Foreword . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9
Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .11
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .13
1. Models: The Marriage of Dream
and Function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .17
2. Flawed Marksmanship: And a Missing
Target . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .28
The Journey: Part One . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .46
3. Step One: Where Does a Sin Addict
Go for Help?. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .55
The Journey: Part Two . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .68
4. WDJD? Where in the Bible Is the
Life-on-Life Model? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .77
5. An Apologetic for Healthy Impact:
Instead of Success . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . 84
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 7
1/16/13 2:49 PM
Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 213
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 8
1/16/13 2:49 PM
Introduction
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 13
1/16/13 2:49 PM
14
Introduction
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 14
1/16/13 2:49 PM
Introduction
15
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 15
1/16/13 2:49 PM
16
Introduction
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 16
1/16/13 2:49 PM
CHA
ONTER
E
Models
The Marriage of Dream and Function
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 17
1/16/13 2:49 PM
18
Insourcing
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 18
1/16/13 2:49 PM
Models
19
You have a dream, a vision that you hope reflects the heart of the
Architect, Jesus, the author and perfecter of our faith (Heb.
12:2). The dream shifts and sharpens over time, but if its from
God, it is big and daunting and over-the-top. It reaches out to
encompass that overarching dream of believers everywhere: to
glorify God and enjoy him forever. If you are a pastor or a leader,
and you dont have a dream, its time to get alone and ask God for
one. Leaders need dreams.
And then theres function, the how-to that connects the big,
noble dream to real, flawed people in real, limited time and space.
Thats where models come in. You cant realize a dream without
one. If you have a God-given dream and a church that functions, there is a model somewhere in your thinking, even if you
havent clearly identified it. Maybe youve followed the prevailing trends. Or youve reinvented the wheel again and your
church is forging its own path. Or you are a classicist who values
the traditional ways. Whether you lead in broad strokes with a
near disdain for planning or you are a meticulous detail person
who draws flowcharts in your spare time, or you are somewhere
in between, you are a ministerial model maker.
The question is, How effective is your ministry model? Is it
a servant, a backdrop that slips into near invisibility behind the
purpose and the people it serves? Or is it so unwieldy that you
feel as if you are serving it and not the other way around? More
important, does your model facilitate your dream? If your dream
were distilled to the fundamental purpose of humanity to glorify and enjoy God forever does your model get you there?
And what kind of people does your ministry model serve? Is
your model made to serve real people with real lives? Think really
hard about that one. How effectively does your model help your
people glorify and enjoy God? Im not talking about just the one
poster child who is a shining example of the dream. Im talking
about all of the individuals in your care.
These questions convince me that models matter.
This book is about a model I have tested for many years.
For more than two decades, this model has served well both
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 19
1/16/13 2:49 PM
20
Insourcing
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 20
1/16/13 2:49 PM
Models
21
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 21
1/16/13 2:49 PM
22
Insourcing
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 22
1/16/13 2:49 PM
Models
23
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 23
1/16/13 2:49 PM
24
Insourcing
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 24
1/16/13 2:49 PM
Models
25
ror Mother Teresas actions without any of Mother Teresas character or faith? We can all think of at least one ministry gone sour
because of the unhealthiness of its leadership. What if, in meeting
the needs of the world, we expose the fact that we are no different
from that world?
What if we do work that matters, but we dont matter? What
if all we build is a model, something that bears the sheen of newness today until it is blown to pieces or shelved to gather dust
tomorrow? And what if we become pioneers of nothing more than
new models, stopping tragically short of the new humanity we
were meant to instill in each and every generation that walks the
earth?
These questions dont negate the value of the models. I consider it a privilege, perhaps even a historic one, to have led Perimeter Church on the crest of both waves, the hybrid pastoral/
attractional and the influential. But I am convinced the reason
these two models have served us well is that we have examined
them closely all along the way, and when we saw a gap a huge
crevasse, it turns out between them, we tried to fill it. The
final model I will describe in this book was designed to bridge
this gap. I am convinced that without its connective capacity, the
other two models have the potential to become at best obsolete
and at worst harmful.
