36,+2',$*12=$02'(51
&+(67,21$5(/('(3(5621$/,7$7(
(GL LDD,9D
(GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH
(GLWXU DFUHGLWDW GH0LQLVWHUXO(GXFD LHLúL&HUFHW ULL
SULQ&RQVLOLXO1D LRQDODO&HUFHW ULLùWLLQ LILFH
GLQÌQY PkQWXO6XSHULRU
'HVFULHUHD&,3D%LEOLRWHFLL1D LRQDOHD5RPkQLHL
0,18/(6&80,+$(/$
3VLKRGLDJQR]DPRGHUQ &KHVWLRQDUHOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
0LKDHOD 0LQXOHVFX (G D ,9D %XFXUHúWL (GLWXUD )XQGD LHL
5RPkQLDGH0kLQH
%LEOLRJU
,6%1
5HSURGXFHUHDLQWHJUDO VDXIUDJPHQWDU SULQRULFHIRUP
úLSULQRULFHPLMORDFHWHKQLFHHVWHVWULFWLQWHU]LV
úLVHSHGHSVHúWHFRQIRUPOHJLL
5 VSXQGHUHDSHQWUXFRQ LQXWXOúLRULJLQDOLWDWHDWH[WXOXL
UHYLQHH[FOXVLYDXWRUXOXLDXWRULORU
7HKQRUHGDFWRU9DVLOLFKLD,21(6&8
&RSHUWD0DULOHQD% /$1
%XQGHWLSDU&ROLWLSDU
)RUPDWu
(GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH
%XOHYDUGXO7LPLúRDUDQU%XFXUHúWL6HFWRU
7HO)D[ZZZVSLUXKDUHWUR
HPDLOFRQWDFW#HGLWXUDURPDQLDGHPDLQHUR
81,9(56,7$7($63,58+$5(7
)$&8/7$7($'(62&,2/2*,(±36,+2/2*,(
0,+$(/$0,18/(6&8
36,+2',$*12=$02'(51
&+(67,21$5(/('(3(5621$/,7$7(
(GL LDD,9D
(',785$)81'$ ,(,520Æ1,$'(0Æ,1(
%XFXUHúWL
&835,16
&XYkQWvQDLQWH«««««««««««««««««««««
&DSLWROXO,&HULQ HIXQGDPHQWDOHvQFRQVWUXLUHD
úLH[SHULPHQWDUHDFKHVWLRQDUXOXLGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
3ULQFLSDOHOHOLPLWHúLGLILFXOW LLQWULQVHFLP VXU ULLSHUVRQDOLW LL
SULQFKHVWLRQDUH««««««««««««««««««
&HULQ HJHQHUDOHúLHWDSHJHQHUDOHvQFRQVWUXLUHDXQXLFKHVWLRQDU
6WUDWHJLLOHGHFRQVWUXLUHDFKHVWLRQDUHORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH««
0HWRGDLQWXLWLY ««««««««««««««««
0HWRGDHPSLULF «««««««««««««««
0HWRGDDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOH««««««««««««
0RGDOLW LOHGHFRQVWUXLUHDLWHPLORUFKHVWLRQDUHORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
3UREOHPDOLPEDMXOXL««««««««««««««
5HOD LDLWHP±WU V WXU «««««««««««««
&DUDFWHULVWLFLGHVXSUDID DOHLWHPLORU«««««««
&DUDFWHULVWLFLVHPDQWLFHDOHLWHPLORU««««««««
&DUDFWHULVWLFLSVLKRPHWULFH««««««««««««
([WLQGHUL&DUDFWHULVWLFLSULYLQGJHQHUDUHDLWHPLORU««««««
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH«««««««««««««
3URLHFWDSOLFDWLYGHVHPHVWUX«««««««««««
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU««««««««««
%LEOLRJUDILHúLFRPHQWDULL««««««««««««
&DSLWROXO,,&KHVWLRQDUXOGH3HUVRQDOLWDWH&DOLIRUQLD
7U V WXULGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH«««««««««««««««
7HRULDOXL+*RXJKSULYLQGGLPHQVLXQLOHLQWHUUHOD LRQDOH
DOHSHUVRQDOLW LL««««««««««««««««««
&RQFHS LDOXL*RXJKSULYLQGHYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL
úLFRQVWUXLUHDXQXLFKHVWLRQDUGHGLFDWQRUPDOLW LL«««««
9DULDQWDGLQD,QYHQWDUXOXLGH3HUVRQDOLWDWH&DOLIRUQLD«
&HOHGLPHQVLXQLDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLQRUPDOH
3UH]HQWDUHDVFDOHORUFRQ LQXWXULúLDWULEXWH
vQFRPSRUWDPHQWXOLQWHUSHUVRQDO«««««««««
,QWHUSUHWDUHDVFDOHORU««««««««««««««
8WLOL]DUHDGDWHORU&3,vQFRQVLOLHUHDHGXFD LRQDO
úLYRFD LRQDO «««««««««««««««««««
6FDOHOHDEUHYLDWH003,««««««««««««««
9DULDQWDD&3,úLPRGHOXOFXERLG««««««««
([HPSOLILFDUHDLQWHUSUHW ULLXQXLSURILO«««««««««
([WLQGHUL&HUFHW ULGHVI úXUDWHFXFKHVWLRQDUXO&3,««««
$GMHFWLYH&KHFN/LVW$&/«««««««««««
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH«««««««««««««
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU«««««««««
%LEOLRJUDILH«««««««««««««««
&DSLWROXO,,,&KHVWLRQDUXO)DFWRUL3ULPDUL±3)4
&KHVWLRQDUXOGH$Q[LHWDWH±&&KHVWLRQDUXOGH3HUVRQDOLWDWH
SHQWUX$GROHVFHQ L±+634
7HRULDIDFWRULDO DOXL5%&DWWHOODVXSUDIRUP ULL
úLIXQF LRQ ULLSHUVRQDOLW LL««««««««««««««
&KHVWLRQDUXOIDFWRULSULPDUL±3)4««««««««
'DWHGHVSUHFKHVWLRQDU«««««««««««««
3UH]HQWDUHDIDFWRULORU««««««««««««««
0RGDOLWDWHDGHFDOFXODIDFWRULORUVHFXQGDUL«««««
&KHVWLRQDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHSHQWUXDGROHVFHQ L±+634«
6LQWH]HDOHFHUFHW ULORUD[DWHSHGLQDPLFDIDFWRULORU
vQDGROHVFHQ «««««««««««««««««
([HPSOLILFDUHDLQWHUSUHW ULLXQXLSURILO3)««««
&KHVWLRQDUXOÄ&´&DWWHOOSULYLQGQLYHOXODQ[LHW LL«««««
([HPSOLILFDUHDLQWHUSUHW ULLXQXLSURILOÄ&´«««««««
([WLQGHUL'DWHGHFHUFHWDUH«««««««««««««««
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH«««««««««««««
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU«««««««««
%LEOLRJUDILH«««««««««««««««
&DSLWROXO,9&KHVWLRQDUHOHGHWLSÄ%LJ)LYH´1(23,5$%&'±0
6WUDWHJLDGHFRQVWUXLUHSRUQLQGGHODVSHFLILFXOOLQJYLVWLF««
6HQVXOVXSHUIDFWRULORUvQFRQWH[WXOLQWHUSUHW ULLVWUXFWXULL
úLGLQDPLFLLSHUVRQDOLW LLWHRULDOXL&RVWDúL0F&UDH««««
&KHVWLRQDUXO1(2353UH]HQWDUHDIDFWRULORUúLID HWHORU««
'DWHGHFHUFHWDUHSULYLQGOHJ WXUDGLQWUH%LJ)LYH
úLVXSHUIDFWRULLPRWLYD LRQDOL«««««««««««
'DWHGHFHUFHWDUHSULYLQGVHPQLILFD LDVXSHUIDFWRULORUSHUVRQDOLW LL
vQUDSRUWGHVLQGURDPHOHFOLQLFH««««««««««««
$ERUG ULVWUXFWXUDOHPRGHOHOHGHWLSFLUFXPSOH[«««««
&HUFHW ULURPkQHúWL5HSOLFDUHDPRGHOXOXLSVLKROLQJYLVWLF
vQOLPEDURPkQ ««««««««««««««««««
&KHVWLRQDUXO$%&'±03UH]HQWDUHDIDFWRULORUúLID HWHORUDFHVWRUD
([HPSOLILFDUHSURILO1(23,5««««««««««««
([WLQGHUL,QVWUXPHQWHGHWLS%LJ)LYH«««««««««««
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH«««««««««««««
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU«««««««««
%LEOLRJUDILH«««««««««««««««««
&DSLWROXO9,QYHQWDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH0\HUV%ULJJV
7HRULDOXL&*-XQJSULYLQGWLSRORJLDGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH«««
,QYHQWDUXOWLSRORJLF0\HUV%ULJJV±IRUPD*«««««««
$WLWXGLQLOH([WUDYHUVLD(úL,QWURYHUVLD,3UHIHULQ D-
3
'HVFULHUHDVFDOHORU0%7,««««««««««««
7HPSHUDPHQWXO««««««««««««««««««
([HPSOLILFDUH«««««««««««««««««««
([WLQGHUL8WLOL]DUHD0%7,vQVHOHF LDSURIHVLRQDO FRQVLOLHUH
YRFD LRQDO úLvQFHUFHWDUH««««««««««««
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH«««««««««««««
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU««««««««««
%LEOLRJUDILH«««««««««««««««««
&DSLWROXO9,&KHVWLRQDUXO(\VHQFNGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH(34
úL,QYHQWDUXO(\VHQFNGH3HUVRQDOLWDWH(3,
7HRULDOXL(\VHQFNSULYLQGVWUXFWXUDSHUVRQDOLW LLúLP VXUDUHD
DFHVWHLD««««««««««««««««««««««
&HLWUHLIDFWRULWLSRORJLFLDLSHUVRQDOLW LLFRQ LQXWXULúLFHUFHW UL
H[SHULPHQWDOH«««««««««««««««««««
(34(\VHQFN3HUVRQDOLW\4XHVWLRQQDLUHúL(3,(\VHQFN
3HUVRQDOLW\,QYHQWRU\««««««««««««««««
,QWHUSUHWDUHDIDFWRULORUGLQ(3,««««««««««««
(34LQFOXGHúLRD,9DVFDO SVLKRWLVPXO«««««««
([HPSOLILFDUHDXQXLSURILO(3,««««««««««««
([WLQGHUL'DWHGHFHUFHWDUHSULYLQGFHLWUHLVXSHUIDFWRULvQVWXGLXO
SHUVRQDOLW LLGHOLFWXDOH«««««««««««««
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH«««««««««««««
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU««««««««««
%LEOLRJUDILH«««««««««««««««««
&DSLWROXO9,,&KHVWLRQDUXOGHWHQGLQ HDFFHQWXDWH6PLHVFKHFN
7HRULDOXL./HRQKDUGSULYLQGQRUPDOLWDWHDúLFRQGL LD
GHDQRUPDOLWDWH«««««««««««««««««««
&KHVWLRQDUXOGHWHQGLQ HDFFHQWXDWH«««««««««««
3UH]HQWDUHDFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUXQRUWLSXULGHILULDFFHQWXDWH««
([WLQGHUL&RQYHUWLUHDQRWHORUEUXWHvQSURFHQWH««««««
$ERUG ULFRQWHPSRUDQHDOHFRQGL LHLSVLKRSDWRORJLFH
DSHUVRQDOLW LL«««««««««««««««
(YROX LLúLWDEORXULFOLQLFHDOHXQRUDGLQWUHSHUVRQDOLW LOH
DFFHQWXDWH«««««««««««««««««
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH«««««««««««««
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU««««««««««
%LEOLRJUDILH«««««««««««««««««
&DSLWROXO9,,,,QYHQWDUXO0XOWLID]LFGH3HUVRQDOLWDWH0LQQHVRWD
&RQVWUXLUHD003,««««««««««««««««
6FDOHOHVWDQGDUGDOH003,FRQ LQXWXOVFDOHORUGHYDOLGDUH
úLDOVFDOHORUFOLQLFHDVSHFWHOHGHSVLKRSDWRORJLH«««««
&RQGL LDGHQRUPDOLWDWHDVFRUXULORU««««««««««
&RGLILFDUHDUH]XOWDWHORU«««««««««««««««
([HPSOLILFDUHDLQWHUSUHW ULLXQXLSURILO003,««««««
([WLQGHUL3UH]HQWDUHDQRLORUVFDOHVWDQGDUGúLH[SHULPHQWDOH
GLQ003,003,$««««««««««««
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH«««««««««««««
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU««««««««««
%LEOLRJUDILH«««««««««««««««««
&DSLWROXO,;&KHVWLRQDUXO3VLKRSDWLH1HYUR] 3DUDQRLD313
&kWHYDGDWHGHLVWRULH««««««««««««««««
$QDOL]DLWHPLORUúLFRQVWLWXLUHDVF ULLGHILQLWLYH«««««
,QWHUSUHWDUHDFKHVWLRQDUXOXL313««««««««««««
([WLQGHUL'DWHGHFHUFHWDUHSULYLQGYHULGLFLWDWHDGLDJQRVWLFXOXL«
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU««««««««««
%LEOLRJUDILH«««««««««««««««««
&DSLWROXO;7HVWHGHWHPSHUDPHQW*=766755=.34$,66
(YLGHQ DFRPSRUWDPHQWDO DFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUWHPSHUDPHQWDOH
&KHVWLRQDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH*XLOIRUG=LPPHUPDQ««««
&KHVWLRQDUXOGHWHPSHUDPHQW6WUHODXUHYL]XLW6755««
&KHVWLRQDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH=XFNHUPDQQ±.XOPDQ=.34«
,QYHQWDUXO6HQVDWLRQ6HHNLQJ$,66«««««««««
([WLQGHUL,QYHQWDUXO$,66LWHPLLJULODLQWHUSUHWDUHD«««««
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU««««««««««
%LEOLRJUDILH«««««««««««««««««
*ORVDU««««««««««««««««««««««««
%LEOLRJUDILHJHQHUDO ««««««««««««««««««
&89Æ17Ì1$,17(
6HFROXO;;DUHSUH]HQWDWXQWULXPIDOúWLLQ HLDSOHFDWHVSUHFXQRDúWHUHD
UHDOXOXL H[WHULRU ILLQ HL XPDQH 6HFROXO ;;, YD WUHEXL V FRPSHQVH]H SULQWUR
HJDO SUHRFXSDUHSHQWUXFXQRDúWHUHDUHDOLW LLLQWHULRDUHDSVLKLFXOXLXPDQD
VWUXFWXULORUSURIXQGHDGLQDPLFLLDVHQVXULORUIRUPDWLYH$FHVWOXFUXFXDWkW
PDLPXOWFXFkWGDF YUHPV VW SkQLPU XOGLQOXPHGLVWUXJHUHDúLKDRVXO
VRFLDOSDVXOYDILVSUHFXQRDúWHUHDúLVW SkQLUHDGLVWUXJHULLúLKDRVXOXLSURSULX
± VSUH UHVSRQVDELOLWDWHD SURIXQG D JHVWXULORU úL DF LXQLORU SURSULL DVXPDWH
FRQúWLHQW
'DF DVW ]L RPXO RELúQXLW úWLH GLQ FH vQ FH PDL PXOW GHVSUH IHOXO FXP
HVWHDOF WXLWúLIXQF LRQHD] FRUSXOXPDQHOúWLHvQV IRDUWHSX LQGHVSUHSURSULXO
SVLKLF OLEHUXO DUELWUX YLVXO HPDQFLS ULL LQGLYLGXOXL GH VXE WXWHOD QDWXULL VH
GRYHGHúWHH[DPLQDWvQGHDSURDSHRKLPHU 1XQRLVXQWHPDGHY UD LLVW SkQL
DL FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL GHFL]LLORU UHDF LLORU FKLDU JkQGXULORU QRDVWUH ùL QLFL
P FDU QX HVWH FLQHYD GLQ H[WHULRUXO QRVWUX DFHOD SH FDUH V O SXWHP vQYLQXL
VDX UXJD 0XOW GLQ FHHD FH IDFHP VXQWHP GHFLGHP JkQGLP YLV P LQH GH
LQWHULRUXOSURIXQGDOILLQ HLQRDVWUHGHIRU HOHXULDúHDOHUHDOLW LLSVLKLFHODIHO
GHXULDúHSUHFXPFHOHFDUH LQODRODOW VWUXFWXUDDWRPXOXLvQWURHQWLWDWH
0DL DOHV GLQ DFHDVW SHUVSHFWLY SULYLWH OXFUXULOH REVHUYD LD XQRUD
GLQWUH JkQGLWRULL FHL PDL VFHSWLFL DL VHFROXOXL WUHFXW vúL GH]Y OXLH DGHY UDWD
VHPQLILFD LHGDF YDILV PDLH[LVW PVHFROXODELDvQFHSXWYDWUHEXLV ILHXQ
VHFRODOILLQ HLQRDVWUHSURIXQGHDOWUDQVFHQGHQ HL8QVHFROvQFDUHRPXOYDIL
UHVSRQVDELOGHVLQHVDXQXYDPDLILGHORF8QVHFROvQFDUHYRPF XWDWHPHLXO
ILLQ ULL vQ DFHO LPDJR GHL QRL vQúLQH UHQXQ kQG OD KLPHUD HJRFHQWULVPXOXL
SHQWUX D SXWHD GD FXUV úL VHQV SRWHQ HORU FUHDWLYH vQWUXQ PRG FRQVWUXFWLY úL
DUPRQLFSHQWUXUHDOLWDWHDGLQMXU
ÌQF GLQ-XQJYRUEHúWHvQ6LQHOHGHVFRSHULWGHPRGXOSDUDGR[DO
ÄGXEOD JkQGLUH´ SULQ FDUH WUHEXLH V OXFUH]H PLQWHD RPXOXL GH úWLLQ GDF
GRUHúWH V vQ HOHDJ FHYD GLQ UHDOLWDWHD SVLKLVPXOXL XPDQ 3H GH R SDUWH
LQWHUYLQHFXQRDúWHUHDDVLJXUDW SULQHGXFD LDúWLLQ LILF ED]DW vQSULQFLSDOSH
DGHY UXOVWDWLVWLFIXUQL]kQGRLPDJLQHUD LRQDO úLUHDOLVW DOXPLLLPDJLQHvQ
FDUH LQGLYLGXO FRQFUHW DSDUH FD XQ IHQRPHQ PDUJLQDO I U D MXFD XQ URO
GHFLVLY 3H GH DOW SDUWH FRQFRPLWHQW YD WUHEXL V LQWHUYLQ vQ MXGHFDW DO
GRLOHDWLSGHJkQGLUHGLDPHWUDORSXVFDUHSRUQHúWHGHODVLWXDUHDLQGLYLGXOXL
vQFHQWUXOFXQRDúWHULLÄGDWH[LVWHQ LDOLUD LRQDOFDUHHVWHDGHY UDWXOSXUW WRU
DOUHDOLW LL´RPXOFRQFUHWRSXVRPXOXLÄQRUPDO´
&D SVLKRGLDJQRVWLFLDQ PDL DOHV XWLOL]kQG GDWHOH RE LQXWH SULQ
LQVWUXPHQWH GH HYDOXDUH FXDQWLILFDELOH SUHFXP FKHVWLRQDUHOH GH
SHUVRQDOLWDWHHVWHGLILFLOGDUDEVROXWQHFHVDUV LDVXPLUHVSRQVDELOLWDWHD
GH D YHGHD GLQFROR GH LQIRUPD LLOH QRUPDOL]DWH IHOXO FXP GDWHOH RE LQXWH
SULQDFHVWHLQVWUXPHQWHSRWILLQWHJUDWHvQHFXD LDSHUVRQDO DRPXOXLYLXSH
FDUH vO DL vQ ID 6 DL vQ DFHODúL WLPS R OLPSHGH JkQGLUH DQDOLWLF úL R
LQWXL LHVLQWHWLF SULYLQGDVSHFWHOHGLQDPLFHVSHFLILFHSHUVRDQHL
3VLKRGLDJQR]D HVWH XQ SDV 0 ULPHD UHDO D DFHVWXL SDV PRGXO FXP
SXWHP V FXQRDúWHP SHQWUX D DMXQJH OD vQ HOHJHUH VHQVXO QRUPDWLY VDX
LGHRJUDILFDOGHPHUVXOXLvQVXúLU PkQRGHFL]LHSHUVRQDO DILHF UXLDGLQWUH
SVLKRORJLGHFL]LHFDUH LQHúLGHFkWGHODUJLúLDSURIXQGDWHVXQWFXQRúWLQ HOH
VDOH FkW GH UHVSRQVDELO HVWH GLVSXV V VH LPSOLFH vQ LQWHUSUHW UL GHS úLQG
WHQWD LDXQXLGHPHUVGLDJQRVWLFUHGXF LRQLVWúLDVXPkQGXúLGLILFLODVDUFLQ D
XQHLvQ HOHJHULFHQWUDWHSHVXELHFWSHVWUXFWXUDGHSURIXQ]LPH8QDVWIHOGHSDV
QX FHUH IRUPD LD XQXL HUXGLW GDU FHUH LQVWLQFWXO FHUFHW WRUXOXL SHQWUX FDUH
ILHFDUH DVSHFW GHVFKLGH QRL SRVLELOLW L IRUPXOHD] QRL LSRWH]H FDUH VH FHU
FRUHODWH YHULILFDWH FDUH FRQGXF VSUH QRL DVSHFWH WRW PDL VWUXFWXUDWH úL PDL
FRHUHQWHGDUI U DXFLGHPLVWHUXOÄFRURODGHPLQXQL´DXQLFLW LLILLQ HLYLL
WUDQVIRUPkQGR vQWUXQ DGHY U vQFUHPHQLW úL LUHOHYDQW SHQWUX YLD ) U D
DPEL LRQDVSUHGHFL]LLGHILQLWLYHSHQWUXF YLD DLUD LRQDO úLSURWHLF QXYD
SXWHDILQLFLRGDW VXSXV úLFXSULQV vQWURGRJP
&HHD FH QH SXWHP GRUL HVWH V S úLP FX VILDO GDU FRQúWLHQ L vQ
VDQFWXDUXO ]HXOXL QX FHUkQGXL VXSXQHUH VDX vQGXUDUH FL vQFHUFkQG V
FXSULQGHPúLV QHLQWHJU PDUPRQLHLúLRUGLQLLFUHD LHLSULPRUGLDOH$WXQFL
DELDDWXQFLYRPSXWHDVSXQHRGDW FX-XQJF QXQXPDLFXQRDúWHPGDUúL
vQ HOHJHP QX QXPDL QH vQ HOHJHP SH QRL vQúLQH GDU vQ HOHJHP úL SH FHO
DVHPHQHD QRX úL WRWXúL PHUHX XQLF RP RELúQXLW &kQG RPXO RELúQXLW DO
SODQHWHLVHYDvQWRDUFHVSUHVLQHSHQWUXDVRQGDSURIXQ]LPLOHLQVRQGDELOHDOH
SVLKLVPXOXL SURSULX vQ HOHJkQG DVWIHO IUXPXVH HD úL IRU D ILLQ HL XPDQH
RDPHQLLQXYRUPDLILXQSHULFROSHQWUX7HUUD
3VLKRORJLD HVWH XQ JKLG SRDWH IL XQ SULP SDV 7UXGD úL YLFWRULD
DVXPDWH LQGLYLGXDO QH SRW vPERJ L PHUHX YLD D (VWH IRDUWH SRVLELO FD R
GDW FXHUDUHDOLW LLYLUWXDOHWHVWHOHSVLKRORJLFHV FXQRDVF RFXWRWXODOW
WXUQXU 9LLWRUXOHVWHPHUHXLQFLWDQWúLGHVFKLV
3ULQ DFHVW FXUV DP XUP ULW FXQRDúWHUHD vQ HOHJHUHD úL IRUPDUHD
DELOLW LORU úL GHSULQGHULORU FDUH SHUPLW SUDFWLFDUHD DFWLYLW LORU VSHFLILFH
SHQWUXWHVWDUHDSVLKRORJLF FXPVHFRQVWUXLHúWHXQFKHVWLRQDUSVLKRORJLFúL
FDUH VXQW FHULQ HOH úWLLQ LILFH FH SHUPLW FD UH]XOWDWHOH úL LQWHUSUHWDUHD
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL SHUVRDQHL V ILH YDOLGH FDUH VXQW VWUDWHJLLOH GH WHVWDUH
SVLKRORJLF DSHUVRQDOLW LLWLSXULGHWHVWHúLWLSXULGHDSOLFD LLSUDFWLFH
$SOLFD LH FRQVWUXLUHD XQXL FKHVWLRQDU GHGLFDW XQHL WU V WXUL GH
SHUVRQDOLWDWH DSOLFDUHD H[SHULPHQWDO SH XQ ORW GH VXELHF L úL DQDOL]D
úWLLQ LILF DQDOL]DGHLWHPLúLILGHOLWDWHD±FRQVLVWHQ DLQWHUQ DDFHVWXLD
ÌQ SUH]HQWDUHD XQRU FRQFHSWHFKHLH DX IRVW SUHOXFUDWH úL GDWHOH GLQ
XUP WRDUHOHGLF LRQDUHGHSVLKRORJLH
'LFWLRQDU\RI3V\FKRORJ\$65HEHU7KH3HQJXLQ
'LF LRQDUGHSVLKRORJLH5'RURQ)3DURW+XPDQLWDV
'LF LRQDUGHSVLKRORJLH8ùFKLRSX
'LF LRQDUGHSVLKRORJLH/DURXVVH(GLWXUD8QLYHUV(QFLFORSHGLF
$XWRDUHD
&DSLWROXO,
&(5,1 ()81'$0(17$/(Ì1&216758,5($
ù,(;3(5,0(17$5($&+(67,21$58/8,
'(3(5621$/,7$7(
&DSLWROXO SULP VH FHQWUHD] SH SUREOHPDWLFD WHKQLFLL GH
FRQVWUXLUH úL H[SHULPHQWDUH D FKHVWLRQDUHORU GHVWLQDWH HYDOX ULL
SHUVRQDOLW LL 'LQWUH DVSHFWHOH WHRUHWLFH úL SUDFWLFH VXQW SUH]HQWDWH
SULQFLSDOHOHOLPLWHúLGLILFXOW LLQWULQVHFLP VXU ULLSHUVRQDOLW LLSULQ
FKHVWLRQDUH FHULQ HOH JHQHUDOH úL HWDSHOH JHQHUDOH FDUH LQWHUYLQ vQ
FRQVWUXLUHDúLH[SHULPHQWDUHDLQVWUXPHQWHORUSVLKRORJLFHGHDFHVWWLS
VWUDWHJLLOHGHFRQVWUXLUHDFKHVWLRQDUHORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHSULQPHWRGD
LQWXLWLY PHWRGD HPSLULF úL PHWRGD DQDOL]HL IDFWRULDOH 6XQW SUH
]HQWDWHúLSULQFLSDOHOHWLSXULGHSUREOHPHFDUHDSDUvQFRQVWUXLUHDúL
H[SHULPHQWDUHDLWHPLORUFKHVWLRQDUXOXLUHVSHFWLYVWUDWHJLLOHJHQHUDOH
GH FRQVWUXLUH D LWHPLORU úL SUREOHPD OLPEDMXOXL XWLOL]DW WLSXULOH GH
UHOD LL vQWUH LWHP úL WU V WXUD GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH SUREOHPHOH OHJDWH GH
FDUDFWHULVWLFLOHGHVXSUDID DOHLWHPLORUGHFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHVHPDQWLFH
DOH LWHPLORU úL GH FHOH SVLKRPHWULFH 'H DVHPHQHD VXQW SUH]HQWDWH
FRQFHSWHOH VHPQLILFDWLYH XQ WHVW FX vQWUHE UL GH HYDOXDUH D FXQRú
WLQ HORUúLUHIHULQ HOHELEOLRJUDILFH
ÌQFDGUXODFHVWXLFXUVVWXGHQWXOUHDOL]HD] úLXQSURLHFWGHFHU
FHWDUHDOF UXLFRQ LQXWHVWHSUH]HQWDWODILQHOHDFHVWXLFDSLWRO
3ULQFLSDOHOHOLPLWHúLGLILFXOW LLQWULQVHFLP VXU ULL
SHUVRQDOLW LLSULQFKHVWLRQDUH
ÌQDLQWHGHDSUH]HQWDFHULQ HOHIXQGDPHQWDOHFDUH LQGHFRQVWUX
LUHDúLYDOLGDUHDXQXLFKHVWLRQDUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHYRPWUHFHvQUHYLVW
FkWHYD GLQWUH SULQFLSDOHOH OLPLWH úL GLILFXOW L SHQWUX DFHVW JHQ GH
LQVWUXPHQWHGHHYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL
&HHD FH WHRUHWLFLHQL GH DQYHUJXUD XQRU $QDVWDVL VDX &URQEDFK
DFXPGHDQLúL$QJOHLWQHU-RKQ/|KUVDX+RIVWHHúL'H5DDG&RVWD
úL0F&UDHSHQWUXDQLL¶UHSURúHD] FKHVWLRQDUHORUFDLQVWUXPHQWH LQH
GHOLPLWHOHFDSDFLW LLGHRSHUD LRQDOL]DUHDGLPHQVLXQLORUGHP VXUDWGH
H[SULPDUH GDU úL GH FRQWUROXO PRGXOXL FXP HVWH WUDQVPLV úL UHFHSWDW
LQIRUPD LD0DLPXOWGHSLQGHGHRGLILFXOWDWHH[WHULRDU LQVWUXPHQWXOXL
SURSULX]LV úL DQXPH GH LQWHQ LRQDOLWDWHD úL VWDUHD LQWHULRDU D UHV
SRQGHQWXOXL úL GLVWRUVLXQLOH FRQVHFXWLYH DFHVWHLD $QDOL]HOH PRGHUQH
vQFHDUF V UHFRQVLGHUHvQWURPDQLHU VLVWHPDWLF GLIHULWHOHQLYHOHDOH
SUREOHPDWLFLL FKHVWLRQDUHORU vQ SULPXO UkQG PRGXO GH FRQVWUXLUH D
LWHPLORU IRUPD úL FRQ LQXWXO ORU vQ DO GRLOHD UkQG VH DGUHVHD] FKLDU
WHKQLFLORUVWDWLVWLFHSHQWUXDGHWHFWDVXUVHGHGLVWRUVLRQDUHVDXSHQWUXD
FRQVWUXLPRGHOHVLVWHPLFHGHFRQWUROPDWHPDWLFDOFRUHO ULLLQIRUPD LLORU
D GLPHQVLXQLORU úL D ID HWHORU DFHVWRUD DWkW vQWUH HOH FkW úL FX DOWH
DVSHFWHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LL
8UPDUHD DFHVWXL VLVWHPDWLF HIRUW GH FRQWURO DO FLUFXOD LHL úL
SUHOXFU ULLLQIRUPD LHLODWRDWHQLYHOHOHGHODIRUPXODUHDúLFRQVWUXLUHD
FKHVWLRQDUXOXL OD UHFHSWDUHD OD SUHOXFUDUHD úL UH]ROYDUHD LWHPLORU GH
F WUH VXELHFW úL DSRL OD LQWHUSUHWDUHD DFHVWRU U VSXQVXUL vQWUR PDQLHU
FDUHV VHDSURSLHFkWPDLPXOWGHUHDOLWDWHDYLHHVWHFRQVWLWXLW SHGHR
SDUWHGLQWD[RQRPL] ULOHFDUHDXFODULILFDWvQXOWLPXOGHFHQLXREXQ
SDUWHGLQÄKDRVXO´XQRUSUREOHPHSUHFXPIRUPDWXOLWHPLORUFRQ LQXWXO
ORUFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHVLWXD LRQDOHHWF3HGHDOW SDUWHDFHVWHSUREOHPHIDF
RELHFWXOXQRUGH]EDWHULvQVLPSR]LRDQHLQWHUQD LRQDOHFXWHPHSUHFXP
FDX]DOLWDWHD6LOYD:HVWPH\HUGH]LUDELOLWDWHD1RZDFN+RIVWHH
+HQGULNV3DUOKXV%RUNHQDX 2VWHQGRUI)HUQDQGH]%DOOHVWHURV
=DPDUURQ ED]HOH ELRFKLPLFH DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL =XFNHUPDQQ
OXDUHD GHFL]LHL vQ SVLKRGLDJQR] :HVWPH\HU YDQ GHU
%HUNHQ YDQ$UOH9RV
ùL WRWXúL GDF DU IL V FRQFOX]LRQ P QX VH SXQH DWkW SUREOHPD
UHODWLYL] ULLYDORULLFKHVWLRQDUHORUvQFXQRDúWHUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLFXPDX
IRVWVDXVXQWXQLLWHQWD LV JkQGHDVF FLDP VXULLvQFDUHXQLQVWUXPHQW
DF UXLVWDQGDUGL]DUHvPSLQJHVSUHLQIHUHQ HWLSRORJLFHFXXQÄJUDGPHGLX
GHJHQHUDOLWDWH´SRDWHVXUSULQGHúLXQLFLWDWHDIRUPDYLHDSVLKLVPXOXL
IHOXO FXP VH PDQLIHVW DFHOH WU V WXUL vQ FRPSOH[LWDWHD LQWHUGHWHUPL
Q ULORUSVLKLFHùLQXHVWHFRUHFWV FHUHPXQXLLQVWUXPHQWV FXDQWLILFH
FHHDFHvQHVHQ DVDQXDSXWXWILFXDQWLILFDW±SVLKLVPXOYLX
$úDGDU OLPLWD SULQFLSDO D FKHVWLRQDUXOXL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH HVWH
LQWULQVHF DFHVWXLWLSGHGHPHUVFXDQWLILFDELO
'HDVHPHQHDGLQWUHGLILFXOW LOHFODVLFHDYXWHvQYHGHUHDF URU
UH]ROYDUHYDPDLvQVHPQDvQF PXOWHWHPHGHFHUFHWDUHVXQWÄYL]LELOL
WDWHD´LWHPLORUJUDGXOGHVFKLPEDUHYVFRQVWDQ DFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL
P VXUDWVSHFLILFLWDWHDPDUHDU VSXQVXULORUvQVIHUDSHUVRQDOLW LLFDUH
DWUDJHGLILFXOW LvQJUXSDUHDORUvQFDWHJRULLELQHGHILQLWHGHWU V WXUL
VDX VWUXFWXUL DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL úL GHWHUPLQDUHD XQRU FULWHULL H[WHUQH
DGHFYDWHSULQFDUHV VHFDOFXOH]HHPSLULFJUDGXOGHYDOLGLWDWH
2DOW SUREOHP PDMRU LQHQXDWkWGHFRQVWUXLUHDFKHVWLRQDUHORU
FkW GH LQWHUSUHWDUHD GDWHORU 2ULJLQHD FKHVWLRQDUHORU VW SUREDELO vQ
QHFHVLWDWHDGHDUHDOL]DXQLQWHUYLXFkWPDLVLVWHPDWL]DW&HHDFHLPSOLF
VXSR]L LDF ILHFDUHU VSXQVWUHEXLHFRQVLGHUDWVDXSRQGHUDWFDLQGLFLXDO
H[LVWHQ HL VDX DO SUH]HQ HL DVSHFWXOXL DYXW vQ YHGHUH ,QWHUSUHWDUHD
IDFWXDO ±YHULGLF ±OLWHUDO VHED]HD] SHYDOLGLWDWHDGHFRQ LQXWúLVH
DSURSLH IRDUWH PXOW GH VLWXD LD LQWHUYLXOXL VLVWHPDWL]DW ,QWHUSUHWDUHD
SVLKRORJLF ± GLDJQRVWLF ± VLPSWRPDWLF HVWH SRVLELO vQ XUPD
H[SHULPHQW ULLúLYDOLG ULLFKHVWLRQDUXOXLUHVSHFWLYDVWDELOLULLHPSLULFH
DUHOD LHLGLQWUHU VSXQVXULOHODLWHPLúLXQFULWHULXVSHFLILFDWGHYDOLGDUH
$QDVWDVL
2DGRXDVXUV GHLQWHUPLQDELOHGLVFX LLSULYLQGFHDQXPHLQWHU
SUHW PDWXQFLFkQGLQWHUSUHW PU VSXQVXOODLWHPLHVWHIDSWXOF H[LVW R
LQHUHQW DPELJXLWDWH D U VSXQVXULORU GRYHGLW GH DOWIHO H[SHULPHQWDO
(LVHQEHUJ )RUVPDQ FHHD FH FRQGXFH VSUH SRVLELOLWDWHD
XQHLJDPHUHODWLYODUJLGHLQWHUSUHW ULSHQWUXILHFDUHU VSXQV)RUPXODUHD
PDLVSHFLILF úLPDLFODU DLWHPLORUSUHFXPúLIRUPXODUHDXQRUVHWXUL
GHU VSXQVXULVSHFLILFDWHSRWFRQGXFHSHGHRSDUWHODVF GHUHDJDPHL
GHSRVLELOLW LGHLQWHUSUHWDUHGHF WUHVXELHFWDFRQ LQXWXOXLGDUSDUD
GR[DOFRQGXFúLVSUHRÄYL]LELOLWDWH´SUHDPDUHFDUHIDFHFDU VSXQVXULOH
V SRDUWH DPSUHQWD SUHD SXWHUQLF D VHWXULORU DWLWXGLQDOH D LQWHQ LRQD
OLW LLDHIHFWXOXLGHID DG úLQXvQXOWLPXOUkQGDVW ULORUHPR LRQDOH
SHFDUHOHWU LHúWHVDXOHDWUDYHUVDWGHFXUkQGVXELHFWXO([LVW YRFLvQ
GRPHQLXOSVLKRORJLHLSHUVRQDOLW LLFDUHRGDW FX$OOSRUWFRQ
VLGHU F SHUVRDQD SRDWH IL DGHFYDW GHVFULV QXPDL vQ WHUPHQLL
SDWHUQXULORU VSHFLILFH GH LQWHUUHOD LRQDUH PDL SX LQ SULQ WU V WXUL
FRPXQH0RGHOXOGLQGHVFULVGH0F&UDHúL&RVWDSXQHvQEXQ
P VXU SUREOHPD FODULILF ULL D FHHD FH SXWHP P VXUD vQ PRG UHDO GLQ
QDWXUDXPDQ úLDPRGDOLW LORUvQFDUHSXWHPWUDWDDFHDVW LQIRUPD LH
&HULQ HJHQHUDOHúLHWDSHJHQHUDOH
vQFRQVWUXLUHDXQXLFKHVWLRQDU
ÌQFRQVWUXLUHDXQXLFKHVWLRQDUGHHYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLH[LVW
GRX SUREOHPHHVHQ LDOHFXFDUHVHFRQIUXQW RULFHSVLKRORJ
GHILQLUHDFRQVWUXFWXOXLGHFLDWU V WXULLFDUHWUHEXLHP VXUDW
FRQVWUXLUHDXQXLVHWGHLWHPLSULQFDUHVXELHFWXOHVWHÄvQWUHEDW´
vQ OHJ WXU FX DFHOH FRPSRUWDPHQWH FDUH VXQW UHOHYDQWH SHQWUX WU V
WXUD UHVSHFWLY VDX vQ OHJ WXU FX VLWXD LLOH UHOHYDQWH SHQWUX DFHD WU
V WXU 5 VSXQVXULOHVXELHFWXOXLODDFHúWLLWHPLYRUVHUYLFDLQGLFDWRUL
DLFRQVWUXFWXOXL
9RPvQFHUFDV SUH]HQW PvQFRQWLQXDUHFkWHYDGLQWUHSUREOHPHOH
OHJDWHGHFRQVWUXLUHDúLH[SHULPHQWDUHDDFHVWXLVHWFRHUHQWGHLWHPLFDUH
UHSUH]LQW FKHVWLRQDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
8Q WLS GH FHULQ H vQ SULPD HWDS GH FRQVWUXLUH D XQXL FKHVWLRQDU
SULYHúWH DOHJHUHD WLSXOXL GH SURE VDX FKHVWLRQDU &H SURE DOHJHP
GHSLQGHGHVFRSXOWHVW ULLFHWHVW PúLGHILQLUHDGRPHQLXOXLGH
DSOLFDUHGHFHWHVW PFRQVLOLHUHYRFD LRQDO H[SHUWL] FOLQLF H[SHUWL]
MXGLFLDU SVLKRWHUDSLHVHOHF LHSURIHVLRQDO VDXUHRULHQWDUHSURIHVLRQDO
HWF$FHVWJHQGHSUREOHPHDSDUHvQP VXUDvQFDUHWHVWDUHDWUHEXLHV
U VSXQG GHVLJXU XQRU SUREOHPH VSHFLILFH FDUH DSDU XQHRUL vQWUXQ
FRQWH[W VSHFLILF FH WUHEXLH GHILQLW OD UkQGXO OXL LDU SH GH DOW SDUWH
SVLKRORJXO SRUQHúWH GH OD EXQ vQFHSXW DYHUWL]DW vQ OHJ WXU FX WLSXO GH
H[SHFWD LLDOHVXELHFWXOXLPRWLYD LLVW ULDIHFWLYHDWLWXGLQLSUHMXGHF L
úLLGLRVLQFUDVLLFDUHSRWGLVWRUVLRQDFRPXQLFDUHDSULQFKHVWLRQDU
$OHJHUHD WLSXOXL GH SUREH vQVHDPQ vQ DFHDVW HWDS vQ DFHODúL
WLPS FRQVWUXLUHD LWHPLORU H[SHULPHQWDOL FX XQ VHW GH FHULQ H FDUH LQ
LQWULQVHFGHFRQVWUXLUHDFKHVWLRQDUXOXLDGHFYDUHDFRQ LQXWXOXLLWHPLORU
QXP UXO GH LWHPL RPRJHQLWDWHD VDX QHRPRJHQLWDWHD DFHVWRUD $FHVWH
FHULQ H YRU LQIOXHQ D FDOLW LOH SVLKRPHWULFH DOH LWHPLORU úL DOH FKHVWLR
QDUXOXLDVSHFWHSHFDUHOHYRPGLVFXWDPDLSHODUJvQDOWVXEFDSLWRO
2 D GRXD HWDS XOWHULRDU FRQVWLWXLULL XQXL SULP HúDQWLRQ GH
LWHPLSULYHúWHDSOLFDUHDH[SHULPHQWDO DDFHVWRUD,QL LDODSOLFDUHDVH
SRDWHUHDOL]DSHXQPLQLPGHVXELHF L0HLOLSHQWUXDU V
SXQGHXQRUvQWUHE ULFHVHUHIHU ODIDFWRULFDUHSRWLQIOXHQ DDOHDWRULX
UH]XOWDWHOHGLPLQXkQGILGHOLWDWHD
'LQWUHVXUVHOHGHHURDUHSRVLELOHFHSRWILDYXWHvQYHGHUHúLFR
UHFWDWHvQDFHDVW HWDS PHQ LRQ PVWDQGDUGL]DUHDFRUHFW DLQVWUXF
WDMXOXLúLDFRQGL LLORUVSHFLILFHGHU VSXQVVWDQGDUGL]DUHDWLSXOXLGH
U VSXQV IRUPXODUHD XQRU LWHPL VDXVFDOHGHÄYDOLGDUH´DFKHVWLRQD
UXOXLvQUDSRUWFXDWLWXGLQHDVXELHFWXOXLVXSUDVDXVXEHVWLPDUHDXQRU
VLPSWRPH VDX VLWXD LL DWLWXGLQL GH ID DG JUDGXO GH GH]LUDELOLWDWH OD
GLIHULWHJHQXULGHVXELHF LFRQVWUXLUHDXQRUH[HPSOHLQWURGXFWLYH
$ WUHLD HWDS D H[SHULPHQW ULL SULYHúWH DQDOL]D VWDWLVWLF SUHOL
PLQDU SHQWUX HOLPLQDUHD LWHPLORU FDUH QX VXQW RPRJHQL QX VXQW
VHPQLILFDWLYLGXEOHD] XQDQXPLWDVSHFWLQYHVWLJDWHWF6HUHDOL]HD]
vQJHQHUHSHXQQXP UGHVXELHF LFDUHV SHUPLW FODULILFDUHDXUP
WRDUHORU DVSHFWH QLYHOXO GH GLILFXOWDWH DO LWHPLORU UHSDUWL LD FR
UHFW D U VSXQVXULORU vQ IXQF LH GH GLIHULWH SRVLELOLW L SUHFL]DUHD
JULOHLFDSDFLWDWHDGHGLVFULPLQDUH
$FHVWHDVSHFWHFRQGXFODUHSDUWL LDHFKLOLEUDW DLWHPLORUvQFKHV
WLRQDU FRERUkUHD QLYHOXOXL GH GLILFXOWDWH DO OLPEDMXOXL OD QLYHOXO FDWH
JRULHL GH SHUVRDQH SHQWUX FDUH HVWH FRQVWUXLW FKHVWLRQDUXO HOLPLQDUHD
DFHORULWHPLFDUHQXFRQWULEXLHODSRVLELOLWDWHDGHDGLKRWRPL]DVXELHF LL
vQIXQF LHGHYDULDELODWHVWDW VDXFDUHVXQWLUHOHYDQ LvQUDSRUWFXDFHDVW
SRVLELOLWDWH $FHDVW XOWLP FDOLWDWH FDSDFLWDWHD GH GLVFULPLQDUH HVWH
FRQVLGHUDW DO WXUL GH RPRJHQLWDWH FD LQVHSDUDELO GH VHPQLILFD LD
SVLKRORJLF DWHVWXOXLUHVSHFWLYGHYDOLGLWDWHDVD0HLOL$FHVWH
FHULQ HLPSXQFDSHGHRSDUWHJUXSXOGHVXELHF LV ILHUHSUH]HQWDWLY
SHQWUX GLPHQVLXQHD DYXW vQ YHGHUH FULWHULX H[WHULRU úL SH GH DOW
SDUWH VDUFLQD VDX FRQ LQXWXO LWHPLORU V VH UHIHUH OD YDULDELOD DYXW vQ
YHGHUH$FHDVW FDSDFLWDWHGHGLIHUHQ LHUHVHGHWHUPLQ VWDWLVWLFILHSULQ
PHWRGD FRUHOD LHL FX XQ FULWHULX H[WHULRU ILH FRPSDUkQG FRUHOD LLOH
ILHF UXLLWHPFXUH]XOWDWXOJOREDODOVFDOHLVDXDOFKHVWLRQDUXOXLH[SHUL
PHQWDW 6FRSXO DFHVWHL HWDSH HVWH GH D HOLPLQD DFHL LWHPL FDUH VXQW
QHDGHFYD L úL GH DL RUGRQD SH FHL U PDúL vQ IXQF LH GH JUDGXO GH
GLILFXOWDWHGDF HVWHFD]XOGHWLSXOGHJULO IRORVLWGHH[HPSOXQXVH
YRU SXQH LWHPLL vQWUR VXFFHVLXQH SUHOXQJLW GH UHDF LL UHOHYDQWH SULQ
DFHODúLIHOGHU VSXQV±QXPDL'$QXPDL18
'HDVHPHQHDYRUILHOLPLQD LúLLWHPLLUHSUH]HQWDWLYLSHQWUXWU
V WXU GDUFDUHGDWRULW XQRUPRWLYHSUHFXPGH]LUDELOLWDWHDSULPHVF
DFHODúLWLSGHU VSXQVGHODPDUHDPDMRULWDWHDVXELHF LORUGHH[HPSOX
LWHPLGHIHOXOÄ(VWHLPSRUWDQWV H[LVWHROHJHPRUDO FDUHV PLJX
YHUQH]HFRPSRUWDPHQWXO´
$ SDWUD HWDS DUH FD VFRS VWDQGDUGL]DUHD LQWHUSUHW ULL SULQ VWDQ
GDUGL]DUHD FKHVWLRQDUXOXL 2 SULP FHULQ HVWH FRQVWLWXLUHD FRQIRUP
HWDSHORUDQWHULRDUHDFKHVWLRQDUXOXLvQIRUPDOXLGHILQLWLY 2DGRXD
HVWHGHDFRQVWUXLXQHúDQWLRQVDXORWGHVXELHF LFkWPDLGLYHUVLILFDW
vQIXQF LHGHFULWHULLOHVSHFLILFHFDWHJRULHLGHSHUVRDQHWHVWDWHFXDFHVW
LQVWUXPHQW 3H DFHúWL VXELHF L YRP DSOLFD FRQVHPQHOH GHILQLWLYH
H[HPSOHOH FDUH DMXW OD IDPLOLDUL]DUHD VXELHFWXOXL FX WLSXO GH SUR
EOHPHH[SHULPHQWDUHDOLPLWHLGHWLPSDYXWHvQYHGHUHGDF HVWHFD]XO
DFHVWXLGLQXUP DVSHFWVHYDFHUHVXELHF LORUV vQFHUFXLDVF QXP UXO
LWHPXOXLODFDUHU VSXQGDSRLGLQPLQXWvQPLQXWDFHODúLOXFUXSkQ
FkQGXOWLPXOVXELHFWWHUPLQ GHU VSXQV
8UPHD] FDOFXODUHDGLIHULWHORUIRUPHGHILGHOLWDWHFHUXWHGHLQVWUX
PHQW6HYDFRQWLQXDFXFHUFHW ULSULYLQGGLIHULWHOHID HWHDOHYDOLGLW LL
LQVWUXPHQWXOXL vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH QH LQWHUHVHD] úL FRQVHFLQ HOH GHFL
]LLORUJHQHUDOL]DUHDWHVWXOXLSHDOWHSRSXOD LLVDXDOWHFXOWXULúLVRFLHW L
RULIHOXOvQFDUHWHVWXOSUH]HQWFRUHOHD] FXDOWHPRGDOLW LGHDP VXUD
WU V WXUD DYXW vQ YHGHUH úL VSHFLILFLWDWHD LQVWUXPHQWXOXL GHWHUPLQDUHD
XQRUID HWHVSHFLILFHWU V WXULLSULQvQFHUFDUHDGHDJ VLVXEIDFWRULFDUH
FRQWULEXLH OD YDULD LD FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL vQ FDGUXO DFHOHLDúL WU V WXUL
YDOLGLWDWHDGHFL]LLORUvQGLIHULWHFRQWH[WHDSOLFDWLYHHWF
6WUDWHJLLOHGHFRQVWUXLUHDFKHVWLRQDUHORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
0HJDUJHHGLVFXWkQGvQSUREOHPHOHDQWUHQDWHGHFRQVWUXLUHD
,QYHQWDUXOXL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH &DOLIRUQLD PRGXO GH VHOHFWDUH D YDULD
ELOHORUVWUDWHJLDGHFRQVWUXLUHDWHVWXOXLSURSULX]LVUHDOL]HD] úLRDQD
OL] VLVWHPDWLF D PHWRGHORU GH FRQVWUXF LH D XQXL FKHVWLRQDU $FHDVW
FODVLILFDUHIDFHRELHFWXOXQXLDFRUGFYDVLJHQHUDOSULQWUHFHUFHW WRULLúL
FRQVWUXFWRULLGHFKHVWLRQDUHÌQPRGIXQGDPHQWDOvQIXQF LHGHPRGD
OLWDWHD GH FRQVWUXLUH úL VHOHFWDUH D LWHPLORU PHWRGHOH JHQHUDOH GH
FRQVWUXLUHDXQXLFKHVWLRQDUVXQWWUHLPHWRGDLQWXLWLY VDXDERUGDUHD
UD LRQDO PHWRGD FULWHULXOXL H[WHUQVDXPHWRGDHPSLULF PHWRGD
FULWHULXOXL LQWHUQ VDX PHWRGD IDFWRULDO 'HVLJXU SRW H[LVWD úL GLIHULWH
FRPELQ ULvQWUHHOHPHQWHOHVSHFLILFHFHORUWUHLWLSXULGHVWUDWHJLLGHFLúL
PHWRGH PL[WH 9RP XUP UL SH UkQG FDUDFWHULVWLFLOH GHPHUVXOXL H[SHUL
PHQWDOúLFRQVHFLQ HOHILHF UHLRS LXQLvQWHUPHQLLOLPLWHORUúLDYDQWDMHORU
0HWRGDLQWXLWLY
0HWRGDLQWXLWLY VHED]HD] SHDERUGDUHDUD LRQDO DFRQVWUXLULL
XQXLFKHVWLRQDUFDUHSXQHDXWRUXOvQSRVWXUDFUHDWRUXOXLFDUHGHFLGHFH
LWHPL WUHEXLH LQFOXúL úL FH FRQ LQXWXUL VXQW UHOHYDQWH SHQWUX D WUDGXFH
WU V WXUD vQWUXQ FRPSRUWDPHQW GHFL]LH FDUH DQWUHQHD] vQ VSHFLDO
H[SHULHQ D VD GH YLD FXQRDúWHUHD SVLKRORJLHL XPDQHvQJHQHUDOúLD
WLSXOXLGHSUREOHPHSVLKLFHDQWUHQDWHGHWU V WXUD LQW vQVSHFLDO
+DVH *ROGEHUJFODVLILF DERUG ULOHUD LRQDOHvQIXQF LH
GHGRX FULWHULL$VWIHOFULWHULXOSULYLQGVHOHF LDFRQ LQXWXOXLLWHPLORU
GLYL]HD] VWUDWHJLLOH LQWXLWLYH vQ DERUG UL vQ FDUH VHOHF LD LWHPLORU VH
ED]HD] SHvQ HOHJHUHDVWULFWLQWXLWLY DWU V WXULLúLUHVSHFWLYDERUG UL
vQFDUHVHOHF LDHVWHJKLGDW GHRWHRULHIRUPDOL]DW DVXSUDSHUVRQDOLW LL
úL FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL XPDQ GH DVHPHQHD FULWHULXO SULYLQG LQVWDQ D
FDUH VHOHF LRQHD] LWHPLL GLYL]HD] vQ VWUDWHJLL vQ FDUH DXWRUXO FKHVWLR
QDUXOXLHVWHFHOFDUHRSWHD] ID GHVWUDWHJLLOHvQFDUHVHFRQVWLWXLHXQ
JUXSGHSHUVRDQHMXGHF WRUL
0HJDUJHHGLIHUHQ LD] vQWUHVHOHF LLOHSXULQWXLWLYHúLFHOH
PL[WHGHQXPLWHÄSDU LDOHPSLULFH´vQFDUHVHOHF LDHVWHSDU LDOJKLGDW
GHGDWHOHH[SHULPHQWDOH$FHVWWLSGHVHOHF LHVHIRORVHúWHGHH[HPSOX
SHQWUX DFHOH VFDOH GLQ &3, FRQVWUXLWH SH ED]D DQDOL]HL FRQVLVWHQ HL
LQWHUQH ÌQ DVWIHO GH VFDOH DXWRUXO VHOHFWHD] LQWXLWLY XQ ORW GH LWHPL
FDUH SDU V UHIOHFWH DFHD WU V WXU XUPkQG FD DOHJHUHD LQL LDO V ILH
DQDOL]DW VXE UDSRUWXO FRQVLVWHQ HL LQWHUQH úL V ILH S VWUD L DFHL LWHPL
FDUH SUH]LQW XQ QLYHO VXILFLHQW GH vQFUHGHUH 3DWUX GLQ FHOH VFDOH
DOHYDULDQWHL&3,VXQWFRQVWUXLWHvQDFHVWPRG
$VWIHO XQ SRVLELO GHPHUV LQWXLWLY SRDWH FXSULQGH vQ JHQHUH
XUP WRULLSDúL
VHOHF LDLQWXLWLY DFRQ LQXWXOXLLWHPLORUúLDORWXOXLLQL LDOGHLWHPL
DGPLQLVWUDUHDvQWUHJXOXLORWGHLWHPLXQXLJUXSGHVXELHF L
FDOFXODUHDVFRUXULORUWRWDOHODDFHDVW VFDO SUHOLPLQDU
FDOFXOXO FRUHOD LLORU GLQWUH VFRUXULOH OD LWHPL úL VFRUXULOH WRWDOH
SHQWUXWR LLWHPLLGLQORWXOSUHOLPLQDU
DFHúWLFRHILFLHQ LGHFRUHOD LHYRUVHUYLGUHSWFULWHULXSHQWUXVHOHF LD
ILQDO DLWHPLORUFDUHSUH]LQW FHOHPDLvQDOWHFRUHOD LLvQWUHVFRUXULOH
SURSULLúLVFRUXULOHWRWDOH'HFLvQWUXQDVWIHOGHGHPHUVPL[WGDWHOH
HPSLULFHSRWILXWLOL]DWHSHQWUXDFUHúWHYDOLGLWDWHDGLVFULPLQDWLY D
WHVWXOXL SULQ HOLPLQDUHD LWHPLORU FDUH ILH DX SDWHUQXUL GH U VSXQV
DPELJXL ILH DX FRUHOD LL VHPQLILFDWLYH FX VFDOH FDUH P VRDU DOW
WU V WXU
0HJDUJHHFRQVLGHU FDSULQFLSDODYDQWDMDOVWUDWHJLHLLQWXLWLYHYDOL
GLWDWHDGHFRQ LQXWULGLFDW 8QDOGRLOHDDYDQWDMFRQVW GLQWURFRHUHQ
LQWULQVHF vQP VXUDvQFDUHXQDVHPHQHDLQVWUXPHQWHVWHXUPDUHDXQHL
FRQVLVWHQ HvQDERUGDUHúLVDXUHIOHFW XQFDGUXWHRUHWLFXQLYRF
3ULQFLSDOHOH GH]DYDQWDMH GRX OD QXP U LQ SH GH R SDUWH GH
IDSWXOF RPRJHQLWDWHDúLFRQ LQXWXOLWHPLORUGHSLQGGHDELOLWDWHDDXWR
UXOXLGHDúLLPDJLQDúLDQWLFLSDU VSXQVXULOHODSUREOHPHOHLWHPLORUD
SHUVRDQHORUFDUDFWHUL]DWHSULQWU V WXUDUHVSHFWLY 3HGHDOW SDUWHOD
IHOGHVLPSOXYDILúLSHQWUXVXELHFWV vQ HOHDJ VHQVXOúLPRGHOXOGH
U VSXQVH[SHFWDWGHDXWRUVDXGHFKHVWLRQDUFHHDFHvLYDIDFLOLWDSRVL
ELOLWDWHDGHDGLVWRUVLRQDYRLWU VSXQVXULOHSHQWUXDVLPXODRULGLVLPXOD
UHDF LLFRQYHQDELOHVDXGH]LUDELOH
0HWRGDHPSLULF
/D QLYHOXO DFHVWHL PHWRGH VHOHF LD LWHPLORU HVWH JKLGDW GRDU GH
UHOD LDGHWHUPLQDW HPSLULFvQWUHLWHPXOWHVWXOXLúLRP VXU FULWHULXVSH
FLILF $FHDVW PHWRG PDLSRDUW QXPHOHGHVWUDWHJLDFULWHULXOXLH[WHUQ
(WDSHOHSULQFLSDOHDOHVWUDWHJLHLFRQVWDXvQ
DVDPEODUHDXQXLHúDQWLRQLQL LDOGHLWHPL±GHRELFHLSHED]H
UD LRQDOHVDXUHXQLQGLWHPLLGLQGLIHULWHFKHVWLRQDUH
DGPLQLVWUDUHDORUXQXLJUXSGHVXELHF LFDUHGLIHU vQWUHHLGRDU
OD QLYHOXO WU V WXULL HYDOXDWH GHFL FHOH GRX ORWXULFULWHULX DU
WUHEXLvQPRGLGHDOV ILHDVHP Q WRDUHvQRULFHSULYLQ FX
H[FHS LDWU V WXULLVSHFLILFDWH
GHWHUPLQDUHD SHQWUX ILHFDUH ORW D IUHFYHQ HL U VSXQVXULORU
$FRUG'H]DFRUG
GHWHUPLQDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLVWDWLVWLFHDGLIHUHQ HORURE LQXWH
LWHPLLFDUHGLIHUHQ LD] VHPQLILFDWLYFHOHGRX ORWXULVXQWVH
OHFWD LSHQWUXVFDODSUHOLPLQDU
DFHDVW VFDO VHDSOLF GLQQRXORWXULORUFULWHULXLQL LDOH
GDF U VSXQVXULOH DQDOL]DWH VXQW VDWLVI F WRDUH VFDOD YD IL
YDOLGDW SH QRL ODWXUL FX VFRSXO GH D LGHQWLILFD úL HOLPLQD
LWHPLLFXRVODE FDSDFLWDWHGHGLVFULPLQDUH
DFHDVW VFDO SUHVFXUWDW úLUDILQDW YDILGLQQRXYDOLGDW
$YDQWDMXO SHQWUX GLDJQR] DO XQHL DVWIHO GH VHOHF LL JKLGDWH GH
FULWHULLH[WHULRDUHMXGHF LLFDOLWDWLYHDSVLKRORJXOXLFRQVW vQIDSWXOF
SHGHRSDUWHGHS úHúWHDELOLWDWHDLQWXLWLY DXQXLVLQJXURPLDUSHGH
DOW SDUWH UHSUH]LQW R FRQVHFLQ D FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL XQXL PDUH
QXP U GH SHUVRDQH ID GH FRQ LQXWXO LWHPLORU úL SRDWH GHWHFWD DVWIHO
LWHPLGLVFULPLQDWLYLFDUHVXQWGHSDUWHGHDILHYLGHQ LGHODVLQH
'HH[HPSOXvQFRQVWLWXLUHDVFDOHLGHVRFLDOL]DUHD&3,GHQX
PLW LQL LDOVFDODGHGHOLQFYHQ H[SHFWDQ DFRQVWUXFWRUXOXLSHQWUXXQ
LWHPGHIHOXOÄ$PIRVWGHVWXOGHLQGHSHQGHQWúLOLEHUGHFRQVWUkQJHUL
GLQSDUWHDIDPLOLHL´HUDFDWLQHULLGHOLQFYHQ LGLQORWXOFULWHULXV U V
SXQG Ä'D´vQP VXUDvQFDUHVWXGLLOHVRFLRSVLKRORJLFHUHOHY DFHDVW
LQGHSHQGHQ vQFD]XOFRSLLORUGHOLQFYHQ L
'DU HPSLULF VD VHOHF LRQDW SHQWUX LWHP FD VHPQLILFDWLY SHQWUX
JULO U VSXQVXO Ä1X´ GDW ILLQG IDSWXO F WLQHULL GHOLQFYHQ L U VSXQG
VHPQLILFDWLYÄ1X´FRPSDUDWLYFXORWXOGHQRQGHOLQFYHQ L/DIHOSHQWUX
VRFLRSDWLH QHDP SXWHD DúWHSWD FD XQ DVWIHO GH VXELHFW V U VSXQG
Ä)DOV´ OD LWHPXO Ä0DMRULWDWHD WLPSXOXL DP I FXW FHYD U X VDX JUHúLW´
HPSLULF UH]XOWDWHOH LQGLF úL IDSWXO F U VSXQVXULOH PDULL PDMRULW L D
VRFLRSD LORUU VSXQVGLIHUHQ LDWRUID GHVXELHF LLFRPXQLVXQWGHWLSXO
Ä$GHY UDW´
$FHVW DVSHFW DO GHSHQGHQ HL LQFOXGHULL LWHPLORU GH DFXUDWH HD
VHOHF LHL ORWXULORUFULWHULX IDFH FD RUJDQL]DUHD JUHúLW D DFHVWRU ORWXUL
V FRQGXF ODDUWHIDFWHODVHOHF LLJUHúLWHGHLWHPLFDUHVXQWGHIDSW
LUHOHYDQ L'HH[HPSOXvQVHOHFWDUHDLWHPLORUVFDOHLGHSVLKRSDWLHGLQ
003,ORWXOPDUWRUGHQRQGHOLQFYHQ LHUDVHPQLILFDWLYPDLWkQ UGHFkW
JUXSXO FDUH UHSUH]HQWD ÄSRSXOD LD DQRUPDO ´ LDU FRQVHFLQ D D IRVW F
VFRUXULOH OD DQXPL L LWHPL OD DGROHVFHQ LL QRQGHOLQFYHQ L HUDX IRDUWH
DSURSLDWHGHVFRUXULOHORWXOXLFULWHULXGHGHOLQFYHQ LXQHRULFKLDUPDL
PDULGHFkWDFHVWHD
'HFLvQPHWRGDFULWHULXOXLH[WHUQUHOD LDHPSLULFVWDELOLW FXXQ
FULWHULXH[WHULRUúLQXFRQ LQXWXOPDQLIHVWDOLWHPLORUGHWHUPLQ VHOHF
WDUHD ORU SHQWUX FKHVWLRQDUXO GHILQLWLY &KLDU vQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH QX QH
SXWHP H[SOLFD SVLKRORJLF GH FH ORWXO FULWHULX VH vQGUHDSW VSUH XQ
U VSXQV SDUDGR[DO ILH UHOD LD LWHPXOXL FX FULWHULXO HVWH REVFXU ILH
GLUHF LD U VSXQVXOXL SDUH DEVXUG LWHPXO YD IL LQFOXV vQ FKHVWLRQDU
GDF HVWHFDSDELOHPSLULFV GLIHUHQ LH]HORWXULOH
ÌQ DFHHDúL RUGLQH GH LGHL SVLKRORJXO QX HVWH SUHRFXSDW GH
DGHY UXOUHDOVDXOLWHUDODOU VSXQVXOXLVXELHFWXOXLGHFLGDF XQDQXPLW
VXELHFWHVWHDúDFXPDILUP F HVWHSULQU VSXQVXOODXQDQXPLWLWHP
YGLIHUHQ DGLQWUHFKHVWLRQDUúLLQWHUYLXFLLQWHUHVXOVHFHQWUHD] SH
UHOD LDGLQWUHU VSXQVXOVXELHFWXOXLODLWHPúLDOWHGLPHQVLXQLFRPSRU
WDPHQWDOHLPSOLFLWH'LQDFHVWHPRWLYHVFDOHOHGHULYDWHHPSLULFSRWIL
PDLVXEWLOHúLPDLGLILFLOGHWUXFDWGHFkWFHOHUD LRQDOH
$FHDVW VF GHUH D YDOLGLW LL DSDUHQWH VDX GH FRQ LQXW IDFH vQ
DFHODúLWLPSFDVFDOHOHV ILHFHYDPDLJUHXDFFHSWDWHGHVXELHF LDGH
VHDDSDUUHDF LLGHWLSXOÄ1XvQ HOHJGHFHY LQWHUHVHD] DFHVWOXFUX´
VDX Ä1X vQ HOHJ GH FH DFHVW DVSHFW DUH LPSRUWDQ SHQWUX DQJDMDUHD
PHD FD«´ HWF $FHODúL WLS GH FDX] IDFH VFDOD GHVWXO GH GLILFLO GH
H[SOLFDW QHVSHFLDOLúWLORU FDUH SUHVXSXQ DFHHDúL HFXD LH FD DFHHD D
LQWHUYLXOXLLQWHUHVXOSHQWUXFRQ LQXWXOIDFWXDODOLWHPLORU
0HWRGDDQDOL]HLFULWHULXOXLH[WHUQGHYLQHGHFLVLY DWXQFLFkQGVH
SXQH SUREOHPD XWLOLW LL SUHGLFWLYH SUDFWLFH D GLIHULWHORU FULWHULL GHFL
SHQWUX FRQVWUXLUHD XQRU FKHVWLRQDUH GH WLS YRFD LRQDO VDX SHQWUX
WU V WXULFDUHVXQWPDUFDWHGHSUHMXGHFDWDPHQWDOLW LLFRPXQH
0HWRGDDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOH
$FHDVW PHWRG SXQH DFFHQW SH DQDOL]D FULWHULXOXL LQWHUQ UHV
SHFWLYSHWHKQLFLVWDWLVWLFHFDUHSHUPLWFDRGDW FXLGHQWLILFDUHDXQXL
IDFWRUFDUHDSDUHFDGLPHQVLXQHUHVSRQVDELO GHYDULD LDVHPQLILFDWLY
DFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLV FRQVWUXLPúLRVFDO SHQWUXDGHILQLSVLKRORJLF
úLDHYDOXDUHVSHFWLYXOIDFWRU
3DúLLvQVWUDWHJLDDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOHSRUQHVFGHOD
FRQVWUXLUHDSHED]HDSULRULDXQXLORWUHODWLYPLFGHLWHPLFHOHODOWH
PHWRGH DYHDX ILHFDUH vQ YHGHUH VHOHFWDUHD ILQDO GLQWUXQ QXP U
LQL LDO PDUH GH SRVLELOL LWHPL LWHPL FH SDU V ILH VWUkQV OHJD L GH
IDFWRUXOYL]DW
DFHúWLLWHPLVXQWDGPLQLVWUD LXQXLQXP UPDUHGHVXELHF LFDUHvQ
SDUDOHOVXQWDGHVHDWHVWD LúLFXDOWHLQVWUXPHQWHLGHQWLILFDWHGHMDFD
VHPQLILFDWLYHvQUDSRUWFXIDFWRUXOVDXGLPHQVLXQHDYL]DW
VH SURFHGHD] OD LQWHUFRUHODUHD LWHPLORU PDWULFHD UH]XOWDW ILLQG
DQDOL]DW IDFWRULDOURWDW FRQIRUPSURFHGXULLDOHVHRE LQkQGXVHR
FOXVWHUL]DUHFDUHHVWHUHVSRQVDELO GHXQDQXPLWFXDQWXPDOYDULD
LHLFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLVXELHF LORUWHVWD L
VHGHWHUPLQ FRUHOD LDILHF UXLLWHPFXIDFWRUXOVDXIDFWRULLUH]XOWD L
vQF UF WXUDIDFWRULDO DLWHPXOXL
YRUILVHOHFWD LSHQWUXVFDODILQDO DFHLLWHPLFDUHDXFHDPDLvQDOW
vQF UF WXU IDFWRULDO &HHDFHDPRE LQXWHVWHRVROX LHVWUXFWXUDO
VLPSO vQFDUHILHFDUHGLQWUHIDFWRULHVWHUHVSRQVDELOSHQWUXRDQX
PLW WU V WXU
ÌQ DFHDVW PHWRG SRW LQWHUYHQL GLVWRUVLXQL GDWRUDWH PHWRGHL GH
DQDOL] IDFWRULDO +RIVWHH'H5DDG*ROGEHUJ+HQGULNV+RIVWHH
'H5DDGVDXÄOLSVHLGHGLVWLQFWLYLWDWHFRQFHSWXDO vQWUHVWUXFWXU
úLIHQRPHQ´3HUXJLQLÌQDFHVWHFRQGL LLDELOLWDWHDFHUFHW WRUXOXL
FRQVW vQDQDOL]DVHPQLILFD LHLSVLKRORJLFHDLWHPLORUFDUHVWUXFWXUHD]
XQ DQXPLW IDFWRU SHQWUX D GD FRQVLVWHQ SVLKRORJLF VHQV FDOLWDWLY
DFHOXLSURGXVDODQDOL]HLVWDWLVWLFHFDQWLWDWLYH0DUHDPDMRULWDWHDFKHVWL
RQDUHORUFRQWHPSRUDQHVXQWFRQVWUXLWHSULQDFHDVW PHWRG vQSUH]HQW
H[LVWkQG WHQGLQ D GH D IL SXVH VXE VHPQXO vQWUHE ULL RULFH FKHVWLRQDUH
FDUHQXDXIRVWVXSXVHDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOH
$YDQWDMXOSULQFLSDODOXQHLDVWIHOGHVFDOHHVWHSXULWDWHDIDFWRULORU
úLRPRJHQLWDWHDORU$VWIHOSXWHPILVLJXULF VFRUXULOHHJDOHUHSUH]LQW
SHUIRUPDQ HHFKLYDOHQWHODWHVWXOUHVSHFWLYXQGH]LGHUDWFHQWUDODOLQV
WUXPHQWHORUSVLKRPHWULFH
ÌQDFHODúLWLPSVXQWIUHFYHQWHYRFLOHGLQUkQGXOXQRUSVLKRGLDJ
QRVWLFLHQL GH RULHQWDUH FOLQLF úL QX QXPDL FDUH LQWHUHVD L vQ SULPXO
UkQG GH YDOLGLWDWHD SUDFWLF D GLDJQR]HL FRQVLGHU F VFDOHOH GH WLS
IDFWRULDOQXUHOD LRQHD] VXILFLHQWGHIOH[LELOúLGHUHOHYDQWFXFRPSRU
WDPHQWXO YLX GHFL FX PRGHOHOH FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH FRPSOH[H vQ FDUH
IDFWRUXOUHVSHFWLYDSDUHGRDUFDXQDGLQWUHGHWHUPLQDQWHÌQDFHVWVHQV
IDFHPWULPLWHUHGLQQRXODPRGHOXO&RVWD 0F&UDHFDUHDFFHQWXkQG
YDORDUHDGHFRQVWUXFWDEVWUDFWDGLPHQVLXQLORUIDFWRULDOHED]DOHRIHU
RPRGDOLWDWHLQWHOLJLELO GHDLQFOXGHVHPQLILFD LDDFHVWRUDSHQWUXFHHD
FHDXWRULLQXPHVFÄDGDSW ULOHFDUDFWHULVWLFHSHUVRDQHL´
ÌQ DQLL ¶ H[LVW SUHRFXS UL PHWRGRORJLFH SULYLQG LQWHJUDUHD
GLIHULWHORUWLSXULGHPHWRGHSHQWUXDVHDMXQJHSHGHRSDUWHODGHWHU
PLQDUHD VHSDUDW D GLIHULWHORU VXUVH GH YDULDQ vQLQWHULRUXODFHOXLDúL
IDFWRUPRGHOXO0XOWL7U V WXU 0XOWL0HWRG ±0700±DSOLFDWvQ
GRPHQLXO %LJ )LYH GH FHUFHW WRUL SUHFXP *DOOXFFL /DXULROD /HRQH
/LYL3HUXJLQL6WH\HU)HUULQJ 6FKPLWWSHGHDOW SDUWH
GHDGHS úLRVWUXFWXU IDFWRULDO VLPSO SHQWUXDRE LQHPRGHOHJHRPH
WULFH GH WLS FLUFXPSOH[ FDUH vQFHDUF V UHGHD FHYD GLQ FRPSOH[LWDWHD
SHUVRQDOLW LL +RIVWHH 'H 5DDG *ROGEHUJ 3HUXJLQL
$VXSUDDFHVWRUGLQXUP FHUFHW ULYRPUHYHQL
0RGDOLW LOHGHFRQVWUXLUHDLWHPLORUFKHVWLRQDUHORU
GHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
'LQWUHSUREOHPHOHFHOPDLYLXGLVFXWDWHvQOLWHUDWXUDGHVSHFLDOLWDWH
OHJDWHGHFRQVWUXLUHDLWHPLORUYRPOXDvQFRQVLGHUDUHGRX PRGDOL
W LOHSURSULX]LVHGHFRQVWUXLUHOLPEDMXOvQFDUHVHFRQVWUXLHúWHLWHPXO
úLUHOHYDQ DOLPEDMXOXLSHQWUXGLDJQR]DSHUVRQDOLW LL6HFRQVLGHU GH
H[HPSOXFXRDUJXPHQWDUHDSOLFDW SHVWUXFWXULOHOH[LFDOHF ÄXQHúDQ
WLRQ RSWLP GH XQLW L GHVFULSWLYH ED]DW SH SDUDGLJPHOH OH[LFDOH QX D
IRVWvQF FRQVWUXLW´'H5DDG
7UHFkQG vQ UHYLVW vQWUR H[WLQV DQDOL] FDUDFWHULVWLFLOH SVLKR
PHWULFHDOHGLYHUVHORUWLSXULGHLWHPL$QJOHLWQHU-RKQúL/|KU
UHOHY RDQXPLW QHJOLMDUHvQWURID] GHvQFHSXWDLVWRULHLSVLKRGLDJ
QR]HLDSURSULHW LORULWHPLORUVDXVWLPXOLORUvQIDYRDUHDXQHLFHQWU UL
DSURDSH H[FOXVLYH SH SULQFLSLLOH GH FRQVWUXLUH D VFDOHORU &RQVHFLQ D
SUREDW GHDXWRULHVWHF QLFLFHOHPDLVRILVWLFDWHWHKQLFLGHJUXSDUHD
LWHPLORU QX VXQW FDSDELOH V UHPHGLH]H GLVWRUVLXQLOH GDWRUDWH XQHL
LGLRVLQFUDWLFHúLQHVLVWHPDWLFHDERUG ULDSUREOHPDWLFLLJHQHU ULLORWX
OXLLQL LDOGHLWHPL
3UREOHPHOHODFDUHQXVDXSUHRFXSDWV U VSXQG FUHDWRULLFODVLFL
GH LQYHQWDUH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH úL SH FDUH OH GH]EDW vQ SUH]HQW FUHDWRULL
PRGHUQLVXQWFXPWUHEXLHFRQVWUXLWORWXOLQL LDOGHLWHPLFXPWUH
EXLHVFULúLDFHúWLLWHPLFXPLQIOXHQ HD] FDUDFWHULVWLFLOHIRUPDOHúLGH
FRQ LQXW DOH IRUPXO ULL IHOXO vQ FDUH YRU SUHOXFUD VXELHF LL DFHO LWHP
$FHVWH DVSHFWH VXQW GH]E WXWH vQ SUH]HQW úL GH DO L DXWRUL 'H 5DDG
0XOGHU .ORRVWHUPDQ +RIVWHH +RIVWHH $QJOHLWQHU
2VWHQGRUI -RKQ 'H 5DDG &DSUDUD 3HUXJLQL
+RIVWHH
ÌQF GLQ 0HHKO vQWUR OXFUDUH UHIHULWRDUH OD VFKLPE UL GH
SHUVSHFWLY vQHYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLFRPHQWHD] IDSWXOF FHUFHW ULOH
DYkQG FD RELHFW FRQVWUXLUHD úL YDOLGDUHD WHVWHORU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH DU
WUHEXL V VH FRQFHQWUH]H PDL GHJUDE SH DFHOH DVSHFWH QHJDWLYH FDUH
LPSLHWHD] DVXSUD YDORULL GLDJQRVWLFH D LWHPLORU úL FKHVWLRQDUHORU
DFHVWHD ILLQG RULFXP PXOW PDL PXOWH úL PDL LPSRUWDQWH GHFkW FDUDFWH
ULVWLFLOH SR]LWLYH Ä/LVWD SURSULHW LORU GH QHGRULW HVWH FRQVLGHUDELO PDL
OXQJ GHFkWFHDDSURSULHW LORUGHGRULW$FHDVWDHFKLYDOHD] FXDVSXQH
F GDW ILLQG VWUXFWXUD PLQ LL XPDQH XQ IDSW DO UHDOLW LL úL QX GRDU R
VO ELFLXQH D XQHL PHWRGH SVLKRPHWULFH VDX D XQHL WHRULL vQ FXUVXO
FRQVWUXLULLXQHLVFDOHVDUSXWHDV WUHEXLDVF V FKHOWXLPPDLPXOWWLPS
PDL PXO L EDQL PDL PXOWH UHVXUVH LQWHOHFWXDOH úL PDL PXOW HQHUJLH
P VXUkQGOXFUXULFDUHV QXILHUHIOHFWDWHGHLWHPGHFkWOXFUXULOHSHFDUH
GRULP V OH UHIOHFWH´ 0HHKO &HHD FH VH úL vQWkPSO vQ FHUFHWDUHD úL
SVLKRGLDJQR]DSHUVRQDOLW LLvQXOWLPLLDQL
3UREOHPDOLPEDMXOXL
2 SUREOHP FRPXQ FRQVW vQ GHILQLUHD UHOHYDQ HL SHQWUX
SHUVRQDOLWDWH D DQXPLWRU FXYLQWH GLQ YRFDEXODUXO FXUHQW 2 GHILQL LH
FODVLF GDW GH $OOSRUW úL 2GEHUW FRQVLGHU GUHSW UHOHYDQ L
SHQWUX SHUVRQDOLWDWH WR L DFHL WHUPHQL FDUH SRW IL IRORVL L SHQWUX D
ÄGLVWLQJHFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXQXLRPGHFRPSRUWDPHQWXODOWXLD´
0DL UHFHQW vQWUXQ VWXGLX UHDOL]DW GH $QJOHLWQHU 2VWHQGRUI úL
-RKQVHvQFHDUF RGHILQLUHúLRSHUDUHVHOHFWLY SULQWUHLPRGD
OLW L3ULPDGLQWUHHOHLGHQWLILF RWD[RQRPLHDWLSXULORUGHFDUDFWHULVWLFL
GHSHUVRQDOLWDWHFDUHSRWILUHJ VLWHGLUHFWODQLYHOXOOLPEDMXOXLQDWXUDO
DGMHFWLYHVXEVWDQWLYHDGYHUEHYHUEHHWF$VWIHOFODVLILFDUHDFXSULQGH
úDVHFDWHJRULLGHFRQ LQXWXULWU V WXULVWDELOHVW ULúLGLVSR]L LLSVLKLFH
DFWLYLW L UROXUL VRFLDOH UHOD LL úL HIHFWH VRFLDOH DELOLW L úL WDOHQWH
FDUDFWHULVWLFLFDUH LQGHSUH]HQ DIL]LF $GRXDPRGDOLWDWHVHUHIHU OD
VSHFLILFDUHDXQRUFULWHULLGHH[FOXGHUHXQWHUPHQQXHVWHUHOHYDQWSHQWUX
SHUVRQDOLWDWH GDF HVWH QRQGLVWLQFWLY úL QX VH DSOLF OD WR L LQGLYL]LL
WHUPHQLFHVHUHIHU ODRULJLQHDJHRJUDILF QD LRQDOLWDWHLGHQWLW LSUR
IHVLRQDOHVDXOHJD LGHRDQXPLW PXQF WHUPHQLFDUHVHUHIHU GRDUODR
SDUWHGLQSHUVRDQ úLWHUPHQLDF URULPSOLFD LHSHQWUXSHUVRQDOLWDWHHVWH
PHWDIRULF úL QHSUHFLV $ WUHLD PRGDOLWDWH HVWH R JULO GH LGHQWLILFDUH
SULQFDUHVHH[FOXGDFHLWHUPHQLFDUHQXVHSRWULYHVFvQQLFLXQDGLQWUH
XUP WRDUHOH SURSR]L LLFULWHULX SHQWUX DGMHFWLYH Ä&kW GH « VXQW"´
VDXÄ&kWGH«VDFRPSRUWDW;"´SHQWUXVXEVWDQWLYHÄ(VWH;«"´
VDXÄ3R LV VSXLF ;HVWHXQ«"´SHQWUXVXEVWDQWLYHDWULEXWLYHÄ«
OXL;HVWHUHPDUFDELO ´VDXÄ3UH]LQW SRVHG ;«"´
ÌQWURVHULHGHVWXGLLUHDOL]DWHDVXSUDOLPELLRODQGH]HFHUFHW WRUL
SUHFXP +RIVWHH LQGLF FLQFL WLSXUL GH REVWDFROH FDUH WUHEXLH
DYXWHvQYHGHUHFkQGVHSXQHSUREOHPDXWLOL] ULLOLPEDMXOXLQDWXUDOvQ
FRQVWUXLUHDXQXLVLVWHPúWLLQ LILFGHFDWHJRULLSVLKRQRVRORJLFH$VWIHO
GRPHQLXOHVWHJUHXGHGHOLPLWDWDWkWvQSULYLQ DFDWHJRULLORUFkW
úLvQFHDDDOHJHULLLWHPLORUGLQLQWHULRUXOFDWHJRULHLUHVSHFWLYH
P VXUDvQFDUHWHUPHQLLVXQWWUDGXFWLELOLGLQWUROLPE vQDOWD
HVWHOLPLWDW
UROXO FRSOHúLWRU DO DVSHFWHORU HYDOXDWLYH vQ OLPEDMXO FRPXQ
HVWHVWkQMHQLWRUSHQWUXXQSXQFWGHYHGHUHúWLLQ LILF
QXVHSRWDSOLFDWD[RQRPL] ULVLPSOHVDXUHJXOLSUHFLVH
PDLPXO LWHUPHQLúLH[SUHVLLVXQWSDUDGR[DOLFkQGVXQWIROR
VL L OD SHUVRDQD vQWkL DXWRGHVFULHUL ÌQ DFHODúL WLPS DXWRUXO
REVHUY F ÄvQFHUF ULOHGHDFRQVWUXLXQOLPEDMWRWDODUWLILFLDO
VDUGRYHGLLQXWLOHvQWUXQIHOVDXDOWXO)LHSHQWUXF QXDUIL
vQ HOHVGHFOLHQ LGHDXGLWRULXOLQWHOHFWXDOGHVSRQVRULVDXGH
vQúLúL LQYHVWLJDWRULL VDX PDL SUREDELO DFHúWL WHUPHQL YRU
DVLPLOD IRDUWH FXUkQG FKLDU LPSHGLPHQWHOH OLPEDMXOXL ]LOQLF
FDGHH[HPSOXvQFD]XOOXL©LQWHOLJHQWªVDX©LQWURYHUWª
&D VWUDWHJLH SULQFLSDO SHQWUX D GHS úL DFHDVW SRVLELO VLWXD LH
HVWHVHOHFWDUHDDFHORUWHUPHQLFDUHVHVXEVXPHD] SULQFLSLXOXLSRODULW LL
WU V WXULORU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH YHULILFkQG GDF HVWH SRVLELO R DQFRUDUH
UHFXUVLY D vQ HOHVXOXL WHUPHQXOXL SULQ LQWURGXFHUHD XQRU QHRORJLVPH
DWXQFL FkQG VXQW FHUXWH úL DEDQGRQkQG DFHL WHUPHQL FDUH UH]LVW XQHL
QHJ ULQHHFKLYRFH'HDVHPHQHDSOHGHD] SHQWUXIRUPXODUHDLWHPLORUOD
SHUVRDQD D WUHLD VLQJXODU úL SHQWUX FKHVWLRQDUH FDUH VH GDX VSUH FRP
SOHWDUH FHORU FDUH FXQRVF VXELHFWXO &RQVLGHU F VH FHU DEDQGRQDWH
FKHVWLRQDUHOH FDUH FHU VXELHFWXOXL vQVXúL V VH DXWRFDUDFWHUL]H]H vQ
IXQF LHGHLWHPLFDUHJHQHUHD] SDUDGR[XULDWXQFLFkQGVXQWDSOLFD LOD
SHUVRDQDvQWkL)DSWXOF DXWRHYDOX ULOHVXQWLQWULQVHFGHILFLWDUHSHQWUX
F HURULOHGHMXGHFDUHQXSRWILFDOFXODWHHVWHUHOXDWGH+RIVWHHvQ
R GDW FX DFHHDúL UHFRPDQGDUH HYDOXDUHD SHUVRQDOLW LL XQHL SHUVRDQH
WUHEXLHI FXW SULQFKHVWLRQDUHIRUPXODWHODSHUVRDQDDWUHLDVLQJXODUúL
GDWH VSUH FRPSOHWDUH FHORU FDUH FXQRVF SHUVRDQD WHVWDW $FHDVW
SURFHGXU SRDWHV LQFOXG VDXQXFDHYDOXDWRUúLSHUVRDQDWHVWDW 'H
DVHPHQHDVHUHIHU ODQHFHVLWDWHDH[WLQGHULLVWXGLLORUFDUHDXvQYHGHUH
YDOLGLWDWHD SUHGLFWLY vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH VFRSXO VHOHFW ULL úL FRQVWUXLULL
XQXLOLPEDMSHQWUXSHUVRQDOLWDWHHVWHGHDvPEXQ W LSUHGLF LDGLIHUHQ
HORULQGLYLGXDOHvQYLD DUHDO
0F&UDHWUHFkQGvQUHYLVW SUREOHPHOHOLPEDMXOXLDILUP
WUDQúDQW XQ VFHSWLFLVP OHJDW GH FDSDFLWDWHD RPXOXL RELúQXLW D
QHVSHFLDOLVWXOXLGHDvQ HOHJHDGHY UDWHOHED]HDOHSHUVRQDOLW LL'LQ
SXQFWXOGHYHGHUHDODFHVWXLFHUFHW WRUúLFUHDWRUGHWHVWHDPHULFDQvQ
VWXGLHUHDOLPELLWUHEXLHV VHFRQWLQXHH[DPLQDUHDOHJ WXULORUHPSLULFH
FX DOWH VLVWHPH DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL WUHEXLH V VH GHS úHDVF XWLOL]DUHD
OH[LFRQXOXLSHQWUXDDQDOL]DOLPEDMXOYRUELWúLVFULVDFWXDO0F&UDHúL
&RVWDGH]YROW YDULDQWHDOHDFHOXLDúLFKHVWLRQDUFDUHVHSRWDGPLQLVWUD
ILH VSUH DXWRHYDOXDUH SHUVRDQD vQWkL VLQJXODU ILH VSUH HYDOXDUHD
VXELHFWXOXLGHF WUHDO LLSHUVRDQDDWUHLDVLQJXODU
2 DOW GLUHF LH GH VWXGLX DO OLPEDMXOXL SHUVRQDOLW LL HVWH SURPR
YDW SULQFHUFHW ULOHOXL'H5DDGúDSUH]HQWDWHvQvQWUXQDUWLFRO
VLQWHWLF UHIHULWRU OD GLIHUHQ LHULOH vQWUH DGMHFWLYH VXEVWDQWLYH úL YHUEH
SULYLQGFDSDFLWDWHDDFHVWRUDGHDFDSWDúLUHGDVHQVXULDOHSHUVRQDOLW LL
$QDOL]kQGGDWHOHGHFHUFHWDUHSVLKROLQJYLVWLF GHWLS%LJ)LYHUHDOL]DWH
VHSDUDWSHFHOHWUHLFDWHJRULLYHUEDOHGHVFRSHU F XWLOL]DUHDLGLRVLQFUDWLF
vQVFDOHOHGHHYDOXDUHHVWHPDLSUREDELO SHQWUXVXEVWDQWLYHGHFkWSHQWUX
YHUEHúLGHDVHPHQHDSHQWUXYHUEHvQUDSRUWFXDGMHFWLYHOH'LIHUHQ HOH
vQ PRGXO FXP VXQW XWLOL]DWH FHOH WUHL FDWHJRULL GH WHUPHQL FRQGXF vQ
SUDFWLF GH H[HPSOX OD GLIHUHQ H vQ RUGLQHD IDFWRULORU úL FKLDU vQ QX
P UXO IDFWRULORU UH]XOWD L vQ XUPD DQDOL]HL IDFWRULDOH )DFWRULL GHULYD L
SULQVXEVWDQWLYHSUH]LQW RWHQGLQ VSUHRGHVFULHUHPDLFRHUHQW úLELQH
GHILQLW GHDVHPHQHDDFHúWLIDFWRULWLQGV FXSULQG FHOHPDLH[WUHPH
VHPQLILFD LLDOHGLPHQVLXQLORUGHULYDWHGLQXWLOL]DUHDDGMHFWLYHORU
ÌQ DFHHDúL RUGLQH GH FRPSDUD LH IDFWRULL GHULYD L GLQ VXEVWDQWLYH
DXRPDLODUJ YDULD LHGHVHQVXUL$FHVWHDVSHFWHFRQILUP FDUDFWHULVWLFD
VXEVWDQWLYHORU GH D IL UHSUH]HQWDWLYH SULQ HOH vQVHOH 9HUEHOH vúL H[WUDJ
SDU LDOVHQVXULOHGLQVLWXD LLLQWHUSHUVRQDOH'LQDFHVWPRWLYHOHVXQWPDL
FRQGL LRQDWHúLDXQHYRLHGHPDLPXOW VSHFLILFDUH'HIDSWREVHUY 'H
5DDGFRPSRUWDPHQWHOHLQWURGXVHSULQYHUEHVXQWFRQVLGHUDWHVHPQLILFD
WLYHSHQWUXSHUVRQDOLWDWHGRDUGDF DFHOHFRPSRUWDPHQWHVXQWvQ HOHVHFD
ILLQGGHWHUPLQDWHGHDQXPLWHGLVSR]L LL'HFLYHUEHOHSRWILFRQVLGHUDWH
FD UHOHYDQWH SHQWUX SHUVRQDOLWDWH vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH FDSWHD] DVWIHO GH
UHOD LL FDX]DOH 8Q VWXGLX UHDOL]DW SH OLPED JHUPDQ GH $QJOHLWQHU úL
5LHPDQQVXEOLQLD] FDSDFLWDWHDYHUEHORUGHDFDSWDDVSHFWHWHP
SHUDPHQWDOH
6HVSHFLILF GHDVHPHQHDIDSWXOF RSRVLELO VXUV GHYDULD LHD
GLPHQVLXQLORU%LJ)LYHvQGLIHULWHOLPEL LQHGHGLIHUHQ HOHGHUHOD LRQDUH
vQWUH FHOH WUHL WLSXUL GH FDWHJRULL GH WHUPHQL ± DGMHFWLYH VXEVWDQWLYH úL
YHUEH±GLIHUHQ HVSHFLILFHSHQWUXDFHVWHOLPEL&RQFOX]LDFHUFHW WRULORU
VHvQGUHDSW VSUHXQDFRUGvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHRPDLEXQ FDSDFLWDWHD
DGMHFWLYHORUGHDGHYHQLGHVFULSWRULGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHGDUHVWHSUHIHUDELO
V VHFRPELQHFDSDFLW LOHGHFDSWDUHDOHGLIHULWHORUFODVHOLQJYLVWLFH'H
5DDGúL+RIVWHHFRQIRUPVSHFLILFXOXLILHF UHLOLPELÌQRULFHFD]
vQWURGLVSXW FDUHSULYHúWHPRGDOLWDWHDGHXWLOL]DUHSUDFWLF VHVSHFLILF
XWLOL]DUHDGHSURSR]L LLúLIUD]HúLQXDXQRUFXYLQWHVLQJXODUH*ROGEHUJ
%ULJVvQIRUPDWXOFHOPDLVLPSOXDFFHSWDELOGLQSXQFWGH
YHGHUHJUDPDWLFDO'H5DDG
5HOD LDLWHPWU V WXU
&DSULP HWDS vQFRQVWUXLUHDLWHPXOXLGHFL]LDSULYLQGWU V WXUD
úLFRQ LQXWXULOHSVLKRORJLFHLPSOLF RFRQVWDQW UDSRUWDUHDLWHPXOXLvQ
ILHFDUHHWDS ODYDOLGLWDWHDVDGLVFULPLQDWLY DVWIHO
'HILQLUHD WU V WXULL RSWLP GLQ SULVPD XQHL WHRULL VWUXFWXUDOH
FDUHV UHIOHFWHúLLPSRUWDQ DSHQWUXYLD DGLIHUHQ HORULQWHULQGLYLGXDOH
JHQHUDWH GH GLPHQVLXQHD SVLKLF DYXW vQ YHGHUH $FHDVW GHILQLUH
WUHEXLH UHDOL]DW H[SOLFLW FXSULQ]kQG R GHVFULHUH DWkW D UHOD LLORU GH WLS
FRQYHUJHQWFkWúLDFHORUGHWLSGLYHUJHQWFXDOWHWU V WXULVDXFRQVWUXFWH
SVLKRORJLFH GDU úL FX WLSXULOH UHOHYDQWH úL VSHFLILFH GH PDQLIHVWDUH D
WU V WXULLUHVSHFWLYH$QJOHLWQHU
3HQWUXHYLWDUHDIRUPXO ULLXQRULWHPLQHSURGXFWLYLVDXGHWLS
LGLRVLQFUDWLFWUHEXLHXWLOL]DWHORWXULGHVXELHF LSHQWUXJHQHUDUHDH[HP
SODUHORUILHF UXLWLSGHLWHPLDUVHOHF LDORUV VHED]H]HSHXQDFRUG
vQWUH XQ QXP U GH SHUVRDQHMXGHF WRUL SULYLQG JUDGXO GH UHOHYDQ DO
FRQ LQXWXOXLLWHPXOXLSHQWUXWU V WXU
3HQWUXDSXWHDFDSWDLQIOXHQ DFRQWH[WXOXLVLWXD LRQDOVHDUHvQ
YHGHUH GDF vQ WH[WXO LWHPXOXL VXQW LQFOXVH DVSHFWH UHOHYDQWH DOH
DFHVWXLDúLGDF FRQ LQXWXOHVWHFkWPDLH[SOLFLWSRVLELO
$QJOHLWQHU UHDOL]HD] R GHVFULHUH VLVWHPDWLF D UHOD LHL LWHP
WU V WXU ED]kQGXVHSHSURSULLOHFHUFHW ULúLSHGHVFULHULDQWHULRDUHGH
FDWHJRULLGHFODVHGHUHOD LLORJLFHUHDOL]DWHGH-DQNHúL/HQQHUW]
ÌQDFHVWÄVLVWHPFDWHJRULDO´SUH]HQWDWVLQWHWLFvQWDEHOXOFDWH
JRULLOH FHQWUDOH D F URU IUHFYHQ HVWH ULGLFDW vQ DSUR[LPDWLY WRDWH
JHQXULOHGHFKHVWLRQDUHVXQWSULPHOHGRX UHDF LLOHFRPSRUWDPHQWDOH
GHVFKLVHDFRSHULWHúLYHJHWDWLYHúLDWULEXWHOHWU V WXULORUFDUHSRWIL
ILH QHPRGLILFDELOH ILH PRGLILFDELOH FDOLWDWLY VDX vQ IXQF LH GH FRQ
WH[WXOVLWXD LRQDO&HOHODOWHFLQFLFDWHJRULL±GRULQ HúLLQWHUHVHIDSWH
ELRJUDILFHDWLWXGLQLúLRSLQLLUHDF LLDOHDOWRUDLWHPLEL]DUL±VHUHIHU
SUHSRQGHUHQW OD FRQ LQXWXUL OHJDWH LQGLUHFW GH WU V WXUD GH SHUVRQD
OLWDWHGHDOWIHODFHVWIDSWHVWHUHVSRQVDELOúLGHGLIHUHQ HvQVWDELOLWDWHD
U VSXQVXULORUODLWHPLLGHDFHVWHWLSXUL*ROGEHUJ
7DEHOXO7D[RQRPLDUHOD LLORUSRVLELOHvQWUHLWHPúLWU V WXU
1U 'HQXPLUH 'HILQLUHDFRQ LQXWXULORUSVLKRORJLFH
GHVFULHUL ,WHPLLHYDOXHD]
GHUHDF LL DFRPSRUWDPHQWHGHVFKLVHREVHUYDELOH
E FRPSRUWDPHQWH DFRSHULWH LQWHUQH QHREVHUYDELOH GH
DO LLVHQ]D LLVHQWLPHQWHFRJQL LLLQWHULRDUH
FVLPSWRPHELRSVLKRORJLFHSUHFXPUHDF LLOHSVLKRIL]LRORJLFH
DWULEXWH UHSUH]LQW GLVSR]L LLGHRELFHLGHVFULVHSULQDGMHFWLYHVDX
DOH VXEVWDQWLYHSRWILGHGRX IHOXUL
WU V WXULL QHPRGLILFDELOHúL
PRGLILFDELOH FkQG VH VSHFLILF IUHFYHQ D GXUDWD
FRQWH[WXOVLWXD LRQDO
GRULQ HúL LQWHQ LD GH D VH DQJDMD vQ FRPSRUWDPHQWH VSHFLILFH
WUHEXLQ H GRULQ D SHQWUX FHYD DQXPH QX úL DFHOHD SHQWUX FDUH VH
VSHFLILF UHDOL]DUHDvQSUH]HQWvQWLPSXOWHVW ULL
IDSWH LWHPLFHQWUD LSHDVSHFWHUHOHYDQWHGLQWUHFXW
ELRJUDILFH
DWLWXGLQL RSLQLL SXWHUQLF VXV LQXWH DWLWXGLQL úL RSLQLL ID GH
GLYHUVHFDWHJRULLGHVXELHFWHJHQHUDOHVRFLDOHSHUVRQDOH
UHDF LLDOH LWHPLFDUHGHVFULXFRPSRUWDPHQWHUHDF LLúLDWLWXGLQLDOH
DOWRUD DOWRUDID GHSHUVRDQ
LWHPL PDMRULWDWHD LWHPLORU GH DFHVW IHO GHVFULX FRPSRUWDPHQWH
EL]DUL úL WU LUL HYLGHQW QHRELúQXLWH VWUDQLL FDUH SDU V VH
DVRFLH]HHPSLULFFXWU V WXUDUHVSHFWLY
&DUDFWHULVWLFLGHVXSUDID DOHLWHPLORU
(WDSD FRQVHFXWLY GHFL]LLORU SULYLQG FRQVWUXFWXO úL WLSXULOH GH
FRQ LQXWXUL UHOHYDQWH HVWH HWDSD VFULHULL SURSULX]LVH$OWIHOVSXVJ
VLUHD IRUPHL FHOHL PDL DGHFYDWH SHQWUX GLIHULWH WLSXUL GH FRQ LQXWXUL
VDUFLQ FDUHLQFOXGHDWkWSUREOHPDIRUPHLGHFRQ LQXWFHOHLPDLDGHF
YDWH SHQWUX D GD LWHPXOXL FDOLWDWHD GH EXQ LQGLFDWRU DO FRQVWUXFWXOXL
GDUúLDIRUPHLGHU VSXQVFHOHLPDLSRWULYLWHSHQWUXDGDVXELHFWXOXL
SRVLELOLWDWHDV úLH[SULPHSURSULDVLWXD LH
ÌQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH IRUPD GH U VSXQV vQ JHQHUDO U VSXQVXULOH OD
LWHPLSRWILVXEVXPDWHXQRUFRPSRUWDPHQWHYHUEDOHvQDOWVWDQGDUGL]DWH
FRPSRUWDPHQWH SURYRFDWH GH VWLPXOL YHUEDOL $QJOHLWQHU 6XQW
U VSXQVXULOHH[SULPDELOHvQWURUHDF LHGHWLSGLKRWRPLFSUHFXPÄ'D1X´
Ä$GHY UDW)DOV´VDXWULKRWRPLFSUHFXPÄ'D1X1XúWLX´ÄÌQWRWGHDXQD
8QHRUL 1LFLRGDW ´ VDX SULQ XWLOL]DUHD XQHL VFDOH PDL H[WLQVH GH WLS
/LNHUW vQ SDWUX FLQFL úDVH VDX úDSWH JUDGH SUHFXP Ä$FRUG WRWDO´
Ä$FRUGSDU LDO´úLÄ$FRUGSDU LDO´Ä$FRUGWRWDO´
6DX SXWHP SUHIHUD VLWXD LD vQ FDUH LWHPLL VXQW H[SULPD L VHF úL
JHQHUDO LDU U VSXQVXULOH UHGDX FRQ LQXWXO SURSULX]LV DO GLYHUVHORU
FRPSRUWDPHQWHSRVLELOH"'HH[HPSOXÄ&kQGWUHFSHOkQJ RSHUVRDQ
GHVH[RSXVDvPLYLQHV WUDYHUVH]SHSDUWHDFHDODOW EURúHVFúLJU
EHVFSDVXOFvQWRUFFDSXOV RSULYHVFPDLELQHGQXLDFRUGQLFLR
LPSRUWDQ ´
ÌQ WLSXO GH U VSXQV WUDGL LRQDO Ä'D1X´ HYHQWXDO Ä1X úWLX´
VXELHFWXO WU LHúWH GLILFXOWDWHD GH D DOHJH XQ U VSXQV SUHD H[WUHPL]DW
'HDFHHDvQFRQVWUXLUHDXQRULWHPLSHQWUXDVWIHOGHIRUPHGHU VSXQV
HVWH LPSRUWDQW V VH PRGXOH]H FRQ LQXWXO LWHPXOXL SULQ VSHFLILFDUHD
IUHFYHQ HL VDX LQWHQVLW LL SHQWUX D VH HYLWD FD úL DFHVWD V H[SULPH
VLWXD LLODIHOGHH[WUHPHFDúLU VSXQVXULOH'HH[HPSOXÄ8QHRULPL
VHvQWkPSO V VSXQRPLQFLXQ ´VDXÄ'HFHOHPDLPXOWHRULP VLPW
DWkWGHRERVLWvQFkWP DSXF VRPQXO´/DDVWIHOGHLWHPLPRGXOD LVH
SRWXWLOL]DU VSXQVXULOHGLKRWRPL]DWH
ÌQSUH]HQWQXVHPDLLQFOXGSULQWUHYDULDQWHOHSRVLELOHGHU VSXQV
Ä"´VDXÄ1XúWLX´FRQVLGHUkQGXVHQHVDWLVI F WRDUHGLQSXQFWXOGHYH
GHUHDOLQIRUPD LHLSR LLQWHUSUHWDILHHúHFXOVXELHFWXOXLGHDvQ HOHJH
LWHPXO ILH QHVLJXUDQ D VXELHFWXOXL LQDSOLFDELOLWDWHD LWHPXOXL úL FKLDU
XQ JUDG LQWHUPHGLDU GH U VSXQV vQ VLWXD LD XQRU LWHPL QHPRGXOD L
$QDVWDVL
'HH[HPSOXFHUFHW ULOHHIHFWXDWHDVXSUDIHOXOXLFXPLQWHUSUHWHD]
VXELHF LLWLSXOGHU VSXQVÄPHGLX´LQGLF FHOSX LQSDWUXPRGDOLW LGH
XWLOL]DUH DOH VDOH *ROGEHUJ R DWULEXLUH VLWXD LRQDO FRQGXLWD
PHDGHSLQGHGHVLWXD LHRH[SUHVLHDLQFHUWLWXGLQLLQXP SRWGHFLGH
SHQWUX F QXPL FXQRVF VXILFLHQW GH ELQH DFHVW DVSHFW DPELJXLWDWHD
LWHPXOXL QX VXQW VLJXU FH SRDWH V vQVHPQH DFHVW LWHP QHXWUDOLWDWHD
P DIOXXQGHYDODPHGLHvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHDFHDVW FDUDFWHULVWLF
&HUFHW ULOH DX GHPRQVWUDW vQV F úL PRGXODUHD SULQ LQWHQVLWDWH
IUHFYHQ VDX P VXU HVWH R VXUV GH DPELJXLWDWH SHQWUXF VXELHF LL
QX vQ HOHJ DFHODúL OXFUX SULQ FXYLQWH FD ÄUDU´ ÄXQHRUL´ ÄDGHVHD´
ÄIUHFYHQW´ÄGHRELFHL´ÌQGHFXUVXOWLPSXOXLVDSUHIHUDWFDIRUP GH
U VSXQV WHKQLFD DOHJHULL IRU DWH GH]YROWDW PDL DOHV GH FKHVWLRQDUHOH
SHQWUXVHOHF LDSURIHVLRQDO LQGXVWULDO VDXvQDUPDW vQSHULRDGDDQLORU
¶ÌQHVHQ FHUVXELHFWXOXLV DOHDJ vQWUHGRX VDXPDLPXOWHU V
SXQVXULGHVFULHULIUD]HFDUHSDUHJDOHGLQSHUVSHFWLYDDFFHSWDELOLW LL
GDUDF URUYDOLGLWDWHHVWHGLIHULW ID GHFULWHULXOH[WHUQ'HRELFHLVH
DOF WXLHVF SHUHFKL VDX WHWUDGH ÌQ FHO GLQ XUP FD] VH FRQVWUXLHVF GH
IDSWGRX SHUHFKLGRX IUD]HGH]LUDELOHúLGRX IUD]HLQGH]LUDELOHÌQ
IRUPHúLPDLH[WLQVHGHWLSXODFLQFLYDULDQWHGHU VSXQVVXELHFWXOXLL
VH FHUH GH RELFHL V SUHFL]H]H FDUH HVWH FHO PDL FDUDFWHULVWLF úL FDUH
HVWHFHOPDLSX LQFDUDFWHULVWLFU VSXQVSHQWUXHO
2IRUP PDLVSHFLDO DWHKQLFLLU VSXQVXULORUIRU DWHHVWHPHWRGD
4DVRUW ULLGH]YROWDW GH6WHSKHQVRQFDUHFHUHVXELHFWXOXLV
UHDOL]H]H R UDQJDUH D XQXL QXP U LPSDU GH U VSXQVXULVLWXD LL FLQFL
úDSWH QRX VRUWkQGXOH JUDGDW vQIXQF LHGHXQFULWHULXGDWGHODR
H[WUHP VSUHFHDODOW $VWIHOGHWHKQLFLXUP UHVFV GHDVXELHFWXOXLR
SRVLELOLWDWHGHDVHH[SULPDPDLSHUVRQDO
ÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHIRUPDLWHPXOXLSURSULX]LVVLWXD LLOHVXQWGH
R GLYHUVLWDWH GH]DUPDQW vQFHUF ULOH GH DQDOL] OLQJYLVWLF D LWHPLORU
VXQW UHODWLY UDUH PDL DOHV vQ OHJ WXU FX FDUDFWHULVWLFLOH VLQWDFWLFH úL
VHPDQWLFH úL HIHFWXO ORU DVXSUD FRQVLVWHQ HL LWHPXOXL 2SLQLD FXUHQW
DVXSUDFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUGHVXSUDID SUHFXPOXQJLPHDLWHPXOXLFRPSOH
[LWDWHDVLQWDFWLF DSURSR]L LHLVDXIUD]HLHVWHF DFHVWHDWUHEXLHFRUHODWH
FX PRGXO FXP DUH ORF SUHOXFUDUHD LWHPXOXL GH F WUH VXELHFWXO VDX VX
ELHF LLFDUHvQFHDUF V U VSXQG 0RGHOHOHGHFHUFHWDUHFRJQLWLYHGHWLS
SVLKROLQJYLVWLFSHQWUXSURFHVXOGHFLWLUHUHDOL]DWHGHFHUFHW WRULSUHFXP
)RVV +DNHVVDX:LJJLQVVSULMLQ FRQFOX]LDLPSRUWDQW
SHQWUXFRQVWUXFWRULLGHFKHVWLRQDUHF JUDGXOGHFRPSUHKHQVLELOLWDWHDO
SURSR]L LLORUFDUHVXQWVXSXVHXQXLPDLPDUHQXP UGHWUDQVIRUP ULúLOD
PDL PXOWH QLYHOH vQ SURFHV ULOH vQ HOHJHULL HVWH LQYHUV SURSRU LRQDO FX
FRPSOH[LWDWHDSUHOXFU ULL'HFLFXFkWQXP UXOGHWUDQVIRUP ULHVWHPDL
PLFFXDWkWHVWHPDLXúRUGHvQ HOHVSURSR]L LDUHVSHFWLY LDPDLSX LQ
WLPSúLGXFHODPDLSX LQHHURUL
7UHLVXQWDVSHFWHOHFHOHPDLLPSRUWDQWHDOHVWUXFWXULLGHVXSUDID
DLWHPLORUOXQJLPHDQXP UXOGHFXYLQWHOLWHUHSURSR]L LLFRP
SOH[LWDWHDFDUHFUHúWHRGDW FXQXP UXOGHQHJD LLWUHFHUHDODGLDWH]D
SDVLY WLPSXOWUHFXWúLDOWHPRGXULGHFkWLQGLFDWLYXOvQFHHDFHSULYHúWH
XWLOL]DUHDYHUEHORUSUHFXPúLFXUHIHULUHSHUVRQDO IRUPDWXOSURSULX]LV
DOLWHPXOXLGDWGHWLSXOGHSURSR]L LHúLGHWLSXOGHU VSXQV
/LHYHUW/|KUúL$QJOHLWQHU$QJOHLWQHUúD
UHFRPDQG LWHPLFkWPDLVFXU LFXHYLWDUHDPXOWRUSURSR]L LLúLQHJD LL
/XQJLPHDPHGLHDLWHPLORUGLQSULQFLSDOHOHFKHVWLRQDUHDQDOL]DWHDOWHOH
GHFkWFHOHGHWLS%LJ)LYHHVWHGHDSUR[LPDWLYFXYLQWHFRQMXJDUHDOD
WLPSXOWUHFXWúLODPRGXOFRQMXQFWLYVDXFRQGL LRQDODSDUHGRDUvQ
GLQFD]XULGRDUGLQWUHLWHPLLFXUHQ LQXDXUHIHULUHSHUVRQDO ([LVW
úLRFRUHODUHSRVLELO FXFDWHJRULDGHUHOD LHLWHPWU V WXU $VWIHOFKHV
WLRQDUHOH FDUH FRQ LQ LWHPL ELRJUDILFL úL DYHP H[HPSOXO 003,XOXL
FRQ LQúLFHOPDLPDUHQXP UGHLWHPLODWUHFXWIUHFYHQ DPDLPDUHD
LWHPLORU OHJD L GH GRULQ H LQWHUHVH DWLWXGLQL RSLQLL FDUDFWHULVWLF GH
H[HPSOX SHQWUX WHVWXO 3)4 FRQGXFH OD H[SULPDUHD SULQ DF LXQL GH
QDWXU LSRWHWLF GHFLYHUEHODPRGXOFRQMXQFWLYVDXFRQGL LRQDO/|KU
$QJOHLWQHU
&DUDFWHULVWLFLVHPDQWLFHDOHLWHPLORU
2DOW GLUHF LHGHVWXGLXVHD[HD] SHSURFHVHOHFRJQLWLYHLPSOL
FDWH vQ U VSXQVXO OD LWHPL úL FRQVHFXWLY GHOLPLWDUHD FDUDFWHULVWLFLORU
VHPDQWLFH UHVSRQVDELOH GH GLILFXOW LOH VDX FRQIX]LLOH vQ DFHVW WLS GH
SURFHVDUHDLQIRUPD LHL6DVWXGLDWDQDOL]DFRQ LQXWXOXLSURWRFRDOHORU
GH U VSXQV FX YRFH WDUH WLPSLL GH UHDF LH DSUHFLHUHD SULQ UDQJDUH D
JUDGXOXLGHVLPLOLWXGLQHGLQWUHLWHPLGHH[HPSOX5RJHUV
SUHFXPúLVWDGLLOHLSRWHWLFHDOHSURFHVXOXLGHU VSXQVGHODFLWL
UHDLWHPXOXLvQFHSkQGFXUHSUH]HQWDUHDFRQ LQXWXOXLSURFHVHOH
GHFRPSDUDUHFXLQIRUPD LDVWRFDW GHVSUHVLQHvQVXúLúLWHUPLQkQGFX
YHULILFDUHDPHQWDO DU VSXQVXOXLvQIXQF LHGHXWLOLWDWHvQ HOHDV
PDL DOHV SULQ SULVPD FRQJUXHQ HL FX QRUPHOH VRFLDOH úL FX YDORULOH
DYXWHvQYHGHUHFI$QJOHLWQHUúD
$FHVWH VWDGLL GH SUHOXFUDUH WUDWDWH FD HWDSH VHFYHQ LDOH úL GLV
WLQFWH VXQW vQV LQWHUDFWLYH úL FKLDU SDUDOHOH vQ SURFHVXO PHQWDO UHDO
&HHDFHvQWURGHVFULHUHVWULFWFRJQLWLY DSDUHFDSURFHVORJLFHVWHvQ
IDSWRSURFHVDUHGHWLSHXULVWLFvQFDUHvQILHFDUHGLQWUHHWDSHLQWHUYLQ
DVSHFWHLQIOXHQ DWHGHFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHLWHPXOXLGDUúLGHVWDUHDJOREDO
DSVLKLVPXOXLVXELHFWLYLQFOXVLYDFWLYDUHDXQRUFRPSOH[HVDXDXQRU
FRQ LQXWXULDOHLQFRQúWLHQWXOXLFDUHvQPRPHQWXOSUH]HQWSRWLQWHUYHQL
vQSURFHV ULOHLQIRUPD LHLI U FDVXELHFWXOV ILHFRQúWLHQWVDXGHSOLQ
FRQúWLHQWGHDFHDVWD
3RUQLQGvQV GHODLWHP$QJOHLWQHUGHVFULHFLQFLFDUDFWHULV
WLFL VHPDQWLFH FDUH LQWHUYLQ VHPQLILFDWLY vQJUHXQkQG VDX VLPSOLILFkQG
SURFHV ULOHU VSXQVXOXLFRPSUHKHQVLELOLWDWHDFkWGHXúRUSRDWHILvQ H
OHVLWHPXODPELJXLWDWHDGDF HVWHSRVLELO DWULEXLUHDDPDLPXOWGHFkW
XQVLQJXUvQ HOHVQLYHOXOGHDEVWUDFWL]DUHFXFkWLQIRUPD LDHVWHPDL
DEVWUDFW FXDWkWFHUHRSURFHVDUHPDLGHVI úXUDW JUDGXOGHUHIHULUH
SHUVRQDO LQIRUPD LD FDUH LQFOXGH GLUHFW úL VHPQLILFDWLY SH VXELHFW
HYDOXDUHDVDXP VXUDGH]LUDELOLW LLVRFLDOHDFRQ LQXWXOXLLWHPXOXL
'LQWUH FDX]HOH FDUH FRQGXF VSUH R VF ]XW FRPSUHKHQVLELOLWDWH
VXQWXWLOL]DUHDXQRUFXYLQWHQHX]XDOHQHRELúQXLWHDXQRUVWUXFWXULSUR
SR]L LRQDOHFRPSOLFDWHIRU DWHVDXQHFODUHHURULOHJUDPDWLFDOH
$PELJXLWDWHD UHSUH]LQW LQFHUWLWXGLQHD OHJDW GH vQ HOHVXO VWL
PXOXOXLVSUHGHRVHELUHGHFDUDFWHUXOHFKLYRFvQ HOHVFDGLIHUHQ vQWUH
SHUVRDQH vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH LQWHUSUHWDUHD LWHPXOXL ± FI *ROGEHUJ
&DX]HOHDPELJXLW LL LQGHSUH]HQ DXQRUFXYLQWHVDXDILUPD LL
FXPDLPXOWHvQ HOHVXULDXQRUUHOD LLHFKLYRFHvQWUHSURSR]L LLOHIUD]HL
LQGHDVHPHQHDGHLQFRPSDWLELOLWDWHDGLQWUHLWHPLúLIRUPDWXOU VSXQ
VXOXLSULQLQWURGXFHUHDXQHLQHJD LLDXQRUFRQMXQF LLGHWLSÄVDXVDX´
DXQRUIUD]HFXPDLPXOWHSURSR]L LLSULQFLSDOH
$FHVWHJUHúHOLSXQVXELHFWXOvQGLIHULWHSRVWXULQXUHFXQRDúWHQD
WXUDDPELJX DLWHPXOXLúLSXUúLVLPSOXvOvQ HOHJHJUHúLWLQWHUSUHWkQGXO
vQDOWVHQVGHFkWFHOH[SHFWDWUHFXQRDúWHDPELJXLWDWHDLWHPXOXLvQV
QXHVWHVLJXUGHFDUHGLQWUHvQ HOHVXULOHSRVLELOHHVWHYRUED
1LYHOXO GH DEVWUDFWL]DUH ULGLFDW LQWHUYLQH vQ SURFHVHOH GH FRP
SDUDUHvQWUHLWHPúLH[SHULHQ DSHUVRQDO 8QLWHPFRQFUHWFDUHDILUP
RLQIRUPD LHVSHFLILFDW ±SUHFXPFHLFDUHVHUHIHU ODFRPSRUWDPHQWH
FODU VSHFLILFDWH QXPHVF FRQGL LL úL VLWXD LL VHPQLILFDWLYH VDX LQFOXG
IDSWHDF URUYHULGLFLWDWHSRDWHILDILUPDW ±DMXW ODRHYRFDUHUDSLG
GLQ PHPRULH ,WHPXO DEVWUDFW FHUH SURFHVDUHD vQ FRQWLQXDUH D vQ HOH
VXOXL V X LQWHJUDUHD WUHSWDW úLVDX VXSOLPHQWDUHD LQIRUPD LHL SULQ
H[HPSOHUHIHULULODIDSWHFRQFUHWH,WHPLLDEVWUDF LVXQWGHUHJXO FHL
FDUHSUH]LQW DWLWXGLQLRSLQLLGHVFULHULJHQHUDOHFHULQWHUSUHWDUHDXQRU
HYHQLPHQWH JHQHUDOH VDX LQWHJUDUHD ORU GHD OXQJXO XQRU VLWXD LL GL
YHUVH FRPSDUDUHD FX VWDQGDUGH QHVSHFLILFDWH LQIHUHQ H SHUVRQDOH
6XQWFHUFHW ULFDUHLQGLF RUHOD LHGLUHFWSURSRU LRQDO vQWUHJUDGXOGH
DEVWUDFWL]DUH úL GLIHUHQ LHULOH vQ PRGXO FXP vQ HOHJ VXELHF LL DFHúWL
LWHPL$QJOHLWQHU
*UDGXO vQ FDUH FRQ LQXWXO LWHPXOXL HVWH VHPQLILFDWLY SHQWUX
LPDJLQHD GH VLQH D VXELHFWXOXL HVWH vQ GLUHFW UHOD LH FX FDSDFLWDWHD
DFHVWXLD GH D U VSXQGH SH ED]D XQHL SHUFHS LL VDX D XQHL H[SHULHQ H
SURSULL DVXSUD OXFUXULORU vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH VXELHFWXO HVWH GLUHFW
PHQ LRQDW SULQ LWHP ILH OD QLYHOXO WU LULL XQRU HYHQLPHQWH VDX DO
DF LXQLL úL DO LPSOLF ULL HPR LRQDOH 5HIHULUHD SHUVRQDO LQWHUYLQH vQ
VWDGLXOFRPSDU ULLLWHPHX
0 VXUDvQFDUHXQLWHPHYRF YDORULVWDQGDUGHDSUREDWHVRFLDO
GHWHUPLQ ULúLSUHMXGHF LFRPXQHHVWHGLUHFWSURSRU LRQDO FXSURED
ELOLWDWHD FD VXELHFWXO V VHOHFWH]H U VSXQVXO vQ VHQVXO GH]LUDELOLW LL
VRFLDOH$FHVWJHQGHMXGHFDW LQWHUYLQHPDLDOHVvQVWDGLXOHYDOX ULORU
XWLOLW LLúLFRQVHFLQ HORU
&DUDFWHULVWLFLSVLKRPHWULFH
ÌQVWXGLLOHFODVLFHDFHVWWLSGHFDUDFWHULVWLFLDFRQVWLWXLWSUREOH
PDWLFDSULQFLSDO 3DUDPHWULLDYX LvQYHGHUHvQDQDOL]DLWHPLORUVXQW
PHGLDFDP VXU DWHQGLQ HLFHQWUDOHYDULDQ DVWDELOLWDWHDFDP VXU D
JUDGXOXLvQFDUHVXELHF LLvúLS VWUHD] ODUHWHVWU VSXQVXOLQL LDOúLFRUH
OD LDLWHPWHVWFDGHWHUPLQDUHDFDSDFLW LLGHGLVFULPLQDUHDILHF UXL
LWHP 'HWHUPLQ ULOH FDUDFWHULVWLFLORU SVLKRPHWULFH GHMD FRPHQWDWH vQ
OXFUDUHD%D]HOHSVLKRGLDJQRVWLFXOXLúL7HRULHúLSUDFWLF vQSVL
KRGLDJQR] VXQWXWLOHRULF URUFHUFHW ULFDUHXUP UHVFVHOHF LD
VFDOHL ILQDOH vQ XUPD H[SHULPHQW ULL SH ORWXUL GH VXELHF L VWDELOLUHD
FDUDFWHULVWLFLORUSVLKRPHWULFHDOHFKHVWLRQDUXOXLvQVSHFLDOvQFDOFXOXO
YDOLGLW LL FRPSDUDUHD FDUDFWHULVWLFLORU úL YDORULL SVLKRGLDJQRVWLFH D
GRX VDXPDLPXOWHFKHVWLRQDUHVWXGLLSULYLQGP VXUDvQFDUHDQXPLWH
FDUDFWHULVWLFLFDUH LQGHFRQVWUXF LDLWHPLORULQIOXHQ HD] VWDELOLWDWHDúL
YDOLGLWDWHDLQWHUQ DLWHPLORU
&HUFHWDUHDH[WLQV GHVI úXUDW GH$QJOHLWQHU-RKQúL/|KUDVXSUD
XQRUFKHVWLRQDUHLPSRUWDQWHvQDULDSVLKRGLDJQR]HLSHUVRQDOLW LLVWXGLX
FDUHDFXSULQVúLGHWHUPLQDUHDúLP VXUDUHDWXWXURUFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUPHQ
LRQDWHLDFRQGXVVSUHFRQFOX]LDF ÄLQIOXHQ DFDUDFWHULVWLFLORULWHPLORU
DVXSUDFDOLW LLFKHVWLRQDUHORUHVWHDWkWVLVWHPDWLF FkWúLVXEVWDQ LDO ´
0RGXOvQFDUHDXU VSXQVFKHVWLRQDUHOHLQWUDWHvQVWXGLX±003,03,
004(3,$úL%3)4$úL%)3,*LHVVHQ7HVWúL3,7±GRYHGHúWH
QXPHURDVH QHUHJXODULW L úL HURUL GH FRQVWUXF LH GDWRUDWH OLSVHL GH
VLVWHPDWL]DUHúLPDLDOHVGRYHGHúWHIDSWXOF ÄVWUXFWXUDGHVXSUDID D
VWLPXOXOXL YHUEDO GDF HVWH P VXUDW FXSULQ] WRU HVWH XQ GHWHUPLQDQW
HVHQ LDODOILGHOLW LLúLYDOLGLW LLU VSXQVXULORUVXELHF LORUODLWHPL´DV
SHFWHvQFDUHH[LVW RPDUHYDULDELOLWDWHODQLYHOXODFHVWRUFKHVWLRQDUH
$FHVWHFHULQ HVDXFRQVWLWXLWD]LvQWURPHWRGRORJLHVLVWHPDWLF
GHFRQVWUXLUHúLH[SHULPHQWDUHDFKHVWLRQDUXOXLGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDSOL
FDW vQ VSHFLDO OD QLYHOXO LQYHQWDUHORU GH WLS %LJ )LYH FDUH WLQGH V
GHYLQ úLLQGLFDWRUGHDFFHSWDELOLWDWHDORULF UXLQRXLQVWUXPHQW
(;7,1'(5,
&DUDFWHULVWLFLSULYLQGJHQHUDUHDLWHPLORU
ÌQ FDGUXO XQXL SURJUDP GHGH]YROWDUHDWHVWHORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
-DFNVRQ vQFHSH SULQ DFFHQWXDUHD QHFHVLW LL GH D RSHUD GHILQL LL
VSHFLILFHúLUHFLSURFH[FOXVLYHSHQWUXILHFDUHFRQVWUXFWSURLHFWUHDOL]DELO
vQFRQGL LLOHWUHFHULLvQUHYLVW DOLWHUDWXULLGHVSHFLDOLWDWHSULYLQGGLPHQ
VLXQHD UHVSHFWLY &HHD FH HFKLSD FRQGXV GH -DFNVRQ úL UHDOL]HD]
JHQHUkQGXQORWLQL LDOGHLWHPLSHQWUXILHFDUHFRQVWUXFWDYXWvQYHGHUH
FXDMXWRUXODFHHDFHDXWRUXOQXPHDÄRJULO GHVLWXD LLúLVHFYHQ HFRP
SRUWDPHQWDOH´-DFNVRQ'HH[HPSOXvQFDGUXODFHHDFH-DFNVRQ
QXPHúWHvQÄXQVLVWHPVHFYHQ LDOGHGH]YROWDUHDVFDOHLGHSHUVR
QDOLWDWH´XQXLJUXSGHMXGHF WRULH[SHU LOLVHGDXGHVFULHULGHULYDWHDOH
XQRU SHUVRDQH Ä LQW ´ FDUH H[HPSOLILF vQ PDUH P VXU vQ FRPSRUWD
PHQWXOORUWU V WXUDGDW 3DVXOXUP WRUFRQVW vQVDUFLQDGHDMXGHFDúL
UDQJD SUREDELOLWDWHD FD DFHVWH SHUVRDQH V DSUREH ILHFDUH GLQWUH LWHPLL
UHVSHFWLYL'HDVHPHQHDJUXSXODUHúLVDUFLQDGHDVWDELOLJUDGXOvQFDUH
LWHPLLSRWILFRQVLGHUD LUHOHYDQ LSHQWUXFRQVWUXFWXOUHVSHFWLY
0RGHOXO OXL -DFNVRQ SRDWH IL FRQVLGHUDW FD SULP vQFHUFDUH GH D
VLVWHPDWL]D JHQHUDUHD GH LWHPL $FHVW PRGHO QX D DYXW FX DGHY UDW
LPSDFWvQHSRF GDUYHQHDV U VSXQG XQRUSUREOHPHULGLFDWHDQWHULRU
GHXQDOWFHUFHW WRU/RHYLQJHU'HILFLHQ DPDMRU LQFULPLQDW GH
/RHYLQJHU UHIHULWRU OD SURFHVXO GH JHQHUDUH D LWHPLORU SHQWUX D UHSUH
]HQWD XQ DQXPLW FRQVWUXFW LQH GH LPSRVLELOLWDWHD GH DO UHSHWD FD SH
RULFHH[SHULPHQWSVLKRORJLFúLDFHVWOXFUXPDLDOHVGDWRULW vQF UF WXULL
GHLGLRVLQFUDVLHGHVXELHFWLYLWDWHvQDSUHFLHUHDGHF WUHFHUFHW WRUDDQX
PLWRUFRQ LQXWXULúLFRPSRUWDPHQWHFRQIRUPSURSULLORUVDOHSUHFRQFHS LL
VWHUHRWLSXUL H[SHULHQ H ÌQ IRUPXODUHD UHJXOLORU FDUH DU SXWHD vQO WXUD
XQHOHLQIOXHQ HQHJDWLYH/RHYLQJHUSOHDF GHODSRVWXODUHDIDSWXOXLF
LWHPLLORWXOXLWUHEXLHH[WUDúLGLQWURDULHGHFRQ LQXWXULPDLODUJ GHFkW
WU V WXUDSURSULX]LV &RQVHFLQ HOHDFHVWXLSRVWXODWvOFRQGXFODIRUPX
ODUHDXQRUUHJXOLDUWUHEXLV ILHFRQVWUXL LúLLWHPLFDUHV HYDOXH]H
DOWH WU V WXUL vQUXGLWH GDU FX YDORDUH GLVFULPLQDWLY SHQWUX WU V WXUD
GDW LWHPLLWUHEXLHDOHúLvQDúDIHOvQFkWV UHSUH]LQWHWRDWHFRQ LQX
WXULOHSRVLELOHFDUHDUSXWHDH[SULPDWU V WXUDUHVSHFWLY vQIXQF LHGH
WRDWHWHRULLOHDOWHUQDWLYHFXQRVFXWHGRPHQLLOHFRQ LQXWXULORUDUWUHEXL
V ILHUHSUH]HQWDWLYHSHQWUXLPSRUWDQ DORUH[LVWHQ LDO
$PLQVLVWDWDLFLDVXSUDDFHVWHLDERUG ULDSUREOHPHLFRQ LQXWXOXL
LWHPLORU SHQWUX F R GDW FX DFHVWH FHULQ H WHRUHWLFH vQ FkPSXO FHU
FHW WRULORU LQWU R FHULQ WD[RQRPLF DFHHD GH D HODERUD R UH HD
QRPRORJLF vQFDUHV ILHFXSULQVHFRQVWUXFWHOHFDUHVXQWHYDOXDWH
3HVWH DQL %XVV &UDLFN SXEOLF XQ DO GRLOHD PRGHO
FRHUHQW SULYLQG VDUFLQD GH JHQHUDUH D LWHPLORU GHSHQGHQW GH FHHD FH
DXWRULL QXPHVF ÄIUHFYHQ D DF LXQLL´ úL FDUH VH ED]HD] SH JUDGXO GH
SURWRWLSLFLWDWHDOXQXLFRPSRUWDPHQWSHQWUXRDQXPLW WU V WXU 3ULPXO
SDVDODFHVWXLSURJUDPFRQVW vQVHOHFWDUHDvQPRGVLVWHPDWLFDXQXLVHW
GH WU V WXUL GLQWUXQ PRGHO VWUXFWXUDW GH FRPSRUWDPHQW LQWHUSHUVRQDO
UHDOL]DWGH:LJJLQV$OGRLOHDSDVVHSXQHvQSUDFWLF SULQWUXQ
HúDQWLRQ ODUJ GH VXELHF L FDUH DX VDUFLQD GH D LGHQWLILFD R VHULH GH
FRPSRUWDPHQWH REVHUYDELOH FDUH FRUHVSXQG WU V WXULL VDX DOWIHO VSXV
JHQHUHD] DFWHFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHFDUHSRWILFRQVLGHUDWHPDQLIHVW ULDOH
WU V WXULL
$O WUHLOHD SDV HVWH vQFUHGLQ DW XQXL DOW ORW GH VXELHF L FDUH YRU
DSUHFLDSULQUDQJDUHJUDGXOGHSURWRWLSLFLWDWHDODFHVWRUDFWHFRPSRUWD
PHQWDOHSHQWUXWU V WXUDGDW $FHDVW HYDOXDUHQXVHIDFHODvQWkPSODUH
FL VH ED]HD] SH XQ VHW GH UHJXOL GH HYDOXDUH D ÄSURWRWLSLFLW LL´ úL SH
FRQVHQVXO XQXL PDUH QXP U GH YRUELWRUL DL XQHL OLPEL $FHDVW SURFH
GXU HODERUDW GH%XVVúL&UDLFNHVWHSULPDFDUHvQFHDUF V FDSLWDOL]H]H
FXQRúWLQ HOH VHPDQWLFH DOH RDPHQLORU vQ OHJ WXU FX DFHOH FRPSRUWD
PHQWHFDUHVXQWWLSLFHSHQWUXRDQXPLW WU V WXU 'H]DYDQWDMXOSULQFL
SDODOPHWRGHLFRQVW vQIDSWXOF QXPDLHVWHODIHOGHXWLO DWXQFLFkQG
VHSXQHSUREOHPDFRQVWUXLULLXQRULWHPLSHQWUXRWU V WXU SHQWUXFDUHQX
H[LVW GHQXPLULHODERUDWHODQLYHOXOOLPEDMXOXLFRPXQúLID GHFDUHQH
SXWHPDúWHSWDFDRDPHQLLV QXDLE LQWXL LLVHPDQWLFHELQHGHILQLWHFD
GH H[HPSOX vQ FD]XO DQXPLWRU GLPHQVLXQL FH VH PDQLIHVW vQ EROLOH
SVLKLFH$QJOHLWQHUúD
6WXGLXO PHQ LRQDW H[DPLQHD] PRGXO GH JHQHUDUH D LWHPLORU OD
PDMRULWDWHDFKHVWLRQDUHORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHúLJ VHúWHF vQSUDFWLF HVWH
YRUED PDL PXOW GH R FRPELQDUH D FHORU WUHL SXQFWH GH YHGHUH DVWIHO
DXWRULSUHFXP&DWWHOOFRQVWUXLHVFQRLLWHPLO VkQGQHH[SOLFDW UD LXQHD
FDUH D VWDW OD ED]D JHQHU ULL ORU DXWRULL 003,XOXL +DWKDZD\ úL
0F.LQOH\ XWLOL]HD] H[SHU L SHQWUX D OH IXUQL]D PDQLIHVW ULOH WLSLFH
SHQWUXWU V WXUDSDWRORJLF YL]DW PDMRULWDWHDSULQWUHFDUHúL*XLOIRUGúL
*RXJK FRSLD] LWHPL GLQ DOWH FKHVWLRQDUH *ROGEHUJ VWXGLLQG
FKHVWLRQDUHOHDPHULFDQHFRQVWDW F LWHPLLFRQVWUXL LODvQFHSXWXOVHFR
OXOXLúLDXJ VLWGUXPSULQPHGLHUHDPDLPXOWRUVHULLGHvPSUXPXWXUL
SkQ vQFKHVWLRQDUHOHLPSRUWDQWHDOHDQLORU¶¶
6XELHFWLYLWDWHDLQL LDO FDUHJUHYHD] vQPRGRELúQXLWSURFHGHHOH
GH JHQHUDUH D LWHPLORU QX SRDWH IL FRULMDW GH PHWRGHOH VWDWLVWLFH GH
H[SHULPHQWDUH vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH GH H[HPSOX FHHD FH D IRVWO VDWSH
GLQDIDU VDX XLWDW QX PDL SRDWH IL UHFXSHUDW SHQWUX D GHYHQL SDUWH D
VFDOHLUH]XOWDWH8QDGLQWUHLGLRVLQFUDVLLOHFDUHJUHYHD] úLvQSUH]HQW
FKHVWLRQDUHOHDYDQVDWHHVWHVXELHFWLYLWDWHDDXWRUXOXLvQGHFL]LDDVXSUD
GHQXPLULL VFDOHL UH]XOWDWH VDX D IDFWRUXOXL UH]XOWDW GHFL]LH FDUH YD
UHIOHFWDvQPDUHP VXU SUHFRQFHS LLOHDFHVWXLD$QJOHLWQHUúD
,DW GHSLOG vQLQYHQWDUHLPSRUWDQWHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHPXOWLWXGLQHDGH
GHQXPLUL vQWkOQLWH SHQWUX R DFHHDúL WU V WXU VLWXD LD HPRWLYLW LL
FRQVHUYDWRULVPXOXLIDFWRUXOXLLQWHOHFWXDOHWF
&HUFHW ULOH SUH]HQWDWH LQGLF LQWHUHVXODFWXDOSHQWUXDGHVI úXUD
HIRUWXUL FRQFHUWDWH VSUH VLVWHPDWL] UL DOH GLIHULWHORU SUREOHPH FX FDUH
VH FRQIUXQW JHQHUDUHD LWHPLORU GDU úL VSUH D R WUDQVIRUPD vQWUR
DFWLYLWDWHF UHLDV LVHFRQWUROH]HPD[LPDOYDULDELOHOH(VWHúLDFHDVWD
RH[SUHVLHDUD LRQDOLVPXOXLH[WUHPFDUHSRDWHDYHDHIHFWHSDUDGR[DOH
vQJXVWkQGFUHDWLYLWDWHDQDWXUDO
2 WHQGLQ FRQWUDU HVWH FHD D XQRU FUHDWRUL GH FKHVWLRQDUH
SUHFXP*RXJKGHDIRORVLVWUDWHJLLOHvQWURPDQLHU IOH[LELO GHDúL
GH]YROWD LQVWUXPHQWXO GLQ LQWHULRUXO DFHOXLDúL ORW LQL LDO GH LWHPL XQLL
SUHOXD LDO LLUHVFULúLDO LLQRXFUHD LGXS FXPYRPYHGHDvQFDSLWROXO
GHGLFDW,QYHQWDUXOXLGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH&DOLIRUQLD
&HUFHW ULOHFRPSDUDWLYHUHDOL]DWHDVXSUDXQRUDGLQWUHFKHVWLRQD
UHOHLPSRUWDQWHúLXQLYHUVDOUHFXQRVFXWHDXGHPRQVWUDWGHH[HPSOXF
VFDOHOHFDUHHYDOXHD] FRQVWUXFWHVLPLODUHVDXDSURDSHVLPLODUHWLQGV
FXSULQG WLSXUL GH LWHPL UHODWLY DVHP Q WRUL LQGLIHUHQW GH GLIHUHQ HOH
GLQWUHFKHVWLRQDUHSULYLQGFRQVWUXF LDúLFKLDUWHRULDGHED] 'HH[HPSOX
$QJOHLWQHUúDDQDOL]kQGFRPSDUDWLYVFDOHOHGHDQ[LHWDWHúLGH
QHYURWLVP GLQ GLYHUVH FKHVWLRQDUH GHPRQVWUHD] F vQ DFHVWHD SUH
YDOHD] vQJHQHUDOLWHPLFDUHGHVFULXRPXO LPHGHUHDF LLSVLKRIL]LR
ORJLFH6FDOHOHGHH[WUDYHUVLHVDXFHOHGHQHVLQFHULWDWHGLPSRWULY DX
XQ SURFHQW ULGLFDW GH LWHPL FRPSRUWDPHQWDOL $FHVW OXFUX SDUH V
vQGUHSW HDVF FRQFOX]LDDXWRULORUF vQWUHFHUFHW WRULH[LVW RLQWXL LH
vPS UW úLW SULYLQG FDUH WLSXUL GH LWHPL VXQW PDL DGHFYD L vQ H[SUL
PDUHD VDX P VXUDUHD XQRU DQXPLWH WU V WXUL DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL FKLDU
GDF DFHVWHLQWXL LLQXDXIRVWSkQ vQSUH]HQWVLVWHPDWL]DWH
'HDVHPHQHDSRUQLQGGHODPHWRGDSURWRWLSXULORUúLDIUHFYHQ HORU
GHDF LXQHDOXL%XVVúL&UDLNFRQVWUXLW vQSULQFLSDOSHWU V WXULGHWLS
LQWHUSHUVRQDOVHSRWFRQVWLWXLDVWIHOGHWD[RQRPL] ULúLSHQWUXDOWHFODVH
GHFRPSRUWDPHQWH3UREOHPDFHDPDLLJQRUDW GHF WUHFRQVWUXFWRULLGH
FKHVWLRQDUHSDUHV ILHFHDDFRQWH[WXOXLVLWXD LRQDOPDLH[DFWDVSHFL
ILFLW LL FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL XPDQ OHJDW GH VLWXD LH $QJOHLWQHU REVHUY
F vQ JHQHUDO FRQVWUXFWRULL GH LWHPL SURFHGHD] FD úL FkQG vQ HOHVXO
SVLKRORJLF DO FDUDFWHULVWLFLORU VLWXD LRQDOH DU SXWHD IL FDSWDW GRDU FD R
UHIHULUHFRQGL LRQDO WHPSRUDO VDXDGYHUELDO
3UREOHPHOH FRQVHFXWLYH XQHL DVWIHO GH WUDW UL D FRQ LQXWXULORU
LWHPLORU ± SUREOHPH GH IHOXO Ä(VWH VHPQLILFDWLY R UHSUH]HQWDUH D
FRQWH[WXOXLVLWXD LRQDOvQWUXQLWHPFDUHWUHEXLHV ILHvQDFHODúLWLPS
VFXUW FODU úL SUHFLV"´ VDX Ä&DUH HVWH FDSDFLWDWHD UHDO GH HYRFDUH D
WU V WXULLGDWHSULQWUXQXQLFDFWFRPSRUWDPHQWDO"´VDXÄ(VWHDVLJXUDW
WLSLFLWDWHD vQ DúD P VXU vQFkW V SXWHP SURFHGD vQ PRG UHDO OD R
UDQJDUH D FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL"´ ± DX FRQGXV VSUH QHFHVLWDWHD XQHL
VLVWHPDWL] UL D FDUDFWHULVWLFLORU LWHPLORU úL D SUREOHPDWLFLL DIHUHQWH
ILHF UHLHWDSHDFRQVWUXLULLVFDOHLGHH[SHULPHQWDUH
$QJOHLWQHUJUXSHD] DVWIHOSDWUXFDWHJRULLGHSUREOHPHSUREOHPH
FDUH LQ GH GHFL]LL SULYLQG WU V WXUD úL UHOD LD HL FX HYHQLPHQWH REVHU
YDELOHUHVSHFWLYUHOD LDVHPDQWLF LWHPWU V WXU úLUHOD LDORJLFIRUPDO
VFULHUHDSURSULX]LV VDXVHOHFWDUHDLWHPXOXLFDUHSXQHSUREOHPHSUL
YLQGFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHSVLKROLQJYLVWLFHGHVXSUDID DOHLWHPLORUFLWLUHD
úLSURFHVXOFRJQLWLYGHUHFHSWDUHDLWHPXOXLUHVSHFWLYSUREOHPHFDUH LQ
GH FRPSUHKHQVLELOLWDWH UHOHYDQ D LWHPXOXL VDX DQDOL]H VWDWLVWLFH úL
FDOLW LSVLKRPHWULFH
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH
DQDOL] GH LWHP DQDOL]D vQ GHWDOLX D LWHPLORU LQGLYLGXDOL DL XQXL WHVW
VDXFKHVWLRQDUFXVFRSXOGHDHYDOXDILGHOLWDWHDúLYDOLGLWDWHDILHF UXLD
DQDOL]HOHVHFHQWUHD] SHFRQ LQXWXOLWHPLORUúLSHIRUPDDFHVWRUDúLVH
SRW GHVI úXUD FDQWLWDWLY VDX FDOLWDWLY VWDELOLQG FkW FRQWULEXLH HIHFWLY
ILHFDUHODILGHOLWDWHDJHQHUDO úLYDOLGLWDWHDWHVWXOXL$QDOL]DFDOLWDWLY
VHSUHRFXS úLGHDVSHFWHSUHFXPDPELJXLWDWHDGLILFXOWDWHDHWF
DQDOL] IDFWRULDO PHWRG VWDWLVWLF FH vQFHDUF V SXQ vQ HYLGHQ
IDFWRULL FRPXQL XQXL DQVDPEOX GH YDULDELOH FDUH DX vQWUH HOH DQXPLWH
FRUHOD LL $QDOL]D UH]XOWDWHORU RE LQXWH SULQ DGPLQLVWUDUHD PDL PXOWRU
WHVWHPHQWDOH
FKHVWLRQDUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHvQVHQVODUJXQVHWGHvQWUHE ULLWHPLFDUH
VHUHIHU ODRWHP DVSHFWDOSHUVRQDOLW LLVDXXQJUXSGHDVSHFWHvQYH
FLQDWHDFHVWHLDvQVHQVVSHFLILFXQLQVWUXPHQWGHHYDOXDUHVWDQGDUGL]DW
HPSLULF DVSHFW FDUH GHFXUJH GLQ WDWRQ UL SUDFWLFH QHJKLGDWH GH XQ
VFRSVDXGHXQFDGUXWHRUHWLF
IDFWRUvQJHQHUDORULFHDVSHFWFDUHDUHRLQIOXHQ FDX]DO DVXSUDXQXL
IHQRPHQSULQH[WLQGHUHIDFWRUXOHVWHRYDULDELO LQGHSHQGHQW ÌQVWD
WLVWLF XQSURGXVDODQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOHQXPHUHvQWURPDWULFHIDFWRULDO
DQDOL]D IDFWRULDO LGHDO LGHQWLILF XQ QXP U PLF GH IDFWRUL ILHFDUH
RUWRJRQDOID GHFHLODO L)DFWRULLFDUHDSDUvQXUPDDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOH
WUHEXLH V ILH H[DPLQD L VXELHFWLY SHQWUX D GHWHUPLQD GDF UHSUH]LQW
GLPHQVLXQLSVLKRORJLFHHYLGHQWH([LVW RWHQGLQ PDLDOHVFkQGWHKQLFD
DQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOHVHDSOLF LQYHQWDUHORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHV VHLGHQWLILFH
IDFWRULLFDUHDSDUFXWU V WXULOH6WULFWYRUELQGIDFWRUXOQXHVWHRWU V
WXU WU V WXUDHVWHLQIHUDW SRUQLQGGHODIDFWRUXORE LQXWUHSUH]LQW R
UHJXODULWDWHVXELDFHQW ED]HLGHGDWHGHODFDUHVDSRUQLWDVWIHOF FHL
GRLWHUPHQLWU V WXU úLIDFWRUQXWUHEXLHFRQVLGHUD LVLQRQLPL3HQWUXD
SXWHDV VWDELOLPRWU V WXU YDOLG DYHPQHYRLHGHLQIRUPD LLDGL LRQDOH
'3
LGHRVLQFUDVLH GHILQHúWH GLVSR]L LD LQGLYLGXOXL GH D RUJDQL]D SULQ úL
SHQWUXHOvQVXúLGDWHúLIDSWHLGHQWLFHGXS GLVSR]L LLOHVDOHSHUVRQDOH
DIHFWLYHVDXFRJQLWLYH'HH[HPSOXPDMRULWDWHDJUHúHOLORUGHOLPEDMVH
GDWRUHD] FRPSRUWDPHQWHORULGHRVLQFUDVLFH'3
LQWXL LH VHVL]DUHD GLUHFW D HOHPHQWHORU RUJDQL]DWH VSRQWDQ vQWUXQ
DQVDPEOXGHWHUPLQDW&*-XQJIDFHGLQHDRIXQF LHIXQGDPHQWDO D
SVLKLFXOXLGDWRULW F UHLDvQPRGVXELWXQFRQ LQXWQHHVWHSUH]HQWDW
VXERIRUP GHILQLWLY I U FDQRLV úWLPFXPVDDMXQVDLFL
PHWRG DQVDPEOXGHSURFHGXULGHPHUVXULVDXUHJXOLDGRSWDWHvQFRQ
GXFHUHDXQHLFHUFHW ULÌQPXOWLSOHOHGRPHQLLDSOLFDWLYHvQSVLKRORJLH
VDXGH]YROWDWPHWRGHFDUHWUDVHD] PRGDOLW LGHLQWHUDF LXQHDSUDFWL
FLDQXOXLFXSHUVRDQHOHVWXGLDWHVDXDVXSUDF URUDVHLQWHUYLQHYRUELP
GHPHWRGDREVHUYD LHLPHWRG GHJUXSPHWRG JOREDO VDXDQDOLWLF
PHWRG QRQGLUHFWLY PHWRG FRPSRUWDPHQWDO HWF(VWHHVHQ LDOV VH
UDSRUWH]HIDSWHOHREVHUYDWHODPHWRGHOHXWLOL]DWHSHQWUXVWXGLX'3
SVLKRGLDJQR] vQPRGVSHFLILFVHUHIHU ODSURFHGXULGHGLDJQRVWLFDUH
D DQRUPDOLW LORU SVLKRORJLFH D WXOEXU ULORU PHQWDOH HWF 0DL JHQHUDO
WHUPHQXOHVWHIRORVLWSHQWUXRULFHSURFHGXU GHHYDOXDUHSVLKRORJLF VDX
GHSHUVRQDOLWDWH7HUPHQXOGHSVLKRGLDJQRVWLFVHUHIHU ODRULFHWHKQLFL
YDOLGHGHHYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLSULQLQWHUSUHWDUHDPRGHOHORUGHFRP
SRUWDPHQWLQFOXVLYDFHORUQRQYHUEDOH'3
SVLKRPHWULHVHUHIHU ODP VXUDUHDDFHHDFHHVWHSVLKRORJLFUHVSHFWLY
DSOLFDUHDSULQFLSLLORUPDWHPDWLFHúLVWDWLVWLFHGDWHORUGLQSVLKRORJLHPDL
VSHFLILFVHUHIHU ODWHVWDUHDPHQWDO LQFOX]kQGHYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL
HYDOXDUHDLQWHOLJHQ HLGHWHUPLQDUHDDSWLWXGLQLORUHWF
WD[RQRPLHFODVLILFDUHVLVWHPDWLF vQVSHFLDODIRUPHORUYLL
WHRULLDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLvQIXQF LHGHRULHQWDUHDJHQHUDO úLPRGXOFXP
FDUDFWHUL]HD] WHUPHQXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHGHRVHELPvQWUHWHRULLWLSRORJLFH
SXQDFFHQWSHFODVLILFDUHDLQGLYL]LORUvQIXQF LHGHWLSXULGHH[HPSOX
-XQJ LQWURYHUW YV H[WUDYHUW WHRULL SULYLQG WU V WXULOH DVWIHO GH WHRULL
RSHUHD] SHSUHVXSXQHUHDF SHUVRQDOLWDWHDXQXLRPHVWHXQFRPSOH[GH
WU V WXULVDXPRGXULFDUDFWHULVWLFHGHFRPSRUWDPHQWJkQGLUHGHDVLP L
VDXUHDF LRQD7HRULLOHUHFHQWHXWLOL]HD] DQDOL]DIDFWRULDO SHQWUXDL]ROD
GLPHQVLXQLOH VXELDFHQWH DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL úL SUREDELO 5%&DWWHOO HVWH
XQD GLQWUH WHRULLOH FHOH PDL GH]YROWDWH FDUH VH ED]HD] SH XQ VHW GH
WU V WXULVXUV SUHVXSXVHDH[LVWDvQFDQWLW LUHODWLYHvQILHFDUHSHUVRDQ
úL FDUH VXQW ÄLQIOXHQ HOH VWUXFWXUDOH UHDOH VXELDFHQWH SHUVRQDOLW LL´
$ERUG ULOH WLSRORJLFH úL FHOH SULYLQG WU V WXULOH VXQW FRPSOHPHQWDUH
WHRULL SVLKRGLQDPLFH úL SVLKDQDOLVWH DYkQG OD ED] WHRULLOH OXL )UHXG
-XQJ VDX FHOH SVLKRVRFLDOH DOH OXL $GOHU )URPP 6XOOLYDQ +RUQH\
/DLQJúL3HDUOVFXDFFHQWXDUHDIDFWRULORUGHGH]YROWDUHWHRULLEHKDYLRULVWH
FDUH VH FHQWUHD] SH R H[WLQGHUH D WHRULLORU vQY ULL WHRULL OHJDWH GH
vQY DUHD VRFLDO FDUH WUDWHD] SHUVRQDOLWDWHD GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD DFHORU
DVSHFWHFDUHVXQWDFKL]L LRQDWHvQFRQWH[WVRFLDOWHRULLVLWXD LRQDOHFDUH
SXQ DFFHQW SH IDSWXO F FHHD FH HVWH FRQVLVWHQW vQ FRPSRUWDPHQWXO
REVHUYDELOHVWHODUJGHWHUPLQDWGHFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHVLWXD LHLPDLGHJUDE
GHFkW GH WU V WXUL VDX IDFWRUL LQWHULRUL WHRULL LQWHUDF LRQLVWH HFOHFWLFH
FDUHPHQ LQLGHHDF SHUVRQDOLWDWHDHPHUJHGLQLQWHUDF LXQLGLQWUHSUH
GLVSR]L LLúLFDOLW LOHSDUWLFXODUHúLPDQLHUDvQFDUHPHGLXOLQIOXHQ HD]
IHOXOORUGHDVHPDQLIHVWDÌQFRQFOX]LHSXWHPGLVFHUQHSHQWUXWHUPHQXO
GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH GRX DVSHFWH JHQHUDOH SULPXO GHULY GLQ SULPHOH WUHL
WLSXUL GH DERUGDUH SHQWUX FDUH SHUVRQDOLWDWHD UHSUH]LQW XQ FRQVWUXFW
WHRUHWLF OHJLWLP R HQWLWDWH LSRWHWLF LQWHULRDU FDUH DUH XQ URO FDX]DO
SHQWUX FRPSRUWDPHQW úL R IRU H[SOLFDWLY DXWHQWLF SHQWUX FHOHODOWH
SHUVSHFWLYHHVWHFRQFHSXW FDXQIDFWRUVHFXQGDULQIHUDWSHED]DFRQVLV
WHQ HLGHFRPSRUWDPHQW'3
WHVW GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH RULFH LQVWUXPHQW SURIHVLRQLVW SHQWUX HYDOXDUHD
SHUVRQDOLW LL 6H GLVWLQJ vQ SULQFLSDO WHVWH GLUHFWH FDUH VH DGUHVHD]
GLUHFWFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLREVHUYDELOVDXFDUHSRDWHILHYDOXDWFRQúWLHQW
SUHFXP FKHVWLRQDUHOH VDX LQYHQWDUHOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH úL WHVWH LQ
GLUHFWH VDX SURLHFWLYH FDUH VH DGUHVHD] vQWUHJXOXL SHUVRQDOLW LL úL
DVSHFWHORULQFRQúWLHQWHH[HPSOXWHVWXO6]RQGL'3
WU V WXU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH UHSUH]LQW R GLVSR]L LH VDX FDUDFWHULVWLF
VXELDFHQW SUHVXSXV FDUH SRDWH IL IRORVLW FD R H[SOLFD LH SHQWUX
UHJXODULW LOHVDXDVSHFWHOHFRQVLVWHQWHDOHFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLDFHVWHLD
ÌQVHQVPDLODUJRGHVFULHUHDPRGXULORUGHFRPSRUWDPHQWSHUFHSHUH
JkQGLUH FDUDFWHULVWLFH SHQWUX R SHUVRDQ DFHVW VHQV HVWH IRORVLW VWULFW
GHVFULSWLYI U H[LVWHQ DXQHLLQWHQ LLH[SOLFDWLYH'3
WU V WXU vQ JHQHUH R FDUDFWHULVWLF UH]LVWHQW FDUH SRDWH VHUYL FD
H[SOLFD LHSHQWUXUHJXODULW LOHFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHREVHUYDWHODDFHDSHU
VRDQ SHQWUXFHHDFHHVWHFRQVLVWHQWvQFRPSRUWDPHQWXOHL7U V WXUD
HVWHRHQWLWDWHWHRUHWLF FDUHHVWHIRORVLW SHQWUXDH[SOLFDFRQVLVWHQ HOH
FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH DOH SHUVRDQHL VDX GLIHUHQ HOH GLQWUH FRQVLVWHQ HOH
FRPSRUWDPHQWDOHDOHPDLPXOWRUSHUVRDQHvQDFHVWVHQVHVWHLQFRUHFW
V XWLOL] P WHUPHQXO SHQWUX D GHVHPQD DFHVWH DVSHFWH FRPSRUWDPHQ
WDOHvQVLQH'3
3URLHFWDSOLFDWLYGHVHPHVWUX
&X VWDWXW REOLJDWRULX &RQVWUXLUHD XQXL FKHVWLRQDU GHGLFDW
XQHLWU V WXULGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
&HULQ HúLSDúL
x YH LDOHJHRWU V WXU GHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
x YH L GHILQL FODU WU V WXUD GLPHQVLXQHD SUHFL]kQG úL ID HWHOH HL
VWXGLXELEOLRJUDILF
x YH L FRQVWUXL XQ FKHVWLRQDU SLORW FRQIRUP PHWRGHL UD LRQDOH vQ
FRQVWUXLUHD LWHPLORU YH L LQH VHDPD GH WRDWH WLSXULOH GH OHJ WXU
LWHP±WU V WXU
x YH L H[SHULPHQWD FKHVWLRQDUXO SLORW DSOLFkQGXO SH XQ QXP U GH
VXELHF L
x YH LUHDOL]DDQDOL]DGHLWHPLJUDGGHGLVFULPLQDUHúLJUDGGHGLIL
FXOWDWH
x YH LUHDOL]DDQDOL]DILGHOLW LLSULQPHWRGDFRQVLVWHQ HLLQWHUQH
x YH LUHVWUXFWXUDFKHVWLRQDUXOFRQIRUPGDWHORUGHFHUFHWDUH
$GDSWDELOLWDWH DJUHVLYLWDWH vQ JHQHUDO vQ DGROHVFHQ vQ WR[L
FRPDQLH HWF DQJDMDPHQW RUJDQL]D LRQDO DQ[LHWDWH DVHUWLYLWDWH DVX
PDUHD ULVFXOXL DWLWXGLQL FUHDWLYH FDULVPD FDSDFLWDWHD GH FRRSHUDUH
FDSDFLWDWHD GH FRQYLQJHUH FDSDFLWDWHD GH GHFL]LH FDSDFLWDWHD GH
HYDOXDUH MXGLFDWLY FDSDFLWDWHD GH PHGLHUH FUHDWLYLWDWH DUWLVWLF
WHKQLF FRPHUFLDO HWFHPSDWLHLQGHSHQGHQ vQGHFL]LLLQWHOLJHQ
HPR LRQDO LQWXL LH vQFUHGHUH vQ VLQH ORFXO FRQWUROXOXL RSWLPLVP
SUH]HQ VRFLDO SHUVHYHUHQ U EGDUH UHVSRQVDELOLWDWH UHVSHFW GH
VLQH VDWLVIDF LH vQ PXQF VLJXUDQ GH VLQH VLP XO XPRUXOXL VSLULW
PRUDOHWLF VXJHVWLELOLWDWH WROHUDQ WLPLGLWDWH ± VXQW QXPDL FkWHYD
H[HPSOH GH WU V WXUL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH SHQWUX FDUH SXWH L vQFHUFD V
FRQVWUXL LXQFKHVWLRQDUVSHFLILF
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU
&DUHHVWHSULQFLSDODOLPLW DFKHVWLRQDUHORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH"
&DUH VXQW SUREOHPHOH HVHQ LDOH vQ FRQVWUXLUHD XQXL FKHVWLRQDU GH
SHUVRQDOLWDWH"
&DUH VXQW HWDSHOH JHQHUDOH vQ FRQVWUXLUHD XQXL FKHVWLRQDU GH
SHUVRQDOLWDWH"
&DUHVXQWVWUDWHJLLOHGHFRQVWUXLUHDFKHVWLRQDUHORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
úLFXPSRWILGHILQLWHILHFDUH"
&DUHVXQWSULQFLSDOHOHDYDQWDMHúLGH]DYDQWDMHDOHPHWRGHLUD LRQDOH"
&DUHHVWHVSHFLILFXOPHWRGHLHPSLULFHúLDYDQWDMHOHXWLOL] ULLDFHVWHLD
vQFRQVWUXLUHDFKHVWLRQDUXOXLGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH"
&DUHVXQWDYDQWDMHOHúLGH]DYDQWDMHOHPHWRGHLDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOH"
&HWLSXULGHUHOD LLSRWH[LVWDvQWUHFRQ LQXWXOúLIRUPDLWHPLORUúL
WU V WXUDWHVWDW FRPSRUWDPHQWXOGHILQLWWHRUHWLF"
&DUHVXQWFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHGHVXSUDID DOHLWHPLORU"
&DUHVXQWFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHVHPDQWLFHDOHLWHPLORU"
&DUHVXQWSUREOHPHOHOHJDWHGHFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHVHPDQWLFHDOHLWHPLORU"
&DUHVXQWFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHSVLKRPHWULFHDOHLWHPLORU"
%LEOLRJUDILHúLFRPHQWDULL
$OOSRUW*: 2GEHUW+67UDLW1DPHV$3V\FKROH[LFDO6WXG\
3V\FKRORJLFDO0RQRJUDSKV
$OOSRUW * : 3HUVRQDOLW\ $ 3V\FKRORJLFDO ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ +ROW
5LQHKDUW :LQVWRQ1HZ<RUN
$QDVWDVL$3V\FKRORJLFDO7HVWLQJ0DF0LOODQ3XEO&R1HZ<RUN
&URQEDFK/*(VVHQWLDOVRI3V\FKRORJLFDO7HVWLQJ+DUSHU 5RZ
1HZ<RUN
$QJOHLWQHU $ 2VWHQGRUI ) -RKQ 2 3 7RZDUGV D 7D[RQRP\ RI
3HUVRQDOLW\'HVFULSWRUVLQ*HUPDQ$3V\FKROH[LFDO6WXG\Ä(XURSHDQ
-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
$QJOHLWQHU $ -RKQ 2 3 /|KU ) - ,W¶V :KDW <RX $VN DQG +RZ
<RX $VN ,W DQ ,WHPPHWULF $QDO\VLV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 4XHVWLRQQDLUHV vQ
$QJOHLWQHU $ :LJJLQV - 6 HGV 3HUVRQDOLW\ $VVHVVPHQW YLD
4XHVWLRQQDLUHV6SULQJHU9HUODJ%HUOLQ
$QJOHLWQHU$5LHPDQQ5:KDW&DQ:H/HDUQIURPWKH'LVFXVVLRQ
RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 4XHVWLRQQDLUHV IRU WKH &RQVWUXFWLRQ RI 7HPSHUDPHQW
,QYHQWRULHV" vQ 6WUHODX - $QJOHLWQHU $ HGV ([SORUDWLRQV LQ
