Anda di halaman 1dari 15

K NADARAJAH & PARTNERS Advocates & Solicitors WISMA KLS, 16 'FLOOR 26 Jln.

Tengku DIAUDIN 41 000 Klang Selangor TEL: 03-33723449/50 0123171908/0123301908 FAX: 03-33725444 19/07/2012 through the Hand K. NADARAJAH Hans BA (Mal) Hans LLB (Land) A. G. Kalidas Hans LLB (UK) LL.M (UM) CLP (Mal) ACIArb Doris G. Hans MAYAPPEN LL.B (Land) CLP (Mal) Marian Nisha Hans BE LLB (Land) CLP (Mal) Hans TARUMAN YUVANES LLB (UK) CLP (Mal) RUJ. Karni: KNP/HC/0751 RUJ. Tuan: Timbalan Applicant Registration Officer Shah Alam High Court. Tuan, SHAH ALAM HIGH COURT PETISYEN NO: 32-387-2010 HERITAGE PROPERTY IN K.R.M. SON OF KARUPPAN Muthuraman Chettiar Chettiar A. Lakshmanan SON OF Muthuraman (Passport NO: H 9729618) 2. SON OF Muthuraman PEMPETISYEN RATHINAKUMAR-PEMPETISYEN / (Passport NO: H 8.17564 million) PENTADBIR-PENTADBIR Is with all the respect we refer to the above case. 2. In harmony with the citation bertarikh 30.4.2012, which Icami received on 18.7.2012 namely En anakguam Karni. Lakshmanan SON OF Muthuraman and En. RATHINAKUMAR SON OF Muthuraman has been submitted to the Attorney Karni Mentadbir bertarikh 02/07/2011 Registrant officials to be left in the Shah Alam High Court. 3. By this we include with this letter Attorney Mentadbir (SKM) 02/07/2011 bertarikh the origin to Shah Alam High Court deposits sementera undangundang regular trips to determine the validity or importance Thamayanthi w / o Ramasamy and related issues. 4. SKM Anakguam we left that came with the "protest" and without admitting any interest Thamayanthi w / o Ramasamy and related as they were charged and without prejudice to the rights of law anakguam Karni. Please acknowledge receipt. The truth, Tetuan K. Nadarajah & Partners Appendix s.k. A. Tetuan Muthu & Partners 2.Anakguam (via E-Mail)

2211CVC-767-06/2012

CASE D PENGIMUSAN IHADAPAN YES DATO NOHANAD Zabidin 04-Jul-2012 9PAGI1E92650 1000091192 06/20/2012 11:39:0 22 = C-767-06/2012 HU001 200_0 X j 'Rh Rm 200.0 *********************** IN THE HIGH COURT IN SHAH ALAM IN NEGER1 Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia BAL. j_IAGIALL $ MD. CIVIL SUIT NO: YEAR 2012 BETWEEN A. THAMAYANTHI Ramaswamy (PASSPORT NO: G733411) Two. TR.SUSILA W / O THIRUNAVUKKAR.ASU (PASSPORT NO: F1222587) 3., SULOCHANA W / 0 RMANATHAN wPLAINTIF (PANCARD NO: BQMPSG541M) PLAINTIFF and A. Lakshmanan SON OF Muthuraman (PASSPORT NO: H 9729618) Two. RETHINAKUMAR SON OF DEFENDANT Muthuraman ... (PASSPORT NO: H 8175640) DEFENDANT writ of Summons "A Chief Justice Zulkefli Makinudin BIN AHMAD HAKIM LETTERS OF MALAYA, THE NAME AND ON BEHALF OF HIS MAJESTY King". The son of Muthuraman Lakshmanan S \ N MFZ94BOXJWCW ** Note: Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via the portal eFILING

Memorandum to be revealed in Writ This writ can not be served more than six (6) calendar months after the date shown on the above unless renewed by order of the Court. A defendant may be present along with the insert present either in person or through the Registration office peguarneara in Shah Alam High Court.

