5.1 Introduction
In the previous chapter, the basic operation of transmission lines was
discussed with a concentration on designing and understanding the
operation of microstrip lines. This chapter focuses on the frequency-
dependent behavior of microstrip lines and on designing the lines so that
undesirable behavior is avoided. The major limitation on the dimensions of
transmission lines is determined by considering when higher-order modes
(field orientations) can exist. Different modes on a transmission line travel
at different velocities. Thus the problem is that if a signal on a line is split
between two modes, then the information sent from one end of the line will
reach the other end in two packets arriving at different times. A combination
of the two modes will be detected and in general the information will be
lost as the two modes combine in an incoherent manner. This multimoding
must be avoided at all costs. The purpose of this chapter is to help you gain
an understanding of frequency-dependent behavior and multimoding on
transmission lines. You will also be able to design the dimensions of lines
to avoid the excitation of higher-order modes, and will be able to debug RF
and microwave circuits that fail to work correctly because of multimoding.
246 MICROWAVE AND RF DESIGN: A SYSTEMS APPROACH
1 Z0 x 2
Z
0
E Z0
t =0
z
t =1
t =2
0V 0V 0V
DC 1 GHz 10 GHz
0V 0V
1 GHz 10 GHz
0V 0V
1 GHz 10 GHz
(a) (b) (c)
Figure 5-2 Crosssectional view of the charge distribution on an interconnect at different frequencies. The
+ and − indicate charge concentrations of different polarity and corresponding current densities. There is
no current bunching or skin effect at DC.
electrons exposing positively charged ions) tend to repel each other, but
this has little effect on the charge distribution for practical conductors with
finite conductivity. (If the conductor had zero resistance then these charges
would be confined to the surface of the conductor.) The bottom conductor is
known as the ground plane and there are balancing negative charges, or a
surplus of electrons, so that electric field lines begin on the positive charges
and terminate on the negative charges. The negative charges on the ground
plane are uniformly distributed across the whole of the ground plane. An
important point is that where there are unbalanced, or net, charges there
can be current flow. So the charge distribution at DC, shown in Figure 5-
2(a), indicates that for the top conductor, current would flow uniformly
EXTRAORDINARY TRANSMISSION LINE EFFECTS 249
(b) (d)
Figure 5-3 Normalized magnitudes of current and charge on an alumina microstrip line at 1 GHz: (a)
normalized scale; (b) longitudinal current, iz , on the strip (10–26 A/m); (c) on the ground plane (0–
3.2 A/m); (d) the charge on the strip (80–400 nC/m2 ); and (e) on the ground plane (0–33 nC/m2 ). (For
alumina, ε = 10.0 and µr = 1.)
distributed throughout the conductors and the return current in the ground
plane would be distributed over the whole of the ground plane.
The charge distribution becomes less uniform as frequency increases
and eventually the signal changes so quickly that information to rearrange
charges on the ground plane is soon (half a period latter) countered by
reverse instructions. Thus the charge distribution depends on how fast the
signal changes. The effects are seen in the higher-frequency views shown in
Figures 5-2(b) and 5-2(c). (The concentration of charges near the surface of
the metal is a separate effect known as the skin effect.) The longitudinal
impact of current or charge bunching alone is illustrated in Figures 5-3,
5-4, and 5-5. These figures present amplitudes of the current and charge
phasors at various frequencies and were calculated using the SONNET
EM simulator. In interpreting these figures, please take into account the
magnitudes of the current and charge distributions as identified in the
captions, as the scales are normalized. An alternative view (or time-domain
view) is the instantaneous snapshot of current and charge shown in Figure
5-6. This situation is not just confined to the transverse plane, and regions
further along the interconnect also send instructions. The net effect is
bunching of charges and hence of current on both the ground plane and
the strip.
(b) (d)
Figure 5-4 Normalized magnitudes of current and charge on an alumina microstrip line at 10 GHz:
(a) normalized scale; (b) longitudinal current, iz , on the strip (10–28 A/m); (c) on the ground plane (0–
4.1 A/m); (d) the charge on the strip (114–512 nC/m2 ); and (e) on the ground plane (0–39 nC/m2 ).
(b) (d)
Figure 5-5 Normalized magnitudes of current and charge on an alumina microstrip line at 30 GHz: (a)
normalized scale; (b) longitudinal current, iz , on the strip (10–31 A/m); (c) on the ground plane (0–6 A/m);
(d) the charge on the strip (200–575 nC/m2 ); and (e) on the ground plane (0–68 nC/m2 ).
CURRENT CHARGE
_
+
(b) (e)
_
+
Figure 5-6 Normalized instantaneous current and charge distribution on an alumina microstrip line and
ground plane at 30 GHz. Current: (a) normalized scale; (b) magnitude of the longitudinal current, ix , on
the microstrip; and (c) on the ground plane. Arrows indicate the direction of current flow. Charge: (d)
scale; (e) microstrip; and (f) ground plane. Signs indicate the polarity of charge.
