Deddeh F. Jones
Drexel University
EDHE 510
December 4, 2008
The great state of Indiana is known as “the Crossroads of America” for the simple fact
that more major highways intersect than in any other state. Symbolically, this state motto also
higher education to the modern day idea of the publicly funded ‘state-university’ model.
Subsequently, higher education in Indiana has come a long way from its early territorial years to
its present day, particularly in the evolution of its governance and funding structures. This paper
will aim to accomplish the following objectives: (1) establish a bird’s eye view of Indiana’s
history in higher education; (2) provide a historical overview its governance system; (3) discuss
three transformative state issues that have affected Indiana’s higher education; (4) present a
current overview of its higher education; (5) describe the state coordinating agency’s role,
structural organization, and membership; (6) provide a brief commentary on the relationship
between the state coordinating agency and individual public institutions of higher education; (7)
survey Indiana’s higher education budget and its funding origination; and (8) address three
contemporary higher education issues currently facing Indiana that perhaps may shed light on its
future path.
History
Like many frontiers of the New World, Indiana was an untamed wildness originally
inhabited by the Native Americans. It was not until the late mid-seventeenth century when the
first early Europeans settlers declared the territory for the Kingdom of France. The French in
turn maintained dominance over the region until the British won the French and Indian War
ending in 1763. This consequently led to British rule over the region known as the Northwest
Territory (which included the areas of the modern states of Ohio, Illinois, Michigan and
Wisconsin as well as the northeastern section of Minnesota). However, due to the defeat of the
British in the American Revolutionary War in 1783, the region under the Ordinance of 1787
ceded to the United States. At the conclusion of much debate, Indiana became its own separate
territory in 1800 and ultimately achieved its statehood in 1816 (Woodburn, 1891).
The Ordinance of 1787 not only provided the blueprint for the government of the
Northwest Territory; it also is one of the earliest legislative documents to date recognizing the
importance of the advancement of education. Article III of the Ordinance explicitly states that in
order to have a “good government and the happiness of mankind, schools and the means of
education shall forever be encouraged.” It is this guarantee that “became the basis and
inspiration of the educational life” (Woodburn, 1891, p. 27) in Indiana. In harmony with the
spirit of the Ordinance, Indiana’s first state Constitution of 1816 embodied the notion of
providing for “a general system of education . . . ascending in regular graduation from the
township schools to a State University, wherein tuition shall be gratis and equally open to all”
(Brubacher & Rudy, 2007, p. 154). This provision according to Cotton (1934) outlined a well
developed system of education, but failed to take root due to the lack of succeeding legislatures
to enacted further laws with “teeth for their enforcement” (p. 15). Moreover, the average
Hoosier during these early frontier years had paradoxically given little contemplation or even
deference to higher education. Mainly because, these settlers were of modest means if not poor,
ignorant, unaspiring, and unchanging migrants of the old south who toiled in their fields
As unflattering as this depiction may be, it would take the enactment of second
Constitution of 1851 for the state government to establish a public school system. By this time,
Indiana was home to a plethora of religiously affiliated institutions of higher education which
typically were available to the elite. When the Morrill Land-Grant Act of 1862 was signed by
President Lincoln, access to higher education for the masses particularly those in rural
communities was transformed and expanded. The Act mandated that proceeds from specified
public land sales would be used to finance public institutions specializing in agricultural industry
and mechanic arts. Soon thereafter the American Civil War, Indiana’s college enrollment began
to boom, sustaining the growth of the approximately 40 colleges, universities, and seminaries in
French Jesuit priests as well as by a series of denominational churches to convert the local Native
American population (History of Indiana, n.d). Despite this tradition, the first General Assembly
of the Indiana territory sought to designate a university for public education commencing with
the founding of the Jefferson Academy in 1801, which was later incorporated as Vincennes
University in 1806. Vincennes made its debut as one of the first public two year universities in
the state of Indiana as well as on the national scene. Ironically, further development of public
junior colleges did not take root in the state until the mid-twentieth century with the founding of
the Ivy Tech State College later reorganized as Ivy Tech Community College (ITCC) in 1963.