Defendants who appear in person may, if it wishes, include attendance by post, and borapg-specific forms can be obtained by sending a postal order worth RM10.00 with self-addressed envelope to the Registrar, High Court at Shah Alam. PadaWrit Pengindorsan be made before production Plaintiffs interest in the estate K, RMMUTHURAMAN CHETTIAR SON OF KARUPPAN CHETTIAR: a. Plaintiffs are the children of legal title to the deceased - SON OF KRMMUTHURAMAN CHETTIAR KARUPPAN CHETTIAR (deceased); b. The deceased has left all movable and immovable beau to the Plaintiffs and the other two children named M.Manomani w / o SP Shanmugakesari and Manimekalai via the a will dated 23.12.2003; 3 SIN MFZ94BOXJWCW ** Note: Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via the portal eFiLING

Adafah defendants administrators of the Estate of Deceased kononya through Grant Letters of Administration issued on 11.07.2011. Except that the defendant-child the defendant is legally Estate & mat!, They have no interest didatam Deceased Estates. The deceased was an express Mafah rejects Defendants from any interest in his property through a will dated 23.12.2003. Pengindorsan, Claims Plaintiffs claim the plaintiff is to order as follows a. Letters of Administration granted by the court on 07.02.2011 and Grant Letters of Administration issued on 11.07.2011 ordered null and void; b. Plaintiff, Plaintiff was appointed as the Administrator of the deceased and follow-up appointment

St.rat the Grant of Administration is issued in the name Plaintiflpiaintif; c. The defendants gave a detailed account of all expenditures and receipts of the Estate of Deceased possession of money; d. The defendants to pay damages to the Estate & mall as a result of the action Defenclan-defendant to obtain S \ N MFZ94BOXJWCW * Note: Serial number MI be used to verify the originality of this document via Filing portal

1Deralamat at No.22, Bharathidasan Street, Balasubramaniam Nagar, Thirupparankundrum, Madura 'District, Tamilnadu, South India 625005. Two. Rethinakumar son of Muthuraman postal address. 25/7, Vandikara Street, PO viii Mayiladuthurai Nagai District FY 609001, Tamilnadu, South India. We command you Lakshmanan son of son of Muthuraman and Rethinakumar Muthuramanbahawa in the after service of this writ on you, including the day of such service, you must cause your presence to dirt in the suit PlaintifPlaintif cause of the above and note that if you default in so doing, may by leave of the Court PlaintifPlaintif continue the suit, and judgment may be given in your absence. WITNESS WHEREOF the Registrar of the Court

Malaya at Shah Alam on the day of 2012. BERTAFIKH :20-Jun-2012 JESSICA ONIBOU KAILAMIN Pen latm Katau Registrar ci ... Tioni ViaIkomob Shot: Alma Messrs Muthu & Partners Solicitors for the Plaintiff, the Plaintiff S \ N MFZ94BOXJWCW Note: Serial number will be used to verity the originality of this document via portalPpnolong Kan0 LING-EFL, the Registrar -1 \ 0111km0-1. Tiri4gi Shah Alam2

Kusa Letter of Administration and of their actions in the administration of the Estate of Deceased; f. The defendants pay the costs of solicitor-client to the Plaintiff the Plaintiff; g. The cost of this action; h. Any further order or fain in the opinion of this Honourable Court and proper. And RM (or so much money as he is allowed after the set) to the cost, and also, if PlaintifPlaintif can order for substituted service further sum of RM (or so much money as authorized seterah set). If the amount claimed and costs paid to PlaintifPlaintif or solicitors within eight (8) the limit after this Writ (including the day of delivery), further proceedings will be postponed, but if it appears from the writ that pengindorsan PlaintifPlaintif is resident outside the scheduled territories, as that ditakri &'s in Exchange Act Kawaian 1953, or is acting in accordance with the order or on behalf of a resident such, the proceedings will only be delayed if the amount claimed and costs be paid into Court within the said and notice pernbayaran is given to the plaintiff or pegs uamcaranya .

S \ N MFZ94BOXJWCW "Note: Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via the portal eFlLING

Pen InclorsalIan Alam at Writ of Summons in issued by Messrs Muthu & Partners., Advocates & solicitors for the Plaintiff, Plaintiff has presented at the address of No.143, Lane fired Rahim 14, TTDI, 60000 Kuala Lumpur. aRrAfnciorsan tentang_penyampalan This writ has been served by by delivery personally (or as appropriate) (specified the manner of service or according to the terms of an order for substituted service) to the Defendant (which I know) (or that has been shown to me by (or who has admitted to me that he was) at (place) in endorsed on the day of 2012 sender Suit Writ of Summons was filed by Messrs Muthu & Partners Counsel for the Plaintiff, the Plaintiff and the address for service in No.14B, Lorong Rahim fired 14, TTDI, 60000 Kuala Lumpur. S \ NI MFZ94BOXJWCW

Note ** Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via the portal eFILIN.G

