Transmittal Message
May, 28, 2013 Mr. Iftikhar Munir Marketing Management Hamdard Institute of Management Sciences Karachi, Pakistan. Dear Mr. Munir, Enclosed is a copy of Marketing Plan for Karachi Tobacco Co which was assignment to our group for the course Marketing Managment conducted by you. This business plan is a summary of our study and findings of business processes, facts sheet, implications as well as our recommendations during the time allotted to us. This business plan shows the critical analysis of the BU (Tobacco) and the principles applied in marketing management which further revolves around the strategic intent of the BU and how it is produced. A number of basic principles being applied have also been explained. We are grateful to Allah and all the people who helped us in completing this report. If you have any questions and/or comments regarding the interpretation of this report please feel free to contact us. Thank you for your initiation of this report. Sincerely, Kamran Ali Shahid Umair Wajid
Tahir Kaleem
Ahmed Amirali
2
Marketing Management
Letter of Acknowledgement
Standing on the bank of a river, a man cannot determine its depth unless and until he sets foot in it. It has always been said that the best way to Learn is through experience.
All praise and thanks to the Almighty Allah who gave us the strength and will to complete the task. I would like to extend our thanks to Mr. Iftikhar Munir, who conducted the course of Marketing Management and taught the basic knowledge and the core concepts of the subject, its infrastructure and provided enough assistance and guidance in materializing of this marketing plan. This has definitely been a unique learning experience for all of us. This research has helped us a lot in applying the theoretical concepts and learning the practical aspects of marketing management.
Ahmed Amirali
3
Marketing Management
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 OVERVIEW OF TOBACCO INDUSTRY.........................................................................................................................6 1.1 PAKISTAN MARKET.............................................................................................................................................................6 1.2 MARKET SEGMENTATION....................................................................................................................................................7 1.3 FRAME WORK FROM HARVESTING TO CIG. MANUFACTURING...........................................................................................8 1.4KEY EMERGING TRENDS......................................................................................................................................................9 1.5 HIGH BARRIERS TO ENTRY FOR NEW ENTRANTS.................................................................................................................9 2.0 KARACHI TOBACCO COMPANY LIMITED..............................................................................................................10 2.2 REGION..............................................................................................................................................................................10 2.3 THE CLIENTELE:................................................................................................................................................................11 2.4 THE SUPPLIERS:.................................................................................................................................................................11 2.5 MANAGEMENT TEAM:.......................................................................................................................................................11 3.0 Business Scope.............................................................................................................................................................12 3.1 WHERE..............................................................................................................................................................................12 3.2 WHAT NEEDS....................................................................................................................................................................12 3.3 WHOSE NEEDS..................................................................................................................................................................12 3.4 ADDED VALUE..................................................................................................................................................................12 4.0 EXTERNAL ANALYSIS ...................................................................................................................................................13 4.1 MARKET STRUCTURE........................................................................................................................................................13 4.1.1 Market Segmentation................................................................................................................................................13 4.2 ANALYSIS..........................................................................................................................................................................15 4.2.1 Fact Sheet.................................................................................................................................................................15 4.2.2 Implications..............................................................................................................................................................16 4.3 MARKET SIZE & SHARE....................................................................................................................................................16 4.3.2 Projected Market Growth for next 4 years...............................................................................................................17 4.4 SEGMENT LIFE CYCLE.......................................................................................................................................................18 4.4.1 Industry.....................................................................................................................................................................18 4.4.1.1 Critical Analysis ...................................................................................................................................................19 4.5 DISTRIBUTION STRUCTURE...............................................................................................................................................20 