The Parkinsons Outcomes Project The mission of the Parkinsons Outcomes Project is to determine what works best in treatment and care with an aim toward slowing the impact of the disease. At its heart is an all-inclusive, international database that will follow patients over time. Currently tracking more than 5,500 patients in four countries, the Quality Improvement Initiative (QII) study will grow in the coming years to follow tens of thousands of patients worldwide. The Project will: Fund comparative research to determine best treatments and why some people respond better to some therapies than others; Create transparency about what strategies produce the best results and how specific centers measure up; Allow individuals to compare their health and treatments to that of similar people; and Inform education and outreach efforts for both families and professionals.
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
This comprehensive evaluation reflects the complicated nature of Parkinsons, which over time can affect nearly every part of a person, as well as their loved ones. Our study encompasses individuals at 20 leading centers for treating Parkinsons, all part of NPFs Center of Excellence network. By studying the best of the best, NPF plans to delve into the key differences in treatment and outcomes because every person with Parkinsons deserves best practice care, no matter where they are treated.
John Nutt, MD
When we study how disease affects individuals, we talk about your health status, and much of this report concerns the health status of people in our study. Health status is important because it encompasses much more than just the disease. Our goal as physicians is to not just help you function better, but to help you feel better. There is a difference between function and feeling, and we have found that how people with Parkinsons feeltheir mood and depressionis a critical factor with a tangible impact on overall health. We have also identified some of the steps that we as doctors, and you as patients, can take to change this. These opportunities for all of us to improve health are the highlight of this inaugural report.
Mark Guttman, MD
We all hope that the next major breakthrough in Parkinsons disease will be a treatment that slows down biological progression. When we achieve this, optimizing care will be even more important: though symptoms may be reduced, they must be addressed over a longer life expectancy. We will still need to work together to prevent falls, treat depression, and address
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
other factors that can speed the deterioration in your health status. As breakthroughs are achieved, care will become more personalized, so that the best therapies are applied to your particular genetic and environmental factors. In short: our goal is not only to optimize todays care, but to help guide tomorrows. On behalf of NPF and our affiliated centers and institutions, we express our gratitude to those who have shared our vision and supported our efforts. In particular, we thank the patients, caregivers, clinicians, and researchers whose participation is steadily filling gaps in our understanding, and supporting a brighter future in the fight against Parkinsons. We look forward to future reports to you, the Parkinsons community, on our progress.
Tanya Simuni, MD
John Nutt, MD Director of the NPF Center of Excellence Movement Disorders Center at Oregon Health and Science University, Portland, OR QII Study Co-Chair
Tanya Simuni, MD Director of the NPF Center of Excellence Parkinsons Disease and Movement Disorders Center at Northwestern University, Chicago, IL QII Study Co-Chair
Eugene Nelson, DSc
Mark Guttman, MD Director of the NPF Center of Excellence Center for Movement Disorders in Markham Ontario, Toronto, Canada QII Study Co-Chair
Eugene Nelson, DSc Director of Quality Administration for the Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center Lebanon, NH QII Study Co-Chair
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
Since 2009, more than 5,500 individuals have joined the study, representing more
8000
37%
Female
6000
63%
Male
4000 2000
0 1/1/10 7/1/10 1/1/11 7/1/09 4/1/11 10/1/09 7/1/11 10/1/11 4/1/10 4/1/12 10/1/10 1/1/12 7/1/12
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
400
300
200
100
0
59-60 89-90 25-26 49-50 29-30 53-54 69-70 87-88 23-24 39-40 63-64 91-92 21-22 27-28 33-34 73-74 99-100 31-32 37-38 43-44 77-78 95-96 45-46 79-80 55-56 61-62 83-84 65-66 93-94 85-86 67-68 97-98 35-36 41-42 47-48 75-76 51-52 81-82 57-58 71-72
disEasE sEvERity
Disease Severity
GENdER
5 point scale of mobility impairment. On this Hoehn and Yahr scale, stages
GENDER
8% 27%
Mid
7%
one and two represent early disease, three is mid stage, and stages four and five are advanced Parkinsons
58%
Early
FEMALE
37%
63%
MALE
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
Young-Onset Parkinsons
The QII study includes data from the largest cohort of young-onset Parkinsons of any study to date. Already, differences are emerging in how younger people experience Parkinsons itself, and how they perceive the effectiveness of their care. For example, we have identified that people with young-onset Parkinsons often progress slowly but feel their symptoms more intensely, perhaps because they are aware of how their visible symptoms set them apart from their peers. In particular, they typically assign a greater weight to the impact of decreased mobility on their lives. Establishing such differences is a first step toward developing best practices for treating individuals who develop Parkinsons at an early age.