Here
√ k is a constant, and while Equation (5.3) indicates proportionality to
f , this is an approximation and the actual frequency dependence may be
different, but Rs always increases more slowly than frequency.
and cannot change orientation with frequency. This is the case with copla-
nar interconnects—in particular, coplanar waveguide (CPW) and coplanar
strip (CPS) lines have lower dispersion characteristics than does microstrip
(for small geometries). The stripline of Figure 4-8(a) also has low dispersion,
as the fields are confined in one medium and the effective permittivity is
just the permittivity of the medium. Thus interconnect choices can have a
significant effect on the integrity of a signal being transmitted.
As discussed earlier, as the frequency is increased, the fields become
more concentrated in the region beneath the strip—where the substrate
permittivity has already resulted in a relatively large electric field
displacement. Since the fields are forced into the dielectric substrate to an
increasing extent as the frequency rises, a frequency-dependent effective
microstrip permittivity, εe (f ), can be defined. This quantity clearly increases
with frequency and the wave is progressively slowed down. The effective
microstrip permittivity is now
2
εe (f ) = {c/ [vp (f )]} . (5.4)
fb
fa = (5.7)
0.75 + 0.75 − 0.332 ε−1.73
r (w/h)
( s )
47.746 × 106 −1 εe (0) − 1
fb = p tan εr (5.8)
h εr − εe (0) εr − εe (0)
m0 mc m0 mc ≤ 2.32
m= (5.9)
2.32 m0 mc > 2.32
1 p −3
m0 = 1 + p + 0.32 1 + w/h (5.10)
1 + w/h
1 + 1.4 0.15 − 0.235e−0.45f /f a , for w/h ≤ 0.7
mc = 1 + w/h . (5.11)
1, for w/h > 0.7
In all the equations given above, SI units are used. The accuracy of the
equations above is within 0.6% for 0.1 ≤ w/h ≤ 10, 1 ≤ εr ≤ 128, and for
any value of h/λ provided that h < λ/10.1
α = αd + αc . (5.12)
For dielectric loss, Equation (4.78) provides a good estimate for the
attenuation when εe is replaced by the frequency-dependent effective
dielectric constant, εe (f ).
Frequency-dependent conductor loss results from the concentration of
current as frequency increases. For a wide strip of thickness three times
greater than the skin depth,
Rs (f )
αc (f ) = . (5.13)
w Z0
For a narrow strip, say w/h < 1, the quasi-static loss equations (Equations
(4.186) to (4.189)) can be used with acceptable accuracy.
1 Note that the free-space wavelength is λ0 , the wavelength in the medium is λ, and the guide
wavelength is λg .
EXTRAORDINARY TRANSMISSION LINE EFFECTS 255
300
ε
r
250 1
2
4
200 6
Z0 10
20
(Ω) 150 40
100
50
0
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0
w/h
α(f ) = αd (f ) + αc (f ) + αr (f ). (5.14)
32
30 ε
28 r
26 1
2
24
4
22
6
20 10
18 20
εe 16 40
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0
w/h
Figure 5-8 Dependence of effective relative permittivity εe of a microstrip line at
1 GHz for various dielectric constants and aspect ratios (w/h).
(a)
(b)
Figure 5-9 Frequency dependence of the real and imaginary parts of the effective permittivity, εe , and
characteristic impedance Z0 of a gold microstrip line on alumina with εr (DC) = 9.9, w = 70 µm, h =
500 µm: (a) real parts ℜ(); and (b) imaginary parts ℑ().
258 MICROWAVE AND RF DESIGN: A SYSTEMS APPROACH
(a)
(b)
Figure 5-10 Frequency dependence of the effective permittivity, εe , and characteristic impedance Z0 of a
gold microstrip line with εr (DC) = 9.9, w = 240 µm, h = 635 µm: (a) real parts; and (b) imaginary parts.
EXTRAORDINARY TRANSMISSION LINE EFFECTS 259
(a)
(b)
Figure 5-11 Frequency dependence of the effective permittivity, εe , and characteristic impedance Z0 of a
gold microstrip line with εr (DC) = 9.9, w = h = 635 µm: (a) real parts; and (b) imaginary parts.
260 MICROWAVE AND RF DESIGN: A SYSTEMS APPROACH
0.78
0.76
0.74
0.72
0.70 εr
0.68 2
q 0.66 4
0.64 6
10
0.62
20
0.60 40
0.58
0.56
0.54
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 20 25 3.0 3.5 4.0
. .
w/h
Figure 5-12 Dependence of the q factor of a microstrip line at 1 GHz for various
dielectric constants and aspect (w/h) ratios. (Data obtained using SONNET.)