4.6 COMPANY & COMPETITOR MARKET SHARE.....................................................................................................................21 4.6.1 2012-13.....................................................................................................................................................................21 4.7 MARKET PROFITABILITY ANALYSIS..................................................................................................................................22 4.8 COST STRUCTURE..............................................................................................................................................................22 4.9 DRIVING FORCES OR KEY SUCCESS FACTORS..................................................................................................................23 4.10 TRENDS IN THE INDUSTRY..............................................................................................................................................25 4.10.2 Bargaining Power of Suppliers..............................................................................................................................25 4.10.4 Threat of New Entrant:...........................................................................................................................................25 4.10.5 Exit Barriers:..........................................................................................................................................................25 5.0 INTERNAL ANALYSIS.....................................................................................................................................................26 5.1 VALUE CHAIN...................................................................................................................................................................26 5.2 SWOT ANALYSIS..............................................................................................................................................................27 5.4 PORTFOLIO ANALYSIS.......................................................................................................................................................29 5.4.1 KTC Brands:.............................................................................................................................................................29 5.4.2 BCG Matrix:.............................................................................................................................................................30 5.5.1 Financial Highlights ................................................................................................................................................32 5.6 PERFORMANCE STANDARDS..............................................................................................................................................33 6.0 VISION, MISSION AND OBJECTIVES..........................................................................................................................33
4
Marketing Management
5
Marketing Management
6
Marketing Management
Marketing Plan: Karachi Tobacco Company ___________________________________________________________________________ even greater if we include the illegal companies that are mostly operating in NWFP and Balochistan. In Pakistan there are two major players. PTC - Pakistan Tobacco Company operating under license from BAT British American Tobacco and LTC Karachi Tobacco Company, now operating under License of Philip Morris International. Both LTC and BAT are more than 90% of the total Tobacco Market in Pakistan. Other players are Sarhad Tobacco Company, Mughal Tobacco Company, while others smaller have insignificant volume contribution. Pakistan has an estimated Cigarette consumption of 79 Billion stick (Unofficial data) per annum. It includes both organized and unorganized sector. Of this total market, 63 Billion stick is with the organized sector, while rest is produced / smuggled illegally. In terms of Pak Rupees the total market of cigarettes is about Rs. 60 billion per year. Pakistan has a total smoking population of 11.07 million, averaging 16 sticks per smoker. (Source: Economic Survey of Pakistan 2005).
7
Marketing Management
Marketing Plan: Karachi Tobacco Company ___________________________________________________________________________ The cigarette market is divided in to the following Categories (Segments) based on the price SKU. Price Range 20 Cig. > Rs.70.00 Rs. 30.01 Rs. 70.00 Rs. 20.01 Rs. 30.00
1.4
9
Marketing Management
2.2 Region
Mainly serving for the local market, with major share of Market (around 20%) in Punjab Province, Karachi is operating with two cigarette manufacturing unit located across Pakistan. With the largest manufacturing unit operating in Sahiwal, Other unit is in Karachi. Karachi consist of 4 Cigarette Depots, 1 st point of contract of its product is with distributors, who are responsible to distribute under guidance of Karachi sales force. With the market volume distribution, 6 Depots are strategically located in Sindh, 7 Depots in Punjab and 1 each in NWFP and Balochistan.
10
Marketing Management
11
Marketing Management
3.0
Business Scope
3.1 Where
All Across Pakistan with major presence in the province of Punjab where around 70% of the product is sold.
12
Marketing Management
MARKET SEGMENTATION
Segment A Price range > 70 for 20s Cig Pack Segment B Price range 40 for 20s Segment C Price range 15 to 22 for 20s
13
Marketing Management
END USERS
Segment A
SEC A / A+: Income Level 30 K and above, who believe in high quality products which can give them a good image.
Segment B
SEC A: Income Level 20 - 30 K, who believe in high quality but settle for local products more often.
Segment C
SEC C: Daily wagers who cant afford expensive cigarettes, usually stick buying behavior prevails in this segment.
PRODUCTS
Segment B Challenger
Segment E Boss.
14
Marketing Management
CHANNELS
Distributors
Distribution and Outbound logistics are handled mostly by companies themselves
Large Wholesalers
About 65% of product is handled by wholesalers in the market for distribution
4.2 Analysis
4.2.1 Fact Sheet
KTC Cigarette Market is divided in 3 segments, A, B, C, based on price of the product. Cigarettes consumers are very price conscious and that is why all the segmentation is based on their price of product in the market. KTC major concentration is in A and C segments where there are many products of their own competing each other in the market. High dependence on distributors for communication of products to the actual consumers.