7HPSHUDPHQW,QWHUQDWLRQDO3HUVSHFWLYHVRQ7KHRU\DQG0HDVXUHPHQW
S3OHQXP3UHVV/RQGRQ
$VVHVVPHQWDQG7HVWLQJ$6XUYH\RIUHVHDUFK8QLYHUVLW\RI&DPEULGJH
%DQQLVWHU ' 1HZ 3HUVSHFWLYHV LQ 3HUVRQDO &RQVWUXFW 7KHRU\
$FDGHPLF3UHVV1HZ<RUN
%UDQG&5 (JDQ97KHÄ%LJ)LYH´'LPHQVLRQVRI3HUVRQDOLW\"
(YLGHQFH IURP ,SVDWLYH $GMHFWLYDO 6HOI$WWULEXWLRQV 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG
,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV
%ULJJV 0\HUV , 0F&DXOOH\ 0 + 0DQXDO $ *XLGH WR WKH
'HYHORSPHQWDQG8VHRIWKH0\HUV%ULJJV7\SH,QGLFDWRU&RQVXOWLQJ
3V\FKRORJLVW3UHVV3DOR$OWR
%URNNHP ) % 7KH /DQJXDJH RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ WH] GH GRFWRUDW
8QLYHUVLWDWHD*URQLJHQ2ODQGD
%XVV ' 0 &UDLN . + 7KH $FW )UHTXHQF\ $SSURDFK WR
3HUVRQDOLW\Ä3V\FKRORJLFDO5HYLHZ´
&DSUDUD * 9 úL 3HUXJLQL 0 3HUVRQDOLW\ 6WUXFWXUH LQ ,WDOLDQ
Ä(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
&DWWHOO 5 % 7KH 'HVFULSWLRQ RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ %DVLF 7UDLWV 5HVROYHG
LQWR&OXVWHUVÄ-RXUQDORI$EQRUPDODQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
&DWWHOO 5 % 'HVFULSWLRQ DQG 0HDVXUHPHQW RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ :RUOG
%RRN1HZ<RUN &RQILUPDWLRQDQG&ODULILFDWLRQRI3ULPDU\
3HUVRQDOLW\)DFWRUV3V\FKRPHWULND
&RVWD37 0F&UDH557KH1(23HUVRQDOLW\,QYHQWRU\0DQXDO
2GHVVD)O3V\FKRORJLFDO$VVHVVPHQW5HVRXUFHV
&RVWD 3 7 0F&UDH 5 5 7KH 1(23,1(2)), 0DQXDO
6XSSOHPHQW 2GHVVD 3$5 1(23,5 3URIHVVLRQDO 0DQXDO
UHYLVHG 1(2 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\ DQG 1(2)LYH)DFWRU ,QYHQWRU\
2GHVVD3$5
'H5DDG% &DOMH+3HUVRQDOLW\LQWKH&RQWH[WRI&RQYHUVDWLRQ
3HUVRQ7DON
'H 5DDG % úD RS FLW +RIVWHH : . % 7KH 8VH RI
(YHU\GD\ /DQJXDJH IRU 6FLHQWLILF 3XUSRVH Ä(XURSHDQ -RXUQDO RI
3HUVRQDOLW\´'H5DDG%7KH5HSOLFDELOLW\RIWKH%LJ
)LYH 3HUVRQDOLW\ 'LPHQVLRQV LQ WKH 7KUHH :RUOG &ODVVHV RI 'XWFK
/DQJXDJH Ä(XURSHDQ -RXUQDO RI 3HUVRQDOLW\´ &DSUDUD
3HUXJLQLRSFLW+RIVWHH:.%RSFLW
'LJPDQ - 0 3HUVRQDOLW\ 6WUXFWXUH (PHUJHQFH RI WKH )LYH)DFWRU
0RGHOÄ$QQXDO5HYLHZRI3V\FKRORJ\´
6SUDQJHU ( 7\SHV RI 0DQ 6WHFKHUW 1HZ <RUN $OOSRUW * :
9HUQRQ3(/LQGVH\*$6WXG\RI9DOXHV+RXJKWRQ0LIIOLQ
%RVWRQHGD,,,DXQGHDXWRULLED]kQGXVHSHWLSRORJLDOXL6SUDQJHU
±RPXOWHRUHWLFHFRQRPLFHVWHWLFVRFLDOSROLWLFúLUHOLJLRV±FRQVWUXLHVF
XQWHVWRPRQLPvQGRX S U LFXXQWRWDOGHGHLWHPL'HH[HPSOX
Ä&kQGDVLVWD LODRFHUHPRQLHIDVWXRDV ELVHULFHDVF VDXDFDGHPLF R
LQVWDODUHvQIXQF LHVXQWH LPDLPXOWLPSUHVLRQDWGHDFXORDUHDúLIDVWXO
RFD]LHL ELQIOXHQ DúLSXWHUHDJUXSXOXL´3UHIHULQ DHVWHUHSUH]HQWDW
JUDILFSULQWUXQSURILO$XWRULLFRQVLGHU WHVWXOFDILLQGGHWLSLGHRJUDILF
(LVHQEHUJ 3 ,QGLYLGXDO ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ RI 3V\FKRQHXURWLF ,QYHQWRU\
,WHPV Ä-RXUQDO RI *HQHUDO 3V\FKRORJ\´ ([SHULPHQW
FRQVWDWDWLYDQFKHWHD] VXELHF LLvQOHJ WXU FXPRWLYXOSHQWUXFDUHDX
GDWDQXPLWHU VSXQVXULODLWHPLLWHVWXOXLU VSXQVXULGHIRUPDWXO'D±"
± 1X ÌQ DIDUD XQHL JDPH ODUJL H[SOLFDWLYH SHQWUX ILHFDUH U VSXQV
GHVFRSHU úLH[SOLFD LLLGHQWLFHSHQWUXIRUPDWHGHU VSXQVXULRSXVH
)RUVPDQ/*LYLQJ([WUHPH5HVSRQVHVWR,WHPVLQ6HOI(VWHHP6FDOHV
5HVSRQVH6HWRU3HUVRQDOLW\7UDLW"Ä(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3V\FKRORJLFDO
$VVHVVPHQW´ FDUH GHVFRSHU F QXP UXO GH U VSXQVXUL
H[WUHPHFRUHOHD] VHPQLILFDWLYvQWUHVFDOHGLIHULWHFHHDFHOFRQGXFHOD
DILUPD LDF DGDU VSXQVXULH[WUHPHSRDWHILXQDVSHFWLQGHSHQGHQWGH
FRQ LQXWXOVFDOHLDQDOL]DDFRQGXVVSUHGHWHUPLQDUHDIDSWXOXLF DFHVWWLS
GH U VSXQVXUL HUDX vQ PDUH P VXU GHWHUPLQDWH GH R UHVSLQJHUH FDWH
JRULF DDFHORULWHPLFDUHGHVFULXRFDUDFWHULVWLF QHJDWLY DSHUVRDQHL
(\VHQFN+- (\VHQFN6%*0DQXDORIWKH(\VHQFN3HUVRQDOLW\
4XHVWLRQQDLUH8QLYHUVLW\RI/RQGRQ3UHVV/RQGRQ
)LVNH ' : &RQVLVWHQF\ RI WKH )DFWRULDO 6WUXFWXUHV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\
5DWLQJV IURP 'LIIHUHQW 6RXUFHV Ä-RXUQDO RI $EQRUPDO DQG 6RFLDO
3V\FKRORJ\´ 7XSHV ( & &KULVWDO 5 &
5HFXUUHQW3HUVRQDOLW\)DFWRUV%DVHGRQ7UDLW5DWLQJV86$LU)RUFH
/DNHODQG
)RVV'-+DNHV'73V\FKROLQJXLVWLFV(QJOHZRRG&OLIIV3UHQWLFH+DOO
)UDQFLV/- 7KH'XDO1DWXUHRIWKH(34/LH6FDOHDPRQJ&ROOHJH
6WXGHQWV LQ (QJODQG 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG ,QGLYLGXDO 'LIIHUHQFHV
*DOOXFL0/DXULROD0/HRQH//LYL63HUXJLQL0&RPSDULQJ
'LIIHUHQW00700HWKRGVRQWKH%LJ)LYH'RPDLQVOXFUDUHSUH]HQWDW
ODD9,,DFRQIHULQ ($330DGULG
3HUXJLQL0/HRQH/*DOOXFL0/DXULROD06HOHFWLRQRID6KRUW
$GMHFWLYH&KHFNOLVWWR0HDVXUH%LJ)LYHOXFUDUHSUH]HQWDW ODD9,,D
FRQIHULQ D($330DGULG
6WH\HU5)HUULQJ'6FKPLWW0-6WDWHVDQG7UDLWVLQ3V\FKRORJLFDO
$VVHVVPHQWÄ(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3V\FKRORJLFDO$VVHVVPHQW´
vQFDUHDXWRULLSURSXQRFODV GHPRGHOHGHQXPLWHÄPRGHOHGHWU V WXUL
VW ULODWHQWH´/670FDUHLDXvQFRQVLGHUDUHHIHFWHOHVLVWHPDWLFHDOHVL
WXD LHLvQFDUHVHGHVI úRDU HYDOXDUHDúLLQWHUDF LXQLOHSHUVRDQ VLWXD LH
3ULQ ÄVLWXD LH´ VH vQ HOHJ WRDWH LQIOXHQ HOH WUHF WRDUH DVXSUD FRPSRUWD
PHQWXOXL SHUVRDQHL vQ PRPHQWXO HYDOX ULL ± FDUDFWHULVWLFL DOH VLWXD LHL
WU LULUHFHQWHVW ULSVLKRIL]LRORJLFHHWF
*ROGEHUJ/5$0RGHORI,WHP$PELJXLW\LQ3HUVRQDOLW\$VVHVVPHQW
(GXFDWLRQDODQG3V\FKRORJLFDO0HDVXUHPHQW
*ROGEHUJ / 5 $ +LVWRULFDO 6XUYH\ RI SHUVRQDOLW\ 6FDOHV DQG
,QYHQWRULHV vQ 0F.H\QROGV 3 HG $GYDQFHV LQ 3V\FKRORJLFDO
$VVHVVPHQWYRO3DOR$OWR
*ROGEHUJ/5 /DQJXDJHDQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV7KH6HDUFKIRU
8QLYHUVDOV LQ 3HUVRQDOLW\ /H[LFRQV vQ :KHHOHU / HG Ä5HYLHZ RI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´6DJH%HYHUO\+LOOV&$
*ROGEHUJ/58QFRQIRXQGLQJ6LWXDWLRQDO$WWULEXWLRQVIURP8QFHUWDLQ
1HXWUDODQG$PELJXRXV2QHV$3V\FKRPHWULF$QDO\VLVRI'HVFULSWLRQ
RI 2QHVHOI DQG 9DULRXV 7\SHV RI 2WKHUV Ä-RXUQDO RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG
6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
*ROGEHUJ / 5 )URP $FH WR =RPELH 6RPH ([SORUDWLRQV LQ WKH
/DQJXDJH RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ vQ 6SLHOEHUJ & ' 1XWFKHU - 1 HGV
$GYDQFHV LQ 3HUVRQDOLW\ $VVHVVPHQW YRO S (UOEDXP
+LOOVGDOH1-
%ULJJV 6 5 $VVHVVLQJ WKH )LYH)DFWRU 0RGHO RI 3HUVRQDOLW\
'HVFULSWLRQÄ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
*ROGEHUJ / 5 RS FLW +RIVWHH : . % 'H 5DDG % *ROGEHUJ / 5
,QWHJUDWLRQRIWKH%LJ)LYHDQG&LUFXPSOH[$SSURDFKHVWR7UDLW
6WUXFWXUHÄ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
+DVH+' *ROGEHUJ/57KH&RPSDUDWLYH9DOLGLW\RI'LIIHUHQW
6WUDWHJLHV RI 'HULYLQJ 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\ 6FDOHV 3V\FKRORJLFDO
%XOOHWLQ
+RIVWHH:.%úDRSFLW3HUXJLQL0$FLUFXPSOH[+LHUDUFKLFDO
$SSURDFK WR ,QGLYLGXDWH D 7D[RQRP\ RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ &KDUDFWHULVWLFV
WH] GHGRFWRUDW8QLYHUVLWDWHDGLQ5RPD
+RIVWHH:.%:KR.QRZV%HVWDERXW3HUVRQDOLW\OXFUDUHSUH]HQ
WDW ODD9,,DFRQIHULQ ($330DGULG
+RIVWHH:.%'H5DDG%*ROGEHUJ/5RSFLW+HQGULNV$$-
+RIVWHH : . % 'H 5DDG % &RQVWUXFWLRQ RI WKH $%&
3HUVRQDOLW\4XHVWLRQQDLUHOXFUDUHSUH]HQWDW ODD,,DFRQIHULQ ($33
*URQLJHQ
-DFNVRQ'13HUVRQDOLW\5HVHDUFK)RUP0DQXDO*RVKHQ5HVHDUFK
3V\FKRORJLVWV
-DFNVRQ'1$6HTXHQWLDO6\VWHPIRU3HUVRQDOLW\6FDOH'HYHORSPHQW
vQ 6SLHOEHUJHU & ' HG &XUUHQW 7RSLF LQ &OLQLFDO DQG &RPPXQLW\
3V\FKRORJ\YRO$FDGHPLF3UHVV1HZ<RUN
-DQNH : 'DV 'LOHPPD YRQ 3HUV|QOLFKNHLWVIUDJHERJHQ /HQQHUW] (
7KHVHQ]XU,WHPVDPPOXQJEHL3HUV|QOLFKNHLWVIUDJHERJHQDPEHOH
vQ 5HLQKDUW * HG %HULFKW EHU GHQ .RQJUHVV GHU 'HXWVFKHQ
*HVHOOVFKDIWIU3V\FKRORJLH.LHO+RJUDIH*|WWLQJHQ
-RKQ237KHÄ%LJ)LYH´)DFWRU7D[RQRP\'LPHQVLRQVRI3HUVRQDOLW\
LQ WKH 1DWXUDO /DQJXDJH DQG LQ 4XHVWLRQQDLUHV vQ 3HUYLQ / HG
+DQGERRN RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 7KHRU\ DQG 5HVHDUFK 1HZ <RUN *XLOIRUG
-XQJ & * 3V\FKRORJLVFKH 7\SHQ *HVDPPHOWH :HUNH YRO 9,
5DVFKHU9HUODJ =ULFK SDU LDO WUDGXV vQ Ä'HVFULHUHD WL
SXULORUSVLKRORJLFH´DQWRORJLD&*-XQJYRO,,(G$QLPD%XFXUHúWL
-XQJ LQWURGXFH GH IDSW SULPD GDW WHUPHQXO GH LQWURYHUVLH vQ vQ
Ä3V\FKLF &RQIOLFWV LQ D &KLOG´ SDU &ROOHFWHG :RUNV DSRL vQ
vQÄ6\PEROVRIWUDQVIRUPDWLRQ´&:SDUùLPDLSHODUJ
vQFRPXQLFDUHDÄ$6WXG\RI3V\FKRORJLFDO7\SHV´IRUPXODUHDH[SOLFLW
DSDUHvQ&:SDUÄ3URSXQIRORVLUHDWHUPHQLORU©H[WUDYHUVLHªúL
©LQWURYHUVLHªSHQWUXDGHVFULHDFHVWHPLúF ULRSXVHDOHOLELGRXOXL´
.HOO\*$7KH3V\FKRORJ\RI3HUVRQDO&RQVWUXFWV1RUWRQ1HZ<RUN
/LHQHUW*$7HVWDXIEDXXQG7HVWDQDO\VH%HOW]:HLQKHLP/|KU)-
$QJOHLWQHU$(LQH8QWHUVXFKWVXQJ]X6RUDFKOLFKHQ)RUPXOLHUXQJHQ
GHU ,WHPV LQ 'HXWVFKHQ 3HUV|QOLFKNHLWVIUDJHERJHQ Ä=HLWVFKULIW IU
'LIHUHQWLHOOH XQG 'LDJQRVWLVFKH 3V\FKRORJLH´ $QJOHLWQHU
úDRSFLW
/RHYLQJHU - / 2EMHFWLYH 7HVWV DV ,QVWUXPHQWV RI 3V\FKRORJLFDO
7KHRU\3V\FKRORJLFDO5HSRUWV
0DUFXV6 &DWLQD$5ROXOFRQVWUXFWHORUvQFXQRDúWHUHDHPSDWLF
Ä5HYLVWDGHSVLKRORJLH´6WLOXULDSUHFLDWLYHÄ5HYLVWD
GH SVLKRORJLH´ 6WLOXUL DSUHFLDWLYH (G $FDGHPLHL
%XFXUHúWL
0LQXOHVFX05H]ROYDUHDGHSUREOHPHúLVWLOXOFRJQLWLYvQLQYHVWLJD LD
MXGLFLDU FHUFHW ULSVLKRORJLFHDVXSUDDFWLYLW LLúLSHUVRQDOLW LLOXFU WR
ULORUGLQMXGLFLDUWH] GHGRFWRUDW8QLYHUVLWDWHD%XFXUHúWLGLQWUH
SURIHVLRQLúWLLHILFLHQ LDSDU LQPRGDOLW LLHPSDWLFHúLPRGDOLW LL
DQWDJRQLFH WHQGLQ D GH D XWLOL]D PHFDQLVPH SURLHFWLYH vQ LQIHUHQ HOH úL
DSUHFLHUHD LQWHUSHUVRQDO HVWH vQDOW VHPQLILFDWLY ILLQG GLVFULPLQDWLY
HPSLULF GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD FULWHULXOXL HILFLHQ HL SURIHVLRQDOH $VWIHO vQFkW
XQDGLQFRQFOX]LLOHFHUFHW ULLHVWHF VWLOXOHPSDWLFúLFHODQDORJLFGHHYD
OXDUHLQWHUSHUVRQDO VHPDQLIHVW SHQWUXDFHDVW FDWHJRULHSURIHVLRQDO FD
RFDUDFWHULVWLF VSHFLILF DVWUXFWXULLSHUVRQDOLW LL
0LQXOHVFX0&KHVWLRQDUHOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHvQHYDOXDUHDSVLKRORJLF
(G*DUHOO%XFXUHúWL
0F&OHOODQG'&,V3HUVRQDOLW\&RQVLVWHQW"vQ5DELQ$,$UQRII
- %HUFOD\ $ 0 =XFNHU 5 $ HGV )XUWKHU ([SORUDWLRQV LQ
3HUVRQDOLW\:LOH\1HZ<RUN
0F&UDH 5 5 &RVWD 3 7 3HUVRQDOLW\ LQ $GXOWKRRG 1HZ <RUN
*XLOIRUG S YRUEHVF GHVSUH VWUXFWXUD GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH FD SDWHUQ DO
FRYDULHULLWU V WXULORUvQWURSRSXOD LH
0F&UDH55 &RVWD37$7UDLW3HUVSHFWLYHRQWKH'HVFULSWLRQ
DQG([SODQDWLRQRI%HKDYLRU9,,,&RQIHUHQFHRI($330DGULG
0F&UDH553V\FKRSDWKRORJ\IURPWKH3HUVSHFWLYHRIWKH)LYH)DFWRU
0RGHO vQ 6WUDFN 6 /RUU 0 HGV 'LIIHUHQWLDWLQJ 1RUPDO DQG
$EQRUPDO 3HUVRQDOLW\ 1HZ <RUN 6SULQJHU &RQVLGHU F
SVLKRORJLD SHUVRQDOLW LL DU WUHEXL V SURILWH GH XQ FDGUX JHQHUDO XQGH
H[SOLFD LLOHSRWILF XWDWHODQLYHOHGLIHULWHXQDVWIHOGHFDGUXJHQHUDOHVWH
PRGHOXORIHULWvQOXFUDUH
0HHKO 5HDFWLRQV 5HIOHFWLRQV 3URMHFWLRQV vQ %XWFKHU - 1 HG
2EMHFWLYH 3HUVRQDOLW\ $VVHVVPHQW &KDQJLQJ 3HUVSHFWLYHV $FDGHPLF
3UHVV1HZ<RUN
0HJDUJHH ( , 7KH &DOLIRUQLD 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\ +DQGERRN
-RVVH\%DVV 6DQ )UDQFLVFR :DVKLQJWRQ /RQGRQ FDSLWROXO 6WUDWHJLD
FRQVWUXLULL LWHPLORU FDSLWROXO 0HWRGH JHQHUDOH GH FRQVWUXLUH D
LQYHQWDUHORUS
0HLOL50DQXHOGXGLDJQRVWLTXHSV\FKRORJLTXH38)3DULV
0LOMNRYLWFK-)DFWRULDO$QDO\VLVDQGWKH'LVWDQFHV&RPSXWDWLRQVLQ
5HSHUWRU\ *ULG 7HVW RI * $ .HOO\ ,QWURGXFWLRQ WR D 'LJLWDO
3URJUDPPHÄ5HYLHZRI$SSOLHG3V\FKRORJ\´
1RUPDQ : 7 7RZDUGV DQ $GHTXDWH 7D[RQRP\ RI 3HUVRQDOLW\
$WWULEXWHV5HSOLFDWHGIDFWRUVWUXFWXUHVLQSHHUQRPLQDWLRQSHUVRQDOLW\
UDWLQJVÄ-RXUQDORI$EQRUPDODQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
2VWHQGRUI ) 6SUDFKH XQG 3HUV|QOLFKNHLWVVWUXNWXU =XU 9DOLGLWlW GHV
)QI)DNWRUHQ0RGHOOVGHU3HUV|QOLFKNHLW5RGHUHU9HUODJ5HJHQVEXUJ
3HDERG\ ' 3 *ROGEHUJ / 5 6RPH 'HWHUPLQDQWV RI )DFWRU
6WUXFWXUH IURP 3HUVRQDOLW\ 7UDLW 'HVFULSWRUV vQ Ä-RXUQDO RI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
3HDERG\'36HOHFWLQJ5HSUHVHQWDWLYH7UDLW$GMHFWLYHVÄ-RXUQDORI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´5HDOL]HD] RGHVFULHUH
GHWDOLDW D FODVLILF ULL HúDQWLRQXOXL GH GHVFULSWRUL úL R VHOHF LH D WHU
PHQLORUFDUHUHSUH]LQW DFHDVW FODVLILFDUHSHED]DORUFRQFKLGHGXS
R DQDOL] GH GHWDOLX F VFDOHOH OXL &DWWHOO QX VXQW UHSUH]HQWDWLYH
'HRDUHFH DFHVWH GH VFDOH DX VWDW OD ED]D FHUFHW ULORU OXL 7XSHV úL
&KULVWDOSUHFXPúLDOHOXL1RUPDQQLFLIRUPXO ULOHWLPSXULLDOHFHORU
FLQFL VXSHUIDFWRUL QX OH FRQVLGHU UHSUH]HQWDWLYH ,GHQWLILF SUREOHPH
PDLDOHVSHQWUXGRLGLQFHLFLQFLIDFWRULVWDELOLWDWHDHPR LRQDO úLFXOWXUD
3HUXJLQL 0 $ &LUFXPSOH[ +LHUDUFKLFDO $SSURDFK WR ,QGLYLGXDWH D
7D[RQRP\RI3HUVRQDOLW\&KDUDFWHULVWLFVWH] GHGRFWRUDW8QLYHUVLWDWHD
GLQ5RPD
3HUYLQ/$$&ULWLFDO$QDO\VLVRI&XUUHQW7UDLW7KHRU\3V\FKRORJLFDO
,QTXLU\ GH DVHPHQHD vQ 7KH 7KUHH 'LVFLSOLQHV RI
3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG WKH 3UREOHP RI 9ROLWLRQ 9,,WK &RQIHUHQFH RI ($33
0DGULG XQGH VXEOLQLD] UROXO IXQGDPHQWDO DO SUREOHPDWLFLL YRLQ HL vQ
PRGXO FXP vQ HOHJHP SURFHVHOH SHUVRQDOLW LL SH FHOH PRWLYD LRQDOH vQ
SDUWLFXODU
5LERW7$7KH3V\FKRORJ\RI(PRWLRQV/RQGRQ
5RJHUV7%7KH3URFHVVRI5HVSRQGLQJWR3HUVRQDOLW\,WHPV6RPH
,VVXHVD7KHRU\DQGVRPH5HVHDUFK0XOWLYDULDWH%HKDYLRUDO5HVHDUFK
0RQRJUDSK
5XVW - +DQGERRN RI WKH 5XVW ,QYHQWRU\ RI 6FKL]RW\SDO &RJQLWLRQV
7KH3V\FKRORJLFDO&RUSRUDWLRQ/RQGRQ
6LOYD ) 6WUXFWXUH DQG &DXVDOLW\ LQ 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG %HKDYLRU
:HVWPH\HU + 7KH &DXVDO 6WDWXV RI 6WUXFWXUDO &RQFHSWV LQ
3HUVRQDOLW\ 3V\FKRORJ\ DPEHOH FRPXQLFDWH OD D 9,,D FRQIHULQ D
($330DGULG
1RZDFN : 3HUVSHFWLYHV RQ WKH 6HOI ,V WKH ,GHDO 6HOI 6RFLDOO\
'HVLUDEOH"
+RIVWHH : . % +HQGULNV $ $ - 6KRXOG :H 7U\ WR &RQWURO IRU
6RFLDOO\'HVLUDEOH5HVSRQGLQJ"
3DXOKXV ' / 0HDQLQJ WKH 'LPHQVLRQDOLW\ RI 6RFLDOO\ 'HVLUDEOH
5HVSRQGLQJ$3DUDGR[
%RUNHQDX 3 2VWHQGRUI ) $UH 6RFLDO 'HVLUDELOLW\ 6FDOHV 8VHIXO WR
,GHQWLI\6XEMHFWVZKR5HVSRQGLQD6RFLDOO\'HVLUDEOH:D\"
)HUQDQGH]%DOOHVWHURV ' $UH 6RFLDO 'HVLUDELOLW\ DQG )DNLQJ
'LIIHUHQW'LPHQVLRQV±D,,DFRQIHULQ D($3$7ULHU
=XFNHUPDQ 0 *RRG DQG %DG +XPRUV %LRFKHPLFDO %DVHV RI
3HUVRQDOLW\ 'LVRUGHUV D 9,,D FRQIHULQ D ($33 :HVWPH\HU $
7KH &RQVWUXFWLRQLVW $SSURDFK WR 3V\FKRORJLFDO $VVHVVPHQW
3UREOHPVDQG3URVSHFWV
%HUFNHQ9DQGHU-+/9DQ$DUOH(-05HFXUVLYH'LDJQRVLV
$0RGHOIRU'LDJQRVWLF5HDVRQLQJ±FRQWULEX LHODD,,,DFRQIHULQ D
($3$7ULHU
6WHSKHQVRQ : 7KH 6LJQLILFDQFH RI 47HFKQLTXH IRU WKH 6WXG\ RI
3HUVRQDOLW\vQ5H\PHUW0/HG)HHOLQJVDQG(PRWLRQV0F*UDZ
+LOO1HZ<RUNS
6WHSKHQVRQ : 7KH 6LJQLILFDQFH RI 47HFKQLTXH IRU WKH 6WXG\ RI
3HUVRQDOLW\vQ5H\PHUW0/HG)HHOLQJVDQG(PRWLRQV0F*UDZ
+LOO1HZ<RUNS
:LJJLQV-6$3V\FKRORJLFDO7D[RQRP\RIWUDLW'HVFULSWLYH7HUPV
WKH ,QWHUSHUVRQDO 'RPDLQ Ä-RXUQDO RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG 6RFLDO
3V\FKRORJ\´
:LJJLQV - 6 OXFUDUHD RULJLQDO SUH]HQWDW vQ ,Q 'HIHQVH RI
7UDLWVvQ+RJDQ5-RKQVRQ-$%ULJJV63HGV+DQGERRNRI
3HUVRQDOLW\3V\FKRORJ\6DQ'LHJR&$$FDG3UHVV
:LWNLQ + $ *RRGHQRXJK ' 5 )LHOG 'HSHQGHQF\ DQG
,QWHUSHUVRQDO %HKDYLRU Ä3V\FKRORJLFDO %XOOHWLQ´
&RJQLWLYH6W\OHV(VVHQFHDQG2ULJLQV,QWHUQDWLRQDO8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
1HZ<RUN
:LWNLQ + $ /HZLV + % +HUW]PDQ 0 0HLVVQHU 3 % :DSQHU 6
3HUVRQDOLW\ WKURXJK 3HUFHSWLRQ $Q ([SHULPHQW DQG &OLQLFDO
6WXG\+DUSHU1HZ<RUN
&DSLWROXO,,
&+(67,21$58/'(3(5621$/,7$7(&$/,)251,$
3UH]HQWDUHD&KHVWLRQDUXOXLGH3HUVRQDOLWDWH&DOLIRUQLDFXSULQGH
DVSHFWHJHQHUDOHSULYLQGWU V WXULOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHWHRULDOXL+*RXJK
SULYLQG GLPHQVLXQLOH LQWHUUHOD LRQDUH DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL FRQFHS LD OXL
*RXJK SULYLQG HYDOXDUHD SHUVRQDOLW LL úL FRQVWUXLUHD XQXL FKHVWLRQDU
GHGLFDWQRUPDOLW LLYDULDQWDGLQD,QYHQWDUXOXLGH3HUVRQDOLWDWH
&DOLIRUQLD FHOH GLPHQVLXQL VWDQGDUG DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL QRUPDOH úL
SUH]HQWDUHD VFDOHORU LQWHUSUHWDUHD VFDOHORU XWLOL]DUHD GDWHORU &3,
vQFRQVLOLHUHHGXFD LRQDO úLYRFD LRQDO VFDOHOHDEUHYLDWHDOH003,
RE LQXWHGLQU VSXQVXULOHODFKHVWLRQDUXO&3,GDWHGHVSUHFHUFHWDUH
GHVSUHYDULDQWDD&3,úLPRGHOXOFXERLGH[HPSOLILFDUHDLQWHU
SUHW ULL XQXL SURILO 'H DVHPHQHD VXQW SUH]HQWDWH FRQFHSWHOH VHPQL
ILFDWLYHXQWHVWFXvQWUHE ULGHHYDOXDUHúLUHIHULQ HOHELEOLRJUDILFH
7U V WXULGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
ÌQ YLD D FRWLGLDQ FkQG HYDOX P WU V WXULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH VDX
SURILOXOÄFDUDFWHULDO´DOXQHLSHUVRDQHQHED] PSHVHWXULGHGDWHRE L
QXWHGLQREVHUYD LHSHFDUHOHXWLOL] PFDÄGRYH]L´VDXDUJXPHQWHÌQ
SVLKRGLDJQR] DFHODúL SURFHV GH HYDOXDUH HVWH PXOW PDL VLVWHPDWLF
LQFOX]kQGRSHUD LXQLGLVWLQFWHúLLQWHJUkQGLQIRUPD LDRE LQXW SULQ
x REVHUYDUHD XQRU PRGHOH GH FRPSRUWDPHQW úL GH WU LUH FHO PDL
DGHVHD SULQ DXWRGHVFULHUL DOH SHUVRDQHL DVSHFWH vQF UFDWH GH VX
ELHFWLYLWDWHGDUúLSULQRE LQHUHDXQRUSURGXF LLúLH[SUHVLLVDXD
XQRUSHUIRUPDQ HDOHSHUVRDQHLDVSHFWHvQF UFDWHGHRELHFWLYLWDWH
SULQ JUDGXO PDL UHGXV GH LQWHUYHQ LH D HXOXL FRQúWLHQW vQ FRQV
WUXLUHDU VSXQVXOXL
x HYDOXDUHDFRPSRUWDPHQWHORUúLDWU V WXULORUVXELDFHQWHGHSHUVR
QDOLWDWH FDUH DU SXWHD GHWHUPLQDDFHVWHUHJXODULW LREVHUYDWHVDX
WLSXULVDXPRGHOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
9DOLGLWDWHD XQRU DVWIHO GH HYDOX UL HVWH VXEVWDQ LDO PDL ULGLFDW
GHFkWDFHORURE LQXWHvQYDULDQWDREVHUYD LHLFRWLGLHQHvQF UFDWHGHSUR
SULDVXELHFWLYLWDWHúLGHSUHMXGHF LOHHYDOXDWRUXOXLúLHVWHFXDQWLILFDW
SULQPLMORDFHúWLLQ LILFHFRQWURODELOHSHQWUXILHFDUHLQVWUXPHQWGHLQYHV
WLJD LHXWLOL]DW'HVLJXUúLHYDOX ULOHSVLKRGLDJQRVWLFHVXSRUW LQIOXHQ D
XQRU DVSHFWH FDUH OH GDX FDUDFWHU UHODWLY OD FDUH DP I FXW UHIHULUH vQ
FDSLWROXOSULPSUHFXPLQIOXHQ DGLVSR]L LLORUWUHF WRDUHDVHWXULORUGH
U VSXQV DOH VXELHFWXOXL HWF &HUFHWDUHD úWLLQ LILF IDFH HIRUWXUL FRQWLQXL
GHDHOLPLQDVDXPLQLPDOL]DDVWIHOGHLQIOXHQ H
0RGHOXOHYDOX ULLWU V WXULORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHúLUHDOL]DUHDSHED]D
ORUDSUHGLF LLORUDVXSUDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLSXQHSUREOHPDH[SOLF ULLvQ
FDGUXO GLQDPLF DO GH]YROW ULL SHUVRQDOLW LL D IHOXOXL FXP GLVSR]L LLOH
ED]DOH LQWHUDF LRQHD] FX XQ PHGLX vQ VFKLPEDUH SHQWUX D SURGXFH
H[SUHVLLOHIHQRWLSLFHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLYDORULSURLHFWHSHUVRQDOHUHOD LL
SHUVRQDOHLPDJLQHDGHVLQHHWF
'LQ DFHDVW SHUVSHFWLY YDORDUHD H[SOLFDWLY D WU V WXULORU GH
SHUVRQDOLWDWH XWLOL]DWH FD H[SOLFD LL FDX]DOH SHQWUX XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW
REVHUYDWHVWHUHDO GRDUDWXQFLFkQGDGXFHXQSOXVGHVHQVúLSHUPLWH
HYDOX ULFDUHGHS úHVFGDWHOHREVHUYDELOH'HH[HPSOXHVWHLQVXILFLHQW
vQ SVLKRORJLH V H[SOLF P F WU V WXUD GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH ÄH[WUDYHUVLH
JUHJDU ´ D GHWHUPLQDW XQ PRGHO GH FRPSRUWDPHQW GHVFKLV vQ FDUH
GRPLQ QHYRLDSHUVRDQHLGHDILvQSUH]HQ DDOWRUD
ÌQ DFHDVW SHUVSHFWLY GDWHOH FRQWHPSRUDQH GLQ FHUFHWDUHD
SVLKRGLDJQRVWLF VSULMLQ SRVLELOLWDWHD GH D YRUEL GHVSUH YDORDUHD
H[SOLFDWLY D WU V WXULORU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH GRDU vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH VH
FHUWLILF VWDELOLWDWHDDFHVWRUDvQWLPS±FHHDFHG SRVLELOLWDWHDUHDO GH
DIDFHSUHGLF LLSHWHUPHQOXQJ
'HDVHPHQHDVXQWDUJXPHQWHFDUHLQGLF RGLQDPLF GHODFHHDFH
HVWH VSHFLILF VSUH JHQHUDO úL GLQ QRX VSUH VSHFLILF SULQ IDSWXO F
WU V WXULOHGLVWLQFWHFRYDULD] vQPRGHOHOHVLPLODUHFDUHVHUHSHW $VWIHO
GHH[HPSOXGLQSXQFWXOGHYHGHUHDOVWDELOLW LLWU V WXULLSXWHPH[SOLFD
VWDUHDGHQHIHULFLUHDXQHLSHUVRDQHILHSULQHYHQLPHQWHUHFHQWHúLFLU
FXPVWDQ HVWUHVDQWHH[LVWHQ LDOHILHSULQH[LVWHQ DXQHLGLVSR]L LLFURQLFH
GHDWU LDQ[LRJHQHYHQLPHQWHOHYLH LLFDUHDQWUHQHD] GHSUHVLHúLDIHFWH
QHJDWLYHWU V WXUDGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHGHILQLW FDÄVWDUHGHELQH´HVWHFXDQ
WLILFDW úLSRDWHILHYDOXDW SULQ,QYHQWDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH&DOLIRUQLD
3XWHPDILUPDDVWIHOF XOWLPXOWLSGHH[SOLFD LHGHULY GLQGDWHOH
SULYLQG PRGXO FXP VXQW UHSUH]HQWDWH GLVSR]L LLOH ED]DOH UHVSHFWLY WU
V WXULOH GHQXPLWH QHYURWLVP úL H[WUDYHUVLH ÌQ DFHODúL IHO R REVHUYD LH
DVXSUDIDSWXOXLF RSHUVRDQ SUH]LQW XQPRGFRQVWDQWGHDILRUGRQDW
SXQFWXDO úL FXUDW QH SRDWH GXFH FX JkQGXO OD XQ DQXPLW QLYHO GH
IXQF LRQDUH VSHFLILF WU V WXULL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH GHQXPLW ÄFRQúWLLQFLR
]LWDWH´LDUDFHVWOXFUXSHUPLWHV FRQFOX]LRQ PF HVWHIRDUWHSUREDELO
FD SHUVRDQD vQ PRG RELúQXLW V ILH FDUDFWHUL]DW úL GH WHQGLQ D GH DúL
XUP UL UHDOL]DUHD SODQXULORU DUH XQ VWLO DWHQW GH D HYDOXD GDWHOH HWF
WRDWHILLQGFRQVHFLQ HOHJDWHGHLQIHUHQ HOHJDWHGHÄFRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWH´2
H[SOLFD LHGHYLQHFXDWkWPDLYDORURDV FXFkWQHSXWHPvQWHPHLDSHHD
LQIHUHQ HDVXSUDXQRUDVSHFWHODFDUHQXDYHPDFFHVGLUHFWSULQREVHU
YD LHVDXSHFDUHQXOHSXWHPSXQHvQHYLGHQ vQSUH]HQW
7HRULDOXL+*RXJKSULYLQGGLPHQVLXQLOHLQWHUUHOD LRQDOH
DOHSHUVRQDOLW LL
3HUVSHFWLYD GLQ FDUH FRQVWUXLHúWH +*RXJK FKHVWLRQDUXO HVWH
GXEO FRQWH[WXOGHXWLOL]DUHúLFRQFHSWHOHFDUHH[LVW GHMDvQGRPHQLXO
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLLQWHUSHUVRQDO$XWRUXOVHFHQWUHD] vQWHRULDSULYLQG
PRGXOFXPVHH[SULP SHUVRQDOLWDWHDXPDQ vQUHOD LHSHDFHLWHUPHQL
SH FDUH RDPHQLL vL XWLOL]HD] vQWUH HL SHQWUX DúL GHVFULH PRGXUL GH
FRPSRUWDPHQWFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHRELúQXLWH]LOQLFHVDXSHQWUXDQHUHIHUL
GLUHFWODGHQXPLUHDGDW GHDXWRUSHÄFRQFHSWHOHSRSXODUH´vQVHQVXO
FHOPDLGLUHFWDODFHVWHLH[SUHVLL
+DUULVRQ**RXJK
3VLKRORJ DPHULFDQ FUHDWRUXO ,QYHQWDUXOXL GH
3HUVRQDOLWDWH &DOLIRUQLD UHFXQRVFXW FD XQXO GLQWUH
FHOH PDL SRSXODUH LQYHQWDUH PRGHUQH GH HYDOXDUH
RELHFWLY DSHUVRQDOLW LLFDUHDFXQRVFXWGHDOXQJXO
GHFHQLLORURODUJ XWLOL]DUHLQWHUQD LRQDO 8QXOGLQWUH
VWXGLLOHFRPSDUDWLYHFDUHHIHFWXDRPHWDDQDOL] D
WHVWH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH GHVFRSHU vQF GLQ F
&3,HVWHFHOPDLEXQLQYHQWDUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
ÌQ+DUULVRQ*RXJKDILUP H[SOLFLWXQXOGLQWUHSULQFLSDOHOH
PRWLYH FDUH ODX GHWHUPLQDWV vQFHDS FRQVWUXLUHDXQXLQRXLQYHQWDU
GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH PRWLY FDUH VH SRDWH UH LQH FD SULQFLSLX GLUHFWRU vQ
LQWHUSUHWDUHD WHVWXOXL Ä7R PH WKH ILUVW DQG FDUGLQDO SULQFLSOH LV WKDW
WHVWVDUHPDGHWREHXVHGDQGDVXEVLGLDU\SULQFLSOHLVWKDWWKH\DUH
WR EH XVHG LQ WKH DQDO\VLV FRQFHSWXDOL]DWLRQ RI WKH LQGLYLGXDO FDVH´
Ä3HQWUX PLQH SULQFLSLXO SULP úL FDUGLQDO HVWH F WHVWHOH VXQW I FXWH
SHQWUX D IL XWLOL]DWH LDU XQ SULQFLSLX VXEVLGLDU HVWH F HOH WUHEXLH
XWLOL]DWHvQvQ HOHJHUHDDQDOL]HLGHFD]LQGLYLGXDO´0HJDUJHH
$P vQFHSXW SULQ DFHVW FLWDW vQ YLUWXWHD IDSWXOXL F HO H[SULP
VLWXD LD XQXL SHUVRQDOLVW D F UXL SUHRFXSDUH SULP QX HVWH FUHDUHD úL
H[SHULPHQWDUHD GH LQVWUXPHQWH (O D vQFHSXW úL FRQWLQX H[SHULPHQ
WDUHDLQYHQWDUXOXLúLWHRULHLSULYLQGILLQ DXPDQ GLQQHYRLDFRQVWLWXLULL
XQXL LQVWUXPHQW GH HYDOXDUH FHQWUDW SH SHUVRDQ 1X HVWH YL]DW vQ
SULPXO UkQG QRUPD QX VH XUP UHúWH vQ SULPXO UkQG J VLUHD XQHL
WLSRORJLL VDX GLPHQVLXQL JHQHUDOH D SHUVRQDOLW LL SULQ FDUH SHUVRDQD
FRQFUHW V SRDW ILLQVHUDW LQWHJUDW UDSRUWDW HWF
6H FDXW XQ LQVWUXPHQW FDUH V O DMXWH SH SVLKRGLDJQRVWLFLDQ V
vQ HOHDJ SHUVRDQDFD]XOYLX'HVLJXUFXPYRPYHGHDGLQDQLL¶úL
SkQ vQGHH[HPSOXDXIRVWUHDOL]DWHSHVWHGHVWXGLLGHYDOL
GDUH H[SHULPHQWDUH SUHGLF LH úL DSOLFDUH SH QRL SRSXOD LL VDX VLWXD LL
VWXGLLHIHFWXDWHQXQXPDLGHJUXSXOGHFHUFHWDUHDOOXL*RXJKFLúLGH
DOWHODERUDWRDUHDPHULFDQHVDXGLQDOWHS U LDOHJOREXOXLWHVWXOGHYHQLQG
XQ LQVWUXPHQW SXWHUQLF GH UHIHULQ vQ OLWHUDWXUD GH VSHFLDOLWDWH 0DL
PXOW YRP GHVFRSHUL F SH P VXU FH GDWHOH GH H[SHULPHQWDUH DX GH
YHQLWWRWPDLERJDWHDXIRVWH[SHULPHQWDWHQRLVFDOHGLQDQLL¶úLVDX
UHDOL]DWFHUFHW ULFDUHDXJUXSDWIDFWRULDOLWHPLLWHVWXOXLVDDMXQVODXQ
QRXPRGHOÄFXERLG´vQIXQF LHGHWUHLVXSHUIDFWRULvQDOWVHPQLILFDWLYLDL
WHVWXOXL I U FD WRDWH DFHVWHD V LQYDOLGH]H SULQFLSLXO FDUGLQDO DO OXL
+*RXJKúLQLFLSR]L LDVDIXQGDPHQWDO
&RQFHS LDOXL*RXJKSULYLQGHYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL
úLFRQVWUXLUHDXQXLFKHVWLRQDUGHGLFDWQRUPDOLW LL
ÌQFRQVWUXF LDVFDOHORU&3,*RXJKQXDDGRSWDWRWHRULHIRUPDO
6HSDUHF HUDLPSOLFDWvQSULPXOUkQGXQDQXPHVFHSWLFLVPSULYLWRUOD
DSOLFDELOLWDWHD vQ SUDFWLF D SR]L LLORU WHRUHWLFH PDL DOHV OLSVD ORU GH
FRQVLVWHQ DWXQFLFkQGVHSXQHDSUREOHPDHYDOX ULLFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL
LQWHUSHUVRQDO QRUPDO $FHODúL VFHSWLFLVP vO IDFH V QX VWDELOHDVF UD
LRQDOFDUHDQXPHSDUV ILHYDULDELOHOHLPSRUWDQWH
0HWRGDJHQHUDO DOXL*RXJKHUDGHDSRUQLGHODVLWXD LLOHvQFDUH
VHFHUHDXWLOL]DWWHVWXOÌQIXQF LHGHVLWXD LLYDFRQVWUXLP VXU WRULFDUH
V VHED]H]HSHDFHOHFRQVWUXFWHFDUHVXQWGHMDRSHUD LRQDOHvQUDSRUWFX
IHOXO FXP VH FRPSRUW LQGLYL]LL vQ FRQMXQFWXULOH VLWXD LRQDOH VSHFLILFH
$FHDVW FRQFHS LH D GHULY ULL GDWHORU SH FDOH HPSLULF HUD GHVLJXU
OHJDW GH WUDGL LD HPSLULVW D 8QLYHUVLW LL 0LQQHVRWD GDU úL GH H[SH
ULHQ DDQWHULRDU SHQWUXF &3,XOWUHEXLDV ILHXQLQVWUXPHQWVLPHWULF
ID GH 003, GDF ,QYHQWDUXO 0XOWLID]LF GH 3HUVRQDOLWDWH 0LQQHVRWD
IXVHVH GHVWLQDW SVLKRSDWRORJLHL WUHEXLD FRQVWUXLW XQ LQVWUXPHQW SDUDOHO
SHQWUX QRUPDOLWDWHD SVLKLF QRUPDOLWDWH FDUH vQVHDPQ ± úL DLFL
DFFHQWX P±SHUVRDQDQXvQLSRVWD]DHLVWDWLF FLvQFHDUHDO GLQDPLF
DGLF vQLQWHUUHOD LRQDUH'HDVHPHQHDGDF LQYHQWDUXOPXOWLID]LFIXVHVH
FRQVWUXLW SRUQLQG GH OD ÄYDULDELOHOH´ FOLQLFH GH OD FRQFHSWH GHULYDWH
HPSLULF GLQ H[SHULHQ D FOLQLF WUHEXLDX J VLWH F LOH SHQWUX FRQVWUXLUHD
LQYHQWDUXOXL SHQWUX ÄQRUPDOLWDWH SVLKLF ´ SRUQLQGXVH GH OD UHDOLW LOH
ILLQ HLQRUPDOHRELúQXLWHDIODWHvQLQWHUUHOD LH
'XS FXPREVHUY 0HJDUJHHDFHDVWDHVWHDERUGDUHDWLSLF SHQWUX
XQSVLKRGLDJQRVWLFLDQSUDFWLFLDQFDUHOXFUHD] FXDFHOHFRQFHSWHFDUHDX
UHOHYDQ IXQF LRQDO
3HUVSHFWLYD GXS FDUH FRQVWUXLHúWH +DUULVRQ *RXJK FKHVWLRQDUXO
HVWHGXEO GHODFRQWH[WXOGHXWLOL]DUHúLGHODDFHOHFRQFHSWHFDUHH[LVW
GHMDvQGRPHQLXOFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLLQWHUSHUVRQDO$QXPHDFHLWHUPHQL
GHVFULSWLYLSHFDUHRDPHQLLvLXWLOL]HD] vQWUHHLSHQWUXDúLGHVFULHPR
GXULOHGHDVHFRPSRUWDFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHRELúQXLWHFRWLGLHQHVDXSHQWUX
DXWLOL]DFKLDUGHQXPLUHDGDW GH*RXJKÄFRQFHSWHOHSRSXODUH´
3R]L LDHVWHLPSRUWDQW SHQWUXLVWRULDSVLKRGLDJQR]HLDúDFXPDP
DERUGDWRvQDFHVWPDQXDOUHFXUVLYSHQWUXF GXS FXPDPY ]XWR
GDW FXDQLL¶úLPDLLQWHQVvQXOWLPLLFLQFLDQLFHUFHW ULOHGHWLSFRJ
QLWLYLVWúLGHWLSIDFWRULDOGDXGUHSWDWHDFHVWXLSXQFWGHYHGHUHúLQXFHOXL
SURPRYDWGHXQDOWPDUHFUHDWRUGHWHVWHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH5%&DWWHOO
ÌQ PRGXO FXP vO GHILQHúWH *RXJK XQ ÄFRQFHSW SRSXODU´ QX HVWH
GRDUXQWHUPHQXWLOL]DWvQYRUELUHDFXUHQW FLDUHúLFDOLWDWHDGHDWUDQV
FHQGH R VRFLHWDWH SDUWLFXODU GH H[HPSOX WHUPHQXO GH ÄUHVSRQVDELO´
VDXÄLUHVSRQVDELO´VHUHJ VHúWHvQYRUELUHDFXUHQW DGLIHULWHORUVRFLHW L
ÌQDFHHDúLP VXU FDV XWLOL] PXQH[HPSOXDODXWRUXOXLWHUPHQXOGH
ÄGRPLQDQW´HUDXWLOL]DWGH3OXWDUKSHQWUXGHVFULHUHDOXL&DHVDUGDUHVWH
XWLOL]DW úL GH RPXO RELúQXLW GH DVW ]L FkQG FDUDFWHUL]HD] GH SLOG XQ
SHUVRQDMSROLWLFFXRSUH]HQ VRFLDO SUHJQDQW
6H VSULMLQ SH úL FDXW DFHOH FRQFHSWH FDUH DSDU vQ LQWHUUHOD
LRQDUHD VRFLDO vQ YLD D VRFLDO FXUHQW DWULEXWH FH VH SRW UHJ VL vQ
WRDWH FXOWXULOH úL VRFLHW LOH úL FDUH DX R UHOD LH GLUHFW úLLQWHJUDO FX
IRUPHOHGHLQWHUUHOD LRQDUHVRFLDO *RXJK
&DVXUV SULP SHQWUXLGHQWLILFDUHDORUHVWHFKLDUOLPEDMXOFRWL
GLDQvQP VXUDvQFDUHH[SHULHQ DVRFLDO DUH LQXWvQIRUPHOHDFHVWXLD
RULFHLQIRUPD LHFDUHHVWHVHPQLILFDWLY SHQWUXVXSUDYLH XLUHDVRFLDO
ÌQSURFHVXOLVWRULFDOFUHúWHULLOLPELLUHVSHFWLYHDSDUGHVLJXUFXYLQWH
QRLHFKLYDOHQWHFDUHVHUH LQúLvQDFHODúLWLPSGLVSDUDOWHFXYLQWH
3HQWUX*RXJKVFRSXOILHF UHLVFDOHHVWHV UHIOHFWHFkWGHILGHO
SRVLELOXQDVSHFWRDQXPHWHP DFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLLQWHUSHUVRQDO
ÌQ*RXJKSXEOLF SULPHOHVFDOHvQDSDUHSULPDHGL LH
GHVFDOHGLQ&3,vQDSDUHSULPDHGL LHGHVFDOHFXSULQ
]kQG GH LWHPL SOXV FDUH UHDSDU FX XQ WRWDO GH GH LWHPL
FHQWUD LPDLDOHVSHFRPSRUWDPHQWHWLSLFHVHQWLPHQWHRSLQLLDWLWXGLQL
6WXGLLOHXOWHULRDUHDXFRQGXVODRQRX UHIRUPXODUHDFKHVWLRQDUXOXLvQ
FXGHVFDOHúLXQWRWDOGHGHLWHPL
5HIHULWRUODLQWHUSUHWDUHDFKHVWLRQDUXOXL*RXJKVXEOLQLD] vQPRG
H[SUHV F QX WUHEXLH LQWHUSUHWDW GHFkW GH SURIHVLRQLúWLL FDOLILFD L vQ
XWLOL]DUHD&3,vQP VXUDvQFDUHXQDGLQWUHFULWLFLOHFHOHPDLGLILFLOH
DGXVHLGHLLÄFRQFHSWHORUSRSXODUH´FRQVW vQSUREOHPDGDF QXFXPYD
DFHVWHFXYLQWHvQXWLOL]DUHDORU]LOQLF QXDXFkúWLJDWXQEDJDMGHvQ HOHV
FRQRWDWLYúLQXFXPYDHVWHDVWIHOLPSRVLELOV OHRSHUD LRQDOL]H]LúLV OH
OLPLWH]LODRGHILQLUHúWLLQ LILF H[DFW &HLFHXWLOL]HD] FKHVWLRQDUXOSRW
V ILH VXELHFWXO SURSULLORU LGLRVLQFUDVLL SUHFRQFHS LL HURQDWH OHJDWH GH
GHILQLUHD VDX IRORVLUHD vQWUXQ DQXPH FDGUX VSHFLILF D WHUPHQLORU UHV
SHFWLYLGHH[HPSOXvQYRUELUHDDUJRWLF *RXJKUHFXQRDúWHIDSWXOF
XQHOHFRQFHSWHVDXFXYLQWHSUHFXPÄVRFLDELOLWDWH´VDXÄUHVSRQVDELOLWDWH´
ÄWROHUDQ ´ ÄVRFLDOL]DUH´ SRW DYHD FRQRWD LL GLIHULWH OD LQGLYL]L GLIHUL L
GDU vQ DFHODúL WLPS GDF DP UHGHQXPL FRQFHSWHOH SHQWUX D OH FUHúWH
SUHFL]LD±vQPDQLHUDLPSXV GH&DWWHOOGHH[HPSOX±QXDPIDFHGHFkW
V DMXQJHPODRSLHUGHUHvQUHOHYDQ FDUHDUSXWHDSHULFOLWDVFRSXOPD
MRUDOFUH ULLúLXWLOL] ULLFKHVWLRQDUXOXLúLDQXPHFUHúWHUHDFRPXQLF ULL
$UJXPHQWXOOXL*RXJKYDODELOúLGLQSXQFWXOQRVWUXGHYHGHUHHVWHF
GRUHúWHV HYDOXH]HWRFPDLFRQVWUXFWXODúDFXPHVWHGHILQLWFXOWXUDOFX
WRDWHFRQRWD LLOHVDOHVXEWLOHúLFXGHQRWD LDVDIRUPDO 0HJDUJHH
*RXJKvúLIDFHXQSXQFWGHVSULMLQGLQIDSWXOF DFHVWHFRQVWUXFWHSRSX
ODUH VXQW XQLYHUVDOH DWkW FXOWXUDO FkW úL vQ WLPS 0XOWH VWXGLL SRUQLWH
LQL LDO GLQWUXQ VFHSWLFLVP ID GH R DVWIHO GH LQWXL LH SVLKRORJLF DX
LQGLFDW vQV F ,QYHQWDUXO &DOLIRUQLD OXFUHD] OD IHO GH ELQH vQ VSD LL
FXOWXUDOHúLVRFLDOHGLIHULWHGHFHODPHULFDQ
$FHDVW OXQJ LQWURGXFHUHQXHVWHOLSVLW GHLPSRUWDQ vQP VXUD
vQFDUHFHLPDLPXO LXWLOL]DWRULGHFKHVWLRQDUHDXWHQGLQ DGHDDSOLFDúL
&3,XOXL R PHWRG WUDGL LRQDO GH LQWHUSUHWDUH FRQIRUP F UHLD VFDOD
HVWHXWLOL]DW FDRGHILQLUHRSHUD LRQDO SHQWUXRDQXPLW WU V WXU GHFL
LQWHUSUHWHD] VFRUXULOH OD VFDO SULQ GHILQLUHD FRQVWUXFWXOXL 6FRSXO OXL
*RXJK HVWH V UHXúHDVF R SUHGLF LH DVXSUD FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL QX V
MXVWLILFHRWHRULHDVXSUDSHUVRQDOLW LL'LQDFHVWSXQFWGHYHGHUHRVHULH
GHVWXGLLVDXFHQWUDWDVXSUDYDOLGLW LLGHFRQVWUXFWGHPRQVWUkQGF VFD
OHOHVXQWOHJDWHGHFHHDFHvúLSURSXQV P VRDUH
2 DOW FULWLF HVWH OHJDW GH OLSVD GH RPRJHQLWDWH D VFDOHORU vQ
VHQVXO vQ FDUH QHILLQG GHULYDWH SULQ DQDOL]D IDFWRULDO QX SUH]LQW
WRDW SXULWDWHD IDFWRULDO FDUDFWHULVWLF DOWRU WHVWH úL FRUHOHD] vQDOW
vQWUH HOH úL WRDWH FX ÄGH]LUDELOLWDWHD´ VRFLDO *RXJK VH VSULMLQ vQ
FRQWUDDUJXPHQWDUH SH XWLOL]DUHD VLVWHPDWLF vQ FRQVWUXF LD VFDOHORU D
DQDOL]HL FRQFHSWXDOH FDUH LQFOXGH DWkW YDOLGDUHD SUDFWLF FkW úL YDOL
GDUHD GH FRQVWUXFW úL OH GHS úHúWH *RXJK 3HQWUX DXWRU SDúLL
QHFHVDULvQFRQVWUXLUHDXQHLVFDOHSULQDQDOL] FRQFHSWXDO FXSULQG
x HYDOXDUHSULPDU FDUHGHWHUPLQ FDUHFULWHULXHVWHvQSULQFLSDOUHOH
YDQWFkWGHELQHSUH]LFHWHVWXOFHHDFHYUHDV SUH]LF
x HYDOXDUHDVHFXQGDU SULQGHVFRSHULUHDIXQGDPHQWHORUSVLKRORJLFH
SHQWUXP VXUDUHSULQVSHFLILFDUHDúLFODULILFDUHDvQ HOHVXOXLDFHHD
FHVHP VRDU DOWIHOVSXVHVWHYRUEDGHVSUHGHVFRSHULUHDGLPHQ
VLXQLLSVLKRORJLFHDVFDOHL
x HYDOXDUHD WHU LDU FDUH DUH VFRSXO GH D MXVWLILFD R DQXPLW P
VXUDUH VHPQLILFD LD LQWULQVHF D VFRSXOXL SULPDU DO P VXU ULL
JDPDGHLPSOLFD LLUHOHYDQWHVXUSULQGHUHDvQWUHJLLJDPHGHVLWXD LL
H[LVWHQ LDOH LPSOLFDWH GLQFROR GH FHHD FH VD DYXW vQ YHGHUH vQ
YDOLGDUHDSULPDU úLSHQWUXFDUHLQVWUXPHQWXOHVWHSUHGLFWLYúLDUH
UHOHYDQ H[SOLFDWLY
9RP SUH]HQWD SULQFLSDOHOH GDWH WHKQLFH SHQWUX ILHFDUH GLQWUH
VFDOHRGDW FXSUH]HQWDUHDGLPHQVLXQLORU
9DULDQWDGLQD,QYHQWDUXOXLGH3HUVRQDOLWDWH&DOLIRUQLD
&HOHGLPHQVLXQLDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLQRUPDOH
3UH]HQWDUHDVFDOHORUFRQ LQXWXULúLDWULEXWH
vQFRPSRUWDPHQWXOLQWHUSHUVRQDO
)RUPDGHED] D&3,FXSULQGHVFDOHúLHVWHODUJXWLOL]DW vQ
SUDFWLFDGLDJQRVWLF 3HQWUXDFHDVW IRUP FHOHVFDOHDXIRVWJUX
SDWH±úLDFHVWOXFUXVHREVHUY úLvQILúDGHSURILO±vQSDWUXJUXSHGH
VHPQLILFD LLSVLKRORJLFHDVWIHO*RXJK
3ULPD JUXS FXSULQGH DFHOH VFDOH FDUH LQGLF PDL DOHV GLPHQ
VLXQLOHSHUVRQDOLW LLFHLQWHUYLQvQDILUPDUHDSHUVRDQHLVLJXUDQ DGH
VLQHLPDJLQHDGHVLQHúLDGHFYDUHDLQWHUSHUVRQDO GRPLQDQ DFDSD
FLWDWHD GH VWDWXW VRFLDELOLWDWHD SUH]HQ D VRFLDO DFFHSWDUHD GH VLQH
VWDUHDGHFRQIRUWVDXGHELQHSVLKLF
$ GRXD JUXS FXSULQGH VFDOH FDUH LQGLF RS LXQLOH YDORULFH úL
PDWXULWDWHD LQWHUUHOD LRQDO DVWIHO UHVSRQVDELOLWDWHD VRFLDOL]DUHD
DXWRFRQWUROXOWROHUDQ DWHQGLQ DGHDIDFHREXQ LPSUHVLHúLDOLQLHUHD
ODPRGHOXOFRPXQVDXFRPXQDOLWDWHD
$WUHLDJUXS GHVFDOHP VRDU PDLDOHVQLYHOXOPRWLYD LRQDOvQ
VHQVXOSRWHQ LDOXOXLGHUHDOL]DUHSHUVRQDO úLDOIRFDOL] ULLSHYDORULOH
LQWHOHFWXDOHUHDOL]DUHSULQFRQIRUPLVPUHDOL]DUHSULQLQGHSHQGHQ úL
HILFLHQ DLQWHOHFWXDO
$ SDWUD JUXS FXSULQGH VFDOH FH VXUSULQG XQHOH PRGDOLW L LQ
WHOHFWXDOH FH PRGHOHD] XQ VWLO SHUVRQDO DVWIHO VFDOHOH GH LQWXL LH
SVLKRORJLF IOH[LELOLWDWHúLIHPLQLWDWHPDVFXOLQLWDWH
+*RXJK RIHU SHQWUX ILHFDUH GLQWUH FHOH VFDOH DO WXULGHFD
UDFWHULVWLFLOH FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL DXWRHYDOXDW úL R JUXSDUH GH DGMHFWLYH
FDUH UHSUH]LQW PRGXO FXP XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW H[WUHP HVWH SHUFHSXW
VRFLDO$VWIHOFXPYRPYHGHDvQDIDUDDVSHFWHORUFDUHDXIRUPDWFRQ L
QXWXO SURSULX]LVDOVFDOHL*RXJKIXUQL]HD] SHQWUX]RQHOHGHVHPQL
ILFD LH SHVWH VDX VXE PHGLH D QLYHOXOXL GH PDQLIHVWDUH D WU V WXULL XQ
QXP UGHDWULEXWHFDUHQXVXQWQLPLFDOWFHYDGHFkWIHOXOvQFDUHDFHVWH
SHUVRDQHVXQWGHVFULVHGHDO LLÌQLQWHUSUHWDUHDVFRUXULORUVFDOHLDFHVWH
HOHPHQWHFDS W WRFPDLJUDGXOGHUHOHYDQ FRPSOH[ VFRQWDWGHDXWRU
6FDOD,'RPLQDQ D±'R
6FDODHVWHFRQVWUXLW SHQWUXDLGHQWLILFDSHUVRDQHSXWHUQLFHGR
PLQDQWH FX DVFHQGHQW DVXSUD DOWRUD FDSDELOH V DLE LQL LDWLY úL V
H[HUFLWHFRQGXFHUHD(YDOXHD] DVSHFWHDOHSURSHQVLXQLLGHDFRQGXFH
SHUVLVWHQ D úL LQL LDWLYD VRFLDO 3HQWUX *RXJK VD SXV SUREOHPD GH D
J VL LWHPL FDUH V L LGHQWLILFH SH FHL FDUH DF LRQHD] vQWUXQ PRG FH
SRDWHILFRQVLGHUDWFDÄGRPLQDQW´vQRULFHFXOWXU úLSHGHDOW SDUWH
V LLPSUHVLRQH]HSHDO LLSULQHYLGHQ DDFHVWHLFDOLW L'HFLV SRDW IL
GHVFULúLFDGRPLQDQ LSOLQLGHIRU VLJXULGHHL
6FDODFXSULQGHvQDFHDVW YDULDQW GHLWHPLGLQWUHFDUHvL
DSDU LQH[FOXVLYLDUFHLODO LVXQWFRPXQLFXVFDOHOH5H6D6\&RQ L
QXWXO LWHPLORU VXUSULQGH vQFUHGHUHD úL HFKLOLEUXO SURSHQVLXQHD GH D
FRQGXFH úL GH DúL DVXPD UHVSRQVDELOLWDWHD SHUVXDVLYLWDWHD úL IOXHQ D
YHUEDO XQ DVSHFW GH SHUVLVWHQ WHQDFH DO WXUL GH FHHD FH DP SXWHD
QXPL ÄVLP XO GDWRULHL´ WHQGLQ D GH D SULYL OXFUXULOH vQ ID GH D VH
FRQIUXQWDFXUHDOLWDWHDFKLDUGDF HVWHQHSO FXW
6FRUXULOH SHVWH PHGLH LQGLF SHUVRDQH DFWLYH VLJXUH SH VLQH
SHUVLVWHQWHFDUHDQWLFLSHD] LQVLVW DXvQFUHGHUHúLLQGHSHQGHQ
$GMHFWLYHOH FDUH GHVFULX SHUFHS LD VRFLDO VXQW GLIHUHQ LDWH SH
VH[H 8Q E UEDW HVWH SHUFHSXW FD DPEL LRV vQGU ]QH GRPLQDQW SX
WHUQLF RSWLPLVW PHWRGLF GHVFXUF UH FRPSHWHQW GH vQFUHGHUH VLJXU
GHVLQHVWDELOVHYHU2IHPHLHHVWHSHUFHSXW FDDJUHVLY RUJROLRDV
FXvQFUHGHUHvQVLQHúLUHYHQGLFDWLY GRPLQDQW SXWHUQLF DXWRULWDU
úLHQHUJLF YRUE UHD
8QVFRUVXEPHGLHLQGLF RSHUVRDQ UHWUDV LQKLEDW FXXQFRP
SRUWDPHQW EDQDO LQGLIHUHQW W FXW QHRUJDQL]DW OHQW vQ JkQGLUH úL
DF LXQHFXWHQGLQ DGHDHYLWDVLWXD LLOHGHWHQVLXQHúLGHFL]LHQHVLJXU
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO DWDúHD] XQXL E UEDW FX QRWD 'R IRDUWH VF
]XW LPDJLQHDXQXLDSDWLFLQGLIHUHQWP UJLQLWLUHVSRQVDELOSHVLPLVW
DQ[LRV ULJLG VXJHVWLRQDELO QHVLJXU 'HVFULHUHD VRFLDO D XQHL IHPHL
FXVFRUIRDUWHVF ]XWOD'RRSUH]LQW FDSUHFDXW DPDELO LQKLEDW
vPS FLXLWRDUHFDOP úLúWHDUV VILRDV vQFUH] WRDUHGLVFUHW
6FDOD,,&DSDFLWDWHDGHVWDWXW±&V
&ULWHULXOH[WHUQÄVWDWXW´DIRVWGHILQLWúLvQWUHEXLQ DWvQYDOLGDUHD
HPSLULF DVFDOHLSULQQLYHOXOUHODWLYDOYHQLWXOXLHGXFD LHLSUHVWLJLXOXL
úLSXWHULLDWLQVHvQPHGLXOVRFLRFXOWXUDOSURSULXDOVXELHFWXOXLSUHFXP
úLFDOLW LOHGHDPEL LHúLvQFUHGHUHvQVLQH'HFLVFDODHYDOXHD] FDSD
FLWDWHDSHUVRQDO SHQWUXVWDWXWVRFLDOSUH]HQWVDXGREkQGLWvQFHUFkQG
V P VRDUH FDOLW L úL DWULEXWH SHUVRQDOH FDUH VWDX OD ED]D DFHVWHL
SURSHQVLXQLúLFRQGXFVSUHVWDWXWVRFLDO
9DULDQWDDFHDVWDFRQ LQHGHLWHPLGLQWUHFDUHVXQWSXULLDU
UHVWXOFRPXQLFXVFDOHOH6S6FúL6D
,WHPLL UHIOHFW vQ FRQ LQXWXO ORU vQFUHGHUHD vQ VLQH úL HFKLOLEUXO
VHQWLPHQWXOGHVLJXUDQ úLDEVHQ DWHPHULORUVDXDQ[LHW LORUH[LVWHQ D
XQRU LQWHUHVH OLWHUDUH VDX DUWLVWLFH JUDGXO GH ÄFRQúWLLQ VRFLDO ´
SUHFXPúLLQWHUHVXOGHDSDUWLFLSDODYLD DVRFLDO DJUXSXOXL
8QVFRUSHVWHPHGLHLQGLF XQLQVDPEL LRVDFWLYHILFLHQWSHUVSL
FDFHLQJHQLRVPXOWLODWHUDODVFHQGHQWFDULHULVWHILFLHQWvQFRPXQLFDUH
FDUHvúLXUP UHúWHVFRSXOSHUVRQDOúLDILUP XQFkPSODUJGHLQWHUHVH
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO LQGLF SHQWUX XQ VFRU IRDUWH vQDOW SHQWUX
FRPSRUWDPHQWXO PDVFXOLQ XUP WRDUHD LPDJLQH GLVFUHW LPDJLQDWLY
LQGHSHQGHQWPDWXURSRUWXQLVWVLPSDWLFDJUHDELOHORJLDWUH]RQDELO
úLSURJUHVLVW)HPHLDFXXQVFRUvQDOWOD&VHVWHSHUFHSXW SULQDGMHFWL
YHOH OXFLG YLJXURDV LQGLYLGXDOLVW LQJHQLRDV SHUVSLFDFH LQWHOL
JHQW FXLQWHUHVHODUJLORJLF úLPXOWLODWHUDO VFKLPE WRDUH
8QVFRUVXEPHGLHLQGLF XQLQGLYLGFXXQFRPSRUWDPHQWWLPLG
DSDWLFFRQYHQ LRQDOUHODWLYHVWRPSDWOHQWFXRJkQGLUHVWHUHRWLS úL
OLPLWDW vQ FRQFHS LL úL LQWHUHVH VWkQJDFL úLSHQLELOvQVLWXD LLOHVRFLDOH
FXFDUHQXHVWHIDPLOLDUL]DW
3HUFHSHUHDVRFLDO GHVFULHSHQWUXXQVFRUIRDUWHVF ]XWFRPSRU
WDPHQWXO PDVFXOLQ SULQ DGMHFWLYHOH DVSUX VXPEUX ODFRP P UJLQLW
FLF OLWRU VXS U FLRV QHOLQLúWLW WHQVLRQDW LUDVFLELO OLSVLW GH RPHQLH
'HVFULHUHD SHQWUXIHPHLFXVFRUXOIRDUWHVF ]XWDF LRQHD] QHJkQGLW
úLUHDW EOkQG PRODWHF VILRDV VLPSO VXSXV WLPLG VODE
6FDOD,,,6RFLDELOLWDWH±6\
6FDODHVWHFRQVWUXLW WRWSULQPHWRGDFULWHULXOXLH[WHUQGHYDOLGDUH
úLDQXPHLQL LDOUDSRUWDWODQXP UXOGHDFWLYLW LH[WUDFXUULFXODUHODFDUH
SDUWLFLS VWXGHQWXO 6RFLDELOLWDWHD XUPD V GLIHUHQ LH]H RDPHQLL FX XQ
WHPSHUDPHQWH[WHULRUL]DWVRFLDELOSDUWLFLSDWLYGHFHLUHWUDúLFDUHHYLW
DILúDUHD VRFLDO &X XQ WRWDO GH GH LWHPL GLQWUH FDUH GRDU QRX vL
DSDU LQvQWRWDOLWDWHVFDODGHVRFLDELOLWDWHFRSDUWLFLS SULQLWHPLLFRPXQL
OD FRPSRUWDPHQWHOH VXEVXPDWH VFDOHORU ,H 6S 6D $L 'R &V &RQ L
QXWXOPDQLIHVWDOLWHPLORUVFDOHLGHVWXOGHDSURSLDWGHRVFDO RELúQXLW
GHVRFLDELOLWDWHDúDFXPRvQWkOQLPvQDOWHSUREHDILUP SO FHUHDSHQWUX
LQWHUDF LXQL VRFLDOH VHQWLPHQWXO GH HFKLOLEUX úL vQFUHGHUH vQ VLQH vQ
UHOD LLOHFXFHLODO LLQWHUHVHFXOWXUDOHúLLQWHOHFWXDOHSUHFXPúLWROHUDQ D
ID GHFHLODO LDVRFLDW FXVWDQGDUGHVWULFWHSHQWUXVLQH
6FRUXULOHSHVWHQRWD7LQGLF vQJHQHUHXQFRPSRUWDPHQWSDU
WLFLSDWLY vQWUHSULQ] WRU LQJHQLRV 8Q LQV FDUH VH DWDúHD] XúRU HVWH
FRPSHWLWLYPHUHXvQSULPHOHUkQGXULIOXHQWvQJkQGLUHúLRULJLQDO
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO GHVFULH XQ E UEDW FX QRWD 7IRDUWHvQDOW FD
GHúWHSWvQFUH] WRUFXLQWHUHVHODUJLORJLFPDWXUGHVFKLVFRPSHWHQW
úL UD LRQDO VRFLDELO úL VLJXU GH VLQH )HPHLD HVWH GHVFULV GH RSLQLD
SXEOLF GUHSWDJUHVLY vQFUH] WRDUHGRPLQDQW HQHUJLF DPDWRDUHGH
IOLUWGHVFKLV FXLQWHUHVHODUJLYRUE UHD úLVRFLDELO
6FRUXO VXE PHGLH LQGLF UHYHUVXO XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW JUHRL úL
FRQYHQ LRQDO vQ VRFLHWDWH OLQLúWLW QHDQJDMDW VXJHVWLELO úL LQIOXHQ DELO
GHUHDF LLOHúLRSLQLLOHDOWRUD
3HUFHS LD VRFLDO GHVFULH XQ E UEDW FX QRWH IRDUWH VF ]XWH SULQ
DGMHFWLYHFDVWkQJDFLDVSUXUHFHUHFODPDJLXFRQIX]LQVWDELOFXLQ
WHUHVHOLPLWDWHDEDQGRQDQWVXSHUILFLDOOLSVLWGHIDPLOLDULWDWH
3HUFHSHUHDIHPHLLFX6\VF ]XWFXSULQGHFDDGMHFWLYHSUHFDXW
LQKLEDW EOkQG PRGHVW OLQLúWLW UH LQXW VILRDV WLPLG GLVFUHW
UHWUDV
6FDOD,93UH]HQ DVRFLDO ±6S
3UH]HQ D VRFLDO HVWH XQD GLQWUH FHOH FLQFL VFDOH FRQVWUXLWH SH
FDOH UD LRQDO úL DQXPH SULQ DQDOL]D FRQVLVWHQ HL LQWHUQH SRUQLQGXVH
GHODXQQXP UGHGHLWHPLOHJD LGHHFKLOLEUXOVRFLDOYHUYDúLVSRQ
WDQHLWDWHDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLÌQVFDO U PkQGHLWHPLGLVWLQF L
LDUUHVWXOFRPXQLFXDOWHVFDOHSUHFXP6\6D&V,HúL3\GDUúLFX
VFDOHOH6FúL*LvQV FRWD LLQYHUV
&RQ LQXWXULOHLWHPLORUVFDOHLYL]HD] SO FHUHDSHQWUXLQWHUDF LXQL
VRFLDOHRvQFUHGHUHELQHDILUPDW VSLULWGHVFKLVDWLWXGLQLDHULVLWHID
GHUHJXOLOHúLSURKLEL LLOHVRFLDOHSDUDOHOFXDFFHQWXOSXVSHvQGDWRULUH
PRGHUD LHFRQIRUPLVP
6FRUXULOHSHVWHQRWD7LQGLF XQFRPSRUWDPHQWVSRQWDQLPD
JLQDWLYQHIRUPDOLVWUDSLGFXRQDWXU H[SUHVLY úLFUHDWLY
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO FDUDFWHUL]HD] XQ E UEDW FX QRWD 7 IRDUWH
vQDOW SULQ DGMHFWLYH FD DYHQWXURV FDXW SO FHUHD UHOD[DW úL VLJXU GH
VLQHVSLULWDVFX LWQHFRQYHQ LRQDOQHLQKLEDWVFKLPE WRUVSLULWXDO
2IHPHLHGHDFHVWWLSHVWHFDUDFWHUL]DW GHFHLGLQMXUSULQDGMHF
WLYHFDDYHQWXURDV vQGU ]QHD IOLUWHD] U XW FLRDV GHVFKLV FDXW
SO FHUHDVSRQWDQ VFKLPE WRDUHLQJHQLRDV VSLULWXDO
6FRUXULOH MRDVH VXE PHGLH FDUDFWHUL]HD] XQ LQGLYLG SUHFDXW
PRGHUDW U EG WRU VLPSOX PRGHVW ÌQ DFHODúL WLPS HVWH RVFLODQW úL
QHVLJXUvQGHFL]LLFXRJkQGLUHQRQFUHDWLY
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO FDUDFWHUL]HD] XQ E UEDW FX QRWD 7 IRDUWH
VF ]XW SULQSUHFDXWFRRSHUDQWDSUHFLDWLYEOkQGDPDELOFXLQWHUHVH
OLPLWDWH SUHI FXW U EG WRU VHULRV )HPHLD HVWH SHUFHSXW vQ WHUPHQLL
XUP WRULSUHFDXW FRQYHQ LRQDO WHP WRDUHJHQWLO UH]HUYDW VHQVL
ELO VXSXV WLPLG UHWUDV
6FDOD9$FFHSWDUHDGHVLQH±6D
6FDO FRQVWUXLW GHDVHPHQHDSULQDQDOL]DFRQVLVWHQ HLLQWHUQHFX
VFRSXOLGHQWLILF ULLXQRUSHUVRDQHFDUHPDQLIHVW XQVLP FRQIRUWDELOúL
ÄLPSHUWXUEDELO´ DO YDORULL SHUVRQDOH LDU FRPSRUWDPHQWXO ORU VRFLDO YD
H[SULPDILHDFWLYILHSDVLYDFHDVW VLJXUDQ
(YDOXHD] DVSHFWH SUHFXP VLP XO YDORULL SHUVRQDOH DFFHSWDUHD
GHVLQHFDSDFLWDWHDGHDJkQGLúLDF LRQDLQGHSHQGHQW
'LQ FHL GH LWHPL DL YHUVLXQLL ILQDOH QXPDL SDWUX DSDU LQ
H[FOXVLYVFDOHL&HLODO LSUH]LQW SULQFRQ LQXWXOORUDVSHFWHGH6\úL
6SOHJDWHGHvQFUHGHUHDvQVLQHúLGHDWLWXGLQHDOLSVLW GHULJLGLWDWHID
GH SURKLEL LLOH VRFLDOH OHJD L LQYHUV GHFkW 6S GH YDORUL]DUHD PXQFLL
SHUVHYHUHQWHDWHQ LHLID GHVDUFLQDGHPXQF úLFRQVLGHUDUHDFHORU
ODO LDO LLWHPLLQGLF RDFFHSWDUHFDQGLG DVO ELFLXQLORUXPDQH
6FRUXULOHSHVWHQRWD7SUH]LQW RSHUVRDQ LQWHOLJHQW VLQFHU
úLVSLULWXDO SUHWHQ LRDV DFWLY FHQWUDW SHVLQHLQVLVWHQW FXIOXHQ
YHUEDO FXVLJXUDQ úLvQFUHGHUHvQVLQH
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO FDUDFWHULVWLF SHQWUX R QRW 7 IRDUWH PDUH
GHVFULHXQE UEDWSULQDGMHFWLYHFDvQFUH] WRUvQWUHSULQ] WRURUJROLRV
LPDJLQDWLYGHVFKLVRSRUWXQDGDSWDELOVLJXUUDILQDWvQILJ UH VRILV
WLFDW2IHPHLHFXVFRUvQDOWDSDUHGHVFULV GHFHLODO LSULQDGMHFWLYHFD
DYHQWXURDV DUJXPHQWDWLY RUJROLRDV UHYHQGLFDWLY GHFLV GRPL
QDQW GHVFKLV VDUFDVWLF YRUE UHD VSLULWXDO
6FRUXULOHVXEPHGLHLQGLF XQFRPSRUWDPHQWFRQVHUYDWRURUGRQDW
GHQ GHMGHOLQLúWLWGHúLFRPRGúLFRQYHQ LRQDOFXVHQWLPHQWHGHFXOSD
ELOLWDWHúLJDWDV VHDXWREODPH]HSDVLYvQDF LXQHúLOLPLWDWFDLQWHUHVH
3HUFHSHUHDVRFLDO GHVFULHXQE UEDWFXQRWD7IRDUWHVF ]XW FD
DVSUX EDQDO DEDQGRQDQW QHFKLE]XLW VXSXV LQGLIHUHQW WHQVLRQDW
QHLQWHOLJHQWQHJDWLYLVWJDWDV VHUHWUDJ FXLQWHUHVHOLPLWDWH)HPHLD
HVWH SHUFHSXW vQ XUP WRULL WHUPHQL SUHFDXW FRQYHQ LRQDO JHQWLO
PRODWLF PRGHVW U EG WRDUH vPS FLXLWRDUH VILRDV vQFUH] WRDUH
GLVFUHW QHSUHWHQ LRDV
6FDOD9,6WDUHSHUVRQDO GHELQH±:E
,QL LDOVDQXPLWÄVFDO GHGLVLPXODUH´:EUHSUH]LQW RGHULYD LH
D VFDOHL LQL LDOH vQ FDUH VD LQYHUVDW FKHLD GH FRWDUH VFRUXULOH ULGLFDWH
UHSUH]LQW LQGLYL]LL V Q WRúL úL VWHQLFL LDU VFRUXULOH MRDVH VXE PHGLH
LQGLYL]LL FX R YLWDOLWDWH GLPLQXDW úL LQFDSDELOL V IDF ID FHULQ HORU
YLH LL FRWLGLHQH 0DL PXOW VFDOD GLIHUHQ LD] LQGLYL]LL FDUH VLPXOHD]
QHYUR]DGHLQGLYL]LLQRUPDOLúLGHSDFLHQ LLFDUHU VSXQGVLQFHUILLQGúL
XQD GLQWUH SULQFLSDOHOH VFDOH GH YDOLGDUH DOH WHVWXOXL DVSHFW SH FDUH vO
YRPDSURIXQGDODFDSLWROXOGHVSUHLQWHUSUHWDUHDSUREHL
,WHPLLVFDOHLvQQXP UGHGLQWUHFDUHDSDU LQH[FOXVLYVFDOHL
DXvQFRQ LQXWUHIHULULODQHJDUHDXQRUYDULDWHVLPSWRPHIL]LFHúLPHQ
WDOHQHJDUHDRULF URUSUREOHPHIDPLOLDOHPDMRUHQHJDUHDFRQIOLFWHORUúL
SUHRFXS ULORUVH[XDOHQHJDUHDXQRUVW ULGHWHQVLXQHDQ[LHWDWHWHDP
DILUP UL DOH LQGHSHQGHQ HL SHUVRQDOH úL DOH VHQWLPHQWXOXL GH VXILFLHQ
GHVLQHvQVHQVXOÄRULFHRPFDUHHVWHFDSDELOV PXQFHDVF DUHRúDQV
UHDO GHDDYHDVXFFHV´DILUPDUHDvQFUHGHULLvQYLLWRU
6FDOD ILLQG FRQVWUXLW SHQWUX D LGHQWLILFD SHUVRDQHOH FDUH vúL
PLQLPDOL]HD] JULMLOHúLQHPXO XPLULOHúLFDUH LQVHDPDPDLPXOWVDX
PDLSX LQGHvQGRLHOLúLGH]LOX]LLDVWIHOF SHVWHQRWD7XQVFRUvQDOW
UHSUH]LQW R SHUVRDQ HQHUJLF vQWUHSULQ] WRDUH DOHUW DPEL LRDV úL
PXOWLODWHUDO SURGXFWLY DFWLY DFRUG YDORDUHPXQFLLúLGHSXQHHIRUW
SHQWUXSO FHUHDSURSULH
3HUFHSHUHDVRFLDO GHVFULHXQE UEDWFXVFRUvQDOWSULQDGMHFWLYH
FDGHPQGHvQFUHGHUHFRQVHUYDWRUGHSHQGHQWELQHYRLWRUV ULWRUEXQ
ODVXIOHWLQKLEDWORJLFPXO XPLWHFKLOLEUDWHORJLDWO XGDWGHVWLQV
UHOD[DW VLQFHU )HPHLD FX VFRU vQDOW HVWH SHUFHSXW vQ XUP WRULL
WHUPHQLFDOP FDSDELO OXFLG FLQVWLW QXVHIRUPDOL]HD] PDWXU
DPDELO vQGDWRULWRDUHHFKLOLEUDW UD LRQDO vQ HOHDSW FKLE]XLW
8QVFRUFXQRWD7VXELQGLF XQFRPSRUWDPHQWI U DPEL LH
FRPRGVWkQJDFLSUHFDXWDSDWLFúLFRQYHQ LRQDO'HIHQVLYFDXW VFX]H
/LPLWDWvQJkQGLUHúLDF LXQH
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO GHVFULH XQ E UEDW FX QRWH IRDUWH VF ]XWH FD
DQ[LRV O XG URV GLVWUDW DLXULW XLWXF JU ELW LPSXOVLY U XW FLRV
DEDQGRQDQW VXSHUILFLDO DJLWDW QHDVWkPS UDW )HPHLD HVWH SHUFHSXW
DVWIHO VWkQJDFH LQFRPRG GHIHQVLY FXVXUJLH SUDFWLF QHLQIOXHQ
DELO vQG U WQLF VDUFDVWLF VHFRPS WLPHúWHOLSVLW GHWDFWQHFRQ
YHQ LRQDO LQVWDELO
6FDOD9,,5HVSRQVDELOLWDWHD±5H
6FDODLGHQWLILF SHUVRDQHOHFRQúWLHQWHUHVSRQVDELOHFDUHvúLLDX
REOLJD LLOHvQVHULRVúLvQFDUHSXWHPDYHDvQFUHGHUH$VWIHOGHVWUXFWXUL
GHSHUVRQDOLWDWHVXQWLQGLYL]LOHJD LGHUHJXOLúLRUGLQHúLFRQVLGHU F
YLD DDUWUHEXLV ILHJXYHUQDW GHUD LXQH6FDODGLIHU GH6RVRFLDEL
OLWDWH úL 6F DXWRFRQWURO SULQ DFFHQWXO SH JUDGXO vQ FDUH YDORULOH úL
FRQWUROXOVXQWvQ HOHVHúLFRQFHSWXDOL]DWH
$UH XQ WRWDO GH GH LWHPL GLQWUH FDUH VXQW H[FOXVLYL LDU
UHVWXO VXQW FRPXQL FX VFDOH SUHFXP 'R 6\ 6F 7R $F $L úL ,H
&RQ LQXWXULOH PDQLIHVWH DOH DFHVWRU LWHPL YL]HD] SUHRFXSDUHD SHQWUX
REOLJD LLOHVRFLDOHFLYLFHúLPRUDOHDFFHQWXOSHGDWRULHúLGLVFLSOLQ GH
VLQH GH]DSUREDUHD SHQWUX RULFH SULYLOHJLL VDX IDYRULWLVPH DILUPDUHD
HFKLOLEUXOXLúLvQFUHGHULLvQVLQHúLvQFHLODO L
3HUFHSHUHDVRFLDO SHQWUXXQE UEDWFXVFRUvQDOWODVFDOD5HHVWH
UHGDW DVWIHOFDSDELOFRQúWLLQFLRVFXPS WDWILGHOUHVSRQVDELOVHULRV
VWDELO FRQVWDQW WHPHLQLF 2 IHPHLH FX VFRU vQDOW DSDUH GHVFULV GH
FHLODO L SULQ FRQúWLLQFLRDV GLVFUHW LQWXLWLY PHWRGLF ILGHO FX
WDFWUHVSRQVDELO FXPS WDW
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO SHQWUX XQ E UEDW FX VFRU IRDUWH VF ]XW HVWH
GHVFULV FDQHS V WRUWXUEXOHQWLUHVSRQVDELOFRPRGLQGLIHUHQWIDFH
SH JUR]DYXO ULVLSLWRU )HPHLD HVWH SHUFHSXW vQ XUP WRULL WHUPHQL
DURJDQW QHJOLMHQW QHVHQWLPHQWDO FRPRG QHFXYLLQFLRDV UHEHO
RERVLWRDUHVDUFDVWLF
6FDOD9,,,6RFLDOL]DUHD±6R
6FDOD HVWH FRQFHSXW SHQWUX D UHIOHFWD JUDGXO GH PDWXULWDWH VR
FLDO LQWHJULWDWHúLFRUHFWLWXGLQHDWLQVGHLQGLYLGILLQGFRQVWUXLW SULQ
PHWRGDFULWHULXOXLH[WHUQ
,WHPLL vQ QXP U GH GLQWUH FDUH VXQW H[FOXVLYL DX FD úL
FRQ LQXWXUL PDQLIHVWH DVSHFWH FDUH LOXVWUHD] WHRULLOH SVLKRORJLFH
SULYLQG GHOLQFYHQ D $VWIHO SRUQLQG GH SLOG GH OD UHOD LD HPSLULF
HYLGHQ LDW GLQWUH GHOLQFYHQ úL R OLSV GH FRH]LXQH vQ IDPLOLH VXQW
LWHPLFDUHVHUHIHU ODVHQWLPHQWXOGHF OGXU VDWLVIDF LHúLVWDELOLWDWH
IDPLOLDO FD RSXV DOLHQ ULL úL UHVHQWLPHQWXOXL $O L LWHPL VH UHIHU OD
VHQVLELOLWDWHVRFLDO úLHPSDWLHFDRSXVHLJQRU ULLVDXGHVFRQVLGHU ULL
YDORULL SHUVRQDOH GH H[HPSOX ÄDGHVHD P JkQGHVF FXP DU W úL FH
LPSUHVLH IDF DOWRUD´ RSWLPLVP úL vQFUHGHUH vQ VLQH vQ FRQWUDVW FX
VHQWLPHQWH GH DOLHQDUH LQIHULRULWDWH GLVSHUDUH DGDSWDUHD IDPLOLDO úL
úFRODU RSXVHYDJDERQGDMXOXLúLRSR]DQ HL
6FDODLQGLF QLYHOXOGHPDWXULWDWHLQWHJULWDWHDPRUDO FDSDFLWDWHD
GHDMXGHFDúLGHDUHVSHFWDQRUPHOHPRUDOH
% UEDWXO FX VFRU IRDUWH vQDOW OD VFDOD 6R HVWH SHUFHSXW FD
DGDSWDELOHILFLHQWRQHVWFRUHFWRUJDQL]DWFXPS WDWVLQFHUWHPHLQLF
V Q WRV UHVSHFWXRV 2 IHPHLH FX VFRU vQDOW HVWH GHVFULV SULQ DGMHF
WLYHOH SUHFDXW OXFLG RUJDQL]DW PHWRGLF UH]RQDELO DXWRFRQWUR
ODW PRGHVW FRQVHUYDWRDUHvQ HOHDSW
8Q E UEDW FX VFRU IRDUWH VF ]XW HVWH SHUFHSXW FD vQF S kQDW
LUHVSRQVDELO FHUW UH LJQRUDQW VDUFDVWLF QHFRQYHQ LRQDO GHIHQVLY
YLFOHDQ)HPHLDHVWHSHUFHSXW vQXUP WRULLWHUPHQLGHIHQVLY QHVWD
WRUQLF QHJOLMHQW QHFKLE]XLW LPSXOVLY LQGLIHUHQW QHLQKLEDW
PDWHULDOLVW QHFRQWURODW
6FDOD,;$XWRFRQWUROXO±6F
6FDODHVWHFRQVWUXLW SULQPHWRGDDQDOL]HLFRQVLVWHQ HLLQWHUQHúL
DUH VFRSXO GH D P VXUD JUDGXO GH OLEHUWDWH DO LQGLYLGXOXL ID GH
LPSXOVLYLWDWHD úL FHQWUDUHD SH VLQH 'HRVHELUHD GH VFDOD 5H FRQVW vQ
IDSWXOF DFHDVWDP VRDU JUDGXOvQFDUHHVWHvQ HOHVFRQWUROXOLDUDOWH
VFDOHSUHFXP6RJUDGXOvQFDUHSHUVRDQDDSURE úLSUH]LQW DVWIHOGH
GLVSR]L LL VSUH DXWRFRQWURO 8Q DOW VSHFLILF DO VFDOHL HVWH IDSWXO F
VFRUXULOHIRDUWHvQDOWHH[SULP vQIDSWVLWXD LDGHFRQWUROSUHDVWUkQVDO
LPSXOVXULORU úL DJUHVLYLW LL FHHD FH SDUDGR[DO SRDWH FRQGXFH OD
DFXPXO UL LQWHULRDUH úL GHVF UF UL EUXúWH VDX QHFRQWURODWH SURYRFDWH
FKLDUGHLQFLW ULPLQRUH
6FDOD FRQ LQH GH LWHPL GLQWUH FDUH GRDU GRL vL DSDU LQ vQ
vQWUHJLPH&RPSRUWDPHQWXOSUH]HQWvQFRQ LQXWXULOHPDQLIHVWHLQGLF R
UHVWUkQJHUH D PDQLIHVW ULORU LUD LRQDOH úL vQ VSHFLDO D DJUHVLYLW LL
UD LXQHD úL ORJLFD VXQW FRQVLGHUDWH GUHSW FHOH PDL DGHFYDWH VROX LL vQ
VLWXD LL SUREOHPDWLFH HYLWDUHD FRQGXLWHORU DQWLVRFLDOH VDX DJUHVLYH
H[LVWHQ D XQRU LQKLEL LL VRFLDOH úL FKLDU D XQXL JUDG GH PRGHVWLH FDUH
LPSOLF RWHQGLQ VSUHDXWRDQXODUHGHJHQXOÄGHRELFHLP VLP HDP
IRDUWHELQHFkQGXQDGLQWUHFRPSXQHULOHPHOHHUDFLWLW vQID DFODVHL´
SHQWUXFKHLD)DOV
6FDOD LQGLF JUDGXO úL DGHFYDUHD DXWRUHJO ULL úL DXWRFRQWUROXOXL
GRPLQDUHDLPSXOVLYLW LLúLFDSDFLWDWHDGHDXWRGLVFLSOLQDUH
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO GHVFULH XQ E UEDW FX VFRU IRDUWH vQDOW OD
DFHDVW VFDO SULQ DGMHFWLYH FD DPDELO ORJLF VkUJXLQFLRV SUHFLV
FXPS WDW ILGHO DXWRFRQWURODW FULWLF GHPQ GH vQFUHGHUH )HPHLD HVWH
SHUFHSXW DVWIHO FDOP PRGHVW FRQVHUYDWRDUH JHQWLO PRGHUDW
U EG WRDUHOLQLúWLW UH]HUYDW DXWRFRQWURODW
8QE UEDWFXVFRUIRDUWHVF ]XWHVWHSHUFHSXWFDvQFUH]XWFXVXU
JLXQHVRFRWLWvQF S kQDWLPSXOVLYvQILJ UH LULWDWFROHULFQHUHDOLVW
LQGLYLGXDOLVW )HPHLD HVWH GHVFULV FD DJUHVLY DURJDQW HPRWLY
LPSXOVLY UHEHO RERVLWRDUHVDUFDVWLF FROHULF QHLQKLEDW
6FDOD;7ROHUDQ D±7R
6FDODLGHQWLILF DWLWXGLQLVRFLDOHSHUPLVLYHOLSVLWHGHSUHMXGHF L
GHVFKLVHFDUHDFFHSW SHFHLODO LDúDFXPVXQW&RQ LQXWXULOHPDQLIHVWH
DOHFHORUGHLWHPLDLVFDOHLGLQFDUHQRX VXQWSURSULLUHIOHFW GHV
FKLGHUHD úL IOH[LELOLWDWHD RSXVH ULJLGLW LL úL GRJPDWLVPXOXL LQWHUHVXO
SHQWUXHVWHWLFúLVFRSXULLQWHOHFWXDOHvQFUHGHUHDFDRSXV VXVSLFLXQLLúL
FULWLFLVPXOXL QHJDUHD UHVHQWLPHQWHORU D WHQGLQ HORU PL]DQWURSLFH úL
RVWLOLW LLID GHFHLODO LQHJDUHDDQ[LHW LLL]RO ULLDOLHQ ULLDILUPDUHD
HFKLOLEUXOXLúLVLJXUDQ HLGHVLQH
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO LQGLF SHQWUX E UED LL FX VFRU IRDUWH vQDOW
XUP WRDUHDLPDJLQHLHUW WRUJHQHURVELQHYRLWRULQGHSHQGHQWQHIRU
PDOPXO XPLWFXPS WDWWDQGUXFXWDFWDOWUXLVW)HPHLDFXVFRUvQDOW
HVWH GHVFULV DVWIHO FDOP HILFLHQW LQWXLWLY OHQW ORJLF PDWXU
UHVSRQVDELO DXWRFRQWURODW FXWDFWvQFUH] WRDUH
8Q E UEDW FX VFRU IRDUWH VF ]XW HVWH SHUFHSXW FD DIHFWDW UHFH
RUJROLRVVkFkLWRULQVHQVLELOVXSHUILFLDOPXO XPLWSOkQJ UH FXVXUJLX
HJRFHQWULF)HPHLDHVWHGHVFULV FDDURJDQW DXWRFUDW DVSU GHIHQVLY
E QXLWRDUHQHVHQWLPHQWDO LQIDQWLO VXS U FLRDV RERVLWRDUHVDUFDVWLF
6FDOD;,,PSUHVLHEXQ ±*L
6FDOD DUH XQ GXEOX VFRS DVHPHQL VFDOHL :E LGHQWLILFDUHD GLVL
PXO ULORUGDUúLDSHUVRDQHORUFDSDELOHV FUHH]HLPSUHVLHIDYRUDELO
úL SH FDUH OH LQWHUHVHD] IHOXO FXP UHDF LRQHD] FHLODO L ID GH HOH
&RQVWUXLW SULQ PHWRGD FULWHULXOXL H[WHUQ VFDOD FRQ LQH GH LWHPL
GLQWUHFDUHVXQWH[FOXVLYL
&RQ LQXWXULOH PDQLIHVWH DFFHQWXHD] SDUWHD SR]LWLY úL HOLPLQ
QHJDWLYXO DVWIHO F PDMRULWDWHD VH UHIHU OD DSUHFLHUL DVXSUD EXQHL
IXQF LRQ UL úL YLUWX LORU QHJDUHD FRQGXLWHL DQWLVRFLDOH D SOkQJHULORU úL
HúHFXULORUSHUVRQDOH'HDVHPHQHDDSDUHQHJDUHDRULF UHLWHQGLQ HVSUH
DJUHVLYLWDWH DILUPDUHD vQFUHGHULL úL VLJXUDQ HL GH VLQH FX DVSHFWH GH
PRGHVWLHDILUPDUHDVWDELOLW LLúLDFDSDFLW LLGHDIDFHID DGYHUVLW LL
D[DUHDSHDVSHFWHOHDSUREDWHVRFLDODILUPDUHDFDSDFLW LLGHDvQWUH LQH
UHOD LLSR]LWLYHFXDO LLúLDRSLQLLORUIDYRUDELOHGHVSUHVHPHQL
6FDOD LGHQWLILF GHFL SHUVRDQHOH FDUH GRUHVF V IDF LPSUHVLH
EXQ SUHRFXSDWHGHFHHDFHJkQGHVFDO LLGHVSUHHOHúLFDUHIDFFHHDFH
VHDúWHDSW DO LL
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO GHVFULH XQ E UEDW FX VFRU IRDUWH vQDOW OD *L
DVWIHO DGDSWDELO DPDELO PDOHDELO ELQHYRLWRU UH]RQDELO WDQGUX FX
WDFWDOWUXLVWFDOGSULHWHQRV)HPHLDHVWHGHVFULV FDPRGHUDW FDOP
FRQVHUYDWRDUHPRGHVW U EG WRDUHvPS FLXLWRDUHvQFUH] WRDUHQHOL
QLúWLW vQ HOHJ WRDUH
% UEDWXO FX VFRU IRDUWH VF ]XW HVWH SHUFHSXW GH FHLODO L FD
UHFODPDJLX QHPXO XPLW FXVXUJLX QHVRFRWLW vQF S kQDW LQGLIHUHQW
VkFkLWRU SHVLPLVW FROHULF )HPHLD FX VFRU VF ]XW HVWH GHVFULV FD
VFKLPE WRDUH FLQLF IUDQF GLUHFW VXS U FLRDV SHVLPLVW VDU
FDVWLF vQF S kQDW FROHULF SHUVSLFDFH
6FDOD;,,&RPXQDOLWDWHD±&P
6FDO PHQLW V GHWHFWH]HSURWRFRDOHOHvQFDUHVDU VSXQVvQWUR
PDQLHU vQWkPSO WRDUHLDUFRQ LQXWXULOHPDQLIHVWHDOHLWHPLORUV LvQ
WRWDOUHIOHFW REXQ VRFLDOL]DUHGHJHQXOÄFkQGFRQGXFPDúLQD
vQFHUF V L vPSLHGLF SH DO LL V P GHS úHDVF ´ FKHLD )DOV QHJDUHD
WHQGLQ HORUQHYURWLFHÄQXSRWV IDFQLPLFELQH´FKHLD)DOVFRPSRU
WDPHQW úL DWLWXGLQL FRQYHQ LRQDOH FRQIRUPLVPXO ÄGH RELFHL IDF FHHD
FHVHDúWHDSW GHODPLQHSHQWUXDHYLWDFULWLFD´FKHLD$GHY UDWRSWL
PLVPXOÄP vQGRLHVFF FLQHYDHVWHFXDGHY UDWIHULFLW´FKHLD)DOV
6FDOD LQGLF JUDGXO vQ FDUH UHDF LLOH úL U VSXQVXULOH LQGLYLGXOXL
FRUHVSXQGXQXLÄPRGHOFRPXQ´VWDELOLWHPSLULF
3HUFHSHUHDVRFLDO SHQWUXE UEDWXOFXVFRUIRDUWHvQDOWvOGHVFULH
FD SUXGHQW FRQúWLLQFLRV UHIOH[LY HILFLHQW SUHFLV RUJDQL]DW SUDFWLF
UHVSRQVDELOWHPHLQLFFXPS WDW)HPHLDHVWHGHVFULV DVWIHOOXFLG GH
vQFUHGHUHHQHUJLF YHVHO SUDFWLF UD LRQDO UHDOLVW
% UED LLFXXQVFRUIRDUWHVF ]XWVXQWGHVFULúLGHFHLODO LFDDWU
J WRU QHJOLMHQW FXUDMRV vQGU ]QH XLWXF FRPRG QHV EXLW ULVLSLWRU
)HPHLD HVWH SHUFHSXW FD DSUHFLDWLY DUWLVW VWkQJDFH IHPLQLQ
XLWXF LHUW WRDUH LQGLIHUHQW LUHVSRQVDELO QHGHPQ GH vQFUHGHUH
QHFRQYHQ LRQDO
6FDOD;,,,5HDOL]DUHDSULQFRQIRUPLVP±$F
(VWH vQ SULPXO UkQG R VFDO PRWLYD LRQDO FDUH UHIOHFW IDFWRUL
PRWLYD LRQDOLúLDWLWXGLQDOLDVRFLD LFXUHDOL]DUHDDFDGHPLF GHQLYHOXUL
vQDOWH 7HUPHQXO ÄFRQIRUPLVP´ UHIOHFW DFHDVW FDQDOL]DUH D WUHEXLQ HL
GHUHDOL]DUHSHUVRQDO úLQXFHHDFHVHvQ HOHJHSULQÄFRQIRUPLWDWH´UHV
SHFWLY XQ VHQV GH VWHUHRWLSLH QHSURGXFWLY FDUH QX HVWH SUHD LPSOLFDW
DLFL6FDODDIRVWFRQVWUXLW SULQPHWRGDFULWHULXOXLH[WHUQ
&RQ LQXWXULOH PDQLIHVWH DOH FHORU GH LWHPL GLQWUH FDUH
H[FOXVLYL UHIOHFW KRW UkUHD úL SO FHUHD SHQWUX D VH SUHJ WL úL D DYHD
HILFLHQ vQ vQY DUH VHQWLPHQWXO GH YLWDOLWDWH úL HILFLHQ vQ JHQHUH
DFFHSWDUHD UHJXOLORU úL FHULQ HORU úL UHIX]XO IULYROLW LL úL DO FRPSRU
WDPHQWXOXL QRQFRQIRUPLVW WHPSHUDUHD úL vQFUHGHUHD vQ SURSULLOH
FDSDFLW LDXWRDSUHFLHUHDSULYLQGPRGXOSODQLILFDWúLPXQFLWRUGHDVH
LPSOLFDvQYLD
,WHPLL VXQW IRORVL L SHQWUX UHOLHIDUHD DFHORU IDFWRUL GH LQWHUHV úL
PRWLYD LHFDUHIDFLOLWHD] UHDOL]DUHDvQRULFHFDGUXXQGHDVHP QDUHDFX
PRGHOXO VDX VXSXQHUHD ID GH DQXPLWH RELFHLXUL HVWH XQ FRPSRU
WDPHQWSR]LWLY
6FRUXULOHSHVWHQRWD7SUH]LQW RSHUVRDQ FDSDELO FRRSHUDQW
HILFLHQW RUJDQL]DW UHVSRQVDELO IHUP úLVLQFHU 3HUVLVWHQW úLPXQ
FLWRDUHDSUHFLD] DFWLYLWDWHDúLUHDOL]DUHDLQWHOHFWXDO
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO GHVFULH XQ E UEDW FX VFRU IRDUWH vQDOW SULQ
DGMHFWLYHFDDPEL LRVFDSDELOFRQúWLLQFLRVDPDELODWHQWSUHYHQLWRU
LQWHOLJHQWORJLFPDWXUUH]RQDELOFXUHVXUVHUHVSRQVDELO
2 IHPHLH FX VFRU vQDOW HVWH GHVFULV DVWIHO FRQVHUYDWRDUH HIL
FLHQW LGHDOLVW vQWUHSULQ] WRDUHDPDELO PHWRGLF ORJLF GHvQFUH
GHUHILGHO UH]HUYDW UHVSRQVDELO
6FRUXULOH VXE QRWD 7 SUH]LQW R SHUVRDQ YXOJDU vQF S
kQDW GLVWDQW GLILFLO SULPHMGLRDV vQIXPXUDW 6HGH]RUJDQL]HD]
XúRU VXE VWUHVXO SUHVLXQLORU úL FRQIRUPLVPXOXL 3HVLPLVW vQ SULYLQ D
YLLWRUXOXLSURIHVLRQDO
3HUFHSHUHDVRFLDO GHVFULHXQDVWIHOGHE UEDWFDDSDWLFE QXLWRU
SUDFWLFLQVHQVLELOLQVXSRUWDELOFDXW SO FHUHDXúXUDWLFQHV EXLWDJL
WDWQHDVWkPS UDWVXSHUILFLDOVFKLPE WRURVWHQWDWLYIDFHSHJUR]DYXO
)HPHLDHVWHSHUFHSXW vQXUP WRULLWHUPHQLDYHQWXURDV QHS V
WRDUHLQGLIHUHQW QHJOLMHQW XúXUDWLF DWLWXGLQHGHJDMDW OHQHú LP
SUHVLRQDELO UHEHO VDUFDVWLF QHFRQYHQ LRQDO QHLQKLEDW QHJKLRDE
6FDOD;,95HDOL]DUHDSULQLQGHSHQGHQ ±$L
6FDOD HVWH PHQLW V P VRDUH LQWHUHVXO VXELHFWXOXL SHQWUX DFHOH
VLWXD LL±LQFOXVLYSUHJ WLUHDDFDGHPLF ±vQFDUHVHFHUHLQGHSHQGHQ
vQJkQGLUHYDORUL]DUHDSRWHQ LDOXOXLSURSULX
&RQ LQXWXULOHPDQLIHVWHDOHLWHPLORUvQWRWDOLQGLF WROHUDQ
FUHVFXW SHQWUX DPELJXLWDWH úL UHIX]XO XQRU DWLWXGLQL VLPSOLVW GRJ
PDWLFH VDX DXWRULWDUH UHIX]XO XQRU UHDF LL FRQYHQ LRQDOH FKLDU GDF
HVWHYRUEDGHDVXV LQHRRSLQLHQHSRSXODU úLFRQWURYHUVDW SO FHUHD
SHQWUX DFWLYLW L LQGHSHQGHQWH FKLDU GDF QX VXQW QHFHVDU XWLOLWDUH
DILUPDUHD XQHL JkQGLUL SR]LWLYH ID GH DO LL DILUPDUHD XQXL QLYHO GH
DGDSWDUH PDQLIHVW vQ SUH]HQW DILUPDUHD XQRU YDORUL PRUDOH ELQH GH]
YROWDWH 6H SRW LGHQWLILFD DFHL IDFWRUL DL LQWHUHVXOXL úL PRWLYD LHL FDUH
IDFLOLWHD] UHDOL]DUHD vQ RULFH FDGUX XQGH DXWRQRPLD úL LQGHSHQGHQ D
VXQWFRPSRUWDPHQWHSR]LWLYH
6FRUXULOH vQDOWH OD DFHDVW VFDO SUH]LQW R SHUVRDQ PDWXU
HILFDFH SXWHUQLF GRPLQDQW SUHWHQ LRDV úL SUHFDXW LQGHSHQGHQW
úLVLJXU SHVLQHFXDELOLWDWHLQWHOHFWXDO úLGLVFHUQ PkQW
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO GHVFULH XQ E UEDW FX VFRU IRDUWH vQDOW FD
SUHY ] WRU DQWLFLSDWLY LQGHSHQGHQW QHIRUPDOLVW LQWHOLJHQW VLP
SDWLF UD LRQDO VDUFDVWLF LUDVFLELO PXOWLODWHUDO )HPHLD HVWH GHVFULV
DVWIHO FDOP FDSDELO OXFLG GLVFUHW LQWHOLJHQW ORJLF PDWXU
RULJLQDO UD LRQDO
6FRUXULOH VF ]XWH LQGLF XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW LQKLEDW DQ[LRV
SUXGHQW QHPXO XPLW P UJLQLW úL VXVSLFLRV XPLO úL VXSXV ID GH
DXWRULW LÌLOLSVHúWHLQWURVSHF LDúLvQ HOHJHUHDGHVLQH
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO SHQWUX XQ E UEDW FX VFRU IRDUWH VF ]XW HVWH
DIHFWDW vQJkPIDW SUXGHQW SUHFDXW UHFH HJRFHQWULF IULFRV IULYRO
FXUWHQLWRU SOLQ GH VLQH ULJLG )HPHLD HVWH SHUFHSXW FD VWkQJDFH
HPRWLY QHFKLE]XLW LPDWXU LQIDQWLO FDS VHF DJLWDW VLPSO
QHUHDOLVW LQVWDELO
6FDOD;9(ILFLHQ DLQWHOHFWXDO ±,H
6FDOD WUHEXLH vQ HOHDV WRW vQ SDUDGLJPD PRWLYD LRQDO QX HVWH
FRQVWUXLW SHQWUXDP VXUDFDSDFLWDWHDGHDUH]ROYDSUREOHPHILHHOHúL
LQWHOHFWXDOH FL HVWH R VFDO FDUH LQGLF LQWHUHVXO SHQWUX YDORUL LQWH
OHFWXDOHRSXVFHOXLSHQWUXYDORULSUDFWLFH
&RQ LQXWXO PDQLIHVW DO FHORU GH LWHPL DSDU LQkQGXL
H[FOXVLYVHUHIHU ODDVSHFWHSUHFXPFDSDFLWDWHDGHDIDFHID XQRU
VLWXD LL GH QHGHWHUPLQDUH úL DPELJXLWDWH VHQWLPHQWXO DGHFY ULL úL
HILFLHQ HL SHUVRQDOH LQWHUHVXO SHQWUX DFWLYLW L GH FHUFHWDUH SO FHUHD
GH D IDFH SODQXUL úL GH D OH UHDOL]D LPSRUWDQ D SH FDUH R DFRUG SUR
EOHPHORU LQWHOHFWXDOH úL GH FXQRDúWHUH XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW vQ JHQHUH
IOH[LELO UHODWLY LQVWDELO úL PDL SX LQ RUJDQL]DW ,QGLF GHFL JUDGXO GH
HILFLHQ SHUVRQDO úLLQWHOHFWXDO ODFDUHDDMXQVLQGLYLGXO
6FRUXOSHVWHQRWD7LQGLF RSHUVRDQ HILFLHQW FXRJkQGLUH
FODU FDSDELO LQWHOLJHQW SURJUHVLVW RUGRQDW PHWLFXORDV úLLQJH
QLRDV PHUHX DOHUW úL ELQH LQIRUPDW $FRUG LPSRUWDQ PDUH SUR
EOHPHORULQWHOHFWXDOHúLGHFXQRDúWHUH
3HQWUXXQE UEDWFXVFRUvQDOWODDFHDVW VFDO SHUFHSHUHDVRFLDO
HVWH FDSDELO GH vQFUHGHUH HILFLHQW SUHY ] WRU DQWLFLSDWLY LQGHSHQ
GHQWLQWHOLJHQWUH]RQDELODXWRFRQWURODWVDWLVI FXWVLQFHUQHSUHI FXW
)HPHLD HVWH GHVFULV SULQ XUP WRDUHOH DGMHFWLYH FDSDELO OXFLG GH
vQFUHGHUHHILFLHQW QHIRUPDO LQWHOLJHQW vúLJkQGHúWHGHFL]LLOHORJLF
UD LRQDO UHOD[DW
6FRUXO VXE QRWD 7 SUH]LQW R SHUVRDQ SUXGHQW FRQIX]
FRPRG GHIHQVLY VXSHUILFLDO úLI U DPEL LH$UHRJkQGLUHFRQYHQ
LRQDO úLVWHUHRWLSLF ÌLOLSVHúWHGLUHF LRQDUHDúLGLVFLSOLQDGHVLQH
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO FDUDFWHUL]HD] XQ DVWIHO GH E UEDW FX QRWH
IRDUWHVF ]XWHSULQVWkQJDFLUHFHXLWXFLQVHQVLELOFXLQWHUHVHOLPLWDWH
VWUDQLX FLXGDW RERVLWRU VXVFHSWLELO VXSHUILFLDO LQIOXHQ DELO VXJHV
WLELO)HPHLDHVWHSHUFHSXW FDQHKRW UkW VWkQJDFHFXLQWHUHVHOLPLWDWH
QHUYRDV SHVLPLVW VLPSO vQFHDW vQF S kQDW WHQVLRQDW UHWUDV
6FDOD;9,ÌQFOLQD LDSVLKRORJLF ±3\
6FDODP VRDU JUDGXOvQFDUHLQGLYLGXOVHLPSOLF úLHVWHVHQVLELO
ODQHFHVLW LOHLQWHUQHODFDX]HúLODH[SHULHQ HOHVHPHQLORU
&RQ LQH GH LWHPL GLQWUH FDUH VXQW VSHFLILFL LDU UHVWXO
FRPXQLFX6S&RQ LQXWXOPDQLIHVWDOLWHPLORUUHIOHFW FDSDFLWDWHDGH
PRELOL]DUH D UHVXUVHORU SHQWUX FRQFHQWUDUHD SH SUREOHP FDSDFLWDWHD
GHDWROHUDDPELJXLWDWHDúLGH]RUGLQHDGLVSRQLELOLWDWHDSHQWUXPXQF
vQJHQHUHúLSHQWUXFHDGHFHUFHWDUHvQVSHFLDOVDFULILFLXOUHFRPSHQVHL
LPHGLDWHSHQWUXDPEL LLOHVDXUHXúLWHOHSHWHUPHQOXQJLQWHUHVXOSHQWUX
DVSHFWHOHSUDFWLFHXQPRGGHVFKLVGHDILDWLWXGLQLGHVFKLVHOLEHUDOH
QHFRQYHQ LRQDOH
6FRUXO SHVWH QRWD 7 OD DFHDVW VFDO LQGLF GHFL R SHUVRDQ
DWHQW VSRQWDQ UDSLG UHFHSWLY YRUE UHD LQJHQLRDV úLIOH[LELO
FXREXQ IOXHQ YHUEDO úLFXDVFHQGHQ VRFLDO 1HVXSXV UHJXOLORU
UHVWULF LLORUúLFRQVWUkQJHULORU
8Q E UEDW FX VFRU IRDUWH vQDOW HVWH GHVFULV FD GLVWDQW HYD]LY
SUHY ] WRUDQWLFLSDWLYLQGHSHQGHQWLQGLYLGXDOLVWSHUVHYHUHQWSUHR
FXSDW UH]HUYDW QHSULHWHQRV FLUFXPVSHFW SUXGHQW )HPHLD HVWH GHV
FULV DVWIHOFDSDELO UHFHLQGHSHQGHQW LQJHQLRDV QHSULSLW ORJLF
QHDVWkPS UDW VLJXU GH VLQH LVWHD DJHU OD PLQWH GHPQ GH
vQFUHGHUH
6FRUXO VXE QRWD 7 SUH]LQW R SHUVRDQ DSDWLF SDúQLF
VHULRDV SUXGHQW úLPRGHVW FXXQWHPSROLQLúWLWúLSUHFDX LHFRQIRU
PLVW úLFRQYHQ LRQDO
3HUFHSHUHD VRFLDO GHVFULH XQ E UEDW FX VFRU VF ]XW SULQ
DGMHFWLYHFDDFWLYYRLRVHQHUJLFIOLUWHD] FXXPRUEOkQGDGDSWDELO
GHVFKLVVRFLDELOYRUE UH )HPHLDHVWHGHVFULV DVWIHOFRQYHQ LRQDO
JHQHURDV RQHVW EOkQG HORJLDW vQFRUGDW GHvQFUHGHUHPRGHVW
FDOG QHOLQLúWLW
6FDOD;9,,)OH[LELOLWDWHD±)[
6FDOD HVWH FRQVWLWXLW SHQWUX LGHQWLILFDUHD SHUVRDQHORU IOH[LELOH
DGDSWDELOHFDSDELOHGHVFKLPEDUHvQJkQGLUHFRQGXLW WHPSHUDPHQW
&HLGHLWHPLVHUHIHU PDQLIHVWvQFRQ LQXWXULOHORUODUHIX]XO
XQRUDWLWXGLQLVLPSOLVWGRJPDWLFHVDXDXWRULWDUHWROHUDQ vQDOW SHQWUX
QHVLJXUDQ VDX DPELJXLWDWH UHODWLY LQVWDELOLWDWH GH JHQXO ÄGHVHRUL
vQFHS OXFUXUL SH FDUH QX OH PDL GXF YUHRGDW OD EXQ VIkUúLW´ FKHLD
$GHY UDW OLSV H[SUHV GH RUGLQH ÄvPL SODFH V DP XQ ORF SHQWUX
ILHFDUH GLQWUH OXFUXUL úL ILHFDUH V VWHD OD ORFXO V X´ FKHLD )DOV XQ
PRG UHOD[DW QHFULWLF GH D DSUHFLD VWDQGDUGHOH PRUDOH úL SUHVFULS LLOH
HWLFHÄvPLIL[H]VWDQGDUGHvQDOWHúLVLPWF úLDO LLDUWUHEXLV IDF OD
IHO´FKHLD)DOV
6FDODLQGLF JUDGXOGHIOH[LELOLWDWHúLGHDGDSWDELOLWDWHDOJkQGLULL
úLFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLXQHLSHUVRDQH
6FRUXO SHVWH QRWD 7 SUH]LQW R SHUVRDQ LQWURVSHFWLY QHIRU
PDO DYHQWXURDV FXvQFUHGHUHvQVLQHFXVLP XOXPRUXOXLQHVXSXV
LGHDOLVW úL HJRLVW VDUFDVWLF úL FLQLF FRQFHQWUDUH vQDOW SH DPX]D
PHQWXOúLSO FHUHDSHUVRQDO
3HUFHSHUHDVRFLDO SHQWUXXQE UEDWFXVFRUvQDOWODDFHDVW VFDO vO
GHVFULH DVWIHO DWLWXGLQH GHJDMDW QHVWDWRUQLF LQGHSHQGHQW OHQHú RSWL
PLVWFDXW SO FHUHDYLRLLVWH DJHUODPLQWHULVLSLWRUVSRQWDQ)HPHLD
HVWHSHUFHSXW FDQHJOLMHQW GHúWHDSW vQGU ]QHD LPDJLQDWLY LQGLYL
GXDOLVW LQJHQLRDV U XW FLRDV RULJLQDO FDXW SO FHUHDVRFLDELO
6FRUXO VXE QRWD 7 SUH]LQW R SHUVRDQ SUHFDXW SUXGHQW
QHOLQLúWLW KDUQLF FHQ]XUDW SROLWLFRDV PHWRGLF úLULJLG IRUPDO
úL SHGDQW vQ JkQGLUH SOLQ GH UHVSHFW ID GH DXWRULWDWH RELFHLXUL úL
WUDGL LH3HUFHSHUHDVRFLDO SHQWUXXQE UEDWFXVFRUXOVF ]XWvOGHVFULH
FD KRW UkW HILFLHQW vQF S kQDW RUJDQL]DW PHWRGLF SUDFWLF VHYHU
vQG U WQLF IOHJPDWLF PLQX LRV )HPHLD HVWH GHVFULV vQ WHUPHQLL
SUHFDXW FRQúWLLQFLRDV FRQVHUYDWRDUH GHIHQVLY SUHI FXW ULJLG
OHQW VLPSO FXWHQGLQ DGHDVHDXWRSHGHSVLDXWREODPD
6FDOD;9,,,)HPLQLWDWH±)H
&RQVWUXLW SULQDQDOL]DFULWHULXOXLH[WHUQVFDODHYDOXHD] vQVSH
FLDOVSUHGHRVHELUHGHVFDODVLPLODU GLQ003,LQWHUHVHOHFDUDFWHULVWLFH
JHQXOXLUHVSHFWLYIHPLQLWDWHDVDXPDVFXOLQLWDWHDLQWHUHVHORUVXELHFWXOXL
&HLGHLWHPLGLQFDUHVXQWH[FOXVLYLDXvQFRQ LQXWXOORU
PDQLIHVW UHIHULUL OD SUHIHULQ D SHQWUX UROXUL FRQYHQ LRQDO IHPLQLQH
ID GH FHOH PDVFXOLQH HPRWLYLWDWHD úL VHQVLELOLWDWHD LQWHUSHUVRQDO
SHUVRDQHOHFX)HvQDOW UH]RQHD] PDLPXOWODDWPRVIHUDHPR LRQDO
JHQHUDO SURSULD PRGHVWLH UH LQHUH úL OLSVD LPSXOVLYLW LL LQWHUHVXO
PDLVF ]XWID GHSROLWLF DIDFHULUHDOL] ULVRFLDOH
6FDODHVWHOHJDW GHDSUHFLHUHDPDVFXOLQLW LLVDXIHPLQLW LLLQWH
UHVHORU VFRUXULOH vQDOWH LQGLF LQWHUHVH PDL PXOW IHPLQLQH VFRUXULOH
MRDVH±LQWHUHVHPDLPXOWPDVFXOLQH
6FRUXOSHVWHQRWD7SUH]LQW RSHUVRDQ DSUHFLDWLY FDOP GH
VSULMLQEOkQG WHPSHUDW SHUVHYHUHQW úLVLQFHU 5HVSHFW úLDFFHSW
VHPHQLL6HFRPSRUW vQWUXQPRGFLQVWLWúLVLPSDWLF
8QE UEDWFXVFRUvQDOWHVWHSHUFHSXWFDUHFXQRVF WRUSOkQJ UH
IHPLQLQIRUPDOLVWEODMLQEOkQGQHUYRVDXWRFULWLFVHQVLELOVODEQH
OLQLúWLW)HPHLDHVWHGHVFULV DVWIHOFRQúWLLQFLRDV GLVFUHW JHQHURDV
JHQWLO VHUYLDELO PDWXU DXWRFRQWURODW VLPSDWLF FXWDFWFDOG
6FRUXOVXEQRWD7LQGLF RSHUVRDQ H[SHGLWLY vQF S kQDW
DPEL LRDV PDVFXOLQ DFWLY UREXVW úL IU PkQWDW P VOXLWRDUH úL
RSRUWXQLVW vQ UHOD LLOH FX VHPHQLL GHVFKLV úL GLUHFW vQ JkQGLUH úL
DF LXQHQHU EG WRDUHODvQWkU]LHUHLQGHFL]LLúLUHIOHF LH
% UEDWXOFXVFRUVF ]XWHVWHGHVFULVGHFHLODO LDVWIHODYHQWXURV
DJUHVLY OXFLG FX JkQGLUH FODU vQGU ]QH LPSXOVLY PDVFXOLQ GHV
FKLVFDXW SO FHUHDIDFHSHJUR]DYXOGXU)HPHLDHVWHSHUFHSXW FD
YXOJDU JURVRODQ EUXWDO QHVDWLVI FXW OHQHú PDVFXOLQ FDXW
SO FHUHD DJLWDW QHDVWkPS UDW UREXVW HJRFHQWULF LUDVFLELO úL
VXVFHSWLELO GXU
,QWHUSUHWDUHDVFDOHORU
6SUH GHRVHELUH GH DOWH FKHVWLRQDUH FODVLFH PRGXO GH FRQVWUXLUH
DO&3,SHUPLWHRLQWHUSUHWDUHPXOWLID]LF úLUHODWLYSURIXQG UHXúLQG
V VXUSULQG FHYD GLQ VXELHFWXO YLX úL QX GRDU RIHULQGXQH XQ PRGHO
DEVWUDFW $FHVW OXFUX HVWH SRVLELO FXP YRP YHGHD PDL DOHV SULQ
LQWHUFRUHODUHDVFDOHORUúLSULQIDSWXOF VFRUXOXQHLVFDOHWUHEXLHvQ HOHV
FD DQWUHQkQG vQ PRG QHFHVDU R LSRWH] OHJDW GH FRPSRUWDPHQW
LSRWH] ODFDUHVHSRDWHU VSXQGHSULQVFRUXODOWRUVFDOH'HDVHPHQHD
YRP YHGHD F *RXJK RIHU úL PRGHOH GH LQWHUFRUHOD LL HPSLULFH vQWUH
VFRUXULOHODXQHOHGLQWUHVFDOH
,QWHUSUHWDUHDGHYLQHGLQFHvQFHPDLPXOWRPXQF GHFHUFHWDUH
IRUPXODUHDGHLSRWH]HúLF XWDUHDVROX LHLGHWHUPLQDUHDXQRUDOWHUQDWLYH
GH FODULILFDUH D GDWHORU úL vPELQDUHD DVSHFWHORU LQWHUFRUHODWH vQWUXQ
PRGHOFRPSRUWDPHQWDOFRHUHQW1XDYHPRVLPSO vQúLUXLUHGHWU V WXUL
FLHYROX PWUHSWDWVSUHRVWUXFWXU FDUHQHSRDWHGHVFKLGHQRLLSRWH]HSH
FDUHGDF QXOHSXWHPYHULILFDGLUHFWSULQWHVWXO&3,úWLPP FDUVSUH
FH V QH vQGUHSW P 'H H[HPSOX XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW FDUH DQWUHQHD]
YkUVWD VXELHFWXOXL VH[XO úL XQHOH VFDOH SUHFXP 6D :E &P 6F HWF
SRDWH FRQGXFH ILH VSUH LGHHD XQXL SRVLELO VLQGURP SVLKRSDWRORJLF ±
YHULILFDELOUDSLGSULQ003,±ILHVSUHLSRWH]DXQXLHXQHIRUPDWLPDWXU
VODEFDUHSRDWHILFHUFHWDW DGHFYDWSULQSUREHSURLHFWLYH
)RUPDUHDSHQWUXDELOLWDUHDvQLQWHUSUHWDUHDSURILOXOXL
,QWHUSUHWDUHD SURWRFROXOXL QX VH SRDWH IDFH GHFkW GH SHUVRDQH
FDUH FXQRVF WHRULLOH SHUVRQDOLW LL GH]YROWDUHD SHUVRQDOLW LL WHRULLOH
PRWLYD LHL úL YDORULORU úL QX vQ XOWLP LQVWDQ WHVWXO úL FODULILF ULOH
FRQFHSWXDOH *RXJK VH H[SULP vQ DFHVW VHQV H[SOLFkQG vQ PRG
OLPSHGH F &3, HVWH XQ WHVW SURIHVLRQLVW LQWHUSUHWDELO GRDU GH
SURIHVLRQLúWLFDUHVDXIRUPDWSHQWUXLQWHUSUHWDUHDDFHVWHLSUREH
3ULPXO SDV SHQWUX D WH IRUPD HVWH V FXQRúWL vQ SURIXQ]LPH
FRQVWUXFWHOHSHFDUHOHGHILQHúWHILHFDUHGLQWUHVFDOHGHDVHPHQHDV
FXQRúWL GDWHOH GH FHUFHWDUH SULYLQG YDOLGDUHD VFDOHORU úL DQDOL]HOH
FRQFHSWXDOHUHDOL]DWH*RXJKFRQVLGHU F PRGXOFHOPDLDGHFYDWGHD
vQFHSHV VWXGLH]LIHOXOFXPVHLQWHUSUHWHD] HVWHOXFUXODO WXULGHXQ
H[SHUW IRORVLQG FRPSRUWDPHQWXO DFHVWXLD FD SH XQ H[HPSOX vQWUXFkW
PRGHODUHDúLIHHGEDFNXOVXQWHVHQ LDOHSHQWUXSURFHVXOGHvQY DUHÌQ
OLSVD XQXL VSHFLDOLVW VH SRDWH FkúWLJD H[SHULHQ GLQ UHLQWHUSUHWDUHD
XQRU SURWRFRDOH VDX SURILOH YHFKL FX YHULILFDUHD IHOXOXL FXP DX
HYROXDWvQWUHWLPSFD]XULOHFRPSDUDWLYFXSURJQR]HOHI FXWHDQWHULRU
ÌQFHS WRUXO SRDWH XWLOL]D GH DVHPHQHD DSOLF UL DOH WHVWXOXL SH R
SRSXOD LHVSHFLILF DO WXULGHDOWHWHVWHSHFDUHOHVW SkQHúWHPDLELQH
FX VFRSXO GH D DQDOL]D GLIHUHQ HOH vQWUH SURILOH úL GH D REVHUYD FDUH
DQXPHDVSHFWHVHUHJ VHVFvQPDMRULWDWHDSURILOHORUúLFRUHVSXQGXQRU
SUREOHPH FRPXQH SRSXOD LHL GDWH 'DWHOH WHVWHORU FXQRVFXWH WUHEXLH
XWLOL]DWHSHQWUXDYHULILFDLQWHUSUHW ULOHRE LQXWHGLQ&3,
8QDOWPRGSDUDOHOHVWHGHDvQY DGLQHURUL$VWIHOGHHURULSRW
FRQúWLHQWL]DGHH[HPSOXIDSWXOF XQHOHVFDOHDXRUHOD LHFXUELOLQLDU
FXFRPSRUWDPHQWXOUHIHULWRUODDJUHVLYLWDWHGHSLOG RQRW vQDOW OD6F
SRDWHLQGLFDXQFRQIOLFWSRWHQ LDOLQVWDELOvQWUHLPSXOVXULOHDJUHVLYHúLXQ
DXWRFRQWUROSUHDULJLGVLWXD LHFDUHSRDWHFRQGXFHSHXQKLSHUFRQWURODW
ODRL]EXFQLUHGHDJUHVLYLWDWHQHDúWHSWDW VDXGLVSURSRU LRQDW $FHHDúL
VLWXD LHúLSHQWUXVFDODGHIOH[LELOLWDWH6FRUXULOHPRGHUDWHVXQWSR]LWLYH
LQGLFkQGXQEXQSRWHQ LDODGDSWDWLYGDUVFRUXULOHH[WUHPGHvQDOWHSHVWH
LQGLF LQVWDELOLWDWHXQFRPSRUWDPHQWSUHDYRODWLO/DDVWIHOGHGDWH
*RXJKIDFHUHIHULUHvQvQÄ,QWHUSUHWHU¶V6\OODEXVIRUWKH&3,´
ÌQSHULRDGDGHIRUPDUHSVLKRORJXOVHYDFRQFHQWUDPDLDOHVSHD
H[WUDJHFkWPDLPXOWHGDWHGLQWUXQSURWRFRO&3,OXFUkQGRDUHFXPvQ
RUEI U DLQWHUDF LRQDFXVXELHFWXOUHDO6LWXD LDVHVFKLPE vQGLDJ
QR]DUHDO FkQGLQWHUSUHWDUHDSURWRFROXOXLYDWUHEXLV U VSXQG XQRU
LSRWH]H VSHFLILFH XQRU vQWUHE UL SH FDUH úL OH IRUPXOHD] SVLKRORJXO
DQWHULRU DGPLQLVWU ULL WHVWXOXL $FHVW OXFUX vQVHDPQ DWkW FXQRDúWHUHD
DQDPQH]HLFD]XOXLFkWúLDFLUFXPVWDQ HORUVSHFLDOHFDUHSRWLQIOXHQ D
VLWXD LD GH WHVWDUH HGXFD LH UDV QLYHO HGXFD LRQDO UHOD LLOH GLQWUH
VXELHFW úL H[DPLQDWRU LSRWH]H GHVSUH FHOH PDL SUREDELOH PRGXUL vQ
FDUHVXELHFWXOYDDERUGDFKHVWLRQDUXO'DF SURWRFROXOYDFRUHVSXQGH
PRGHOXOXL H[SHFWDW SVLKRORJXO SRDWH DYHD vQFUHGHUH PDL PDUH vQ
DFXUDWH HD LQWHUSUHW ULORU VDOH 'H DVHPHQHD VH SRW XWLOL]D SURILOH
SHQWUXJUXSXULGHUHIHULQ VDXGDWHOHGHFHUFHWDUHSULYLQGHFXD LLOHGH
UHJUHVLHFDUHHYDOXHD] XQQXP UGHFDUDFWHULVWLFLSUHFXPPDWXULWDWHD
VRFLDO QLYHOXOULGLFDWGHVXFFHVDFDGHPLFVDXDOWHWLSXULGHUHDOL] UL
9DOLGDUHDSURILOXOXL
8Q SULP QLYHO VDX HWDS D LQWHUSUHW ULL HVWH YDOLGDUHD SURWR
FROXOXL ([LVW XQ VLVWHP GH YDOLGDUH VLPSOX VWXGLLOH PDL UHFHQWH DX
DMXQV OD HFXD LL GH UHJUHVLH FX VHPQLILFD LH VWDWLVWLF SULQ FDUH VH
HOLPLQ WUHSWDWGLIHULWHJHQXULGHDWLWXGLQL
$FHVWH YDOLG UL SH FDUH OH FRQVWUXLHúWH DXWRUXO LQL LDO GRDU FX
DMXWRUXO VFDOHORU :E &P úL *L GDX DFFHV VSUH R LPDJLQH DQWLFLSDW
DVXSUD SURWRFROXOXL SH FDUH vO LQWHUSUHWH]L VDX PDL ELQH]LV D IHOXOXL
FXPvOSR LLQWHUSUHWD$FHDVWDSHQWUXF WHRUHWLFRULFHSURWRFROHVWH
LQWHUSUHWDELO LQYDOLGDUHD QX VHPQLILF DLFL LPSRVLELOLWDWHD GH D
vQ HOHJHFHYDGLQSURWRFROvQV G RFKHLHGHDFFHVVSUHXQJKLXOGLQ
FDUHSRWILI FXWHLQWHUSUHW ULOH
3HQWUX vQFHSXW VH FHUH V VH YHULILFH GDF VD U VSXQV OD WR L
LWHPLL WHVWXOXL ,WHPLL QHFRPSOHWD L VFDG YDOLGLWDWHD FKHVWLRQDUXOXL
7UHEXLH FRQWURODWH LQGHFL]LLOH U VSXQVXULOH GXEOH FHUkQGXOLVH VX
ELHF LORUV HYLWHDVWIHOGHVLWXD LL'HDVHPHQHDSULYLQGSURWRFROXOGH
U VSXQV VDX SURILOXO UH]XOWDW VH SRDWH XUP UL GDF H[LVW XQ DQXPLW
PRGHOÄWLSLF´SHFDUHODDGRSWDWVXELHFWXOSHQWUXDIDFHID VDUFLQLL
V U VSXQG QXPDLQHJkQGVDXQXPDLDFFHSWkQGHWF
6FDOHOH :E *L úL &P VXQW VSHFLDO FRQVWUXLWH SHQWUX D RIHUL úL
SRVLELOLWDWHD YDOLG ULL PRGXOXL vQ FDUH VXELHFWXO D U VSXQV 6FRUXULOH
PLFLOD:EúL&PPDLDOHVFHOHVXEQLYHOXOQRWHVWDQGDUGLQGLF
WHQGLQ D VXELHFWXOXL GH D U VSXQGH DFFHSWkQG ³$GHY UDW´ LWHPLL
VLPSWRPDWLFL$VSHFWXOSRDWHILYHULILFDWúLSULQQLYHOHOHVFDOHORU6F7R
$LúL)[FDUHYRUILIRDUWHPLFLGDF HVWHSUH]HQW WHQGLQ DGHDDFFHSWD
XQLWHPQHIDYRUDELO6FRUXOOD*LHVWHGLQDFHVWSXQFWGHYHGHUHúLPDL
VLJXU SHQWUX R IDOVLILFDUH vQ VHQVXO vQU XW LULL FX REVHUYD LD F DFHVW
OXFUXSDUHV ILHPDLYDOLGODE UED LGHFkWODIHPHL,QYDOLGDUHDXQXL
SURILO GLQ FDX]D VLPXO ULL vQ VHQVXO QHJDWLYL] ULL VLWXD LHL QX QH YD
SHUPLWHV XWLOL] PDGHFYDWFKHVWLRQDUXOSHQWUXDGLDJQRVWLFDIRU DVDX
VO ELFLXQHDHXOXLRULSHQWUXDHYDOXDGLQDPLFDúLWHQGLQ HOHFRQIOLFWXDOH
ÌQPRGRELúQXLWXQVFRU&PVXEQRWD7SRDWHLQGLFDILHF
VXELHFWXODU VSXQVODvQWkPSODUHPDUFkQGDQDSRGDU VSXQVXULOHILHF
D vQFHUFDW V U VSXQG GDU QX D vQ HOHV FRQ LQXWXO LWHPLORU GLQ FDX]D
XQXL4,VXEPHGLXILHSUH]LQW XQJUDGQHRELúQXLWGHVWUDQLHWDWHvQ
IHOXOvQFDUHMXGHF OXFUXULOHRELúQXLWH$FHDVW XOWLP LSRWH] SRDWHIL
WHVWDW SULQDSOLFDUHDJULOHORUSHQWUXVFDOHOHDEUHYLDWHGLQ003,
ÌQDIDUDDFHVWXLWLSGHYHULILFDUHSURWRFROXOSRDWHILYDOLGDWúLGLQ
SHUVSHFWLYD LSRWH]HL F VXELHFWXO D IDOVLILFDW U VSXQVXULOH SHQWUX D VH
SXQH vQWUR OXPLQ IDYRUDELO ÌQ DFHDVW VLWXD LH DSDU VFRUXUL PDUL OD
WRDWHVFDOHOHvQVSHFLDOOD*L$VWIHOGHFD]XULDSDUPDLDOHVODVXELHF LL
DOFRROLFLDOF URUVODEDXWRUHJODMQXOHSHUPLWHV úLPRGXOH]HVXILFLHQW
UHDF LLOHDVWIHOF U VSXQGFYDVLDXWRPDWIRORVLQGSRVLELOLWDWHDFDUHOLVH
SDUHF HVWHFHDPDLGH]LUDELO (YLGHQWH[LVW VLWXD LLvQFDUHVXELHF L
PDL ELQH HFKLOLEUD L GRUHVF V VH SXQ vQWUR OXPLQ PDL IDYRUDELO
6FDOHOH vQ DFHDVW VLWXD LH QX YRU IL DWkW GH SR]LWLYL]DWH vQV WHQGLQ D
XQXLVFRUULGLFDWOD*LHVWHGHILHFDUHGDW XQLQGLFHVLJXUSHQWUXGRULQ D
VXELHFWXOXLGHDLPSUHVLRQDvQVHQVIDYRUDELOSR]LWLY
6HPQLILFDWLYHVWHIDSWXOF vQVWXGLLOHHPSLULFHORWXOGHVXELHF L
F UXLDLVHFHUHDSULQLQVWUXFWDMV IDOVLILFHDUHPHGLDSHQWUXVFRUXULOH
ODVFDOHOH&3,PDLVF ]XW GHFkWORWXOGHDOFRROLFLúLORWXULOHGHVLPX
ODQ LDGHY UD L
$X IRVW UHDOL]DWH VWXGLL úL FX ORWXUL FRPSDUDWLYH IRUPDWH GLQ
SVLKRORJLFDUHDXUHXúLWV RE LQ SURILOHvQDFHODúLWLPSHFKLOLEUDWHúL
FXVFRUXUL*LPRGHUDWH
3HQWUXYDULDQWD&3,SDúLLvQYDOLGDUHVXQWPXOWPDLH[DFW
FXDQWLILFD L SULQ XWLOL]DUHD HFXD LLORU GH UHJUHVLH IRORVLWH WUHSWDW SH
P VXU FH VH FRQILUP GHS úLUHD VFRUXULORU FULWLFH úL GHFL XQ DQXPH
VHQVGHLQYDOLGDUHÌQDFHVWHHFXD LLVXQWFXSULQVHúLGRX GLQWUHVFDOHOH
FDUHQXLQWU vQYDULDQWDSUH]HQWDW 'DWHOHUHVSHFWLYHVXQWSUH]HQWDWH
GH3LWDULXúL$OEX
,QWHUSUHWDUHD SURSULX]LV D SURILOXOXL QX SRDWH IL I FXW GHFkW
GXS YDOLGDUH
6WUDWHJLLvQLQWHUSUHWDUHDFRUHODWLY DGLPHQVLXQLORUUHOHYDQWH
$QDOL]D VFDOHORU vQFHSH FX FRQILJXUD LD VFRUXULOH SHVWH PHGLH
LQGLF vQJHQHUDORDGDSWDUHSR]LWLY LDUVFRUXULOHVXEPHGLHLQGLF
]RQHOH XQGH DSDU SUREOHPH $SUHFLHUL PDL H[DFWH VH SRW RE LQH XWLOL
]kQGQRUPHOHXQRUJUXSXULGHUHIHULQ XQDEVROYHQWSVLKRORJSRDWHIL
FRPSDUDW FX QRUPHOH SRSXOD LHL JHQHUDOH GDU GDWH PDL SUHFLVH SRW IL
RE LQXWHSULQFRPSDUDUHDFXQRUPHOHFRQVWUXLWHSHORWXOSURIHVLRQDO
ÌQWUR DVWIHO GH DQDOL] JOREDO VH DFRUG LPSRUWDQ PDL DOHV
VFRUXULORUH[WUHPHFRQVWUXLQGXVHSRVLELOHLSRWH]HGHOXFUXSULQLQWHU
UHOD LRQ ULORJLFH
8Q SULP GHPHUV GH FHUFHWDUH VH SRDWH UHDOL]D SRUQLQG GH OD
LSRWH]DOHJDW GHYkUVWDúLVH[XOVXELHFWXOXLúLGHHYDOXDUHDFRQGL LHL
HXOXL3RWILOXDWHvQFRQVLGHUDUHvQVSHFLDOGLQWUHVFDOH6D:EúL
)H $FHVWH WUHL VFDOH SHUPLW ILHFDUH V QH IRUP P R LPDJLQH SULYLQG
IRU D HXOXL DFFHSWDUHD GH VLQH FRUHODW FX QLYHOXO HQHUJLHL YLWDOH
FDSDFLWDWHD GH D WUHFH SHVWH GLILFXOW L VDX UHYHUVXO VWDJQDUHD úL
SHVLPLVPXOvQID DYLH LLúLFXQLYHOXOGHLQWHJUDUHDFDOLW LORUUHODWLYH
OD JHQXO IHPLQLQ VDX PDVFXOLQ F UXLD vL DSDU LQH VXELHFWXO 3XWHP V
GHVFRSHULPSHUVRDQHDF URU6DHVWHvQDOW GDUVXQWSHVLPLúWLúLUHWUDúL
vQID DYLH LLúLQXúLDFFHSW QLFLFDOLW LOHOHJDWHGHJHQXOIHPLQLQVDX
PDVFXOLQ GLPSRWULY SDU V WLQG VSUH DILúDUHD XQRU FRPSRUWDPHQWH
FDUH LQGHJHQXORSXV3XWHPvQWkOQLGHH[HPSOXRIHPHLHFDUHDUH
XQFRPSRUWDPHQWGXUUHFHFULWLFVFRUOD)HPXOWVXEPHGLHVDXXQ
E UEDWFXXQFRPSRUWDPHQWVXVFHSWLELOVHQVLELODIHFWLYWLSLFIHPLQLQ
&RUHODWúLODYkUVWDVXELHFWXOXLDFHVWHJHQXULGHVLWXD LLVXQWPDL
SX LQ JUDYH ± PDL DOHV SHQWUX SHUVRDQHOH DIDWH vQ SOLQ SURFHV GH IRU
PDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLvQDGROHVFHQ GDUSHQWUXYvUVWHOHPDWXUHLQGLF
ILHRFRQGL LHSVLKLF VWDELOL]DW FXPDLSX LQHúDQVHGHFRUHFWDUHILH
RFRQGL LHUHDFWLY GHWLSQHYURWLF'HVLJXUSHQWUXGLDJQR]DFRPSOHW
HVWHLPSRUWDQWV XUP ULPúLIHOXOFXPU VSXQGHODFHOHODOWHVFDOHúLvQ
XOWLP LQVWDQ QLYHOXO U VSXQVXULORU OD VFDOHOH DEUHYLDWH 003,
GHVSUHFDUHYRPYRUELXOWHULRU
ÌQ FRQWLQXDUH VH SRDWH DERUGD HYDOXDUHD FHORU SDWUX JUXS UL
PHQ LRQ PF DFHDVW JUXSDUHHVWHFRQVWUXLW GHDXWRUvQFRQIRUPLWDWH
FX QXPHURDVH VWXGLL FDUH DX DYXW FD RELHFW LQWHUFRUHO ULOH VFDOHORU úL
HVWHHYLGHQ LDW GHIRDLDGHSURILO*RXJKUHFRPDQG VWXGLHUHDGLIH
UHQ HORUGHVFRUXULvQPRGFRUHODWQXL]RODWSHQWUXILHFDUHVFDO
$VWIHO SULPD JUXS GH VFDOH GH OD 'R OD :E HYLGHQ LD] vQ
JHQHUDO DVFHQGHQ D HILFLHQ D SHUVRQDO VLJXUDQ D GH VLQH 3XWHP
VWDELOLvQVLWXD LDvQFDUHDYHPGHH[HPSOXVFRUXULSHVWHPHGLHF HVWH
YRUED GH XQ VXELHFW H[WUDYHUW FDUH VH LPSOLF vQ UHOD LRQ UL FX R
LPDJLQHGHVLQHSR]LWLY 6DúL:EÌQVLWXD LDvQFDUHDYHPVFRUXULOD
6S úL 6\ VXE PHGLH HOH FRQILUP WHQGLQ D VSUH LQWURYHUVLH VSUH UHV
WUkQJHUHDQLYHOXOXLLQWHUUHOD LLORU
*UXSXODO,,OHDGHVFDOHGHOD5HOD&PVHUHIHU vQJHQHUHOD
JUDGXOGHFRQúWLHQWL]DUHúLDFFHSWDUHDFHULQ HORUVRFLDOHODQLYHOXOGH
VRFLDOL]DUHDWLQVODPDWXULWDWHDVRFLDO vQVHQVXOPRGXOXLQHWHQVLRQDW
DXWRFRQWURODWGHDUHOD LRQD
*UXSDUHDD,,,DGHOD$FOD,HUHSUH]LQW VFDOHSULQFDUHDVSHFWHOH
PRWLYD LRQDOH LPSOLFDWH P VRDU SRWHQ LDOXO GH UHDOL]DUH SHUVRQDO
VWLOXOGHLQWHJUDUHWLSXOGHYDORULGRPLQDQW
*UXSXODO,9OHDUHSUH]LQW PRGDOLW LLQWHOHFWXDOHDWLWXGLQDOHúL
WLSRORJLDIHPLQLQ VDXPDVFXOLQ DLQWHUHVHORU
8QDOWWLSGHHYDOXDUHVHSRDWHIDFHFRQIRUPJUXS ULORUUH]XOWDWH
vQXUPDDQDOL]HORUIDFWRULDOH
8Q SULP IDFWRU GHVFULV FD V Q WDWH PHQWDO DGDSWDUH úL FRQIRU
PLVPVRFLDODO WXU VFDOHOH:E5H6R6F7R*LúL$F$FHVWHVFDOH
VXQWvQ HOHVHFDWRWDWkWHDID HWHDOHDGDSW ULLVRFLDOHSR]LWLYH
)DFWRUXO,,GHRVHELWGHVWDELOUHVSHFWLYVFDOHOH'R&V6\6SúL
6DFXSULQGHFXH[FHS LD:ESULPDJUXSDUHDWHVWXOXLGHVFULLQGHIL
FLHQ DLQWHUSHUVRQDO
)DFWRUXO ,,, UHVSHFWLY VFDOHOH $L úL )[ vQ SULQFLSDO vQ XQHOH
VWXGLL DO WXUkQGXVH úL VFDOHOH 7R ,H úL 3\ SXQH DFFHQW SH LQGHSHQ
GHQ DvQJkQGLUHúLDF LXQHYVULJLGLWDWHDVDXFRQIRUPLVPXOULJLGID
GHDXWRULWDWH3RUQLQGGHODIDSWXOF WUHLGLQWUHVFDOH±7R$LúL)[±
DXSHVWHGLQLWHPLvQFKHLD)DOVXQLLFHUFHW WRULDXGHQXPLWIDF
WRUXO,,,WHQGLQ DGHÄDVSXQHGD´YVÄDVSXQHQX´
)DFWRULL,9úL9VXQWVFDOHOH&P6RúLUHVSHFWLY)H
)DFWRUXO 9, D IRVW GHQXPLW GDWRULW vQF UF WXULL SULQFLSDOH vQ
&P ÄVHW PHQWDO´ VDX ÄDWLWXGLQHD ID GH WHVW´ 8QLL FHUFHW WRUL vO
GHILQHVF GLUHFW GUHSW FRQIRUPLVP LQIOH[LELO vQ UDSRUW FX VWDQGDUGHOH
FRQYHQ LRQDOHVDXIRU DVXSHUHJRXOXL
)DFWRUXO 9 QX DSDUH vQ WRDWH DQDOL]HOH IDFWRULDOH ILLQG GHQXPLW
VHQVLELOLWDWH HPR LRQDO IHPLQLQ YV GXULWDWH PDVFXOLQ VDX SXU úL
VLPSOXIHPLQLWDWHYVPDVFXOLQLWDWH
,QGLIHUHQW FDUH GLQWUH JUXS UL HVWH VWXGLDW UHFRPDQGDUHD
DXWRUXOXLHVWHGHDVHOLVWDVFDOHOHFXVFRUXULH[WUHPHPDULúLPLFLúLGH
DUHDOL]DDQDOL]HFRQFHSWXDOHDOHUHVSHFWLYHORUVFDOHvQUDSRUWFXVFR
UXULOHFRUHVSXQ] WRDUH
6H YD DFRUGD DWHQ LH úL UHOD LHL FXUELOLQLDUHGLQWUHXQHOHVFDOHúL
FRPSRUWDPHQW ± VFRUXULOH H[WUHP SHVWH PHGLH VXQW OD IHO GH QHJDWLY
VHPQLILFDWLYH FD úL FHOH VXE PHGLH VFDOHOH 6F )[ ÌQ DFHDVW SULP
ID] VHUHFRPDQG ILHFRPSDUDUHDQLYHOXOXLGHULGLFDUHDVFDOHORUFRQ
IRUPSULPHLJUXS ULILHHOHYD LDUHODWLY vQFDGUXOFHORUFLQFLIDFWRUL
3DVXO XUP WRU SHQWUX YHULILFDUHD LSRWH]HORU DS UXWH GLQ VWXGLXO
VHPQLILFD LHL QLYHOXOXL VFDOHORU JUXSDWH HVWH DQDOL]D XQRUD GLQWUH PR
GHOHOHGHUHOD LRQDUHVDXDQDOL]DGHSDWHUQ$LFLGHYLQHúLPDLHYLGHQW
IDSWXO F LQWHUSUHWDUHD XQHL VFDOH vúL FDS W WRDWH VHQVXULOH GRDU SULQ
FRUHODUHDFXFHOHODOWHVDXDOWIHOVSXVSULQWURDQDOL] VWUXFWXUDO
$VWIHO FkQG VWDELOLP R DQXPLW WHQGLQ PRGXO GH PDQLIHVWDUH
DODFHVWHLDYDILUHOLHIDWSULQVHPQLILFD LDFRWHORUDOWRUVFDOHSULQFDUH
FDS W VHQVFRPSRUWDPHQWDO
$VWIHOGHJUXS ULVXQWVFDOH'RvQUDSRUWGH*LúLGH6\GHSHQ
GHQ HOHGLQWUH6RúL6FGLQWUH5HúL&VGLQWUH5HúL'RGLQWUH$FúL$L
'H H[HPSOX GDF DWkW VFDOD 'R FkW úL VFDOD *L SUH]LQW VFRUXUL
ULGLFDWHSHVWHPHGLHHVWHYRUEDGHVSUHRSHUVRDQ FDUHGRUHúWHV GR
PLQHV FRQGXF GDUDFRUGkQGUHVSHFWFHORUODO LÌQVLWXD LD'RvQDOW*L
VF ]XW DYHP FRQGXF WRUL HJRFHQWULFL 3HQWUX PRGHOXO 'R VF ]XW úL *L
vQDOWVXQWSHUVRDQHFDUHHYLW SR]L LLOHGHUHVSRQVDELOLWDWHVRFLDO GHúLvL
LQWHUHVHD] DSUREDUHDVRFLDO 3HQWUXPRGHOXODPEHORUVFDOHFXVFRUXUL
VXEPHGLLSXWHPDQWLFLSDF HVWHYRUEDGHXQVXELHFWUHWUDVPDLSX LQ
HILFLHQW VRFLDO FDUH VH VLPWH XúRU RIHQVDW 6DX SHQWUX D PDL GD XQ
H[HPSOX VFRUXULOH ULGLFDWH OD 6R úL 6F LQGLF R SHUVRDQ VWDWRUQLF vQ
IHOXOGHDVHPDQLIHVWDFXJUDYLWDWHúLVLJXUDQ GHVLQH3HQWUX6RULGL
FDW úL 6F VF ]XW LQWHUSUHWDUHD GLVFHUQH XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW PDL GHJUDE
FULWLF FRPEDWLY úL GRPLQDQW ÌQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH DO WXUL GH 6R VF ]XW
H[LVW XQ6FULGLFDWSDWHUQXOLQGLF XQFRPSRUWDPHQWPDLGHJUDE IDOV
GHIHQVLY FDUH QX SUH]LQW vQFUHGHUH 6R VF ]XW DO WXUL GH 6F VF ]XW
LQGLF GHMDDJUHVLYLWDWHvQF S kQDUHXQPRGH[FLWDELOúLUHIUDFWDUGHD
IL&RPELQD LLOHGHVFDOHSRVLELOHSHQWUXDGHVSULQGHVHPQLILFD LLSHQWUX
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOUHDOVXQWUHOLHIDWHGH*RXJK0HJDUJHH
3LWDULXúL+HKQ
,QWHUSUHWDUHD SHUFHS LHL VRFLDOH D FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL VH IDFH
SRUQLQG GH OD VFDOHOH FDUH DX VFRUXUL H[WUHPL]DWH GH OD QRWD 7 vQ
VXVVDXQRWD7vQMRV
1X OLSVLW GH VHPQLILFD LH SVLKRORJLF HVWH UDSRUWDUHD OD DGMHF
WLYHOH FDUH vQVR HVF ILHFDUH VFDO $FHDVW DQDOL] DGMHFWLYDO VH IDFH
GRDU SHQWUX VFRUXULOH ULGLFDWH úL SHQWUX FHOH FRERUkWH úLUHSUH]LQW vQ
JHQHUDO LPDJLQHD VRFLDO SH FDUH FRPSRUWDPHQWXO SHUVRDQHL R SRDWH
FUHDFHORUGLQMXUFRQIRUPPHQWDOLW LLFRPXQH
3URFHGXUD GH VHOHF LH D DGMHFWLYHORU SHQWUX VFDOH D FRQVWDW vQ
JHQHUDOvQXWLOL]DUHD$&/*RXJK±+HLOEUXQGHF WUHJUXSXULGHSHU
VRDQHFDUHFXQRVFVXELHFWXO LQW SHUVRDQHF URUDOLVHFHUHV DOHDJ
GLQWUH FHL GH WHUPHQL DL VFDOHL DGMHFWLYHOH FDUH FDUDFWHUL]HD]
VXELHFWXO $FHOH DGMHFWLYH DVXSUD F URUD VH RE LQH XQ DFRUG DX IRVW
FRQVLGHUDWHFDGHVFULSWLYHSHQWUXVXELHFW*UXSXOXLGHVXELHF L LQW OL
VD DGPLQLVWUDW LQYHQWDUXO &DOLIRUQLD úL VD GHWHUPLQDW SULQ FDOFXOH
VWDWLVWLFH OLVWD GH DGMHFWLYH FDUH FDUDFWHUL]HD] FRPSRUWDPHQWXO XQXL
VXELHFWPDVFXOLQVDXIHPLQLQvQRFKLLRSLQLHLSXEOLFHSHQWUXVFRUXULOH
vQDOWHúLVFRUXULOHVF ]XWHDOHILHF UHLVFDOH
ÌQJHQHUDOVHUHFRPDQG FDvQDQDOL]DDGMHFWLYDO V VHHYLWHJH
QHUDOL] UL FDUH V GHS úHDVF GDWHOH HúDQWLRQXOXL LQL LDO 'H H[HPSOX
IDSWXO F VWXGHQ LL FDUH DX RE LQXW XQ 'R vQDOW DX IRVW GHVFULúL FD
DPEL LRúL QX QH vQGUHSW HúWH V DSOLF P WHUPHQXO úL XQRU SDFLHQ L
SVLKLDWULFLFDUHDX'RvQDOW
2 WHQGLQ D vQFHS WRULORU HVWH V DSOLFH DGMHFWLYHOH GHVFULSWLYH
GLUHFW I U V LD vQ FRQVLGHUDUH FkW GH PXOW DU SXWHD V PRGLILFH R
LQWHUSUHWDUHVWULFWPRGDO QLYHOXODEVROXWDOVFRUXULORULQGLYLGXOXLVDX
FRQILJXUD LDJHQHUDO
8WLOL]DWH FX DFHVWH SUHFL] UL DGMHFWLYHOH IXUQL]HD] DVSHFWH
UHOHYkQG YDOLGLWDWHD GH FRQVWUXFW D VFDOHL $QDOL]HOH DGMHFWLYDOH SRW
VXJHUD FRUHOD LL QHDúWHSWDWH GH H[HPSOX FRPSRQHQWD GH QDUFLVLVP D
VFRUXULORU 6D vQDOWH D IRVW VXUSULQV PDL vQWkL GH GDWHOH $&/ 'H
DVHPHQHD HVWH VHPQLILFDWLY GH QRWDW F DQDOL]HOH DGMHFWLYDOH SRW IL
IRDUWHXWLOHSULQIDSWXOF SXQvQHYLGHQ VHPQLILFD LDVFRUXULORUMRDVH
'H H[HPSOX SHQWUX XQ VFRU 'R VF ]XW QX DYHP GRDU LQGLFD LD F
VXELHFWXOXLvLOLSVHúWHDELOLWDWHDGHDFRQGXFHFLúLIDSWXOF HYRUEDGH
RSHUVRDQ LPSUHYL]LELO GHWDúDW UHODWLYRVWLO úLDOLHQDW
$QDOL]D DGMHFWLYDO VXJHUHD] DFFHQWH GLIHULWH SHQWUX ILHFDUH
VFDO PDL DOHV vQ UDSRUW FX VH[XO VXELHFWXOXL úL FX FRPSRUWDPHQWXO
V X 'H H[HPSOX vQ GHVFULHUHD XQHL SHUVRDQH FDUH DUH VFRUXUL PDL
vQDOWHOD'RID GH&VVHSXQHDFFHQWSHIRU DúLGLQDPLVPXOV XÌQ
LQWHUSUHWDUH HVWH LPSRUWDQW V QX VH XLWH UHOHYDQ D FRQWH[WXOXL VRFLR
FXOWXUDOúLGLIHUHQ HOHGHPHQWDOLWDWHSRVLELOHvQWUHGLIHULWHFXOWXULVDX
VXEFXOWXUL2UHDO DGDSWDUHDUFHUHUHIDFHUHDSHSRSXOD LDDXWRKWRQ
úLDOLVWHORUGHDGMHFWLYHGHVFULSWLYH
'XS DQDOL]H UHDOL]DWH vQ IXQF LH GH VLWXD LD FRQFUHW D SURWR
FROXOXLSHDFHOHSDWHUQXULFDUHSRWGDVHQVúLSRWU VSXQGHXQRULSRWH]H
IRUPXODWHSRUQLQGGHODLVWRULDFD]XOXLGHODYkUVWDúLVH[XOVXELHFWXOXL
VHWUHFHODUH LQHUHDDFHORULSRWH]HFDUHYRUFRQVWLWXLVWUXFWXUDH[SOLFDWLY
JHQHUDO úL OD FRUHODUHD ORU FX DOWH GDWH GLQ GRVDUXO VXELHFWXOXL FDUH
FRQILUP VDX LQILUP VHPQLILFD LLOH ORU $YHP DVWIHO vQ ILQDO DVSHFWH
FDUH VXQW FRH]LYH JUXSkQG vQ MXUXO ORU R PXOWLWXGLQH GH FDUDFWHULVWLFL
FDOLWDWLYH GDU DYHP úL DVSHFWH FDUH DSDU FRQWUDGLFWRULL úL FHU DQDOL]H
VXSOLPHQWDUHSULQQRLWHVWHVDXFODULILF ULODQLYHOXOLQWHUYLXOXL
1X H[LVW IRUPXOH LGHDOH GH LQWHUSUHWDUH D SURILOXOXL7RDWH LQWHU
SUHW ULOHWUHEXLHV XUPH]HGDWHOHFD]XOXLLQGLYLGXDOFHOHFkWHYDWLSXUL
GH JUXS UL QX HSXL]HD] VHQVXULOH QHDúWHSWDWH GDU UHDOH SH FDUH OH SRW
DYHDFRUHOD LLOHGLQWUHVHPQLILFD LLOHFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHDOHPRGXOXLFXP
YDULD] VFDOHOH 'LQ DFHVW SXQFW GH YHGHUH WHVWXO &3, SHUPLWH LQWHU
SUHW ULIOH[LELOHQXDQ DWHvQUDSRUWGLUHFWFXFD]XOVWXGLDWFHHDFHSRDWH
FRQGXFHSVLKRORJXOúLVSUHLSRWH]HFDUHGHS úHVFGDWHOHVWULFWFRPSRUWD
PHQWDOH$VWIHOSXWHPDYHDFRQILJXUD LLFDUHLQGLF GLVIXQF LLODQLYHOXO
LPDJLQLL GH VLQH GRPLQDQ D XQRU FRPSOH[H úL PHFDQLVPH GH DS UDUH
HPHUJHQ DSRVLELO DXQRUFRPSRUWDPHQWHDJUHVLYHVDXRSR]DQWH
6XEOLQLHPGLQQRXLPSRUWDQ DLQWHUSUHW ULLGDWHORUvQIXQF LHGH
YkUVWD VXELHFWXOXL 'H H[HPSOX vQ VLWXD LD XQXL DGROHVFHQW D F UXL
SHUVRQDOLWDWH HVWH vQ IRUPDUH VHPQLILFD LD XQRU RSR]DQ H VDX D XQRU
VF GHUL D VFRUXULORU OD 6D úL :E HVWH PDL SX LQ JUDY GHFkW SHQWUX R
SHUVRDQ PDWXU D F UHL SHUVRQDOLWDWH HVWH GHMD VWUXFWXUDW vQ MXUXO
DFHVWRU IRUPD LXQL SVLKLFH GHILFLWDUH SUHFXP RLPDJLQHGHVLQHQHJD
WLY XQPRGSHVLPLVWúLQHJDWLYGHDúLSHUFHSHúLWU LYLD D
'DWHOHGHFHUFHWDUHSULYLQGFRUHODWHOHXQRUDGLQWUHVFDOHOH&3,úL
VFDOH ID HWH DOH FKHVWLRQDUXOXL WLS %LJ )LYH 1(2 ± 3, 5 LQGLF XQ
PRGHOFRPXQúLFHUWLILF YDOLGLWDWHDGLVFULPLQDWLY DID HWHORU&RVWDúL
0F&UDHLGHQWLILF FRUHO ULVHPQLILFDWLYHvQWUH'RGRPL
QDQ úL ( DILUPDUH QHJDWLY ,Q LQGHSHQGHQ úL 1 FRQúWLLQ
GHVLQH,QLQGHSHQGHQ úL&FRPSHWHQ 6DDFFHSWDUHDGHVLQH
úL ( DFWLYLVPXO QHJDWLY 6S SUH]HQ D VRFLDO úL $ PRGHVWLD
(PHPSDWLDúL2GHVFKLGHUHDVSUHPRGXULOHSURSULLGHDVLP L(P
HPSDWLDúL2GHVFKLGHUHDvQSODQXODF LXQLORUQHJDWLY 6FDXWRFRQ
WUROXOúL1LPSXOVLYLWDWHDQHJDWLY 6FDXWRFRQWUROXOúL(F XWDUHD
H[FLWD LHL 6F DXWRFRQWUROXO úL $ DOWUXLVPXO 6F DXWRFRQWUROXO úL
$EXQ YRLQ D6RVRFLDOL]DUHúL(HPR LLSR]LWLYH*LLPSUHVLH
EXQ úL & VLP XO GDWRULHL $F UHDOL]DUH SULQ FRQIRUPLVP úL &
FRPSHWHQ $FUHDOL]DUHSULQFRQIRUPLVPúL&VLP XOGDWRULHL$F
UHDOL]DUHSULQFRQIRUPLVPúL&GLVFLSOLQ GHVLQH$LUHDOL]DUHSULQ
LQGHSHQGHQ úL2GHVFKLGHUHvQSODQXOYDORULORU)[IOH[LELOLWDWHúL
2 GHVFKLGHUH VSUH IDQWH]LH )[ IOH[LELOLWDWH úL 2 GHVFKLGHUH vQ
SODQXOYDORULORU)HIHPLQLWDWHúL$DOWUXLVP
8WLOL]DUHDGDWHORU&3,vQFRQVLOLHUHDHGXFD LRQDO
úLYRFD LRQDO
&KHVWLRQDUXO GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH &DOLIRUQLD FRQVWLWXLH XQXO GLQWUH
FHOHPDLFXQRVFXWHúLPDLDSOLFDWHLQVWUXPHQWH
ÌQ PDQXDOXO &3,XOXL *RXJK VFULH H[SOLFLW F WHVWXO HVWH vQ
SULPXOUkQGSHQWUXVXELHF LQRUPDOLI U WXOEXU ULSVLKLDWULFH6FDOHOH
VDOH VH DGUHVHD] vQ SULQFLSDO DFHORU FDUDFWHULVWLFL DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL
FDUH VXQW LPSRUWDQWH SHQWUX FRQYLH XLUHD VRFLDO úL UHOD LRQDUHD LQWHU
SHUVRQDO 'HúL VWXGLLOH UHDOL]DWH FX WHVWXO DX GRYHGLW XWLOLWDWHD VD
SHQWUX SUREOHPDWLFD XQRU JUXSXUL VSHFLDOH SUHFXP WHQGLQ HOH DQWLVR
FLDOHVDXVSUHGHOLQFYHQ WRWXúLFHDPDLODUJ XWLOL]DUHHVWHLQGLFDW
SHQWUX SUREOHPDWLFD GLQ úFROL FROHJLL LQGXVWULH úL DIDFHUL VDX GLQ
DFHOH LQVWLWX LL PHGLFDOH úL DFHOH ELURXUL GH FRQVLOLHUH FDUH VXQW D[DWH
SHSUREOHPHGHQHDGDSWDUHVRFLDO 0HJDUJHH
8WLOL] ULOH VXQW PXOWLSOH FXP YDULDWH VXQW úL PRGDOLW LOH GH
DGPLQLVWUDUHDWHVWXOXL