This is the largest clinical study to date of people with youngonset Parkinsons. Almost 400 people
NUMBER OF PARTICIPANTS
250 200
37%
Female
63%
Male
150 100
50 0
43-44
39-40
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
49-50
45-46
29-30
41-42
33-34
35-36
47-48
23-24
25-26
31-32
37-38
<20
21-22
27-28
Long-Duration Parkinsons
This study is also the first to include more than 350 subjects who have lived with Parkinsons for more than 20 years. These people tend to be doing better than we would have predicted based on the trajectory of people with shorter-duration disease. In particular, they tend to be more active and have better cognition. By following these survivors and their care over time, we hope to learn what factors have kept them in better health.
disEasE dURatioN
Why do some people continue to thrive, in some cases, for decades? Study participants include more than 350
DISEASE DURATION
400
300
200
100
48 Years
Maximum Duration
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50+
YEARS
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
varieties of care:
While the participants in our study are unusually diverse, they share one thing in
common: they all have received care at specialty clinics in academic medical centers designated by NPF as Centers of Excellence. These centers are recognized leaders in Parkinsons care and meet rigorous criteria for research, care and outreach, evaluated in a peer-review site visit. The benefits of expert care are well established: those who see an expert neurologist live longer, better lives than those who dont. However, even specialized centers have different approaches to care, and achieve different outcomes. What, exactly, do various centers do differently? Measuring those differences is our first goal. Are those differences the real reason for better outcomes? Testing those explanations is our second goal. And finally, what is the best way to share these findings with everyone who provides Parkinsons care? Ultimately, the Parkinsons Outcomes Project is a cycle of learning. Physicians and therapists need to teach what theyve learned, learn what others have to teach, then repeat. Together, we can help everyone committed to discovering, understanding and sharing the most effective ways to treat Parkinsons.
Inconsistent Results Even at the Best the Centers iNcoNsistENt REsUlts EvEN at thE BEst cENtERs
30
25
HEALTH STATUS %
20
15
10
severity.
5 0
CENTERS
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
Referrals for REfERRals different centers diffERENt cENtERs therapy at foR thERapy at
70 60 50
Referral rates to physical, occupational, speech and other therapists varied by as much as 50% in our study for similar
% REFERRED
40 30 20 10 0
CENTERS
MEdicatioNs foR Mid-staGE patiENts By cENtER MEDICATIONS FOR MID-STAGE PATIENTS BY CENTER
100 90 80
In many cases, there is little evidence to support one choice of medication over another. As a result, medication use can vary substantially from one neurologist to another, even for similar patients.
% PRESCRIBED
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
managing mood:
A clear finding of the study is that, taken together, depression and anxiety have
the greatest impact of health status. In fact, in a study of QII data presented at a Parkinsons conference in 2012, scientists showed that the impact of depression on health status is almost twice that of the motor impairments universally associated with Parkinsons. At least 50 percent of people with Parkinsons experience depression, and anxiety is also frequently reported. Depression can be disabling, resulting in difficulty with work or engaging in activities like exercise that can help manage symptoms. Yet physicians often have trouble recognizing anxiety and depression, or their roles in hampering efforts to treat Parkinsons. As previous studies have found, addressing depression can positively impact levels of disability, relapse and quality of life. Indeed, participants in clinics with the most active approach to counseling reported the lowest rates of depression. For many people with Parkinsons, acknowledging depression is a critical step toward more effective treatment, and better health status overall.
Mood/depression and mobility are the most important contributors to overall health status for people with Parkinsons, and should be priorities in evaluating patients and developing care plans.
PERCENTAGE
10
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
Depression Care
80
dEpREssioN caRE
Different centers will treat between 45% and 75% of people with
signs of depression,
60
40
20
NPF Recommends:
Physicians should screen you for depression at least once a year. You should discuss any change in your mood with a healthcare professional, and make sure that your Parkinsons doctor is aware. You should bring a family member with you to your doctors office and he or she should be encouraged to discuss any changes in your mood.
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
11
mobility:
Regular exercise (more than 2.5 hours per week) provides many
40
20
PERCENTAGE
with Parkinsons. It is associated with lower degrees of mobility impairment, caregiver burden, and impairment in everyday activities.