E field H field
Electric wall Normal Parallel
Magnetic wall Parallel Normal
z x
DIRECTION OF PROPAGATION
ε, µ REVERSE−TRAVELING WAVE
d
DIRECTION OF PROPAGATION
FORWARD−TRAVELING WAVE
(a)
y
d
0
0 x
(b)
∂B
∇×E = (5.17)
∂t
∂D
∇×H = J+ (5.18)
∂t
∇·D = ρV (5.19)
∇·B = 0, (5.20)
where ρV is the charge density and J is the current density. J and ρV will be
zero except at an electric wall. The above equations do not include magnetic
charge or magnetic current density. They do not actually exist and so a
modified form of Maxwell’s equations incorporating these is not necessary
to solve the fields on a structure. They are invoked in Appendix D to draw
an analogy between an electric wall at a conductor and a magnetic wall at
the interface between two regions of different permittivity.
In the lateral direction, the parallel-plate waveguide in Figure 5-13
extends indefinitely, and this is indicated by the broken continuation
of the top and bottom metal planes in Figure 5-13(a). For this regular
264 MICROWAVE AND RF DESIGN: A SYSTEMS APPROACH
E A
y E
H B H
x
C
(a) (b)
Figure 5-14 Parallel-plate waveguide showing electric, E, and magnetic, H, field
lines: (a) the TEM mode; and (b) the TE mode. The electric (E) and magnetic (H)
field lines are shown with the line thickness indicating field strength. The shading of
the E field lines indicates polarity (+ or −) and the arrows indicate direction (and
also polarity). The z direction is into the page.
∇ · Dy ŷ = ρ (5.23)
∇ · Bx x̂ = 0. (5.24)
Expanding the curl, ∇×, and div, ∇·, operators using Equations (D.15) and
(D.16) these become (with D = εE and B = µH)
∂Ey ∂Bx x̂ ∂µHx x̂
x̂ = = (5.25)
∂z ∂t ∂t
∂Hx ∂Dy ŷ ∂εEy ŷ
ŷ = +J= +J (5.26)
∂z ∂t ∂t
∂Dy ∂εEy
= =ρ (5.27)
∂y ∂y
∂Bx ∂µHx
= = 0. (5.28)
∂x ∂x
These equations describe what happens at each point in space. Equation
(5.25) indicates that if there is a time-varying component of the x-directed B
field then there must be a z-varying component of the Ey field component.
This is just part of the wave equation describing a field propagating in the
z direction. Equation (5.26) indicates the same thing, but now the roles of
the electric and magnetic fields are reversed. Equation (5.25) shows that
the y component of the electric field can be constant between the plates,
but at the plates there must be charge on the surface of the conductors
(see Equation (5.27)),to terminate the electric field (as indicated by Equation
(5.27)), as there is no electric field inside the conductors (assuming that they
are perfect conductors for the moment). Since magnetic charges do not exist,
captured by the zero on the right-hand side of Equation (5.28), Equation
(5.28) indicates that the x component of the magnetic field cannot vary in
the x direction (i.e., Bx and Hx are constant). Thus the assumption behind
the trial solution about the form of this mode is correct. The electric and
magnetic field are uniform in the transverse plane, the xy plane, and the
only variation is in the direction of propagation, the z direction. Thus the
test solution satisfies Maxwell’s equations. This is the TEM mode, as all field
components are in the x and y directions and none are in the z direction.
The TEM mode can be supported at all frequencies in the parallel-plate
waveguide.
Putting Equations (5.25)–(5.28) in phasor form, and considering the source
free region between the plates (so J = 0 and ρ = 0), these become
∂Ey
= ωµHx (5.29)
∂z
∂Hx
= ωεEy (5.30)
∂z
∂Ey
=0 (5.31)
∂y
266 MICROWAVE AND RF DESIGN: A SYSTEMS APPROACH
∂Hx
=0 (5.32)
∂x
and the solution becomes
∂ 2 Ey
= γ 2 Ey (5.33)
∂z 2
∂ 2 Hx
= γ 2 Hx , (5.34)
∂z 2
√
where γ = ω µε and there is no variation of the Ey component of the
electric field in the y direction and no variation of the Hx component of the
magnetic field in the x direction.
