1
Issue One 05
4 CHANGING PERSPECTIVE
Mark Weldon
Chief Executive Officer, NZX
7 PERSPECTIVE
7 WANTED
Dr. Alan Bollard
Governor, Reserve Bank of New Zealand
8 INNOVATION
Brian Ward
Chief Executive Officer, NZBio
11 A LUST FOR
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
Geoff Ross
Chief Executive Officer, 42 Below
33
CHANGING
PERSPECTIVE
MARK WELDON
C H I E F EXECUTIVE OFFICER, NZX
The New Zealand business mindset has traditionally been that ownership is immaterial
and it makes no difference whether New Zealand ends up as an economy fuelled by
ownership, or by income. There may have been a blip in time when ownership versus
income could be viewed as a distinction without a difference, but that time is gone.
It is a truism that, for there to be any material increase Basic health – savings and deeper capital markets
in our standard of living, New Zealand companies must Right now the body of New Zealand, the economy, is pretty
develop lasting competitive advantage in global markets healthy, as can be seen in most of the numbers. To keep it
and, crucially, the benefits of that competitive advantage healthy over the medium term, however, a change of diet will
must accrue here. be required. At the bottom of the economic food pyramid,
To determine what needs to be done to make the New the base that maintains the heart pumping, is savings.
Zealand economy great in 2010 we therefore need to focus Improved savings outcomes will pump blood into both the
on what will give New Zealand businesses the best possible household balance sheets and company fortunes.
chance to develop advantages that will win globally. It is
The main structural change needed, which is currently
my belief that in 2010 sustainable competitive advantage,
being debated and addressed at the policy level, is to
and hence real economic returns, will for countries
create individual long-term savings accounts for all New
outside China/India/Brazil be driven almost entirely by
Zealanders, with contributions primarily coming out of
intangible assets like brand, patents and design, whether
workplace earnings. As a recent quote in The Economist
in children’s clothing, vodka or tourism. To me, creating
stated, “[in] New Zealand, personal savings rates are
these intangible assets, and ensuring that they are owned
negative as people borrow to consume more than they
here, should be the single goal of our private and public
earn”.
economic planning over the next decade.
Workplace superannuation needs to be introduced and be
The economy is a complex system like the human body.
made to work. For success, three things are needed:
This article focuses on what I believe will get the economic
body of New Zealand competing and winning on a global • a minimum level of compulsion,
level. A sick or unhealthy body can not run and leap. A • incentives available for those who choose to save
healthy and fit body can do all sorts of amazing things. beyond the compulsory amount, and
4
• a very simple framework that people can use easily and It is my bet that small countries with homogenous
be confident in. workforces will fall rapidly down the OECD ladder over
Based on numerous conversations, a plan that involved a the next 20 years compared to countries that effectively
mix of a targeted tax cut of about 1-1.5 cents in the dollar leverage diversity. An experiment conducted by a group
with an extra 1.5-3 cents directed from each person’s pre- in New York is instructive. Groups of business people
tax earnings into individual savings accounts, alongside a were clustered together to develop recommendations
range of incentives for workers to contribute further pre- on series of hardcore business issues. Similarly, groups
tax earnings on a matched basis by employers, would be of non-business people from wide ranging backgrounds
almost universally well received. While it would cost the (think Navy Seal plus fine arts major) were put together.
Government purse, it will result in a much healthier nation This latter group argued more, was much less affirming
at both the individual and company level as we position of how brilliant each other was, but got to much more
ourselves for our future. creative and insightful
If these actions are taken, recommendations.
households will be able Groupthink is the opposite
to provide for retirement, of creativity.
education and the passages Ultimately immigration
of life where individuals should both fill needs and
have no earning power and create opportunities. For
must use their individual example, immigration
balance sheets to get them from China will grow our
through. Productive business knowledge of that market
investment will also increase and, through informal
and, importantly, the suite networks, result in
of intangible assets that substantial trade. Similarly
will deliver us competitive with Brazil, which is
advantage will also increase
another of the world’s major
significantly. We have seen
economies that is hard to
the growth of a local savings
penetrate without local
pool fuel all of these positive
knowledge. New Zealand,
effects in Australia and in a
with its time zone position
myriad of other counties. It
between Asia and America,
will happen here.
is ideally situated to use
Strength and fitness significant immigration as
– growing the size and a strategic tool to deliver
diversity of the workforce a larger and more diverse
labour pool that in turn
With a healthy heart, the economy can start to grow some
delivers much stronger trade and innovation outcomes.
muscle. For me growing muscles is about getting our
labour pool right. There is no question that lack of labour Apart from trade and innovation outcomes, scale has its
availability and the right skill base is the biggest risk to our own virtues for our companies and their workers. New
medium term economic fitness. Zealand companies exhaust their local market quicker
New Zealand needs both greater mass and diversity in our than their competitors and thus can be forced to sell their
workforce to create the right environment for increased source of competitive advantage (their intangible assets)
productivity and core growth. Independent of any “political much too cheaply. A larger population, even a population
correctness” arguments there are sound economic reasons of 5 million (about the same size as greater Sydney),
to believe that, in a world where intangible assets and would create a much stronger base for our businesses
the ideas that create them are key, diversity is critical to and the conditions so that we could keep the benefits of
economic outcomes. success here.
5
Performance – dominating global slivers and ownership If we continue to sell companies offshore, those learnings
and beliefs will never occur and we will end up as a call
Dominating global slivers
centre that can’t compete with the 2.5 billion people in
With a strong heart and good overall strength, the New India/China/Brazil. Unfortunately, as a recent Grant
Zealand economy will be able to compete and win. For New Thornton Global Business survey shows , New Zealand 1
Zealand, winning means that we develop deep expertise business owners have the highest expectation of a change
and become distinctive in a series of global slivers, niches in ownership over the next 10 years of any country globally.
and products where we can own and set pricing for a good Learning how to succeed cannot be found in a book and,
part of the category. Current New Zealand examples while it is intangible, it is very real. A good analogy from
would include Fisher & Paykel Healthcare, with its sport is the different approach of the Australian cricket
dominant global market share in high end medical devices team (winning) versus the New Zealand cricket team
for specialist situations, and luxury outdoor/beauty tourism (playing). The core skill difference is not technical ability,
(e.g. Blanket Bay, Huka Lodge). but the knowledge of how to win.
More broadly, these slivers could be product and In business the analogy is obvious. New Zealand companies
expertise, and should be consistent with an evolved New continually innovate and create amazing products. But,
Zealand brand which is based unfortunately, that is where we
on a much broader notion of mostly leave it. Unless we own
national distinctiveness than “The economy is a the wins, and build on those, there
just rugby and the outdoors. won’t be much real change. To do
This “NZ 2010” brand should complex system like the that we need to start a virtuous
have elements of Sir Edmund circle based on ownership.
Hillary (independent), 42 Below/
Karen Walker (cool and edgy),
human body. A sick or Ultimately I want to see New
Zealand as a country with a
Weta/Peter Jackson (creative)
and our ex-pats and business
unhealthy body can not distinctive reach right across
the globe, with the benefits of
stories like Fletcher Building,
Michael Hill and Pumpkin Patch run and leap. A healthy ownership coming back to New
(international and successful). Zealand, and each and every
Ownership
Apart from ownership of intangible assets generating the
real wealth, ownership of these assets in itself creates a
Mark is the Chief Executive of NZX, and works closely
priceless intangible asset: the knowledge, of how to win.
with management to implement the Board’s strategies.