30
PERCENTAGE
None Casual Regular
benefits to people
15
20
10
10
None
Casual
Regular
12
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
NPF Recommends:
To feel good enough to exercise regularly, take your medications on time. Keep to your schedule. Exercise can help improve all your symptoms. Any exercise you can do safely will help. Talk with your doctor about both exercise and physical therapy. On your next visit, discuss the type of program you should pursue. If your symptoms become hard to manage, talk to your doctor about your options. There are many ways to try to control difficult symptoms. A physical or occupational therapist who understands Parkinsons can be a great resource between your physician visits.
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
13
No two people face Parkinsons in quite the same way. People vary substantially in
their combination of symptoms, rate of progression, and reaction to treatment. It may be that no two doctors approach Parkinsons in quite the same way, either; unlike many other diseases, there are no clearly established standards for treating a person with Parkinsons in a particular circumstance. As a result, two neurologists who might prescribe identical therapies for similar patients with Alzheimers disease would likely recommend different strategies for similar patients with Parkinsons. The reason is that, despite many prior studies on specific elements of the disease, none has successfully evaluated the full range of factors that bear on the experience of the disease. The Parkinsons Outcomes Project is beginning to change that. By embracing the diversity of people with Parkinsons, we are gathering the most complete data set ever assembled. By involving the worlds best neurologists at NPF Centers of Excellence, we are developing the best insights into individual care. And by working together, we will define standards of care for people with Parkinsons everywhere.
Participants where one issue stands out paRticipaNts whERE oNE issUE staNds oUt Stigma Social Support Pain Communication Cognition Activities of Daily Living Mood & Depression Mobility
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
For many people, one issue stands out as the most challenging part of Parkinsons. Over half the people in the study had one aspect of Parkinsons that was much more troubling than the others. Everyones journey is different.
PERCENTAGE
14
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
15
Laura Marsh, MD
Michael E. DeBakey VA Medical Center, Houston, TX
16
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
References
The main findings reported in this document are derived from the QII study and presentations and publications based on its information. These publications include: A. Hassan, S.S. Wu, P. Schmidt, I. Malaty, Y.F. Dai, J.M. Miyasaki, M.S. Okun. What are the issues facing Parkinsons disease patients at ten years of disease and beyond? Data from the NPF-QII study. Parkinsonism and Related Disorders. 2012. 18(8):925-30. A. Hassan, S.S. Wu, P. Schmidt, I. Malaty, M.S. Okun, Risk Factors for ER and Hospitalization in Parkinsons disease: Results from the NPF Quality Improvement Initiative (NPF-QII). Movement Disorders Society 16th International Congress. Dublin, Ireland. 2012. J.D. Jones, I. Malaty, C.C. Price, M.S. Okun, D. Bowers. Health comorbidities and cognition in 1948 patients with idiopathic Parkinsons disease. Data from the NPF-QII study. Parkinsonism and Related Disorders. 2012. In press. M. Kwasny, O. Oguh, B. Stell, T. Simuni, on behalf of the NPF-QII investigators. Speech therapy utilization in Parkinsons disease. Movement Disorders Society 16th International Congress. Dublin, Ireland. 2012. J.G. Nutt, A.D. Siderowf, M. Guttman, E.C. Nelson, P. Schmidt, J. Zamudio, S.S. Wu, M.S. Okun, on behalf of the NPF-QII investigators. Correlates of health-related quality of life (HRQL) in Parkinsons disease. Movement Disorders Society 16th International Congress. Dublin, Ireland. 2012. O. Oguh, M. Kwasny, J. Carter, T. Simuni, on behalf of the NPF-QII investigators. Predictors of caregiver burden in Parkinsons disease. Movement Disorders Society 16th International Congress. Dublin, Ireland. 2012. O. Oguh, M. Kwasny, T. Simuni C., Zadikoff on behalf of the NPF-QII investigators. Racial disparities in access to deep brain stimulation. Movement Disorders Society 16th International Congress. Dublin, Ireland. 2012. O. Oguh, M. Kwasny, B. Stell, T. Simuni, on behalf of the NPF-QII investigators. Predictors of caregiver burden in Parkinsons disease. American Academy of Neurology 64th Annual Meeting. New Orleans, Louisiana. 2012.