In 1828, the Indiana legislature again met to formally authorize the establishment of
Indiana University in Bloomington (IU), the state’s first public four year university. Then came
Purdue University, a product of the Morrill Land-Grant Act of 1862 founded in 1869 and
currently operates four regional campuses. Together through a collaborative effort and
partnership, IU and Purdue have combined resources to create the Indiana University-Purdue
universities in Indiana were established with religious affiliations. Most notable are the
University of Notre Dame (1844) with its Roman Catholic heritage founded by the Jesuits,
DePauw University (1837) with its Methodist affiliation, and Valparaiso University (1859) with
its Lutheran roots. Notre Dame is nationally and internationally known for its excellent
academic reputation and is ranked 18th in top universities in the country by the U.S. News World
Report. DePauw University houses Indiana's first Phi Beta Kappa chapter (the nation's oldest
and most widely known academic Honor Society) and established the first 10-watt college FM
radio station in the country, WGRE-FM, which went on the air in 1949 (DePauw History and
Traditions, n.d.). Valparaiso is hailed as on the first co-educational universities in Indiana and it
History of Governance
Indiana’s higher education governance system began its evolutionary development with
the creation of local individualized boards of trustees which were largely made up of prominent
citizens of influence. With respect to private post-secondary institutions, these entities were for
the most part highly decentralized, autonomous and self-perpetuating. As for public institutions,
their boards of trustees were quintessentially accountable to the state government due to
to the endemic budgetary challenges and systemic accretion of the public higher education
system, the state’s coordinating agency evolved through a series of commissions reporting on
Beginning in 1945 the coordinating agency later known as Indiana Commission for
Higher Education (ICHE) was first conceived as an advisory group comprised of representatives
appointed by the governor who would oversee the general policies and procedures affecting
higher education (Metz & Gosetti, 1999). According to Wells (1980), the Conference’s main
objective was to assist the state government in facilitating the proliferation of new units, taking
into account the offerings of well established private colleges in the state and the branches of
other state institutions (p.136). This policy goal would naturally provide balance and foster a
solid foundation for managing the emerging post-World War II higher education institutional
By the 1960s, there were two commissions and one committee established by the General
Assembly and a Legislative Council. The purpose of these entities was to re-evaluate Indiana’s
higher education system in the wake of the nascent vocational movement where in the first
statewide comprehensive community college system was finally realized (Metz & Gosetti,
1999). In 1971, Indiana General Assembly enacted Senate Enrolled Act No. 2 creating a
Commission for Higher Education of the State of Indiana. The ICHE functions as the state level
statutory coordinating agency for all post-secondary education in the state. The commission
consists of a fourteen-member public body appointed by the governor and is responsible for the
long term strategic planning, budgetary approval and review, clarification of institutional roles,
and the approval of all new campuses and academic programs (Landini, 1997). During the
1980s and 1990s, the commission has fortified its efforts to keep up with the pulse of the shifting
demands of its higher education system through policy initiatives that have improved articulation
recommendations.
Transformative State Issues
As acknowledged previously, Indiana’s citizenry since its pioneer days have consistently
demonstrated their lack of support for public funding for the state’s higher education institutions.
Principally because there was a general unwillingness on the part of these hard-working Hoosiers
to be taxed for financing higher education which in their eyes seemed out of touch with their
vital interests (Brubacher, 2007). In fact, state appropriations for higher learning tended to be
looked upon with suspicion as helping to build up the aristocracy (Brubacher, 2007). It was no
wonder that Indiana’s state universities were little more than colleges, with relatively miniscule
endowments, inadequate staffing and resources, and with few professional schools. Hence, the
Since the 1980s, these tuition increases have been climbing and unfortunately have been
entrenched in supplying state colleges and universities with the much needed capital to operate
their facilities in lieu of declining state appropriations. Over the past decade or so, there has
been a significant shift in the perception of higher education; more and more Hoosiers are
recognizing the necessity of obtaining a college degree (Jones, 2003). No longer are good
paying jobs in manufacturing and the agricultural sectors viable options of employment. As a
result, enrollment has risen to 61 percent in 2000 from 38 percent in 1986 (Jones, 2003).