This knowledge, along with institutionalisation of success Mark is also a Director of Smartshares Limited and
and building a country where business success is in our Chairman of Link Market Services Limited.
DNA, creates a virtuous circle of knowing how to win and
achieving it. 1
Grant Thornton Global Business Survey, released April 2005
6
PERSPECTIVE
WANTED
RESILIENT BROAD BASED GROWTH
1. What would they like to see the economy of New Zealand What are the top three things that will need to change for
like in 2010? the New Zealand economy to be where you would like it to
be in 2010?
2. What in their opinion, would need to change, for this to
become a reality? I could get all technical about this, but in simple terms my
3. How would these changes impact the economy? top picks are:
• Increase labour productivity from roughly 1.5% p.a. to
Those who chose to give their views have been asked to be roughly 2% to keep growth strong.
as open and honest about them in the interests of providing • Get a good Doha WTO trade round, or failing that, get
the market some insight into what could be. Their views are
a NZ-US Free Trade Agreement.
published unedited.
• Increase our country’s overall savings rate in the
Contributions are from: medium-term.
• Dr. Alan Bollard, Governor, Reserve Bank of New Zealand
• Brian Ward, Chief Executive Officer, NZBio What would need to happen in order to facilitate these
changes?
• Mark Franklin, Chief Executive Officer, Vector
• Deepen our capital markets to work for New Zealand
• Geoff Ross, Chief Executive Officer, 42 Below
firms.
• Bill Day, Chief Executive Officer, Seaworks
• Don’t let our labour markets get increasingly inflexible.
• Ian Narev, Managing Partner, McKinsey & Company
• Private sector managers need to make quality decisions.
• Brian Gaynor, Business Columnist, NZ Herald
• Households need to invest in financial instruments
• Lance Jenkins, Managing Director & Chief Executive
other than housing.
Officer, Goldman Sachs JB Were
• Peter Townsend, Chief Executive, Canterbury Employers’ How would these changes impact the economy?
Chamber of Commerce They will help us get resilient broad-based growth, at
• Dr Roderick Deane, Chairman, Telecom New Zealand least equivalent to Australian levels, plus a good level of
• Chris Moller, Chief Executive Officer, New Zealand Rugby economic stability. Many of the other things that we want
Union for New Zealand will follow from this.
• Scott St John, Chief Executive Officer, First NZ Capital
In addition, we asked a selection of New Zealanders their Dr. Alan Bollard is currently Governor of RBNZ. His
views on the same topic. These range from an 18 year old previous positions include Secretary to the Treasury,
graduate to a retired Police Officer. Chairman of the NZ Commerce Commission and
Director of the NZ Institute of Economic Research. Dr.
NZX would like to thank all those that took the time to Bollard has also written a number of books on the New
document their perspectives. We appreciate your candour Zealand economy and worked as an economist in the
UK and South Pacific.
and are challenged by your views.
The views represented in this article are the express views of the author, and do not
necessarily reflect the views of NZX.
7
INNOVATION
A POWERFUL ECONOMIC DRIVER
BRIAN WARD
New Zealand will become recognised as an originator of Currently, the most severe constraint to exploiting our
businesses, products and services that are elegant, smart, and existing innovations is a lack of funds to move projects from
distinctive. Our companies will rely on innovation in their discovery to the ‘investor ready’ stage. The Government
products and services, business processes and models, and needs to apply serious public financial commitment to this
position themselves carefully within global value chains to stage, as its international counterparts have done.
maximise returns. As a consequence, intellectual property
The private sector also has a role to play. Funding for
will become more and more important. The recent growth
early-stage companies in New Zealand is presently very
of the New Zealand economy has come more from increased
limited. A relatively low portfolio allocation to high risk
labour utilisation than from increased productivity. Future
asset classes limits funding for new ventures, and in a
growth must come more from increased productivity, and
small market individual company setbacks can have
innovation will help to make this happen.
an inordinate influence on market sentiment. Success
The rise of the high performance exporter will breed success, but it is also a numbers game. In the
meantime, we need to back ourselves and feed more
Export-based companies will outperform other business
private capital into the pipeline.
categories; they will have a strong focus on growth and
increasingly be publicly listed. Recent New Zealand The rise of the high performance exporter depends on New
economic growth has been driven more by domestic demand Zealand moving beyond just recognising the importance
than by overseas demand (i.e. exports). Future growth needs of building exports, to targeting niche opportunities that
to be driven more by satisfying overseas demand. are high growth and high margin, where we can stake
a claim as world leaders. Niche businesses within the
Success will come from reaching outside of New Zealand
life sciences stand out in this regard. Fundamental to
early, with a determination to partner wisely and often.
this development is deeper insight by Government and
New Zealanders are famously self-reliant, but we can
businesses into opportunities of genuine competitive
do better by working with international partners, whilst
advantage where there are accessible channels to market.
maintaining our enterprising spirit.
The Government’s “Growth and Innovation Framework”
Innovation is the most powerful economic driver has begun to address this question.
There is no shortage of good ideas. New Zealanders, and Further progress is dependent on an entrepreneurial
particularly those involved in the biological sciences, are partnership between the public and private sectors and
internationally recognised as originators of world class an acceptance on both sides that the way forward is
basic and applied research. We could do even better if uncharted territory with uncertainties and risks, but if
public R&D investment rose from just below 1% of GDP we are intent on lifting our economic performance then
to OECD norms of between 2% to 5% of GDP. we must act with conviction. Government leadership is
8
“New Zealand will become recognised as an
originator of businesses, products and services
that are elegant, smart, and distinctive.”
necessary to create an operating environment that favours its clusters, networks, partnerships and collaborations, but
high performance exporters. These companies need to government departments like the Ministry of Economic
have the opportunity to be on an equal footing with their Development and New Zealand Trade and Enterprise
international competitors and realise their full potential. are pivotal, bringing to bear their resources, skills and
If this means favouring high performance exporters over business-strengthening capabilities.
other businesses, so be it.
Economic Impact
The taxation system also needs adjustment to facilitate The economic benefits from these changes will be
the development of high growth companies. Their future significant. The private sector wins through greater
value as taxpayers will more than compensate for early export revenues, higher growth, higher margins, higher
concessions. Regulatory and compliance requirements value added products and services, enhanced competitive
must be streamlined because this is an overhead that advantage, greater scale and better paid jobs.
diverts resources from building the business. Within the
private sector, we need to improve our ability to aggregate The Government wins through increased taxation revenue
resources, build on individual and collective strengths, which means there is greater capacity to improve publicly
and create critical mass. funded services New Zealanders value, like better
healthcare, education, social services, and environmental
Leveraging international partners management. In addition, the economy will also have a
In the global marketplace there are very few areas where broader base from which to grow in the future.
New Zealand can hope to dominate the entire supply
chain, particularly given our distance from major markets.
To grow companies quickly and capture the value of new
technologies, New Zealand companies will need to be
Brian Ward is currently the CEO of NZBio, New
excellent at entering markets quickly and concurrently. Zealand’s biotechnology industry organisation. Over
Our companies need to develop the networks, skills and the last 20 years he has worked in a wide range of roles
experience to be among the world’s best at executing in the area of life sciences, both in New Zealand and
internationally.
sophisticated partnering arrangements to leverage
distribution channels, profile, insight and new business The views represented in this article are the express views of the author, and do not
options. Much of this responsibility falls to industry, with necessarily reflect the views of NZX.