Another possible set of modes occurs when the electric field is only in
the y direction, but then there must be a variation of the field strength, as
shown in Figure 5-14(b). The full EM development of the fields is given in
Appendix E and here we summarize the results qualitatively. The simplest
variation is when there is a half-sinusoidal spatial variation of the Ey field
component. Applying the methodology described above, it is found that
there must be a component of the magnetic field in the z direction to
support this mode. Hence these modes are called Transverse Electric (TE)
modes. (Interchanging the roles of the electric and magnetic fields yields the
Transverse Magnetic (TM) modes where there is an electric field component
in the z direction.) The half-sinusoidal variation still enables the charge to
support the existence of an Ey electric field. A key result from our previous
discussion is that there must be enough distance for the field to curl by the
half-sinusoidal spatial variation and this is related to wavelength, λ. This
transverse electric mode can only exist when h ≥ λ/2. When h is smaller
than one-half wavelength, this mode cannot be supported, and is said to be
cut off. Only the TEM mode can be supported all the way down to DC, so
modes other than TEM have a cutoff frequency, fc , and a cutoff wavelength,
√
λc . The concept of wavenumber k(= 2π/λ = ω µε) is also used, and for the
lowest TE mode, kc = 2π/λc with λc = 2h. The cutoff wavelength, λc , and
the cutoff wavenumber, kc , are both related to the dimension below in which
a mode cannot “curl” sufficiently to be self-supporting. In general, for TE
modes, there can be n variations of the electric field, and so we talk about the
nth TE mode, denoted as TEn , for which kc,n = nπ/h and λc = 2h/n. Also
note that kc = 2π/λc . The propagation constant of any mode in a uniform
lossless medium (not just in a parallel-plate waveguide mode) is
p
β = k 2 − kc2 . (5.35)
For the TEM mode we have kc = 0. High-order modes are described by their
cutoff wavenumber, kc .
Transverse magnetic (TM) modes are similarly described, and again kc =
nπ/h for the TMn mode. A mode can be supported at any frequency above
EXTRAORDINARY TRANSMISSION LINE EFFECTS 267
the cutoff frequency for the mode. It just cannot be supported at frequencies
below the cutoff frequency, as it is not possible for the fields to vary (or curl)
below cutoff.
0 hy 0 h y 0 hy
Hx Ez Hz
0 hy 0 h y 0 h y
no E x Hy E z Hz
TEM mode TM mode TE mode
ELECTRIC
h
y
OR
E H H E
x0
MAGNETIC
Ey Ex
Hx Hy
(b) Hz Ez
NONE 0 hy 0 h y
Ez Hz
0 hy 0 hy
MAGNETIC h
y
OR
H E E H H E
x0
MAGNETIC
Ex Ey Ex
(c) Hx Hy
0 hy 0 hy 0 h y
Hy Ez Hz
0 hy 0 h y 0 hy
no E y Hx E z Hz
TEM mode TM mode TE mode
can be frequencies where the phase velocities of two modes can coincide.
Since discontinuities are inevitable it is always a good idea to use the
first consideration. As was noted previously, the modal analysis that was
possible with the parallel-plate waveguide cannot be repeated easily for the
microstrip line because of the irregular crosssection, but the phenomena is
very similar. Instead of a TEM mode, there is a quasi-TEM mode and there
are TE and TM modes.
c tan−1 (εr )
fc1 = √ √ . (5.36)
2πh εr − 1
c
fc2 = √ . (5.37)
4h εr
The development here assumes that the interface between the dielectric and
air forms a good magnetic wall. With a dielectric having a permittivity of 10,
typical for microwave circuits, the effective value of h would be increased
by up to 10%. However, it is difficult to place an exact value on this.
In summary, fc2 is the lowest frequency at which the dielectric mode will
exist if there is a discontinuity, and fc1 is the lowest frequency at which the
dielectric mode will exist if there is not a discontinuity.
270 MICROWAVE AND RF DESIGN: A SYSTEMS APPROACH
The strip of a microstrip has a width of 1 mm and is fabricated on a lossless substrate that is
2.5 mm thick and has a relative permittivity of 9. At what frequency does the substrate (or
slab) mode first occur?
w
h
εr=9
w +0.4h
Solution:
There are two frequencies that must be considered. One that comes from the dimensions of
the dielectric slab and the other from considerations of matching phase velocities. From
phase velocity consideration, the development behind Equation (5.36), the first critical
frequency is
c tan−1 (εr )
fc1 = √ √ = 13.9 GHz. (5.38)
2πh εr − 1
The first slab mode occurs when a variation of the magnetic or electric field can be
supported between the ground plane and the approximate magnetic
√ wall supported by the
dielectric/free-space interface; that is, when h = λ4 = λ0 /(4 9) = 2.5 mm ⇒ λ0 = 3 cm.
Thus the second slab mode critical frequency is
Since discontinuities cannot be avoided (you cannot build an interesting circuit with just a
transmission line), fc2 is the critical frequency to use.
Figure 4-4. However, the variations that are closest to the quasi-TEM mode
are called higher-order microstrip modes and the one that occurs at the
lowest frequency corresponds to a half-sinusoidal variation of the electric
field between the edge of the strip and the ground plane. This path is
a little longer than the path directly from the strip to the ground plane.
