new HIV infections, zero discrimination, zero aids-related death. Especially paragraph 17f where ASEAN countries commit towards zero new HIV infections through encouraging and support the active involvement of key affected populations and vulnerable groups. We applaud ASEAN in its commitment to ensure that national prevention strategies comprehensively address communities at higher risk, of HIV infection such as people who use drugs, sex workers, and men having sex with men, including transgender people. We are proud that this sub region has taken up this important leadership role.
Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

ASEAN Member states have also pledged to eliminate gender inequalities and gender based abuse and violence especially by promoting the rights of women and girls, strengthening national social and child protection systems, empowering women and young people to protect themselves from HIV and have access to health services, including, SRH as well as full access to comprehensive information and education. These are crucial strategies in ending Intimate Partner Transmission of HIV infections.

Our Call to ASEAN

We want to live in a world where these commitments are realized, where programs and funds, and resources are reaching us, key affected women and girls, ensuring that we can live in dignity and enjoy our human rights. We are worried and deeply concerned that gender, women empowerment and womens rights are lost in the HIV response. We, key affected women and girls are able to help ASEAN countries realize these commitments. To do so, we call on ASEAN member states to: To reduce Intimate Partner Transmission by scaling up programs that support work with Key Affected Communities; that guarantee the sexual and reproductive rights of women and girls; and that end gender based violence against women and girls. To scale up action and resources for policies and programs that address the rights of women and girls in the context of HIV and AIDS. To strengthen all laws and policies to protect the human rights of key affected women and girls, including women and girls living with HIV. Ensure an enabling environment by decriminalizing all sex work, drug use, same-sex behavior and relationships and transmission of HIV. To remove barriers to women and girls access to non-judgmental gender sensitive health and legal services. To address stigma and discrimination in health care settings for key affected women and girls including ending forced sterilization, forced abortion and compulsory HIV testing among women and girls Ensuring access to comprehensive gender and sexuality education for girls and boys for both in and out of school. Invest in women and girls leadership and guarantee the sustainability of community organizations and groups working for key affected communities through core funding support.
Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

We key affected women and girls know our problems best and we know how to address them. We are not the problem; we are part of the solution. We are not only a target group, we are partners in ensuring HIV responses are truly effective. We offer our partnership and request ACW and ATFOA to open up spaces for our meaningful involvement within ASEAN processes and bodies. We therefore request people gathered here in this room today to take our call forward to your home countries. And for those attending the 20th Annual Meeting of ATFOA, to support us in getting a seat so we could jointly strengthen our efforts towards a more 50 women-centred response.

Visit our website to find out more information and access resources:

www.unzipthelips.org
CONTACT US If you have stories, resources or other information to share with the community, please email us at unzip@unzipthelips.org To find out more about becoming a supporting partner of Unzip the Lips, please write to partners@unzipthelips.org

Report of Unzip the Lips Workshop 21-22 September 2012, Bangkok, Thailand

51

Anda mungkin juga menyukai