9
THINK LOCAL, ACT GLOBAL
MARK FRANKLIN
As a nation we need to ensure there is real openness for linked to business efficiency if they are to contribute to
investment. At present, there is no framework in place the country’s future success.
to give international investors long-term confidence
These changes will enable New Zealand to improve our
and certainty. We talk about the country being open for
place in the world and to enjoy a better standard of life.
investment, but too often contradict that by our reaction It is going to be difficult to move up from being in the
to proposed investments. bottom half of the OECD’s wealth index. But we can
We also need to continue to have a flexible labour market do this or, at least, have it as an objective. Hope is not a
structure, giving people greater freedom in the way good strategy.
they balance their work and life By making these changes, we
but without undermining the
efficiency of operations.
“New Zealand has to decide should be able to better compete
in the world, and we will become
In my opinion New Zealand whether we move proactively more innovative as a country. At the
is becoming over-regulated as or reactively, whether we moment individuals
we are full of innovative
but, because of our
increasingly there is a perception
that law and policy will solve lead the way and control our regulatory environment and lack
everything. This needs to change of flexibility in the labour market,
and the issues of regulation versus own destiny, or whether we innovation is not encouraged.
We also need to become more
competition need to be better are simply pulled along.” attractive to overseas skilled
understood.
labour given we are now operating
To a certain extent, these changes will occur by osmosis in a highly competitive world labour market.
as the world moves on. But New Zealand has to decide
whether we move proactively or reactively, whether we The country would also benefit from opening up
lead the way and control our own destiny or whether we investment opportunities and being an active player in the
simply are pulled along. global economy, with far greater control over our future and
economic wellbeing than if we try to resist and regulate
New Zealanders are generally aspirational, but we need to our way out of the global realities.
back up those aspirations with effective action. We need
to start acting as part of the global economy and have a
more thoughtful view about the balance of nationalism Mark Franklin was appointed CEO of Vector in 2003. He
has a Bachelor of Electrical Engineering from Sydney
versus harmonisation with Australia. We need to recognise
University and has extensive experience in the energy
the long term benefits of opening up opportunities to and technology sectors in New Zealand, Australia
international investors. and Japan. His previous leadership roles include
Chief Executive of Orion Energy in the Hunter Valley
There also needs to be a considerable change in attitude (Australia) and Asia Pacific General Manager of IBM
regarding labour reform and regulatory activity. Regulatory GSA for utilities.
10
A LUST FOR
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
GEOFF ROSS
11
CREATING THE ENVIRONMENT
FOR WEALTH CREATION
BILL DAY
CHIEF EXECUTIVE, SEAWORKS LTD
In 2010, I want to see a productive and growing economy introduction of constraints on the growth in government.
that creates opportunities and prosperity for all New This could occur through a regulatory constitution and tax/
Zealanders. Economic growth is not an end in itself, but spending limitations in the Fiscal Responsibility Act.
it is the key to lifting living standards. It is only through
Finally, we need to develop our human capital. We cannot
economic growth that our country can afford higher wages,
compete with other countries on
good schools, first-class health care,
the basis of our size or natural
better environmental protection,
as well as opportunities for future “The private sector must resources. But New Zealand can
compete with our minds and our
generations.
2010 is not far away. To build the
be the main engine of creativity. Our education system
has served us adequately in the
foundations for a stronger economy,
we need to think well beyond 2010.
economic growth, and past, but we need to aspire for
much more. We need higher
As the experience of the 1980s
and 1990s has shown, it can take
the Government must expectations, less regulation of
education providers, changes to
years before the beneficial effects
of policy reforms are felt in the
play a supportive role.” the way teachers are paid and
rewarded, and more choice and
economy. Equally, it takes time for competition across all levels.
the adverse effects of poor policy
decisions to filter through. New Zealand is small and isolated. A good policy
framework can provide us with an important source of
First, we need to put in place a policy environment competitive advantage over other nations. We also need
that encourages innovation, entrepreneurship and a change in attitudes, so that we become a nation that
wealth creation. The recipe for this is well known: clear celebrates business success.
property rights, a sound judiciary, good general laws,
low taxes, a flexible labour market and a generally light
level of regulation. The private sector must be the main
engine of economic growth, and the Government must
play a supportive role. Unfortunately, we have seen too Bill Day is the owner and Managing Director of
many policy decisions take us backward in recent years Seaworks Ltd, a specialised maritime company with a
– employment law, business regulation, taxation, welfare head office in Wellington and a branch in Dubai. Bill
studied law at university along with a BA and MBA. He
policies, to name just a few.
is also Vice Chairman of the New Zealand Business
Second, we need strong and effective legal and political Roundtable.
12
A CULTURE OF SUCCESS
IAN NAREV
13
BUILDING BETTER BUSINESSES
BRIAN GAYNOR
BUSINESS COLUMNIST, NEW ZEALAND HERALD
The main drivers of wealth and economic growth in a free The only really successful offshore acquisition by a New
enterprise society are business people and their companies. Zealand company, prior to Fletcher Building’s recent
With this in mind a number of developments are required moves in Australia, was Lion Nathan’s purchase of
if New Zealand is to improve its economic performance National Brewing. The Australian brewer was owned by
over the next five years. These include; the troubled Bond Corporation and Lion Nathan was able
to acquire it at a large discount to underlying value.
• Our top corporate leaders need to create great
companies instead of selling out and retiring to their New Zealand companies - Michael Hill International
yachts, golf courses or overseas is a good example - have been more
retreats at a relatively early age. “Our top corporate successful when they have adopted an
• Directors and management should organic growth strategy.
adopt a more measured and long-
leaders need to create
Shareholders also need to take a more
term approach to growth. The great companies instead proactive stance towards management
widely adopted big bang strategy
has not been successful, particularly
of selling out and retiring issues. It would be far more rewarding in
the longer term if shareholders changed
offshore. to their yachts, golf the management of a poorly performing
• Shareholders should play an active courses overseas retreats company instead of selling out to the
role in ensuring that companies first foreign buyer.
achieve their full potential. They at a relatively early age.”
should also have a longer-term The development of successful,
perspective and reject opportunistic bids from overseas internationally orientated companies, would be a huge
bidders. boost to the New Zealand economy because they would
One of the biggest problems with the New Zealand economy act as an inspiration and role model to the remainder of the
is that we are not creating enough great companies. We don’t business community.
have businessmen with the ambition of Rupert Murdoch of These successful commercial enterprises are the key
News Corporation or Frank Lowy of Westfield. to the future success of the New Zealand economy
Many of our successful business leaders are content as in a free enterprise environment it is private sector
to retire while still in their business prime. This is the companies, not the Government, which creates wealth
equivalent of a successful sports coach rejecting a national and economic growth.
position after achieving provincial success. Warren Buffett
and Rupert Murdoch, who are both 74, are still creating
wealth yet most of our successful entrepreneurs have
much more modest goals. In addition to being a business columnist for the New
Zealand Herald, Brian is Executive Director of Milford
Our directors and management also need to take a more Asset Management and Director of The New Zealand
realistic approach to growth, particularly overseas. Too many Investment Trust plc. Brian studied for B.Comm (Econ)
companies have adopted the big bank approach, namely at the National University of Ireland.