ÌQSULYLQ DFHORUGLQXUP SXWHPFRQVHPQDGHH[HPSOXFkWHYD
GLQWUHFHOHPDLVSHFLDOL]DWH$VWIHOGDF GHUHJXO &3,VHDGPLQLV
WUHD] FD SURE GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH DO WXUL GH DOWH SUREH SVLKRORJLFH
H[LVW úLXWLOL] ULVLQJXODUHVSHFLDOL]DWH'HH[HPSOXvQGHWHUPLQDUHD
GLVWDQ HL GLQWUH LPDJLQHD GH VLQH DFFHSWDW GH VXELHFW úL HXO LGHDO
3URFHGXUD VH DSOLF vQ VLWXD LD XQRU FD]XUL GH FRQVLOLHUH FRPSRUWD
PHQWDO VDXFOLQLF FkQGGHH[HPSOXVHSRDWHFHUHXQXLDGROHVFHQW
VDXXQXLQHYURWLFV FRPSOHWH]HWHVWXODGRXDRDU DúDFXPDUGRULV
ILHÌQFRQVLOLHUHDFOLQLF VHSRDWHDSOLFDvQVHQVXOXQHLLPDJLQLUHWUR
VSHFWLYH FDUH V DILUPH PRGXOvQFDUHVHDSUHFLDVXELHFWXOvQVLWXD LL
WUHFXWHFRPSDUDWLYFXVLWXD LDSUH]HQW
ÌQFRQVLOLHUHDGHIDPLOLHvQFHUFHW ULOHGHWLSFOLQLFDXIRVWWHV
WD LDGROHVFHQ LFXGHYLD LLFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHÌQDVWIHOGHVLWXD LLWHVWXO
VHDGPLQLVWUHD] DWkWSDFLHQWXOXLFkWúLPHPEULORUIDPLOLHLSHQWUXDVH
VWDELOL QDWXUD UHOD LLORU GH IDPLOLH HYHQWXDOHOH PRGHOH FRPSRUWD
PHQWDOHFDUHLQIOXHQ HD] FRQGXLWDDGROHVFHQWXOXLLQFRQJUXHQ HOHVDX
FKLDU LQFRPSDWLELOLW LOH GLQWUH PHPEULL IDPLOLHL FDUH SRW VWD OD ED]D
XQXLFRQIOLFWGHVFKLVVDXDVFXQV
'HDVHPHQHDVHSRWVWXGLDSURILOHOHVR LORUFkQGH[LVW FRQIOLFWH
LQWHUSHUVRQDOH vQWUH VR úL VR LH VDX DOWH SHUHFKL GLQ VIHUD IDPLOLHL
RSHUkQGXVHSULQSURFHGXUDDQDOL]HLGHSURIXQ]LPHDFHORUGRX SUR
WRFRDOHFRUHOkQGVHPQLILFD LDVFRUXULORUODGLIHULWHVFDOH
ÌQIXQF LHGHRELHFWLYHOHWHVW ULLJHQHUDOHVHSRWDSOLFDúLIRUPXOH
GLQ HFXD LLOH GH UHJUHVLH FDOFXODWH SHQWUX SUHGLF LD FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL
GHOLQFYHQWDHILFLHQ HLúFRODUHúLDFDGHPLFHJHQHUDOHDVXFFHVXOXLSUR
IHVLRQDOvQGLIHULWHSURIHVLXQLHWF0HJDUJHH*RXJK
$VWIHO GH VWXGLL QX DX IRVW UHDOL]DWH vQF SH SRSXOD LD URPk
QHDVF DúD vQFkW IRUPXOHOH DPHULFDQH DX PDL DOHV XQ URO RULHQWDWLY
LQIRUPkQGXQH GHVSUH DFHOH WU V WXUL FDUH vQ FRQWH[WXO VRFLRFXOWXUDO
UHVSHFWLYVXQWLPSOLFDWHvQVXFFHVXOVRFLDOVDXSURIHVLRQDO
9RPSUH]HQWDFkWHYDGLQWUHHFXD LLOHSUHGLFWLYHRE LQXWHFXDMX
WRUXOVWXGLLORUGHYDOLGDUHSUHGLFWLY DVFDOHORU&3,
7DEHOXO7LSXULGHHFXD LLGHUHJUHVLHSULYLQGSRQGHUHD
XQRUDGLQWUHVFDOHOH&3,vQSUHGLF LDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL
7LSGHSUHGLF LH
(FXD LD
DXWRUXOVWXGLXOXL
5HXúLWDODQLYHOXOOLFHXOXL*RXJK D&V±6S
6R±*L$F
DSHQWUXE LH L E5H6R±
ESHQWUXIHWH *L$F$L
,H
5HDOL]DUHDDFDGHPLF ODQLYHOXOFR D±6S±6F
OHJLXOXL SHQWUX SVLKRORJLH *RXJK $F$L,H
3\
DSHQWUXE LH L E±6\5H±
ESHQWUXIHWH *L±&P$L
3\
(ILFLHQ D vQ SUHGDUH FD SURIHVRU 6R±*L
'XUIOLQJHUúL+LOO $F3\±)[
(ILFLHQ D vQ SURIHVLD GH PHGLF GH 6\ 7R &P ±
IDSWSUHGLF LDGHDDMXQJHXQPHGLF &V
EXQ*RXJKúL+DOO
6FDOHOHDEUHYLDWH003,
&KHVWLRQDUXO &DOLIRUQLD HVWH FRQVWUXLW FX VFRSXO HYDOX ULL SHU
VRQDOLW LL QRUPDOH ([LVW R VHULH GH VWXGLL UHDOL]DWH FX FKHVWLRQDUXO
&3, FDUH DUDW F WHVWXO QX HVWH OD IHO GH HILFLHQW FkQG VH DSOLF SH
JUXSXULGHVXELHF LFXSUREOHPHSVLKRSDWRORJLFHPDMRUHvQVHQVXOF
GHúLVFRUXULOHMRDVHLQGLF QHDGDSWDUHDVDXRDGDSWDUHSURDVW LQYHQ
WDUXOQXGLVFULPLQHD] GLIHULWHPRGHOHGHQHDGDSWDUHúLDUHRXWLOLWDWH
OLPLWDW vQGLDJQR]DGLIHUHQ LDO DVLPSWRPDWRORJLHLFOLQLFH(VWHPDL
XWLO GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD QHDGDSW ULL SHQWUX VXELHF L GHOLQFYHQ L FULPLQDOL
VDX SHQWUX FHL DOH F URU SUREOHPH SRUQHVF GLQ FRQIOLFWHOH H[LVWHQWH
vQWUHLQGLYLGúLVRFLHWDWHLDUQXGLQFRQIOLFWHLQWUDSVLKLFH
&3,SRDWHILPDLGHJUDE XWLOL]DWvQGLDJQR]DSVLKRSDWRORJLF
SHQWUXDVXSOLPHQWDDOWHWHVWHSURSULX]LVFOLQLFHSULQWUHFDUH003,
VDXWHVWHOHSURLHFWLYH$VWIHOSRDWHILXWLOvQ
±HYDOXDUHDFDQGLGD LORUSHQWUXJUXSXULOHGHWHUDSLHIRUPDWLYHvQ
P VXUD vQ FDUH GHWHFWHD] PRGHOH GH FRPSRUWDPHQW LQWHUSHU
VRQDOSULQWUHRDPHQLLFDUHIXQF LRQHD] UHODWLYQRUPDO
±GHWHFWDUHDXQRUDVSHFWHSXWHUQLFSR]LWLYHvQVWUXFWXUDXQHLSHU
VRQDOLW LFXSUREOHPHSVLKLDWULFH
±vQSURJQR]HSULYLQGJUDGXOvQFDUHVXELHFWXOSRDWHSURILWDGHSH
XUPDXQRUSURJUDPHGHSVLKRWHUDSLHYRFD LRQDO HGXFD LRQDO
úLGHUHDELOLWDUH
,PSRUWDQW SHQWUX PRGXO GH XWLOL]DUH D U VSXQVXULORU OD WHVWXO
&3,HVWHIDSWXOF RPDUHSDUWHGLQWUHLWHPLLSUREHLDXIRVWSUHOXD L
GLUHFW GLQ 003, VDX VXQW FYDVLVLPLODUL DFHVWXLD 3URSRU LD GH LWHPL
FRPXQLYDULD] GHODODPHGLDGH
([LVW VWXGLL5RGJHUV0HJDUJHHFDUHDXLGHQWLILFDW
FRUHOD LL IRDUWH ULGLFDWH vQWUH VFRUXULOH OD VFDOHOH 003, FRQVWUXLWH SH
ED]D &3, úL VFDOHOH 003, FRPSOHWH vQWUH úL PHGLD GH
FHHD FH D SHUPLV vQ FRQWLQXDUH UHDOL]DUHD HFXD LLORU GH UHJUHVLH
SHQWUXDSXWHDHVWLPDVFRUXULOHEUXWHSHQWUXVFDOHOH003,I U FRUHF LDN
SRUQLQG GH OD VFDOHOH FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH SRVLELOH GDU DEUHYLDWH
FRQVWLWXLWH GLQ LWHPLL &3, 3HQWUX D DMXQJH OD DFHVWH VFDOH DEUHYLDWH
&3,5RGJHUVXWLOL]HD] HFXD LD\ D[EvQFDUH\UHSUH]LQW VFRUXO
EUXW HVWLPDW DO VFDOHL FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH GLQ 003, [ UHSUH]LQW VFRUXO
EUXWDOVFDOHLDEUHYLDWHFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHGLQLWHPLLWHVWXOXL&3,LDUDúL
E UHSUH]LQW FRQVWDQWH FDOFXODWH SHQWUX ILHFDUH GLQWUH DFHVWH VFDOH &X
DFHVWHVFRUXULEUXWHÄ\´WUHEXLHSURFHGDWvQFRQWLQXDUHFRQIRUPFRUHF
LLORURELúQXLWHFDUHVHDSOLF VFRUXULORUEUXWHRE LQXWHGLQDGPLQLVWUDUHD
SURSULX]LV D003,SHQWUXDVHDMXQJHvQILQDOODXWLOL]DUHDHWDORDQHORU
úLDSURILOXOXLSVLKRSDWRORJLF
'HVLJXURDVWIHOGHXWLOL]DUHDLWHPLORU&3,DSDUHFDXQVSULMLQ
vQVLWXD LLOHGHXUJHQ SHQWUXVXELHF LLFDUHSUH]LQW vQSURILOXO&3,
XQHOH DVSHFWH FDUH vQGUHSW HVF R VXVSLFLXQH DVXSUD JUDYLW LL XQRU
VLPSWRPH SVLKRSDWRORJLFH $FHDVW OLQLH GH UD LRQDPHQW SRDWH IL
YHULILFDW UDSLG SULQ DSOLFDUHD JULOHORU SHQWUX VFDOHOH DEUHYLDWH úL D
SURFHGXULORU FDUH SHUPLW DSUR[LPDUHD vQ ILQDO D XQXL SRVLELO SURILO
SVLKRSDWRORJLF &HL FDUH QX SRW VDX QX YRU V DGPLQLVWUH]H DPEHOH
LQYHQWDUHSRWIRORVLLWHPLLORUFRPXQLSHQWUXDHVWLPDVFRUXULOHSHQWUX
VFDOHOHFHOXLODOWLQYHQWDU'LQGDWHOHGHFHUFHWDUH0HJDUJHHHVWLPHD]
F GLQWUH VFDOHOH &3, QXPDL XQHOH SRW IL HVWLPDWH SOHFkQG GH OD
003, SHQWUX FRPSDUD LL SULYLQG JUXSXUL GH LQGLYL]L UHVSHFWLY 'R
&V6\:E5H7R$F$LGDUSHQWUXLQWHUSUHW ULLQGLYLGXDOHGRDU
GRX VFDOH:EúL7R
9DULDQWDD&3,úLPRGHOXOFXERLG
&3,6FDOHOHVWDQGDUG
ÌQ DQXO *RXJK SXEOLF XOWLPD YHUVLXQH D FKHVWLRQDUXOXL
PRGLILFDW SH GH R SDUWH SULQ LQFOXGHUHD D vQF GRX VFDOH FDUH SUH
]HQWDXRVWDELOLWDWHúLYDOLGLWDWHELQHGHPRQVWUDWHSULQFRHUHQ DGDWHORU
GHFHUFHWDUHUHVSHFWLYFHORUVFDOHVWDQGDUGOLVDXDG XJDWvQF GRX
VFDOHVWDQGDUGÄLQGHSHQGHQ D´úLÄHPSDWLD´3LWDULX$OEX
ÌQDIDUDDFHVWRUGHVFDOHVWDQGDUGQRXO&3,GHILQHúWHúLXQ
QXP UGHVFDOHFXÄRULHQWDUHVSHFLDO ´FDGHH[HPSOXÄSRWHQ LDO
PDQDJHULDO´ÄRULHQWDUHF WUHPXQF ´ÄWHPSHUDPHQWFUHDWLY´ÄVFDO
XQLSRODU SHQWUX PDVFXOLQLWDWH´ ÄVFDO XQLSRODU SHQWUX IHPLQLWDWH´
ÄVFDOD /HYHQGKDO SHQWUX DQ[LHWDWH´ ÄVFDOD GH QDUFLVLVP´ ÄVFDOD GH
RULHQWDUH VSUH vQW ULUHD OHJDO ´ HWF 'LQWUH HOH FHD FDUH DUH FHOH PDL
VHULRDVH úDQVH V ILH LQFOXV SULQWUH VFDOHOH VWDQGDUG HVWH FHD GH WHP
SHUDPHQWFUHDWLY&W
1RLOH VFDOH VWDQGDUG FDUH VDX DG XJDW FHORU DQWHULRDUH HYD
OXHD] FRPSRUWDPHQWXOvQXUP WRULLWHUPHQL
,QVFDODGHLQGHSHQGHQ HVWHIRUPDW GLQGHLWHPLúLHVWH
GHVWLQDW P VXU ULLUHVXUVHORULQGLYLGXOXLúLGLVWDQ HLGLQWUHVLQHúLFHL
ODO L 6FRUXULOH vQDOWH LQGLF XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW LQGHSHQGHQW HFKLOLEUDW
úLUHODWLYGHWDúDWGHFHLODO L
6FRUXULOHVXEPHGLHLQGLF WHQGLQ DGHDF XWDVSULMLQGLQSDUWHD
DOWRUDGHDHYLWDFRQIOLFWHOHGHDvQWkU]LDVDXGHDHYLWDDF LXQHD
(PVFDODGHHPSDWLHHYDOXHD] LQWXL LDúLUH]RQDQ DDIHFWLYFRJ
QLWLY ID GHDOWHSHUVRDQH1RWHOHSHVWHPHGLHLQGLF XQVHQWLPHQWGH
FRQIRUWSHUVRQDOúLDFFHSWDUHDGHF WUHFHLGLQMXURULHQWDWVSUHVHVL]DUHD
QXDQ HORUVRFLDOHúLVSUHRSWLPLVP
6FRUXULOHVXEPHGLHLQGLF XQFRPSRUWDPHQWQHHPSDWLFVFHSWLF
vQUHOD LLOHFXFHLODO LGHIHQVLYvQUDSRUWFXGRULQ HOHVDXVHQWLPHQWHOH
DOWRUD
*UXSDUHDGHLQWHUSUHWDUHSHFDUHRRIHU QRXDYDULDQW FXSULQGH
HYDOXDUHDVWLOXOXLúLRULHQW ULLLQWHUSHUVRQDOH'R&V6\6S
6D,Q(P
HYDOXDUHD RULHQW ULL QRUPDWLYH úL D YDORULORU 5H 6R 6F *L
&P:E7R
HYDOXDUHDIXQF LRQ ULLFRJQLWLYHúLLQWHOHFWXDOH$F$L,H
HYDOXDUHDSHUFHSHULLUROXOXLúLVWLOXOXLSHUVRQDO3\)[)0
'DWHOH VWDWLVWLFH SULYLQG H[SHULPHQWDUHD WHVWXOXL SH SRSXOD LD
URPkQHDVF RIHULWH GH 3LWDULX úL $OEX SHUPLW UHDOL]DUHD XQRU QRUP UL
DXWRKWRQHRULHQWDWLYH
0RGHOXOFXERLG
ÌQDIDUDSURFHGXULLVWDQGDUGGHLQWHUSUHWDUHDVFDOHORUFDUHQXGL
IHU GHYDULDQWDDQWHULRDU FDSDúLúLFDPRGDOLW LQRXDYDULDQW LQFOXGH
vQ SOXV R QRX SRVLELOLWDWH UHVSHFWLY UHIHULUHD OD XQ PRGHO DO SHUVR
QDOLW LLGHQXPLWGH*RXJKÄPRGHOXOFXERLG´*RXJKRIHU XQPRGHO
FRQFHSWXDODVXSUDVWUXFWXULLSHUVRQDOLW LLXWLOL]kQGFDD[HFDUGLQDOHWUHL
YHFWRUL FI 3LWDULX $OEX YHFWRUXO FDUH VHPQLILF VWLOXO
LQWHUSHUVRQDOYHFWRUXOFDUHVHPQLILF UDSRUWDUHDODQRUPHOHVRFLDOH
úLYHFWRUXOFDUHVHPQLILF VHQWLPHQWXOSHUVRQDOGHFRPSHWHQ
$FHúWL YHFWRUL P VXUD L SULQ VFDOH VSHFLDO VWUXFWXUDWH VXQW vQ
FRQFHS LD OXL *RXJK WUHL GLPHQVLXQL FDUGLQDOH DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL
UHVSRQVDELOH GH VWLOXO SHUVRQDO FDUH HVWH VSHFLILF FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL
GHVI úXUDWDOSHUVRDQHL
$FHVWH GLPHQVLXQL WUHEXLH vQ HOHVH FD XQ FRQWLQXXP GH OD XQ
PD[LPVSUHXQPLQLPGHDOXQJXOF UXLD*RXJKSUH]LQW úDSWHQLYHOH
GHFRPSRUWDPHQWFDUHGHILQHVFLQWHUFRUHODUHDYHFWRULORUODQLYHOXOXQHL
VHF LXQL WUDQVYHUVDOH D PRGHOXOXL FXERLG 0DL H[DFW LQWHUVHF LD
YHFWRUXOXLH[WUDYHUVLD±LQWURYHUVLDúLDYHFWRUXOXLGHSHQGHQ D±
LQGHSHQGHQ DGHQRUPHSULOHMXLHúWHGHILQLUHDDSDWUXVWLOXULFRPSRU
WDPHQWDOH GHQXPLWH GH *RXJK FX OLWHUHOH JUHFHúWL DOID H[WUDYHUW úL
GHSHQGHQW EHWD LQWURYHUW úL GHSHQGHQW JDPD H[WUDYHUW úL LQGH
SHQGHQWúLGHOWDLQWURYHUWúLLQGHSHQGHQW
$FHVWHSDWUX]RQHDOHLQWHUVHF LHLGLQWUHYHFWRUXO,úL,,FDS W XQ
VSHFLILFSULQUDSRUWDUHDODYHFWRUXOvQFUHGHUH±QHvQFUHGHUHvQVLQHúL
YDULD] GHDOXQJXODFHVWHLGLPHQVLXQL*RXJKGHILQHúWHúDSWHWLSXULGH
DOID GH OD FDULVPDWLF OD DXWRULWDU WUHFkQG SULQ QLYHOXO PDQLSXODWLY
úDSWHWLSXULGHEHWDGHODYLUWXRVODFRQIRUPLVWWUHFkQGODQLYHOXOSULQ
FRQYHQ LRQDOúDSWHWLSXULGHJDPDGHODFUHDWLYODDQWLVRFLDOWUHFkQG
OD QLYHOXO SULQ vQVWU LQDW úDSWH WLSXUL GH GHOWD GH OD FRPSOH[ OD
LQVWDELOWUHFkQGODQLYHOXOSULQFRQIOLFWXDO3ROXOVXSHULRUHVWHGHILQLW
SULQ FRQWULEX LD PD[LP D vQFUHGHULL vQ VLQH ID GH SROXO LQIHULRU
GHILQLWSULQFRQWULEX LDPD[LP DQHvQFUHGHULLvQVLQH0RGHOXOFXERLG
HVWH R vQFHUFDUH SDUDOHO PRGHOHORU FLUFXPSOH[H SUH]HQWDWH GH D FX
SULQGH SHUVRQDOLWDWHD vQWUR VWUXFWXU LQWHUSUHWDWLY JHRPHWULF PDL
DSURSLDW GHUHDOLWDWHDYLH1XHVWHGHFLvQWkPSO WRUIDSWXOF H[LVW GHMD
FHUFHW WRUL FDUH vQFHDUF V LQWHJUH]H FHOH GRX WLSXUL GH GDWH GH
FHUFHWDUH $VWIHO -RKQVRQ vQ vQFHDUF V LQWHUSUHWH]H PRGHOXO
FXERLG&3,vQUDSRUWFXPRGHOXOFLUFXPSOH[$E&
ÌQSUH]HQWFKHVWLRQDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH&DOLIRUQLDHVWHXQXOGLQ
WUHFHOHPDLELQHH[SHULPHQWDWHLQVWUXPHQWHSVLKRORJLFHGHHYDOXDUHD
SHUVRQDOLW LL úL HYROXHD] vQ PRG ILUHVF VSUH PRGDOLW L FDUH V
SHUPLW R LQWHUSUHWDUH DSURIXQGDW D GDWHORU vQ LQWHUFRUHOD LD GLPHQ
VLXQLORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
([HPSOLILFDUHDLQWHUSUHW ULLXQXLSURILO
0DWHULDOHQHFHVDUH
&KHVWLRQDUFXLWHPLIRDLDGHU VSXQVJULO HWDORQIRDLHGH
SURILOPDVFXOLQúLIHPLQLQPDQXDOSHQWUXLQWHUSUHWDUHDFDOLW LORUúL
DELOLW LORUGHDFRQYLH XLFXFHLGLQMXU
$SOLFDUH
7HVWXOVHDSOLF I U OLPLW GHWLPSLQVWUXFWDMXOVHIDFHXWLOL]kQG
IRDLD GH U VSXQV SHQWUX H[HPSOLILFDUH 6XELHFWXO HVWH DYHUWL]DW V QX
RPLW QLFL XQ U VSXQV úL V U VSXQG FkW PDL RQHVW SHQWUX FD UH]XO
WDWHOH V vO UHSUH]LQWH 6H DSOLF LQGLYLGXDO VDX FROHFWLY 5HFRPDQGDW
SHQWUXDGXO LúLWLQHUL
&RWDUH
6HDSOLF VXFFHVLYJULOHOHSHQWUXILHFDUHVFDO 6HDFRUG XQSXQFW
SHQWUXILHFDUHU VSXQVFDUHFRLQFLGHJULOHORU6HIDFHVXPDQRWHORUEUXWH
SHQWUX ILHFDUH VFDO vQ SDUWH úL VH PDUFKHD] SH IRDLD GH SURILO 6H
GHWHUPLQ QRWHOHVWDQGDUGFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHFRQIRUPQRWHORU7vQVFULVH
vQFRORDQHOHODWHUDOHGLQVWkQJDúLGUHDSWDúLVHGHVHQHD] SURILOXO
,QWHUSUHWDUH
6HIDFHFRQIRUPLQGLFD LLORUGLQPDQXDOXOWHVWXOXL
5H]XOWDWHOHRE LQXWHGHVXELHFWXO$%IHPHLHDQLSHVFDOHOH
&3,VXQWXUP WRDUHOH
6FDOH 'R&V6\6S6D:E 5H6R6F7R*L&P $F$L,H3\)[)H
1RWHEUXWH
1RWHVWDQGDUG
3ULPXO SDV DO LQWHUSUHW ULL FRQVW vQ YHULILFDUHD YDOLGLW LL
SURILOXOXL ,Q DFHVW VFRS VH DQDOL]HD] UH]XOWDWHOH RE LQXWH SH VFDOHOH
:E&P*L3HQLFLXQDGLQDFHVWHVFDOHVXELHFWXOQXDUHUH]XOWDWHVXE
QVFHHDFHvQVHDPQ F VXELHFWXOQXDvQFHUFDWV GLVLPXOH]HVDX
V U VSXQG OD vQWkPSODUH 1LFL SHQWUX VFDOD *L YDORDUHD QRWHL 7 QX
GHS úHúWH]RQDPHGLHL&DXUPDUHSURILOXOHVWHLQWHUSUHWDELOFDDWDUH
$OGRLOHDSDVFRQVW vQLQWHUSUHWDUHDFRUHODWLY DSHUIRUPDQ HORU
SH VFDOH ÌQ DFHVW VFRS VH IRORVHVF ÄSDWHUQXULOH´ LQWHUSUHWDWLYH 5H
]XOWDWHOH RE LQXWH GH VXELHFWXO ;; SHUPLW XUP WRDUHD FDUDFWHUL]DUH
GLILFXOW LOH GH UHOD LRQDUH LQWHUSHUVRQDO SHUIRUPDQ H VXE PHGLH SH
VFDOHOH'R&V6\6S6D:EVXQWJHQHUDWHGHOLSVDGHvQFUHGHUHvQVLQH
6D úL FRQIOLFWH PDVFDWH :E &DXUPDUHHVWHUHWUDV W FXW
WLPLG 'R SX LQ DPEL LRDV &V SX LQ SULHWHQRDV 6\
W FXW LQKLEDW FRQYHQ LRQDO 6S
'LQ SXQFWXO GH YHGHUH DO RULHQW ULL PRUDOH HVWH SHUFHSXW FD R
SHUVRDQ FDUH GRUHúWH V IDF R EXQ LPSUHVLH VRFLDO *L HVWH
FRQúWLLQFLRDV vQOLPLWHPHGLL5HWROHUDQW WRWvQOLPLWHPHGLL7R
FX SRVLELOH H[SOR]LL GH PkQLH vQ FRQGL LLOH XQXL DXWRFRQWURO
VXEPHGLH6FúLDOHLQWHULRUL] ULLUHODWLYHDQRUPHORUVRFLDOH&P
6R'LQSXQFWXOGHYHGHUHDOIXQF LRQmULLFRJQLWLYHúLLQWHOHF
WXDOH VH GH]YROW úL vQYD PDL ELQHvQWUXQPHGLXVWUXFWXUDWRUGRQDW
$F ILLQG FRQúWLLQFLRDV úL WLQ]kQG V UHVSHFWH FRQYHQ LLOH ÌQ
VLWXD LLvQFDUHPRGHOXOGHUHDOL]DUHOLSVHúWHVHSRDWHDGDSWDGDUFXR
UHODWLY GLILFXOWDWH $L /LSVD GH vQFUHGHUH vQ VLQH 6D HVWH
FRUHODW UH]XOWDWHORU VXE PHGLH GLQ SXQFWXO GH YHGHUH DO RULHQW ULL
LQWHOHFWXDOH $SWLWXGLQLOH FRPSHWHQ HOH LQWHOHFWXDOH SUH]HQWH QX VXQW
XWLOL]DWH HILFLHQW ,H 8úRU ULJLG )[ HVWH FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQ
DWLWXGLQL GHVFKLVH ID GH VHPHQL 3\ WROHUDQ GDU úL LQWHJUDUHD
QRUPDO DDWULEXWHORUGHUROVH[XDO)H
(;7,1'(5,
&HUFHW ULGHVI úXUDWHFXFKHVWLRQDUXO&3,
'HDOXQJXOFHORUSHVWHGHDQLGHXWLOL]DUHWHVWXO&3,QXD
vQFHWDW V ILH RELHFWXO D QXPHURDVH VWXGLL WHPD DFHVWRU VWXGLL ILLQG
SULQWUH DOWHOH úL P VXUD vQ FDUH SULQ LWHPLL OXL VH SRDWH VXUSULQGH úL
DOWFHYDGHFkWFHOHVFDOHVWDQGDUGDOWIHOVSXVFHUHDOLWDWHHPSLULF vL
SRDWH IL DFFHVLELO SVLKRORJXOXL vQ U VSXQVXULOH VXELHFWXOXL =HFL GH
SURJUDPH GH FHUFHWDUH DX SRUQLW GHD OXQJXO DQLORU OD GHWHUPLQDUHD
P VXULLvQFDUHXQHOHFOXVWHUL] ULGHLWHPLSRWFRQVWLWXLVFDOHQRLFDUH
P VRDU DOWH DVSHFWH VSHFLILFH FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL ÌQF GH OD QLYHOXO
DQLORU¶VDXFRQVWLWXLWFHUWLWXGLQLvQMXUXOXQRUDGLQWUHLSRWH]HOHGH
FHUFHWDUHFRQILUPDWHHPSLULF9RPSUH]HQWDvQWURSULP ID] DFHVWH
VFDOH H[SHULPHQWDOH SUH]HQWDWH vQ GH 0HJDUJHH FD VFDOH
ÄH[SHULPHQWDOH´ +DVH VFDOH ÄIDFWRULDO DQDOLWLFH´ VFDOH ÄWHRUHWLFH´ úL
VFDOHÄUD LRQDOH´±XQWRWDOGHGHQRLVFDOHFRQVWUXLUHSRUQLQGGHOD
LWHPLL&3,1HYRPP UJLQLV SUH]HQW PGRDUXQHOHGLQWUHHOHFHOH
FDUHSULQFRQILUP ULOHH[SHULPHQWDOHVDXFRQVWLWXLWvQFHUWLWXGLQL
'HDVHPHQHDXQPDUHQXP UGHFHUFHW ULUHDOL]DWHFX&3,XO
DXvQFHUFDWGXS FXPDPY ]XWV LGHWHUPLQHYDORDUHDGHSUHGLF LH
SHQWUX UHDOL] UL SURIHVLRQDOH DFDGHPLFH HWF 'LQ DVWIHO GH GDWH VDX
GHVSULQV XQHOH FHUFHW UL FDUH VDX D[DW SH IDFWRUXO GH FUHDWLYLWDWH vQ
P VXUD vQ FDUH UHDOL]DUHD FUHDWLY HVWH GHILQLWRULH SHQWUX QLYHOXO GH
GH]YROWDUHúLHILFLHQ DWLQVGHLQGLYLG
) U DLQWUDvQDP QXQWHOHGLVFX LLORUGHVSUHFUHDWLYLWDWHúLSHUVR
QDOLWDWHDFUHDWLY VHPQDO PLQWHUHVXOOXL*RXJKSHQWUXGLIHUHQ LHULGH
ILQH HvQWUHWLSXULGHFUHDWLYLWDWHúLQLYHOXOGHUHDOL]DUHSHUVRQDO VWXGLL
FDUH DX FXSULQV XQ QXP U LPSUHVLRQDQW GH FHUFHW WRUL ILH XWLOL]kQG
&3,SHQWUXDRE LQHGDWHGHVSUHVWUXFWXUDSHUVRQDOLW LLFUHDWLYHILH
SHQWUX D GHILQL R VFDO FDUH V P VRDUH ÄWHPSHUDPHQWXO FUHDWLY´
&3,XODUHOD LRQDWFXQXPHURDVHFULWHULLDOHFUHDWLYLW LLSHXQPDUH
QXP UGHORWXULGHVXELHF L5HOD LLOHVHPQLILFDWLYHGLQSXQFWGHYHGHUH
VWDWLVWLF FRQILUP H[LVWHQ D XQRU GLIHUHQ H GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH vQWUH
RDPHQLL FUHDWLYL úL FHL QRQFUHDWLYL 0RGHOXO FHO PDL FRQVLVWHQW FDUH
VDGHJDMDWGLQFHUFHWDUHHVWHFHOFDUHLQGLF GHH[HPSOXF VXELHF LL
FHLPDLFUHDWLYLDXVFRUXULPDLvQDOWHODVFDOHOHIDFWRUXOXLWUHL±)[$L
úL 3\ FHHD FH GHPRQVWUHD] FODU vQ FRPSRUWDPHQWXO DFHVWRUD R UHV
SLQJHUHDWHQGLQ HORUDXWRULWDUHULJLGHúLDGRJPDWLVPXOXLvQIDYRDUHD
XQHLJkQGLULLQGHSHQGHQWHDXQHLDWLWXGLQLGHVFKLVHúLUHFHSWLYH$VWIHO
GH SHUVRDQH DX úL FRWH PDL ULGLFDWH OD 6S úL 6D LQGLFkQG XQ FRP
SRUWDPHQWDILUPDWLYGDUFXRGLUHF LRQDUHúLVSUHUHDOLWDWHDLQWHULRDU
$FHVWXL PRGHO GH FRYDULHUH D VFDOHORU PHQ LRQDWH L VH DVRFLD] úL
VFRUXULOH FHYD PDL VF ]XWH OD VFDOHOH &P úL 6F FDUH LQGLF LQGHSHQ
GHQ DúLDWLWXGLQLOHQHFRQYHQ LRQDOH
6WXGLLOHURPkQHúWLDXXWLOL]DW&3,úLSUREHGHDELOLWDWHFUHDWLY
HYLGHQ LLQGFDUDFWHULVWLFLGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHFDUHGLIHUHQ LD] vQWUHFUHDWLY
úLQRQFUHDWLY$VWIHO0LQXOHVFXDXWLOL]DWYDULDELOHFDUHVDX
GRYHGLW vQDOW GLVFULPLQDWLYH vQWUH LQYHVWLJDWRUL FUHDWLYL HILFLHQ L úL FHL
QRQFUHDWLYL QRQHILFLHQ L UHVSHFWLY VFDOHOH 6S &P $L ,H úL 3\ GLQ
&3,vPSUHXQ FXWUHLVFDOHGLQ3)4&2úL4SUHFXPúLGRX
P VXULDOHJkQGLULLGLYHUJHQWH±IOH[LELOLWDWHDúLRULJLQDOLWDWHD$QDOL]D
IDFWRULDO D UHOLHIDW SDWUX FRPSRQHQWH SULQFLSDOH UHVSRQVDELOH GH
GLQ YDULDQ D FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL )DFWRUXO , HVWH R FRPSRQHQW
SUHGRPLQDQWFRJQLWLYRSHUD LRQDO FHH[SULP XQVWLOUH]ROXWLYHILFLHQW
IOH[LELO úL RULJLQDO FDSDELO V DERUGH]H V DQDOL]H]H úL V H[WUDJ
VHPQLILFD LLGHRVHELWHGHFHOHUXWLQLHUHSULQXWLOL]DUHDXQHLPXOWLWXGLQL
GHFULWHULLúLRSHUkQGLQGHSHQGHQWvQFkPSXOLQIRUPD LRQDOIDFWRUXO,,
DSURSLDW FD SRQGHUH HVWH SXWHUQLF VDWXUDW vQ YDULDELOHOH 2 ± 3\
$L,HUHSUH]LQW RFRPSRQHQW DWLWXGLQDO±VWLOLVWLF WHQGLQ DVSUH
RUHIOH[LYLWDWHOXFLG FDOP ORJLF YDORUL]kQGLQGHSHQGHQ DGHVSLULWúL
vQFUHGHUHD vQ VLQH PDWXULWDWHD UH]ROXWLY )DFWRULL ,,, úL ,9 VXQW FHYD
PDL SX LQ SUHJQDQ L GDU VHPQLILFDWLYL FkWH SURFHQWH GLQ YDULDQ
UHSUH]LQW GHDVHPHQHDDVSHFWHDWLWXGLQDOH$VWIHOIDFWRUXO,,,VXUSULQGH
GHVFKLGHUHD VSUH VSLULW FULWLF VSUH QRX úL VSUH QRQFRQYHQ LRQDOLVP
VDWXUDWvQ4úL&)DFWRUXO,9DUHXQFRQ LQXWSVLKRORJLFDSURSLDWGH
FHHDFHDPSXWHDGHILQLGUHSWIRU DVXSUDHXOXLSULQDVSHFWXOGHFRQWURO
SULQFHULQ HOHH[WHULRDUHDOHVRFLDOXOXLDVXSUDLQGLYLGXOXLSULQVDWXUD LD
vQ &P úL $L ± 3HQWUX DVWIHO GH VWUXFWXUL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH FUHDWLY DO
F URU LQWHUHV VH IRFDOL]HD] SH FHUFHWDUHD úL UH]ROYDUHD SUREOHPHORU
MXGLFLDUHFRPSOH[HVDUHOLHIDWXQVWLODOHF UXLGHWHUPLQDQWHDWLWXGLQDOH
VXQWGHVFKLGHUHDVSUHUHDOLVPUD LRQDOLWDWHDHFKLOLEUDW úLOXFLG FXXQ
DXWRFRQWURO IOH[LELO SXWHUQLF VRFLDOL]DW 9HFWRUXO FRJQLWLY VHPQLILF
RSHUDUHD PHQWDO vQWUR PDQLHU IOH[LELO úL RULJLQDO FX HYHQLPHQWH
VHPQLILFD LLVHQVXUL
6FDOHH[SHULPHQWDOH
6FDOHOHH[SHULPHQWDOHSHQWUXDP VXUDÄRULHQWDUHDVSUHYDORDUH´
úL ÄRULHQWDUHD VSUH SHUVRDQ ´ DX IRVW GHVWLQDWH SHQWUX VXUSULQGHUHD D
GRL IDFWRUL L]ROD L SULQ DQDOL] IDFWRULDO 6DX FRQVWLWXLW SULQ DGPL
QLVWUDUHD&3,XOXLSHXQORWGHGHSHUVRDQHúLSULQVHOHFWDUHDvQ
PRG VHSDUDW D LWHPLORU FDUH DYHDX R vQF UF WXU IDFWRULDO ULGLFDW
QXPDLODIDFWRUXO,úLUHVSHFWLYDFHORUFDUHFRQWULEXLDXVHPQLILFDWLY
QXPDLODIDFWRUXO,,
)DFWRUXOÄ9R´±RULHQWDUHVSUHYDORDUHFDUHDIRVWH[SHULPHQWDW
GH1LFKROVúL6FKQHOODIRVWGHULYDWSHQWUXDP VXUDFHHDFHvQ
XUPD DQDOL]HL IDFWRULDOH VD JUXSDW FD IDFWRU SULP 'HFL FXSULQGH R
PXO LPH GLQWUH LWHPLL WHVWXOXL FX R vQF UF WXU vQDOW vQ VFDOHOH :E
5H 6R 6F 7R *L úL $F 1RXD VFDO IDFWRULDO D IRVW H[SHULPHQWDW
SULQ FRUHO UL FX VFDOH GLQ 003, *=76 &KHVWLRQDUXO GH SUHIHULQ H
(GZDUGV(33668,%úLVDXRE LQXWFRUHOD LLVHPQLILFDWLYHSR]LWLYH
FXVFDOHúLFRPSRUWDPHQWHLQGLFkQGVWDELOLWDWHDSVLKLF DXWRFRQWUROXO
R EXQ VWUXFWXUDUH D UHOD LLORU LQWHUSHUVRQDOH 'H DVHPHQHD VDX
RE LQXWFRUHOD LLQHJDWLYHFXVFDOHOHGHQHDGDSWDUHúLHPRWLYLWDWH
)DFWRUXO3R±RULHQWDUHVSUHSHUVRDQ ±DIRVWGHULYDWSULQDQD
OL] IDFWRULDO GH1LFKROVúL6FKQHOOFDIDFWRUVHFXQG&XSULQGH
GHLWHPLHYDOXkQGYDULD LDFRPXQ SHQWUXVFDOHOH'R&V6\6S
6D &RUHOHD] H[SHULPHQWDO FX VFDOH GLQ DOWH FKHVWLRQDUH FDUH LQGLF
DFWLYLVPúLGHVFKLGHUHvQFRPSRUWDPHQW
8QVSUH]HFH VFDOH H[SHULPHQWDOH DX IRVW FRQVWUXLWH GH +DVH úL
*ROGEHUJ,QVWLWXWXOGHFHUFHW UL2UHJRQWRWSHED]DDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOH
D LWHPLORU 6FDOHOH FXSULQG GH OD OD GH LWHPL úL VXQW GHQXPLWH
H[WUDYHUVLHYVLQWURYHUVLHFRSLO ULHDUPRQLRDV H[FLWDELOLWDWHFRQ
IRUPLVPYVUHEHOLXQHDVFHQGHQ YVVXEPLVLYLWDWHQHYURWLVPVSLULW
ULJLG YV IOH[LELOLWDWH vQFUHGHUH vQ VLQH DPDELOLWDWH YV LULWDELOLWDWH
VHQLQ WDWHYVGHSUHVLHSVLKRWLVP
6FDOHWHRUHWLFH
6FDOHOH WHRUHWLFH DX IRVW FRQVWUXLWH SH ED]D VHOHF LHL LQWXLWLYH D
LWHPLORUFRQIRUPWHRULHLSHUVRQDOLW LLGH]YROWDW GH0XUUD\6HOHF LD
LWHPLORU D IRVW UHDOL]DW GH H[SHU L S VWUkQGXVH FHL FDUH SULQ
FRQIUXQWDUHD RSLQLLORU vQWUXQHDX FRQVHQVXO D GRX WUHLPL GLQWUH
VSHFLDOLúWL&HOHVFDOHFXXQQXP UGHLWHPLYDULLQGGHODOD
DX IRVW GHQXPLWH UHDOL]DUH DILOLD LH DXWRQRPLH GHIHUHQ
GRPLQDQ H[KLEL LHHYLWDUHFUHúWHUHRUGLQHMRFvQ HOHJHUH
6FDOHUD LRQDOH
6FDOHOH UD LRQDOH VDX FRQVWLWXLW SULQ DQDOL]D FULWHULXOXL LQWHUQ
6HOHF LD LQL LDO D LWHPLORU XUPD FULWHULL UD LRQDOH VDX FDSDFLWDWHD
LQWXLWLY D DXWRULORU GDU GXS DGPLQLVWUDUHD SH XQ ORW GH VXELHF L DX
IRVWS VWUD LDFHLLWHPLFDUHFRUHODXvQDOWFXVFRUXOWRWDO
6XQWXQWRWDOGHúDSWHVFDOHUD LRQDOHDOF WXLWHFXDMXWRUXOXQXL
ORW GH DSUR[LPDWLY VXELHF L &HOH úDSWH VFDOH VXQW GHQXPLWH
GRPLQDQ VRFLDELOLWDWH UHVSRQVDELOLWDWH GHVFKLGHUH SVLKRORJLF
IHPLQLWDWHUHDOL]DUHúFRODU FRQIRUPLVP
$OWHFDWHJRULLGHVFDOH
$VRFLDWHODDFHVWHVFDOH+DVHDIRORVLWGHDVHPHQHDVFDOHGH
VWLO SHQWUX D HYDOXD GLIHULWH VWLOXUL GH U VSXQV SUHFXP úL VFDOH
FRPSXVHGLQLWHPLVHOHF LRQD LDOHDWRUODvQWkPSODUHSHQWUXDIXUQL]D
R P VXU OLQLDU GH FRPSDUD LH &HUFHW ULOH H[WHQVLYH GHVI úXUDWH OD
8QLYHUVLWDWHD2UHJRQDXDYXWFDVFRSGHWHUPLQDUHDFDSDFLW LLDFHVWRU
VFDOHGHDDQWLFLSDGLIHULWHWLSXULGHFRPSRUWDPHQWH5H]XOWDWHOHXQRUD
GLQWUH FHUFHW ULOH H[SHULPHQWDOH GHPRQVWUHD] úL IDSWXO F YDOLGLWDWHD
VFDOHORU SURGXVH SH ED]D D GLIHULWH SURFHGHH GH GHULYDUH HVWH
FRPSDUDELO
2DOW VFDO GH]YROWDW GHVSHFLDOLúWLLXQHLDJHQ LLGHFRQVLOLHUHD
SLOR LORUDUHFDVFRSP VXUDUHDJUDGXOXLGHGHVFKLGHUHVSUHFRQVLOLHUH
LQWHQVLY DGHOLQFYHQ LORUMXYHQLOL6DQXPLWÄVFDODGHDPHOLRUDUH´úL
D IRVW FRQVWUXLW SH ED]D FULWHULXOXL H[WHUQ $QDOL]HOH SULPDUH DOH
&3,XOXL GHPRQVWUDVHU GHMD F VFDOH SUHFXP 6\ :E 6R 6F $F
GLIHUHQ LD] FHOPDLELQHORWXULOHFHORUFDUHG GXVHU UH]XOWDWHEXQHOD
SURJUDPHOH GH FRQVLOLHUH FRPSDUDWLY FX FHLODO L $QDOL]D GH LWHP D
FHORUGHLWHPLLPSOLFD LvQDFHVWHVFDOHDFRQGXVVSUHS VWUDUHDD
GLQWUHHLFDUHDXGHPRQVWUDWRPD[LP FDSDFLWDWHGHGLIHUHQ LHUH
6FDODGHDQ[LHWDWHFRQVWUXLW GH/HYHQWKDOVDFRQVWLWXLW
SULQSUHOXFUDUHDUH]XOWDWHORUXQXLORWGHVWXGHQ LFDUHDXFHUXWDVLVWHQ
SVLKRWHUDSHXWLF SHQWUX SUREOHPH HPR LRQDOH VDX VRFLDOH ID GH
UH]XOWDWHOHXQXLORWI U DVWIHOGHSUREOHPHGHLWHPLDXGHPRQVWUDW
R EXQ FDSDFLWDWH GH GLIHUHQ LHUHvQWUHFHOHGRX ORWXULLWHPLFDUHDX
IRVWDSRLVXSXúLXQRUSURFHGXULGHYDOLGDUHVXSUDYLH XLQG6FDODD
IRVWvQFRQWLQXDUHH[SHULPHQWDW SULQSURFHGXULGHYDOLGDUHúLVWXGLHUH
FRPSDUDWLY DGDWHORUXWLOL]kQGUH]XOWDWHOHODFHOHODOWHVFDOH&3,úLOD
VFDOHOH003,SUHFXPúLODDOWHVFDOHFOLQLFH3HUPLWHRGLDJQR] DVX
SUDVHYHULW LLSUREOHPHORUVXELHF LORUFXQRWHULGLFDWHúLDQXP UXOXL
GHúHGLQ HGHFRQVLOLHUHQHFHVDUH
6FDOD GH HPSDWLH HVWH FRQVWUXLW GH +RJDQ vQ SULQWUR
DERUGDUH UD LRQDO FRPELQDW FX DERUGDUHD HPSLULF 3HQWUX D RE LQH
XQFULWHULXSHQWUXHPSDWLHFHUHXQXLQXP UGHúDSWHSVLKRORJLH[SHU L
V úL GHVFULH FRQFHS LLOH DVXSUD HPSDWLHL ± UHVSHFWLY GHVFULHUHD XQHL
SHUVRDQH vQDOW HPSDWLFH ± XWLOL]kQG WHKQLFD GH VRUWDUH 4 3H ED]D
DFHVWRUGDWHVDXUHDOL]DWDSRLGHVFULHULSHQWUXHYDOX ULWRWvQVLVWHPXO
VRUW ULL 4 'HVFULHULOH DX IRVW DSOLFDWH XQXL ORW GH VXELHF L úL DX IRVW
VHOHF LRQDWH DFHOH SHUVRDQH FDUH DX I FXW RELHFWXO UDQJ ULORU OD FHOH
GRX H[WUHPHDOHGHVFULHULORUHPSDWLHLvQDOWHPSDWLFLúLVODEHPSDWLFL
6D UHDOL]DW DQDOL]D U VSXQVXULORU ORU OD WHVWXO &3, úL 003, VHOHF
LRQkQGXVHSHED]DGDWHORUVWDWLVWLFHXQQXP UGHGHLWHPLSHQWUXR
VFDO FDUH V FRQVWLWXLH VFDOD HPSDWLHL GLQWUH LWHPL DSDU LQkQG
&3,XOXL ÌQ DIDUD LWHPLORU FDUH GLIHUHQ LDX FHOH GRX ORWXUL GH VX
ELHF L+RJDQDLQFOXVúLXQQXP UGHLWHPLGHVSUHFDUHDFRQVLGHUDW
F DXUHOHYDQ GHFRQ LQXWGHúLUH]XOWDWXOVWDWLVWLFQXHUDSURSULX]LV
VHPQLILFDWLY'HDVHPHQHDDXIRVWLQFOXúLúLLWHPLSHQWUXDHFKLOLEUD
FKHLDGHVFRUDUHDGHY UDW±IDOV
6DXGHVI úXUDWRVHULHGHDOWHVWXGLLH[SHULPHQWDOHDWkWSHQWUXD
YDOLGD VFDOD FD P VXU D HPSDWLHL FkW úL SHQWUX D R FRQWUROD GLQ
SHUVSHFWLYDDOWRUSRVLELOHFRQ LQXWXUL$VWIHOGHH[HPSOXVDXRE LQXW
GLIHUHQ HVHPQLILFDWLYHSHQWUXORWXULGLKRWRPL]DWHGHSHUVRDQHSHQWUX
GLPHQVLXQHDÄDFXLW LLVRFLDOH´
'LQDQLL¶+RJDQDDYDQVDWRWHRULHDVXSUDGH]YROW ULLPRUDOH
vQFDGUXOF UHLDHPSDWLDGHILQLW RSHUD LRQDOGHVFDOD&3,DSDUHFDXQ
FRQVWUXFWFDUGLQDOÌQDOWHVWXGLLUHDOL]DWHFXDMXWRUXODFHVWHLVFDOHVDX
RE LQXW GDWH GHVSUH FRUHOD LD SR]LWLY GLQWUH HPSDWLH úL FRQVXPXO GH
PDULMXDQD OD QLYHOXO HOHYLORU GH OLFHX úL FROHJLX GH DVHPHQHD GLQWUH
HPSDWLH úL PDWXULWDWHD MXGHF LL PRUDOH GLQWUH HPSDWLH úL VRFLDOL]DUH
7RDWH FHUFHW ULOH VXQW FRQVLVWHQWH VXV LQkQG WHRULD OXL +RJDQ DVXSUD
UROXOXL HPSDWLHL vQ FRPSRUWDPHQWXO PRUDO 6WXGLLOH DX LGHQWLILFDW
FRPSRUWDPHQWH FDUH UHIOHFW DFXLWDWHD SHUFHS LHL VRFLDOH PDWXULWDWHD
MXGHF LL PRUDOH VRFLDOL]DUHD FDSDFLWDWHD GH D vQ HOHJH PRGXO DOWRUD
GH D DSUHFLD úL JkQGL UHFHSWLYLWDWHD FRPSRUWDPHQWXO VLPSDWHWLF úL
QHULJLGUH]RQDQ DODDWPRVIHUDGHJUXS
$FHVWHVFDOHDXIRVWvQJHQHUDOXWLOL]DWHPDLSX LQvQVHOHF LHVDX
FRQVLOLHUHúLPDLPXOWSHQWUXFHUFHW UL
$GMHFWLYH&KHFN/LVW$&/
/LVWDGHVHOHF LDGHDGMHFWLYHHVWHXQLQYHQWDUFRPSXVGLQGH
DGMHFWLYH VDX H[SUHVLL VFXUWH DO F URU RELHFWLY HVWH V VH RE LQ R GH
VFULHUHGHVLQHRGHVFULHUHDHXOXLLGHDODDOWRUSHUVRDQHDDQLPDOHORU
RELHFWHORU ORFXULORU SHUVRQDMHORU LVWRULFH SURGXVHORU FRPHUFLDOH
VW ULORU SVLKRORJLFH VWHUHRWLSXULORU LGHLORU FRQFHSWHORU HWF GH IDSW
VSXQH *RXJK D WXWXURU IHQRPHQHORU VXVFHSWLELOH GH D IL SHUFHSXWH
vQ HOHVHúLHYDOXDWHvQWURPDQLHU GLIHUHQ LDO
7HUPHQLLSHUPLWVXELHFWXOXLV VHH[SULPHGHVWXOGHQXDQ DWV
IDF GLVWLQF LLVXEWLOHXWLOL]kQGFDOLW LPDLJOREDOH
$IRVWGH]YROWDW RSULP OLVW GHWHUPHQLvQGHF WUH
*RXJKÌQDFHDVW OLVW DFXSULQVWHUPHQLúLGLQ
WHUPHQL
$OHJHUHD DGMHFWLYHORU D SRUQLW GH OD FRQVLGHUD LL WHRUHWLFH úL
PHWRGRORJLFH DúD FXP DX IRVW GLVFXWDWH vQ OXFU ULOH XQRU $OOSRUW úL
2GEHUW&DWWHOO0XHOOHU+DWKDZD\úL
0HHKDúL%ODFNLDUPDMRULWDWHDLWHPLORUSURYLQGLQDFHVWH
OXFU UL'DUVXQWúLLWHPLFHSURYLQGLQWHRULDOXL)UHXG-XQJ0HDGúL
0XUUD\SUHFXPúLGLQOLPEDMXOFRWLGLDQ
6XELHFWXOXLLVHFHUHV ELIH]HLWHPLLGHVSUHFDUHFRQVLGHU F vO
SRWGHVFULHVDXSRWHYDOXDFHHDFHLVHFHUHQXH[LVW QLFLRUHVWULF LH
UHIHULWRDUH OD QXP U DVWIHO F YDULD LD QXP UXOXL HVWH R UHIOHFWDUH D
FDUDFWHULVWLFLORU SHUVRQDOLW LL ÌQPDMRULWDWHDVLWXD LLORUQXP UXOWRWDO
GHDGMHFWLYHYDULD] vQWUHúLFXRPHGLHGHLWHPL
6FDOHOHWHVWXOXLVXQWJUXSDWHvQXUP WRDUHOHFDWHJRULL
6FDOH GH WLS PRGXV RSHUDQGL PRG GH RSHUDUH &NG 1XP UXO
WRWDO GH DGMHFWLYH DOHV )DY 1XP UXO GH DGMHFWLYH IDYRUDELOH DOHV
8QIDY1XP UXOGHDGMHFWLYHGHIDYRUDELOHDOHV&RP&RPXQDOLWDWHD
6FDOH GH WUHEXLQ H $FK 7UHEXLQ D GH UHDOL]DUH 'RP 7UH
EXLQ DGHGRPLQDQ (QG7UHEXLQ DGHSHUVHYHUDUHvQFHHDFHIDFH
2UG 7UHEXLQ D GH RUGLQH ,QW ,QWURVSHF LH 1XU 6HUYLDELOLWDWH
$II $ILOLHUH +HW +HWHURVH[XDOLWDWH ([K $WUDJHUHD DWHQ LHL $XW
$XWRQRPLH$JJ$JUHVLYLWDWH&KD6FKLPEDUH6XF7UHEXLQ DGH
VXV LQHUH $ED 6HQWLPHQW GH LQIHULRULWDWH 'HI & XWDUHD úL PHQ
LQHUHDXQXLUROGHVXERUGRQDUHvQUHOD LL
6FDOHGLYHUVH&UV6XVFHSWLELOLWDWHDGHDSURILWDGHXQVIDWSVLKR
ORJLF6&Q$XWRFRQWURO6&IGÌQFUHGHUHvQVLQH3$GM$GDSWDUH
SHUVRQDO ,VV$FRUGvQWUHHXúLHXOLGHDO&SV3HUVRQDOLWDWHFUHDWLY
0OV$SWLWXGLQHGHFRPDQG PLOLWDU 0DV&DUDFWHULVWLFLPDVFXOLQH
)HP&DUDFWHULVWLFLIHPLQLQH
6FDOHGHDQDOL] WUDVDF LRQDO 3&S ULQWHFULWLF133 ULQWH
DIHFWXRV$$GXOW)&&RSLOOLEHU$&&RSLODGDSWDW
6FDOHGHRULJHQ LQWHOHFWDQ WHUPHQLGHULYD LGLQFRQFHSWHOH
GHRULJLQDOLWDWHFUHDWLYLWDWHLQWHOLJHQ $2ULJHQ ULGLFDW ,QWH
OHFWDQ VF ]XW $ 2ULJHQ ULGLFDW ,QWHOHFWDQ ULGLFDW $
2ULJHQ VF ]XW ,QWHOHFWDQ VF ]XW $ 2ULJHQ VF ]XW ,QWH
OHFWDQ ULGLFDW
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH
DQDOL]D SURILOXOXL SURILOXO XQHL SHUVRDQH vQ VHQVXO XQHL SUH]HQW UL
JHQHUDOH DWU V WXULORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHúLDFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUSUH]HQWHOD
DFHDSHUVRDQ UHODWLYODXQVHWGHQRUPHFRQVWUXLWHID GHRSRSXOD LH
GHUHIHULQ $QDOL]DSRDWHOXDIRUPDXQXLSURILOFDDWDUHvQFDUHGDWHOH
VXQWSUH]HQWDWHvQIRUP JUDILF FDvQFD]XOWHVWHORU&3,VDX003,
VDXSRDWHDYHDIRUPDPDLJHQHUDO DXQHLSUH]HQW ULDFDUDFWHULVWLFLORU
LQGLYLGXOXLVDXDWU V WXULORUvQIRUP VXPDU '3
DQRUPDOFDUHVHvQGHS UWHD] GHQRUP VDXQRUPDOSRDWHVHPQLILFD
GHYLD LLSXUFDQWLWDWLYHvQDQDOL]HOHVWDWLVWLFHGDUúLPRGHOHGHFRPSRU
WDPHQWGHYLDQWHDOHLQGLYL]LORU'LILFXOWDWHDGHOLPLW ULLQRUPDOXOXLGH
DQRUPDOSRUQHúWHGLQWHQGLQ DGHDDYHDJUDQL HGHQRUPDOLWDWHGHILQLWH
GHXQDVDXDOWDGLQWUHWHRULLOHDVXSUDSHUVRQDOLW LLGHH[HPSOXvQYL
]LXQHD SVLKDQDOLWLF FODVLF KRPRVH[XDOLWDWHD HVWH SULYLW FD DQRUPD
OLWDWHFRQWUDUWHRULLORUSULYLQGvQY DUHDVRFLDO ([LVW RWHQGLQ GHD
XWLOL]D WHUPHQL SUHFXP QHDGDSWDUH QHDFRPRGDUH GHYLDQW vQ OHJ WXU
FXHYDOXDUHDXQXLLQGLYLGFRQVLGHUDWUHVSHFWLYvOHYDOX PvQIXQF LHGH
P VXUDvQFDUHSXWHPYRUELGHXQFRPSRUWDPHQWDGDSWDWLYúLQXSHQWUX
DOHWLFKHWDSXUúLVLPSOX'3
FRPSRUWDPHQW LQWHUSHUVRQDO SHQWUX *RXJK SHUVRQDOLWDWHD XQXL
LQGLYLGVHUHOHY vQFDGUXOFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLDFHVWXLDvQUHOD LDFXDOW
VDXDOWHSHUVRDQH
FRQFHSWHSRSXODUHWHUPHQSULQFDUH*RXJKVHUHIHU ODFXYLQWHOHSH
FDUHRDPHQLLRELúQXL LOHXWLOL]HD] FXUHQWSHQWUXDVHUHIHULODHYDOX UL
VDXGHVFULHULGHFRPSRUWDPHQW
FRQWLQXXPWHUPHQFDUHVHUHIHU ODGLPHQVLXQLOHSHFDUHSRDWHYDULD
RFDUDFWHULVWLF GLVWLQFW GHFRPSRUWDPHQWvQWUHGRX H[WUHPHVDXSROL
GH H[HPSOX FRQWLQXXPXO H[WUDYHUVLH LQWURYHUVLH VH DSOLF DWkW
XQRUGLPHQVLXQLIL]LFHFkWúLXQRUGLPHQVLXQLVXELHFWLYHFDUHSRWIDFH
RELHFWXOXQHLHYDOX ULGHJUDGLHQ
GHYLDQ RULFH PRGHO GH FRPSRUWDPHQW FDUH HVWH HYLGHQW GLIHULW GH
VWDQGDUGHOH DFFHSWDWH vQ FDGUXO VRFLHW LL GHVLJXU GHILQL LD FRQ LQH
SXWHUQLFH DFFHQWH GLQ GRPHQLXO HWLFPRUDO úL IRORVLUHD WHUPHQXOXL VH
IDFHVSHFLILFkQGIRUPDUHVSHFWLY GHGHYLDQ '3
GLPHQVLXQH RULFH WU V WXU SVLKRORJLF FH SRDWH IDFH RELHFWXO XQHL
FXDQWLILF ULVDXRULFHVFDO FRQVWUXLW ODFDUHSRWILUDSRUWD LLQGLYL]LL
GLQDPLFD SHUVRQDOLW LL VWXGLXO DVSHFWHORU GLQDPLFH FRPSOH[H LQ
WHUDFWLYHDOHPRWLYD LHLHPR LHLVDXFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL'3
IDFWRU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH FDUDFWHULVWLFLOH LPSOLFD LHL úL LQYHVWL LLORU SVL
KLFH vQ FRPSRUWDPHQWH úL DFWLYLW L )DFWRUXO UHSUH]LQW R FOXVWHUL]DUH
VWDWLVWLF GH LWHPL RE LQXW vQ XUPD GHUXO ULL XQHL DQDOL]H IDFWRULDOH D
F UHLFRQVLVWHQ úLGHQXPLUHSVLKRORJLF QHFHVLW RDFWLYLWDWHVSHFLDOL]DW
LQIOXHQ HVXELHFWXOFUHGHF HVWHVXSXVXQHLIRU HLQWHUQHVDXH[WHUQH
FDUHL GLULMHD] JkQGXULOH vL PRGXOHD] VHQWLPHQWHOH úL vL FRPDQG
DFWHOHVDXFRPSRUWDPHQWXO
LQWHJUDUHD SHUVRQDOLW LL WHUPHQ FDUH VH UHIHU OD FRRUGRQDUHD RUJD
QL]DUHDVDXXQLILFDUHDXQRUWU V WXULVHSDUDWHDXQRUGLVSR]L LLGHFRP
SRUWDPHQWPRWLYHVDXHPR LLFDUHFRQVWLWXLHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDXQXLLQGLYLG
VLWXD LDLQYHUV HVWHGHQXPLW GH]LQWHJUDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL'3
QRUPDOvQVHQVODUJVHUHIHU ODFHHDFHGHULY GLQWURQRUP vQVHQV
SVLKRORJLF VSHFLILF VH UHIHU OD FRQGL LD SVLKRORJLF GH QRQERDO
DEVHQ DWXOEXU ULORUPHQWDOHDUHWDUGXOXLPLQWDOVDXDDOWRUGLVIXQF LL
SVLKRORJLFH
SDWHUQ WHUPHQ DSURSLDW GH FHO GH VWUXFWXU GH IRUP FRQILJXUD LH
WLSPRGHOVFKHP PDWULFH,QGLF DWkWVWUXFWXUDRUJDQLF IL]LF FkW
úLFHDFRPSRUWDPHQWDO
SHUFHSHUHVRFLDO vQVHQVODUJRULFHDVSHFWDOSHUFHSHULLFDUHFRQ LQH
XQHOHPHQWVRFLDOWHUPHQXOHVWHXWLOL]DWvQJHQHUDOUHODWLYODFDSDFLWDWHD
XQXLLQGLYLGGHDILFRQúWLHQWGHP VXUDvQFDUHFRPSRUWDPHQWXODOWRUD
OH UHOHY PRWLYHOH DWLWXGLQLOH UHDF LLOH LQWHULRDUH OD *RXJK GHILQHúWH
PRGXOvQFDUHSULQH[SHULPHQWDUHHVWHSHUFHSXW GHDQWXUDMRSHUVRDQ
FDUHSUH]LQW RDFFHQWXDUHDXQHLDVDXDOWHLDGLQWUHGLPHQVLXQLOHGHSHU
VRQDOLWDWHDOH&3,
SURJQR] RSUHGLF LHSULYLQGFXUVXOVDXUH]XOWDWXOXQXLSURFHVILHHO
SVLKRORJLFHGXFD LRQDOPHWRGRORJLFHWF'3
VFDO GHHYDOXDUHLQVWUXPHQWGHFHUFHWDUHFOLQLFLQL LDODSRLH[WLQVúLvQ
DOWH WLSXUL GH VWXGLL FDUH VXQW FRPSOHWDWH GH XQ REVHUYDWRU FOLQLFLDQ
DYkQG FD RELHFWLY GLVWLQJHUHD FODVHORU VDX FDWHJRULLORU GH GLDJQRVWLF
VFDOHGLIHUHQ LDOHSUHYHGHUHDXQHLHYROX LLVFDOHSUHGLFWLYHGHVFULHUHD
XQHL VW UL FOLQLFH VDX GLVWULEX LHL XQHL YDULDELOH vQWUR SRSXOD LH VFDOH
GHVFULSWLYH6HGHRVHEHVFPDLPXOWHWLSXULGHVFDOHGHVFULSWLYHLQYHQ
WDUHOH JOREDOH FDUH VXQW OLVWH GH VLPSWRPHVFDOHOHQRVRJUDILFHJOREDOH
FDUHIXUQL]HD] XQLQGLFHJOREDOGHSDWRORJLHFDGHH[HPSOXVFDODGH
GHSUHVLHDOXL+DPLOWRQVFDOHGHVLQGURPVDXSROLGLPHQVLRQDOH'3
VFDO vQVHQVJHQHUDORULFHSURFHGXU VDXLQVWUXPHQWIRORVLWFXVFRSXO
GH D DUDQMD RELHFWHOH VDX HYHQLPHQWHOH vQ VHULL SURJUHVLYH DVWIHO F vQ
ILHFDUH FD] vQ SDUWH H[LVW R UHJXO SHQWUX D SHUPLWH DWULEXLUHD XQXL
QXP U VDX XQHL YDORUL RELHFWHORU VDX HYHQLPHQWHORU VFDODWH ÌQ PRG
VSHFLILF LQGLF XQ LQVWUXPHQW GH WHVWDUH FDUH DUH LWHPLL VDX VDUFLQLOH
DUDQMDWH GHD OXQJXO XQHL GLPHQVLXQL GLPHQVLXQHD SRDWH IL XQD GLQWUH
PDL PXOWH SUHFXP FHD D GLILFXOW LL GH H[HPSOX vQ VFDOHOH GH LQWHOL
JHQ VDX SUHIHULQ HL FD GH H[HPSOX vQ VFDOHOH GH DWLWXGLQL 2 VFDO
SVLKRORJLF VSHFLILF XQVLVWHPGHP VXUDUHDXQHLYDULDELOHSVLKRORJLFH
2ULFH VFDO QHFHVLW XQ QXP U GH FDOLW L SULQWUH DFHVWHD YDOLGLWDWHD
VHPQLILF IDSWXOF LQVWUXPHQWXOP VRDU FRUHFWRELHFWXOVWXGLDWvQWUR
PRGDOLWDWHVSHFLILF 9DOLGLWDWHDVHSRDWHRE LQHúLFRPSDUkQGFXRDOW
VFDO 9DOLGLWDWHD H[WHUQ VH RE LQH SULQ FRPSDUDUHD FX XQ FULWHULX
H[WHUQ )LGHOLWDWHD LPSOLF GH H[HPSOX RPRJHQLWDWHD LWHPLORU VFDOHL
SRVLELOLWDWHD GH D UHSOLFD UH]XOWDWHOH vQ WLPS VDX FX R IRUP SDUDOHO
3ULQFLSDOHOH HURUL PHWRGRORJLFH GHFXUJ GLQ OLSVD GH DGHFYDUH D LQVWUX
PHQWHORU DOHVH vQ UDSRUW FX SUH]XP LD WHRUHWLF D XQXL VWXGLX VDX GLQ
LQIHUDUHDXQRUFRQFOX]LLDEX]LYHSOHFkQGGHODUH]XOWDWHOHFRGDWH6WDQ
GDUGL]DUHD VFDOHORU SVLKRORJLFH D LQWURGXV XQ SURJUHV PHWRGRORJLF
LPSRUWDQWSHQWUXHYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL'3
VFDOHDEUHYLDWHWHKQLF FHSHUPLWHH[SORUDUHDDVSHFWHORUSVLKRSDWROR
JLFHúLDDWLWXGLQLLVXELHFWXOXLFRQIRUPVFDOHORUFOLQLFH003,SHQWUX
VXELHF LLFDUHSUH]LQW vQSURILOXO&3,XQHOHDVSHFWHFDUHvQGUHSW HVF
RVXVSLFLXQHDVXSUDJUDYLW LLXQRUVLPSWRPHSVLKRSDWRORJLFH
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU
'HILQL L úL DUJXPHQWD L WHRULD OXL *RXJK SULYLQG ÄFRQFHSWHOH SR
SXODUH´
&XFHDUJXPHQWHSXWH LVXV LQHF &3,UHSUH]LQW SHQWUXQRUPD
OLWDWHD SHUVRQDOLW LL FHHD FH 003, UHSUH]LQW SHQWUX SVLKRSD
WRORJLDSHUVRQDOLW LL"
&DUH HVWH DUJXPHQWD LD OXL *RXJK SULYLQG QHFHVLWDWHD IRUP ULL
SVLKRORJXOXLFDUHXWLOL]HD] ,QYHQWDUXOGH3HUVRQDOLWDWH&DOLIRUQLD"
&DUH HVWH SULPD JUXS GH VFDOH D YDULDQWHL VWDQGDUG VHQVXO
FRPXQDODFHVWRUVFDOHúLGHILQLUHDILHF UHLD"
&DUHHVWHDGRXDJUXS GHVFDOHDYDULDQWHLVWDQGDUGVHQVXO
ORUFRPXQúLGHILQLUHDILHF UHLD"
&DUHHVWHDWUHLDJUXS GHVFDOHDYDULDQWHLVWDQGDUGVHQVXO
ORUFRPXQúLGHILQLUHDDFHVWRUD"
&DUHHVWHDSDWUDJUXS GHVFDOHDYDULDQWHLVWDQGDUGVHQVXO
ORUFRPXQúLGHILQLUHDDFHVWRUD"
&DUHVXQWFHOHWUHLVFDOHGHYDOLGDUHúLFHVHPQLILF vQDFHVWVHQV
ILHFDUH"
&XPSXWHPHYDOXDFRQGL LDHXOXLDLPDJLQLLGHVLQH"
&DUHVXQWJUXS ULOHIDFWRULDOHDOHVFDOHORU&3,VWDQGDUG"
ÌQFHFRQVWDXPRGHOHOHSDWHUQXULOHGHILQLWHGH*RXJK"([HP
SOLILFD L
&kQG úL vQ FH IHO VH SRDWH HYDOXD SHUFHS LD VRFLDO D FRPSRUWD
PHQWXOXLSHUVRDQHLWHVWDWH"
&HvQVHDPQ ÄVFDOHDEUHYLDWH´003,úLFkQGLQWHUYLQHQHFHVLWDWHD
IRORVLULLDFHVWHLSRVLELOLW LGHLQWHUSUHWDUH"
&DUHVXQWFHOHGRX VFDOHVWDQGDUGLQWURGXVHGH*RXJKvQYDULDQWD
GLQ"
&DUHVXQWFHLWUHLYHFWRULDLÄPRGHOXOXLFXERLGDOSHUVRQDOLW LL´"
%LEOLRJUDILH
&RVWD 3 7 0F&UDH 5 5 3HUVRQDOLW\ LQ $GXOWKRRG $ 6L[<HDU
/RQJLWXGLQDO6WXG\RI6HOI5HSRUWVDQG6SRXVH5DWLQJVRQWKH1(23,
Ä-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´&RVWD3
7 0F&UDH 5 5 1(2 3, 5 3URIHVVLRQDO 0DQXDO 3$5
2GHVVDS
'LQF 03URFHVXDO&UHDWLYH6WUXFWXUHVDQG/HYHOVRI3HUIRUPDQFH
Ä5HYXHGHSV\FKRORJLH´
*RXJK * + +HLOEUXQ $ % $GMHFWLYH &KHFN /LVW 0DQXDO &33
3DOR$OWR&$
*RXJK + * 0DQXDO IRU WKH &DOLIRUQLD 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\
&RQVXOWLQJ3V\FKRORJLVW3UHVV3DOR$OWR&DOLIRUQLD
*RXJK + * +HLOEUXQ $ % $GMHFWLYH &KHFN/LVW 0DQXDO 3DOR
$OWR&D&RQVXOWLQJ3V\FKRORJLVW3UHVV
*RXJK + * 7KH &DOLIRUQLD 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\ $GPLQLVWUDWRU¶V
*XLGH&333DOR$OWR&D
-RKQVRQ-$ ,QWHUSUHWLQJWKH&DOLIRUQLD3HUVRQDOLW\,QYHQWRU\ZLWK
WKH$E&0RGHOD9,DFRQIHULQ D($33*URQLQJHQ
0HJDUJHH ( , 7KH &DOLIRUQLD 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\ +DQGERRN
-RVVH\%DVV,QF6DQ)UDQFLVFR:DVKLQJWRQ/RQGRQ
0LQXOHVFX05H]ROYDUHDGHSUREOHPHúLVWLOXOFRJQLWLYvQLQYHVWLJD LD
MXULGLF WH] GHGRFWRUDW8QLYHUVLWDWHD%XFXUHúWL
0LQXOHVFX0&KHVWLRQDUHOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHvQHYDOXDUHDSVLKRORJLF
(G*DUHOO%XFXUHúWL
3LWDULX + ' $OEX 0 ,QYHQWDUXO GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH &DOLIRUQLD SUH
]HQWDUH úL UH]XOWDWH H[SHULPHQWDOH Ä5HYLVWD GH SVLKRORJLH´ QU
3LWDULX+'+HKQ+,QYHVWLJDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLFXDMXWRUXO,QYHQWD
UXOXLGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH&DOLIRUQLDÄ5HYLVWDGHSVLKRORJLH´
&DSLWROXO,,,
&+(67,21$58/)$&725,35,0$5,±3)4
&+(67,21$58/'($1;,(7$7(&
&+(67,21$58/'(3(5621$/,7$7(
3(1758$'2/(6&(1 ,+634
3UH]HQWDUHD &KHVWLRQDUHORU FRQVWUXLWH 5% &DWWHOO FXSULQGH XU
P WRDUHOHDVSHFWHWHRULDIDFWRULDO DOXL5%&DWWHOOSULYLQGIRUPDUHD
úLIXQF LRQDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLFKHVWLRQDUXOIDFWRULSULPDUL±3)4
FKHVWLRQDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHSHQWUXDGROHVFHQ L±+634H[HPSOLILFDUH
SURILO 3)4 FKHVWLRQDUXO &DWWHOO SULYLQG QLYHOXO DQ[LHW LL Ä&´
H[HPSOLILFDUHDXQXLSURILO&6XQWSUH]HQWDWHFRQFHSWHOHFDUDFWHULVWLFH
XQWHVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORUúLUHIHULQ HOHELEOLRJUDILFH
7HRULDIDFWRULDO DOXL5%&DWWHOODVXSUDIRUP ULL
úLIXQF LRQ ULLSHUVRQDOLW LL
3HQWUX5%&DWWHOOPHWRGDDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOHDSOLFDW vQSVLKR
ORJLD SHUVRQDOLW LL DUH GRX RELHFWLYH V GHWHUPLQH PRGHOH DOH
XQLW LORUIXQF LRQDOHIDFWRULLFDDVSHFWHVWUXFWXUDOHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LL
úLV RIHUHRHVWLPDUHQXPHULF DJUDGXOXLGHPDQLIHVWDUHvQHFXD LD
SHUVRQDO D LQGLYLGXOXL D ILHF UXLD GLQWUH IDFWRULL SULPDUL DL SHUVRQD
OLW LLvQ HOHúLFDWU V WXULVXUV SHQWUXFRPSRUWDPHQW
5D\PRQG%&DWWHOO±
1 VFXW vQ $QJOLD IRUPDW FD SVLKRORJ OD /RQGUD GLQ
GHYLQHSURIHVRUXQLYHUVLWDUDO8QLYHUVLW LL&ODUNGLQ
0DVVDFKXVHWWVDSRLDO8QLYHUVLW LL+DUYDUGSHQWUXFDGLQ
V úL GHGLFH vQWUHDJD YLD FHUFHW ULORU vQ SVLKRORJLD
SHUVRQDOLW LL ILLQG SULPXO FDUH DDQDOL]DWVLVWHPDWLFWU V
WXULOHúLDRIHULWRFODVLILFDUHGHWDOLDW DDFHVWRUD7U V WXULOH
VXQW IDFWRUL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH RE LQX L SULQ DSOLFDUHD VLVWH
PDWLF D DQDOL]HL IDFWRULDOH úL H[WUDúL GLQWUR GHRVHELW GH
ODUJ PDV GH P VXU WRUL D FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL XPDQ $
SXEOLFDW GH F U L úL FRQVLGHU F D GH]YROWDW XQ FDGUX
ILGHO FDUH V SHUPLW P VXUDUHD SHUVRQDOLW LL úL PRWLYD LHL
XPDQH WHKQLF GH P VXUDUH FDUH SHUPLWH SVLKRORJLHL V
DF LRQH]HFDúWLLQ
&DWWHOODILUP FODUF QXPDLSULQFXQRDúWHUHDSUHFLV DvQWUHJXOXL
PRGHO DO WU V WXULORU FDUH GHILQHVF DFHD SHUVRDQ FD R XQLFLWDWH VH
SRDWHUHDOL]DRSUHGLF LHGHVSUHFHYDIDFHSHUVRDQDvQWURVLWXD LHGDW
7U V WXULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH VXQW ÄIDFWRULL´ UH]XOWD L vQ XUPD
DQDOL]HL IDFWRULDOH D XQHL PDVH FULWLFH GH LQIRUPD LL GHVSUH FRPSRU
WDPHQWXOXPDQ
&HUFHW ULOH OXL &DWWHOO DVXSUD SHUVRQDOLW LL VXQW QRPRWHWLFH vQ
P VXUDvQFDUHDQDOL]DIDFWRULDO LQFOXGHFHUFHWDUHDXQXLPDUHQXP U
GH SHUVRDQH úL QLYHOXO GH SHUIRUPDQ OD GLIHULWH LQVWUXPHQWH GH
FHUFHWDUH$XWRUXOHVWHLQWHUHVDWPDLDOHVvQDIODUHDXQRUSULQFLSLLODUJL
JHQHUDOH FDUH SRW IL DSOLFDWH PDL PXOWRU RDPHQL 7RWXúL &DWWHOO
XWLOL]HD] GDWHOH SHQWUX D vQ HOHJH FRPSRUWDPHQWXO XQHL SHUVRDQH
DSOLFkQGXOHvQWURPDQLHU LGHRJUDILF
3HQWUX &DWWHOO ÄWU V WXULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH´ VXQW DFHL IDFWRUL
UH]XOWD L SULQ DSOLFDUHD PHWRGHL DQDOL]HL IDFWRULDOH SH PDUHD PDV GH
P VXU WRUL UHDOL]DWH DVXSUD XQXL JUXS ODUJ GH RDPHQL 'LQ DFHDVW
SHUVSHFWLY GHVLJXU WU V WXULOH DSDU FD WHQGLQ H GH UHDF LH UHODWLY
SHUPDQHQWH úL IRUPHD] VSXQH DXWRUXO XQLWDWHD GH ED] D VWUXFWXULL
SHUVRQDOLW LL LQGLYLGXOXL UHVSHFWLY 3UHGLF LD FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL VH
SRDWH UHDOL]D GRDU SULQ FXQRDúWHUHD FRPSOHW D WU V WXULORU XQHL SHU
VRDQH3HUVRQDOLWDWHDHVWHSHQWUX&DWWHOOXQPRGHOSDWHUQGHWU V WXUL
'HIDSWVSXQHDXWRUXOWU V WXULOHFDDWDUHQXWUHEXLHvQ HOHVHFDDYkQG
R H[LVWHQ UHDO vQ YLD D ILHF UHL SHUVRDQH SHQWUX F HOH VXQW DG
OLWHUDP FRQVWUXFWH LSRWHWLFH VDX LPDJLQL LQIHUDWH GLQ REVHUYDUHD
RELHFWLY DFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL
3HQWUX&DWWHOOSHUVRQDOLWDWHDDUHXQVHQVGLUHFWGLDJQRVWLFúL
GLIHUHQ LDO
) FkQG GLIHUHQ D vQWUH WU V WXUL úL WLSXUL FD DOWHUQDWLY vQ H[SOR
UDUHD SHUVRQDOLW LL úL UHFXQRVFkQG F vQ IRQG ÄQDWXUD LQWULQVHF úL
HFKLYDOHQ D GH HVHQ vQWUH DFHVWH DOWHUQDWLYH QX D IRVW vQWRWGHDXQD
FXQRVFXW ´ &DWWHOO GHILQHúWH WLSXO FD XQ PRGHO SDUWLFXODU úL UHFXUHQW
GHDWULEXWHSULQFDUHVHGDXVHPQLILFD LLFRQRWDWLYH$WULEXWXOVHSRDWH
GHILQLFDXQDVSHFWXQLWDUúLGLVFUHW3ULPDJULM DSHUVRQRORJXOXLDIRVW
V GHILQHDVF úWLLQ LILF DWULEXWHOH VDX WU V WXULOH 7HRULD VD QX DUH XQ
FDGUX FOLQLF GH UHIHULQ DVHPHQL 003,XOXL VDX XQXO LQWHUUHOD LRQDO
FDvQFD]XO&3,XOXL7HRULDVDSRUQHúWHGHODGDWHVWULFWúWLLQ LILFHúL
FHUFHWDUHD HPSLULF XWLOL]HD] VXELHF L F URUD OL VH VWXGLD] H[WHQVLY
FRPSRUWDPHQWXO FROHFWkQG R PDV HQRUP GH GDWH SULQ FKHVWLRQDUH
WHVWHRELHFWLYHREVHUYD LLGLUHFWHFRW ULDOHFRQGXLWHLvQVLWXD LLUHDOH
GH YLD 'DWHOH VXQW SUHOXFUDWH SULQ DQDOL] IDFWRULDO LDU IDFWRULL
RE LQX L VXQW FRQVLGHU DXWRUXO FKLDU WU V WXULOH SHUVRQDOLW LL UHV
SRQVDELOH GH YDULD LD FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL DFHVWRU VXELHF L Ä9DULDQ D
YDULDELOHORUFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHFDUHFRUHOHD] vQDQDOL]DIDFWRULDO HVWH
vQPRGWLSLFDFHHDDGLIHUHQ HORULQGLYLGXDOHvQWUHRDPHQL´
)DFWRUXOHVWHXQSDWHUQGHYDULDELOHFHVHSRDWHUHODWLYVFKLPED
GH OD FHUFHWDUH OD FHUFHWDUH GDWRULW GH H[HPSOX HURULORU GH HúDQ
WLRQDUHVDXH[SHULPHQWDUH0DLPXOWXQDVWIHOGHSDWHUQYDUHSUH]HQWD
RUHDO VFKLPEDUHRGDW FXYkUVWDVDXQLYHOXOSRSXOD LHLLQYHVWLJDWH
&HHD FH QX VH VFKLPE HVWH vQV WU V WXUDVXUV FDUHU PkQHDFHHDúL
LGHQWLF úL LGHQWLILFDELO LQIOXHQ FH SURGXFH DFHVW SDWHUQ &HHD FH
WUHEXLH FXQRVFXW úL vQ HOHV HVWH DFHDVW WU V WXU VXUV FDUH SHQWUX
SVLKRORJLH QH VSXQH DXWRUXO HVWH ÄDVHPHQL JHQRWLSXOXL SHQWUX FDUH
IDFWRUXOHVWHIHQRWLSXO´vQJHQHWLF
ÌQHIRUWXOV XGHDDMXQJHODRGHVFULHUHFRHUHQW úLFXSULQ] WRDUHD
SHUVRQDOLW LL&DWWHOOvQFHSHDVDPEOkQG±SULQWUXQVWXGLXGHGLF LRQDUúL
GH OLWHUDWXU SVLKLDWULF úL SVLKRORJLF WRDWH GHQXPLULOH WU V WXULORU GH
SHUVRQDOLWDWH 3HQWUX &DWWHOO VXUVD SULP úL VLQJXUD LPHGLDW XWLOL]DELO
SHQWUX FXQRDúWHUHD TXDVLWRWDOLW LL WU V WXULORU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH HVWH
OLPEDMXO ÄGHD OXQJXO VHFROHORU SULQ SUHVLXQHD QHFHVLW LL LPHGLDWH
ILHFDUH DVSHFW DO FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL ILLQ HL XPDQH FDUH HUD SRVLELO V
DIHFWH]HSHXQDOWRPDDMXQVV ILHPDQHYUDWSULQWUXQDQXPHVLPERO
YHUEDO´(QJOH]DVWDELOL]kQGXVHGLQWLPSXOOXL6KDNHVSHDUHFHOH
GH FXYLQWH GHVFULVH FD WU V WXUL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH GH $OOSRUW úL 2GEHUW
FRQVWLWXLH SHQWUX &DWWHOO VWRFXO FXOWXUDO GH VLPEROXUL DOH FRPSRUWD
PHQWXOXLXPDQ*UXSDUHDORUSHVLQRQLPHvOIDFHV UHGXF OLVWDLQL LDOOD
GHQXPLUL GH WU V WXUL GH VLQH VW W WRDUH OLVW XWLOL]DW SHQWUX D
RE LQH HYDOX UL GH FRPSRUWDPHQW SH XQ ORW GH GH DGXO L )LHFDUH
VXELHFW HUD HYDOXDW GH FLQHYD FDUH vO FXQRúWHD ELQH SH R VFDO GH
YDORUL PHGLX GHDVXSUD úL GHGHVXEWXO PHGLHL ,QWHUFRUHOD LLOH RE LQXWH
VWDWLVWLFvOFRQGXFVSUHRUHGXFHUHGHGHFOXVWHULQXFOHDUL&RQWLQXkQG
H[SHULPHQWXOGHHYDOXDUHSHED]DQRLORUJUXS ULGHQXPLULSHXQORWGH
VXELHF LHYDOXD LILHFDUHGHFkWHGRLHYDOXDWRULLQGHSHQGHQ LRE LQH
vQXUPDDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOHDGDWHORURUHGXFHUHDDFHVWXLQXP UOD
WU V WXUL $FHVWHD VXQW GHVFULVH FD VXUVH SULPDUH DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL $
HYDOXDúLDvQ HOHJHRSHUVRDQ vQVHDPQ DFXQRDúWHFXSUHFL]LHvQWUHJXO
PRGHOGHWU V WXULFDUHRGHILQHVF
'HILQLWH vQ DFHúWL WHUPHQL WU V WXULOH DSDU FD WHQGLQ H GH D
UHDF LRQD UHODWLY SHUPDQHQWH FDUH IRUPHD] XQLWDWHD IXQGDPHQWDO D
SHUVRQDOLW LL LQGLYLGXOXL &XQRDúWHUHD SUHFLV D vQWUHJXOXL PRGHO DO
WU V WXULORUFDUHGHILQHVFDFHDSHUVRDQ FDRXQLFLWDWHSHUPLWHUHDOL]DUHD
SUHGLF LHLFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLSHUVRDQHLÌQDFHVWVFRSXWLOL]HD] HFXD LD
GHVSHFLILFDUHDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLFXIRUPXOD
5£L V£O7OLV£7LV£Q7QLV£7£LV£HL
)RUPXODDILUP F P ULPHDU VSXQVXOXLSHUIRUPDQ HL5GHILQLW
GHVLWXD LDVWLPXO£SHQWUXLQGLYLGXOLHVWHHJDO FXVXPDGRW ULLDFHOXL
LQGLYLG7OL7LvQWU V WXULOHVXUV 7O77QILHFDUHPXOWLSOLFDW SULQ
vQF UF WXUDIDFWRULDO H[SHULPHQWDORE LQXW SHQWUXYDULDELODGDW 5£GH
ILQLW FDRVLWXD LHVDXXQPRGGHP VXUDUHDU VSXQVXOXLvQDFHLIDFWRUL
ÌQ HFXD LH vQF UF WXULOH IDFWRULDOH DSDU FD ÄV´ SHQWUX F SHQWUX
&DWWHOO HOH VXQW SVLKRORJLF GHILQLELOH FD ÄLQGLFL VLWXD LRQDOL´ FDUH LQ
GLF JUDGXOvQFDUHGLIHULWHWU V WXULVXUV VXQWVWLPXODWHúLLPSOLFDWHvQ
DF LXQHGHVLWXD LDVWLPXO£ID GHFDUHVHUHDOL]HD] U VSXQVXO5
5H]XOWDWHvQXUPDDQDOL]HORUVWDWLVWLFHWU V WXULOHQXDXRH[LVWHQ
FDDWDUHvQSVLKRORJLDILHF UHLSHUVRDQH&DWWHOOOHFRQVLGHU FRQVWUXFWH
LSRWHWLFH VDX LPDJLQDUH LQIHUDWH GLQ REVHUYDUHD RELHFWLY D FRPSRUWD
PHQWXOXLGHVFKLV
([LVW OD&DWWHOOFkWHYDPRGDOLW LGHWD[RQRPL]DUHDWU V WXULORU
$VWIHO IDFH R GLVWLQF LH vQWUH WU V WXUL FRPXQH úL WU V WXUL
XQLFH GLVWLQF LH SH FDUH R I FXVH úL $OOSRUW 3HQWUX &DWWHOO
WU V WXUD FRPXQ HVWH FHD SH FDUH R DUH ILHFDUH RP vQWUXQ
DQXPH JUDG GH GH]YROWDUH LQWHOLJHQ D FD DELOLWDWH PHQWDO
JHQHUDO LQWURYHUVLDH[WUDYHUVLD VSLULWXO JUHJDU FD GLPHQ
VLXQLFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHHWFSHQWUXF VSXQH&DWWHOOSHGHR
SDUWH WR L RDPHQLL DX vQ FRPXQ XQ DQXPH IXQGDO JHQHWLF
HUHGLWDU PDL PXOW VDX PDL SX LQ VLPLODU úL SH GH DOWD WR L
RDPHQLLVXQWVXSXúLXQRUPRGHOHVLPLODUHGHSUHVLXQLVRFLDOH
FHOSX LQODQLYHOXODFHOHLDúLFXOWXUL
7U V WXULOHXQLFHVXQWFHOHFDUHUDUVXQWvPS UW úLWHGHDO LLúL
DSDUPDLDOHVvQVIHUDLQWHUHVHORUúLDWLWXGLQLORUFLQHYDQHG
H[HPSOX &DWWHOO DUH R SDVLXQH ID GH R DQXPH VSHFLH GH
IOXWXUL
2 DOW WD[RQRPL]DUH SURSXV GH &DWWHOO JUXSHD] WU V WXULOH
FRQIRUPIRUPHLGHPDQLIHVWDUHvQFDSDFLW LVDXDELOLW LFDUH
GHWHUPLQ FkWGHHILFLHQW HVWHSHUVRDQDvQDDF LRQDvQYHGHUHD
XQXL DQXPLW VFRS GH H[HPSOX LQWHOLJHQ D WU V WXUL WHPSH
UDPHQWDOH FDUH GHILQHVF VWLOXO VDX WHPSRXO GH DF LXQH GH
H[HPSOX QLYHOXO GH LULWDELOLWDWH UDSLGLWDWHD vQ DF LXQH HWF úL
WU V WXUL GLQDPLFH FDUH VXQW DFHOH PRGDOLW L VDX IRU H FDUH
DFWLYHD] úLFRQGXFFRPSRUWDPHQWHOHGHH[HPSOXPRWLYD LLOH
úLWUHEXLQ HOH
0DLLPSRUWDQW vQRUGLQHDvQ HOHJHULLHIHFWLYHDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL
úLGH]YROW ULLSHUVRQDOLW LLDSDUHGLVWLQF LDvQWUHWU V WXULGHVXSUDID úL
WU V WXULVXUV
7U V WXULOH GH VXSUDID VXQW XQ VHW GH FDUDFWHULVWLFL DOH SHUVR
QDOLW LL FDUH FRUHOHD] vQWUH HOH I U D IRUPD SURSULX]LV XQ IDFWRU vQ
P VXUD vQ FDUH QX VXQW GHWHUPLQDWH GH R DFHHDúL WU V WXU VXUV 'HFL
WU V WXULOH GH VXSUDID SH FDUH OH YRP vQWkOQL FD IDFWRUL GH RUGLQ
VHFXQGDUVXQWFOXVWHULGHFRUHOD LLDUELWUDULFDúLFRQWXUFDUHQXVHSRW
GHILQL FD HQWLW L GLVWLQFWH FDUH GHSLQG GLUHFW GH YDULDELOHOH LQFOXVH vQ
PDWULFHDGHLQWHUFRUHOD LLFRPSOHFúLFDVWUXFWXU IDFWRULDO úLPDLSX LQ
VWDELOLGHODORWGHVXELHF LODORWGHVXELHF LGHFkWIDFWRULLSULPDUL$XR
YDORDUHvQSULPXOUkQGGHVFULSWLY DVHPHQLVLQGURDPHORUFOLQLFH
'H H[HPSOX VLQGURPXO QHYURWLVPXOXL GLIHULWH HOHPHQWH GH
FRPSRUWDPHQW SUHFXP DQ[LHWDWHD LQGHFL]LD WHPHULOH LUD LRQDOH SRW
FRYDULDIRUPHD] XQFOXVWHUGHHOHPHQWHDOF WXLQGDFHDVW WU V WXU
GHVXSUDID
)RUPDWH ILLQG GLQ PDL PXOWH HOHPHQWH GHWHUPLQDWH GLIHULW WU
V WXULOH GH VXSUDID DSDU PDL SX LQ VWDELOH úL DX R QDWXU PDL SX LQ
SHUPDQHQW (OH QX DX VSXQH &DWWHOO R LPSRUWDQ GHFLVLY SHQWUX
vQ HOHJHUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL'LQDFHDVW SHUVSHFWLY DOLPLWHORUIDFWRULORU
GHVXSUDID VXV LQH&DWWHOOvQSVLKRORJLHVDGDWRSUHDPDUHDWHQ LH
XQRUFRQFHSWHSUHFXPH[WUDYHUVLDGDWRULW PDLDOHVXQHLLOX]RULLQHYRL
GHDILPDLDSURDSHGHIDSWXOSVLKLFJHQXLQÌQWUXQVHQVGDÄVXQWPDL
DSURDSHGHIDSWHGDUDFHDVWDQXHVWHRYLUWXWHúWLLQ LILF SHQWUXF R
LPSRUWDQW OHF LH D úWLLQ HL HVWH IDSWXO F H PDL HFRQRPLF úL VHPQLIL
FDWLYV OXFUH]LFXPHFDQLVPHOHWHRUHWLFHFDUHVWDXvQVSDWHOHIDSWHORU
GHFkWFXRSOXUDOLWDWHGHIDSWH´
7U V WXULOHVXUV VXQWLPSRUWDQWHVWDELOHúLSHUPDQHQWHSHQWUXF
VXQW IDFWRUL XQLWDUL ILHFDUH GLQWUH HOH ILLQG VXUVD XQXL DVSHFW DO
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL )DFWRULL SULPDUL FDUH GHULY GLQ DQDOL]D IDFWRULDO
H[SULP DFHVWH WU V WXUL VXUV FD HOHPHQWH GH ED] DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL
Ä(VWH SHUPLV V YRUELP GHVSUH IDFWRUL SULPDUL FX VHQVXO GH FHOH PDL
LPSRUWDQWH GLPHQVLXQL DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL VSXQH &DWWHOO QXPDL GDF
YRUELPvQPRGUD LRQDOGHROLVW GHYDULDELOHSULPDUHVDXED]DOH´
ÌQ H[SORUDUHD GH WLS DQDOLWLF IDFWRULDO HVWH QHFHVDU DGRSWDUHD
DFHVWXL SXQFW GH YHGHUH OD LHúLUH SHQWUX F QX VH SRW H[SORUD WUHSWDW
GLPHQVLXQLOH IDFWRULDOH úL DSRL V OH SXL DO WXUL vQWUR ÄKDUW ´ FX
SURSRU LLOHFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHÌQDFHVWVHQVHVWHGHGRULWV VHSRUQHDVF
úWLLQ LILFSULQWURFRQFHS LHXQLWDU DVXSUDSHUVRQDOLW LLWRWDOHúLIDFWR
UL]DUHD V vQFHDS DVWIHO GH OD XQ QXP U FkW PDL ODUJ GH YDULDELOH
&DWWHOOSRUQHúWHGXS FXPDPSUHFL]DWGHODPXOWLWXGLQHDGHWHUPHQL
OLQJYLVWLFL
/D UkQGXO ORU WU V WXULOH VXUV SRW IL FODVLILFDWH vQ GRX WLSXUL
WU V WXULFRQVWLWX LRQDOHúLWU V WXULFDUH LQGHPHGLX7U V WXULOHVXUV
FRQVWLWX LRQDOHvúLDXRULJLQHDvQFRQGL LLOHLQWHUQHDOHRUJDQLVPXOXLGHúL
QX VXQW vQ PRG QHFHVDU vQQ VFXWH úL GHFL GHSLQG GH IL]LRORJLD RUJD
QLVPXOXL&DH[HPSOX&DWWHOOLQGLF IDSWXOF XWLOL]DUHDDOFRROXOXLGXFH
ODLQIOXHQ HFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHFHVHSRWGHVFULHFDOLSV GHJULMLOLPEX LH
URVWLUHD QHFODU D FXYLQWHORU $QDOL]D IDFWRULDO YD JUXSD DFHVWH LQIOX
HQ HLQGLFkQGXOHFDWU V WXU VXUV
7U V WXULOH VXUV FDUH LQ GH PHGLX GHULY FXP DUDW úL GH
QXPLUHD GLQ LQIOXHQ HOH FDGUXOXL VRFLRIL]LF &DWWHOO JUXSHD] DFHOH
FDUDFWHULVWLFL vQY DWH VDX PRGDOLW L GH FRPSRUWDPHQW vQY DWH HWF
FDUHIRUPHD] XQPRGHOFHHVWHLPSXVúLLPSULPDWvQSHUVRQDOLWDWHGH
PHGLX 'H H[HPSOX XQ FkQW UH GH MD] HVWH GLIHULW FD WU V WXUL VXUV
IRUPDWHGHPHGLXOV XGHXQRIL HUGHFDULHU
ÌQDIDUDDFHVWRUGLVWLQF LLúLWD[RQRPL] ULDWU V WXULORUSHQWUX
vQ HOHJHUHD RUJDQL] ULL GLQDPLFH D SHUVRQDOLW LL HVWH GHFLVLY
VSXQH&DWWHOOV VHLDvQFRQVLGHUDUHIRU HOHGLQDPLFHVDXPRWL
YD LRQDOH ([LVW vQ SVLKLFXO XPDQ GRX WLSXUL GH WU V WXUL
GLQDPLFHDPEHOHVHPDQLIHVW ODQLYHOXODWLWXGLQLORU$FHVWHD
VXQWGHQXPLWHVHQWLPHQWHúLHUJL&XYkQWXOHUJHVWHGHULYDWGH
&DWWHOOGLQJUHFHVFXOHUJRQSHQWUXDvQORFXLFRQFHSWXOSUHDYDJ
GHLPSXOVVDXLQVWLQFW8QHUJHVWHHQHUJLDVXUV SHQWUXvQWUHJ
FRPSRUWDPHQWXO XQLWDWHD GH ED] D PRWLYD LHL (UJXO HVWH
GLUHF LRQDWVSUHVFRSXULSUHFLVH
&HUFHW ULOHGHDQDOL] IDFWRULDO H[WUDJHUJLFDPRWLYHXPDQH
IXQGDPHQWDOHFXULR]LWDWHDVH[XDOLWDWHDJUHJDULWDWHDQHYRLDGHSURWHF LH
DILUPDUHDGHVLQHQHYRLDGHVHFXULWDWHIRDPHDPkQLDGH]JXVWXODWUDF
WLYLWDWHD VXSXQHUHD 6HQWLPHQWXO HVWH R WU V WXU VXUV GH WLS PHGLX
GHFLXQPRGHOGHDWLWXGLQLvQY DWHGHLQGLYLG(VWHFHQWUDWSHDVSHFWHOH
LPSRUWDQWHGLQYLD DOXLSDUWHQHUSURIHVLHUHOLJLHKREE\XULSDWULHHWF
'LIHUHQ D GLQWUH HUJ úL VHQWLPHQW LQH GH GXUDELOLWDWHD GLIHULW
(UJXOILLQGFRQVWLWX LRQDOHVWHRVWUXFWXU SHUPDQHQW úLQLFLRGDW QX
YDGLVS UHDWRWDOGLQSVLKLFXOSHUVRDQHLSRDWHYDULDGRDUFDLQWHQVLWDWH
6HQWLPHQWXO IRUPDW SULQ vQY DUH SRDWH IL vQ WLPS VXSXV SURFHVXOXL
LQYHUVGHGH]vQY DUHDVWIHOF SRDWHGLVSDUHQHPDLDYkQGLPSRUWDQ
YLD D SHUVRDQHL 3HQWUX ILHFDUH SHUVRDQ H[LVW XQ PRGHO VDX VHW GH
VHQWLPHQWHFDUHYDIXQF LRQDFDXQVHQWLPHQWPDVWHUGHQXPLUHSULQ
FDUH&DWWHOOQHLQWURGXFHVHQWLPHQWXOGHVLQH$FHVWVHQWLPHQWID GH
SURSULDSHUVRDQ HVWHFHOPDLLPSRUWDQWúLYLUWXDOVHUHIOHFW vQWRDWH
DWLWXGLQLOHSHUVRDQHL(VWHFHHDFHDVLJXU XQLWDWHDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL
DSVLKLVPXOXLLQGLYLGXOXLUHVSHFWLYVWDELOLWDWHDFRHUHQ DRUJDQL]DUHD
WXWXURUWU V WXULORUVXUV /HJDWGLUHFWGHH[SULPDUHDHUJXULORUúLVHQWL
PHQWHORUVHQWLPHQWXOGHVLQHSULQIXQF LRQDUHDVDFRQWUROHD] WRDWH
VWUXFWXULOHSHUVRQDOLW LL
'HDVHPHQHDSULYLQGGLQDPLFDGH]YROW ULLSHUVRQDOLW LL&DWWHOO
RIHU RYL]LXQHED]DW SHRPXOWLWXGLQHGHGDWHH[SHULPHQWDOHRE LQXWH
SULQVWXGLHUHDORQJLWXGLQDO úLWUDQVYHUVDO DYkUVWHORU([LVW VWDGLL
PDUL SULQ FDUH WUHFH SHUVRQDOLWDWHD 0LFD FRSLO ULH FDUH GXUHD]
SkQ VSUH DQL úL HVWH FRQVLGHUDW FD R SHULRDG GH IRUPDUH PDMRU
SHQWUXSHUVRQDOLWDWHFkQGLQGLYLGXOVXSRUWkQGSXWHUQLFHLQIOXHQ HGLQ
SDUWHDS ULQ LORUIUD LORUDWU LULORUOHJDWHGHPRGXOvQFDUHLVHLPSXQ
úL IRUPHD] GHSULQGHULOH SULYLQG WRDOHWD úL HYDFXDUHD vúL VWUXFWXUHD]
DWLWXGLQLOH VRFLDOH SULPDUH VWDELOLWDWHD úL IRU D HXOXL úL VXSUDHXOXL
VHQWLPHQWXOGHVHFXULWDWHVDXLQVHFXULWDWHDWLWXGLQHDID GHDXWRULWDWH
úL SRVLELOD WHQGLQ VSUH QHYURWLVP 6WDGLXO DO GRLOHD DO FRSLO ULHL
GXUHD] SkQ VSUH DQL ILLQG R SHULRDG GH FRQVROLGDUH vQFHSXWXO
XQHLWHQGLQ HGHHPDQFLSDUHúLLQGHSHQGHQ ID GHS ULQ LúLRFUHú
WHUH vQ SDUDOHO D WHQGLQ HL GH D VH LGHQWLILFD FX FHL DVHPHQHD GLQ MXU
$GROHVFHQ DHVWHDWUHLDHWDS FDUHGXUHD] SkQ VSUHGHDQLúLHVWH
FHDPDLSOLQ GHVWUHVúLSUREOHPHVXELHFWLYH([LVW WUDQVIRUP ULDOH
WU V WXULORU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH XQHOH GLVSDU GHILQLWLY DOWHOH DELD DFXP
DSDU6XUVHOHPDMRUHDOHFRQIOLFWXOXLVXQWQHYRLDGHLQGHSHQGHQ GH
DILUPDUHSHUVRQDOHúLWUHEXLQ HOHVH[XDOHÌQFRQVHFLQ vQDFHDVW SH
ULRDG LQFLGHQ DEROLORUQHUYRDVHúLDGHOLQFYHQ HLFUHúWH0DWXULWDWHD
vQWUHúLGHDQLHVWHRSHULRDG SURGXFWLY SHUVRQDOLWDWHDWLQGHV
GHYLQ VWDELOL]DW FUHúWH VWDELOLWDWHD HPR LRQDO 0DWXULWDWHD WkU]LH
LQFOXGHVFKLPE ULúLDGDSW ULvQSHUVRQDOLWDWHFDU VSXQVODFHOHIL]LFH
VRFLDOH SVLKRORJLFH SULQ FDUH WUHFH SHUVRDQD $UH ORF UHH[DPLQDUHD
YDORULORUúLRF XWDUHDVLQHOXL% WUkQH HDLQFOXGHSUREOHPDWLFDDGDS
W ULLODRVHULHGHSLHUGHULSUHFXPúLRELúQXLQ DFXVLQJXU WDWHDúLOLSVD
VHFXULW LLSHUVRQDOH
7RDWHDFHVWHDVSHFWHVXQWSDUDGLJPHOHSULQFDUHWUHEXLHvQ HOHVH
úL LQWHUSUHWDWH HYDOX ULOH FDUH UH]XOW GLQ DSOLFDUHD FKHVWLRQDUHORU OXL
&DWWHOO OD GLIHULWH YkUVWH ÌQ DIDUD FKHVWLRQDUXOXL FHORU IDFWRUL DL
SHUVRQDOLW LL ± 3)4 GHGLFDW YkUVWHL DGXOWH &DWWHOO FRQVWUXLHúWH
QXPHURDVHDOWHFKHVWLRQDUHSUHFXP&KHVWLRQDUXOSHQWUXDGROHVFHQ L±
+634 DSOLFDELO SHQWUX YkUVWH vQWUH úL DQL FKHVWLRQDUXO SHQWUX
FRSLL±&34DSOLFDELOvQWUHúLDQLúL(634FKHVWLRQDUXOSHQWUX
SUHúFRODULvQWUHúLDQL([LVW GHDVHPHQHDPXOWHDOWHFKHVWLRQDUHúL
LQVWUXPHQWHGHHYDOXDUHSULQWUHFDUHPDLFXQRVFXWHVWH&$4&OLQLFDO
$QDO\VLV4HVWLRQQDLUHODQLYHOXOF UXLDDO WXULGHFHOHWU V WXULSUL
PDUHDSDUvQF WU V WXULVXUV SHQWUXHYDOXDUHDDQRUPDOLW LLSVLKLFH
ÌQ OXFUDUHD VD 3HUVRQDOLWDWHD úL GLVSR]L LLOH SULQ FKHVWLRQDUH
&DWWHOOvúLSUH]LQW SURIHVLXQHDGHFUHGLQ FRPXQ FXFHDDXQXL
DOWPDUHSHUVRQRORJ(\VHQFNLQGLYL]LLGLIHU SULQSR]L LDORUUHODWLY
GHD OXQJXO FRQWLQXXOXL WU V WXULORU úL GLVSR]L LLORU ID GH VW ULOH VDX
ÄFRQGL LLOHLQWHUQHGHWUHFHUH$FHVWHGLPHQVLXQLVXQWP VXUDELOHSULQ
LQWHUPHGLXOIDFWRULORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
&KHVWLRQDUXOIDFWRULSULPDUL±3)4
'DWHGHVSUHFKHVWLRQDU
3HQWUX D HYDOXD WU V WXULOH LGHQWLILFDWH SULQ DQDOL]D IDFWRULDO
&DWWHOO FRQVWUXLHúWH úL SXEOLF vQ FKHVWLRQDUXO 3) GHQXPLW
Ä&KHVWLRQDUXOFHORUIDFWRULDLSHUVRQDOLW LL´
,QYHQWDUXOSRUQHúWHGHODFHOHWU V WXULVXUV GHILQLWHSULQDQD
OL]DIDFWRULDO LDULWHPLLVXQWVHOHFWD LSHED]DVDWXUD LHLvQIDFWRULLUHV
SHFWLYLI U DVHVSHFLILFDIHOXOvQFDUHDXIRVWLQL LDOIRUPXOD LVDXDOHúL
0XOWHGLQWUHGHQXPLULOHWU V WXULORUVXQWIRUPXO ULVSHFLDOHDOHOXL
&DWWHOO3HQWUXDFHVWDFHHDFHDUHLPSRUWDQ HVWHH[DFWLWDWHDúWLLQ LILF D
WHUPLQRORJLHLúLvQDFHVWVFRSDHOLPLQ ULLWXWXURUFRQRWD LLORUVSHFLILFH
OLPEDMXOXLRELúQXLWDOHJHVROX LDUHGHILQLULLH[DFWHDFRQFHSWHORUIRORVLWH
úLPDLPXOWDVLVWHPDWL] ULLúLFRG ULLWHUPHQLORUÌQDFHVWVHQVFKHV
WLRQDUXOHVWHLQGLFDWV ILHXWLOL]DWGRDUGHSURIHVLRQLúWLIDPLOLDUL]D LFX
WHRULDOXL&DWWHOOúLFXVHPQLILFD LDH[DFW DILHF UXLIDFWRU
&DWWHOODIRVWGLQWUHFHLFDUHDXLQVWDXUDWRULJRDUHvQPXOWLWXGLQHD
GHWHUPHQLSHQWUXGLIHUL LIDFWRULDLSHUVRQDOLW LLSOHGkQGúLLQWURGXFkQG
vQ FHOH GLQ XUP XQ FRG XQLYHUVDO GHQXPLW Ä,QGH[ XQLYHUVDO´ FDUH vL
SHUPLWHV vQPDJD]LQH]HFRHUHQWUH]XOWDWHOHGLIHULWHORUFHUFHW UL,QL LDO
VLVWHPDWL]DUHDDvQFHSXWSULQVLPEROXUL±OLWHUHDSRLVLPEROXULQXPHULFH
$FHDVW OLVW vQ FDUH ILHF UXL IDFWRU L VH G XQ LQGLFDWLY GH FRG 8,
LQGH[XQLYHUVDOQXVHSDU IDFWRULLGHWLSDELOLWDWHPHQWDO GHFHLWHP
SHUDPHQWDOLVDXGHFHLGLQDPLFLÌQDQH[DDOXFU ULL3HUVRQDOLWDWHúL
PRWLYD LH6WUXFWXU úLP VXUDUHSUH]LQW GHWDOLDWDFHVW,QGH[XQLYHUVDO
&RQ LQXWXOLWHPLORUHVWHH[SULPDWSULQGRX PRGHOHXQLLLQFOXG
vQWUHE ULOHJDWHGHSURSULXOFRPSRUWDPHQWDOVXELHFWXOXLFDUHU VSXQGH
SUHFXP úL H[SULPDUHD XQRU RSLQLL VDX DWLWXGLQL JHQHUDOH GHVSUH
RDPHQLFHLODO LFHUVXELHFWXOXLV DOHDJ vQWUHGRX SRVLELOHRFXSD LL
DFWLYLW L UHFUHDWLYH WLSXUL GH RDPHQL VDX DOWHUQDWLYH SULYLQG MXGHF L
GHYDORDUH([LVW úLLWHPLYHUEDOLVDXQXPHULFLGHVWLQD LHYDOX ULLXQXL
IDFWRUGHDELOLWDWHUH]ROXWLY
&KHVWLRQDUXO DUH GRX IRUPH SDUDOHOH D FkWH LWHPL 3RDWH IL
XWLOL]DWFXDPEHOHIRUPHVLPXOWDQ'DUFHUFHW ULOHDXGHPRQVWUDWRPDUH
ILGHOLWDWH D DFHVWRU IRUPH SHQWUX WRDWH FHOH VFDOH DOH FKHVWLRQDUXOXL
GHODODFRHILFLHQ LLGHRPRJHQLWDWHGHODODúLGHYDOL
GLWDWHGHODODFDUHvQGUHSW HVFRHFKLYDODUHDVFRUXULORUSHQWUX
IRUPD$úL%
1XPHURDVHVWXGLLDXIRVWUHDOL]DWHSHQWUXDUHOLHIDYDOLGLWDWHDHP
SLULF DFKHVWLRQDUXOXLGHDVHPHQHDQXPHURDVHWUDGXFHULH[SHULPHQW UL
úL QRUP UL SH SRSXOD LL QRQDPHULFDQH ([LVW úL QRUP UL UHDOL]DWH SH
SRSXOD LD URPkQHDVF )RDLD GH SURILO D WHVWXOXL LQGLF PDQLIHVW ULOH
FRPSRUWDPHQWDOHSHQWUXFHOHGRX H[WUHPHDOHGLPHQVLXQLLFDUHWUHEXLH
vQ HOHVHGLQSHUVSHFWLYDGDWHORUGHFHUFHWDUHSULYLQGIDFWRULLUHVSHFWLYL
3UH]HQWDUHDIDFWRULORU
)DFWRULL HYDOXD LSULQDQDOL] IDFWRULDO VXQWFRQVWUXFWHELSRODUH
FDUH vQFHDUF V FXSULQG PXO LPHD GH PDQLIHVW UL FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH
VSHFLILFH GLPHQVLXQLL vQ PRG JUDGDW GH OD XQXO GLQWUH SROLL DFHVWHLD
FDUDFWHUL]DWSULQWURPD[LP H[SULPDUHvQFRPSRUWDPHQWDXQHLH[WUHPH
DGLPHQVLXQLLVSUHFHO ODOWFDUDFWHUL]DWSULQWURPD[LP H[SULPDUHD
RSXVXOXL
7HVWXO HYDOXHD] SULQ GDWHOH QRUPDWLYH SR]L LD LQGLYLGXOXL GHD
OXQJXODFHVWXLFRQWLQXXP6SHFLILFDFHVWXLWLSGHHYDOX ULFHHDFHVHLD
vQFRQVLGHUDUHvQLQWHUSUHW ULFDVHPQLILFDWLYúLDFWLYvQFRPSRUWDPHQWXO
UHDODOSHUVRDQHLHVWHDFHOIDFWRUDF UXLSRQGHUHGHS úHúWHvQWUXQVHQV
VDXDOWXO]RQDGHVHPQLILFD LHPHGLH$VWIHOGHH[HPSOXvQVLVWHPXOGH
QRUPDUHvQFODVHVWDQGDUGXWLOL]DWGH&DWWHOOVXQWVHPQLILFDWLYHSHQ
WUXFRPSRUWDPHQWXOUHDODOSHUVRDQHLDFH,HWU V WXULFDUHDXRSR]LWLHGH
OD FRWD VWDQGDUG VSUH VDX GH OD FRWD VSUH &X DWkW HVWH PDL
DFWLY WU V WXUDFXXQSROVDXDOWXODOHLFXFkWFRWDVWDQGDUGHVWHPDL
H[WUHPL]DW GHFLQRWHOHúLúLLQGLF XQPD[LPDFWLYLVPDODFHVWHL
WU V WXUL vQ SDWHUQXO GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH FDUH VH H[SULP SULQ FDUDFWH
ULVWLFLOHVSHFLILFHSROXOXLUHVSHFWLY
3HQWUXLQWHUSUHWDUHvQVWDELOLUHDHFXD LHLFDUDFWHULVWLFHVXELHFWXOXL
VHH[WUDJDFHLIDFWRULSULPDULFDUHVXQWGHRVHELWGHDFWLYLvQFHSkQGFX
IDFWRULLFDUHDXQRWD7úLDSRLVHFRQWLQX FXIDFWRULLFDUHDXQRWD7
úLDSRLúLúLvQILQDOXOOLVWHLIDFWRULLFXQRWD7úLÌQFRQWL
QXDUHVHWUHFHODFDOFXODUHDQRWHL7DIDFWRULORUVHFXQGDUL
)$&7258/$±6FKL]RWLPLHYVFLFORWLPLH
3ROXO H[SULPDW SULQ FRWH VWDQGDUG MRDVH GH OD OD FDUDFWHUL
]HD] XQFRPSRUWDPHQWSULQDVSHFWHSUHFXPVFKL]RWLPLHRUJROLXVSLULW
FULWLFRSR]DQ U FHDO úLLQGLIHUHQ VXVSLFLXQHULJLGLWDWH3ROXORSXV
vQFHSkQGGHODFRWDVWDQGDUGVSUHLQGLF XQFRPSRUWDPHQWFDUDFWH
UL]DWSULQFLFORWLPLHLQGLYLGXOHVWHEXQDPDELOSULHWHQRVVHUYLDELOFX
LQWHUHVSHQWUXFHLODO LEOkQGvQFUH] WRUDGDSWDELOúLFDOG
'DWHOH GH FHUFHWDUH LQGLF SRUQLQG GH OD GLKRWRPLD FOLQLF vQWUH
SVLKR]HOH VFKL]RLGH úL GH]RUGLQHD FLFOLF PDQLDFRGHSUHVLY RGLPHQ
VLXQH GHILQLW TXDVLVLPLODU úL vQ ]RQD GH QRUPDOLWDWH SVLKLF vQWUH
U FHDOD DIHFWLY úL F OGXUD DIHFWLY &DUDFWHULVWLFH FLFORWLPXOXL DIHFWL
YLW LL FLFOLFH VXQW XúXULQ D FX FDUH WUDLHúWH VH HPR LRQHD] LQWHUHVXO
PDUFDWSHQWUXVHPHQLúLILLQ HvQJHQHUDOFDUHQXUDUHRULVHH[SULP úLvQ
DOHJHUHDXQHLSURIHVLLFDUHvQVHDPQ FRQWDFWHLQWHUXPDQHúLRWHQGLQ
VSUHDVHFRQIRUPDFRQYHQLHQ HORUVRFLDOH8QJUXSIRUPDWGLQSHUVRDQH
GH WLS FLFORWLPLF HVWH DFWLY PDL SX LQ D[DW SH FULWLF FX LQGLYL]L PDL
JHQHURúLvQUDSRUWXULOHLQWHUSHUVRQDOH3HUVRDQHOHGHODSROXORSXVVXQW
PDL SX LQ FRQFLOLDQWH SUHIHU OXFUXULOH FXYLQWHOH YLD D VROLWDU VXQW
LQWURVSHFWLYLDSDUVHULRúLSUHIHU RFDPDUDGHULHLQWHOHFWXDO ÌQDFHODúL
WLPSVXQWPDLSURIXQ]LvQDSUHFLHUHDDOWRUDPDLVLJXULvQWURDFWLYLWDWH
FDUH FHUH SUHFL]LH XQHRUL PDL LQYHQWLYL PDL DWHQ L vQ DúL UHVSHFWD
SURPLVLXQLOHúLvQVDWLVIDFHUHDREOLJD LLORUFHOHUHYLQ
)$&7258/%±$ELOLWDWHUH]ROXWLY JHQHUDO
6FDODQXDUHFRUHOD LLVHPQLILFDWLYHFXWHVWHOHGHDELOLW LPHQWDOH
RELúQXLWHFDUHWLSLFVXQWSUREHSVLKRORJLFHvQWLPSOLPLWDW
)DFWRUXO % P VRDU GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD WHRULHL OXL &DWWHOO DFHO
IDFWRU JHQHUDO GHQXPLW LQWHOLJHQ &DWWHOO GLVWLQJH vQWUH LQWHOLJHQ D
IOXLG GHILQLW FDRFDSDFLWDWHvQQ VFXW FDUHSRDWHILDSOLFDW ODWRDWH
WLSXULOHGHFRQ LQXWXULúLLQWHOLJHQ DFULVWDOL]DW FDIRUP FDUHGHSLQGH
PXOW GH HGXFD LD IRUPDO H[SULPkQG WLSXULOH GH DELOLW L vQY DWH vQ
úFRDO ,QWHOLJHQ D IOXLG DIHFWHD] LQWHOLJHQ D FULVWDOL]DW SULQ IDSWXO
F LQIOXHQ HD] FkW GH PXOW EHQHILFLHP GLQ vQY DUHD úFRODU (YD
OXDUHDLQWHOLJHQ HLIOXLGHVHSRDWHUHDOL]DGRDUSULQWHVWHFDUHQXIDFvQ
FRQ LQXWXOORUUHIHULQ HODFXOWXU FXOWXUHIDLULQWHOOLJHQFHWHVW
$FHVW JHQ GH WHRULH DVXSUD LQWHOLJHQ HL FD DSWLWXGLQH DGDSWDWLY
SUHPHUJH vQ HSRF DERUG ULOH VLVWHPLFH FRQWHPSRUDQH DOH LQWHOLJHQ HL
GHS úLQGYL]LXQHDVWULFWELRORJLF VDXSHFHDSVLKRPHWULF $FHVWWLSGH
DERUGDUH VLVWHPLF DL F UHL UHSUH]HQWDQ L FRQWHPSRUDQL VXQW *DUGQHU
úL 6WHUQEHUJ vQFHDUF V FHUFHWH]H LQWHUVHF LD GLQWUH
FRJQL LH úL FRQWH[WX, vQ FDUH VH DSOLF FD XQ VLVWHP 7HRULD WULDUKLF D
LQWHOLJHQ HL D OXL 6WHUQEHUJ GH H[HPSOX VH UHIHU OD WUHL DVSHFWH DOH
DFHVWHLLQWHUVHF LLFHOHWUHLIXQF LLDOHLQWHOLJHQ HLvQFRQWH[WXOH[LVWHQ LDO
UHDOFHOHWUHLWLSXULGHFRPSRQHQWHLPSOLFDWHvQSURFHVDUHDLQIRUPD LHL
QLYHOXOGHIDPLOLDULWDWHQRXWDWHDOVDUFLQLORUDFWXDOH6WHUQEHUJ
0DL DOHV GLQ DFHDVW SHUVSHFWLY &DWWHOO VH FRQHFWHD] WHRUHWLF DILU
PkQG GH H[HPSOX vQ LPSRUWDQ D QLYHOXOXL GH UHODWLY QRXWDWH DO
VDUFLQLL SHQWUX P VXUDUHD LQWHOLJHQ HL UHODWLY vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH VH
DUJXPHQWHD] RVDUFLQ FRPSOHWQRX QXHVWHRP VXU DGHFYDW SHQWUX
HYDOXDUHDLQWHOLJHQ HLSHQWUXF QXH[LVW DFHOHVWUXFWXULFRJQLWLYHFDUH
VXQWQHFHVDUHSHQWUXDERUGDUHDDFHYDFRPSOHWQHFXQRVFXW
&RWHOH VWDQGDUG VF ]XWH OD IDFWRUXO % P VXUDW SULQ VDUFLQL DWkW
UHDOHFkWúLRS LRQDOHLQGLF RVODE DELOLWDWHPHQWDO FDUHDWUDJHGXS
VLQH úL R PRUDOLWDWH LQIHULRDU WHQGLQ D GH D DEDQGRQD FX XúXULQW
OLSVDGHLQWHUHVSHQWUXVXELHFWHLQWHOHFWXDOHOLSVDGHFXOWXU vQJHQHUDO
3ROXORSXVGHODVSUHvQFUHúWHUHLQGLF LQWHOLJHQ DYLHFRQúWLLQ
FLR]LWDWHD úL SHUVHYHUHQ D vQ UH]ROYDUHD SUREOHPHORU WHQGLQ D GH D IL
FXOWLYDWúLGHDJkQGLvQSODQDEVWUDFWORJLF
)$&7258/&±,QVWDELOLWDWHHPR LRQDO YV
VWDELOLWDWHHPR LRQDO
3ROXO FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQ LQVWDELOLWDWH UHSUH]LQW FDUDFWHULVWLFL DOH
XQXL HX VODE HPRWLYLWDWH LPDWXULWDWH DIHFWLY LQVWDELOLWDWH LQGLYLGXO
UHDF LRQHD] ODIUXVWUD LHvQWURPDQLHU HPR LRQDO HVWHLQFRQVWDQWvQ
DWLWXGLQL úL LQWHUHVH HVWH H[FLWDELO úL KLSHUUHDFWLY IXJH GH UHVSRQVD
ELOLW LDEDQGRQHD] XúRUHVWHQHOLQLúWLWLPSOLFDWvQFRQIOLFWHDJLWDW
YLV WRUSRDWHILLPSOLFDWúLvQDFFLGHQWH
/DSROXORSXVDSDUFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHXQXLHXSXWHUQLFPDWXUFDOP
,QGLYLGXO HVWH VWDELO FRQVWDQW vQ LQWHUHVH HFKLOLEUDW HPR LRQDO FKLDU
IOHJPDWLF VDX SODFLG UHDOLVW VH DGDSWHD] IDSWHORU QX VH PDQLIHVW
XúRURERVHDODQHUYRDV QXVHDPHVWHF vQFRQIOLFWH
)RU DHXOXLGHILQLW FDúLJUDGGHUHDOL]DUHDLQWHJU ULLGLQDPLFHúL
DFRQWUROXOXLHPR LRQDOQXHVWHSHQWUX&DWWHOOFDúLSHQWUX(\VHQFNR
SUREOHP FDUH V LQ SUHSRQGHUHQW GH IRUPDUH úL PHGLX 7HQGLQ HOH
FRQVWLWX LRQDOHIDFFDIRUPDUHDFRQWUROXOXLHPR LRQDOV ILHPDLGLILFLO
SHQWUX XQHOH SHUVRDQH 'LDJQR]D GLIHUHQ LDO D IHOXOXL GH D WU L IUXV
WUDUHDGHH[HPSOXWUHEXLHV VHUDSRUWH]HODDFHVWDVSHFWFRQVWLWX LRQDO
3HUVRDQD FX XQ HX VODE WLQGH V ILH FX XúXULQ FRQWUDULDW GH
OXFUXULúLRDPHQLWU LQGXQVHQWLPHQWGHLQVDWLVIDF LHvQIDPLOLHúFRDO
VDX SURIHVLH úL DUH GLILFXOW L vQ S VWUDUHD FDOPXOXL V VH EXFXUH VH
GHVFXUDMHD] OHVQH ÌQ DFHVW VHQV OD DFHVW SRO DSDU PDL GHVH UHDF LLOH
QHYURWLFHJHQHUDOL]DWHVXEIRUPDXQRUWXOEXU ULSVLKRVRPDWLFHWXOEXU UL
GLJHVWLYHGHVRPQVDXWHPHULLUD LRQDOHúLFRPSRUWDPHQWHREVHVLYH3H
GHDOW SDUWHvQPXOWHFD]XULGHWXOEXU ULGHSHUVRQDOLODWHúLGHQHYUR]H
VHvQWkOQHVFFRWHVF ]XWHDOHIDFWRUXOXL&
)$&7258/(±6XSXQHUHYVGRPLQDQ
3ROXO FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL VXSXV EOkQG FX QRWH 7 vQWUH úL
LQGLF GHSHQGHQ D GDU úL R QDWXUDOH H úL R EXQ YRLQ FDUDFWHULVWLFH
2 SHUVRDQ FRQIRUPLVW úL XúRU GH GRPLQDW VXILFLHQW VLHúL 3ROXO
RSXVQRWHOHvQWUHúLLQGLF XQFRPSRUWDPHQWDJUHVLYFRPEDWLY
vQF S kQDWVLJXUGHVLQHDILUPDWLYVHYHUFKLDUGXUVDXRVWLODXVWHU
FXRJUDYLWDWHDIHFWDW 1RQFRQIRUPLVWGDUGRUQLFV FDSWH]HDWHQ LD
'DWHOHHPSLULFHLQGLF IDSWXOF DFHDVW GLPHQVLXQHFRPSRUW R
UHODWLY GLIHUHQ LHUH vQ IXQF LH GH VH[ OD IHPHL VH PDQLIHVW SULQWUR
QXDQ PDL PDUFDW GH LSRKRQGULH SULQ WHQGLQ D GH D DWUDJH DWHQ LD
GDUúLGHHFKLOLEUXVRFLDOFDUHGLIHU GHDQVDPEOXORULHQWDWPDLDJUHVLY
OD E UED L /D DPEHOH VH[H vQV HVWH VSHFLILF IDSWXO F R GRPLQDQW
SXWHUQLF SRDWHFRQGXFHODXQWLSGHYRLQ REVWLQDW úLFKLDUVSUHXQ
FRPSRUWDPHQWDQWLVRFLDOUHEHO
8QHOH GDWH GH FHUFHWDUH LQGLF IDSWXO F GRPLQDQ D WLQGH V
FRUHOH]HFXVWDWXWXOVRFLDOILLQGPDLULGLFDW ODOLGHULLUHFXQRVFX LÌQ
JUXSHOH GH SHUVRDQH IRUPDWH GLQ LQGLYL]L GRPLQDQ L VH QRWHD] R
LQWHUUHOD LHGHUROXULPDLHILFLHQW SUHFXPúLGRPLQDUHDXQRUSURFHGHH
GH WLS GHPRFUDWLF DVWIHO GH SHUVRDQH VH VLPW OLEHUH V SDUWLFLSH VH
DQJDMHD] I U HIRUWXUL VDX H]LW UL vQ SUREOHPHOH GH JUXS FULWLF
GHVFKLVLPSHUIHF LXQLOH
1RWHOHULGLFDWHVHDVRFLD] GHDVHPHQHDFXFRPSRUWDPHQWHOHGH
WLS GHOLFWXDO GLQ SHULRDGD DGROHVFHQ HL 1RWHOH VF ]XWH VH vQWkOQHVF
DGHVHDODQHYURWLFL
)$&7258/)±([SDQVLYLWDWHYVQRQH[SDQVLYLWDWH
)DFWRUXO)HVWHXQFRQVWLWXHQWLPSRUWDQWDOH[WUDYHUVLHLLQWURYHUVLHL
FDIDFWRUVHFXQGDU
3ROXOQRQH[SDQVLYFXQRWH7vQWUHúLLQGLF XQFRPSRUWDPHQW
PRGHUDW SUXGHQW WDFLWXUQ LQWURVSHFWLY FX WHQGLQ D VSUH GHSULPDUH úL
UHYHULH ÌQ JHQHUDO QHFRPXQLFDWLY PXO XPLW GH VLQH OHJDW GH YDORUL
SHUVRQD,HOHQWUHIOHFWDQW3ROXORSXVDOH[SDQVLYLW LLLQGLF XQFRP
SRUWDPHQWLPSXOVLYHQWX]LDVWYHVHOGLUHFWSOLQGHYLD ,QGLYLGXOHVWH
JXUDOLYH[SUHVLYOHJDWGHJUXSVSRQWDQvQUHDF LL
(VWH XQXO GLQWUH IDFWRULL FDUH VXSRUW LQIOXHQ D PHGLXOXL GH IRU
PDUHvQP VXUDvQFDUHGDWHOHGHFHUFHWDUHDUDW F FHLH[SDQVLYLDXDYXW
vQJHQHUDOXQPHGLXPDLIDFLOPDLSX LQVHYHUFUHDWRUGHRSWLPLVPGDU
úLFXDVSLUD LLPDLSX LQH[LJHQWH1RQH[SDQVLYLLVXQWvQJHQHUDOFUHV
FX LGXS QRUPHPDLVHYHUHúLWLQGVSUHXQSOXVGHPRGHUD LH
1RQH[SDQVLYLLDSDUYLV WRULvúLURGXQJKLLOH([SDQVLYLWDWHDFRUH
OHD] FXSUHIHULQ DSHQWUXDJORPHU ULXUEDQHGDUúLFXSR]L LDvQIDPLOLH
FHOPDLvQYkUVW WLQGHVSUHQRQH[SDQVLYLWDWHFHOPDLWkQ UVSUHDILúL
FHOPDLH[SDQVLY'XS SHULRDGDDGROHVFHQ HLH[SDQVLYLWDWHDSUH]LQW R
GHVFUHúWHUHFXXQGHFOLQPDLPDUFDWSHQWUXSHULRDGDvQWUHúLDQL
'HDVHPHQHDVXQWGDWHFDUHLQGLF FRUHODWLYF QRQH[SDQVLYLWDWHDHVWH
DVRFLDW FXFUHúWHUHDvQF UF WXULLGHDQ[LHWDWH
)$&7258/*±6XSUDHXVODEYVIRU DVXSUDHXOXL
([LVW GRDU R DVHP QDUH VXSHUILFLDO FX IDFWRUXO & SHQWUX F
IDFWRUXO*HVWHOHJDWvQSULQFLSDOGHHQHUJLHúLSHUVHYHUHQ
/D SROXO XQXL VXSUDHX VODE FDUDFWHULVWLF SHQWUX FRPSRUWDPHQW
HVWHOLSVDGHWROHUDQ ODIUXVWUDUHXQLQGLYLGVFKLPE WRULQIOXHQ DELO
FX R HPRWLYLWDWH JHQHUDOL]DW RERVHDO QHUYRDV LQFRQVWDQ úLQHVL
JXUDQ FDUH QHJOLMHD] REOLJD LLOH VRFLDOH ÌQ JHQHUDO FX GH]LQWHUHV
ID GH QRUPHOH PRUDOH FROHFWLYH 3ROXO RSXV FX QRWH vQWUH úL
DWUDJHGXS VLQHDWLWXGLQLGHFRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWHSHUVHYHUHQ UHVSRQVD
ELOLWDWH SHUVRQDO LQVXO H RUGRQDW FRQVHFYHQW DWHQW OD RDPHQLL úL
OXFUXULOHGLQMXU
&RQIRUP GHQXPLULL IDFWRUXO FRUHVSXQGH vQ YL]LXQHD OXL &DWWHOO
VXSUDHXOXLSVLKDQDOLWLFSULQDFFHQWXOSXVSHFRQVLGHUD LDID GHQRU
PHOHPRUDOHWHQGLQ DGHDVXV LQHHXOúLDIUkQDLPSXOVXULOHLGXOXL6H
SRDWH GLVWLQJH GH VWDELOLWDWHD HPR LRQDO P VXUDW GH IDFWRUXO & SULQ
IDSWXOF UH]XOW GLQWURLQWHJUDUHGLQDPLF DGHFYDW GHDOXQJXOYLH LL
3HUVRDQDFXXQ*ULGLFDWVHPDQLIHVW FDUHVSHFWXRDV PHWRGLF
FX R EXQ FDSDFLWDWH GH FRQFHQWUDUH UHIOHFWkQG vQDLQWH GH D YRUEL
SUHIHUkQG GH DVHPHQHD FRPSDQLD FHORU HILFLHQ L $FHVW SRO LQGLF
UHXúLWDvQDFWLYLW LYDULDWHGDUFDUHLPSXQSHUVHYHUHQ UHJXODULWDWHúL
R EXQ RUJDQL]DUH PHQWDO ILLQG vQ JHQHUH XQ SURJQRVWLF EXQ SHQWUX
VXFFHVXOSURIHVLRQDODSWLWXGLQHDSHQWUXUROXULOHGHOLGHUSRSXODULWDWH
3ROXOVF ]XWVHDVRFLD] FXWHQGLQ DVSUHGLVLPXODUHYDJDERQGDMGLV
WUXJHUHúLvQF OFDUHDOHJLLVSUHDFFHVHGHIXULHQHVW SkQLWH
)$&7258/+±7KUHFWLDYVSDUPLD
&HOHGRX GHQXPLULDVFXQGPDQLIHVW ULOHRSXVHDOHGLPHQVLXQLL
UHVSRQVDELOHGHWLPLGLWDWHúLVHQVLELOLWDWHODDPHQLQ DUHSHGHRSDUWH
ID GHFXUDMúLOLSV GHVHQVLELOLWDWHSHGHDOWD
3ROXO WKUHFWLD FX QRWH 7 vQWUH úL LQGLF XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW
GRPLQDWGHWHQGLQ DGHUHSOLHUHDVXSUDSURSULHLSHUVRDQHSUXGHQWUH]HU
YDWGLVWDQWFRQWHPSODWLYFXWHQGLQ DGHDDSDUHDFUXUHFHGH]LQWHUHVDW
GH VH[XO RSXV PRGHUDW úL FRQúWLLQFLRV GDU FX LQWHUHVH OLPLWDWH VXQW
FkWHYDGLQWUHPDQLIHVW ULOHFDUDFWHULVWLFHSHQWUXFRPSRUWDPHQW'HDVH
PHQHDVHUHPDUF RDEVHQ DLQWHUHVXOXLDUWLVWLFVDXDIHFWLYRWHQGLQ
VSUHSHUFHSHUHDUDSLG DSHULFROXOXL3ROXOSDUPLDQRWHOH7vQWUHúL
LQGLF RVRFLDELOLWDWHJUHJDU RSHUVRDQ vQGU ]QHD F UHLDvLSODFHV
vQWkOQHDVF RDPHQL HVWH DFWLY FXUDMRV FX LQWHUHV SHQWUX VH[XO RSXV
,PSXOVLYIULYROQHOLQLúWLWQXYHGHXúRUVHPQHOHSHULFROXOXLFXLQWHUHVH
DUWLVWLFHúLFXRERJDW UH]RQDQ HPR LRQDO
/D QLYHOXO DFHVWXL IDFWRU SXWHUQLF GRPLQDW GH HUHGLWDWH vQWkOQLP
FHHDFH&DWWHOOFRQVLGHUDDILXQWHPSHUDPHQWFRQVWLWX LRQDOVFKL]RWLP
OHSWRVRP5HSOLHUHDSHSURSULDSHUVRDQ JULMDSHQWUXRÄEXQ FRQGXLW ´
SRWILODVFKL]RL]LSUHSVLKRWLFLRWU V WXU GLIHUHQ LDO 6HUHPDUF WRWXúL
F XQDVWIHOGHFRPSRUWDPHQWSRDWHILFRQVLGHUDWQRUPDOvQFLUFXPVWDQ H
WUDXPDWL]DQWHSHQWUXLQGLYLG8QLQVH[FHVLYGHWHP WRUOHQWFXJUHXW L
vQH[SULPDUHFDUHIXJHGHSURIHVLXQLVDXGHVLWXD LLFDUHvLFHUFRQWDFWH
VRFLDOHHVWHPHWLFXORVHYLW PDULOHUHXQLXQLSUHIHU XQXOVDXGRLDPLFL
LQWLPLvLHWHDP GHVLWXD LLOHQRLVDXFRPSHWL LLOHSXEOLFHUHODWLYPDOL
LRV GDU DWHQW OD VHQWLPHQWHOH DOWRUD WU LHúWH XQ VHQWLPHQW GH UHODWLY
LQDGHFYDUHID GHWRWFHHDFHVHvQWkPSO vQMXU
3HUVRDQHOH SDUPLD VH VLPW OLEHUH V SDUWLFLSH GDU DSDU SUROL[H
LQVHQVLELOHLDUvQJUXSWLQGVSUHUHPDUFLGHRUGLQSHUVRQDOPDLGHJUDE
GHFkWOHJDWHGHSUREOHPDvQFDX]
7HUPHQXOGHWKUHFWLDYLQHGHODHQJOH]HVFXOWKUHDWDPHQLQ DUHLQ
GLFkQGRFRUHOD LHFXUHDFWLYLWDWHDULGLFDW DVLVWHPXOXLQHUYRVDXWRQRP
ID GH DPHQLQ DUH RSXV WHPHQXOXL SDUPLD FDUH LQGLF SUHGRPLQDQ
SDUDVLPSDWLF
)$&7258/,±+DUULDYVSUHPVLD
3ROXO KDUULD LQGLF XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW UHDOLVW GDU GXU WLSXO GH
SHUVRDQ FDUH QX VH DúWHDSW ODOXFUXULH[WUDRUGLQDUHGHODFHLODOWLVH
ED]HD] SHVLQHDUHVSLULWSUDFWLFúLUHODWLY LQVHQVLELOLWDWHID GHDO LL
PDWXU HPR LRQDO DVSUX FKLDU FLQLF I U VLP DUWLVWLF UHDF LRQHD]
SUHDSX LQODDVSHFWHHVWHWLFHI U FDvQPRGQHFHVDUV ILHúLOLSVLWGH
JXVWúLQXLDvQVHDP LQFRPRGLW LOHIL]LFH
3ROXO SUHPVLD LQGLF XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW VHQVLELO OD HVWHWLF H[L
JHQW GDU QHU EG WRU UHODWLY LPDWXU HPR LRQDO LQVXO FDXW DMXWRUXO úL
VLPSDWLD DOWRUD HVWH SULHWHQRV EOkQG LQGXOJHQW FX VLQH úL FHLODO L
GLILFLOGHVDWLVI FXWvQSUREOHPHGHDUW LQWURVSHFWLYLPDJLQDWLYúLFX
R ERJDW YLD LQWHULRDU DF LRQHD] SULQ LQWXL LH VHQVLELO vQ SODQ
VRFLDO PDQLIHVW R UHODWLY IULYROLWDWH GRUQLF V DWUDJ DWHQ LD HVWH
QHOLQLúWLWFKLDULSRKRQGUX
'DWHOH HPSLULFH FRUHOHD] SROXO SUHPVLD FX SO FHUHD SHQWUX
F O WRULLúLH[SHULHQ HQRLFXWHQGLQ DVSUHRLPDJLQD LHODELO JXVWXO
SHQWUX WHDWUX úL R UHODWLY LQFDSDFLWDWH SUDFWLF vQ PRGXO GH DúL
FRQGXFH DIDFHULOH vQ JHQHUDO $UWLúWLL SUH]LQW DGHVHD FRWH ULGLFDWH OD
DFHVW IDFWRU )DFWRUXO HVWH vQV VHQVLELO OD PRGHOH FXOWXUDOH QRUPHOH
HXURSHQHILLQGPDLULGLFDWHGHFkWFHOHDPHULFDQH'HDVHPHQHDH[LVW
R GLIHUHQ LHUH VH[XDO IHPHLOH úL IHWHOH SUH]LQW vQ JHQHUH FRWH PDL
ULGLFDWHGHFkWE UED LLVDXE LH LL([LVW RUHOD LHLQYHUVSURSRU LRQDO
vQWUHUH]XOWDWHOHPXQFLLvQJUXSúLQLYHOXOFRWHLIDFWRUXOXL,UH]XOWDWHOH
WLQG V ILH FX DWkW PDL VF ]XWH FX FkW FRWD PHGLH D LQGLYL]LORU H PDL
ULGLFDW PHPEULL ILLQG GHVFULúL FD OHQ L vQ PXQFD GH JUXS vQ GHFL]LL
DF LRQkQG LQXWLO FX WHQGLQ D VSUH UHPDUFL GH QDWXU HPR LRQDO úL
VRFLDO QHJDWLYLúWL
+DUULDUHSUH]LQW RGRPLQDQW FRPSRUWDPHQWDO DGXULW LLPDV
FXOLQLW LL úL D VSLULWXOXL SUDFWLF &RPSRUWDPHQWXO HVWH PDWXU VRFLDO
JHQHUHD] VROLGDULWDWHGHJUXSúLUHDOLVP
)DFWRUXOHVWHGLQFDWHJRULDFHORUIRUPD LSULQLQIOXHQ DPHGLXOXLúL
D FXOWXULL 7HUPHQXO GH SUHPVLD YLQH GH OD H[SUHVLD HQJOH] SURWHFWHG
HPRWLRQDOVHQVLWLYLW\ GHFLRVHQVLELOLWDWHHPR LRQDO SURWHMDW FHHDFH
HFKLYDOHD] FXDLPSOLFDIRUPDUHDvQLQWHULRUXOXQHLFXOWXULUDILQDWHFDUH
SURWHMHD] VHQVLELOLWDWHD úL JXVWXO HVWHWLF 7HUPHQXO KDUULD YLQH GH OD
KDUGQHVVDQGUHDOLVPLQGLFkQGDVSHFWXOGHGXULWDWHúLUHDOLVPvQPHGLXO
GHIRUPDUH
6WXGLLFRPSDUDWLYHúLORQJLWXGLQDOHLQGLF SHQWUXFRWHOHULGLFDWH
ODDFHVWIDFWRUDVHP Q ULFXVLQGURPXOLVWHULHLGHFRQYHUVLHDQJRDVHL
úL LSRKRQGULHL GH DVHPHQHD R WHQGLQ PDL PDUFDW VSUH IRUPH GH
DQJRDV ODFRSLLLFXFRWHvQDOWHOD,6SHFLDOLúWLLvQSVLKLDWULHDUWLúWLLúL
IHPHLOH vQ JHQHUH WLQG V SUH]LQWH FRWH PDL ULGLFDWH /D SROXO RSXV
J VLPRDPHQLLSROLWLFLFHLFDUHFRQGXFúLGLUHF LRQHD] HOHFWULFLHQLL
PHFDQLFLLúLFRQWDELOLL
)$&7258//±$OH[LDYVSURWHQVLRQ
&RPSRUWDPHQWXO OD SROXO DOH[LD FX QRWH 7 vQWUH úL DSDUH
FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQ vQFUHGHUHDGDSWDELOLWDWHFRRSHUDUHDEVHQ DJHOR]LHL
VDX LQYLGLHLRJUDYLWDWHDPDELO GDUSOLQ GHVSLULWLQWHUHVXOID GH
FHLODO L 3ROXO SURWHQVLRQ FX QRWH 7 vQWUH VSUH UHSUH]LQW WHQ
VLXQHDXQPRGGHDWU LQHvQFUH] WRUvQFOLQDWVSUHJHOR]LHvQG U WQLF
VXVSLFLRVúLWLPLGUHODWLYULJLGGXUúLLQGLIHUHQWID GHDO LL
1RWD MRDV FDUDFWHUL]HD] XQ VXELHFW FDUH VH DFRPRGHD] XúRU
QX FDXW ULYDOLWDWH VH SUHRFXS GH WRW VRLXO GH RDPHQL H[FHOHD] vQ
PXQFD GH HFKLS ÌQ JHQHUDO VXVSLFLRV LQGLYLGXO FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQWUR
FRW ULGLFDW DSDUHDGHVHDHJRFHQWULFULJLGvQLQWHUHOD LLFXLQWHUHVPDL
GHJUDE SHQWUX YLD D VD LQWHULRDU GHFkW ID GH RDPHQL ÌQ JHQHUDO
FLUFXPVSHFWHVWHXQHOHPHQWWHQVLRQDQWvQFDGUXOXQXLJUXSHFKLSH6H
VXEOLQLD] vQV IDSWXO F GDWHOH DVXSUD FRQH[LXQLL GLQWUH / ULGLFDW úL
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOSDUDQRLGQXVXQWWRWDOHGLILFDWRDUH
)$&7258/0±3UD[HUQLDYVDXWLD
'LPHQVLXQHD GHILQHúWH XQ IDFWRU FDUH FXSULQGH GH DVHPHQL
WU V WXULGLILFLOGHLQWHJUDWvQWURIRUPXO GLQOLPEDMXORELúQXLW$VWIHO
GH H[HPSOX SROXO FRWHORU VF ]XWH SUD[HUQLD GHILQHúWH XQ FRPSRUWD
PHQWSUDFWLFúLFRQúWLLQFLRVHVWHLQVXOFDUH LQHODIRUP HVWHFDSDELO
VDúLS VWUH]HVkQJHOHUHFHúLSUH]LQW RUHODWLY OLSV GHLPDJLQD LHÌQ
DFHODúL WLPS HVWH XQ VSLULW ORJLF H[SUHVLY GHVFKLV FD LQWHUHVH FX
VkQJHUHFHvQFD]GHXUJHQ VDXSHULFRO3ROXODXWLDGHILQHúWHFHHDFH
DP SXWHD QXPL QRQFRQYHQ LRQDOXO H[FHQWULF LPDJLQDWLY ERHP PDL
SX LQ SUHRFXSDW GH FRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWH FX XQ DVSHFW H[WHULRU FDOP DUH
RFD]LRQDOHL]EXFQLULHPRWLYHGHQDWXU LVWHULF
'DWHOH GH FHUFHWDUH FRQYHUJ VSUH LPDJLQHD XQHL SHUVRDQH SUHR
FXSDWH GH D IDFH RULFH OXFUX ÄFXP WUHEXLH´ FDUH DFRUG LPSRUWDQ
DVSHFWHORUSUDFWLFHQXDF LRQHD] KD]DUGDWHVWHDWHQW ODGHWDOLL3HU
VRDQD DXWLD HVWH XQ LPDJLQDWLY FHQWUDW vQ vQWUHJLPH SH LQVWDQ HOH
LQWHULRDUH SUHD SX LQ SUHRFXSDW GH FRQWLQJHQ H DGHVHD RULJLQDO úL
LJQRUkQGUHDOLW LOHFRWLGLHQHvúLXUPHD] FDOHDSURSULH'RWDWvQV FX
LPDJLQD LHFUHDWRDUHúLSUHRFXSDWGHPDULOHLGHL'H]LQWHUHVDWID GH
YDORULOH PDWHULDOH PRWLYD LLOH LQWHULRDUH vO DGXF XQHRUL vQ SRVWXUL
H[WUDYDJDQWHDFRPSDQLDWHGHUHDF LLHPR LRQDOHYLROHQWH&RQúWLHQWGH
SURSULDSHUVRQDOLWDWHVHSRDWHvQWkPSODV HYLWHDFWLYLW LOHFROHFWLYH
)$&7258/1±1DLYLWDWHYVVXEWLOLWDWH
3ROXOQDLYLW LLUHVSHFWLYDOFRWHORUMRDVHLQGLF XQFRPSRUWDPHQW
GLUHFW QDLY VHQWLPHQWDO QDWXUDO XQHRUL VWkQJDFL úL QHvQGHPkQDWHF VH
LQWHUHVHD] GH DO LL úL HVWH XúRU GH VDWLVI FXW 3ROXO RSXV LQGLF SHUV
SLFDFLWDWHúLOXFLGLWDWHvQRSLQLLXQPRGGHDILUDILQDWFLYLOL]DWúLVXEWLO
vQJHQHUDOGDUUHFHLQGLIHUHQWID GHDO LLúLGLILFLOGHVDWLVI FXW
'DWHOH LQGLF FRUHOD LL FX XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW SROLWLFRV H[SHUL
PHQWDWPRGHUQVXEWLOFXVSLULWDQDOLWLFúLFHOPDLDGHVHDUHFHRDOXU
LQWHOHFWXDO RYL]LXQHQHVHQWLPHQWDO DVXSUDOXFUXULORUúLYLH LLXQHRUL
IUL]kQGFLQLVPXO$VSHFWHOHFDUDFWHULVWLFHSROXOXLRSXVLQGLF OLSVDGH
DIHFWDUH QDWXUDOH H úL VSRQWDQHLHWDWH XQHRUL VWkQJ FLH úL EUXVFKH HD
UHDF LLORU
$FHVWDOOHDIDFWRUQXDIHFWHD] vQV GHFLVLYFRPSRUWDPHQWXO
)$&7258/2±vQFUHGHUHYVWHQGLQ DVSUHFXOSDELOLWDWH
3ROXO FRWHORU MRDVH LQGLF XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW FDOP FX vQFUHGHUH
vQVLQHVHQLQOLQLúWLWUH]LVWHQWODVWUHVHILFLHQWYLJXURVXQHRULFKLDU
EUXWDOI U IRELLVHDQJDMHD] vQJHQHUHvQDFWLYLW LVLPSOH
3ROXO FRWHORU vQDOWH LQGLF OLSVD GH VHFXULWDWH XQ PRG DQ[LRV
GHSUHVLYDJLWDWGHDVHUDSRUWDODH[LVWHQ I U vQFUHGHUHvQFHLODO L
E QXLWRUFXVHQWLPHQWHGHFXOSDELOLWDWH
6DX RE LQXW GDWH FDUH vQGUHSW HVF GHILQLUHD VD FD WHQGLQ GH
SUHVLY VHQVLELOLWDWH HPR LRQDO GHSUHFLHUH GH VLQH FKLDU QHYURWLVP
3HUVRDQD DSDUH RERVLW GH VLWXD LLOH H[FLWDQWH VH VLPWH LQFDSDELO V
vQIUXQWH H[LJHQ HOH H[LVWHQ LDOH FRWLGLHQH VH GHVFXUDMHD] FX XúXULQ
HVWH SOLQ GH UHPXúF UL úL HVWH GHSULPDW GHVFRSHULQG F RDPHQLL QX
VXQWQLFLPRUDOLQLFLDWHQ LID GHDVSHFWHOHLPSRUWDQWHHVWHvQFOLQDW
VSUHPLO OHFWXULOLQLúWHDVHPHQLORU5HDF LRQHD] YLXODGLILFXOW LVH
GHVFXUDMHD] /DFRSLLLFXQRWHULGLFDWHVDXDSDUWHPHULVHQWLPHQW
GH VROLWXGLQH úL LQVXILFLHQ ([SHULPHQWHOH SULYLQG GLQDPLFD JUXSXOXL
GHPRQVWUHD] F DVWIHOGHSHUVRDQHQLFLQXVHVLPWDFFHSWDWHGHJUXSVDX
OLEHULV SDULWLFLSHVXQWIRDUWHVHQVLELOHODQRUPHOHGHJUXSGHDOWIHOQLFL
QX VXQW DFFHSWDWH XúRU GH FHLODO L LDU GLQ SXQFW GH YHGHUH VRFLDO VXQW
SURVWDGDSWDWH&OLQLF2ULGLFDWDSDUHvQWRDWHIRUPHOHGHQHYUR] SVL
KR] vQWXOEXU ULGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHúLLQILUPLW LSVLKLFH
8UP WRULLIDFWRULGHQXPL L4VXQWPDLSX LQH[SULPD LúLFOD
ULILFD LGDUDXRFRQWULEX LHvQFRPSRUWDPHQWDWXQFLFkQGVXQWDFWLYL
$XIRVWGHULYD LGLQDQDOL]DIDFWRULDO UHDOL]DW DVXSUDFHORUODO LIDFWRUL
0DLDOHVYDOLGLWDWHDSURJQRVWLF SULYLQGWHQGLQ HOHVSHFLILFHGHFRP
SRUWDPHQWOHDDVLJXUDWORFXOvQFDGUXOFKHVWLRQDUXOXL
)$&7258/4±&RQVHUYDWRULVPYV
OLSVDGHUHVSHFWSHQWUXFRQYHQ LL
3ROXO FRQVHUYDWRU LQGLF XQ PRG UHODWLY QHFULWLF GH DFFHSWDUH D
QRUPHORU SROXO RSXV UHSUH]LQW XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW GHVFKLV VSUH QRX
LQRYDWRUFULWLFFXXQDVFX LWJXVWSHQWUXDQDOL]
)$&7258/4±'HSHQGHQ DGHJUXSYV
LQGHSHQGHQ DSHUVRQDO
1X HVWH XQ IDFWRU FODU VWDELOLW vQ YDULD LLOH FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH
PDQLIHVWkQGXVHPDLDOHVODQLYHOXODWLWXGLQLORULQWHULRDUH'HIDSWQLFL
XQXO GLQWUH DFHúWL IDFWRUL 4 QX DX IRVW J VL L FX PD[LP
FHUWLWXGLQHvQYDOLG ULOHHPSLULFHDS UkQGPDLDOHVvQU VSXQVXULOHOD
FKHVWLRQDUH
)DFWRUXO4FRQWULEXLHODIDFWRUXOVHFXQGLQWURYHUVLH
3HUVRDQD FX FRWH 4 ULGLFDWH HVWH UD LRQDO FDSDELO V VH
GHFLG VLQJXU /DSROXORSXVHVWHWLSXOGHLQGLYLGFDUHPHUJHRGDW
FXJUXSXOFDXW DSUREDUHDVRFLDO XUPHD] PRGD'DWHOHGHFHUFHWDUH
LQGLF FRUHODUHD FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL 4 VF ]XW FX SURIHVLL GLQ VIHUD
FHUFHW ULL FDGUHORU GH FRQGXFHUH úL GHFL]LH vQ JHQHUDO LQGLYL]L FDUH
JkQGHVFPXOWSULQHLvQúLúL
&HUFHW ULSULYLQGGLQDPLFDJUXSXOXLLQGLF GHDVHPHQHDF FHL
FX 4 ULGLFDW WU LHVF LQVDWLVIDF LL OHJDWH GH LQWHJUDUHD vQ JUXS IDF
UHPDUFLFDUHFHOPDLDGHVHDVXQWVROX LLLDUJUXSXOWLQGHV LUHIX]HÌQ
FROHFWLYXO úFRODU DVWIHO GH FRSLL VXQW LQX L OD GLVWDQ SDU V DLE
LQWHUHVHPDLPDWXUHGHFkWFHLODO LúLDWLQJXúRUVXFFHVXODFDGHPLF
)$&7258/4±6HQWLPHQWGHVLQHVODEYV
VHQWLPHQWGHVLQHSXWHUQLF
ÌQFRPSRUWDPHQWVHPDQLIHVW SULQOLSVDGHFRQWUROVSUHGHRVHELUH
GHSROXORSXVUHVSHFWLYGLVFLSOLQDGHVLQHH[LJHQ DYRLQ DGH]YROWDW
)DFWRUXOVHSDUHF H[SULP JUDGXOvQFDUHLQGLYLGXODDFFHSWDWR
LPDJLQHGHVLQHLGHDO SULQFDUHvúLGLULMHD] FRPSRUWDPHQWXOUHDO8Q
DVWIHOGHIDFWRUGHSLQGHGHPHGLXvQVHQVXOGHSHQGHQ HLGHvQFXUDMDUH
VWLPXODUHDYDORULORUFRQVWUXFWLYHúLDUHVSHFWXOXLGHVLQH&RSLOXOFXR
FRW 4 ULGLFDW SUH]LQW XQ EXQ DXWRFRQWURO vQFHDUF V DSOLFH úL
DSUREHQRUPHOHHWLFHDFFHSWDWHGRUHúWHV IDF ELQHDUHFRQVLGHUD LH
SHQWUXDO LLHVWHSUHY ] WRUúLGLVSXVV úLFRQWUROH]HH[SULPDUHDHPR
LLORU)DFWRUXOSUH]LQW HPSLULFRFRUHOD LHVXEVWDQ LDO FXVHQWLPHQWXO
GH VLQH FX LQWHJUDUHD SXOVLRQDO FDUH YL]HD] PHQ LQHUHD XQHL DGHF
YDWHLPDJLQLGHVLQH
2SXV4VF ]XWSUH]LQW vQSULQFLSDORHPRWLYLWDWHQHFRQWURODW
FDUH VH DVHDP Q FX IDFWRUXO ' GLQ +634 IDFWRU FDUH GLVSDUH
SUDFWLFFDDWDUHODYkUVWDDGXOW 2FRW VF ]XW 4HVWHDVRFLDW FXGH
OLQFYHQ DMXYHQLO
)DFWRUXO4FRQWULEXLHVHPQLILFDWLYODIDFWRUXOVHFXQGDQ[LHWDWH
ÌQ FHUFHW ULOH SULYLQG GLQDPLFD GH JUXS 4 ULGLFDW FDUDFWHUL
]HD] GHRELFHLSHFHLDOHúLFDOLGHULHILFLHQ LVXQWVW SkQLSHVLQHIDF
PXOWHMXGHF LvQOHJ WXU FXJUXSXOQXDSDUFDMHQDQ LVDXLQRSRUWXQL
4 ULGLFDW LQGLF GH DVHPHQHD UHXúLWD vQ SURIHVLXQL PHFDQLFH vQ
PDWHPDWLF vQ DFWLYLW L GH RUJDQL]DUH FD GLUHFWRUL úL IXQF LRQDUL vQ
VHUYLFLL SXEOLFH 8QHRUL D IRVW QXPLW úL IDFWRU ÄJLURVFRSLF´ DO SHUVR
QDOLW LLLQGLFkQGVWDELOLWDWHDúLRULHQWDUHDDFHVWHLD
)$&7258/4±7HQVLXQHHUJLF VODE YV
WHQVLXQHHUJLF ULGLFDW
&RPSRUWDPHQWXO4ODSROXOFRWHORUMRDVHLQGLF XQPRGGHDWU L
GHVWLQVFDOPQRQúDODQWVDWLVI FXWGHVLQH3ROXORSXVHVWHFDUDFWHUL]DW
SULQ vQFRUGDUH WHQVLXQH H[FLWDELOLWDWH úL VHQWLPHQWH GH IUXVWUDUH 4
ULGLFDW FDUDFWHUL]HD] XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW QHOLQLúWLW I U PRWLY vQFRUGDW
LULWDELODJLWDW
'DWHOH FOLQLFH LQGLF SHQWUX IDFWRULL 2 úL 4 FDSDFLWDWHD GH D
GLIHUHQ LD QRUPDOXO GH QHYURWLF ILLQG XQD GLQWUH GLPHQVLXQLOH VHPQL
ILFDWLYHSHQWUXFRQWULEX LDODLQGLFHOHGHDQ[LHWDWHJHQHUDO ÌQDFHODúL
WLPSFOLQLFVHUHOHY 4ULGLFDWvQWXOEXU ULOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHLQILU
PLW LOHIL]LFHúLvQSVLKR]H
&DWWHOOLQWHUSUHWHD] DFHVWIDFWRUvQVHQVXOQLYHOXOXLGHH[FLWD LH
úLWHQVLXQHGDWRUDWHSXOVLXQLORUQHGHVF UFDWHVDXIUXVWUD LHL
)DFWRULLGHRUGLQDVHFXQGDUGHVXSUDID
)DFWRULLGHRUGLQVHFXQGDUDXVHPQLILFD LDGHWU V WXULGHVXSUDID
úLVXQWGHILQL LúLGHWHUPLQD LH[SHULPHQWDOGH&DWWHOO(LVXQWFDOFXOD LvQ
IXQF LHGHSRQGHUHDFRQWULEX LHLILHF UHLDGLQWUHFRPSRQHQWHOHSULPDUH
vQFOXVWHUXOIDFWRULDOODFDOFXODUHVHXWLOL]HD] FRWHOHVWDQGDUGQXQRWHOH
EUXWHLDUFHHDFHVHRE LQHDUHVHPQLILFD LDXQHLFRWHVWDQGDUGGHOD
ODÌQPRGRELúQXLWVHXWLOL]HD] XQVLVWHPPDLUDSLGSHFDUHvOYRP
SUH]HQWD FDUH DGPLWH URWXQMLUHD QRWHL ILQDOH úL D FRQWULEX LHL FRWHORU
FRPSRQHQWHDFHVWVLVWHPVXIHU GHRUHODWLY LPSUHFL]LHvQVHQVXOF SRW
DSDUHVLWXD LLFkQGQRWDILQDO HVWHPDLPLF GHVDXPDLPDUHGH
FHHD FH VH UHFWLILF SULQ DSUR[LPDUHD HL OD QLYHOXO FRWHL FHOHL PDL
DSURSLDWHUHVSHFWLYVDX9DORULOHVF ]XWHDOHLQWHUFRUHOD LLORUGLQWUH
IDFWRULLVHFXQ]LLQGLF LQGHSHQGHQ DDFHVWRUD
)$&7258/,±$GDSWDUHYVDQ[LHWDWH
2FRW ULGLFDW ODIDFWRUXOVHFXQGDU,LQGLF RDQ[LHWDWHULGLFDW
vQ VHQVXO RELúQXLW DO GHQXPLULL 3HUVRDQD QX HVWH QHFHVDU QHYURWLF
DQ[LHWDWHD SRDWH IL UHDFWLY OD R VLWXD LH GDU LQGLFD LD GH QHDGDSWDUH
HVWH SUHFLV (VWH SHUVRDQD QHVDWLVIDFXW GH FDSDFLWDWHD VD GH D U V
SXQGH FHULQ HORU YLH LL úL DúL UHDOL]D GRULQ HOH $Q[LHWDWHD SXWHUQLF
SHUWXUE UDQGDPHQWXOúLDWUDJHWXOEXU ULSVLKRVRPDWLFH
)$&7258/,,±,QWUDYHUVLHYVH[WUDYHUVLH
&RWDVF ]XW ODDFHVWIDFWRUVHFXQGLQGLF WHQGLQ DVSUHWLPLGLWDWH
úLLQKLEL LHvQUHOD LLOHFXFHLODO L$FHVWOXFUXSRDWHILGHIDYRUDELOSHQWUX
SURIHVLLFDUHFHUFRQWDFWHVRFLDOHPXOWLSOHGDUSRDWHILXQLQGLFHVHQVLELO
úLIDYRUDELOSHQWUXRPXQF FDUHFHUHSUHFL]LH
([WUDYHUVLD OD FHO ODOW SROLQGLF OLSVDGHLQKLEL LHVRFLDO úLR
VDWLVIDF LH JHQHUDO ID GH SURSULD SHUVRDQ )DYRUDELO vQ SUHGLF LD
SHQWUX DFWLYLW L FDUH FHU FRQWDFWH VRFLDOH PXOWLSOH HVWH QHIDYRUDELO
GHH[HPSOXvQHFXD LDUHXúLWHLDFDGHPLFH
)$&7258/,,,±(PRWLYLWDWHYVGLQDPLVP
&RWHOH VF ]XWH OD DFHVW IDFWRU LQGLF R HPRWLYLWDWH GLIX] FDUH
SRDWHILGHWLSGHSUHVLYúLIUXVWUDQWSHQWUXSHUVRDQ $FHVWJHQGHRP
HVWH VHQVLELO OD UDILQDPHQWHOH H[LVWHQ HL FX XQ WHPSHUDPHQW DUWLVWLF
SO FXW vQ JDPD GLILFXOW LORU DUH WHQGLQ D GH D UHIOHFWD SUHD PXOW
H[DPLQkQGVLWXD LDSHWRDWHIH HOHvQDLQWHGHDWUHFHODDF LXQHDF LXQH
FDUHDSDUHGLQDFHVWPRWLYSUHDvQWkU]LDW
3ROXO RSXV UHSUH]LQW XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW GLQDPLF vQWUHSULQ] WRU
úL GHFLV FRPSHWHQW ([LVW ULVFXO FD DVWIHO GH SHUVRDQH V DF LRQH]H
RULHQWkQGXVHSUHGLOHFWGXS FHHDFHOHDSDUHFODUúLLQGLVFXWDELOI U
V H[DPLQH]HDVSHFWHPDLVXEWLOHVDXUHOD LLOHXPDQHLPSOLFDWHÌQID D
GLILFXOW LORUWHQGLQ DWUHFHULLODDF LXQHSULPHD] QXFHDGHUHIOHF LH
)$&7258/,9±6XSXQHUHYVLQGHSHQGHQ
&RWHOHVF ]XWHLQGLF XQFRPSRUWDPHQWPRGHUDWSDVLYOHJDWúL
GHSHQGHQW GH FHLODO L FX WHQGLQ D GH D F XWD DSUREDUHD úL VSULMLQXO
FHORUGHFDUHDUHQHYRLHúLGHDúLRULHQWDFRQGXLWDvQIXQF LHGHFHLFH
DFRUG DFHDVW VXV LQHUH
,QGHSHQGHQ D OD SROXO RSXV VH PDQLIHVW SULQ WHQGLQ D VSUH
DJUHVLYLWDWH vQGU ]QHDO XQ PRG WUDQúDQW GH D DF LRQD LQL LDWLY 2
DVWIHO GH SHUVRDQ FKLDU FDXW VLWXD LLOH vQ FDUH VH WROHUHD] VDX VH
vQFXUDMHD] RDVWIHOGHDWLWXGLQH
0RGDOLWDWHDGHFDOFXODIDFWRULORUVHFXQGDUL
9RP SUH]HQWD PRGDOLWDWHD SULQ URWXQMLUH úL PRGDOLWDWHD FX DMX
WRUXO FRQVWDQWHORU H[DFWH FDUH YRU DSDUH vQ SDUDQWH]H DúD FXP VXQW
SUH]HQWDWHúLvQPDQXDOXOWHVWXOXL&kQGVHYRUXWLOL]DFRWLHQ LLH[DF L
GLQSDUDQWH]HQRWHOHILQDOHQXVHPDLvPSDUWOD
7DEHOXO0RGDOLWDWHDGHFDOFXODIDFWRULORUVHFXQGDUL
'HQXPLUHIDFWRU (FXD LH
$GDSWDUHYVDQ[LHWDWH /24&
+4
/D WRWDOXO DVWIHO RE LQXW VH DGXQ FRQVWDQWD
úLWRWXOVHvPSDUWHOD
'HQXPLUHIDFWRU (FXD LH
,QWURYHUVLHYVH[WUDYHUVLH $()1
4
'LQWRWDOVHVFDGHLDUUH]XOWDWXOVH
vPSDUWHOD