Due to this incredible growth, the General Assembly has alleviated some of the financial
burden by establishing the Twenty-First Century Scholars Program in 1990. This innovative
early intervention program enrolls middle school aged students from grades six through eight,
asks them to sign a pledge to complete high school and avoid illegal activities, and provides
them with academic support and assistance throughout high school (Erisman, W. & Del Rios, M.,
2008). After graduation and affirming compliance, participants are guaranteed four years of
financial aid covering 100 percent of their tuition costs at any in-state public or private post-
secondary institution in Indiana. The rationale behind this program is that if funding for college
education is no longer a barrier to access, students will be more motivated to prepare themselves
for higher learning, and thus remain engaged. Sadly, this was not the case; less than half of those
who successfully participated met the requirements to attend college which leads us to the
evaluation of the next transformative issue shaping Indiana’s higher education: college
Great strides have been made in better preparing Indiana’s high school graduates for the
rigors of post-secondary education. However, the state’s public school system continues to
struggle with this issue until reform of its high school curriculum was implemented in 2005.
Prior to this reform, Indiana received an average grade of C regarding college preparation from
the Measuring Up 2006 higher education report card. According to ICHE data, 26 percent of
high school students who pursued a post-secondary education were enrolled in at least one
remedial course as of 2004 (Gwaltney, 2008). To combat this reality, the state legislature devised
The Core 40 diploma entails requiring high school students to take up to a minimum of
40 credits covering the completion of four years of English, three years of math, and three years
of science in order to graduate (Erisman, W. & Del Rios, M., 2008). At first, the Core 40
diploma requirements were optional for high school students in 1994. Because of resistance
from some K-12 educators who argued that Core 40 was inappropriate for those not wanting to
attend college, the requirements have since been revised and are now on schedule to become the
admissions standard for Indiana’s public four-year post-secondary institutions by 2011 (Erisman,
W. & Del Rios, M., 2008). This is significant since it will force the state’s community college
system to work even harder to accommodate those students who may slip through the cracks
As a result, the emergence of the statewide community college system, otherwise known
as Ivy Tech Community College (ITCC) will have an even more profound effect on increasing
access to and affordability of higher education in Indiana. Approximately 19,000 students have
enrolled in its system since its reorganization in 2000 (Jones, 2003). ITCC has ushered the state
of Indiana in alignment with the nation’s progressive systems of junior colleges. Currently, it is
nation’s only exclusively state-supported community college system, receiving its funding
directly from state appropriations and private foundations (Erisman, W. & Del Rios, M., 2008).
In the short few years, ITCC has transformed itself as feeder institution to the state’s other four
year colleges and universities, and serves as a low cost alternative for those wanting to obtain an
associate’s degree. As ITCC continues to grow and strengthen itself, its presence suggests a
transition to a highly structured and differentiate higher education system similar to that of
California, where junior colleges, baccalaureate institutions, and research driven institutions are
Status Quo
Higher education in Indiana has become a greater priority for many Hoosiers in
comparison to a decade ago. As it stands, the ebb and flow of the state’s manufacturing and
agricultural industry have been volatile causing the employment market to favor more highly
skilled labor. Accordingly, the state’s unique compilation of assorted higher education
(Erisman, W. & Del Rios, M., 2008). Public universities include major research institutions such
as Indiana University at Bloomington and Purdue University at West Lafayette, as well as the
single campus institutions of Ball State University, Indiana State University, Vincennes
University, and the University of Southern Indiana. As recent as 2000, the state’s community
college system, known as ITCC, was launched and now has 23 campuses. Also, the state is
home to another 40 or so private, nonprofit colleges and universities, including the renowned
(Erisman, W. & Del Rios, M., 2008). Public colleges and universities in the state enrolled just
about 275,000 students in 2006 and 2007 along with independent colleges and universities
accumulating another 81,000 students (Erisman, W. & Del Rios, M., 2008).