14
SAVINGS,
INVESTMENT AND OWNERSHIP
LANCE JENKINS
When NZX first asked me to put together some brief I am excited to say I returned to New Zealand with my wife
comments on a perspective for New Zealand, I was initially and two children in January of this year) I saw first hand
reticent. As someone who has been living in New York City the benefits of incentivised retirement plans, investment
for the past nine years I wasn’t sure I could be so bold as to plans and savings plans that are very much a part of the
put across a point of view. (I have been back in New Zealand American psyche. Savings, Investment and Ownership
for four months.) However on reflection, a fresh set of eyes are concepts that are embraced in the USA and it is no
and new perspectives as to how we approach business or accident that the US is also one of the richest nations in
the way we do things, can be genuinely helpful. the world. It is part of their cultural thread and US business
and Government understand that.
As a preface to my comments I believe New Zealand is a
one of the greatest places in the world. I am excited to be While the Government and opposition are currently
back, but like any business or country, there are always talking about an “ownership society” the concept of a
things we can do better to improve our lot as a society. savings programme for New Zealanders seems to me to be
a key requirement for future growth. David Skilling and
After careful consideration, I felt it was worthwhile to the NZ Institute have done some very interesting work
focus on those issues that: around this issue, and while not wanting to steal their
• I had either observed overseas or thunder, their belief that New Zealanders as a whole need
• I felt I had some insight into (from my time spent in to embrace ownership and savings as concepts to be taken
New York). from the cradle to the grave are ideals we should all be
Three key issues emerged, when thinking about focussed on.
opportunities for New Zealand: While we need a safety net for the less fortunate within
• The challenge of creating a culture of savings and our society, most of us function best when we feel we
investment have an ownership stake in society. Ownership does not
• Creating a culture of self reliance, and necessarily mean home ownership (of course it can) but
the idea that we have some “skin in the game” via savings
• Celebrating our successes, our leadership and our
entrepreneurs. or investment is a notion that motivates the majority of us
to do better and to stretch ourselves. In doing so, we not
There has been a good deal of discussion around these
only create benefit for ourselves and our families, we also
issues, but the need for an investment and savings culture
create a better New Zealand. After years of solid growth
within New Zealand stands out as arguably one of the in New Zealand, we need to use this current period to
greatest requirements for growth for our country. develop a culture of savings, investment and ownership. If
As someone who has spent the last nine years living in the not now, we will have lost an opportunity that is unlikely
USA, (despite press reports of a mass exodus out of NZ, to repeat itself for many years.
15
By way of example, one of the great wonders I was look to Government for relief in terms of benefits or other
able to witness while living in the US was the power of government handouts, instead of first looking at the source
retirement savings and the culture of investment that not of the problem. Throwing money at an issue without fully
only increased the wealth of that country (as those savings understanding what is causing the problem is never the
and investments were able to be used productively by long term solution and it is up to us as individuals (not
businesses), but also I saw first hand the wealth created by Government) to find our own solutions. As I have stated
retirees and the benefits they were able to enjoy. earlier, we need to have a safety net for those who are less
fortunate, however a safety net is what it should remain,
My wife, Melissa, grew up in Cape Cod, Massachusetts,
it should never become a crutch. Government has an
USA, and comes from a very modest background (as do
important role to play in encouraging behaviour that adds
I). Her father was an electrical lines repairman who spent
to New Zealand and our economy, and business should
most of his life working for the local electric utility, Cape
work closely with Government to achieve that outcome.
Cod Electric, retiring two years ago as a lines foreman for
It is an important leadership role for Government to create
that company. What was remarkable to me was seeing
outcomes that reward behaviours, and that benefit – not
the wealth that her father had accumulated throughout detract from – the economy. With an unemployment rate
his working life. This was a guy who probably earned no of 3.5%, we have a fantastic window to work on this ideal.
more than $50,000 in his best year, but who at the age of 60,
through investing and saving throughout his working life Finally I would add while the tall poppy syndrome is
now owned his home outright, and had a portfolio of stocks slowly being removed from our thinking, we need to do
and bonds worth approx $1 million. In addition he had sent everything we can do to celebrate our successes, learn
his child to a private university in Rhode Island, USA (if from our mistakes, and encourage our leaders in business,
we think our university fees are bad in New Zealand, they society, and Government to make the tough decisions. As
are nothing compared to private universities in America!). I have discovered in my previous role of managing our
Clearly saving and investing throughout one’s life does allow Goldman Sachs JBWere New York office and now working
even the average earner to create wealth for themselves, with the leadership team in New Zealand, it is always the
and allows business to productively borrow those savings in hardest and toughest decisions that need to be answered
order for the country as a whole to grow and expand. in order for business to continue to grow and develop.
By celebrating success and by rewarding leadership we
I use the example because often, when we think about develop a society that can take on the best.
savings and ownership, we assume it is for the wealthy,
We need to be careful not to become too comfortable
and clearly this is not the case. By encouraging young
with our current solid economic state and we should take
participants in our workforce to set aside income now and
this opportunity to plan for the long term. By creating
not consume it, the outcome for the individual and for the
ownership and investment cultures, by creating a culture
country is a large net positive. By creating a culture that
of self reliance and by celebrating success, leadership and
understands the basic benefits of investing and saving
entrepreneurship, we plant the seeds for long term success
throughout our working life is a something our country
for our country. Speaking personally, it is fantastic to be
must do in order for New Zealand to grow productively.
back in a country that appears poised to make the tough
My second issue fits nicely with the creation of a savings decisions to ensure continued growth of our nation and I
and investment culture. It is the issue of creating a culture feel privileged to be part of it.
of self reliance. New Zealanders have long held a belief of
self reliance and entrepreneurship, however while we are Prior to moving into the role of Managing Director
and CEO of Goldman Sachs JBWere (New Zealand) in
certainly doing well in this country, there does appear to
January 2005, Lance Jenkins was President of Goldman
be an underlying belief that the Government should be Sachs JBWere (New York) and has been a partner of
our first port of call for any issues we face. Goldman Sachs JBWere since 1999. Lance received
an MBA from New York University (Stern School of
The reality is the Government should always be the call Business) and has LLB and BCA degrees from Victoria
of last resort and that if we truly believed in a culture of University of Wellington.
16
SUSTAINABILITY AND INTEGRITY
PETER TOWNSEND
CHIEF EXECUTIVE,
CANTERBURY EMPLOYERS’ CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
What are the top three things that will need to change for the New for all employees and that linkages between educational
Zealand economy to be where you would like it to be in 2010? institutions and businesses are improved markedly.
• A significant shift across New Zealand with respect to • We need to start thinking about infrastructure issues
an understanding of the linkage between sustainable, strategically and long-term plans need to be developed
profitable business, community wellbeing and individual with regard to provision of efficient transport. It’s
welfare. Business success and people who are successful time to get real about the future of electricity supply,
in business need to be appreciated and lauded. We need transmission and conservation in this country and
a platform of sound and stable public policy on which to develop a workable long-term plan. With respect
build an environment conducive to business success. to water we need to ensure the tension between
• Ensuring that as many New Zealanders as is possible hydro-electric generation, irrigation, recreational, the
are in useful, productive, well-paid work so that we can enhancement of rivers, industrial use of water and
better harness the human resource capacity, increase town supply are worked through in the best interests
productivity and sustainably grow the economy at of the overall community and we need to look at the
a rate that will markedly increase per capita income. tradability of water rights.