However, for a wide strip, most of the EM energy is between the strip
and the ground plane (both of which are electric walls) with approximate
magnetic walls on the side of the strip. The modes are then similar to the
parallel-plate waveguide modes described in Appendix D on Page 847. The
next highest microstrip mode (or parallel-plate TE mode) occurs when there
can be a half-sinusoidal variation of the electric field between the strip
and the ground plane. This corresponds to Figure 5-15(a). However, for
finite-width strips the first higher-order microstrip mode occurs at a lower
frequency than implied by the parallel-plate waveguide model. In reality,
multimoding occurs at a slightly lower frequency than would be implied
by this model. This is because the microstrip fields are not solely confined
to the dielectric region, and in fact the electric field lines do not follow the
shortest distance between the strip and the ground plane. Thus the fields
along the longer paths to the sides of the strip can vary at a lower frequency
than if we considered only the direct path. With detailed EM modeling and
with experimental support it has been established that the first higher-order
microstrip mode can exist at frequencies greater than [51, page 143]:
c
fHigher−Microstrip = √ . (5.40)
4h εr − 1
This is only an approximate guide, and it is best to use the thinnest substrate
possible. Most EM software programs used to model microstrip and other
planar transmission lines report when higher-order moding can occur.
The strip of a microstrip has a width of 1 mm and is fabricated on a lossless substrate that
is 2.5 mm thick and has a relative permittivity of 9. At what frequency does the first higher
microstrip mode first propagate?
w
h
εr=9
w +0.4h
Solution:
The higher-order microstrip mode occurs when a half-wavelength variation of the electric
field between the strip and the ground plane can be supported. When h = λ/2 = λ0 /(3·2) =
2.5 mm; that is, the mode will occur when λ0 = 15 mm. So
272 MICROWAVE AND RF DESIGN: A SYSTEMS APPROACH
ELECTRIC WALL
MAGNETIC MAGNETIC
WALL WALL
(a) (b)
Figure 5-16 Approximation of a microstrip line as a waveguide: (a) crosssection of microstrip; and (b)
model with magnetic and electric walls.
′
fHigher−Microstrip = 20 GHz. (5.41)
A better estimate of the frequency where the higher-order microstrip mode becomes a
problem is given by Equation (5.40):
√
fHigher−Microstrip = c/(4h εr − 1) = 10.6 GHz. (5.42)
So two estimates have been calculated for the frequency at which the first higher-order
microstrip mode can first exist. The estimate in Equation (5.41) is approximate and is based
on a half-wavelength variation of the electric field confined to the direct path between the
strip and the ground plane. Equation (5.42) is more accurate as it considers that on the edge
of the strip the fields follow a longer path to the ground plane. It is the half-wavelength
variation on this longer path that determines if the higher-order microstrip mode will exist.
Thus the more precise determination yields a lower critical frequency.
w
h
εr=9
Shorter half wavelength path Longer half wavelength path
Higher frequency estimate Lower frequency estimate
ε0 d
w
εr h
w +2 d
Ey
Figure 5-17 Transverse resonance: standing wave (|Ey |) and equivalent transmis-
sion line of length w + 2d where d = 0.2h.
λc
= w + 2d = w + 0.4h (5.43)
2
or
c
√ = w + 0.4h. (5.44)
2fc εr
Hence
c
fc = √ . (5.45)
εr (2w + 0.8h)
The strip of a microstrip has a width of 1 mm and is fabricated on a lossless substrate that is
2.5 mm thick and has a relative permittivity of 9.
w
h
εr=9
w +0.4h
√
Solution: h = 2.5 mm, w = 1 mm , λ = λ0 / εr = λ0 /3
(a) The magnetic waveguide model of Figure 5-16 can be used in estimating the frequency
at which this occurs. The frequency at which the first transverse resonance mode
occurs is when there is a full half-wavelength variation of the magnetic field between
the magnetic walls, that is, the first transverse resonance when ω+0.4h = λ/2 = 2 mm:
λ0
= 2 mm ⇒ λ0 = 12 mm,
3·2
and so
′
fTRAN = 25 GHz . (5.46)
(b) All of the critical multimoding frequencies must be considered here and the minimum
taken. The slab mode critical frequencies are fc1 (Equation (5.38)) and fc2 (Equation
(5.39)); the higher-order mode critical frequency is fHigh−Microstrip (Equation (5.42));
and the transverse resonance frequency (Equation (5.46)). So the operating frequency
range is DC to 10 GHz.
Mode Critical
frequency
Dielectric (or substrate) mode with no discontinuity Equation (5.36)
Dielectric (or substrate) mode with discontinuity Equation (5.39)
Higher Order Microstrip Mode Equation (5.42)
Transverse Resonance Mode Equation (5.45)
(b) The introduction of lossy (i.e., absorbent) material near any radiative
discontinuity.
(d) Reducing the current densities flowing in the outer edges of any metal
sections and concentrate currents toward the center and in the middle
of the microstrip.
(e) Possibly shape the discontinuity in some way to reduce the radiative
efficiency.
Si Bulk
z
x
d1 ε 1 ,σ1 ,µ 0 Axis of wave
propagation
d d ε ,σ ,µ
2 2 2 0 y
propagation that derives from the charge layer formed at the silicon-silicon
dioxide interface. The slow-wave effect is utilized in delay lines, couplers,
and filters. With Schottky contact lines, the effect is used in variable-phase
shifters, voltage-tunable filters, and various other applications.