15
Marketing Management
4.2.2 Implications
Our product is of sensory nature and consumers are very receptive of its taste and smoke. Consumers are brand conscious but they tends to switch to similar or superior brands if they cant seek the satisfaction they wanted from their own brand. Cigarette is a part of the personality of the consumer that he looks forward towards its packaging and style that would match his social standing. In short the company needs to build a strong packaging along with consistent taste building a strong brand persona, though it is facing a strong challenge of Black Marketing due to ban on ATL activities.
16
Marketing Management
100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0%
HL20 HL10 SC20
Demand
S. No 1 2 3
17
Marketing Management
Marketing Plan: Karachi Tobacco Company ___________________________________________________________________________ As forecasted by the market research agents, it is seen that the overall growth of the tobacco industry is going to increase proportionally and gradually 2% annually as the players are going to focus more on the upper segments and will be using aggressive marketing and trade initiatives.
4.4.1 Industry
The tobacco industry has attained maturity stage as the massive market of segment B & C has been penetrated with the percentage of penetration being 75% which consists mostly of the rural areas and some of the urban areas. Less than 5% of the market are those potential people who either dont take cigarettes as there means of nicotine satisfaction and go for other alternatives such as paan, eatable tobacco, shisha or hukka and cigars. The others are those who casually take cigarettes as a sign of attitude and prestige. Segment A and B are still in the growth stage which still needs to go in the maturity stage.
18
Marketing Management
4.4.1.1
Critical Analysis
It has been observed that the market segments of the tobacco industry are in two stages one is in the growth stage which includes segment A, B and the maturity stage which includes segments B & C. The major reasons for the segments to be divided into these major groups are: There is a greater range of different brands in the lower segments like C then the upper segments which are A, B. Hence, consumers of the tobacco industry have a more differentiated choice of cigarettes in the lower segments then the upper segments and hence the lower segments have grown rapidly then the upper segments. Price is a main factor because of which the lower segments have reached their maturity stage as more of the rural areas have responded to these stages then the urban areas who prefer to respond to the upper segments.
S.No 1 2 3
Intro .
19
Marketing Management
Local Manufacturing
Inbound Logistics
Imports
Company
Distributor And Outbound Logistics Large Scale Retailers (35%) Wholesalers (65%) Consumers Retailers (Small Scale) / Trolleys
The distribution norm in the industry is very conventional that the manufacturers sell from their warehouses to their major distributors, which sell directly to wholesalers and large scale retailers. The whole sellers pass it to the retailers and trolleys who then pass it to the consumers. Also, there are distributors who sell directly to large retailers and then the product is passed onto the consumers. This distribution trend of the industry is very similar to what Karachi follows. In order to not only have a greater sale in the tobacco industry but to have a better market coverage, companies are brainstorming on strategies of how to effectively use the distribution channel to achieve this milestone. The example of this is that the companies in the tobacco industry is making a strong alliance with the distribution agencies who are much organized then the local distributors and using there particular expertise and widely spread network, the company can easily and effectively improve the coverage of the market they are entertaining or plan to entertain.
20
Marketing Management
4.6.1 2012-13
52%
1%
0%
2012-13
Brand MORVEN GOLD KSF 20HL B 20HL GOLD FLAKE KSF 10HL GOLD LEAF KSF 20HL
The above table is showing the top 4 Brands, Volume wise in the Industry with their market share and the segment they belong to. Karachi is present with its major brand BOSS in the 2 nd brands list.
21
Marketing Management
22
Marketing Management
Marketing Plan: Karachi Tobacco Company ___________________________________________________________________________ much as 73 % of the total cost. Of which 10 15 % is on the tobacco used for the manufacturing of the cigarettes. Per 20 Cigs. UPPER MEDIUM LOWER
Retail Price ABOVE Rs. 70.00 > Rs. 15 & up to Rs. 40.00 UPTO Rs. 15
Cost of raw material used in manufacturing of cigarette is also high as both the rivals use imported raw and packaging materials. But the volume is justifiable for their usage to give product a good quality and sustainability . KTC has placed itself somewhere towards the middle continuum. It cannot sell itself solely on the basis of its brand name; hence, it has to practice a high level of marketing and sales promotion activities. On the other hand, since most of its raw material is imported, and its volume sales are high enough, yet its major chunk of the budget should be spent on marketing but this is not a common practice.