This will enable us to better apply technology to our How would these changes impact the economy?
natural capital to create value.
• Understanding the role that business plays in sustainable
• Do a lot better in respect to our infrastructure and economic growth and what the raising of our per capita
utilities supply. Overcome the issues of increasing income will mean to all of us will reinforce the chance
congestion in our cities, improve the road/rail/shipping for business to succeed. The connection is compelling;
between our cities and ensure that we have adequate it is just not understood.
supplies of reasonably priced electricity and water to
• New Zealand is lagging in terms of its productivity
support our growing economy.
and its per capita income. We must break out of the
What would need to happen in order to facilitate these changes?
position of being a low wage economy if we are to offer
a reasonable standard of living to all of our citizens.
• Every politician at a local and central Government Increasing the contribution to the economy, made by
level must prioritise working on an environment that human capital, is fundamental.
will encourage sustainable, profitable business. We
• No economy can grow on suspect infrastructure. There
need to eliminate the cringe syndrome in New Zealand
is not much point talking about innovation and future
with respect to business and we need to ensure that
growth if the wheels are falling off your infrastructure.
businesses are operating on a platform of sustainability
and integrity so that good business practices are seen to
be the norm in this country. We also need to celebrate
our business successes. Peter Townsend has been the Chief Executive of the
Canterbury Employers’ Chamber of Commerce since
• We need to encourage family-friendly workplaces and a 1996. Peter also holds several corporate directorships
flexible, high quality labour relations environment. We and is heavily committed to a range of community
must reinforce a real commitment to, and belief in, good groups and initiatives in this region that are in harmony
educational outcomes and celebrate the importance of with the objectives of the Employers’ Chamber.
17
SELF DETERMINATION, SELF RELIANCE
D r. R O D E R I C K D E A N E
What are the top three things that will need to change for the • More vibrant, faster growth economy.
New Zealand economy to be where you would like it to be in
• Better solutions to social challenges.
2010?
We also need to solve our massive infrastructure problems
• Deregulation rather than re-regulation.
(e.g. roading and electricity), which essentially need more
• Lower taxes and reduced size of government. market oriented solutions. These currently constrain
• Upgraded social policy (education, health, social welfare). growth and increase risks for the private sector.
What would need to happen in order to facilitate these changes?
• Government stops pretending it has all the solutions Dr. Roderick Deane is currently Chairman of
for all our problems. Telecom, Fletcher Building Limited, ANZ National
Bank Limited, Te Papa Tongarewa (the Museum of
• More self determination, more self reliance. New Zealand) and the New Zealand Seed Fund. Dr.
• More market oriented solutions. Deane is also a Director of the Australian companies,
Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited
How would these changes impact the economy? and Woolworths Limited.
18
BUILDING A NATION ON
19
PRODUCTIVITY = POWER
SCOTT ST JOHN
20
FROM THE HEARTLAND
THE VIEWS OF NEW ZEALANDERS
“In five years time I will have graduated with a commerce degree
“Here is my wish list for New Zealand in 2010;
majoring in finance, and a physics degree. Also I will have a
student loan which I will be looking to start paying off. I will be • The number of current MP’s reduced to at least half the
faced with the decision of going overseas and gaining experience present number
or staying in New Zealand and begin paying off my student loan. • A complete overhaul of WINZ, with only the legitimate
For me to want to stay in New Zealand the New Zealand economy beneficiaries being catered for
must be in a strong position. For me, this would mean businesses • A substantial reduction in overseas debt
must be expanding and looking to employ young graduates. Also • A severe reduction in compliance costs
the Government must ensure there are incentives for young • An ANZAC currency scheme for use by New Zealand and
graduates to stay in New Zealand between now and 2010 to help Australia
strengthen the economy. Good, well paid jobs for young graduates • A realistic, but much cheaper, Defence Force
will only come when New Zealand businesses are doing well and • An independent traffic department with its own budget
expanding. Also, for me, I am interested in investing money in the
• A criminal justice system operating with sensible sentencing
stock market. I will be faced with a decision on which economy
culture
to invest my money in. For me to choose New Zealand in 2010 it
• An overhauled and properly administered employment
will be its past performance which I will be basing my opinion on.
contracts process.”
If between now and 2010, the New Zealand economy does well it
Bill Brien, former Police Officer, Chairman of Wellington Museums
will gain the attention of young investors like myself.
Trust.
So, for me, the three important things New Zealand needs to
do between now and 2010, are to ensure young graduates are
encouraged to stay in New Zealand and work off their student loan,
“New Zealand is all about people and places. We have to do all we
New Zealand businesses do well and expand to create well paid
can to ensure we keep our talent here and keep them motivated
jobs for young graduates and also for the New Zealand economy
to be clever and inspiring. We must ensure we are creating a
to be a good healthy option for young investors to invest in.”
country and economy that will provide young people a place
Montague Hare, Commerce & Science Student, Canterbury University,
to live, work, and a place that is competitive with international
18 years.
standards. This is about protecting our future.
Our people create products and places for New Zealand to
“I’m an investor in equities because I believe the stock market can attract world currency. Let’s make sure we think about the
provide a good return for someone like me, with a long-term view. ‘brain drain’ and work hard to afford the right opportunities to
But I’m also a member of the community I live in, and my take on young New Zealanders so they want to stay here and build great
the economy reflects that. I love the fact that New Zealand has one companies.”
of the lowest unemployment rates around. It means my neighbours, Dianne Jones, Gardener, 53 years.
my friends and I are more likely to have decent jobs – and the
confidence to put some money into savings and investments.
In the future, I’d like to see our full employment goal broadened “New Zealanders have to “think bigger”. Transport,
to include a real push for more productivity and higher skills – so telecommunications and energy production all need some serious
companies can afford to pay better wages as well as delivering decent attention if we want to keep our economy growing. Control of this
profits. I believe our success depends on our ability to build value crucial infrastructure needs to be brought back into New Zealand
through innovation and great New Zealand brands that can take on the and appropriate public money invested to ensure future economic
world. Commodities are important, but only as the raw ingredients. I’d growth is not constricted.”
love to see us develop an economy that reflected that.” Davin Murdoch, Business Owner, 38 years.
Matt Bostwick, Marketing Communications Manager, 31 years.
21
ABN AMRO INSTALMENT WARRANTS
A VEHICLE FOR ACCELERATING WEALTH CREATION
AARON MILNE
DIRECTOR, ABN AMRO EQUITIES NEW ZEALAND LTD
Much has been written of New Zealand retail investors’ enduring love affair with
real estate. Whilst exploring some of the reasons for this popularity, this article will
also look at whether ABN AMRO Instalment Warrants can offer the same potential
for accelerating wealth creation.
22
The question at this point is whether the principles New Zealand equities have posted gross average annual
outlined can be applied just as successfully to leveraged returns of 12.8% since 1932. Due to the lack of directly
investing in the equity market? The good news is yes, comparable figures in New Zealand, it is difficult to make a
and Instalment Warrants have been designed with these case that long run equity returns exceed those of residential
concepts in mind. real estate. Research findings overseas, however, confirm
that equities typically outperform other asset classes such
The recent introduction of Instalment Warrants offers retail
as property, bonds and cash over the long term.
investors access to one of the most popular investment products
in Australia. Since January 2001 to mid 2004, turnover growth The high gross dividend yields on offer in the New
in Instalment Warrants listed on the ASX has been 63% pa Zealand equity market are amongst the highest in the
with turnover now exceeding $2.1 billion pa. world, with 8% – 10% gross dividends not uncommon.