Now, an intuitive explanation of the propagation characteristics of
microstrip lines of this type can be based on the parallel-plate structure
shown in Figure 5-19. For an exact EM analysis of the slow-wave effect with
silicon substrates see Hasegawa et al. [75]. As well as developing a very
useful approximation for the important situation of transmission lines on a
semiconductor, the treatment below indicates the type of approach that can
be used to analyze unusual structures. In this structure, assume a quasi-TEM
mode of propagation. In other words, the wave propagation parameters
α, β, and Z0 can be deduced from electrostatic and magnetostatic solutions
for the per unit length parameters C, G, L, and R.
The analysis begins with a treatment of the classic Maxwell-Wagner
capacitor. Figure 5-20(a) shows the structure of such a capacitor where
there are two different materials between the parallel plates of the capacitor
with different dielectric constants and conductivity. The equivalent circuit is
shown in Figure 5-20(b) with the elements given by
A 1 d1
C1 = ε1 , R1 = (5.47)
d1 σ1 A
EXTRAORDINARY TRANSMISSION LINE EFFECTS 277
ε1 ,σ1 d1 R1 C1
d ε2 ,σ2 Y(ω)
d2
R2 C2
(a) (b)
Figure 5-20 Structure of the Maxwell-Wagner capacitor: (a) structure; and (b) its
equivalent circuit.
A 1 d2
C2 = ε2 , R2 = (5.48)
d2 σ2 A
ε1
τ1 = R1 C1 = (5.49)
σ1
ε2
τ2 = R2 C2 = . (5.50)
σ2
The admittance of the entire structure at radian frequency ω is
τ1 + τ2 − τ + τ τ1 τ2 ω 2 d
ε′e = . (5.54)
(R1 + R2 ) [1 + (ωτ )2 ] A
Consider now the case when R1 goes to infinity (i.e., layer 1 in Figure 5-20
is an insulator). For this case, Equation (5.54) becomes
2
1 + 1 + dd12 εε12 ωε2
σ2
d
′
εe = 2 2 ε1 . (5.55)
d1
1 + 1 + dd12 εε12 ωε2
σ2
It is clear from Equations (5.54) and (5.55) that the effective complex
permittivity has a frequency-dependent component. Consider how this
278 MICROWAVE AND RF DESIGN: A SYSTEMS APPROACH
Consider the structure in Figure 5-19. Determine the guide wavelength, λg , and the
wavelength in the insulator, λ1 , at a frequency of 1 GHz. SiO2 and Si are the dielectrics,
with permittivities ε1 = 4ε0 and ε2 = 13ε0 (the conductivities are zero). The depths d2 and
d1 of the two dielectrics are d2 = 250 µm and d1 = 0.1 µm.
Solution:
3×108
λ1 = √ = 0.15 m = 15 cm,
109 4
ε1 ε2 (d1 + d2 ) 3×108
ǫe = = 12.99ε0 λg = √ = 0.0832 m = 8.32 cm (5.58)
ε 1 d2 + ε 2 d1 9
10 12.99
ε 1,µ 0 d1
d ε2 ,σ 2,µ 0
d2
W
(a)
L L1 L2 R2 L1 R (f)
C1
C1
C1
C2 G2
G2
∆x ∆x ∆x
(b) (c) (d)
Figure 5-21 Modes on an MOS transmission line: (a) equivalent structure of the MOS line of Figure 5-18;
(b) quasi-TEM mode; (c) skin effect mode; and (d) slow-wave mode.
W
C2 = ε2 (5.61)
d2
W
G2 = σ2 . (5.62)
d2
In SI units these have the units: H/m for L, F/m for C1 , F/m for C2 , and
S/m for G2 .
Skin-Effect Mode
The second possible mode is the skin-effect mode, for which the sectional
equivalent circuit model of Figure√5-21(c) is applicable. Here, σ2 ≪ ωε2 is
such that the skin depth δ = 1/ πf µ0 σ2 in the semiconductor is much
smaller than d2 and
′ ′ ′ µ0 δ
εe = εe,0 , µe = d1 + ,
d 2
Thus
d1 W
L1 = µ0 , C1 = ε1 (5.63)
W d1
1 δ 1 δ
L2 = µ0 , R2 = 2πf µ0 . (5.64)
W 2 W 2
These have the SI units: H/m for L1 and L2 , F/m for C1 , and Ω/m for R2 .
280 MICROWAVE AND RF DESIGN: A SYSTEMS APPROACH
Slow-Wave Mode
The third possible mode of propagation is the slow-wave mode [76, 77], for
which the sectional equivalent circuit model of Figure 5-21(d) is applicable.
This mode occurs when f is not so large and the resistivity is moderate so
that the skin depth, δ, is larger than (or on the order of) d2 . Thus ε′e = ε′e,0 ,
but µ′e = µ0 . Therefore
r
1 1 1 d1
vp = p = √ √ (5.65)
′ ′
εe µe µ ε
0 0 ε 1 d
p
(with SI units of m/s) and λg = λ1 d1 /d, where λ1 is the wavelength in the
insulator.