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
17
O. Oguh, M. Kwasny, B. Stell, T. Simuni, on behalf of the NPF-QII investigators. Predictors of exercise habits in Parkinsons disease. Movement Disorders Society 16th International Congress. Dublin, Ireland. 2012. M.S. Okun, A. Siderowf, J.G. Nutt, G.T. OConner, B.R. Bloem, E.M. Olmstead, M. Guttman, T. Simuni, E. Cheng, E.V. Cohen, S. Parashos, L. Marsh, I. Malaty, N. Giladi, P. Schmidt, J. Oberdorf,. Piloting the NPF data-driven quality improvement initiative. Data from the QII study. Parkinsonism and Related Disorders. 2010. 16(8):517-21. S.A. Parashos, C.L. Wielinski, on behalf of the NPF QII investigators. National Parkinson Foundation Quality Improvement Initiative: Risk Factors for Falls in Parkinson Disease. Movement Disorders Society 16th International Congress. Dublin, Ireland. 2012. P. Schmidt, M.S. Okun, A.D. Siderowf, J.G. Nutt, G.T. OConner, B.R. Bloem, E.M. Olmstead, M. Guttman, T. Simuni, E. Cheng, S.A. Parashos, L. Marsh, I.A. Malaty, N. Giladi, S.S. Wu, J. Oberdorf. Are results from PD trials generalizable? The NPF database reveals a mismatch between typical clinic populations and subjects in PD trials. World Parkinsons Congress 2nd International Congress. Glasgow, Scotland. 2010. P. Schmidt, A.D. Siderowf, M. Guttman, E. Nelson, J. Zamudio, M.S. Okun, J.G. Nutt, on behalf of the NPFQII investigators. How should pushing off or the use of assistive devices be incorporated in the timed up and go (TUG)? Movement Disorders Society 16th International Congress. Dublin, Ireland. 2012. P. Schmidt, J. Zamudio, M. Guttman, J. Nutt, A. Siderowf, E. Nelson, on behalf of the NPF-QII investigators. Variation of patient-reported outcomes (PDQ-39) in a cross-sectional analysis of the NPF-QII research registry. American Academy of Neurology 64th Annual Meeting. New Orleans, Louisiana. 2012. P. Schmidt. Current and future impact on clinical practice. Movement Disorders Society 16th International Congress. Dublin, Ireland. 2012. B. Stell , O. Oguh, M. Kwasny, T. Simuni, on behalf of the NPF-QII investigators. Utilization of antidepressants and mental health services in a large cohort of patients with Parkinsons disease. Movement Disorders Society 16th International Congress. Dublin, Ireland. 2012.
18
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
In addition to the QII study, important points and recommendations concerning Parkinsons are drawn from a range of publications, including: J.M. Miyasaki, K. Shannon, V. Voon, B. Ravina, G. Kleiner-Fisman, K. Anderson, L.M. Shulman, G. Gronseth, W.J. Weiner; Quality Standards Subcommittee of the American academy of neurology. Practice Parameter: evaluation and treatment of depression, psychosis, and dementia in Parkinson disease (an evidence-based review): report of the QualityStandards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. Neurology. 2006. 66(7):996-1002. S.K. Van Den Eeden, C.M. Tanner, A.L. Bernstein, R.D. Fross, A. Leimpeter, D.A. Bloch, L.M. Nelson. Incidence of Parkinsons disease: variation by age, gender, and race/ethnicity. American Journal of Epidemiology. 2003. 157(11):1015-22. J.M. Pavon, H.E. Whitson, M.S. Okun. Parkinsons disease in women: a call for improved clinical studies and for comparative effectiveness research. Maturitas. 2010. 65(4) 352-8. C. Goetz, W. Poewe, O. Rascol, C. Sampiro, G.T. Stebbins, C. Counsell, N. Giladi, R.G. Holloway, C.G. Moore, G.K. Wenning, M.D. Yahr, L. Seid; Movement Disorder Society Task Force on Rating Scales for Parkinsons Disease. Movement Disorder Society Task Force report on the Hoehn and Yahr staging scale: status and recommendations. Movement Disorders. 2004. 19(9):1020-8. L.O. Ramig, S. Sapir, S. Countryman, A.A. Pawlas, C. OBrien, M. Hoehn, L.L. Thompson. Intensive voice treatment (LSVT) for patients with Parkinsons disease: a 2 year follow up. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry. 2001. 71(4):493-8.
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
19
20
n at i o n a l Pa r k i n s o n f o u n dat i o n
About the National Parkinson Foundation Unique among the Parkinsons organizations, the National Parkinson Foundation (NPF) has a singular focus: our mission is to improve the quality of care through research, education and outreach. We have created a global network serving the needs of the Parkinsons community including: 41 Centers of Excellence at top medical centers around the world, including 26 in the U.S. and 15 internationally An extensive network of chapters and support groups across the U.S., serving more than 100,000 people with Parkinsons and their families Website and educational materials that reach more than 1 million people each year.