As a consequence Instalment Warrants will typically be
Similar to purchasing residential real estate with only
positively geared, meaning dividend income will exceed
partial capital outlay and borrowing the rest, Instalment
the funding costs. In this light, it is interesting to consider
Warrants allow investors to buy blue chip NZX shares by
that average rental yields are seldom above 5% once
way of two separate payments. In practice, the investor
maintenance costs, rates, insurances, management fees
pays approximately half the value of the share up-front
etc are taken into consideration.
and borrows the rest from the Instalment Warrant issuer.
As with any loan, the investor is liable for interest costs To conclude, the purpose of this article is not to detract
which in the case of Instalment Warrants are paid up front from investment in residential real estate. For the reasons
and represent a part of the initial payment. outlined above, it is has proven a compelling investment
class in a New Zealand context. Rather, leverage and
The popularity of Instalment Warrants in Australia can be
specifically Instalment Warrants issued over NZX
explained by the following factors:
shares should be viewed as an equally powerful tool for
• Leveraged exposure to the share price of the underlying accelerating wealth creation. Importantly, often with
equity superior returns.
• Full entitlement to dividend and imputation credit
income (for only partial capital outlay)
• Full deductibility of interest costs for tax purposes. 1
Ben Graham & David Dodds (1934) Security Analysis
Unlike Australia, however, New Zealand investors are 2
Mary Holm (1998) The Real Story: Saving and investing, now
generally not liable for capital gains tax on the sale of inflation is under control (commissioned by the RBNZ)
Instalment Warrants. 3
ASX (September 2004) – Investment Strategies Using Instalment
• Built-in downside protection arising from the fact the Warrants
investor does not have to repay the loan regardless of 4
ABN AMRO Research (May 2005) In the long run…..2004 Update
the underlying entity share price performance.
The views represented in this article are the express views of the author, and do not
As noted, the test for any investment should be safety of necessarily reflect the views of NZX.
principal plus the likelihood of an adequate return. To this
end, it is imperative that investors focus on established
blue chip companies operating in healthy industries. To
borrow a real estate analogy, blue ribbon areas tend to
experience less volatility in a downturn but also perform
more strongly in an upswing. The same principle generally
applies to equities.
23
DIRECT MARKET ACCESS (DMA)
ADRIENNE QUINN
24
Why would an investor or fund manager want to switch What is an Independent Software Vendor (ISV)?
to DMA when they already have a good relationship with An ISV provides technically conformed software to NZX
their NZX Advisor?
Participants, to enable DMA. The role of an ISV is to
There is no need for the relationship between the investor provide varying features and functionality to enhance
and their NZX Advisor to change that much due to the trading. NZX currently have two accredited NZX ISVs
introduction of DMA. NZX Firms will simply be able to (IRESS and SecuritEase).
execute orders more quickly and easily on behalf of their
clients, through having multiple inputs for market orders. Will we see more ISVs entering the NZ Market?
NZX Firms will also, at their discretion, be able to give NZX would like to see more ISVs develop open interfaces
some clients authorisation to enter orders directly into the solutions to NZX, especially those from overseas
market. marketplaces which will facilitate more international
order flow. ISV applications play a critical role in offering
Who is using DMA applications?
an entire product suite to help NZX, NZX Firms and the
Since the introduction of DMA in August 2004, 10 of trading community work smarter.
NZX’s 16 Trading Participants have now been accredited
to make use of DMA within their firms. These Firms are: To ensure that all ISVs software is compliant, NZX
mandates that ISV applications undertake a technical
• CitiGroup Global Markets (NZ) Limited conformance to meet the minimum requirements defined
• ABN AMRO New Zealand Ltd by NZX to support DMA.
• Macquarie New Zealand Ltd
• Goldman Sachs JBWere (NZ) Ltd
• First NZ Capital Securities Limited
• Forsyth Barr Ltd For more information on DMA trading, please contact
• Deutsche Bank Securities New Zealand Ltd Adrienne Quinn, NZX Participant Relations Manager,
• Direct Broking Ltd at adrienne.quinn@nzx.com
• UBS New Zealand Ltd
• ASB Securities Ltd
How many trades are implemented via a DMA
application?
One quarter (24.5%) of all trades on NZX markets in
March 2005 were the result of orders placed through a
DMA application. NZX expects this to continue to rise as
Participants increase their use of DMA trading facilities.
25
SMARTSHARES
LAUNCHES SAVINGS PLAN
Over the last 18 months there has been a growing
Regular savings directly into Smartshares - what a difference it could make!
level of discussion on New Zealanders’ savings habits. $16,000
$15,000
especially regarding our rate of savings and our attitudes $14,000
$12,000
$10,000
a great deal of interest in saving directly into the $9,000
$7,000
especially those with little time or money, find it difficult $6,000
Smartshares Savings Plan to help the first time investor. *The 25 cent transaction fee as outlined in the Investment Statement
Mary Holm, a prominent business writer for the New is currently being waived by NZX Funds Management Limited.
Zealand Herald stated recently “…It’s a particularly good
way to invest via a share fund – which is the best higher-
risk, higher-return vehicle for those with a small amount JOINING THE SAVINGS PLAN
of money.”
To join the plan, Smartshares investors simply need to
Our example here illustrates how a modest contribution order an investment statement from the Smartshares
of $100 per month into Smartshares can help a first website (www.smartshares.co.nz) or call 0800 80 87 80.
time investor reach their investment goals sooner.
26
smartshares
NZX Operating Metrics - Quarter 1 2005
NZX metrics are available on a monthly basis and can be found at www.nzx.com/aboutus/investor/metrics
All Domestic Equity 63,246 17% 52% NZSX 50 Index 3,039 17%
ISSUERS PARTICIPANTS
Q1 Change Added YTD Q1
Companies Trading & Advising Firm 16
NZSX Domestic 141 4% 0 Advising Firm 11
NZSX Dual Full 3 50% 0 Delivery & Settlement Participants 18
NZSX Overseas 55 -4% 0 FASTER Participants 2
NZAX 22 83% 0 Futures & Options Participants 5
NZDX 42 11% 0 Sponsors 40
Securities
Debt 85 5% 1
ETFs 6 50% 0 MARKET DATA
Warrants 8 -20% 0 Q1
Q1($m) YTD ($m) Primary Data Distributors 18
New equity raised $487 $487 Real Time Data Terminals 6,944
New debt raised $152 $152
NOTES:
1. All figures are measured at the end of the last trading day or for the duration of the quarter.
2. Change refers to the change since the same period in the previous year
3. All Domestic Equity Market Capitalisation includes all securities quoted on the NZSX and NZAX markets of New Zealand, Incorporated Issuers and Dual Listed Issuers.
The Market Capitalisation of Dual Listed Issuers is calculated according to the proportion of revenue generated in New Zealand.
4. Market Capitalisation for the NZDX is the total nominal (face) value of all quoted securities excluding New Zealand Government Stock.
5. Number of Direct Market Access trades includes any trade that involves at at least one Direct Market Access side
6. The number of orders is the number of new orders. It does not represent any ammended orders nor does it consider the number of trades that results from it.