Marketing Plan: Karachi Tobacco Company ___________________________________________________________________________ can get aware of it. Also good relationship with the suppliers help them reduce their inventory costs and benefit on part of them whenever there is shortage of any raw material in the global as well as local markets. Sales Promotion Strategies: Merchandising, sales promotion and other aggressive marketing techniques are the rules of the game in this industry. Most common is the inserts practice that is always offered to the consumers by both the rivals. Also there is a practice of offering incentives to the big retailers and wholesalers in terms of volumes of sales made by them for the company. Product Portfolio: Since the lower segments of the tobacco industry is getting saturated therefore the major players of the industry require a set of healthy brands which not only bring in profit to them but are also strong brands as they would be ultimate instruments with which the major players will hit and capture the upper segments of the market.
24
Marketing Management
4.10.2
The suppliers of the industry have a considerably neutral bargaining power, since the pool of local suppliers for various materials is considerably large. As the industry has developed a lot through the years therefore more and more local suppliers have started there operations in the country and hence are providing raw material to the companies in the tobacco industry and hence reducing the cost of the tobacco products for the consumers. But still there are still some raw materials which are only provided by some specific manufactures. For example is the Packages Ltd. Is a supplier for Corrugated Cartons, Cigarette paper and Tipping paper from Germany, namely Tann paper and Wattens paper respectively.
4.10.4
The threat of new entrant in the tobacco industry is relatively less, on account of the capital investment involved in producing high quality cigarettes. However, there is an ever growing number of Mardan products who produce brands in the lower price categories and evade taxes, on account of which they are able to earn handsome margins. Also, as the government rules and regulations are high therefore, new competitors have to think a thousand times to come into this industry, as heavy taxes are imposed on the tobacco industry. An example of the heavy taxes imposed is that almost 68% of the revenue generated by KTC goes to the government as tax.
4.10.5
Exit Barriers:
As the tobacco industry involves high investment in the specialized assets and secondly it requires a major fixed cost to exit from the tobacco industry therefore the exit barriers are high and the industry is mildly unfavorable. Hence the competitors of the tobacco industry would have to strive hard to remain in the industry by striving for new marketing strategies that can help them to remain in the competition with its competitors. In short in this industry is a highly competitive.
25
Marketing Management
Centralized Warehousing
(3 Months Production Forecast)
Consumer
26
Marketing Management
Local company, therefore good and flexible Not having strong presence in urban areas relation ships with Inbound and Outbound channel members. Now will enjoy more experienced approach of World Giant Philip Morris. 35 Plus of Years of learning experience. Absence of premium products Trusted name by both the trade, and the end Restriction by the government over consumers advertising and promotional activities. They cannot target females, children under 18 or families in Pakistan Strong distribution network (Established Lack of Strategic Focus, which now hopefully relationship with distributors). improve after Philip Morris Acquisition. Maintaining and improving quality in products Market share deteriorating. and services High cash inflow. Severe Labor Union problem faced in one of the manufacturing unit. Strong R&D: Technology advancements for quality enhancements and knowledge engine Involvement in community services
Increasing level of taxes due to which cigarette prices increasing Niche market for flavored products 70% of total revenue taken by government yearly Potential market in urban areas specially of Counterfeit Products Sindh Increasing segment of young smokers
27
Marketing Management
Marketing Plan: Karachi Tobacco Company ___________________________________________________________________________ Higher Levels of Disposable Income Export sales
28
Marketing Management
29
Marketing Management
30
Marketing Management
Challengerr Boss
Cash-Cows Dogs
Prism
Karachi Tobacco as a whole business is at the moment in the moderate or even low growthhigh share stage, that is, it is nearing the star as well as dogs. It is a growing business with a moderately 2nd highest share in the market. The companys current strategy is to invest to build with emphasis on the segments A, B and C with its short term plans to capture segment A & B as well.
31
Marketing Management
32
Marketing Management
33
Marketing Management
34
Marketing Management
Marketing Plan: Karachi Tobacco Company ___________________________________________________________________________ Since majority of Karachis raw material is imported, it is subject to foreign exchange rates, import and excise duties. Provide consumers with quality products like KTC has always done, and attempt to decrease cost at the same time, especially in the face of such fierce competition based solely on price. Employee resistance to change toward new technology. Competitor having strong positioning in the Urban areas due to which segment A and B are left untouched. Unionized work force.