5.9 Summary
In this chapter, extraordinary transmission line effects were considered.
Multimoding can occur in many forms, but whenever crosssectional
dimensions are large enough compared to a wavelength multimoding
occurs. This sets the upper bound on the frequency of operation of most
transmission line structures. There are also significant frequency-dependent
effects with all transmission lines and arise from a number of sources.
However, most of these effects in transmission lines of two or more
conductors can be understood as resulting from skin effect and charge
bunching. Different transmission line structures have varying degrees of
frequency-dependent properties.
14. Using Figure 5-9 on Page 257, determine the 635 µm thick and has a relative permittivity of
complex characteristic impedance and com- 4.1.
plex effective permittivity of a microstrip line (a) At what frequency will the first trans-
at 12 GHz. The line is fabricated on alumina verse resonance occur?
with εr (DC) = 9.9, w = 70 µm, h = 500 µm.
(b) At what frequency will the first higher-
15. A magnetic wall and an electric wall are 2 cm order microstrip mode occur?
apart and are separeted by a lossless material (c) At what frequency will the slab mode oc-
having an effective permittivity of 10 and an cur?
effective permeability of 23. What is the cut-
(d) Identify the useful operating frequency
off frequency of the lowest-order mode in this
range of the microstrip.
system.
19. The electrical design space for transmission
16. The strip of a microstrip has a width of 600 µm lines in microstrip designs is determined by
and is fabricated on a lossless substrate that is the design project leader to be 20 to 100 Ω. This
1 mm thick and has a relative permittivity of is based on experience with the types of loads
10. and sources that need to be matched. The pre-
(a) Draw the magnetic waveguide model of ferred substrate has a thickness of 500 µm
the microstrip line. Put dimensions on and a relative permittivity of 8. What is the
your drawing. maximum operating frequency range of de-
(b) Sketch the electric field distribution of the signs supported by this technology choice.
first transverse resonance mode and cal- Ignore frequency dispersion effects (i.e., fre-
culate the frequency at which the trans- quency dependence of effective permittivity
verse resonance mode occurs. and losses). [Hint: First determine the dimen-
sions of the strip that will provide the required
(c) Sketch the electric field distribution of the
impedance range and then determine the fre-
first higher-order microstrip mode and
quency at which lowest-order multimoding
calculate the frequency at which it occurs.
will occur.]
(d) Sketch the electric field distribution of the
slab mode and calculate the frequency at 20. Consider the design of transmission lines in
which it occurs. microstrip technology using a lossless sub-
strate with relative permittivity of 10 and
17. A microstrip line has a width of 352 µm and is thickness of 400 µm. You will want to use the
constructed on a substrate that is 500 µm thick formulas in Section 4.10.2 on Page 223.
with a relative dielectric constant of 5.6.
(a) What is the maximum characteristic
(a) Determine the frequency at which trans- impedance that can be achieved for a
verse resonance would first occur. transmission line fabricated in this tech-
(b) When the dielectric is slightly less than nology?
one quarter wavelength in thickness the (b) Plot the characteristic impedance versus
dielectric slab mode can be supported. strip width.
Some of the fields will appear in the air (c) From manufacturing tolerance consider-
region as well as in the dielectric, extend- ations, the minimum strip width that can
ing the effective thickness of the dielec- be manufactured is 20 µm. What is the
tric. Ignoring the fields in the air (so that maximum characteristic impedance that
we are considering a quarter-wavelength can be achieved in practice?
criterion), at what frequency will the di-
(d) If the operating frequency range is 1 to
electric slab mode first occur?
10 GHz, determine the maximum width
18. The strip of a microstrip has a width of 600 µm of the strip from higher-order mode con-
and is fabricated on a lossless substrate that is siderations. You must consider the trans-
284 MICROWAVE AND RF DESIGN: A SYSTEMS APPROACH
verse resonance mode as well as higher- (b) At what frequency does the first higher-
order microstrip modes. order microstrip mode first propagate?
(e) Identify the electrical design space (i.e., (c) At what frequency does the substrate (or
the achievable characteristic impedance slab) mode first occur?
range).
22. The strip of a microstrip has a width of 250 µm
(f) Identify the physical design space (i.e.,
and is fabricated on a lossless substrate that is
the range of acceptable strip widths).