27
MARKETPLACE
Quarter ended 31 March 2005
• Fletcher Building Ltd raises $141 million in an First NZ 1,387 19.7 (22.1) First NZ 27,511 17.1 (15.7)
institutional book build, to fund the acquisition of GSJBWere 1,207 17.2 (22.0) ABN AMRO Craigs 20,293 12.6 (12.7)
Amatek Holdings Ltd in Australia.
UBS 883 12.6 (14.6) GSJBWere 18,283 11.4 (10.4)
• Macquarie Goodman Property Trust embarks on
ABN AMRO NZ 856 12.2 (9.3) ASB Securities 18,205 11.3 (8.6)
a capital raising of $231 million via a placement,
institutional book build, and entitlements offer to Macquarie 786 11.2 (7.1) Forsyth Barr 17,653 11.0 (12.3)
existing shareholders. The funds will be used to Citigroup 745 10.6 (9.5) Direct Broking 15,304 9.5 (6.3)
acquire a portfolio of property assets from Macquarie
Forsyth Barr 494 7.0 (5.7) Macquarie 12,979 8.1 (6.8)
Goodman Group.
ABN AMRO Craigs 301 4.3 (3.6) UBS 8,405 5.2 (4.4)
• Tower Ltd completes a scheme of arrangement to
distribute shares of subsidiary Australian Wealth ASB Securities 160 2.3 (1.8) ABN AMRO NZ 7,883 4.9 (4.9)
Management to all shareholders. Direct Broking 129 1.8 (1.5) Citigroup 6,495 4.0 (4.6)
• Tenon delivers a capital repayment of $321 million to
shareholders. The distinction between Tenon Ordinary
and Tenon Preference shares is removed. GLOBAL INDEX RETURNS
Global markets, as measured by the MSCI Indices,
• Wrightson completes a full takeover of rival rural
showed mixed returns this quarter. The Australian market
services company Williams & Kettle. Williams &
withstood a weak March to give an overall positive return
Kettle is delisted.
for the quarter. Pacific and European markets were also
• AMP acquires 10% of Capital Properties NZ via a stand
up, but the strengthening of the New Zealand dollar
in the market.
against the Yen and Euro dampened the returns available
from these markets in New Zealand dollar terms.
NZX FIRMS
The increase in trading activity has allowed most
NZX Firms to increase their absolute trading turnover ����������������������������������������
compared to Q1 2004. The biggest increases in market ����
Forsyth Barr (in terms of value traded) and by First NZ, ����
trades). The market share statistics for NZX Firms on all ����
����
NZX’s markets this quarter were:
�����
�����
Source: MSCI
�����
�� ��������� ������� ��� ������
�������������� ���
28
DIRECT MARKET ACCESS
A major development for NZX this quarter has been the
uptake of Direct Market Access (DMA) by NZX Firms.
DMA has opened the way for the development of software
that interacts directly with NZX’s trading system. This NZSX MARKET - TRADING ACTIVITY
new technology allows the streamlining of order processing Trading activity on the NZSX Market has been up this
at NZX Firms and the implementation of automated quarter. February and March 2005 were the two busiest
algorithmic trading. months since 2001 in terms of the number of trades (2806
DMA makes it easier for participants to access the markets, and 2675 average trades per day respectively). Value of
which will have positive spin-offs in terms of liquidity, trading was also high, averaging over $114 million per day
demand for New Zealand securities and new listings. in both February and March.
��������������������������� ����������������������������������������
������ ��� �����
� � �
������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������
������ ������ ������ ������ ������ ������ ������ ������
�������������������� ����������������������
In March 2005, 14,300 trades were executed using DMA NZSX MARKET – TOTAL RETURNS
technology (with a DMA order on the buy side, the sell
The market retreated slightly in the March 2005 quarter,
side or both sides). This represented 24.5% of all trades
on the back of weakening macroeconomic indicators and a
in March.
small number of below expectation profit announcements
The value of DMA trades in March 2005 was $114 million, in March. This quarter is the first time the NZSX 50 Index
4.6% of total value traded. Thus far DMA has been used has delivered a negative quarterly return since March
mostly in environments where there is a large volume of 2003.
small value trades.
The market is still well above its 2004 levels. 12 month
If we consider only on-market equity trading (i.e. returns for the NZSX Indices vary from 14.0% for the
excluding debt trading and off-market negotiated deals), NZSX 10 Index to 29.4% for the small-cap NZSX SCI
DMA activity accounts for 29.4% of the number of trades Index.
and 15.4% of value traded in March.
29
NZSX 50 Index
�������������
Top 10 Positive Contributors
����
Security Index Last Q1 05 Q1 Index 12 Month
���� weight price Return impact Return
���� (%) ($) (%) (points) (%)
Independent 4.20 6.00 7.16 8.58 27.3
����
Newspapers
���� Fletcher Building 6.50 6.64 3.48 6.95 60.6
���� Auckland Intl Airport 5.47 8.10 4.28 6.84 30.0
���� Telecom Corp of NZ 26.06 6.06 0.72 6.05 14.1
���� Waste Management 1.35 6.12 12.50 4.67 45.7
NZ
����
��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� Pumpkin Patch 0.77 3.28 20.88 4.04 -
Contact Energy 8.29 6.50 1.56 3.45 23.8
The Warehouse Group 1.31 3.97 9.37 3.31 -2.8
Sky Network TV 1.25 6.43 7.49 2.70 25.9
Mainfreight 0.38 2.65 17.78 1.71 56.2
NZSX Market - Total Index Return
Index Value Q1 2005 (%) 12 Months (%)
Of the 50 securities in the NZSX 50 Index, 23 gave a Nuplex Industries 0.81 4.97 -12.06 -3.44 18.1
positive return this quarter. Overall, the NZSX 50 Index Guinness Peat Group
Plc
3.08 2.08 -3.02 -2.96 14.6
fell by 0.8%, or 25.8 index points. Lion Nathan 0.54 7.84 -15.43 -2.96 17.4
Cavalier Corporation 0.40 3.80 -16.71 -2.47 -15.9
The securities which had the biggest impacts on the Index
were Independent Newspapers (which pushed the Index
up 8.6 points), Fisher and Paykel Appliances and Fisher NZSX SCI INDEX
and Paykel Healthcare (dragging the Index down 23.2 There were a number of strong performers among the small-
points and 8.5 points respectively). cap stocks this quarter. NZ Finance Holdings, which listed
after an IPO in October 2004, doubled in price this quarter,
The poorer performing securities this quarter were mainly
partly due to popularity with strategic shareholders.
stocks that have given strong returns over the past year.