(PRWLYLWDWHYVGLQDPLVP & ( ) 1
$±,0
7RWDOXOXLLVHDGDXJ FRQVWDQWDLDU
UH]XOWDWXOVHvPSDUWHOD
6XSXQHUHYVLQGHSHQGHQ (044
±$±*
1X H[LVW R FRQVWDQW GRDU SHQWUX IRUPD
]HFLPDO 5H]XOWDWXOVHvPSDUWHOD
&KHVWLRQDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHSHQWUXDGROHVFHQ L±+634
([LVW FHO SX LQ SDWUX SHUVSHFWLYH FDUH LQWHUYLQ vQ LQIHUHQ HOH
DVXSUDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLFDUHVXQWWRWDWkWHDPRGDOLW LGHDGHVFULH
SHUVRQDOLWDWHD
3OHFkQG GH OD DVHU LXQHD F HVWH FRPSXV GLQWUXQ QXP U GHWHU
PLQDW GH GLPHQVLXQL YLUWXDO SUH]HQWH VH SXQH SUREOHPD P VXULL
vQFDUHILHFDUHGLQWUHDFHVWHDHVWHRSHUDQW vQVWUXFWXUDGDW
3OHFkQGGHODDILUPD LDFDUHDGXFHvQHFXD LHFDUDFWHUXOVLWXD LRQDO
DO FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL VH SXQH SUREOHPD GHWHUPLQ ULL D FHHD FH vL
DVLJXU FRQVLVWHQ DGHDOXQJXOVLWXD LLORU
$YkQGvQYHGHUHFDUDFWHUXODGDSWDWLYDOFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLÄFDSD
FLWDWHD GH D IDFH ID ´ VH YD SXQH SUREOHPD PLMORDFHORU XWLOL]DWH
GHSHUVRDQ SHQWUXDIDFHRSHUDQWHGLIHULWHOHGLPHQVLXQLSHFDUHOH
UHSUH]LQW
ÌQILQHSOHFkQGGHODLQWHUUHOD LDGLIHULWHORUGLPHQVLXQLvQFRPSRU
WDPHQWXO UHDO VH LPSXQH FHUFHWDUHD PRGHOXOXL SDUWLFXODU DO IXQF
LRQ ULLDFHVWRUD
$VWIHOSVLKRGLDJQR]DSHUVRQDOLW LLFDUHvúLSXQHSUREOHPDFHQWUDO
D PRGXOXL FXP LQWHUUHOD LRQHD] WU V WXULOH HVWH vQ IDSW VSXQH &DWWHOO
XQSURFHVFRPSOH[GHSURFHVDUHGHLQIRUPD LLFXVHFYHQ HVSHFLILFH
VHFDXW GLPHQVLXQLOHFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHFHDSDUVHPQLILFDWLYH
vQH[LVWHQ DSHUVRDQHLUHVSHFWLYH
VHGHWHUPLQ JUDGXOvQFDUHDFHVWHDVXQWSUH]HQWHVSHFLILFXOORU
VHGHWHUPLQ IHOXOvQFDUHLQGLYLGXOOHIDFHRSHUDQWHvQGLIHULWH
VLWXD LLH[LVWHQ LDOH
VH FHUFHWHD] vQ FH FRQGL LL úL VLWXD LL DSDU DFHVWH LQVHU LL
DGDSWDWLYH
VH GHWHUPLQ DGHUHQ D OD UHDO D XWLOL] ULL GH F WUH LQGLYLG D
FDUDFWHULVWLFLORUSHFDUHOHSRVHG
SHQWUX FD vQ ILQDO V ILH SRVLELO FRQVWUXLUHD XQHL LPDJLQL
LQWHUDF LRQLVWHSULYLQGLQWHUUHOD LLOHGLPHQVLXQLORUUHVSHFWLYHvQ
FRPSRUWDPHQW
ÌQ DFHVW FRPSOH[ SURFHV GH SUHOXFU UL SUREOHPD YkUVWHL úL
VWDELOLW LLIDFWRULDOHDFRQVWLWXLWXQGRPHQLXSUHIHUHQ LDOSHQWUXPXOWH
HFKLSH GLQWUR SHUVSHFWLY VWUXFWXUDOLVW úL ORQJLWXGLQDO $VWIHO
&DWWHOO *UXHQ&DWWHOO&DWWHOO &RDQ3HWHUVRQ
(\VHQFN (DVWLQJ (\VHQFN DMXQJ V UHOHYH F H[LVW
WU V WXULFDUHDSDUvQDGROHVFHQ vQWLPSFHDOWHWU V WXULGLVSDUúLF
XQLLIDFWRULVXQWSUH]HQ LGHDOXQJXOWXWXURUYkUVWHORU
6HSUHIHU GRX WLSXULGHFHUFHW UL
3ULPDWHKQLF FHP VRDU FRUHOD LLOHGLQWUHHYDOX ULFDQWLWDWLYH
UHDOL]DWHvQSHULRDGHGHYkUVW GLIHULWHVSHFLILFHSHQWUXHWDSDGHGH]
YROWDUHLQFOXV vQVWXGLXHVWHPHWRGDORQJLWXGLQDO FDUHHVWHLQGLFDW
SHQWUXDRE LQHGDWHSULYLQGUHOD LLOHGLQWUHÄYkUVWHOHFURQRORJLFH´DOH
GLPHQVLXQLORUVDXFRQGL LLORUOXDWHvQVWXGLX
$ GRXD WHKQLF VH D[HD] SH GDWHOH LQWHUVHF LRQDOH vQ FDUH
VHFYHQ DGHGH]YROWDUHHVWHVWDELOLW SULQVXELHF LFDUHWU LHVFVLPXOWDQ
vQDFHHDúLSHULRDG GHWLPSSHQWUXDVHRE LQHRFRPSLODUHDOLQLLORUGH
WHQGLQ OHJDWHGHYkUVW &DWWHOOúLDVRFLD LLOXLGHOD8QLYHUVLWDWHDGLQ
,OOLQRLVSUHIHU DFHVWWLSGHFHUFHW ULDVWIHOvQFkWJHQHUDOL] ULOHSULYLQG
VWUXFWXUDSHUVRQDOLW LLvQDGROHVFHQ SURGXVHSULQVWXGLLOHOXL6HDO\
&DWWHOO 6FKDLH %ODFN SURYLQ GLQ FHUFHW UL LQWHU
VHF LRQDOH
6LQWH]HDOHFHUFHW ULORUD[DWHSHGLQDPLFDIDFWRULORU
vQDGROHVFHQ
3HQWUX&DWWHOOúL6HDO\DVSHFWHOHPDMRUHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LL
VHVFKLPE GHDOXQJXODGROHVFHQ HLLDUDFHVWHVFKLPE ULSUH]LQW XQ
LPSRUWDQWVSHFLILFvQIXQF LHGHVH[XOVXELHFWXOXL&XFkWDYDQVHD] vQ
DGROHVFHQ GHDOXQJXOSHULRDGHLvQWUHúLDQLPRGHOHOHFXOWXUDOH
úL H[SHFWD LLOH OHJDWH GH URO VXQW UHVSRQVDELOH GH PXOWH GLQWUH GLIH
UHQ HOHLQWHUVH[XDOHGHWHUPLQDWHvQP VXUDvQFDUHGHH[HPSOXUROXO
IHPLQLQGHYLQHWRWPDLDFFHQWXDWRGDW FXYkUVWHOHPDLPDUL$XWRULL
FRQVLGHU GH H[HPSOX F WHQGLQ D GH GRPLQDUH vQ FUHúWHUH OD VH[XO
IHPLQLQ ÄSRDWH IL OHJDW GH WU LUHD FUHúWHULL GH]LUDELOLW LL VRFLDOH úL
VH[XDOH GHD OXQJXO DFHVWHL SHULRDGH´ $GROHVFHQ D DSDUH vQ JHQHUDO
SHQWUXDPEHOHVH[HFDRSHULRDG GHFUHúWHUHDVRFLDELOLW LLLGHQWLW LL
úL VXILFLHQ HL SHUVRQDOH GRPLQDQ HL DGDSW ULL OD VRFLDO % LH LL GHYLQ
PDL KRW Uk L DUH ORF OD DPEHOH VH[H R GH]YROWDUH D FRQúWLHQWL] ULL
FHULQ HORUUHDOXOXLúLRWUHSWDW GHVFUHúWHUHDQHOLQLúWLLúLDQ[LHW LL
5HDOL]kQGRVLQWH] DGDWHORUSULYLQGHYROX LDIDFWRULORUSHUVRQDOL
W LLGHDOXQJXOSHULRDGHLvQWUHúLDQLvQIXQF LHGHFULWHULLOHYkUVW
úL VH[ 6HDO\ úL &DWWHOO VXEOLQLD] SRVLELOLWDWHD XQRU GDWH VXSOLPHQWDUH
SULQ FRQVLGHUDUHD DOWRU FULWHULL SUHFXP VWDWXVXO VRFLRHFRQRPLF WLSXO
FRPXQLW LL GH UH]LGHQ UDVD 9RP SUH]HQWD vQ WDEHOXO SULQFLSDOHOH
DVSHFWH VXUSULQVH vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH DFHVWHD VXQW LPSRUWDQWH vQ LQWHU
SUHWDUHDGLIHUHQ LDO DGDWHORUFKHVWLRQDUHORU+634úL3)4
7DEHOXO7HQGLQ HvQGH]YROWDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLvQDGROHVFHQ
7U V WXUDVXUV 6HDO\ &DWWHOO
$VFKL]RWLPLHFLFORWLPLH GHODODDQLRFUHúWHUHDVRFLDELOLW LLúL
RUHGXFHUHDvQVLQJXU ULLODE LH LLGHSHVWH
DQL FROHJLX R FUHúWHUH D RELHFWLYLW LL
VFHSWLFLVPXOXL OD IHWH DSDUH XQ GHFOLQ VODE
VSUHFLFORWLPLH
%LQWHOLJHQ RFUHúWHUHVWDGLDO GHODODDQL
&IRU DHXOXL FUHúWHUHD QX HVWH VHPQLILFDWLY SHQWUX QLFL
XQXOGLQWUHVH[H
'IOHJPDWLFH[FLWDELO GHODODDQLODDPEHOHVH[HVHQRWHD]
FUHúWHUHD LGHQWLW LL úL VXILFLHQ HL SHUVRQDOH
RVF GHUHDH[FLWDELOLW LLúLQHVLJXUDQ HL
(VXEPLVLYGRPLQDQW ODDPEHOHVH[HGHDOXQJXOSHULRDGHLFUHúWH
GRPLQDQ DGDUFXXQPRGHOGLIHULWGDF OD
IHWH DUH ORF PDL vQWkL R FUHúWHUH vQWUH úL
DQLODE LH LFRQWLQX FUHúWHUHDWHQGLQ HL
GHGRPLQDUHGHODODDQLvQWLPSFHOD
IHWH VH SURGXFH R VWDJQDUH FKLDU R XúRDU
WHQGLQ OD XQHOH IHWH VSUH VXEPLVLYLWDWH
SHQWUX WRDW SHULRDGD GH YkUVW VFRUXULOH
IHWHORU VXQW PDL VF ]XWH vQ JHQHUDO FD DOH
E LH LORU
)WDFLWXUQH[SDQVLY H[SDQVLYLWDWHD FUHúWH GH OD OD DQL
DSRL DSDUH R WHQGLQ VSUH DSODWL]DUH vQWUH
úLDSRLGHFOLQ
*IRU DVXSUDHXOXL QXDSDUHQLFLRWHQGLQ VHPQLILFDWLY
+SDUPLDWKUHFWLD XúRUGHFOLQDOWLPLGLW LLGHDOXQJXOYkUVWHORU
7U V WXUDVXUV 6HDO\ &DWWHOO
,SUHPLVDKDUULD VFRUXULOHSHQWUXE LH LDSDUPXOWPDLVF ]XWH
GHFkWODIHWHvQDGROHVFHQ DWLPSXULHE LH LL
SUH]LQW RFUHúWHUHFODU SHP VXU FHGHYLQ
PDLUHDOLúWLFXvQFUHGHUHvQVLQHPDLKRW
Uk LFUHúWHUHDODIHWHHVWHPDLVHPQLILFDWLY
vQWUH±DQL
-FRDVWKHQLD]HSSLD GHODODDQLXúRUGHFOLQvQFRDVWKHQLD
SH P VXU FH VFDGH LGHRVLQFUDVLD úL FUHúWH
SDUWLFLSDUHD OD JUXS GHFOLQXO OD E LH L
DSDUH PDL PLF HL WLQG V U PkQ PDL
GRPLQD LGHLGHRVLQFUDVLL
/SURWHQVLRQDOH[LD SHQWUX IHWH DSDUH XQ GHFOLQ RUGRQDW GHD
OXQJXODGROHVFHQ HL
0DXWLDSUD[HUQLD R WHQGLQ GH FUHúWHUH D VFRUXULORU vQ SH
ULRDGD ± DQL UHODWLY PDL LPSRUWDQW
FX VHPQLILFD LD GH FRQYHQ LRQDOLVP VSLULW
SUDFWLF UHDOLVP vQ SHULRDGD XUP WRDUH OD
IHWHDSDUHXQGHFOLQVHPQLILFDWLY
1QDLYLWDWHVXEWLOLWDWH RWHQGLQ GHFUHúWHUHPDLVHPQLILFDWLY GH
ODODDQL
2vQFUHGHUHVXEWLOLWDWH R WHQGLQ JHQHUDO GH GHVFUHúWHUH OD IHWH
WHQGLQ D VSUH FXOSDELOL]DUH vQUHJLVWUHD]
VFRUXULPDLPDULE LH LLGHYLQGHDOXQJXO
DGROHVFHQ HLvQPRGVHPQLILFDWLYPDLSX LQ
QHOLQLúWL L
4FRQVHUYDWRUUDGLFDO IHWHOHVXQWPDLFRQVHUYDWRDUHúLI U DSUH
]HQWDFXDGHY UDWUDGLFDOLVPH[LVW WHQGLQ D
GH FUHúWHUH D VFRUXULORU GHD OXQJXO FROH
JLXOXLE LH LLODYkUVWDFROHJLXOXLSUH]LQW R
WHQGLQ FODU VSUHFUHúWHUHDUDGLFDOLVPXOXL
OD FHL FDUH QX VXQW OD FROHJLX VH PDQLIHVW
XQGHFOLQ
4GHSHQGHQ LQGHSHQGHQ SHQWUXIHWHXQGHFOLQVHPQLILFDWLYGHOD
ODDQLGXS DQLDSDUHODDPEHOHVH[H
RFUHúWHUHVHPQLILFDWLY
4FRQWURODWQHFRQWURODW FUHúWHUH VHPQLILFDWLY GRDU OD E LH L vQ
SULPDSDUWHDDGROHVFHQ HL
4UHOD[DUHWHQVLXQH vQDGROHVFHQ DWLPSXULHRFUHúWHUHODDPEHOH
VH[HRVF GHUHVHPQLILFDWLY GHODWHQVLXQHD
HUJLF ODDQLSHQWUXWLQHULLGHODFROHJLX
VDXSHQWUXE LH LLFDUHQXVXQWODFROHJLX
([HPSOLILFDUHDLQWHUSUHW ULLXQXLSURILO3)
0DWHULDO &KHVWLRQDU FX GRX IRUPH SDUDOHOH $ úL % $UH
LWHPLRIRDLHGHU VSXQVJULOHGHFRUHF LHHWDORQXOGHWUDQVIRUPDUH
D QRWHORU EUXWH OD VFDOH vQ QRWH VWDQGDUG FRQVWUXLW vQ FODVH VWDQGDU
GL]DWHPDQXDOGHLQWHUSUHWDUH
6FRS 'HILQLUHD XQXL SURILO XQ PRGHO DO IXQF LRQ ULL IDFWRULORU
SULPDULúLVHFXQGDUL
6WUXFWXU 6XQWFRQVWUXLWHVFDOHGHVWLQDWHHYDOX ULLFHORU
IDFWRULSULPDULDLSHUVRQDOLW LLPDWXUHGHQXPLWHFXOLWHUHGHOD$OD
46XQWGDWHIRUPXOHGHFRPELQDUHDQRWHORUHWDORQGHODDQXPLWH
VFDOH SHQWUX D GHWHUPLQD JUDGXO GH PDQLIHVWDUH D FHORU WU V WXUL
VHFXQGDUH 3URILOXO FXSULQGH OD FHOH H[WUHPH XUP WRDUHOH DWULEXWH
FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH
6FDOD $ 5H]HUYDW GHWDúDW FULWLF UHFH ID GH SROXO RSXV GHV
FKLVFDOGDPDELOFRRSHUDQWVRFLDELO
6FDOD % /HQW vQ vQ HOHJHUH VDX vQY DUH LQWHOLJHQ PDL SX LQ
HILFLHQW JkQGLUH DEVWUDFW ID GH SROXO RSXV LQWHOLJHQ YLH FDSD
FLWDWHEXQ GHDEVWUDFWL]DUH
6FDOD&(XVODEVWDELOLWDWHHPR LRQDO VF ]XW KLSHUVHQVLELOLWDWH
LULWDELOLWDWH I U WROHUDQ OD IUXVWUDUH ID GH HX SXWHUQLF FX XQ EXQ
FRQWURODOHPRWLYLW LLVWDELOFDOPUHDOLVW
6FDOD('RFLODPDELOFRQFLOLDQWDFRPRGDELOXPLOID GHDILU
PDWLYVLJXUGHVLQHVSLULWLQGHSHQGHQWDXWRULWDUGRPLQDWRUvQF S kQDW
6FDOD ) 0RGHUDW WDFLWXUQ SUXGHQW UH]HUYDW ID GH LPSXOVLY
VSRQWDQH[SDQVLYHQWX]LDVWSOLQGHYLD GLUHFW
6FDOD*6XSUDHXVODERSRUWXQLVWI U VLP XOGDWRULHLQHS V WRU
WHQGLQ VSUH QHJOLMHQ ID GH VXSUDHX SXWHUQLF FRQúWLLQFLRV SHUVH
YHUHQWFXVLP XOGDWRULHLúLUHVSRQVDELOLW LLPRUDOL]DWRU
6FDOD + 7LPLG WLPRUDW VXVSLFLRV FX R SUXGHQ H[WUHP
H[WHULRUL]DUH GLILFLO VHQWLPHQWH GH LQIHULRULWDWH ID GH vQGU ]QH
vQWUHSULQ] WRUVRFLDELOFXUH]RQDQ HPR LRQDO ERJDW
6FDOD , 5HDOLVW GXU VH ED]HD] SH VLQH SR]LWLYLVW FX VSLULW
SUDFWLF LQVHQVLELO ID GH WDQGUX GHSHQGHQW DIHFWLY VHQVLELO SkQ OD
LPDWXULWDWHHPR LRQDO FHUHDMXWRUXOúLVWLPDDOWRUDI U VSLULWSUDFWLF
6FDOD / ÌQFUH] WRU FRRSHUDQW DGDSWDELO ID GH QHvQFUH] WRU
vQG U WQLFQHLQGLFDWSHQWUXPXQFDvQHFKLS
6FDOD03UDFWLFFRQúWLLQFLRV LQHODIRUP FDSDELOV úLS VWUH]H
VkQJHOH UHFH RDUHFDUH OLSV GH LPDJLQD LH ID GH LPDJLQDWLY ERHP
YLV WRU
6FDOD 1 'LUHFW QDLY VHQWLPHQWDO QDWXUDO ID GH VXEWLO SHUV
SLFDFHFODUY ] WRUOXFLG
6FDOD2&DOPvQFUH] WRUvQVLQHVHQLQID GHDQ[LRVGHSUHVLY
FXVHQWLPHQWHGHFXOSDELOLWDWH
6FDOD 4 &RQVHUYDWRU FX UHVSHFW SHQWUX FRQYHQ LRQDO ID GH
GHVFKLVVSUHQRXLQRYDWRUFULWLFDQDOLWLF
6FDOD4'HSHQGHQWGHFROHFWLYID GHLQGHSHQGHQ SHUVRQDO
GHFLVSOLQGHUHVXUVHLQWHULRDUH
6FDOD 4 2 VODE LQWHJUDUH D LPSXOVXULORU QHFRQWURODW úL vQ
FRQIOLFW FX VLQH LPSXOVLY ID GH FRQWURO DO LPSXOVXULORU IRUPDOLVW
SUXGHQWvQUDSRUWXULOHVRFLDOHFXDPRUSURSULX
6FDOD46ODE WHQVLXQHHUJLF GHVWLQVFDOPúLQHS V WRUID GH
WHQVLXQHHUJLF ULGLFDW WHQVLRQDWFXVHQWLPHQWHGHIUXVWUDUHGHS úLWGH
HYHQLPHQWH
)DFWRULLVHFXQGDULGHVXSUDID
)DFWRUXO , $GDSWDELO úL OD H[WUHP OLSVLW GH PRWLYD LH SHQWUX
VDUFLQL GLILFLOH ID GH DQ[LHWDWH SXWHUQLF LQDGDSWDW &DOFXOXO QRWHL
VWDQGDUG VH IDFH SRUQLQG GH OD QRWHOH VWDQGDUG DOH IDFWRULORU SULPDUL
FRPSRQHQ LDVWIHO/24&+4WRWDOXOXLLVH
DGDXJ FRQVWDQWDLDUVXPDVHvPSDUWHOD
)DFWRUXO,,,QWURYHUWID GHH[WUDYHUW&DOFXOXOQRWHLVWDQGDUGVH
IDFH SRUQLQG GH OD QRWHOH VWDQGDUG DOH IDFWRULORU SULPDUL FRPSRQHQ L
DVWIHO$()14'LQWRWDOVHVFDGHFRQVWDQWDúL
VHvPSDUWHOD
)DFWRUXO ,,, (PRWLYLWDWH GLIX] VHQVLELO WHPSHUDPHQW GH DUWLVW
ID GHGLQDPLVPGHFLVúLvQWUHSULQ] WRUWUHFHUHSHGHODDF LXQH&DO
FXOXOQRWHLVWDQGDUGVHIDFHSRUQLQGGHODQRWHOHVWDQGDUGDIDFWRULORU
SULPDULFRPSRQHQ LDVWIHO&()1$,0/D
WRWDOVHDGDXJ FRQVWDQWDúLVHvPSDUWHOD
)DFWRUXO ,9 6XSXQHUH XQ FDUDFWHU PRGHUDW SDVLY FDXW DSUR
EDUHD úL VSULMLQXO ID GH LQGHSHQGHQ DJUHVLYLWDWH úL vQGU ]QHDO vQ
PRGXOGHDVHLPSXQHWUDQúDQWFXLQL LDWLY &DOFXOXOQRWHLVWDQGDUGVH
IDFH SRUQLQG GH OD QRWHOH VWDQGDUG DOH IDFWRULORU SULPDUL FRPSRQHQ L
DVWIHO(044$*7RWDOXOVHvPSDUWHOD
$SOLFDUH &KHVWLRQDUXO VH DSOLF LQGLYLGXDO VDX FROHFWLY I U
OLPLW GH WLPS 6XELHFWXO YD FRPSOHWD U VSXQVXULOH REOLJDWRULX OD WR L
LWHPLL$YkQGvQYHGHUHILGHOLWDWHDvQDOW GLQWUHIRUPD$úLIRUPD%VH
SRDWH UD LRQD vQ OHJ WXU FX PRGXO FXP D U VSXQV VXELHFWXO OD WHVW
FRPSDUkQGUH]XOWDWHOHODFHOHGRX SURILOH
,QWHUSUHWDUH'LPHQVLXQLOHIDFWRULDOHVHLQWHUSUHWHD] SRUQLQGGH
ODIDSWXOF RQRW ODH[WUHPHLQGLF XQPD[LPGHDFWLYLVPDOLQIOXHQ HL
UHVSHFWLYH DVXSUD FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL LDU QRWD GLQ ]RQD ÄPHGLH UHV
SHFWLYODFODVHOHúLSDUHV LQGLFHRLQIOXHQ VSHFLILF QHVHPQL
ILFDWLY &XFkWQRWDHVWHPDLH[WUHPL]DW VSUHXQXOVDXDOWXOGLQWUHFHL
GRL SROL DL GLPHQVLXQLL FX DWkW SXWHP FRQVLGHUD LQIOXHQ D VSHFLILF D
IDFWRUXOXLUHVSHFWLYPDLSXWHUQLF ÌQDFHVWVHQVVHWUHFvQUHYLVW FHL
IDFWRULúLVHVHOHFWHD] vQIXQF LHGHSRQGHUHDLQIOXHQ HLvQFHSkQGGHOD
FHLPDLSXWHUQLFLúLVHQVXODFHVWHLLQIOXHQ HQRWHOHúLúLúL
OD FHL FDUH SDU D LQIOXHQ D PDL VODE FRPSRUWDPHQWXO QRWHOH VDX
$SRLvQFHUF PV QHLPDJLQ PFHWLSGHFRPSRUWDPHQWUH]XOW vQXUPD
XQRUDVWIHOGHLQIOXHQ HúLvQFHDQXPHVLWXD LLDFHVWJHQGHDUHDF LRQD
SDUH V FRQGXF VSUH HúHFXUL YXOQHUDELOLW L VDX LQYHUV OD UHXúLWH 6H
FDOFXOHD] IDFWRULLVHFXQGDULúLVHUHDOL]HD] RLPDJLQHPDLLQWHJUDW vQ
OHJ WXU FXIHOXOFXPHVWHSHUFHSXW SHUVRQDOLWDWHDVXELHFWXOXLWHVWDW
([HPSOX5H]XOWDWHOHRE LQXWHODFKHVWLRQDUGHVXELHFWE UEDW
DQLVXQW
6FDOH $%&()*+,/0124444
1RWHVWDQGDUG
)DFWRULLDFWLYLvQFRPSRUWDPHQWVXQW%)&*/úL41úL4
ÌQXUPDDSOLF ULLIRUPXOHORUSHQWUXFDOFXOXOIDFWRULORUVHFXQGDUL
DUH]XOWDW,,,,,,,9&RPSRUWDPHQWXOHVWHGRPLQDWGHLQWH
OLJHQ GHOXFLGLWDWHúLUH LQHUHvQFHHDFHIDFHVHPDQLIHVW VSRQWDQúL
H[SDQVLYQXUHXúHúWHV úLFRQWUROH]HVXILFLHQWHPR LLOHHVWHOHJDWGH
FHLODO L SO FXW YHVHO UHODWLY FRRSHUDQW úL DGDSWDELO OD JUXS $WUDJH
DWHQ LDvQVSHFLDOGLQDPLVPXOFDUHI U V ILHH[WUHPL]DWvLG SRVL
ELOLWDWHD XQHL UHOD LRQ UL HILFLHQWH vQ VLWXD LLOH SUREOHPDWLFH WHQGLQ D
ILLQG V DF LRQH]H ÌQ JHQHUDO DSDUH FD GHVFKLV VRFLDELO H[WUDYHUW
FHHDFHvQVHDPQ F vQFRPSRUWDPHQWúLGHFL]LLVXELHFWXOHVWHOHJDWGH
GDWHOHúLRELHFWHOHUHDOLW LL
&KHVWLRQDUXOÄ&&DWWHOOSULYLQGQLYHOXODQ[LHW LL
3RURWvQ0DQXDOXODOIDEHWLFGHSVLKLDWULHVLQWHWL]kQGGHILQLULOH
DQ[LHW LLVHPQDOHD] WUHLFRQGL LLHVHQ LDOH
6HQWLPHQWXOLPLQHQ HLXQXLSHULFROQHGHWHUPLQDWVHQWLPHQWGH
RELFHLDFRPSDQLDWGHIDQWDVPHWUDJLFHFDUHSRWDPSOLILFDWRWXO
ODSURSRU LLOHXQHLUHDOHWUDJHGLL
VWDUHDGHDWHQ LHID GHXQSHULFRORYHULWDELO DOHUW SVLKLF
FDUH FXSULQGH VXELHFWXO vQ vQWUHJLPH FD úL FXP RULFH DOWFHYD
DUvQFHWDúLWRWXOFRQYHUJHVSUHRLPLQHQW FDWDVWURI
FRQYLQJHUHDGHQHSXWLQ DEVROXW vQVR LW GHVHQWLPHQWXOGH
GH]RUJDQL]DUHúLDQHDQWL]DUHvQID DSHULFROXOXL
'HVLJXU GRPLQDQWD DIHFWLY D DQ[LHW LL HVWH vQVR LW GH R
VLPSWRPDWRORJLHYHJHWDWLY GLVIXQF LLUHVSLUDWRULLúLFDUGLDFHGLVSQHH
SDORDUHUHOD[DUHDvQWUHJLLPXVFXODWXULVDXFRQWUDFWXULYLROHQWHDOHXQRU
VHJPHQWH SUHFXP IUXQWHD HWF $FHVWH UHDF LL SHUPLW R GLVWLQF LH vQWUH
DQ[LHWDWHD OD QLYHO SVLKLF úL DQJRDVD FD WHUPHQ FDUH LQWURGXFH SUH
SRQGHUHQWSODQXOVRPDWLF
$Q[LHWDWHPDQLIHVW úLDQ[LHWDWHYRDODW
&KHVWLRQDUXOVSHFLDOGHGLFDWDQ[LHW LLFXSULQGHXQQXP UGH
GHLWHPLRUJDQL]D LGXS IDFWRULLSULPDULFRPSRQHQ LúLGXS FDUDFWHUXO
PDQLIHVWVDXLQWHULRUL]DWDOVLPSWRPHORUUHVSHFWLYHDVWIHOvQFkWSULPLL
VHUHIHU ODPDQLIHVW ULLQGLUHFWHÄYRDODWHDOHDQ[LHW LLLDUFHLODO L
OD H[SUHVLD GLUHFW D VW ULL OD QLYHOXO FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL 5DSRUWXO
vQWUHMXP WDWHD$úLMXP WDWHD%FDOFXODWVHSDUDWGHQRWDJHQHUDO GH
DQ[LHWDWHGHYLQHXQLQGLFHSHQWUXJUDGXOGHPDVFDUHVDXGHH[SULPDUH
vQFRPSRUWDPHQWXOREVHUYDELODODQ[LHW LL
'DWH SULYLQG LPSRUWDQ D VH[XOXL úL YkUVWHL VXELHFWXOXL vQ
LQWHUSUHWDUHDDQ[LHW LL
6WXGLLOH ODX FRQGXV SH &DWWHOO OD XWLOL]DUHD D GRX LPSRUWDQWH
FRUHF LLDQRWHLJHQHUDOHGHDQ[LHWDWHvQIXQF LHGHVH[XOVXELHFWXOXLúL
vQIXQF LHGHYkUVW ÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHYkUVWDQRWDJHQHUDO VFDGHGHR
SDUWHúLGHDOWDDYkUVWHLGH±DQLÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHVH[XOQLYHOXO
GH DQ[LHWDWH IHPLQLQ HVWH vQ JHQHUDO PDL FUHVFXW úL vQ FUHúWHUH PDL
DFFHQWXDW ODIHPHL$FHVWHGRX DVSHFWHFRUHODWHDXFRQGXVODDSOLFDUHD
vQPRGGLIHUHQ LDWSHVH[HDXQRUFRUHF LL
3HQWUXE UED LvQWUH±DQLVHVFDGSXQFWHvQWUH±
VH VFDGH SXQFW vQWUH ± QX VH VFDGH QLPLF vQWUH ± VH
DGDXJ SXQFWvQWUHúLVHDGDXJ SXQFWH
3HQWUX IHPHL vQWUH ± VH VFDG SXQFWH vQWUH ± VH
VFDGSXQFWHvQWUH±VHVFDGSXQFWHvQWUH±VHVFDGH
SXQFWGHODvQVXVQXVHPDLRSHUHD] PRGLILF UL
3UH]HQWDUHD IDFWRUXOXL DQ[LHWDWH úL D ID HWHORU DERUGDWH GH
FKHVWLRQDU
3HQWUX &DWWHOO IDFWRUXO DQ[LHWDWH HVWH VHFXQGDU UHSUH]HQWkQG R
SDUWLFXODU FRPELQDUH D FRQWULEX LHL D IDFWRULSULPDULFRQúWLLQ DGH
VLQH 4 IRU D HXOXL & SURSHQVLXQHD SDUDQRLG / SURSHQVLXQHD VSUH
FXOSDELOLWDWH2úLWHQVLXQHDHUJLF 4
3HQWUX SHUVRQRORJXO DPHULFDQ DQ[LHWDWHD VH UHIHU OD FDUDFWH
ULVWLFLSUHFXPWHQVLXQHDLQWHULRDU LQVWDELOLWDWHDOLSVDGHvQFUHGHUHvQ
VLQHUH]HUYDvQDVXPDUHDVLWXD LLORUGHULVFWHPHULGLIHULWHPDQLIHVW UL
SVLKRVRPDWLFH DPSOLILFDWH vQ SODQ VXELHFWLY $Q[LHWDWHD GLIHU GH
QHYURWLVPSULQDFFHQWXOSXVSHLQFDSDFLWDWHDGHDGDSWDUHODVLWXD LLQRL
úLULJLGLWDWHDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL
'H DVHPHQHD PRGXO GH RUJDQL]DUH DO FHORU GRX MXP W L vQ
IXQF LHGHIDFWRULLSULPDULHVWHVLPLODUFkWHLWHPLSHQWUX4LWHPL
SHQWUX&LWHPLSHQWUX/LWHPLSHQWUX2úLLWHPLSHQWUX4vQ
IXQF LHGHSRQGHUHDFRQWULEX LHLILHF UXLD
'DF DUILV UHOX PVHPQLILFD LDVSHFLILF DDFHVWRUFRQWULEX LLSHQ
WUXFRQGL LDDQ[LHW LLYRPDFFHQWXDSHXUP WRDUHOHDVSHFWHVSHFLILFH
'H]YROWDUHDFRQúWLLQ HLGHVLQH4LQGLF JUDGXOGHPRWLYDUHD
LQWHJU ULL FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL vQ MXUXO DFFHSW ULL úL LPDJLQLL GH
VLQH GHILQLW FRQúWLHQW FODU úL vQ IXQF LH GH VWDQGDUGHOH
VRFLDOH DFFHSWDWH ÌQ DFHVW VHQV 4 UHVSHFWLY DEVHQ D XQHL
DVWIHOGHLQWHJU ULDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLHVWHFRQVLGHUDW XQDGLQ
FDX]HOHPDMRUHDOHGH]YROW ULLDQ[LHW LL9DULD LDQRWHLOD4
SRDWH IL OHJDW úL GH VWUXFWXULOH FDUDFWHULDOH úL GHSULQGHULOH
DFFHSWDWHvQSODQVRFLDO
)RU DHXOXLVDXFDSDFLWDWHDGHDFRQWURODúLH[SULPDWHQVLXQLOH
vQWURPDQLHU UHDOLVW úLDSUREDW VRFLDOLQWHUYLQHvQVWDUHDGH
DQ[LHWDWHSULQFRQVHFLQ HOHLQFDSDFLW LLXQXLHXVODEUHVSHFWLY
&LQFDSDELOGHDXWRFRQWUROFDUHUHFXUJkQGODPXOWLSOHDS U UL
GXFH OD FUHúWHUHD WHQVLXQLL VXELHFWLYH R LSRWH] VXSOLPHQWDU
SRUQHúWHGHODHIHFWXOXQHLWHQVLXQLSXWHUQLFHFDUHSRDWHFRQGXFH
ODUHJUHVSVLKLFúLvPSLHGLF FUHúWHUHDQRUPDO DIRU HLHXOXL
0DL SX LQ FODU DSDUH FDX]D LQWHUQ D FRUHO ULL SURSHQVLXQLL
SDUDQRLGH/FXDQ[LHWDWHDGDUVHSUHVXSXQHGHH[HPSOXOD
DFHVWQLYHOUHODWLYH[WHULRUDOH[SOLFD LHLSVLKRORJLFHF VLWXD LD
VRFLDO GLILFLO LQGXV GH FRPSRUWDPHQWHOH GRPLQDWH GH WHQ
GLQ DSDUDQRLG DUHFDHIHFWDQ[LHWDWHDFXVHQVXOF QHVLJXUDQ D
VRFLDO SDUDOHO DS U ULLSDUDQRLGHFRQGXFHODDQ[LHWDWH
'HVFULSWLYIDFWRUXO2UHSUH]LQW FXOSDELOLWDWHDDQ[LRDV GH
SUHVLY úLSRDWHUHSUH]HQWDRSURSHQVLXQHFRQVWLWX LRQDO VSUH
DQ[LHWDWHÌQIRUPHOHH[WUHPHVHLQFOXGHvQWUXQVLQGURPFDUH
FRPELQ GHSUHVLD DXWRFXOSDELOL]DUHD úL DQ[LHWDWHD VLQGURP
FDUH SRDWH IL vQWkOQLW vQ SUDFWLFD SVLKLDWULF &DUDFWHULVWLFD
FHQWUDO GHVFULV SULQ WHVWXO Ä& HVWH VHQWLPHQWXO OLSVHL GH
GHPQLWDWH SHUVRQDO DQ[LHWDWHD úL GHSUHVLD vPSUHXQ FX SUR
SHQVLXQHDVSUHWRWIHOXOGHVHQWLPHQWHGHDXWRFXOSDELOL]DUH
&RPSRQHQW LPSRUWDQW D DQ[LHW LL WHQVLXQHD HUJLF 4
SULQ LPSXOVXUL DFWLYDWH VDX SURYRFDWH SULQ QHFHVLW L QHVDWLV
I FXWHGHRULFHWLSFRQWULEXLHODVWDUHDGHQHOLQLúWH$VWIHOGH
H[HPSOX H[FLWDUHD DSHWLWXOXL VH[XDO QHYRLD GH FRQVLGHUD LH
VDXWHDPDGHRVLWXD LHDSDUFDLPSXOVXULOHJDWHGHVLQGURPXO
DQ[LHW LL 1LYHOXO ULGLFDW DO WHQVLXQLL HUJLFH VH UHIOHFW vQ
SXOVLXQHDVSUHDJUHVLYLWDWHWHQVLXQHLULWDELOLWDWHQHUYR]LWDWH
&RWHOHULGLFDWHH[WUHPHvQFHSkQGGHODQRWDVWDQGDUGLQGLF
LQVWDODUHD DQ[LHW LL 1LYHOXO SHQWUX R VFDO vQ FODVH VWDQGDU
GL]DWHLQGLF QHFHVLWDWHDXQHLLQWHUYHQ LLWHUDSHXWLFH
1HYUR]D FD GLPHQVLXQH GLVWLQFW GH DQ[LHWDWH FRQGXFH OD FUHú
WHUHDFRWHLDFHVWHLDÌQXQHOHVW ULQHYURWLFHDFXWHSXWHPvQWkOQLFUHúWHUL
H[WUHPHDOHDQ[LHW LLvQJHQHUDOXQQHYURWLFúLGLUHFWSURSRU LRQDOFX
VWDELOL]DUHD QHYUR]HL SRDWH DYHD QRWH RVFLOkQG vQWUH úL vQ WHUPHQLL
QRWHORUVWDQGDUG'HDVHPHQHDQLYHOXOQRWHLVWDQGDUGGLIHUHQ LD] vQWUH
XQ GLDJQRVWLF GH LVWHULH VDX GH DQJRDV WUHL VIHUWXUL GLQWUH EROQDYL DX
QRWHSHVWHúLGHQRUPDOLWDWHWUHLVIHUWXULGLQWUHÄQRUPDOLDXQRWHVXE
'DWHOHFOLQLFHLQGLF úLIDSWXOF vQJHQHUDOIRUPHOHGHSVLKR] DQ
WUHQHD] RULGLFDUHDQLYHOXOXLGHDQ[LHWDWHQRWDILLQGPDLULGLFDW GHFkW
ODQHYURWLFLGHFLSHVWH$FHVWWLSGHLQWHUSUHW ULODPvQWkOQLWúLSHQWUX
VFDOHOH003,
6HSRDWHGLVWLQJHvQWUHDQ[LHWDWHÄQRUPDO FkQGVWDUHDSVLKLF
HVWHGLUHFWGHSHQGHQW GHRVLWXD LHH[LVWHQ LDO DQ[LRJHQ úLDQ[LHWDWHD
SDWRORJLF
'LQWUH FRPSRQHQWHOH SULPDUH DOH DQ[LHW LL 4 úL 4 VXQW FHO
PDLGLUHFWOHJDWHúLLQIOXHQ DWHGHPHGLXLDU&DUHRLPSRUWDQW FRQWUL
EX LHHUHGLWDU
'HDVHPHQHDIDFWRULL2úL/VXQWFHLPDLVWDELOL6LWXD LLOHVWUH
VDQWHGHWHUPLQ RPDLSXWHUQLF SUHVLXQHDSXOVLXQLORU4úLWXOEXU
XQHXLPDWXU&
2 QRW VWDQGDUG vQWUH úL HVWH VHPQLILFDWLY SHQWUX OLSVD GH
PRWLYD LH JHQHUDO VDX SHQWUX VWDUHD GH DSDWLH ÌQ DFHVW VHQV GH
H[HPSOXUHXúLWDúFRODU FRUHOHD] FXDQ[LHWDWHDvQ]RQDPHGLH
([HPSOLILFDUHDLQWHUSUHW ULLXQXLSURILOÄ&´
0DWHULDOH QHFHVDUH &KHVWLRQDU FX LWHPL IRDLH GH U VSXQV
JULO HWDORQSHYkUVWHúLVH[HIRDLHGHSURILOPDQXDOSHQWUXLQWHUSUHWDUH
6FRS $Q[LHWDWHD FRQIRUP WHRULHL OXL 5% &DWWHOO GHILQHúWH
FDUDFWHULVWLFL GH WHQVLXQH LQWHULRDU LQVWDELOLWDWH OLSV GH vQFUHGHUH vQ
VLQHUH]HUY vQDVXPDUHDVLWXD LLORUGHULVFWHPHULGLIHULWHPDQLIHVW UL
SVLKRVRPDWLFHDPSOLILFDWHVXELHFWLY)DFWRUXOGHDQ[LHWDWHHDSURSLDWGH
QHYURWLVPvQV VHGHRVHEHúWHGHDFHVWD1HYURWLVPXOHVWHLQFDSDFLWDWHD
GHDGDSWDUHODVLWXD LLQRLULJLGLWDWHvQFRPSRUWDPHQW&KHVWLRQDUXOHVWH
FRQVWUXLWFXVFRSXOGHDP VXUDDQ[LHWDWHD,WHPLLVXQWRUJDQL]D LGXS
IDFWRULLSULPDULFRPSRQHQ LúLGXS FDUDFWHUXOPDQLIHVWVDXLQWHULRUL]DW
DOVLPSWRPHORU$VWIHOSULPLLLWHPLVHUHIHU ODPDQLIHVW ULLQGLUHFWH
YRDODWH DOH DQ[LHW LL XUP WRULL OD H[SUHVLD GLUHFW D VW ULL OD QLYHO
FRPSRUWDPHQWDO5DSRUWXOGLQWUHSULPDúLDGRXDMXP WDWHFDOFXODWVH
SDUDWGHQRWDJHQHUDO GHDQ[LHWDWHGHYLQHXQLQGLFHSHQWUXJUDGXOGH
PDVFDUHVDXGHDFFHQWXDUHFRPSRUWDPHQWDO DWU LULLDQ[LRDVH
6WUXFWXU &KHVWLRQDUXO HYDOXHD] QLYHOXO DQ[LHW LL JOREDOH
SULQ VXEVFDOH FDUH GHWHUPLQ IDFWRUL SULPDUL DL DQ[LHW LL $FHúWL
IDFWRULVXQWXUP WRULL
6FDOD4 QLYHOXOGHLQWHJUDUHDLPDJLQLLGHVLQHFXFRPSRUWD
PHQWXOVDXGH]YROWDUHDFRQúWLLQ HLGHVLQH$FHVWIDFWRUDUDW JUDGXOGH
PRWLYDUH D LQWHJU ULL FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL LQGLYLGXDO vQ FH SULYHúWH
LPDJLQHDGHVLQHDFFHSWDW FRQúWLHQWúLUDSRUWDW ODVWDQGDUGHOHVRFLDOH
DFFHSWDWH$EVHQ DXQHLDVWIHOGHLQWHJU ULDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLvQMXUXO
XQHLLPDJLQLGHVLQHFODU HVWHXQDGLQWUHFDX]HOHPDMRUHDOHGH]YRO
W ULLDQ[LHW LL1RWDSHQWUXFRPSRQHQWD4SRDWHV ILHGHDVHPHQHD
OHJDW GHVWUXFWXULOHGHFDUDFWHUúLGHRELFHLXULOHVRFLDOPHQWHDSUREDWH
6FDOD& IRU D(XOXLFDSDFLWDWHDGHDVHFRQWURODIDFLOLWDWHDGH
DúL UHFXQRDúWH UHDOLVW WHQVLXQLOH LQWHULRDUH )DFWRUXO Ä&´ UHSUH]LQW
FRQFHSWXOELQHFXQRVFXWDOIRU HL(XOXLFDSDFLWDWHDGHDFRQWURODúLGH
DH[SULPDWHQVLXQLOHvQWURPDQLHU DGRSWDW úLUHDOLVW WHQVLXQLOHJH
QHUDWHGHVLQH(XOVODELQFDSDELOGHDXWRFRQWUROUHFXUJHODPXOWLSOH
DS U ULFDUHGXFODFUHúWHUHDWHQVLXQLLVXELHFWLYH2DGRXDLSRWH] HVWH
F RWHQVLXQHDQ[LRDV SXWHUQLF FRQGXFHODUHJUHVúLvPSLHGLF FUHú
WHUHDQRUPDO DIRU HL(XOXL
6FDOD/ VHQWLPHQWGHLQVHFXULWDWHWHQGLQ HSDUDQRLGH0RWLYXO
FRUHO ULL WHQGLQ HL SDUDQRLFH FX DQ[LHWDWHD HVWH REVFXU 6LWXD LD VRFLDO
GLILFLO FDX]DW GHFRPSRUWDPHQWHOHSDUDQRLFHDUSXWHDV VHvQUXGHDVF
FX DQ[LHWDWHD VDX PDL YHULGLF DFHDVW QRW V UHSUH]LQWH SDUWLFLSDUHD
QHVLJXUDQ HL VRFLDOH OD DQ[LHWDWH FDUH GXFH SDUDOHO OD GH]YROWDUHD GH
FRPSRUWDPHQWHDVHP Q WRDUHWLSLFHGHIHQVLYHLSDUDQRLFH
6FDOD2 vQFOLQDUHF WUHDXWRDFX]DUHÌQSODQGHVFULSWLYIDFWRUXO
Ä2´ HVWH FXQRVFXW FD UHSUH]HQWkQG FXOSDELOLWDWHD DQ[LRDV GHSUHVLY
3RDWH V ILH XQ HOHPHQW FRQVWLWX LRQDO DO DQ[LHW LL ÌQ IRUPHOH VDOH
H[WUHPHSDUHDILXQVLQGURPGHGHSUHVLHDXWRDFX]DUHúLDQ[LHWDWHFRP
ELQDW vQWkOQLW ODXQLLEROQDYLGLQVSLWDOHOHGHSVLKLDWULH&DUDFWHULVWLFD
VD FHQWUDO HVWH XQ VHQWLPHQW GH OLSV GH GHPQLWDWH GH DQ[LHWDWHúLGH
GHSUHVLH ÌQ WHUPHQL IUHXGLHQL HD SRDWH IL DFRSHULW GH FRQFHSWXO GH
DQ[LHWDWHSURYRFDWGHDQ[LHWDWHDGDW GHSUHVLXQHD6XSUDHXOXL
6FDOD4 WHQVLXQHHUJLF WHQVLXQHDSXOVD LLORULQWHULRDUHFHQX
SRWILUH]ROYDWHWHQGLQ HDVRFLDOH$FHDVW FRPSRQHQW SDUHV UHSUH
]LQWHJUDGXOvQFDUHDQ[LHWDWHDHSURYRFDW GHSUHVLXQLOHúLQHFHVLW LOH
WUHEXLQ HOHLPSXOVXULOHQHVDWLVI FXWHGHRULFHIHO
$SOLFDUH 7HVWXO VH DSOLF I U OLPLW GH WLPS LQVWUXFWDMXO VH
IDFH XWLOL]kQG IRDLD GH U VSXQV SHQWUX H[HPSOLILFDUH 6XELHFWXO HVWH
DYHUWL]DWV HYLWHU VSXQVXULOHGHWLSÄRDUHFXPQHVLJXUXQHRUL´V QX
RPLW QLFLXQU VSXQVV U VSXQG FkWPDLRQHVWSHQWUXFDUH]XOWDWHOH
V vOUHSUH]LQWH6HDSOLF LQGLYLGXDOVDXFROHFWLY5HFRPDQGDWSHQWUX
DGXO LúLWLQHUL
&RWDUH 6H DSOLF JULOD 6H DFRUG SXQFW VDX SXQFWH vQ
FRQIRUPLWDWHFXLQGLFD LLOHJULOHL6HIDFHVXPDWXWXURUSXQFWHORUSHQWUX
DRE LQHVFRUXOEUXWSHQWUXVFDODGHDQ[LHWDWHJOREDO 6HFDOFXOHD] VFR
UXULOHEUXWH$úL%úLVHIDFHUDSRUWXO$%6HFDOFXOHD] VFRUXULOHEUXWH
SDU LDOH SHQWUX ILHFDUH VXEVFDO IDFWRU 4 & / 2 4 6H DSOLF
FRUHF LLOH FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH vQ IXQF LH GH YkUVW úL VH[ 6H WUDQVIRUP
QRWHOH EUXWH vQ QRWH VWDQGDUG SULQ XWLOL]DUHD HWDORQXOXL 6H GHVHQHD]
SURILOXOúLVHIDFLQWHUSUHW ULOH
$GROHVFHQWDQLHOHYOLFHXRE LQHXUP WRDUHOHUH]XOWDWH
6FDOH ,QGLFHJOREDO 4 & / 2 4
1RWHEUXWHI U FRUHF LH
1RWHEUXWHFXFRUHF LH
1RWHVWDQGDUG
,QWHUSUHWDUH $Q[LHWDWH vQ OLPLWH QRUPDOH LQGLFH JOREDO
)DFWRUXO4LQGLF RXúRDU FUHúWHUHDDQ[LHW LLGDWRUDW XQRUSUR
EOHPHGHLQWHJUDUHDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLFXLPDJLPHDGHVLQHUHVSHFWLY
RUHODWLY QHVLJXUDQ úLQHvQFUHGHUHvQVLQHvQVLWXD LLOHVRFLDOH
(;7,1'(5,
'DWHGHFHUFHWDUH
6FKDLH FHUFHWHD] GH]YROWDUHD GHD OXQJXO SHULRDGHL ±
DQL FX ORWXUL GLKRWRPL]DWH vQ IXQF LH GH VH[ SHQWUX ILHFDUH DQ GH
YkUVW 7R L IDFWRULL SULPDUL FX H[FHS LD 0 DXWLD DX SUH]HQWDW GLIH
UHQ HvQIXQF LHGHYkUVW úLVH[OLQLLOHGHWHQGLQ HSHQWUXDFHVWHYkUVWH
VXQW QRQPRQRWRQH RVFLOkQG GHD OXQJXO SHULRDGHORU GH YkUVW FUHú
WHUHDVDXGHVFUHúWHUHDQXVHUHDOL]HD] JUDGDWJUDGLHQ LLGHPDWXUL]DUH
FRLQFLGFDIRUP GDUGLIHU FDQLYHO
&D DVSHFWH PDL VSHFLILFH SHQWUX IDFWRUXO $ OLQLD GH WHQGLQ
LQGLF H[LVWHQ DXQHLFUL]HSUHSXEHUWDOHODDQLSHQWUXDPEHOHVH[H
IHWHOH vúL UHYLQ PDL UDSLG GDU VH FRQIUXQW FX R QRX FUL] OD DQL
UHODWLYDVRFLDW SURFHVHORUSXEHUW LL
)DFWRUXO(GRPLQDQ DGLIHUHQ LD] FODUvQWUHVH[HRWHQGLQ GH
VF GHUH WUHSWDW FD UH]XOWDW SRVLELO DO VRFLDOL] ULL úL FRQIUXQW ULORU FX
UHDOLWDWHD YkUIXO OD IHWH vQWUH ± DQL FX VSHFLILFDUHD LQIOXHQ HL
FRQWH[WXOXLvQFDUHHVWHHYDOXDWFRPSRUWDPHQWXO
3HQWUX IDFWRUXO , GXS DQL H[LVW R WHQGLQ vQ GLUHF LD
FDUDFWHULVWLFLLGHEOkQGH HODIHWHODE LH LPDLSX LQDFFHQWXDW VSUH
UHDOLVPúLKRW UkUHGXS DQLRGDW FXDFFHSWDUHDUROXOXLFXOWXUDO
WHQGLQ DHPDLSXWHUQLF ODE LH L
$FHODúL DXWRU SRUQLQG GH OD GHVFRSHULUHD XQRU YDULD LL VHPQLIL
FDWLYHGHODDQODDQúLFKLDUODQLYHOXOVXESHULRDGHLGHDQFRQFKLGH
Ä3XWHPWUDJHFRQFOX]LDF DFHVWFRQFHSWGHSHULRDG GHYkUVW DUHR
SUHDPDUHUHVSLUD LH$FLWDRYDORDUHPHGLHSHQWUXWR LFHLVDXDQL
DLFRSLO ULHLPLMORFLLvQOHJ WXU FXHPRWLYLWDWHDGHH[HPSOXQXDUIL
GHFkW V PDVFKH]L vQ PRG FODU FHOH FLFOXUL GH GH]YROWDUH FX ]RQHOH
VF ]XWHODODúLODDQL´
$OWFHUFHW WRU%HUQLHLQGLF RVFKLPEDUHWUHSWDW vQWUH
úL DQL FDUH WLQGH FKLDU V XUPH]H XQ PRGHO RUGRQDW vQ VHQVXO F
IHOXOvQFDUHVXELHFWXOYDU VSXQGHODDQLDUHRFRUHOD LHVXEVWDQ LDO
FXPRGXOOXLGHDU VSXQGHODDQLHWF
5HDOL]kQGRVLQWH] SURSULHDGDWHORUGLIHULWHORUFHUFHW UL+RUURFNV
LQGLF XUP WRULLIDFWRULFDVHPQLILFDWLYLSHQWUXSHULRDGDDGROHVFHQ HL
DQ[LHWDWHDWHQGLQ DVSUHIUXVWUDUHULJLGLWDWHDúLFRQIRUPLVPXOQHYRLD
GHDVHHOLEHUDGHIULF LXQLúLFRQWURYHUVHQHYRLDGHDVHUHDOL]DWHQGLQ D
VSUHDXWRULWDWHúLRVFLODUHDvQWUHFRPSHWLWLYLWDWHVDXQRQFRPSHWLWLYLWDWH
GLUHF LRQDUHDVSUHLQWHULRUVDXH[WHULRUGHIHQVLYLWDWHDDXWRVDXH[WUDSX
QLWLYLWDWHDQHYURWLVPXOWHQGLQ DVSUHKHGRQLVP
ÌQSULYLQ DIDFWRUXOXLVHFXQGDULQWURYHUVLHH[WUDYHUVLHVXQWDXWRUL
FDUH YRUEHVF GH R ÄFUL] D LQWURYHUVLHL´ vQ MXU GH ± DQL $PHV
GHILQHúWH VLWXD LD FD PDL FRPSOH[ GHFkW R VLPSO FUL] Ä6FR
UXULOHPHGLLVXQWGHWLSLQWURYHUVLYODILHFDUHGLQWUHYkUVWHOHvQWUHúL
DQL0DLPXOWGHGHSDUWHvQPDMRULWDWHDFD]XULORUGHDGROHVFHQ LVH
REVHUY F XQ LQGLYLG HVWH OD DQXPLWH YkUVWH PDL LQWURYHUVLY GHFkW OD
DOWHOH vQ VSHFLDO vQWUH úL DQL SHULRDGHOH GH FRPSRUWDPHQW LQWUR
YHUVLYDOWHUQHD] FXFHOHGHH[SDQVLYLWDWHÄ$GROHVFHQWXOQXLQWU úLQX
LHVHSXUúLVLPSOXGLQLQWURYHUVLHVDXGLQSHULRDGHPDLUHVWULFWLYH0DL
GHJUDE WUHFH SULQWUR VHFYHQ GH ID]H vQ FDUH WHQGLQ HOH LQWURYHUVLYH
VDX UHVWULFWLYH DOWHUQHD] FX WHQGLQ H PDL H[SDQVLYH´ ([SOLFD LD LQH
GHSHULRDGHOHvQFDUHDGROHVFHQWXOQXUHXúHúWHV úLFRQVWLWXLHDGDSW UL
DGHFYDWHODUHDOLWDWHDFXFDUHVHFRQIUXQW ([LVW XQHOHGDWHFDUHLQGLF
GH DVHPHQHD F FHL PDL H[WUDYHUWL L SURYLQ GH RELFHL GLQ IDPLOLL FX
SUDFWLFLGHFUHúWHUHSR]LWLYHúLFOLPDWGHDFFHSWDUHúLDIHF LXQH
%URQVRQ RSHUkQG SULQWUR DERUGDUH KROLVWLF D SHUVRQDOLW LL
LQWURGXFHvQFHUFHWDUHLSRWH]DF RULFHSHUVRDQ HVWHFDUDFWHUL]DW
GH XQ DQXPH VWLO H[LVWHQ LDO FDUH DU FRQVWD GLQ VHWXUL GH DWLWXGLQL
DELOLW L WU V WXUL FDUH vPSUHXQ LPSXQ XQ ÄSDUIXP FDUDFWHULVWLF
WXWXURULQWHUDF LXQLORUSHUVRDQHL´
$VWIHO VXQW SRVWXODWH RULHQW UL FHQWUDOH FDUH VH GH]YROW GH WLP
SXULXvQYLD DFRSLOXOXLFDUH]XOWDWDOH[SHULHQ HORUSHUVRQDOHDOHYHQL
PHQWHORU IL]LFRIL]LRORJLFH úL DO PRGXOXL FXP LQWU vQ FXUV FDUDFWH
ULVWLFLOH JHQHWLFH ÌQ FDGUXO ILHF UHL RULHQW UL HVWH SRVLELO R YDULHWDWH
GHFRPSRUWDPHQWHvQIXQF LHGHDGHFYDUHDODGLIHULWHOHWLSXULGHPHGLX
ÌQ DMXQJH OD GHILQLUHD D GRX GLPHQVLXQL FHQWUDOH SHQWUX
RULHQWDUHD FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL SODFLGLWDWHD ± UHDFWLYLWDWHD H[SOR]L
YLWDWHD úL HPRWLYLWDWHD ± UH]HUYD $VWIHO VH FRQVWLWXLH DFHOH VWLOXUL
H[LVWHQ LDOH GHILQLWH vQ IXQF LH GH PRGXO vQ FDUH LQGLYLGXO VXSRUW úL
PRGXO FXP DERUGHD] UHOD LLOH FX VHPHQLL $FHVWH DVSHFWH GHúL VXQW
DIHFWDWH GH H[SHULHQ D LQWHUSHUVRQDO VXQW LPSRUWDQWHSHQWUXGLIHUHQ
LHUHD vQ IXQF LH GH WLSXO GH H[SHULHQ IXUQL]DW GH PHGLX )LHFDUH
GLPHQVLXQH D SHUVRQDOLW LL HVWH FRQFHSXW FD R DUHQ ODUJ SHQWUX
DWLWXGLQLúLFRQGXLWHúLFRQVW GLQWUXQQXP UGHFRPSRUWDPHQWHFDUH
ILHFDUHVHPDQLIHVW GHDOXQJXOXQXLFRQWLQXXúLILHFDUHHVWHOHJDWGH
WRDWH FHOHODOWH vQWUXQ DQXPH JUDG $FHDVW YL]LXQH QH DSDUH LPSRU
WDQW SHQWUXDLQWHJUDFRHUHQWGDWHOHUH]XOWDWHGLQHYDOX ULOHFDQWLWDWLYH
DOH IDFWRULORU SULPDUL vQWUR YL]LXQH XQLWDU DVXSUD FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL
úLSHUVRQDOLW LLVXELHFWXOXLH[DPLQDW
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH
WU V WXU ±DELOLWDWHDXWRUXOVHUHIHU ODWU V WXULFDUHGHVFULXDELOLWDWHD
XQXL SHUVRDQH úL JUDGXO GH HILFLHQ FX FDUH HVWH FDSDELO V OXFUH]H
SHQWUXXQDQXPHVFRSGHH[HPSOXIDFWRUXO%
DWLWXGLQL&DWWHOODUHRYL]LXQHPDLODUJ DVXSUDDWLWXGLQLORUFRQVLGHUkQG
F HOH UHSUH]LQW DWkW LQWHUHVHOH RSLQLL XQXL LQGLYLG FkW úL HPR LLOH úL
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOV XID GHRSHUVRDQ RELHFWVDXHYHQLPHQW
HX VHGLXO úL DQVDPEOXO PRWLYD LLORU úL DFWHORU XQXL LQGLYLG FDUH FRQ
GL LRQHD] DGDSWDUHD VD OD UHDOLWDWH vL VDWLVIDFH WUHEXLQ HOH úL UH]ROY
FRQIOLFWHOHGDWRUDWHXQRUGRULQ HYVFRQGL LLLQFRPSDWLELOH
HUJ HQHUJLH OD GLVSR]L LD FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL WU V WXUL VXUV FRQVWLWX
LRQDO FXDF LXQHSHUPDQHQW
LGHRJUDILFXQVLVWHPVDXWHRULHSVLKRORJLF RULHQWDWVSUHFRQFUHWLQGL
YLGXDOXQLF'3
LQWHJUDUH vQ VHQV ODUJ SURFHVXO GH D FRRUGRQD úL XQLILFD HOHPHQWH
VHSDUDWHvQWUXQvQWUHJ3ULQFLSLXGHRUJDQL]DUHFHVHDSOLF ODVWUXFWXUL
FXHOHPHQWHRUGRQDWHLHUDUKLFQLYHOHOHVXSHULRDUHH[HUFLW XQFRQWURO
DVXSUD FHORU LQIHULRDUH ÌQ SVLKRORJLH WHUPHQXO HVWH DSOLFDW vQ VHQV
ODUJ GHVFULSWLY RULF UHL FRQGXLWH DOH F UHL HOHPHQWH VXQW FODU VXERU
GRQDWHXQXLVFRSILQDOL]DWRULF UHLDF LXQLLQWHQ LRQDWH'3
QRPRWHWLF XQ VLVWHP VDX WHRULH SVLKRORJLF RULHQWDW VSUH DEVWUDFW
XQLYHUVDOVDXJHQHUDO'3
RUJDQL]DUHD WU V WXULORU XQ WHUPHQ FDUH VH UHIHU OD XQ VHWLSRWHWLF
GH LQWHUUHOD LRQ UL vQWUH GLIHULWHOH WU V WXUL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH DOH XQHL
SHUVRDQH
SURILO GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH SUH]HQW UL JHQHUDOH DOH WU V WXULORU GH SHUVR
QDOLWDWHúLDOHFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUSUH]HQWHODDFHDSHUVRDQ UHODWLYODXQVHW
GHQRUPHFRQVWUXLWHID GHRSRSXOD LHGHUHIHULQ vQSURILOGDWHOHVXQW
SUH]HQWDWHvQIRUP JUDILF FDvQFD]XOWHVWHORU&3,VDX003,VDX
DFHVWD SRDWH DYHD IRUPD PDL JHQHUDO D XQHL SUH]HQW UL D FDUDFWHULV
WLFLORULQGLYLGXOXLVDXDWU V WXULORUvQIRUP VXPDU '3
SURJQR] RSUHGLF LHSULYLQGFXUVXOVDXUH]XOWDWXOXQXLSURFHVILHHO
SVLKRORJLFHGXFD LRQDOPHWRGRORJLFHWF'3
VHQWLPHQW GH VLQH FRQFHSXW GH DXWRU FD LPDJLQH GHVSUH VLQH FDUH
FRRUGRQHD] úLRUJDQL]HD] DWLWXGLQLOHúLPRWLYD LLOHVXELHFWXOXL
VXSUDHXDQVDPEOXGHLQWHUGLF LLPRUDOHLQWURLHFWDWH
WD[RQRPLH XQ VHW GH SULQFLSLL VLVWHPDWLFH FH SHUPLW FODVLILFDUHD
WD[RQRPLD UHDOL]DW GH &DWWHOO GRUHúWH V VLVWHPDWL]H]H ULJXURV
PXOWLWXGLQHD GH WHUPHQL FDUH VH UHIHU OD SHUVRQDOLWDWH vQ VHQV ODUJ úL
UHDOL]HD] XQ ,QGH[ 8QLYHUVDO ILHFDUH IDFWRU SULPLQG XQ LQGLFDWLY GH
FRG SURSULX GH DVHPHQHD XQLL GLQWUH IDFWRULL DVWIHO FODVLILFD L DX
SULPLW úL GHQXPLUL FROD LRQDWH GH DXWRU FX VFRSXO HYLW ULL FRQIX]LLORU
GHH[HPSOXIDFWRUXO-GHQXPLW]HSLDYVFRDVWKHQLD'DWHPDLDPSOH
vQ OXFUDUHD 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG 0RWLYDWLRQ 6WUXFWXUH DQG PHDVXUHPHQW
:RUOG%RRN1HZ<RUN
WU V WXUL GLQDPLFH WU V WXUL FDUH GHVFULX PRWLYHOH úL LQWHUHVHOH XQHL
SHUVRDQH
WU V WXULGHVXSUDID XQJUXSGHFRPSRUWDPHQWHLQWHUUHOD LRQDWHD
F URU DSDUL LH SRDWH IL REVHUYDW vQ YDULDWH FRQGL LL úL VLWXD LL vQ VHQV
VSHFLILF R WU V WXU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH LSRWHWLF FDUH VH LGHQWLILF SULQ
DQDOL]DIDFWRULDO úLVHSUHVXSXQHDILUHVSRQVDELO GHDFHVWHFRPSRU
WDPHQWHFRUHODWH'3
WU V WXUL VXUV R WU V WXU SVLKRORJLF LSRWHWLF ÄGH SURIXQ]LPH´
FDUH vQ WHUPHQL VWDWLVWLFL HFKLYDOHD] FX IDFWRULL SULPDUL RE LQX L vQ
XUPDDQDOL] ULLIDFWRULDOHDGDWHORUGHHYDOXDUHDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLVH
FRQVLGHU F DFHVWHWU V WXULVXUV H[SOLF IDSWXOF PXOWHGLQWUHWU V
WXULOHGHVXSUDID SUH]LQW FRUHOD LLUHFLSURFHUHODWLYPDUL
WU V WXUL GH WHPSHUDPHQW WU V WXUL FH GHVFULX VWLOXO JHQHUDO GH
FRPSRUWDPHQWDOXQXLLQGLYLGFDU VSXQVODPHGLX
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU
&DUHHVWHVSHFLILFXOWHRULHLOXL&DWWHOOSULYLQGSHUVRQDOLWDWHD"
&HVXQWIDFWRULLvQUDSRUWFXGLPHQVLXQLOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH"
&H WLSXUL GHWU V WXULWHRUHWL]HD] &DWWHOOGLQSHUVSHFWLYDDQDOL]HL
IDFWRULDOH"WD[RQRPLL
&HWLSXULGHWU V WXULWHRUHWL]HD] &DWWHOOGLQSHUVSHFWLYDFRQ LQX
WXULORUSVLKRORJLFH"H[HPSOLILF UL
&DUHVXQWIDFWRULLVHFXQGDULGHILQL LSHQWUXSHUVRQDOLWDWHDPDWXU úL
FDUHHVWHVHQVXOSVLKRORJLFDODFHVWRUD"
&DUHHVWHVSHFLILFXOSHUVRQDOLW LLvQDGROHVFHQ úLFDUHHVWHFRQ
VHFLQ DvQVWUXFWXUDIDFWRULDO DúDFXPDIRVWGHILQLW GH&DWWHOO"
&DUH VXQW FHL PDL SXWHUQLFL IDFWRUL vQ VWUXFWXUD IDFWRULDO D SHU
VRQDOLW LLPDWXUL]DWHHQXPHUD LSULPLLIDFWRULGLQFHLIDFWRUL
SULPDUL"
&XPYHGH&DWWHOOGHILQLUHDúLORFXOLPDJLQLLGHVLQHúLvQFUHGHULLvQ
VLQHvQVWUXFWXUDúLIXQF LRQDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL"
&DUHVXQWSDúLLvQLQWHUSUHWDUHDSURILOXOXLIDFWRULDO"
&XP GHILQHúWH &DWWHOO DQ[LHWDWHD FD IDFWRU VHFXQGDU vQ UDSRUW FX
QHYURWLVPXO"
([LVW RGLIHUHQ vQWUHPDQLIHVWDUHDIDFWRULORUVHFXQGDULvQSHUVR
QDOLWDWHODDGROHVFHQ ID GHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDPDWXU "
&DUHVXQWFHLFLQFLIDFWRULSULPDULLPSOLFD LvQFDOFXOXOQLYHOXOXLGH
DQ[LHWDWHSULQ&KHVWLRQDUXOÄ&´"
%LEOLRJUDILH
$$QDVWDVL3V\FKRORJLFDO7HVWLQJ0DFPLOODQ1<
%URQVRQ:&7KH5ROHRI(QGXULQJ2ULHQWDWLRQWRWKH(QYLURQPHQWLQ
3HUVRQDOLW\'HYHORSPHQW*HQHWLF3V\FKRORJ\0RQRJUDSKV
&DWWHOO5%3HUVRQDOLW\DQG0RWLYDWLRQ6WUXFWXUHDQG0HDVXUHPHQW
:RUOG%RRN&R1HZ<RUN
&DWWHOO5%0DQXHOSRXUO¶DSSOLFDWLRQGHO¶(FKHOOHG¶$Q[LHWp&3$
3DULV
&DWWHOO5%3HUVRQDOLW\DQG0RRGE\4XHVWLRQQDLUH-DVVH\%DVV6DQ
)UDQFLVFR
&DWWHOO5%&RDQ5:3HUVRQDOLW\)DFWRUVLQ0LGGOH&KLOGKRRGDV
5HYHDOHGLQ3DUHQWV5DWLQJVvQ&KLOG'HYHORSPHQW
&DWWHOO 5% (EHU +: 0DQXHO GµDSSOLFDWLRQ GX WHVW 3) (G
&3$3DULV
&DWWHOO5%*UXHQ:7KH3HUVRQDOLW\IDFWRU6WUXFWXUHRI\HDUROG
FKLOGUHQ LQ WHUPV RI %HKDYLRU 5DWLQJ 'DWD Ä-RXUQ 2I &OLQLFDO
3V\FKRORJ\´±
(\VHQFN +- (DVWLQJ * (\VHEFN 6% 3HUVRQDOLW\ 0HDVXUHPHQW LQ
&KLOGUHQ$'LPHQVLRQDO$SSURDFKÄ-RXUQRI6SHFLDO(GXFDWLRQ´
±
1LFROD*U,VWRULDSVLKRORJLHL(GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH
%XFXUHúWL
+3LWDULX3VLKRORJLDVHOHF LHLúLIRUP ULLSURIHVLRQDOH'DFLD&OXM1DSRFD
+3LWDULX0$OEX3VLKRORJLDSHUVRQDOXOXL0 VXUDUHDúLLQWHUSUHWDUHD
GLIHUHQ HORULQGLYLGXDOH(GLWXUD3UHVD8QLY&OXMHDQ &1
+RUURFNV-(7KH3V\FKRORJ\RI$GROHVFHQFH+RXJKWRQ0LIIOLQ&R
%RVWRQ
,QYHQWDUHPXOWLID]LFHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH,6(%XFXUHúWL
&URQEDFK /- 'UHQWK 3-' 0HQWDO 7HVWV DQG FXOWXUDO $GDSWDWLRQ
7KH+DJXH0RXWRQ
0LQXOHVFX 0 7HVWXO 313 7HVWXO 3V\KRUDWHU &RQVWUXLUHD úL LQWHU
SUHWDUHD WHVWXOXL &3, úL 3) vQ ,QYHQWDUHOH GH 3HUVRQDOLWDWH
,QVWLWXWXOGHùWLLQ HDOH(GXFD LHL
0LQXOHVFX00HWDSKRUVYV6LQJOH7HUPVLQ([SUHVVLQJDQG$VVHVLQJ
3HUVRQDOLW\vQÄ(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3V\FKRORJLFDO$VVHVVPHQW´Y
0LQXOHVFX0&KHVWLRQDUHOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHvQHYDOXDUHDSVLKRORJLF
*DUUHO%XFXUHúWL
0LQXOHVFX0(YDOXDUHDSVLKRORJLF vQVHOHF LDSURIHVLRQDO (GLWXUD
3DQ%XFXUHúWL
0 0LQXOHVFX 5HSOLFDUHD PRGHOXOXL %LJ )LYH vQ OLPED URPkQ
6SHFLILFXOVRFLRFXOWXUDOH[SULPDWvQFRQ LQXWXOIDFWRULORU&KHVWLRQDUXO
$%&'0vQ0=ODWH3VLKRORJLDYLH LLFRWLGLHQH3ROLURP,DúL
0LQXOHVFX 0 %D]HOH SVLKRGLDJQRVWLFXOXL (GLWXUD 8QLYHUVLW LL 7LWX
0DLRUHVFX%XFXUHúWL
0LQXOHVFX0,QWURGXFHUHvQDQDOL]DMXQJLDQ (GLWXUD7UHL%XFXUHúWL
00LQXOHVFX(YDOXDUHDWU V WXULORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDOHSDFLHQ LORU
vQ % /XEDQ3OR]]D úL ,% ,DPDQGHVFX 'LPHQVLXQHD SVLKRVRFLDO D
3UDFWLFLL0HGLFDOH(GLWXUD,QIR0HGLFD%XFXUHúWL
00LQXOHVFX 7HRULHúLSUDFWLF vQSVLKRGLDJQR] (GLWXUD)XQGD LHL
5RPkQLDGH0kLQH%XFXUHúWL
05RúFD0HWRGHGHSVLKRGLDJQRVWLF(GLWXUDGLGDFWLF úLSHGDJRJLF
%XFXUHúWL
1'6XQGEHUJ$VVHVVPHQWRISHUVRQV3UHQWLFH+DOO1HZ-HUVH\
2*-RKQVRQ7HVWVDQGPHDVXUHPHQWLQFKLOGGHYHORSPHQW9RO,úL
,,-RVVH\%DVV6DQ)UDQFLVFR
5 'UXPPRQG $SSUDLVDO SURFHGXUHV IRU FRXQVHORUV DQG KHOSLQJ
SURIHVVLRQDOV0HUULOO1<
50HLOL0DQXHOGHSV\FKRGLDJQRVWLTXH38)3DULV
6 5 +DWKDZD\ (' 0RQDFKHVL $GROHVFHQW 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG
%HKDYLRXU 0 0 3 , SDWWHUQV 7KH 8QLYHUVLW\ RI 0LQQHVRWD 3UHVV
0LQQHDSROLV
6FKDLH.:<HDUE\\HDUFKDQJHVLQ3HUVRQDOLW\IURPWR<HDUV
0XOWLYDULDWH%HKDYLRUDO5HVHDUFK,
6FKXOW] ' 7KHRULHV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ %URRNV DQG &RROH 3XEO &R
3DFLILF*URYH
6HDOO\ $3 &DWWHOO 5% $GROHVFHQW 3HUVRQDOLW\ 7UHQGV LQ 3ULPDU\
)DFWRUV 0HDVXUHG RQ WKH 3) DQG +634 4XHVWLRQQDLUHV Ä%ULWLVK
-RXUQ2I6RFLDODQG&OLQLFDO3V\FKRORJ\´
6WHUQEHUJ5-+XPDQ$ELOLWLHV$Q,QIRUPDWLRQ3URFHVVLQJ$SSURDFK
)UHHPDQDQG&R1HZ<RUN
8ùFKLRSX,QWURGXFHUHvQSVLKRGLDJQRVWLF8QLYHUVLWDWHD%XFXUHúWL
&DSLWROXO,9
&+(67,21$5(/('(7,3Ä%,*),9(´1(23,5$%&'±0
3UH]HQWDUHDFKHVWLRQDUHORUPRGHUQHFRQVWUXLWHFRQIRUPWHRULLORU
SVLKROLQJYLVWLFH GH WLS ÄFLQFL VXSHUIDFWRUL DL SHUVRQDOLW LL´ FXSULQGH
VWUDWHJLDGHFRQVWUXLUHSRUQLQGGHODVSHFLILFXOOLQJYLVWLFVHQVXOVXSHU
IDFWRULORUvQFRQWH[WXOLQWHUSUHW ULLVWUXFWXULLúLGLQDPLFLLSHUVRQDOLW LL
WHRULDOXL&RVWDúL0F&UDHFKHVWLRQDUXO1(23,5GDWHGHFHUFHWDUH
SULYLQGOHJ WXUDGLQWUH%LJ)LYHúLVXSHUIDFWRULLPRWLYD LRQDOLGDWHGH
FHUFHWDUHSULYLQGVHPQLILFD LDVXSHUIDFWRULORUSHUVRQDOLW LLvQUDSRUWFX
VLQGURDPHOH FOLQLFH DERUG UL VWUXFWXUDOH PRGHOH GH WLS FLUFXPSOH[
FHUFHW ULURPkQHúWLFKHVWLRQDUXO$%&'0FXHWDSHOHGHH[SHULPHQWDUH
úL IDFWRULL RE LQX L 6XQW SUH]HQWDWH XQHOH H[WLQGHUL DOH SUREOHPDWLFLL
FXUVXOXLFRQFHSWHOHFDUDFWHULVWLFHXQWHVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU
úLUHIHULQ HOHELEOLRJUDILFH
6WUDWHJLDGHFRQVWUXLUHSRUQLQGGHODVSHFLILFXOOLQJYLVWLF
ÌQ vQFHUFDUHD GH D VXUSULQGH DVSHFWHOH VWDELOH FDUH GHILQHVF
SHUVRQDOLWDWHD XPDQ VD FRQVWLWXLW WUHSWDW XQD GLQWUH LSRWH]HOH FHOH
PDL IUXFWXRDVH GLQ LVWRULD WHRULLORU GHVSUH SHUVRQDOLWDWH úL D HYDOX ULL
SVLKRORJLFHLSRWH]DOH[LFDO $FHDVWDSUHVXSXQHF ODQLYHOXOOLPED
MXOXL FXUHQW DX IRVW HQFRGDWH WRFPDL WU V WXULOH FHOH PDL SUHJQDQWH
FRQIRUPF URUDRDPHQLLVHHYDOXHD] XQLLSHFHLODO L$FHVWHWU V WXUL
VXELDFHQWH UHSUH]LQW ÄGLPHQVLXQL DOH GLIHUHQ HORU LQGLYLGXDOH FDUH
GHWHUPLQ DSDUL LD XQRU UHJXODULW L vQ JkQGLUH VLP LUH úL DF LXQH
FRQVLGHU 0F&UDHúL&&RVWD
(VWHSRVLELO RWD[RQRPLHDGHVFULSWRULORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHH[WUDV
GLQOLPEDMXOQDWXUDO"(VWHDFHDVW WD[RQRPLHFDUDFWHULVWLF XQXLVSD LX
FXOWXUDOVDXHVWHFHOSX LQFDVWUXFWXU vQOLQLLOHVDOHJHQHUDOHXQLYHUVDO "
3DUDGLJPD OH[LFDO D DERUG ULL OLQJYLVWLFH D GLPHQVLXQLORU GH
SHUVRQDOLWDWH DILUP F DQDOL]D GLF LRQDUXOXL OLPEDMXOXL QDWXUDO ± OH[L
FRQXOXQHLOLPEL±SRDWHRIHULRED] SHQWUXRWD[RQRPLHFXSULQ] WRDUH
DWU V WXULORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH1RUPDQOLPEDMXOQDWXUDOHVWHXQ
GHSR]LWDU DO GHVFULSWRULORU SRWHQ LDOL SHQWUX SHUVRQDOLWDWH *ROGEHUJ
LDUDFHOHGLIHUHQ HFDUHVXQWFHOHPDLVHPQLILFDWLYHvQWUDQ]DF LLOH
FRWLGLHQHGLQWUHRDPHQLHVWHSRVLELOV ILHHQFRGDWHvQOLPEDMXOORU
6HOHF LDWHUPHQLORUGLQGLF LRQDUHSXQHGRX WLSXULGHSUREOHPH
FXPVHIDFHRDVWIHOGHVHOHF LHFHWLSXULGHWHUPHQL±DGMHFWLYH
VXEVWDQWLYH YHUEH ± WUHEXLH LQFOXVH vQ LWHPLL GLQ FKHVWLRQDUHOH GH
SHUVRQDOLWDWHSHQWUXH[SHULPHQWDUH1XH[LVW GHIDSWYUHRGHILQL LHD
SHUVRQDOLW LL FDUH V JKLGH]H FHUFHW WRUXO vQ OHJ WXU FXDFHLWHUPHQL
FXYLQWHVLQJXODUHVDXH[SUHVLLFDUHDXFDOLWDWHDGHDILGHVFULSWRULDL
SHUVRQDOLW LL
0DMRULWDWHD VWXGLLORU úL HIRUWXULORU VLVWHPDWLFH VDX D[DW SH
DGMHFWLYHúLDXFRQGXVvQSULQFLSDOVSUHWHVWHVXEIRUPDXQRUVHWXULGH
DGMHFWLYH ELSRODUH 0HWRGD LQL LDO D SXV DFFHQWXO ILH SH FXQRúWLQ HOH
H[SHU LORU ILH SH FHOH DOH RDPHQLORU RELúQXL L ILH SH R vPELQDUH D
H[SHULHQ HLúWLLQ LILFHFXH[SHULHQ DFRPXQ $VWIHO/LVWDGHDGMHFWLYH
ED]DW SH HQJOH]D DPHULFDQ FRQVWUXLW GH *ROGEHUJ vQ D SXV
DFFHQWXOSHMXGHFDWDH[SHU LORUÌQFRQVWUXLUHDOLVWHLGHDGMHFWLYHRODQ
GH]H vQ GH F WUH %URNNHQ úL JHUPDQH GH F WUH $QJOHLWQHU úD
GHFL]LD ILQDO VD ED]DW SH RDPHQLL RELúQXL L ([SHU LL DX IRVW
XWLOL]D LSHQWUXDH[FOXGHLQL LDODQXPLWHFODVHGHDGMHFWLYHFDUHQXVH
UHIHU ODSHUVRQDOLWDWHúLODGLIHUHQ HOHLQWHULQGLYLGXDOH
,SRWH]D F DGMHFWLYHOH VXQW GHVFULSWRULL FHL PDL DGHFYD L úL
SUHIHUD LFkQGVHIDFGHVFULHULOLEHUHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLXQXLRP)LVNH
úL&R[+DPSVRQ/LYHVOH\úL%URPOH\DIRVWvQV
UHODWLYL]DW SULQ DOWH FHUFHW UL H[SHULPHQWDOH $VWIHO 'H 5DDG
FDUH GRDU vQ FD]XUL GLQWUXQ WRWDO GH VXELHF L FDUH WUHEXLDX V
GHVFULH OLEHU XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW SUREHD] IRORVLUHD DGMHFWLYHORU $VH
P Q WRU +RIVWHH GHVFRSHU F SHQWUX RODQGH] GRDU
GLQWUHDGMHFWLYHOHOLVWHLOXL%URNNHQIDFSDUWHGLQWUROLVW GHIUHFYHQ H
GH FXYLQWH VFULVH úL YRUELWH GLQWUH FDUH XQHOH QLFL P FDU QX
VXQW SUH]HQWDWH FD GHVFULSWRUL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH ÌQ YRUELUHD VSRQWDQ
DSDUQXDWkWDGMHFWLYHFkWPDLDOHVH[SUHVLLúLSURSR]L LL
)LHFDDOWHUQDWLY ILHFDVXSOLPHQWDUHDXIRVWOXDWHvQFRQVLGHUDUH
úLDOWHFODVHGHFXYLQWHFDSRWHQ LDOLGHVFULSWRULGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHSUHFXP
VXEVWDQWLYHOH *ROGEHUJ 'H 5DDG úL +RVNHQV úL YHUEHOH
'H5DDG0XOGHU.ORRVWHUPDQúL+RIVWHHFDUHSXQDFFHQWSH
FRPSRUWDPHQWVSUHGHRVHELUHGHDGMHFWLYHFDUHSXQDFFHQWSHGLVSR]L LH
$OW GLUHF LHvQFRQVWUXLUHDFKHVWLRQDUHORU%LJ)LYHHVWHFHDFDUH
SUHIHU SURSR]L LL%URPOH\6WXGLLFDDFHOHDDOHOXL$QJOHLWQHU
-RKQ úL /|KU DX UHDOL]DW WD[RQRPL]DUHD WLSXULORU SRVLELOH GH
UHOD LL vQWUH FRQ LQXWXO LWHPXOXL úL WU V WXUD GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH VDX
+RIVWHH FDUH GHPRQVWUHD] F VWUXFWXUD SURWRWLS D LWHPXOXL
XQXLFKHVWLRQDUHVWHRWU V WXU GHWLSFRQGL LRQDOGHFLRSUHGLVSR]L LH
GHDVHFRPSRUWDvQWUXQDQXPHIHOvQWURVLWXD LHVSHFLILFDW
&RQWURYHUVDPDMRU FRQWHPSRUDQ vQHYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLSUL
YHúWHGLIHUHQ LHUHDúLXWLOLWDWHDDERUG ULLGHWLSWU V WXULDOHSHUVRQDOLW LL
±FRQVLGHUDW GHPXO LFODVLF ±ID GHDERUGDUHDGHWLSFRPSRUWDPHQWDO
$FHDVW GLIHUHQ VHUHJ VHúWHúLvQGLIHUHQ LHUHDOLPEDMXOXLSHUVRQDOLW LL
([LVW DVWIHODGMHFWLYHDEVWUDFWHSULQFDUHVHGHVFULHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDID
GH SURSR]L LL FDUH IDF UHIHULUH OD FRPSRUWDPHQWH VSHFLILFH UHOHYDQWH
SHQWUXSHUVRQDOLWDWHVDXvQWHUPLQRORJLDOXL%XVúL&UDLNÄDF LXQL´
$VSHFWHOHFDUHUHVWUkQJXWLOLWDWHDDGMHFWLYHORUVXQWOLSVDGHVSH
FLILFLWDWH QLYHOXO vQDOW GH DEVWUDF LH FDUDFWHUXO LQIHUHQ LDO ID GH
REVHUYD LHDODWULEXLULLSUHFXPúLDSOLFDELOLWDWHDGLPLQXDW UHVSHFWLY
IXQF LRQDUHD ORU vQWUR UH HD VHPDQWLF GH WLS DVRFLDWLY FDUH REVFX
UL]HD] UHOD LLOHORUHPSLULFH%RUNHQDX1LVEHWWúL5RVV
3H GH DOW SDUWH SURSR]L LLOH GH WLS FRPSRUWDPHQWDO DX R JDP PDL
UHVWUkQV GH FXSULQGHUH JHQHUDOLWDWH úL QLYHOXO GH ILGHOLWDWH HVWH PDL
VF ]XW1LYHOXOULGLFDWGHVSHFLILFLWDWHSHQWUXFRPSRUWDPHQWHVWHDUJX
PHQWDW GH R VF ]XW DSOLFDELOLWDWH VSHFLILFLWDWHD VLWXD LRQDO vQ PRG
SDUDGR[DOOHSRDWHIDFHQHIDPLOLDUHXQRUDGLQWUHVXELHF L
ÌQSODQWHRUHWLFVHIDFHGLVWLQF LDvQWUHVSHFLILFLWDWHDFRPSRU
WDPHQWDO GLIHUHQ LLQGXVH GHVFULSWRULL vQ DEVWUDF L QHVSHFLILFL úL
FRQFUH L VSHFLILFL úL VSHFLILFLWDWHD VLWXD LRQDO GLIHUHQ LLQG vQWUH
LWHPL FDUH VH UHIHU OD FRPSRUWDPHQWH VSHFLILFH SHQWUX R VLWXD LH
DQXPH FRQGL LRQDOL ID GH FHL FDUH QX VXQW VHQVLELOL OD VSHFLILFXO
VLWXD LRQDOQHFRQGL LRQDOL
2vQFHUFDUHGHDFODVLILFDOLPEDMXOSHUVRQDOLW LLSULQLQWHUPHGLXO
VSHFLILFLW LLFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHúLDOVSHFLILFLW LLVLWXD LRQDOHDFRQGXV
SH'H5DDG0XOGHU.ORRVWHUPDQúL+RIVWHHODDJ VLWLSXUL
GHLWHPLSRVLELOLSHQWUXLQVWUXPHQWHOHGHWLS%LJ)LYH
DGMHFWLYHVLQJXODUHGHH[HPSOXÄH[WUDYHUW´ÄVWDELO´ÄFRQú
WLHQW´ HWF FDUH VXQW VLPXOWDQ DEVWUDFWH úL QHFRQGL LRQDOH YHUEH
VLQJXODUHGHH[HPSOXÄVHEkOEkLH´ÄURúHúWH´ÄLQVXOW ´HWFFDUHVXQW
VSHFLILFHVDXFRQFUHWHGLQSXQFWGHYHGHUHFRPSRUWDPHQWDOGDUU PkQ
QHFRQGL LRQDOH SURSR]L LL DGMHFWLYDOH GH H[HPSOX ÄHVWH GHVFKLV
FkQG VH DIO vQ SUH]HQ D DOWRUD´ FDUH QX DX VSHFLILFLWDWH FRPSRUWD
PHQWDO GDU DX VSHFLILFLWDWH VLWXD LRQDO SURSR]L LL FX FHQWUXO GH
JUHXWDWHSHVHQVXOYHUEXOXLGHH[HPSOXÄVHEkOEkLHFkQGHVWHvQSUH
]HQ DXQHLSHUVRDQHGHVH[RSXV´FDUHDXSULQIRUPXODUHVSHFLILFLWDWH
FRPSRUWDPHQWDO úLVSHFLILFLWDWHVLWXD LRQDO 'DF SURSR]L LLOHGHWLS
DGMHFWLYDO DX IRVW XWLOL]DWH PXOW vQ FKHVWLRQDUHOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH
XOWLPD FDWHJRULH D SURSR]L LLORU FHQWUDWH SH YHUE D IRVW PDL SX LQ
VWXGLDW úLHVWHPDLSX LQH[WLQV vQSUDFWLFDFKHVWLRQDUHORU
'H IDSW vQ SUDFWLF QX D DYXW ORF R SURSULX]LV LQWHUIHUHQ VDX
RSR]L LHvQWUHFHOHGRX GLUHF LLFLPDLGHJUDE RÄGLYL]LXQHDPXQFLL´
GXS H[SUHVLD OXL +RIVWHH vQ VHQVXO F PDL DOHV FHUFHW ULOH
WHRUHWLFH VDX VHUYLW GH DGMHFWLYH vQ WLPS FH vQ SODQ DSOLFDWLY VDX
SUHIHUDW SURSR]L LLOH vQ FRQVWUXLUHD FKHVWLRQDUHORU FDUH V VWXGLH]H
SHUVRDQHUHDOH&HOGLQXUP DVSHFWVHFRQMXJ úLFXFRQVLGHUHQWXOGHD
QXOHFHUHVXELHF LORUV IDF MXGHF LDEVWUDFWH
3URFHGXUDGHVHOHF LHOH[LFDO LQFOXGHPDLPXOWHHWDSH6XUVHOHGH
RE LQHUH D GHVFULSWRULORU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH VXQW OH[LFRDQH DOH OLPELL VDX
GLF LRQDUHELOLQJYH&ULWHULLOHGHVHOHF LHVXQWDSOLFDWHSHUkQGSHQWUXD
UHGXFHPXO LPHDGHVXWHGHPLLGHFXYLQWHODXQQXP UGHFXYLQWHDG
MHFWLYHYHUEHVXEVWDQWLYHFDUHV ILHDWkWvQDOWVSHFLILFHSHQWUXGHVFUL
HUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLFkWúLODUJFXQRVFXWHYRUELWRULORUOLPELLUHVSHFWLYH
&ULWHULLGHVHOHF LH
8Q SULP FULWHULX SHQWUX VHOHF LD GLQ OH[LFRQ HVWH SRWHQ LDOXO FD
GHVFULSWRUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH'HRELFHLVHOXFUHD] FXRHFKLS GHGRL
H[SHU L FDUH VFDQHD] LQGHSHQGHQWDFHODúLOH[LFRQ'HUHJXO VHVFRW
vQMXUGHGLQWUHWHUPHQLLGLQFDWHJRULDDYXW vQYHGHUH
$FHDVW SULP OLVW HVWH VXSXV VHOHF LHL SULQ SULVPD FULWHULXOXL
XWLOL] ULLvQOLPEDMXO]LOQLFUHDOL]DWGHRDOW HFKLS GHGRLSDWUXH[SHU L
5HGXFHUHD FRQWLQX SULQ DSOLFDUHD XQHL HYDOX UL vQ IXQF LH GH
GRX FULWHULLGHVFULSWLYH±FULWHULXOÄQDWXU ´úLFULWHULXOÄSHUVRDQ ´
GH]YROWDWHGH%URNNHQ&ULWHULXOQDWXU FRQ LQHLQVWUXF LXQHDGH
DLQGLFDGDF DGMHFWLYXOVHSRWULYHúWHXQHLSURSR]L LLGHIRUPDÄ(OHD
HVWH « GH OD QDWXU ´ FULWHULXO SHUVRDQ FRQ LQH LQVWUXF LXQHD GH D
LQGLFDGDF DGMHFWLYXOSRDWHILIRORVLWSHQWUXDU VSXQGHODRvQWUHEDUH
GHIRUPDÄ&HIHOGHSHUVRDQ HVWHGRPQXOGRDPQD;"´
ÌQ DFHVW PRPHQW QXP UXO GH SHUVRDQH FDUH HYDOXHD] LQGH
SHQGHQW OLVWD GH DGMHFWLYH SH ED]D FHORU GRX FULWHULL HVWH PXOW PDL
PDUH ± vQWUH úL 6H YRU UH LQH vQ DFHDVW HWDS QXPDL DFHOH
DGMHFWLYH FDUH DX IRVW HYDOXDWH GH FHO SX LQ GLQWUH HYDOXDWRUL FD
GHVFULSWLYHSHQWUXSHUVRQDOLWDWH
(WDSDXUP WRDUHUHDOL]HD] RHYDOXDUHSHED]DFULWHULXOXLÄIXQ
GDPHQWDOLW LL´ P VXUD vQ FDUH XQ DGMHFWLY HVWH FRQVLGHUDW ÄIXQGD
PHQWDO´ YV ÄVXSHUILFLDO´ 'LQ QRX QXP UXO GH HYDOXDWRUL HVWH PDUH
vQWUHúL
/LVWD GH DGMHFWLYH FRQVWUXLW GH %URNNHQ D FXSULQV vQ HWDSD GH
H[SHULPHQWDUH XQ QXP U GH LWHPL FDUH DX IRVW GD L SHQWUX
DXWRHYDOXDUH úL KHWHURHYDOXDUH HYDOXDUHD XQHL DOWH SHUVRDQH FRQ
VWLWXLQGHúDQWLRQXOGHED] SHQWUXWHVWXOUHVSHFWLY
$OWHFHUFHW ULDXVLP LWQHYRLDV UHGXF úLPDLPXOWQXP UXOGH
DGMHFWLYHúLDXFRQWLQXDWSULQDSOLFDUHDXQXLFULWHULXFRPSR]LWVHOHFWDUHD
WUHLPLL VXSHULRDUH SHQWUX VFRUXULOH vQVXPDWH DOH FULWHULLORU QDWXU úL
SHUVRDQ 'H5DDGúD&DOFXOkQGSHQWUXILHFDUHGLQWUHVFRUXULOH
ODFULWHULLOHQDWXU SHUVRDQ úLIXQGDPHQWDOLWDWHQLYHOXO6VXSHULRU0
PHGLXúL6EVODEvQFDUH0UHSUH]LQW LQWHUYDOGHvQFUHGHUHvQ
MXUXO FHQWUXOXL VFDOHL 'H 5DDG RSHUHD] vQF R UHGXFHUH UH L
QkQGGRDUDGMHFWLYHOHSHQWUXWRDWHWUHLFULWHULLOHFXQLYHOXOGHvQFUHGHUH
6 VDX FHO SX LQ GRX QLYHOH 6 úL XQXO 0 5HGXFHUHD SHQWUX YHUEH úL
VXEVWDQWLYHGHRELFHLPDLSX LQQXPHURDVHGHFkWDGMHFWLYHOHDMXQJHOD
XQQXP UUH]RQDELO±vQMXUGH±GXS SULPHOHGRX VDXWUHLHWDSH
$FHVWHD DX IRVW OLVWHOH FDUH DX LQWUDW vQ H[SHULPHQWDUH $X IRVW
DSOLFDWHSHXQQXP UUHODWLYPLFGHVXELHF L8QLLFHUFHW WRULDXIRORVLW
QXPDL SURFHGHXO DXWRHYDOX ULORU DO LL DX IRORVLW úL KHWHURHYDOX UL
5H]XOWDWHOHDFHVWRUVXELHF LDXLQWUDWvQFDOFXOHOHVWDWLVWLFHLPSOLFDWHGH
DQDOL]DIDFWRULDO 8QLLFHUFHW WRULSUHIHU V OXFUH]HGXS FHDXVXSXV
GDWHOH EUXWH XQHL SURFHGXUL QXPLWH LSVDWL]DUH PHQLW D QHXWUDOL]D
XQHOH GLQWUH LGLRVLQFUDVLLOH FDUH DSDU OD IRORVLUHD HYDOX ULORU GH WLS
/LFNHUW ,SVDWL]DUHD vQVHDPQ R VWDQGDUGL]DUH SH VXELHFW GHD OXQJXO
WXWXURUWHUPHQLORU2VWHQGRUI
$O L FHUFHW WRUL DFX] SURFHGXUD LSVDWL] ULL GH IDSWXO F VXSXQH
U VSXQVXULOH XQHL UHODWLYH DUWLILFLDOL] UL SULQ HIHFWHOH LQHUHQWH ÄWHQ
GLQ HLFHQWUDOH´DQXPHHOLPLQDUHDIRU DW DU VSXQVXULORUH[WUHPHVDX
QHRELúQXLWH FDUH DX úL HOH R VHPQLILFD LH HPSLULF VHPQLILFD LH FDUH
DVWIHOVHSLHUGH
ÌQDIDUDFHUFHW ULORUúLPHWRGRORJLHLHFKLSHLRODQGH]HVDXUHDOL]DW
VWXGLL OLQJYLVWLFH SHQWUX HYLGHQ LHUHD QXP UXOXL GH IDFWRUL vQ HQJOH]D
DPHULFDQ *ROGEHUJ -RKQ &RVWD úL 0F&UDH
:LJJLQV vQ JHUPDQ $QJOHLWQHU 2VWHQGRUI -RKQ vQ
LWDOLDQ &DSUDUD3HUXJLQL'L%ODV)RU]L3HUXJLQL/HRQH
*DOOXFL /DXULROD &DSUDUD %DUEDUDQHOOL %RUJRJQL 3HUXJLQL
vQ IUDQFH] 0DUYLHOGH PDJKLDU 'H 5DDG 6PLV]HN
FURDW 0ODFLF.QH]RYLFD¶DUDOLPE YRUELW vQ,QVXOHOH
6RORPRQ úL RULVVD OLPE YRUELW vQ ,QGLD :KLWH GLDOHFWH
MDSRQH]H %RQG %RQG )RUJDV ILOLSLQH] &KXUFK
.DWLJEDNURPkQ 0LQXOHVFX7RDWHDXHYLGHQ LDW
VROX LL IDFWRULDOH RSWLPH GH FLQFL VXSHUIDFWRUL GHúL QX WRDWH DX IRORVLW
PHWRGRORJLD VWDQGDUG GH VHOHF LH (YLGHQW VROX LLOH IDFWRULDOH SUH]LQW
GLIHUHQ LHULPDLDOHVvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHRUGLQHDVHPQLILFD LHLXWLOLWDWHD
IDFWRULORU SHQWUX YDULDQ D FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL YRUELWRULORU GLYHUVHORU
OLPEL GDU úL vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH FRPSR]L LD LQWUDIDFWRULDO ID HWHOH úL
VHPQLILFD LDORU
$O LDXWRULSUHFXPDPHULFDQLL&RVWDúL0F&UDHVDX-RKQ
DX XWLOL]DW vQ VWXGLLOH PHQLWH V FRQGXF OD LQVWUXPHQWH SHQWUX
P VXUDUHDFHORUFLQFLVXSHUIDFWRULGHSR]LWXOGHGDWHRIHULWGHFRQ LQXWXULOH
XQRU WHVWH DQWHULRDUH'HH[HPSOX&RVWDúL0F&UDHXWLOL]HD] 6FDOHOH
%LJ)LYHGHGHDGMHFWLYHELSRODUHDOHOXL*ROGEHUJFRPELQkQGXOHFX
XQVHWVXSOLPHQWDUGHDOWHGHVFDOHGHDGMHFWLYHÌQFRPELQD LHFXR
YHUVLXQHWLPSXULHDWHVWXOXL1(2FDUHDYHDGRDUWUHLVFDOHSHQWUXQH
YURWLVPH[WUDYHUVLHúLGHVFKLGHUHDFHVWHDVXQWDGPLQLVWUDWHVXELHF LORU
5H]XOWDWHOH DQDOL]DWH IDFWRULDO FRQGXF VSUH PRGHOXO GH FLQFL PDUL
VXSHUIDFWRUL0F&UDHIDFWRULFDUHDVWIHOSRWILP VXUD LSULQWUXQ
IRUPDW PDL WUDGL LRQDO GHFkW OLVWHOH GH WHUPHQL 6WXGLXO UHDOL]DW vQ
FRQWLQXDUHGHFHLGRLDPHULFDQLDLQWURGXVvQFKHVWLRQDUXO1(23,GRX
QRL VFDOH DJUHDELOLWDWHD úL FRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWHD DVWIHO vQFkW vQFHSkQG GLQ
LQVWUXPHQWXO HUD FRPSOHW úL FRQVLGHUDW FD VXUV SULPDU SHQWUX
RE LQHUHDFHORUFLQFLIDFWRUL6WXGLLOHH[SHULPHQWDOHDXXUP ULWvQFRQWL
QXDUH GHOLPLWDUHD HPSLULF D ID HWHORU IDFWRULORU úL YDOLGDUHD HPSLULF
XWLOL]kQG vQ SDUDOHO DOWH FKHVWLRQDUH 003, 0%7, (3, 35) ±
3HUVRQDOLW\ 5HVHDUFK )RUP *=76 :LJJLQ¶V ,QWHUSHUVRQDO $GMHFWLYH
6FDOHV %ORFN¶V &DOLIRUQLD 46HW $&/ ± *RXJK+HLOEUXQ $GMHFWLYH
&KHFN/LVW
6HQVXOVXSHUIDFWRULORUvQFRQWH[WXOLQWHUSUHW ULLVWUXFWXULL
úLGLQDPLFLLSHUVRQDOLW LLWHRULDOXL&RVWDúL0F&UDH
&D]XOFHORUGRLDXWRULDPHULFDQLUHSUH]LQW RQRW DSDUWHvQUkQGXO
FHUFHW WRULORUúLFUHDWRULORUGHLQVWUXPHQWHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHGHWLSXO%LJ
)LYH&HLGRLDXIRVWúLVXQWSUHRFXSD LQXQXPDLGHDFHUFHWDFLúLPDL
DOHVGHDFRQVWUXLYDOLGDúLvQWHPHLDúWLLQ LILFLQWHUSUHWDUHDXQXLLQVWUX
PHQWSVLKRGLDJQRVWLFFkWPDLFRPSOHW'LQFkQGODQVHD] SULPD
YDULDQW DLQYHQWDUXOXLGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH1(2FHUFHW ULOHORUVDXIRFD
OL]DWSHGHVFRSHULUHDúLYDOLGDUHDID HWHORUIDFWRULDOHDOHFHORUFLQFLPDUL
IDFWRULúLGHDVHPHQHDSHFRQVWUXLUHDXQXLPRGHOLQWHUSUHWDWLYFDUHV
MXVWLILFHIDSWXOF WU V WXULOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHVXQWIDFWRULGHWHUPLQDWLYL
GHFLH[SOLFDWLYLSHQWUXFRPSRUWDPHQW
$FHVW PRGHO D IRVW SUH]HQWDW SHQWUX SULPD GDW vQ LXOLH OD
0DGULGODD9,,D&RQIHULQ (XURSHDQ GH3VLKRORJLHD3HUVRQDOLW LL
ÌQ DUWLFXOD LLOH DFHVWXL ÄPRGHO DO SHUVRDQHL´ VDX DP SXWHD VSXQH DO
QDWXULLXPDQHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDDSDUHFDXQDGLQWUHVXEGLYL]LXQLOHIXQGD
PHQWDOHDO WXULGHDELOLW LOHFRJQLWLYHúLGHFHOHIL]LFHSUHFXPúLGHDOWH
DVSHFWHFDUHLQWU vQDOF WXLUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLFDÄPDWHULDO´EUXW8UP
ULQGXOH SXWHP vQ HOHJH FH úL FXP DERUG P GLQ FRPSOH[XO GH IDSWH
SVLKLFHSULQFKHVWLRQDUHOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
ÌQ DFHDVW FRQFHS LH SVLKRGLDJQR]D QX DERUGHD] GLUHFW DFHVWH
WHQGLQ HED]DOHvQP VXUDvQFDUHHOHQXVXQWGLUHFWREVHUYDELOHúLIXQF
LRQHD] FD úL FRQVWUXFWH LSRWHWLFH &HHD FH LQWHUHVHD] SVLKRORJXO QX
HVWHDWkWDQDOL]DGHILQH HDSURFHVHORUGHWUDQVIRUPDUHFDUHVHSHWUHFRUL
VDXSHWUHFXWvQGHFXUVXOGH]YROW ULLLQGLYLGXOXLúLFDUHDXGXVODFHHDFH
FXQRDúWHP DLFL úL DFXP SULQ LQVWUXPHQWHOH GH P VXUDUH FL FHHD FH
DXWRULL QXPHVF DGDSW ULOH VSHFLILFH UHVSHFWLY IHOXO FXP DX IRVW PR
GHODWHWHQGLQ HOHGHED] SULQLQIOXHQ HOHH[WHUQHúLLQIOXHQ HOHLQWHUQH
([SOLFD LLOH FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL SUH]HQW QX DX QHYRLH GH VSHFLIL
FDUHDPHFDQLVPHORUFDX]DOHGHúLHLUHFXQRVFF HVWHXWLOXQHRULV FDX L
úLV UHXúHúWLV VSHFLILFLDFHVWHSURFHVHLQWHUPHGLDUHÄvQVSHFLDOSHQWUX
F DVWIHO GH SURFHVH SRW RIHUL SRVLELOLW L GH LQWHUYHQ LH´ 0F&UDH
&RVWD 3VLKRORJXO QX SRDWH VFKLPED WU V WXULOH GH ED] DOH
VXELHFWXOXL VDX SDFLHQWXOXL GDU H[SOLFDUHD VDX FXQRDúWHUHD FRUHFW D
DFHVWRUDúLDIHOXOXLFXPHOHLQWHUYLQvQSUREOHPHOHH[LVWHQ LDOHDOHSHU
VRDQHLvOSRDWHDMXWDV UHGXF ODXQPLQLPGLILFXOW LOHúLLQFRQJUXHQ HOH
ÌQ DFHVW PRGHOFDGUX H[SOLFDWLY H[SOLFD LLOH WUHEXLH F XWDWH OD
GLIHULWH QLYHOH úL DQXPH SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO DúDQXPLWHORU SURFHVH GH
LQWHUPHGLHUH QLYHOHFDUHDSDUH[SOLFLWDWHvQILJXUD
%,2*5$),(2%,(&7,9
%$=(%,2/2*,&(
UHDF LLHPR LRQDOH
VFKLPE ULVHPQLILFDWLYH
$'$37 5, ,1)/8(1 (
7(1',1 (%$=$/( &$5$&7(5,67,&( (;7(51(
QHYURWLVPH[WUDYHUVLH VFRSXULSHUVRQDOH QRUPHFXOWXUDOH
GHVFKLGHUHDJUHDELOLWDWH DWLWXGLQL HYHQLPHQWH
FRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWH vQW ULUL
,6
,0$*,1('(6,1(
VFKHPHDOHHXOXL
PLWXULSHUVRQDOH
)$&7258/,([WUDYHUVLH,QWURYHUVLH
(;75$9(56,(
$FWLYLVP 2SWLPLVP 8PRU $ELOLWDWH $ILUPDUHSHUVRQDO
LQWHUSHUVRQDO FDXW VXFFHVXO
( ( ( ( (
3DVLYLWDWH 3HVLPLVP /LSV XPRU ) U DELOLW L 'H]LQWHUHV
VRFLDOH SHQWUXDILUPDUH
,17529(56,(
)$&7258/,,0DWXULWDWHDGDSWDUHYV,PDWXULWDWHSVLKRSDWLH
0$785,7$7($'$37$5(1250$/
ÌQFUHGHUH $GDSWDWLY 3ULHWHQRV )RU D )RU DHXOXL
vQFHLODO L FRQVHUYDWRU LQKLEL LHL
0 0 0 0 0
0DQLSXODWLY 5HEHO 'HVSRWLVP ([FLWDELO (JRFHQWULVP
RVWLO LULWDELO
36,+23$7,(,0$785,7$7($*5(6,9,7$7(
)$&7258/,,,$JUHDELOLWDWHYV/LSVDDJUHDELOLW LL
$*5($%,/,7$7(
$OWUXLVP 5RPDQWLVP & OGXU (PSDWLH 2QHVWLWDWH
VHQWLPHQWDOLVP DIHFWLY FRUHFWLWXGLQH
$ $ $ $ $
(JRLVP ,QVHQVLELOLWDWH 5 FHDO /LSVDHPSDWLHL /LSVD
DIHFWLY RQHVWLW LL
/,36$$*5($%,/,7 ,,
)$&7258/,9&RQúWLLQFLR]LWDWHYV/LSV GHRUGLQH
&21ù7,,1&,2=,7$7(
9RLQ 6SLULWGH 5D LRQDO 3ODQLILFDUH &RQWURO
SHUVHYHUHQ SHUIHF LRQDUH RELHFWLY HPR LRQDO
& & & & &
/LSVD 6XSHUILFLDO 6XELHFWLY 5LVLSLWRU 1HOLQLúWH
PRELOL] ULL DQ[LHWDWH
/,36$25',1,,
)$&7258/9$FWXDOL]DUHYV6WDJQDUH
$&78$/,=$5($7,78',1(ù,027,9$ ,,*(1(5$7,9(
$SURIXQGDUH 7ROHUDQ 5DILQDUH ,QGHSHQGHQ &UHDWLYLWDWH
GHVFKLGHUH SHUVRQDO IOH[LELOLWDWH
$F $F $F $F $F
3ODWLWXGLQH ,QWHUSUHWDWLY 5XGLPHQWDU 'HSHQGHQW 1RQFUHDWLY
LQWHOHFWXDO ULJLG
67$*1$5(121(92/87,9
$SOLFDUH 6H DSOLF LQGLYLGXDO VDX FROHFWLY ILHFDUH VXELHFW
DYkQG OD GLVSR]L LH &KHVWLRQDUXO FX LWHPLL úL IRDLD GH U VSXQV &KHV
WLRQDUXOFXSULQGHGHLWHPL6HDSOLF JULOHOHúLVHFRQYHUWHVFQRWHOH
EUXWHvQQRWHVWDQGDUGFRQIRUPHWDORQ ULLvQQRWHVWDQGDUG
,QWHUSUHWDUH ,QWHUSUHWDUHD VH UHDOL]HD] FRQIRUP XQRU SURILOH
VH SRUQHúWH GH OD VHPQLILFD LD FDOLWDWLY D IDFWRUXOXL SULQFLSDO úL VH
WUHFH DSRL OD GHOLPLWDUHD ID HWHORU úL D VHPQLILFD LHL ORU vQ FRQWH[WXO
IDFWRUXOXL UHVSHFWLY 6H LQWHJUHD] vQ ILQDO LQWHUSUHW ULOH UHDOL]DWH
SHQWUX ILHFDUH GLQWUH FHL FLQFL IDFWRUL vQWUR LPDJLQH XQLWDU GHVSUH
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOSHUVRDQHL
([HPSOLILFDUHSURILO1(23,5
6XELHFW DQL
1RWHOH7SHQWUXIDFWRULLPDUL
1(2$&
1RWHOH7ODVXEIDFWRUL
111111
((((((
222222
$$$$$$
&&&&&&
1HYURWLVP PHGLX ([WUDYHUVLH PHGLH VSUH LQWURYHUVLH 'HVFKL
GHUHSHVWHPHGLH$JUHDELOLWDWHVXEPHGLH&RQúWLLQFLR]LWDWHPHGLH
(VWH vQ JHQHUDO R SHUVRDQ HFKLOLEUDW 1X SUH]LQW VW UL GH
WHDP MHQ IULF 1 DQ[LHWDWH VDX VHQWLPHQWH GH LQXWLOLWDWH 1
1XDUHVHQWLPHQWHGHLQIHULRULWDWH1(VWHFHYDPDLLPSXOVLY 1
GHúLUH]LVW QRUPDOODIUXVWU UL1
1X FDXW vQ PRG VSHFLDO UHOD LD FX VHPHQLL PDL GHJUDE DUH
WHQGLQ DGHDILUH]HUYDW ((HVWHvQV RSHUVRDQ F UHLDvLSODFH
V VHDILUPH(úLSUH]LQW VHQWLPHQWHSR]LWLYHGHvPSOLQLUHRSWLPLVP
VWDUHGHELQH
,PDJLQD LHERJDW 2FXSHULFROXOVXELDFHQWGHDIXJLGHUHDOL
WDWHD FD DWDUH ÌL SODFH IUXPRVXO úL DGPLU YDORULOH HVWHWLFH 2 HVWH
GHVFKLV VSUH LGHL QHFRQYHQ LRQDOH 2 GDU XQ LQWHUHV VF ]XW SHQWUX
DF LXQLQRL2HVWHGHVFKLV VSUHYDORULGLIHULWHGHDOHVDOH
$UH vQFUHGHUH vQ RDPHQLL GLQ MXUXO HL $ GDU QXúL H[SULP
GLUHFWVHQWLPHQWHOH$(JHQHURDV vLDMXW SHFHLGLQMXUúLúWLHV
FRRSHUH]HFkQGDSDUFRQIOLFWHOH$3DUHvQV GLVWDQW úLQXHVWHGLUHFW
DJUHDELO vQP VXUDvQFDUHHYLW LQWURYHUVLHUHOD LDFXVHPHQLL
(VWH RUJDQL]DW FDSDELO úL HILFLHQW vQ PXQF & & úL &
UH]ROY FHHDFHvúLSURSXQHGHúLQXVHFRQIRUPHD] VWULFWSURJUDPXOXL
&(VWHRSHUVRDQ FDSDELO V LDGHFL]LL
(;7,1'(5,
,QVWUXPHQWHGHWLS%LJ)LYH
ÌQ SODQXO LQVWUXPHQWHORU SURSULX]LVH VH OXFUHD] ILH FX WHVWH
VWUXFWXUDWH vQ ILHFDUH OLPE ILH IRORVLQG WUDGXFHUL DFUHGLWDWH H[SHUL
PHQWDWHúLDQDOL]DWHIDFWRULDO
&DIRUP DFHVWHLQVWUXPHQWHVXQWGHGRX WLSXULOLVWHGHDGMHF
WLYHúLFKHVWLRQDUHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH'LQWUHFHOHPDLVWXGLDWHHPSLULFúL
XWLOL]DWHOLVWHGHDGMHFWLYHPHQ LRQ P
x %56%LSRODU5DWLQJ6FDOHVUHVSHFWLYOLVWDGHDGMHFWLYH
*ROGEHUJ FDUH FRQ LQH DGMHFWLYH vQ VFDOH ELSRODUH
UHSUH]LQW PDUF UL VWDQGDUG SHQWUX VWUXFWXUD IDFWRULDO %LJ
)LYHúLFRQVW GLQVFDOHGHHYDOXDUHvQQRX SXQFWHSHQ
WUXILHFDUHGLQWUHFHLFLQFLVXSHUIDFWRUL
x ,$65,QWHUSHUVRQDO$GMHFWLYH6FDOHV±5HYLVHGFRQVWUXLW
GH:LJJLQV
x %$56%LSRODU$GMHFWLYH5DWLQJ6FDOHVFDUHFXSULQGH
GHDGMHFWLYHELSRODUHRUJDQL]DWHvQVFDOH
x 6$&%,) 6KRUW $GMHFWLYH &KHFNOLVW %LJ )LYH XQ FKHFNOLVW
FDUHFXSULQGHGHDGMHFWLYHELSRODUHSHQWUXFHOHFLQFLVFDOH
UHDOL]DWGH3HUXJLQL/HRQH*DOOXFL/DXULROD
&KHVWLRQDUHOHFHOHPDLH[SHULPHQWDWHúLFXQRVFXWHVXQW
x 1(2 3, 5 1(2 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\ 5HYLVHG &RVWD
0F&UDH
x 334 3URIHVVLRQDO 3HUVRQDOLW\ 4XHVWLRQQDLUH .OLQH
/DSKDP
x =.34,,, =XFNHUPDQ.XKOPDQ 3HUVRQDOLW\,QYHQWRU\IRU
PDD,,,D
x %)4 %LJ )DFWRU 4XHVWLRQQDLUH &DSUDUD %DUEDUDQHOOL
%RUJRJQL3HUXJLQL
x ))3,+HQGULFNV+RVIWHH'H5DDG
ÌQ2VWHQGRUIúL$QJOHLWQHUUHDOL]HD] XQVWXGLXFRPSDUDWLY
SHGLIHULWHLQVWUXPHQWHFDUHvúLSURSXQV P VRDUHFHLFLQFLVXSHUIDFWRUL
1(2 3, 5 334 =.34,,, $XWRULL DQDOL]HD] FDSDFLWDWHD VFDOHORU
DFHVWRUWUHLFKHVWLRQDUHGHDHYLGHQ LDFHLFLQFLVXSHUIDFWRULOXFUkQGFX
R OLVW GH DGMHFWLYH GHFL XQ LQVWUXPHQW GHULYDW GLUHFW GLQWUXQ VWXGLX
OH[LFDO%$56VFRUXULIDFWRULDOHGHULYDWHGLQVFDOHGHHYDOXDUHFX
GHDGMHFWLYHELSRODUH
'DWHOHUHOHY SHQWUX1(23,5FDSDFLWDWHDFHDPDLYHULGLF GHD
RE LQH GDWH SHQWUX P VXUDUHD FHORU FLQFL VXSHUIDFWRUL &HOHODOWH GRX
FKHVWLRQDUH334úL=.34,,,SUH]LQW vQF UF WXULIDFWRULDOHPDLSX LQ
FODUHVFDOHOHUHVSHFWLYHILLQGSXWHUQLFvQF UFDWHSHQWUXPDLPXO LIDFWRUL
VLPXOWDQ VDX QX DX QLFL R vQF UF WXU IDFWRULDO FODU SHQWUX YUHXQXO
GLQWUHFHLFLQFL$VWIHOGHH[HPSOXQLFLXQDGLQWUHFHOHFLQFLVFDOHDOH
WHVWXOXL 334 LQVHFXULWDWH EOkQGH H LQWURYHUVLH FRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWH FRQ
YHQ LRQDOLVP QX SUH]LQW R vQF UF WXU VHPQLILFDWLY SHQWUX IDFWRUXO
QHYURWLVPVFDOHOHLQVHFXULWDWHLQWURYHUVLHFRQYHQ LRQDOLWDWHFRQWULEXLH
WRDWHVHPQLILFDWLYODIDFWRUXOGHVFKLGHUHÄLQWHOHFWXDO´VFDOHOHEOkQGH H
úL LQWURYHUVLH FRQWULEXLH VHPQLILFDWLY OD IDFWRUXO DJUHDELOLWDWH 6LWXD LD
HVWHDVHP Q WRDUHSHQWUX=.34,,,XQGHQLFLXQDGLQWUHFHOHFLQFLVFDOH
DOH WHVWXOXL LPSXOVLYLWDWH QHYURWLVP DQ[LHWDWH DJUHVLYLWDWHRVWLOLWDWH
DFWLYLVP úL VRFLDELOLWDWH QX FRQWULEXLH OD IDFWRUXO LQWHOHFWXDO GHV
FKLGHUH GH DVHPHQHD VFDOHOH LPSXOVLYLWDWH úL VRFLDELOLWDWH FRQWULEXLH
VHPQLILFDWLYSHQWUXIDFWRUXOH[WUDYHUVLHLDUVFDOHOHLPSXOVLYLWDWHúLDFWL
YLVPFRQWULEXLHVHPQLILFDWLYODIDFWRUXOFRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWH
8OWLPD FHUFHWDUH HXURSHDQ HIHFWXDW GH +HQGULNV +RIVWHH 'H
5DDG úL $QJOHLWQHU D FRQGXV GLQ OD LQVWUXPHQWXO ))3, )LYH
)DFWRU3HUVRQDOLW\,QYHQWRU\,QYHQWDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDOFHORUFLQFL
PDULIDFWRULvQWUHLYHUVLXQLVWDQGDUGL]DWHRODQGH] HQJOH] úLJHUPDQ
))3,HVWHXQFKHVWLRQDUFRQVWLWXLWLWHUDWLYvQHQJOH] RODQGH]
úL JHUPDQ GLQ GH SURSR]L LL VFXUWH FRQFUHWH FDUH SRDWH IL
DGPLQLVWUDWvQ±PLQXWHÌQDIDU GHVFRUXULOHSHFHLIDFWRUL
FKHVWLRQDUXOSRDWHILIRORVLWSHQWUXDVHFDOFXODVFRUXULOHSHFHOH
GH ID HWH ELSRODUH FDUH DSDU FD úL DPHVWHFXUL DOH FHORU IDFWRUL
&KHVWLRQDUXO SRDWH IL XWLOL]DW SHQWUX DXWRHYDOXDUH GDU úL SHQWUX
HYDOXDUHGHF WUHDO LL
&XSULQGH VFRUXUL OD FHL FLQFL IDFWRUL PDUL GHILQL L vQ DFHDVW
YDULDQW GUHSW([WUDYHUVLH$JUHDELOLWDWH&RQúWLLQFLR]LWDWH6WDELOLWDWH
HPR LRQDO úLXOWLPXOIDFWRU$XWRQRPLHÌQSOXVID GHDFHVWHVFDOH
SULQ ))3, SRU IL HYDOXDWH FHOH GH ID HWH ELSRODUH FDUH DSDU FD
DPHVWHFDODFHVWRUIDFWRUL0DMRULWDWHDLWHPLORUDSDUDILDPHVWHFXULGH
GRL IDFWRUL DFHúWL WHUPHQL DX R vQF UF WXU vQDOW SH XQ IDFWRU úL R
vQF UF WXU VHFXQGDU GHVWXO GH VXEVWDQ LDO SH XQ DO GRLOHD DOWIHO
VSXVHLVXQWDSURSLD LGHXQYHFWRUvQVSD LXOFXFLQFLGLPHQVLXQLFDUH
HVWHSR]L LRQDWXQGHYDvQWUHGRLGLQWUHFHLFLQFLIDFWRUL
([HPSOHGHDVWIHOGHWU V WXULUHVSHFWLYLWHPLÄYHVHO´DPHVWHF
vQWUH,FX,,ÄEOkQGH H,,FX,DFHúWLWHUPHQLVHGLVWLQJFODUGH
WHUPHQLL VSHFLILFL SHQWUX IDFWRUL SUHFXP ÄH[WUDYHUVLH´ SHQWUX , úL
ÄDJUHDELO´SHQWUX,,5H]XOWDWXOHVWHRSDUWL LRQDUHDVSD LXOXLWU V
WXULORUvQGHÄID HWH´FDUHFRQ LQFOXVWHULGHWHUPHQLGHWU V WXULFDUH
VXQWPXOWPDLRPRJHQLGHFkWFHLPDULFOXVWHULDLPRGHOXOXLVWUXFWXULL
VLPSOHWLS%)0RGHOXO$%&RIHU LQVWUXPHQWXOXL))3,XQSXQFWGH
DQFRUDUHPXOWPDLEXQSHQWUXLQWHUSUHWDUHvQYLUWXWHDUHSUH]HQW ULLVDOH
QXDQ DWHvQvQ HOHVXOWU V WXULL
$XWRULL VXEOLQLD] OHJDW GH IDFWRUXO FLQFL IDSWXO F vQ FDGUXO
FHUFHW ULORU GHVI úXUDWH vQ FDGUXO SDUDGLJPHL SVLKROH[LFDOH FHO GH
DO 9OHD IDFWRU HVWH UHODWLY LQVWDELO ,QVWDELOLWDWHD VH PDQLIHVW QX
QXPDLODQLYHOXOGHILQLULLLQL LDOGHQXPLWÄFXOWXU ´±7XSHVúL&KULVWDO
DSRLÄLQWHOHFW´±*ROGEHUJ2VWHQGRUIÄFUHDWLYLWDWH´
± -RKQVRQ 6DXFLHU ÄRULJLQDOLWDWH´ ± 6DXFLHU VDX
ÄLPDJLQD LH´ ± 6DXFLHU RUL ÄGHVFKLGHUH OD H[SHULHQ ±
&RVWDúL0F&UDH´FkWPDLDOHVODQLYHOXOFRQ LQXWXOXLúL
DOHUHSOLFDELOLW LLOXL
6WXGLLOHFDUHDXFRQGXVOD))3,QXDXUHXúLWV DMXQJ ODD9D
GLPHQVLXQHGHILQLELO FD,QWHOHFW'HILQLUHDIDFWRUXOXLFDÄDXWRQRPLH´
VD UHDOL]DW vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH DX IRVW RE LQX L WHUPHQL SXUL IDFWRULDOL
SUHFXPÄOHDJ OXFUXULOHODRODOW ´ÄYUHDV úLIRUPH]HSURSULDRSLQLH´
ÄDQDOL]HD] SUREOHPHOH´ ± WR L SHQWUX SROXO SR]LWLY YV 3HQWUX SROXO
QHJDWLYÄXUPHD] SHDO LL´ÄFRSLD] SHDO LL´VDXÄIDFHFHIDFúLDO LL´
0DUHDPDMRULWDWHGHSURSR]L LL±LWHPLLQFOXúLvQJUXSXOILQDODSDUFD
DPHVWHFXULvQWUHIDFWRUXO9úLIDFWRUXO,,,FRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWH$GMHFWLYH
FDÄLQWHOLJHQW´ÄvQ HOHSW´ÄUDSLG´ÄGHúWHSW´FDRSXVHOXLÄQHLQWHOLJHQW´
ÄQHvQ HOHSW´ÄVWXSLG´VDXDVRFLDWFXDPHVWHFXOGLQWUH9,,,9,,,
'LQWUH FHOH WUHL VWUXFWXUL OLQJYLVWLFH JHUPDQLFH GRDU VWUXFWXUD
IDFWRULDO SURSULX]LV JHUPDQ 2VWHQGRUI D SUH]HQWDW XQ IDFWRU
FODUGH,QWHOHFW0LH]XOIDFWRUXOXLDPHULFDQRHQJOH]VHUHIHU 6DXFLHU
úL*ROGEHUJODWU V WXULFDUHVHOHDJ PDLGHJUDE GH$XWRQRPLH
ILORVRILF LQWHURJDWLY LQWXLWLY vQ WLPS FH WU V WXULOH FH VXQW FDUDFWH
ULVWLFH SHQWUX ,QWHOHFW SUHFXP LQWHOLJHQW LQWHOHFWXDO VWU OXFLWRU DX
SURLHF LLPDULvQDPHVWHFXOGLQWUH9,,,ÌQFRQWH[WDXWRULLODQVHD]
LSRWH]DF LPDJLQD LDFUHDWLYLWDWHDúLGHVFKLGHUHDODH[SHULHQ DUWUHEXL
FRQFHSXWHFDID HWHDOH$XWRQRPLHLGHFkWLQYHUV$XWRQRPLDFDID HW D
XQRUDGLQWUHHOH
3HQWUX DXWRUL GHYLQH LPSRUWDQW FODULILFDUHD UHOD LHL GLQWUH IDF
WRUXO$XWRQRPLHDO))3,úLP VXULDOHÄHILFLHQ HLSHUVRQDOH´%DQGXUD
VDX D ÄORFXOXL FRQWUROXOXL´ /HYHQVRQ 5RWWHU
&HUFHW ULSUHOLPLQDUHUHDOL]DWHFXWUDGXFHUHDLWDOLDQ D))3,0DULQR
3HUXJLQLSDUDVXJHUDF FHOHWUHLFRQFHSWHVXQWILHSXWHUQLFILH
PRGHUDWFRUHODWH
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH
DGDSW ULFDUDFWHULVWLFHFRQ LQXWXODFHVWRUDHVWHIRUPDWDWkWGHSHUVR
QDOLWDWHFkWúLGHFXOWXU DGDSW ULOHQHILLQGDOWFHYDGHFkWFDUDFWHULVWLFLOH
GREkQGLWH FH FRQVWLWXLH H[SUHVLD IHQRWLSLF D WU V WXULORU 5HSUH]LQW
GHFL DFHOH RELFHLXUL DWLWXGLQL GHSULQGHUL YDORUL PRWLYH UROXUL UHOD LL
FDUH GHILQHVF ÄLGHQWLWDWHD FRQWH[WXDOL]DW ´ SHUVRDQD SXV vQ FRQWH[WXO
LQWHUUHOD LLORUvQFDUHVDIRUPDWúLHYROXHD] ÌQWUHWHQGLQ HOHED]DOHúL
DGDSW ULOHFDUDFWHULVWLFHFHFRQVWLWXLHH[SUHVLDGLUHFW DSHUVRQDOLW LLDX
DYXW ORF úL DX ORF PHUHX SURFHVH GLQDPLFH UHVSRQVDELOH GH XQ DQXPH
L]RPRUILVP ,QGLYLGXO LQWU vQ YLD FX DQXPLWH GLVSR]L LL SDUWLFXODUH
F URUD OL VH G FXORDUH ORFDO úL VHQV SULQ FXOWXUD SUHYDOHQW SULQ
LQWHUPHGLXOSURFHVHORUGHGH]YROWDUHFDUHFUHHD] DFHVWL]RPRUILVP
DJUHDELOLWDWHDFDGLPHQVLXQHSUHJQDQWLQWHUSHUVRQDO $VSHFWHOHFHQ
WUDOH DOH IDFWRUXOXL VXQW DOWUXLVPXO XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW FRRSHUDQW
VLPSDWHWLF úL GH DMXWRUDUH D DOWRUD FX WHQGLQ D GH DL FRQVLGHUD SH
FHLODO LODIHOGHVLPSDWHWLFLúLJDWDV OHRIHUHVSULMLQXO
FRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWHD GRPHQLXO DFHVWXL IDFWRU VH UHIHU OD DXWRFRQWURO
VXE DVSHFWXO FDSDFLW LL GH DXWRRUJDQL]DUH vQGHSOLQLUH D vQGDWRULULORU
SODQLILF ULL VXQW SHUVRDQH FDUH vúL GHILQHVF úL XUP UHVF VFRSXULOH
KRW UkWHúLFXYRLQ DIRUPDW
GHVFKLGHUHHOHPHQWHOHFDUHDSDUvQFHUFHW ULOHHPSLULFHDOHOXL&RVWDúL
0F&UDH OHJDWH GH DFHVW VXSHUIDFWRU VXQW LPDJLQD LD DFWLY VHQVLEL
OLWDWHDHVWHWLF DWHQ LDSHQWUXYLD úLVLP PLQWHOHLQWHULRDUHSUHIHULQ D
SHQWUX YDULHWDWH FXULR]LWDWHD LQWHOHFWXDO LQGHSHQGHQ D vQ PRGXO GH D
JkQGL OXFUXULOH $FHVWH DVSHFWH QX VH DVRFLD] vQ PRG QHFHVDU FX
HGXFD LDVDXFXLQWHOLJHQ DJHQHUDO GHDFHHDDXWRULLSUHIHU GHQXPLUHD
GHÄGHVFKLGHUH´
GH]YROWDUH VH UHIHU VSHFLILF SHQWUX SHUVRQDOLWDWH OD SURFHVXO GH
VFKLPE UL FDUH DUH ORF GHD OXQJXO vQWUHJLL YLH L D LQGLYLGXOXL SULQ
VFKLPEDUH QH UHIHULP vQ DFHVW FRQWH[W OD PRGLILF UL FDOLWDWLYH VDX
FDQWLWDWLYHvQVWUXFWXU úLIXQF LRQDUH'3
H[WUDYHUVLH WU V WXU GH ED] D SHUVRQDOLW LL FDUH LPSULP DQXPLWH
FDUDFWHULVWLFL SHUVRDQHL H[WUDYHUWXO DSDUH VRFLDELO VH VLPWH vQ ODUJXO
V X SULQWUH RDPHQL úL JUXSXUL PDUL HVWH DILUPDWLY DFWLY YRUE UH vL
SODFHFHHDFHHVWHH[FLWDQWVWLPXODWLYDUHRGLVSR]L LHJHQHUDO YHVHO
HQHUJLF úLRSWLPLVW
IDFWRUvQJHQHUDORULFHDVSHFWFDUHDUHRLQIOXHQ FDX]DO DVXSUDXQXL
IHQRPHQ SULQ H[WLQGHUH IDFWRUXO HVWH R YDULDELO LQGHSHQGHQW ÌQ
VWDWLVWLF XQ SURGXV DO DQDOL]HL IDFWRULDOH QXPHUH vQWUR PDWULFH
IDFWRULDO DQDOL]DIDFWRULDO LGHDO LGHQWLILF XQQXP UPLFGHIDFWRUL
ILHFDUH RUWRJRQDO ID GH FHLODO L )DFWRULL FDUH DSDU vQ XUPD DQDOL]HL
IDFWRULDOH WUHEXLH V ILH H[DPLQD L VXELHFWLY SHQWUX D GHWHUPLQD GDF
UHSUH]LQW GLPHQVLXQLSVLKRORJLFHHYLGHQWH([LVW RWHQGLQ PDLDOHV
FkQGWHKQLFDDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOHVHDSOLF LQYHQWDUHORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
V VHLGHQWLILFHIDFWRULLFDUHDSDUFXWU V WXULOH6WULFWYRUELQGIDFWRUXO
QXHVWHRWU V WXU WU V WXUDHVWHLQIHUDW SRUQLQGGHODIDFWRUXORE L
QXW UHSUH]LQW R UHJXODULWDWH VXELDFHQW ED]HL GH GDWH GH OD FDUH VD
SRUQLW DVWIHO F FHL GRL WHUPHQL WU V WXU úL IDFWRU QX WUHEXLH FRQVL
GHUD L VLQRQLPL 3HQWUX D SXWHD V VWDELOLP R WU V WXU YDOLG DYHP
QHYRLHGHLQIRUPD LLDGL LRQDOH'3
LPDJLQHD GH VLQH FD R VXEGLYL]LXQH D DGDSW ULORU FDUDFWHULVWLFH
SHUVRDQHL5 VSXQVXULOHODFKHVWLRQDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHVXQWOHJDWHFHO
PDLPXOWúLGHVLJXUFHOPDLGLUHFWGHDFHVWQLYHODOLPDJLQLLGHVLQH
,PDJLQHDGHVLQHQXHVWHXQDVSHFWVLQJXODUFLRRUJDQL]DUHGHLGHLXQ
PRGHOGHSHUFHSHUHOHJDW GHHXOSURSULX2GDW VWDELOL]DW LPDJLQHD
GHVLQHIXUQL]HD] XQHFUDQVDXXQILOWUXSULQFDUHHVWHSHUFHSXWY ]XW
HYDOXDWVDXvQ HOHVRULFHDOWFHYD)HOXOFXPVHSHUFHSHFHVLPWHGHVSUH
VLQHRSHUVRDQ HVWHvQXOWLP LQVWDQ LQIOXHQ DWGHRPXOWLWXGLQHGH
H[SHULHQ H WU LWH DFDV OD úFRDO vQ GLIHULWH JUXSXUL VRFLDOH GLQ FDUH
IDFHSDUWH
PRGHO vQ HQJOH] úL XQHRUL SUHOXDW vQ OLPED URPkQ ÄSDWHUQ´ VH
UHIHU ILHODXQPRGHOVDXXQHúDQWLRQILHODRFRQILJXUD LHVDXJUXSDUH
GHS U LVDXHOHPHQWHFXRVWUXFWXU FRHUHQW $QDOL]DGHSDWHUQHVWHR
WHKQLF VWDWLVWLF SULQFDUHVHvQFHDUF GHVFRSHULUHDVHWXOXLGHLWHPLGH
WHVWFDUHDXRÄDSDUWHQHQ ´FRPXQ '3
PRGHOHFLUFXPSOH[HVWUXFWXUDOHPRGHOHFRPSOH[HFXRQDWXU JHR
PHWULF VXEDVSHFWXOUHSUH]HQW ULLVSD LDOHvQFDUHYHFWRULLWU V WXULORU
VXQW FDUDFWHUL]D L GH SR]L LLOH ORU XQJKLXODUH vQWUXQ VSD LX ELGLPHQ
VLRQDOVDXWULGLPHQVLRQDO0RGHOHOHFLUFXPSOH[HSULQQDWXUDORUGDX
RPDLPDUHúDQV GHLGHQWLILFDUHDXQRUFOXVWHULGHWU V WXULFDUHVXQW
GLQSXQFWGHYHGHUHVHPDQWLFFRH]LYH2HWDS XOWHULRDU DIRVWGHD
LQWHJUDWR LVXSHUIDFWRULLúLPRGHOHOHFLUFXPSOH[HvQDGHY UDWHPRGHOH
JHRPHWULFHFXPDLPXOWGHGRX GLPHQVLXQL
QHYURWLVP GHILQLW FD VWDELOLWDWH HPR LRQDO DGDSWDUH ID GH QHYUR
WLVPQHDGDSWDUH&RVWD0F&UDH7HQGLQ DJHQHUDO GHDWU L
DIHFWHSUHFXPWHDPDWULVWH HDMHQDPkQLDYLQRY LDGH]JXVWXOUHSUH
]LQW PLH]XODFHVWXLIDFWRU
RUWRJRQDO vQ XQJKL GUHSW FDUDFWHULVWLFD XQXL VHW GH YDULDELOH GLQ
FDGUXO XQXL H[SHULPHQW LQGHSHQGHQWH vQWUH HOH 6ROX LD RUWRJRQDO VH
DSOLF vQ DQDOL]D IDFWRULDO vQ FDUH D[HOH FH UHSUH]LQW IDFWRULL
VXEVLGLDULVHVLWXHD] DVWIHOF DXRSR]L LHvQXQJKLGUHSWXQXOID GH
FHO ODOW vQWUR DVWIHO GH VROX LH IDFWRULL QX FRUHOHD] 7U V WXUD
RUWRJRQDO vQPDWULFHDGHDQDOL] IDFWRULDO RULFHWU V WXU FDUHHVWH
LQGHSHQGHQW GHRULFDUHDOWD
SVLKRGLDJQR] vQ YL]LXQHD DXWRULORU DPHULFDQL HVWH XQ SURFHV VLVWH
PDWLFFDUHDUHGRX HWDSHREVHUY PPRGHOHGHFRPSRUWDPHQWúLGH
WU LUH DGHVHD SULQ DXWRGHVFULHUL RE LQXWH GH OD VXELHFW úL IDFHP
HYDOX UL SULYLQG WU V WXULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH FDUH DU SXWHD GHWHUPLQD
DFHVWHUHJXODULW LDFHVWHWLSXULVDXPRGHOHGHFRPSRUWDPHQW'DF DúD
FXPHVWHILUHVFQHSXQHPSUREOHPDYDOLGLW LLXQRUDVWIHOGHHYDOX UL
REVHUY P F DVHPHQL HYDOX ULORU FRWLGLHQH úL HYDOX ULOH SVLKRGLDJ
QRVWLFH VXSRUW LQIOXHQ D XQRU DVSHFWH FDUH OH UHODWLYL]HD] 9DORDUHD
H[SOLFDWLY D WU V WXULORU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH GHSLQGH GH P VXUD vQ FDUH
FHUWLILF SHGHRSDUWHVWDELOLWDWHDORUvQWLPSFHHDFHG SRVLELOLWDWHD
GHDVHIDFHSUHGLF LLSHWHUPHQOXQJúLSHGHDOW SDUWHVXQWDUJXPHQWH
FHLQGLF RGLQDPLF GHODVSHFLILFVSUHJHQHUDOúLGLQQRXVSUHVSHFLILF
SVLKROLQJYLVWLF XQGRPHQLXFUHDWvQDQLL¶DLVHFROXOXL;;vQFDUH
FHQWUDUHD HVWH SH VWXGLXO FRPSRUWDPHQWHORU FDUH VXQW OLQJYLVWLFH
'DWRULW XELFXLW LL FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL YHUEDO XPDQ PXOWH SUREOHPH
SVLKROLQJYLVWLFHHPHUJvQDULLSUHFXPSVLKRORJLDFRJQLWLY PHPRULH
SURFHVDUHDLQIRUPD LLORUVRFLROLQJYLVWLF QHXURSVLKRORJLHSVLKRORJLH
FOLQLF ÌQGRPHQLXOWHRULLORUSHUVRQDOLW LLXQDGLQGLUHF LLOHFHOHPDL
IUXFWXRDVH GH FHUFHWDUH FRQWHPSRUDQH vQ VWXGLXO UHJXODULW LORU vQ
HYDOXDUHDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLúLSHUVRQDOLW LL
WHQGLQ HVDXWU V WXULED]DOHIDLPRúLLVXSHUIDFWRULDLSHUVRQDOLW LL±
QHYURWLVPH[WUDYHUVLHGHVFKLGHUHDJUHDELOLWDWHFRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWH±DSDU
DLFLFDGLVSR]L LLSVLKLFHIXQGDPHQWDOHÌQWUHDFHVWHWHQGLQ HED]DOHGLQ
FDUH IDF SDUWH WU V WXULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH úL ELRJUDILD RELHFWLY D SHU
VRDQHL FDUH LQFOXGH FRPSRUWDPHQWHOH VSHFLILFH QX H[LVW R OHJ WXU
GLUHFW 7U V WXULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH DSDU FD VXEGYL]LXQH PDMRU D
WHQGLQ HORU GH ED] DO WXUL GH DELOLW LOH FRJQLWLYH VH[XDOH úL GH DOWH
PDWHULDOHSULPDUHDOHSVLKLVPXOXL
WU V WXU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH UHSUH]LQW R GLVSR]L LH VDX FDUDFWHULVWLF
VXELDFHQW SUHVXSXV FDUH SRDWH IL IRORVLW FD R H[SOLFD LH SHQWUX
UHJXODULW LOHVDXDVSHFWHOHFRQVLVWHQWHDOHFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLDFHVWHLD
ÌQVHQVPDLODUJRGHVFULHUHDPRGXULORUGHFRPSRUWDPHQWSHUFHSHUH
JkQGLUH FDUDFWHULVWLFH SHQWUX R SHUVRDQ DFHVW VHQV HVWH IRORVLW VWULFW
GHVFULSWLYI U H[LVWHQ DXQHLLQWHQ LLH[SOLFDWLYH'3
WU V WXU vQ JHQHUH R FDUDFWHULVWLF UH]LVWHQW FDUH SRDWH VHUYL FD
H[SOLFD LHSHQWUXUHJXODULW LOHFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHREVHUYDWHODDFHDSHU
VRDQ SHQWUXFHHDFHHVWHFRQVLVWHQWvQFRPSRUWDPHQWXOHL7U V WXUD
HVWHRHQWLWDWHWHRUHWLF FDUHHVWHIRORVLW SHQWUXDH[SOLFDFRQVLVWHQ HOH
FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH DOH SHUVRDQHL VDX GLIHUHQ HOH GLQWUH FRQVLVWHQ HOH
FRPSRUWDPHQWDOHDOHPDLPXOWRUSHUVRDQHvQDFHVWVHQVHVWHLQFRUHFW
V XWLOL] P WHUPHQXO SHQWUX D GHVHPQD DFHVWH DVSHFWH FRPSRUWDPHQ
WDOHvQVLQH'3
WXOEXUDUHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHWHUPHQXODVHUYLWPXOWWLPSSHQWUXRULFH
WLSGHWXOEXUDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL,QL LDOVHPQLILFDRULFHWXOEXUDUHPHQ
WDO PDQLIHVWDW SULQQHDGDSWDUHúLPRGHOHQHDGDSWDWLYHGHUHOD LRQDUH
FXPHGLXOFHHDFHQXDMXWDODGLIHUHQ LHUHDGLQWUHVLPSWRPHQHYURWLFH
PLQRUH ID GH WXOEXU UL PDMRUH SVLKRWLFH ÌQ SUH]HQW PDL VSHFLILF R
FODV GHWXOEXU ULGHFRPSRUWDPHQWH[FOX]kQGQHYUR]HOHúLSVLKR]HOH
PDQLIHVWDWHFDGH]YROW ULSDWRORJLFHvQSHUVRQDOLWDWHDvQWUHDJ DLQGLYL
GXOXLúLPDUFDW GHRDQ[LHWDWHUHODWLYVF ]XW VDXGHHPR LLQHJDWLYH
LQFOX]kQG DVWIHO WUHL VXEFODVH GH WXOEXU UL WXOEXU UL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH
JHQHUDO LQFOX]kQGWXOEXUDUHDFRPSXOVLY FLFORWLPLF SDUDQRLG HWF
WXOEXU ULOH VRFLRSDWH FDUH VXQW FDUDFWHUL]DWH SULQWUR OLSV JHQHUDO D
DIHFWHORU DGHFYDWH D VHQWLPHQWHORU GH YLQRY LH vQ XUPD vQF OF ULL
OHJLORU úL D LQFDSDFLW LL GH D IRUPD OHJ WXUL HPR LRQDOH GH GXUDW
LQFOX]kQG GH H[HPSOX WXOEXUDUHD VRFLRSDW WXOEXUDUHD SVLKRSDW
GHYLHULOH VH[XDOH ÌQ SUH]HQW R WXOEXUDUH PHQWDO DOH F UHL WU V WXUL
HVHQ LDOH VXQW PRGHOH GH UHOD LRQDUH QHDGDSWDWLYH SURIXQG vQU G
FLQDWHGHGXUDW PRGXULGHJkQGLUHúLSHUFHSHUHDPHGLXOXLFDUHVXQW
H[WUHPH SkQ vQ FRQGL LD GH D FRQGXFH OD vPSLHGLFDUHD IXQF LRQ ULL
VRFLDOH úL FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH 7XOEXU ULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH SRW IL UHFX
QRVFXWHvQJHQHUDOvQFRSLO ULHVDXDGROHVFHQ úLFRQWLQX GHDOXQJXO
YLH LLDGXOWH'3
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU
&DUHHVWHSDUDGLJPDDERUG ULLSVLKROLQJYLVWLFHDSHUVRQDOLW LL"
&DUH HVWH GXS &RVWD úL 0F&UDH JUHúHDOD WLSLF vQ LQWHUSUHWDUHD
WU V WXULORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH"
&DUHHVWHGHRVHELUHDGLQWUHÄWHQGLQ HOHED]DOH´úLÄDGDSW ULOHFDUDFWH
ULVWLFH´"&DUHHVWHFRPSRQHQWDFHQWUDO DDGDSW ULORUFDUDFWHULVWLFH"
'H FH QX SXWHP YRUEL GH R OHJ WXU GLUHFW vQWUH WU V WXULOH GH
SHUVRQDOLWDWHED]DOHúLÄELRJUDILDRELHFWLY ´FRPSRUWDPHQWHVSH
FLILFHDSHUVRDQHL"
'HQXPL L IDFWRULL GHILQL L GH 1(2 3, ± 5 úL ID HWHOH ILHF UXLD
GLQWUHHL"
&H SXWH L DUJXPHQWD GHVSUH OHJ WXUD GLQWUH FHL PDUL IDFWRUL DL
SHUVRQDOLW LLúLIDFWRULLPRWLYD LRQDOL"
ÌQFHP VXU HVWHFKHVWLRQDUXO1(23,5XQHYDOXDWRUDOJUDGXOXL
GHSVLKRSDWRORJLH"&XPDUJXPHQWHD] &RVWDúL0F&UDH"
&DUH VXQW FHL PDUL IDFWRUL vQ PRGHOXO URPkQHVF úL FDUH VXQW
ID HWHOHRE LQXWH"
%LEOLRJUDILH
$QJOHLWQHU $ -RKQ 2 3 /|KU ) - ,W¶V :KDW <RX $VN DQG +RZ
<RX $VN ,W DQ ,WHPPHWULF $QDO\VLV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 4XHVWLRQQDLUHV vQ
$QJOHLWQHU $ DQG :LJJLQV - 6 HGV 3HUVRQDOLW\ $VVHVVPHQW YLD
4XHVWLRQQDLUHV6SULQJHU9HUODJ%HUOLQ
$QJOHLWQHU $ 2VWHQGRUI ) -RKQ 2 3 RS FLW &DSUDUD * 9
3HUXJLQL03HUVRQDOLW\'HVFULEHGE\$GMHFWLYHV*HQHUDOLVDELOLW\
RI WKH %LJ)LYH WR WKH ,WDOLDQ /H[LFDO &RQWH[W Ä(XURSHDQ -RXUQDO RI
3HUVRQDOLW\´
$QJOHLWQHU $ 2VWHQGRUI ) -RKQ 2 3 7RZDUGV D 7D[RQRP\ RI
3HUVRQDOLW\'HVFULSWRUVLQ*HUPDQD3V\FKROH[LFDO6WXG\Ä(XURSHDQ
-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´SULPDSUH]HQWDUHDOLVWHORUDUHORFvQ
%RUNHQDX 3 6\VWHPDWLF 'LVWRUWLRQV LQ WKH 5HFRJQLWLRQ RI 7UDLW
,QIRUPDWLRQ vQ $QJOHLWQHU $ )XUQKDP $ 9DQ +HFN * HGV
3HUVRQDOLW\3V\FKRORJ\LQ(XURSH&XUUHQW7UDLWVDQG&RQWURYHUVLHV
6ZHWV =HLWOLQJHU/LVVH1LVEHWW55RVV/+XPDQ
,QWHUIHUHQFH 6WUDWHJLHV DQG 6KRUW FRPLQJV RI 6RFLDO -XGJHPHQWV
3UHQWLFH+DOO(QJOHZRRG&OLIIV1-
%URNNHQ)%7KH/DQJXDJHRI3HUVRQDOLW\WH] GHGRFWRUDW8QLYHU
VLWDWHD*URQLQJHQ2ODQGD
%URPOH\ ' % 3HUVRQDOLW\ 'HVFULSWLRQV LQ 2UGLQDU\ /DQJXDJH
/RQJPDQ/RQGRQ
%XVV ' 0 &UDLN . + 7KH $FW )UHTXHQF\ &RQFHSW RI
'LVSRVLWLRQV'RPLQDQFHDQG3URWRW\SLFDOO\'RPLQDQW$FWVÄ-RXUQDO
RI3HUVRQDOLW\´
&DQWRU1 )URP7KRXJKWWR%HKDYLRUÄ+DYLQJ´DQGÄ'RLQJ´LQWKH
6WXG\RI3HUVRQDOLW\DQG&RJQLWLRQ$PHULFDQ3V\FKRORJLVW
&DQWRU1=LUNHO63HUVRQDOLW\&RJQLWLRQDQG3XUSRVLYH%HKDYLRU
vQ/3HUYLQHG+DQGERRNRI3HUVRQDOLW\7KHRU\DQG5HVHDUFK7KH
*XLOIRUG3UHVV1HZ<RUN
&DSUDUD * 9 %DUEDUDQHOOL & %RUJRJQL / 3HUXJLQL 0 7KH %LJ
)LYH 4XHVWLRQQDLUH D 1HZ 4XHVWLRQQDLUH WR $VVHVV WKH )LYH )DFWRU
0RGHO3HUVRQDOLW\DQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV
&RVWD 3 7 0F&UDH 5 5 1(2 3, 5 3URIHVVLRQDO 0DQXDO
3V\FKRORJLFDO$VVHVVPHQW5HVRXUFHV2GHVVD)ORULGD
&RVWD370F&UDH557KH1(23HUVRQDOLW\,QYHQWRU\0DQXDO
2GHVVD )ORULGD 3$6 :LJJLQV - 6 $ 3V\FKRORJLFDO
7D[RQRP\ RI 7UDLW 'HVFULSWLYH 7HUPV WKH ,QWHUSHUVRQDO 'RPDLQ
Ä-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
&RVWD370F&UDH553HUVRQDOLW\'LVRUGHUVDQGWKH)LYH)DFWRU
0RGHORI3HUVRQDOLW\Ä-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\'LVRUGHUV´
&RVWD 3 7 0F&UDH 5 5 '\H ' $ )DFHW 6FDOHV IRU
$JUHHDEOHQHVVDQG&RQVFLRXVQHVV$5HYLVLRQRI1(23,3HUVRQDOLW\
DQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV
&RVWD370F&UDH55,QIOXHQFHRI([WUDYHUVLRQDQG1HXURWLFLVP
RQ 6XEMHFWLYH :HOO²%HLQJ +DSS\ DQG 8QKDSS\ 3HRSOH Ä-RXUQDO RI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
'H5DDG%3HUVRQ7DONLQ(YHU\GD\/LIH3UDJPDWLFVRI8WWHUDQFHV
IRU 6FLHQWLILF 3XUSRVHV WH] GH GRFWRUDW 8QLYHUVLWDWHD *URQLQJHQ
2ODQGD
'H5DDG%+LVNHQV0 3HUVRQDOLW\'HVFULSWLYH1RXQVÄ(XURSHDQ
-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
'H5DDG%0XOGHU(.ORRVWHUPDQ.+RIVWHH(.%3HUVRQDOLW\
'HVFULSWLYH9HUEVÄ(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
'H5DDG%6]LUPDN= 7KH6HDUFKIRUWKH%LJ)LYHLQD1RQ,QGR
(XURSHDQ/DQJXDJHWKH+XQJDULDQ7UDLW6WUXFWXUHDQG,WV5HODWLRQVKLS
WRWKH(34DQG376Ä(XURSHDQ5HYLHZRI$SSOLHG3V\FKRORJ\´
'L%ODV/)RU]L0$)XUWKHU6WHS7RZDUGVWKH,WDOLDQ7D[RQRP\RI
3HUVRQDOLW\ 'HVFULSWLYH 7HUPV FRPXQLFDUH D 9,,D FRQIHULQ D
($330DGULG
)LVNH 6 7 &R[ 0 * 3HUVRQ &RQFHSWV WKH (IIHFW RI 7DUJHW
)DPLOLDULW\ DQG 'HVFULSWLYH 3XUSRVH RQ WKH 3URFHVV RI 'HVFULELQJ
2WKHUVÄ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
*ROGEHUJ/$/DQJXDJHDQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHVWKH6HDUFKIRU
8QLYHUVDOVLQ3HUVRQDOLW\/H[LFRQVÄ5HYLHZRI3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO
3V\FKRORJ\´
*ROGEHUJ/5'HYHORSLQJD7D[RQRP\RIWUDLW'HVFULSWLYH7HUPVvQ
)LVNH ' : HG 1HZ 'LUHFWLRQV IRU 0HWKRGRORJ\ RI 6RFLDO
%HKDYLRUDO6FLHQFHV3UREOHPVZLWK/DQJXDJH,PSUHFLVLRQ-RVVH\
%DVV6DQ)UDQFLVFR&$
*ROGEHUJ / 5 )URP $FH WR =RPELH 6RPH ([SORUDWLRQV LQ WKH
/DQJXDJHRI3HUVRQDOLW\vQ6SLHOEHUJ&'DQG%XWFKHU-1HGV
$GYDQFHVLQ3HUVRQDOLW\$VVHVVPHQW(UOEDXP+LOVGDOH
*ROGEHUJ/7KH'HYHORSPHQWRI0DUNHUVIRUWKH%LJ)LYH)DFWRU6WUXFWXUH
3V\FKRORJLFDO$VVHVVPHQW
*ROGEHUJ RS FLW -RKQ 2 3 7RZDUGV DQ 7D[RQRP\ RI 3HUVRQDOLW\
'HVFULSWRUVvQ%XVV'0 &DQWRU1HGV3HUVRQDOLW\3V\FKRORJ\
UHFHQW 7UHQGV DQG (PHUJLQJ 'LUHFWLRQV 6SULQJHU 9HUODJ 1HZ <RUN
*RXJK + * +HLOEUXQ $ % $GMHFWLYH &KHFN/LVW 0DQXDO 3DOR
$OWR&D&RQVXOWLQJ3V\FKRORJLVW3UHVV
+DPSVRQ 6 ( 7UDLW $VFULSWLRQ DQG 'HSWK RI $FTXDLQWDQFH WKH
3UHIHUHQFHIRU7UDLWVLQ3HUVRQDOLW\'HVFULSWLRQVDQG,WV5HODWLRQVWR
7DUJHW)DPLOLDULW\Ä-RXUQDORI5HVHDUFKLQ3HUVRQDOLW\´
/LYHVOH\:-%URPOH\'%3HUVRQ3HUFHSWLRQLQ&KLOGKRRG
DQG$GROHVFHQFH:LOH\1HZ<RUN
+HQGULNV$$-+RIVWHH:%.'H5DDG%&RQVWUXFWLRQRIWKH
$%& 3HUVRQDOLW\ 4XHVWLRQQDLUH FRPXQLFDUH OD D ,,D FRQIHULQ D
($33*URQLQJHQ
+RIVWHH : . % 7KH 8VH RI (YHU\GD\ 3HUVRQDOLW\ /DQJXDJH IRU
6FLHQWLILF3XUSRVHVÄ(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
+RIVWHH:.%'H5DDG%*ROGEHUJ/5,QWHJUDWLRQRIWKH%LJ
)LYH DQG &LUFXPSOH[ $SSURDFKHV WR 7UDLW 6WUXFWXUH Ä-RXUQDO RI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
-RKQ237KH%LJ)LYH)DFWRU7D[RQRP\'LPHQVLRQVRI3HUVRQDOLW\
LQWKH1DWXUDO/DQJXDJHDQGLQ4XHVWLRQQDLUHVvQ3HUYLQ/$HG
+DQGERRN RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 7KHRU\ DQG 5HVHDUFK 7KH *XLOIRUG 3UHVV
1HZ<RUN
-RKQVRQ-$ 7KHÄ6HOI'LVFORVXUH´DQGÄ6HOI3UHVHQWDWLRQ´9LHZV
RI,WHP5HVSRQVH'\QDPLFVDQG3HUVRQDOLW\6FDOH9DOLGLW\Ä-RXUQDORI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
-XQJ&*3V\FKRORJLVFKH7\SHQ*:WUDGXV vQOLPEDURPkQ SDU LDO
vQ$QWRORJLD&*-XQJYRO(GLWXUD$QLPD%XFXUHúWLVHYRU
FRQVXOWDFDSLWROHOHÄ7LSXOH[WUDYHUWLW´DWLWXGLQHDJHQHUDO DFRQúWLHQ
WXOXLDWLWXGLQHDLQFRQúWLHQWXOXLúLÄ7LSXOLQWURYHUWLW´DWLWXGLQHDJHQH
UDO DFRQúWLHQWXOXLDWLWXGLQHDLQFRQúWLHQWXOXLS
0DVRQ21HZ6FDOHVIRUWKH$VVHVVPHQWRI6FKL]RWLS\FRPXQLFDUHOD
D9,,DFRQIHULQ D($330DGULG
0DVRQ 2 &ODULGJH * 6FDOHV 0HDVXULQJ 3URQHQHVV WR 3V\FKRWLF
'LVRUGHUVDQG7KHLU5HODWLRQVKLSWRWKH)LYH)DFWRU0RGHOFRPXQLFDUH
ODD9,,DFRQIHULQ D($330DGULG
0F&UDH 5 5 +RZ :HOO LV 2SHQQHVV 5HSUHVHQWHG LQ 1DWXUDO
/DQJXDJHV"Ä(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
0F&UDH 5 5 +RZ :HOO LV 2SHQQHVV 5HSUHVHQWHG LQ 1DWXUDO
/DQJXDJHV"Ä(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
0F&UDH 5 5 RS FLW -RKQ 2 3 7KH %LJ )LYH)DFWRU7D[RQRP\
'LPHQVLRQV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ LQ WKH 1DWXUDO /DQJXDJH DQG LQ
4XHVWLRQQDLUHV vQ 3HUYLQ / $ HG +DQGERRN RI 3HUVRQDOLW\
7KHRU\DQG5HVHDUFK7KH*XLOIRUG3UHVV1HZ<RUN
0HUYLHOGH , $ &RPSDULVRQ RI )LYH )DFWRU 5DWLQJV DQG )UHH
GHVFULSWLRQVRI&KLOGUHQ$JHVWRFRPXQLFDUHODD9,,DFRQIHULQ
D($330DGULG
0LQXOHVFX00HWDSKRUVYV6LQJOH7HUPVLQ([SUHVVLQJDQG$VVHVVLQJ
3HUVRQDOLW\ Ä(XURSHDQ -RXUQDO RI 3V\FKRORJLFDO $VVHVVPHQW´
VXSO
0ODFLF%.QH]RYLF=%LJ)LYH6WXGLHVLQ&URDWLD$7UDQVSDUHQW
YV2SDTXH)RUPDWVFRPXQLFDUHODD9,,DFRQIHULQ D($330DGULG
1RUPDQ : 7 7RZDUGV DQ $GHTXDWH 7D[RQRP\ RI 3HUVRQDOLW\
$WWULEXWHV5HSOLFDWHG)DFWRU6WUXFWXUHLQ3HHU1RPLQDWLRQ3HUVRQDOLW\
5DWLQJVÄ-RXUQDORI$EQRUPDODQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
2VWHQGRUI ) /DQJXDJH DQG 3HUVRQDOLW\ 6WUXFWXUH 7RZDUGV WKH
9DOLGLW\ RI WKH )LYH)DFWRU 0RGHO RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 6 5RGHUHU 9HUODJ
5HJHQVEXUJ
3HDERG\'*ROGEHUJ/56RPH'HWHUPLQDQWVRI)DFWRU6WUXFWXUHV
IURP3HUVRQDOLW\7UDLWGHVFULSWRUVÄ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO
3V\FKRORJ\´
3HUXJLQL0/HRQH/*DOOXFL0/DXULROD06HOHFWLRQRID6KRUW
$GMHFWLYH &KHFNOLVW WR 0HDVXUH %LJ )LYH 6$&%,) FRPXQLFDUH OD D
9,,DFRQIHULQ D($330DGULG
5REHUWV % : 5RELQ 5 : %URDG 'LVSRVLWLRQV %URDG $VSLUDWLRQV
7KH,QWHUVHFWLRQRIWKH%LJ)LYH'LPHQVLRQVDQG/LIH*RDOVFRPXQLFDUH
ODD9,,DFRQIHULQ D($330DGULG
5RNHDFK07KH2SHQDQG&ORVHG0LQG%DVLF%RRNV1HZ<RUN
7UDSQHOO3':LJJLQV-6([WHQVLRQRIWKH,QWHUSHUVRQDO$GMHFWLYH
6FDOHV WR ,QFOXGH %LJ )LYH 'LPHQVLRQV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ Ä-RXUQDO RI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´6$&%,)±3HUXJLQL
/HRQH*DOOXFFL/DXULROD RSFLW%$56334=.34±SUH]HQWDWHvQ
2VWHQGRUI ) $QJOHLWQHU $ $ &RPSDULVRQ RI 'LIIHUHQW ,QVWUXPHQWV
3URSRVHG WR 0HDVXUH WKH %LJ )LYH FRPXQLFDUH D ,,D FRQIHULQ D
($33*URQLQJHQ%)4vQ&DSUDUDúD
:KLWH * 0 &RQFHSWXDO 8QLYHUVDOV LQ ,QWHUSHUVRQDO /DQJXDJH
$PHULFDQ$QWKURSRORJLVW
:LJJLQV-6&LUFXPSOH[0RGHOVRI,QWHUSHUVRQDO%HKDYLRULQ&OLQLFDO
3V\FKRORJ\ vQ .HQGDOO 3 6 úL %XWFKHU - 1 HGV +DQGERRN RI
5HVHDUFK0HWKRGVLQ&OLQLFDO3V\FKRORJ\:LOH\1HZ<RUN
:LJJLQV-63LFXV$/ &RQFHSWLRQVRI3HUVRQDOLW\'LVRUGHUVDQG
'LPHQVLRQV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 3V\FKRORJLFDO $VVHVVPHQW $ -RXUQDO RI
&RQVXOWLQJDQG&OLQLFDO3V\FKRORJ\:LGLJHU7$&RVWD
3 7 HGV 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG 3HUVRQDOLW\ 'LVRUGHUV Ä-RXUQDO RI
$EQRUPDO3V\FKRORJ\´
:LJJLQV-67UDSQHOO33KLOOLSV13V\FKRPHWULFDQG*HRPHWULF
&KDUDFWHULVWLFVRIWKH5HYLVHG,QWHUSHUVRQDO$GMHFWLYH6FDOHV,$65
0XOWLYDULDWH%HKDYLRUDO5HVHDUFK
:LVH 7 1 )DJDQ 3 - 6FKPLGW & : 3RQWLFDV < &RVWD 2 7
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6H[XDO)XQFWLRQLQJRI7UDQVYHVWLWH)HWLVKLVWVDQG2WKHU
3DUDSK\OLFVÄ-RXUQDORI1HUYRXVDQG0HQWDO'LVHDVHV´
&DSLWROXO9
,19(17$58/'(3(5621$/,7$7(0<(56%5,**6
3UH]HQWDUHDFKHVWLRQDUXOXL0%7,FXSULQGHDVSHFWHGLQWHRULDOXL
&*-XQJSULYLQGWLSXULOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHXWLOL]DUHD0%7,vQVHOHF LD
SURIHVLRQDO FRQVLOLHUHYRFD LRQDO úLvQFHUFHWDUHLGHQWLILFDUHDWLSX
ULORUUHJXOLH[HPSOLILFDUHDXQHLLQWHUSUHW UL6XQWSUH]HQWDWHH[WLQGHUL
ODLQIRUPD LDFDSLWROXOXLFRQFHSWHOHFDUDFWHULVWLFHXQWHVWGHHYDOXDUH
DFXQRúWLQ HORUúLUHIHULQ HOHELEOLRJUDILFH
7HRULDOXL&*-XQJSULYLQGWLSRORJLDGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
&RPSOHPHQWDUDERUG ULLSHUVRQDOLW LLSULQSULVPDWU V WXULORUVDX
GLPHQVLXQLORUGHED] FXQRDúWHUHDSVLKLVPXOXLXPDQSRDWHILUHDOL]DW
SHPRGHOXOWLSRORJLFvQFDUHDVSHFWXOFHQWUDOHVWHLQWHUDF LXQHDVSHFLILF
FX SUHVXSXQHUHD VXELDFHQW F ILHFDUH LQGLYLG UHSUH]LQW R HFKLOLEUDUH
VSHFLILF DXQRUWLSXULGHVWUXFWXULGHED] ([LVW QXPHURDVHWLSRORJLL
XQHOH FX LPSDFW GLUHFW DVXSUD SVLKRGLDJQR]HL ILHFDUH FX XQ VLVWHP GH
FDWHJRULDOL]DUH SRUQLQG GH OD SUHVXSXQHUHD GH ED] F H[LVW PRGHOH
FRHUHQWHGHFRPSRUWDPHQWUHVSHFWLYVWLOXULGHDF LXQHFDUHVXQWVXILFLHQW
GHVWDELOHSHQWUXDSHUPLWHRFODVLILFDUHDSHUVRDQHORUGHDOXQJXODFHVWRU
WLSXUL$FHDVW SUHVXSXQHUHDDYXWYDORDUHHXULVWLF vQSVLKRORJLDSHUVR
QDOLW LL úL LPSOLFLW vQ SVLKRORJLD FOLQLF HGXFD LRQDO VDX VRFLDO úL D
FRQGXVODFRQVWUXLUHDXQRULQVWUXPHQWHGHHYDOXDUHSVLKRORJLF VSHFLILFH
$VWIHO H[LVW GLYHUVH WLSRORJLL SULYLQG WHPSHUDPHQWXO úL LQVWUX
PHQWHOHFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHFRQVWUXLWHGLQDFHVWJHQGHDERUG ULFRQVWL
WX LRQDOH SVLKRQHXURHQGRFULQH vQ IXQF LH GH FDUDFWHULVWLFL DOH DFWL
YLW LLQHUYRDVHVXSHULRDUHvQIXQF LHGHSURSHQVLXQHDVSUHH[FLWDUHúL
ULVF HWF 6XQW DXWRUL FDUH DX PRGHODW WLSRORJLL SRVLELOH vQ IXQF LH GH
RULHQWDUHD YDORULF JHQHUDO 'H OD .UHWVFKPHU DX U PDV vQ
OLWHUDWXU FODVLILF UL ED]DWH SH FULWHULXO FRQVWLWX LH FRUSRUDO DVRFLDW
XQHLSUHGLVSR]L LLSVLKRSDWRORJLFH7LSRORJLDVDLQFOXGHFDWLSXULGLV
WLQFWH SLFQLFXO DVWHQLFXO DWOHWLFXO úL GLVSODVWLFXO 'LQWUH úFROLOH FHOH
PDLVHPQLILFDWLYHSHQWUXSVLKRORJLDQRUPDOLW LLYRPSUH]HQWDDVSHFWH
SULYLQGWHRULDWLSRORJLF MXQJLDQ
$XWRUXO&*-XQJGHVFULHúLDGXFHDUJXPHQWHHPSLULFHSULYLQG
H[LVWHQ D úL GLQDPLFD XQHL WLSRORJLL vQ FDUH VH SXQH vQ MRF R YL]LXQH
VWUXFWXUDO DVXSUDSVLKLFXOXL
&DUO*XVWDY-XQJ±
3VLKLDWUXúLSVLKRORJHOYH LDQvQWHPHLHWRUDOSVLKR
ORJLHLDQDOLWLFHúLDOPRGHOXOXLGHDQDOL] GHSURIXQ]LPH
úLSVLKRWHUDSLHFDUHvLSRDUW QXPHOH
,QWURGXFH vQ YL]LXQHD VD VWUXFWXUDO úL GLQDPLF
DVXSUD SVLKLFXOXL LQVWDQ D GHQXPLW LQFRQúWLHQW FROHFWLY
SUHFXPúLGRFXPHQWHD] úWLLQ LILFUHOHYDQ DSVLKRORJLF D
XQRUIRUPD LXQLSVLKLFHSUHFXPDUKHWLSXULOHFRPSOH[HOH
HWFSUHFXPúLPRGDOLW LGLQDPLFHGHIXQF LRQDUHSUHFXP
LQGLYLGXDUHDIXQF LDVLPEROLF HWF6HGLIHUHQ LD] QHWGH
SVLKDQDOL]DIUHXGLDQ SULQDPSORDUHDYL]LXQLLVDOHúLSULQ
DFFHQWXO SXV SH VHQVXO YLH LL XPDQH úL SH GH]YROWDUHD
FRQúWLLQ HL
([LVW PDL PXOWH QLYHOH SVLKLFH SVLKLFXO FRQúWLHQW SVLKLFXO
LQFRQúWLHQW SHUVRQDO úL PDWULFHD GH ED] IRUPDWLY VDX SVLKLVPXO
LQFRQúWLHQWXOXLDUKHWLSDOÌQGLQDPLFDGLQWUHFHOHWUHLLQVWDQ HLQWHUYLQ
FRPSOHPHQWDU DVSHFWH GLVWLQFWH FDUH SHUPLW R YL]LXQH WLSRORJLF
DVXSUDSHUVRQDOLW LLXPDQH
$VWIHO LQWHUYLQH PRGXO vQ FDUH VH RULHQWHD] HXO FRQúWLHQW vQ
UDSRUWFXOXPHDúLFRPSOHPHQWDUID GHRULHQWDUHDLQFRQúWLHQWXOXLúLGH
DVHPHQHDLQWHUYLQHIHOXOúLP VXUDvQFDUHHXOvúLGH]YROW úLVW SkQHúWH
vQUDSRUWXULOHFXUHDOXOFHOHSDWUXIXQF LLSRVLELOHGHFXQRDúWHUHGRX UD
LRQDOHIXQF LDORJLF úLIXQF LDYDORULF VDXDIHFWLY úLGRX LUD LRQDOH
UHVSHFWLYIXQF LDVHQ]RULDO úLIXQF LDLQWXL LHL'HH[HPSOXvQVLWXD LDvQ
FDUHvQSODQXOFRQúWLHQWDOSVLKLVPXOXLH[LVW RSUHGRPLQDQW RULHQWDUH
VSUH OXPHD H[WHULRDU YRUELP GH H[WUDYHUVLD HXOXL úL D IXQF LHL SUHIH
UHQ LDOHRULFDUHDUILDFHDVWD'HDVHPHQHDFRPSOHPHQWDURQWRJHQHWLF
VHYDGH]YROWDRDGRXDIXQF LHVHFXQGDU FDUHYDDYHDvQV RRULHQWDUH
LQWURYHUW SHQWUX D SHUPLWH DFFHVXO HXOXL úL vQVSUH DOWH ]RQH &RPSOH
PHQWDUvQLQFRQúWLHQWVHPDQLIHVW LQWURYHUVLDúLFHOHODOWHIXQF LLU PDVH
UHFHVLYHúLQHVRFLDOL]DWH
7HRULDWLSXULORUSRUQHúWHGHODGDWHOHHPSLULFHFDUHLQGLF RSUH
GLVSR]L LHDLQGLYL]LORUVSUHDSUHIHUDRDQXPLW DWLWXGLQHúLRDQXPLW
IXQF LHGHFXQRDúWHUHFDUHSULQH[HUVDUHFRQGXFHODXQVHQWLPHQWGH
ÄFRPSHWHQ SHUVRQDO LDU vQW ULUHD VXFFHVXOXL VH JHQHUDOL]HD] úL
SHQWUXDOWH]RQHGHDFWLYLWDWHFDUHVHUH]ROY SULQLPSOLFDUHDDFHORUDúL
DELOLW L $FHDVW GLQDPLF FRQGXFH WUHSWDW OD GHILQLUHD XQRU WU V WXUL
GH VXSUDID GHSULQGHUL úL FRPSRUWDPHQWH DVRFLDWH DFHVWHL IXQF LL ÌQ
DFHVW FRQWH[W WLSRORJLD MXQJLDQ GHVFULH UHDF LL úL SUHIHULQ H FXUHQWH
DVSHFWHIRUWHúLDVSHFWHOLPLWDWLYHSHQWUXWLSXULSULQFLSDOHvQIXQF LH
GHRULHQWDUHDúLIXQF LDGRPLQDQW ODQLYHOXOHXOXLFRQúWLHQWLQWURYHUW
VHQ]RULDO H[WUDYHUW VHQ]RULDO LQWURYHUW LQWXLWLY H[WUDYHUW LQWXLWLY
LQWURYHUW ORJLF H[WUDYHUW ORJLF LQWURYHUW DIHFWLY H[WUDYHUW DIHFWLY FI
WDEHOXOXL 6XQW GH DVHPHQHD GHVFULVH úL WLSXUL VHFXQGDUH vQ
VLWXD LD FkQG SUHIHULQ HL GRPLQDWH L VH DGDXJ IXQF LD VHFXQGDU 2
GHVFULHUH PDL H[WLQV DSDUH vQ 0 0LQXOHVFX ,QWURGXFHUH vQ DQDOL]D
MXQJLDQ
7DEHOXO'HVFULHUHDFHORUWLSXULSVLKRORJLFHED]DOH
'HQXPLUHDWLSXOXL 'HVFULHUHDEUHYLDW
7LSXOJkQGLUHH[WUDYHUW (7 3HUVRDQHFDUHWU LHVFvQFRQFRUGDQ FXUH
JXOLSUHFLVHWLQGV úLUHSULPHVHQWLPHQWHOH
úL HPR LLOH SHQWUX D U PkQH RELHFWLYL GDU
FD XUPDUH WLQG úL VSUH GRJPDWLVP vQ JkQ
GLUHúLRSLQLL
7LSXODIHFWLYH[WUDYHUW() 3HUVRDQHOH GH DFHVW JHQ UHSULP DQDOL]D
ORJLF úLWLQGV HYDOXH]HSUHSRQGHUHQWGLQ
SULVPDYDORULLDIHFWLYHVHFRQIRUPHD] YD
ORULORURELFHLXULORUúLWUDGL LLORUvQFDUHVDX
IRUPDW(PSDWLFLúLGHRVHELWGHVHQVLELOLOD
H[SHFWD LLOHúLRSLQLLOHDOWRUD
7LSXOVHQ]RULDOH[WUDYHUW(6 6H FHQWUHD] SH LQIRUPD LLOH VHQ]RULDOH
FDXW QRLVHQ]D LLúLH[SHULHQ H7LQGV ILH
RULHQWD L úL OHJD L GH UHDOLWDWHD LPHGLDW
WU LW úLVHSRWDGDSWDFXXúXULQ ODVLWXD LL
úLRDPHQL
7LSXOLQWXLWLYH[WUDYHUW(1 $XRFDSDFLWDWHDFXW GHDVLP LúLH[SORDWD
RSRUWXQLW LOH FHHD FH vL DMXW vQ SROLWLF
VDXDIDFHULVXQWDWUDúLGHLGHLQRLúLWLQGV
VH PDQLIHVWH FUHDWLY GDU úL V LQVSLUH SH
DO LLVSUHUHDOL] ULúLUHXúLWH
'HQXPLUHDWLSXOXL 'HVFULHUHDEUHYLDW
7LSXOJkQGLUHLQWURYHUW ,7 3HUVRDQHOH QX VH GHVFXUF ELQH vQ UHOD LLOH
LQWHUXPDQH DX GLILFXOW L vQ FRPXQLFDUHD
LGHLORUSURSULLúLGDXDSDUHQ DGHU FHDO úL
OLSV GH FRQVLGHUD LH SHQWUX FHLODO L DX R
FDSDFLWDWHGHDF LXQHSUDFWLF LQHILFLHQW
7LSXODIHFWLYLQWURYHUW,) 7U LHVF PDL DOHV vQ SODQXO H[SHULHQ HORU
DIHFWLYHúLDOYDORULORUDIHFWLYHSHFDUHúLOH
FRQVWUXLHVF vQ SODQ LQWHULRU GLQ DIDU SDU
PLVWHULRúLúLLQDFFHVLELOLúLWLQGV ILHW FX L
PRGHúWLFXSX LQ FRQVLGHUD LHSHQWUXVHQ
WLPHQWHOHFHORUODO L
7LSXOVHQ]RULDOLQWURYHUW,6 3HUVRDQHSUHGRPLQDQWLUD LRQDOHFDUHWU LHVF
UHODWLYGHWDúDWHGHYLD DGHILHFDUH]LSULYHVF
PDMRULWDWHD DFWLYLW LORU XPDQH FX EHQHYR
OHQ úLDPX]DPHQWGDUVXQWIRDUWHVHQVLELOL
vQSODQHVWHWLFVHFHQWUHD] SHSURSULLOHVHQ
]D LLUHSULP LQWXL LD
7LSXOLQWXLWLYLQWURYHUW,1 3HUVRDQH FDUH VH FHQWUHD] SXWHUQLF SH
SURSULLOH LQWXL LL GDU DX SX LQ FRQWDFW FX
UHDOLWDWHD SUDFWLF 6XQW YL]LRQDUL YLVHD]
ÄFXRFKLLGHVFKLúL´6XQWJUHXGHvQ HOHVGH
FHL GLQ MXU úL XQHRUL OH DSDU DFHVWRUD FD
FLXGD LúLH[FHQWULFL
&X DOWH FXYLQWH ILHFDUH SHUVRDQ vQ PRG QDWXUDO YD GHYHQL
UHODWLYGLIHUHQ LDW vQWURDQXPLW DULHúLQHGLIHUHQ LDW vQDOWHDULLDOH
IXQF LRQ ULL SVLKLFH vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH ÄKRPHRVWD]LD YLH LL FRWLGLHQH
GHWHUPLQ LQGLYLGXO V úL FDQDOL]H]H LQWHUHVHOH úL HQHUJLLOH VSUH DFHOH
DFWLYLW LFDUHvLGDXúDQVDFHDPDLPDUHGHDúLXWLOL]DPLQWHDvQPRGXO
SHFDUHvOSUHIHU 'HH[HPSOXFHLFDUHSUHIHU V úLWU LDVF YLD DPDL
DOHVSULQLQWHUPHGLXOVHQ]RULDOXOXLúLDXGLIHUHQ LDWSUHIHUHQ LDODFHVWH
SURFHVH LQGLYLGXO GHYHQLQG vQ WLPS XQ DFXW REVHUYDWRU DO UHDOLW LL
LPHGLDWH3HP VXU FHVHGH]YROW SHUVRDQDvúLYDGH]YROWDúLDFHOH
FDUDFWHULVWLFL FDUH VXQW FRQVXEVWDQ LDOH XQHL RULHQW UL VSUH VHQ]RULDO
GHFL UHDOLVPXO VSLULWXO SUDFWLF VLP XO FRPXQ HWF $WHQ LD VD YD IL
FDQDOL]DW GLQ FH vQ FH PDL PXOW VSUH VSHFLILFXO PHGLXOXL úL vúL YD
FKHOWXLGLQFHvQFHPDLSX LQWLPSúLHQHUJLHSHQWUXDXWLOL]DúLGH]
YROWDúLIXQF LDGLDPHWUDORSXV UHVSHFWLYLQWXL LDODIHOFHQWUDUHDSH
SUH]HQWvLG SX LQ HQHUJLHSHQWUXDVHIRFDOL]DúLSHYLLWRUFHQWUDUHD
SHFRQFUHWvLG SX LQ HQHUJLHGLVSRQLELO SHQWUXDEVWUDFWFHQWUDUHDSH
UHDO vO vQGHS UWHD] GH OD LPDJLQDU FHQWUDUHD SH DSOLFD LL SUDFWLFH vO
vQGHS UWHD] GHODSUHRFXS ULWHRUHWLFHHWF
,QYHQWDUXOWLSRORJLF0\HUV%ULJJVIRUPD*
0\HUV%ULJJV7\SH,QGLFDWRU,QGLFDWRUXOWLSRORJLF0\HUV%ULJJV
0%7,HVWHXQFKHVWLRQDUGHHYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLFUHDWGH.DWKHULQH
%ULJJVúL,VDEHO0\HUVPDP úLILLF FDUHDXSOHFDWvQFHUFHW ULOHORUGH
OD WHRULD MXQJLDQ D WLSXULORU SVLKRORJLFH 5H]XOWDWHOH 0%7, VXUSULQG
GLIHUHQ H YDORURDVH vQWUH LQGLYL]LL QRUPDOL FKHVWLRQDUXO VH DGUHVHD]
SHUVRQDOLW LLQRUPDOHúLQXHVWHFRQFHSXWFDXQWHVWFOLQLF
,QGLFDWRUXOWLSRORJLF0\HUV%ULJJVDIRVWSXEOLFDWvQ7HVWXO
HVWHODUJIRORVLWDWkWvQFHUFHWDUHFkWúLvQSVLKRORJLDDSOLFDW
6DXFRQVWUXLWúLSXEOLFDWFLQFLYDULDQWHIRUPD)GHLWHPL
IRUPD*LWHPLRIRUP DEUHYLDW GHDXWRHYDOXDUHIRUPD$9
LWHPL IRUPD 007,& 0XUSK\0HVJHLHU 7\SH ,QGLFDWRU &KLOGUHQ GH
LWHPLFDUHHVWHRYDULDQW SHQWUXFRSLLúLFHDPDLUHFHQW IRUPD0
GH LWHPL SXEOLFDW vQ FD UH]XOWDW DO FHUFHW ULORU FHORU GH OD
&RQVXOWLQJ3V\FKRORJLVWV3UHVV$FHDVW XOWLP IRUP DIRVWUHDOL]DW vQ
VFRSXOvPEXQ W LULLIRUPHL*
)RUPHOH FRPSOHWH ) úL * FRQ LQ DWkW LWHPL FDUH HYDOXHD]
SURSULX]LVWLSXOFkWúLLWHPLGHFHUFHWDUH,WHPLLVXQWDSURDSHLGHQWLFL
SHQWUX ) úL * GDU vQ YDULDQWD * VXQW UHDUDQMD L DVWIHO FD DFHL LWHPL
FDUH DX R YDOLGLWDWH SUHGLFWLY PD[LP V DSDU OD vQFHSXW FUHVFkQG
DVWIHOSRVLELOLWDWHDFDVXELHFWXOFDUHQXDMXQJHV WHUPLQHFKHVWLRQDUXO
V U VSXQG WRWXúLODLWHPLLFHLPDLSHUWLQHQ L
)RUPD*HVWHIRUPDVWDQGDUGD0%7,LDUIRUPD)HVWHUHFRPDQ
GDW SHQWUXFRQVLOLHUHVDXFHUFHWDUH
,QGLFDWRUXOGHWLSXUL0\HUV%ULJJVHVWHXQLQVWUXPHQWGHHYDOXDUH
DSHUVRQDOLW LLOHJDWGHSVLKRORJLDDQDOLWLF DOXL&DUO*-XQJYL]kQG
WLSRORJLDGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHFRQVWUXLW GHDOXQJXOGLQDPLFLLGLQWUHDWLWX
GLQHD H[WUDYHUW úL FHD LQWURYHUW GLQWUH HXO FRQúWLHQW úL FRQ LQXWXULOH
LQFRQúWLHQWHúLDFHORUSDWUXWLSXULGHIXQF LLGHFXQRDúWHUH$FHVWHDGLQ
XUP VXQWGRX UD LRQDOHúLGRX LUD LRQDOHvQWHUPHQLLSURSULL0%7,
ÄSHUFHSWLYH´
&HOHUD LRQDOHVHUHIHU ODIDSWXOF LQIRUPD LDHVWHUD LRQDOL]DW
úL IRORVLW SHQWUX D OXD GHFL]LL VDX SHQWUX IRUPDUHD RSLQLLORU úL HOH
VXQWIXQF LDORJLF UHVSHFWLYJkQGLUHDFDORJRVúLIXQF LDDIHF
WLY VDXHYDOXDUHDUHOD LHLGLQWUHHXúLRELHFW
&HOHODOWHGRX IXQF LLLUD LRQDOHVHQXPHVFÄLUD LRQDOH´GHRDUHFH
DFHVWHIXQF LLVHDXWRUHJOHD] GXS FXUVXOHYHQLPHQWHORUúLRSHUHD] FHO
PDL FRUHFW VL FRHUHQW DWXQFL FkQG QX VXQW FRQVWUkQVH GH GLUHFWLYH
UD LRQDOH'HH[HPSOXWHKQLFDPRGHUQ DEUDLQVWRUPLQJXOXLXWLOL]HD]
LQWXL LDvQVHQVXOSUHVFULVWHUPHQXOXLGH-XQJFDIXQF LHÄLUD LRQDO ´ÌQ
WLPSXO úHGLQ HORU GH EUDLQVWRUPLQJ LQVSLUD LD HVWH vQFXUDMDW V FXUJ
OLEHU I U FRQVWUkQJHULOH FULWLFLORU VDX HYDOX ULL UD LRQDOH ÌQ WHRULD
DQDOLWLF úLvQFDGUXO0%7,DFHVWHGRX IXQF LLLUD LRQDOHVXQWIXQF LD
VHQ]RULDO OHJDW GHLQIRUPD LLOHGHWLSSHUFHSWLYúLIXQF LDLQWXLWLY
FDUHDSDUvQFkPSXOFRQúWLLQ HLúLVXQWOHJDWHGHFXSULQGHUHDXQHLVLWXD LL
FDvQWUHJ
'LQ H[SHULHQ UH]XOW F HVWH LPSRVLELO FD WRDWH IXQF LLOH V VH
GH]YROWHvQPRGHJDO)XQF LDFDUHvQSURFHVXOGHGLIHUHQ LHUHU PkQH
FHO PDL vQ XUP HVWH QXPLW GH -XQJ ÄIXQF LH LQIHULRDU ÌQVHúL H[L
JHQ HOHVRFLDOHIDFFDXQLQGLYLGV úLGH]YROWHPDLPXOWDFHDIXQF LH
SHQWUX FDUH HVWH vQGHRVHEL GRWDW vQ PRG QDWXUDO úL VDX FDUH vL RIHU
LQVWUXPHQWHSHQWUXVXFFHVXOV XVRFLDO&HOPDLDGHVHDQHLGHQWLILF P
PDLPXOWVDXPDLSX LQFRPSOHWFXIXQF LDFHDPDLSULYLOHJLDW úLGH
DFHHDFHDPDLGH]YROWDW $LFLvúLDXRULJLQHDWLSXULOHSVLKRORJLFH
7HRULD WLSXULORU SOHDF GH OD LGHHD F RDPHQLL VXQW Q VFX L FX R
SUHGLVSR]L LH SHQWUX SUHIHUDUHD XQHL DQXPLWH IXQF LL vQ ID D FHORUODOWH
8WLOL]DUHDFRQWLQX úLFRQVWDQW DIXQF LHLSUHIHUDWHFRQVWLWXLHXQVWLPXO
úLPRWLYDWRUSXWHUQLFSHQWUXDDYHDvQFUHGHUHúLDVHDWDúDUHVSHFWLYXOXL
PRGGHDSULYLOXPHDÌQWLPSFHDUHORFGH]YROWDUHDXQHLIXQF LLSUH
IHUDWH H[LVW R UHODWLY QHJOLMDUH D SROXOXL RSXV DFHOHL SUHIHULQ H ÌQ
DFHDVW ID] GHH[HPSOXXQFRSLOFHSUHIHU vQPRGQDWXUDORSHUFHS LH
VHQ]RULDO úL XQ FRSLO FH SUHIHU R SHUFHS LH LQWXLWLY VH YRU GH]YROWD
GHD OXQJXO XQRU OLQLL HYROXWLYH GLYHUJHQWH 3HQWUX ILHFDUH WLS GRX
GLQWUHFHOHSDWUXIXQF LLDOHOXL-XQJVXQWPDLLQWHUHVDQWHúLGHFLHVWHPDL
SRVLELO V ILH GH]YROWDWH úL IRORVLWH vQ PRG FRQúWLHQW &HOHODOWH IXQF LL
PDLSX LQSUHIHUDWHVXQWFRQVLGHUDWHPDLSX LQDGHFYDWHúLVXQWGHFHOH
PDL PXOWH RUL QHJOLMDWH 'H RELFHL vQ WLQHUH H HVWH GH]YROWDW SULPD
IXQF LHFHDÄGRPLQDQW úLFRPSOHPHQWDUHLRDGRXDÄDX[LOLDUD´ÌQ
WLPSXOYLH LLGHDGXOWLQGLYL]LLFDS W PDLPXOWVDXPDLSX LQFRQWUROúL
DVXSUDFHORUODOWHGRX IXQF LLPDLSX LQSUHIHUDWH
)RORVLUHD RSWLP D FHORU SDWUX IXQF LL QX WUHEXLH úL QX VH SRDWH
RE LQHSULQHJDOL]DUHFLSULQGH]YROWDUHDVHOHFWLY DILHF UHLDvQSDUWH
'H]YROWDUHDFRHUHQW vQSODQXOGH]YROW ULLFDSDFLW LLHXOXLGHD
OHXWLOL]DFRQúWLHQWDUQHFHVLWDvQFRQFOX]LHSHUIHF LRQDUHDvQSURFHVXO
IDYRULW GRPLQDQW GH]YROWDUHD DGHFYDW GDU QX HJDO D SURFHVXOXL
DX[LOLDUDGPLWHUHDHYHQWXDO DSURFHVHORUPDLSX LQGH]YROWDWHSHQWUX
IRORVLUHDORUFRQúWLHQW úLXWLO vQVHUYLFLXOSURFHVXOXLGRPLQDQWFKLDU
GDF DFHDVWD DU QHFHVLWD FD SURFHVXO GRPLQDQW úL FHO DX[LOLDU V
ÄSUHGHD´WHPSRUDUFRQWUROXOFRQúWLHQWXOXLSUHFXPúLFDSDFLWDWHDGHD
IRORVLILHFDUHIXQF LHSHQWUXVDUFLQLOHODFDUHVHSUHWHD] FHOPDLELQH
$WLWXGLQLOH([WUDYHUVLD(VL,QWURYHUVLD,
3UHIHULQ D-3
&HDPDLPDUHSDUWHD7LSXULORUSVLKRORJLFHDOXL-XQJHVWH
FRQVDFUDW LVWRULHLúLGHVFULHULLH[WUDYHUVLHLúLLQWURYHUVLHL$FHVWHDVXQW
Y ]XWH FD DWLWXGLQL FRPSOHPHQWDUH VDX FD RULHQW UL FRPSOHPHQWDUH vQ
UDSRUWFXYLD D
-XQJ D GHVFULV RULHQWDUHD H[WUDYHUVLH YHUVXV LQWURYHUVLH (,
SUHFXP úL IXQF LLOH FRPSOHPHQWDUH VHQ]RULDOLWDWH LQWXL LH 61 úL
JkQGLUHDIHFWLYLWDWH 7) vQ PRG H[SOLFLW vQ RSHUHOH VDOH /D QLYHOXO
WHVWXOXL0%7,DO WXULGHRULHQWDUHDVSUHOXPHDH[WHULRDU H[WUDYHUVLH
úLGHRULHQWDUHDVSUHOXPHDLQWHULRDU LQWURYHUVLHFRQIRUP-XQJHVWH
GHVFULV úLFRPSOHPHQWDULWDWHD-3$FHDVWDUHSUH]LQW RULHQWDUHDSUHGL
OHFW VSUHUD LRQDOLWDWHVDXRULHQWDUHDMXGLFDWLY -GHODÄMXGJHPHQW´
UD LXQH úL UHVSHFWLY RULHQWDUHD SUHGLOHFW VSUH QRQUD LRQDO VDX
SHUFHS LH3GHODÄSHUFHSWLRQ´
3UHIHULQ D -3 DúD FXP HVWH UH LQXW vQ IRUPXOD WLSRORJLF DUH
GRX XWLOLW LÌQSULPXOUkQGGHVFULHDWLWXGLQLúLFRPSRUWDPHQWHID GH
OXPHDvQFRQMXU WRDUHUHODWLYVWDELOHLGHQWLILFDELOHODXQPDUHQXP UGH
LQGLYL]L ÌQ DO GRLOHD UkQG HVWH IRORVLW vQ FRQMXQF LH FX (, SHQWUX D
VWDELOLFDUHGLQWUHFHOHGRX IXQF LLSUHIHUDWHHVWHFHDGRPLQDQW úLFDUH
HVWH FHD DX[LOLDU $FHDVW UHFXQRDúWHUH D SRWHQ LDOLW LL IXQF LHL -3 úL
GH]YROWDUHDVXEVHFYHQW DWHRULHLVDOHHVWHFRQWULEX LDDGXV GH%ULJJVúL
0\HUVODWHRULDWLSXULORUSVLKRORJLFH
'HVFULHUHDVFDOHORU0%7,
&HOHSDWUXVFDOHP VXUDWHGH0%7,VXQW
(,SUHIHULQ DSHQWUXIRFDOL]DUHDDWHQ LHL([WUDYHUWLUH,QWURYHUWLUH
61 SUHIHULQ D SHQWUX DGXQDUHD LQIRUPD LHL GLQ PHGLX 6HQ]RULD
OLWDWHD,QWXL LD
7) SUHIHULQ D SHQWUX OXDUHD GHFL]LLORU *kQGLUHD ORJLF $IHFWL
YLWDWHD
-3SUHIHULQ DSHQWUXRULHQWDUHDID GHOXPHDH[WHULRDU -XGHFDWD
3HUFHS LD
6FDOD(,GHVFULHPRGXOFXPHVWHRULHQWDW HQHUJLDODGLVSR]L LDHXOXL
([WUDYHUW
&HLFDUHSUHIHU H[WUDYHUVLDWLQGV úLIL[H]HDWHQ LDF WUHOXPHD
H[WHULRDU úLF WUHPHGLXOH[WHULRU([WUDYHU LLVXQWVWLPXOD LGHFHHDFH
VHvQWkPSO vQOXPHDGLQMXUXOORUúLWLQGV úLIRFDOL]H]HHQHUJLDF WUH
PHGLX(LSUHIHU V FRPXQLFHSULQYLXJUDLúLQXSULQVFULV6LPWQHYRLD
V H[SHULPHQWH]HOXPHDSHQWUXDRvQ HOHJHúLGHDFHHDWLQGVSUHDF LXQH
,QWURYHUW
,QWURYHU LLVXQWVWLPXOD LúLLQFLWD LGHFHHDFHVHvQWkPSO vQOX
PHDORULQWHULRDU úLDFHDVWDHVWH]RQDF WUHFDUHWLQGV úLGLUHF LRQH]H
HQHUJLD,QWURYHU LLVXQWPDLLQWHUHVD LúLPDLvQODUJXOORUDWXQFLFkQG
PXQFDVDXDFWLYLWDWHDGHVI úXUDW OHFHUHFDRPDUHSDUWHGLQWLPSV
VWHDVLQJXUL(LSUHIHU V vQ HOHDJ OXPHDvQDLQWHGHDRH[SHULPHQWD
úLDVWIHOvQDLQWHGHDDF LRQDDGHVHDPHGLWHD] ODFHDXGHI FXW
6FDOD61GHVFULHPRGXOFXPHVWHSHUFHSXW LQIRUPD LD
6HQ]RULDO
6LP XULOHYL]XDOúLDXGLWLYvQSULQFLSDOvLVSXQDFHVWXLWLSXPDQ
GHVSUHFHHDFHH[LVW ÄDFROR´RULVHvQWkPSO HIHFWLY&KLDUúLLPDJLQLOH
PHQWDOHQXVXQWYDJLPHWDIRULFHFLSOLQHGHSXWHUHGHHYRFDUHYL]XDOH
FRORUDWH JU LWRDUH 7LSXULOH VHQ]LWLYH WLQG V DFFHSWH úL V OXFUH]H FX
FHHDFHHVWHGDWÄDLFLúLDFXP´ILLQGDVWIHOUHDOLúWLúLSUDFWLFL([FHOHD] vQ
UHPHPRUDUHDúLPkQXLUHDXQXLPDUHQXP UGHIDSWHVDXGDWHFRQFUHWH
,QWXLWLY
&HDODOW FDOH GH D DIOD HVWH LQWXL LD FDUH v L GH]Y OXLH vQ HOHVXO
UHDOLW LOHúLSRVLELOLW LOHFHVHDIO GLQFRORGHLQIRUPD LDWUDQVPLV GH
VLP XUL ,QWXL LD FHUFHWHD] DQVDPEOXO úL FDXW V GHVFRSHUH FHHD FH
HVWHHVHQ LDO'DF SUHIHULLQWXL LDGHYLLH[SHUWvQGHVFRSHULUHDGHQRL
SRVLELOLW LúLF LGHDIDFHOXFUXULOH7LSXOLQWXLWLYDSUHFLD] LPDJLQD LD
úLLQVSLUD LD
6FDOD 7) LQGLF IHOXO FXP LHL GHFL]LL 6FDOD 7) HVWH VLQJXUD VFDO
FDUHVHFRWHD] GLIHUHQ LDWvQIXQF LHGHVH[XOVXELHFWXOXL
/RJLFUD LRQDO
2GDW GREkQGLW LQIRUPD LD SULQWUXQD GLQ F LOH SHUFHSWLYH HD
WUHEXLHIRORVLW 7LSXULOHÄ7´IRORVHVFJkQGLUHDFDPHWRG FRQFOXVLY
SUH]LFkQG FRQVHFLQ HOH ORJLFH DOH XQHL DOHJHUL VSHFLILFH VDX DOH XQXL
DFWSDUWLFXODU&kQGIRORVHúWLJkQGLUHDGHFL]LvQPRGRELHFWLYSHED]D
FDX]HLúLHIHFWXOXLLHLGHFL]LDDQDOL]kQGúLFkQW ULQGGRYH]LOHLQFOXVLY
UHDOLW LOH QHSO FXWH 2DPHQLL FH SUHIHU JkQGLUHD FDXW XQ VWDQGDUG
RELHFWLY DO DGHY UXOXL (L H[FHOHD] DGHVHD vQ DQDOL]D VLWXD LLORU GH
FUL] RUL FDUH FHU DGDSWDELOLWDWH P ULW GDU QX vQ FD]XULOH vQ FDUH VH
PDQLIHVW VLWXD LLDPELJXH
$IHFWLY
7LSXULOHÄ)´IRORVHVFDIHFWLYLWDWHDFDPHWRG FRQFOXVLY ÌQDFHVW
IHO WLSXULOH Ä)´ LDX vQ FRQVLGHUDUH FHHD FH HVWH LPSRUWDQW SHQWUX HL úL
SHQWUX FHL GLQ MXU I U V SUHWLQG F DFHVW OXFUX HVWH úL ORJLF $FHúWL
RDPHQLSUHIHU V GHYLQ HPSDWLFLIDYRUDELOLúLSOLQLGHWDFWvQGHFL]LLOH
ORU(VWHLPSRUWDQWGHvQ HOHVF WHUPHQXOÄDIHFWLYLWDWH´VHIRORVHúWHvQ
DFHVW FRQWH[W FX VHQVXO GH ÄGHFL]LL OXDWH SH ED] GH YDORUL´ úL QX VH
UHIHU ODVHQWLPHQWHVDXHPR LLvQVLQH
6FDOD -3 LPSOLF U VSXQVXO OD SUREOHPD PRGXOXL FXP DERUGH]L
UD LRQDO VDX LUD LRQDO GDWHOH GH LQIRUPD LH DVXSUD UHDOLW LL LQWHULRDUH
VDXH[WHULRDUH"
5D LRQDOWUDGXVXQHRULFDÄMXGLFDWLY´
$FHDVW VFDO GHVFULHVWLOXOGHYLD SHFDUHvODGRS LvQFRQIUXQ
WDUHDFXOXPHDH[WHULRDU úLPRGDOLW LOHSULQFDUHWHRULHQWH]LvQUHOD LH
FXHD'LKRWRPLDGHVFULV DLFLVHED]HD] SHGRX GLQVFDOHOHDQWHULRDUH
vQ UHOD LRQDUHD FX PHGLXO ILH SUHIHUL R DWLWXGLQH ED]DW SH HYDOXDUH
FRQúWLHQW úLSHFRQFOX]LLSURSULLLQGLIHUHQWGDF HOHVXQWUD LRQDOORJLFH
RULDIHFWLYYDORULFHILHSUHIHULRDWLWXGLQHQRQUD LRQDO ED]DW SHSHU
FHS LH VHQ]RULDO VDX LQWXLWLY &HL FDUH SUHIHU R DWLWXGLQH UD LRQDO
WLQG V WU LDVF vQ PRG RUGRQDW SODQLILFDW V úL UHJOH]H úL FRQWUROH]H
YLD D(LSUHIHU V S VWUH]HÄIUkQHOH´VLWXD LHLSUHIHU V LDGHFL]LL6XQW
RUJDQL]D LúLVWUXFWXUD LúLYRUFDOXFUXULOHV úLXUPH]HFDOHDSODQLILFDW
V ILHELQHVWDELOLWH
3HUFHSWLY
&HL FDUH SUHIHU SURFHVXO SHUFHSWLY ILH SULQ VHQ]RULDOLWDWH ILH
SULQLQWXL LHSUHIHU V WU LDVF vQWUXQPRGIOH[LELOúLVSRQWDQ3UHIHU
V úL WU LDVF YLD D PDL GHJUDE GHFkW V R vQ HOHDJ VDX FRQWUROH]H
U PkQGHVFKLúLH[SHULHQ HLEXFXUkQGXVHGHHDúLDYkQGvQFUHGHUHvQ
DELOLWDWHDORUGHDVHDGDSWDPRPHQWXOXL
)XQF LDGRPLQDQW
'LQWUHFHOHSDWUXIXQF LLVHQ]RULDO LQWXLWLY ORJLF DIHFWLY
GRX VXQWSUHIHUDWHGHRDUHFHVXQWPDLGH]YROWDWH'DUGLQWUHFHOHGRX
XQDHVWHPDLSXWHUQLF HVWHIXQF LDFHDPDLGH]YROWDW IXQF LDQXP UXO
XQX(VWHIXQF LDFDUHU VSXQGHSULPDFkQGWHDIOLvQID DXQHLLQIRUPD LL
QRL $ELD GXS DFHHD U VSXQGH D GRXD IXQF LH DX[LOLDU /D FHD GHD
WUHLDúLDSDWUDIXQF LHRSXVHFHORUGRX VHDMXQJHPDLJUHXGDUHOHvQ
SULQFLSLXSRWILDFFHVDWHFRQúWLHQWIRUPDWHúLXWLOL]DELOH±FKLDUGDF SH
WHUPHQPDLVFXUW
)XQF LDGRPLQDQW ILLQGFHDPDLGH]YROWDW QHHVWHúLFHDPDL
IDPLOLDU
)XQF LD GRPLQDQW VH PDQLIHVW GLIHULW OD H[WUDYHUWL L úL OD
LQWURYHUWL L3HQWUXSULPLLHDHVWHXWLOL]DW vQVSUHDIDU VSUHUHDOLWDWHD
GLQMXUDLFLúLDFXPÌQVFKLPEODLQWURYHU LIXQF LDSUHIHUHQ LDO HVWH
PHQLW FRQVWUXLULL UHDOLW LL LQWHULRDUH FHD PDL EXQ D LQWURYHUWL LORU
HVWHvQ XQWUXDVFXQV
7HPSHUDPHQWXO
&HUFHW ULOH DVXSUD WLSXOXL HIHFWXDWH GH 'U 'DYLG .HLUVH\ VL
0DULO\Q %DWHV OD 8QLYHUVLWDWHD GLQ &DOLIRUQLD DUDW F DQXPLWH FRP
ELQD LLGHOLWHUHVXQWDWkWGHVWUkQVOHJDWHvQWUHHOHvQFkWS VWUDUHDDGRX
OLWHUH SHQWUX XQ WLS GHYLQH GH OD VLQH vQ HOHDV .HLUVH\ úL %DWHV DX
FRQVWDWDW F D GRXD OLWHU vQ WLSXO LQGLYLGXDO GHWHUPLQ WHPSHUDPHQWXO
V X 'DF D GRXD OLWHU SHQWUX R SHUVRDQ HVWH 6 DWXQFL XUP WRDUHD
OLWHU LPSRUWDQW SHQWUX HYDOXDUHD WHPSHUDPHQWXOXL HVWH RUL - RUL 3
'DF D GRXD OLWHU HVWH 1 DWXQFL XUP WRDUHD OLWHU LPSRUWDQW vQ HYD
OXDUHHVWHRUL7RUL)
7LSXULGHWHPSHUDPHQWH
6- VHQ]RULDO úL UD LRQDO VDX WHPSHUDPHQWXO HSLPHWHDQ VDX
ÄJDUGLDQ´ &RPELQD LD JHQHUHD] XQ GH]YROWDW VLP DO GDWRULHL 3HU
VRDQHOH FX DFHVWH OLWHUH VXQW DúH]DWH DVFXOW WRDUH úL vQ SULPXO UkQG
GRUHVF V ILH GH IRORV JUXSXULORU VRFLDOH F URUD OH DSDU LQ 6H VLPW FHO
PDL ELQH FkQG DX REOLJD LL YRU V ILH FHL FDUH SRDUW GH JULM vQWUHJLL
OXPL6HVLPWPDLELQHDWXQFLFkQGGDXGHFkWDWXQFLFkQGSULPHVF)LLQG
FHL PDL UHVSRQVDELOL GLQWUH FHOH SDWUX WHPSHUDPHQWH GHVHRUL GHYLQ
FRORDQDYHUWHEUDO DPDMRULW LLLQVWLWX LLORUIDPLOLHELVHULF FRUSRUD LL
FOXEXULE QFLúLQD LXQH'HH[HPSOX6-FXSULQGHDSUR[LPDWLYGLQ
SRSXOD LD68$úLVXQWFXQRVFX LFDWUDGL LRQDOLúWLVDXVWDELOL]DWRUL
63 VHQ]RULDO úL SHUFHSWLY VDX WHPSHUDPHQWXO GLRQLVLDF GH
DVHPHQHDÄDUWL]DQ´&RPELQD LDJHQHUHD] XQLQWHUHVSHQWUXEXFXULLOH
YLH LLúLGLVWUDF LH63YUHDVDILHDQJDMDWLPSOLFDWV IDF FHYDDFXP
)UHFYHQWSOLFWLVL LGHXQVWDWXVTXRDGHVHDVXQWVSRQWDQLúLLPSXOVLYL
3UHIHU V OXFUH]HPDLDOHVFXVLWXD LLGHFUL] SHFDUHOHFRQGXFELQH
vQSUDFWLF SHF LELQHVWDELOLWH'HH[HPSOX63FXSULQGHDSUR[LPDWLY
GLQSRSXOD LD68$úLVXQWFXQRVFX LFDFHLFDUHUH]ROY SUREOHPH
VDXQHJRFLDWRUL
17LQWXLWLYúLORJLFVDXWHPSHUDPHQWXOSURPHWHDQGHDVHPHQHD
ÄUD LRQDO´ &RPELQD LD JHQHUHD] XQ LQWHUHV SHQWUX SXWHUH úL LQWHOHFW
(VWH FXQRVFXW SHQWUX GRULQ D VD GH SXWHUH QX QHDS UDW SXWHUH DVXSUD
RDPHQLORU FL SXWHUH DVXSUD PHGLXOXL vQFRQMXU WRU (L GRUHVF V ILH
FDSDELOL V vQ HOHDJ V FRQWUROH]H V SUH]LF úL V H[SOLFH UHDOLWDWHD
$FHDVWDIDFHGLQ17RDPHQLGHúWLLQ QDWXUDOL/HSODFHWHRULDDEVWUDFW
úL FRQVWUXLHVF SODQXUL DUKLWHFWXUDOH P UH H SHQWUX YLLWRU 'RUHVF V ILH
FXQRVFX L SHQWUX FRPSHWHQ D ORU 17 FXSULQGH DSUR[LPDWLY GLQ
SRSXOD LD68$úLVXQWFXQRVFX LGUHSWYL]LRQDUL
1) LQWXLWLY úL DIHFWLY VDX WHPSHUDPHQWXO DSRORQLDQ GH DVH
PHQHDÄLGHDOLVW´6HDIO vQF XWDUHDDXWHQWLFLW LLúLDXWRDFWXDOL] ULL
6XQWF XW WRULQDWXUDOLvQF XWDUHD6LQHOXL'RUHVFV GHYLQ DúDFXP
VXQWvQUHDOLWDWH1)HVWHFHOPDLLGHDOLVWúLURPDQWLFGLQWUHWLSXUL$X
PDUHFDSDFLWDWHGHDVFXOWDUHHPSDWLF $GHVHD1)DXRDELOLWDWHYHU
EDO GH]YROWDW 1) FXSULQGH DSUR[LPDWLY GLQ SRSXOD LD 68$ úL
VXQWFXQRVFX LGUHSWFDWDOL]DWRUL
([HPSOLILFDUH
0DWHULDOH QHFHVDUH &KHVWLRQDU IRDLD GH U VSXQV IRDLD GH
FDOFXODSURILOXOXLúLVHPQLILFD LDVFDOHORU
6FRS ,QGLFDWRUXO GH WLSXUL 0\HUV %ULJJV HVWH XQ LQVWUXPHQW GH
HYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLOHJDWGHSVLKRORJLDDQDOLWLF DOXL&DUO*-XQJ
YL]kQGWLSRORJLDGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHFRQVWUXLW GHDOXQJXOGLQDPLFLLGLQWUH
DWLWXGLQHD H[WUDYHUW úL FHD LQWURYHUW úL D FHORU SDWUX IXQF LL GH FX
QRDúWHUH
,GHQWLILFDUHDWLSXULORUUHJXOL
x ÌQFDGUXOXQXLWLSXQDGLQWUHIXQF LLYDILGRPLQDQW IXQF LDSULP
VDXGRPLQDQW
x 3HUVRDQHOH GLQ DFHO WLS YRU IRORVL vQ SULQFLSDO SULPD IXQF LH vQ
VHQVXODWLWXGLQLLIDYRULWH
([WUDYHUWXOvúLYDIRORVLIXQF LDSULP PDLDOHVvQOXPHDH[WHULRDU
,QWURYHUWXOvQOXPHDLQWHULRDU DFRQFHSWHORUúLLGHLORU
x $GRXDIXQF LHVHYDGH]YROWDSHQWUXDSHUPLWHHFKLOLEUXO
x $GRXDIXQF LHYDDGXFHúLHFKLOLEUDUHDGLQWUH(úL,
&HO FH DUH GRPLQDQWD H[WUDYHUW YD IRORVL VHFXQGDUD vQ OXPHD
LQWHULRDU
,QWURYHUWXO YD IRORVL DX[LOLDUD WLSLF vQ OXPHD LQWHULRDU 'HFL
GH]YROWkQGXúL IXQF LD DX[LOLDU SHUVRDQD vúL YD GH]YROWD GHSULQGHULOH
FDUHvLSHUPLWV IXQF LRQH]HúLvQOXPHDLQWHULRDU úLvQFHDH[WHULRDU
8QLQWURYHUWELQHGH]YROWDWSRDWHIDFHID OXPLLH[WHULRDUHGDUOXFUHD]
FHOPDLELQHFHOPDLXúRUFHOPDLSO FXWFXLGHLOH8QH[WUDYHUWELQH
GH]YROWDWSRDWHOXFUDHILFLHQWFXLGHLOHGDUFHOPDLELQHFXFHOPDLPDUH
LQWHUHVúLVDWLVIDF LHOXFUHD] SULQDF LXQLH[WHULRDUH
x $ GRXD IXQF LH SHUPLWH úL HFKLOLEUDUHD GLQWUH SHUFHSWLY úL UD LRQDO
'DF SULPDHVWHRIXQF LHLUD LRQDO SHUFHSWLY DGRXDYDILXQD
UD LRQDO ùLLQYHUV3ULQGH]YROWDUHDDX[LOLDUHLSHUVRDQDFkúWLJ FD
SDFLWDWHDGHDFRPDQGDDWkWDVSHFWXOSHUFHSWLYFkWúLSHFHOUD LRQDO
x 3UHIHULQ D -3 LQGLF IXQF LD XWLOL]DW vQ DWLWXGLQHD H[WUDYHUW úL
SHUVRDQHOHH[WUDYHUWHúLODFHOHLQWURYHUWH
x 'DF IXQF LD GRPLQDQW HVWH WLSLF H[WUDYHUW FHDODOW WLSLFYDIL
LQWURYHUW 'DF IXQF LD GRPLQDQW HVWH WLSLF LQWURYHUW FHOHODOWH
WUHLVXQWWLSLFH[WUDYHUWH
x )XQF LDRSXV GRPLQDQWHLHVWHWLSLFFHDPDLSX LQGH]YROWDW VDX
IXQF LDLQIHULRDU VDXD,9DIXQF LH
x )XQF LDRSXV DX[LOLDUHLHVWHD,,,DVDXWHU LDU
,GHQWLILFDUHDGLQDPLFLLODH[WUDYHU L
x 3ULYHúWHXOWLPDOLWHU 'DF HVWH-LQGLF D,,,DOLWHU LQGLF IXQF LD
GHMXGHFDUH
x 'DF HVWH3LQGLF D,,DIXQF LHXQGHDSDUHIXQF LDSHUFHSWLY
x (67--LQGLF 7
x (1)33LQGLF 1
x 3ULQ GHILQL LH -3 LQGLF XQD GLQWUH IXQF LLOH SUHIHUDWH FDUH HVWH
WLSLFH[WUDYHUW &HDODOW IXQF LHSUHIHUDW YDILWLSLFLQWURYHUW
x (67-7HVWHH[WUDYHUW 6HVWHLQWURYHUW
x (1)31HVWHH[WUDYHUW )HVWHLQWURYHUW
x 7LSXULOH H[WUDYHUWH IXQF LD H[WUDYHUW HVWH GRPLQDQW úL IXQF LD
LQWURYHUW HVWHDX[LOLDU
x (67-7H[WUDYHUWGHFLWUHEXLHV ILHGRPLQDQWD6HVWHVHFXQGD
x (1)31HVWHH[WUDYHUWGHFLFHDGRPLQDQW )HVWHLQWURYHUWDX[LOLDUD
x 3HQWUX WRDWH WLSXULOH D ,,,D HVWH FHD RSXV VHFXQGHL LDU D ,9D
HVWHLQIHULRDUDRSXV SULPHL
x (67-7HVWH,6HVWH,,1HVWH,,,)HVWH,9
x (1)31HVWH,)HVWH,,7HVWH,,,6HVWH,9
,GHQWLILFDUHDUHOD LHLGLQDPLFHODLQWURYHU L
x $,9DOLWHU 'DF HVWH-LQGLF OLWHUDD,,,D'DF HVWH3LQGLF
OLWHUDD,,D
x ,67--LQGLF 7
x ,1)33LQGLF 1
x -3LQGLF IXQF LDH[WUDYHUW GHFL
x ,67-7HVWHH[WUDYHUW 6HVWHLQWURYHUW
x ,1)31HVWHH[WUDYHUW )HVWHLQWURYHUW
x 3HQWUX WLSXULOH LQWURYHUWH IXQF LD H[WUDYHUW HVWH DX[LOLDU úL
IXQF LDLQWURYHUW HGRPLQDQW
x ,67-7HH[WUDYHUW GHFLWUHEXLHV ILHVHFXQGDU
x 6HLQWURYHUW GHFLWUHEXLHV ILHSULPDU
x ,1)3 1 HVWH H[WUDYHUW GHFL HVWH VHFXQGDU ) HVWH LQWURYHUW
GHFLGRPLQDQW
x 3HQWUX WRDWH WLSXULOH D ,,,D IXQF LH HVWH RSXV VHFXQGDUHL LDU D
,9DHVWHRSXV SULPHL
,67-6HVWH,7HVWH,,)HVWH,,,1HVWH,9
,1)3)HVWH,1HVWH,,6HVWH,,,7HVWH,9
([HPSOLILFDUHSURILO0%7,
6XELHFW SUH]LQW UH]XOWDWXO ,1)- FX QLYHOHOH VWDQGDUG
,QWXL LH LQWURYHUW FD IXQF LH GRPLQDQW FX DIHFWLYLWDWH
H[WUDYHUW FDIXQF LHVHFXQGDU
)XQF LD GRPLQDQW HVWH LQWXL LD 1 FHHD FH LQGLF XQ PRG GH
SHUFHSHUH vQ FDUH VH SXQH DFFHQW SH FRQH[LXQLOH GLQWUH LQIRUPD LL
WHQGLQ D HVWH GH D SUHOXD VHQVXUL GLQ OXPHD LQWHULRDU ) FD IXQF LH
VHFXQGDU FRPSOHPHQWDU VHPQLILF R UD LXQH FHQWUDW WRW SH OHJ
WXULOH GLQWUH RELHFWHOH OXPLL FX DFFHQWXO SH YDORUL DIHFWLYH (URV
'HFL]LLOHúLDF LXQLOHVXQWFRQGXVHGHSURSULDYL]LXQHLQWHULRDU DVXSUD
OXFUXULORU XQ PRG GH D VH LPSOLFD DIHFWLY vQ UHOD LL GH D MXGHFD GLQ
SHUVSHFWLY HPSDWLFDIHFWLY OXPHD
1)GHQRW XQWHPSHUDPHQWLGHDOLVWúLURPDQWLFFDUHvQFHDUF V L
FRQYLQJ SH DO LL V FRRSHUH]H ,QWXLWLY úL DIHFWLY WHPSHUDPHQWXO
DSRORQLDQHVWHOHJDWGHLQWHUHVXODXWHQWLFúLDFWXDOL]DUHSHUVRQDO HVWHR
F XW WRDUHLQFOXVLYvQVHQVXOF XW ULLGHVLQHGRUHúWHV GHYLQ DúDFXP
HVWH vQ UHDOLWDWH 2 PDUH FDSDFLWDWH GH DVFXOWDUH HPSDWLF 2 DELOLWDWH
YHUEDO GH]YROWDW ÌúL IRFDOL]HD] DWHQ LD SH SRVLELOLW L SH FDUH OH
DERUGHD] SULQYDORULOHDIHFWLYHGHDLFLF OGXUDDIHFWLY FDUDFWHULVWLF
WLQGH V GHYLQ HQWX]LDVW úL vQ HOHJ WRDUH ÌúL SRDWH IRORVL DELOLW LOH
SHQWUX vQ HOHJHUH úL FRPXQLFDUH FX RDPHQLL &D GRPHQLL SRVLELOH
FHUFHWDUH úWLLQ D FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL DUW PX]LF OLWHUDWXU LQWHUHVH
UHOLJLRDVH vQ GRPHQLXO V Q W LL úL vQY PkQWXOXL 'LQWUH FDSFDQHOH
XQXLDVWIHOGHWHPSHUDPHQWHVWHSUHDWHQWDWV VDOYH]HSHRULFLQHúLVH
]EDWHFkQGFLQHYDDUHSUREOHPHWHQGLQ DGHDVHDXWRvQYLQRY LHYLW
FRQIOLFWXOGHúLSRDUW SLF
3UHIHULQ D-ILLQGUHODWLYH[SULPDW ID GH3GHúLSRQGHUHDHVWH
WRWXúL VF ]XW SUREDELO vQ SUH]HQW DERUGDUHD UD LRQDO SUHGRPLQ vQ
UDSRUWFXYLD DSURIHVLDOXPHDH[WHULRDU
, LQGLF R SUHIHULQ PRGHUDW SHQWUX SR]L LD LQWURYHUW VX
ELHFWD HVWH DWHQW vQ VSHFLDO DVXSUD VHQVXULORU HYHQLPHQWHORU XWLOL]kQG
LQWXL LDúLPHGLLQGSXQHUHDvQSUDFWLF SULQUD LXQLOHJDWHGHUHOD LRQDUHD
FXFHLODO LúLUHOD LRQ ULOHGLQWUHRELHFWHOHOXPLL
'HVFULHUHDVWDQGDUGSHQWUX,1)-,3URIXQ]LPHDFRQFHQWU ULL1
,QWXLUHDSRVLELOLW LORU)F OGXU úLVLPSDWLH-RUJDQL]DUHÄ2DVSLUD LH
VSUHDOWFHYD´
6WLOXOGHFL]LRQDO)HVWHSUHGRPLQDQWOHJDWGHHYDOX ULDIHFWLYH
SUHRFXSDW GHGLPHQVLXQLOHLQWHUSHUVRQDOHSRDWHUHDF LRQDSUHDUDSLG
úLHPR LRQDODSUHFLD] DUPRQLDHPSDWLDúLVHQVLELOLWDWHDYDORUL]HD]
FHHDFHHVWHÄELQH´
&DVWLOGHYLD ,SUHGRPLQ IRFDOL]DUHDSHLQWHULRULWDWHUHIOH[LY
SUH]LQW RSURIXQ]LPHDLQWHUHVHORUDUHWHQGLQ DGHDDQWLFLSDHVWHPDL
UH]HUYDW W FXW HQHUJLDHVWHRULHQWDW VSUHvQ XQWUXLQWURVSHFWLY
6WLOXO GH SURFHVDUH D LQIRUPD LLORU 1 HVWH SUHGRPLQDQW LQWXLWLY
DFFHQW SH vQ HOHVXUL VHQVXUL UHOD LL DVRFLD LL SHUFHSH vQ WHUPHQLL
PRGHOHORURULHQWDWVSUHYLLWRUVSUHVFKLPEDUHOXFUHD] vQH[SOR]LLGH
HQHUJLH XQHRUL SRDWH DSDUH ÄFX FDSXO vQ QRUL´ LQYHQWLY úL RULJLQDO
WHQGLQ DGHDILFUHDWLY WHQGLQ DGHDLQWHUSUHWDIDSWHOHHVWHGRPLQDQW
6WLOXOGHUHOD LRQDUH-HVWHvQSUH]HQWRUJDQL]DWUHVLPWHQHYRLD
GHULJRDUHúLFODULWDWHYUHDV ODVHOXFUXULOHvQFKHLDWHXUP UHúWHV ILH
FRUHFW úLVLVWHPDWLF
6WLOGHFRQGXFHUHÌQPRGXOGHDFRQGXFHHVWHWHQWDW VSUHDF XWD
vQ HOHVXULúLDXWHQWLFLWDWHHPSDWLF YHGHSRVLELOLW LOHRDPHQLORUGDUúL
DOHLQVWLWX LHLFRPXQLF DSUHFLHUHDHQWX]LDVPXOúLDSUREDUHDHVWHVHQ
VLELO ODWUDQ]DF LLOHSHUVRQDOHS VWUHD] XQFRQWDFWVWUkQVFXSHUVRQDOXO
HVWH SHUVRQDOL]DW ú FDSDELO V GHD úL DUH QHYRLH GH OLEHUWDWH GH
PLúFDUH3UHIHU FRRSHUDUHDvQORFXOFRPSHWL LHL
(;7,1'(5,
8WLOL]DUHD0%7,vQVHOHF LDSURIHVLRQDO
FRQVLOLHUHYRFD LRQDO úLvQFHUFHWDUH
7LSXULOHúLUH]ROYDUHDGHSUREOHPH
2SWLPL]DUHDFDSDFLW LLGHDUH]ROYDSUREOHPHúLGHDOXDGHFL]LL
HVWHDWkWODQLYHOXOLQGLYLGXDOFkWúLDOJUXSXULORUXQVFRSXUP ULWvQ
GRPHQLXOHGXFD LRQDOLQGXVWULHVDXLQVWLWX LLJXYHUQDPHQWDOH6WXGLLOH
UHFHQWHDXHYLGHQ LDWXQPRGHOSUHVFULVGHUH]ROYDUHGHSUREOHPHGHúL
QX H[LVW XQ DFRUG XQDQLP DVXSUD FHORU PDL SRWULYLWH WHKQLFL 6WXGLL
VHSDUDWH DVXSUD SHUVRQDOLW LL úL DVXSUD VWLOXOXL FRJQLWLY DX DU WDW F
H[LVW GLIHUHQ H LPSRUWDQWH vQWUH LQGLYL]L UHIHULWRDUH OD DERUGDUHD úL
UH]ROYDUHDXQHLSUREOHPHSUHFXPúLODPRGXOvQFDUHLDXRGHFL]LH
ÌQ FRQWLQXDUH SUH]HQW P XQ PRGHO DO SURFHVXOXL UH]ROY ULL GH
SUREOHPHOHJDWGHWHRULDWLSXULORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDOXL-XQJDúDFXP
VXQW P VXUDWH GH 0%7, úL FXP VH SRW LGHQWLILFD WHKQLFL VSHFLILFH
DGDSWDWHGLIHUHQ HORULQGLYLGXDOH
0DMRULWDWHD PRGHOHORU UH]ROY ULL GH SUREOHPH LQFOXG FHO SX LQ
SDWUXID]H%UDQVIRUGúL6WHLQ'HZH\3RO\DR
ID] LQSXW vQ FDUH SUREOHPD HVWH SHUFHSXW úL VH vQFHDUF vQ HOHJHUHD
VLWXD LHL VDX D SUREOHPHL ID]D SURFHV ULL vQ FDUH VXQW JHQHUDWH úL
HYDOXDWH DOWHUQDWLYHOH úL HVWH VHOHFWDW R VROX LH ID]D RXWSXW FDUH
LQFOXGH SODQLILFDUHD PRGXOXL GH LPSOHPHQWDUH DO VROX LHL ID]D GH
YHULILFDUHvQFDUHVROX LDHVWHHYDOXDW úLGDF HVWHQHFHVDUVXQWI FXWH
PRGLILF UL &HL PDL PXO L FHUFHW WRUL GHVFULX UH]ROYDUHD GH SUREOHPH
OXDUHDGHFL]LLORUFDvQFHSkQGFXSHUFHSHUHDXQHLOLSVHúLILQDOL]kQGFX
LPSOHPHQWDUHD úL HYDOXDUHD VROX LHL FDUH DFRSHU DFHD OLSV EUHúD
)LHFDUH ID] D SURFHVXOXL LQFOXGH SDúL VSHFLILFL FH WUHEXLH XUPD L
vQDLQWHGHDVHWUHFHODXUP WRDUHDID]
&HUFHW WRULL DX LQYHVWLJDW UHOD LD vQWUH WHRULD OXL -XQJ SULYLQG
SUHIHULQ HOHLQGLYLGXDOHúLDERUGDUHDUH]ROY ULLGHSUREOHPHúLDOX ULL
GHFL]LLORU/DZUHQFH0F&DXOOH\0\HUV 0F&DXOOH\
&kQG UH]ROY R SUREOHP LQWURYHU LL YRU GRUL V OL VH DFRUGH
WLPSSHQWUXDVHJkQGLúLSHQWUXDúLFODULILFDLGHLOHvQDLQWHGHDYRUEL
vQWLPSFHH[WUDYHU LLYRUGRULV YRUEHDVF GHVSUHLGHLOHORUSHQWUXDOH
FODULILFD ÌQ FRQFOX]LH GH RELFHL SULPLL YRU IL PDL SUHRFXSD L V úL
vQ HOHDJ LGHLOHLPSRUWDQWHvQYUHPHFHH[WUDYHU LLYRUF XWDIHHGEDFN
XULvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHYLDELOLWDWHDLGHLORUORU
6HQ]RULDOLL VXQW SUHGLVSXúL V GHD DWHQ LH IDSWHORU GHWDOLLORU úL
UHDOLW LL 'H DVHPHQHD HL WLQG V DOHDJ VROX LL VWDQGDUG FDUH DX GDW
UH]XOWDWHvQWUHFXW'LQFRQWU SHUVRDQHOHFXIXQF LDGRPLQDQW LQWXLWLY
VHFRQFHQWUHD] SHVHPQLILFD LDIDSWHORUDUHOD LLORUvQWUHHYHQLPHQWHúL
DVXSUDSRVLELOHORUYLLWRDUHHYHQLPHQWHFDUHSRWILLPDJLQDWHSOHFkQGGH
ODDFHVWHIDSWH(LYRUPDQLIHVWDRWHQGLQ GHDGH]YROWDPDLGHJUDE
VROX LL QRL RULJLQDOH GHFkW V IRORVHDVF FHYD FH DX H[SHULPHQWDW
DQWHULRU
,QGLYL]LL FX SUHIHULQ SHQWUX IXQF LD ORJLF YRU DYHD WHQGLQ V
DQDOL]H]HúLV IRORVHDVF ORJLFDvQWLPSXOUH]ROY ULLXQHLSUREOHPH(L
DX GH DVHPHQHD WHQGLQ D GH D IL RELHFWLYL úL LPSHUVRQDOL FkQG WUDJ
FRQFOX]LL (L YRU FD VROX LLOH V DLE XQ VHQV OHJDW GH IDSWH SULQFLSLL
JHQHUDOHPRGHOH3ULQFRQWUDVWDIHFWLYLL LQFRQWGHYDORULúLVHQWLPHQWH
vQSURFHVXOUH]ROY ULLGHSUREOHPH(LYRUDYHDWHQGLQ DV ILHVXELHFWLYL
vQOXDUHDGHFL]LLORUúLV LDvQFRQVLGHUDUHPRGXOFXPGHFL]LLOHORUSRW
DIHFWDSHFHLODO LRDPHQL
8OWLPD GLPHQVLXQH OXDW vQ FRQVLGHUDUH GHVFULH SUHIHULQ D XQXL
LQGLYLG ILH SHQWUX -XGHFDW UD LXQH ORJLF VDX DIHFWLY ILH SHQWUX
3HUFHS LHVHQ]RULDO VDXLQWXLWLY &HLFDUHSUHIHU MXGHFDWDUD LXQHD
WLQG V ILH VWUXFWXUD L úL RUJDQL]D L YRU V ODVH OXFUXULOH WHUPLQDWH ÌQ
RSR]L LH SHUFHSWLYLL SUHIHU IOH[LELOLWDWHD úL DGDSWDELOLWDWHD (L YRU IL
PDL SUHRFXSD L FD vQ SURFHVXO UH]ROY ULL GH SUREOHPH V LD vQ FRQVL
GHUDUHRYDULHWDWHGHWHKQLFLúLSUHY GVFKLPE ULOHQHDúWHSWDWH
7LSXULOHúLWHPSHUDPHQWXOvQGHFL]LH
7HPSHUDPHQWXO 63 QRQUD LRQDO LQGLYL]LL VXQW RULHQWD L VSUH
UHDOLWDWH vQWUR PDQLHU ÄMXF Xú ´ úL DGDSWDELO 6FRSXO FHORU 63 HVWH
DF LXQHDWLPSXOORUUHIHUHQ LDOILLQGSUH]HQWXO(LYRUGRULV DF LRQH]H
LPHGLDWIRORVLQGRDERUGDUHLWHUDWLY SHQWUXDDMXQJHODUH]XOWDWXOVDX
VFRSXO ILQDO 'HILQLWRULX SHQWUX XQ 63 HVWH VFKLPEDUHD vQ SURFHVXO
UH]ROY ULLXQHLSUREOHPH,QGLYL]LLFHDXDFHVWWHPSHUDPHQWQXVHVLPW
OHJD L GH SHUFHS LD LQL LDO D SUREOHPHL úL YRU V DLE OLEHUWDWHD V úL
VFKLPEH RSWLFD vQ IXQF LH GH QRLOH LQIRUPD LL &kWHRGDW OLSVD XQXL
SODQFRHUHQWGHDF LXQHvLIDFHV GLYDJKH]HGHODSUREOHPDRULJLQDO
,QGLYL]LLFXWHPSHUDPHQW6-6HQ]RULDOúL5D LRQDOVXQWRULHQWD L
VSUH UHDOLWDWH vQWUR PDQLHU RUJDQL]DW VH VWU GXLHVF V ILH GH IRORV
FHORUODO L úL vQGHSOLQHVF VDUFLQL WUDGL LRQDOH ILLQG FHL PDL UHVSRQVDELOL
GLQWUHFHOHSDWUXWHPSHUDPHQWH(LVXQWFRQúWLHQ LGHGHWDOLLDQWLFLSDWLYL
úLSUHIHU VFKLPE ULOHHYROXWLYHPDLGHJUDE GHFkWFHOHUHYROX LRQDUH(L
DXQHYRLHvQV GHDMXWRUSHQWUXDRUJDQL]DGHWDOLLOHvQPRGHOHGHVHPQL
ILFD LHúLDJHQHUDDOWHUQDWLYHFDUHQXVXQWVWDQGDUGFUHDWLYH
&HL FX WHPSHUDPHQW 17 DERUGHD] UH]ROYDUHD GH SUREOHPH vQ
PRG úWLLQ LILF úL VXQW RULHQWD L VSUH YLLWRU (L VXQW PDL GHJUDE
LQWHUHVD LGHOHJLOHVDXSULQFLSLLOHFDUHJXYHUQHD] RVLWXD LH3URFHVXO
UH]ROY ULL GH SUREOHPH OXDUHD GHFL]LLORU GHVFULV GH FHUFHW WRUL HVWH
VSHFLILFFHORUFXWHPSHUDPHQW17(LWLQGV DFRUGHRLPSRUWDQ SUHD
PDUH IDSWHORU úL GHWDOLLORU úL HVWH QHYRLH V ILH DMXWD L V LD vQ FRQVL
GHUDUHLPSDFWXOVROX LLORUDVXSUDRDPHQLORU
3HUVRDQHOH FX WHPSHUDPHQW 1) ,QWXLWLY $IHFWLY VXQW vQ
F XWDUHD6LQHOXLFDUHHVWHXQVFRSPDMRUúLVXQWRULHQWDWHVSUHYLLWRU
vQ WHUPHQLL SRVLELOLW LORU XPDQH &kQG VXQW LPSOLFD L vQ SURFHVXO
UH]ROY ULLXQHLSUREOHPHHLVHSRWED]DSHDOWHUQDWLYHLQWHUQHFDUHQX
VXQWDQFRUDWHvQUHDOLWDWHVDXORJLF &HHDFHXUP UHVFHLHVWHGH]YRO
WDUHDSHUVRQDO (LDXQHYRLHGHDMXWRUSHQWUXD LQHFRQWGHGHWDOLLúL
SHQWUXDIRUPXODVROX LLUHDOLVWH
9DOLGLWDWHD SURFHVXOXL UH]ROY ULL GH SUREOHPH HVWH vQ HOHDV GLQ
SHUVSHFWLYH GLIHULWH GH ILHFDUH WHPSHUDPHQW &HL FX WHPSHUDPHQW 63
SXQSUH SHSURSULDORUH[SHULHQ FHLFXWHPSHUDPHQW6- LQFRQWGH
WUDGL LH úL DXWRULWDWH FHL 17 YDORUL]HD] ORJLFD úL UD LXQHD FHL 1)
SUH XLHVF LQVLJKWXO úL LQVSLUD LD 3URYRFDUHD UHSUH]HQWDW GH PRGHOXO
UH]ROY ULL GHSUREOHPHGHVFULVGHVSHFLDOLúWLVHUHIHU ODXWLOL]DUHDGH
WHKQLFLúLSURFHGHHFDUHDGPLWDFHVWHGLIHUHQ HLQGLYLGXDOHúLUHSUH]LQW
RRSRUWXQLWDWHSHQWUXDOXDvQFRQVLGHUDUHGLIHULWHSHUVSHFWLYH
6WLOXOPDQDJHULDOúLGHDOXDGHFL]LL
.LOPDQQúL0LWURIIDXUHDOL]DWPDLPXOWHVWXGLLvQDFHVWGRPHQLX
,DW FRQFOX]LLOHORU
WLSXO1)SUHIHU FUHDWLYLWDWHDSUREOHPHOHY ]XWHFDRSRUWXQLW L
WLSXO 17 SUHIHU V GHILQHDVF SUREOHPHOH XUP UHúWH RELHFWLYH
FODUHRSROLWLF vúLVWDELOHúWHFULWHULLSHQWUXVXFFHV
WLSXO 67 SUHIHU V GHILQHDVF VROX LLOH úL V úL SODQLILFH LPSOH
PHQWDUHDORU
WLSXO6)HVWHSUDFWLFGDUOXFUHD] vQED]DDFHHDFHVLPWHHOF HVWH
PDLELQHV IDF
$OHJHUHDFDULHUHL±RULHQWDUHSURIHVLRQDO
2DPHQLLWLQGV ILHDWUDúLúLVXQWPXOWPDLVDWLVI FX LvQVOXMEHúL
FDULHUH FDUH OH RIHU RSRUWXQLWDWHD GH DúL H[SULPD úL XWLOL]D SUHIH
ULQ HOH*HQXOGHPXQF vQFDUHYDILFHOPDLHILFLHQWúLGHFDUHVHYD
EXFXUDSRDWHV GHSLQG GHH[HPSOXGHSUHIHULQ DSHUVRDQHLSHQWUX(
VDX , 6DX UHDOL]DW VWXGLL SULYLQG OHJ WXUD GLQWUH RFXSD LL úL WLSXULOH
0%7,'HH[HPSOXSURIHVLXQHDGHSVLKRORJHvQFDGUDW WLSXOXL,1)-
FHDGHHFRQRPLVWWLSXOXL,17-LDUFHDGHSLORW,673
,QWHUYHQ LDWLSXOXLvQFRQVLOLHUHDGHFXSOX
6WLOXUL GHFRPXQLFDUHDPHOLRUDUHDFRPXQLF ULL±GLIHUHQ HOHVXE
DFHVWHDVSHFWHDOHWLSXULORUvLDMXW SHRDPHQLV OvQ HOHDJ PDLELQHSH
FHO ODOW úL V IRORVHDVF DERUG UL vQ IXQF LH GH WLSXO F UXLD vL DSDU LQH
LQGLYLGXO$SOLFD LLOHVXQWGLYHUVHGHODGRPHQLXOYkQ] ULORUSUHJ WLUHD
DJHQ LORU UHOD LLOH GH OD ORFXO GH PXQF GHFL vQ RUJDQL]D LL SkQ OD
VDUFLQD FRQVLOLHUXOXL SVLKRORJXOXL ILLQG PXOWH RUJDQL]D LL FDUH LQL LD]
IRUP ULúLZRUNVKRSXUL
&DH[HPSOLILFDUHOLPEDMXOWLSXOXLORJLFHVWHPDLRELHFWLYúLPDL
DQDOLWLF vQ WLPS FH OLPEDMXO VHQ]RULDOXOXL HVWH FRQFUHW FHO DO LQWXLWL
YXOXLHVWHPDLDEVWUDFWúLVLPEROLF
9DORDUHDSUHGLFWLY 0%7,SHQWUXSHUIRUPDQ DDQJDMD LORU
ÌQWUHEDUHD QXP UXO XQX UHIHULWRDUH OD vQFUHGHUHD vQ XWLOL]DUHD
DFHVWXL WHVW HVWH GDF GHD OXQJXO WLPSXOXLRDPHQLLvúLVFKLPE WLSXO
6WXGLLOHHIHFWXDWHGH&ROOHJH
V2IILFHRI&DUHHU6HUYLFHVDXDU WDWF
vQWLPSFHXQLLLQGLFDWRULVHVFKLPE vQWLPSHVHQ DÄPLH]XO´SUHIH
ULQ HORU LQWHUHVHORU úL RELFHLXULOH U PkQ UHODWLY VWDELOH $FHVWH VWXGLL
VXJHUHD] F PHGLXODFDGHPLFIDPLOLDOúLVRFLDOGLQPRPHQWXOWHVW ULL
SRWILLQKLELWRDUHVDXGLQFRQWU V DFFHQWXH]HXQHOHDVSHFWH7LPSXO
SRDWHILXQPRWLYSHQWUXFDUHvQVWXGLXOFLWDWGH*DUGQHUúL0DUWLQNR
QXPDLGLQVXELHF LDXFRPSOHWDWODIHOGXS FLQFLV SW
PkQL$FHODúLVWXGLXDUDW F SHVWHúLDXS VWUDWRS LXQLOHODFHO
SX LQWUHLGLQWUHVFDOHDVWIHOvQFkWDXFRQVLGHUDWWHVWXOUHODWLYVWDELOÌQ
FLXGDSURFHQWDMXOXLPLFGHVXELHF LFDUHDXDYXWDFHOHDúLVFRUXULGXS
FLQFLV SW PkQLUDWDFRQVWDQW GHODFHOSX LQWUHLVFDOHDUDW F
UH]XOWDWHOHOD0%7,QXVHVFKLPE GUDPDWLFFXVDXPDLPXOWHOLWHUH
ODWHVWDUHDODFLQFLV SW PkQLGLVWDQ
6WXGLLOHvQFHSkQGGLQSULYLQGSHUIRUPDQ DvQPXQF DXI FXW
FD 0%7, V GHYLQ XQ LQVWUXPHQW SRSXODU SHQWUX FRPSDQLL SHQWUX D
vQY DGHVSUHPRGXOORUGHDSURFHVDLQIRUPD LDLDUFRPSDQLLFD$OOLHG
6LJQDO$7 7*(0úL([[RQFROHJLLVSLWDOHúLIRU HOHDUPDWHDOH
68$ DX IRORVLW FX WR LL 0%7, SHQWUX D RSWLPL]D SURGXFWLYLWDWHD úL
VDWLVIDF LDvQPXQF DDQJDMD LORU'DYH\6FKHOO 0RUULVRQ
3ULFKDUGúL6DZ\HUDILUP F SUHIHULQ HOH0%7,QXVXQW
HJDOH FX DELOLW L 3HUVRQDOLWDWHD LQFOXGH PXOWH WU V WXUL FDUH QX VXQW
FRUHODWH SR]LWLY FX DELOLWDWHD LQWHOHFWXDO 1X HVWH UH]RQDELO V QH
DúWHSW PFDUH]XOWDWHOH0%7,V ILHODIHOGHYDOLGHFDLQVWUXPHQWHOH
SHQWUXDELOLW LFRJQLWLYHvQSULYLQ DSHUIRUPDQ HLvQPXQF
%HUU&KXUFKúL:DFODZVNLDILUP F GHúLDXIRVWI FXWH
PXOWH FHUFHW UL DVXSUD SHUVRQDOLW LL úL SHUIRUPDQ HL vQ PXQF UH]XO
WDWHOH U PkQ LQFRQVLVWHQWH úL FKLDU DWXQFL FkQG HVWH J VLW R FRUHOD LH
DFHDVWDHVWHGHVWXOGHPLF U *DUGQHUúL0DUWLQNRFKLDU
GDF VXQWGHDFRUGDXJ VLWRH[SOLFD LH/XkQGGHH[HPSOXVFDOD61
vQ WLPS FH *DUGQHU úL 0DUWLQNR úL *DVWHU 7REDF\N úL 'DZVRQ
DXJ VLWF FHLVHQ]RULDOLVHGHVFXUF PDLELQH/XHGHUúL
-RKQVRQDXDU WDWF FHLLQWXLWLYLDXUH]XOWDWHPDLEXQH
$FHVWH UH]XOWDWH SDU RSXVH GDU WUHEXLH DPLQWLW F DFHVWH VWXGLL
LJQRU XQHOH YDULDELOH $VWIHO OD R SULYLUH PDL DWHQW FHUFHW WRULL QH
DUDW IDSWXOF vQWLPSFHVXELHF LLWHVWD LGH*DUGQHUúL0DUWLQNR
úL*DVWHU7REDF\NúL'DZVRQRFXSDXSRVWXULPLFLúLvQGHSOLQHDX
IXQF LLGHVWXOGHUXWLQLHUHFHLODO LRFXSDXSR]L LLGHFRQGXFHUHvQDOWHúL
DYHDXGHvQGHSOLQLWVDUFLQLPDLFUHDWLYHÌQDFHVWFRQWH[WFHUFHW WRULLDX
WUDVFRQFOX]LDF DSDUHQWVHQ]RULDOLLVXQWPDLSRWULYL LSHQWUXVDUFLQLGH
UXWLQ úLFXGHWDOLLFRQFUHWHIDSWHvQFDGUXOXQRUSRVWXULQXSUHDvQDOWH
vQWLPSFHLQWXLWLYLLVXQWPDLSRWULYL LSHQWUXSRVWXULGHFRQGXFHUHvQDOWH
FHSUHVXSXQUHVSRQVDELOLW LGHSODQLILFDUHVWUDWHJLF
'H YUHPH FH VWXGLLOH DX DU WDW R OHJ WXU vQWUH UH]XOWDWHOH GH OD
0%7,úLSHUIRUPDQ DvQRFXSD LLVSHFLILFHHYLGHQWXQHOHWU V WXULVXQW
GHGRULWvQDQXPLWHIXQF LL&HUFHW ULOHDXDU WDWF vQSRVWXULOHvQDOWHGH
FRQGXFHUH HVWH GH SUHIHUDW WLSXO 7 ORJLFUD LRQDOúLGLVFLSOLQDWGHFkW
WLSXO)±DIHFWLY6WXGLLGLYHUVHDXDU WDWWRWXúLF GHúLWLSXOGHSHUVR
QDOLWDWH0%7,HVWHXQIDFWRUFDUHGHVFULHRSHUVRDQ QXHVWHFHOPDLLP
SRUWDQWIDFWRU)LHFDUHDQJDMDWHVWHXQLFúLQXVHFRQIRUPHD] XQXLWLSDU
2DOW FRQWURYHUV HVWHIDSWXOF HFKLSHOHFXLQGLYL]LDYkQGWLSXUL
GLIHULWHVXQWPDLHILFLHQWHGHFkWFHOHFXDFHOHDúLWLSXULS UHUHVXV LQXW
GH0\HUVvQ
7LSXULOHvQFRQVLOLHUHDHGXFD LRQDO
6WXGLXSULYLQGUHOD LDGLQWUHWLSXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH0%7,úLVDWLV
IDF LDvQPXQF ODSHUVRQDOXOGHFRQGXFHUHDOúFROLORUGLQ:HVW9LUJLQLD
&HUFHWDUHDDIRVWUHDOL]DW vQDQXOúFRODUSHXQQXP U
GHIHPHLGLQDGPLQLVWUD LDúFROLORU&DLQVWUXPHQWHDXIRVWIRORVLWH
,QGLFDWRUXO0%7,IRUPD*LDUSHQWUXP VXUDUHDVDWLVIDF LHLvQPXQF
0RKUPDQ&RRNH0RKUPDQ -RE 6DWLVIDFWLRQ 6FDOH 0RKUPDQ &RRNH
0RKUPDQ 'XQFDQ =DOWPDQ 5H]XOWDWHOH VWXGLXOXL LQGLF R
VWUkQV OHJ WXU vQWUHVXSRUWXOSHUFHSXWúLVDWLVIDF LDPXQFLL&XFkWHVWH
PDLVXSRUWLYPHGLXOFXDWkWFUHúWHSUREDELOLWDWHDFUHúWHULLVDWLVIDF LHL
5HOD LDGLQWUHGLPHQVLXQLOH0%7,úLVFRUXULOHPHGLLODWHVWXOGH
$SWLWXGLQHùFRODU VDUHDOL]DWSHXQHúDQWLRQGHGHVWXGHQ LGH
ODRSWFROHJLL5H]XOWDWHOHDXLQGLFDWF LQWURYHU LLDXvQUHJLVWUDWVFRUXUL
VHPQLILFDWLY PDL PDUL GHFkW H[WUDYHU LL DFHODúL OXFUX VD RE LQXW úL
SHQWUXLQWXLWLYLID GHVHQ]RULDOLúLSHQWUXSHUFHSWLYLID GHMXGLFDWLYL
6FRUXULOH0%7,DXIRVWFRPSDUDWHúLFXUH]XOWDWHRE LQXWHODDOWHWHVWH
0HGLFDO 6FKRRO $GPLVVLRQV 7HVW WKH $UPHG 6HUYLFHV 9RFDWLRQDO
%DWWHU\ WKH *DWHV 5HDGLQJ 7HVW vQ PRG VHPQLILFDWLY DX RE LQXW
VFRUXULPDLPDULLQWXLWLYLLID GHVHQ]RULDOLúLWLSXOORJLFID GHWLSXO
DIHFWLYÌQSDUWLFXODUSUHIHULQ DSHQWUXLQWXL LHVDDVRFLDWFODUFXVFRU
vQDOWODDSWLWXGLQL0\HUV 0F&DXOOH\
5HOD LDGLQWUHVFRUXULOH0%7,úLFRHILFLHQWXOGHLQWHOLJHQ
ÌQWUXQ VWXGLX DX IRVW WHVWD L VWXGHQ L WR L E UED L
&HUFHWDUHD D DU WDW F WR L LQWXLWLYLL DX vQUHJLVWUDW XQ FRHILFLHQW PDL
PDUH GHFkW FHL VHQ]RULDOL LDU FHL LQWURYHU L úL LQWXLWLYL WRWRGDW DX
vQUHJLVWUDWFHOHPDLvQDOWHVFRUXUL0\HUV 0F&DXOOH\
ÌQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH WLSXULOH 0%7, úL FRSLLL VXSUDGRWD L GH
IHWHúLGHE LH LFXYkUVWHvQWUHúLDQLDYkQGXQ,4SHVWH
DFHúWLDHUDXWLSXOLQWXLWLYvQWUXQSURFHQWPDLPDUHIHWHOHúL
E LH LL GH DVHPHQHD WLSXO PDMRULWDU HUD FHO SHUFHSWLY úL FHO
ORJLF0LOOV'DWHOHDXIRVWFRQILUPDWHúLGHXQDOWVWXGLX
DO OXL 'HOEULGJH3DUNHU úL 5RELQVRQ SUHGRPLQDQWH ILLQG vQ
ORWXO GH VXSUDGRWD L FHUFHWDW SUHIHULQ HOH SHQWUX LQWXL LH WLSXO ORJLF úL
FHO SHUFHSWLY )XQF LD LQWXLWLY D IRVW FDUDFWHULVWLFD GLVWLQFWLY D
VWXGHQ LORUVXSUDGRWD LWHVWD LODQXP U
&HUFHWDUHSULYLQGWLSXULOH0%7,úLGLIHUHQ HvQSR]L LDvQIDPLOLH
8Q VWXGLX FYDVLH[SHULPHQWDO FX GH VXELHF L D IRVW UHDOL]DW
SHVWXGHQ LOD)XMLWD7HQQHVVHH7HFKQRORJLFDO8QLYHUVLW\)UDQN
5H]XOWDWHOHDXDU WDWF E LH LLFHLVLQJXULODS ULQ LúLIUD LLPDLPDUL
DL IHWHORU VXQW PDL LQWURYHUWL L GHFkW VXURULOH PDL PLFL DOH E LH LORU úL
IHWHOHVLQJXUHODS ULQ LÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHLQWXL LDúLVHQ]RULDOLWDWHD
QX DX IRVW J VLWH GLIHUHQ H VHPQLILFDWLYH % LH LL DX IRVW vQ JHQHUDO
RULHQWD L VSUH WLSXO ORJLF PDL PXOW GHFkW IHWHOH LDU IUD LL PDL PDUL DL
E LH LORUDXDSDU LQXWvQWURPDLPDUHP VXU WLSXOXLDIHFWLYGHFkWIUD LL
PDL PLFL &D LQVWUXPHQWH DX IRVW IRORVLWH 0%7, úL FHOH RSW WLSXUL
P VXUDWHGH7RPDQCV)DPLO\7HVW
5HOD LD GLQWUH WLSXULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH0%7,úLHILFDFLWDWHD
vQvQY PkQW
6WXGLXO D IRVW UHDOL]DW OD :HVW 9LUJLQLD 8QLYHUVLW\ ,QVWLWXWH RI
7HFKQRORJ\IRORVLQGXVHFDLQVWUXPHQWH0%7,IRUPD*úL&ODVVURRP
2EVHUYDWLRQ .H\HG IRU (IIHFWLYHQHVV 5HVHDUFK &2.(5 VXELHF L DX
IRVW SURIHVRUL vQFHS WRUL GH HGXFD LHDV Q W LL0DMRULWDWHDFHORUFDUH
DXU VSXQVODWHVWDXSUH]HQWDWWLSXO(67-7LSXULOHGHWHPSHUDPHQWVHQ
]RULDOúLLQWXLWLYDXIRVWFHLPDLEXQLSUHGLFWRULDLHILFLHQ HLSURIHVRULORU
vQFRPSDUD LHFXDOWHSURILOHWLSRORJLFH
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH
IXQF LH GRPLQDQW HVWH IXQF LD FHD PDL GH]YROWDW IXQF LD QXP UXO
XQX(VWHIXQF LDFDUHU VSXQGHSULPDFkQGWHDIOLvQID DXQHLLQIRUPD LL
QRL(VWHúLFHDPDLIDPLOLDU
SUHIHULQ D(,GHVFULHRULHQWDUHDHXOXLVSUHOXPHDH[WHULRDU H[WUDYHUVLH
ID GHRULHQWDUHDFRPSOHPHQWDU VSUHOXPHDLQWHULRDU LQWURYHUVLH
SUHIHULQ D -3 LPSOLF SUREOHPD PRGXOXL FXP DERUGH]L UD LRQDO VDX
LUD LRQDOGDWHOHGHLQIRUPD LHDVXSUDUHDOLW LLLQWHULRDUHVDXH[WHULRDUH
SUHIHULQ D61GHVFULHPRGXOFXPHVWHSHUFHSXW LQIRUPD LD
SUHIHULQ D7)LQGLF IHOXOFXPLDHXOGHFL]LLOH
WHPSHUDPHQWXODSRORQLDQ1)LQWXLWLYúLDIHFWLY
WHPSHUDPHQWXOGLRQLVLDF63VHQ]RULDOúLSHUFHSWLY
WHPSHUDPHQWXOHSLPHWHDQ6-VHQ]RULDOúLUD LRQDO
WHPSHUDPHQWXOSURPHWHDQ17LQWXLWLYúLORJLF
WLSGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHvQJHQHUHRULFHGHQXPLUHXWLOL]DW SHQWUXDFODVL
ILFDSHUVRQDOLWDWHDXQXLRPH[LVW GLIHULWHWLSRORJLLILHFDUHDYkQGXQ
VLVWHPSURSULXGHFDWHJRULDOL]DUHGDUWRDWHSOHDF GHODSUHVXSXQHUHD
F H[LVW PRGHOHFRHUHQWHGHFRPSRUWDPHQWVDXVWLOXULFRQVLVWHQWHGHD
DF LRQD FDUH VXQW VXILFLHQW GH ELQH GHILQLWH FD V SHUPLW FODVLILFDUHD
LQGLYL]LORU'HIDSWSUHVXSXQHUHDDUHRYDORDUHHXULVWLF GHúLFDDGH
Y UDEVROXWU PkQHvQF RLQFHUWLWXGLQH'3
WLSRORJLDMXQJLDQ SRUQLQGGHODRYL]LXQHVWUXFWXUDO úLGLQDPLF D
SVLKLFXOXL XPDQ -XQJ GHVFULH R WLSRORJLH vQ FDUH LQWHUYLQH PRGXO vQ
FDUHVHRULHQWHD] HXOFRQúWLHQWvQUDSRUWFXOXPHDFRPSOHPHQWDUID
GHRULHQWDUHDLQFRQúWLHQWXOXLúLGHDVHPHQHDLQWHUYLQHIHOXOúLP VXUD
vQFDUHHXOvúLGH]YROW úLVW SkQHúWHvQUDSRUWXULOHFXUHDOXOFHOHSDWUX
IXQF LLSRVLELOHGHFXQRDúWHUHGRX UD LRQDOHIXQF LDORJLF úLIXQF LD
YDORULF VDXDIHFWLY úLGRX LUD LRQDOHUHVSHFWLYIXQF LDVHQ]RULDO úL
IXQF LDLQWXL LHL'HH[HPSOXvQVLWXD LDvQFDUHvQSODQXOFRQúWLHQWDO
SVLKLVPXOXL H[LVW R SUHGRPLQDQW RULHQWDUH VSUH OXPHD H[WHULRDU
YRUELP GH H[WUDYHUVLD HXOXL úL D IXQF LHL SUHIHUHQ LDOH RULFDUH DU IL
DFHDVWD 'H DVHPHQHD FRPSOHPHQWDU RQWRJHQHWLF VH YD GH]YROWD R D
GRXD IXQF LH VHFXQGDU FDUH YD DYHD vQV R RULHQWDUH LQWURYHUW
SHQWUX D SHUPLWH DFFHVXO HXOXL úL vQVSUH DOWH ]RQH &RPSOHPHQWDU vQ
LQFRQúWLHQWVHPDQLIHVW LQWURYHUVLDúLFHOHODOWHIXQF LLU PDVHUHFHVLYH
úLQHVRFLDOL]DWH7LSRORJLDMXQJLDQ GHVFULHUHDF LLúLSUHIHULQ HFXUHQWH
DVSHFWHIRUWHúLDVSHFWHOLPLWDWLYHSHQWUXWLSXULSULQFLSDOHvQIXQF LH
GHRULHQWDUHDúLIXQF LDGRPLQDQW ODQLYHOXOHXOXLFRQúWLHQWLQWURYHUW
VHQ]RULDO H[WUDYHUW VHQ]RULDO LQWURYHUW LQWXLWLY H[WUDYHUW LQWXLWLY
LQWURYHUW ORJLF H[WUDYHUW ORJLF LQWURYHUW DIHFWLY H[WUDYHUW DIHFWLY
6XQW GH DVHPHQHD GHVFULVH úL WLSXUL VHFXQGDUH vQ VLWXD LD FkQG
SUHIHULQ HLGRPLQDQWHLVHDGDXJ IXQF LDVHFXQGDU
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU
&XPSXWH LGHVFULHWHRULDWLSRORJLF DOXL&*-XQJ"
&DUH VXQW VFDOHOH 0%7, úL FDUH HVWH FRQWULEX LD DXWRDUHORU LQWUX
PHQWXOXLID GHWHRULDOXL-XQJ"
&XPGHVFULH LFRPSOHPHQWDULWDWHDGLQWUHIXQF LDGRPLQDQW úLFHD
VHFXQGDU "
&XPSXWHPGHILQLWHPSHUDPHQWXOGLQSHUVSHFWLYD0%7,"
&HWLSXULGHWHPSHUDPHQWHúLFHFDUDFWHULVWLFLSXWH LGHVFULH"
%LEOLRJUDILH
%DVK6:,QWURGXFWLRQWRJHQHUDOFOLQLFDOSV\FKRSDWRORJ\7KHSV\FKRSDWKRORJ\
RIWKHEDVLFIXQFWLRQV
+HGJHV33HUVRQDOLWDWHúLWHPSHUDPHQW+XPDQLWDV%XFXUHúWL
-XQJ &* 7LSXUL 3VLKRORJLFH +XPDQLWDV 7LSXUL SVLKRORJLFH WLSXO
H[WUDYHUWLWúLIXQF LLOH7LSXOLQWURYHUWLWúLIXQF LLOH
)XQF LDSULQFLSDO úLIXQF LDVHFXQGDU
/DYLQ73-XQJ
VSV\FKRORJLFDOW\SHVLQDQDO\VLVvQ06WHLQ-XQJLDQ
$QDO\VLV2SHQ&RXUW,OOLQRLV
0LQXOHVFX 0 ,QGLFDWRUXO GH WLSRORJLH 0\HUV%ULJJV SULYLQG VWLOXULOH
DSUHFLDWLYHvQ&KHVWLRQDUHOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHvQHYDOXDUHDSVLKRORJLF
*DUHOO3+%XFXUHúWL
0LQXOHVFX 0 7LSRORJLD MXQJLDQ vQ DQDOL] vQ ,QWURGXFHUH vQ DQDOL]D
MXQJLDQ (G7UHL%XFXUHúWL
0\HUV%ULJJV,0F&DXOOH\0+0DQXDODJXLGHWRWKHGHYHORSPHQW
DQGXVHRIWKH0%7,&333DOR$OWR
7D\ORU$UOHQH%HQ]LJHU.DWKHULQH7KH3K\VLRORJ\RI7\SH)DOVLILFDWLRQ
RI7\SHDQG3$663URORQJHGDGDSWDWLRQ6WUHVV6\QGURPH
7LHJHU 3' %%DUURQ 7LHJHU 'HVFRSHULUHD SURSULHL SHUVRQDOLW L
7HRUD%XFXUHúWLZZZW\SRORJLHFRP
&DSLWROXO9,
&+(67,21$58/(<6(1&.'(3(5621$/,7$7((34
ù,,19(17$58/(<6(1&.'(3(5621$/,7$7((3,
3UH]HQWDUHD &KHVWLRQDUXOXL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH (\VHQFN úL D
,QYHQWDUXOXL GH 3HUVRQDOLWDWH (\VHQFN FXSULQGH WHRULD OXL (\VHQFN
SULYLQGVWUXFWXUDIDFWRULDO DSHUVRQDOLW LLSUH]HQWDUHDFKHVWLRQDUHORU
(34úL(3,H[HPSOLILFDUHDXQXLSURILO(3,'HDVHPHQHDDO WXUL
GH H[WLQGHUL SULYLQG SHUVRQDOLWDWHD vQ GHOLQFYHQ VXQW SUH]HQWDWH
FRQFHSWHOHFDUDFWHULVWLFHXQWHVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORUúLUHIH
ULQ HOHELEOLRJUDILFH
7HRULDOXL(\VHQFNSULYLQGVWUXFWXUDSHUVRQDOLW LL
úLP VXUDUHDDFHVWHLD
$XWRUXO GH]YROW R WHRULH DVXSUD SHUVRQDOLW LL IXQGDPHQWDO vQ
VLVWHPDWLFHVWXGLLH[SHULPHQWDOH
(\VHQFN+DQV-XUJHQ
3VLKRORJHQJOH]Q VFXWOD%HUOLQ6WXGLD] vQ)UDQ DúLOD
8QLYHUVLWDWHD GLQ /RQGUD D IRVW SURIHVRU GH SVLKRORJLH OD
8QLYHUVLWDWHDGLQ/RQGUD0DUHSDUWHGLQPXQFD
VDVDGHVI úXUDWvQGRPHQLXOFHUFHW ULLSVLKRPHWULFHDVXSUDYD
ULD LLORUQRUPDOHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLúLLQWHOLJHQ HLXPDQHúLDIRVW
XQFULWLFVHPQLILFDWLYDODFHORURSLQLLFDUHQXDXODED] GRYH]L
HPSLULFHDGHFYDWH)UHFYHQWVHVSULMLQ SHSHUVSHFWLYDJHQHWLF
IDFWRULL JHQHWLFL MRDF XQ URO PDUH vQ GHWHUPLQDUHD GLIHUHQ HORU
SVLKRORJLFHGLQWUHRDPHQLDUHDGHVHDYHGHULFRQWURYHUVDWHPDL
DOHVvQSULYLQ DVWXGLXOXLGLIHUHQ HORUUDVLDOHvQLQWHOLJHQ
&RQFHS LD VD DVXSUD VWUXFWXULL úL GH]YROW ULL SHUVRQD
OLW LLúLHYDOX ULLDFHVWHLDHVWHH[SXV vQOXFU ULIXQGDPHQWDOH
SUHFXP'LPHQVLRQVRI3HUVRQDOLW\FX6\ELOúL%&(\VHQFN
7KHVWUXFWXUHRI+XPDQ3HUVRQDOLW\7KH%LRORJLFDO
%DVLV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 7KH 0HDVXUHPHQW RI 3HUVRQDOLW\
0DQXDO RI WKH (\VHQFN 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\
&ULPH DQG 3HUVRQDOLW\ +XPDQ 0HPRU\ 7KHRU\
5HVHDUFKDQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV
3HQWUX(\VHQFNSHUVRQDOLWDWHDHVWHVWUXFWXUDW SHQLYHOHLQWHU
UHOD LRQDOHLHUDUKLFH
ODQLYHOED]DOVXQWFRPSRUWDPHQWHOHVDXDFWHOHPHQWDOHFDUHDSDU
VLQJXODU
XUPHD] vQLHUDUKLHGHSULQGHULOHVDXDFWHOHPHQWDOHKDELWXDOH
QLYHOXO DO WUHLOHD vO UHSUH]LQW WU V WXULOH GHILQLWH FD úL FRUHOD LL
vQWUH FRPSRUWDPHQWHOH KDELWXDOH R FRQVLVWHQ REVHUYDELO vQWUH
GHSULQGHULVDXDFWHUHSHWDWHDOHVXELHFWXOXL
QLYHOXO XOWLP FHO PDL vQDOW FD JUDG GH JHQHUDOL]DUH vO UHSUH]LQW
WLSXO SHUVRQDOLW LL GHILQLW FD úL FRUHOD LH D WU V WXULORU VDX
ÄFRQVWHOD LLREVHUYDELOHVDXVLQGURDPHGHWU V WXUL´
7LSXO XQHL SHUVRDQH GHWHUPLQ WU V WXULOH HL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH
DFHVWHWU V WXULGHWHUPLQ PRGXULOHRELúQXLWHKDELWXDOHGHDU VSXQGH
LDUDFHVWHRELFHLXULODUkQGXOORUGHWHUPLQ U VSXQVXULOHHLVSHFLILFH
&HOH SDWUX QLYHOH GHVFULSWLYH FRUHVSXQG FHORU WLSXUL GH IDFWRUL
GHULYD L SULQ DQDOL]D IDFWRULDO $QDOL]D IDFWRULDO HVWH SHQWUX (\VHQFN
PHWRGDIXQGDPHQWDO SULQFDUHSRDWHILVWXGLDW VWUXFWXUDSHUVRQDOLW LL
Ä'DF VDUFLQDQRDVWU HVWHV IXUQL] PFHOSX LQRVROX LHSURYL]RULHOD
SUREOHPD WD[RQRPL] ULL vQ SVLKRORJLD SHUVRQDOLW LL DWXQFL LQWU P
DXWRPDW vQ SUREOHPD J VLULL GLPHQVLXQLORU DGHFYDWH DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL
,DUSHQWUXDDYHDRPHWRG FDUHV QHDMXWHvQJ VLUHDXQHLVROX LRQ UL
WUHEXLH V QH vQGUHSW P VSUH DQDOL]D IDFWRULDO SHQWUX F vQ FLXGD
GLILFXOW LORUUHFXQRVFXWHúLDVO ELFLXQLORUDFHVWHLPHWRGHQXH[LVW vQ
VWDGLXODFWXDODOFXQRDúWHULLYUHRDOW PHWRG FDUHV QHSRDW DMXWDvQ
DFHDVW F XWDUH´
'LQSHUVSHFWLYDDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOHWLSXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHFRUHV
SXQGHXQXLIDFWRUJHQHUDOWU V WXUDFRUHVSXQGHXQXLIDFWRUGHJUXS
GHSULQGHULOHVDXU VSXQVXULOHKDELWXDOHFRUHVSXQGIDFWRULORUVSHFLILFL
LDUU VSXQVXOVSHFLILFFRUHVSXQGHXQXLIDFWRUGHHURDUH
7U V WXULOHVDXGLPHQVLXQLOHSULPDUHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLDVWIHOGHIL
QLWHRSHUD LRQDOVXQWGHFLFRQFHSWXDOL]DWHGH(\VHQFNFDXQFRQWLQXXP
GLPHQVLRQDO GHD OXQJXO F UXLD SXWHP DILUPD F XQHOH SHUVRDQH VXQW
PDL DSURDSH GH R H[WUHP DOWHOH GH FHDODOW DOWHOH VH DIO vQ GLIHULWH
SR]L LLSHDFHVWFRQWLQXXP
&OXVWHUXOGHWU V WXULSHFDUHOHDVRFLD] (\VHQFNLQWURYHUVLHLHVWH
GLIHULWGHFOXVWHUXODVRFLDWH[WUDYHUVLHL'HH[HPSOXLQWURYHUVLDFDWLS
VHH[SULP ODQLYHOGHWU V WXU SULQSHUVLVWHQ ULJLGLWDWHVXELHFWLYLWDWH
WLPLGLWDWH LULWDELOLWDWH FDUH OD UkQGXO ORU VH PDQLIHVW vQ PRGXULOH
RELúQXLWHúLVSHFLILFHSULQFDUHU VSXQGHSHUVRDQDSURYRF ULORUUHDOLW LL
7U V WXULOH DVRFLDWH H[WUDYHUVLHL VXQW LPSXOVLYLWDWH OLSVD UHIOHFW ULL
DVXPDUHDULVFXOXLDFWLYLVPVRFLDELOLWDWHOLSVDUHVSRQVDELOLW LLH[SUH
VLYLWDWH7U V WXULOHDVRFLDWHQHYURWLVPXOXLVXQWDQ[LHWDWHVWLP GHVLQH
VF ]XW REVHVLYLWDWH OLSVD DXWRQRPLHL WHQGLQ H VSUH LSRKRQGULH QH
IHULFLUH úL YLQRY LH 3HQWUX DXWRU QHYURWLVPXO HVWH R GLPHQVLXQH GH
SHUVRQDOLWDWH ED]DW SH UHODWLYD VWDELOLWDWH VDX LQVWDELOLWDWHDVLVWHPXOXL
QHUYRV úL QX R VWDUH FOLQLF VDX VXEFOLQLF FDUH UH]XOW GLQ FRQIOLFWHOH
GLQWUH LPSXOVXULOH LGXOXL úL FRQVWUkQJHULOH UHDOLW LL VDX DOH VXSHU
HJRXOXLFXPDSDUHvQYL]LXQHDSVLKDQDOLWLF
$GHILQLGLPHQVLXQHDGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHGRDUSULQDQDOL] IDFWRULDO
HVWHLQVXILFLHQWDWHED]DGRDUSHFKHVWLRQDUHHYDOX ULVDXDXWRHYDOX UL
DOHFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLvQVHDPQ V GHSLQ]LGHGDWHÄVXELHFWLYH(\VHQFN
HVWH úL XQ H[SHULPHQWDOLVW FDUH SURSXQH úL XWLOL]HD] R PXOWLWXGLQH GH
P VXULH[SHULPHQWDOHSULQFDUHV HYLWHVXELHFWLYLWDWHDÌLHVWHFDUDFWHULV
WLF OXL(\VHQFNDFHDVW DERUGDUHH[SHULPHQWDO GLQGLYHUVHSHUVSHFWLYH
D LSRWH]HORU VDOH SULYLQG FRPSRUWDPHQWXO 'H H[HPSOX vQ VWXGLHUHD
IDFWRUXOXL SVLKRWLVP VWXGLD] PDL PXOWH FODVH GH YDULDELOH YDULDELOH
ELRORJLFHOHJDWHGHGLIHULWHWLSXULVHURWRQLQD0$2%+$YDULD
ELOH GH ODERUDWRU QLYHOH GH VHQVLELOLWDWH DVFXOWDUHDGLFRWLF YDULDELOH
DOH vQY ULL FRQGL LRQDWH LQKLEL LD ODWHQW SULPLQJ QHJDWLY YDULDELOH
IL]LRORJLFH (0* LQYHUVDUHD SHUFHS LHL DXWRQRPH YDULDELOH SVLKROR
JLFHDFWLYLWDWHDKDOXFLQDWRULHDVRFLD LLOHGHFXYLQWHFUHDWLYLWDWHD
&HUFHW WRUXOúLGLDJQRVWLFLDQXOSHUVRQDOLW LLWUHEXLHV XWLOL]H]HR
YDULHWDWH GH VXUVH SHQWUX D SURGXFH P VXU WRUL VLJXUH úL RELHFWLYH DOH
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLXPDQÄV OXFUH]LvQGRPHQLXOSHUVRQDOLW LLvQVHDPQ
V QXWHUHVWUkQJLvQWUXQVHFWRUPLFFLWUHEXLHV vPEU LúH]LSHUVRQD
OLWDWHDvQWRDWHDVSHFWHOHHL´'RFWULQDÄSHUVRQDOLW LLvQWUHJLSDUHV ILH
vQvQWUHJLPHMXVWLILFDW vQP VXUDvQFDUHDERUG ULSDU LDOHVXQWFDSDELOH
V FRQGXF GRDUODvQ HOHJHULSDU LDOH&HUFHW WRULLWUHEXLHV VHED]H]H
FkWGHODUJSRVLELOSHWRDWHWLSXULOHGHLQIRUPD LLIDFWXDOHVDXRELHFWLYH
LQFOX]kQGHYDOX ULDXWRHYDOX ULWHVWHRELHFWLYHGHFRPSRUWDPHQWHVWL
P ULIL]LFHDOHVLVWHPXOXLDXWRQRPVDXDOHDOWRUP VXU WRULIL]LRORJLFH
LQIRUPD LLELRJUDILFHúLDOWHLQIRUPD LLDQDPQHVWLFHFDUHSRWILXWLOL]DWH
SHQWUXDVSULMLQLVDXUHVSLQJHLSRWH]HOHLQYHVWLJDWH´(\VHQFN
ÌQvQOXFUDUHD7KH%LRORJLFDO%DVLVRI3HUVRQDOLW\(\VHQFN
VXEOLQLD] ED]D HUHGLWDU VXEVWDQ LDO D SHUVRQDOLW LL ÌQ vQ 7KH
0HDVXUHPHQWV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ DILUP Ä3HUVRQDOLWDWHD HVWH GHWHUPLQDW
vQPDUHP VXU GHJHQHOHSHUVRDQHLHVWHFHHDFHDSURGXVDUDQMDPHQWXO
DFFLGHQWDODOJHQHORUSDUHQWDOHúLGHúLPHGLXOSRDWHIDFHFHYDSHQWUXD
UHGUHVDHFKLOLEUXOLQIOXHQ DVDHVWHVHYHUOLPLWDW 3HUVRQDOLWDWHDHVWHvQ
ÄDFHHDúLEDUF ´FXLQWHOLJHQ DSHQWUXDPEHOHLQIOXHQ HOHJHQHWLFHVXQW
GHRVHELWGHSXWHUQLFHúLUROXOPHGLXOXLvQPDMRULWDWHDFD]XULORUHUHGXVOD
DHIHFWXDXúRDUHVFKLPE ULúLSRDWHXQIHOGHÄvQYHOLú´
,SRWH]DSHFDUH(\VHQFNvQFHDUF V RSUREH]HSULQWURPXOWLWX
GLQHGHH[SHULPHQWHGHODERUDWRUOHDJ WLSXULOHSVLKRORJLFHGHQLYHOHOH
GHDFWLYLWDWHDOHGLIHULWHORUS U LDOHFUHLHUXOXLÌQF GLQ(\VHQFN
VXJHUD F LQWURYHUVLD HVWH LQIOXHQ DW GH VLVWHPXO UHWLFXODU DFWLYDWRU
DVFHQGHQWQHYURWLVPXOHVWHLQIOXHQ DWGHVWLPXODUHDVLVWHPXOXLOLPELF
FUDQLDQDULLOHKLSRFDPS±DPLJGDO ±KLSRFDPS
ÌQ DILUPD LLOH VDOH VXQW UHOXDWH úL vQVR LWH GH GDWH H[SHUL
PHQWDOH H[WUDYHUVLD HVWH OHJDW GH VLVWHPXO DFWLYDWRU DVFHQGHQW FDUH
DF LRQHD] FDXQPHFDQLVPGHDFWLYDUHFRQWURODWGHFRUWH[QHYURWLVPXO
HVWHOHJDWGHVLVWHPXOOLPELFúLDFWLYDUHDHPR LLORUODQLYHOXOVLVWHPXOXL
QHUYRVDXWRPDWFDUHUHJOHD] PXúFKLLQHWH]LúLJODQGHOHHQGRFULQHUHV
SRQVDELOHGHGH]YROWDUHDúLPHQ LQHUHDFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUPDVFXOLQH
&DX]DOLWDWHD JHQHWLF HVWH PHGLDW GHFL GH DVSHFWHOH IL]LRORJLFH
QHXURORJLFHúLKRUPRQDOHDOHRUJDQLVPXOXLSHUVRDQHL&DX]HOHHUHGLWDUH
DSDUDVWIHOFDÄSUHGLVSR]DQWH´GHILQLQGWHQGLQ HGHUHDF LLQDWXUDOHFDUH
IDFFDRUJDQLVPXOV VLPW V SHUFHDS V U VSXQG VWLPXO ULLPHGLXOXL
SULQDQXPLWHPRGDOLW LVSHFLILFH
&RPSRUWDPHQWXOREVHUYDELOHVWHÄRIXQF LHDGLIHUHQ HORUFRQVWL
WX LRQDOH vQ LQWHUDF LXQH FX PHGLXO DFHDVW LQWHUDF LXQH G QDúWHUH OD
GLIHUHQ HGHVFULSWLYHFDUH LQGHIHQRWLSvQH[WUDYHUVLH±LQWURYHUVLHúL
FDUHVHSRWFHOPDLELQHP VXUDvQWHUPHQLLXQRUFKHVWLRQDUHSUHFXP
(34´ 5HIHULWRU OD GLIHUHQ D vQWUH SUREHOH GH ODERUDWRU úL U VSXQVXO
VXELHFWXOXLODLWHPLLFKHVWLRQDUXOXL(\VHQFNFRQWLQX Ä$FHDVW GLIH
UHQ LHUHvQWUHWHVWHGHODERUDWRUúLFKHVWLRQDUHVWUkQVOHJDW GHDVSHF
WHOH JHQRWLSH úL UHVSHFWLY IHQRWLSH DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL QX HVWH GHVLJXU
XQDDEVROXW ´
([LVW GHFLGLIHUHQ HLQGLYLGXDOHFHVHSRWLGHQWLILFDODQLYHOXO
WU V WXULORUúLWLSXOXLúLFDUHSHUPLWGHVFULHUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLúLH[LVW úL
SRVLELOLWDWHD GH D J VL H[SOLFD LL OHJDWH GH FDX]HOH DFHVWRU GLIHUHQ H
LQGLYLGXDOH ÌQ DFHVW VLVWHP FRQFHSWXDO FRQFHSWHOH vQVHúL MRDF UROXO
GHSLORQLDLPRGHOXOXLUHVSHFWLYSHUPLWUHGXFHUHDQXP UXOXLWHRUHWLF
LQILQLWGHHYHQLPHQWHH[LVWHQ LDOHGHIDSWHSVLKLFHGHFRPSRUWDPHQWH
UHDOHODXQQXP UPLFGHYDULDELOHFDUHVXQWOHJDWHvQWUHHOHSULQUHJXOL
úL OHJL $FHVWH FRQFHSWH úL OHJ WXULOH OHJLFH SHUPLW FHUFHW WRUXOXL VDX
GLDJQRVWLFLDQXOXLV IDF SUHGLF LDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL
&RQVLGHUkQG YDOLGLWDWHD GH FRQVWUXFW FD WLSXO IXQGDPHQWDO GH
YDOLGDUHvQWURUHFHQW SUH]HQWDUH(\VHQFNVLQWHWL]HD] FHULQ HOH
HVHQ LDOH SHQWUX VWDELOLUHD XQHL DGHFYDWH YDOLGLW L GH FRQVWUXFW SHQWUX
FRQFHSWHOHSHUVRQDOLW LL$FHVWHFHULQ HLPSOLF FRPELQDUHDVWXGLLORUGH
WLSFRUHOD LRQDOVWDWLVWLFHFXFHOHGHWLSH[SHULPHQWDODVWIHOSRUQLQG
GHODPRGHOXOWHRUHWLFDOFRQFHSWXOXLVHFRQVWUXLHVFLWHPLLFKHVWLRQD
UXOXLSHED]DFRPSRUWDPHQWHORUWLSLFHFRQJUXHQ DDFHVWRUVFDOHGHLWHPL
VWDELOLQGXVHSULQDQDOL] IDFWRULDO FRQVWUXFWXOIDFWRULDOHVWHH[DPLQDW
DSRLSULQFRQMXQF LDGLQWUHGHGXF LLOHWHRUHWLFHúLWHVWDUHDH[SHULPHQWDO
ÌQDFHDVW WHVWDUHFKHVWLRQDUXOUHSUH]LQW FRQFHSWXOGHH[HPSOXSHQWUX
GLPHQVLXQHDFRQFHSWXOGHH[WUDYHUVLHDVWIHOGHGHGXF LLSRWILWROHUDQ D
OD GHSULYDUH VHQ]RULDO FRQGL LRQDUHD GLVWUDJHUHD DWHQ LHL SUHIHULQ D
SHQWUXMXGHF LED]DWHSHLQWHQVLWDWHDVWLPXOXOXLVHVWDELOHVFSUHGLF LL
GLVWDOH vQ FkPSXO VRFLDO GH H[HPSOX SHQWUX H[WUDYHUVLH IUHFYHQ D
GLYRU XOXL VFKLPE UL DOH ORFXOXL GH PXQF SUHIHULQ H SURIHVLRQDOH
SUHIHULQ DGHDvQY DSULQUHFHSWDUHFRPSRUWDPHQWXODQWLVRFLDOVH
FDXW DQWHFHGHQWHGLVWDOHvQVSHFLDOIDFWRULJHQHWLFLVHFDXW SRUQLQG
GHODGHWHUPLQDUHDJHQHWLF SXWHUQLF LQWHUPHGLDULELRORJLFLGHH[HP
SOXSHQWUXH[WUDYHUVLHVLVWHPXOGHDFWLYDUHVHWHVWHD] H[SHULPHQWDO
GHGXF LLOH FH VH SRW IDFH SRUQLQG GH OD WHRULD DFWLY ULL GH H[HPSOX
GLIHUHQ HOH ((* ('5 HWF VH UHYL]XLHúWH vQWUHJXO VLVWHP SULQ DO
WXUDUHDDQWHFHGHQ LORUGLVWDOLúLSUR[LPDOLDWHRULHLúLP VXU WRULORUVH
FRQVLGHU GLVWDO úL SUR[LPDO GHVFRSHULULOH FX VFRSXO GH D vPERJ L
UH HDXDQRPRORJLF UHVSHFWLY
&HLWUHLIDFWRULWLSRORJLFLDLSHUVRQDOLW LLFRQ LQXWXUL
úLFHUFHW ULH[SHULPHQWDOH
&KHVWLRQDUHOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH DOH OXL (\VHQFN GHSLQG GH XWLOL
]DUHDP VXU WRULORUSVLKRPHWULFHSULQFDUHVWDELOHúWHFHHDFHFRQVLGHU
D IL VWUXFWXUL XQLYHUVDOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH $FHVW WLS GH DERUGDUH HVWH
QRPRWHWLF
ÌQ PRGHOXO IDFWRULDO DO SHUVRQDOLW LL GH]YROWDW GH (\VHQFN vQ
HVHQ H[LVW WUHLIDFWRULWLSRORJLFLFXRLPSRUWDQW FRQWULEX LHHUHGLWDU
vQ JUDGLHQWXO GH QRUPDOLWDWH DQRUPDOLWDWH H[WUDYHUVLH YV LQWURYHUVLH
VWDELOLWDWHDHPR LRQDO YVLQVWDELOLWDWHQHYURWLVPúLDGDSWDELOLWDWHYV
SVLKRWLVP
'H H[HPSOX SHQWUX DFHDVW XOWLP GLPHQVLXQH H[SHULPHQWHOH
GHODERUDWRUúLFHUFHW ULOHHPSLULFHDXSXVvQOXPLQ XQFRQWLQXXPGH
DOXQJXOXQHLGLPHQVLXQLFDUHvQH[WUHPDDGDSWDWLY QRUPDO FXSULQGH
FRPSRUWDPHQWHSUHFXPDOWUXLVPVRFLDOL]DUHFDSDFLWDWHGHHPSDWLHúL
GH FRQIRUPDUH YV FRPSRUWDPHQWXOSVLKRSDWFDUDFWHUL]DWSULQLPSXO
VLYLWDWH RVWLOLWDWH DJUHVLYLWDWH FRPSRUWDPHQWXO VFKL]RLG XQLSRODU
GHSUHVLY WXOEXU ULOH GH DIHFWLYLWDWH WXOEXU ULOH VFKL]RDIHFWLYH úL
VFKL]RIUHQLD7U V WXULOHFDUHVHFOXVWHUL]HD] vQSURILOXOSHUVRQDOLW LL
SVLKRSDWH VXQW DJUHVLYLWDWH U FHDO HJRFHQWULVP LPSHUVRQDOLWDWH
LPSXOVLYLWDWHWHQGLQ DQWLVRFLDO OLSVDGHHPSDWLHvQF S kQDUHDúL
FRJQLWLYWHQGLQ DGHDIDFHDVRFLD LLPHQWDOHGLVWDOHFHHDFHFRQIHU XQ
SOXVGHLQHGLWUHDF LLORUúLDF LXQLORU
3URILOXOWXOEXU ULLGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHSVLKRSDWHSRDWHILSUH]HQWDWvQ
XUP WRULLWHUPHQLGHVFULSWLYLVROLWDUQXLSDV GHRDPHQLSDUHDQXVH
SRWULYL QLF LHUL SRDWH IL FUXG úL LQXPDQ vL OLSVHVF VHQWLPHQWHOH úL
HPSDWLDHVWHRVWLODOWRUDúLDJUHVLYFKLDUúLFXFHLSHFDUHvLLXEHúWHvL
SODFOXFUXULOHQHRELúQXLWHFLXGDWHúLQXLSDV GHSHULFROvLSODFHV úL
EDW MRFGHDO LRDPHQLúLV LQHOLQLúWHDVF &RSLOXOSDUHFLXGDWL]RODW
JODFLDOúLIUL]HD] SULQOLSVDGHVHQWLPHQWHXPDQHSHQWUXFHLDSURSLD L
úLDQLPDOHDSDUHDJUHVLYúLRVWLOFKLDUFXFHLGLQIDPLOLHVRFLDOL]DUHD
HPSDWLD VHQWLPHQWXO GH YLQRY LH úL VHQVLELOLWDWHD ID GH DO LL VXQW
QR LXQLQHIDPLOLDUHORU
([WUDYHUVLDGHQXPLW úLH[WUDYHUVLHLQWURYHUVLHVHGHILQHúWHvQ
SULQFLSDOSULQLQWHUFRUHOD LLOHGLQWUHWU V WXULOHGHDILUPDUHVRFLDELOLWDWH
HQHUJLHGHYLD úLGRPLQDQ 'HVFULHULOHFDUHVXQWGDWHGHRELFHLSUL
YLQGFRPSRUWDPHQWXOLQWURYHUWúLUHVSHFWLYH[WUDYHUWUHSUH]LQW VLWXD LL
TXDVLH[WUHPH (\VHQFN OH GHQXPHúWH H[WUHPH ÄLGHDOL]DWH DOH XQXL
FRQWLQXXPSHFDUHRDPHQLLUHDOLVHSRWVLWXDODXQJUDGPDLvQDOWVDXPDL
VF ]XW´'HDVHPHQHDLQVLVW SHIDSWXOF DFHVWHGHVFULHULVXQWH[SUHVLL
IHQRWLSHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHQXFRQVWLWX LRQDOHJHQRWLSH
ÌQ SODQ GHVFULSWLY (\VHQFN SUH]LQW LQWURYHUWXO DVWIHO ÄLQWUR
YHUWXO SUH]LQW R WHQGLQ GH D GH]YROWD VLPSWRPH GH DQ[LHWDWH úL
GHSUHVLHúLHVWHFDUDFWHUL]DWGHWHQGLQ HREVHVLRQDOHDSDWLHODELOLWDWHD
VLVWHPXOXL DXWRPDW 'XS SURSULLOH ORU DILUPD LL VHQWLPHQWHOH OH VXQW
FX XúXULQ U QLWH VXQW FRQúWLHQ L GH VLQH QHUYRúL FX WHQGLQ D VSUH
VHQWLPHQWH GH LQIHULRULWDWH GLVSR]L LL DIHFWLYH DGHVHD DX UHYHULL vQ
VLWXD LLVRFLDOHVH LQvQIXQGDOVXIHU GHOLSV GHVRPQÌQFRQVWUXF LD
ORU FRUSRUDO FUHúWHUHD YHUWLFDO SUHGRPLQ DVXSUD FHOHL RUL]RQWDOH
HIRUWXO GH U VSXQV HVWH VODE úL DFWLYLWDWHD FROLQHVWHUD]HORU HVWH vQDOW
6HFUH LD VDOLYDU HVWH LQKLEDW ,QWHOLJHQ D HVWH FRPSDUDWLY vQDOW
YRFDEXODUXOH[FHOHQWúLWLQGV ILHSHUVLVWHQ LÌQJHQHUDOVXQWOLPSH]L
GDU OHQ L 1LYHOXO GH DVSLUD LH HVWH vQDOW GDU WLQG V úL VXEHVWLPH]H
SURSULDSHUIRUPDQ 6XQWPDLGHJUDE ULJL]LúLSUH]LQW RYDULDELOLWDWH
LPSHUVRQDO VODE 3UHIHULQ HOH HVWHWLFH VH vQGUHDSW VSUH XQ WLS GH
WDEORXUL OLQLúWLWH GH PRG YHFKH ÌQ FUHD LD HVWHWLF SURGXF GHVHQH
FRPSDFWH FX VXELHFWH DGHVHD FRQFUHWH 1X DSUHFLD] SUHD PXOW JOX
PHOHvQVSHFLDOSHFHOHVH[XDOH6FULVXOHVWHGLVWLQFWLY
Ä([WUDYHU LL SUH]LQW R WHQGLQ VSUH D GH]YROWD VLPSWRPH GH
FRQYHUVLH LVWHULF úL R DWLWXGLQH LVWHULF ID GH VLPSWRPH 0DL PXOW
SUH]LQW RHQHUJLHVODE LQWHUHVHvQJXVWHDXXQSURVWWUHFXWSURIHVLRQDO
VXQWLSRKRQGULDFL'XS SURSULLOHDILUPD LLDXRSURSHQVLXQHVSUHDFFL
GHQWH IUHFYHQW DEVHQWHD] GH OD PXQF GLQ FDX]D EROLORU DX GXUHUL úL
QHSO FHULIL]LFHÌQFRQVWUXF LDORUFRUSRUDO SUHYDOHD] FUHúWHUHDRUL]RQ
WDO ID GHFHDYHUWLFDO 1LYHOXOGHDVSLUD LHHVWHVF ]XWGDUWLQGV úL
VXSUDHYDOXH]H SHUIRUPDQ HOH 1X VXQW IRDUWH ULJL]L úL SUH]LQW R PDUH
YDULDELOLWDWHLQWUDSHUVRQDO 3UHIHULQ HOHORUHVWHWLFHVXQWSHQWUXLPDJLQL
FRORUDWH PRGHUQH ÌQ FUHD LD HVWHWLF SURGXF XQ GHVHQ vPSU úWLDW
DGHVHD FX VXELHFW DEVWUDFW $SUHFLD] JOXPHOH PDL DOHV SH FHOH FX
VXELHFWVH[XDO$XXQVFULVGLVWLQFWLY´
ÌQSOXV(\VHQFNVXJHUHD] F DFHVWHGRX WLSXULDXFHOSX LQR
UHOD LHGHDQDORJLHFXGLIHUHQ LHUHDPHQWDO UHDOL]DW GH)UHXG$VWIHO
vQ FD]XO H[WUDYHUWXOXL SDUH V SUHGRPLQH LGXO FD IRUPD LXQH LDU vQ
FD]XOLQWURYHUWXOXLVXSUDHJRXO
1HYURWLVPXO GHQXPLW úL LQVWDELOLWDWH HPR LRQDO H GHILQLW GH
LQWHUUHOD LDGLQWUHWU V WXULOHGHDQ[LHWDWHGHSUHVLHVF ]XW DXWRDSUHFLHUH
WLPLGLWDWH 5HDF LLOH HPR LRQDOH SXWHUQLFH DOH LQVWDELOXOXL LQWHUIHU FX
DGDSWDUHDVDVODE FRQGXFkQGXOVSUHUHDF LLLUD LRQDOHXQHRULULJLGH
'DF HVWH YRUED GH XQ LQVWDELO H[WUDYHUW QHOLQLúWHD úL VHQVLELOLWDWHD
VXQWSHSULPSODQGHYLQHH[FLWDELOFKLDUDJUHVLY/DFHDODOW H[WUHP
UHDF LLOH HPR LRQDOH VXQW OHQWH úL VODEH WHQGLQ D ILLQG GH DúL UHOXD
VWDUHDLQL LDO IRDUWHUHSHGHGXS DFWLYDUHDHPR LRQDO
ÌQ OXFUDUHD FLWDW (\VHQFN GHVFULH QHYURWLFXO vQ XUP WRULL
WHUPHQLÄVROGDWXOQHYURWLFvQPHGLHHVWHRSHUVRDQ GHIHFWLY PHQWDO
úL FRUSRUDO VXE PHGLH FD LQWHOLJHQ YRLQ FRQWURO HPR LRQDO
DFXLWDWH VHQ]RULDO úL FDSDFLWDWH GH D VH DILUPD (VWH VXJHVWLELO OLSVLW
GH SHUVLVWHQ úL OHQW vQ JkQGLUH úL DF LXQH QHVRFLDELO úL WLQGH V
UHSULPHIDSWHOHQHSO FXWH´
3VLKRWLVPXO HVWH FHD PDL FRPSOH[ GLPHQVLXQH GHILQLW GH
LQWHUUHOD LLOH GLQWUH WU V WXULOH GH DJUHVLYLWDWH HJRFHQWULVP FRPSRU
WDPHQWDQWLVRFLDOúLOLSVDGHHPSDWLH6HFDUDFWHUL]HD] SULQWHQGLQ DGH
D SURGXFH WXOEXU UL D IL VROLWDU D DU WD FUX]LPH D IL RVWLO DOWRUD D
SUHIHUDOXFUXULFLXGDWHúLQHRELúQXLWH/DXQSRODSDUSHUVRDQHFDUHQX
DX QLFL R FRQVLGHUD LH ID GH UHJXOLOH VRFLDOH OD FHO ODOW FHL vQDOW
VRFLDOL]D LPDLDOHVOHJDWGHGUHSWXULOHDOWRUSHUVRDQH
'HVFULHUHD GDW GH (\VHQFN SHQWUX SHUVRDQHOH FX VFRU PDUH OD
VFDOD SVLKRWLVP HVWH ÄSVLKRWLFLL VXQW PDL SX LQ IOXHQ L FX VODEH
SHUIRUPDQ H vQ DFWLYLW L FRQWLQXL SUHFXP úL OD GHVHQXO vQ RJOLQG
SUH]LQW R RVFLOD LH VODE OD WHVWXO GH LQYHUVDUH D SHUVSHFWLYHL VXQW
VODELvQXUP ULUHDXQXLWUDVHXFXXQRELHFWDVFX LWVXQWPDLLQGHFLúLvQ
SULYLQ D DWLWXGLQLORU VRFLDOH SUH]LQW R FRQFHQWUDUH VODE DX R
PHPRULH PDL VODE WLQG V IDF PLúF UL ODUJL úL V VXSUDHVWLPH]H
GLVWDQ HOHúLVFRUXULOHWLQGV FLWHDVF PDLvQFHWV WDSH]HPDLOHQWúL
V SUH]LQWHQLYHOHGHDVSLUD LHPXOWPDLSX LQDGDSWDWHODUHDOLWDWH´
ÌQ=XFNHUPDQVXJHUHD] vQORFXLUHDGHQXPLULLGHSVLKRWLVP
SULQSVLKRSDWLH
(\VHQFNVXEOLQLD] F vQ HOHVXOFRQFHSWHORUVHUHIHU ODFRPSRU
WDPHQWHLQWHJUDWHQRUPDOLW LLSVLKLFHQXVLPSWRPDWRORJLHLSVLKLDWULFH
ÄQHRFXS PGHYDULDELOHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLVXELDFHQWHFRPSRUWDPHQWHORU
FDUHGHYLQSDWRORJLFHGRDUvQFD]XULH[WUHPH´
0LFKDHO(\VHQFNDERUGkQGPRGXODUDQ[LHWDWHDFDWU V WXU
FRQVLGHU FRPSRUWDPHQWHOHGLQSHUVSHFWLY FRJQLWLY FRPSRUWDPHQWDO
úL IL]LRORJLF SDU LDO LQGHSHQGHQWH ILHFDUH GLQWUH HOH ILLQG DIHFWDW GH
IDFWRULUHODWLYGLIHUL L'LQSHUVSHFWLYDFRJQLWLY FHOHPDLPXOWHGDWHGH
FHUFHWDUHVDXD[DWSHVLVWHPXOFRJQLWLYvQFRUHOD LHFXH[SUHVLDFRPSRU
WDPHQWDO D DQ[LHW LL GHWHUPLQkQG GLIHUHQ H SVLKLFH vQWUH DQ[LHWDWHD
PDQLIHVW úLDQ[LHWDWHDUHSULPDW $VWIHODGHWHUPLQDWF FHLFXXQVFRU
ULGLFDW GH DQ[LHWDWH GHFODUDW VXQW FDUDFWHUL]D L SULQWUR YDULHWDWH GH
LQIOXHQ HFRJQLWLYHLQIOXHQ HFDUH LQGHVHOHFWLYLWDWHDDWHQ LHLLQIOXHQ H
LQWHUSUHWDWLYH LQIOXHQ H QHJDWLYH FDUH LQ GH PHPRULH 7RDWH DFHVWH
WLSXULGHLQIOXHQ HYRUDIHFWDQLYHOXOGHDQ[LHWDWHvQVLVWHPXOFRJQLWLYÌQ
DFHODúL WLPS VXELHF LL FX XQ VFRU VF ]XW OD DQ[LHWDWH VXE DVSHFWXO
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLGDUFXVFRUXULvQDOWHODDVSHFWXOGH]LUDELOLW LLVRFLDOH
± FHHD FH vQVHDPQ F vúL UHSULP UHDF LLOH FRQIRUP DFHVWRU WLSXUL GH
FHULQ H ± SUH]LQW PRGHOH GH LQIOXHQ H FRJQLWLYH LQYHUVH WU V WXUD
DQ[LHW LLQHLQIOXHQ kQGQHJDWLYVLVWHPXOFRJQLWLY'HDVHPHQHDvQWLPS
FH SULPLL UDSRUWHD] DQ[LHWDWHD vQ SODQXO WU LULL DIHFWLYH GDU I U
PRGLILF UL IL]LRORJLFH VDX FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH VHPQLILFDWLYH FHLODO L QX
UDSRUWHD] DIHFWLY DQ[LHWDWHD GDU vQ SODQ IL]LRORJLF DSDU FD H[WUHP GH
DQ[LRúLFXLPSRUWDQWHPRGLILF ULYHJHWDWLYH
'H IDSW GDF DU IL V GHRVHELP vQWUH FDWHJRULD QRUPDOXOXL
QHDQ[LRúLLFDWHJRULDDQ[LRúLORUFDUHúLWU LHVFVWDUHDDIHFWLY FDDWDUH
úLFDWHJRULDFHORUFDUHvúLFRQWUROHD] VWULFWFRPSRUWDPHQWXOSULQUHSUL
PDUHDUHDF LHLFRQIRUPGH]LUDELOLW LLVRFLDOHGDUSUH]LQW LPSRUWDQWH
PRGLILF UL IL]LRORJLFH FHL GLQ DFHDVW XOWLP FDWHJRULH úL FDUH QX VH
FRQVLGHU DQ[LRúL VXQW Y ]X L GH DQWXUDMODIHOGHDQ[LRúLFDFHLFHúL
FRQúWLHQWL]HD] DQ[LHWDWHDVLWXD LLOHDQ[LRJHQHYRUILODIHOGHQHIDVWH
DPkQGXURUD
(34(\VHQFN3HUVRQDOLW\4XHVWLRQQDLUH
úL(3,(\VHQFN3HUVRQDOLW\,QYHQWRU\
3ULPXOFKHVWLRQDUGLQVHULDGH]YROWDW GH(\VHQFNHVWH0DXGVOH\
0HGLFDO4XHVWLRQQDLUH004(\VHQFNFDUHFXSULQGHRVFDO
SHQWUX QHYURWLVP HPR LRQDELOLWDWH IRUPDW GLQ GH LWHPL $ XUPDW
0DXGVOH\ 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\ 03, (\VHQFN FRQ LQkQG
VFDOHSHQWUXP VXUDUHDQHYURWLVPXOXLúLDH[WUDYHUVLHL±LQWURYHUVLHL
(\VHQFN 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\ (\VHQFN (\VHQFN
DGDXJ R VFDO / ÄPLQFLXQD´ SHQWUX D P VXUD GLVLPXODUHD (VWH
UHDOL]DW vQ GRX YDULDQWH SDUDOHOH SHQWUX D SHUPLWH WHVWDUHD UHSHWDW D
DFHOHLDúLSRSXOD LL'HDVHPHQHDOLPEDMXOLWHPLORUHVWHFHYDPDLSX LQ
SUHWHQ LRVFXVFRSXOGHDILDFFHVLELOúLXQRUQLYHOHPDLSX LQHGXFDWH
DOHSRSXOD LHL
'LQWUHPRGLILF ULOHVHPQLILFDWLYHSHFDUHOHDGXFH(3,LPSRUWDQW
HVWH FRPSOHWD LQGHSHQGHQ D FHORU GRX GLPHQVLXQL H[WUDYHUVLD úL
QHYURWLVPXOvQ03,FHOHGRX SUH]HQWDXRXúRDU FRUHOD LH'HVLJXU
VFDOHOH GLQ 03, FRUHOHD] SXWHUQLF FX VFDOHOH VLPLODUH DOH (3, úL FX
VFDOHOH FKHVWLRQDUXOXL FDUH YD XUPD (34 DVWIHO F vQ IRQG FHOH WUHL
FKHVWLRQDUHVXQWHFKLYDOHQWHvQSULYLQ DHYDOX ULLFHORUGRX GLPHQVLXQL
,QWHUSUHWDUHDSURSULX]LV DVFDOHORUFRQVWUXLWHSULQDQDOL] IDFWR
ULDO vQVHDPQ SHQWUX (\VHQFN V VH PHDUJ GLQFROR GH VWDWLVWLF
SHQWUXDVHvQFHUFDFRQHFWDUHDGLPHQVLXQLORUDWkWFXGDWHOHWHRUHWLFHFkW
úLFXFHOHH[SHULPHQWDOHGHODERUDWRU5HVSHFWLYvQPRGXOGHDvQ HOHJH
FHLGRLIDFWRULWUHEXLHV VHIDF WUDQVODUHDGHODQLYHOXOFRPSRUWDPHQWDO
VDXIHQRWLSODFHOFRQVWLWX LRQDOWHPSHUDPHQWDOVDXJHQRWLSÌQDFHVW
VHQV LQWURGXFH úL PRGHOXO ELGLPHQVLRQDO DO WHPSHUDPHQWXOXL vQ FDUH
YDULD LD FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL VH H[SULP SULQ LQWHUVHF LD LQWURYHUVLHL FX
LQVWDELOLWDWHD HPR LRQDO $VWIHO DYHP XUP WRDUHOH VWUXFWXUL SRVLELOH
GHQXPLWHGH(\VHQFNSULQWHUPHQLFODVLFLSHQWUXWHPSHUDPHQWHVWUXF
WXUD WHPSHUDPHQWXOXL FROHULF FDUH YDULD] vQ IXQF LH GH JUDGXO GH
PDQLIHVWDUH DO LQVWDELOLW LL HPR LRQDOH QHYURWLVP úL DO H[WUDYHUVLHL úL
FXSULQGHFDUDFWHULVWLFLJUDGDWHGHODVHQVLELOQHOLQLúWLWDJUHVLYH[FLWDELO
VSUHVFKLPE WRULPSXOVLYRSWLPLVWDFWLYVWUXFWXUDWHPSHUDPHQWDO
VDQJYLQLF FDUHYDULD] vQIXQF LHGHJUDGXOGHPDQLIHVWDUHDOH[WUDYHUVLHL
úL DO VWDELOLW LL HPR LRQDOH úL SUH]LQW FDUDFWHULVWLFL JUDGDWH GH OD VR
FLDELOGHVFKLVYRUE UH UHDFWLYVSUHSOLQGHYLD I U JULMLFRQGXF WRU
VWUXFWXUDWHPSHUDPHQWXOXLIOHJPDWLFFDUHYDULD] vQIXQF LHGHJUDGXO
GH PDQLIHVWDUH DO VWDELOLW LL HPR LRQDOH úL DO LQWURYHUVLHL GHVFULSWLELO
SULQ FDUDFWHULVWLFL GH OD FDOP PHUHX WHPSHUDW GH vQFUHGHUH FRQWURODW
VSUHSDúQLFUHIOH[LYJULMXOLXSDVLYVWUXFWXUDWHPSHUDPHQWXOXLPH
ODQFROLFFDUHYDULD] vQIXQF LHGHJUDGXOGHPDQLIHVWDUHDOLQWURYHUVLHL
úL DO LQVWDELOLW LL HPR LRQDOH GHVFULSWLELO SULQ WU V WXUL GH OD OLQLúWLW
QHVRFLDELO UH]HUYDW SHVLPLVW VSUH VREUX ULJLG DQ[LRV SOLQ GH WRDQH
GLVSR]L LLODELOH
6FDOD GH PLQFLXQ FRQ LQH LWHPL FDUH DILUP FRPSRUWDPHQWH
VRFLDOHGH]LUDELOHGDUSHFDUHPDUHDPDMRULWDWHDSRSXOD LHLOHvQFDOF
IUHFYHQW vQ FRPSRUWDPHQWXO LQIRUPDO 7HRUHWLF FX FkW WHQGLQ D VSUH
GLVLPXODUH HVWH PDL PDUH FX DWkW VXELHFWXO YD DOHJH U VSXQVXUL FDUH
DILUP UHVSHFWDUHD vQWRFPDL D FRQGXLWHORU GH]LUDELOH IRUPDO 6FDOD D
IRVW VWXGLDW SULQ FHUFHW UL GHWDOLDWH (\VHQFN (\VHQFN 1LDV
0LFKDHOLVFDUHDXGHPRQVWUDWXQLWDWHDHLIDFWRULDO 3HGHDOW
SDUWH GHúL VH LQWHQ LRQD V HYDOXH]H QXPDL JUDGXO GH GLVLPXODUH VD
GHVFRSHULWF P VRDU XQIDFWRUVWDELOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHFDUHDUSXWHDIL
UHVSRQVDELOGHXQDQXPHJUDGGHQDLYLWDWHVRFLDO
,QWHUSUHWDUHDIDFWRULORUGLQ(3,
&DUDFWHULVWLFLVSHFLILFHWLSXULORUH[WUDYHUWúLLQWURYHUW
3ULPD VFDO UHSUH]LQW GLPHQVLXQHD LQWURYHUVLH YV H[WUDYHUVLH
SHQWUX H[WUHPD QRWHORU PDUL FRPSRUWDPHQWXO HVWH GHILQLW SULQ
H[WUDYHUVLH([WUDYHUWXOHVWHVRFLDELOvLSODFDFWLYLW LOHGLVWUDFWLYHDUH
PXO LSULHWHQLVLPWHQHYRLDGHDGLVFXWDFXRDPHQLLúLQXvLSODFHV
OXFUH]H GH XQXO VLQJXU ÌúL DVXP XúRU ULVFXO vL SODFH DYHQWXUD úL VH
H[SXQHSHULFROHORU7LQGHVSUHHPR LLSXWHUQLFHGRUHúWHDJLWD LDúLHVWH
vQJHQHUDOLPSXOVLYÌLSODFHV IDF JOXPHHVWHRVFLODQWRSWLPLVWDUH
WHQGLQ DGHDILDJUHVLYúLvúLSLHUGHFXXúXULQ VW SkQLUHDGHVLQH7LS
DUWLVWLF vQFOLQDW VSUH H[WHULRU &RQFUHW DOHUW FX LQL LDWLY úL EXQ
RUJDQL]DWRU 7LQGH V VH VXSUDDSUHFLH]H úL V DFFHSWH GRDU SURSULXO
SXQFWGHYHGHUH
1RWHOHVF ]XWHvQPRGRELúQXLWQRUPDUHDHVWHvQVWDQLQHLQGLF
SHQWUX LQWURYHUW HVWH OLQLúWLW UHWUDV LQWURVSHFWLY DUH R YLD LQWHULRDU
ERJDW (VWH WLSXO JkQGLWRU LQGLFDW SHQWUX FHUFHWDUH SRVHG JkQGLUH
DEVWUDFW GDU XQ VSLULW GH REVHUYD LH PDL SX LQ GH]YROWDW F FL HVWH
RULHQWDWVSUHLQWHULRUúLRDUHFXPUXSWGHH[WHULRU8úRUWHQVLRQDWF FLvL
OLSVHúWH XúXULQ D H[WHULRUL] ULL ERJDWHORU WU LUL LQWHULRDUH ÌQ UHOD LLOH
VRFLDOHHVWHUH]HUYDWúLGLVWDQWQHvQFUH] WRUúLSODQLILFDWQRQLPSXOVLY
ÌQFOLQDWVSUHXQPRGGHYLD RUGRQDWQXDJUHHD] DJLWD LDvúLGRPLQ
DJUHVLYLWDWHDúLQXúLSLHUGHXúRUFXPS WXO7LQGHV VHVXEDSUHFLH]H
6FDODD,,DP VRDU LQVWDELOLWDWHHPR LRQDO YVOLSVDHPR LRQDOL
W LL1HYURWLVPXOHVWHFDUDFWHULVWLFDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLFXQRWHULGLFDWH
HVWHGHQXPLWúLLQVWDELOLWDWHHPR LRQDO HVWHGHILQLWGHLQWHUUHOD LDGLQWUH
WHQGLQ DVSUHDQ[LHWDWHGHSUHVLHRVF ]XW DXWRDSUHFLHUHúLWLPLGLWDWH
WRDWH GDWRUDWH OLSVHL GH FRQWURO HPR LRQDO 5HDF LLOH HPR LRQDOH SXWHU
QLFH DOH LQVWDELOXOXL HPR LRQDO LQWHUIHU FX DGDSWDUHD VD VF ]XW OD
HYHQLPHQWHOH GH YLD úL vO FRQGXF VSUH UHDF LL HPR LRQDOH LUD LRQDOH
DGHVHD ULJLGH $SDWLD HVWH FDUDFWHULVWLFD LQYHUV OD FHDODOW H[WUHP D
VWDELOLW LL HPR LRQDOH DYHP GHD IDFH FX SHUVRDQH H[WUHP GH JUHX GH
VWLPXODWHPR LRQDOUHDF LLOHHPR LRQDOHVXQWVODEHFDLQWHQVLWDWHOHQWH
LQWU JUHXvQDWPRVIHUDHPR LRQDO úLDXWHQGLQ DGHDUHYHQLODVWDUHDGH
DSDWLHFDOPÄSODW´IRDUWHUHSHGHGXS DFWLYDUHDHPR LRQDO
&kQGVXELHFWXOSUH]LQW RQRW ULGLFDW ODH[WUDYHUVLHDO WXULGHR
QRW ULGLFDW OD QHYURWLVP GLDJQRVWLFXO HVWH LQVWDELO H[WUDYHUW vQWUR
DVWIHOGHFRQGL LHvQSULPSODQDSDUQHOLQLúWHDúLVHQVLELOLWDWHDGHYLQH
H[FLWDELO DJUHVLY 'DF HVWH YRUED GH XQ LQWURYHUW VXQW GRPLQDQWH
WLPLGLWDWHDDQ[LHWDWHDEORFDMXOHPR LRQDO
(34LQFOXGHúLRD,9DVFDO SVLKRWLVPXO
&DUDFWHULVWLFLVSHFLILFHGLPHQVLXQLLGHSVLKRWLVP
3VLKRWLVPXOHVWHFHDPDLFRPSOH[ GLPHQVLXQHGHILQLW GHLQWHU
UHOD LLOHGLQWUHWHQGLQ HOHVSUHDJUHVLYLWDWHHJRFHQWULVPFRPSRUWDPHQW
DQWLVRFLDOúLOLSVDGHHPSDWLH'DF WU V WXUDHVWHSUH]HQW vQJUDGvQDOW
vQFRPSRUWDPHQWVHUHPDUF WHQGLQ DGHDSURGXFHWXOEXU ULVROLWXGLQHD
FUX]LPHDRVWLOLWDWHDID GHFHO ODOWSUHIHULQ HSHQWUXOXFUXULFLXGDWHúL
QHRELúQXLWH/DFHO ODOWSRODYHPGHDIDFHFXSHUVRDQHVRFLDOL]DWHFX
WHQGLQ D GH D DFRUGD XQ PDUH UHVSHFW UHJXOLL VRFLDOH FRQYHQ LLORU
GUHSWXULORUFHORUODO LFXQLYHOHGHDVSLUD LHDGDSWDWHODUHDOLWDWH
(\VHQFN VXEOLQLD] F vQ HOHVXO FRQFHSWHORU VH UHIHU vQ SULPXO
UkQG OD FRPSRUWDPHQWH FLUFXPVFULVH vQ HOHVXOXL ODUJ GH QRUPDOLWDWH
SVLKLF ÄQHRFXS PGHYDULDELOHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLVXELDFHQWHFRPSRUWD
PHQWHORU FDUH GHYLQ SDWRORJLFH GRDU vQ FD]XUL H[WUHPH´ 'LQ DFHDVW
SHUVSHFWLY GH H[HPSOX GRDU OD R PLF SURSRU LH GH SHUVRDQH FDUH
SUH]LQW XQQLYHOvQDOWGHSVLKRWLVPHVWHSRVLELOV VHGH]YROWHRFRQGL LH
SVLKRWLF SURSULX]LV 6FKL]RIUHQLD HVWH OD XQ FDS W H[WUHP DO GLPHQ
VLXQLLSVLKRWLVPGHH[HPSOXFDUHLQFOXGHGHDVHPHQHDSHQWUXQLYHOH
vQDOWHFULPLQDOLWDWHSVLKRSDWLHWXOEXU ULGHWLSPDQLDFRGHSUHVLY,WHPLL
VFDOHLFRQ LQvQSULPXOUkQGFDUDFWHULVWLFLFDUHVHPQLILF XQFRPSRUWD
PHQW DQWLVRFLDO DVSHFWH VDGLFH LPSXOVLYH úL GRDU vQ DO GRLOHD UkQG
LGHD LHGHWLSSDUDQRLG
([HPSOLILFDUHDXQXLSURILO(3,
0DWHULDOHQHFHVDUH&KHVWLRQDUIRDLDGHU VSXQVJULO HWDORQ
IRDLHGHSURILOPDQXDOSHQWUXLQWHUSUHWDUH
6FRS &KHVWLRQDUXO P VRDU H[WUDYHUVLD LQWURYHUVLD úL QHYUR
WLVPXOHPR LRQDELOLWDWHD
6WUXFWXU 7HVWXO FXSULQGH WUHL VFDOH ELSRODUH SULYLQG IDFWRULL
SHUVRQDOLW LLRVFDO SHQWUXP VXUDUHDLQWURYHUVLHLH[WUDYHUVLHL(,
R VFDO GH HFKLOLEUX HPR LRQDO QHYURWLVP 1 R VFDO GH DGDSWDUH
SVLKRWLVPSUHFXPúLRD,9DVFDO GHFRQWURODDWLWXGLQLLVXELHFWXOXL
GHQXPLW VFDO GHPLQFLXQ /
$SOLFDUH 6XELHF LL DX OD GLVSR]L LH XQ FKHVWLRQDU úL R IRDLH GH
U VSXQV 6H IDFH LQVWUXFWDMXO úL VH U VSXQGH I U OLPLW vQ WLPS 6H
DSOLF LQGLYLGXDO VDX FROHFWLY 5HFRPDQGDW SHQWUX DGXO L úL WLQHUL
3HQWUXFRSLLHVWHRIRUP VSHFLDO
&RWDUH 3HQWUX RE LQHUHD QRWHORU VH DSOLF JULOH SHQWUX ILHFDUH
GLQ FHOH WUHL VFDOH DOH WHVWXOXL 6H QXP U U VSXQVXULOH VLPSWRPDWLFH
SHQWUX'$úLSHQWUX18
,QWHUSUHWDUH6HIDFHFRQIRUPLQGLFD LLORUGLQPDQXDOXOWHVWXOXL
3ULPXOSDVvQLQWHUSUHWDUHHVWHGHWHUPLQDUHDYDOLGLW LLSURILOXOXL
ÌQ DFHVW VFRS VH YHULILF SHUIRUPDQ HOH RE LQXWH SH VFDOD / SHVWH
FRLQFLGHQ HSXWHPYRUELGHVXELHF LGLVLPXODQ L$OGRLOHDSDVFRQVW
vQ LQWHUSUHWDUHD SURSULX]LV D SURILOXOXL SVLKRORJLF DO VXELHFWXOXL
SHQWUX ILHFDUH GLQ FHOH VFDOH úL SHQWUX FRUHODUHD GLQWUH FHOH GRX
GLPHQVLXQLFRQIRUPFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
6XELHFWXO 06 DUH DQL (VWH XQ DGROHVFHQW VSLWDOL]DW SHQWUX
vQFHUFDUH GH VXLFLG FH RE LQH XUP WRDUHOH SHUIRUPDQ H SH VFDOHOH (\
QRWHOHEUXWH1 ( /
3HQWUXDDIODYDORULOHVWDQGDUGDOHDFHVWRUSHUIRUPDQ HVHDSHOHD]
OD HWDORQ ÌQ FD]XO DFHVWXL LQYHQWDU GRDU UH]XOWDWHOH EUXWH RE LQXWH SH
VFDOHOH 1H úL ( VH WUDQVIRUP vQ QRWH VWDQGDUG 3ULQ WUDQVIRUPDUHD
QRWHORUEUXWHvQQRWHVWDQGDUGSHUIRUPDQ HOHSHDFHVWHVFDOHVXQW1H
($úDGDUYRPDQDOL]DXUP WRUXOSURILO1 ( /
5H]XOWDWHOHRE LQXWHSHQWUXVFDODGHPLQFLXQ /LQGLF WHQGLQ
GHGLVLPXODUHúLXQDQXPLWJUDGGHULJLGLWDWHFDUHSUREDELOLQWHUIHU FX
DGDSWDELOLWDWHDSHUVRDQHLúLWHQGLQ DGHDDEVROXWL]DDQXPLWHSXQFWHGH
YHGHUH
6FDOD ( QH DUDW F VXELHFWXO QRVWUX HVWH LQWURYHUW LDU VFDOD 1
VHPQDOHD] SUH]HQ D XQHL VWUXFWXUL QHYURWLFH 3HUIRUPDQ HOH FUHVFXWH
SH VFDOD / úL 1 VH FRUHOHD] úL SXWHP DILUPD F VXELHFWXO HVWH
QHDGDSWDWLQIOH[LELO
3ULQ XUPDUH GHVFULHUHD VXELHFWXOXL YD IL XUP WRDUHD VXELHFW
LQWURYHUWULJLGúLWHQVLRQDWFXGHFRPSHQVDUHQHYURWLF
(;7,1'(5,
'DWHGHFHUFHWDUHSULYLQGFHLWUHLVXSHUIDFWRUL
vQVWXGLXOSHUVRQDOLW LLGHOLFWXDOH
2VHULHGHFHUFHW ULDXIRVWGHGLFDWHFULPLQDOLW LLúLPRGXOXLFXP
FHLGRLUHVSHFWLYWUHLIDFWRULLQWHUYLQGLIHUHQ LDWRUSHQWUXSHUVRQDOLWDWHD
GHOLQFYHQW ID GHQRUPDO+(\VHQFNFRUHODVFKHPDELGLPHQVLRQDO D
H[SOLF ULL FULPLQDOLW LL FX H[WUDYHUVLD vQDOW úL FX QHYURWLVPXO vQDOWvQ
VHQVXOVXEVRFLDOL] ULLGHOLQFYHQ LORUPDLDOHVGLQFDX]DJUDGXOXLUHGXV
GHFRQGL LRQDELOLWDWHDVRFLDWFXH[WUDYHUVLDORUULGLFDW HUDXGHILQL LFD
LQFDSDELOL V vQYH H UROXUL VRFLDOH úL FRPSRUWDPHQWH GH FRRSHUDUH
&RQFOX]LD JHQHUDO HVWH F ÄLQIUDFWRULL VH FDUDFWHUL]HD] SULQ DQXPLWH
WU V WXULGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHFDUHLQFOXGLQWURYHUVLDúLH[WUDYHUVLD´
$VWIHOVHUHIHU ODH[SHULPHQWHSULYLQGYLWH]DGHGREkQGLUHúLGX
UDWDIL[ ULLUHDF LLORUFRQGL LRQDWHGLIHULWHODH[WUDYHU LID GHLQWURYHU L
8QDVWIHOGHH[SHULPHQW+(\VHQFN0(\VHQFNDXUP ULW
UHIOH[XO GH FOLSLUH GHFODQúDW GH VXIODUHD XQXL MHW GH DHU VSUH FRUQHH
VXELHF LLDXSULPLWRFKHODULVSHFLDOLFXRULILFLLvQFDUHVDXLQWURGXVGRX
PLFLWXEXULGHFDXFLXFSULQFDUHVHSXWHDSRPSDDHUFXMHWXOGLUHF LRQDW
VSUHFRUQHH6WLPXOXOFRQGL LRQDWHUDXQVXQHWFDUHDMXQJHDODVXELHF L
SULQ F úWLOH FDUH OH DFRSHUHDX XUHFKLOH H[SHULPHQWXO FRQVWD vQ P VX
UDUHD UHDF LHL GH vQFKLGHUH D SOHRDSHORU OD HPLWHUHD VXQHWXOXL 'DF OD
vQFHSXWQXVHFRQVWDWDQLFLRUHDF LHSHP VXU FHVXQHWXOHUDXUPDW
UHSHWDW GH MHWXO GH DHU VXELHFWXO GREkQGHD UHIOH[XO FRQGL LRQDW GH D
FOLSLQXPDLODDX]LUHDVXQHWXOXL6XELHF LLLQWURYHU LúLDXIRUPDWFRQVL
GHUDELO PDL UHSHGH UHIOH[XO GH D FOLSL ([WUDYHU LL VXQW PDL JUHX GH
FRQGL LRQDWúLvQDOWHSULYLQ H
&RQFOX]LDDXWRULORUHVWHF ÄvQFRQGL LLOHXQRUSDUDPHWULúLUHSHUH
HJDOHHLDUILvQFOLQD LFXRPDLPDUHSUREDELOLWDWHVSUHFRPLWHUHDGH
DFWHDQWLVRFLDOH´S$XWRULLVHUHIHU ODQXPHURDVHVWXGLLH[SHUL
PHQWDOHFDUHFRQILUP DFHDVW LSRWH] LQGLIHUHQWGHYkUVWDVXELHF LORU
'HDVHPHQHDFDWU V WXU GHSHUVRQDOLWDWHFRPXQ GHOLQFYHQ LORU
úL LQGLYL]LORU FX FRPSRUWDPHQW DQWLVRFLDO HVWH HPRWLYLWDWHD H[FHVLY
UHVSHFWLYKLSHUVHQVLELOLWDWHDVLVWHPXOXLOLPELFORFDOL]DWvQSDOHRFRUWH[
8OWHULRU vQ SULQ VFKHPD WULGLPHQVLRQDO D SHUVRQDOLW LL
(\VHQFN LQWURGXFH vQ HFXD LH SVLKRWLVPXO GLIHUHQ LLQG DVWIHO vQWUH
GHOLQFYHQ L FDUH DF LRQHD] PDL PXOW VROLWDU FDUH FRPLW GHOLFWH úL
FULPHFXRDJUHVLYLWDWHVDXFUX]LPHLQXWLO DF URUHFXD LHHVWHGRPL
QDW GHQLYHOXOULGLFDWDOFHOHLGHDWUHLDGLPHQVLXQLGHFLGHSRQGHUHD
PDUHDSVLKRWLVPXOXLvQPRGHOXOSHUVRQDOLW LL
&HUFHW ULOH OXL :LOVRQ LQGLF vQV F QX H[LVW HPSLULF R
GLIHUHQ vQWUH PRGHOHOH GH FRQGL LRQDUH GHWHUPLQDWH SHQWUX ORWXUL GH
GHOLQFYHQ LúLORWXOGHFRQWURO$FHODúLFHUFHW WRULQGLF GHDVHPHQHDF
H[WUDYHUVLD DúD FXP HVWH HYDOXDW GH FKHVWLRQDUHOH (\VHQFN QX H XQ
IDFWRU XQLWDU 3DUH D IL DOF WXLW GLQ GRX FRPSRQHQWH VRFLDELOLWDWHD úL
LPSXOVLYLWDWHD 3ULPD FRPSRQHQW UHIOHFW R XúXULQ vQ UHOD LLOH LQWHU
SHUVRQDOHFXLWHPLSUHFXPSOLQGHYLD YRUE UH OLSVLWGHWLPLGLWDWH
$ GRXD FRPSRQHQW LPSXOVLYLWDWHD LQFOXGH LWHPL SUHFXP DF LRQHD]
GXS LPSXOVXO PRPHQWXOXL UDSLG QX JkQGHúWH ÌQ VWXGLLOH SULYLQG
FULPLQDOLWDWHD úL GLPHQVLXQHD H[WUDYHUVLHL DVSHFWXO FDUH LQWHUYLQH
GLIHUHQ LDWRUSHQWUXORWXOGHGHOLQFYHQ LQXHVWHVRFLDELOLWDWHDFLWRFPDL
LPSXOVLYLWDWHD:LOVRQSULQLQFDSDFLWDWHDGHDDPkQDSULQOLSVD
GHU EGDUH
8QDOWVWXGLXUHDOL]DWGH*UD\URWHúWHFHOHD[HDOHIDF
WRULORU(úL1FXJUDGHúLLGHQWLILF GRLIDFWRULODFDUHFHLDQWHULRUL
FRQWULEXLHDVWIHO
IDFWRUXO DQ[LHWDWH FX DVSHFWHOH GH VWDELO H[WUDYHUW OD R
H[WUHP YVQHYURWLFLQWURYHUWODFHDODOW
IDFWRUXO LPSXOVLYLWDWH FX H[WUHPD VWDELO LQWURYHUW YV
QHYURWLFH[WUDYHUW
$Q[LHWDWHDDSDUHOHJDW vQSODQIL]LRORJLFGHXQVLVWHPGHLQKLEL LH
FRPSRUWDPHQWDO GHVXV LQHUHvQWLPSFHLPSXOVLYLWDWHDDVWIHOGHILQLW
HVWHOHJDW GHXQVLVWHPLQGHSHQGHQWvQF LQVXILFLHQWLQYHVWLJDW
$VWIHOUHLQWHUSUHWkQGWHRULDOXL(\VHQFNFRQVLGHU F WHVWHOHVDOH
VXQWFDSDELOHV GLIHUHQ LH]HORWXULOHGHFULPLQDOLGHORWXULOHGHFRQWURO
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH
FRQGL LRQDUH vQ JHQHUH FHHD FH GHSLQGH GH DOWFHYD ÌQ VWXGLLOH GH
FRQGL LRQDUH GHVFULH XQ U VSXQV FDUH D IRVW I FXW GHSHQGHQW GH XQ
VWLPXOLQL LDOQHXWUX7HUPHQXORULJLQDODOOXL3DYORYGHUHIOH[FRQGL
LRQDWHVWHGHQXPLWvQSUH]HQWU VSXQVFRQGL LRQDW
FRQWLQXXPWHUPHQFDUHVHUHIHU ODGLPHQVLXQLOHSHFDUHSRDWHYDULD
RFDUDFWHULVWLF GLVWLQFW GHFRPSRUWDPHQWvQWUHGRX H[WUHPHVDXSROL
GH H[HPSOX FRQWLQXXPXO H[WUDYHUVLH LQWURYHUVLH VH DSOLF DWkW
XQRUGLPHQVLXQLIL]LFHFkWúLXQRUGLPHQVLXQLVXELHFWLYHFDUHSRWIDFH
RELHFWXOXQHLHYDOX ULGHJUDGLHQW'3
GLVWDOGHS UWDWGHH[HPSOXvQSHUFHS LHVWLPXOGLVWDO
IDFWRU JHQHUDO IDFWRU GH JUXS IDFWRU VSHFLILF IDFWRU GH HURDUH
VXQW QLYHOH DOH DQDOL]HL IDFWRULDOH FDUH GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD WHRULHL OXL
(\VHQFNFRUHVSXQGWLSXOXLGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHWU V WXULLGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
GHSULQGHULORU VDX U VSXQVXULORU KDELWXDOH úL UHVSHFWLY U VSXQVXULORU
VSHFLILFHXQXLVXELHFW
IHQRWLSWRWDOLWDWHDvQVXúLULORUFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUúLWU V WXULORUDVWUXFWXULORU
IXQF LRQDOH GREkQGLWH vQ FXUVXO GH]YROW ULL SHUVRDQHL VXE LQIOXHQ D
IDFWRULORUFHDXDF LRQDWDVXSUDVD
JHQRWLS DQVDPEOXO FDUDFWHULVWLFLORU HUHGLWDUH WUDQVPLVH SULQ LQWHU
PHGLXOFHOXOHORUJHUPLQDOHFDGUXOJHQHWLFvQDIDUDRULF URULQIOXHQ H
SHULVWDOWLFHGHPHGLX
SULPLQJ SUHJ WLUHD XQXL VLVWHP GH IXQF LRQDUH XWLOL]DW vQ DFWLYLWDWHD
SVLKRORJLF SHQWUX D VH UHIHUL OD IDSWXO F XQ DQLPDO FDUH D U VSXQV
DQWHULRU XQHL VWLPXO UL HOHFWULFH FUDQLHQH SRDWH V QX UHXúHDVF V
U VSXQG XOWHULRUGDF QXLVHG XQDVDXPDLPXOWHVWLPXO ULGHWLS
SULPLQJ ÌQ VWXGLXO vQY ULL VH UHIHU OD SUH]HQWDUHD XQHL H[SHULHQ H
VSHFLILFHFDUHIDFHXQDQLPDOPDLVHQVLELOVDXPDLDSWV U VSXQG ODR
JDP ODUJ GHVWLPXOL
SUR[LPDODSURSLDW
SVLKRWLFVHUHIHU ODWXOEXODUHSVLKRWLF RFRQGL LHVHYHU GHRULJLQH
RUJDQLF VDXHPR LRQDO DOHF UHLVLPSWRPHFODVLFHLQFOXGLOX]LDKDOX
FLQD LDFRPSRUWDPHQWHUHJUHVLYHVHYHUHYRUELUHLQFRHUHQW GLVSR]L LL
GUDPDWLFQHDGHFYDWHIRORVLWvQFRPELQD LHFXDOWWHUPHQGLDJQRVWLFVH
UHIHU OD FRQGL LD vQ FDUH XQXO GLQWUH VLPSWRPHOH FDUH FDUDFWHUL]HD]
ERDO SVLKLF DUHFDUDFWHULVWLFLFDUHVHDVHDP Q PXOWFXRSVLKR] GH
H[HPSOXGHSUHVLHSVLKRWLF
SVLKRSDWFDWHUPHQJHQHUDOGHVHPQHD] RWXOEXUDUHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
VHYHU FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQ DPRUDOLWDWH OLSVD DIHFWHORU úL XQ VLP GLPL
QXDWDOQHOLQLúWLLúLYLQRY LHLvQVLWXD LLOHFkQGvQFDOF OHJHD
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU
ÌQFHFRQVW YL]LXQHDOXL(\VHQFNDVXSUDLHUDUKLHLIDFWRULORURE L
QX LSULQDQDOL]DIDFWRULDO vQGHVFULHUHDQLYHOHORUSHUVRQDOLW LL"
&DUHHVWHGHVFULHUHDIDFWRUXOXLH[WUDYHUVLHLQWURYHUVLHOD(\VHQFN"
&DUHHVWHIXQGDOXOELRIXQF LRQDODOH[WUDYHUVLHL"
&DUHHVWHGHVFULHUHDIDFWRUXOXLHFKLOLEUXQHYUR]LVPLQVWDELOLWDWH
VWDELOLWDWHHPR LRQDO "
&DUHHVWHIXQGDOXOELRIXQF LRQDODODFHVWXLIDFWRU"
&DUHHVWHGHVFULHUHDIDFWRUXOXLSVLKRWLVPOD(\VHQFN"
&HVHPQLILF vQLQWHUSUHWDUHDWHVWHORU(3,VDX(34VFDOD/"
%LEOLRJUDILH
% EDQ $ 'HUHYHQFR 3 (\VHQFN 6%* 7HVWXO (34 Ä5HYLVWD GH
3VLKRORJLH´
&KDSPDQ -3 &KDSPDQ /- .ZDSLO 75 'RHV WKH (\VHQFN
3V\FKRWLVP 6FDOH 3UHGLFW 3V\FKRVLV" $ 7HQ <HDU /RQJLWXGLQDO 6WXG\
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV
(\VHQFN+-/HVGLPHQVLRQVGHODSHUVRQDOLWp38)3DULV
(\VHQFN+-7KH6FLHQWLILF6WXG\RI+XPDQ3HUVRQDOLW\:LOH\1HZ
<RUN
(\VHQFN+-7KH%LRORJLFDO%DVHVRI3HUVRQDOLW\&KDUOHV&7KRDV
6SULQJILHOG
(\VHQFN 7KH 0HDVXUHPHQW RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 5RXWOHGJHDQG .HJDQ
/RQGRQ
(\VHQFN +- 6\ELO (\VHQFN 0DQXDO RI WKH (\VHQFN 3HUVRQDOLW\
4XHVWLRQQDLUH8QLYRI/RQGRQ3UHVV/RQGRQ
(\VHQFN +- +XPDQ 0HPRU\ 7KHRU\ 5HVHDUFK DQG ,QGLYLGXDO
'LIIHUHQFHV3HUJDPRQ2[IRUG
(\VHQFN+-&ULPHDQG3HUVRQDOLW\5RXWOHGJHDQG.HJDQ/RQGRQ
(\VHQFN +- 7KH 'HILQLWLRQ DQG 0HDVXUHPHQW RI 3V\FKRWLFLVP
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV
(\VHQFN+-&UHDWLYLW\DQG3HUVRQDOLW\D7KHRUHWLFDO3HUVSHFWLYHvQ
Ä3V\FKRORJLFDO,QTXLU\´
(\VHQFN+-&UHDWLYLW\DVD3URGXFWRI,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG3HUVRQDOLW\
vQ 6DORIVNH '+ =HLGQHU 0 HG ,QWHUQDWLRQDO +DQGERRN RI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG,QWHOOLJHQFH3OHQXO1HZ<RUN
(\VHQFN +- &RQVWUXFW 9DOLGLW\ RI ([SHULHPQWDO 6WXGLHV RI
3HUVRQDOLW\Ä(XURS-RXUQRI3HUVRQDOLW\$VVHVVPHQW´VXSO
(\VHQFN 0: 7UDLW $Q[LHW\ $ 0RGXODU $SSURDFK $ 9,,D FRQIH
ULQ D($33
=XFNHUPDQ03HUVRQDOLW\DQGWKH7KLUG'LPHQVLRQD3V\FKRELRORJLFDO
$SSURDFK3HUVRQDOLW\DQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV
&DSLWROXO9,,
&+(67,21$58/'(7(1',1 (
$&&(178$7(60,(6&+(&.