2 211CVC-7 67-0 6/2 012 KAND, mAHKANDA 1592651 1000091192 20/06/201 11:39:0 22UCUC-767-06/2012 HP106 8 0 X IN THE HIGH COURT MAVAIVAINSHAtfAtiktr'''''''' 8. 0 DOMESTIC Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia (CIVIL DIVISION) CIVIL SUIT NO: YEAR 2012 A. THAMAYANTHI W / O Ramaswamy (PASSPORT NO: G733411) Two. TR.SUSILA W / O THIRUNAVUKKARASU (PASSPORT NO: F1222587) Three. SULOCHANA W / 0 RAMANATHAN (PANCARD NO: BOMPS6541M) and A. LAKSHIVIANAN SON OF MUTHURA.MAN (PASSPORT NO: H 9729618) Two. RETHINAKUMAR SON OF Muthuraman (PASSPORT NO: H 8175640) PLAINTIFF ... PLAINTIFFDEFENDANT DEFENDANT .... STATEMENT OF CLAIM A. Plaintiffs are individuals who have an address for service at No. 429, Galena Road 11/2, Galena Hills Park, 70200 Seremban, Negeri Sembilan.

Two. The first defendant is an individual who has a residential address in India at No 22, Bharathidasan Street, Balasubramaniam Nagar, Thirupparankundrum, Madura 'District, Tamilnadu, 825005 S \ N E2RN6PBYYE88 1 ** Note: Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via the portal eFELING

South India and mailing address in Malaysia at No, 29, Lorong Palas, Suthern Park, 41000 Klang, Selangor. Three. The defendant is an individual who has a residential address in India at No. 25/7, Vandikara Street, PO viii Mayiladuthurai Nagai District FY 609001, Tamilnadu, South India and mailing address at No.29, Lorong Palas, Southern Park, 41000 Klang, Selangor. 4. Plaintiffs and Defendants piaintif are siblings. Five. Father of the Plaintiffs and Defendants is a man named MSC, Muthuraman CHETTIAR SON OF KARUPPAN CHETTIAR who had died on 22.02.2010 ["Simatil. 6. Has been exposed deceased died leaving a few hartahada movable and can not be assumed to be in the jurisdiction of the courts in Malaysia, among others of which are as follows: a. 1/3 of the properties held under Grant No: 3893 for Lot No. 20, Section 5, Town of Klang, Selangor; E2R1 \ 18P8YVE88 2 ** Note: Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this. Document via the portal aFILING

b. 1/3 of the properties held dlbawah EMR 8831 for Lot No.60, Section 1, Village of Meru, Reuters Kapar, Klang, Selangor; c. 1/3 of the properties held under Grant No. 4896 for Lot No.121, Section 2, Town of Port Swettenham, Selangor; d. 1/3 of the properties held under CTNo, 11,099 for Lot # 28, Section 2, Town of Port Swettenharn, WA; e. 1/24 portion of the property held under Grant No. 47625 for Lot No. 47, Section 10, District Kiang, WA; and 1/3 of the money deposited in Standard Chartered Bank through the current account noombor: 7081-0617067-6. (hereinafter all of these properties are referred to as "the Host") 7. The property is a list of properties that are in Balk knowledge of the Plaintiffs and therefore not a final one. E2RN6P8YYE88 3 'r * Note: Serial number will be used to verify the originality ofthis document via the portal eFILING

Eight. The deceased has left a will dated 23/12/1993 (hereinafter referred to as "the Will") which in accordance with the Will of Deceased has left all the property to the Plaintiffs and two other daughters, namely tVI.Manomani w / o SP Shanmugakesari and Manimekalai. 9. Express the will meniatkan that Defendants have no right to property or to all property belonging to deceased. 10. Therefore, Defendants are not beneficiaries of the property and the Estates of Deceased. 11. So even though Defendants have through the Petition Under the Probate and Administration Act 1959 through the Petition No: 32-387-2010 at the Shah Alam High Court to apply for Letters of Administration with Will Attached. 12. The defendants had applied for the Shah Alam High Court for a Letter of Administration of Deceased Estates diata-s because they are the beneficiaries in the Will and on this ground that this Honorable Court Terah provide Letters of Administration of Estates of Deceased on 07.02.2012 and subsequent to this a grant Letters of Administration issued on 11.07.2011 [Power Mentadbirl. S11 1 E2RN6P8YYE88 -Note: Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via the portal eFILING