300 µm thick and has a relative permittivity of
(g) If the electrical design space requires 15.
that transmission line impedances be
achieved within ±2 Ω. What tolerance (a) At what frequency does the transverse
must be achieved in the manufacturing resonance first occur?
process if the substrate thickness can be (b) At what frequency does the first higher-
achieved exactly? [Hint: First identify the order microstrip mode first propagate?
critical physical process corner and thus (c) At what frequency does the substrate (or
the critical strip width that is most sus- slab) mode first occur?
ceptible to width variations. Then deter-
mine the tolerance on the strip width 23. A microstrip line has a strip width of 100 µm
to achieve the allowable characteristic is fabricated on a lossless substrate that is
impedance variation. That is, characteris- 150 µm thick and has a relative permittivity
tic impedance is a function of strip width of 9.
and height. If the substrate is perfect (no (a) Draw the microstrip waveguide model
height variation), then how much can the and indicate and calculate the dimen-
strip width vary to keep the impedance sions of the model.
within ±2 Ω of the desired value? You can (b) Based only on the microstrip waveguide
solve this graphically using a plot of Z0 model, determine the frequency at which
versus width or you can iteratively arrive the first transverse resonance occurs?
at the answer by recalculating Z0 .]
(c) Based only on the microstrip waveguide
(h) If the electrical design space requires
model, determine the frequency at which
that transmission line impedances be
the first higher-order microstrip mode oc-
achieved within ±2 Ω. What tolerance
curs?
must be achieved in the manufacturing
process if the substrate thickness toler- (d) At what frequency will the slab mode
ance is ±2 µm? (Assume that the per- occur? For this you cannot use the mi-
fectly symmetrical stripline property will crostrip waveguide model.
be achieved accurately.) If the substrate 24. A microstrip line has a strip width of 100 µm
is not perfect (the height variation is and is fabricated on a lossless substrate that is
±2 µm), then how much can the strip 150 µm thick and has a relative permittivity of
width vary to keep the impedance within 9.
±2 Ω of the desired value? This problem
is directly applicable to real-world pro- (a) Define the properties of a magnetic wall.
cess/design trade-offs. (b) Identify two situations where a magnetic
wall can be used in the analysis of a
21. The strip of a microstrip has a width of 500 µm
microstrip line; that is, give two loca-
and is fabricated on a lossless substrate that is
tions where a magnetic wall approxima-
635 µm thick and has a relative permittivity
tion can be used.
of 12. [Parallels Examples 5.1, 5.2, and 5.3 on
Pages 270, 271 and 273. ] (c) Draw the microstrip waveguide model
and indicate and calculate the dimen-
(a) At what frequency does the transverse
sions of the model.
resonance first occur?
EXTRAORDINARY TRANSMISSION LINE EFFECTS 285
25. Consider the design of transmission lines in must be achieved in the manufacturing
microstrip technology using a lossless sub- process if the substrate thickness can be
strate with relative permittivity of 20 and achieved exactly? [Hint: First identify the
thickness of 200 µm. critical physical process corner and thus
the critical strip width that is most sus-
(a) Using qualitative arguments, show that
ceptible to width variations. Then deter-
the maximum characteristic impedance
mine the tolerance on the strip width
that can be achieved for a transmission
to achieve the allowable characteristic
line fabricated in this technology is 116
impedance variation.]
Ω. The maximum is not actually 116 Ω,
but a simple argument will bring you to (h) If the electrical design space requires
this conclusion. Hint: This will occur at that transmission line impedances be
the minimum width possible. achieved within ±2 Ω. What tolerance
must be achieved in the manufacturing
(b) Plot the characteristic impedance versus
process if the substrate thickness toler-
substrate width.
ance is ±2 µm. (Assume that the per-
(c) From manufacturing tolerance consider- fectly symmetrical stripline property will
ations, the minimum strip width that can be achieved accurately.)
be manufactured is 20 µm. What is the
26. Consider the structure in Figure 5-19. Deter-
maximum characteristic impedance that
can be achieved in practice? mine the guide wavelength, λg , and the wave-
length in the top insulator, λ1 , at a frequency
(d) If the operating frequency range is 2 to of 20 GHz. The dielectric permittivities are
18 GHz, determine the maximum width ε1 = 3.9ε0 and ε2 = 13ε0 . The depths of the
of the strip from higher-order mode con- two dielectrics are d2 = 100 µm and d1 =
siderations. You must consider the trans- 1.0 µm. [Parallels Examples 5.4, on Page 278.]
verse resonance mode, the higher-order
stripline mode, and the slab mode. 27. Consider a metal-oxide-semiconductor trans-
mission medium as examined in Section 5.8.
(e) Identify the electrical design space (i.e.,
The structure in the form of the Maxwell-
the achievable characteristic impedance
Wagner capacitor is shown in Figure 5-20(a)
range).
with d1 = 100 µm, d2 = 500 µm, and rel-
(f) Identify the physical design space (i.e., ative permittivities εr1 = 3.9 and εr2 = 13.
the range of acceptable strip widths). Ignore the finite conductivity. What is the ca-
(g) If the electrical design space requires pacitance model of this structure (see Figure
that transmission line impedances be 5-20(b)) and what are the values of the capaci-
achieved within ±2 Ω. What tolerance tance?
286 MICROWAVE AND RF DESIGN: A SYSTEMS APPROACH