The state’s institutions of higher education grant four types of associate degrees: the
Associate of Arts (A.A.), the Associates of Science (A.S.), and the Associate of Applied Science
(A.A.S.). With exception of the later degree which can be found by and large at ITCC, the other
associates degrees are conferred by a combination of the nine state’s four-year campuses and
fourteen of the private universities within Indiana (Metz & Gosetti, 1999). In addition, five state
four-year institutions grant the associates degree as well as the bachelors, masters, professional,
and doctoral degrees (Metz & Gosetti, 1999). As for professional degrees, there are only four
American Bar Association accredited law schools and just one official school of medicine and
dentistry in Indiana.
Generally speaking, the health of higher education in any given state is sometimes
measured by its enrollment trends and high school graduation rates. Indiana has made
considerable progress over the past two decades in these areas. Such progress can be attributed
to a change in perception as formerly discussed. In addition, it is undergoing an economic
metamorphosis due to the decline in manufacturing employment---for gone are the days when a
college degree was not needed to support a middle class standard of living. Since 1992, the
percentage of high school graduates enrolled in college has steadily increased only to surpass the
1994 (Erisman, W. & Del Rios, M., 2008). What is more astonishing is that adult learners are
pushing enrollment figures upward from the establishment of the ITCC system. Furthermore,
the state’s population is on target to grow by 6percent between 2005 and 2020 producing a
projected increase of 22 percent in the number of high school graduates (The National Center for
Public Policy and Higher Education, 2006). This is just a prelude to the work at hand that
Indiana’s higher education system will have to confront as economic conditions continue to alter
Contemporary Governance
changes to its system are made through the General Assembly---meaning that independent
institutions of higher education remain for the most part autonomous and self-governing whereas
public institutions of higher education are held accountable to the state government. This
dichotic scheme makes the Indiana model of higher education very complex, diverse, and
independent system.
The ICHE is the leading coordinating agency which has statutory authorization to do the
following: define the educational missions of public colleges and universities; plan and
disapprove for public institutions the establishment of new programs or expansion of campuses
(ICHE, n.d.). Over the last decade, the commission has become more activist in nature spear
heading policy changes to increase college access, readiness, and success for Hoosiers.
Seven distinct governing boards exist for public higher education in Indiana. Five of
these boards govern the major state universities: Purdue University, Indiana University, Indiana
State University, Ball State University, and the University of Southern Indiana. An independent,
local community college board governs Vincennes University while yet another board governs
Ivy Tech. Indiana's private colleges and universities naturally belong to the Independent
Colleges of Indiana Association, a professional organization that has a representative who sits on
ICHE governing board. Out of the fourteen members of the ICHE, the Governor appoints
twelve, nine representing each of the state’s congressional districts and three at-large members
for a term of four years which may be renewed (ICHE, n.d.). In 1990, the legislature added a
student and a faculty representative who are appointed by the Governor for terms of two years in
Governance Relationships
The ICHE is a regulatory entity by virtue and does not govern any particular higher
education institution per se. By law, the commission has no power or authority involving any
managerial or operational aspect of Indiana’s public or private colleges and universities. Said
institutions retain these responsibilities and are usually governed by their board of trustees. The
ICHE does cultivate working relationships with the various colleges and universities as well as
other auxiliary state agencies by providing constant substantive assistance and education
regarding its policy objectives. It also facilitates the cooperation between the state government
and the public institutions of higher education by acting as a buffer for both sides in establishing
common ground.
Budgetary Funding
Under the Constitution of 1851, the Indiana General Assembly was given the power and
authority to enact laws affecting the organization and financing of the public education system.
It is the state legislature that approves funding to public institutions of higher education in
Indiana. This funding for higher education is basically derived from state appropriations. The
ICHE submits suggested budgetary recommendations to the state legislature on behalf of state
colleges and universities. The total state appropriations for higher education increased $97.2
million for FY 2008 over the appropriations in FY 2007, and an additional $89.6 million for FY
2009 over appropriations for FY 2008 (Ruhl, n.d.). This is striking because these appropriations
are rising despite budget shortfalls especially during the current recession.