13. Defendants are not beneficiaries in the Will. Even the beneficiaries of the Will is the Plaintiffs and M.Manomani w / o SP Shanmugakesari and Manimekalai demiklan only and with the Plaintiffs and M.Manomani w / o SP Shanmugakesari and Manimekarai is the party had the right to apply for and obtain a power administration. 14. Further the Plaintiffs, wio M.Manomani SP Shanmugakesari and Manimekalai at all material times did not agree to administer Defendants Deceased Estates. 15. In no event shall the Plaintiffs, M.Manomani w / o SP Manimekalai Shanmugakesari and never gave permission to the Defendants to apply for Letters of Administration and also never release the rights to administer the Estate of Deceased Huta. 16. In this case Defendants have clearly mislead this honorable court by not disclosing the fact that: a. Wills expressly deceased men yigkir Defendants from any interest in any property of belonging to the deceased and with the demiklan they are not beneficiaries of deceased estates; S \ N E2RN6P8YYE88 5 Note: Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via Filing portal

b. Plaintiffs and M.Manomani w / o SP Manimekalai Shanmugakesari and not at all material times to allow the defendants to apply for Letters of Administration; c. Plaintiffs and M.Manomani w / o SP and Manimekalai not Shanmugakesari Defendants agreed to administer the Estate of Deceased, and d. and M.Manomani w / o SP Shanmugakesari and Manimekalai not release the rights to administer the Deceased Estate. 17. In this case the Letter of Administration is one of not valid and should be canceled. 18 For the purpose of cancel the Letter of Administration and in order to file this Writ of Summons against the Defendants, Plaintiff Plaintiff through Plaintiff First Registration request from the High Court of Shah Nam Sitasi Lintuk issued a Rule 72 in accordance with Rule 2 (3) and Order 72 rule 7 of the High Court rules 1980. This Sitasi applied in proceedings Petition No: 32-387-2010 in the High Court Shah Alan. SlNI E2RN6P8YYE88 ** Note: Serial numbor will be used to verify the originality of this document via the portal eFILENG

19. Shah Alam High Court issued a sitasi dated tefah 30.04.2012 received by my solicitors on 28.05.2012. 20. Sitasi has been delivered to Defendants Solicitors, Messrs KNadarajah & Partners on 29.04.2012 but on 01.06.2012 solicitor was returning on the grounds that they have no instructions to accept the sedarigkan Messrs. sitasi KNadarajah & Partners is still in the record as the solicitor the defendants to Petition No: 32-387-2010. 21. Defendants intentionally avoid legal action and court proceedings menyalahgunankan. In no event shall Defendants are now ready sitasi informed about and in terms of the delivery of legal sitasi on 29.04.2012 against their solicitor is sufficient. - 22. M.Manomani w / o SP Shanmugakesari and Manimekalai agree for giving the Plaintiffs the right to administer the Estate of Deceased. E2RN6P8YYE88 "* Note: Serial number wilt be used to verify the originality of this document via the portal eFILING

23.

Oleh yang demikian Plaintif-plaintif memohon untuk:-

i. Surat Kuasa Mentadbir yang diberi oleh mahkamah pada 07.02.2011 dan Geran Surat Kuasa Mentadbir yang dikeluarkan pada 11.07.2011 diperintahkan tidak sah dan dibataikan; Plaintif-Plaintif adalah dilantik sebagai Pentadbir Harta Pusaka Simati dan susulan daripada perlantikan ini maka Geran Surat Kuasa Mentadbir adalah dikeluarkan diatas nama Defendan-defendan memberikan satu akaun yang terperinci berkenaan dengan segala perbelanjaan dan penerimaan wang milikan Harta Pusaka Simati; iv. Defendan-defendan membayar gantirugi kepada Estet Simati yang diakibatkan daripada tindakan Defendan-defendan untuk memperolehi Surat Kusa Mentadbir dan daripada tindakan mereka didalam mentadbir Harta Pusaka Simati; v. Kos bagi tindakan ini; dan 8

E2RN6P8YVE88

**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document vie eFILING portal

iv. Peintah-order and re1ifre1ief where the court otherwise This began to deem it fit and / or munasanbah daniatau appropriate. Dated on 05.06.2012 M i u ara Partners Lawyers Statement of Claim is filed by Messrs Muthu & Partners, Advocates Peguameara and plaintiffplaintiff whose address No.I4B penyamapaian at Lorong Rahim fired 14, Taman Tun Drismail, 60000 Kuala Lumpur. S \ N E2RN6P8YYE88 9 Note ** Sorial number will be used to verify the originality of this document portal vi ei eFILING