Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
PARTIAL DISCHARGE MEASUREMENT SAMPLE REPORT FOR ABC COMPANY PTE LTD ON 19TH NOVEMBER 2004
Report Prepared : 19th November 2004 Tested By : Lim Chee Meng Certified Infrared Thermographer
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
COMPANY PROFILE
We are a specialist company providing Equipment Condition Inspection services for the benefits of our customers in Singapore and the region for the past 10 years. We have been successful in working with our clients on providing a one-stop solution to their various needs and problems in Condition Monitoring and Maintenance. We can provide non-invasive testing of airconditioning systems, mechanical and electrical installations using proven methods of infrared, partial discharge testing, vibration analysis & motor signature test for customers at reasonable cost. Also, we have been involved in the fight against SARS by providing SARS fever detection services to various organizations in Singapore. To further enhance our ties with customers such as you and to further develop our infrared, vibration analysis and other reliable condition monitoring techniques, we would be happy to work with you by providing the relevant training and sharing of our experience and expertise necessary to help you extend your expensive equipment life. We can detect early problems in equipment before damage occurs, and provide other support services through the use of innovative techniques and equipment. All these have been done with one very important objective of assisting you in managing your costly equipment and reduce downtime due to equipment failure and reduce expensive replacement of equipment. The benefits to you, our valued customers, are immeasurable. Not only do you get see the results of our work by having to spend less on equipment maintenance but also machine utilization is maximized as well. To be Asias leading Equipment Condition Inspection Specialist and other related services provider by providing high quality value-added products and services to meet the rising needs of our customers in the region. To provide the best and reliable inspection service to customers in the region. Infrared Thermography Inspection for the Low Voltage Electrical System, Building Faade and Mechanical Equipment Partial Discharge Testing with Spectrum Analyzer for High Voltage Equipment of more than 3.3KV without the need to shut down AHU Performance Management Program Condition Monitoring with Maintenance Vibration Analysis and Diagnostic for rotating equipment. Motor Signature Test for Low Voltage Motors of less than 600V EMI (electromagnetic inference) Measurement & Solutions Power Quality Analysis & Solutions
INTRODUCTION
OUR BUSINESS
OUR VISION
OUR MISSION
RELIABILITY
Name of the Company
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
Hoestar Inspection International Pte Ltd Hoestar PD Technology Pte Ltd Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd Leong Weng Hoe Certified Thermographer Level II Certified Vibration Specialist Level II
Managing Director
SINGAPORE Established 3rd July 1991 5A Siang Kuang Avenue, Singapore 347923
Tel: 64881603 Fax: 62819477 MALAYSIA Established 1st June 2005 CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya Selangor Darul Eshan, Malaysia Tel: 03-56326832 Fax: 03-56376832 12 with 4 Certified Thermographers Inframetrics PM 350 1 in No. (for Infrared Inspection) FLIR PM675 1 in No. (for Infrared Inspection) MTech PM200 1 in No, (for Infrared Inspection) Ultrasound SDT 100 1 in No. (for Ultrasound Inspection & Partial Discharge Testing in HV equipment) Partial Discharge Analysis proprietary Analytical Software Spectrum Analyser 1 in No. ( for Partial Discharge Testing in HV equipment) Entek IRD DataPAC 1500 Analyser /Data Collector - 1 in No. (for Vibration Analysis Inspection) Motor Current Analyser Kit 1 in No. (for Motor Analysis Inspection)
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
Services
To provide: a) Advanced Vibration Diagnostics and Motor Signature Analysis of rotating equipment e.g., AC motors, turbines, compressors, Chillers, Pumps b) Advanced Infrared Thermography of: Electrical System: i) LV Transformers ii) Sub Station 3.3KV & below iii) Main Switch Boards iv) Bus Ducts v) Chiller Switch Boards vi) Sub Boards Building: i) Facades falling tiles moisture ingress and energy loss ii) Roof Inspection for leaks Mechanical Equipment: i) Furnaces ii) Refractories iii) Chiller & Steam Pipes iv) Rotating Equipment bearings & motors v) Heat Exchanger corrosion leak detection c) To provide Partial Discharge Testing using Ultrasound & Spectrum Analyser for High Voltage Equipment of more than 3.3 KV without the need to shut down. Use of PD Test to check Oil Quality before Oil Test. d) AHU Performance Management Program Condition Monitoring with Maintenance.