There are three critical areas of contention concerning Indiana higher education in
relation to (1) access and affordability, (2) college preparation, and (3) the brain drain. In recent
years, Indiana’s economy has continued to depend highly on manufacturing, an industry that is
rapidly changing. Manufacturing companies are making productivity gains by generating more
with fewer employees; therefore creating a growing demand for more highly skilled workers
(Report of the Subcommittee on Higher Education, 2004). Such a demand has fostered a greater
need for a knowledge-based economy. In fact, Indiana is experiencing an unmet skill shortage of
nurses and teachers (Report of the Subcommittee on Higher Education, 2004). As a result, a
great debate has ensued concerning the manner in which policymakers i.e. ICHE should
approach these challenges in the wake of dwindling public financial support for higher education
in the state.
Access and affordability go hand in hand. Without adequate financial resources to afford
college tuition, access to obtain a post-secondary education is virtually impossible for many
individuals. Although financial aid and family incomes have increased over the past decade, cost
of attending college has jumped nearly three times the rate of inflation (ICHE, 2003). In the
Measuring Up 2006 higher education report card, Indiana received a grade of F in affordability,
largely because the cost of attending college in the state, even after the application of financial
aid, represented a considerable share of family income for the state’s poorest families (p.8).
Therefore, students from these families would be unable to attend college in Indiana without
relying heavily on student loans or working while enrolled in school (Erisman, W. & Del Rios,
M., 2008).
In reaction, lawmakers have begun to discuss ideas to remedy the situation with such
suggestions as restructuring taxes to curb the rising tuition costs. Some have proposed to raise
Indiana’s cigarette tax in order to generate more revenue for supporting its state’s institutions of
higher education. Another recommendation suggested tuition caps. Several bills to restrict
tuition increases were introduced in the General Assembly; however, none have yet passed, in
part because of concerns about limiting the funding available to the state’s higher education
institutions in an era of rigid state budgets (Erisman, W. & Del Rios, M., 2008). So far without
any real consensus on a solution, access and affordability will continue to plague higher learning
Beyond having access and being able to afford a higher education, potential college
students must be sufficiently prepared in order to obtain success while working towards their
degree. Indiana has had difficulty in this area due to the generational perception embedded in the
psyche of its citizenry. Hoosiers have been content for decades with a basic education because
of its heavy reliance on manufacturing. Since the manufacturing industry has weakened, there is
now a need to seek higher education to compete in the global economy. ITCC has compensated
for the inadequate college preparation by expanding its remediation programming for both its
After completing a post-secondary degree, many graduates are having a tough time
acquiring employment that meets their educational needs and therefore are leaving the state
otherwise known as the brain drain. Indiana is still experiencing the growing pains for having to
expand its economy to accommodate the increasing demand for highly skilled workers.
Moreover, Indiana does not fair well when comparing to other states in terms of the educational
attainment of its populace (ICHE, 2003). There is now a drive to attract businesses that will
In summation, a lot can be said about the development of Indiana’s higher education,
nevertheless, there appears to be three reigning themes that continually stimulates its future
progression: (1) the challenges posed to funding its operations and sequestering financial
assistance for its low-income students; (2) the improvement of academic preparation of its
citizenry who have traditionally opted out of pursuing higher education; (3) Indiana’s fledging
dependency on its manufacturing industry. These challenges will have to be met with urgency
PS Governance
State-Level Coordinating and/or Established in 1971, the Commission of Higher Education functions as the
Governing Agency statutory coordinating agency for postsecondary education in the state. The
commission has 14 members--12 are appointed by the governor for four-year
terms and represent the general public; one student and one faculty member serve
two-year terms. The commission is charged with six responsibilities by statute: (1)
long-range planning for postsecondary education in Indiana; (2) defining
institutional roles; (3) approving new campuses or extension sites; (4) approving
new program requests; (5) reviewing existing programs; (6) reviewing budget
requests and recommending consolidated requests to the executive and legislative
branches of state government. Indiana does not have an office of secretary of
education and the coordinating agency is not a cabinet department. The executive
officer of the commission is appointed by the commission and serves at its
pleasure.