3UH]HQWDUHD &KHVWLRQDUXOXL GH WHQGLQ H DFFHQWXDWH FXSULQGH
GDWHSULYLQGWHRULDOXL./HRQKDUGSULYLQGQRUPDOLWDWHDúLFRQGL LDGH
DQRUPDOLWDWHSUH]HQWDUHD&KHVWLRQDUXOXLGHWHQGLQ HDFFHQWXDWHSUH
]HQWDUHDXQRUFDUDFWHULVWLFLDOHWLSXULORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDFFHQWXDWH
6XQWSUH]HQWDWHH[LVWLQGHULSULYLQGGLDJQR]DSVLKLDWULF DWXOEXU ULORU
GHSHUVRQDOLWDWHSUHFXPúLFXYLQWHFDUDFWHULVWLFHXQWHVWGHHYDOXDUH
DFXQRúWLQ HORUúLUHIHULQ HOHELEOLRJUDILFH
7HRULDOXL./HRQKDUGSULYLQGQRUPDOLWDWHD
úLFRQGL LDGHDQRUPDOLWDWH
ÌQFDGUXOFRQWLQXXPOXLGLQWUHQRUPDOLWDWHúLDQRUPDOLWDWHDYkQG
vQYHGHUHDVSHFWHOHGHVWUXFWXU IXQF LRQDUHúLDGDSWDUHGLQSHUVSHFWLYD
SVLKRORJLF GHSHUVRQDOLW LPDWXUHYVLPDWXUHGHH[HPSOXLPDWXULWDWHD
SHUVRQDOLW LLvQIRUPDUHDDGROHVFHQWXOXLSXWHPYRUELGHSHUVRQDOLW L
DFFHQWXDWHSHUVRQDOLW LGHVWUXFWXUDWHúLSHUVRQDOLW LSDWRORJLFH
&DWHJRULDSHUVRQDOLW LORUDFFHQWXDWHSUH]LQW RVHULHGHFDUDFWH
ULVWLFLFDUHLHVGLQFRPXQGLQÄPHGLD´GHPDQLIHVWDUHvQFDGUXOSRSX
OD LHLJHQHUDOHFDUHPDQLIHVW WHQGLQ DGHDDOXQHFDvQDQRUPDOI U D
GHYHQL SURSULX]LV WXOEXU UL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH 7U V WXULOH VSHFLILFH
DFFHQWX ULL VH PDQLIHVW FD LQYDULDQ L RSHUD LRQDOL úL YRU JHQHUD
PDQLIHVW UL SUHJQDQWH vQ WHUPHQL QRUPDWLYL QX QXPDL vQ UDSRUW GH
ÄPHGLH´GDUúLGHÄDEDWHULOHGHODPHGLH´/LPLWHOHGLQWUHQRUPDOvQ
WHUPHQLFDQWLWDWLYLWHQGLQ DVSUHÄPHGLX´DFFHQWXDWúLGL]DUPRQLFQX
VXQW IL[H LDU GHOLPLW ULOH VSHFLILFH VH UHDOL]HD] vQ IXQF LH GH LQWHQ
VLWDWHDFRQVWDQ DúLJUDGXOGHVRFLDOL]DUHDOPDQLIHVW ULLFDUHH[SULP
WU V WXUDDFFHQWXDW LQGHSHQGHQWGHvPSUHMXU ULOHH[WHULRDUH
7HQGLQ D VSUH SDWRORJLH H[LVW OD QLYHOXO VWUXFWXULORU GH SHU
VRQDOLWDWH DFFHQWXDWH GDU vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH HD HVWH VRFLDOL]DW úL
VXEOLPDW SXWHP YRUEL OD DFHVWH SHUVRDQH GH R ÄDGDSWDUH FX QRWH
VSHFLDOH´$FFHQWXDUHDvQVHQVSR]LWLYVDXQHJDWLYSUHVXSXQHRPDQL
IHVWDUH LHúLW GLQ FRPXQ vQ PRG FRQVWDQW LQGLIHUHQW GH VLWXD LH 2
WU V WXU DFFHQWXDW HYROXHD] FX XQ JUDG PDL PDUH GH SUREDELOLWDWH
VSUH VHQVXO QHJDWLY DWXQFL FkQG vPSUHMXU ULOH GH YLD DOH SHUVRDQHL
IDYRUL]HD] DFHVW OXFUX ÌQ DFHVWH FRQGL LL OLSVD GH VRFLDOL]DUH D
WU V WXULL FRQGXFH VSUH GH]YROWDUHD XQHL SHUVRQDOLW L GL]DUPRQLFH úL
SHUVRDQDVHDIO vQWUXQGH]HFKLOLEUXFRQVWDQWFXVLQHúLFXOXPHDLDU
GHYLHUHD GHYLQH IXQGDPHQWDO 3HUVRDQD vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH DUH
FRQúWLLQ D DFHVWHL WXOEXU UL D IDSWXOXL F DGDSWDUHD OD UHDOLWDWH HVWH
SXWHUQLF SHUWXUEDW VH DS U MXVWLILFkQG FRQGL LD vQ IDYRDUHD VD úL vQ
GHIDYRDUHDOXPLL
.DUO/HRQDUGGHVFULHDFHVWHWLSXULGLQGDWHOHHPSLULFHFOL
QLFHúLHVWHFHOFDUHLQWURGXFHWHUPHQXOGHÄSHUVRQDOLWDWHDFFHQWXDW ´
.DUO/HRQKDUG
$XWRUXOJHUPDQDGXFHvQGLDJQR]DSHUVRQDOLW LL
RWHRULHIRQGDW SHSUDFWLFDVDSVLKLDWULF FDPHGLFúL
GLUHFWRUDO&OLQLFLLGHSVLKLDWULHúLQHXURORJLHD8QLYHU
VLW LL +XPEROGW GLQ %HUOLQ /XFUDUHD UHSUH]HQWDWLY
FDUH vL FRQVDFU WHRULD úL SUDFWLFD WHUDSHXWLF HVWH
$N]HQWXLHUWH3HUV|QOLFKNHLWHQ%HUOLQ
3HQWUX /HRQKDUG WU V WXULOH VSHFLILFH DFFHQWX ULL VXQW vQ IDSW
LQYDULDQ LRSHUD LRQDOLFDUHJHQHUHD] PDQLIHVW ULSUHJQDQWHQXQXPDLvQ
UDSRUW FX PHGLD FL úL FX DEDWHULOH GH OD PHGLH 6XE UDSRUWXO LQWHJU ULL
VRFLDOHDXWRUXOGHPRQVWUHD] F SHUVRQDOLW LOHDFFHQWXDWHSUH]LQW GRDU
R WHQGLQ VSUH SDWRORJLH GDU FkQG DFHDVW WHQGLQ HVWH VXEOLPDW
DFHVW SURFHV IDFH FD úL FRPSRUWDPHQWXO SHUVRDQHL V VH SRDW vQFDGUD
vQWUHOLPLWHOHXQHLDGDSWDELOLW LVRFLDOHÄFXQRWHVSHFLILFH´VDXVSHFLDOH
$VWIHOVLWXkQGFRQGXLWDvQVSUHFHOHGRX H[WUHPHDFFHQWXDUHDSUHVXSXQH
RPDQLIHVWDUHLHúLW GLQFRPXQvQPRGFRQVWDQWLQGLIHUHQWGHVLWXD LH
&HOPDLSUREDELOHVWHFDRWU V WXU DFFHQWXDW V HYROXH]HFXXQJUDG
PDLPDUHGHSUREDELOLWDWHvQVHQVQHJDWLYPDLDOHVFkQGvPSUHMXU ULOH
GH YLD FX FDUH VH FRQIUXQW LQGLYLGXO IDYRUL]HD] DFHVW OXFUX &kQG
SULQ WU V WXUD DFFHQWXDW VH GH]YROW R SHUVRQDOLWDWH GLVDUPRQLF XQ
GH]HFKLOLEUXFRQVWDQWFXVLQHúLFXOXPHDVXQWHPvQVLWXD LDQHJDWLY vQ
FDUHGHYLHUHDHVWHSXWHUQLF VWUXFWXUDúLIXQF LRQDOLWDWHDVXQWSHUWXUEDWH
FHHDFHGXFHODSHUWXUEDUHDVHPQLILFDWLY DFDSDFLW LLGHDVHDGDSWDOD
UHDOLWDWHÌQDFHDVW VLWXD LHLQGLYLGXODUHFRQúWLLQ DSHUWXUE ULLGDUVSUH
GHRVHELUHPDLDOHVGHFRQGL LDQHYURWLF DUHWHQGLQ DV MXVWLILFHDFHVW
OXFUXvQIDYRDUHDVDúLvQGHIDYRDUHDOXPLL'HVLJXUHVWHOHVQHGHvQ HOHV
F GLQDFHDVW SHUVSHFWLY OLPLWHOHGLQWUHQRUPDOúLDQRUPDODFFHQWXDW
úL GLVDUPRQLF ± SVLKRSDWRORJLH VDX VRFLRSDWRORJLH QX VXQW GHORF IL[H
GHOLPLW ULOH SRW IL I FXWH vQ IXQF LH GH LQWHQVLWDWHD úL FRQVWDQ D PDQL
IHVW ULLXQHLDQXPLWHWU V WXULLQGHSHQGHQWGHvPSUHMXU ULOHH[WHULRDUH
/HRQKDUG FD SVLKLDWUX WLQGH V H[SOLFH F WLSXULOH VH IRUPHD]
vQYLD SULQIDSWXOF RDQXPLW FRQGL LHVRFLDO vQFDUHLQWU úLUHOD LD
úL SR]L LD LQGLYLGXOXL vQ VRFLHWDWH vúL SXQH DPSUHQWD PRGHOHD] R
vQFOLQD LHQDWXUDO FDUHPHUJHvQDFHHDúLGLUHF LH9RUEHúWHDVHPHQHD
DOWRU SVLKRORJL GH H[HPSOX / 6]RQGL 0 / VFKHU úL GH XQ DQXPH
WURSLVP vQ UHOD LH FX SURIHVLD DOHDV LQGLYLGXO WLQGH V DOHDJ R
SURIHVLH SHQWUX F DFHDVWD SHUPLWH vQFOLQD LLORU VDOH QDWXUDOH V VH
H[SULPH V VH UHDOL]H]H vQ PRGXO FHO PDL FRPSOHW $FHVWH PRGHO UL
GLQVSUH VRFLDO PDUFKHD] SHULRDGD GH IRUPDUH GLDJQRVWLFXO SHUVRQD
OLW LL QX HVWH vQ PRG VHULRV SHULFOLWDW GH LQIOXHQ HOH FH LQWHUYLQ vQ
SHULRDGD GH PDWXULWDWH SHQWUX F DFHVWHD PDL GHJUDE IL[HD] IRUPD
H[WHULRDU DFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLúLQXRULHQW ULOHGHED] O XQWULFH
&ODVLILFDUHDVDFXSULQGHFDWU V WXULDFFHQWXDWHDOHILULL
x WLSXOKLSHUSHUVHYHUHQWVXVFHSWLELOLWDWHDúLDPEL LD
x WLSXOKLSHUH[DFWFRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWHDúLVHULR]LWDWHDVXQWH[DJHUDWH
x WLSXOGHPRQVWUDWLYWHDWUDOVHDXWRODXG úLDXWRFRPS WLPHúWH
x WLSXO QHVW SkQLW LUDVFLELO LQGLVSR]L LH FURQLF GHYLHUL vQ GLUHF LD
DOFRROLVPXOXLVDXVH[XDOH
&RPELQD LLDOHWU V WXULORUGHFDUDFWHUDFFHQWXDWHFHFRQGXFVSUH
x WLSXOKLSHUWLPLFORFYDFHFXRFRQVWDQW EXQ GLVSR]L LH
x WLSXOGLVWLPLFSRVRPRUkWVHULR]LWDWHH[DJHUDW
x WLSXOODELORVFLOD LLvQWUHYHVHOLHúLW FHUHKLSHUúLGLVWLPLH
x WLSXO HPRWLY WU LUL DIHFWLYH SXWHUQLFH GHWHUPLQDWH DWkW GH HYHQL
PHQWHWULVWHFkWúLIHULFLWH
x WLSXOH[DOWDWH[FHVLY RVFLOD LHDDIHFWHORUvQWUHHXIRULHúLGHSUHVLH
x WLSXODQ[LRV
&RPELQD LLDOHWU V WXULORUGHFDUDFWHUúLWHPSHUDPHQWDFFHQWXDWH
x WLSXOLQWURYHUWLWWU LHúWHSUHSRQGHUHQWvQOXPHDLPDJLQD LHL
x WLSXOH[WUDYHUWLWWU LHúWHSUHSRQGHUHQWvQOXPHDSHUFHS LHL
x WLSXOLQWURYHUWLWKLSHUWLPLF
&KHVWLRQDUXOGHWHQGLQ HDFFHQWXDWH
ÌQFDWHJRULDLQVWUXPHQWHORUGHHYDOXDUHDGLPHQVLXQLORUDFFHQWXDWH
DOHSHUVRQDOLW LLOD8QLYHUVLWDWHD+XPEROG+6FKPLHVFKHFNFUHHD]
vQ&KHVWLRQDUXOGHWHQGLQ HDFFHQWXDWH&KHVWLRQDUXOHVWHWUDGXV
úLH[SHULPHQWDWvQOLPEDURPkQ GH,1HVWRUvQ
(VWHIRUPDWGLQLWHPLUHSDUWL]D LSHVFDOHFDUHFRUHVSXQG
ODWLSXULGHWU V WXULDFFHQWXDWHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLVFDOD,GHPRQV
WUDWLYLWDWH LWHPL VFDOD ,, KLSHUH[DFWLWDWH LWHPL VFDOD ,,,
KLSHUSHUVHYHUHQ LWHPLVFDODD,9DOLSVDGHVW SkQLUHFRQWURO
LWHPLVFDOD9KLSHUWLPLHLWHPLVFDODD9,DGLVWLPLHLWHPL
VFDOD D 9,,D FLFORWLPLH LWHPL VFDOD D 9,,,D H[DOWDUH LWHPL
VFDODD,;DDQ[LHWDWHLWHPLVFDODD;DHPRWLYLWDWHLWHPL
7LPSXOGHOXFUXHVWHOLEHUúLGHRELFHLYDULD] vQWUHúLPL
QXWH&RUHFWXUDVHIDFHvQIXQF LHGHJULODGHU VSXQVXULVLPSWRPDWLFH
GDUFDOFXODUHDQRWHORUEUXWHVHIDFHSULQWURFRUHF LHvQPXO LQGXVHFX
XQ FRHILFLHQW VSHFLILF SHQWUX ILHFDUH VFDO vQ IXQF LH GH QXP UXO
LWHPLORU &LIUD UH]XOWDW SRDWH OXD FD YDORDUH PD[LP GH SXQFWH
YDORDUHD LQGLF XQ SURFHQW VLPSWRPDWLF GH YDORDUHD XQ
SURFHQWGHYDORDUHDXQSURFHQWGHYDORDUHDXQSURFHQW
GHÌQDFHVWHFRQGL LLVHSRDWHYRUELGHRYHULWDELO DFFHQWXDUHGRDU
vQVLWXD LDFkQGSURFHQWXOODXQDVDXPDLPXOWHVFDOHWUHFHGH
3UH]HQWDUHDFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUXQRUWLSXULGHILULDFFHQWXDWH
)LUHDGHPRQVWUDWLY
(VHQ D ILULL GHPRQVWUDWLYH FDUH DWXQFL FkQG DWLQJH JUDGH PDL
vQDOWHGHYLQHILUHLVWHULF UH]LG vQFDSDFLWDWHDDQRUPDO GHUHIXODUH
1R LXQHD GH UHIXODUH D IRVW vQWUHEXLQ DW vQDLQWHD OXL )UHXG GDU VD
vQFHW HQLW vQ OLWHUDWXUD SVLKLDWULF GDWRULW OXL 5HIXODUHD SRDWH IL
FRQVLGHUDW FDXQSURFHVSVLKLFXQLYHUVDOGHRDUHFHVHDIO ODRULJLQHD
FRQVWLWXLULL LQFRQúWLHQWXOXL FD GRPHQLX VHSDUDW GH UHVWXO SVLKLVPXOXL
)UHXG GHILQHúWH UHIXODUHD FD ILLQG RSHUD LXQHD SULQ FDUH VXELHFWXO
vQFHDUF V UHVSLQJ VDX V PHQ LQ vQ LQFRQúWLHQW UHSUH]HQW UL JkQ
GXULLPDJLQLDPLQWLULOHJDWHGHRSXOVLXQH5HIXODUHDVHSURGXFHvQ
FD]XULOHvQFDUHVDWLVIDFHUHDXQHLSXOVLXQL±VXVFHSWLELO SULQHDvQV úL
V SURGXF SO FHUH ± ULVF V SURYRDFH QHSO FHUH vQ UDSRUW FX DOWH
H[LJHQ H /DSODQFKH 3RQWDOLV ÌQ DFHDVW VLWXD LH VH YRUEHúWH
GHVSUH DIHFW EORFDW ÌQ FD]XO LVWHULFLORU DIHFWXO vQ ORF V ILH OHJDW GH
UHSUH]HQWDUH HVWH FRQYHUWLW UHDOL]kQGXVH DVWIHO R VFL]LXQH H[LVW
DIHFWI U UHSUH]HQWDUHúLUHSUH]HQWDUHI U DIHFW
)UHXG6LJPXQG
1 VFXWvQ)UHLEHUJ0RUDYLD6WXGLD] PHGLFLQDOD
8QLYHUVLWDWHDGLQ9LHQDVHVSHFLDOL]HD] FDQHXURORJúL
FRODERUHD] VWUkQV FX QHXURORJXO -RVHI %UHXHU vQ WUD
WDPHQWXO LVWHULHL 6WXGLD] OD 3DULV VXE FRQGXFHUHD OXL
-0&KDUFRWVSHFLDOL]kQGXVHvQSVLKRSDWRORJLH
'H]YROW WHKQLFDÄDVRFLD LHLOLEHUH´GHILQHúWHSVLK
DQDOL]D FD PHWRG GH WUDWDPHQW LQWHUSUHWkQG GDWH GLQ
FRSLO ULD SDFLHQ LORU úL DPLQWLUHD YLVHORU úL SHUPL kQG
SDFLHQWXOXL V úL H[SULPH JkQGXULOH vQWUR VWDUH GH FRQ
úWLLQ UHOD[DW
' QDúWHUHFRQFHSWXOXLGHÄFRPSOH[DOOXL2HGLS´
QXPH GDW SHQWUX VHQWLPHQWHOH HURWLFH DOH ILXOXL SHQWUX
PDPDVDúLVLP XOXLGHFRPSHWL LHFXWDW O
2SHUDVDPDMRU LQWHUSUHWDUHDYLVHORUVXV LQH
F YLVHOHVXQWRvPSOLQLUHGHJKL]DW DGRULQ HORU3URGXFH
OXFU UL FUXFLDOH SHQWUX GH]YROWDUHD WHRULHL SVLKDQDOLWLFH
3VLKRSDWRORJLDYLH LLFRWLGLHQH7UHLHVHXULDVXSUD
WHRULHL VH[XDOLW LL 7RWHP úL 7DEX 'LQFROR
GHSULQFLSLXOSO FHULL(JRXOúL,GXOHODER
UkQGXúLWHRULDDVXSUDvPS U LULLLQFRQúWLHQWXOXLvQLGHJR
úLVXSHUHJR
,GHLOHúLGDWHOHVDOHDXDYXWLQIOXHQ DVXSUDPXOWRU
GRPHQLLFULPLQRORJLHVRFLRORJLHDQWURSRORJLHOXFU ULOH
VDOHDXVFKLPEDWPRGXOFXPHUDFRQVLGHUDW SHUVRQDOLWDWHD
úLPRWLYD LDúLDXFRQGXVODRUHHYDOXDUHDLPSRUWDQ HLDWUL
EXLWH UHOD LLORU WLPSXULL GH IDPLOLH úL D HIHFWHORU DFHVWRUD
DVXSUDGH]YROW ULLSHUVRQDOLW LL
2DOW WU V WXU FDUDFWHULVWLF ILULLGHPRQVWUDWLYHHVWHODXGD'H
RELFHL RDPHQLL QX VH ODXG VLQJXUL FKLDU GDF DGHVHD DU GRUL DFHVW
OXFUX SHQWUX F VH WHP GH GH]DSUREDUHD FHORUODO L 3HUVRQDOLWDWHD
GHPRQVWUDWLY SRDWHvQO WXUDDVHPHQHDLQKLEL LLúLGHFLVHSRDWHO XGD
VLQJXU EXFXUkQGXVH I U UH]HUYH GH DXUHROD SH FDUH VLQJXU úLD
I XULWR /DXGHL GH VLQH FD DFWLYLWDWH YHUEDO L VH DGDXJ GH RELFHL
DFWLYLWDWHDSUDFWLF vQVFRSXOGHDVHDILUPDDGLF VW UXLQ DGHDVWkUQL
LQWHUHVXO SOLQ GH UHVSHFW DO FROHFWLYLW LL 3HUVRDQHOH GHPRQVWUDWLYH
UHIXOHD] GLVFRQIRUWXO DWXQFL FkQG VXQW vQ FHQWUXO DWHQ LHL JHQHUDOH
UHYHQGLFkQGI U MHQ SHQWUXVLQHRVLWXD LHDSDUWHúLVXQWvQVWDUHV VH
EXFXUH GH HD I U UH]HUYH $FHDVW GRULQ GH D IL FX RULFH SUH vQ
FHQWUXODWHQ LHLVHvQFDGUHD] vQQHYRLDGHUHFXQRDúWHUHVRFLDO
/D SHUVRQDOLW LOH GHPRQVWUDWLYH SRDWH IL UHPDUFDW WHQGLQ D GH
DXWRFRPS WLPLUH,VWHULFXOvúLUHIX] LQKLEL LLOHSULYLWRDUHODODPHQW ULOH
VDOHúLvúLMRDF QHVWLQJKHULWUROXOGHPDUWLU$FHúWLDVXQWRDPHQLLFDUHvúL
J VHVFvQERDO DWkWVDWLVIDF LDGLUHFW FkWúLSHFHDLQGLUHFW ÌQDFHVW
VHQV)UHXGYRUEHúWHGHVSUHÄEHQHILFLXOSULPDU´úLÄEHQHILFLXOVHFXQGDU´
DOEROLLÄ%HQHILFLXOSULPDU´HVWHOHJDWGHvQVXúLGLQDPLVPXOVLPSWRPHORU
ÌQ DFHDVW VLWXD LH VH GLVWLQJ GRX S U L ÄSDUWHD LQWHUQ D EHQHILFLXOXL
SULPDU´FRQVW vQUHGXFHUHDGHWHQVLXQHSHFDUHRSURFXU VLPSWRPXO
DFHVWDRULFkWGHGXUHURVDUILDUHGUHSWVFRSV OVFXWHDVF SHVXELHFWGH
FRQIOLFWH XQHRUL PDL QHSO FXWH ± HVWH PHFDQLVPXO DúD]LVHL ÄIXJL vQ
ERDO ´Ä3DUWHDH[WHUQ DEHQHILFLXOXLSULPDU´DUILOHJDW GHPRGLILF ULOH
SH FDUH VLPSWRPXO OH DGXFH vQ UHOD LLOH LQWHUSHUVRQDOH DOH VXELHFWXOXL
$VWIHORIHPHLHÄRSULPDW GHVR XOHL´SRDWHRE LQHPXO XPLW QHYUR]HL
PDL PXOW WDQGUH H úL DWHQ LH U ]EXQkQGXVH vQ DFHODúL WLPS SHQWUX
WUDWDPHQWXODVSUXvQGXUDW
'LQWUHvQVXúLULOHSHUVRQDOLW LORUGHPRQVWUDWLYHIDFHSDUWHREXQ
FDSDFLWDWH GH DGDSWDUH OD DO L RDPHQL 3HUVRDQHOH DYkQG R WU V WXU
LVWHULF DX DGHVHD VXFFHV vQ DFHOH SURIHVLXQL vQ FDUH HVWH QHFHVDU
HPSDWLD$FHVWWDOHQWDOORUSURYLQHGLQIDSWXOF HLSRWV IDF DEVWUDF LH
GHSURSULDORUILUHúLV MRDFHDFHOUROFDUHFRUHVSXQGHILULLFHOXLODOWVDX
VHSRDWHGDWRUDQHYRLLORUGHDILDFFHSWD LúLDSUHFLD LGHFHLODO LÌQIHOXO
DFHVWDVHH[SOLF GHIDSWGDUXOSHFDUHvODXSHUVRQDOLW LOHGHPRQVWUD
WLYHGHDVHIDFHLXELWH
ÌQ SVLKDQDOL] VH YRUEHúWH GHVSUH GRX IRUPH VLPSWRPDWLFH
LVWHULD GH FRQYHUVLH vQ FDUH FRQIOLFWXO SVLKLF HVWH VLPEROL]DW SULQ
VLPSWRPHFRUSRUDOHGLQWUHFHOHPDLGLYHUVHSDUR[LVWLFHVDXGXUDELOHúL
LVWHULDGHDQJRDV vQFDUHDQJRDVDHVWHIL[DW vQWUXQPRGPDLPXOW
VDXPDLSX LQVWDELOODXQDQXPLWRELHFWH[WHULRUIRELL
6SHFLILFLWDWHD LVWHULHL HVWH F XWDW vQ SUHYDOHQ D XQXL DQXPLW WLS
GH LGHQWLILFDUH D DQXPLWRU PHFDQLVPH PDL DOHV UHIXODUHD GHVHRUL
PDQLIHVW vQHPHUJHQ DFRQIOLFWXOXL°GLSLDQ
,VWHULFLL FRQVHUY HPR LD UHIXODW PRWLY SHQWUX FDUH VH SRDWH
DILUPDF HLVXQWEROQDYLGHHPR LH$FHDVW HPR LHGHFODQúDW GHR
FLUFXPVWDQ SDWRJHQ QXSRDWHILH[SULPDW vQPRGQRUPDOúLDVWIHO
U PkQH ÄEORFDW ´ $FHVWH HIHFWH EORFDWH DX XQ GXEOX GHVWLQ HOH SRW
SHUVLVWDDúDFXPVXQWúLGHYLQDS V WRDUHSHQWUXvQWUHDJDYLD SVLKLF
ID GHFDUHUHSUH]LQW RVXUV GHLULWDUHSHUPDQHQW VDXVHWUDQVIRUP
vQ SURFHVH FRUSRUDOH DQRUPDOH SURFHVH GH LQHUYD LH VDX GH LQKLEL LH
FDUHQXVXQWDOWFHYDGHFkWVLPSWRPHSVLKLFHDOHQHYUR]HLGHIDSWFRQ
YHUVLHLVWHULF ÌQYLD DQRUPDO RDQXPHFDQWLWDWHGLQHQHUJLDQRDVWU
DIHFWLY HVWHvQWUHEXLQ DW vQLQHUYD LDFRUSRUDO úLSURGXFHIHQRPHQXO
GH H[SULPDUH D HPR LLORU &RQYHUVLD LVWHULF QX HVWH DOWFHYD GHFkW R
H[SUHVLHH[DJHUDW DHPR LHLFDUHVHWUDGXFHSULQPLMORDFHQHRELúQXLWH
3ULQXUPDUHSURFHVXODIHFWLYRFXS SULPXOORFvQFDGUXOLVWHULHL
'RULQ DLVWHULFXOXLVHUHIHU vQWRWGHDXQDODHOXGDUHDXQHLVLWXD LL
GLILFLOHDXQXLFRQIOLFWHYLWDUHDXQXLHIRUW3HUVRQDOLW LOHGHPRQVWUDWLYH
DU IL FDUDFWHUL]DWH vQ RSLQLD DXWRUXOXL SULQ ODXG GH VLQH vQVR LW GH
RELFHL GH XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW VSHFLILF FX VFRS GH DILUPDUH WHQGLQ GH
DXWRFRPS WLPLUHSULSHDO vQGHFL]LLFDSDFLWDWHGHDVHIDFHLXELWH
3DWRVXOHVWHFRQVLGHUDWGH/HRQKDUGIRUPDWLSLF DSHUVRQDOLW LL
LVWHULFH XQ DGHY UDW HWDORQ )LULOH GHPRQVWUDWLYH SUH]LQW SDWHWLVP vQ
YRUELUHJHVWLF PLPLF 6XQWVXEOLQLDWHGHDVHPHQHDWHQGLQ HOHSHUVR
QDOLW LORUGHPRQVWUDWLYHúLLVWHULFHGHDvQO WXUDGLQFRQúWLLQ DVSHFWHOH
QHSO FXWH FDUH DU SXWHD V VWLPXOH]H R JkQGLUH DFWLY VXELHF LL PHQ L
QkQGXVH vQWUR DWLWXGLQH GHWDúDW O VkQGXVH vQ YRLDPDQLIHVW ULORUFH
VHGHVI úRDU QHVWLQJKHULWvPERJ LQGWH]DXUXOIDQWH]LHL
(JRFHQWULVPXO DFHVWXL WLS GH LQGLYLG YHULWDELO ÄVXJDWLY DIHF
WLY vúLDIO U G FLQLOHvQLQDGHFYDUHDDSUHFLHULLYDORULORUXPDQHúLvQ
LQFDSDFLWDWHD GH DúL UHSUH]HQWD WU LULOH úL GRULQ HOH FHOXLODOW $FHVWHD
VH GDWRUHD] LPDWXULW LL úL ODELOLW LL HPR LRQDOH HYLGHQ LDWH SULQWUR
SDUWLFLSDUHFDOHLGRVFRSLF ODWU LULOHDQWXUDMXOXL5HIHULWRUODDFHDVW
ODELOLWDWH-DQHVFKDILUP F LVWHULFXODUHRPLHGHVLP PLQWHGDUQLFL
XQVHQWLPHQW
)LUHDKLSHUH[DFW
)LUHDKLSHUH[DFW HVWHFRQWUDULXOILULLGHPRQVWUDWLYHúLVHGLVWLQJH
SULQ OLSVD FDSDFLW LL GH UHIXODUH ÌQ WLPS FH LVWHULFLL DF LRQHD] VXE
LPSXOVXO PRPHQWXOXL FKLDU úL vQ FD]XULOH vQ FDUH DU WUHEXL V PDL
UHIOHFWH]HDQDQFDúWLLQXSRWOXDRKRW UkUHQLFLDWXQFLFkQGH[LVW WRDWH
SUHPLVHOH SHQWUX DFHDVWD (L YRU V DQDOL]H]H WRWXO SkQ OD XOWLPHOH
FRQVHFLQ HvQDLQWHGHDDF LRQDQXSRWHOLPLQDGLQFRQúWLLQ QLFLFHOH
PDLPLFLSRVLELOLW LGHDJ VLSRDWHWRWXúLRVROX LHPDLEXQ FXDOWH
FXYLQWHQXVXQWvQVWDUHV UHIXOH]HúLGLQDFHDVW FDX] DXGLILFXOW L
vQ DFWLYLWDWHD ORU $VWIHO SULSHDOD LVWHULF DUH OD SROXO RSXV QHKRW
UkUHDDQDQFDVW ,QKLEDUHDGHYLQHGLILFLO QXPDLvQFD]XULOHvQFDUHVH
FRQWXUHD] XQSHULFRO±DFHODGHDSURFHGDJUHúLWSULFLQXLQGDVWIHOXQ
UH]XOWDW QHSO FXW VDX FRPSURPL kQG DVWIHO R SHUVSHFWLY SO FXW
&KHVWLXQLOH GH PLF LPSRUWDQ SRW IL UH]ROYDWH O XQWULF I U PDUH
JUHXWDWHSHQWUXDFHDVWDQHILLQGYUHRGLILFXOWDWHvQOXDUHDXQHLKRW UkUL
QLFLFKLDUSHQWUXXQDQDQFDVW
ÌQVLWXD LDvQFDUHVHDMXQJHODRQHYUR] OXDUHDKRW UkULORULP
SRUWDQWHU PkQHRSUREOHP GDUSHULFROXOFDUHvPSLHGLF OXDUHDXQHL
KRW UkULSRDWHV GLPLQXH]H
7HDPD GH vPEROQ YLUH PLFUREL HVWH IUHFYHQW vQ QHYUR]HOH RE
VHVLYHRFXS XQORFDSDUWHvQWRWGHDXQDPDLSRWH[LVWDXUPHLQILPHGH
PXUG ULHDúDGDUGHPLFUREL'DF SRVLELOLW LOHUHGXVHVDXFKLDULQILPH
GH SHULFOLWDUH SURGXF WRWXúL HIHFWH SXWHUQLFH IDSWXO LQGLF R HYROX LH
H[SUHVLHDXQHLOHJLSVLKRORJLFH3RWULYLWDFHVWHLOHJLWHQGLQ HOHDIHFWLYH
VXSXVH RVFLO ULL vQWUH GRL SROL FUHVF vQ DVHPHQHD P VXU vQFkW VHQWL
PHQWHQHvQVHPQDWHVHWUDQVIRUP vQDIHFWHSURIXQGH$FHDVW OHJHHVWH
SUH]HQW úLvQFD]XOGH]YROW ULORUSDUDQRLFHÌQQHYUR]DREVHVLY WHDPD
FDUHIDFHFDRSULPHMGLHPLQLP V DSDU DúDGHDPHQLQ WRDUHGHYLQH
DWkW GH SXWHUQLF WRFPDL GDWRULW QHKRW UkULL SHUPDQHQWH SULYLWRDUH OD
IDSWXO GDF H[LVW VDX QX PRWLY GH WHDP 'LQ DFHDVW IU PkQWDUH
GRPLQDW GHvQGRLHOLFXRYHúQLF RVFLODUHvQWUHGRLSROLLDQDúWHUHIULFD
SDWRORJLF D QHYURWLFLORU REVHVLYL IULFD SH FDUH HL vQúLúL R FRQVLGHU
QHvQWHPHLDW GDUSHFDUHQXRSRWvQYLQJH
$QDQFDVWXO vQFHDUF V OXSWH vPSRWULYD REVHVLHL VDOH vQF GLQ
SHULRDGDGHGH]YROWDUHDDIHFWXOXLFDSDFLWDWHDVDGHUHIXODUHILLQGvQV
LQVXILFLHQW OXSWD vPSRWULYD REVHVLHL HVWH WRFPDL FHHD FH FUHHD]
REVHVLDGHRDUHFHDOWHUQDQ DVSRUHúWHPDLPXOWIULFD
ÌQFD]XOQHYUR]HLKLSHUH[DFWLWDWHDSUH]LQW GH]DYDQWDMHDWXQFLFkQG
VHPDQLIHVW FXRLQWHQVLWDWHSVLKRWLF &DSDFLWDWHDGHDOXDKRW UkULHVWH
vQ DFHDVW VLWXD LH DWkW GH SUHMXGLFLDW vQFkW PXQFD QX PDL SRDWH IL
HIHFWXDW vQ PRG IOXHQW 3HUPDQHQW DSDU vQGRLHOL VXELHFWXO WUHEXLH V
YHULILFHGDF FHHDFHHVWHGHMDI FXWSRDWHILFRQVLGHUDWvQPRGGHILQLWLY
GUHSW EXQ ÌQ IHOXO DFHVWD DQDQFDVWXO U PkQH vQ XUP FX OXFUXO PHWL
FXOR]LWDWHD OXL QHSXWkQG DYHD GHFkW vQ SDUWH HIHFW FRPSHQVDWRU (O
UHFXSHUHD] GHFHOHPDLPXOWHRULWLPSXOSLHUGXWSULQRUHVXSOLPHQWDUH
YROXQWDUH'XS WHUPLQDUHDRUHORUGHOXFUXvLHVWHJUHXV VHvQGHS UWH]H
GH ORFXO V X GH PXQF XQHRUL VH vQWRDUFH V YDG GDF D vQFKLV WRDWH
XúLOHúLGDF DO VDWWRWXOvQRUGLQH&kQGQXFHGHD] GRULQ HORUGHDFHVW
IHOvQGUXPVSUHFDV HVWHSUREDELOSUHRFXSDWúLQHOLQLúWLWGHOXFU ULOHSH
FDUHOHDYXVHVHGHH[HFXWDWvQWLPSXORUHORUGHVHUYLFLX$FHVWOXFUXVH
vQWkPSO vQ VSHFLDO DWXQFL FkQG DUH VDUFLQL GH U VSXQGHUH $GHVHD
PRPHQWHOHGLQDLQWHGHDDGRUPLVXQWFHOPDLEXQSULOHMGHDVHJkQGL
GLQQRXODDFWLYLWDWHDSURIHVLRQDO úLSUREDELOODPXQFDGLQ]LXDXUP
WRDUHúLODPRGXOvQFDUHHDDUSXWHDILI FXW FkWPDLELQH
2WU V WXU GHILQLWRULHDDQDQFDVWXOXLHVWH QHVLJXUDQ DSUH]HQW
DWXQFL FkQG SOHDF GH DFDV (O VH vQWRDUFH V YDG GDF QX D O VDW
URELQHWXO GH JD] VDX FHO GH DS GHVFKLV GDF QX D XLWDW V VWLQJ
OXPLQD VDX V vQFXLH XúD $FHVWH YHULILF UL LQXWLOH UHGXF SRVLELOLWDWHD
SHUVRDQHLGHDVDYXUDFOLSHOHIHULFLWH
&kQG KLSHUH[DFWLWDWHD QX VH PDQLIHVW GHFkW VXE IRUPD XQHL
vQVXúLUL DFFHQWXDWH HD QX DUH DFHVWH HIHFWH QHJDWLYH 7RW FHHD FH DP
GHVFULVPDLVXVSRDWHV DSDU úLODDFHVWHSHUVRDQHGDUQXPDLvQWUR
P VXU FDUH QX DWLQJH OLPLWHOH DEVXUGXOXL ÌQ DVHPHQHD FD]XUL VH
HYLGHQ LD] vQGHRVHEL DYDQWDMHOH XQHL vQFOLQD LL VSUH PHWLFXOR]LWDWH
0XQFD GH U VSXQGHUH VSRUHúWH QHOLQLúWHD KLSHUFRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWHD DVL
JXUkQGXOH XQ EXQ UHQXPH R EXQ DSUHFLHUH OD ORFXO GH PXQF GH
FDUHVHVLPWIRDUWHOHJD L
(IHFWHOHDFHVWRUWU V WXULSRWILH[SULPDWHúLSHSODQXOJULMLLH[DJH
UDWH SHQWUX SURSULD EXQ VWDUH ,QGLYLGXO KLSHUH[DFW VH IHUHúWH GH SUL
PHMGLLLQXWLOHHYLW H[FHVHOHQXEHDSUHDPXOWQXIXPHD] SUHDPXOW
)LUHDKLSHUSHUVHYHUHQW
6XEVWUDWXOILULLKLSHUSHUVHYHUHQWHUHVSHFWLYDOFHOHLSDUDQRLGHHVWH
SHUVHYHUHQ DDQRUPDO DDIHFWXOXL6HQWLPHQWHOHFDUHDXWHQGLQ DGHD
SURYRFDUHDF LLVHHVWRPSHD] WUHSWDWGXS FHDFHDVW UHDF LHDDYXWORF
'DF DFHDVW UHDF LH QX HVWH SRVLELO GDU SHUVRDQD UHVSHFWLY vúL
vQGUHDSW WRWXúLJkQGXULOHVSUHDOWHSUREOHPHDIHFWXOQXGHVFUHúWHGHFkW
IRDUWH OHQW vQV vQ PRG QRUPDO HO GLVSDUH WRWXúL GXS FkWYD WLPS /D
SHUVRQDOLW LOH KLSHUSHUVHYHUHQWH DFHDVW HVWRPSDUH D DIHFWXOXL DUH ORF
PXOWPDLvQFHW&kQGDVHPHQHDSHUVRDQHVHJkQGHVFODFHOHvQWkPSODWH
DIHFWXOFRUHVSXQ] WRUDSDUHGLQQRXHOFRQWLQXkQGV ILHPHUHXSUH]HQW
6DUSXWHDV QXGLVSDU FRPSOHWQLFLGXS V SW PkQLúLOXQLGH]LOHFX
WRDWH F QX D IRVW DOLPHQWDW GH QRL HYHQLPHQWH ÌQ VSHFLDO DIHFWHOH
HJRLVWH VXQW FHOH FDUH GDWRULW LQWHQVLW LL FDUH OH HVWH SURSULH VH SRW
PDQLIHVWD vQWUXQ PRG DQRUPDO 6SHFLILFXO ILULL KLSHUSHUVHYHUHQWH VH
PDQLIHVW vQWRWGHDXQD DWXQFL FkQG VXQW DWLQVH LQWHUHVHOH SHUVRQDOH 'H
DFHHDVHIRUPHD] DIHFWHFRQWUDXQRUSUHMXGLFLLVDXDFWHGHRSUHVLXQH
FKLDUGDF DFHVWHDVXQWRELHFWLYQHvQVHPQDWH
'DF XQ RP vQFOLQ VSUH DVHPHQHD UHDF LL VH SRDWH YRUEL GH
VXVFHSWLELOLWDWH8QFRQ LQXWVLPLODUvODUHúLSUHGLVSR]L LDGHDVHVLP L
FX XúXULQ MLJQLW GDU DLFL HVWH YRUED PDL DOHV GH VIHUD RQRDUHL SHU
VRQDOHFDUHVHDIO GHDVHPHQHDSHSULPXOSODQODRDPHQLLFDUHVHVLPW
OHVQH RIHQVD L +LSHUSHUVHYHUHQ D HVWH FHO PDL XúRU GHPRQVWUDELO VXE
DFHDVW IRUP F FLLQGLYL]LLGHDFHVWWLSVXQWDYL]LGHSUHVWLJLXSHUVRQDO
'DUúLXQSUHMXGLFLXDGXVDOWRULQWHUHVH±FHOHOHJDWHGHSLOG GHSRVH
VLDEXQXULORUPDWHULDOHHVWHVXSRUWDWJUHX&kQGHVWHOH]DWVHQWLPHQWXO
GHGUHSWDWHVHQVLELOLWDWHDVHPDQLIHVW PDLSX LQGHRDUHFHDIHFWHOHSUL
PDUHVXQWDLFLPDLSX LQSURIXQGHGHFkWvQFD]XOVHQWLPHQWHORUHJRLVWH
'DF WRWXúL RDPHQL KLSHUSHUVHYHUHQ L GHYLQ DGHVHD OXSW WRUL SHQWUX
GUHSWDWH DFHDVWD vPEUDF OD HL XQ DVSHFW VSHFLILF UHYHQGLFkQG GHIDSW
XQ DQXPLW GUHSW SHQWUX HL vQúLúL HL JHQHUDOL]HD] DFHDVW UHYHQGLFDUH
QXPDLSHQWUXDLGDPDLPXOW IRU
3HUVRDQHORU KLSHUSHUVHYHUHQWH OH VXQW FDUDFWHULVWLFH VHQWLPHQWH
HJRLVWHPDLLQWHQVHGHFkWDOWRURDPHQLÌQIHOXODFHVWDVHDMXQJHODXQ
PDLSURQXQ DWVHQWLPHQWDOSURSULHLYDORUL
'HRDUHFH DVSLUD LLOH HJRLVWH vQWkPSLQ REVWDFROH vQGHRVHEL GLQ
SDUWHD FHORUODO L RDPHQL vQWkOQLP vQ FD]XO XQXL JUDG PDL vQDOW GH
KLSHUSHUVHYHUHQ ±DGLF DWXQFLFkQGHVWHYRUEDGHRILUHSDUDQRLG ±
WU V WXUDQXPDLSX LQFDUDFWHULVWLF DDWLWXGLQLLSHUPDQHQWE QXLWRDUH
1HvQFUHGHUHDKLSHUSHUVHYHUHQWXOXLHVWHPDLPXOWVDXPDLSX LQJHQH
UDOL]DW (D QX GHSLQGH GH DQXPLWH vPSUHMXU UL H[WHULRDUH FL vúL DUH
U G FLQLOHvQvQVXúLSVLKLFXOVXELHFWXOXL
5HSHWDUHDH[SHULHQ HORUGHYLD GHXQDQXPLWWLSSRDWHGHFODQúD
GH]YROWDUHD SDUDQRLF GDU DFHDVWD QX VH SRDWH H[SOLFD GRDU SULQWUR
VLPSO UHSHWDUHúLvQVXPDUH/DXQRPFDUHHVWHSHUPDQHQWMLJQLWGHXQ
DOWRPVHYDSURGXFHWUHSWDWRRDUHFDUHLQVHQVLELOL]DUHILUHDVF ID GH
OXFUXULFDUHVHvQWkPSO FXUHJXODULWDWHDVWIHOvQFkWXUPHD] RGHVFUHú
WHUHDDIHFWXOXLvQDFHDVW VLWXD LHQXLDQDúWHUHRGH]YROWDUHSDUDQRLF
2 LQWHQVLILFDUH QHvQWUHUXSW D DIHFWXOXL UH]XOW QXPDL vQ FD]XO XQHL
DOWHUQDQ H vQWUH VXFFHV úL LQVXFFHV &kQG FLQHYD QX SRDWH U VSXQGH OD
MLJQLUHGDUQXRE LQHGHFkWXQVXFFHVSDU LDOFDUHHVWHDSRLDQLKLODWGH
RFRQWUDDF LXQHúLFkQGvQDFHVWIHOVXFFHVXOúLHúHFXOWUHFDOWHUQDWLYSH
SULPXOSODQLDQDúWHUHDIHFWXOSDUDQRLF/HRQKDUG
ÌQDIDUDVIHUHLSDUDQRLFHSXWHPREVHUYDGH]YROW ULSDUDQRLFHFX
XQFDUDFWHUDSURDSHGHOLUDQWvQVSHFLDOJHOR]LH
'DF LGHLOH FDUH VH IL[HD] vQ GH]YROWDUHD SDUDQRLF QX VXQW
REVHVLYHHOHVXQWWRWXúLSUHYDOHQWH8QRPSRDWHILDWkWGHSUHRFXSDW
GHJkQGXOXQXLHYHQWXDOSUHMXGLFLXVDXGHJkQGXORE LQHULLXQXLPDUH
VXFFHVvQFkWV SLDUG vQPDUHP VXU GLQYHGHUHDOWHLQWHUHVHúLDOWH
HOXUL6HSURILOHD] DVWIHOvQF S kQDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LORUSDUDQRLGH
)LUHD KLSHUSHUVHYHUHQW VH DVHDP Q vQWUR RDUHFDUH P VXU FX
FHDDQDQFDVW úLFDXQHOHPHQWFRPXQSRDWHILDPLQWLW WHDPDFDUHHVWH
SRWHQ DW 'DF GDWRULW XQHL VLWXD LL RELHFWLY QHGHFLVH LQWHUYLQH R
RVFLOD LHvQWUHVSHUDQ úLWHDP DQ[LHWDWHDVHLQWHQVLILF PDLPXOWGHFkW
GH RELFHL FKLDU OD XQ RP KLSHUSHUVHYHUHQW vQWUXFkW HD QX GHVFUHúWH vQ
LQWHUYDOHOHGLQWUHúRFXULOHDIHFWLYH5H]XOWDWXOHVWHF DYHPGHDIDFHFX
R GH]YROWDUH LSRKRQGULDF OD SHUVRDQHOH KLSHUSHUVHYHUHQWH HD HVWH
VLPLODU FHOHLFHVHREVHUY ODSHUVRDQHOHKLSHUH[DFWHGHúLQXHVWHODIHO
GHIUHFYHQW FDODDFHVWHDGLQXUP
ÌQ JHQHUDO RPXO RE LQH VWLPD FHORUODO L QXPDL GDF UHDOL]HD]
FHYD FDUH V O HYLGHQ LH]H ,VWHULFLL SRW IL vQFkQWD L GH VLQH FKLDU I U
PRWLYF FLSULQGHIXO ULvúLSRWFUHDvQPRGVXELHFWLYLOX]LDXQXLUHVSHFW
GHFDUHvQPRGRELHFWLYQXVHEXFXU 3HUVRQDOLW LOHSDUDQRLGHQXVXQW
FDSDELOHGHRDVHPHQHDDXWRVXJHVWLHSHQWUXDVHVLP LPkQGUHHOHDX
QHYRLHGHDSUHFLHUHDUHDO DFHORUODO LRDPHQL$LFLDSDUHFODUFRQWXUDW
DVSHFWXO SR]LWLY GH HYROX LH D DFHVWRU SHUVRQDOLW L $FHVWD VH FRQFUH
WL]HD] vQ DPEL LD FX FDUH HL VH PRELOL]HD] SHQWUX DWLQJHUHD HOXOXL
SURSXV R DGHY UDW IRU PRWULFH SHQWUX UHDOL] ULOH SHUVRQDOH $WXQFL
vQV FkQG DFHúWL LQGLYL]L GLVFUHGLWHD] úL FKLDU vQO WXU DO L RDPHQL SH
FDUH vL SHUFHS GUHSW LQGLYL]L SHULFXORúL KLSHUSHUVHYHUHQ D DUH HIHFWH
QHJDWLYHFDUHVHL]EHVFGHUH]LVWHQ DFROHFWLYLW LL
$PEL LDúLVXVFHSWLELOLWDWHDIDYRUL]HD] LQVWDODUHDVHQWLPHQWXOXL
GHSUHMXGLFLXúLGHFODQúDUHDXQRUUHDF LLGHRVWLOLWDWHID GHWRWFHHDFH
VHvPSRWULYHúWHSUHWHQ LLORUVXELHF LORU
)LUHDQHVW SkQLW
)LUH LQFDSDELO V VH VW SkQHDVF SUH]LQW R OLSV D FRQWUROXOXL
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL HPR LRQDO FD R FDUDFWHULVWLF GHILQLWRULH ([LVW úL
DOWH FDUDFWHULVWLFL SH FDUH /HRQKDUG OH JUXSHD] SHQWUX DFHVWH SHUVR
QDOLW L DFFHQWXDWH DVWIHO vQFOLQD LD VSUH DFWLYLWDWH IL]LF FHHD FH OH
SHUPLWH V RE LQ vQ DFHVW GRPHQLX UH]XOWDWH PDL EXQH GHFkW DOWH
SHUVRDQHRVXVFHSWLELOLWDWHFUHVFXW ID GHSHUWXUE UL
6H SRDWH FRQVWDWD FD IHQRPHQ JHQHUDO LQFRQVWDQ D vQ YLD
DFHVW OXFUX QX HVWH GDWRUDW GRULQ HL GH D RFROL GLILFXOW LOH FL VH
GDWRUHD] WHQGLQ HLVSUHDFWHLPSXOVLYHúLLQGLVSR]L LHL
&kQGH[LVW FHYDFDUHQXOHFRQYLQHUHQXQ úLvQFHSDOWFHYDI U
V SHUVLVWHSUHDPXOW'LQDFHDVW FDX] GHH[HPSOXvQWUHED LGHPRWLYHOH
FDUHLDXGHWHUPLQDWV VFKLPEHORFXOGHPXQF WLQGV LQYRFHPRWLYD LL
VXSHUILFLDOHSUHFXPIDSWXOF úHIXOQXDDFFHSWDWV LVDWLVIDF RDQXPH
GRULQ DWLWXGLQHDXQRUFROHJLLDYH[DWHWF/HRQKDUGREVHUY IDSWXOF
SHUVRQDOLWDWHDGHWLSQHVW SkQLWSRDWHILIRDUWHFDSDELO GHPXQF úWLXW
ILLQG SO FHUHD SHQWUX HIRUW IL]LF vQV LQFRQVWDQ D HVWH GHWHUPLQDW GH
OLSVDGHVW SkQLUHvQSODQXODIHFWHORUÄWULVWH HDFDX]DW GHRvQWkPSODUH
FDUH OH SDUH vPSRY U WRDUH SRDWH GXFH OD DF LXQL QHFKLE]XLWH HYHQWXDO
FKLDUODRvQFHUFDUHGHVLQXFLGHUH´S
/HHVWHFDUDFWHULVWLF LULWDELOLWDWHDQHFRQWURODW FDUHFRQGXFHVSUH
L]EXFQLUL GH IXULH 0XO L UHFXQRVF GHVFKLV LULWDELOLWDWHD FDUH GH DOWIHO
HVWHFRQILUPDW GHFHLFDUHvLFXQRVFPHPEULLIDPLOLHLSULHWHQLFROHJL
2 DOW WHQGLQ FDUDFWHULVWLF HVWH LPSUHVLD SH FDUH R FUHHD]
DOWRUDHDHVWHOHJDW GHOLSV GHDJHULPHVSLULWXDO SHQWUXF SDUV LDvQ
FRQVLGHUDUHPDLDOHVOXFUXULOHFDUHVXQWXúRUSHUFHSWLELOH'HDVHPHQHD
DXXQDHULQGLVSXVU VSXQGPRQRVLODELFODvQWUHE ULQXSHQWUXF QXYRU
V ILHSULHWHQRúLFLGDWRULW IDSWXOXLF OHHVWHQHSO FXWV U VSXQG OD
vQWUHE ULPLPLFDvLWU GHD] FHOPDLDGHVHDDVWIHOF úLGDF DUGRULV
ILHDJUHDELOLPLPLFDSDUHDSUH]HQWDRID RSXV
/HRQKDUGFRQVWDW F DWXQFLFkQGWHQGLQ DHVWHIRDUWHSURQXQ DW
VHSRDWHYRUELGHXQWDEORXFOLQLFGHWLSXOSVLKRSDWLHLHSLOHSWRLGHSRW
SUH]HQWD GHYLHUL GH OD YLD D VRFLDO PDL DOHV GH WLSXO YLROHQ HORU GLQ
SHULRDGHOHFkQGVXQWGRPLQD LGHDFFHVHOHGHIXULH$OFRROLVPXOFURQLF
VHLQVWDOHD] SHIRQGXOGXUDWHLSUHOXQJLWHDSHULRDGHORUGHLQGLVSR]L LH
3RW DSDUH úL FRQGXLWH QHVW SkQLWH SH IRQGXO H[FHVXOXL LPSXOVXULORU
VH[XDOHODIHWHPDLDOHVvQSHULRDGDSRVWSXEHUW LL
)LUHDKLSHUWLPLF
7HPSHUDPHQWXOKLSHUWLPLFDF UXLDFFHQWXDUHHVWHGHQXPLW WUD
WDPHQWKLSRPDQLDFDOHVWHELQHFXQRVFXWvQSVLKLDWULHGDWRULW PRGXOXL
LPSUHVLRQDQWvQFDUHVHPDQLIHVW &DúLvQFD]XOXQHLPDQLLGDUvQWUR
IRUP PDLDWHQXDW J VLPODWHPSHUDPHQWXOKLSHUWHUPLFRFRPELQD LHD
YHVHOLHLFXGRULQ DGHDF LXQHúLFXQHYRLDGHDYRUELSUHFXPúLFXR
vQFOLQD LHVSUHGLYDJ ULvQFOLQD LHFDUHXQHRULYL]HD] FKLDUIXJDGHLGHL
$FFHQWXDUHD KLSHUWLPLF UHSUH]LQW R YDULDQW SR]LWLY D WHPSHUDPHQ
WXOXLXPDQ9LD DHVWHSULYLW PDLPXOWVXEDVSHFWXOHLSO FXWVHWUHFHFX
PDL PXOW XúXULQ SHVWH QHSO FHUL 1HYRLD GH DF LXQH SRDWH JHQHUD
UHDOL] UL GH YDORDUH 'HSUHVLXQLOH JkQGLULL VXQW vQVR LWH GH ERJ LD GH
LGHLFHHDFHGHDVHPHQHDSRDWHVWLPXODPXQFDSURGXFWLY %RJ LDGH
LGHL VH DO WXU ERJ LHL GH VHQWLPHQWH FHHD FH DUH HIHFWH VWLPXODWRDUH
DWkW vQ SURIHVLH FkW úL vQ UHXQLXQLOH VRFLDOH XQGH KLSHUWLPLFXO HVWH
QXFOHXODQWUHQDQWSHQWUXFUHDUHDXQHLEXQHGLVSR]L LLJHQHUDOH
$FFHQWXDUHDDFHVWRUWU V WXULDIHFWHD] YHFWRUXOSR]LWLYDODFHVWRU
SHUVRQDOLW L9HVHOLDGHYLQHDFXPRSULPHMGLHHVWHSUH]HQW RLQHUHQW
VXSHUILFLDOLWDWH PDQLIHVW DWkW SH SODQ DF LRQDO FkW úL SH FHO HWLF 3ULQ
VXSHUILFLDOLWDWHD VD XQ KLSRPDQLDF vúL SXQH vQ MRF EXQD UHSXWD LH úL
GHVWXOGHIUHFYHQWvúLSHULFOLWHD] vQV úLVLWXD LDPDWHULDO GHRDUHFHVH
ODQVHD] vQDF LXQLVDXVSHFXOD LLFDUHvLIDFSO FHUHSHQWUXPRPHQWGDU
FDUHFXWUHFHUHDWLPSXOXLVHY GHVFDILvQUHDOLWDWHGH]DYDQWDMRDVHVDX
FKLDU FDWDVWURIDOH 1HYRLD GH DF LXQH ± GDF H[LVW vQWUR P VXU H[
FHVLY ±DUHFDUH]XOWDWRDFWLYLWDWHIHEULO GDUVWHULO ,QGLYLGXOGHYLQH
ÄvPSU úWLDW´ VH DSXF GH PXOWH úL QX GXFH QLPLF SkQ OD FDS W LDU
URGQLFDVDERJ LHGHLGHLVHSRDWHWUDQVIRUPDvQWUXQMRF±FHLGUHSW
SOLQGHIDQWH]LH±FXLGHLQHUHDOL]DELOH
8QDOWGH]DYDQWDMDSDUHDWXQFLFkQGH[LVW WHQGLQ DFDYHVHOLDV
VH WUDQVIRUPH vQ LULWDELOLWDWH IHQRPHQ UHODWLY IUHFYHQW &kQG DFHVW
OXFUXGHYLQHIRDUWHHYLGHQWSXWHPSUHVXSXQHF DYHPGHDIDFHFXR
FRPSRQHQW SDUDQRLF
&RPSRQHQWHOHSVLKRORJLFHDOHWHPSHUDPHQWXOXLKLSHUWLPLFFDUHVH
UHIHU ODDIHFWLYLWDWHJkQGLUHúLYRLQ QXFRH[LVW vQWRWGHDXQDvQDFHODúL
JUDG 9HVHOLD SRDWH IL SUHGRPLQDQW VDX SRDWH FHGD ORFXO QHYRLL GH D
YRUELÌQXQHOHFD]XULWHQGLQ DVSUHGLJUHVLXQLvQJkQGLUHHVWHIRDUWHSUR
QXQ DW ÌQ JHQHUDO vQV FHOH WUHL WU V WXUL VXQW OHJDWH vQWUH HOH úL
IRUPHD] R XQLWDWH FD vQ FD]XO PDQLHL 8QHRUL SXWHP DYHD GRYH]L
GLUHFWH F ILUHD KLSRPDQLDFDO QX UHSUH]LQW GHFkW R PDQLH GLOXDW
DWHQXDW úLDQXPHvQFD]XULOHFkQGVXELHFWXOvQFDX] VDXXQDGLQUXGHOH
VDOHDVXIHULWFkQGYDGHDFHDVW ERDO ÌQSULQFLSLXvQV QXHVWHREOLJD
WRULXFDXQDVWIHOGHWHPSHUDPHQWV DLE LPSOLFD LLPDQLDFDOH
$úDFXPDPDU WDWúLvQGHVFULHUHDILULLGLVWLPLFHGXS 0HODQLH
.OHLQ RULFH FRSLO WUHFH SULQ ID]D QXPLW GHSUHVLY 3H SDUFXUVXO
DFHVWHL ID]H DSDU FkWHYD HOHPHQWH GHILQLWRULL GLQWUH FDUH UHDPLQWLP
GRDU DQJRDVD GHSUHVLY FDUH VH UHIHU OD SHULFROXO IDQWDVPDWLF GH D
GLVWUXJH úL GH D SLHUGH PDPD GLQ FDX]D VDGLVPXOXL VXELHFWXOXL 2
PRGDOLWDWH GH D FRPEDWH DFHDVW DQJRDV HVWH GXS 0HODQLH .OHLQ
GHIHQVDPDQLDFDO $FHDVW GHIHQV XWLOL]HD] PDLPXOWVDXPDLSX LQ
PRGLILFDWH PHFDQLVPHOH ID]HL SDUDQRLGH QHJDUH LGHDOL]DUH FOLYDM
FRQWURORPQLSRWHQWDORELHFWXOXL
0HODQLH.OHLQ±
3VLKDQDOLVW HQJOH] GHRULJLQHDXVWULDF $UHFHUFHW UL
úLRSHUVSHFWLY RULJLQDO DVXSUDVWUXFWXULLúLGH]YROW ULLSHU
VRQDOLW LLGDUúLDVXSUDSVLKDQDOL]HLFRSLOXOXLGHH[HPSOX
HVWHFHDFDUHLQWURGXFHvQWHKQLFDSVLKDQDOLWLF MRFXO
&HUFHW ULOH VDOH VXQW D[DWH PDL DOHV SH FRQIOLFWHOH
SUHFRFHFDUHDSDUvQUHOD LDPDP FRSLO$VWIHOGLVWLQJH
GRX PRPHQWHvQGHVI úXUDUHDSULPXOXLDQGHYLD FDUDF
WHUL]kQGXOHSULQSULVPDPRGXOXLVSHFLILFGHDUHOD LRQDFX
RELHFWXOUHVSHFWLYDPRGXOXLGHDVHVL]DÄRELHFWXO´úLGHD
VHVLWXDvQUDSRUWGHDFHVWD3ULPXOPRPHQWHVWHGHQXPLW
ÄSR]L LHVFKL]RSDUDQRLG ´úLDFRSHU SULPHOHOXQLGH
YLD ILLQG FDUDFWHUL]DW GH IDSWXO F EHEHOXúXO VWDELOHúWH
UHOD LLFXXQRELHFWÄSDU LDO´DVXSUDF UXLDVXQWSURLHFWDWH
LPSXOVLLOHOLELGLQDOHúLFHOHDJUHVLYHÌQFRQWLQXDUHúLSkQ
OD VIkUúLWXO DFHVWXL SULP DQ DUH ORF SH IRQGXO XQHL PDL
EXQH RUJDQL] UL D SHUFHS LLORU R VHVL]DUH D RELHFWXOXL
ÄPDP ´vQWRWDOLWDWHDVDVHLQVWDOHD] ÄSR]L LDGHSUHVLY ´
ODRELHFWXOWRWDOVXQWUDSRUWDWHLPSXOVLLOHOLELGLQDOHúLFHOH
DJUHVLYGLVWUXFWLYHLDUFRSLOXOWU LHúWHH[SHULHQ DDPELYD
OHQ HLJHQHUDWRDUHGHFXOSDELOLWDWH
'LQWUH OXFU ULOH IXQGDPHQWDOH 7KH 3V\FKDQDO\VLV RI
FKLOGUHQ(QY\DQG*UDWLWXGH2XU$GXOW:RUOG
)LUHDGLVWLPLF
7HPSHUDPHQWXO GLVWLPLF GHYLQH OD XQ JUDG PDL ULGLFDW WHPSH
UDPHQWVXEGHSUHVLY2DPHQLLGHDFHVWWLSVHULRúLGLQILUHVXQWvQPDL
PDUH P VXU DIHFWD L GH HYHQLPHQWHOH WULVWH DOH YLH LL GHFkW GH FHOH
YHVHOH$úDFXPDU WD.6FKQHLGHUSHQWUXHLYLD DHVWHÄXQIHOGHGUD
JRVWHQHIHULFLW ´(YHQLPHQWH]JXGXLWRDUHSRWDGkQFLFRQGL LDRELúQXLW
GHVHULR]LWDWHJUDY SkQ ODRGHSUHVLHUHDFWLY FHHDFHVHvQWkPSO PDL
DOHV DWXQFL FkQG VWDUHD GH GHSUHVLH HVWH IRDUWH DFFHQWXDW úL GH OXQJ
GXUDW /DRDPHQLLFXWHPSHUDPHQWGLVWLPLFLPEROGXOVSUHDF LXQHHVWH
GLPLQXDW LDU JkQGLUHD HVWH PDL OHQW GHFkW OD FHLODO L RDPHQL /D UH
XQLXQLSHUVRQDOLW LOHGLVWLPLFHQXSDUWLFLS GHFkWSX LQODFRQYHUVD LH
6HSRDWHDILUPDF SDUWLFLSDUHDODYLD DJUXSXOXLHVWHUHGXV
$FHVWH SHUVRQDOLW L VXQW DOWUXLVWH VREUH úL OLSVLWH GH HJRLVP
3UHGLVSR]L LDVSUHVHULR]LWDWHDUHGUHSWUH]XOWDWF SHSULPXOSODQDSDU
VHQWLPHQWH FRQWUDUH WHQGLQ HORU ORU HJRLVWH $úD VH H[SOLF IDSWXO F
DFHDVW VHULR]LWDWH GXFH OD R LQXW HWLF VHULRDV ÌQVXúL IDSWXO F vQ
DPEHOH H[SUHVLL UHYLQH QR LXQHD GH ÄVHULRV´ DWHVW FRQH[LXQHD GLQWUH
GLVSR]L LHúL LQXWDHWLF $LFLVHPDQLIHVW ODWXUDSR]LWLY DWHPSHUD
PHQWXOXL GLVWLPLF ÌQ VFKLPE GLPLQXDUHD LPEROGXOXL VSUH DF LXQH úL
vQFHWLQHDOD JkQGLULL DX FkQG DWLQJ XQ DQXPLW JUDG HIHFWH QHJDWLYH
VF ]kQGUDQGDPHQWXO
&kQGWHPSHUDPHQWXOVXEGHSUHVLYHVWHIRDUWHDFFHQWXDWQHSXWHP
JkQGL OD R VWDUH GH PHODQFROLH GDU QX vQWRWGHDXQD H[LVW R DVHPHQHD
FRQH[LXQH9DULDQWDGHWHPSHUDPHQWGLVWLPLF SRDWHILDEVROXWQRUPDO
5HOD LD WHPSHUDPHQWXOXL GLVWLPLF FX GHSUHVLD HQGRJHQ QX VH
ED]HD] SH R OHJLWDWH SUHFLV DFHVW WLS GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH UHSUH]HQWkQG
XQDGLQWUHYDULD LLOHQRUPDOLW LLGHúLLQGLYL]LLGLQDFHDVW FDWHJRULHOH
DSDU FHORUODO L OLSVL L GH YHVHOLH GRPLQD L GH R RDUHFDUH GHSULPDUH
LQHU LHúLvQFHWLQHDO LPSXQHUHDSHSODQVRFLDOI FkQGXVHGHRELFHL
FXRDUHFDUHGLILFXOWDWH
'XS 0HODQLH .OHLQ GLVWLPLD vúL DUH RULJLQHD vQ FRSLO ULD WLP
SXULHHDQXHVWHDOWFHYDGHFkWRIL[D LHVDXUHJUHVLHODSR]L LDGHSUHVLY
DOWIHO QRUPDO OD FRSLOXO GH SDWUX OXQL ÌQ DFHDVW ID] FRSLOXO GHYLQH
FDSDELO V úL SHUFHDS PDPD FD RELHFW WRWDO &OLYDMXO GLQWUH RELHFWXO
ÄEXQ´úLRELHFWXOÄU X´VHDWHQXHD] DVWIHOvQFkWSXOVLXQLOHOLELGLQDOHúL
RVWLOHWLQGV VHUDSRUWH]HODDFHODúLRELHFW$QJRDVDQXPLW GHSUHVLY
VHUHIHU ODSHULFROXOIDQWDVPDWLFGHDGLVWUXJHúLGHDSLHUGHPDPDGLQ
FDX]DVDGLVPXOXLVXELHFWXOXL$FHDVW DQJRDV HVWHFRPE WXW SULQGLIH
ULWHPRGDOLW LGHIHQVLYHUHSDUD LHLQKLEL LHDDJUHVLYLW LLúLGHS úLW
FkQGRELHFWXOLXELWHVWHLQWURLHFWDWvQPRGVWDELOúLVHFXUL]DQW'DF VH
UHDOL]HD] IL[D LDODDFHVWVWDGLXLQGLYLGXOVHYDVWUXFWXUDFDRSHUVRDQ
DSDWLF QHSDUWLFLSDWLY VREU LDUHJRLVPXOFDUDFWHULVWLFRULF UXLRPVH
YDWUDQVIRUPDSULQLQWHUPHGLXOPHFDQLVPHORUGHDS UDUHvQDOWUXLVP
)LUHDFLFORWLPLF
/HRQKDUG YRUEHúWH GH SHUVRQDOLW L ODELOH DIHFWLY FRQVWDWkQG F
DWXQFLFkQGDFHDVW ODELOLWDWHDIHFWLY HVWHIRDUWHSURQXQ DW SUHGRPLQ
H[FOXVLYRVFLOD LLOHSURYRFDWHGHRFDX] O XQWULF FD]vQFDUHHVWHYRUED
GHFLFORWLPLHvQVHQVXOXQHLSVLKRSDWLL
&DUDFWHULVWLFLOHVSHFLILFHODELOXOXLDIHFWLYSRWILGHWHUPLQDWHúLGH
VLWXD LH FD vQ FD]XO vQ FDUH vQWUR FRQYHUVD LH VH SUH]LQW ILH YHVHOL úL
YLRLILHVHULRúLúLW FX LvQIXQF LHGHPRGXOvQFDUHHVWHFRQGXV FRQ
YHUVD LD'DUDXPDLDOHVRGHWHUPLQDUHLQWHULRDU vQVHQVXOF QXRVFL
OHD] FRQWLQXX vQWUH GRL SROL FL SH IRQGXO XQHL GLVSR]L LL KLSHUWLPLFH
SRWUHDF LRQDGHH[HPSOXSURIXQGúLH[DJHUDWGHSUHVLYODRvPSUHMXUDUH
GHIDYRUDELO 6XQWJDWDV WUHDF GHODXQHODQGHHQWX]LDVPODDSDWLHúL
WULVWH HvQPRPHQWXOXUP WRU$GHVHDHVWHJUHXGHVSHFLILFDWvQFHP
VXU RVFLOD LLOHVXQWGHWHUPLQDWHGHvPSUHMXU ULH[WHULRDUHVDXLQWHULRDUH
'LVSR]L LDDIHFWLY DSHUVRDQHLRVFLOHD] vQWUHH[WUHPHFLFORWLPLFLL
VXQW FLFOLF GHSUHVLYL úL KLSHUWLPLFL $FHDVW LQVWDELOLWDWH D GLVSR]L LHL
DIHFWHD] SXWHUQLFSHUVRDQDDIHFWLYXQDVWIHOGHRPWUHFHSULQSHULRDGH
vQFDUHVHVLPWHELQHHVWHSURGXFWLYDFWLYYHVHOSHULRDG FkQGvúLDVX
P úLVDUFLQLVDXUHVSRQVDELOLW LSURIHVLRQDOHVDXvQYLD DVRFLDO DSRL
GLVSR]L LDVHVFKLPE I U FDDFHDVW VFKLPEDUHV SRDW ILFRQWURODW
LDU ORFXO RSWLPLVPXOXL HVWH OXDW EUXVF GH SHVLPLVP YLD D SVLKLF HVWH
LQYDGDW GHRYL]LXQHVXPEU GHIHQVLY vQUDSRUWFXYLD DLDUSHUVRDQD
PDQLIHVW R HQHUJLH GUDPDWLF VF ]XW ID GH FDUH WRDWH DQJDMDPHQWHOH
GLQID]DDQWHULRDU GHYLQRSRYDU LQVXUPRQWDELO FDUHSURYRDF VXIH
ULQ 3HUVRDQD SRDWH OXD GHFL]LL OD IHO GH LPSUXGHQWH SH WHUPHQ OXQJ
GHRDUHFHWHQGLQ DHVWHGHDUHIX]DFKLDURSRUWXQLW LÌQWLPSDUHORFúLR
WUHFHUHvQVSUHRGLVSR]L LHQRUPDOL]DW RVWDUHGHUHODWLY H[DOWDUH
)LUHDH[DOWDW
3HUVRDQHOHvQDF URUSHUVRQDOLWDWHGRPLQ DFHDVW WHQGLQ VXQW
GH RELFHL YHVHOH PDQLIHVW R LPSUHVLRQDQW GRULQ GH D WU L GH D
ÄJXVWDYLD DGLQSOLQ´SRWPDQLIHVWDRH[DOWDUHQHRELúQXLW ,QGLYLGXO
SRDWH V DLE R MXGHFDW LQDGHFYDW FRQFOX]LLOH SRW IL SULSLWH SUHD
SX LQORJLFHúLFULWLFH$GHVHDEXQDGLVSR]L LHRELúQXLW HVWHvQWUHUXSW
QHDúWHSWDWGHSHULRDGHGHLULWDELOLWDWHPDLDOHVFkQGUHVLPWIUXVWUDUH
$FFHQWXDUHDvQVHDPQ vQDFHODúLWLPSúLWHQGLQ DVSUHDILUHYHQ
GLFDWLYFHQWUDWSHSURSULLOHGRULQ HHJRLVW
/HRQKDUGDGPLWHVLPLOLWXGLQLvQWUHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDH[DOWDW úLSHUVR
QDOLW LOHHPRWLYHúLFHOHODELOHWRDWHDFHVWHILULDXWHQGLQ DGHDUHDF LRQD
SURIXQGODGLYHUVHHYHQLPHQWHúLGHDWUHFHLPHGLDWvQWURVWDUHJHQHUDO
GHSUHVLY UHVSHFWLYHXIRULF 'HRVHELUHDFRQVW vQIDSWXOF SHUVRQDOL
W LOHH[DOWDWHSUH]LQW XQH[FHVvQRVFLOD LDVHQWLPHQWHORUSRWF GHDvQWUR
GLVSHUDUHI U GHPDUJLQLODIHOGHUHSHGHúLXúRUFDvQVWDUHDRSXV GH
IHULFLUH H[DOWDW 6H SDVLRQHD] SHQWUX FHYD VDX FLQHYD FX R SXWHUQLF
SDUWLFLSDUHO XQWULF LDUGLVSHUDUHDvQVLWXD LDXQRUHYHQLPHQWHGHVFXUD
MDQWH DWLQJH OLSVD GH VSHUDQ WRWDO ÌQ VSDWHOH DFHVWXL SDWHWLVP H[LVW
vQV VHQWLPHQWHDXWHQWLFHQXFDvQVLWXD LDLVWHULFLORUXQMRFWHDWUDO
/D DVWIHO GH SHUVRDQH vQWkOQLP IUHFYHQW LQWHUHVH DUWLVWLFH SUR
QXQ DWH ÌQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH H[DOWDUHD VH PDQLIHVW SUHGRPLQDQW VXE
IRUPDHQWX]LDVPXOXLDYHPILULOHFDUHVXQWPDUFDWHGHWHQGLQ DGHDVH
HQWX]LDVPD XúRU LDU GDF SUHGRPLQ WHQGLQ D FRQWUDU DYHP ILULOH
FDUHVXQWPDUFDWHGHGLVSHU UL
)LUHDDQ[LRDV
$FHVWWLSGHSHUVRDQHVXQWWRWWLPSXODQ[LRúLVWkQMHQL LvQFRQWH[W
VRFLDOVHWHPGHFULWLF VDXGH]DSUREDUHVXQWQHOLQLúWL LGHWHDPDGHD
QX IL SXúL vQ vQFXUF WXU 3UHFDX L ID GH QRL H[LJHQ H DVWIHO F QX
DJUHHD] vQWkOQLUHDFXSHUVRDQHSHFDUHQXOHFXQRVFvúLIDFSUREOHPH
OHJDWH GH SHUVSHFWLYD XQHL VLWXD LL QHSUHY ]XWH VDX QHFXQRVFXWH $X
IRDUWHSX LQLSULHWHQLDSURSLD LHYLW vQJHQHUHREOLJD LLOHVRFLDOHVDXOD
VHUYLFLXSUHOXDUHDXQRUUHVSRQVDELOLW L
'H IDSW QX VXQW UHFL HPR LRQDO FXP VXQW GH H[HPSOX WLSXULOH
VFKL]RWLPHúLvúLGRUHVFUHOD LLVRFLDOHGDUQXúWLXúLQXVHFUHGvQVWDUH
V OHRE LQ
'HPXOWHRULREVHUY /HRQKDUGHVWHSRVLELOFDVXEVWUDWXOV ILH
GDW GH R ILUH H[DOWDW /D FRSLL GH DVHPHQHD DSDU GHVWXO GH GHV PD
QLIHVW UL DFFHQWXDWH vQ VHQVXO IULFLL ÌQ JHQHUDO FkQG VH SUHVXSXQH R
SUHGLVSR]L LHSURQXQ DW VSUHIULF VHLQYHVWLJKHD] SHULRDGDFRSLO ULHL
GDF H[LVW RPDQLIHVWDUHH[DJHUDW DIULFLLGHvQWXQHULFGHIXUWXQ GH
DQLPDOH HWF &kQG WHDPD DUH FD VXEVWUDW R QHYUR] REVHVLY U VSXQ
VXULOHODDFHDVW DQDPQH] VXQWGHRELFHLQHJDWLYH'HRELFHLWHPHULOH
úLIRELLOHVHIRUPHD] SHXQIRQGDQDQFDVW
7HQGLQ DDFFHQWXDW VSUHIULF SRDWHOXDSURSRU LLSDWRORJLFHGDU
GHRELFHLODDGXO LDFHVWOXFUXVHSHWUHFHSHIRQGXOXQHLFRQWLQXLDPH
QLQ ULGLQH[WHULRUODFDUHHVWHVXSXV FRQVWDQWSHUVRDQDUHVSHFWLY
)LUHOHHPRWLYH
(PRWLYLL VXQW LPSUHVLRQD L GRDU GH WU LULOH vQVHúL vQ WLPS FH
GLVSR]L LD JHQHUDO D ODELOLORU VH VFKLPE vQ IXQF LH GH HYHQLPHQWHOH
H[WHULRDUH2SHUVRDQ FXRILUHHPRWLY HVWHFDUDFWHUL]DW GHFHLODO L
GH RELFHL SULQ IDSWXO F DUH ÄR LQLP EXQ ´ F HVWH LPSUHVLRQDW
SURIXQGGHHYHQLPHQWHGXUHURDVHúLQXSRDWHWUHFHXúRUSHVWHHOHFKLDU
GDF QX L VH vQWkPSO OXL SHUVRQDO 'H DVHPHQHD R DVWIHO GH ILUH VH
HPR LRQHD] XúRUúLSRDWHSOkQJHODILOPHOHVDXvQWkPSO ULOHFLWLWHVDX
SRYHVWLWH FDUH DX GHVI úXU UL WULVWH VDX GUDPDWLFH GH RELFHL HVWH
ÄPLORV´±QXSRDWHV YDG XQFRSLOFDUHSOkQJHI U V DLE WHQGLQ D
GHDSOkQJHHOvQVXúLGHHPR LH
ùLHYHQLPHQWHOHSO FXWHvLLPSUHVLRQHD] vQHJDO P VXU $VWIHO
GH SHUVRDQH UHVLPW SURIXQG EXFXULD GDWRUDW XQRU vQWkPSO UL IHULFLWH
VDXRSHUHORUGHDUW 0LPLFDSDUWLFLS GLUHFWODH[SULPDUHDHPR LHLúLD
VHQVLELOLW LLVXIOHWHúWL
ÌQVLWXD LDFkQGRDVWIHOGHILUHSUH]LQW RLQWHQVLWDWHSDWRORJLF úL
WLQGHV DFDSDUH]HYLD DLQWHUIHUkQGFXPRGXOQRUPDOGHDWU LUHDOL
WDWHDFDDWDUHVHSRDWHYRUELGHRSVLKRSDWLHUHDFWLY ODELO /DDVWIHO
GHSHUVRDQHVXQWIUHFYHQWHGHSUHVLLOHUHDFWLYHXQHRULFKLDUFXWHQGLQ D
VSUHVLQXFLGHUH
(;7,1'(5,
&RQYHUWLUHDQRWHORUEUXWHvQSURFHQWH
3HQWUXUD LRQDOL]DUHDRSHUD LHLGHFRQYHUVLHDGDWHORUEUXWHvQSUR
FHQWHLDW XQWDEHOFXSURFHQWDMHOHFDOFXODWHSOHFkQGGHODIRUPXODFHD
PDLVLPSO GDF VHLDFDH[HPSOXVFDOD,FXLWHPLVLPSWRPDWLFLXQ
U VSXQVVLPSWRPDWLFHFKLYDOHD] FXSURFHQWH[
U VSXQVXULVLPSWRPDWLFHHFKLYDOHD] FX[ HWF
7DEHOFXSURFHQWDMHOHSHQWUXILHFDUHVFDO
1UGHLWHPL
6FDOHOH 6FDOHOH 6FDOHOH
1UU VSXQVXUL
FXLWHPL FXLWHPL FXLWHPL
VLPSWRPDWLFH
$ERUG ULFRQWHPSRUDQH
DOHFRQGL LHLSVLKRSDWRORJLFHDSHUVRQDOLW LL
(VWH LPSRUWDQW V GLVWLQJHP WXOEXU ULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH GH
WU V WXULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH DFFHQWXDWH FDUH QX DWLQJ SUDJXO SHQWUX R
ÄWXOEXUDUHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH´
7U V WXULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH SRW IL GLDJQRVWLFDWH FD WXOEXU UL GH
SHUVRQDOLWDWH vQ VLWXD LD FkQG ÄVXQW LQIOH[LELOH GH]DGDSWDWLYH úL SHU
VLVWHQWH úL FDX]HD] R GHWHULRUDUH IXQF LRQDO VDX GHWUHV VXELHFWLY
VHPQLILFDWLY ´ '60 ,9 S 'LQ SHUVSHFWLYD '60 ,9
WXOEXU ULOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHVXQWFRQVLGHUDWHVLQGURDPHFOLQLFHFDOLWDWLY
GLVWLQFWH$FHODúLQRUPDWLYIL[HD] úLFULWHULLOHGHGLDJQRVWLFSHQWUXR
WXOEXUDUHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
$ 8Q SDWHUQ GXUDELO GH H[SHULHQ LQWHUQ úL GH FRPSRUWDPHQW
FDUHGHYLD] FRQVLGHUDELOGHODH[SHFWD LLOHFXOWXULLLQGLYLGXOXL$FHVW
SDWHUQVHPDQLIHVW vQGRX VDXPDLPXOWHGLQXUP WRDUHOHGRPHQLL
x FXQRDúWHUH DGLF PRGXULOH GH D VH SHUFHSH úL LQWHUSUHWD SH VLQH
DOWHSHUVRDQHúLHYHQLPHQWHOH
x DIHFWLYLWDWH DGLF JDPD LQWHQVLWDWHD ODELOLWDWHD úL DGHFYDUHD U V
SXQVXOXLHPR LRQDO
x IXQF LRQDUHDLQWHUSHUVRQDO FRQWUROXOLPSXOVXOXL
% 3DWHUQXO GXUDELO HVWH LQIOH[LELO úL SHUYD]LY ID GH R JDP
ODUJ GHVLWXD LLSHUVRQDOHúLVRFLDOH
& 3DWHUQXO GXUDELO GXFH OD R GHWUHV VDX R GHWHULRUDUH
VHPQLILFDWLY FOLQLFvQGRPHQLXOVRFLDOSURIHVLRQDOVDXvQDOWHGRPHQLL
LPSRUWDQWHGHIXQF LRQDUH
'3DWHUQXOHVWHVWDELOúLGHOXQJ GXUDW LDUGHEXWXOV XSRDWHIL
WUDVDW UHWURVSHFWLY FHO SX LQ SkQ vQ DGROHVFHQ VDX OD vQFHSXWXO
SHULRDGHLDGXOWH
(3DWHUQXOGXUDELOQXHVWHH[SOLFDWPDLELQHFDPDQLIHVWDUHVDX
FRQVHFLQ DXQHLWXOEXU ULPHQWDOH
) 3DWHUQXO GXUDELO QX VH GDWRUHD] HIHFWHORU IL]LRORJLFHGLUHFWH
DOHXQHLVXEVWDQ HGHH[HPSOXXQGURJXQPHGLFDPHQWRULDOHXQHL
FRQGL LLPHGLFDOHJHQHUDOHGHH[XQWUDXPDWLVPFUDQLDQ
7XOEXUDUHD GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH HVWH XQ SDV PDL GHSDUWH vQ GLUHF LD
DQRUPDOLW LL SVLKLFH UHSUH]LQW R GHYLD LH VHPQLILFDWLY VDX H[WUHP
GH OD PRGHOXO VDX PRGHOHOH GH FRPSRUWDPHQW H[LVWHQWH vQ JUXSXO
VRFLRFXOWXUDO UHVSHFWLY úL vQ SOXV WXOEXUDUHD DGXFH FkWHYD DVSHFWH
FKHLHFDUHVHUHJ VHVFvQVWUXFWXUDSVLKLF vQF GLQFRSLO ULHDEVHQ D
U VSXQVXULORUHPR LRQDOHSURIXQGHvQFRUHOD LHFXSR]L LDHJRFHQWULF
QHSXWLQ DGHDSURILWDGHH[SHULHQ DO WXULGHOLSVDGHUHVSHFWúLFRQVL
GHUDUHDQRUPHORUVRFLDOH
(WLRORJLF WXOEXU ULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH GH GH]YROWDUH DX FRQGL LL
IDYRUL]DQWH PXOWLSOH VSUH GHRVHELUH GH PRGLILF ULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH
FDUH VXQW vQWRWGHDXQD VHFXQGDUH XQRU VLWXD LL VDX FRQGL LL GLVWUXFWLYH
SUHFXPGH]DVWUHWRUWXU FDSWLYLWDWHERDO SVLKLF VHYHU
ÌQ SVLKRSDWRORJLH VH FRQVLGHU F GLVDUPRQLLOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH
QX SRW IL FRQVLGHUDWH EROL SVLKLFH SURSULX]LVH PDL DOHV GDWRULW
FDUDFWHUXOXLHOX]LYDOGHEXWXOXLGHDVHPHQHDQXSUH]LQW RSHULRDG
GH VWDUH GH PD[LP PDQLIHVWDUH FOLQLF úL QLFL QX VH SRDWH VSHUD R
ÄYLQGHFDUH´VDXP FDUUHPLVLXQHVHPQLILFDWLY
7XOEXU ULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH DX IRVW GHQXPLWH ÄGH]YROW UL´ ILLQG
vQ VLQH VWUXFWXU UL SDUWLFXODUH DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL úL SUH]LQW FkWHYD
FDUDFWHULVWLFLVSHFLILFHSUHFXP
x SRWILREVHUYDWHvQF GLQFRSLO ULHSHQWUXF HOHPHQWHOHSULQFLSDOH
DSDUVFKL DWHvQFRPSRUWDPHQWXOFRSLOXOXL
x GHYLQHYLGHQWHvQSUHDGROHVFHQ úLVHFULVWDOL]HD] vQDGROHVFHQ
RGDW FXVWUXFWXUDUHDGHILQLWLY DSHUVRQDOLW LL
x vQVR HVFSHUVRDQDvQWRWFXUVXOYLH LL
7RFPDL DFHDVW FDUDFWHULVWLF GH VWUXFWXUDUH úL HYROX LH UHODWLY
FRQVWDQW IDFH FD WXOEXU ULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH V ILH PHQ LQXWH vQ
FDWHJRULDSVLKRSDWRORJLHLDO WXULGHEROLOHSVLKLFHSURSULX]LVH
6SUH GHRVHELUH GH VWUXFWXUDUHD FRPXQ D SHUVRQDOLW LL XQGH
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOSHUVRDQHLHVWHSUHYL]LELOGL]DUPRQLLOHVXQWVWUXFWXU UL
LQHGLWHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLQXvQWRWGHDXQDvQVHQVQHJDWLY*,RQHVFXvL
FDUDFWHUL]HD] vQSULPXOUkQGSULQLPSUHYL]LELOXOFRQGXLWHLSULQIDSWXO
F VXQW ÄVXUSULQ] WRUL vQ UDSRUWDUHD ORU OD QRUPH RELFHLXUL UHJXOL GH
FRQYLH XLUH VRFLDO OD FHLODO L úL QX UDUHRUL OD HL vQúLúL 3DUWLFXODUL vQ
FRQGXLW GDUQXúLvQGLVSRQLELOLW LYXOQHUDELOLODLQIUDF LXQHGDUúLOD
DGHY UXUL SH FDUH QRL QX OH URVWLP VHGXF WRUL VDX UHVSLQJ WRUL
VXJHVWLELOL úL QDLYL VDX IOH[LELOL úL SHUVXDVLYL HL VXQW VDUHD úL SLSHUXO
RPHQLULLHLWXOEXU YDOXULOHYLH LLVRFLDOHúLXQHRULOHGDXFXORDUH´
'HVLJXUILLQGYRUEDGHVSUHVWUXFWXU GHSHUVRQDOLWDWHGL]DUPRQLLLOH
UHSUH]LQW XQDQVDPEOXFDUDFWHULVWLFúLSHUVLVWHQWGHWU V WXULFRJQLWLYH
GHGLVSR]L LHúLUHOD LRQDOHFRQIHULQGRODUJ JDP GHFXORDUHSVLKLDWULHL
H[WUDPXURV
ÌQSUDFWLFDSVLKLDWULF úLSVLKRORJLF DXIRVWXWLOL]D LúLDO LWHUPHQL
DOF URUFRQ LQXWVHUHIHU ODWXOEXUDUHDGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHSUHFXPFDUDFWH
URSDWLLVRFLRSDWLLSVLKRSDWLLÌQFODVLILFDUHDORUGHQXPLUHDSULQFLSDOHORU
IRUPHGHWXOEXU ULGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHGHULY vQJHQHUDOGLQGHQXPLUHDSULQ
FLSDOHORUEROLSVLKLFHWXOEXUDUHSDUDQRUPDO DSHUVRQDOLW LLSDUDQRLD
WXOEXUDUHVFKL]RLG DSHUVRQDOLW LLVFKL]RIUHQLHWXOEXUDUHKLVWHURLG D
SHUVRQDOLW LLLVWHULH
ÌQWD[RQRPLD,&'&ODVLILFDUHDWXOEXU ULORUPHQWDOHúLGH
FRPSRUWDPHQW6LPSWRPDWRORJLHúLGLDJQRVWLFFOLQLFvQIXQF LH
GHVRUJLQWH
x VRUJLQWH SVLKRWLF WXOEXUDUH SDUDQRLG D SHUVRQDOLW LL WXOEXUDUH
VFKL]RLG DSHUVRQDOLW LL
x VRUJLQWHSVLKRVRFLDO WXOEXUDUHGLVRFLDO DSHUVRQDOLW LLWXOEXUDUH
ERUGHUOLQHDSHUVRQDOLW LLWXOEXUDUHKLVWULRQLF DSHUVRQDOLW LL
x VRUJLQWH QHYURWLF D SHUVRQDOLW LL WXOEXUDUH DQ[LRDV D SHUVRQD
OLW LLWXOEXUDUHGHSHQGHQW DSHUVRQDOLW LLWXOEXUDUHDQDQFDVW D
SHUVRQDOLW LLWXOEXUDUHHPR LRQDOLQVWDELO
&ODVLILFDUHD '60 ,9 0DQXDO GH GLDJQRVWLF úL VWDWLVWLF D
WXOEXU ULORUPHQWDOHLQWURGXFHFULWHULXOFOXVWHULORUGHVHQV
x &OXVWHU$WXOEXUDUHVFKL]RLG DSHUVRQDOLW LLWXOEXUDUHSDUDQRLG
DSHUVRQDOLW LLWXOEXUDUHVFKL]RWLSDO DSHUVRQDOLW LL
x &OXVWHU%WXOEXUDUHDQWLVRFLDO DSHUVRQDOLW LLWXOEXUDUHERUGHUOLQH
DSHUVRQDOLW LLWXOEXUDUHKLVWULRQLF DSHUVRQDOLW LLWXOEXUDUHQDU
FLVLF DSHUVRQDOLW LL
x &OXVWHU&WXOEXUDUHHYLWDQW DSHUVRQDOLW LLWXOEXUDUHGHSHQGHQW
DSHUVRQDOLW LLWXOEXUDUHREVHVLYFRPSXOVLY DSHUVRQDOLW LL
(YROX LLúLWDEORXULFOLQLFH
DOHXQRUDGLQWUHSHUVRQDOLW LOHDFFHQWXDWH
)LULOHDFFHQWXDWHSRWFRQGXFHvQDQXPLWHVLWXD LLVSUHFRPSRUWD
PHQWHVLPSWRPDWLFHSHQWUXXQJUDGGHSDWRORJLHDYDQVDW6XQWGHVFULVH
vQ'60GLIHULWHVLQGURDPHFDUDFWHULVWLFHSHQWUXXQHOHH[WUHPL] UL
+LVWULRQLFXO HVWH SUH]HQWDW GH '60 FD LQFOX]kQG XQ PRGHO
SHUYD]LYGHHPR LRQDOLWDWHH[FHVLY úLGHF XWDUHDDWHQ LHLvQFHSkQGGH
WLPSXULXvQSHULRDGDDGXOW úLSUH]HQWvQWURYDULHWDWHGHFRQWH[WHGXS
FXPHVWHLQGLFDWGHFHOSX LQSDWUXGLQXUP WRDUHOHFDXW FRQVWDQWVDX
FHUH UHDVLJXUDUH DSUREDUH VDX ODXG SHUVRDQD HVWH LPSURSULH FD
VHGXF LHVH[XDO vQDVSHFWVDXFRPSRUWDPHQWSHUVRDQDHVWHH[WUHPGH
SUHRFXSDW GH DWUDF LD VD IL]LF vúL H[SULP HPR LLOH FX R H[DJHUDUH
LQDGHFYDW GH H[HPSOX vPEU LúHD] FXQRúWLQ HOH vQWkPSO WRDUH FX R
DERUGDUHH[FHVLY SOkQVXOHVWHFXVXVSLQHLQFRQWURODELODUHDFFHVHGH
IXULH HVWH GHUDQMDW GH VLWXD LLOH vQ FDUH QX HVWH vQ FHQWUXO DWHQ LHL
SUH]LQW RVFKLPEDUHUDSLG úLRH[SUHVLHVXSHUILFLDO DHPR LLORUHVWH
DXWRFHQWUDW DF LXQLOH ILLQG RULHQWDWH VSUH RE LQHUHD GH VDWLVIDF LH
LPHGLDW QXDUHQLFLRWROHUDQ SHQWUXIUXVWUDUHDGHRJUDWLILFD LHFDUH
vQWkU]LHDUHXQVWLOGHDYRUELFDUHHVWHH[FHVLYGHLPSUHVLRQLVWúLOLSVLW
GHGHWDOLLGHH[HPSOXFkQGHVWHSXV V úLGHVFULHPDPDSHUVRDQDQX
SRDWHILPDLH[SOLFLW GHFkWFXÄHUDRSHUVRDQ IRDUWHIUXPRDV ´
ÌQ FRQGL LL H[WHULRDUH QHIDYRUDELOH FRPSRUWDPHQWXO KLSHUH[DFW
SRDWHILRULJLQHDXQHLGH]YROW ULKLSRFRQGULFH1HYUR]HOHKLSRFRQGULFH
QXSRWILvQWRWGHDXQDGHOLPLWDWHGHQHYUR]HOHREVHVLYH2DPHQLLFDUH
DXRFDUGLRIRELHSRWDYHDvQDFHODúLWLPSúLWHDPDGHDLHúLSHVWUDG
XQGHDUSXWHDVXIHULXQDWDFGHFRUG$FHDVW IRELHDXQRUVLWXD LLFDUH
LQH GH QHYUR]HOH REVHVLYH HVWH DLFL FRQVHFLQ D QRVRIRELHL DGLF D
WHPHULL GH D IL EROQDY SH FkQG vQ DOWH FD]XUL UHSUH]LQW GHVLJXU WRW
IULFDGHRY W PDUHGDUI U LGHHDXQHLEROLIL]LFH
$QDQFDúWLL VXSRUW ELQH GLVFLSOLQD VHYHU GLQ DUPDW UHXúLQG
XQHRUL úL vQ YLD D FLYLO V úL LPSXQ R DWDUH GLVFLSOLQ GDF VXQW
VXV LQX LSVLKRWHUDSHXWLFFRUHVSXQ] WRU
Ä=JkUFHQLDVHQWLPHQWHORU´FDúLULJLGLWDWHDPRUDO IDFFDDFHúWL
LQGLYL]L V ILH SHUFHSX L GH FHLODO L FD IRUPDOL úL FRQYHQ LRQDOL 'HúL
UH]LVWHQ LODDXWRULWDWHDFHORUODO LHLFHURUHVSHFWDUHVWULFW DSURSULHL
DXWRULW L
ÌQFDGUXOQHYUR]HLREVHVLRQDOHFRQIOLFWXOSVLKLFvQIRUPDVDFHD
PDL WLSLF VH H[SULP SULQ VLPSWRPH FRPSXOVLYH LGHL REVHGDQWH
FRPSXOVLH OD FRPLWHUHD GH DFWH LQGH]LUDELOH OXSWD FRQWUD DFHVWRU
JkQGXUL úL WHQGLQ H ULWXDOXUL GH H[RUFL]DUH HWF úL SULQWUXQ PRG GH
JkQGLUH GHILQLW PDL DOHV SULQ UXPLQD LH PHQWDO vQGRLDO VFUXSXOH úL
GXFkQGODLQKLEL LLDOHJkQGLULLúLDF LXQLL
0HFDQLVPHOH GH DS UDUH GHVFULVH GH SVLKDQDOL] FH VXQW VSHFL
ILFHDFHVWHLVWUXFWXULGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHVXQWGHSODVDUHDDIHFWXOXLDVXSUD
UHSUH]HQW ULORUPDLPXOWVDXPDLSX LQGHS UWDWHGHFRQIOLFWXORULJLQDO
L]RODUH DQXODUH UHWURDFWLY 'LQ SXQFW GH YHGHUH DO YLH LL SXOVLRQDOH
SRWILGHVFULVHDPELYDOHQ DIL[D LDODVWDGLXODQDOúLUHJUHVLD/DSHUVR
QDOLW LOH REVHVLRQDOH VH vQWkOQHúWH IUHFYHQW R UHOD LH VDGRPDVRFKLVW
LQWHULRUL]DW VXE IRUPD WHQVLXQLL GLQWUH HX úL XQ VXSUDHX H[WUHP GH
FUXG $FHDVW SXQHUH vQ HYLGHQ D GLQDPLFLL VXELDFHQWH QHYUR]HL
REVHVLRQDOHúLSHGHDOW SDUWHGHVFULHUHDFDUDFWHUXOXLDQDOúLDIRUPD
LXQLORU UHDF LRQDOH FDUH vO FRQVWLWXLH SHUPLW DG XJDUHD OD QHYUR]D
REVHVLRQDO DXQRUWDEORXULFOLQLFHvQFDUHVLPSWRPHOHSURSULX]LVHQX
VXQWHYLGHQWHODSULPDYHGHUH
6WUXFWXULOH REVHVLRQDOH DMXQJ V L]ROH]H R LGHH VDX XQ FRP
SRUWDPHQW vQ DúD IHO vQFkW FRQH[LXQLOH ORU FX DOWH LGHL VDX FX UHVWXO
H[LVWHQ HLVXELHFWXOXLVXQWvQWUHUXSWH3ULQWUHSURFHGHHOHGHL]RODUHV
FLW P SDX]HOH vQ IOX[XO JkQGLULL IRUPXOHOH ULWXDOXULOH úL vQ JHQHUDO
WRDWH P VXULOH FDUH SHUPLW L]RODUHD XQXL KLDWXV vQ VXFFHVLXQHD WHP
SRUDO DLGHLORUVDXDFWHORU$QXPL LREVHVLRQDOLVHDS U FRQWUDXQRU
LGHL LPSUHVLL DF LXQL L]ROkQGXOH SULQWUR SDX] vQ WLPSXO F UHLD
QLPLFQXPDLDUHGUHSWXOV VHSURGXF QLPLFQXHVWHSHUFHSXWQLFLR
DF LXQHQXVHUHDOL]HD]
,]RODUHDREVHVLRQDOXOXLSRDWHILFRPSDUDW FXUHIXODUHDODLVWHULF
GHúL H[SHULHQ D WUDXPDWL]DQW QX HVWH UHIXODW vQ LQFRQúWLHQW HD HVWH
SULYDW GHDIHFWXOHLLDUUHOD LLOHHLDVRFLDWLYHVXQWUHSULPDWHVDXUXSWH
vQ DúD IHO vQFkW SHUVLVW FD úL FXP DU IL L]RODW úL QDU ILUHSURGXV vQ
FXUVXODFWLYLW LLGHJkQGLUH
$FFHQWXO LQWHUHVXO LQWHQVLWDWHD XQHL UHSULP UL VH SRW GHWDúD GH
DFHVWHDSHQWUXDWUHFHODDOWHUHSUH]HQW ULRULJLQDUPDLSX LQLQWHQVH
GDUOHJDWHGHSULPDUHSUH]HQWDUHSULQWUXQODQ DVRFLDWLY
ÌQFDGUXOFDWHJRULHLREVHVLRQDOLORUVHUHPDUF HIRUWXULOHSHFDUHOH
IDF VXELHF LL SHQWUX D DQXOD UHWURDFWLY JkQGXUL FXYLQWH JHVWXUL DFWH
vQI SWXLWH HL IRORVHVF vQ DFHVW VFRS XQ JkQG VDX XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW FX
VHPQLILFD LHRSXV (VWHYRUEDDLFLGHRFRPSXOVLHFXFDUDFWHUÄPDJLF´
$FWHOHFRPSXOVLRQDOHVHUHDOL]HD] vQGRLWLPSLvQFDUHSULPXOWLPSHVWH
DQXODWGHFHOGHDOGRLOHD$GHY UDWDORUVHPQLILFD LHUH]LG vQDFHHDF
HOHUHSUH]LQW FRQIOLFWXODGRX WHQGLQ HRSXVHúLGHLQWHQVLWDWHDSURDSH
HJDO DOWHRULXQDFHODúLDFWHVWHUHSHWDWGDUFXVHPQLILFD LLFRQúWLHQWH
VDXLQFRQúWLHQWHRSXVHvQDOWHFD]XULDFWXOGHDQXODUHHVWHFRQWDPLQDW
GHDFWXOSHFDUHvQFHDUF V OúWHDUJ
ÌQ GH]YROWDUHD SDUDQRLG D ILULL KLSHUSHUVHYHUHQWH DPEL LD úL
OXSWD LQGLYLGXOXL VH FDQDOL]HD] VSUH R VLQJXU SUHRFXSDUH FDUH vO
DFDSDUHD] FXWRWXO
0HODQLH.OHLQYRUEHúWHGHVSUHSR]L LDSDUDQRLG SHFDUHLQL LDOD
QXPLWR ID] SHUVHFXWLY 7U V WXULOH SULQ FDUH VH FDUDFWHUL]HD] VXQW
XUP WRDUHOH SXOVLXQLOH DJUHVLYH FRH[LVW GH OD vQFHSXW FX SXOVLXQLOH
OLELGLQDOHúLVXQWGHRVHELWGHSXWHUQLFHRELHFWXOHVWHSDU LDOúLFOLYDWvQ
RELHFWXO ÄEXQ´ úL RELHFWXO ÄU X´ SURFHVHOH SVLKLFH SUHYDOHQWH VXQW
LQWURLHF LDúLSURLHF LDDQJRDVDLQWHQV HVWHGHQDWXU SHUVHFXWLY
$úDGDU vQ SDUDQRLD IXQF LRQHD] XQ PHFDQLVP GH DS UDUH GH
RULJLQHIRDUWHDUKDLF FHFRQVW vQRSHUD LDGHH[SXO]DUHGLQVLQHúLOR
FDOL]DUHvQDOWXOSHUVRDQ VDXOXFUXDFDOLW LORUVHQWLPHQWHORUGRULQ HORU
úLFKLDUDÄRELHFWHORU´SHFDUHSHUVRDQDQXOHFXQRDúWHVDXOHUHIX] vQ
VLQHvQV úL$OWIHOVSXVSURLHF LDDSDUHFDRDS UDUHSULPDU FDUHFRQVW
vQWURSURDVW XWLOL]DUHDPHFDQLVPXOXLQRUPDOGHDF XWDvQH[WHULRURUL
JLQHDXQHLQHSO FHUL3DUDQRLFXOvúLSURLHFWHD] UHSUH]HQW ULOHLQWROHUDELOH
FDUH VH vQWRUF OD HO GLQ H[WHULRU VXE IRUP GH UHSURúXUL FRQ LQXWXO U
PkQHLQWDFWGDUH[LVW RVFKLPEDUHvQDPSODVDUHDDQVDPEOXOXL
'60SUH]LQW FDHOHPHQWHVHQ LDODOWXOEXU ULLGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHGH
WLS SDUDQRLG R WHQGLQ SDVLY úL QHMXVWLILFDW GH D LQWHUSUHWD GHOLUDQW
DF LXQLOHDOWRUDFDILLQGvQMRVLWRDUHúLDPHQLQ WRDUHWHQGLQ FDUHvQFHSH
GHWLPSXULXvQYLD DDGXOW úLHVWHSUH]HQW vQWURYDULHWDWHGHFRQWH[WH
3HQWUXDVWDELOLGLDJQRVWLFXOHVWHQHFHVDU SUH]HQ DDFHOSX LQSDWUXGLQ
XUP WRDUHOH VH DúWHDSW I U ED] VXILFLHQW V ILH H[SORDWDW VDX
QHGUHSW LWGHDO LLDUHI U QLFLRMXVWLILFDUHGXELLvQOHJ WXU FXORLDOL
WDWHDúLVLQFHULWDWHDDPLFLORUVDXDDVRFLD LORUYHGHLQWHQ LLMRVQLFHVDX
DPHQLQ WRDUHDVFXQVHvQFHOHPDLEHQLJQHUHPDUFLVDXHYHQLPHQWHGH
H[HPSOXVXVSHFWHD] F YHFLQXOvúLVFRDWHDIDU OXFUXULOHGLVGHGLPLQHD
FDV ODJDVH]HSHGkQVXOSRDUW UDQFKLXQ VDXHVWHLPSODFDELOODLQVXOWH
VDXODOLSVDGHUHVSHFWQXDUHvQFUHGHUHvQDO LLGLQFDX]DWHRULHLQHMXVWL
ILFDWHF LQIRUPD LDYDILIRORVLW FRQWUDVDHVWHXúRUGHYH[DWúLSURPSW
vQDUHDF LRQDFXPkQLHVDXFRQWUDDWDFDUHvQPRGQHMXVWLILFDWGXELLvQ
OHJ WXU FXILGHOLWDWHDVR LHLVDXSDUWHQHUHLVH[XDOH
3HQWUX SHUVRQDOLWDWHD GLVWLPLF GHFRPSHQV ULOH VXUYLQ FKLDU OD
HúHFXUL PLQRUH SXWkQG vPEU FD IRUPH VHYHUH DOH GHSUHVLHL FH SRW
DMXQJHUDUHRULODVXLFLG$OFRROLVPXOHVWHFRPSOLFD LDPDMRU DDFHVWXL
WLSGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHGHWHULRUDUHDSURGXV GHWR[LFRPDQLHGRPLQkQGvQ
WLPSWDEORXOSVLKRSDWRORJLF
'60SUH]LQW SHUVRQDOLWDWHDGHWLSGLVWLPLFFDDYkQGvQFHQWUXO
GH]YROW ULLVDOHRSUHGLVSR]L LHGHSUHVLY SHQWUXFHDPDLPDUHSDUWHD
]LOHLWLPSGHPDLPXOWH]LOHGXS FXPLQGLF ILHUHODWDUHDVXELHFWLY
ILHREVHUYD LDDOWRUDWLPSGHFHOSX LQGRLDQL
ÌQWLPSXOGHSUHVLHLSUH]LQW FHOSX LQGRX GLQXUP WRDUHOHDSHWLW
UHGXV VDX H[DJHUDW LQVRPQLH VDX KLSHUVRPQLH HQHUJLH UHGXV VDX
IDWLJDELOLWDWHVWLP GHVLQHVF ]XW FRQFHQWUDUHUHGXV VDXGLILFXOWDWHvQ
DOXDGHFL]LLVHQWLPHQWHGHGLVSHUDUH
7XOEXUDUHD GH WLS FLFORWLPLF HVWH FDUDFWHUL]DW GH HSLVRDGH FDUH
VHUHSHW vQFDUHQLYHOHOHGHGLVSR]L LHúLDFWLYLWDWHDOHSHUVRDQHLVXQW
SHUWXUEDWHVHPQLILFDWLY,&'3HUWXUEDUHDLQFOXGHXQHOHHSLVRDGH
GH H[DOWDUH D GLVSR]L LHL HQHUJLHL úL DFWLYLWDWH FUHVFXW PDQLH VDX
KLSRPDQLHDO WXULGHDOWHHSLVRDGHGHVF GHUHDGLVSR]L LHLHQHUJLHL
úLDFWLYLW LLGHSUHVLH)UHFYHQ DHSLVRDGHORUúLPRGHOXOUHF GHULORUúL
UHPLVLXQLORU VXQW IRDUWH YDULDWH FX WHQGLQ D FD R GDW FX MXP WDWHD
YLH LLUHPLVLXQLOHV GHYLQ PDLVFXUWHLDUGHSUHVLLOHPDLIUHFYHQWHúL
PDLSUHOXQJLWH
7XOEXUDUHD GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH GH WLS DQ[LRV HVWH FDUDFWHUL]DW GH
VHQWLPHQWHSHUVLVWHQWHúLJHQHUDOHGHWHQVLXQHúLvQJULMRUDUH3HUVRDQD
HVWHGRPLQDW GHVHQWLPHQWXOGHLQIHULRULWDWHVRFLDO HVWHFRQYLQV F
HVWH LQFDSDELO vQ SODQ VRFLDO QX HVWH DWUDFWLY úL HVWH LQIHULRDU
FHORUODO LDFHVWVHQWLPHQWRIDFHV DSDU H[FHVLYSUHRFXSDW GHFULWLFD
VDX UHVSLQJHUHD VRFLDO DO WXUL GH GRULQ D GH D HYLWD UHOD LLOH FX
H[FHS LD VLWXD LLORU vQ FDUH DUH FHUWLWXGLQHD F HVWH DJUHDW ÌQ YLD D
SHUVRQDO GRPLQ UHVWULF LL OHJDWH GH QHYRLDFUHVFXW GHVHFXULWDWHIL
]LF 'LQFDX]DWHPHULLGHUHVSLQJHUHúLKLSHUVHQVLELOLW LLODUHVSLQJHUH
úL FULWLF SHUVRDQD HYLW DFWLYLW LOH VRFLDOH VDX SURIHVLRQDOH FDUH R
VLOHVFV ILHVDXV LQWUHvQUHOD LHFXDOWHSHUVRDQH
7XOEXUDUHD HPR LRQDOLQVWDELO vQVHDPQ WHQGLQ D PDUFDW GH D
UHDF LRQDLPSXOVLYI U DOXDvQFRQVLGHUDUHFRQVHFLQ HOHGHDVHPHQHD
HVWHvQVR LW GHLQVWDELOLWDWHDIHFWLY
6F GHUHDODPLQLPDFDSDFLW LLGHDSODQLILFDDQWLFLSDWLYH[SOR
]LLOH GH IXULH LQWHQV SRW GXFH OD YLROHQ VDX OD ÄH[SOR]LL FRPSRUWD
PHQWDOH´FDUHVHSHWUHFXúRUFkQGDFWHOHLPSXOVLYHSDUVDXVXQWFULWLFDWH
GHDO LLVDXVXQWvPSLHGLFDWH
D $FFHQWXDUHD LPSXOVLYLW LL FDUDFWHULVWLFD GRPLQDQW HVWH LQ
VWDELOLWDWHD HPR LRQDO úL OLSVD GH FRQWURO D LPSXOVXULORU ([SOR]LL GH
YLROHQ VDXGHFRPSRUWDPHQWDJUHVLYDSDUvQPRGRELúQXLWPDLDOHV
FDU VSXQVODFULWLF VXQWLQFOXVHúLWXOEXU ULDJUHVLYH[SOR]LYH
E$FFHQWXDUHDLQVWDELOLW LL±ERUGHUOLQHFRQGXFHF WUHRWXOEXUDUH
GRPLQDQW GH WLS ERUGHUOLQH FDUDFWHULVWLFL DOH LQVWDELOLW LL HPR LRQDOH
vQVR LWHGHRWXOEXUDUHúLQHFODULWDWHODQLYHOXOLPDJLQLLGHVSUHVLQHGHV
SUH HOXULOHúLSUHIHULQ HOHVDOHLQWHUQHLQFOXVLYFHOHVH[XDOH'HRELFHL
LQWHUYLQHXQVHQWLPHQWFURQLFGHJROLQWHULRURWHQGLQ GHDVHLPSOLFD
vQ UHOD LL LQWHQVH úL LQVWDELOH FDUH SRDWH FRQGXFH VSUH FUL]H HPR LRQDOH
UHSHWDWHúLVHSRDWHDVRFLDFXHIRUWXULH[FHVLYHGHDHYLWDDEDQGRQXOúLR
VHULHGHDFWHGHVXLFLGVDXGHDXWRY W PDUHDFHVWHDSRWDSDUHúLI U
GHFODQúDWRULHYLGHQ L
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH
DQDQFDVW GXS .DKQ WHUPHQ XWLOL]DW SHQWUX VLPSWRPDWRORJLD
REVHVLY FRPSXOVLY $YDQWDMXO XWLOL] ULL OXL HVWH F VH HYLW V VH
LPSOLFH vQ PRG HURQDW R FRQH[LXQH vQWUH DFHVW WLS GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH úL
WXOEXU ULOH REVHVLRQDOH vQ VHQV GLDJQRVWLF WLS GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH
KLSHUH[DFW FDUHVHGLVWLQJHSULQOLSVDFDSDFLW LLGHUHIXODUHFRQúWLLQ
FLR]LWDWHúLVHULR]LWDWHH[DJHUDWH
DQRUPDOFDUHVHvQGHS UWHD] GHQRUP VDXQRUPDOSRDWHVHPQLILFD
GHYLD LLSXUFDQWLWDWLYHvQDQDOL]HOHVWDWLVWLFHGDUúLPRGHOHGHFRPSRU
WDPHQWGHYLDQWHDOHLQGLYL]LORU'LILFXOWDWHDGHOLPLW ULLQRUPDOXOXLGH
DQRUPDOSRUQHúWHGLQWHQGLQ DGHDDYHDJUDQL HGHQRUPDOLWDWHGHILQLWH
GH XQD VDX DOWD GLQWUH WHRULLOH DVXSUD SHUVRQDOLW LL GH H[HPSOX vQ
YL]LXQHD SVLKDQDOLWLF FODVLF KRPRVH[XDOLWDWHD HVWH SULYLW FD DQRU
PDOLWDWH FRQWUDU WHRULLORU SULYLQG vQY DUHD VRFLDO ([LVW R WHQGLQ
GHDXWLOL]DWHUPHQLSUHFXPQHDGDSWDUHQHDFRPRGDUHGHYLDQWvQOHJ
WXU FX HYDOXDUHD XQXL LQGLYLG FRQVLGHUDW UHVSHFWLY vO HYDOX P vQ
IXQF LHGHP VXUDvQFDUHSXWHPYRUELGHXQFRPSRUWDPHQWDGDSWDWLY
úLQXSHQWUXDOHWLFKHWDSXUúLVLPSOX'3
ERUGHUOLQHWHUPHQXOHVWHFHOPDLIUHFYHQWXWLOL]DWSHQWUXDGLDJQRVWLFD
RJDP ODUJ GHWXOEXU ULGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHúLUHWDUGPHQWDOGLDJQRVWLFXO
GHWXOEXUDUHGHWLSERUGHUOLQHVHUHIHU ODVLWXD LDXQHLSHUVRDQHFDUHvQ
PRGFURQLFÄWU LHúWHSHJUDQL ´vQWUHRIXQF LRQDUHQRUPDO DGDSWDWLY
úLRGL]DELOLWDWHSVLKLF UHDO 'HRELFHLvQFRPSRUWDPHQWDSDURVHULHGH
LQVWDELOLW LI U WU V WXULFODUHGHH[HPSOXUHOD LLOHLQWHUSHUVRQDOHWLQG
V ILHLQVWDELOHDIHFWHOHVHVFKLPE GUDPDWLFúLLQDGHFYDWLPDJLQHDGH
VLQHSRDWHILWXOEXUDW vQPRGFXUHQWDSDULHúLULGHIXULHDFWHLPSXOVLYH
FDUHDMXQJV ILHDXWRGLVWUXFWLYHFRPSXOVLDVSUHMRFXULGHQRURFVWDUH
GHDSDWLHHQGHPLF HWF
FOLYDMSURFHVSULQFDUHRVWUXFWXU vúLSLHUGHXQLFLWDWHDúLHVWHvQORFXLW
SULQGRX VWUXFWXULSDU LDOHVDXPDLPXOWHÌQSVLKLDWULHHVWHVLQRQLPFX
GLVRFLHUHDGHGXEODUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL
FOXVWHU vQ DQDOL]D IDFWRULDO GHQXPHúWH XQ JUXS GH YDULDELOH FDUH DX
FRUHOD LLPDLvQDOWHXQDFXFHDODOW GHFkWID GHDOWHYDULDELOHvQVHQV
ODUJGHQXPHúWHRULFHJUXSGHRELHFWHVDXHYHQLPHQWHFDUHVXELHFWLY
SDUV DLE RDSDUWHQHQ FRPXQ
FRQYHUVLHWUDQVIRUPDUHDXQHLHPR LLDXQXLHIHFWUHIXODWvQPDQLIHVWDUH
GHSDWRORJLHVRPDWLF
GHIHQV UHDF LHRELúQXLW WLSLF LQFRQúWLHQW QDWXUDO GHDXWRSURWHF LH
ID GHDQ[LHWDWH
GH]YROW ULSDUDQRLFHH[SUHVLHDXQHLOHJLSVLKRORJLFHSRWULYLWF UHLD
WHQGLQ HOH DIHFWLYH VXSXVH RVFLO ULL vQWUH GRL SROL FUHVF vQ DVHPHQHD
P VXU vQFkWVHQWLPHQWHQHvQVHPQDWHVHWUDQVIRUP vQDIHFWHSURIXQGH
GLVWLPLHWXOEXUDUHGHUHJODUHDGLVSR]L LHL
KLVWULRQLF vQFOLQD LH VSUH GUDPDWL]DUHD VLWXD LLORU VSUH H[SULPDUHD
HPIDWLF D VHQWLPHQWHORU úL VSUH IDSWXO F SURGXFHUHD GH VLPSWRPH
QHFHVLW SUH]HQ DXQXLDOWUHLOHDVSHFWDWRUúLHVWHvQVR LW GHRUHODWLY
LQGLIHUHQ vQSULYLQ DORU
LQWURLHF LHPHFDQLVPSVLKRORJLFLQFRQúWLHQWGHvQFRUSRUDUHLPDJLQDU
DXQXLRELHFWVDXDXQHLSHUVRDQHFDUHFRQVW vQDSUHOXDRFkWPDL
PDUHSDUWHGLQOXPHDH[WHULRDU úLDDWULEXLVLQHOXLFDOLW LOHUHDOHVDX
SUHVXSXVHDOHRELHFWXOXL
QHYUR] GHILQHúWHRWXOEXUDUHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHVDXPHQWDO FDUHQXVH
GDWRUHD] XQHL GLVIXQF LL QHXURORJLFH VDX RUJDQLFH FXQRVFXWH WHU
PHQXOSRDWHILIRORVLWGHVFULSWLYSHQWUXDGHQXPLXQVLPSWRPVDXJUXS
GHVLPSWRPHOHJDWHHWLRORJLFSHQWUXDLQGLFDUROXOFDX]DOMXFDWGHXQ
FRQIOLFWLQFRQúWLHQWFDUHHYRF DQ[LHWDWHúLFRQGXFHODXQPHFDQLVPGH
DS UDUH FH SURGXFH vQ XOWLP LQVWDQ VLPSWRPXO REVHUYDW ÌQ XOWLPLL
DQLVDXSURGXVGRX PRGLILF ULVHPQLILFDWLYHvQXWLOL]DUHDWHUPHQXOXL
XWLOL]DUHDGHQXPLULLGHWXOEXUDUHQHYURWLF FDXQWHUPHQJHQHULFSHQWUX
RULFH WXOEXUDUH PHQWDO GH GXUDW WHUPHQ UHODWLY QHXWUX vQ SULYLQ D
IDFWRULORU HWLRORJLFL HOLPLQDUHD WHUPHQXOXL GLQ GLDJQR]D SVLKLDWULF
DFRPSDQLDW GH R UHDWULEXLUH D YDULDWHORU WLSXUL DQWHULRU UHFXQRVFXWH
GHQHYUR]HXQRUDOWRUFODVLILF ULGLDJQRVWLFH'3
SHUVRQDOLWDWHSVLKRSDW RWXOEXUDUHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHFDUDFWHUL]DW GH
DPRUDOLWDWHOLSV DDIHFWLYLW LLúLXQVF ]XWVHQVDOQHOLQLúWLLúLYLQR
Y LHL OHJDWH GH vQF OFDUHD OHJLORU R H[WUHP GH ODUJ JDP GH FRP
SRUWDPHQWHH[KLEDWHGHSHUVRDQH'3
SVLKRSDWRORJLH VH UHIHU OD VWXGLXO úWLLQ LILF DO WXOEXU ULORU PHQWDOH
GRPHQLXOLQFOXGHFHUFHW ULvQGRPHQLXOSVLKRORJLHLQHXURORJLHLSVLKL
DWULHL HQGRFULQRORJLHL úL IDUPDFRORJLHL 'RPHQLXO DFWLYLW LL SUDFWLFH
DOSVLKRORJLORUFOLQLFLHQLvQWHUDSLDWXOEXU ULORUPHQWDOH
UHIXODUHIHQRPHQSVLKLFLQFRQúWLHQWGHDS UDUHDHXOXLSULQLQWHUPHGLXO
F UXLDVHQWLPHQWHOHDPLQWLULOHúLHPR LLOHSHQLELOHVDXFHOHFDUHVXQWvQ
GH]DFRUG FX PRGHOXO VRFLDO DO XQHL SHUVRDQH VXQW PHQ LQXWH vQ DIDUD
FkPSXOXLFRQúWLLQ HLvQVWUXFWXULOHVXEFRQúWLHQWH
VXEOLPDUH vQ VHQV FODVLF SVLKDQDOLWLF FRQFHSWXO VH UHIHU OD SURFHVXO
LQFRQúWLHQWGHUHGLUHF LRQDUHDLPSXOVXULORUSULPLWLYHvQFRPSRUWDPHQWH
QRLvQY DWHQRQLQVWLQFWLYH&XVHQVPDLJHQHUDOUHGLUHF LRQDUHDHQHU
JLHLGLQVSUHFHHDFHHVWHLQDFFHSWDELOVRFLDOVSUHDFFHSWDELO
WHQGLQ DFFHQWXDW LQYDULDQ RSHUD LRQDO FDUHJHQHUHD] PDQLIHVW UL
SUHJQDQWHQXQXPDLvQUDSRUWFXPHGLDFLúLFXDEDWHULOHGHODPHGLH
WLPLHVLWXD LDJOREDO DVW ULLGHVSLULWFDUHFRUHVSXQGHXQRUFRPELQD LL
vQWUHPDLPXOWHGLPHQVLXQLHPR LRQDOH
WU V WXU DFFHQWXDW FDUDFWHULVWLFLOHVSHFLILFHDFFHQWX ULLVHPDQLIHVW
FDLQYDULDQ LRSHUD LRQDOLYRUJHQHUDPDQLIHVW ULSUHJQDQWHvQWHUPHQL
QRUPDWLYL QX QXPDL vQ UDSRUW GH ÄPHGLD´ GDU úL GH ÄDEDWHULOH GH OD
PHGLH´ /LPLWHOH GLQWUH QRUPDO vQ WHUPHQL FDQWLWDWLYL WHQGLQ D VSUH
ÄPHGLX´DFFHQWXDWúLGL]DUPRQLFQXVXQWIL[HLDUGHOLPLW ULOHVSHFLILFH
VHUHDOL]HD] vQIXQF LHGHLQWHQVLWDWHDFRQVWDQ DúLJUDGXOGHVRFLDOL]DUH
DOPDQLIHVW ULLFDUHH[SULP WU V WXUDDFFHQWXDW LQGHSHQGHQWGHvPSUH
MXU ULOHH[WHULRDUH
WXOEXUDUHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHWHUPHQXODVHUYLWPXOWWLPSSHQWUXRULFH
WLSGHWXOEXUDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL,QL LDOVHPQLILFDRULFHWXOEXUDUHPHQ
WDO PDQLIHVWDW SULQQHDGDSWDUHúLPRGHOHQHDGDSWDWLYHGHUHOD LRQDUH
FXPHGLXOFHHDFHQXDMXWDODGLIHUHQ LHUHDGLQWUHVLPSWRPHQHYURWLFH
PLQRUH ID GH WXOEXU UL PDMRUH SVLKRWLFH ÌQ SUH]HQW PDL VSHFLILF R
FODV GHWXOEXU ULGHFRPSRUWDPHQWH[FOX]kQGQHYUR]HOHúLSVLKR]HOH
PDQLIHVWDWH FD GH]YROW UL SDWRORJLFH vQ SHUVRQDOLWDWHD vQWUHDJ D
LQGLYLGXOXL úL PDUFDW GH R DQ[LHWDWH UHODWLY VF ]XW VDX GH HPR LL
QHJDWLYH LQFOX]kQG DVWIHO WUHL VXEFODVH GH WXOEXU UL WXOEXU UL GH
SHUVRQDOLWDWH JHQHUDO LQFOX]kQG WXOEXUDUHD FRPSXOVLY FLFORWLPLF
SDUDQRLG HWF WXOEXU ULOH VRFLRSDWH FDUH VXQW FDUDFWHUL]DWH SULQWUR
OLSV JHQHUDO D DIHFWHORU DGHFYDWH D VHQWLPHQWHORU GH YLQRY LH vQ
XUPDvQF OF ULLOHJLORUúLDLQFDSDFLW LLGHDIRUPDOHJ WXULHPR LRQDOH
GH GXUDW LQFOX]kQG GH H[HPSOX WXOEXUDUHD VRFLRSDW WXOEXUDUHD
SVLKRSDW GHYLHULOHVH[XDOHÌQSUH]HQWRWXOEXUDUHPHQWDO DOHF UHL
WU V WXUL HVHQ LDOH VXQW PRGHOH GH UHOD LRQDUH QHDGDSWDWLYH SURIXQG
vQU G FLQDWH GH GXUDW PRGXUL GH JkQGLUH úL SHUFHSHUH D PHGLXOXL
FDUH VXQW H[WUHPH SkQ vQ FRQGL LD GH D FRQGXFH OD vPSLHGLFDUHD
IXQF LRQ ULL VRFLDOH úL FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH 7XOEXU ULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH
SRW IL UHFXQRVFXWH vQ JHQHUDO vQ FRSLO ULH VDX DGROHVFHQ úL FRQWLQX
GHDOXQJXOYLH LLDGXOWH'3
WXOEXUDUH SVLKRWLF XQ WHUPHQ FDUH DFRSHU XQ QXP U GH WXOEXU UL
PHQWDOHVHYHUHGHRULJLQHRUJDQLF VDXHPR LRQDO 'LDJQRVWLFDUHDDUH
vQYHGHUHLQYDOLGLWDWHDGHWHULRUDUHDFDSDFLW LLGHWHVWDUHDUHDOLW LL
SHUVRDQDIDFHLQIHUHQ HLQFRUHFWHSULYLWRDUHODUHDOLWDWHDH[WHUQ HYD
OX ULLPSURSULLDOHDFXUDWH HLJkQGXULORUúLSHUFHS LLORUVDOHúLFRQWLQX
V IDF HURUL vQ FLXGD GRYH]LORU FRQWUDULL 6LPSWRPHOH FODVLFH LQFOXG
KDOXFLQD LL FRPSRUWDPHQWH UHJUHVLYH VHYHUH GLVSR]L LL GUDPDWLF
QHDGHFYDWHYRUELUHLQFRHUHQW '3
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU
ÌQFHFRQVW FRQFHSWXOGHWU V WXU DFFHQWXDW "
&DUHVXQWFHOHVFDOHDOHWHVWXOXLGHWHQGLQ HDFFHQWXDWH"
'HILQL LDVSHFWHOHFDUDFWHULVWLFHDOHILULLGHPRQVWUDWLYH
'HILQL LDVSHFWHOHFDUDFWHULVWLFHDOHILULLKLSHUH[DFWH
'HILQL LDVSHFWHOHFDUDFWHULVWLFHDOHILULLKLSHUSHUVHYHUHQWH
'HILQL LDVSHFWHOHFDUDFWHULVWLFHDOHILULLGLVWLPLFH
&DUHHVWHGHRVHELUHDGLQWUHILULOHH[DOWDWHDQ[LRDVHúLHPRWLYH"
&DUHVXQWDVSHFWHOHFDUDFWHULVWLFHSHQWUXILUHDFLFORWLPLF "
&DUHVXQWSDúLLvQLQWHUSUHWDUHDU VSXQVXULORUVXELHFWXOXLODWHVW"
&DUHHVWHGHRVHELUHDGLQWUHWU V WXU GHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDFFHQWXDW úL
WXOEXUDUHDGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH"([HPSOLILFD L
%LEOLRJUDILH
,&'&ODVLILFDUHDWXOEXU ULORUPHQWDOHúLGHFRPSRUWDPHQW:RUOG+HDOWK
$VVRFLDWLRQ(GLWXUD$//%XFXUHúWL
'60,90DQXDOGH'LDJQRVWLFúLVWDWLVWLF DWXOEXU ULORUPHQWDOH$PHULFDQ
3V\FKLDWULF$VVRFLDWLRQ(GLWXUD$3/5%XFXUHúWL
/HRQKDUG . 3HUVRQDOLW L DFFHQWXDWH vQ YLD úL OLWHUDWXU (GLWXUD
(QFLFORSHGLF 5RPkQ %XFXUHúWL
6FKPLHVFKHFN + )UDJHERJHQ ]XU (UPLWWOXQJ DN]HQWXLHUWHU
3HUV|QOLFKNHLWHQ vQ 3V\FKRORJLH 1HXURORJLH XQG PHGL]LQVFKH
3V\FKRORJLH+HIW/HLS]LJ
&DSLWROXO9,,,
,19(17$58/08/7,)$=,&
'(3(5621$/,7$7(0,11(627$
3UH]HQWDUHD FRQVWUXLULL 003, VFDOHOH VWDQGDUG DOH 003,
FRQ LQXWXO VFDOHORU GH YDOLGDUH úL DO VFDOHORU FOLQLFH DVSHFWHOH GH
SVLKRSDWRORJLH FRQGL LD GH QRUPDOLWDWH D VFRUXULORU FRGLILFDUHD
UH]XOWDWHORU UHJXOL FRQVWUXLUHD 003, ,, WLSXULOH QRL GH VFDOH DOH
003,,,H[HPSOLILFDUHDLQWHUSUHW ULLXQXLSURILO003,6XQWRIHULWH
FkWHYDH[WLQGHULODSUH]HQWDUHD003,FRQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFHXQWHVW
GHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORUSUHFXPúLUHIHULQ HOHELEOLRJUDILFH
&RQVWUXLUHD003,
ÌQSUH]HQWSUREOHPDFHQWUDO vQGRPHQLXOHYDOX ULLWXOEXU ULORU
GHSHUVRQDOLWDWHHVWHGDF DFHVWHDWUHEXLHLGHQWLILFDWHúLGLDJQRVWLFDWH
FD úL FDWHJRULL QRVRORJLFH VDX FD úL GLPHQVLXQL DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL
:LGLJHU )UDQFHV'60GHILQHúWHvQPRGFODUWXOEXU ULOHGH
SHUVRQDOLWDWHFDVHWXULGHWU V WXULFDUHDSDULQIOH[LELOHúLQHDGDSWDWLYH
FHHDFHFRQGXFHILHODRSUHMXGLFLHUHDIXQF LRQ ULLvQSODQXOVRFLDOXOXL
VDXDVIHUHLSURIHVLRQDOHILHODRVWDUHSURDVW vQSODQVXELHFWLY
'LQ DFHDVW SHUVSHFWLY FKHVWLRQDUXO 003, HVWH FRQVWUXLW vQ
PRG GHOLEHUDW ÄV HYDOXH]H DFHOH WU V WXUL FDUH VXQW FDUDFWHULVWLFL
FRPXQH DOH DQRUPDOLW LL SVLKRORJLFH GL]DELOLWDQWH´ +DWKDZD\ úL
0F.LQOH\ úL D VXIHULW GHD OXQJXO FHORU SHVWH GH DQL GH OD
SULPD SXEOLFDUH UHHYDOX UL GLYHUVH ÌQ SUH]HQW R GDW FX HYROX LD
GLDJQRVWLFXOXL úL FDWHJRULLORU QRVRORJLFH vQ SVLKLDWULD FRQWHPSRUDQ
YDULDQWD 003, GLIHU FD PRG GH FRQFHSHUH D GLDJQRVWLFXOXL GH
YDULDQWDFODVLF
3ULQ PRGXO GH FRQVWUXF LH úL SULQ WHKQLFD GH YDOLGDUH DSDU LQH
GHVLJXURGDW FXWRDWHDVSHFWHOHSR]LWLYHVDXQHJDWLYHXQHLJHQHUD LL
WUHFXWH GH WHVWH GH SVLKRGLDJQR] FOLQLF $XWRULL +DWKDZD\ úL
0F.LQOH\ SUH]LQW SULPD YDULDQW vQ FX VFRSXO GH D SXQH OD
GLVSR]L LD FOLQLFLHQLORU XQ LQVWUXPHQW FDUH V H[SORUH]H FkW GH H[WLQV
SRVLELO SUREOHPDWLFD SVLKRSDWRORJLHL XPDQH V SRDW IL DSOLFDW PDL
XúRU úL SUDFWLF vQ FRQGL LL FOLQLFH V GHD SRVLELOLWDWHD FRQWUROXOXL
YDOLGLW LLU VSXQVXULORUúLV ILHYDOLGDWHPSLULF$FHVWGLQXUP DVSHFW
FDUHODHSRFDUHVSHFWLY HUDRUHDOL]DUHVXEVWDQ LDO DXWRULLSOHFkQGvQ
FRQVWUXF LDLWHPLORUúLVFDOHORUUHVSHFWLYHGHODFDWHJRULLOHQRVRORJLFH
DOH YUHPLL HVWH GLQ S FDWH FHO FDUH D LPSXV vQ SUH]HQW XQHOH OLPLWH
PRGDOLW LLSURSULX]LVHGHDGLDJQRVWLFDSVLKLDWULFXWLOL]kQGVFDOHOHFD
DWDUH vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH GHD OXQJXO VHFROXOXL GDWHOH FOLQLFLL SVLKLD
WULFHDXVFKLPEDWFRQFHS LDDVXSUDFRPSRUWDPHQWHORUSVLKRSDWRORJLFH
úLDVXSUDGLDJQR]HLVLPSWRPDWRORJLHLFOLQLFHúLWRWXúLYDOLGDUHDHPSL
ULF VWDELOLW SULQORWXULGHSDFLHQ LRPRJHQHDOF URUFRPSRUWDPHQW
SVLKRSDWRORJLFHUDELQHVWDELOLWDSHUPLVúLRIRDUWHEXQ FDSDFLWDWHGH
GLDJQR] GLIHUHQ LDO OXFUXYDODELOúLDVW ]L
&HUFHW UL FRQWHPSRUDQH LQGLF GH H[HPSOX F QDWXUD DVRFLD LHL
vQWUHWU V WXULOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHúLHYDOX ULDOHJUDGXOXLGHWXOEXUDUHD
SHUVRQDOLW LL QX HVWH OLQLDU $VWIHO GH H[HPSOX OD XQLL VXELHF L
WXOEXU ULOH VDX VLPSWRPHOH GLQ VLQGURPXO GH DQ[LHWDWH DU WUHEXL FRQ
VLGHUDWH FD R DS UDUH IXQF LRQDO ID GH WHQGLQ H GH GH]LQWHJUDUH
VXELDFHQWHvQWLPSFHODDO LVXELHF LVFKL]RWLSDOLVDXERUGHUOLQHXQHOH
WU V WXUL QHYURWLFH SUHFXP VRPDWL] ULOH VDX WLPLGLWDWHD SRW IL
FRQVLGHUDWHFDIXQF LRQDOHúLGHIHQVLYH(XUHOLQJV%RQWHNRH'XLMVHQV
6QHOOHQ'LHNVWUD2XZHUVORRW
003,XO D IRVW GHVWLQDW XWLOL] ULL GH F WUH FOLQLFLHQL H[SHUL
PHQWD LúLVSHFLDOL]D LvQDSOLFDUHDDFHVWXLWHVW7RWXúLH[LVW PDLPXOWH
PRGDOLW LGHDXWLOL]DVFDOHOHWHVWXOXL$QDVWD]L2VHULHGHVWXGLL
VDX D[DW SH YDOLGDUHD OXL HPSLULF FD XQ LQVWUXPHQW GH GLDJQRVWLFDUH
JHQHUDO DDQRUPDOLW LLSVLKLFH$VWIHOVDGHPRQVWUDWF vQJHQHUDOFX
FkWHVWHPDLPDUHQXP UXOúLP ULPHDGHYLDQ HLODQLYHOXOXQHLVFDOHFX
DWkWSXWHPVSXQHF SHUVRDQDHVWHPDLVHYHUWXOEXUDW SVLKLF
2DOW VHULHGHFHUFHW ULVDXD[DWFKLDUSHYDOLGLWDWHDGLDJQRVWLF D
GLIHULWHORU VFDOH OXDWH VHSDUDW 0DMRULWDWHD GDWHORU LQGLF UH]XOWDWH
QHJDWLYHFKLDUDXWRULLWHVWXOXLDYHUWL]HD] vPSRWULYDXQHLLQWHUSUHW ULDG
OLWHUDPDVFDOHORUFOLQLFHúLXQLLSUHIHU V VXEVWLWXLHSULQFRGXULQXPH
ULFHGHQXPLULOHLQL LDOHDOHVFDOHORU$FHVWHDVSHFWHHPSLULFHFRQYHUJFX
RELHF LLFOLQLFHID GHXWLOL]DUHDVFDOHORU003,vQGLDJQR]DGLIHUHQ
LDO LQGLYLGXDO vQSODQFOLQLFFHHDFHDUHLPSRUWDQ úLUHOHYDQ HVWH
WRFPDL UHFLSURFD LQWHUUHOD LH D WU V WXULORU vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH R DFHHDúL
WU V WXU SRDWH DYHD LPSOLFD LL GHRVHELWH vQ IXQF LH GH FOXVWHUL] ULOH vQ
FDUHDSDUH
ÌQF GLQDQLL
DQDOL]DIDFWRULDO DVFDOHORU003,DFRQGXV
OD FRQFOX]LD F ÄXQ GLDJQRVWLF GLIHUHQ LDO UDILQDW SH ED]D SURILOHORU
003, HVWH R SURFHGXU FDUH SRDWH GD QDúWHUH OD vQWUHE UL´ GHúL
WHVWXO GLIHUHQ LD] XWLO úL YDOLG vQWUH SVLKRWLFL QHYURWLFL úL QRUPDOL
:KHHOHU úD ùL DFHDVWD vQ DIDUD IDSWXOXL GHMD PHQ LRQDW F
WD[RQRPLD SVLKLDWULF WUDGL LRQDO FDUH D VWDW OD ED]D VFDOHORU D]L úLD
SLHUGXWGLQUHOHYDQ DSUDFWLF
'LUHF LDFDUHVDGRYHGLWGHRVHELWGHIUXFWXRDV SHQWUXGLDJQR]
HVWH XWLOL]DUHD 003, SULQ DVSHFWHOH FRQILJXUDOH DOH SURILOHORU VDX
SULQPRGHOHOHGHVFRUXULÌQF GLQDXWRULLWHVWXOXLSXEOLF XQ$WODV
SHQWUXXWLOL]DUHDFOLQLF D003,vQFDUHFRGLILF QXPHULFVFDOHOHúL
IXUQL]HD] DVWIHOGHSURILOHFRGLILFDWHvPSUHXQ FXDQDPQH]HOHFD]XULORU
DSHVWHGHVXELHF L7D[RQRPLLODUJLDXIRVWGHULYDWHHPSLULFSULQGL
IHULWHVWXGLLDVXSUDPRGHOHORUGHSURILOHSHQWUXSUREOHPHGHWLSQHYURWLF
SVLKRWLFFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHVDXSVLKRVRPDWLFH
ÌQILQHRXWLOL]DUHLQHGLW GDUVHPQLILFDWLY FDOLWDWLYFDUHGRYH
GHúWHDOWHQXPHURDVHSUREHGLQLWHPLLOXL&HOHVFDOHLQL LDOHvPSUHXQ
FX FHOH VFDOH GH YDOLGDUH LQL LDOH VFDOD . ILLQG FRQVWUXLW XOWHULRU
LQWHJUHD] GRDUGLQFHLGHLWHPLSRVLELOLFDUHGHDOWIHOVHUHFR
PDQG V ILH vQ vQWUHJLPH SDUFXUúL GH VXELHF L $]L GRDU LDU XQLL
GLQWUHLWHPLQXVXQWGHORFFXSULQúLvQYUHRDOW VFDO DGL LRQDO
3ULQWUH QRLOH VFDOH GHULYDWH VXQW LQWURYHUVLD VRFLDO 6L GRPL
QDQ D'RUHVSRQVDELOLWDWHD5HQHYURWLVPXO1HSUHMXGHFDWD3U
VWDWXW VRFLRHFRQRPLF 6W UHFLGLYLVP 5F úL FKLDU VFDOH RUJDQLFH
SUHFXP3)GHVWLQDW GLIHUHQ LHULLFD]XULORUFXOH]LXQLDOHOREXOXLSDULHWDO
YV FHOH FX OH]LXQL DOH OREXOXL IURQWDO VDX /%2 GHVWLQDW P VXU ULL
FDUDFWHULVWLFLORUSVLKLFHODYHWHUDQLFXGXUHULORPEDUHIXQF LRQDOHGLIH
UHQ LDWRUGHFD]XULOHFXSDWRORJLHRUJDQLF
([LVW LQYHQWDUH FDUH vQ PRG H[SUHV vQ FRQVWUXLUHD ORU VDX
UDSRUWDWOD003,$VWIHO&3,FDUHVDFRQVWLWXLWSULQRSR]L LHFDR
ID DQRUPDOXOXLVDXPDLUHFHQWXO190FDUHJUXSHD] vQFLQFLVFDOH
QHJDWLYLVP VRPDWL]DUH WLPLGLWDWH SVLKRSDWRORJLH H[WUDYHUVLH FX
LWHPLGLYHUúLGLQVFDOHVWDQGDUG003,/XWHLMQ .RN
3ULPXO FKHVWLRQDU FOLQLF ED]DW SH VLQGURDPH QRVRORJLFH úL
YDOLG ULFOLQLFH
3ULPHOHVWXGLLvQFHSOD8QLYHUVLWDWHD0LQQHVRWDvQGHF WUH
FHLGRLDXWRUL+DWKDZD\úL0F.LQOH\'DF SULPDSXEOLFDUHVDSURGXV
vQ SULPD UHYL]XLUH VHULRDV D IRVW SXEOLFDW DQL PDL WkU]LX
ÌQWUH WLPS vQ HVWH SXEOLFDW RILFLDO PDQXDOXO úL WHVWXO vQ IRUPD
SULPDU ÌQDQXODSDUHXQPDQXDOVXSOLPHQWDUSUH]HQWkQGVFDOD.