Of the bottom 10 negative contributors this quarter, seven NZSX SCI Index
have still given positive 12 month returns, all in excess of Top 10 Performers
14%, despite their poor performance this quarter. Security Last Q1 05 12 Month
price Return Return
($) (%) (%)
NZ Finance Holdings 0.82 105.0 -
Training Solutions Plus 0.002 100.0 0.0
Vertex Group Holdings 2.06 31.2 54.1
NZ Refining Co 34.50 17.8 145.9
CDL Investments NZ 0.37 15.6 48.0
Cadmus Technology 0.30 15.4 160.9
Metlifecare 3.90 14.1 72.6
Allied Farmers 2.88 13.7 92.1
Toll NZ 3.05 13.0 117.9
Mooring Systems 4.45 12.7 18.4
30
NZSX SCI Index NZAX Market – Total Returns
Bottom 10 Performers Bottom 10 Performers
Security Last Q1 05 12 Month Security Last Q1 05 Six
price Return Return price Return Months
($) (%) (%) ($) (%) (%)
New Image 0.07 -64.8 -77.6 RetailX 0.08 33.3 -60.0
Widespread Portfolios 0.017 -39.3 -37.9 Livestock Improv Corp 1.30 20.6 10.9
Genesis R&D Corp 0.28 -37.8 -56.9 Just Water International 0.94 20.4 23.5
Apple Fields 0.03 -33.3 0.0 Ashburton BS Ordinary 4.30 12.9 25.9
Life Pharmacy Limited 1.35 -32.5 -3.6 Wool Equities 0.72 12.5 50.0
Broadway Industries 0.80 -28.6 -16.8 Comvita 2.20 6.1 -7.1
Aust Prop Hldgs Group 0.03 -28.6 -40.0 Eastern HiFi 0.96 4.3 -
KidiCorp Group 0.18 -28.0 0.0 Loan and Buildng Society 4.56 3.6 16.8
Blue Chip New Zealand 0.90 -25.0 -44.4 Ashburton BS Preference 1.26 1.5 15.5
Heritage Gold NZ 0.083 -24.5 -16.2 Oyster Bay Mlb Vineyards 2.74 1.5 2.6
Speirs Group 1.20 0.0 37.4
Satara Co-op Group 1.18 -2.3 -
The NZ Wine Company 1.90 -5.0 -2.3
NZ Wool Services Intl 0.50 -7.4 -4.9
Zintel Group 1.00 -9.1 -18.9
Seeka Kiwifruit Inds 4.50 -9.6 -0.6
Southern Travel Holdings 1.08 -11.3 -
Cynotech 0.22 -15.4 50.4
Windflow Technology 2.50 -16.7 -20.4
The NZAX Market has matured significantly since its Solution Dynamics 1.08 -32.5 -10.0
A2 Corp 0.22 -45.0 -56.0
launch in November 2003. There are now 23 Issuers with
The CACI Group 0.18 -50.0 -47.1
securities listed on the market. The growth in the market
can be seen in the number of trades and value of shares
traded, which are up 150% and 190% respectively this NZAX ALL INDEX
quarter as compared to the same period in 2004. The NZAX All Index followed the NZSX Market indices
down this quarter, down 4.5% to 1202.21. The 12 month
return on this in Index is 17.3%.
����������������������������������
���� �����
���� �����
����
���
����
���
����
���
����
���� ���
���� �
������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������
�������������������� ����������������������
31
NZX DEBT INDICES
NZX calculates a range of government bond, corporate bond
and bank bill indices designed to track the performance of
fixed interest securities in New Zealand. The table below
shows the performance of the main indices to the end of
NZDX MARKET - TRADING ACTIVITY March.
Trading on the NZDX Market has been moderate this
quarter.
NZX Debt Indices - Returns
Returns 31 March 05 Data
Index Q1 05 12 Months Yield Mod.
���������������������������������������� (%) (%) (%) Duration
�� ���
NZX NZ Government Stock 0.53 3.86 6.24 4.04 years
�� ��� Index
�� NZX Corporate Investment 0.76 4.49 7.13 2.50 years
���
Grade Bond Index
��
�� NZX 90-Day Bank Bill Index 1.65 6.42 7.08 n/a
�
��
�
�
��
The raising of interest rates in the past year has weakened
� �� the market value of existing bonds, resulting in low
�
������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������
� 12 month returns for the NZ Government Stock and
�������������������� ����������������������
Corporate Bond Indices.
A significant event for NZX NZ Government Stock
Index this quarter was the maturity of the February
NZDX MARKET - NEW LISTINGS 2005 Government Bond, which lengthened the modified
The first quarter of the year is usually quiet for new listings, duration of the Index by about 0.6 years.
however there was one new security quoted on the NZDX
Market this quarter.
32
Q1-05 UPDATE
Corporate Accreditation of NZX Market We believe that the outcome has been extremely beneficial
Participants in that NZX now has detailed information relating to, as
well as a greater understanding of, the composition and
Corporate accreditation is one of the pillars of the activities of its Participants. Furthermore, Participants
regulatory supervision conducted by NZX in respect of are likely to have a much greater understanding of their
its Market Participants (commonly known as Broking regulatory responsibilities having undergone the process.
Firms). The road to successfully attaining corporate During the process, each Market Participant had to
accreditation commences with submitting an application demonstrate that they had:
form and providing a number of prescribed documents
• Professional indemnity insurance
which contain details of the Firm’s business, key staff,
procedures, systems and controls. The application process • Written compliance procedures
also requires the principals (i.e. the directors, partners or • A designated, independent compliance resource to
the sole trader him/herself) of the Firm to make certain provide compliance oversight
undertakings to NZX to the effect that they are fit and • Written business continuity and emergency
proper to hold that position and they will ensure that the arrangements.
Firm will comply with its regulatory obligations. Any new NZX freely admits that it has deliberately raised the bar of
Firm seeking to become a Market Participant will need to what it takes to become and remain a “member” of NZX
undergo this application process. (as was the terminology used prior to the demutualisation).
Under the NZX Participant Rules, which came into effect We believe that this has greatly enhanced the section of the
on 3 May 2004, all existing Firms had to apply to attain financial services industry for which NZX, in exercise of its
the newly created designation of Market Participant. This function as a “Self-regulating Organisation” is responsible.
application had to be made by 3 November 2004, the end NZX wishes to congratulate all Firms that have successfully
of the transitional period for the new Rules. NZX has now attained the designation of NZX Market Participant.
completed processing all of the applications received from Accreditation for existing Firms was by no means a
existing Firms and made determinations in respect of all formality. In this regard, we note that not all applications
of the applicants. A list of Firms accredited as Market were successful. We firmly believe that using the NZX
Participants (and NZX Sponsors) is provided on the NZX brand, as Market Participants are entitled and encouraged
website in the ‘Market Participants’ section. to do (whether in signage or stationery), will provide a
Given its fundamental importance, the application process mark of quality and is an achievement to be proud of.
for all existing Firms was a meticulous one involving
a considerable amount of work for both NZX and the
applicants. We acknowledge the hard work performed by
the applicants prior to the submission of their application.
We wish to thank all applicants for this.
33
NZX Submissions
34
The source for market information
www.i-Search.nzx.com
Special offer
Try i-Search free for one month.
To trial i-Search or for more information please
email data@nzx.com.
35
To advertise here, contact open@nzx.com
If you have any comments or feedback on this publication, or would like to be added to the
OPEN mailing list, please email open@ nzx.com.
This newsletter is provided with the understanding that neither NZX nor its representatives NZX, ASB Tower
are engaged in rendering professional advice or services. NZX and its representatives make Level 9, 2 Hunter Street
no warranties, express or implied, as to the accuracy of the content of this newsletter. PO Box 2959
Neither NZX nor its representatives shall be liable for any direct, indirect, consequential or Wellington, New Zealand
other loss arising from the use of this newsletter or any information contained herein and/or P: +64 4 472 7599
further communications in relation to this newsletter. If you wish to unsubscribe from the F: +64 4 496 2893
OPEN mailing list please email us at open @ nzx.com W: www.nzx.com
36 Zealand Exchange Limited, 2005
© New