35
Marketing Management
Marketing Plan: Karachi Tobacco Company ___________________________________________________________________________ To restructure and reorganize functional departments, making them more attuned to each others activities.
Product
PRISM Challenger BOSS
Price
Rs. 70 Rs. 40 Rs. 15
Benchmark
Rs. 65 Rs. 40 Rs. 15
Since PRISM has been targeted for the upper middle and upper class therefore its priced highest. But the volumes that were coming from the market were simply too low for the brand to operate and now the management is planning to shelf it. Challenger fall at the lower pricing then PRISM.
36
Marketing Management
8.1 Product
30% Health Warning on packs (front and back) has been imposed since May 2012 but there is still no Tar / Nicotine ceilings set by the government, but it is already anticipated by both players. Both are working to gradually reduce Nicotine and Tar levels so that the consumer cannot perceive.
8.2 Advertising
Ads allowed in age controlled cinemas only and not on Television or Radio. Sampling is allowed at non-public events. No ads less than 50 meters from schools Models are allowed. Even in ads the age of model used must be over 40 years old. The size of Billboards is limited to max 1m with 20% health warning. After all these regulations, the communication to the consumers is limited to merchandizing only or through sales promotions. Concerts and other BTL activities are still available to communicate the message to the consumer.
37
Marketing Management
Product
Positioning Positioned at premium level, with the same international brand image. Position for good taste and Modern Approach. Positioned as hard, energetic and rugged.
38
Marketing Management
Positioning
Largest leader in providing a variety of strong taste brands Targeting consumers who want to enjoy highest standard of tobacco at affordable prices Being the only players providing far superior soft packs and Emperor packaging Providing the finest American blended tobacco Providing highest quality tobacco to the lower segment masses Available in every shop of every city
Advertising Program
Ads in magazines, kiosk for product trial Sales promotion, personalling selling Kiosk showing packaging features Products carrying int. ISO achievements Ads providing the association between the product and the lower segment masses, merchandising on outlets in the lower segement areas Merchandising on outlets, increased shelf share and incentives to the distributor, building an association of the distributor with the concerned brands
Easy Availability
How
By launching a new brand in B category and A category of the segment New markets and distribution network Evaluate each products performance, its potential and contribution to revenue. By induction of high speed packers
Who
By Marketing Department Sales & brand Management Marketing Director, Operations Director and Operational & Marketing Finance Team Operations Department
When
As early as possible ASAP Immediately to get rid of non performing SKUs. By Mid 2014
39
Marketing Management
Marketing Plan: Karachi Tobacco Company ___________________________________________________________________________ SKU. Improve Increase productivity by Factories and ASAP Productivity and proper maintenance Production planning Yield scheduling of equipment department and better production planning. Distribution More emphasis Sales Team, should Sales Department As soon as on secondary analyze the secondary GM Sales, possible sales to have data collected from NSM, DSM, ASM better ideas of SAP. sales Promotion Aggressive Have to give the Brand Management As soon as promotional merchandisers good Team. possible activities at promotional offer to merchandizing push the product into level the market and make it available. Kiosks building and distribution on a large scale. Consumers More emphasis should Brand Management ASAP interaction be given to urban area Sales and Marketing markets and attract Team more consumers through BTL activities like concerts, shows sponsoring Innovation and R&D New product Product Research & R&D and Marketing 2015 development in Development team Manager and Boutique along with Marketing Marketing Research products research team should focus on this developing trend in the market for boutique brands. Financial Cost Cutting in Financial records New advance 2014 various areas reviewing machinary and plant setup to cut the variable cost in the long run
40
Marketing Management
12.0 Conclusion
To sum up all the findings presented in this report in order to move to the position of a company that excels and wins in the dynamic marketing environment today from the position it is in today Karachi needs to take the strategic direction outlined by the following points. KTC must increase its product portfolio for Segment A & B. This is to eliminate the concern of being present in the market but not in visibility. These segments are profitable and KTC almost doesnt exist in these segments. Karachi needs to change and develop a better and clearer positioning statement for its products, which it lags now after the imposition of government regulations. For operational point, KTC needs to cut down its FME and improve in quality even further to excel and compete in the market.
41
Marketing Management