úLIRUPDFROHFWLY ÌQDSDUHXQQRXPDQXDOSUHFXPúLDWODVXOGH
LQWHUSUHWDUH
&RQ LQXWXULOH LWHPLORU DFRSHU R JDP GLYHUV úL ODUJ GH
SUREOHPH GH WLSXUL GLIHULWH GLQWUH FDUH V Q WDWHD VLPSWRPHOH
SVLKRVRPDWLFHWXOEXU ULQHXURORJLFHGLVIXQF LLPRWRULLDWLWXGLQLUHOL
JLRDVH SROLWLFH VRFLDOH PDQLIHVW UL FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH QHYURWLFH VDX
SVLKRWLFHSUHFXPVW ULREVHVLYHúLFRPSXOVLYHLOX]LLKDOXFLQD LLLGHL
GH SHUVHFX LH IRELL DVSHFWH VDGLFH VDX PDVRFKLVWH DVSHFWH SULYLQG
PDVFXOLQLWDWHDIHPLQLWDWHDDVSHFWHSULYLQGIDPLOLDHWF
(úDQWLRQXOGHQRUPDUHXWLOL]DWFRQVW vQSULQFLSDOGLQSHVWH
GH VXELHF L DL VSLWDOXOXL GLQ 0LQQHVRWD VWXGHQ L SUHFXP úL ORWXUL GH
HSLOHSWLFL úL WXEHUFXORúL 7HVWXO HVWH VDWLVI F WRU SHQWUX YkUVWH vQWUH
DQL SHQWUX DPEHOH VH[H &D]XULOH SVLKRSDWRORJLFH DX IRVW vQ
DP QXQ LPH VWXGLDWH úL GLDJQRVWLFDWH GXS QRUPDWLYHOH FOLQLFH DOH
YUHPLL úL DX IRVW FRPSDUDWH FX ORWXUL GH QRUPDOL SULQFLSDOXO FULWHULX
HPSLULF ILLQG JUDGXO GH FRQFRUGDQ vQWUH GLDJQRVWLFXO SUH]XPWLY SH
ED]DVFDOHORUWHVWXOXLúLGLDJQRVWLFXOFOLQLF6WXGLLOHGHYDOLGDUHLQGLF
GH H[HPSOX vQ PDQXDOXO GLQ F vQ FD]XO D GLQWUH EROQDYLL
QRL DGPLúL GLDJQRVWLFXO IRUPXODW SH ED]D WHVWXOXL FRLQFLGH FX FHO
FOLQLFGHILQLWLYDWXOWHULRU
&KLDU vQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH XQ UH]XOWDW ULGLFDW DO XQHL VFDOH YD IL
FRQFRUGDQW FX GLDJQRVWLFXO FOLQLF SURSULX]LV SUH]HQ D XQHL WU V WXUL
DQRUPDOHvQWDEORXOFOLQLFYDILFRQVWDWDW DSURDSHvQWRWGHDXQD$WODV
ÌQWUHGLIHULWHVLQGURDPHFOLQLFHH[LVW LQWHUUHOD LLGLQDPLFHFDUH
SHUPLW DXWRULORU SUH]HQWDUHD XQRU PRGHOH GH FRYDULD LH D VFRUXULORU
XQRUDGLQWUHVFDOH
/LPLWHvQLQWHUSUHWDUHDGDWHORU
'LVFXWDUHDFULWLF DFKHVWLRQDUXOXLVHSRDUW vQVSHFLDOFXPDP
PHQ LRQDWGHMDvQOHJ WXU FXYDOLGLWDWHDGHFRQVWUXFWDVFDOHORU
ÌQ DIDUD DFHVWHL OLPLWH SH FDUH R YRP SUH]HQWD PDL DPSOX vQ
VHFYHQ DXUP WRDUHVHPDLUHSURúHD] FKHVWLRQDUXOXLXQDVSHFWFDUHHVWH
LQWULQVHFDFHVWXLWLSGHSUREHYDORDUHDU VSXQVXULORUGHSLQGHGHPRGXO
FXP VXELHFWXO HVWH FDSDELO V úL FRQúWLHQWL]H]H SURSULLOH VHQWLPHQWH
DWLWXGLQLHWF7RWXúLXQHLDVWIHOGHFULWLFLLVHU VSXQGHF vQYDOLGDUHD
VFDOHORU QX VD LQXW VHDPD GH FRQ LQXWXO U VSXQVXULORU FL GH YDORDUHD
GLVFULPLQDWLY vQWUH SDWRORJLH úL QRUPDOLWDWH $FHVW DVSHFW H[SOLF úL
YDORDUHDGLDJQRVWLF vQDOW úLUHFXQRVFXW D003,XOXLSHQWUXXQHOH
WU V WXULFDSVLKRSDWLDVDXLVWHULDXQGHGHUHJXO U VSXQVXULOHúLFRPSRU
WDPHQWXOVXELHFWXOXLVXQWGLDPHWUDORSXVH'HOD\3LFKRW3HUVH
7HVWXO QX LQH VHDPD QLFL GH JUDGXO GH FRQúWLHQWL]DUH QLFL GH SUHFL]LD
HYDOX ULL U VSXQVXOXL QLFL GH H[DFWLWDWHD DFHVWXLD &D RULFH VFDO YDOL
GDW SULQ PHWRGD FULWHULXOXL H[WHUQ DX IRVW VHOHF LRQD L DFHL LWHPL FDUH
H[SHULPHQWDOVDXHYLGHQ LDWFDVHPQLILFDWLYLGHúLFRQ LQXWXOORUQXSDUH
WRWGHDXQDDDYHDRUHOD LHHYLGHQW FXVLQGURPXODYXWvQYHGHUH
'DWHGHVSUHPRGHOXO003,
2 SUREOHP FDUH D WUHQDW GHD OXQJXO DQLORU GH XWLOL]DUH D
003,XOXL D IRVW UHODWLYD V U FLH D GDWHORU LQIRUPD LHL GH WLS
SVLKRPHWULF UDSRUWDW GH DXWRUL vQ 0DQXDOXO WHVWXOXL ÌQ DIDUD PDQX
DOXOXLGLQDXIRVWSXEOLFDWHIRUPHUHYL]XLWHvQúL6H
GDXIRDUWHSX LQHGDWHvQDIDUDFRHILFLHQ LORUGHILGHOLWDWHGHVSUHFDUH
VHúWLHF YDULD] GHODODSHQWUXRUHWHVWDUHGHODWUHL]LOHGLV
WDQ ODXQDQGLVWDQ SHQWUXFHOHVFDOHFOLQLFHGDUQXVHGDXGDWH
GHVSUH FRQVLVWHQ D LQWHUQ VDX GHVSUH FRHILFLHQ LL GH YDOLGLWDWH 'H
IDSWDFHVWDVSHFWFRQWUDYLQHVWDQGDUGHORULQWHUQD LRQDOHSHQWUXWHVWDUHD
HGXFD LRQDO úLSVLKRORJLF $3$úLH[LVW PXOWHYRFLFULWLFHOD
DGUHVDFKHVWLRQDUXOXL
$VWIHO GH H[HPSOX +-(\VHQFN REVHUYD vQF GLQ F ÄQX
VH úWLH QLPLF GHVSUH LQWHUFRUHOD LLOH VFDOHORU GLDJQRVWLFH´ ÄILGHOLWDWHD
VFDOHORUQXHVWHIRDUWHvQDOW ´ÄJUXSHOHGHGLDJQRVWLFVHED]HD] SHR
FODVLILFDUH SVLKLDWULF UHFXQRVFXW FD LQDGHFYDW úL GLVFXWDELO ´ úL vQ
ILQHÄQXP UXOGHLWHPLHVWHH[FHVLY´'HDVHPHQHDSHVWHDQL(OOLV
VXEOLQLDF ÄGHúLVHSRDWHFRQFKLGHF 003,SRDWHILPDLYDOLGvQGLV
FULPLQDUHDGHJUXSGHFkWXQLQYHQWDURELúQXLWYDOLGLWDWHDVDDEVROXW
U PkQHvQF vQGXELX´úLÄSUHVXSXQkQGF 003,DUHXQDQXPHJUDG
DGHFYDWGHYDOLGLWDWHvQFDSDFLWDWHDGHDGLVWLQJHXQWLSGHSHUVRDQHGH
DOWXO HILFLHQ D XWLOL] ULL OXL OD QLYHOXO GLDJQR]HL LQGLYLGXDOH U PkQH
vQF V ILHGRYHGLW ´
ÌQ DSDUH IRUPD D GRXD D 003, FD XUPDUH D DFWLYLW LL
XQXL &RPLWHW GH UHVWDQGDUGL]DUH D 003, QXPLW vQ úL IRUPDW
GLQ -%XWFKHU *'DKOVWURP -*UDKDP úL $7HOOHJHQ $X IRVW PRGL
ILFD LGLQWUHLWHPLLRULJLQDOLúLVDXDG XJDWvQF 1RXDYHUVLXQH
DUH UHGLVWULEXL L LWHPLL VFDOHL ) FRQ LQH vQF GRX VFDOH GH YDOLGDUH
95,1 ± VFDO FH P VRDU LQFRQVLVWHQ D U VSXQVXULORU VXELHFWXOXL úL
75,1 ± VFDO GHVWLQDW HYDOX ULL WHQGLQ HL VXELHFWXOXL GH D DSURED
RULFHLWHP'HDVHPHQHDDXIRVWLQFOXVHvQF VFDOHFOLQLFHVWDQGDUG
GLQWUH FDUH VFDOD +($ HYDOXkQG SUHRFXS ULOH SHQWUX V Q WDWH VFDOD
73$ YL]kQG WLSXO GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH $ LULWDELO QHU EG WRU KLSHUDFWLY
VFDOD )$0 FDUH LQFOXGH SUREOHPDWLFD WXOEXU ULORU VDX DEX]XULORU
LQWUDIDPLOLDOHVFDOD:5.FDUHHYDOXHD] DWLWXGLQLVDXFRPSRUWDPHQWH
FHSRWLQWHUIHUDFXSHUIRUPDQ DvQPXQF
6XEOLQLHPF GHúLVDSXEOLFDW003,FDUHHVWHvQPRGFXUHQW
XWLOL]DW SURED RULJLQDO QX D IRVW VFRDV GLQ X] HVWH FRQVLGHUDW vQ
FRQWLQXDUH FD RSHUD LRQDO úL H[LVW vQF PDL PXO L XWLOL]DWRUL FDUH R
SUHIHU 0HUHQGD
0DQXDOXOIRUPHLHVWHPDLERJDWvQGDWHSVLKRPHWULFHGDWHGHV
SUH HúDQWLRDQHOH QRUPDWLYH GDWH LWHPPHWULFH UHIHULQ H ELEOLRJUDILFH
FRPSOHWH $VWIHO GH H[HPSOX PDQXDOXO 003, RIHU FRHILFLHQ L
WHVWUHWHVW VHSDUD L SHQWUX ORWXUL GH VXELHF L PDVFXOLQL úL ORWXUL GH
VXELHF LIHPLQLQLRE LQXWHGXS XQLQWHUYDOGHvQPHGLH]LOH$FHúWL
FRHILFLHQ LVXQWVHPQLILFDWLYLSHQWUXWRDWHFHOHVFDOHFHOPDLVF ]XW
ILLQGGHSHQWUXVFDOD0DFHOPDLvQDOWSHQWUXVFDOHOH+\úL3W
2SHUD LRQDOSURILOHOH003,úL003,ED]DWHSHFHOH
úLUHVSHFWLYVFDOHFOLQLFHVXQWLQWHUSUHWDWHFDúLFkQGDUHYDOXDWU
V WXULÌQDFHVWVHQVXQDGLQWUHFULWLFLOHFDUHSHUVLVW úLvQSUH]HQWHVWH
IDSWXOF RDVWIHOGHXWLOL]DUHFHUHXQFDOFXODOILGHOLW LLGXS LQWHUYDOH
PDLPDULGHOXQLVDXDQL
ÌQ SULYLQ D FRQVLVWHQ HL LQWHUQH D IRVW FDOFXODW FRHILFLHQWXO
.XGHU5LFKDUVRQSHQWUXDPEHOHYDULDQWHFXREVHUYD LDF ORWXULOHGH
VXELHF LPDVFXOLQLúLIHPLQLQLVXQWPXOWPDLPDULSHQWUX003,
3HQWUXVFDOHOHLQGLYLGXDOHH[LVW RYDULDELOLWDWHFRQVLGHUDELO DVSHFWXO
FHO PDL LQDFFHSWDELO HVWH OHJDW GH QLYHOXO VF ]XW OD VFDOH SUHFXP 0I
3D0D3GVXEFHHDFHSDUHV LQGLFHPDLGHJUDE HWHURJHQLWDWHD
DFHVWRUVFDOHGHFkWRPRJHQLWDWHDORU
$FHDVW VLWXD LH DGXFH SUREOHPD GDF LWHPLL DFHVWRU VFDOH FKLDU
DSDU LQ UHVSHFWLYHORU FRQ LQXWXUL úL FRQWULEXLH OD VFRUXO VFDOHL GDWH
6LWXD LD HVWH PDL QHIDYRUDELO SHQWUX 003, FHHD FH SHQWUX XQLL
FHUFHW WRUL QDúWH vQWUHEDUHD GDF UHYL]LD 003,XOXL D vPEXQ W LW
VDXvQU XW LWLQYHQWDUXOÄILHFDUHGLQFHOHVFDOHFOLQLFHVHFRPSXQH
GLQWUXQ QXP U GH LWHPL FDUH WLQG V GXF OD XQ FRHILFLHQW vQDOW GRDU
DWkWD WLPS FkW WR L LWHPLL VFDOHL QX FRUHOHD] VDX QHJDWLY XQXO FX
FHO ODOW´&RUWLQD
6DUHDOL]DWúLRDQDOL] IDFWRULDO DVXSUDVFDOHORUVHSDUDWSHQWUX
FHOH GRX ORWXUL PDVFXOLQ VXELHF L úL IHPLQLQ VXELHF L
FDUHvQYL]LXQHDXQRUFHUFHW WRULULGLF GHDVHPHQHDSUREOHPH$VWIHO
GHH[HPSOXVHUHSURúHD] PDQXDOXOXLF QXUHDOL]HD] RvQFHUFDUHGHD
LQWHUSUHWDVWUXFWXUDIDFWRULDO FRQIXQGDW ODQLYHOXOIDFWRULORU,,úL,,,úL
QLFL GH D VH H[SOLFD HPHUJHQ D XQRU VFDOH SUHFXP SHQWUX VXELHF LL
PDVFXOLQL GHSUHVLD ' SDUDQRLD 3D úL LQWURYHUVLD VRFLDO 6L FDUH
FRQWULEXLH VLPXOWDQ SR]LWLY vQ FRPSRQHQ D IDFWRUXOXL ,,, 3HQWUX ORWXO
IHPLQLQLSRKRQGULD+VúLGHSUHVLD'DSDUDWkWSHQWUXIDFWRUXO,,FkW
úL SHQWUX IDFWRUXO ,,, LDU VFKL]RIUHQLD 6F FRQWULEXLH VXEVWDQ LDO OD
QLYHOXOIDFWRULORU,úL,,
$VWIHOVHFRQVLGHU ±QXOLSVLWGHVHQVDYkQGvQYHGHUHFDSDFLWDWHD
UHFXQRVFXW D FKHVWLRQDUXOXL GH D GLVFHUQH vQWUH QHYURWLFL SVLKRWLFL úL
QRUPDOLF GDWHOHDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOHGHPRQVWUHD] PDLGHJUDE F FHOH
VFDOHFOLQLFHP VRDU XQIDFWRUJHQHUDOGRLIDFWRULGHJUXSúLSRDWH
XQIDFWRUVSHFLILFPDVFXOLQLWDWHD±IHPLQLWDWHD
7RDWHDFHVWHDVSHFWHPHQ LRQDWHVSULMLQ vQFRQWLQXDUHUH]HUYDID
GHYDOLGLWDWHDGHFRQVWUXFWDSURILOHORU003,vQDPEHOHYDULDQWH
6FDOHOHVWDQGDUGDOH003,FRQ LQXWXOVFDOHORUGHYDOLGDUH
úLDOVFDOHORUFOLQLFHDVSHFWHOHGHSVLKRSDWRORJLH
6HPQLILFD LDVFDOHORUGHYDOLGDUHDOHSURILOHORU
6XQW FRQVWUXLWH GH DXWRUL VFDOH GH YDOLGDUH Ä«´ Ä/´ Ä)´
Ä.´ 3ULPHOH WUHL VXQW GH RELFHL XWLOL]DWH SHQWUX HYDOXDUHD JOREDO D
vQUHJLVWU ULORUODSURE GDF VFRUXULOHWUHFGHRYDORDUHPD[LPDGPLV
SRWILVXVSHFWDWHvQUHJLVWU ULOH
6FDOD Ä.´ DUH IXQF LD XQHL ÄYDULDELOH QRUPDOL]DWRDUH´ FDOFXODWH
SHQWUXDSHUPLWHRFRUHF LHDVFRUXULORUVFDOHORUFOLQLFH8QHOHGDWHGLQ
FHUFHW ULOHH[SHULPHQWDOHQXVSULMLQ vQV YDORDUHDFRUHF LLORUNSHQWUX
FUHúWHUHDFDSDFLW LLGLVFULPLQDWLYHDVFDOHORU
*RXJK IXUQL]HD] R P VXU VXSOLPHQWDU ED]DW SH
GLIHUHQ D vQWUH VFRUXULOH ) . FD HYDOXDUH D GLVWRUVLXQLL SRVLELOH GH
H[HPSOXDVLPXO ULLYRLWHDXQRUVLPSWRPDWRORJLL
6FDODÄ"´QXP UXOGHLWHPLODFDUHVXELHFWXODU VSXQVÄ1XúWLX´
1RWDEUXW QXP UXOGHvQWUHE ULODFDUHVXELHFWXOU VSXQGHÄQX
úWLX´ &kQG VFRUXO H IRDUWH ULGLFDW UH]XOWDWHOH vQWUHJXOXL WHVW QX VXQW
YDOLGH 0RGHUDW ULGLFDW FRQIRUP QRUP ULL vQ QRWH 7 VHPQLILF R
VXEHYDOXDUHDDQVDPEOXOXLSURILOXOXL
6FDODÄ/´±PLQFLXQD
,WHPLLVFDOHLDXIRVWUH LQX LvQED]DFULWHULXOXLF VXELHFWXO
DUSXWHDV DGPLW XQFRPSRUWDPHQWQHIDYRUDELO'LQGDWHOHHPSLULFH
VH FRQVLGHU F XQHOH WLSXUL GH FRPSRUWDPHQWH QHIDYRUDELOH VXQW
DGPLVHGHSHVWHGLQWUHVXELHF LLQRUPDOL
'LQDFHDVW SHUVSHFWLY XQUH]XOWDWULGLFDWLQGLF RWHQGLQ GH
SUH]HQWDUH FRQúWLHQW VDX TXDVLFRQúWLHQW VXE R OXPLQ IDYRUDELO
IDSW FDUH LQIOXHQ HD] U VSXQVXULOH OD WHVW $FHVW OXFUX FRQGXFH OD R
SUREDELO VXEDSUHFLHUHDQRWHORUSDWRORJLFH
3HQWUX ORWXO GH FRPSDUDWLYH IRUPDW GLQ VXELHF L QRUPDOL VD
REVHUYDWF QRWDHVWHFXDWkWPDLULGLFDW FXFkWVXQWPDLULJL]L
6HPQLILFD LDXQHLQRWHULGLFDWH
±vQLVWHULHULGLFDUHDQRWHLUH]XOW GLQWURDWLWXGLQHLQFRQúWLHQW
±ODXQLLSDUDQRLFLúLvQSVLKRSDWLLULGLFDUHDQRWHLUH]XOW GLQWUR
GRULQ FRQúWLHQW GHDVHSUH]HQWDvQWUROXPLQ IDYRUDELO
6FDODQXLQYDOLGHD] SURSULX]LVSRVLELOLWDWHDGHDLQWHUSUHWDDQ
VDPEOXOSURILOXOXLFLLQGLF RVXEHVWLPDUHDQRWHORUSVLKRSDWRORJLFH
6FDODÄ)´IUHFYHQ
$UH XQ WRWDO GH GH LWHPL 6XELHF LL VXQW GH DFRUG FX PDMRUL
WDWHDDFHVWRUD1RWDEUXW PHGLHVHVLWXHD] vQWUHúL
5 VSXQVXULOHFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHVFDOHLILLQGUHODWLYFRQYHQ LRQDOHVX
ELHF LLQHFRQYHQ LRQDOLDMXQJV SUH]LQWHVFRUXULULGLFDWHvQWUHúL
8QVFRUEUXWVXSHULRUOXLLQGLF ILHF VXELHFWXOQXDvQ HOHV
WHVWXOGHúLSUREDWUHEXLHDGPLQLVWUDW QXPDLXQRUVXELHF LFXXQ4,
QRUPDOILHF VXELHFWXOSUH]LQW RDQRPDOLHPHQWDO VHULRDV LDUvQ
DFHDVW VLWXD LHQRWD)LQGLF JUDGXOGHDQRUPDOLWDWHDOVXELHFWXOXL
6FDODÄ.´FRUHF LH
$IRVWFRQVWUXLW SHQWUXDVHSXWHDFRULMDRHYHQWXDO LQIOXHQ D
DWLWXGLQLLVXELHFWXOXLGDUSRDWHHYLGHQ LDúLXQHOHVLPSWRPHSDWRORJLFH
'HúL HVWH OHJDW GH / úL ) H[SORUHD] XQ DOW WLS GH IDFWRUL GH
GLVWRUVLXQH VXELHF LL FX XQ VFRU . ULGLFDW WLQG V DGRSWH R DWLWXGLQH
GHIHQVLY ID GHRELFHLXULOHORUSVLKRORJLFHGHDFHHDWLQGV SUH]LQWH
XQSURILOÄQRUPDOL]DW´6XELHF LLFXXQVFRUVF ]XWDXWHQGLQ DRSXV
VSUHDXWRFULWLF úLDGPLWHUHDXQRUVLPSWRPHFKLDUGDF HVWHQHVHPQL
ILFDWLY LPSRUWDQ DUHDO DDFHVWRUD
1RWD . DUH úL R VHPQLILFD LH vQ VLQH VFRUXO ULGLFDW HVWH XQ
SURJQRVWLFEXQSHQWUXXQEROQDYPHQWDOLQGLFkQGFDSDFLWDWHDUHODWLY
DVXELHFWXOXLGHDúLUH]ROYDSURSULLOHSUREOHPH
'LIHUHQ D).
(OLPLQ SRVLELOLWDWHDH[LVWHQ HLXQXLÄWUXFDM´GHOLEHUDWDOU VSXQ
VXULORUÌQPRGQRUPDOGLIHUHQ DHVWHFXSULQV vQWUHúLFDOFXODWH
SHQWUXXQORWGHQRUPDOLEROQDYLFXVLPSWRPDWRORJLHSVLKRSD
WRORJLF úLEROQDYLVRPDWLFLPHGLDFDOFXODW ILLQG±
*RXJKFRQVLGHU F RGLIHUHQ FXSULQV vQWUHVLDUWUHEXL
V WUH]HDVF R XúRDU vQGRLDO vQWUH úL HVWH VXVSHFW LDU R
GLIHUHQ VXSHULRDU VDX HJDO FX HVWH vQ PRG VLJXU OHJDW GH R
IDOVLILFDUHvQVHQVSDWRORJLF
&kQG GLIHUHQ D ). LQGLF R IDOVLILFDUH D U VSXQVXULORU SURILOHOH
DXRIRUP DWLSLF ILHVXEIRUP GHÄGLQ LGHILHU VWU X´ILHÄIORWDQWH´
LDUQRWHOH7VXQWVXSHULRDUHOXL
6HPQLILFD LDVFDOHORUFOLQLFH
6FDODLSRKRQGULH+V
2QRW +VULGLFDW LQGLF IDSWXOF VXELHFWXODUHWHQGLQ DGHDVH
SOkQJHH[FHVLYGHEROLIL]LFHI U QLFLRED] RUJDQLF
,SRKRQGULDFLL LGHQWLILFD L GH DFHDVW VFDO VXQW GLIHUL L GH
LSRKRQGULDFLL FX PDQLIHVW UL VRPDWLFH (L DX vQ XUPD ORU XQ OXQJ
LVWRULFGHH[DJHUDUHDFRPHQWDULLORUDVXSUDVLPSWRPHORUIL]LFH1XDX
vQFUHGHUHvQPHGLFFULWLF WUDWDPHQWXOFDUHOLVHDSOLF úLDOHDUJ GHOD
PHGLFODPHGLF
6FDUD GLIHUHQ LD] ELQH SH FHL FX VLQGURP LSRKRQGULDF GH FHL
FDUHSUH]LQW RERDO IL]LF UHDO DF URUQRW QXHVWHSUHDULGLFDW 'H
RELFHL+VDQWUHQHD] úLRRDUHFDUHULGLFDUHFRQFRPLWHQW DGHSUHVLHL
HOHPHQWXOHVHQ LDODOSDWHUQXOXL'+VILLQGvQV +V
6FDODGHSUHVLHL'
$IRVWYDOLGDW SHXQJUXSGHGHSUHVLYLPHODQFROLFL
(IRDUWHVHQVLELO VHULGLF LPHGLDWFHvQVLPSWRPDWRORJLHH[LVW
RQRW GHSUHVLY VDXDQ[LRDV
(VWHHJDOVHQVLELO úLODHIHFWHOHWHUDSLHLúLFRERDU UDSLGDWXQFL
FkQGEROQDYXOVHDPHOLRUHD] FOLQLF6HULGLF vQWUXQPDUHQXP UGH
VW ULQHYURWLFHVDXSVLKRWLFH
'HWHFWHD] VXELHF LLGHSULPD LGDUFDSDELOLV úLDVFXQG VLPS
WRPHOHGHSUHVLYHDYkQGLGHLDFWLYHGHVLQXFLGHUH
6FDODLVWHULHL+\
$IRVWYDOLGDW SHXQJUXSGHLVWHULFLGHFRQYHUVLH&XSULQGHGH
IDSWGRX JUXSHGHFRQ LQXWXUL
DRVFDO GHWHPSHUDPHQWLVWHURLGFDUDFWHUL]kQGVXELHF LFXDWLWX
GLQLVRFLDOHQDLYHFDUHFHUQXPDLSHQWUXHLDIHF LXQHúLDMXWRUXODQWXUD
MXOXLSUH]LQW UHDF LLLQIDQWLOHFkQGSUHWHQ LLOHQXOHVXQWVDWLVI FXWH
ERVFDO GHVLPSWRPHGHFRQYHUVLH
ÌQ SRSXOD LD QRUPDO FHOH GRX WLSXUL GH SUREOHPH QX VXQW
LQWHUFRUHODWH/DQLYHOXOJUXSXOXLFOLQLFGDWHOHLQGLF IDSWXOF PDQLIHV
W ULOHGHFRQYHUVLHVHGH]YROW GHSUHIHULQ SHXQWHPSHUDPHQWLVWHURLG
$XWRULL LQVLVW SH OLSVD GH PDWXULWDWH D LVWHULFXOXL FDUH IDFH FD GHúL
DSDUHQWRWHUDSLHVDXSHUVXDVLXQHWHUDSHXWLF SDUHV FRQGXF VSUHDWH
QX ULWHPSRUDUHV H[LVWHSRVLELOLWDWHDUHDSDUL LHLVLPSWRPHORU
6FDODGHGHYLD LHSVLKRSDW 3G
$IRVWYDOLGDW SHXQJUXSGHVXELHF LVSLWDOL]D LFXGLDJQRVWLFXO
GHÄSHUVRQDOLWDWHSVLKRSDW ´
&DUDFWHULVWLFLSULQFLSDOH
x DEVHQ DU VSXQVXULORUHPR LRQDOHSURIXQGH
x QHSXWLQ DGHDSURILWDGHH[SHULHQ
x DEVHQ DUHVSHFWXOXLSHQWUXQRUPHOHVRFLDOH
$VWIHOGHVXELHF LVXQWGHH[HPSOXGHOLQFYHQ LFDUHFRPLWGHOLFWH
GH WLSXO PLQFLXQLL IXUWXULORU DOFRROLVPXOXL WR[LFRPDQLHL VDX GHOLFWH
VH[XDOH(LVHFDUDFWHUL]HD] vQFRPSRUWDPHQWXOORUDQWLVRFLDOSULQ
x UHFLGLYLVPLQFDSDFLWDWHGHDSURILWDGHH[SHULHQ DDQWHULRDU
x OLSVDXQHLPRWLYD LLDDFWLYLW LLORUGHOLFWXDOH
x QHJOLMDUHDSUHFDX LLORUFDUHV HYLWHGHVFRSHULUHD
6FDODSRDWHILULGLFDW FKLDUGDF VXELHFWXOQDFRPLVQLFLXQGHOLFW
6FDOD3GHVWHPDLPXOWRVFDO GHFDUDFWHUGHFkWVLPSWRPDWRORJLF
úLHVWHJUHXGHIDOVLILFDW
6FDOD QX LQGLF QXPDL F VXELHFWXO D SUH]HQWDW FRQGXLWH SVLKR
SDWHFLúLF HOHVXVFHSWLELOV OHSUH]LQWH
2QRW ULGLFDW SRDWHILvQV LQWHUSUHWDW úLFDRP UWXULHDXQXL
FDUDFWHUQDUFLVLF
'LQ SXQFW GH YHGHUH WHUDSHXWLF R QRW ULGLFDW OD DFHDVW VFDO
DUHXQSURJQRVWLFSURVW
3DWHUQXOQRWHORU3G3DULGLFDWHHVWHQHJDWLYLQGLFkQGXQFDUDFWHU
DJUHVLYRVWLOúLKLSHUVHQVLWLY
$VRFLD LD0D3GFDUDFWHUL]HD] GHRELFHLGHOLQFYHQ D
6FDODPDVFXOLQLWDWH0I
6FDODDIRVWYDOLGDW SHXQJUXSGHKRPRVH[XDOL
$XWRULLJUXSHD] KRPRVH[XDOLLvQFDWHJRULL
x KRPRVH[XDOLLPSXOVLYL
x KRPRVH[XDOLSULQDXWRSXQL LHPDVRFKLVW
x KRPRVH[XDOL SVLKRSD L FX WHQGLQ D VSUH SURVWLWX LH KRPRVH[XDO
FRQVLGHUkQGI U LPSRUWDQ DWDúDPHQWXODIHFWLYDOSDUWHQHUXOXL
x KRPRVH[XDOLÄDGHY UD L´FXSHUVRQDOLWDWHIHPLQLQ FRQVWLWX LRQDO
*UXSXO GH VWDQGDUGL]DUH D IRVW FRQVWLWXLW GLQ KRPRVH[XDOL GLQ
XOWLPDFDWHJRULH
([SHULHQ D DUDW F QRWD GH OD DFHDVW VFDO HVWH vQ FRUHOD LH FX
LQWHOLJHQ D$FHVWOXFUXVHPQLILF F RQRW ULGLFDW QXHVWHREOLJDWRULX
VHFRQGDW GH KRPRVH[XDOLWDWH 3H GH DOW SDUWH XQ VXELHFW SRDWH IL
KRPRVH[XDOI U DDYHDRQRW ULGLFDW 6FDODDUHvQV RUHODWLY YDORDUH
GLDJQRVWLF SHQWUXDVSHFWHOHSDWRORJLFH
6FDODSDUDQRLD3D
6FDOD D IRVW YDOLGDW SH XQ JUXS GH EROQDYL SDUDQRLFL (VWH R
VFDO ÄFDUDFWHULDO ´ GHWHFWkQG WHQGLQ H SDUDQRLGH úL OD VXELHF L FDUH
QDXSUH]HQWDWQLFLRGDW PDQLIHVW ULSDWRORJLFH
'HúLDUHRIRDUWHEXQ YDOLGDUHXQLLSDUDQRLFLRE LQQRWHIRDUWH
MRDVH 2 QRW GH DFHVW QLYHO GDF HVWH DVRFLDW FX R QRW /
ULGLFDW LQGLF DSURDSHVLJXUWHQGLQ HOHSDUDQRLGH
,WHPLLFDUHFRPSXQVFDOD LQGHWUHLWLSXULSVLKRSDWRORJLFH
DFHLFXVHQ]LWLYLWDWHULGLFDW VXELHF LFXÄHSLGHUPDVHQVLELO ´
EFHLFXPRUDOLWDWHH[FHVLY úLFDUHvúLDILUP UD LRQDOLVPXO
FFHLFXLGHLGHSHUVHFX LHQHvQFUHGHUH
2ULFHVXELHFWSUH]HQWkQGXQ3DVXSHULRUQRWHL7HVWHVXVSHFW
SDWRORJLFLDURQRW VXSHULRDU OXL7DGXFHFHUWLWXGLQH
6FDODSVLKDVWHQLH3W
$IRVWYDOLGDW SHXQPLFJUXSGHVXELHF LFHSUH]HQWDXQHYUR]D
REVHVLRQDO
(VWH R VFDO VLPSWRPDWLF LWHPLL UHIHULQGXVH OD VLPSWRPHOH
IRELFHúLREVHVLRQDOH
2 QRW ULGLFDW SRDWH vQ JHQHUDO V ILH FRQVLGHUDW FD XQ LQGLFH
GHDQ[LHWDWH
&HDPDLPDUHSDUWHDQHYUR]HORUJUDYHDXRQRW 3WULGLFDW
'DF DFHDVW VFDO DUH R FRUHOD LH PDUH FX 6F úL FX '
FRUHOHD] PDLVODEFX.
6FDODVFKL]RIUHQLH6F
$ IRVW YDOLGDW SH XQ JUXS HWHURJHQ GH VFKL]RIUHQL FXSULQ]kQG
GHPHQ D SUHFRFH GLDJQRVWLFXO GH VFKL]RIUHQLH SVHXGRQHYURWLF GH
KHEHIUHQRFDWDWRQLHSUHFXPúLVFKL]RIUHQLHSDUDQRLG
$XWRULLDGPLWIDSWXOF SHUPLWHGHSLVWDUHDDGLQVFKL]RIUHQLL
8QHOH VFKL]RIUHQLL SDUDQRLGH DX XQ 6F FRERUkW GXEODW GH VFDOD
3DULGLFDW
/DIHOXQLLVXELHF LSXUVFKL]RL]LSRWDYHDXQ6FQRUPDO
6XQW QXPHURDVH FD]XULOHvQFDUHVFRUXOSRDWHILULGLFDWI U DIL
YRUEDGHRVFKL]RIUHQLHGHH[HPSOXvQDQXPLWHQHYUR]HJUDYHVDXOD
XQLLVXELHF LFXRSXWHUQLF LQWURYHUVLH
$GROHVFHQ LLDXvQPRGRELúQXLWQRWHFXSULQVHvQWUHúL
/DVFKL]RIUHQLH[LVW RUHOD LHFXUELOLQLDU vQWUHJUDYLWDWHDVW ULL
SDWRORJLFH úL QRW vQ VHQVXO F OD VFKL]RIUHQLL YHFKL UH]LVWHQ L OD
LQVXOLQRWHUDSLHQRWDWLQGHV FRERDUH
&XFkWQRWD6FHVWHPDLULGLFDW FXDWkWSURJQRVWLFXOHVWHPDLEXQ
6FHVWHVWUkQVOHJDW GH3W'DF FHOHGRX QRWHVXQWULGLFDWHLDU
3WHVWHPXOWPDLULGLFDW GHFkW6FDWXQFLGLDJQRVWLFXOYDILSUREDELOGH
QHYUR]
$XWRULL WHVWXOXL LQVLVW DVXSUD SUXGHQ HL vQ LQWHUSUHWDUHD QRWHORU
ULGLFDWHODDFHDVW VFDO
6FDODKLSRPDQLH0D
6FDODDIRVWYDOLGDW SHXQJUXSGHKLSRPDQLDFL
,WHPLLSULQFRQ LQXWFRQVWLWXLHVXEVFDOH
DH[SDQVLYLWDWH
ELULWDELOLWDWH
GLQ VXELHF LL FX GLDJQRVWLFXO GH KLSRPDQLH DX R QRW
VXSHULRDU OXLLDUDO LLDXRQRW FXSULQV vQWUHúL
$VRFLD LD0D3GULGLFDW HVWHGHVWXOGHWLSLF ODDGROHVFHQ
$FHVWWLSGHSVLKRSDWDUDYHDXQSURJQRVWLFUHODWLYPDLEXQGHFkW
WLSXULOH3GVDX3G3D
6FDODLQWURYHUVLHLVRFLDOH6
6FDODQXHVWHRVFDO FOLQLF VWULFWRVHQVXHDHVWHFRQVWLWXLW SULQ
GLVFULPLQDUHD vQWUH XQ ORW GH VWXGHQ L FDUH VH DQJDMHD] vQ SX LQH
DFWLYLW L H[WUDFXUULFXODUH úL XQ ORW FX FDUDFWHULVWLFL RSXVH 6FRUXULOH
ULGLFDWHLQGLF WHQGLQ DGHDHYLWDFRQWDFWHOHVRFLDOH
6FDOHVXSOLPHQWDUH
ÌQDIDUDDFHVWRUVFDOHVWDQGDUGQXPHURDVHOHFHUFHW ULDXHYLGHQ
LDWúLDOWHSRVLELOLW LGHLQWHUSUHWDUHúLJUXSDUHDVFDOHORUVDXLWHPLORU
$VWIHOVHSRWFDOFXODGRX P VXULDQLYHOXOXLGHDQ[LHWDWHúLD
JUDGXOXLGHLQWHULRUL]DUH:HOFK
,QGLFHOHGHDQ[LHWDWH$L
$L +V'+\'3W±+V+\
6HXWLOL]HD] QRWHOH71LYHOXODQ[LHW LLHVWHFXDWkWPDLULGLFDW
FXFkWUH]XOWDWXOGHS úHúWHRQRW 7ILQDO GH
5DSRUWXOGHLQWHULRUL]DUH,Q
,Q +V3W+\3G0D
5DSRUWXO VH FDOFXOHD] vQ QRWH 7 SODVkQGXVH WHRUHWLF vQ MXUXO
OXLVXELHF LLFXWHQGLQ DVSUHÄLQWHULRUL]DUHD´GLILFXOW LORUGHFLVSUH
QXPHURDVH VLPSWRPH SVLKRVRPDWLFH VDX VXELHFWLYH DX QRWH 7 VXSH
ULRDUHOXLFHLFDUHvúLH[WHULRUL]HD] FRQIOLFWHOHúLWUHFODDF LXQHDX
QRWH7PDLPLFLGH
&RQGL LDGHQRUPDOLWDWHDVFRUXULORU
'DF VFRUXULOH OD VFDOHOH FOLQLFH VH DIO vQ ]RQD GH QRUPDOLWDWH
UHVSHFWLYvQ]RQDQRWHORU7vQWUHúLSXWHPFDUDFWHUL]DFRPSRUWD
PHQWXOvQXUP WRULLWHUPHQLvQIXQF LHGHVSHFLILFXOILHF UXLFRQ LQXW
DOFHORUGLPHQVLXQLSVLKRSDWRORJLFH
6FDOD +V SOkQJHUL OHJDWH GH VLPSWRPH IL]LFH SHQWUX VFRUXULOH
SHVWHPHGLHGDUvQ]RQDvQWUHúLQRWH7SXWHPYRUELGHXQ
FRPSRUWDPHQW vQ FDUH VH H[SULP RERVHDO FKLDU DVSHFWXO GH
OHWDUJLHVXELHFWXOVHVLPWHIL]LFU X
6FDOD ' VLPSWRPH GHSUHVLYH FRQGXFH VSUH LPDJLQHD XQXL FRP
SRUWDPHQWPDUFDWGHLPSUHVLDGHVHULR]LWDWHGDUVLPXOWDQVHSRDWH
GHVFLIUDVWDUHDGHQHIHULFLUHúLRLQVDWLVIDF LHFXVLQHvQVXúL
6FDOD +\ DSDUH LGHDOLVW QDLY vQ FRQGXLWH úL FX WHQGLQ D GH D QX
IDFHID GHORFVWUHVXOXLPDLDOHVFHOXLVRFLDO
6FDOD 3G LQGLF XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW UHEHO FLQLF FDUH QX LD vQ
FRQVLGHUDUHUHJXOLOHHVWHDJUHVLYvQSODQVRFLDODSDUHHJRLVW
6FDOD 0) SHQWUX VFRUXULOH SHVWH PHGLH DYHP GH D IDFH FX XQ
FRPSRUWDPHQWGRPLQDWGHVHQVLELOLWDWHVFRUXULOHVF ]XWHLQGLF XQ
LQWHUHVH[DJHUDWSHQWUXPRGHOXOSURSULXOXLVH[8QVFRUvQDOWODXQ
SURILO PDVFXOLQ SHUVRDQD DSDUH ELQHFUHVFXW FX R FRQGXLW PD
QLHUDW GDU FX QRWH IHPLQLQH XQ VFRU vQDOW OD XQ SURILO IHPLQLQ
LQGLF XQFRPSRUWDPHQWGXUGRPLQDWGHDPEL LHúLYRLQ
6FDOD3DXQFRPSRUWDPHQWGHWLSSHUIHF LRQLVWúLJUHXGHGHVFLIUDW
VHFUHWRVVFRUXULOHPRGHUDWHvOIDFPDLÄDFFHSWDELO´vQSODQVRFLDO
6FDOD3WGHSHQGHQWGRUHúWHV SODF GDUGRPLQDWúLGHXQVHQWLPHQW
GHLQIHULRULWDWHFDUHvOIDFHLQGHFLVúLQHOLQLúWLW
6FDOD 6F XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW GLILFLO QHJDWLYFLXGDWDSDWLFRSHU
VRDQ F UHLDSDUF vLOLSVHúWHFDSDFLWDWHDGHDLQWHUUHOD LRQD
6FDOD 0D XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW H[SDQVLY RSWLPLVW IRDUWH UDSLG úL
GHFLVúLvQDFHODúLWLPSGHORFOHJDWGHRELFHLXUL
6FDOD 6L QHDILUPDWLY PXOW SUHD FRQúWLHQW GH VLQH WLPLG 3HQWUX
VFRUXULOH VXE PHGLH QH DúWHSW P V J VLP UHYHUVXO UHVSHFWLY XQ
FRPSRUWDPHQWDFWLYúLVRFLDELO
&RGLILFDUHDUH]XOWDWHORU
5HJXOL
6HVHOHFWHD] VFRUXULOHSHVWHQRW 7úLVHSXQvQRUGLQHLHUDUKLF
GHODQRWD7FHDPDLPDUHODFHOHFDUHGHS úHVF7
'DF H[LVW GRX VFDOHFXDFHHDúLQRW 7VHVXEOLQLD] FXROLQLH
OHJ WXUDGLQWUHHOH'DF H[LVW úLVFRUXULSHVWH7FRGXOVFDOHL
YDILVHSDUDWSULQDSRVWURI¶
'DF H[LVW VFDOH FX VFRUXUL SHVWH 7 VH YRU SXQH GRX DSRV
WURIXUL¶¶
'DF H[LVW VFDOHSHVWH7VHSXQDSRVWURIXUL¶¶¶
/DVIkUúLWXOVFDOHORUFXQRWH7SHVWHVHSXQHROLQLH
6FDOHOHvQWUH7úL7QXVXQWLQGLFDWHvQIRUPXO
3HQWUXVFRUXULOHvQQRWH7VXEVHWUHFDVWIHOLPHGLDWGXS OLQLD
GHGHPDUFD LHVHWUHFHVFDODFXQRWD7FHDPDLVF ]XW úLGXS HD
XQDSRVWURI¶DSRLvQRUGLQHFUHVF WRDUHVFDOHOHSkQ vQQRWD7
GHVS U LWHGHFkWHXQSXQFWGDF H[LVW VFDOHFXQRWD7HJDO
VHYRUVXEOLQLD
([HPSOXGHIRUPXO GHFRGLILFDUHDUH]XOWDWXOXLODSURILO¶¶
)RUPXODSRDWHILGHVFLIUDW vQIHOXOXUP WRUH[LVW VFDOHFOLQLFH
FXQRWD7SHVWHVFDODDUHQRWD7VDXPDLPDUHXUPHD] VFDOD
úLVFDOHOHúLFDUHDXQRWH7HJDOH6XEQRWD7H[LVW DOWHWUHLVFDOH
GLQWUHFDUHFHDPDLVF ]XW HVWHVFDODLDUPDLvQDOWHFDHDVFDOHOHúL
FDUHDXQRWH7HJDOH6FDOHOHU PDVHvQDIDUDIRUPXOHLUHVSHFWLYVFDOHOH
úLDXQRWD7vQWUHúLvQ]RQDLPHGLDW DPHGLHL
([HPSOLILFDUHDLQWHUSUHW ULLXQXLSURILO003,
0DWHULDOH QHFHVDUH &KHVWLRQDU 003, IRDLD GH U VSXQV
JULOHOHIRDLDGHSURILOVDX&KHVWLRQDU&3,IRDLDGHU VSXQV&3,
JULO HWDORQ IRDLH GH SURILO 003, PDVFXOLQ úL IHPLQLQ PDQXDO
SHQWUXLQWHUSUHWDUH
6FRS 'HVWLQDW HYDOX ULL WU V WXULORU FDUDFWHULVWLFH DQRUPDOLW LL
SVLKRORJLFHGL]DELOLWDWH+DWKDZD\úL0F.LQOH\
2EV6FDOHOH003,VXQWLQFOXVHvQVWUXFWXUDVFDOHORU&3,VXE
IRUPDXQRUVFDOHDEUHYLDWHYFDS&3,$VWIHODSOLFDUHD,QYHQWDUXOXL
&DOLIRUQLD SHUPLWH SULQ XWLOL]DUHD XQRU JULOH VSHFLILFH 003, úL
HYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLGLQSXQFWGHYHGHUHSVLKRSDWRORJLF3URSRU LDGH
LWHPLFRPXQLvQWUHFHOHGRX WHVWHYDULD] GHODODPHGLDGH
úLVHMXVWLILF SULQIDSWXOF RPDUHSDUWHGLQWUHLWHPLL&3,DXIRVW
SUHOXD LGLUHFWGLQ003,0LQXOHVFX
6WUXFWXU ,QYHQWDUXOFODVLFHVWHDOF WXLWGLQVFDOHGHYDOLGLWDWH
úLVFDOHFOLQLFH
6FDOHOHGHYDOLGLWDWHVXQWDVFDOD1XúWLX"VFDODPLQFLXQ /
VFDODGHQHvQ HOHJHUHDWHVWXOXLVDXGHU VSXQVXULODvQWkPSODUH)VFDOD
ELSRODU GHGLVLPXODUHSR]LWLY VDXQHJDWLY .
'LIHUHQ D).LQGLFHOH*RXJKHOLPLQ SRVLELOLWDWHDXQXLWUXFDM
GHOLEHUDWDOU VSXQVXULORU
6FDOHOH FOLQLFH VXQW VFDOD LSRKRQGULH +V VFDOD GHSUHVLH '
VFDOD LVWHULH +\ VFDOD GHYLD LH SVLKRSDW 3G VFDOD PDVFXOLQLWDWH
IHPLQLWDWH 0I VFDOD SDUDQRLD 3D VFDOD SVLKDVWHQLH 3W VFDOD
VFKL]RIUHQLH6FVFDODKLSRPDQLH0DVFDODLQWURYHUVLHVRFLDO 6L
,QWHUSUHWDUHDSUHVFXUWDW DVFDOHORU
6FDOD LSRKRQGULH +V ± R QRW ULGLFDW SH DFHDVW VFDO LQGLF
IDSWXO F VXELHFWXO DUH WHQGLQ D GH D VH SOkQJH H[FHVLY GH EROL
IL]LFHI U QLFLRED] RUJDQLF
6FDODGHSUHVLH'±GHWHFWHD] VXELHF LLGHSUHVLYLúLDQ[LRúL
6FDOD LVWHULH +\ ± GHWHUPLQ WHPSHUDPHQWXO LVWHURLG úL VLPSWR
PHOHGHFRQYHUVLH
6FDODGHYLD LHSVLKRSDW 3G±HVWHPDLPXOWRVFDO GHFDUDFWHU
GHFkW XQD VLPSWRPDWRORJLF úL LQGLF SUH]HQ D FX VDX I U FRQ
GXLWHPDQLIHVWHDFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUSVLKRSDWHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
6FDODPDVFXOLQLWDWHIHPLQLWDWH0I±P VRDU FDUDFWHULVWLFLOHKR
PRVH[XDOHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLGHGLIHULWHFDWHJRULLSULQDXWRSXQL LH
PDVRFKLVW LPSXOVLYLSVLKRSD LFXSHUVRQDOLWDWHIHPLQLQ
6FDODSDUDQRLD3D±GHWHFWHD] WHQGLQ HOHSDUDQRLGHúLSDUDQRLFH
6FDODSVLKDVWHQLH3W±VFDO VLPSWRPDWLF FDUHP VRDU VLPSWR
PHOHIRELFHúLREVHVLRQDOH
6FDODVFKL]RIUHQLH6F±VXUSULQGHGHPHQ DSUHFRFHVFKL]RIUHQLD
SVHXGRQHYURWLF KHEHIUHQRFDWDWRQLF SDUDQRLG
6FDOD KLSRPDQLH 0D ± P VRDU H[SDQVLYLWDWHD úL LULWDELOLWDWHD
KLSRPDQLDFDO
6FDODLQWURYHUVLHVRFLDO 6L±QXHVWHRVFDO SDWRORJLF SURSULX]LV
(DP VRDU WHQGLQ DGHHYLWDUHDFRQWDFWHORUVRFLDOH
6H FDOFXOHD] FHL GRL LQGLFL QLYHOXO GH DQ[LHWDWH $L úL JUDGXO
GH LQWHULRUL]DUH,QFRQIRUPXQRUIRUPXOHLQGLFDWHGH:HOVKvQFDUH
VXQWXWLOL]DWHQRWHOHVWDQGDUGQRWH7
$SOLFDUHDIRUPHLDEUHYLDWHD003,SUHVXSXQHXWLOL]DUHD&3,
3ULQ XUPDUH VH DSOLF &3, FRQIRUP UHJXOLORU SUHFL]DWH vQ GHVFULHUHD
&3, ÌQWUR DVWIHO GH VLWXD LH FRWDUHD VH IDFH vQ PRG VSHFLILF DVWIHO
SRUQLQG GH OD UH]XOWDWHOH RE LQXWH OD VFDOH VH DSOLF úL R IRUPXO GH
FDOFXO VSHFLILF FDUH LQFOXGH LQGLFL GH SRQGHUDUH 5RJHUV XWLOL]HD]
HFXD LD \ D[ E SHQWUX D GHWHUPLQD YDORDUHD VFRUXULORU SH VFDOHOH
GHULYDWH\UHSUH]LQW VFRUXOEUXWHVWLPDWDOVFDOHLFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHGLQ
003, [ UHSUH]LQW VFRUXO EUXW DO VFDOHL DEUHYLDWH FRQVWUXLWH GLQ
LWHPLLWHVWXOXL&3,VHRE LQHSULQDSOLFDUHDJULOHLúLVXPDUHDFRLQFL
GHQ HORU U VSXQVXULORU D úL E UHSUH]LQW FRQVWDQWH FDOFXODWH SHQWUX
ILHFDUHGLQWUHDFHVWHVFDOH&XDFHVWHVFRUXULEUXWH\WUHEXLHSURFHGDWvQ
FRQWLQXDUHFRQIRUPFRUHF LLORURELúQXLWHFDUHVHDSOLF VFRUXULORUEUXWH
RE LQXWHSULQDSOLFDUHDSURSULX]LV D003,
&RWDUHÌQVLWXD LDFkQGXWLOL] PWHVWXO003,FRWDUHDVHIDFH
GLUHFW SH XQ SURILOPDVFXOLQVDXIHPLQLQvQDFRUGFXVH[XOVXELHFWXOXL
UHVSRQGHQW'HDVHPHQHDQRWHORUEUXWHODXQHOHGLQWUHVFDOHOLVHDGDXJ
R FRW GLQ QRWD EUXW D VFDOHL . VFDOD GH FRUHF LH LDU UH]XOWDWXO VH
UDSRUWHD] ODHWDORQXOvQQRWH7DOSURILOXOXL6HPDUFKHD] SHIRDLDGH
SURILO003,UH]XOWDWHOHDVWIHORE LQXWHúLVHWUDVHD] SURILOXO
,QWHUSUHWDUH6HUHVSHFW UHJXOLOHSUHFL]DWHGHPDQXDO&DUHJXO
JHQHUDO RULFH SHUIRUPDQ FDUH GHS úHúWH QRW 7 LQGLF SUH]HQ D
XQHLWHQGLQ HDQRUPDOH
10IHPHLHDQLDUHXUP WRDUHOHUH]XOWDWHSHVFDOHOHFOLQLFH
003,¶±VFRUXULIRDUWHvQDOWHSHVWHQRWH7OD
+6LSRKRQGULHúL+\LVWHULHVFRUXULvQDOWHSHVWHQRWH7úL3W
SVLKDVWHQLDúL'GHSUHVLD3GGHYLD LHSVLKRSDW 6FVFKL]RIUHQLH
úL UHVSHFWLY 3D SDUDQRLD úL 0D KLSRPDQLD 0I PDVFXOLQLWDWH ±
IHPLQLWDWHDUHVFRUXOQRW 7LDUODVFDOHOHGHYDOLGDUHSUH]LQW /
)úL.
'HVFULHUH DEUHYLDW D FD]XOXL SUREOHPH OHJDWH GH OLSVD GH
FRQWUROFRPSRUWDPHQWDOvQUHOD LDFXILXOSUREOHPHSURIHVLRQDOHQLYHO
GHDQ[LHWDWHULGLFDWGHFk LYDDQLDGHPLVLRQDWSUREOHPHHPR LRQDOH
VR XO HVWH XQ E XWRU vPS WLPLW HD VH PDQLIHVW FDXVWLF GHIHQVLY
HVWHLQWHUQDW FXGLDJQRVWLFXOGHDOFRROLVP
3DFLHQWD DWULEXLH FRQVXPXO H[FHVLY GH DOFRRO QHYRLL GH DVF SD
GLQGLVSXWHOHFRQMXJDOH)UHFYHQWHOHSUREOHPHPDULWDOHGDUGHILHFDUH
GDW FRQWLQX V FRQVXPH DOFRRO vQ FLXGD FRQVHFLQ HORU DGYHUVH ÌQ
SUH]HQWFDVLPSWRPHWUHPXUXOPkLQLLLQVRPQLDQHUYR]LWDWHDJUHD D
QHYRLDGHDYRPDDQ[LHWDWHD
,QWHUSUHWDUHDFD]XOXLFI003,
6FRUXULOH GH YDOLGDUH D VFDOHORU 003, VXQW vQ JDPD QRUPDO
FHHD FH LQGLF YDOLGLWDWHD SURILOXOXL úL SRVLELOLWDWHD GH D LQWHUSUHWD
VFRUXULOH OD VFDOHOH FOLQLFH FD DWDUH vQ P VXUD vQ FDUH QLFL XQD GLQWUH
VFDOHOHGHYDOLGDUHQXLQGLF RWHQGLQ GHIDOVLILFDUHDU VSXQVXULORU
5H]XOWDWHOHLQGLF RWHQGLQ HYLGHQW VSUHLSRKRQGULH7U V WXUD
HVHQ LDO D LSRKRQGULHL HVWH SUHRFXSDUHD OHJDW GH WHDPD GH D DYHD R
ERDO VHULRDV GLQFDX]DXQHLJUHúLWHLQWHUSUHW ULDXQXLDVDXPDLPXOWRU
VLPSWRPH ([DPLQDUHD PHGLFDO JHQHUDO QX D LGHQWLILFDW XQ VLQGURP
FRHUHQW'HVLJXULGHHDXQHLEROLúLFHQWUDUHDSHRULFHVLPSWRPIL]LFDX
SHUVLVWDW úL SHUVLVW vQ PLQWHD EROQDYHL 3DFLHQWD DWULEXLH VLPSWRPHOH
GDWRUDWHDEX]XOXLGHDOFRROXQHLEROLVXVSHFWHúLHVWHIRDUWHSUHRFXSDW
GHDFHDVW SRVLELOLWDWH$UHRDWLWXGLQHFULWLF ID GHPHGLFúLWUDWDPHQW
/DSDFLHQW VLPSWRPHOHLSRKRQGULDFHVXQWDVRFLDWHFXFHOHGHWLS
LVWHULFWU V WXUDHVHQ LDO HVWHRHPR LRQDOLWDWHH[FHVLY úLQHFRQWURODW
úLFRPSRUWDPHQWXOGHDWUDJHUH±FDSWDUHDDWHQ LHLVHVLPWHQHFRQIRU
WDELO úL QHDSUHFLDW FkQG QX HVWH vQ FHQWUXO DWHQ LHL WLQGH V DWUDJ
DWHQ LDFKLDUvQPRGDOLW LGUDPDWLFH$OFRROXOSRDWHILLQWHUSUHWDWFDR
GHIHQV FDRWHQGLQ GHDVHUHWUDJHúLDúLFRQVWUXLSURSULDOXPHGDU
GHDVHPHQHDXWLOL]DUHDDOFRROXOXLSRDWHvQVHPQDXQPLMORFGHDWUDJHUHD
DWHQ LHL$FHVWHLWU V WXULLVHDGDXJ úLXQJUDGvQDOWGHVXJHVWLELOLWDWH
FDUHHVWHvQVLQHRFDUDFWHULVWLF LPSRUWDQW DXQXLDOFRROLFRSLQLLOHHL
VHQWLPHQWHOHHLVXQWLQIOXHQ DWHXúRUGHDO LLVDXGHDWPRVIHUDGLQMXU
3HUVRDQD DUH VFRUXUL vQDOWH úL OD VFDOHOH SVLKDVWHQLH GHSUHVLH
GHYLD LHSVLKRSDW SDUDQRLDúLVFKL]RIUHQLH6FRUXOODVFDOD3WLQGLF XQ
QLYHOvQDOWGHDQ[LHWDWHúLRSUHRFXSDUHGHÄDIDFHWRWFHSRDWH´WLQGHV
LQ WRWXOvQRUGLQHV DLE XQFRQWUROPLQWDOúLLQWHUSHUVRQDOFXSUH XO
OLSVHLGHIOH[LELOLWDWHGHVFKLGHUHúLHILFLHQ 3DFLHQWXOHVWHH[FHVLYGH
DWHQWúLJDWDV UHSHWHDFRUG RDWHQ LHPDUHGHWDOLLORUúLPHUHXYHULILF
GDF QXH[LVW SRVLELOHJUHúHOLLQH[WUHPLVSXWHPYRUELGHIRELDGHDQX
JUHúL 'HVLJXU OD ORFXO GH PXQF R DVWIHO GH SHUVRDQ HVWH DSUHFLDW
SHQWUXF DSDUHH[FHVLYGHGHYRWDW PXQFLLúLSURGXFWLYLW LLLDUSHQWUX
SDFLHQW PXQFDSURIHVLRQDO DIRVWXQPLMORFGHDúLGRYHGLFDOLW LOH
DELOLWDWHD GH D GHYHQL ÄFLQHYD´ GH DúL VDWLVIDFH QHYRLOH KLVWULRQLFH
&kQGQXDPDLPHUVODVHUYLFLXVDVLP LWGH]DP JLW GHVLQHDFUHVFXW
OLSVDGHVWLP SHUVRQDO úLVROX LDWHPSRUDU DIRVWDOFRROXOPRGXOGHD
VF SDúLGHDHYLWDFRQIUXQWDUHDFXGLIHULWHOHSUREOHPHH[LVWHQ LDOH
ÌQFRQVHFLQ úLGLVSR]L LDHLDIHFWLY DIRVWDIHFWDW úLDXDS UXW
VLPSWRPHGHWLSGHSUHVLYSHUVRQDOLWDWHVHQVLELO vQJHQHUDOSDFLHQWDD
GHYHQLW WULVW PLQWHD HL VD SRSXODW FX LGHL QHJDWLYH FKLDU OHJDWH GH
VLQXFLGHUHSUH]HQWXOWUHFXWXOúLYLLWRUXOVXQWSULYLWHvQWUXQPRGQHJD
WLYÌQFUHGHUHDvQSURSULLOHSRVLELOLW LúLDELOLW LDVF ]XWVHPQLILFDWLY
3HQWUX D VH VLP L PDL ELQH D IRORVLW DOFRROXO FDUH SHQWUX R SHULRDG
VFXUW GHWLPSLDDGXVOLQLúWHDQHFHVDU DWkWF DFHDVW SDFHHUDIDOV
úLDSURGXVGLIHULWHWXOEXU UL
1LYHOXO 3G LQGLF DEVHQ D XQHL LPSOLF UL HPR LRQDOH vQ UHOD LR
QDUHDXPDQ úLvQRULFHDFWLYLWDWHLQFDSDFLWDWHDGHDvQY DGLQSURSULD
H[SHULHQ SURSULLOHJUHúHOLúLFKLDUGH]DFRUGXOFXQRUPHOHVRFLDOH$UH
XQFRQWUROQHJDWLYvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHUHJXOLOHVRFLDOHúLYDORULOHDFFHS
WDWHGHPDUHDPDMRULWDWHDVHPHQLORUEkQGYLROHD] QRUPHOHVRFLDOHúL
J VHúWHRSRVLELOLWDWHGHDHYLWDWHPSRUDUFRQVWUkQJHULOHVRFLDOH
3XWHPREVHUYDúLvPSUHMXUDUHDSHFDUHDXWRULLPDQXDOXOXLWHVWXOXL
RSUHY GIDSWXOF vQVLWXD LDvQFDUHVFRUXOOD3GHVWHODIHOGHvQDOWFD
FHO GH OD 6F HVWH YRUED GH R SHUVRDQ QHYURWLF 3H GH DOW SDUWHSR
WHQ LDOXO OHJDW GH KDOXFLQD LL úL LOX]LL SRDWH IL GLUHFW HYDOXDW FD HIHFW
SVLKRORJLFDODEX]XOXLGHDOFRRO$FHVWHPDQLIHVW ULVXQWOHJDWHFXPYD
GHLGHLOHGHWLSSDUDQRLG6FDODLGHQWLILF WUHLWLSXULGHSHUVRDQHFHLFDUH
SUH]LQW XQ QLYHO vQDOW GH VHQ]LWLYLWDWH SHUVRDQH FX R PRUDOLWDWH
H[FHVLY FDUHvúLVXV LQUD LRQDOLVPXOLQGLYL]LFHVXQWVXVSLFLRúLúLQX
FUHGSHQLPHQL3DFLHQWDHVWHXQWLSVHQ]LWLYGDUHVWHSRVLELOV H[LVWHúL
RGR] GHLQWHUSUHWDWLYLWDWHGDWRUDW QHVLJXUDQ HL
6FRUXO0DHVWHH[SOLFDELOFDHIHFWDODOFRROXOXLvQSULPXOVWDGLX
FRQVXPXO DOFRROXOXL FRQGXFH VSUH R GLVSR]L LH ÄEXQ ´ WHQGLQ D VSUH
H[KLEDUH D UHVXUVHORU úL LPSXOVXULORU H[KLEDWH FDUH HVWH DVRFLDW FX
LULWDUHDúLQHUYR]LWDWHDXQHRULFXXQFRPSRUWDPHQWYLROHQW
6FRUXO GH 0) LQGLF R LGHQWLILFDUH EXQ FX UROXO VRFLDO DVRFLDW
VWDWXWXOXLIHPLQLQ
$QDOL]DDIRVWUHSURGXV GXS $Q$WODVIRUWKH&OLQLFDO8VHRI
003,8QLY0LQQHVRWD3UHVV0LQHDSROLVSJ±
(;7,1'(5,
3UH]HQWDUHDQRLORUVFDOHVWDQGDUGúLH[SHULPHQWDOHGLQ003,
003,$
6FDOHFOLQLFHGHED]
/ PLQFLXQ LWHPL ) 5DULWDWH LWHPL . &RUHF LH
LWHPL+VLSRKRQGULHLWHPL''HSUHVLHLWHPL+\
LVWHULH GH FRQYHUVLH LWHPL 3G GHYLD LH SVLKRSDW LWHPL
0IP0DVFXOLQLWDWH)HPLQLWDWHE UED LLWHPL0II)HPHL
LWHPL 3D SDUDQRLD LWHPL 3W 3VLKDVWHQLH LWHPL
6F VFKL]RIUHQLH LWHPL 0D KLSRPDQLH LWHPL 6L
,QWURYHUVLHVRFLDO LWHPL
6XEVFDOHOH+DUULV/LQJRHV
' 'HSUHVLH VXELHFWLY LWHPL ' /HQWRDUH SVLKRPRWRULH
LWHPL''LVIXQF LRQDUHIL]LF LWHPL'2EWX]LWDWHPHQWDO
LWHPL'5XPLQDUHLWHPL+\1HJDUHDDQ[LHW LLVRFLDOH
LWHPL+\1HYRLHGHDIHF LXQHLWHPL+\6O ELFLXQHLWHPL
+\ 3OkQJHUL VRPDWLFH LWHPL +\ ,QKLEDUHD DJUHVLYLW LL
LWHPL 3G 1HvQ HOHJHUL vQ IDPLOLH LWHPL 3G 3UREOHPH FX DXWR
ULWDWHDLWHPL3G,PSHUWXUEDELOLWDWHVRFLDO LWHPL3G$OLHQDUH
VRFLDO LWHPL3G$OLHQDUHGHVLQHLWHPL3D,GHLGHSHUVH
FX LH LWHPL 3D 6HQVLELOLWDWH LWHPL 3D 1DLYLWDWH LWHPL
6F $OLHQDUH VRFLDO LWHPL 6F $OLHQDUH HPR LRQDO LWHPL
6F/LSV GHVW SkQLUHD(XOXLSHSODQFRJQLWLYLWHPL6F/LSV
GHVW SkQLUHD(XOXLSHSODQFRQDWLYLWHPL6F/LSV GHVW SkQLUH
D(XOXLSULQGHIHFWXOLQKLEL LHLLWHPL6F7U LULVHQ]RULDOHEL]DUH
LWHPL0D$PRUDOLWDWHLWHPL0D$FFHODUDUHSVLKRPRWRULH
LWHPL0D,PSHUWXUEDELOLWDWHLWHPL0D,QIOD LHD(XOXLLWHPL
6XEVFDOHOH62DOHOXL:LHQHUúL+DUPRQ
'2'HSUHVLH 2 LWHPL '6'HSUHVLH 6 LWHPL +\2
,VWHULH2LWHPL+\6,VWHULH6LWHPL3G2'HYLD LHSVLKRSDW
2 LWHPL 3'6'HYLD LH SVLKRSDW 6 LWHPL 3D23DUDQRLD 2
LWHPL 3D63DUDQRLD 6 LWHPL 0D2+LSRPDQLH2 LWHPL
0D6+LSRPDQLH6LWHPL
6XEVFDOHOH6L
6L 7LPLGLWDWH MHQ LWHPL 6L (YLWDUH VRFLDO LWHPL
6L$OLHQDUHGHVLQHúLDO LLLWHPL
6FDOHVXSOLPHQWDUH
$ $Q[LHWDWH LWHPL 5 5HIXODUH LWHPL (V )RU D
(XOXL LWHPL 0$&5 $OFRROLVP 0DF$QGUHZ UHYL]XLW
LWHPL)EVFDOD)SDUWHDDGRXDLWHPL95,1,QFRHUHQ YDULD
ELO DU VSXQVXULORUSHUHFKLGHLWHPL75,1,QFRHUHQ SXWHUQLF
D U VSXQVXULORU SHUHFKL 2+ 2VWLOLWDWH KLSHUFRQWURODW
LWHPL 'R 'RPLQDQ LWHPL 5H 5HVSRQVDELOLWDWH VRFLDO
LWHPL 0W $GDSWDUH SURDVW HOHYL LWHPL *0 5RO VH[XDO JHQ
PDVFXOLQ LWHPL *) 5RO VH[XDO JHQ IHPLQLQ LWHPL 3.
3HUWXUE ULGHVWUHVSRVWWUDXPDWLF.HDQHLWHPL363HUWXUE ULGH
VWUHV SRVWWUDXPDWLF 6FKOHQJHU LWHPL 0'6 6FDO GH VXIHULQ
FRQMXJDO LWHPL $36 6FDO GH WHQGLQ VSUH DGLF LH LWHPL
$$66FDO GHDGPLWHUHDDGLF LHLLWHPL
6FDOHGHFRQ LQXW
$1; $Q[LHWDWH LWHPL )56 7HPHUL LWHPL 2%6 2E
VHVLRQDOLWDWH LWHPL '(3 'HSUHVLH LWHPL +($ 3UHRFXS UL
OHJDWH GH V Q WDWH LWHPL %,= %L]DUHULD JkQGLULL LWHPL $1*
0kQLHLWHPL&<1&LQLVPLWHPL$63&RQGXLWHDQWLVRFLDOH
LWHPL 73$ 7LS $ LWHPL /6( 6WLP GH VLQH VF ]XW
LWHPL62''LVFRQIRUWVRFLDOLWHPL)$03UREOHPHIDPLOLDOH
LWHPL :5. ,QWHUIHUHQ FX PXQFD LWHPL 757 $WLWXGLQH
QHJDWLY ID GHXQWUDWDPHQWLWHPL
,WHPLFKHLH.RVV%XWFKHUSULYHVFVLPSWRPHFHQWUDOH
6WDUH GH DQ[LHWDWH DFXW $PHQLQ DUHD DJUHVLXQLL &RQIX]LH
PHQWDO ,GHD LH VXLFLGDU GH WLS GHSUHVLY 6WUHV VLWXD LRQDO GDWRUDW
DOFRROLVPXOXL,GHLGHSHUVHFX LH
,WHPLFKHLH/DFKDU:UREHO
$Q[LHWDWHúLWHQVLXQH3HUWXUEDUHDVRPQXOXL*kQGXULúLWU LULGH
YLDQWH$WLWXGLQHDQWLVRFLDO 0kQLHSUREOHPDWLF 6LPSWRPHVRPDWLFH
'HSUHVLH úL QHOLQLúWH &UHGLQ H GHYLDQWH $EX] GH VXEVWDQ H &RQIOLFWH
IDPLOLDOH3UREOHPHúLGHYLD LLVH[XDOH
003,$
003, QX D IRVW FRQVWUXLW SHQWUX SHUVRDQH VXE DQL
003, $ HVWH R YHUVLXQH FRQVWUXLW SHQWUX DGROHVFHQ L XWLOL]DELO
SHQWUXLQWHUYDOXOGHYkUVW DQL
'HúL 003, XO LQL LDO D IRVW GHVWLQDW XWLOL] ULL SHQWUX DGXO L
WHVWXO D IRVW XWLOL]DW úL SHQWUX DGROHVFHQ L +DWKDZD\ úL 0RQDFKHVL
GHIDSWSDUDGR[DOVDGRYHGLWDILFHOPDL
ODUJXWLOL]DWLQVWUXPHQWSHQWUXHYDOXDUHDDGROHVFHQ LORU
7RWXúL R DQDOL] D LWHPLORU DGXFH GDWH OHJDWH GH IDSWXO F PXO L
LWHPL VXQW LQDGHFYD L SHQWUX H[SHULHQ D GH YLD D XQXL DGROHVFHQW úL
FRPSOHPHQWDUIRDUWHSX LQLLWHPLSULYHVFH[SHULHQ HWLSLFHVDXVSHFLILFH
DGROHVFHQ HL OHJDWH GH JUXSXO GH HJDOL GH úFRDO HWF 'H DVHPHQHD
XWLOL]DUHDQRUPHORUSHQWUXDGXO LvQFD]XODGROHVFHQ LORUQXHVWHDGHFYDW
SHQWUXF WLQGHV VXSUDSDWRORJL]H]HVXELHF LLDGROHVFHQ LGHIDSWVD
GRYHGLWúLFRQWUDULXOXWLOL]DUHDXQRUQRUPHSHQWUXDGROHVFHQ LFRQVWUXLWH
SH003,FODVLFWLQGLQYHUVV VXESDWRORJL]H]HDGROHVFHQ LLFXSUR
EOHPH $UFKHU $UFKHU úL DO FI -*UDKDP 003,
$VVHVVLQJ3HUVRQDOLW\DQG3V\FKRSDWKRORJ\
,QL LDO VD GH]YROWDW R IRUP H[SHULPHQWDO IRUPD 7; FDUH
LQFOXGHD XQ WRWDO GH LWHPL GLQ FDUH FHL LWHPL GLQ 003,
LQL LDOXQLLUHVFULúLQRLLWHPLDG XJD LFHSULYHVFFRPSOLDQ DDWLWXGLQLOH
ID GHVFKLPEDUHDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLLWHPLOHJD LGHSUREOHPHSULYLQG
DOFRROXOVDXGURJXULOHGHDVHPHQHDDXIRVWDG XJD LLWHPLSULYLQGDULL
VSHFLILFHDGROHVFHQ HLFRPSRUWDPHQWúFRODUDWLWXGLQLID GHSURIHVRUL
LQIOXHQ HvQJUXSXOGHHJDOLSUREOHPHGHGLHW UHOD LLFXS ULQ LLúLDO L
DGXO L([SHULPHQWDUHDDFHVWRULWHPLDFRQGXVODVHOHFWDUHDvQILQDO
DGLQWUHHLXQLLGLQWUHDFHúWLDDXIRVWUHVFULúLGHH[HPSOXSULQWUH
FHUHD GH OD WLPSXO WUHFXW OD WLPSXO SUH]HQW 3H DFHDVW IRUP DX IRVW
FDOFXODWH QRUPHOH SH XQ ORW GH DGROHVFHQ L úL DGROHVFHQWH FX
YkUVWHvQWUHúLDQL
6FDOHOH/)úL.DXIRVWS VWUDWHGLQ003,RULJLQDOFXXQHOH
VFKLPE UL VHPQLILFDWLYH SHQWUX LWHPLL VFDOHL ) 'H DVHPHQHD FRUHV
SXQ] WRU IRUPHL 003, ,, DX IRVW LQWURGXVH VFDOHOH 95,1 FDUH V
HYDOXH]H LQFRQVLVWHQ D U VSXQVXULORU úL 75,1 FDUH HYDOXHD] LQIOX
HQ HOHQHJDWLYHDVXSUDU VSXQVXULORUDGHY UDWúLIDOV
&HOH VFDOH FOLQLFH VWDQGDUG DOH 003, VXQW PHQ LQXWH vQ
003, $ GHúL XQHOH DX PDL SX LQL LWHPL VDX LQFOXG LWHPL SX LQ
VFKLPED L 1LFL XQD GLQWUH VFDOHOH 003, $ QX HVWH FRUHFWDW SULQ
VFDOH.
$XIRVWFRQVWUXLWHúLFkWHYDVFDOHVXSOLPHQWDUHSUHFXPVFDODGH
DQ[LHWDWHVFDODGHUHSUHVLHVFDODGHDOFRROLVP0DF$QGUHZVFDODGH
SURSHQVLXQHSHQWUXDOFRROGURJVFDODGHUHFXQRDúWHUHDSUREOHPHORU
OHJDWHGHDOFRROGURJVFDODGHLPDWXULWDWH
'H DVHPHQHD DX IRVW FRQVWUXLWH VFDOH GH FRQ LQXW OD QXP U
SHQWUX D HYDOXD GLPHQVLXQLOH IXQGDPHQWDOH DQ[LHWDWH REVHVLRQDOLWDWH
GHSUHVLH JULML OHJDWH GH V Q WDWH EL]DUHULL PHQWDOH PkQLH FLQLVP
DOLHQDUHSUREOHPHGHFRQWURODXWRVWLP VF ]XW QLYHOGHDVSLUD LLVF
]XWHGLVFRQIRUWVRFLDOSUREOHPHGHIDPLOLHSUREOHPHOHJDWHGHúFRDO
LQGLFDWRUL GH WUDWDPHQW QHJDWLY 6H FRQVLGHU F DFHVWH VFDOH DU WUHEXL
XWLOL]DWH vQ FRQMXQF LH FX VFDOHOH FOLQLFH VFDOHOH GH FRQ LQXW FODULILF
DGHVHDPRWLYHOHULGLF ULLVFRUXULORUODDFHVWHVFDOHúLDMXW FOLQLFLDQXOV
GHWHUPLQHFDUHGLQWUHQXPHURúLLGHVFULSWRULWUDGL LRQDODVRFLD LFXDFHVWH
VFDOHVXQWLPSOLFD LvQFD]XOUHVSHFWLY'HRDUHFHLWHPLLVFDOHORUGHFRQ
LQXWVXQWHYLGHQ LúLDXYDOLGLWDWHGHDSDUHQ HLVXQWIRDUWHVHQVLELOLOD
DWLWXGLQHDGHPDQLSXODUHDDGDSW ULLVDXQHDGDSW ULL
6XQW GH DVHPHQHD GLVSRQLELOH VXEVFDOHOH +DUULV/LQJRHV úL
VXEVFDOHOHSHQWUX6LGHúLHOHQXSRWILIRORVLWHFDVFDOHLQGHSHQGHQWH
SHQWUXLQWHUSUHW ULOHFOLQLFHLDUVFRUXULOHVF ]XWHODDFHVWHVXEVFDOHQX
WUHEXLHLQWHUSUHWDWH
(VWHLQWHUHVDQWV VXEOLQLHPúLFkWHYDDVSHFWHSULYLQGVWUDWHJLDGH
LQWHUSUHWDUHSHQWUXSURILOXO003,$DVHP Q WRDUHFX003,
$VWIHO%XWFKHUúL:LOOLDPVDXVXJHUDWXUP WRDUHOHDVSHFWHFDUH
WUHEXLHDYXWHvQYHGHUH
GDF H[LVW IDFWRULH[WUDWHVWFDUHSRWH[SOLFDUH]XOWDWHOH003,$
FDUHVXQWDWLWXGLQLOHGHU VSXQVDOHLQGLYLGXOXL"
FDUHVXQWVLPSWRPHOHúLFRPSRUWDPHQWHOHUDSRUWDWHGHLQGLYLG"
FDUHHVWHSUREDELOLWDWHDXQRUFRPSRUWDPHQWHGHWLSLHúLULLPSXOVLYH
úLFDUHHVWHSUREDELOLWDWHDFDvQVLWXD LLVSHFLILFHV DSDU DVWIHOGH
UHDF LLSUHFXPúLFkWGHVHYHUHSRWILDFHVWHD"
GDF SUREOHPHOHGLQúFRDO MRDF XQUROVHPQLILFDWLYvQLPDJLQHD
FOLQLF úLFDUHVXQWDFHVWHD"
DGPLWH DGROHVFHQWXO F DUH SUREOHPH FX DOFRROXO VDX DOWH GURJXUL
VDXH[LVW SRVLELOLWDWHDGHDGH]YROWDDVWIHOGHSUREOHPH"
FXPDUDW UHOD LLOHVDOHLQWHUSHUVRQDOHH[LVW LQIOXHQ HQHJDWLYHGH
ODJUXSXOGHHJDOLVXQWVHPQLILFDWLYHSUREOHPHOHGHIDPLOLHFXP
U VSXQGH DXWRULW LL VXQW DOLHQDUHD VDX FLQLVPXO VDX L]RODUHD XQ
IDFWRUL]RODW"
VXJHUHD] UH]XOWDWHOHQHFHVLWDWHDGHDHYDOXDXQSRVLELODEX]IL]LF
VDXVH[XDO"
FDUH VXQW SXQFWHOH SXWHUQLFH DOH DGROHVFHQWXOXL" &DUH VXQW LPSOL
FD LLOHSURILOXOXLODWHVWFDUHVXQWLPSOLFD LLOHVDXUHFRPDQG ULOHFH
SRWILVXJHUDWHSHED]D003,$"
&RQFHSWHFDUDFWHULVWLFH
DQRUPDOFDUHVHvQGHS UWHD] GHQRUP VDXQRUPDOSRDWHVHPQLILFD
GHYLD LLSXUFDQWLWDWLYHvQDQDOL]HOHVWDWLVWLFHGDUúLPRGHOHGHFRPSRU
WDPHQWGHYLDQWHDOHLQGLYL]LORU'LILFXOWDWHDGHOLPLW ULLQRUPDOXOXLGH
DQRUPDOSRUQHúWHGLQWHQGLQ DGHDDYHDJUDQL HGHQRUPDOLWDWHGHILQLWH
GHXQDVDXDOWDGLQWUHWHRULLOHDVXSUDSHUVRQDOLW LLGHH[HPSOXvQYL
]LXQHD SVLKDQDOLWLF FODVLF KRPRVH[XDOLWDWHD HVWH SULYLW FD DQRUPD
OLWDWHFRQWUDUWHRULLORUSULYLQGvQY DUHDVRFLDO ([LVW RWHQGLQ GHD
XWLOL]D WHUPHQL SUHFXP QHDGDSWDUH QHDFRPRGDUH GHYLDQW vQ OHJ WXU
FXHYDOXDUHDXQXLLQGLYLGFRQVLGHUDWUHVSHFWLYvOHYDOX PvQIXQF LHGH
P VXUDvQFDUHSXWHPYRUELGHXQFRPSRUWDPHQWDGDSWDWLYúLQXSHQWUX
DOHWLFKHWDSXUúLVLPSOX'3
FDWHJRULL QRVRORJLFH VH UHIHU OD FDWHJRULL GH EROL U G FLQD FXYkQ
WXOXLSURYLQHGLQJUHDF FXVHQVXOGHERDO QRVRORJLDHVWHRGHVFULHUH
VLVWHPDWLF úLRFODVLILFDUHDEROLORU
GHYLDQ RULFH PRGHO GH FRPSRUWDPHQW FDUH HVWH HYLGHQW GLIHULW GH
VWDQGDUGHOH DFFHSWDWH vQ FDGUXO VRFLHW LL GHVLJXU GHILQL LD FRQ LQH
SXWHUQLFH DFFHQWH GLQ GRPHQLXO HWLFPRUDO úL IRORVLUHD WHUPHQXOXL VH
IDFHVSHFLILFkQGIRUPDUHVSHFWLY GHGHYLDQ '3
GL]DELOLWDWH vQ JHQHUDO RULFH LQFDSDFLWDWH GH D UHDOL]D R DQXPLW
IXQF LHSRDWHILXWLOL]DWSHQWUXGLVIXQF LLFRQJHQLWDOHVDXSHQWUXIXQF LL
SLHUGXWH GLQ FDX]D XQRU WUDXPH EROL HWF 'L]DELOLWDW VHPQLILF IDSWXO
F SHUVRDQDVXIHU GHRDQXPHGL]DELOLWDWH'LQFDX]DPXOWRUFRQRWD LL
QHJDWLYHFRQVWLWXLWHvQMXUXOFXYkQWXOXLKDQGLFDSKDQGLFDSDWVHSUH
IHU GHVHPQDUHDSULQGL]DELOLWDW
GLDJQRVWLF GLIHUHQ LDO GLDJQRVWLFXO FDUH DUH FD VFRS GLIHUHQ LHUHD
vQWUHGRX VDXPDLPXOWHEROLVDXWXOEXU ULVLPLODUHSHFDUHOHSUH]LQW
XQLQGLYLG([WLQVDDMXQVV ILHIRORVLWSHQWUXDGLVWLQJHvQWUHFRQGL LL
GHPXOWHIHOXULvQSVLKRORJLDVRFLDO úLvQVWXGLXOSHUVRQDOLW LL
LQWHUUHOD LLGLQDPLFHWHUPHQDSOLFDELORULF UXLWLSGHUHOD LLXPDQHvQ
FDUHPDLPXOWHDVSHFWHVHvQWUHS WUXQGúLLQWHUUHOD LRQHD] DVWIHOvQFkW
VFKLPEDUHD FDUH DSDUH OD R SHUVRDQ YD DYHD HIHFWH DVXSUD FHOHLODOWH
SHUVRDQH
GLQDPLF HVWH XQ WHUPHQ FDUH vQ PRG VSHFLILF VH UHIHU OD PRWLYD LH
56:RRGZRUWKSURFHVHLQFRQúWLHQWH6)UHXG&*-XQJúLFkPSXUL
FRPSOH[HGHIRU SVLKRORJLF ./HYLQ
QHYUR] GHILQHúWHRWXOEXUDUHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHVDXPHQWDO FDUHQXVH
GDWRUHD] XQHLGLVIXQF LLQHXURORJLFHVDXRUJDQLFHFXQRVFXWHWHUPHQXO
SRDWH IL IRORVLW GHVFULSWLY SHQWUX D GHQXPL XQ VLPSWRP VDX JUXS GH
VLPSWRPH OHJDWH HWLRORJLF SHQWUX D LQGLFD UROXO FDX]DO MXFDW GH XQ
FRQIOLFWLQFRQúWLHQWFDUHHYRF DQ[LHWDWHúLFRQGXFHODXQPHFDQLVPGH
DS UDUHFHSURGXFHvQXOWLP LQVWDQ VLPSWRPXOREVHUYDWÌQXOWLPLLDQL
VDX SURGXV GRX PRGLILF UL VHPQLILFDWLYH vQ XWLOL]DUHD WHUPHQXOXL
XWLOL]DUHDGHQXPLULLGHWXOEXUDUHQHYURWLF FDXQWHUPHQJHQHULFSHQWUX
RULFH WXOEXUDUH PHQWDO GH GXUDW WHUPHQ UHODWLY QHXWUX vQ SULYLQ D
IDFWRULORU HWLRORJLFL HOLPLQDUHD WHUPHQXOXL GLQ GLDJQR]D SVLKLDWULF
DFRPSDQLDW GHRUHDWULEXLUHDYDULDWHORUWLSXULDQWHULRUUHFXQRVFXWHGH
QHYUR]HXQRUDOWRUFODVLILF ULGLDJQRVWLFH'3
VRPDWL]DUH H[SUHVLD vQ VRPDWLF D FRQGL LHL SVLKLFH WXOEXUDUHD SULQ
VRPDWL]DUHHVWHRFRQGL LHFDUDFWHUL]DW SULQWURLVWRULHGHVLPSWRPHIL
]LFHPXOWLSOHúLUHFXUHQWHSHQWUXFDUHQXH[LVW RFDX] IL]LF DSDUHQW
7XOEXUDUHDvQFHSHYLUWXDOvQSHULRDGDDGROHVFHQ HLúLDUHXQFXUVFURQLF
VDX IOXFWXDQW LPSOLFkQG R YDULHWDWH GH SOkQJHUL OHJDWH GH GLVIXQF LL
RUJDQLFH SUHFXP GXUHUL YDJL DOHUJLL SUREOHPH JDVWURLQWHVWLQDOH
VLPSWRPHSVLKRVH[XDOHSDOSLWD LLVLPSWRPHGHFRQYHUVLH
WXOEXUDUH SVLKRWLF XQ WHUPHQ FDUH DFRSHU XQ QXP U GH WXOEXU UL
PHQWDOHVHYHUHGHRULJLQHRUJDQLF VDXHPR LRQDO 'LDJQRVWLFDUHDDUH
vQYHGHUHLQYDOLGLWDWHDGHWHULRUDUHDFDSDFLW LLGHWHVWDUHDUHDOLW LL
SHUVRDQDIDFHLQIHUHQ HLQFRUHFWHSULYLWRDUHODUHDOLWDWHDH[WHUQ HYD
OX ULLPSURSULLDOHDFXUDWH HLJkQGXULORUúLSHUFHS LLORUVDOHúLFRQWLQX
V IDF HURUL vQ FLXGD GRYH]LORU FRQWUDULL 6LPSWRPHOH FODVLFH LQFOXG
KDOXFLQD LL FRPSRUWDPHQWH UHJUHVLYH VHYHUH GLVSR]L LL GUDPDWLF
QHDGHFYDWHYRUELUHLQFRHUHQW '3
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU
&DUHVXQWPRGDOLW LOHGHYDOLGDUHúLFRUHF LHDSURILOXOXL003,"
&DUHHVWHSULPDVFDO FOLQLF VHPQLILFD LLúLLQWHUSUHWDUH"
&DUHHVWHVFDODFOLQLF QUVHPQLILFD LLúLLQWHUSUHWDUH"
&DUHHVWHVFDODFOLQLF QUVHPQLILFD LLúLLQWHUSUHWDUH"
&DUHHVWHVFDODFOLQLF QUVHPQLILFD LLúLLQWHUSUHWDUH"
&DUHHVWHVFDODFOLQLF QUVHPQLILFD LLúLLQWHUSUHWDUH"
&DUHHVWHVFDODFOLQLF QUVHPQLILFD LLúLLQWHUSUHWDUH"
&DUHHVWHVFDODFOLQLF QUVHPQLILFD LLúLLQWHUSUHWDUH"
&DUHHVWHVFDODFOLQLF QUVHPQLILFD LLúLLQWHUSUHWDUH"
&DUHHVWHVFDODFOLQLF QUVHPQLILFD LLúLLQWHUSUHWDUH"
&DUHHVWHVFDODFOLQLF QUVHPQLILFD LLúLLQWHUSUHWDUH"
&XPVHUHDOL]HD] FRWDUHDúLFRGLILFDUHDSURILOXOXL003,"
&HVFDOHVXSOLPHQWDUHDSDUSHQWUXDFHDVW SULP IRUP "
&H HVWH 003, vQ FH FRQVWDX GHRVHELULOH úL VXSOLPHQW ULOH vQ
IRUPDQRX "
%LEOLRJUDILH
+DWKDZD\ 65 0F.LQOH\ -& 0LQQHVRWD 0XOWLSKDVLF 3HUVRQDOLW\
,QYHQWRU\8QLY0LQQ3UHVV0LQQHDSROLV
+DWKDZD\ 65 0HHKO 3( $Q $WODV IRU WKH &OLQLFDO 8VH RI 003,
8QLY0LQQ3UHVV0LQQHDSROLV
+DWKDZD\ 6DUNH 5 0RQDFKHVL ( ' $Q $WODV RI -XYHQLOH 003,
3URILOHV803UHVV0LQQHDSROLV
*RXJK*+7KH)PLQXV.'LVVLPXODWLRQLQGH[IRUWKH003,-RXUQ
&RQVXOW3V\FKRO
*UDKDP-57KH003,$3UDFWLFDO*XLGH2[IRUG8QLY3UHVV1HZ
<RUN
*UDKDP -5 003, $VVHVVLQJ 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG 3V\FKRSDWKRORJ\
2[IRUGXQLY3UHVV1HZ<RUN
0HUHQGD 3) &RPSDULVRQ %HWZHHQ WKH 0DQXDOV IRU WKH 003, DQG
003,DFULWLTXHÄ(XURS-RXUQRI3VFK$VVHVVPHQW´
0DQXDO IRU $GPLQLVWUDWLRQ DQG 6FRULQJ 003, 8QLYHUVLW\ RI
0LQQHVRWD3UHVV1DWLRQDO&RPSXWHU
&DSLWROXO,;
&+(67,21$58/36,+23$7,(1(952= 3$5$12,$313
3UH]HQWDUHD WHVWXOXL 313 vQFHSH SULQ SUH]HQWDUHD PRGXOXL FXP
33LFKRWDDMXQVODFRQVWUXLUHDWHVWXOXLGHSVLKRSDWLHQHYUR] SVLKR]
VXQW SUH]HQWDWH VFDOHOH WHVWXOXL úL VHPQLILFD LD DFHVWRUD SUHFXP úL
PRGXOGHFRUHFWDUHúLLQWHUSUHWDUHDGDWHORU6XQWSUH]HQWDWHH[WLQGHUL
XQWHVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORUúLUHIHULQ HOHELEOLRJUDILFH
&kWHYDGDWHGHLVWRULH
3UREOHPDGHWHFW ULLRDPHQLORUDQRUPDOLSVLKLFvQWURFROHFWLYLWDWH
FXDMXWRUXOWHVWHORUPHQWDOHVDSXVSHQWUXSULPDGDW vQvQDUPDWD
68$:RRGZRUWKDSURSXV3HUVRQDO'DWDXQFKHVWLRQDUvQFDUHHUDX
FXSULQVH VLPSWRPHOH vQWkOQLWH FHO PDL IUHFYHQW OD VXELHF LL UHIRUPD L
SHQWUX QHYUR]H ÌQ SUH]HQW FKHVWLRQDUXO :RRGZRUWK0DWKHXV QX PDL
HVWHvQX](YROXWLYPHWRGHOHVDXPXOWLSOLFDWúLHVWHSRVLELOFDODRUD
DFWXDO V VHSUHFL]H]HFDUDFWHUHOHIRUPDOHSHFDUHWUHEXLHV OHSRVHGH
DVHPHQHDSUREH
1X WUHEXLH V ILH WUDXPDWL]DQWH SHQWUX VXELHFW (VWH DGHY UDW vQ
PHGLXO PLOLWDU úL vQWUXQ FDGUX GHH[DPHQPHGLFDOHVWHSRVLELOV
SXLVXELHFWXOXLvQWUHE ULUDSRUWDWHODWXOEXU ULQHXURSVLKLFHFDUDFWH
ULVWLFHGDUHVWHGHGRULWFDúLvQPHGLXOFLYLOLQVWUXPHQWXOV SRDW IL
DSOLFDWvQDFHHDúLP VXU LDULWHPLLV QXSDU F DXYUHROHJ WXU
FX DQRPDOLLOH FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH VDX PDL PXOW V IDF DOX]LL OD WXO
EXU ULPHQWDOH
7UHEXLHV SRDW ILDGPLQLVWUDWHUHSHGHúLFROHFWLYVXEIRUPDXQXL
WHVWFUHLRQKkUWLHFROHFWLY
7UHEXLH V ILH DSOLFDELOH úL VXELHF LORU GH QLYHO LQWHOHFWXDO UHODWLY
VF ]XW$FHDVW FRQGL LHHVWHHYLGHQW GDF VHGRUHúWHRSURE DSOL
FDELO OD SRSXOD LD JHQHUDO úL QX QXPDL OD SRSXOD LL VHOHF LRQDWH
LQWHOHFWXDOH 7UHEXLH QRWDW F DFHDVW FRQGL LH SDUH D IL vQ FRQIOLFW
UHODWLY FX SUHFHGHQWD SHQWUX F XQ WHVW FUHLRQKkUWLH QHFHVLW XQ
QLYHOLQWHOHFWXDOPLQLP
7UHEXLH V SHUPLW R FRUHFWXU UDSLG úL XúRDU ILH FX DMXWRUXO
XQHLJULOHFXDMXWRUXOFDOFXODWRUXOXLvQRULFHFD]FXDMXWRUXOXQXL
SHUVRQDO QRQVSHFLDOL]DW úL XQ SURFHV GH LQWHUSUHWDUH OD IHO GH
VLPSOX vQ SUDFWLF LQWHUSUHWDUHD V ILH GLUHF LRQDW GH IL[DUHD
UH]XOWDWHORU vQWUH DQXPLWH OLPLWH QXPHULFH FX R YDORDUH GH QRW
GLVFULPLQDWRULH ([LVW OD RUD DFWXDO XQ DQXPLWQXP UGHSUREH
GH H[HPSOX &RUQHOO ,QGH[ FKHVWLRQDU ILOWUX FRQVWUXLW SHQWUX
HYLGHQ LHUHD UDSLG GLQWUXQ QXP U PDUH GH VXELHF L LQL LDO WRW
SHQWUX PHGLXO PLOLWDU FDUH SUH]LQW VLPSWRPH SVLKRVRPDWLFH VDX
GH WXOEXUDUH D SHUVRQDOLW LL FDUH VXQW PDL SX LQ WUDXPDWL]DQWH
FDUHU VSXQGODDFHVWHFRQGL LL
) U vQGRLDO QLFL R SURE QX YD SHUPLWH V VH HOLPLQH SUDFWLF
WR LVXELHF LLFDUHSUH]LQW WHQGLQ HQHYURWLFH([SHULHQ DFOLQLF DUDW
F GDF WXOEXU ULOH QHYURWLFH UHSUH]LQW FHD PDL PDUH SURSRU LH OD
VXELHF LLHOLPLQD LH[LVW úLDOWHGRX WLSXULGHVXELHF LFDUHSXQSUR
EOHPH GHOLFDWH VXELHF LL SUH]HQWkQG WU V WXUL FDUDFWHULVWLFH SDUDQRLFH
úLSHUVRQDOLW LOHSVLKRSDWLFH$FHVWHGRX WLSXULGHVXELHF LIUHFYHQW
QRFLYH vQWUXQ FROHFWLY QX SRW IL GHWHFWD L SULQWUR SURE FDUH H[SOR
UHD] GRDUWHQGLQ HOHQHYURWLFH
33LFKRWúLDSXVSUREOHPDXQHLSUREHFDUHSUH]HQWkQGFDUDFWH
ULVWLFLOHSUH]HQWDWHV SHUPLW RGHWHFWDUHUDSLG DFHORUWUHLFODVHGH
VXELHF L
ÌQ GRPHQLXO GHWHFW ULL WHQGLQ HORU QHYURWLFH SULQWUH GLYHUVHOH
SUREHSURSXVHWUHLWHVWHúLDXSUREDWYDOLGLWDWHDORU
D &KHVWLRQDUH QHYURWLFH GHULYkQG GLQ VSLULWXO FKHVWLRQDUXOXL OXL
:RRGZRUWKúLDO003,
E 7HVWHOH GH DVRFLD LH GH FXYLQWH FX DOHJHUH IRU DW GHULYDWH GLQ
H[SHULPHQWXODVRFLDWLYYHUEDODOOXL-XQJSUHFXPWHVWXOOXL3UHVVH\
WHVWXO &URZQ :RUG /LVW vQ 0DUHD %ULWDQLH úL WHVWXO &RUQHOO :RUG
)RUXPvQ68$
F 7HVWHOHGHJXVWXULDOLPHQWDUH:DOOHXFDUHDXGHPRQVWUDWF
QHYURWLFLL GHFODU F QX OH SODFH XQ QXP U PDL PDUH GH DOLPHQWH
GHFkWVXELHF LLQRUPDOL$FHVWDVSHFWDIRVWYHULILFDWvQGLYHUVH ULúL
vQSDUWLFXODUvQ0DUHD%ULWDQLHGHF WUH*RXJKvQ$VWIHOGDF
FKHVWLRQDUHOH vQWUR DQXPLW P VXU VXQW GHVFKLVH ÄWUXFDMXOXL´
WHVWXOGHDVRFLD LHHVWHvQWURP VXU PDLPLF WUXFDELOúLVHSRDWH
DILUPDF WHVWXOGHJXVWDOLPHQWDUQXSRDWHILGHORF
'HWHFWDUHD WHQGLQ HORU SDUDQRLFH úL SVLKRSDWLFH HVWH PDL GLILFLO
ÌQWUDGHY UQXPDLFKHVWLRQDUHOHSRWILIRORVLWHvQWUXQPRGYDOLG$FHVWH
GRX WLSXUL GH VXELHF L VXQW vQ PRG RELúQXLW LQWHOLJHQ L úL DX DGHVHD
WHQGLQ DGHDúLPDVFDWXOEXU ULOHGHDFHHDHVWHQHFHVDUV VHXWLOL]H]H
FKHVWLRQDUH ÄFDPXIODWH vQ FDUH YDOLGLWDWHD HVWH GHWHUPLQDW HPSLULF
&HOH GRX VF UL 3G úL 3D GLQ 003, U VSXQG OD DFHVWH GRX FRQGL LL
$VWIHO*XLOIRUGDFRQVWUXLWXQFKHVWLRQDUGHWHQGLQ HSDUDQRLFHYDOLGDW
SULQDQDOL]DIDFWRULDO 3UH]HQ DVFDOHORUvQ313DGXVODLQWURGXFHUHDúL
D XQHL VF UL GH QHVLQFHULWDWH FRQVWLWXLQG R JDUDQ LH DGL LRQDO FRQWUD
ÄWUXFDMXOXL´HYHQWXDO6DDGRSWDWVFDUDÄ/´GHOD003,
&DSXQFWGHSOHFDUHvQIRUPDUHDWHVWXOXL313GHF WUHSVLKLDWUXO
IUDQFH]3LHUUH3LFKRWDXIRVWUH LQXWHSUREHOHXUP WRDUHDYkQGFDED]
SULQFLSLLOHHQXPHUDWHPDLvQDLQWH
3HQWUXGLDJQRVWLFXOWHQGLQ HORUSDUDQRLFH
D*XLOIRUG0DUWLQ3HUVRQDO,QYHQWDU\
E6FDUD3DGHOD003,
3HQWUXGLDJQRVWLFXOWHQGLQ HORUSVLKRSDWLFH
6FDUD3VGHOD003,
3HQWUXWHQGLQ HQHYURWLFH
D7KH0DQGVOH\0HGLFDO4XHVWLRQQDLUH
E7KH&URZQ:RUG&RQQHFWLRQ/LVW
F2VFDU RULJLQDO GHJXVWXULDOLPHQWDUH
3HQWUXGLDJQRVWLFDUHDQHVLQFHULW LLvQU VSXQVXUL
6FDUDÄ/´OD003,
$QDOL]DLWHPLORUúLFRQVWLWXLUHDVF ULLGHILQLWLYH
2DQDOL] GXV SHUH]XOWDWHOHVXELHF LORUQRUPDOLDDU WDWF HVWH
QHFHVDUV VH LQ FRQWvQLQWHUSUHWDUHDUH]XOWDWHORU
x GHVH[
x GH QLYHOXO FXOWXUDO WR L VXELHF LL DX IRVW FODVD L GLQ DFHODúL SXQFW
GHYHGHUHvQGRX JUXSHGHSRSXOD LLGHHWDORQDUHQLYHOVF ]XW±
FHUWLILFDWGHVWXGLLHOHPHQWDUHúLVDXJHQHUDOHQLYHOULGLFDWFXO
WXU VHFXQGDU VDXVXSHULRDU
$ DS UXW HYLGHQW F vQWUR PDQLHU JHQHUDO VXELHF LL GH QLYHO
FXOWXUDOVF ]XWDXWHQGLQ DGHDU VSXQGHPDLSDWRORJLFGHFkWVXELHF LL
GHQLYHOULGLFDWúLF IHPHLOHODQLYHOFXOWXUDOHJDODXU VSXQVXULPDL
SDWRORJLFHGHFkWE UED LL3HQWUXDQDOL]DLWHPLORUVDXFRQVWLWXLWJUXSH
VHSDUDWHSHVH[HúLQLYHOFXOWXUDO
2 DQDOL] D LWHPLORU D IRVW SUDFWLFDW SH ILHFDUH FRQWUDVW SHQWUX
LWHPLL FRUHVSRQGHQ L XWLOL]kQG GUHSW FULWHULX JUDGXO VHPQLILFDWLY DO
GLIHUHQ HLvQWUHQRUPDOLúLVXELHF LSDWRORJLFL6DUH LQXWDVWIHO
x LWHPLGLQFKHVWLRQDUHOHGHWHQGLQ HSVLKRSDWLFHDXDU WDWRGLIH
UHQ VHPQLILFDWLY GHFHOSX LQGH
x LWHPL GH FKHVWLRQDUH GH WHQGLQ H SDUDQRLFH DUDW R GLIHUHQ
VHPQLILFDWLY GHFHOSX LQ
x GHLWHPLGLQFKHVWLRQDUHGHWHQGLQ HQHYURWLFHDUDW RGLIHUHQ
VHPQLILFDWLY GHFHOSX LQ
x GHLWHPLGHWHVWXOGHJXVWXULDOLPHQWDUHDUDW RGLIHUHQ GHFHO
SX LQ
x GH LWHPL GLQ WHVWXO GH FRQH[LXQH YHUEDO DUDW R GLIHUHQ
VHPQLILFDWLY GHFHOSX LQ
ÌQ SULYLQ D VFDOHL GH QHYUR] D DS UXW XWLO V VH FRPELQH FHOH
SUREHFKHVWLRQDUJXVWDOLPHQWDUFRQH[LXQHYHUEDO SHQWUXF DFHDVW
FRPELQD LHDGHPRQVWUDWRYDORDUHGLVFULPLQDWLY PDLPDUHvQGLIHUHQ
LHUHDvQWUHVXELHF LLQRUPDOLúLQHYUR]D L8WLOL]kQGRPHWRG ED]DW SH
YDORDUHD FRUHOD LHL vQWUH SUHGLF LH úL FULWHULX FHD PDL EXQ SRQGHUH
SHQWUXDRE LQHRQRW FRPELQDW HVWH[Ä*XVWXULDOLPHQWDUH´[
Ä&RQH[LXQLYHUEDOH´[Ä&KHVWLRQDU´QRWHOHXWLOL]DWHILLQGQRWH7
,QWHUSUHWDUHDFKHVWLRQDUXOXL313
6XQWSRVLELOHGRX PHWRGH
DXWLOL]DUHDDVFDOHvQWUHFDUHFHOHVFDOHGHQHYURWLVPGHVLQH
VW W WRU2QRW 7ULGLFDW VDXVXSHULRDU OXLHVWHFRQVLGH
UDW FDLQGLFDWLYGHSDWRORJLFSHQWUXRULFDUHGLQWUHDFHVWHD
E XWLOL]DUHD D VF UL vQ FDUH VLQJXUD VFDU JOREDO D WHQGLQ HL
QHYURWLFH UH]XOW SULQ FRPELQDUHD SRQGHUDW D FHORU VFDOH
SDU LDOHJXVWXULFRQH[LXQLFKHVWLRQDU
0HWRGDDRULFHSHUVRDQ FDUHSUH]LQW RQRW 7VXSHULRDU OXL
OD PDL PXOWH VDX GRDU OD XQD GLQWUH FHOH VFDOH DUH R SUREDELOLWDWH
ULGLFDW GHDSUH]HQWDRSVLKRSDWRORJLHúLHVWHGHGRULWV ILHVXSXV ODXQ
H[DPHQSVLKRORJLFPDLDSURIXQGDWHYHQWXDOGHF WUHXQVSHFLDOLVW
0HWRGDE6HYRUXWLOL]DFHOHVFDOHVLQFHULWDWHQHYUR] SVLKR]
úLSVLKRSDWLHúLVHLQWHUSUHWHD] WHQGLQ DFXQRWD7FHDPDLULGLFDW
7HKQLFDúLFRQFOX]LLOHVXQWLGHQWLFH(VWHRPLF GLIHUHQ vQWUH
FHOH PHWRGH vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH SURFHQWDMXO VXELHF LORU SDWRORJLFL
GHWHFWD L úL SURFHQWDMXO VXELHF LORU IDOúL FD SDWRORJLFL (VWH SRVLELO V
J VHúWL FD OLPLW SDWRORJLF R QRW 7 GLIHULW GH GXS VFRSXO úL
VHYHULWDWHDVHOHF LHLFHUFHW ULL
$FHDVW XWLOL]DUH SRDWH IL FRQVLGHUDW FD ILLQG FRPSOHPHQWDU
FHOHL XWLOL]DWH (D SHUPLWH SVLKRORJXOXL V RULHQWH]H VSHFLDOLVWXO vQ
H[DPHQXODSURIXQGDWDOVXELHFWXOXLGHWHFWDWFDDQRUPDOÌQSULQFLSLX
H[LVW R PD[LP úDQV FD SDFLHQWXO H[DPLQDW V SUH]LQWH R WU V WXU
SDWRORJLF SUHGRPLQDQW FRUHVSXQ] WRDUHFHOHLFDUHFRUHVSXQGHVFDOHL
ODFDUHDUHQRWD7FHDPDLULGLFDW ÌQDFHVWVFRSVHSRWIRORVLDPEHOH
PHWRGHODIHOGHHILFLHQW([LVW vQV RGLIHUHQ vQWUHFHOHGRX PHWRGH
UHVSHFWLY PHWRGD D SHUPLWH V VH GHWHFWH]H PDL ELQH QHYUR]HOH LDU
PHWRGDESDUDQRLFLLúLGH]HFKLOLEUD LL
7HRUHWLFVHSRDWHXWLOL]DDFHDVW PHWRG FKLDUGDF QRWHOH7QX
DWLQJÌQDFHVWFD]WUHEXLHV VHPDQLIHVWHXQPD[LPGHSUXGHQ vQ
LQWHUSUHWDUH F FL QX VH SRDWH YRUEL GH WU V WXUL SDWRORJLFH FL GRDU GH
WHQGLQ HFDUHVHVLWXHD] SUREDELOvQOLPLWHQRUPDOH
&kQGQRWHOH7VXQWLQIHULRDUHOXLúLGRDUQRWD7GHODQHVLQFH
ULWDWHGHS úHúWHHVWHYRUEDvQJHQHUDOGHXQVXELHFWFDUHFDXW V VH
SUH]LQWHIDYRUDELOFRQúWLHQWVDXQX(VWHSRVLELOFDDFHDVW DWLWXGLQHV
QXILHDVRFLDW ODRDOW WHQGLQ SDWRORJLF GDUQXUDUHVWHFD]XOvQFDUH
RSXWHPvQWkOQLODSDUDQRLFL8QDVWIHOGHSURILOWUHEXLHV ILHFRQVLGHUDW
FDVXVSHFWúLQHFHVLW XQH[DPHQPDLFRPSOHW'DF XQDVDXPDLPXOWH
QRWH7VXQWULGLFDWHDFHHDúLGHFL]LHVHLPSXQHGDUvQDFHVWFD]QRWD7
FHD PDL ULGLFDW RELúQXLW WHQGLQ H SDUDQRLFH VDX WHQGLQ H SVLKRSDWLFH
G RLQGLFD LHDVXSUDGHYLD LHLSDWRORJLFHDVXELHFWXOXL
3UH]HQWDUHWHVW
0DWHULDOHQHFHVDUH&KHVWLRQDUIRDLDGHU VSXQVJULO HWDORQ
IRDLHGHSURILOPDQXDOSHQWUXLQWHUSUHWDUH
6FRS'HSLVWDUHDVXELHF LORUFXWHQGLQ HSDUDQRLFHQHYURWLFHVDX
SVLKRSDWH
6WUXFWXU 7HVWXOHVWHDOF WXLWGLQVXEWHVWHXQFKHVWLRQDUFDUH
DUHVFDOHGHVLQFHULWDWHGHQHYURWLVPGHWHQGLQ HSDUDQRLGHGHWHQ
GLQ HSVLKRSDWHXQWHVWDVRFLDWLYYHUEDOXQWHVWGHJXVWXULDOLPHQWDUH
$SOLFDUH 7HVWXO VH DSOLF I U OLPLW GH WLPS LQVWUXFWDMHOH VH
IDFSHQWUXILHFDUHVXEWHVWvQSDUWH6XELHFWXOHVWHDYHUWL]DWV QXQRWH]H
QLFLXQU VSXQVODUXEULFDÄ"´SHIRDLDGHU VSXQV6HDSOLF LQGLYLGXDO
VDXFROHFWLY5HFRPDQGDWSHQWUXDGXO LúLWLQHUL
&RWDUH
7HVWXO QXP UXO JXVWXUL DOLPHQWDUH VH UH LQH QXP UXO DOL
PHQWHORUVXEOLQLDWHúLVHWUHFHvQUXEULFDFRUHVSXQ] WRDUH*XVWDOSH
IRDLDGHSURILO
7HVWXOQXP UXOFKHVWLRQDUXOVHDSOLF FHOHSDWUXJULOHúLVH
WUHF SXQFWDMHOH vQ UXEULFLOH FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH 1HVLQFHULWDWH 1HY 3D
3VDOHIRLLGHSURILO
7HVWXOQXP UXODVRFLDWLYYHUEDO±VHDSOLF JULODúLVHWUHFSH
IRDLDGHSURILOSXQFWHOHvQUXEULFDFRUHVSXQ] WRDUH&RQH[LXQLYHUEDOH
ÌQFD]XOWHVWHORUúLVHDFRUG XQSXQFWSHQWUXILHFDUHU VSXQVFRLQ
FLGHQWFXJULOD
6HOXFUHD] SHIRDLDGHSURILOFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHQLYHOXOXLFXOWXUDO
DOVXELHFWXOXL
,QGLFHOH GH JUDYLWDWH SDWRORJLF FUHúWH GLUHFW SURSRU LRQDO FX
FUHúWHUHD UH]XOWDWHORU SHVWH /D VFDOD GH PLQFLXQ SHUIRUPDQ H
SHVWHQRWH7LQGLF GRULQ DGHDVHSXQHvQWUROXPLQ IDYRUDELO
(;7,1'(5,
'DWHGHFHUFHWDUHSULYLQGYHULGLFLWDWHDGLDJQRVWLFXOXL
'DF XWLOL] P VF UL VH DMXQJH vQ VLWXD LD GH D GLDJQRVWLFD FD
SDWRORJLHSVLKLF PDMRU GLQWUHSVLKRSD LGLQWUHQHYURWLFL
GLQWUHSDUDQRLFLÌQDFHODúLWLPSGRDUGLQVXELHF LLQRUPDOL
VXQWIDOVGLDJQRVWLFD LFDSDWRORJLFL
'DF VDU XWLOL]D QXPDL VFDOH vQ FDUH VFDOD 1HYURWLF HVWH
FRPELQDW SXWHPDYHDvQYHGHUHXUP WRDUHOHSURFHQWHSHQWUXDDYHDR
LPDJLQHDVXSUDSUREDELOLW LLFRUHFWLWXGLQLLGLDJQRVWLFXOXLGHSDWRORJLH
SVLKRSD L QHYURWLFL SDUDQRLFL vQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH
GLQFHLGLDJQRVWLFD LSRWV ILHÄIDOúLSR]LWLYL´ODVXELHF LLQRUPDOL
'LDJQRVWLFXOQRVRORJLFLQGHSHQGHQWGHFULWHULXOSDWRORJLFED]DW
SH SULQFLSLXO F VFDOD DYkQG QRWD 7 FHD PDL ULGLFDW LQGLF GLDJQRV
WLFXOSUH]LQW XUP WRDUHOHSURFHQWHGHFHUWLWXGLQH
±3VLKRSD LFXVFDOHFXVFDOH
±3DUDQRLFLFXVFDOHFXVFDOH
±1HYURWLFLFXVFDOHFXVFDOH
6H YHGH F XWLOL]DUHD D SDWUX VFDOH SHUPLWH R DPHOLRUDUH D
GLDJQRVWLFXOXL FRUHFW SHQWUX SDUDQRLFL úL SVLKRSD L úL R GLPLQXDUH
SHQWUXQHYURWLFL$FHVWHFLIUHWUHEXLHFRQVLGHUDWHvQUHOD LHFXYDORDUHD
FULWHULXOXL QRVRORJLF IRORVLW 3URFHQWDMHOH FDUH FRUHVSXQG vQ FD]XULOH
FRUHFWDERUGDWHSHQWUXFDUHVDI FXWVLPXOWDQXQGLDJQRVWLFSDWRORJLF
úLQXXQXOQRVRORJLFVXQW
±3VLKRSD LFXVFDOHFXVFDOH
±3DUDQRLFLFXVF ULFXVFDOH
±1HYURWLFLFXVF ULFXVFDOH
7HVWHGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU
ÌQ FH FRQVW SDUWLFXODULWDWHD WHVWXOXL 313 vQ HYDOXDUHD WHQGLQ HL
VSUHQHYUR] "
ÌQFHFRQVW PHWRGDDvQLQWHUSUHWDUHDWHVWXOXL313"
ÌQFHFRQVW PHWRGDEvQLQWHUSUHWDUHDWHVWXOXL313"
'HODFHQLYHODOQRWHORU7VHSRDWHFRQVWDWDH[LVWHQ DXQHLWHQGLQ H
SDWRORJLFH"
%LEOLRJUDILH
'HOD\ - 3LFKRW 3 3HUVH - 0HWKRGHV SV\FKRPpWULTXHV HQ FOLQLTXH
7HVW0HQWDX[HWLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ38)3DULV
0LQXOHVFX0&KHVWLRQDUHOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHvQHYDOXDUHDSVLKRORJLF
(GLWXUD*DUHOO%XFXUHúWL
3LFKRW3/HTXHVWLRQQDLUH313Ä5HYXHGHSV\FKRORJLHDSSOLTXH´
3LFKRW30DQXHOGXTXHVWLRQQDLUH313&$33DULV
&DSLWROXO;
7(67('(7(03(5$0(17*=76675,=.34$,66
6XQW SUH]HQWDWH FkWHYD GLQWUH SHUVSHFWLYHOH GLQ FDUH SRDWH IL
FRQVLGHUDWWHPSHUDPHQWXO6XQWSUH]HQWDWHDSRLSHQWUXILHFDUHGLQWUH
WHVWHOHGHWHPSHUDPHQWFkWHYDGDWHSULYLQGFRQVWUXLUHDFKHVWLRQDUXOXL
SUHFXPúLDVSHFWHVHPQLILFDWLYHSULYLQGGLPHQVLXQLOHVFDOHORUúLLQWHU
SUHWDUHD ORUÌQ ILQDOXO FDSLWROXOXL DSDUH XQ WHVW GH HYDOXDUH úL
UHIHULQ HOHELEOLRJUDILFH
(YLGHQ DFRPSRUWDPHQWDO DFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUWHPSHUDPHQWDOH
8QD GLQWUH GHILQL LLOH DSOLFDWLYH SUH]LQW WHPSHUDPHQWXO FD WHQ
GLQ FRPSRUWDPHQWDO DXQHLSHUVRDQH8QLLRDPHQLVHFRPSRUW vQWUR
PDQLHU SDVLY DO LL VXQW JDWD V GRPLQH XQRUD OH SODFH V DUJX
PHQWH]H V LQWUH vQ GLVSXWH DOWRUD V ILH RUGRQD L úL FDOPL XQLL VXQW
IOH[LELOLDO LLULJL]LXQLLVXQWVHQVLELOLDO LLLPSHUWXUEDELOL7RDWHDFHVWHD
UHSUH]LQW PRGXOJHQHUDOGHDDF LRQDGHDOXQJXOXQHLSHULRDGHGHWLPS
GHúLQXvQPRGQHFHVDUWRWGHDXQD)LHFDUHLQGLYLGvúLIRUPHD] DQXPLWH
RELFHLXULOHJDWHGHPRGXOGHDDF LRQD'HH[HPSOXFHOF UXLDvLSODFH
V DUJXPHQWH]H YD DF LRQD vQWUR PXOWLWXGLQH GH VLWXD LL vQ DFHVW IHO
H[SULPkQGXúL DFHDVW WHQGLQ úL YD SURWHVWD GDF IULSWXUD SH FDUH D
FRPDQGDWR OD UHVWDXUDQW QX HVWH J WLW H[DFW DúD FXP D FHUXW GDU vQ
DFHHDúLP VXU VHYDDGUHVDúLúHIXOXLSHQWUXDúLH[SULPDGH]DFRUGXOFX
IHOXOvQFDUHJkQGHúWHDFHVWDDVWIHOGHFRPSRQHQWHFDUHVHFRQVWLWXLHFD
RELFHLXULOXDWHvPSUHXQ VXQWRRJOLQG YLHDWHPSHUDPHQWXOXLÌQJH
QHUDOWHQGLQ DWHPSHUDPHQWDO vQFHSHV ILHRSUREOHP SHQWUXLQGLYLG
úLFHLGLQMXUvQVLWXD LDFkQGDFHVWHFRPSRQHQWHWLQGV VHH[WUHPL]H]H
vQFRPSRUWDPHQWVDXFkQGPDLPXOWHFRPSRQHQWHDOHWHPSHUDPHQWXOXL
WLQGV ILHvQFRQIOLFWvQWUHHOHÌQRULFDUHFD]SXWHPVSXQHF SHUVRDQDvQ
FDX] QXSUH]LQW RSHUVRQDOLWDWHELQHLQWHJUDW
3HUVSHFWLYD IXQGDPHQWDO DVXSUD WHPSHUDPHQWXOXL FRQVLGHU
DFHVWWLSGHFDUDFWHULVWLFLFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHFDH[SULPkQGFRPSRQHQWD
GLQDPLF HQHUJHWLF DSHUVRQDOLW LL'LQDPLFDDUHvQYHGHUHDVSHFWHOH
FDUHVHUHIOHFW vQUDSLGLWDWHVDXOHQWRDUHPRELOLWDWHVDXULJLGLWDWHULWPXO
DOHUW VDX OHQW IOH[LELOLWDWHD VDX XQLIRUPLWDWHD FRQGXLWHL (QHUJHWLFD VH
UHIOHFW PDLDOHVvQDVSHFWHOHOHJDWHGHHQHUJLDODGLVSR]L LHúLSULYHúWH
PRGXO FXP HVWH FRQVXPDW LQWHQVLWDWHD úL HFKLOLEUXO XQHOH SHUVRDQH
SUH]LQW XQVXUSOXVGHHQHUJLHDOWHOHVHGHVFDUF YLROHQWúLH[SOR]LY
XQHOH vúL FRQVXP HQHUJLD vQ PRG HFKLOLEUDW DOWHOH úLR ULVLSHVF úL
H[LVW úLVLWXD LLFkQGQLYHOXOGHHQHUJLHHVWHVODELQVXILFLHQW
&RPSOHPHQWDUVHDUHvQYHGHUHPRGXOvQFDUHVHH[SULP WHPSH
UDPHQWXOFHOPDLYL]LELOSULQPLúF ULUHDF LLVDXFRQGXLWDQRQYHUEDO
PLPLF JHVWLF SRVWXU FOLSLWXO RFKLORU 'LQWUH LQGLFDWRULL FHL PDL
HYLGHQ L SXWHPFLWDLQWHQVLWDWHDYLH LLSVLKLFHULWPXOúLYLWH]DWU LULORU
VDXVW ULORUSVLKLFHLPSXOVLYLWDWHDúLLPSUHVLRQDELOLWDWHDIUHFYHQ DWU
LULORUSVLKLFHGXUDELOLWDWHDúLHFKLOLEUXOWU LULORUSVLKLFHFDSDFLWDWHDGH
DGDSWDUHODVLWXD LLQRL
&D IRUP GH PDQLIHVWDUH D SHUVRQDOLW LL WHPSHUDPHQWXO QX
JHQHUHD] FRQ LQXWXULVDXSHUIRUPDQ HSVLKLFHúLQXVHSRDWHVSXQHF
DFRUG YDORDUHHWLFPRUDO
([LVW GHVLJXUGLIHUHQ HvQWUHSVLKRORJLFSULYLQGIDFWRULLGHWHP
SHUDPHQWVDXSHUVRQDOLWDWHSHFDUHvLFRQVLGHU LPSRUWDQ L0DMRULWDWHD
XWLOL]HD] LQYHQWDUHOHSHQWUXDP VXUDFRQGXLWDSUH]HQW úLFHDWUHFXW
SHQWUX D GLDJQRVWLFD úL DQWLFLSD 9 SUH]HQW P vQ FHOH FH XUPHD]
FkWHYDGLUHF LLGHDERUGDUHDFRPSRQHQWHORUWHPSHUDPHQWXOXL
&KHVWLRQDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH*XLOIRUG=LPPHUPDQ
'LPHQVLXQLúLLQWHUSUHWDUH
3RUQLQGGHODPHWRGHOHLQWHUYLXOXLFOLQLFúLDQDPQHVWLF*XLOIRUG
FRQVWUXLHúWHvQDLQWHGHRVHULHGHFKHVWLRQDUHILHFDXQLFDXWRU±
LQYHQWDUHOH 6(0 úL 67'&5 ILH vPSUHXQ FX 0DUWLQ ± FKHVWLRQDUHOH
3HUVRQHO,QYHQWRU\,QYHQWRU\RIIDFWRUV*DPLQ
-R\3DXO*XLOIRUGQ
3VLKRORJDPHULFDQSURIHVRUXQLYHUVLWDUúLFHUFH
W WRUGHGLFDWVWXGLXOXLLQWHOHFWXOXLXPDQúLFDUDFWHULVWLFLORU
SHUVRQDOLW LL OXFUHD] vQ XOWLPLL DQL OD 8QLYHUVLWDWHD
GLQ&DOLIRUQLDGH6XG0RQXPHQWDOXOV XWUDWDW1DWXUD
LQWHOLJHQ HL XPDQH D FRQFHQWUDW vQWUR WHRULH XQLWDU
GDWHOHGHFHUFHWDUHSULYLQGVWUXFWXUDLQWHOLJHQ HLXPDQH
IXQF LRQDUHD úL GHWHUPLQDQ LL DFHVWHLD úL D GHVFKLV GH
DVHPHQHD QXPHURDVH FHUFHW UL DSOLFDWLYH vQ VSHFLDO vQ
SULYLQ DYDOLG ULLúLFRQVWUXLULLXQRUSUREHSVLKRGLDJQRVWLFH
FDUHV DFRSHUHDELOLW LOHVSHFLILFH*XLOIRUGGLVFXW vQ
DFHVW WUDWDW ED]HOH IL]LFH DOH LQWHOLJHQ HL FRQGL LLOH GH
PHGLXúLGH]YROWDUHDLQWHOHFWXOXL SUHFXPúLFDUDFWHULV
WLFLOHGHFOLQXOXLLQWHOHFWXDO
'HDVHPHQHDvQFDOLWDWHGHGLUHFWRUDOXQRUSUR
JUDPH GH FHUFHWDUH SVLKRORJLF DSOLFDW GH]YROW FHU
FHW ULSULYLQGIDFWRULLSHUVRQDOLW LLúLLPSOLFDUHDORUvQ
FkPSXO DFWLYLW LORU XPDQH SUHFXP úL SUREH SHQWUX
VHOHF LDSHUVRQDOXOXL
&KHVWLRQDUHOHFLWDWHUHSUH]LQW UH]XOWDWXOXQXLHIRUWGHFHUFHWDUHúL
GHFDOFXODOLQWHUFRUHOD LLORULWHPLORUPDLPXOWRUWLSXULGHFKHVWLRQDUHÌQ
XUPDDFHVWRUVWXGLLDXIRVWLGHQWLILFD LIDFWRULLQWURYHUVLDVRFLDO 6
LQWURYHUVLD FRJQLWLY 7 GHSUHVLD ' WHQGLQ D FLFORLG UKDWK\PLD 5
DFWLYLVPXOJHQHUDO*DVFHQGHQ YVVXEPLVLYLWDWH$PDVFXOLQLWDWHYV
IHPLQLWDWH 0 LQIHULRULWDWH , QHUYR]LWDWH 1 RELHFWLYLWDWH 2 FRRSHUDUH
&RDJUHDELOLWDWH$J,QYHQWDUXOGHIDFWRUL67'&5DFRSHU SULPLLFLQFL
IDFWRUL GHVFRSHUL L SULQ DQDOL]D IDFWRULDO DSOLFDW XQRU FKHVWLRQDUH GH
LQWURYHUVLHH[WUDYHUVLH*$0,1LQFOXGHSHFHLODO LIDFWRUL,DUXOWLPLL
IDFRELHFWXOOXL*03HUVRQDO,QYHQWRU\
ÌQ *XLOIRUG SXEOLF *XLOIRUG =LPPHUPDQ 7HPSHUDPHQW
6XUYH\FDUHLQFOXGHWU V WXULPDMRUHDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLLGHQWLILFDWH
VXQWLGHQWLFHFXFHOHLQFOXVHvQFKHVWLRQDUHDQWHULRDUHGHúLSHQWUXXQHOH
VDVFKLPEDWGHQXPLUHDSHQWUXVLPSOLILFDUHúLRPDLPDUHFODULWDWH,DU
XQD GLQWUH WU V WXULOH HYDOXDWH UHSUH]LQW R FRPELQDUH D GRX GLQWUH
WU V WXULOH vQDOW FRUHODWH GLQ FKHVWLRQDUHOH DQWHULRDUH $QDOL]DWH VXE
UDSRUWXO FRQ LQXWXULORU SVLKRORJLFH GRDU FkWHYD GLQWUH VFDOH FXSULQG R
PDMRULWDWH GH LWHPL FDUH VH UHIHU OD DVSHFWH VWULFW WHPSHUDPHQWDOH vQ
DFHVWVHQVSULPLLIDFWRULvQRUGLQHDLHUDUKLF VXQWFHOPDLLPSUHJQD L
GHDVSHFWHWHPSHUDPHQWDOHDFWLYLVPDXWRFRQWURODSRLvQRUGLQHIDFWRULL
GHVWDELOLWDWHHPR LRQDOHKLSRKLSHUVHQVLELOLWDWH&HLODO LIDFWRULDLWHV
WXOXLFXSULQGDVSHFWHFDUH LQúLGHDWLWXGLQLSUHIHULQ HFDUDFWHULVWLFLGH
JHQHWFFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHOHJDWHGHWHPSHUDPHQWILLQGPDLSX LQSUHJQDQWH
'LPHQVLXQLOH vQ QRXD IRUP VXQW * DFWLYLWDWH JHQHUDO FX
LWHPLFDUHVHUHIHU ODDVSHFWHSUHFXPSO FHUHSHQWUXYLWH] JUDE YLWD
OLWDWHSOLQGHYLD SURGXF LHúLHILFLHQ YVOHQWGHOLEHUDWLYRERVHúWH
XúRU LQHILFLHQW 5 DXWRFRQWURO FX DVSHFWH SUHFXP VHULR]LWDWH GHOL
EHUDUHSHUVLVWHQ YVLQGLIHUHQ LPSXOVLYLWDWHSO FHUHSHQWUXH[FLWDUH
UKDWK\PLD $ DVFHQGHQ DVSHFWH SUHFXP DXWRDS UDUH FRQGXFH
YRUEHúWHvQSXEOLFVW SkQSHVLQHYVVXEPLVLYLWDWHH]LWDUHHYLW SOLQGH
SUHFDX LH6VRFLDELOLWDWHSULQFDUDFWHULVWLFLSUHFXPDDYHDPXO LSULH
WHQLDF XWDFRQWDFWHVRFLDOHYVSULHWHQLSX LQLúLWLPLGLWDWHLQWURYHUVLH
VRFLDO (VWDELOLWDWHHPR LRQDO SULQHJDOLWDWHDGLVSR]L LHLRSWLPLVP
FDOPYVIOXFWXDUHDGLVSR]L LHLSHVLPLVPUHYHULHH[FLWDELOLWDWHVHQWLPHQWH
GH YLQRY LH QHOLQLúWH VLQJXU WDWH úL R SURDVW V Q WDWH FRPELQDUHD
IDFWRULORU&úL'2RELHFWLYLWDWHFDUDFWHUL]DW SULQKLSRVHQVLELOLWDWHYV
KLSHUVHQVLELOLWDWHFHQWUDWSHVLQHVXVSLFLRVÄLQWU vQQHFD]XUL)SULH
WHQLHSULQWROHUDQ DDF LXQLLRVWLOHDFFHSWDUHDGRPLQ ULLUHVSHFWXOSHQWUX
FHLODO LYVEHOLJHUDQWRVWLOFXUHVHQWLPHQWHGRULQ DGHDGRPLQDGLVSUH
ID GHDO LLDJUHDELOLWDWH7UHIOH[LYLWDWHSULQUHIOH[LYREVHUY SHDO LL
úL SH VLQH HFKLOLEUX PHQWDO YV LQWHUHV ID GH DFWLYLW L FRQFUHWH VH
GHVFXPS QHúWHXúRUJkQGLUHLQWURYHUW 3UHOD LLSHUVRQDOHWROHUDQ D
RDPHQLORUvQFUHGHUHvQLQVWLWX LLVRFLDOHYVFDXW PHUHXJUHúHDODFULWLF
LQVWLWX LLOH VXVSLFLRV vúL SOkQJH GH PLO FRRSHUDUH 0 PDVFXOLQLWDWH
SULQLQWHUHVSHQWUXDFWLYLW LPDVFXOLQHQXVHGH]JXVW XúRUDVSUXGXU
vúLLQKLE H[SUHVLDHPR LLORUGH]LQWHUHVSHQWUXvPEU F PLQWHúLVWLOYV
LQWHUHV vQ DFWLYLW L úL SUHRFXS UL IHPLQLQH VH GH]JXVW XúRU WHP WRU
URPDQWLFH[SULP HPR LLOH
ÌQLQWHUSUHWDUHVHSXQHDFFHQWúLSHLQWHUFRUHODUHDGDWHORU$VWIHO
R QRW ULGLFDW OD XQ IDFWRU SRDWH PRGLILFD SURJQRVWLFXO GDF HVWH
DVRFLDW FXRQRW VF ]XW ODXQDOWIDFWRU'HH[HPSOXXQJUDGULGLFDW
GHGRPLQDQ DVRFLDWXQHLQRWHVF ]XWHODDJUHDELOLWDWHFRQGXFHVSUH
LPDJLQHDXQXLVWLOGXUDXWRULWDUXQJUDGULGLFDWODVWDELOLWDWHHPR LRQDO
DVRFLDWXQHLDFWLYLW LVF ]XWHFRQGXFHVSUHLSRWH]DXQXLFRPSRUWDPHQW
FRPRGOHQHú
,QYHQWDUXOFRQ LQHGHLWHPLFkWHSHQWUXILHFDUHVFDO IDFWR
ULDO H[SULPD LSULQH[SUHVLLDILUPDWLYHPDMRULWDWHDFXGLUHFW UHOHYDQ
SHQWUXSHUVRDQ úLGRDUSX LQLUHSUH]HQWkQGJHQHUDOL] ULDEVWUDFWL] UL
&HHDFHVHUHSURúHD] FKHVWLRQDUXOXLHVWHOLSVDGHYDOLGDUHHPSL
ULF úLOLSVDGHFRQWURODDWLWXGLQLLVXELHFWXOXLID GHSURE (VWHXWLOL]DW
ILHvQVHOHF LDSURIHVLRQDO ILHvQRULHQWDUHúLFRQVLOLHUHSURIHVLRQDO
2SRVLELO PHWRG SHFDUHRVXJHUHD] DXWRULLHVWHGHDFRUHFWD
ILHFDUHIDFWRUvQGRX S U LLWHPLLSDULúLLWHPLLLPSDULQXDWkWSHQWUX
FDOFXOXOILGHOLW LLFLSHQWUXDYHGHDGDF VXELHFWXOVHFRPSRUW HJDO
ID GH WU V WXUD UHVSHFWLY 'DF FHOH GRX MXP W L VXQW vQ DFRUG ±
OXkQGXVHvQFRQVLGHUDUHHURDUHDVWDQGDUGLQWHUSUHWDUHDSRDWHGHFXUJH
QRUPDO GDF GLIHUHQ D GHS úHúWH YDORDUHD D GRX HURUL VWDQGDUG
UH]XOWDWXOSRDWHILSXVODvQGRLDO ÌQP VXUDvQFDUHODDFHODúLVXELHFW
H[LVW PDL PXOWH GLIHUHQ H OD IHO GH PDUL GHS úLQG GXEOXO HURULL
VWDQGDUGHVWHVXVSLFLRQDWDQVDPEOXOUH]XOWDWHORUSURILOXOXL
8QD GLQWUH SRVLELOHOH H[SOLFD LL SHQWUX R DVWIHO GH VLWXD LH HVWH
JUDGXOGHWHQVLXQHSVLKLF úLGHFRQIOLFWHLQWUDSVLKLFH1XP UXOPDUH
GHGLIHUHQ HFXYDORULSHVWHGXEOXOHURULLVWDQGDUGDGPLVHGHYLQHDVWIHO
XQLQGLFHFHVHPQDOHD] JUDYLWDWHDWXOEXU ULORUSVLKLFH
8QDGLQWUHUHDQDOL]HOHGDWHORUOXL*XLOIRUGODFRQGXVSH7KXUVWRQH
OD FRQFOX]LD F GLQWUH IDFWRUL VXQW VXILFLHQ L SHQWUX D MXVWLILFD YD
ULDQ DFRPSRUWDPHQWDO $VWIHOGLPHQVLXQLOHDFWLYYLJXURVLPSXOVLY
GRPLQDQW VWDELO VRFLDELO UHIOH[LY IRUPHD] VFDOHOH FKHVWLRQDUXOXL
GHULYDW 7KXUVWRQH 7HPSHUDPHQW 6FKHGXOH 776 FRQVWUXLW vQ
XOWLPDUHYL]LH'HH[HPSOXDFWLYLVPXOP VRDU JUDGXOvQFDUH
LQGLYLGXO OXFUHD] úL VH PLúF UDSLG YLJXUR]LWDWHD JUDGXO vQ FDUH
SDUWLFLS OD DFWLYLW L IL]LFH LPSXOVLYLWDWHD P VRDU GLVSR]L LD VSUH
QHS VDUHúLUDSLGLWDWHvQGHFL]LLGRPLQDQ DDELOLWDWHDGHFRQGXFHUHGH
DOXDLQL LDWLYDúLDILUHVSRQVDELOVWDELOLWDWHDVHUHIHU ODRGLVSR]L LH
YHVHO úLVWDELO VRFLDELOLWDWHDODSO FHUHDGHDILvQFRPSDQLDDOWRUD
LDUUHIOH[LYLWDWHDFDSDFLWDWHDGHDPHGLWDúLSO FHUHDSHQWUXSUREOHPH
WHRUHWLFH
&KHVWLRQDUXOGHWHPSHUDPHQW6WUHODXUHYL]XLW67,5
'LPHQVLXQLúLLQWHUSUHWDUH
-$*UD\vQvQOXFUDUHD3DYORY
VW\SRORJ\UHLDWLSRORJLDOXL
3DYORY úL UHLQWHUSUHWHD] FRQFHSWXO GH ÄIRU D H[FLWD LHL´ vQ WHUPHQLL
DFWLY ULLúLFDSDFLW LLGHDFWLYDUH2vQFHUFDUHGHDF XWDOHJ WXULvQWUH
WLSRORJLDSDYORYLDQ úLGLPHQVLXQLOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDIRVWUHDOL]DW GH
5% &DWWHOO vQ FkQG SHUVRQRORJXO DPHULFDQ GH]YROW LSRWH]H
SULYLQGUHOD LDGLQWUHIRU DVLVWHPXOXLQHUYRVUHVSHFWLYIRU DH[FLWD LHLúL
IDFWRUL WHPSHUDPHQWDOL HJRXO DVHUWLY 8, LQKLEL LD JHQHUDO
8, WHPSHUDPHQWXO KLSRPDQLDF 8, H[XEHUDQ D 8,
FRUWHUWLD8,FDSDFLWDWHGHDVHPRELOL]DYVUHJUHVLH8,H[YLD
YVLQYLD8,'XS &DWWHOOHJRXODVHUWLYVHUHIHU SULQWUHDOWHOHúL
ODÄFDSDFLWDWHDGHDVXSRUWDVWLPXODUHD´H[XEHUDQ DODFDOLWDWHDWHPSH
UDPHQWDO GHH[FLWDELOLWDWHúLLPSXOVLYLWDWHFRUWHUWLDSRDWHILSULYLW FD
DYkQG VHQVXO GH YLRLFLXQH FRUWLFDO WR L ILLQG IDFWRUL FDUH SDU V
FRQWULEXLHPXOWODIRU DVLVWHPXOXLQHUYRV'HIDSWLSRWH]HOHOXL&DWWHOO
UHIHULWRDUHODUHOD LDGLQWUHWHPSHUDPHQWúLIRU DVLVWHPXOXLQHUYRVQXDX
IRVWVXSXVHXQHLYHULILF ULVLVWHPDWLFH'LQWUHIDFWRULLSULPDULGLQFKHV
WLRQDUXO3)GRDUVXUJHQF\IDFWRUXO)8,FRUHOHD] SR]LWLY
,YDQ3HWURYLFL3DYORY±
&HUFHW WRUIL]LRORJUXV,QL LDOLQWHUHVDWGHSURFHVXO
GHGLJHVWLHSHQWUXDFHVWHVWXGLLSULPHúWHSUHPLXO1REHO
SHQWUXPHGLFLQ
&RQVWUXLHúWHRSURFHGXU H[SHULPHQWDO SULQFDUHXQ
VWLPXOQHXWUXGHYLQHXQVWLPXOFRQGL LRQDWvQYLUWXWHDDVR
FLHULLVDOHFXXQVWLPXOQHFRQGL LRQDWSURFHGXU GHQXPLW
FRQGL LRQDUHFODVLF SDYORYLDQ 3DYORYHVWHFXQRVFXWGH
DVHPHQHD SHQWUX VWXGLLOH VDOH DVXSUD SURSULHW LORU DFWL
YLW LL QHUYRDVH VXSHULRDUH vQ ED]D FHUFHW ULORU DVXSUD
UHIOH[HORUFRQGL LRQDWHvQWHUPHQLGHLQWHQVLWDWHIRU úL
PRELOLWDWHDGHVFKLVRFDOHQRX vQVWXGLXOH[SHULPHQWDO
DODFWLYLW LLFUHLHUXOXLSUHFXPúLvQH[SOLFDUHDFRPSRUWD
PHQWXOXLDQLPDOúLXPDQ
ÌQWUXQVWXGLXVLQWHWLFGLQ$QJOHLWQHUUHDOL]HD] RGLIHUHQ
LHUHvQWUHFKHVWLRQDUHOHGHHYDOXDUHDWU V WXULORUSHUVRQDOLW LLúLFHOH
SHQWUX HYDOXDUHD DVSHFWHORU WHPSHUDPHQWDOH GDF SHQWUX SULPHOH
SULPHD] HYDOX ULvQWHUPHQLGHIUHFYHQ SR]L LDXQHLSHUVRDQHGHD
OXQJXO YDULDELOHL HYDOXDWH HVWH vQ IXQF LH GH IUHFYHQ D FRPSRUWDPHQ
WXOXL vQUHJLVWUDW SHQWUX WHVWHOH FDUH LPSOLF DVSHFWH SVLKRIL]LRORJLFH
SDUDGLJPDHVWHDLQWHQVLW LLLWHPLLDFFHQWXHD] LQWHQVLWDWHDPDQLIHV
W ULORUWU V WXULLDYXWHvQYHGHUHÌQFRQVHFLQ GDWHOHSVLKRIL]LRORJLFH
DXRPDLPDUHOHJ WXU LQWULQVHF FXVW ULOHSVLKLFHGHFkWFXWU V WXULOH
SURSULX]LVHFLUFXPVFULLQGDULDWHPSHUDPHQWXOXL7U V WXULOHWHPSHUD
PHQWDOHVXQWWU V WXULDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLGDUU G FLQLOHORUVXQWvQPDUH
SDUWHvQELRORJLF
([LVW R PXOWLWXGLQH GH FKHVWLRQDUH FDUH vúL SURSXQ V P VRDUH
DVSHFWHOHWHPSHUDPHQWXOXLILHH[SOLFLWGHH[HPSOXFKHVWLRQDUXO666
± 6HQVDWLRQ 6HHNLQJ 6FDOH VFDOD GH F XWDUH D VHQ]D LHL DO OXL
=XFNHUPDQQ ILH LPSOLFLW SULQ QDWXUD WHRULHL DXWRULORU úL DP
VWXGLDWGHMDFKHVWLRQDUXO(3,DOOXL(\VHQFN
8QXO GLQWUH DXWRULL HXURSHQL UHFXQRVFX L GHMD GH GHFHQLL SHQWUX
VWXGLLOHVDOHH[SHULPHQWDOHúLLQWHUFXOWXUDOHSULYLQGWU V WXULOHWHPSHUD
PHQWDOHVDXDOHFRQILJXUD LLORUGHWU V WXULFUHDWRUGHFKHVWLRQDUHHVWH
SVLKRORJXOSRORQH]-DQ6WUHODXÄ7HRULDUHJODWRULHDWHPSHUDPHQWXOXL´
577DIRVWSUH]HQWDW vQPRGVLVWHPDWLFvQPRQRJUDILDVDGLQ
/D GDWD UHVSHFWLY WHRULHL OLSVLQGXL SDU LDO RSHUD LRQDOL]DUHD WHUPH
QLORU úL vQ FHD PDL PDUH P VXU LQVWUXPHQWXO VDX LQVWUXPHQWHOH GH
HYDOXDUHRVHULHGHVWXGLLH[SHULPHQWDOHúLSUH]HQW ULXOWHULRDUH6WUHODX
6WUHODX úL 3ORPLQ DX UHOXDW úL DGkQFLW GLIHULWHOH
DVSHFWHWHRUHWLFH
$XWRULL FRQVLGHU F WU V WXULOH WHPSHUDPHQWDOH VH UHIHU OD
FDUDFWHULVWLFLOH IRUPDOH DOH FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL FDUH VH HYLGHQ LD] vQ
FDUDFWHULVWLFLOHQLYHOXOXLHQHUJHWLFúLvQDVSHFWHWHPSRUDOH([LVW DVWIHO
GRX GLPHQVLXQL IXQGDPHQWDOH DOH WHPSHUDPHQWXOXL UHVSRQVDELOH GH
GLIHUHQ HOHvQFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHHQHUJHWLFHDOHFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLUHDFWL
YLWDWHúLDFWLYLWDWHD5HDFWLYLWDWHDVHUHOHY vQLQWHQVLWDWHDUHDF LLORUOD
VWLPXOL FX DVSHFWH FDUH FLUFXPVFULX VHQVLELOLWDWHD FDSDFLWDWHD GH
OXFUX$FWLYLWDWHDHVWHRWU V WXU WHPSHUDPHQWDO FDUHVHHYLGHQ LD]
vQ FDQWLWDWHD úL JDPD GH DF LXQL SUHOXDWH GH VXELHFW FRPSRUWDPHQWH
GLUHF LRQDWH VSUH VFRS $VSHFWXO WHPSRUDO DQWUHQHD] FDUDFWHULVWLFL
DOHWHPSHUDPHQWXOXLPRELOLWDWHDSHUVLVWHQ DUHFXUHQ DUHJXODULWDWHD
YLWH]D GH UHDF LH WHPSRXO UHDF LHL GLQWUH DFHVWHD GRDU PRELOLWDWHD D
SULPLWVXILFLHQWHFRQILUP ULHPSLULFH
&KHVWLRQDUXOFHLQL LDOVHQXPHD6WUHODX7HPSHUDPHQW,QYHQWRU\
67,SUH]LQW RYDULDQW 67,5UHY ]XWÌQ6WUHODXFRQVWUXLHúWH
)&%7L,QYHQWDUXOGHWHPSHUDPHQWSULYLQGFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHIRUPDOHDOH
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL
&RQVWUXF LD DFHVWRU FKHVWLRQDUH VH ED]HD] SH R VWUDWHJLH
UD LRQDOHPSLULF SHQWUX FDUH WHRULD OXL 3DYORY SULYLQG WLSXULOH GH
DFWLYLWDWHQHUYRDV VXSHULRDU DFRQVWLWXLWSXQFWXOGHSRUQLUH
&HOHWUHLVFDOHVXQWIRU DH[FLWD LHL6(IRU DLQKLEL LHL6,PREL
OLWDWHDSURSULHW LORUVLVWHPXOXLFHQWUDOQHUYRV%6FDOHOHSURSULX]LVH
VXQW IRUPDWH GLQ GHILQL LL DOH FRPSRUWDPHQWHORU úDSWH SHQWUX 6(
FLQFL SHQWUX 6, FLQFL SHQWUX 02 LDU % HVWH R VFDO VHFXQGDU FDUH
LQGLF SURSRU LDGLQWUH6(úL6,
&RQVWUXLQGFKHVWLRQDUXODXWRULL6WUHODXúLXOWHULRUvQFROD
ERUDUH FX $QJOHLWQHU DX FRQVLGHUDW SURSULHW LOH 61& FD WU V WXUL
JHQHUDOH FDUH VH SRW HYLGHQ LD vQ WRDWH WLSXULOH GH WHPSHUDPHQWH vQ
FDUDFWHULVWLFLOHPRWRULLvQDFWLYLWDWHDYHUEDO vQUHDF LLOHHPR LRQDOH
)RU DH[FLWD LHLHVWHGHILQLW FDRFDSDFLWDWHIXQF LRQDO D61&
FDUHVHPDQLIHVW vQDELOLWDWHDGHDVXSRUWDRVWLPXODUHLQWHQV VDXGH
OXQJ GXUDW I U D WUHFH OD LQKLEL LD GH SURWHF LH WUDQVPDUJLQDO
6XUVHOH GH VWLPXODUH VXQW PXOWLSOH SUHFXP VLWXD LL PHGLL VDUFLQL úL
VWLPXOL GLVFUH L FDUDFWHUL]D L SULQWUXQ QLYHO GDW GH YDULD LH QRXWDWH
LQWHQVLWDWHFRPSOH[LWDWHVHPQLILFD LHùLDFWLYLWDWHDSURSULHDSHUVRDQHL
DSDUHFDVXUV GHVWLPXODUH6WUHODX*HQHUDUHDVWLPXO ULL LQH
GHDFWLYLW LGLIHULWHFDUHSUH]LQW DVSHFWHYDULDWHGHDPHQLQ DUHULVF
WHQVLXQH úL DX XQ LPSDFW vQ FUHúWHUHD QLYHOXOXL GH DFWLYDUH FRQIRUP
VWXGLXOXLUHDOL]DWGH6WUHODX$QJOHLWQHU%DQWHOPDQ5XFK
6(VFDODGHIRU DH[FLWD LHLDIRVWFRQVWUXLW LQL LDOGLQLWHPL
FRQ LQXWXO LPSOLFkQG FRPSRQHQWH SULQ FDUH VH GHILQHúWH VLWXD LLOH
DPHQLQ WRDUHQXRSUHVFSHUVRDQHOHFXRvQDOW IRU GHH[FLWD LHGHODR
DF LXQH SODQLILFDW DQWHULRU WHQGLQ D GH D vQFHSH R DF LXQH vQ FRQGL LL
vQDOW VWLPXODWLYH SUHIHULQ D SHQWUX DFWLYLW L FDUH SUHVXSXQ ULVF OLSVD
WXOEXU ULORU HPR LRQDOH FkQG GHVI úRDU R DFWLYLWDWH FX vQF UF WXU
VRFLDO VDXIL]LF SHUIRUPDQ DQXGHVFUHúWHVHPQLILFDWLYvQVLWXD LLvQDOW
VWLPXODWLYH UH]LVWHQ D OD RERVHDO FkQG SHUVRDQD HVWH LPSOLFDW vQ
DFWLYLW L GH GXUDW VDX LQWHQVH FDSDFLWDWHD GH D UHDF LRQD DGHFYDW OD
WHQVLXQLHPR LRQDOHSXWHUQLFH
6,VFDODGHIRU DLQKLEL LHLGHILQLW OD3DYORYFDLQKLEL LHFRQ
GL LRQDW VH P VRDU SULQ DELOLWDWHD GH D PHQ LQH R VWDUH GH LQKLEL LH
FRQGL LRQDW &DLQGLFDWRUIXQGDPHQWDODSDUHSHUVLVWHQ DLQKLEL LHLFHVH
PDQLIHVW úL HYDOXHD] SULQ FDQWLWDWHD GH WLPS vQ FDUH VLVWHPXO QHUYRV
FHQWUDO 61& HVWH FDSDELO V U PkQ vQ VWDUHD GH LQKLEL LH ÌQ FRQ
VWUXLUHDVFDOHL6WUHODXDOXDWvQFRQVLGHUDUHFRPSRUWDPHQWHOHUHDF LLOH
SULQFDUHVHPDQLIHVW DFHVWHWLSXULGHLQKLEL LLFRQGL LRQDWHFDSDFLWDWHD
GH D VH UH LQH GH OD UHDF LL úL DFWH FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH FDUH QX VXQW GH]L
UDELOHVRFLDODúWHDSW I U GLILFXOWDWHvQGHSOLQLUHDXQHLDF LXQLFkQGHVWH
QHFHVDU vQWkU]LHUHD DFHVWHLD FDSDFLWDWHD GH D vQWUHUXSH R UHDF LH VDX
DF LXQH GDF HVWH QHFHVDU FKLDU GDF VH DIO vQ SOLQ GHVI úXUDUH D
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLUHVSHFWLYFDSDFLWDWHDGHDúLvQWkU]LDUHDF LDID GH
VWLPXOLL SUH]HQ L GDF FLUFXPVWDQ HOH R FHU FDSDFLWDWHD GH DúL UH LQH
H[SULPDUHDHPR LLORUODQHYRLH
02 PRELOLWDWHD SURFHVHORU QHUYRDVH HVWH GHILQLW FD DELOLWDWHD
61&GHDU VSXQGHDGHFYDWúLFkWPDLUDSLGSRVLELOODVFKLPE ULFRQ
WLQXLGHPHGLX6HGLVWLQJHGHÄODELOLWDWH´vQ HOHDV FDYLWH]DFXFDUH
VXQWJHQHUDWHúLRSULWHSURFHVHOH61&3VLKRPHWULFDFHDVW WU V WXU
WHPSHUDPHQWDO VH P VRDU vQ ODERUDWRU SULQ YLWH]DFXFDUHVXELHFWXO
HODERUHD] UHIOH[HFRQGL LRQDWHDGHFYDWHODVFKLPE ULOHYDORULLVHPQD
OXOXL VWLPXOLORU FRQGL LRQDOL 6FDOD VH UHIHU OD FRPSRQHQWH FDUH
GHILQHVFWU V WXUDUHDF LDDGHFYDW ODVFKLPE ULQHDúWHSWDWHGHPHGLX
DGDSWDUHDUDSLG ODQRLFLUFXPVWDQ HvPSUHMXU ULWUHFHUHDIDFLO GHOD
RDFWLYLWDWHODDOWDVFKLPEDUHDIDFLO DGLVSR]L LHLGHODVSHFWUXOSR]LWLY
OD FHO QHJDWLY vQ IXQF LH GH VHPQLILFD LD VLWXD LHL SUHIHULQ D SHQWUX
VLWXD LLFDUHVROLFLW UHDOL]DUHDVLPXOWDQ DXQRUDFWLYLW LGLIHULWH
7HVWXO67,5GHED] FRQ LQHLWHPLúLFRQVWLWXLHSXQFWXOGH
SOHFDUHSHQWUXFRQVWUXLUHDXQRUYDULDQWHVSHFLILFHOLPELLVDX ULLUHV
SHFWLYH ([LVW GLIHULWH YDULDQWH H[SHULPHQWDWH vQ *HUPDQLD 3RORQLD
68$5XVLD&RUHHDGH6XG,WDOLD*UHFLD)UDQ D-DSRQLD&KLQDúL
5RPkQLD 6WXGLXO GH H[SHULPHQWDUH D YDULDQWHL URPkQHúWL 67, 5 5
0LQXOHVFX D UH LQXW XQ WRWDO GH GH LWHPL FkWH SHQWUX
ILHFDUHGLQWUHFHOHWUHLVFDOHSULPDUH'DWHOHWHKQLFHDOHVFDOHORULQGLF
±VFDOD6(FRHIDOSKDPHGLDDEDWVW
±VFDOD6,FRHIDOSKDPHGLDDEDWVW
±VFDOD02FRHIDOSKDPHGLDDEDWVW
8QWRWDOGHVXELHF LYkUVWDPHGLHE UED L
&RUHOD LLVHPQLILFDWLYHVDXRE LQXWvQWUH6(úLVH[XOVXELHF LORU
&KHVWLRQDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH=XFNHUPDQ.XOPDQ=.34
'DWHGHVSUHWHRULDOXL=XFNHUPDQSULYLQGWU V WXUDGHED]
ÄF XWDUHDVHQ]D LHL´
7U V WXUDHVWHGHVFULV FDWHQGLQ GHDF XWDVHQ]D LLúLWU LULQRL
YDULDWHFRPSOH[HúLLQWHQVHSUHFXPúLYRLQ DGHDúLDVXPDULVFXULGH
GUDJXO XQRU DVWIHO GH WU LUL 3ULPD VFDO GH F XWDUHD VHQ]D LHL 6FDOD
VHQVDWLRQVHHNLQJ666DIRVWGH]YROWDW vQúLGHDWXQFLDXWRUXOD
VWXGLDWGLQFHvQFHPDLH[WLQVLPSOLFD LLOHSHQWUXSHUVRQDOLWDWHDXPDQ
SUHFXP úL FRQGL LD GH WU V WXU GH ED] $XWRUXO úLD ED]DW DFHVW FRQ
FHSW F XWDUHD VHQ]D LHL SH LGHHD H[LVWHQ HL XQRU GLIHUHQ H FRQVLVWHQWH