Training
a) b) c) d)
Basic and Advanced Vibration Analysis Infrared Thermography Precision shaft alignment In-house training for Vibration Analysis, Thermography e) Partial Discharge Testing Certification.
Infrared
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
whleong@hoestarinsp.com.sg
HOESTAR INSPECTION INTERNATIONAL PTE LTD
INTRODUCTION:
A number of users with high tension equipment such as HV Switchgears ,transformers and motors have rightly or wrongly assume that Partial Discharges do not occur in their systems. However from our work done ,it can be shown that partial discharges do and are occurring in all HV equipment though their magnitudes are usually very small .However they can change because of the following factors; a)Environment b)Manufacturing Defects c)Electrical, Thermal and Mechanical Stresses d)Poor maintenance e)Poor equipment design From our field work there are many instances of partial discharge occurring due to the above factors. As a result, massive losses had resulted from equipment failure. Most of the time this can be prevented if the correct and proper testing had been used.
1] Yu Ming and S Birlasekaran, Characterization of partial discharge signals using wavelet and statistical techniques, Proc. of the 2002 IEEE International Symposium on Electrical Insulation, Boston, MA, USA, April,2002, pp 9-13.
vi.
vii.
7
viii.
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
**********
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
DIAGNOSTIC PARTIAL DISCHARGE MEASUREMENT FOR HIGH TENSION SWITCHGEAR Date : 10 December 2004 Client : ABC COMPANY Page : 1 of 1 Time : 1500Hrs Location : Main Substation Floor : 1st Storey Voltage : 22 KV Brand / Type : Yorkshire Switchgear / Oil Dry Test Instrument Partial Discharge Analyser HT SWITCHGEAR PANEL
B
BACK Environmental Reading:
Location of Sensor
Panel No. Partial Discharge Measurement (mV) BACK T B 234 800
Status X
Panel No. 11
Remark:
RELIABILITY
Customer Date Location Equipment 10 /12/ 2004 Main Substation 22KV SWBD Panel 11
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
ABC COMPANY
Time Level Brand / Type 15:00 PM 1st Storey
Remarks : No significant cavity discharge detected for Panel 12 during this measurement.
Remarks : Corona discharges detected with some pulses occurring at very high magnitude.
10
RELIABILITY
Customer Date Location Equipment 10 /12/ 2004 Main Substation 22KV SWBD Panel 11
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
ABC COMPANY
Time Level Brand / Type 15:00 PM 1st Storey
Corona
Remarks: Significant Corona Partial discharges are detected within this panel.
11
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
Skirting Cable
Section A
Section B
Skirting Conductor
Discharge present between skirting & cable insulation due to dust ingress in gap.
12
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
13
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
14
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
15
RELIABILITY
Customer Date Location Equipment
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
ABC Company Pte Ltd 12 / 10 / 2005 Time Arc Furnace Room Level 33 KV Reactor Brand / Type
Remarks : Minor partial discharges on the corona (derive from the pattern below) are detected within this transformer. The max. PD magnitude for 1 pd pulse is 1726mV after eliminating the surrounding noise.