Let me rephrase the questions posed above more alarmingly:
What if the pastoral/attractional model of church produced an
army of Christians who are consumeristic, shallow, and bland?
And what if the influential model of church cranked out wildeyed activists who do loving acts without the love that springs
from spiritual maturity? What if the church marched on, resolutely doing many of the right things, but without being the right
people?
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 25
1/16/13 2:49 PM
26
Insourcing
that kind of message as if no one else loves quite like this one
church, or, more arrogant, as if they took the love test and aced
it. Neither assertion could possibly be true. And yet I realize how
easily this book could sound a little like that marquee. Im going
to talk about something as basic to the Christian life as love, and
yet it is something often neglected. Most church leaders will agree
that what I propose is indispensable to the life of the church.
But some will wonder if its possible in todays church. They will
dismiss it because it sets a bar that they think is too high. But Im
going to share my own story, and the story of Perimeter Church,
as pardon the marquee-like bravado a beacon of hope. Yes,
this model is imperative. And yes, it can be done.
As I introduce another model of church, I am also aware that
we are neither the first to do it nor the only ones. Thats why I
hesitate to call it a new model. Because it isnt. The best ideas are
both new and old. They are fresh enough to arrest us, to catch
us off guard. But they are old enough to cause us to say, upon
further reflection, Oh, I knew that all along. If an idea is old
enough to be rooted in ancient truth and new enough to startle
us with its originality, it is probably worth our attention.
This model is public domain, like the words of an old hymn
or the literature of antiquity. We call it the life-on-life model.
This is the model the church must embrace if the people who
come to Christ via the pastoral/attractional model and go out into
the world via the influential model are to do so smelling of Jesus
himself.3 Im not suggesting that pastors and leaders throw out
the old models. We didnt. But I am suggesting we ask questions
of them. And in the answers to these questions, I believe we will
rediscover the life-on-life model, the one that functions as the
missing link between the other two.
As Ive mentioned, we questioned our own models at Perimeter. But our most important questions werent sparked by the
models at all. They had more to do with the people themselves.
Because after the model has been relegated to the storage unit or
the dumpster, the people will still be here. And so we asked, Were
our people becoming the right people? Not just a few of them,
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 26
1/16/13 2:49 PM
Models
27
but the majority of them? Did their lives glorify God? Were they
qualitatively Christlike? Did they know how to make good, biblical, kingdom-centric decisions? What kind of wives, husbands,
fathers, mothers, bosses, employees, and neighbors were they?
Again, Im not talking about the statistical outliers; Im talking
about the rule versus the exception. Were they attractive and missional? If not, what good were our models? We didnt just scrutinize the models; we examined the people the models were created
to shape and serve, the people we were called to lead. And when
we looked at the people, we were stunned by what we didnt see.
The pastoral/attractional and the influential models are not
enough because they do not account adequately for real people.
It is easy for them to miss the individual, and they do not include
essential elements in the mechanism for individual change. The
pastoral/attractional model gives expression to the dramatic
nature of the gospel message. The influential model reminds us
that our message is too large to contain inside the walls of our
churches. These models have challenged the church to stretch
its presence in the world to the epic proportions it was meant to
have. But they leave out one key ingredient. And this ingredient,
if omitted, will one day render the church tasteless, toothless, and
the very thing we set out to avoid all those years ago: irrelevant.
Somehow, we must learn to take the broad message of the
gospel and the wide mission of the church and deliver it personby-person until our people are filled with it. Somehow, the church
must possess an integrity that bridges the gap between its words
and its people, between its sermons and the souls in its pews,
between its programs and each persons life. If this kind of integrity matters to you at all, youll want to hear about this life-on-life
model. And when I tell you about it, youll probably say, I knew
that all along.
9780310490678_Insourcing_int_CS5.indd 27
1/16/13 2:49 PM
Insourcing
Bringing Discipleship Back to the Local Church
by Randy Pope