System/Institutional Governing Indiana has eight public institutional governing boards: (1) Ball State University
Boards Board of Trustees; (2) Indiana State University Board of Trustees; (3) Ivy Tech
State College Board of Trustees with authority over 22 campuses and centers and
the newly created Community College of Indiana in partnership with Vincennes
University; (4) Indiana University Board of Trustees with authority over seven
campuses; (5) IUPU Ft. Wayne campus administered by Purdue University
maintains dual program responsibilities, with some academic units answerable to
Purdue and others to Indiana University; (6) Purdue University Board of Trustees
responsible for four campuses; (7) Vincennes University Board of Trustees with
jurisdiction over the newly created Community College of Indiana in partnership
with Ivy Tech State College; and (8) University of Southern Indiana Board of
Trustees.
State Student Assistance and The State Student Assistance Commission of Indiana serves as the state student
Loan Agencies assistance agency.
Postsecondary Vocational- The Commission on Vocational and Technical Education is the State Board for
Technical Education Vocational Education. The commission consists of 11 citizens who are appointed
to four-year terms by the governor. Each of 10 congressional districts is
represented by a member; the remaining member represents the state at-large.
State-Level Organization of The Independent Colleges of Indiana represents 32 private colleges and
Independent (Not for Profit) universities within the state. The Association of Private Schools is a similar
Colleges and Universities organization representing the private trade, business and technical schools in
Indiana.
Licensure/Approval Agencies The Indiana Commission on Proprietary Education functions as the statutory
licensing and approval authority for proprietary institutions.
Other Statewide Postsecondary The Indiana Conference of Higher Education represents both the public and
Organizations private colleges and universities and is a voluntary organization dedicated to the
betterment of overall postsecondary education.
Statutory Advisory Committee None.
References
State Profiles - Postsecondary Governance Structures Database. (n.d.). Retrieved October 26, 2008, from
http://www.ecs.org/ecsmain.asp?page=/html/issuesPS.asp
Blake, I. G. (1963, August 4). The Civil War Came to the Campus.' Retrieved December 2,
http://history.hanover.edu/hhr/99/hhr99_3.html
Brubacher, J. S. & Rudy, W. (2007). Higher Education in Transition. New Brunswick, NJ &
http://www.depauw.edu/visitors/traditions/
Erisman, W. & Del Rios, M. (2008, September). Creating Change One Step At a Time: Efforts to
Improve College Access and Success in Indiana. Retrieved December 4, 2008, from
http://www.che.state.in.us/
Gwaltney, C. (2008, March/April). Raising the Bar: Higher Education Goals and Aspirations.
http://www.bizvoicemagazine.com/archives/08marapr.htm
Hebel, S. (2005, August 26). Indiana. Chronicle of Higher Education, 52(1), 54-56. Retrieved
Hebel, S. (2006, January 6). Outlook for Higher Education in the State Legislatures: Indiana.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_indiana
Indiana Commission for Higher Education (ICHE). (n.d.). Retrieved October 26, 2008, from
http://www.che.state.in.us/
Indiana Commission for Higher Education (ICHE). (2003, November 14). Indiana’s Framework
for Policy and Planning Development in Higher Education Retrieved October 26, 2008,
from http://www.che.state.in.us/
http://www.bizvoicemagazine.com/archives/03mayjun.htm
Landini, R. (1997, Winter97). Reflections on the Indiana Commission for Higher Education.
Metz, G. & Gosetti, P. (1999, January). Indiana Higher Education: The Hoosier Commitment to
Localism and Vocationalism. Community College Journal of Research & Practice, 23(1),
Northwest Ordinance, July 13, 1787; (National Archives Microfilm Publication M332, roll 9);
1789, Record Group 360; National Archives. Retrieved on October 26, 2008 from
http://www.ourdocuments.gov/doc.php?doc=8
St. John, E., Hu, S., & Weber, J. (2001, August). State Policy and The Affordability of Public
Higher Education, 42(4), 401-428. Retrieved October 26, 2008, from Education Research
Complete database.
Ruhl, C.A. Budget Director’s Introduction Letter. Retrieved December 2, 2008, from
http://www.in.gov/sba/3083.htm
State Profiles - Postsecondary Governance Structures Database. (n.d.). Retrieved October 26,
The National Center for Public Policy and Higher Education. (2006). Measuring Up 2006: The
http://measuringup.highereducation.org/reports/stateprofilenet.cfm?myyear=2006&state
Name=Indiana
Indiana University.