16
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
ABC Company Pte Ltd 12 / 10 / 2005 Time Arc Furnace Room Level 33 KV Reactor Brand / Type
Remarks : Density of the Partial discharges on corona (derive from the pattern above) are shown above with max. number of pulses detected at 51
17
RELIABILITY
Customer Date Location Equipment
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
ABC Company Pte Ltd 12 / 10 / 2005 Time Arc Furnace Room Level 33 KV Reactor Brand / Type
18
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
Wideband pulse measurement (100Mhz) Sampling rate 100MS/s Large internal storage buffer (32MB) 40 GB hardisk with 3 USB ports for greater storage capability Computing and processing Ultra fast 1.7Ghz Centrino laptop, 2M cache & 512M DDR2 R Dual Batteries operation for longer operating time unit Fast Data PCI transfer rate (32MB/S) Sensors 1) Capacitive sensor 100 MHz bandwidth. Ultra sensitive to detect PD signal as low as 2.5mV with amplification 2) High Frequency Current Transformer (HFCT) Output sensitivity in 0.5 V/A Maximum current (rms) 5A Rise time 0.7 ns High cut-off frequency (-3db) 500 MHz Software Data Acquisition software (exe file) Data analysis software (exe file) All specifications are subject to change without prior notice
19
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
NON-INTRUSIVE PARTIAL DISCHARGE MEASUREMENTS 1. INTRODUCTION Partial discharges in high voltage metal-clad switchgear or transformers can result in catastrophic failure of the individual plant and in some cases of the substation. Therefore, there has been a need for detection and location of the damaging discharges without the plant or substation being taken out of service. The conventional partial discharge detection technique requires either the use of Infrared Thermography or Ultrasound which requires the panels to be opened in order to see any thermal anomaly generated by Partial Discharge activity or to hear them. The PD Pac has been designed to fulfil this important requirement. The PD Pac uses the principle of ElectroMagnetic Wave (EM) measurement. The PD Pac is a portable instrument used to survey high voltage switchboards and transformers while live without endangering the lives of the PD Specialists. 2. ELECTRO MAGNETIC WAVE MEASUREMENT (EM) TECHNIQUE If a partial discharge occurs in the phase to earth insulation of a conductor in a high voltage system such as metalclad switchgear, a Partial Discharge current pulse will flow on the surface of the conductor and the metal cladding. This current will generate an EM wave which will penetrate through the metal cladding to be detected by the EM sensor of the measuring system. Advantages of TEV Technique: Non-invasive diagnostic technique Measurement can be made on live equipment No switching of power system is required No high voltage test source is required No need for a sanction for test
20
RELIABILITY
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
Figure 1 is a simplified cross section showing just one phase of a high voltage busbar with a gasketed joint on the left hand side.
Figure 1 : Transient Earth Voltage Detection of Partial Discharge Activity. Electromagnetic Sensor (EM Sensor) When partial discharge occurs, Partial Discharge (PD) of very short duration (in a few nanoseconds) current pulses will flow along the metal cladding or on the skin of the conductor. This current will then generate both electric or magnetic field and emits electromagnetic radiation known as Electromagnetic wave (EM wave). This EM wave will either penetrate through the metal cladding or propagate through an opening in the metal cladding. When Partial Discharge is sensed using this Electromagnetic sensor, this EM wave will be converted to a voltage signal with a few nanosecond rise time and an amplitude from milivolts to volts. In conclusion, this electromagnetic sensor basically senses for EM wave and acts as a antenna to detect the radiated EM radiation.
21
RELIABILITY
3. CONCLUSIONS
Hoestar Reliability Instruments Sdn Bhd (693347-T) CT-04-07, Subang Square Business Centre Jalan SS 15/4G, Subang Jaya 47500 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Email: hoestar@streamyx.com Tel: 02-03-56326832 Fax: 02-03-56376832
The EM Wave technique is designed for use on metalclad high voltage switchgear and transformers from 3.3KV above containing compound, oil or air insulation. With this method, the higher the voltage the greater is the distance of detection. Therefore it is suitable for Partial Discharge detection in outdoor or indoor high voltage applications. As the EM probes used is sensitive to micro pd discharges, the test can be used to determine the health of high voltage equipment early before damage occurs. Also it will help engineers to decide which equipment is in need of service thus saving companies from downtime losses. In fact if servicing is really warranted, a pre & post pd inspection will go a long way in preventing damage which may occur due to human errors or cavity discharges which is usually not detectable during normal servicing. However, Partial Discharge Test is in no way replace calibration of protection devices for high voltage equipment. From numerous site tests carried out, a severity table for determining the condition of high voltage equipment has been developed to help electrical engineers decide on the next course of action to be taken before failure occurs. Finally, with this test, we can measure the condition of High Voltage equipment while it is in operation without the need to open the panels or shutting it down.
22