vQWUH RDPHQL vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH QLYHOHOH GH DFWLYDUH úL VWLPXODUH
WU V WXU JHQHUDO FDUH HUD VXEVLGLDU WXWXURU PRGDOLW LORU VHQ]RULDOH
&HUFHW ULOHFDUHDXFRQGXVODXQIDFWRUJHQHUDOúLGLIHUL LVXEIDFWRULODX
FRQYLQV F DFHDVW WU V WXU QX HUD QLFL vQJXVW úL QLFL QX DYHD XQ
VSHFLILFOHJDWGHRPRGDOLWDWHVDXDOWD
ÌQ SUH]HQW IDFWRULL GHVFULúL úL GHWHUPLQD L SULQ DQDOL] IDFWRULDO
GHVFULX GLIHULWH F L GH F XWDUH D VHQ]D LHL úL GH DFWLYDUH GH H[HPSOX
PHQWDO VHQ]RULDO SULQLQWHUDF LXQLVRFLDOHSULQVSRUWXULGHULVFULGL
FDWSULQDFWLYLW LFXQLYHOGHULVFÄ)LHFDUHLQGLYLGFRQVLGHU DXWRUXO
DUHFDUDFWHULVWLFQLYHOHRSWLPHGHVWLPXODUHúLDFWLYDUHSHQWUXDFWLYLWDWHD
FRJQLWLY DFWLYLWDWHDPRWRULHúLWRQXODIHFWLYSR]LWLY´S
6WXGLLOHGHGLFDWHUHOD LHLDFHVWHLWU V WXULFXDOWHGLPHQVLXQLDOH
SHUVRQDOLW LL SXQ vQ UHOLHI DVSHFWH OHJDWH GH QHYRLD GH QRXWDWH úL
VFKLPEDUH GHVFKLGHUHD OD H[SHULHQ FXULR]LWDWH GRPLQDQ D FRQFHQ
WU ULL SH XQ VFRS HYLWDUHD PRQRWRQLHL DVXPDUHD ULVFXOXL LPSXOVLYL
WDWHGDUúLFXDQXPLWHFDUDFWHULVWLFLFDUHGHVFULXSO FHUHDSHDFWLYLW L
FHPRWLYHD] ±KHGRQLVPXOúLMRFXOFDSDFLWDWHDGHDH[SULPDPkQLDúL
DJUHVLYLWDWHDQRQFRQIRUPLVPXO
5HIHULWRU OD FHUFHW ULOH UHDOL]DWH GH 6WUHODX DVXSUD WHPSH
UDPHQWXOXLF XWDUHDVHQ]D LHLDUHPXOWvQFRPXQFXXQVLVWHPQHUYRV
SXWHUQLF vQ WHUPHQLL DXWRUXOXL HXURSHDQ FX IRU D H[FLWD LHL úL FX
QRQUHDFWLYLWDWHD
=XFNHUPDQ.XKOPDQúL&DPDFVHOHFWHD] GHVFDOHGLQ
WHVWHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHSHQWUXDRE LQHFHOSX LQFkWHPDUNHULSHQWUX
FHLIDFWRULSHFDUHvLDYHDXvQYHGHUHDFWLYLVPVRFLDELOLWDWHLPSXO
VLYLWDWHVRFLDOL]DUHF XWDUHDVHQ]D LHLHPRWLYLWDWHJHQHUDO DQ[LHWDWH
RVWLOLWDWH úL GH]LUDELOLWDWH VRFLDO 6WXGLHUHD UH]XOWDWHORU SULQ DQDOL]D
IDFWRULDO D VFRV vQ HYLGHQ VROX LL FX úL IDFWRUL &HUFHW UL
UHOXDWHvQXWLOL]kQGGHVFDOHPDUNHULDXDMXQVODVROX LLSXWHU
QLFHGHVDXIDFWRUL
&KHVWLRQDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH.XOPDQ=XFNHUPDQ
&KHVWLRQDUXO HVWH FRQVWUXLW GH XQ JUXS GH DXWRUL FRQGXV GH
0=XFNHUPDQ.XKOPDQ'0-RLUHPDQ-7HWD3.UDIW0
'H]YROWDUHDWHVWXOXL=.34HVWHGHVFULV GHDXWRULvQWUXQDUWLFRO
SXEOLFDWvQvQFDUHVHSUH]LQW PRGHOXOFHORUPDULIDFWRULDS UXW
GLQ DQDOL]D IDFWRULDO D VFDOHORU FRQVLGHUDWH D P VXUD GLPHQVLXQL GH
ED] DOHSHUVRQDOLW LLLQFOXVLYDVSHFWHGHWLSWHPSHUDPHQWDO$XWRULLvO
FRQVLGHU XQ PRGHO %LJ )LYH DOWHUQDWLY OD FHO GHULYDW SVLKROLQJYLVWLF
0DMRULWDWHDVFDOHORUXWLOL]DWHvQFHUFHWDUHDIRVWXWLOL]DW vQVWXGLLGHWLS
SVLKRELRORJLF3ULPDVHOHF LHGHLWHPLDIRVWI FXW vQXUPDFRUHOD LLORU
LWHPLORUFXVFRUXULOHODIDFWRULGHULYD LGLQDQDOL]DIDFWRULDO DVFDOHORU
vPSUHXQ FXRVFDO GHGH]LUDELOLWDWHVRFLDO ,WHPLLDXIRVWVHOHFWD LSH
ED]D FRUHOD LLORU FHORU PDL vQDOWH FX XQXO GLQWUH IDFWRUL úL VLPXOWDQ
DYkQGvQF UF WXULUHODWLYPLQLPHFXGH]LUDELOLWDWHDVRFLDO ,WHPLLSUHOL
PLQDUL GLQWUH FDUH PXO L DX IRVW UHVFULúL DX IRVW DQDOL]D L IDFWRULDO vQ
FDGUXO XQXL QRX ORW GH VXELHF L QRUPDOL SHQWUX D GHWHUPLQD VFDOHOH GH
ED] SHQWUX=.34GLQFHLGHLWHPLDXDYXWvQF UF WXULvQDOWHFX
IDFWRUXOSHQWUXFDUHDXIRVWDWULEXL LGHúLXQXOFDUHDDYXWRvQF UF WXU
ULGLFDW SH XQ DO GRLOHD IDFWRU D IRVW HOLPLQDW $VWIHO DX U PDV GH
LWHPLGHFRQ LQXW$XIRVWDG XJD LSHQWUXRVFDO GHÄUDULWDWH´PH
QLW DVHPQDOL]DWHQGLQ DGHDGLVLPXODVDXGHDU VSXQGHQHJOLMHQW
'HVFULHUHDVFDOHORUWHVWXOXL
,PSXOVLYH 6HQVDWLRQ 6HHNLQJ ,PS66 LWHPL F XWDUHD
VHQ]D LHL LPSXOVLYLWDWHOLSV GHSODQLILFDUH
)DFWRUL]DUHD D FRQGXV OD IDFWRUL ,WHPLL GH LPSXOVLYLWDWH GH
VFULXROLSV GHSODQLILFDUHúLRWHQGLQ GHDDF LRQDLPSXOVLYI U V
VHJkQGHDVF
,WHPLLGHF XWDUHDVHQ]D LHLGHVFULXRQHYRLHJHQHUDO GHH[FLWDUH
RSUHIHULQ SHQWUXVLWXD LLLPSUHGLFWLELOHúLSULHWHQLúLQHYRLDGHVFKLP
EDUH úL QRXWDWH 18 DSDUH QLFL R PHQ LRQDUH D DFWLYLW LORU VSHFLILFH
SUHFXPE XWXUDXWLOL]DUHDGURJXOXLVH[XDOLWDWHVSRUWXULULVFDQWH
1HXURWLFLVP$Q[LHW\6FDOH1$Q[LWHPL
,WHPLL GHVFULX R FRQGL LH GH WXOEXUDUH HPR LRQDO WHQVLXQH
vQJULMRUDUH WHDP LQGHFL]LH REVHVLY OLSVD GH vQFUHGHUH vQ VLQH úL
VHQVLELOLWDWHODFULWLF $QDOL]DIDFWRULDO LQGLF XQVLQJXUIDFWRU
$JJUHVLRQ+RVWLOLW\$JJ+RVWLWHPL
-XP WDWH GLQWUH LWHPL GHVFULX WHQGLQ D VSUH H[SULPDUH YHUEDO
DJUHVLY DO LLLQGLF XQFRPSRUWDPHQWEUXWDOQHFKLE]XLWVDXDQWLVRFLDO
U ]EXQ WRUúLGLVSUH XLWRUXQWHPSHUDPHQWYLXúLPDQLIHVWkQGQHU EGDUH
ID GHFHLODO L6FDODHVWHRPRJHQ DQDOL]DLQGLFkQGXQVLQJXUIDFWRU
$FWLYLW\$FWLWHPLDFWLYLVPJHQHUDO HIRUWvQPXQF
6FDODFXSULQGHGRX JUXSHGHLWHPLSULPXOVHUHIHU ODQHYRLDGH
DFWLYLWDWH QHU EGDUH úL QHOLQLúWH FkQG QX DUH QLPLF GH I FXW DO GRLOHD
LQGLF SUHIHULQ D SHQWUX PXQF JUHD úL SURYRFDWLY úL PXOW HQHUJLH
LQYHVWLW vQPXQF úLDOWHVDUFLQL
6RFLDELOLWDWH 6\ LWHPL SHWUHFHUL úL SULHWHQL L]RODUH
LQWROHUDQ
$QDOL]D IDFWRULDO LQGLF XQ JUXS GH LWHPL FDUH GHVFULX SO FHUHD
SHQWUXSHWUHFHULPDULLQWHUDF LXQLODSHWUHFHULúLGHDDYHDPXO LSULHWHQL
$OGRLOHDIDFWRURE LQXWLQGLF RLQWROHUDQ SHQWUXL]RODUHVRFLDO
úLSO FHUHDSHQWUXDFWLYLW LVROLWDUHODLQWURYHU L
5DULWDWHD LWHPL 1X FRQVWLWXLH R VFDO WHPSHUDPHQWDO GDU
SRDWH IL IRORVLW SHQWUX D HOLPLQD VXELHF LL FDUH DX U VSXQV I U JULM
SHQWUX DGHY U ,WHPLL VFDOHL VXQW vQ PDMRULWDWHVFRUD LÄ$GHY UDW´LDU
FRQ LQXWXULOHORUVXQWGH]LUDELOHVRFLDOVDXH[DJHUDWHúLLPSUREDELOGHD
IL FRQVLGHUDWH ÄDGHY UDW´ GH RULFH RP 0DMRULWDWHD VFRUXULORU VXQW
VDXGRDUGLQWUHVXELHF LVFRUHD] SHVWHSXQFWHGHFLUH]XOWDWXO
SRDWHILXWLOL]DWFDROLPLW SHQWUXvQUHJLVWU ULOHFXVHPQGHvQWUHEDUH
,QYHQWDUXO6HQVDWLRQ6HHNLQJ$UQHW$,66
7HVWXO OXL $UQHWW $,66 7KH $UQHWW ,QYHQWRU\ RI 6HQVDWLRQ
6HHNLQJP VRDU RGLPHQVLXQHDWHPSHUDPHQWXOXLFRQFHSWXDOL]DW GH
0=XFNHUPDQQ6HQVDWLRQ6HHNLQJ66$FHDVW GLPHQVLXQHDúDFXP
R UH LQH WHVWXO SUH]HQW HVWH GHVFULSWLELO vQ HVHQ FD QHYRLD SHQWUX
H[SHULHQ H úL VHQ]D LL YDULDWH QRL FRPSOH[H úL GRULQ D GH DúL DVXPD
ULVFXUL IL]LFH úL VRFLDOH GH GUDJXO XQRU DVHPHQHD H[SHULHQ H
&HUFHW ULOH DX GHPRQVWUDW UHOD LD GLQWUH 66 úL FRPSRUWDPHQWHOH GH
ULVFSUDFWLFLGHFRQGXVSHULFXORDVHRGLYHUVLWDWHGHH[SHULHQ HVH[XDOH
XWLOL]DUHD DOFRROXOXL XWLOL]DUHD GURJXULORU LPSOLFDUHD vQ LQIUDF LXQL
PLQRUH %D]D ELRORJLF D IRVW GHWHUPLQDW SULQWUR VHULH GH FHUFHW UL
GHVFRSHULQGXVH FRUHOD LL vQWUH WHQGLQ D GH 66 úL FUHúWHUHD U VSXQ
VXULORU QHXURORJLFH SUHFXP úL QLYHOHOH FUHVFkQGH GH WHVWRVWHURQ 6D
FHUFHWDWGHDVHPHQHDUROXOVRFLDOL] ULLvQPRGXODUHDWHQGLQ HLELROR
JLFHQDWXUDOHGHDF XWDVHQ]D LL
&HOH GRX VXEVFDOH DOH FKHVWLRQDUXOXL LQWHQVLWDWH úL QRXWDWH DX
IRVWGH]YROWDWHSHED]DWHRULHLGHPDLVXVúLLWHPLLDXIRVWVHOHFWD LSH
ED]DDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOH
6DXGH]YROWDWFHUFHW ULFDUHDXGHPRQVWUDWF FHLGRLIDFWRULDL
66SDUV FRUHOH]HFXFRPSRUWDPHQWHVRFLDOHSUHFXPDWLQJHUHDXQRU
SR]L LL GH OLGHU LQWHQVLWDWHD FUHVFXW D H[SHULHQ HL WU LWH IHOXO
SURIHVLXQLLDOHVHGHLQGLYLGSURIHVLLOHGLIHU GLQSHUVSHFWLYDJUDGXOXL
GHQRXWDWHúLLQWHQVLWDWHSHFDUHvOLPSOLF UHDOL] ULOHvQDOWHGLQXQHOH
GRPHQLLSO FHUHDSHQWUXLQWHQVLWDWHSRDWHILUHIOHFWDW vQDELOLWDWHDGH
DU PkQHHFKLOLEUDWvQVLWXD LLvQDOWVWUHVDQWHLDUGRULQ DSHQWUXQRXWDWH
SRDWHILH[SULPDW FDRJkQGLUHFUHDWLY GLYHUJHQW
(;7,1'(5,
,QYHQWDUXO$,66LWHPLLJULODúLLQWHUSUHWDUHD
7HVWXO VH SRDWH OXFUD LQGLYLGXDO VDX FROHFWLY $GPLQLVWUDUHD
GXUHD] PD[LPPLQXWH
9 UXJ P SHQWUX ILHFDUH vQWUHEDUH V LQGLFD L FDUH WLS GH
U VSXQVYLVHDSOLF FHOPDLELQH
Ä0 GHVFULHFHOPDLELQH´
Ä0 GHVFULHUHODWLY´
Ä1XP GHVFULHSUHDELQH´
Ä1XP GHVFULHGHORF´
,WHPLLWHVWXOXL
ÌPLLPDJLQH]FHLQWHUHVDQWDUILV P F V WRUHVFFXFLQHYDGLQWUR
DU VWU LQ
&kQGDSDHIRDUWHUHFHSUHIHUV QXLQWUXvQHDFKLDUGDF HR]L
GRJRUkWRDUH
'DF WUHEXLHV DúWHSWODRFRDG OXQJ GHRELFHLDPU EGDUH
&kQGDVFXOWPX]LF vPLSODFHV ILHGDW WDUH
&kQG SRUQHVF vQWURF O WRULHvPLSODFHV PLIDFFkWPDLSX LQH
SODQXULGLQDLQWHúLV LDXOXFUXULOHDúDFXPYLQ
1X P XLW OD ILOPHOH GHVSUH FDUH VH VSXQH F VXQW vQIULFRú WRDUH
VDXFXPXOWVXVSDQV
&UHGF HVWHGLVWUDFWLYúLH[FLWDQWV P SURGXFVDXV YRUEHVFvQ
ID DXQXLJUXS
'DF PDúGXFHvQWUXQSDUFGHGLVWUDF LLPLDUSODFHV PHUJSH
UROHVDXDOWHYHKLFXOHUDSLGH
0LDUSODFHV F O WRUHVFvQORFXULVWU LQHúLvQGHS UWDWH
1LFLRGDW QX PLDU IDFH SO FHUH V MRF MRFXUL GH QRURF SH EDQL
FKLDUGDF PLDúSXWHDSHUPLWHDFHVWOXFUX
0LDUILSO FXWV ILXXQXOGLQWUHH[SORUDWRULLXQXLS PkQWQHFXQRVFXW
ÌPLSODFHXQILOPvQFDUHVXQWRPXO LPHGHH[SOR]LLúLXUP ULULFX
PDúLQL
1XPLSODFPkQF UXULOHH[WUHPGHILHUELQ LúLFRQGLPHQWDWH
ÌQJHQHUDOOXFUH]PDLELQHVXEWHQVLXQH
ÌPLSODFHDGHVHDV DPWHOHYL]RUXOVDXUDGLRXOGHVFKLVvQWLPSFH
IDFDOWFHYDFXPDUILFLWLWVDXFXU HQLH
$UILLQWHUHVDQWGHY ]XWXQDFFLGHQWGHPDúLQ
&kQGHúWLODUHVWDXUDQWFUHGF HVWHFHOPDLELQHV FRPDQ]LXQIHO
GHPkQFDUHFXQRVFXW
ÌPLSODFHFHVLPWFkQGVWDXODPDUJLQHDXQXLORFvQDOWúLSULYHVFvQMRV
'DF DUILSRVLELOV YL]LWH]OXQDVDXRDOW SODQHW SHJUDWLVDúIL
SULQWUHSULPLLFDUHVDUvQVFULH
ÌPLGDXVHDPDFkWGHH[FLWDQWWUHEXLHV ILHV WHDIOLvQSOLQ OXSW
vQWLPSXOXQXLU ]ERL
*ULOD
6FDODGHQRXWDWH
6FDODGHLQWHQVLWDWH
3XQFWDMH $ % & ' SHQWUX LWHPLL FKHLD
HVWHLQYHUVDW
3HQWUXVFDODvQvQWUHJLPHPLQLPXPSXQFWHPD[LPXP
SXQFWH
3HQWUXDFRQVWLWXLXQHWDORQVHFDOFXOHD] PHGLDúLDEDWHUHDVWDQ
GDUGSHQWUXvQWUHJORWXOGHVXELHF LSHFDUHDSOLFD LWHVWXO
6HDSOLF IRUPXOD7SHQWUXHWDORQDUHDvQQRUPHVWDQGDUG
7 DEDWHUHDVWDQGDUG[QRWDEUXW PHGLD
$VWIHO VH SRDWH YHGHD SHQWUX ILHFDUH VXELHFW GDF QRWD VD HVWH
GHDVXSUDVDXGHGHVXEWXOPHGLHLvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHvQWUHDJDGLPHQVLXQH
VDXLPSXOVXOVSUHQRXWDWHVDXLPSXOVXOVSUHLQWHQVLWDWHDVWLPXOXOXL
7HVWGHHYDOXDUHDFXQRúWLQ HORU
&XP VH SRW GHILQL SULQFLSDOHOH FDUDFWHULVWLFL DOH WHPSHUDPHQWXOXL
vQUDSRUWFXFRPSRUWDPHQWXO"
(VWH FKHVWLRQDUXO *XLOIRUG =XFNHUPDQ XQ FKHVWLRQDU GH WHPSHUD
PHQWVWULFWRVHQVX"
&DUH VXQW VFDOHOH FKHVWLRQDUXOXL *= HQXPHUD L FHO SX LQ VFDOH
GLQFHOH"
&DUH HVWH YL]LXQHD DVXSUD WHPSHUDPHQWXOXL FDUH OD FRQGXV SH
6WUHODXODFRQVWUXLUHD675"
&HP VRDU FHOHWUHLVFDOHDOHWHVWXOXL"
&HFDUDFWHULVWLF DWHPSHUDPHQWXOXLHVWHVWXGLDW úLGHILQLW GH0
=XFNHUPDQ"
&DUHVXQWFHLPDULIDFWRULWHPSHUDPHQWDOLFXSULQúLvQ=.34"
&DUH VXQW FHL GRL VXEIDFWRUL DL WU V WXULL WHPSHUDPHQWDOH HYDOXD L
GH$,66"
%LEOLRJUDILH
$QJOHLWQHU $ 3HUVRQDOLW\ 3V\FKRORJ\ 7UHQGV DQG 'HYHORSPHQW
Ä(XURS-RXUQRI3HUVRQDOLW\´
$QJOHLWQHU $ 6WUHODX - 3V\FKRPHWULF 0HDVXUHV RI 3DYORYLDQ
7HPSHUDPHQW7UDLWVDQG2EMHFWLYH3HUVRQDOLW\7HVWVD&RPHEDFNIRU
&DWWHOO+\SRWKHVHVvQ)RUWVFKULWWHGHU'LIIHUHQWLHOOHQ3V\FKRORJLHXQG
3V\FKRORJLVFKHQ'LDJQRVWLF'%DUWXVVHN0$PHODQJHGV+RJUHIH
*|WWLQJHQ
$UQHWW - 6HQVDWLRQ 6HHNLQJ $ 1HZ &RQFHSWXDOLVDWLRQ DQG D 1HZ
6FDOH3HUVRQDOLW\DQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHVIHEU
0LQXOHVFX06WUHODX-$QJOHLWQHU$&RQFHSHUHDúLH[SHULPHQWDUHD
YDULDQWHL URPkQHúWL D WHVWXOXL GH P VXUDUH D FDUDFWHULVWLFLORU ED]DOH
HQHUJHWLFHDSHUVRQDOLW LL675,&RQIHULQ DQD LRQDO GHSVLKRORJLH
6WUHODX-7HPSHUDPHQW3HUVRQDOLW\$FWLYLW\$FDGHPLF3UHVV/RQGRQ
6WUHODX-HG7HPSHUDPHQWDO%DVLVRI%HKDYLRXU6ZHWVDQG=HLWOLQJHU
/LVVH
6WUHODX - 7KH UHJXODWLYH 7KHRU\ RI 7HPSHUDPHQW DV D 5HVXOW RI
(DVW:HVW ,QIOXHQFH vQ =XFNHUPDQ 0 6HQVDWLRQ VHHNLQJ
%H\RQGWKH2SWLPDO/HYHORI$URXVDO(UOEDXP+LOOVGDOH1HZ-HUVH\
6WUHODX - =DZDG]NL % 7KH )RUPDO &KDUDFWHULVWLFV RI %HKDYLRXU
7HPSHUDPHQW ,QYHQWRU\ )&%7, 7KHRUHWLFDO $VVXPSWLRQV DQG 6FDOH
&RQVWUXFWLRQÄ(XURS-RXUQRI3HUVRQDOLW\´
6WUHODX - $QJOHLWQHU $ HGV ([SORUDWLRQV LQ 7HPSHUDPHQW
,QWHUQDWLRQDO3HUVSHFWLYHVRQ7KHRU\DQG0HDVXUHPHQW3OHQXP3UHVV
1HZ<RUN
6WUHODX-(OLDV]$7HPSHUDPHQW5LVNIDFWRUVIRU7\SH$%HKDYLRXU
3DWWHUQ LQ $GROHVFHQWV vQ 3UHYHQWLRQ DQG HDUO\ ,QWHUYHQWLRQV :%
&DUH\6&0F'HYLWWHGV%UXQQHU0D]HO3XEO1HZ<RUN
=XFNHUPDQ 0 .XKOPDQ '0 -RLUHPDQ - 7HWD 3 .UDIW 0 $
FRPSDULVRQ RI WKH WKUHH VWUXFWXUDO PRGHOV IRU SHUVRQDOLW\ 7KH ELJ
WKUHHWKHELJILYHDQGWKHDOWHUQDWLYHILYHÄ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\DQG
6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´±
=XFNHUPDQ 0 %HKDYLRUDO ([SUHVVLRQV DQG %LRVRFLDO %DVHV RI
6HQVDWLRQ6HHNLQJ&DPEULGJH8QLY3UHVV
*/26$5
$GDSW ULFDUDFWHULVWLFHFRQ LQXWXODFHVWRUDHVWHIRUPDWDWkWGHSHUVR
QDOLWDWHFkWúLGHFXOWXU DGDSW ULOHQHILLQGDOWFHYDGHFkWFDUDFWHULVWLFLOH
GREkQGLWH FH FRQVWLWXLH H[SUHVLD IHQRWLSLF D WU V WXULORU 5HSUH]LQW
GHFL DFHOH RELFHLXUL DWLWXGLQL GHSULQGHUL YDORUL PRWLYH UROXUL UHOD LL
FDUH GHILQHVF ÄLGHQWLWDWHD FRQWH[WXDOL]DW ´ SHUVRDQD SXV vQ FRQWH[WXO
LQWHUUHOD LLORUvQFDUHVDIRUPDWúLHYROXHD] ÌQWUHWHQGLQ HOHED]DOHúL
DGDSW ULOHFDUDFWHULVWLFHFHFRQVWLWXLHH[SUHVLDGLUHFW DSHUVRQDOLW LLDX
DYXW ORF úL DX ORF PHUHX SURFHVH GLQDPLFH UHVSRQVDELOH GH XQ DQXPH
L]RPRUILVP ,QGLYLGXO LQWU vQ YLD FX DQXPLWH GLVSR]L LL SDUWLFXODUH
F URUDOLVHG FXORDUHORFDO úLVHQVSULQFXOWXUDSUHYDOHQW SULQLQWHU
PHGLXOSURFHVHORUGHGH]YROWDUHFDUHFUHHD] DFHVWL]RPRUILVP
DJUHDELOLWDWHD FD GLPHQVLXQH SUHJQDQW LQWHUSHUVRQDO $VSHFWHOH
FHQWUDOH DOH IDFWRUXOXL VXQW DOWUXLVPXO XQ FRPSRUWDPHQW FRRSHUDQW
VLPSDWHWLF úL GH DMXWRUDUH D DOWRUD FX WHQGLQ D GH DL FRQVLGHUD SH
FHLODO LODIHOGHVLPSDWHWLFLúLJDWDV OHRIHUHVSULMLQXO
DQDOL]D SURILOXOXL SURILOXO XQHL SHUVRDQH vQ VHQVXO XQHL SUH]HQW UL
JHQHUDOH DWU V WXULORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHúLDFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUSUH]HQWHOD
DFHDSHUVRDQ UHODWLYODXQVHWGHQRUPHFRQVWUXLWHID GHRSRSXOD LH
GHUHIHULQ $QDOL]DSRDWHOXDIRUPDXQXLSURILOFDDWDUHvQFDUHGDWHOH
VXQWSUH]HQWDWHvQIRUP JUDILF FDvQFD]XOWHVWHORU&3,VDX003,
VDXSRDWHDYHDIRUPDPDLJHQHUDO DXQHLSUH]HQW ULDFDUDFWHULVWLFLORU
LQGLYLGXOXLVDXDWU V WXULORUvQIRUP VXPDU '3
DQDOL] GH LWHP DQDOL]D vQ GHWDOLX D LWHPLORU LQGLYLGXDOL DL XQXL WHVW
VDXFKHVWLRQDUFXVFRSXOGHDHYDOXDILGHOLWDWHDúLYDOLGLWDWHDILHF UXLD
DQDOL]HOHVHFHQWUHD] SHFRQ LQXWXOLWHPLORUúLSHIRUPDDFHVWRUDúLVH
SRW GHVI úXUD FDQWLWDWLY VDX FDOLWDWLY VWDELOLQG FkW FRQWULEXLH HIHFWLY
ILHFDUHODILGHOLWDWHDJHQHUDO úLYDOLGLWDWHDWHVWXOXL$QDOL]DFDOLWDWLY
VHSUHRFXS úLGHDVSHFWHSUHFXPDPELJXLWDWHDGLILFXOWDWHDHWF
DQDOL] IDFWRULDO PHWRG VWDWLVWLF FH vQFHDUF V SXQ vQ HYLGHQ
IDFWRULL FRPXQL XQXL DQVDPEOX GH YDULDELOH FDUH DX vQWUH HOH DQXPLWH
FRUHOD LL $QDOL]D UH]XOWDWHORU RE LQXWH SULQ DGPLQLVWUDUHD PDL PXOWRU
WHVWHPHQWDOH
DQDQFDVW GXS .DKQ WHUPHQ XWLOL]DW SHQWUX VLPSWRPDWRORJLD
REVHVLY FRPSXOVLY $YDQWDMXO XWLOL] ULL HL HVWH F VH HYLW V VH LP
SOLFHvQPRGHURQDWRFRQH[LXQHvQWUHDFHVWWLSGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHúLWXOEX
U ULOH REVHVLRQDOH vQ VHQV GLDJQRVWLF WLS GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH KLSHUH[DFW
FDUH VH GLVWLQJH SULQ OLSVD FDSDFLW LL GH UHIXODUH FRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWH úL
VHULR]LWDWHH[DJHUDWH
DQRUPDOFDUHVHvQGHS UWHD] GHQRUP VDXQRUPDOSRDWHVHPQLILFD
GHYLD LLSXUFDQWLWDWLYHvQDQDOL]HOHVWDWLVWLFHGDUúLPRGHOHGHFRPSRU
WDPHQWGHYLDQWHDOHLQGLYL]LORU'LILFXOWDWHDGHOLPLW ULLQRUPDOXOXLGH
DQRUPDOSRUQHúWHGLQWHQGLQ DGHDDYHDJUDQL HGHQRUPDOLWDWHGHILQLWH
GH XQD VDX DOWD GLQWUH WHRULLOH DVXSUD SHUVRQDOLW LL GH H[HPSOX vQ
YL]LXQHD SVLKDQDOLWLF FODVLF KRPRVH[XDOLWDWHD HVWH SULYLW FD DQRU
PDOLWDWH FRQWUDU WHRULLORU SULYLQG vQY DUHD VRFLDO ([LVW R WHQGLQ
GHDXWLOL]DWHUPHQLSUHFXPQHDGDSWDUHQHDFRPRGDUHGHYLDQWvQOHJ
WXU FX HYDOXDUHD XQXL LQGLYLG FRQVLGHUDW UHVSHFWLY vO HYDOX P vQ
IXQF LHGHP VXUDvQFDUHSXWHPYRUELGHXQFRPSRUWDPHQWDGDSWDWLY
úLQXSHQWUXDOHWLFKHWDSXUúLVLPSOX'3
DWLWXGLQL&DWWHOODUHRYL]LXQHPDLODUJ DVXSUDDWLWXGLQLORUFRQVLGHUvQG
F HOH UHSUH]LQW DWkW LQWHUHVHOH RSLQLL XQXL LQGLYLG FkW úL HPR LLOH úL
FRPSRUWDPHQWXOV XID GHRSHUVRDQ RELHFWVDXHYHQLPHQW
ERUGHUOLQHWHUPHQXOHVWHFHOPDLIUHFYHQWXWLOL]DWSHQWUXDGLDJQRVWLFD
RJDP ODUJ GHWXOEXU ULGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHúLUHWDUGPHQWDOGLDJQRVWLFXO
GHWXOEXUDUHGHWLSERUGHUOLQHVHUHIHU ODVLWXD LDXQHLSHUVRDQHFDUHvQ
PRGFURQLFÄWU LHúWHSHJUDQL ´vQWUHRIXQF LRQDUHQRUPDO DGDSWDWLY
úLRGL]DELOLWDWHSVLKLF UHDO 'HRELFHLvQFRPSRUWDPHQWDSDURVHULHGH
LQVWDELOLW LI U WU V WXULFODUHGHH[HPSOXUHOD LLOHLQWHUSHUVRQDOHWLQG
V ILHLQVWDELOHDIHFWHOHVHVFKLPE GUDPDWLFúLLQDGHFYDWLPDJLQHDGH
VLQHSRDWHILWXOEXUDW vQPRGFXUHQWDSDULHúLULGHIXULHDFWHLPSXOVLYH
FDUHDMXQJV ILHDXWRGLVWUXFWLYHFRPSXOVLDVSUHMRFXULGHQRURFVWDUH
GHDSDWLHHQGHPLF HWF
FDWHJRULL QRVRORJLFH VH UHIHU OD FDWHJRULL GH EROL U G FLQD FXYkQ
WXOXLSURYLQHGLQJUHDF FXVHQVXOGHERDO QRVRORJLDHVWHRGHVFULHUH
VLVWHPDWLF úLRFODVLILFDUHDEROLORU
FKHVWLRQDUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHvQVHQVODUJXQVHWGHvQWUHE ULLWHPLFDUH
VHUHIHU ODRWHP DVSHFWDOSHUVRQDOLW LLVDXXQJUXSGHDVSHFWHvQYH
FLQDWHDFHVWHLDvQVHQVVSHFLILFXQLQVWUXPHQWGHHYDOXDUHVWDQGDUGL]DW
FOLYDMSURFHVSULQFDUHRVWUXFWXU vúLSLHUGHXQLFLWDWHDúLHVWHvQORFXLW
SULQGRX VWUXFWXULSDU LDOHVDXPDLPXOWHÌQSVLKLDWULHHVWHVLQRQLPFX
GLVRFLHUHDGHGXEODUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL
FOXVWHU vQ DQDOL]D IDFWRULDO GHQXPHúWH XQ JUXS GH YDULDELOH FDUH DX
FRUHOD LLPDLvQDOWHXQDFXFHDODOW GHFkWID GHDOWHYDULDELOHvQVHQV
ODUJGHQXPHúWHRULFHJUXSGHRELHFWHVDXHYHQLPHQWHFDUHVXELHFWLY
SDUV DLE RDSDUWHQHQ FRPXQ
FRPSRUWDPHQW LQWHUSHUVRQDO SHQWUX *RXJK SHUVRQDOLWDWHD XQXL
LQGLYLGVHUHOHY vQFDGUXOFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLDFHVWXLDvQUHOD LDFXDOW
VDXDOWHSHUVRDQH
FRQFHSWHSRSXODUHWHUPHQSULQFDUH*RXJKVHUHIHU ODFXYLQWHOHSH
FDUHRDPHQLLRELúQXL LOHXWLOL]HD] FXUHQWSHQWUXDVHUHIHULODHYDOX UL
VDXGHVFULHULGHFRPSRUWDPHQW
FRQGL LRQDUH vQ JHQHUH FHHD FH GHSLQGH GH DOWFHYD ÌQ VWXGLLOH GH
FRQGL LRQDUH VH GHVFULH XQ U VSXQV FDUH D IRVW I FXW GHSHQGHQW GH XQ
VWLPXOLQL LDOQHXWUX7HUPHQXORULJLQDODOOXL3DYORYGHUHIOH[FRQGL
LRQDWHVWHGHQXPLWvQSUH]HQWU VSXQVFRQGL LRQDW
FRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWHGRPHQLXODFHVWXLIDFWRUVHUHIHU ODDXWRFRQWUROVXE
DVSHFWXOFDSDFLW LLGHDXWRRUJDQL]DUHvQGHSOLQLUHDvQGDWRULULORUSOD
QLILF ULLVXQWSHUVRDQHFDUHvúLGHILQHVFúLXUP UHVFVFRSXULOHKRW UkWH
úLFXYRLQ DIRUPDW
FRQWLQXXPWHUPHQFDUHVHUHIHU ODGLPHQVLXQLOHSHFDUHSRDWHYDULD
RFDUDFWHULVWLF GLVWLQFW GHFRPSRUWDPHQWvQWUHGRX H[WUHPHVDXSROL
GH H[HPSOX FRQWLQXXPXO H[WUDYHUVLH LQWURYHUVLH VH DSOLF DWkW
XQRUGLPHQVLXQLIL]LFHFkWúLXQRUGLPHQVLXQLVXELHFWLYHFDUHSRWIDFH
RELHFWXOXQHLHYDOX ULGHJUDGLHQW
FRQYHUVLHWUDQVIRUPDUHDXQHLHPR LLDXQXLHIHFWUHIXODWvQPDQLIHVWDUH
GHSDWRORJLHVRPDWLF
GHIHQV UHDF LHRELúQXLW WLSLF LQFRQúWLHQW QDWXUDO GHDXWRSURWHF LH
ID GHDQ[LHWDWH
GHVFKLGHUHHOHPHQWHOHFDUHDSDUvQFHUFHW ULOHHPSLULFHDOHOXL&RVWDúL
0F&UDH OHJDWH GH DFHVW VXSHUIDFWRU VXQW LPDJLQD LD DFWLY VHQVLEL
OLWDWHDHVWHWLF DWHQ LDSHQWUXYLD úLVLP PLQWHOHLQWHULRDUHSUHIHULQ D
SHQWUX YDULHWDWH FXULR]LWDWHD LQWHOHFWXDO LQGHSHQGHQ D vQ PRGXO GH D
JkQGL OXFUXULOH $FHVWH DVSHFWH QX VH DVRFLD] vQ PRG QHFHVDU FX
HGXFD LDVDXFXLQWHOLJHQ DJHQHUDO GHDFHHDDXWRULLSUHIHU GHQXPLUHD
GHÄGHVFKLGHUH´
GHYLDQ RULFH PRGHO GH FRPSRUWDPHQW FDUH HVWH HYLGHQW GLIHULW GH
VWDQGDUGHOH DFFHSWDWH vQ FDGUXO VRFLHW LL GHVLJXU GHILQL LD FRQ LQH
SXWHUQLFH DFFHQWH GLQ GRPHQLXO HWLFPRUDO úL IRORVLUHD WHUPHQXOXL VH
IDFHVSHFLILFkQGIRUPDUHVSHFWLY GHGHYLDQ '3
GH]YROWDUH VH UHIHU VSHFLILF SHQWUX SHUVRQDOLWDWH OD SURFHVXO GH
VFKLPE UL FDUH DUH ORF GHD OXQJXO vQWUHJLL YLH L D LQGLYLGXOXL SULQ
VFKLPEDUH QH UHIHULP vQ DFHVW FRQWH[W OD PRGLILF UL FDOLWDWLYH VDX
FDQWLWDWLYHvQVWUXFWXU úLIXQF LRQDUH'3
GH]YROW ULSDUDQRLFHH[SUHVLHDXQHLOHJLSVLKRORJLFHSRWULYLWF UHLD
WHQGLQ HOH DIHFWLYH VXSXVH RVFLO ULL vQWUH GRL SROL FUHVF vQ DVHPHQHD
P VXU vQFkWVHQWLPHQWHQHvQVHPQDWHVHWUDQVIRUP vQDIHFWHSURIXQGH
GLDJQRVWLF GLIHUHQ LDO GLDJQRVWLFXO FDUH DUH FD VFRS GLIHUHQ LHUHD
vQWUHGRX VDXPDLPXOWHEROLVDXWXOEXU ULVLPLODUHSHFDUHOHSUH]LQW
XQLQGLYLG([WLQVDDMXQVV ILHIRORVLWSHQWUXDGLVWLQJHvQWUHFRQGL LL
GHPXOWHIHOXULvQSVLKRORJLDVRFLDO úLvQVWXGLXOSHUVRQDOLW LL
GLPHQVLXQH RULFH WU V WXU SVLKRORJLF FH SRDWH IDFH RELHFWXO XQHL
FXDQWLILF ULVDXRULFHVFDO FRQVWUXLW ODFDUHSRWILUDSRUWD LLQGLYL]LL
GLQDPLFD SHUVRQDOLW LL VWXGLXO DVSHFWHORU GLQDPLFH FRPSOH[H LQ
WHUDFWLYHDOHPRWLYD LHLHPR LHLVDXFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL'3
GLVWDOGHS UWDWGHH[HPSOXvQSHUFHS LHVWLPXOGLVWDO
GLVWLPLHWXOEXUDUHGHUHJODUHDGLVSR]L LHL
GL]DELOLWDWH vQ JHQHUDO RULFH LQFDSDFLWDWH GH D UHDOL]D R DQXPLW
IXQF LHSRDWHILXWLOL]DWSHQWUXGLVIXQF LLFRQJHQLWDOHVDXSHQWUXIXQF LL
SLHUGXWHvQXUPDXQRUWUDXPHEROLHWF'L]DELOLWDWVHPQLILF IDSWXOF
SHUVRDQD VXIHU GH R DQXPH GL]DELOLWDWH 'LQ FDX]D PXOWRU FRQRWD LL
QHJDWLYH FRQVWLWXLWH vQ MXUXO FXYkQWXOXL KDQGLFDS KDQGLFDSDW VH
SUHIHU GHVHPQDUHDSULQGL]DELOLWDW
HPSLULF DVSHFW FDUH GHFXUJH GLQ WDWRQ UL SUDFWLFH QHJKLGDWH GH XQ
VFRSVDXGHXQFDGUXWHRUHWLF
HUJ HQHUJLH OD GLVSR]L LD FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL WU V WXUL VXUV FRQVWLWX
LRQDO FXDF LXQHSHUPDQHQW
HX VHGLXO úL DQVDPEOXO PRWLYD LLORU úL DFWHORU XQXL LQGLYLG FDUH FRQ
GL LRQHD] DGDSWDUHD VD OD UHDOLWDWH vL VDWLVIDFH WUHEXLQ HOH úL UH]ROY
FRQIOLFWHOHGDWRUDWHXQRUGRULQ HYVFRQGL LLLQFRPSDWLELOH
H[WUDYHUVLH WU V WXU GH ED] D SHUVRQDOLW LL FDUH LPSULP DQXPLWH
FDUDFWHULVWLFL SHUVRDQHL H[WUDYHUWXO DSDUH VRFLDELO VH VLPWH vQ ODUJXO
V X SULQWUH RDPHQL úL JUXSXUL PDUL HVWH DILUPDWLY DFWLY YRUE UH vL
SODFHFHHDFHHVWHH[FLWDQWVWLPXODWLYDUHRGLVSR]L LHJHQHUDO YHVHO
HQHUJLF úLRSWLPLVW
IDFWRU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH FDUDFWHULVWLFLOH LPSOLFD LHL úL LQYHVWL LLORU
SVLKLFHvQFRPSRUWDPHQWHúLDFWLYLW L)DFWRUXOUHSUH]LQW RFOXVWHUL]DUH
VWDWLVWLF GH LWHPL RE LQXW vQ XUPD GHUXO ULL XQHL DQDOL]H IDFWRULDOH D
F UHLFRQVLVWHQ úLGHQXPLUHSVLKRORJLF QHFHVLW RDFWLYLWDWHVSHFLDOL]DW
IDFWRU JHQHUDO IDFWRU GH JUXS IDFWRU VSHFLILF IDFWRU GH HURDUH
VXQW QLYHOH DOH DQDOL]HL IDFWRULDOH FDUH GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD WHRULHL OXL
(\VHQFNFRUHVSXQGWLSXOXLGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHWU V WXULLGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
GHSULQGHULORU VDX U VSXQVXULORU KDELWXDOH úL UHVSHFWLY U VSXQVXULORU
VSHFLILFHXQXLVXELHFW
IDFWRUvQJHQHUDORULFHDVSHFWFDUHDUHRLQIOXHQ FDX]DO DVXSUDXQXL
IHQRPHQ SULQ H[WLQGHUH IDFWRUXO HVWH R YDULDELO LQGHSHQGHQW ÌQ
VWDWLVWLF XQ SURGXV DO DQDOL]HL IDFWRULDOH QXPHUH vQWUR PDWULFH
IDFWRULDO DQDOL]DIDFWRULDO LGHDO LGHQWLILF XQQXP UPLFGHIDFWRUL
ILHFDUH RUWRJRQDO ID GH FHLODO L )DFWRULL FDUH DSDU vQ XUPD DQDOL]HL
IDFWRULDOH WUHEXLH V ILH H[DPLQD L VXELHFWLY SHQWUX D GHWHUPLQD GDF
UHSUH]LQW GLPHQVLXQLSVLKRORJLFHHYLGHQWH([LVW RWHQGLQ PDLDOHV
FkQGWHKQLFDDQDOL]HLIDFWRULDOHVHDSOLF LQYHQWDUHORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
V VHLGHQWLILFHIDFWRULLFDUHDSDUFXWU V WXULOH6WULFWYRUELQGIDFWRUXO
QXHVWHRWU V WXU WU V WXUDHVWHLQIHUDW SRUQLQGGHODIDFWRUXORE L
QXW UHSUH]LQW R UHJXODULWDWH VXELDFHQW ED]HL GH GDWH GH OD FDUH VD
SRUQLW DVWIHO F FHL GRL WHUPHQL WU V WXU úL IDFWRU QX WUHEXLH FRQ
VLGHUD L VLQRQLPL 3HQWUX D SXWHD V VWDELOLP R WU V WXU YDOLG DYHP
QHYRLHGHLQIRUPD LLDGL LRQDOH'3
IHQRWLS WRWDOLWDWHD vQVXúLULORU FDUDFWHULVWLFLORU úL WU V WXULORU D VWUXF
WXULORU IXQF LRQDOH GREkQGLWH vQ FXUVXO GH]YROW ULL SHUVRDQHL VXE
LQIOXHQ DIDFWRULORUFHDXDF LRQDWDVXSUDVD
IXQF LH GRPLQDQW HVWH IXQF LD FHD PDL GH]YROWDW IXQF LD QXP UXO
XQX(VWHIXQF LDFDUHU VSXQGHSULPDFkQGWHDIOLvQID DXQHLLQIRUPD LL
QRL(VWHúLFHDPDLIDPLOLDU
JHQRWLS DQVDPEOXO FDUDFWHULVWLFLORU HUHGLWDUH WUDQVPLVH SULQ LQWHU
PHGLXOFHOXOHORUJHUPLQDOHFDGUXOJHQHWLFvQDIDUDRULF URULQIOXHQ H
SHULVWDOWLFHGHPHGLX
KLVWULRQLF vQFOLQD LH VSUH GUDPDWL]DUHD VLWXD LLORU VSUH H[SULPDUHD
HPIDWLF D VHQWLPHQWHORU úL VSUH IDSWXO F SURGXFHUHD GH VLPSWRPH
QHFHVLW SUH]HQ DXQXLDOWUHLOHDVSHFWDWRUúLHVWHvQVR LW GHRUHODWLY
LQGLIHUHQ vQSULYLQ DORU
LGHRJUDILF XQ VLVWHP VDX WHRULH SVLKRORJLF RULHQWDW VSUH FRQFUHW
LQGLYLGXDOXQLF'3
LGHRVLQFUDVLH GHILQHúWH GLVSR]L LD LQGLYLGXOXL GH D RUJDQL]D SULQ úL
SHQWUXHOvQVXúLGDWHúLIDSWHLGHQWLFHGXS GLVSR]L LLOHVDOHSHUVRQDOH
DIHFWLYHVDXFRJQLWLYH'HH[HPSOXPDMRULWDWHDJUHúHOLORUGHOLPEDMVH
GDWRUHD] FRPSRUWDPHQWHORULGHRVLQFUDVLFH'3
LPDJLQHD GH VLQH FD R VXEGLYL]LXQH D DGDSW ULORU FDUDFWHULVWLFH
SHUVRDQHL5 VSXQVXULOHODFKHVWLRQDUXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHVXQWOHJDWHFHO
PDLPXOWúLGHVLJXUFHOPDLGLUHFWGHDFHVWQLYHODOLPDJLQLLGHVLQH
,PDJLQHDGHVLQHQXHVWHXQDVSHFWVLQJXODUFLRRUJDQL]DUHGHLGHLXQ
PRGHOGHSHUFHSHUHOHJDW GHHXOSURSULX2GDW VWDELOL]DW LPDJLQHD
GHVLQHIXUQL]HD] XQHFUDQVDXXQILOWUXSULQFDUHHVWHSHUFHSXWY ]XW
HYDOXDWVDXvQ HOHVRULFHDOWFHYD)HOXOFXPVHSHUFHSHFHVLPWHGHVSUH
VLQHRSHUVRDQ HVWHvQXOWLP LQVWDQ LQIOXHQ DWGHRPXOWLWXGLQHGH
H[SHULHQ H WU LWH DFDV OD úFRDO vQ GLIHULWH JUXSXUL VRFLDOH GLQ FDUH
IDFHSDUWH
LQIOXHQ HVXELHFWXOFUHGHF HVWHVXSXVXQHLIRU HLQWHUQHVDXH[WHUQH
FDUHL GLULMHD] JkQGXULOH vL PRGXOHD] VHQWLPHQWHOH úL vL FRPDQG
DFWHOHVDXFRPSRUWDPHQWXO
LQWHJUDUH vQ VHQV ODUJ SURFHVXO GH D FRRUGRQD úL XQLILFD HOHPHQWH
VHSDUDWHvQWUXQvQWUHJ3ULQFLSLXGHRUJDQL]DUHFHVHDSOLF ODVWUXFWXUL
FXHOHPHQWHRUGRQDWHLHUDUKLFQLYHOHOHVXSHULRDUHH[HUFLW XQFRQWURO
DVXSUD FHORU LQIHULRDUH ÌQ SVLKRORJLH WHUPHQXO HVWH DSOLFDW vQ VHQV
ODUJGHVFULSWLYRULF UHLFRQGXLWHDOHF UHLHOHPHQWHVXQWFODUVXERUGR
QDWHXQXLVFRSILQDOL]DWRULF UHLDF LXQLLQWHQ LRQDWH'3
LQWHJUDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLWHUPHQFDUHVHUHIHU ODFRRUGRQDUHDRUJDQL
]DUHDVDXXQLILFDUHDXQRUWU V WXULVHSDUDWHDXQRUGLVSR]L LLGHFRPSRU
WDPHQW PRWLYH VDX HPR LL FDUH FRQVWLWXLH SHUVRQDOLWDWHD XQXL LQGLYLG
VLWXD LDLQYHUV HVWHGHQXPLW GH]LQWHJUDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL'3
LQWHUUHOD LLGLQDPLFHWHUPHQDSOLFDELORULF UXLWLSGHUHOD LLXPDQHvQ
FDUHPDLPXOWHDVSHFWHVHvQWUHS WUXQGúLLQWHUUHOD LRQHD] DVWIHOvQFkW
VFKLPEDUHD FDUH DSDUH OD R SHUVRDQ YD DYHD HIHFWH DVXSUD FHOHLODOWH
SHUVRDQH GLQDPLF HVWH XQ WHUPHQ FDUH vQ PRG VSHFLILF VH UHIHU OD
PRWLYD LH56:RRGZRUWKSURFHVHLQFRQúWLHQWH6)UHXG&*-XQJ
úLFkPSXULFRPSOH[HGHIRU SVLKRORJLF ./HYLQ
LQWURLHF LHPHFDQLVPSVLKRORJLFLQFRQúWLHQWGHvQFRUSRUDUHLPDJLQDU
DXQXLRELHFWVDXDXQHLSHUVRDQHFDUHFRQVW vQDSUHOXDRFkWPDL
PDUHSDUWHGLQOXPHDH[WHULRDU úLDDWULEXLVLQHOXLFDOLW LOHUHDOHVDX
SUHVXSXVHDOHRELHFWXOXL
LQWXL LH VHVL]DUHD GLUHFW D HOHPHQWHORU RUJDQL]DWH VSRQWDQ vQWUXQ
DQVDPEOXGHWHUPLQDW&*-XQJIDFHGLQHDRIXQF LHIXQGDPHQWDO D
SVLKLFXOXLGDWRULW F UHLDvQPRGVXELWXQFRQ LQXWQHHVWHSUH]HQWDW
VXERIRUP GHILQLWLY I U FDQRLV úWLPFXPVDDMXQVDLFL
PHWRG DQVDPEOXGHSURFHGXULGHPHUVXULVDXUHJXOLDGRSWDWHvQFRQ
GXFHUHDXQHLFHUFHW ULÌQPXOWLSOHOHGRPHQLLDSOLFDWLYHvQSVLKRORJLH
VDXGH]YROWDWPHWRGHFDUHWUDVHD] PRGDOLW LGHLQWHUDF LXQHDSUDFWL
FLDQXOXLFXSHUVRDQHOHVWXGLDWHVDXDVXSUDF URUDVHLQWHUYLQHYRUELP
GHPHWRGDREVHUYD LHLPHWRG GHJUXSPHWRG JOREDO VDXDQDOLWLF
PHWRG QRQGLUHFWLY PHWRG FRPSRUWDPHQWDO HWF(VWHHVHQ LDOV VH
UDSRUWH]HIDSWHOHREVHUYDWHODPHWRGHOHXWLOL]DWHSHQWUXVWXGLX'3
PRGHO vQ HQJOH] úL XQHRUL SUHOXDW DG OLWHUDP vQ OLPED URPkQ
ÄSDWHUQ´VHUHIHU ILHODXQPRGHOVDXXQHúDQWLRQILHODRFRQILJXUD LH
VDX JUXSDUH GH S U L VDX HOHPHQWH FX R VWUXFWXU FRHUHQW $QDOL]D GH
SDWHUQHVWHRWHKQLF VWDWLVWLF SULQFDUHVHvQFHDUF GHVFRSHULUHDVHWXOXL
GHLWHPLGHWHVWFDUHDXRÄDSDUWHQHQ ´FRPXQ '3
PRGHOHFLUFXPSOH[HVWUXFWXUDOHPRGHOHFRPSOH[HFXRQDWXU JHR
PHWULF VXE DVSHFWXO UHSUH]HQW ULL VSD LDOH vQ FDUH YHFWRULL WU V WXULORU
VXQWFDUDFWHUL]D LGHSR]L LLOHORUXQJKLXODUHvQWUXQVSD LXELGLPHQVLRQDO
VDX WULGLPHQVLRQDO 0RGHOHOH FLUFXPSOH[H SULQ QDWXUD ORU GDX R PDL
PDUH úDQV GH LGHQWLILFDUH D XQRU FOXVWHUL GH WU V WXUL FDUH VXQW GLQ
SXQFWGHYHGHUHVHPDQWLFFRH]LYH2HWDS XOWHULRDU DIRVWGHDLQWHJUD
WR L VXSHUIDFWRULL úL PRGHOHOH FLUFXPSOH[H vQ DGHY UDWH PRGHOH JHR
PHWULFHFXPDLPXOWGHGRX GLPHQVLXQL
QHYURWLVP GHILQLW FD VWDELOLWDWH HPR LRQDO DGDSWDUH ID GH
QHYURWLVPQHDGDSWDUH&RVWD0F&UDH7HQGLQ DJHQHUDO GHD
WU L DIHFWH SUHFXP WHDPD WULVWH HD MHQD PkQLD YLQRY LD GH]JXVWXO
UHSUH]LQW PLH]XODFHVWXLIDFWRU
QHYUR] GHILQHúWHRWXOEXUDUHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHVDXPHQWDO FDUHQXVH
GDWRUHD] XQHLGLVIXQF LLQHXURORJLFHVDXRUJDQLFHFXQRVFXWHWHUPHQXO
SRDWH IL IRORVLW GHVFULSWLY SHQWUX D GHQXPL XQ VLPSWRP VDX JUXS GH
VLPSWRPH OHJDWH HWLRORJLF SHQWUX D LQGLFD UROXO FDX]DO MXFDW GH XQ
FRQIOLFWLQFRQúWLHQWFDUHHYRF DQ[LHWDWHúLFRQGXFHODXQPHFDQLVPGH
DS UDUHFHSURGXFHvQXOWLP LQVWDQ VLPSWRPXOREVHUYDWÌQXOWLPLLDQL
VDXSURGXVGRX PRGLILF ULVHPQLILFDWLYHvQXWLOL]DUHDWHUPHQXOXLXWLOL
]DUHDGHQXPLULLGHWXOEXUDUHQHYURWLF FDXQWHUPHQJHQHULFSHQWUXRULFH
WXOEXUDUHPHQWDO GHGXUDW WHUPHQUHODWLYQHXWUXvQSULYLQ DIDFWRULORU
HWLRORJLFLHOLPLQDUHDWHUPHQXOXLGLQGLDJQR]DSVLKLDWULF DFRPSDQLDW
GHRUHDWULEXLUHDYDULDWHORUWLSXULDQWHULRUUHFXQRVFXWHGHQHYUR]HXQRU
DOWRUFODVLILF ULGLDJQRVWLFH'3
QRPRWHWLF XQ VLVWHP VDX WHRULH SVLKRORJLF RULHQWDW VSUH DEVWUDFW
XQLYHUVDOVDXJHQHUDO'3
QRUPDOvQVHQVODUJVHUHIHU ODFHHDFHGHULY GLQWURQRUP vQVHQV
SVLKRORJLF VSHFLILF VH UHIHU OD FRQGL LD SVLKRORJLF GH QRQERDO
DEVHQ DWXOEXU ULORUPHQWDOHDUHWDUGXOXLPLQWDOVDXDDOWRUGLVIXQF LL
SVLKRORJLFH
RUJDQL]DUHD WU V WXULORU XQ WHUPHQ FDUH VH UHIHU OD XQ VHWLSRWHWLF
GH LQWHUUHOD LRQ UL vQWUH GLIHULWHOH WU V WXUL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH DOH XQHL
SHUVRDQH
RUWRJRQDOvQXQJKLGUHSWFDUDFWHULVWLFDXQXLVHWGHYDULDELOHGLQFDGUXO
XQXLH[SHULPHQWLQGHSHQGHQWHvQWUHHOH6ROX LDRUWRJRQDO VHDSOLF vQ
DQDOL]D IDFWRULDO vQ FDUH D[HOH FH UHSUH]LQW IDFWRULL VXEVLGLDUL VH VL
WXHD] DVWIHOF DXRSR]L LHvQXQJKLGUHSWXQXOID GHFHO ODOWvQWUR
DVWIHOGHVROX LHIDFWRULLQXFRUHOHD] 7U V WXUDRUWRJRQDO vQPDWULFHD
GHDQDOL] IDFWRULDO RULFHWU V WXU FDUHHVWHLQGHSHQGHQW GHRULFDUHDOWD
SDWHUQ WHUPHQ DSURSLDW GH FHO GH VWUXFWXU GH IRUP FRQILJXUD LH
WLSPRGHOVFKHP PDWULFH,QGLF DWkWVWUXFWXUDRUJDQLF IL]LF FkW
úLFHDFRPSRUWDPHQWDO
SHUFHSHUHVRFLDO vQVHQVODUJRULFHDVSHFWDOSHUFHSHULLFDUHFRQ LQH
XQHOHPHQWVRFLDOWHUPHQXOHVWHXWLOL]DWvQJHQHUDOUHODWLYODFDSDFLWDWHD
XQXLLQGLYLGGHDILFRQúWLHQWGHP VXUDvQFDUHFRPSRUWDPHQWXODOWRUD
OH UHOHY PRWLYHOH DWLWXGLQLOH UHDF LLOH LQWHULRDUH OD *RXJK GHILQHúWH
PRGXOvQFDUHSULQH[SHULPHQWDUHHVWHSHUFHSXW GHDQWXUDMRSHUVRDQ
FDUHSUH]LQW RDFFHQWXDUHDXQHLDVDXDOWHLDGLQWUHGLPHQVLXQLOHGHSHU
VRQDOLWDWHDOH&3,
SHUVRQDOLWDWHSVLKRSDW RWXOEXUDUHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHFDUDFWHUL]DW GH
DPRUDOLWDWHOLSV DDIHFWLYLW LLúLXQVF ]XWVHQVDOQHOLQLúWLLúLYLQR
Y LHLOHJDWHGHvQF OFDUHDOHJLORURH[WUHPGHODUJ JDP GHFRPSRU
WDPHQWHH[KLEDWHGHSHUVRDQH'3
SUHIHULQ D(,GHVFULHRULHQWDUHDHXOXLVSUHOXPHDH[WHULRDU H[WUDYHUVLH
ID GHRULHQWDUHDFRPSOHPHQWDU VSUHOXPHDLQWHULRDU LQWURYHUVLH
SUHIHULQ D -3 LPSOLF SUREOHPD PRGXOXL FXP DERUGH]L UD LRQDO VDX
LUD LRQDOGDWHOHGHLQIRUPD LHDVXSUDUHDOLW LLLQWHULRDUHVDXH[WHULRDUH
SUHIHULQ D61GHVFULHPRGXOFXPHVWHSHUFHSXW LQIRUPD LD
SUHIHULQ D7)LQGLF IHOXOFXPLDHXOGHFL]LLOH
SULPLQJ SUHJ WLUHD XQXL VLVWHP GH IXQF LRQDUH XWLOL]DW vQ DFWLYLWDWHD
SVLKRORJLF SHQWUX D VH UHIHUL OD IDSWXO F XQ DQLPDO FDUH D U VSXQV
DQWHULRU XQHL VWLPXO UL HOHFWULFH FUDQLHQH SRDWH V QX UHXúHDVF V
U VSXQG XOWHULRU GDF QX L VH G XQD VDX PDL PXOWH VWLPXO UL GH WLS
SULPLQJ ÌQ VWXGLXO vQY ULL VH UHIHU OD SUH]HQWDUHD XQHL H[SHULHQ H
VSHFLILFHFDUHIDFHXQDQLPDOPDLVHQVLELOVDXPDLDSWV U VSXQG ODR
JDP ODUJ GHVWLPXOL
SURILO GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH SUH]HQW UL JHQHUDOH DOH WU V WXULORU GH SHUVR
QDOLWDWHúLDOHFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUSUH]HQWHODDFHDSHUVRDQ UHODWLYODXQVHW
GHQRUPHFRQVWUXLWHID GHRSRSXOD LHGHUHIHULQ vQSURILOGDWHOHVXQW
SUH]HQWDWHvQIRUP JUDILF FDvQFD]XOWHVWHORU&3,VDX003,VDX
DFHVWD SRDWH DYHD IRUPD PDL JHQHUDO D XQHL SUH]HQW UL D FDUDFWHULVWL
FLORULQGLYLGXOXLVDXDWU V WXULORUvQIRUP VXPDU '3
SURJQR] RSUHGLF LHSULYLQGFXUVXOVDXUH]XOWDWXOXQXLSURFHVILHHO
SVLKRORJLFHGXFD LRQDOPHWRGRORJLFHWF'3
SUR[LPDODSURSLDWGHH[HPSOXVWLPXOSUR[LPDO
SVLKRGLDJQR] vQPRGVSHFLILFVHUHIHU ODSURFHGXULGHGLDJQRVWLFDUH
D DQRUPDOLW LORU SVLKRORJLFH D WXOEXU ULORU PHQWDOH HWF 0DL JHQHUDO
WHUPHQXOHVWHIRORVLWSHQWUXRULFHSURFHGXU GHHYDOXDUHSVLKRORJLF VDX
GHSHUVRQDOLWDWH7HUPHQXOGHSVLKRGLDJQRVWLFVHUHIHU ODRULFHWHKQLFL
YDOLGH GH HYDOXDUH D SHUVRQDOLW LL SULQ LQWHUSUHWDUHD PRGHOHORU GH
FRPSRUWDPHQW LQFOXVLY D FHORU QRQYHUEDOH '3 ÌQ YL]LXQHD
DXWRULORUDPHULFDQL&RVWDúL0F&UDHHVWHXQSURFHVVLVWHPDWLFFDUHDUH
GRX HWDSHREVHUY PPRGHOHGHFRPSRUWDPHQWúLGHWU LUHDGHVHD
SULQ DXWRGHVFULHUL RE LQXWH GH OD VXELHFW úL IDFHP HYDOX UL SULYLQG
WU V WXULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH FDUH DU SXWHD GHWHUPLQD DFHVWH UHJXODULW L
DFHVWHWLSXULVDXPRGHOHGHFRPSRUWDPHQW'DF DúDFXPHVWHILUHVFQH
SXQHP SUREOHPD YDOLGLW LL XQRU DVWIHO GH HYDOX UL REVHUY P F
DVHPHQL HYDOX ULORU FRWLGLHQH úL HYDOX ULOH SVLKRGLDJQRVWLFH VXSRUW
LQIOXHQ D XQRU DVSHFWH FDUH OH UHODWLYL]HD] 9DORDUHD H[SOLFDWLY D
WU V WXULORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHGHSLQGHGHP VXUDvQFDUHFHUWLILF SHGHR
SDUWH VWDELOLWDWHD ORU vQ WLPS FHHD FH G SRVLELOLWDWHD GH D VH IDFH
SUHGLF LLSHWHUPHQOXQJúLSHGHDOW SDUWHVXQWDUJXPHQWHFHLQGLF R
GLQDPLF GHODVSHFLILFVSUHJHQHUDOúLGLQQRXVSUHVSHFLILF
SVLKROLQJYLVWLF XQGRPHQLXFUHDWvQDQLL¶DLVHFROXOXL;;vQFDUH
FHQWUDUHD HVWH SH VWXGLXO FRPSRUWDPHQWHORU FDUH VXQW OLQJYLVWLFH
'DWRULW XELFXLW LL FRPSRUWDPHQWXOXL YHUEDO XPDQ PXOWH SUREOHPH
SVLKROLQJYLVWLFHHPHUJvQDULLSUHFXPSVLKRORJLDFRJQLWLY PHPRULH
SURFHVDUHDLQIRUPD LLORUVRFLROLQJYLVWLF QHXURSVLKRORJLHSVLKRORJLH
FOLQLF ÌQGRPHQLXOWHRULLORUSHUVRQDOLW LLXQDGLQGLUHF LLOHFHOHPDL
IUXFWXRDVHGHFHUFHWDUHFRQWHPSRUDQHvQVWXGLXOUHJXODULW LORUvQHYD
OXDUHDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLúLSHUVRQDOLW LL
SVLKRPHWULHVHUHIHU ODP VXUDUHDDFHHDFHHVWHSVLKRORJLFUHVSHFWLY
DSOLFDUHDSULQFLSLLORUPDWHPDWLFHúLVWDWLVWLFHGDWHORUGLQSVLKRORJLHPDL
VSHFLILFVHUHIHU ODWHVWDUHDPHQWDO LQFOX]kQGHYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL
HYDOXDUHDLQWHOLJHQ HLGHWHUPLQDUHDDSWLWXGLQLORUHWF
SVLKRSDWFDWHUPHQJHQHUDOGHVHPQHD] RWXOEXUDUHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH
VHYHU FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQ DPRUDOLWDWH OLSVD DIHFWHORU úL XQ VLP GLPL
QXDWDOQHOLQLúWLLúLYLQRY LHLvQVLWXD LLOHFkQGvQFDOF OHJHD
SVLKRSDWRORJLH VH UHIHU OD VWXGLXO úWLLQ LILF DO WXOEXU ULORU PHQWDOH
GRPHQLXO LQFOXGH FHUFHW UL vQ GRPHQLXO SVLKRORJLHL QHXURORJLHL SVL
KLDWULHLHQGRFULQRORJLHLúLIDUPDFRORJLHL'RPHQLXODFWLYLW LLSUDFWLFH
DOSVLKRORJLORUFOLQLFLHQLvQWHUDSLDWXOEXU ULORUPHQWDOH
SVLKRWLFVHUHIHU ODWXOEXUDUHSVLKRWLF RFRQGL LHVHYHU GHRULJLQH
RUJDQLF VDXHPR LRQDO DOHF UHLVLPSWRPHFODVLFHLQFOXGLOX]LDKDOX
FLQD LDFRPSRUWDPHQWHUHJUHVLYHVHYHUHYRUELUHLQFRHUHQW GLVSR]L LL
GUDPDWLFQHDGHFYDWHIRORVLWvQFRPELQD LHFXDOWWHUPHQGLDJQRVWLFVH
UHIHU OD FRQGL LD vQ FDUH XQXO GLQWUH VLPSWRPHOH FDUH FDUDFWHUL]HD]
ERDODSVLKLF DUHFDUDFWHULVWLFLFDUHVHDVHDP Q PXOWFXRSVLKR] GH
H[HPSOXGHSUHVLHSVLKRWLF
UHIXODUHIHQRPHQSVLKLFLQFRQúWLHQWGHDS UDUHDHXOXLSULQLQWHUPHGLXO
F UXLDVHQWLPHQWHOHDPLQWLULOHúLHPR LLOHSHQLELOHVDXFHOHFDUHVXQWvQ
GH]DFRUG FX PRGHOXO VRFLDO DO XQHL SHUVRDQH VXQW PHQ LQXWH vQ DIDUD
FkPSXOXLFRQúWLLQ HLvQVWUXFWXULOHVXEFRQúWLHQWH
VFDO GHHYDOXDUHLQVWUXPHQWGHFHUFHWDUHFOLQLFLQL LDODSRLH[WLQVúLvQ
DOWH WLSXUL GH VWXGLL FDUH VXQW FRPSOHWDWH GH XQ REVHUYDWRU FOLQLFLDQ
DYkQG FD RELHFWLY GLVWLQJHUHD FODVHORU VDX FDWHJRULLORU GH GLDJQRVWLF
VFDOHGLIHUHQ LDOHSUHYHGHUHDXQHLHYROX LLVFDOHSUHGLFWLYHGHVFULHUHD
XQHL VW UL FOLQLFH VDX GLVWULEX LHL XQHL YDULDELOH vQWUR SRSXOD LH VFDOH
GHVFULSWLYH6HGHRVHEHVFPDLPXOWHWLSXULGHVFDOHGHVFULSWLYHLQYHQ
WDUHOH JOREDOH FDUH VXQW OLVWH GH VLPSWRPHVFDOHOHQRVRJUDILFHJOREDOH
FDUHIXUQL]HD] XQLQGLFHJOREDOGHSDWRORJLHFDGHH[HPSOXVFDODGH
GHSUHVLHDOXL+DPLOWRQVFDOHGHVLQGURPVDXSROLGLPHQVLRQDOH'3
VFDO vQVHQVJHQHUDORULFHSURFHGXU VDXLQVWUXPHQWIRORVLWFXVFRSXO
GH D DUDQMD RELHFWHOH VDX HYHQLPHQWHOH vQ VHULL SURJUHVLYH DVWIHO F vQ
ILHFDUHFD]vQSDUWHH[LVW RUHJXO SHQWUXDSHUPLWHDWULEXLUHDXQXLQXP U
VDX XQHL YDORUL RELHFWHORU VDX HYHQLPHQWHORU VFDODWH ÌQ PRG VSHFLILF
LQGLF XQLQVWUXPHQWGHWHVWDUHFDUHDUHLWHPLLVDXVDUFLQLOHDUDQMDWHGHD
OXQJXO XQHL GLPHQVLXQL GLPHQVLXQHD SRDWH IL XQD GLQWUH PDL PXOWH
SUHFXP FHD D GLILFXOW LL GH H[HPSOX vQ VFDOHOH GH LQWHOLJHQ VDX
SUHIHULQ HLFDGHH[HPSOXvQVFDOHOHGHDWLWXGLQL2VFDO SVLKRORJLF
VSHFLILF XQVLVWHPGHP VXUDUHDXQHLYDULDELOHSVLKRORJLFH2ULFHVFDO
QHFHVLW XQQXP UGHFDOLW LSULQWUHDFHVWHDYDOLGLWDWHDVHPQLILF IDSWXO
F LQVWUXPHQWXO P VRDU FRUHFW RELHFWXO VWXGLDW vQWUR PRGDOLWDWH
VSHFLILF 9DOLGLWDWHDVHSRDWHRE LQHúLFRPSDUkQGFXRDOW VFDO 9DOL
GLWDWHD H[WHUQ VH RE LQH SULQ FRPSDUDUHD FX XQ FULWHULX H[WHUQ )LGH
OLWDWHD LPSOLF GH H[HPSOX RPRJHQLWDWHD LWHPLORU VFDOHL SRVLELOLWDWHD
GH D UHSOLFD UH]XOWDWHOH vQ WLPS VDX FX R IRUP SDUDOHO 3ULQFLSDOHOH
HURULPHWRGRORJLFHGHFXUJGLQOLSVDGHDGHFYDUHDLQVWUXPHQWHORUDOHVH
vQ UDSRUW FX SUH]XP LD WHRUHWLF D XQXL VWXGLX VDX GLQ LQIHUDUHD XQRU
FRQFOX]LLDEX]LYHSOHFkQGGHODUH]XOWDWHOHFRGDWH6WDQGDUGL]DUHDVFD
OHORU SVLKRORJLFH D LQWURGXV XQ SURJUHV PHWRGRORJLF LPSRUWDQW SHQWUX
HYDOXDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LL'3
VFDOHDEUHYLDWHWHKQLF FHSHUPLWHH[SORUDUHDDVSHFWHORUSVLKRSDWRORJLFH
úLDDWLWXGLQLLVXELHFWXOXLFRQIRUPVFDOHORUFOLQLFH003,SHQWUXVX
ELHF LLFDUHSUH]LQW vQSURILOXO&3,XQHOHDVSHFWHFDUHvQGUHSW HVFR
VXVSLFLXQHDVXSUDJUDYLW LLXQRUVLPSWRPHSVLKRSDWRORJLFH
VHQWLPHQW GH VLQH FRQFHSXW GH DXWRU FD LPDJLQH GHVSUH VLQH FDUH
FRRUGRQHD] úLRUJDQL]HD] DWLWXGLQLOHúLPRWLYD LLOHVXELHFWXOXL
VRPDWL]DUH H[SUHVLD vQ VRPDWLF D FRQGL LLORU SVLKLFH WXOEXUDUHD SULQ
VRPDWL]DUH HVWH R FRQGL LH FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQWUR LVWRULH GH VLPSWRPH
IL]LFHPXOWLSOHúLUHFXUHQWHSHQWUXFDUHQXH[LVW RFDX] IL]LF DSDUHQW
7XOEXUDUHDvQFHSHYLUWXDOvQSHULRDGDDGROHVFHQ HLúLDUHXQFXUVFURQLF
VDXIOXFWXDQWLPSOLFkQGRYDULHWDWHGHSOkQJHULOHJDWHGHGLVIXQF LLRUJD
QLFH SUHFXP GXUHUL YDJL DOHUJLL SUREOHPH JDVWURLQWHVWLQDOH VLPSWRPH
SVLKRVH[XDOHSDOSLWD LLVLPSWRPHGHFRQYHUVLH
VXEOLPDUH vQ VHQV FODVLF SVLKDQDOLWLF FRQFHSWXO VH UHIHU OD SURFHVXO
LQFRQúWLHQWGHUHGLUHF LRQDUHDLPSXOVXULORUSULPLWLYHvQFRPSRUWDPHQWH
QRLvQY DWHQRQLQVWLQFWLYH&XVHQVPDLJHQHUDOUHGLUHF LRQDUHDHQHU
JLHLGLQVSUHFHHDFHHVWHLQDFFHSWDELOVRFLDOVSUHDFFHSWDELO
VXSUDHXDQVDPEOXGHLQWHUGLF LLPRUDOHLQWURLHFWDWH
WD[RQRPLHFODVLILFDUHVLVWHPDWLF vQVSHFLDODIRUPHORUYLL
WD[RQRPLH XQ VHW GH SULQFLSLL VLVWHPDWLFH FH SHUPLW FODVLILFDUHD
WD[RQRPLD UHDOL]DW GH &DWWHOO GRUHúWH V VLVWHPDWL]H]H ULJXURV
PXOWLWXGLQHD GH WHUPHQL FDUH VH UHIHU OD SHUVRQDOLWDWH vQ VHQV ODUJ úL
UHDOL]HD] XQ ,QGH[ 8QLYHUVDO ILHFDUH IDFWRU SULPLQG XQ LQGLFDWLY GH
FRG SURSULX GH DVHPHQHD XQLL GLQWUH IDFWRULL DVWIHO FODVLILFD L DX
SULPLW úL GHQXPLUL FROD LRQDWH GH DXWRU FX VFRSXO HYLW ULL FRQIX]LLORU
GHH[HPSOXIDFWRUXO-GHQXPLW]HSLDYVFRDVWKHQLD'DWHPDLDPSOH
vQ OXFUDUHD 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG 0RWLYDWLRQ 6WUXFWXUH DQG PHDVXUHPHQW
:RUOG%RRN1HZ<RUN
WHPSHUDPHQWXODSRORQLDQ1)LQWXLWLYúLDIHFWLY
WHPSHUDPHQWXOGLRQLVLDF63VHQ]RULDOúLSHUFHSWLY
WHPSHUDPHQWXOHSLPHWHDQ6-VHQ]RULDOúLUD LRQDO
WHPSHUDPHQWXOSURPHWHDQ17LQWXLWLYúLORJLF
WHQGLQ DFFHQWXDW LQYDULDQ RSHUD LRQDO FDUHJHQHUHD] PDQLIHVW UL
SUHJQDQWHQXQXPDLvQUDSRUWFXPHGLDFLúLFXDEDWHULOHGHODPHGLH
WHQGLQ H VDX WU V WXUL ED]DOH IDLPRúLL VXSHUIDFWRUL DL SHUVRQDOLW LL
± QHYURWLVP H[WUDYHUVLH GHVFKLGHUH DJUHDELOLWDWH FRQúWLLQFLR]LWDWH ±
DSDU DLFL FD GLVSR]L LL SVLKLFH IXQGDPHQWDOH ÌQWUH DFHVWH WHQGLQ H ED
]DOHGLQFDUHIDFSDUWHWU V WXULOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHúLELRJUDILDRELHFWLY
DSHUVRDQHLFDUHLQFOXGHFRPSRUWDPHQWHOHVSHFLILFHQXH[LVW ROHJ
WXU GLUHFW 7U V WXULOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDSDUFDVXEGYL]LXQHPDMRU D
WHQGLQ HORU GH ED] DO WXUL GH DELOLW LOH FRJQLWLYH VH[XDOH úL GH DOWH
PDWHULDOHSULPDUHDOHSVLKLVPXOXL
WHRULLDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLvQIXQF LHGHRULHQWDUHDJHQHUDO úLPRGXOFXP
FDUDFWHUL]HD] WHUPHQXO GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH GHRVHELP vQWUH WHRULL WLSR
ORJLFH SXQ DFFHQW SH FODVLILFDUHD LQGLYL]LORU vQ IXQF LH GH WLSXUL GH
H[HPSOX -XQJ LQWURYHUW YV H[WUDYHUW WHRULL SULYLQG WU V WXULOH DVWIHO
GH WHRULL RSHUHD] FX SUHVXSXQHUHD F SHUVRQDOLWDWHD XQXL RP HVWH XQ
FRPSOH[ GH WU V WXUL VDX PRGXUL FDUDFWHULVWLFH GH FRPSRUWDPHQW
JkQGLUH GH D VLP L VDX UHDF LRQD 7HRULLOH UHFHQWH XWLOL]HD] DQDOL]D
IDFWRULDO SHQWUX D L]ROD GLPHQVLXQLOH VXELDFHQWH DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL úL
SUREDELO5%&DWWHOOHVWHXQDGLQWUHWHRULLOHFHOHPDLGH]YROWDWHFDUHVH
ED]HD] SH XQ VHW GH WU V WXUL VXUV SUHVXSXVH D H[LVWD vQ FDQWLW L
UHODWLYH vQ ILHFDUH SHUVRDQ úL FDUH VXQW ÄLQIOXHQ HOH VWUXFWXUDOH UHDOH
VXELDFHQWH SHUVRQDOLW LL´ $ERUG ULOH WLSRORJLFH úL FHOH SULYLQG WU V
WXULOHVXQWFRPSOHPHQWDUHWHRULLSVLKRGLQDPLFHúLSVLKDQDOLVWHDYkQGOD
ED] WHRULLOHOXL)UHXG-XQJVDXFHOHSVLKRVRFLDOHDOHOXL$GOHU)URPP
6XOOLYDQ +RUQH\ /DLQJ úL 3HDUOV FX DFFHQWXDUHD IDFWRULORU GH GH]
YROWDUH WHRULL EHKDYLRULVWH FDUH VH FHQWUHD] SH R H[WLQGHUH D WHRULLORU
vQY ULL WHRULL OHJDWH GH vQY DUHD VRFLDO FDUH WUDWHD] SHUVRQDOLWDWHD
GLQSHUVSHFWLYDDFHORUDVSHFWHFDUHVXQWDFKL]L LRQDWHvQFRQWH[WVRFLDO
WHRULLVLWXD LRQDOHFDUHSXQDFFHQWSHIDSWXOF FHHDFHHVWHFRQVLVWHQWvQ
FRPSRUWDPHQWXO REVHUYDELO HVWH ODUJ GHWHUPLQDW GH FDUDFWHULVWLFLOH
VLWXD LHL PDL GHJUDE GHFkW GH WU V WXUL VDX IDFWRUL LQWHULRUL WHRULL
LQWHUDF LRQLVWHHFOHFWLFHFDUHPHQ LQLGHHDF SHUVRQDOLWDWHDHPHUJHGLQ
LQWHUDF LXQLGLQWUHSUHGLVSR]L LLúLFDOLW LOHSDUWLFXODUHúLPDQLHUDvQFDUH
PHGLXO LQIOXHQ HD] IHOXO ORU GH D VH PDQLIHVWD ÌQ FRQFOX]LH SXWHP
GLVFHUQHSHQWUXWHUPHQXOGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHGRX DVSHFWHJHQHUDOHSULPXO
GHULY GLQ SULPHOH WUHL WLSXUL GH DERUGDUH SHQWUX FDUH SHUVRQDOLWDWHD
UHSUH]LQW XQ FRQVWUXFW WHRUHWLF OHJLWLP R HQWLWDWH LSRWHWLF LQWHULRDU
FDUH DUH XQ URO FDX]DO SHQWUX FRPSRUWDPHQW úL R IRU H[SOLFDWLY
DXWHQWLF SHQWUX FHOHODOWH SHUVSHFWLYH HVWH FRQFHSXW FD XQ IDFWRU
VHFXQGDULQIHUDWSHED]DFRQVLVWHQ HLGHFRPSRUWDPHQW'3
WHVW GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH RULFH LQVWUXPHQW SURIHVLRQLVW SHQWUX HYDOXDUHD
SHUVRQDOLW LL 6H GLVWLQJ vQ SULQFLSDO WHVWH GLUHFWH FDUH VH DGUHVHD]
GLUHFWFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLREVHUYDELOVDXFDUHSRDWHILHYDOXDWFRQúWLHQW
SUHFXPFKHVWLRQDUHOHVDXLQYHQWDUHOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHúLWHVWHLQGLUHFWH
VDXSURLHFWLYHFDUHVHDGUHVHD] vQWUHJXOXLSHUVRQDOLW LLúLDVSHFWHORU
LQFRQúWLHQWHH[HPSOXWHVWXO6]RQGL'3
WLPLH VLWXD LD JOREDO D VW ULL GH VSLULW FDUH FRUHVSXQGH XQRU FRP
ELQD LLvQWUHPDLPXOWHGLPHQVLXQLHPR LRQDOH
WLSGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHvQJHQHUHRULFHGHQXPLUHXWLOL]DW SHQWUXDFOD
VLILFDSHUVRQDOLWDWHDXQXLRPH[LVW GLIHULWHWLSRORJLLILHFDUHDYkQGXQ
VLVWHPSURSULXGHFDWHJRULDOL]DUHGDUWRDWHSOHDF GHODSUHVXSXQHUHD
F H[LVW PRGHOHFRHUHQWHGHFRPSRUWDPHQWVDXVWLOXULFRQVLVWHQWHGHD
DF LRQD FDUH VXQW VXILFLHQW GH ELQH GHILQLWH FD V SHUPLW FODVLILFDUHD
LQGLYL]LORU 'H IDSW SUHVXSXQHUHD DUH R YDORDUH HXULVWLF GHúL FD
DGHY UDEVROXWU PkQHvQF RLQFHUWLWXGLQH'3
WLSRORJLDMXQJLDQ SRUQLQGGHODRYL]LXQHVWUXFWXUDO úLGLQDPLF D
SVLKLFXOXL XPDQ -XQJ GHVFULH R WLSRORJLH vQ FDUH LQWHUYLQH PRGXO vQ
FDUHVHRULHQWHD] HXOFRQúWLHQWvQUDSRUWFXOXPHDFRPSOHPHQWDUID
GHRULHQWDUHDLQFRQúWLHQWXOXLúLGHDVHPHQHDLQWHUYLQHIHOXOúLP VXUD
vQFDUHHXOvúLGH]YROW úLVW SkQHúWHvQUDSRUWXULOHFXUHDOXOFHOHSDWUX
IXQF LLSRVLELOHGHFXQRDúWHUHGRX UD LRQDOHIXQF LDORJLF úLIXQF LD
YDORULF VDXDIHFWLY úLGRX LUD LRQDOHUHVSHFWLYIXQF LDVHQ]RULDO úL
IXQF LDLQWXL LHL'HH[HPSOXvQVLWXD LDvQFDUHvQSODQXOFRQúWLHQWDO
SVLKLVPXOXL H[LVW R SUHGRPLQDQW RULHQWDUH VSUH OXPHD H[WHULRDU
YRUELP GH H[WUDYHUVLD HXOXL úL D IXQF LHL SUHIHUHQ LDOH RULFDUH DU IL
DFHDVWD 'H DVHPHQHD FRPSOHPHQWDU RQWRJHQHWLF VH YD GH]YROWD R D
GRXD IXQF LH VHFXQGDU FDUH YD DYHD vQV R RULHQWDUH LQWURYHUW
SHQWUX D SHUPLWH DFFHVXO HXOXL úL vQVSUH DOWH ]RQH &RPSOHPHQWDU vQ
LQFRQúWLHQWVHPDQLIHVW LQWURYHUVLDúLFHOHODOWHIXQF LLU PDVHUHFHVLYH
úL QHVRFLDOL]DWH 7LSRORJLD MXQJLDQ GHVFULH UHDF LL úL SUHIHULQ H
FXUHQWHDVSHFWHIRUWHúLDVSHFWHOLPLWDWLYHSHQWUXWLSXULSULQFLSDOHvQ
IXQF LH GH RULHQWDUHD úL IXQF LD GRPLQDQW OD QLYHOXO HXOXL FRQúWLHQW
LQWURYHUW VHQ]RULDO H[WUDYHUW VHQ]RULDO LQWURYHUW LQWXLWLY H[WUDYHUW
LQWXLWLY LQWURYHUW ORJLF H[WUDYHUW ORJLF LQWURYHUW DIHFWLY H[WUDYHUW
DIHFWLY6XQWGHDVHPHQHDGHVFULVHúLWLSXULVHFXQGDUHvQVLWXD LD
FkQGSUHIHULQ HLGRPLQDQWHLVHDGDXJ IXQF LDVHFXQGDU
WU V WXU ±DELOLWDWHDXWRUXOVHUHIHU ODWU V WXULFDUHGHVFULXDELOLWDWHD
XQXL SHUVRDQH úL JUDGXO GH HILFLHQ FX FDUH HVWH FDSDELO V OXFUH]H
SHQWUXXQDQXPHVFRSGHH[HPSOXIDFWRUXO%
WU V WXU DFFHQWXDW FDUDFWHULVWLFLOHVSHFLILFHDFFHQWX ULLVHPDQLIHVW
FDLQYDULDQ LRSHUD LRQDOLYRUJHQHUDPDQLIHVW ULSUHJQDQWHvQWHUPHQL
QRUPDWLYL QX QXPDL vQ UDSRUW GH ÄPHGLD´ GDU úL GH ÄDEDWHULOH GH OD
PHGLH´ /LPLWHOH GLQWUH QRUPDO vQ WHUPHQL FDQWLWDWLYL WHQGLQ D VSUH
ÄPHGLX´DFFHQWXDWúLGL]DUPRQLFQXVXQWIL[HLDUGHOLPLW ULOHVSHFLILFH
VHUHDOL]HD] vQIXQF LHGHLQWHQVLWDWHDFRQVWDQ DúLJUDGXOGHVRFLDOL]DUH
DOPDQLIHVW ULLFDUHH[SULP WU V WXUDDFFHQWXDW LQGHSHQGHQWGHvPSUH
MXU ULOHH[WHULRDUH
WU V WXU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH UHSUH]LQW R GLVSR]L LH VDX FDUDFWHULVWLF
VXELDFHQW SUHVXSXV FDUH SRDWH IL IRORVLW FD R H[SOLFD LH SHQWUX
UHJXODULW LOHVDXDVSHFWHOHFRQVLVWHQWHDOHFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLDFHVWHLD
ÌQVHQVPDLODUJRGHVFULHUHDPRGXULORUGHFRPSRUWDPHQWSHUFHSHUH
JkQGLUH FDUDFWHULVWLFH SHQWUX R SHUVRDQ DFHVW VHQV HVWH IRORVLW VWULFW
GHVFULSWLYI U H[LVWHQ DXQHLLQWHQ LLH[SOLFDWLYH'3
WU V WXU vQ JHQHUH R FDUDFWHULVWLF UH]LVWHQW FDUH SRDWH VHUYL FD
H[SOLFD LHSHQWUXUHJXODULW LOHFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHREVHUYDWHODDFHDSHU
VRDQ SHQWUXFHHDFHHVWHFRQVLVWHQWvQFRPSRUWDPHQWXOHL7U V WXUD
HVWHRHQWLWDWHWHRUHWLF FDUHHVWHIRORVLW SHQWUXDH[SOLFDFRQVLVWHQ HOH
FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH DOH SHUVRDQHL VDX GLIHUHQ HOH GLQWUH FRQVLVWHQ HOH
FRPSRUWDPHQWDOHDOHPDLPXOWRUSHUVRDQHvQDFHVWVHQVHVWHLQFRUHFW
V XWLOL] P WHUPHQXO SHQWUX D GHVHPQD DFHVWH DVSHFWH FRPSRUWD
PHQWDOHvQVLQH'3
WU V WXULGHVXSUDID XQJUXSGHFRPSRUWDPHQWHLQWHUUHOD LRQDWHD
F URU DSDUL LH SRDWH IL REVHUYDW vQ YDULDWH FRQGL LL úL VLWXD LL vQ VHQV
VSHFLILF R WU V WXU GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH LSRWHWLF FDUH VH LGHQWLILF SULQ
DQDOL]DIDFWRULDO úLVHSUHVXSXQHDILUHVSRQVDELO GHDFHVWHFRPSRU
WDPHQWHFRUHODWH'3
WU V WXULGHWHPSHUDPHQWWU V WXULFHGHVFULXVWLOXOJHQHUDOGHFRP
SRUWDPHQWDOXQXLLQGLYLGFDU VSXQVODPHGLX
WU V WXUL GLQDPLFH WU V WXUL FDUH GHVFULX PRWLYHOH úL LQWHUHVHOH XQHL
SHUVRDQH
WU V WXUL VXUV R WU V WXU SVLKRORJLF LSRWHWLF ÄGH SURIXQ]LPH´
FDUH vQ WHUPHQL VWDWLVWLFL HFKLYDOHD] FX IDFWRULL SULPDUL RE LQX L vQ
XUPDDQDOL] ULLIDFWRULDOHDGDWHORUGHHYDOXDUHDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLVH
FRQVLGHU F DFHVWH WU V WXUL VXUV H[SOLF IDSWXO F PXOWH GLQWUH
WU V WXULOHGHVXSUDID SUH]LQW FRUHOD LLUHFLSURFHUHODWLYPDUL
WXOEXUDUHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHWHUPHQXODVHUYLWPXOWWLPSSHQWUXRULFHWLS
GH WXOEXUDUH D SHUVRQDOLW LL ,QL LDO VHPQLILFD RULFH WXOEXUDUH PHQWDO
PDQLIHVWDW SULQ QHDGDSWDUH úL PRGHOH QHDGDSWDWLYH GH UHOD LRQDUH FX
PHGLXO FHHD FH QX DMXWD OD GLIHUHQ LHUHD GLQWUH VLPSWRPH QHYURWLFH
PLQRUH ID GH WXOEXU UL PDMRUH SVLKRWLFH ÌQ SUH]HQW PDL VSHFLILF R
FODV GH WXOEXU UL GH FRPSRUWDPHQW H[FOX]kQG QHYUR]HOH úL SVLKR]HOH
PDQLIHVWDWHFDGH]YROW ULSDWRORJLFHvQSHUVRQDOLWDWHDvQWUHDJ DLQGLYL
GXOXL úL PDUFDW GH R DQ[LHWDWH UHODWLY VF ]XW VDX GH HPR LL QHJDWLYH
LQFOX]kQG DVWIHO WUHL VXEFODVH GH WXOEXU UL WXOEXU UL GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH
JHQHUDO LQFOX]kQG WXOEXUDUHD FRPSXOVLY FLFORWLPLF SDUDQRLG HWF
WXOEXU ULOH VRFLRSDWH FDUH VXQW FDUDFWHUL]DWH SULQWUR OLSV JHQHUDO D
DIHFWHORUDGHFYDWHDVHQWLPHQWHORUGHYLQRY LHvQXUPDvQF OF ULLOHJLORU
úLDLQFDSDFLW LLGHDIRUPDOHJ WXULHPR LRQDOHGHGXUDW LQFOX]kQGGH
H[HPSOXWXOEXUDUHDVRFLRSDW WXOEXUDUHDSVLKRSDW GHYLHULOHVH[XDOHÌQ
SUH]HQWRWXOEXUDUHPHQWDO DOHF UHLWU V WXULHVHQ LDOHVXQWPRGHOHGH
UHOD LRQDUH QHDGDSWDWLYH SURIXQG vQU G FLQDWH GH GXUDW PRGXUL GH
JkQGLUHúLSHUFHSHUHDPHGLXOXLFDUHVXQWH[WUHPHSkQ vQFRQGL LDGHD
FRQGXFH OD vPSLHGLFDUHD IXQF LRQ ULL VRFLDOH úL FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH 7XO
EXU ULOH GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH SRW IL UHFXQRVFXWH vQ JHQHUDO vQ FRSLO ULH VDX
DGROHVFHQ úLFRQWLQX GHDOXQJXOYLH LLDGXOWH'3
WXOEXUDUH SVLKRWLF XQ WHUPHQ FDUH DFRSHU XQ QXP U GH WXOEXU UL
PHQWDOHVHYHUHGHRULJLQHRUJDQLF VDXHPR LRQDO 'LDJQRVWLFDUHDDUH
vQ YHGHUH LQYDOLGLWDWHD GHWHULRUDUHD FDSDFLW LL GH WHVWDUH D UHDOLW LL
SHUVRDQD IDFH LQIHUHQ H LQFRUHFWH SULYLWRDUH OD UHDOLWDWHD H[WHUQ HYD
OX ULLPSURSULLDOHDFXUDWH HLJkQGXULORUúLSHUFHS LLORUVDOHúLFRQWLQX
V IDF HURUL vQ FLXGD GRYH]LORU FRQWUDULL 6LPSWRPHOH FODVLFH LQFOXG
KDOXFLQD LLFRPSRUWDPHQWHUHJUHVLYHVHYHUHGLVSR]L LLGUDPDWLFQHDGHF
YDWHYRUELUHLQFRHUHQW '3
%,%/,2*5$),(*(1(5$/
$OOSRUW*: 2GEHUW+67UDLW1DPHV$3V\FKROH[LFDO6WXG\
3V\FKRORJLFDO0RQRJUDSKV
$OOSRUW * : 3HUVRQDOLW\ $ 3V\FKRORJLFDO ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ +ROW
5LQHKDUW :LQVWRQ1HZ<RUN
$QDVWDVL$3V\FKRORJLFDO7HVWLQJ0DF0LOODQ3XEO&R1HZ<RUN
$QJOHLWQHU $ 3HUVRQDOLW\ 3V\FKRORJ\ 7UHQGV DQG 'HYHORSPHQW
Ä(XURS-RXUQRI3HUVRQDOLW\´
$QJOHLWQHU $ 6WUHODX - 3V\FKRPHWULF 0HDVXUHV RI 3DYORYLDQ
7HPSHUDPHQW7UDLWVDQG2EMHFWLYH3HUVRQDOLW\7HVWVD&RPHEDFNIRU
&DWWHOO+\SRWKHVHVvQ)RUWVFKULWWHGHU'LIIHUHQWLHOOHQ3V\FKRORJLHXQG
3V\FKRORJLVFKHQ 'LDJQRVWLF '%DUWXVVHN 0 $PHODQJ HGV
+RJUHIH*|WWLQJHQ
$QJOHLWQHU $ -RKQ 2 3 /|KU ) - ,W¶V :KDW <RX $VN DQG +RZ
<RX $VN ,W DQ ,WHPPHWULF $QDO\VLV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 4XHVWLRQQDLUHV vQ
$QJOHLWQHU $ :LJJLQV - 6 HGV 3HUVRQDOLW\ $VVHVVPHQW YLD
4XHVWLRQQDLUHV6SULQJHU9HUODJ%HUOLQ
$QJOHLWQHU$2VWHQGRUI)-RKQ23RSFLW&DSUDUD*93HUXJLQL
03HUVRQDOLW\'HVFULEHGE\$GMHFWLYHV*HQHUDOLVDELOLW\RIWKH
%LJ)LYH WR WKH ,WDOLDQ /H[LFDO &RQWH[W Ä(XURSHDQ -RXUQDO RI
3HUVRQDOLW\´
$QJOHLWQHU $ 2VWHQGRUI ) -RKQ 2 3 7RZDUGV D 7D[RQRP\ RI
3HUVRQDOLW\'HVFULSWRUVLQ*HUPDQ$3V\FKROH[LFDO6WXG\Ä(XURSHDQ
-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
$QJOHLWQHU$5LHPDQQ5:KDW&DQ:H/HDUQIURPWKH'LVFXVVLRQ
RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 4XHVWLRQQDLUHV IRU WKH &RQVWUXFWLRQ RI 7HPSHUDPHQW
,QYHQWRULHV" vQ 6WUHODX - $QJOHLWQHU $ HGV ([SORUDWLRQV LQ
7HPSHUDPHQW,QWHUQDWLRQDO3HUVSHFWLYHVRQ7KHRU\DQG0HDVXUHPHQW
S3OHQXP3UHVV/RQGRQ
$UQHWW - 6HQVDWLRQ 6HHNLQJ $ 1HZ &RQFHSWXDOLVDWLRQ DQG D 1HZ
6FDOH3HUVRQDOLW\DQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHVIHEU
$VVHVVPHQWDQG7HVWLQJ$6XUYH\RIUHVHDUFK8QLYHUVLW\RI&DPEULGJH
%DQQLVWHU ' 1HZ 3HUVSHFWLYHV LQ 3HUVRQDO &RQVWUXFW 7KHRU\
$FDGHPLF3UHVV1HZ<RUN
%DVK 6: ,QWURGXFWLRQ WR JHQHUDO FOLQLFDO SV\FKRSDWRORJ\ 7KH
SV\FKROSDWKRORJ\RIWKHEDVLFIXQFWLRQV&*-XQJ,QVWLWXWH
% EDQ $ 'HUHYHQFR 3 (\VHQFN 6%* 7HVWXO (34 Ä5HYLVWD GH
3VLKRORJLH´
%HUFNHQ9DQGHU-+/9DQ$DUOH(-05HFXUVLYH'LDJQRVLV
$0RGHOIRU'LDJQRVWLF5HDVRQLQJ±FRQWULEX LHODD,,,DFRQIHULQ D
($3$7ULHU
%RUNHQDX 3 6\VWHPDWLF 'LVWRUWLRQV LQ WKH 5HFRJQLWLRQ RI 7UDLW
,QIRUPDWLRQ vQ $QJOHLWQHU $ )XUQKDP $ 9DQ +HFN * HGV
3HUVRQDOLW\ 3V\FKRORJ\ LQ (XURSH &XUUHQW 7UDLWV DQG &RQWURYHUVLHV
6ZHWV =HLWOLQJHU /LVVH 1LVEHWW 5 5RVV /
+XPDQ ,QWHUIHUHQFH 6WUDWHJLHV DQG 6KRUW FRPLQJV RI 6RFLDO
-XGJHPHQWV3UHQWLFH+DOO(QJOHZRRG&OLIIV1-
%RUNHQDX 3 2VWHQGRUI ) $UH 6RFLDO 'HVLUDELOLW\ 6FDOHV 8VHIXO WR
,GHQWLI\6XEMHFWVZKR5HVSRQGLQD6RFLDOO\'HVLUDEOH:D\"
%UDQG&5 (JDQ97KHÄ%LJ)LYH´'LPHQVLRQVRI3HUVRQDOLW\"
(YLGHQFH IURP ,SVDWLYH $GMHFWLYDO 6HOI$WWULEXWLRQV 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG
,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV
%ULJJV 0\HUV , 0F&DXOOH\ 0 + 0DQXDO $ *XLGH WR WKH
'HYHORSPHQWDQG8VHRIWKH0\HUV%ULJJV7\SH,QGLFDWRU&RQVXOWLQJ
3V\FKRORJLVW3UHVV3DOR$OWR
%ULJJV 6 5 $VVHVVLQJ WKH )LYH)DFWRU 0RGHO RI 3HUVRQDOLW\
'HVFULSWLRQÄ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
%URNNHP ) % 7KH /DQJXDJH RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ WH] GH GRFWRUDW
8QLYHUVLWDWHD*URQLJHQ2ODQGD
%URPOH\ ' % 3HUVRQDOLW\ 'HVFULSWLRQV LQ 2UGLQDU\ /DQJXDJH
/RQJPDQ/RQGRQ
%URQVRQ:&7KH5ROHRI(QGXULQJ2ULHQWDWLRQWRWKH(QYLURQPHQWLQ
3HUVRQDOLW\'HYHORSPHQW*HQHWLF3V\FKRORJ\0RQRJUDSKV
%XVV ' 0 &UDLN . + 7KH $FW )UHTXHQF\ &RQFHSW RI
'LVSRVLWLRQV'RPLQDQFHDQG3URWRW\SLFDOO\'RPLQDQW$FWVÄ-RXUQDO
RI3HUVRQDOLW\´
&DQWRU1 )URP7KRXJKWWR%HKDYLRUÄ+DYLQJ´DQGÄ'RLQJ´LQWKH
6WXG\RI3HUVRQDOLW\DQG&RJQLWLRQ$PHULFDQ3V\FKRORJLVW
&DQWRU1=LUNHO63HUVRQDOLW\&RJQLWLRQDQG3XUSRVLYH%HKDYLRU
vQ/3HUYLQHG+DQGERRNRI3HUVRQDOLW\7KHRU\DQG5HVHDUFK7KH
*XLOIRUG3UHVV1HZ<RUN
&DSUDUD * 9 úL 3HUXJLQL 0 3HUVRQDOLW\ 6WUXFWXUH LQ ,WDOLDQ
Ä(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
&DSUDUD * 9 %DUEDUDQHOOL & %RUJRJQL / 3HUXJLQL 0 7KH %LJ
)LYH 4XHVWLRQQDLUH D 1HZ 4XHVWLRQQDLUH WR $VVHVV WKH )LYH )DFWRU
0RGHO3HUVRQDOLW\DQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV
&DWWHOO5%3HUVRQDOLW\DQG0RWLYDWLRQ6WUXFWXUHDQG0HDVXUHPHQW
:RUOG%RRN&R1HZ<RUN
&DWWHOO5%0DQXHOSRXUO¶DSSOLFDWLRQGHO¶(FKHOOHG¶$Q[LHWp&3$
3DULV
&DWWHOO 5% 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG 0RRG E\ 4XHVWLRQQDLUH -DVVH\ %DVV
6DQ)UDQFLVFR
&DWWHOO5%&RDQ5:3HUVRQDOLW\)DFWRUVLQ0LGGOH&KLOGKRRGDV
5HYHDOHGLQ3DUHQWV5DWLQJVvQ&KLOG'HYHORSPHQW
&DWWHOO 5% (EHU +: 0DQXHO GµDSSOLFDWLRQ GX WHVW 3) (G
&3$3DULV
&DWWHOO5%*UXHQ:7KH3HUVRQDOLW\IDFWRU6WUXFWXUHRI\HDUROG
FKLOGUHQ LQ WHUPV RI %HKDYLRU 5DWLQJ 'DWD Ä-RXUQ RI &OLQLFDO
3V\FKRORJ\´±
&DWWHOO 5 % 7KH 'HVFULSWLRQ RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ %DVLF 7UDLWV 5HVROYHG
LQWR&OXVWHUVÄ-RXUQDORI$EQRUPDODQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
&DWWHOO 5 % 'HVFULSWLRQ DQG 0HDVXUHPHQW RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ :RUOG
%RRN1HZ<RUN &RQILUPDWLRQDQG&ODULILFDWLRQRI3ULPDU\
3HUVRQDOLW\)DFWRUV3V\FKRPHWULND
&KDSPDQ -3 &KDSPDQ /- .ZDSLO 75 'RHV WKH (\VHQFN
3V\FKRWLVP 6FDOH 3UHGLFW 3V\FKRVLV" $ 7HQ <HDU /RQJLWXGLQDO 6WXG\
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV
&RVWD37 0F&UDH557KH1(23,1(2)),0DQXDO6XSSOHPHQW
2GHVVD3$5
&RVWD37 0F&UDH557KH1(23HUVRQDOLW\,QYHQWRU\0DQXDO
2GHVVD)ORULGD3V\FKRORJLFDO$VVHVVPHQW5HVRXUFHV
&RVWD 3 7 0F&UDH 5 5 7KH 1(2 3, 5 3URIHVVLRQDO 0DQXDO
5HYLVHG3V\FKRORJLFDO$VVHVVPHQW5HVRXUFHV2GHVVD)ORULGD
&RVWD 3 7 0F&UDH 5 5 3HUVRQDOLW\ LQ $GXOWKRRG $ 6L[<HDU
/RQJLWXGLQDO6WXG\RI6HOI5HSRUWVDQG6SRXVH5DWLQJVRQWKH1(23,
Ä-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´&RVWD3
7 0F&UDH 5 5 1(2 3, 5 3URIHVVLRQDO 0DQXDO 3$5
2GHVVDS
&RVWD370F&UDH553HUVRQDOLW\'LVRUGHUVDQGWKH)LYH)DFWRU
0RGHORI3HUVRQDOLW\Ä-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\'LVRUGHUV´
&RVWD370F&UDH55'\H'$)DFHW6FDOHVIRU$JUHHDEOHQHVV
DQG &RQVFLRXVQHVV $ 5HYLVLRQ RI 1(2 3, 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG ,QGLYLGXDO
'LIIHUHQFHV
&RVWD370F&UDH55,QIOXHQFHRI([WUDYHUVLRQDQG1HXURWLFLVP
RQ 6XEMHFWLYH :HOO²%HLQJ +DSS\ DQG 8QKDSS\ 3HRSOH Ä-RXUQDO RI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
&URQEDFK/*(VVHQWLDOVRI3V\FKRORJLFDO7HVWLQJ+DUSHU 5RZ
1HZ<RUN
&URQEDFK /- 'UHQWK 3-' 0HQWDO 7HVWV DQG FXOWXUDO $GDSWDWLRQ
7KH+DJXH0RXWRQ
'H5DDG% &DOMH+3HUVRQDOLW\LQWKH&RQWH[WRI&RQYHUVDWLRQ
3HUVRQ7DON
'H5DDG%3HUVRQ7DONLQ(YHU\GD\/LIH3UDJPDWLFVRI8WWHUDQFHVIRU
6FLHQWLILF3XUSRVHVWH] GHGRFWRUDW8QLYHUVLWDWHD*URQLQJHQ2ODQGD
'H 5DDG % HW DO RS FLW +RIVWHH : . % 7KH 8VH RI
(YHU\GD\ /DQJXDJH IRU 6FLHQWLILF 3XUSRVH Ä(XURSHDQ -RXUQDO RI
3HUVRQDOLW\´'H5DDG%7KH5HSOLFDELOLW\RIWKH%LJ
)LYH 3HUVRQDOLW\ 'LPHQVLRQV LQ WKH 7KUHH :RUOG &ODVVHV RI 'XWFK
/DQJXDJH Ä(XURSHDQ -RXUQDO RI 3HUVRQDOLW\´ &DSUDUD
3HUXJLQLRSFLW+RIVWHH:.%RSFLW
'H5DDG%+LVNHQV0 3HUVRQDOLW\'HVFULSWLYH1RXQVÄ(XURSHDQ
-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
'H5DDG%0XOGHU(.ORRVWHUPDQ.+RIVWHH(.%3HUVRQDOLW\
'HVFULSWLYH9HUEVÄ(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
'H5DDG%6]LUPDN= 7KH6HDUFKIRUWKH%LJ)LYHLQD1RQ,QGR
(XURSHDQ/DQJXDJHWKH+XQJDULDQ7UDLW6WUXFWXUHDQG,WV5HODWLRQVKLS
WRWKH(34DQG376Ä(XURSHDQ5HYLHZRI$SSOLHG3V\FKRORJ\´
'HOD\-3LFKRW33HUVH-0HWKRGHVSV\FKRPpWULTXHVHQFOLQLTXH7HVW
0HQWDX[HWLQWHUUHWDWLRQ38)3DULV
'L%ODV/)RU]L0$)XUWKHU6WHS7RZDUGVWKH,WDOLDQ7D[RQRP\RI
3HUVRQDOLW\ 'HVFULSWLYH 7HUPV FRPXQLFDUH D 9,,D FRQIHULQ D
($330DGULG
'LJPDQ - 0 3HUVRQDOLW\ 6WUXFWXUH (PHUJHQFH RI WKH )LYH)DFWRU
0RGHOÄ$QQXDO5HYLHZRI3V\FKRORJ\´
'LQF 03URFHVXDO&UHDWLYH6WUXFWXUHVDQG/HYHOVRI3HUIRUPDQFH
Ä5HYXHGHSV\FKRORJLH´
'UXPPRQG $SSUDLVDO SURFHGXUHV IRU FRXQVHORUV DQG KHOSLQJ
SURIHVVLRQDOV0HUULOO1<
'60 ,9 0DQXDO GH 'LDJQRVWLF úL VWDWLVWLF D WXOEXU ULORU PHQWDOH
$PHULFDQ3V\FKLDWULF$VVRFLDWLRQ(GLWXUD$3/5%XFXUHúWL
(LVHQEHUJ 3 ,QGLYLGXDO ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ RI 3V\FKRQHXURWLF ,QYHQWRU\
,WHPVÄ-RXUQDORI*HQHUDO3V\FKRORJ\´
(\VHQFN+-7KH6FLHQWLILF6WXG\RI+XPDQ3HUVRQDOLW\:LOH\1HZ<RUN
(\VHQFN +- 6\ELO (\VHQFN 0DQXDO RI WKH (\VHQFN 3HUVRQDOLW\
4XHVWLRQQDLUH8QLY2I/RQGRQ3UHVV/RQGRQ
(\VHQFN+-/HVGLPHQVLRQVGHODSHUVRQDOLWp38)3DULV
(\VHQFN+-7KH%LRORJLFDO%DVHVRI3HUVRQDOLW\&KDUOHV&7KRDV
6SULQJILHOG
(\VHQFN+-&ULPHDQG3HUVRQDOLW\5RXWOHGJHDQG.HJDQ/RQGRQ
(\VHQFN +- 7KH 'HILQLWLRQ DQG 0HDVXUHPHQW RI 3V\FKRWLFLVP
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV
(\VHQFN+-&UHDWLYLW\DQG3HUVRQDOLW\D7KHRUHWLFDO3HUVSHFWLYHvQ
3V\FKRORJLFDO,QTXLU\
(\VHQFN +- &RQVWUXFW 9DOLGLW\ RI ([SHULHPHQWDO 6WXGLHV RI
3HUVRQDOLW\Ä(XURS-RXUPRI3HUVRQDOLW\$VVHVVPHQW´VXSO
(\VHQFN+-&UHDWLYLW\DVD3URGXFWRI,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG3HUVRQDOLW\
vQ 6DORIVNH '+ =HLGQHU 0 HG ,QWHUQDWLRQDO +DQGERRN RI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG,QWHOOLJHQFH3OHQXO1HZ<RUN
(\VHQFN +- (DVWLQJ * (\VHEFN 6% 3HUVRQDOLW\ 0HDVXUHPHQW LQ
&KLOGUHQ$'LPHQVLRQDO$SSURDFKÄ-RXUQRI6SHFLDO(GXFDWLRQ´
±
(\VHQFN0:7UDLW$Q[LHW\$0RGXODU$SSURDFK$9,,DFRQIHULQ
D($33
(\VHQFN7KH0HDVXUHPHQWRI3HUVRQDOLW\5RXWOHGJHDQG.HJDQ/RQGRQ
(\VHQFN+- (\VHQFN6%*0DQXDORIWKH(\VHQFN3HUVRQDOLW\
4XHVWLRQQDLUH8QLYHUVLW\RI/RQGRQ3UHVV/RQGRQ
(\VHQFN +- +XPDQ 0HPRU\ 7KHRU\ 5HVHDUFK DQG ,QGLYLGXDO
'LIIHUHQFHV3HUJDPRQ2[IRUG
)HUQDQGH]%DOOHVWHURV ' $UH 6RFLDO 'HVLUDELOLW\ DQG )DNLQJ
'LIIHUHQW'LPHQVLRQV±D,,DFRQIHULQ D($3$7ULHU
)LVNH ' : &RQVLVWHQF\ RI WKH )DFWRULDO 6WUXFWXUHV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\
5DWLQJV IURP 'LIIHUHQW 6RXUFHV Ä-RXUQDO RI $EQRUPDO DQG 6RFLDO
3V\FKRORJ\´ 7XSHV ( & &KULVWDO 5 &
5HFXUUHQW3HUVRQDOLW\)DFWRUV%DVHGRQ7UDLW5DWLQJV86$LU)RUFH
/DNHODQG
)LVNH 6 7 &R[ 0 * 3HUVRQ &RQFHSWV WKH (IIHFW RI 7DUJHW
)DPLOLDULW\ DQG 'HVFULSWLYH 3XUSRVH RQ WKH 3URFHVV RI 'HVFULELQJ
2WKHUVÄ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
)RUVPDQ/*LYLQJ([WUHPH5HVSRQVHVWR,WHPVLQ6HOI(VWHHP6FDOHV
5HVSRQVH6HWRU3HUVRQDOLW\7UDLW"Ä(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3V\FKRORJLFDO
$VVHVVPHQW´
)RVV'-+DNHV'73V\FKROLQJXLVWLFV(QJOHZRRG&OLIIV3UHQWLFH
+DOO
)UDQFLV/- 7KH'XDO1DWXUHRIWKH(34/LH6FDOHDPRQJ&ROOHJH
6WXGHQWV LQ (QJODQG 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG ,QGLYLGXDO 'LIIHUHQFHV
*DOOXFL0/DXULROD0/HRQH//LYL63HUXJLQL0&RPSDULQJ
'LIIHUHQW00700HWKRGVRQWKH%LJ)LYH'RPDLQVOXFUDUHSUH]HQWDW
ODD9,,DFRQIHULQ ($330DGULG
*ROGEHUJ/$/DQJXDJHDQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHVWKH6HDUFKIRU
8QLYHUVDOVLQ3HUVRQDOLW\/H[LFRQVÄ5HYLHZRI3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO
3V\FKRORJ\´
*ROGEHUJ/5$0RGHORI,WHP$PELJXLW\LQ3HUVRQDOLW\$VVHVVPHQW
(GXFDWLRQDODQG3V\FKRORJLFDO0HDVXUHPHQW
*ROGEHUJ / 5 $ +LVWRULFDO 6XUYH\ RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 6FDOHV DQG
,QYHQWRULHV vQ 0F.H\QROGV 3 HG $GYDQFHV LQ 3V\FKRORJLFDO
$VVHVVPHQWYRO3DOR$OWR
*ROGEHUJ/5'HYHORSLQJD7D[RQRP\RIWUDLW'HVFULSWLYH7HUPVvQ
)LVNH ' : HG 1HZ 'LUHFWLRQV IRU 0HWKRGRORJ\ RI 6RFLDO
%HKDYLRUDO6FLHQFHV3UREOHPVZLWK/DQJXDJH,PSUHFLVLRQ-RVVH\
%DVV6DQ)UDQFLVFR&$
*ROGEHUJ/5 /DQJXDJHDQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV7KH6HDUFKIRU
8QLYHUVDOV LQ 3HUVRQDOLW\ /H[LFRQV vQ :KHHOHU / HG Ä5HYLHZ RI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´6DJH%HYHUO\+LOOV&$
*ROGEHUJ / 5 )URP $FH WR =RPELH 6RPH ([SORUDWLRQV LQ WKH
/DQJXDJHRI3HUVRQDOLW\vQ6SLHOEHUJ&'DQG%XWFKHU-1HGV
$GYDQFHVLQ3HUVRQDOLW\$VVHVVPHQW(UOEDXP+LOVGDOH
*ROGEHUJ / 5 8QFRQIRXQGLQJ 6LWXDWLRQDO $WWULEXWLRQV IURP
8QFHUWDLQ1HXWUDODQG$PELJXRXV2QHV$3V\FKRPHWULF$QDO\VLVRI
'HVFULSWLRQ RI 2QHVHOI DQG 9DULRXV 7\SHV RI 2WKHUV Ä-RXUQDO RI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
*ROGEHUJ / 5 RS FLW +RIVWHH : . % 'H 5DDG % *ROGEHUJ / 5
,QWHJUDWLRQRIWKH%LJ)LYHDQG&LUFXPSOH[$SSURDFKHVWR7UDLW
6WUXFWXUHÄ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
*ROGEHUJ/7KH'HYHORSPHQWRI0DUNHUVIRUWKH%LJ)LYH)DFWRU6WUXFWXUH
3V\FKRORJLFDO$VVHVVPHQW
*ROGEHUJ RS FLW -RKQ 2 3 7RZDUGV DQ 7D[RQRP\ RI 3HUVRQDOLW\
'HVFULSWRUVvQ%XVV'0 &DQWRU1HGV3HUVRQDOLW\3V\FKRORJ\
5HFHQW 7UHQGV DQG (PHUJLQJ 'LUHFWLRQV 6SULQJHU 9HUODJ 1HZ <RUN
*RXJK *+ 7KH ) PLQXV . 'LVVLPXODWLRQ LQGH[ IRU WKH 003,
Ä-RXUQ&RQVXOW3V\FKRO´
*RXJK * + +HLOEUXQ $ % $GMHFWLYH &KHFN /LVW 0DQXDO &33
3DOR$OWR&$
*RXJK + * 0DQXDO IRU WKH &DOLIRUQLD 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\
&RQVXOWLQJ3V\FKRORJLVW3UHVV3DOR$OWR&DOLIRUQLD
*RXJK + * 7KH &DOLIRUQLD 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\ $GPLQLVWUDWRU¶V
*XLGH&333DOR$OWR&D
*RXJK + * +HLOEUXQ $ % $GMHFWLYH &KHFN/LVW 0DQXDO 3DOR
$OWR&D&RQVXOWLQJ3V\FKRORJLVW3UHVV
*UDKDP -5 7KH 003, $ 3UDFWLFDO *XLGH 2[IRUG 8QLY 3UHVV
1HZ<RUN
*UDKDP -5 003, $VVHVVLQJ 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG 3V\FKRSDWKRORJ\
2[IRUGXQLY3UHVV1HZ<RUN
+DPSVRQ 6 ( 7UDLW $VFULSWLRQ DQG 'HSWK RI $FTXDLQWDQFH WKH
3UHIHUHQFHIRU7UDLWVLQ3HUVRQDOLW\'HVFULSWLRQVDQG,WV5HODWLRQVWR
7DUJHW)DPLOLDULW\Ä-RXUQDORI5HVHDUFKLQ3HUVRQDOLW\´
/LYHVOH\:-%URPOH\'%3HUVRQ3HUFHSWLRQLQ&KLOGKRRG
DQG$GROHVFHQFH:LOH\1HZ<RUN
+DVH+' *ROGEHUJ/57KH&RPSDUDWLYH9DOLGLW\RI'LIIHUHQW
6WUDWHJLHV RI 'HULYLQJ 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\ 6FDOHV 3V\FKRORJLFDO
%XOOHWLQ
+DWKDZD\ 65 0F.LQOH\ -& 0LQQHVRWD 0XOWLSKDVLF 3HUVRQDOLW\
,QYHQWRU\8QLY0LQQ3UHVV0LQQHDSROLV
+DWKDZD\ 65 0HHKO 3( $Q $WODV IRU WKH &OLQLFDO 8VH RI 003,
8QLY0LQQ3UHVV0LQQHDSROLV
+DWKDZD\ 6DUNH 5 0RQDFKHVL ( ' $Q $WODV RI -XYHQLOH 003,
3URILOHV803UHVV0LQQHDSROLV
+DWKDZD\ (' 0RQDFKHVL $GROHVFHQW 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG %HKDYLRXU
003,SDWWHUQV7KH8QLYHUVLW\RI0LQQHVRWD3UHVV0LQQHDSROLV
+HGJHV33HUVRQDOLWDWHúLWHPSHUDPHQW+XPDQLWDV%XFXUHúWL
+HQGULNV$$-+RIVWHH:%.'H5DDG%&RQVWUXFWLRQRIWKH
$%& 3HUVRQDOLW\ 4XHVWLRQQDLUH FRPXQLFDUH OD D ,,D FRQIHULQ D
($33*URQLQJHQ
+RIVWHH:.%úDRSFLW3HUXJLQL0$FLUFXPSOH[+LHUDUFKLFDO
$SSURDFK WR ,QGLYLGXDWH D 7D[RQRP\ RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ &KDUDFWHULVWLFV
WH] GHGRFWRUDW8QLYHUVLWDWHDGLQ5RPD
+RIVWHH : . % 7KH 8VH RI (YHU\GD\ 3HUVRQDOLW\ /DQJXDJH IRU
6FLHQWLILF3XUSRVHVÄ(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
+RIVWHH : . % :KR .QRZV %HVW DERXW 3HUVRQDOLW\ OXFUDUH
SUH]HQWDW ODD9,,DFRQIHULQ ($330DGULG
+RIVWHH:.%'H5DDG%*ROGEHUJ/5,QWHJUDWLRQRIWKH%LJ
)LYH DQG &LUFXPSOH[ $SSURDFKHV WR 7UDLW 6WUXFWXUH Ä-RXUQDO RI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
+RIVWHH : . % +HQGULNV $ $ - 6KRXOG :H 7U\ WR &RQWURO IRU
6RFLDOO\'HVLUDEOH5HVSRQGLQJ"
+RUURFNV-(7KH3V\FKRORJ\RI$GROHVFHQFH+RXJKWRQ0LIIOLQ&R
%RVWRQ
,&' &ODVLILFDUHD WXOEXU ULORU PHQWDOH úL GH FRPSRUWDPHQW :RUOG
+HDOWK$VVRFLDWLRQ(GLWXUD$//%XFXUHúWL
,QYHQWDUHPXOWLID]LFHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWH,6(%XFXUHúWL
-DFNVRQ'13HUVRQDOLW\5HVHDUFK)RUP0DQXDO*RVKHQ5HVHDUFK
3V\FKRORJLVWV
-DFNVRQ'1$6HTXHQWLDO6\VWHPIRU3HUVRQDOLW\6FDOH'HYHORSPHQW
vQ 6SLHOEHUJHU & ' HG &XUUHQW 7RSLF LQ &OLQLFDO DQG &RPPXQLW\
3V\FKRORJ\YRO$FDGHPLF3UHVV1HZ<RUN
-DQNH : 'DV 'LOHPPD YRQ 3HUV|QOLFKNHLWIUDJHERJHQ /HQQHUW] (
7KHVHQ]XU,WHPVDPPOXQJEHL3HUV|QOLFKNHLWVIUDJHERJHQDPEHOH
vQ 5HLQKDUW * HG %HULFKW EHU GHQ .RQJUHVV GHU 'HXWVFKHQ
*HVHOOVFKDIWIU3V\FKRORJLH.LHO+RJUDIH*|WWLQJHQ
-RKQ237KHÄ%LJ)LYH´)DFWRU7D[RQRP\'LPHQVLRQVRI3HUVRQDOLW\
LQ WKH 1DWXUDO /DQJXDJH DQG LQ 4XHVWLRQQDLUHV vQ 3HUYLQ / HG
+DQGERRN RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 7KHRU\ DQG 5HVHDUFK 1HZ <RUN *XLOIRUG
-RKQVRQ-$ ,QWHUSUHWLQJWKH&DOLIRUQLD3HUVRQDOLW\,QYHQWRU\ZLWK
WKH$E&0RGHOD9,DFRQIHULQ D($33*URQLQJHQ
-RKQVRQ-$ 7KHÄ6HOI'LVFORVXUH´DQGÄ6HOI3UHVHQWDWLRQ´9LHZV
RI,WHP5HVSRQVH'\QDPLFVDQG3HUVRQDOLW\6FDOH9DOLGLW\Ä-RXUQDORI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
-XQJ &* 7LSXUL 3VLKRORJLFH +XPDQLWDV Y -XQJ & *
3V\FKRORJLVFKH 7\SHQ *HVDPPHOWH :HUNH YRO 9, 5DVFKHU9HUODJ
=ULFKSDU LDOWUDGXV vQÄ'HVFULHUHDWLSXULORUSVLKRORJLFH´
DQWRORJLD&*-XQJYRO,,(G$QLPD%XFXUHúWL
.HOO\*$7KH3V\FKRORJ\RI3HUVRQDO&RQVWUXFWV1RUWRQ1HZ<RUN
/DYLQ73-XQJ
VSV\FKRORJLFDOW\SHVLQDQDO\VLVvQ06WHLQ-XQJLDQ
$QDO\VLV2SHQ&RXUW,OOLQRLV
/HRQKDUG . 3HUVRQDOLW L DFFHQWXDWH vQ YLD úL OLWHUDWXU (GLWXUD
(QFLFORSHGLF 5RPkQ %XFXUHúWL
/LHQHUW*$7HVWDXIEDXXQG7HVWDQDO\VH%HOW]:HLQKHLP/|KU)-
$QJOHLWQHU$(LQH8QWHUVXFKFKXQJ]X6RUDFKOLFKHQ)RUPXOLHUXQJHQ
GHU ,WHPV LQ 'HXWVFKHQ 3HUV|QOLFKOHLWVIUDJHERJHQ =HLWVFKULIW IU
'LIHUHQWLHOOHXQG'LDJQRVWLVFKH3V\FKRORJLH
/RHYLQJHU - / 2EMHFWLYH 7HVWV DV ,QVWUXPHQWV RI 3V\FKRORJLFDO
7KHRU\3V\FKRORJLFDO5HSRUWV
0DQXDO IRU $GPLQLVWUDWLRQ DQG 6FRULQJ 003, 8QLYHUVLW\ RI
0LQQHVRWD3UHVV1DWLRQDO&RPSXWHU
0DUFXV6 &DWLQD$5ROXOFRQVWUXFWHORUvQFXQRDúWHUHDHPSDWLF
Ä5HYLVWDGHSVLKRORJLH´6WLOXULDSUHFLDWLYHÄ5HYLVWD
GHSVLKRORJLH´6WLOXULDSUHFLDWLYH(GLWXUD$FDGHPLHL
%XFXUHúWL
0DVRQ21HZ6FDOHVIRUWKH$VVHVVPHQWRI6FKL]RWLS\FRPXQLFDUHOD
D9,,DFRQIHULQ D($330DGULG
0DVRQ 2 &ODULGJH * 6FDOHV 0HDVXULQJ 3URQHQHVV WR 3V\FKRWLF
'LVRUGHUVDQG7KHLU5HODWLRQVKLSWRWKH)LYH)DFWRU0RGHOFRPXQLFDUH
ODD9,,DFRQIHULQ D($330DGULG
0F&OHOODQG'&,V3HUVRQDOLW\&RQVLVWHQW"vQ5DELQ$,$UQRII
- %HUFOD\ $ 0 =XFNHU 5 $ HGV )XUWKHU ([SORUDWLRQV LQ
3HUVRQDOLW\:LOH\1HZ<RUN
0F&UDH 5 5 &RVWD 3 7 3HUVRQDOLW\ LQ $GXOWKRRG 1HZ <RUN
*XLOIRUGS
0F&UDH55 &RVWD37$7UDLW3HUVSHFWLYHRQWKH'HVFULSWLRQ
DQG([SODQDWLRQRI%HKDYLRU9,,,&RQIHUHQFHRI($330DGULG
0F&UDH 5 5 +RZ :HOO LV 2SHQQHVV 5HSUHVHQWHG LQ 1DWXUDO
/DQJXDJHV"Ä(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\´
0F&UDH 5 5 3V\FKRSDWKRORJ\ IURP WKH 3HUVSHFWLYH RI WKH )LYH
)DFWRU 0RGHO vQ 6WUDFN 6 /RUU 0 HGV 'LIIHUHQWLDWLQJ 1RUPDO
DQG$EQRUPDO3HUVRQDOLW\1HZ<RUN6SULQJHU
0F&UDH55 RSFLW-RKQ23 7KH%LJ)LYH)DFWRU7D[RQRP\
'LPHQVLRQV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ LQ WKH 1DWXUDO /DQJXDJH DQG LQ
4XHVWLRQQDLUHV vQ 3HUYLQ / $ HG +DQGERRN RI 3HUVRQDOLW\
7KHRU\DQG5HVHDUFK7KH*XLOIRUG3UHVV1HZ<RUN
0HHKO 5HDFWLRQV 5HIOHFWLRQV 3URMHFWLRQV vQ %XWFKHU - 1 HG
2EMHFWLYH 3HUVRQDOLW\ $VVHVVPHQW &KDQJLQJ 3HUVSHFWLYHV $FDGHPLF
3UHVV1HZ<RUN
0HJDUJHH ( , 7KH &DOLIRUQLD 3HUVRQDOLW\ ,QYHQWRU\ +DQGERRN
-RVVH\%DVV,QF6DQ)UDQFLVFR:DVKLQJWRQ/RQGRQ
0HLOL50DQXHOGXGLDJQRVWLTXHSV\FKRORJLTXH38)3DULV
0HUHQGD 3) &RPSDULVRQ %HWZHHQ WKH 0DQXDOV IRU WKH 003, DQG
003,DFULWLTXHÄ(XURS-RXUQRI3VFK$VVHVVPHQW´
0HUYLHOGH,$&RPSDULVRQRI)LYH)DFWRU5DWLQJVDQG)UHH'HVFULSWLRQV
RI &KLOGUHQ $JHV WR FRPXQLFDUH OD D 9,,D FRQIHULQ D ($33
0DGULG
0LOMNRYLWFK-)DFWRULDO$QDO\VLVDQGWKH'LVWDQFHV&RPSXWDWLRQVLQ
5HSHUWRU\*ULG7HVWRI*$.HOO\,QWURGXFWLRQWRD'LJLWDO3URJUDPPH
Ä5HYLHZRI$SSOLHG3V\FKRORJ\´
0LQXOHVFX 0 7HVWXO 313 7HVWXO 3V\KRUDWHU &RQVWUXLUHD úL LQWHU
SUHWDUHD WHVWXOXL &3, úL 3) vQ ,QYHQWDUHOH GH 3HUVRQDOLWDWH
,QVWLWXWXOGHùWLLQ HDOH(GXFD LHL
0LQXOHVFX00HWDSKRUVYV6LQJOH7HUPVLQ([SUHVVLQJDQG$VVHVVLQJ
3HUVRQDOLW\vQÄ(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3V\FKRORJLFDO$VVHVVPHQW´Y
0LQXOHVFX 0 ,QGLFDWRUXO GH WLSRORJLH 0\HUV%ULJJV SULYLQG VWLOXULOH
DSUHFLDWLYHvQ&KHVWLRQDUHOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHvQHYDOXDUHDSVLKRORJLF
*DUHOO3+%XFXUHúWL
0LQXOHVFX0&KHVWLRQDUHOHGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHvQHYDOXDUHDSVLKRORJLF
*DUUHO%XFXUHúWL
0LQXOHVFX0(YDOXDUHDSVLKRORJLF vQVHOHF LDSURIHVLRQDO (GLWXUD
3DQ%XFXUHúWL
0LQXOHVFX 0 %D]HOH SVLKRGLDJQRVWLFXOXL (GLWXUD 8QLYHUVLW LL 7LWX
0DLRUHVFX%XFXUHúWL
0LQXOHVFX0,QWURGXFHUHvQDQDOL]DMXQJLDQ (GLWXUD7UHL%XFXUHúWL
0LQXOHVFX06WUHODX-$QJOHLWQHU$&RQFHSHUHDúLH[SHULPHQWDUHD
YDULDQWHL URPkQHúWL D WHVWXOXL GH P VXUDUH D FDUDFWHULVWLFLORU ED]DOH
HQHUJHWLFHDSHUVRQDOLW LL675,&RQIHULQ DQD LRQDO GHSVLKRORJLH
%XFXUHúWL
0LQXOHVFX05HSOLFDUHDPRGHOXOXL%LJ)LYHvQOLPEDURPkQ 6SHFLILFXO
VRFLRFXOWXUDOH[SULPDWvQFRQ LQXWXOIDFWRULORU&KHVWLRQDUXO$%&'0
vQ0=ODWH3VLKRORJLDYLH LLFRWLGLHQH3ROLURP,DúL
0LQXOHVFX0(YDOXDUHDWU V WXULORUGHSHUVRQDOLWDWHDOHSDFLHQ LORU
vQ % /XEDQ3OR]]D úL ,% ,DPDQGHVFX 'LPHQVLXQHD SVLKRVRFLDO D
3UDFWLFLL0HGLFDOH(GLWXUD,QIR0HGLFD%XFXUHúWL
0LQXOHVFX07HRULHúLSUDFWLF vQSVLKRGLDJQR] 7HVWDUHD,QWHOHFWXOXL
(GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH%XFXUHúWL
0LQXOHVFX05H]ROYDUHDGHSUREOHPHúLVWLOXOFRJQLWLYvQLQYHVWLJD LD
MXULGLF WH] GHGRFWRUDW8QLYHUVLWDWHD%XFXUHúWL
0ODFLF%.QH]RYLF=%LJ)LYH6WXGLHVLQ&URDWLD$7UDQVSDUHQWYV
2SDTXH)RUPDWVFRPXQLFDUHODD9,,DFRQIHULQ D($330DGULG
0\HUV%ULJJV,0F&DXOOH\0+0DQXDODJXLGHWRWKHGHYHORSPHQW
DQGXVHRIWKH0%7,&333DO $OWR
1'6XQGEHUJ$VVHVVPHQWRISHUVRQV3UHQWLFH+DOO1HZ-HUVH\
1LFROD*U,VWRULDSVLKRORJLHL(GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH
%XFXUHúWL
1RUPDQ : 7 7RZDUGV DQ $GHTXDWH 7D[RQRP\ RI 3HUVRQDOLW\
$WWULEXWHV5HSOLFDWHGIDFWRUVWUXFWXUHVLQSHHUQRPLQDWLRQSHUVRQDOLW\
UDWLQJVÄ-RXUQDORI$EQRUPDODQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
1RZDFN:3HUVSHFWLYHVRQWKH6HOI,VWKH,GHDO6HOI6RFLDOO\'HVLUDEOH"
2*-RKQVRQ7HVWVDQGPHDVXUHPHQWLQFKLOGGHYHORSPHQW9RO,úL,,
-RVVH\%DVV6DQ)UDQFLVFR
2VWHQGRUI ) /DQJXDJH DQG 3HUVRQDOLW\ 6WUXFWXUH 7RZDUGV WKH
9DOLGLW\ RI WKH )LYH)DFWRU 0RGHO RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 6 5RGHUHU 9HUODJ
5HJHQVEXUJ
2VWHQGRUI ) 6SUDFKH XQG 3HUV|QOLFKNHLWVVWUXNWXU =XU 9DOLGLWlW GHV
)QI)DNWRUHQ0RGHOOVGHU3HUV|QOLFKNHLW5RGHUHU9HUODJ5HJHQVEXUJ
3DXOKXV ' / 0HDQLQJ WKH 'LPHQVLRQDOLW\ RI 6RFLDOO\ 'HVLUDEOH
5HVSRQGLQJ$3DUDGR[
3HDERG\ ' 3 *ROGEHUJ / 5 6RPH 'HWHUPLQDQWV RI )DFWRU
6WUXFWXUHIURP3HUVRQDOLW\7UDLW'HVFULSWRUVvQÄ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\
DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
3HDERG\'36HOHFWLQJ5HSUHVHQWDWLYH7UDLW$GMHFWLYHVÄ-RXUQDORI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
3HUXJLQL 0 $ &LUFXPSOH[ +LHUDUFKLFDO $SSURDFK WR ,QGLYLGXDWH D
7D[RQRP\RI3HUVRQDOLW\&KDUDFWHULVWLFVWH] GHGRFWRUDW8QLYHUVLWDWHD
GLQ5RPD
3HUXJLQL0/HRQH/*DOOXFL0/DXULROD06HOHFWLRQRID6KRUW
$GMHFWLYH&KHFNOLVWWR0HDVXUH%LJ)LYHOXFUDUHSUH]HQWDW ODD9,,D
FRQIHULQ D($330DGULG
3HUYLQ/$$&ULWLFDO$QDO\VLVRI&XUUHQW7UDLW7KHRU\3V\FKRORJLFDO
,QTXLU\ GH DVHPHQHD vQ 7KH 7KUHH 'LVFLSOLQHV RI
3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG WKH 3UREOHP RI 9ROLWLRQ 9,,WK &RQIHUHQFH RI ($33
0DGULG
3LFKRW3/HTXHVWLRQQDLUH313Ä5HYXHGHSV\FKRORJLHDSSOLTXHH´
3LFKRW30DQXHOGXTXHVWLRQQDLUH313&$33DULV
3LWDULX+3VLKRORJLDVHOHF LHLúLIRUP ULLSURIHVLRQDOH'DFLD&OXM1DSRFD
3LWDULX+0$OEX3VLKRORJLDSHUVRQDOXOXL0 VXUDUHDúLLQWHUSUHWDUHD
GLIHUHQ HORULQGLYLGXDOH(G3UHVD8QLY&OXMHDQ &1
3LWDULX+'&3,0DQXDO8%%&OXM1DSRFD
3LWDULX + ' $OEX 0 ,QYHQWDUXO GH SHUVRQDOLWDWH &DOLIRUQLD SUH
]HQWDUH úL UH]XOWDWH H[SHULPHQWDOH Ä5HYLVWD GH SVLKRORJLH´ QU
3LWDULX+'+HKQ+,QYHVWLJDUHDSHUVRQDOLW LLFXDMXWRUXO,QYHQWDUXOXL
GHSHUVRQDOLWDWH&DOLIRUQLDÄ5HYLVWDGHSVLKRORJLH´
5LERW7$7KHSV\FKRORJ\RI(PRWLRQV/RQGRQ
5REHUWV % : 5RELQ 5 : %URDG 'LVSRVLWLRQV %URDG $VSLUDWLRQV
7KH,QWHUVHFWLRQRIWKH%LJ)LYH'LPHQVLRQVDQG/LIH*RDOVFRPXQLFDUH
ODD9,,DFRQIHULQ D($330DGULG
5RJHUV7%7KH3URFHVVRI5HVSRQGLQJWR3HUVRQDOLW\,WHPV6RPH
,VVXHVD7KHRU\DQGVRPH5HVHDUFK0XOWLYDULDWH%HKDYLRUDO5HVHDUFK
0RQRJUDSK
5RNHDFK07KH2SHQDQG&ORVHG0LQG%DVLF%RRNV1HZ<RUN
5RúFD00HWRGHGHSVLKRGLDJQRVWLF(GLWXUDGLGDFWLF úLSHGDJRJLF
%XFXUHúWL
5XVW - +DQGERRN RI WKH 5XVW ,QYHQWRU\ RI 6FKL]RW\SDO &RJQLWLRQV
7KH3V\FKRORJLFDO&RUSRUDWLRQ/RQGRQ
6FKDLH.:<HDUE\\HDUFKDQJHVLQ3HUVRQDOLW\IURPWR<HDUV
0XOWLYDULDWH%HKDYLRUDO5HVHDUFK,
6FKPLHVFKHFN+)UDJHERJHQ]XU(UPLWWOXQJDN]HQWXLHUWHU3HUV|QOLFKNHLWHQ
vQ 3V\FKRORJLH 1HXURORJLH XQG PHGL]LQVFKH 3V\FKRORJLH +HIW
/HLS]LJ
6FKXOW] ' 7KHRULHV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ %URRNV DQG &RROH 3XEO &R
3DFLILF*URYH
6HDOO\ $3 &DWWHOO 5% $GROHVFHQW 3HUVRQDOLW\ 7UHQGV LQ 3ULPDU\
)DFWRUV 0HDVXUHG RQ WKH 3) DQG +634 4XHVWLRQQDLUHV Ä%ULWLVK
-RXUQRI6RFLDODQG&OLQLFDO3V\FKRORJ\´
6LOYD ) 6WUXFWXUH DQG &DXVDOLW\ LQ 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG %HKDYLRU
:HVWPH\HU + 7KH &DXVDO 6WDWXV RI 6WUXFWXUDO &RQFHSWV LQ
3HUVRQDOLW\ 3V\FKRORJ\ DPEHOH FRPXQLFDWH OD D 9,,D FRQIHULQ D
($330DGULG
6SUDQJHU ( 7\SHV RI 0DQ 6WHFKHUW 1HZ <RUN $OOSRUW * :
9HUQRQ3(/LQGVH\*$6WXG\RI9DOXHV+RXJKWRQ0LIIOLQ
%RVWRQHGD,,,D
6WHSKHQVRQ : 7KH 6LJQLILFDQFH RI 47HFKQLTXH IRU WKH 6WXG\ RI
3HUVRQDOLW\vQ5H\PHUW0/HG)HHOLQJVDQG(PRWLRQV0F*UDZ
+LOO1HZ<RUNS
6WHUQEHUJ5-+XPDQ$ELOLWLHV$Q,QIRUPDWLRQ3URFHVVLQJ$SSURDFK
)UHHPDQDQG&R1HZ<RUN
6WH\HU5)HUULQJ'6FKPLWW0-6WDWHVDQG7UDLWVLQ3V\FKRORJLFDO
$VVHVVPHQWÄ(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI3V\FKRORJLFDO$VVHVVPHQW´
6WUHODX-HG7HPSHUDPHQWDO%DVLVRI%HKDYLRXU6ZHWVDQG=HLWOLQJHU
/LVVH
6WUHODX-7HPSHUDPHQW3HUVRQDOLW\$FWLYLW\$FDGHPLF3UHVV/RQGRQ
6WUHODX-7KHUHJXODWLYH7KHRU\RI7HPSHUDPHQWDVD5HVXOWRI(DVW:HVW
,QIOXHQFHvQ
6WUHODX - $QJOHLWQHU $ HGV ([SORUDWLRQV LQ 7HPSHUDPHQW
,QWHUQDWLRQDO3HUVSHFWLYHVRQ7KHRU\DQG0HDVXUHPHQW3OHQXP3UHVV
1HZ<RUN
6WUHODX-(OLDV]$7HPSHUDPHQW5LVNIDFWRUVIRU7\SH$%HKDYLRXU
3DWWHUQ LQ $GROHVFHQWV vQ 3UHYHQWLRQ DQG HDUO\ ,QWHUYHQWLRQV :%
&DUH\6&0F'HYLWWHGV%UXQQHU0D]HO3XEO1HZ<RUN
6WUHODX - =DZDG]NL % 7KH )RUPDO &KDUDFWHULVWLFV RI %HKDYLRXU
7HPSHUDPHQW ,QYHQWRU\ )&%7, 7KHRUHWLFDO $VVXPSWLRQV DQG 6FDOH
&RQVWUXFWLRQÄ(XURS-RXUQRI3HUVRQDOLW\´
7D\ORU$UOHQH%HQ]LJHU.DWKHULQH7KH3K\VLRORJ\RI7\SH)DOVLILFDWLRQ
RI7\SHDQG3$663URORQJHGDGDSWDWLRQ6WUHVV6\QGURPH
7LHJHU 3' %%DUURQ 7LHJHU 'HVFRSHULUHD SURSULHL SHUVRQDOLW L
7HRUD%XFXUHúWL
7UDSQHOO3':LJJLQV-6([WHQVLRQRIWKH,QWHUSHUVRQDO$GMHFWLYH
6FDOHV WR ,QFOXGH %LJ )LYH 'LPHQVLRQV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ Ä-RXUQDO RI
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´6$&%,)±3HUXJLQL
/HRQH*DOOXFFL/DXULROD RSFLW%$56334=.34±SUH]HQWDWHvQ
2VWHQGRUI ) $QJOHLWQHU $ $ &RPSDULVRQ RI 'LIIHUHQW ,QVWUXPHQWV
3URSRVHG WR 0HDVXUH WKH %LJ )LYH FRPXQLFDUH D ,,D FRQIHULQ D
($33*URQLQJHQ%)4vQ&DSUDUDHWDO
8ùFKLRSX,QWURGXFHUHvQSVLKRGLDJQRVWLF8QLYHUVLWDWHD%XFXUHúWL
:KLWH * 0 &RQFHSWXDO 8QLYHUVDOV LQ ,QWHUSHUVRQDO /DQJXDJH
$PHULFDQ$QWKURSRORJLVW
:LJJLQV-6$3V\FKRORJLFDO7D[RQRP\RIWUDLW'HVFULSWLYH7HUPVWKH
,QWHUSHUVRQDO'RPDLQÄ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´
:LJJLQV-6&LUFXPSOH[0RGHOVRI,QWHUSHUVRQDO%HKDYLRULQ&OLQLFDO
3V\FKRORJ\ vQ .HQGDOO 3 6 úL %XWFKHU - 1 HGV +DQGERRN RI
5HVHDUFK0HWKRGVLQ&OLQLFDO3V\FKRORJ\:LOH\1HZ<RUN
:LJJLQV - 6 ,Q 'HIHQVH RI 7UDLWV vQ +RJDQ 5 -RKQVRQ - $
%ULJJV 6 3 HGV +DQGERRN RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 3V\FKRORJ\ 6DQ 'LHJR
&$$FDG3UHVV
:LJJLQV-63LFXV$/ &RQFHSWLRQVRI3HUVRQDOLW\'LVRUGHUVDQG
'LPHQVLRQV RI 3HUVRQDOLW\ 3V\FKRORJLFDO $VVHVVPHQW $ -RXUQDO RI
&RQVXOWLQJDQG&OLQLFDO3V\FKRORJ\:LGLJHU7$&RVWD
3 7 HGV 3HUVRQDOLW\ DQG 3HUVRQDOLW\ 'LVRUGHUV Ä-RXUQDO RI
$EQRUPDO3V\FKRORJ\´
:LJJLQV-67UDSQHOO33KLOOLSV13V\FKRPHWULFDQG*HRPHWULF
&KDUDFWHULVWLFVRIWKH5HYLVHG,QWHUSHUVRQDO$GMHFWLYH6FDOHV,$65
0XOWLYDULDWH%HKDYLRUDO5HVHDUFK
:LVH 7 1 )DJDQ 3 - 6FKPLGW & : 3RQWLFDV < &RVWD 2 7
3HUVRQDOLW\DQG6H[XDO)XQFWLRQLQJRI7UDQVYHVWLWH)HWLVKLVWVDQG2WKHU
3DUDSK\OLFVÄ-RXUQDORI1HUYRXVDQG0HQWDO'LVHDVHV´
:LWNLQ+$ *RRGHQRXJK'5)LHOG'HSHQGHQF\DQG,QWHUSHUVRQDO
%HKDYLRU3V\FKRORJLFDO%XOOHWLQ&RJQLWLYH6W\OHV
(VVHQFHDQG2ULJLQV,QWHUQDWLRQDO8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV1HZ<RUN
:LWNLQ+$/HZLV+%+HUW]PDQ00HLVVQHU3%:DSQHU6
3HUVRQDOLW\ WKURXJK 3HUFHSWLRQ $Q ([SHULPHQW DQG &OLQLFDO 6WXG\
+DUSHU1HZ<RUN
ZZZW\SRORJLHFRP
=XFNHUPDQ 0 6HQVDWLRQ VHHNLQJ %H\RQG WKH 2SWLPDO /HYHO RI
$URXVDO(UOEDXP+LOOVGDOH1HZ-HUVH\
=XFNHUPDQ03HUVRQDOLW\DQGWKH7KLUG'LPHQVLRQD3V\FKRELRORJLFDO
$SSURDFK3HUVRQDOLW\DQG,QGLYLGXDO'LIIHUHQFHV
=XFNHUPDQ 0 %HKDYLRUDO ([SUHVVLRQV DQG %LRVRFLDO %DVHV RI
6HQVDWLRQ6HHNLQJ&DPEULGJH8QLY3UHVV
=XFNHUPDQ 0 .XKOPDQ '0 -RLUHPDQ - 7HWD 3 .UDIW 0 $
FRPSDULVRQ RI WKH WKUHH VWUXFWXUDO PRGHOV IRU SHUVRQDOLW\ 7KH ELJ
WKUHHWKHELJILYHDQGWKHDOWHUQDWLYHILYHÄ-RXUQDORI3HUVRQDOLW\DQG
6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\´±
=XFNHUPDQ 0 *RRG DQG %DG +XPRUV %LRFKHPLFDO %DVHV RI
3HUVRQDOLW\'LVRUGHUVD9,,DFRQIHULQ D($33:HVWPH\HU$
7KH &RQVWUXFWLRQLVW $SSURDFK WR 3V\FKRORJLFDO $VVHVVPHQW 3UREOHPV
DQG3URVSHFWV