To Hold A Moonbeam:
Research Supplement A Missive to Harpists in Healthcare
A Missive to Harpists 1–4
Stroke Study to Launch 1, 5 How do you hold a Soon she is humming With a nod and a
Happy Music, Healthy Hearts 5 moonbeam in your along. I segue into smile, I walk slowly to
Arts & Health: New Publication 6 hand?1 “Bye, Bye Blackbird.” her. Tears well up in
On Our Research Drawing Board 6
Harp Therapist Research Course 7 I approach a room on
the third floor of a
hospital. The patient, a
“How did you know?”
she asks with a child’s
glee, “that’s my all-
her eyes as she tells
me that I will never
know how much she
THE BEDSIDE HARP™ REPORT woman in her 70s, is time favorite song!”
Edie Elkan, Founding Director Continued on page 2
sitting in a chair star- As I begin to take my
Diana V. Nolan, Editor ing into space. She leave five minutes 2009 MAR YTD
Neshaminy Medical Professional Center does not seem to notice later, she whispers, Number of patients
4802 Neshaminy Boulevard, Suites 3–4 that I am in her door- “Better than medi- in our host hospitals
who received live
Bensalem, PA 19020 way quietly strumming cine.” harp therapy ses-
654 1826
(PA) 215-752-7599; (NJ) 609-273-0068 my harp. I begin play- Playing softly in sions lasting five or
more minutes
ing, “You Are My the hall, I notice
Sunshine.” She turns to another patient in a Number of hours of
live harp therapy
look at me and breaks room at the end of
Report
delivered to pa-
tients, their loved
into a smile that seems the corridor. She ones, staff and
167.5 509.75
to radiate from the beckons me to doctors at our host
hospitals
very core of her being. come into her room.
patient’s residual ef- trol group. These day, more often when-
fects?” was inspired by findings demonstrate ever possible.
a study conducted in for the first time that Participants will also
Helsinki last year. In music listening dur-
that project, recorded ing the early post- Continued on page 5
Page 1
A Missive to Harpists in Healthcare
Continued from page 1 force. In 1975 he went out on a investigators in a research project
needs my visit today. I play for her limb when he published his semi- lasting ten years, involving 1,802
for about ten minutes. As I finish my nal work, The Relaxation Re- patients, and costing $2.4 million
song, she shares with me that she sponse. Here he provided convinc- dollars. This study provided evidence
must make a very important decision. ing data that interrupting one’s that “prayers offered by strangers had
I play now to the rhythm of her normal thought pattern for a period no effect on the recovery of people
words. Straightening her back and of 11 to 18 minutes twice a day who were undergoing heart sur-
taking a deep breath she suddenly promoted better healing—at the gery.”4 Worse yet, one of the parts of
declares, “You know, I feel ready to time, a fairly revolutionary stance the study indicated, in direct opposi-
do that.” to be taken by a man of science. It tion to the results of a number of
How do you hold these moon- began with Dr. Benson, a cardiolo- other smaller studies on the same
beams, these precious moments of gist, wondering why certain of his topic, that having someone you do
hope, clarity, joy, comfort and sooth- patients healed faster and experi- not know pray for you could actually
ing in your hand? How do you meas- enced far fewer complications than be harmful.
ure a smile, gauge a patient’s delight, others after heart surgery. He in- Overseen by top doctors, taking a
find the frequency of a moment of vestigated this curiosity by ques- decade to complete, this study was
healing that you know happened be- tioning all of them. What he found conducted in six hospitals, involved
cause you, playing your harp, walked was that those who healed more nearly 2,000 patients, and cost a cou-
right into the eye of the storm these quickly had one thing in com- ple of million dollars. And with all of
patients are living through? mon—they either prayed or medi- that, what was actually learned here?
We are harpists in healthcare, and tated regularly. The more he tested That we should never pray for any-
we must strive to put what we do to this, the more this was confirmed. one we do not know? That prayer
the same rigorous tests that scientists He termed this phenomenon the chains should be disbanded? Cer-
hold in high regard. And so we do. relaxation response (RR). tainly the good doctor would never
Or rather, we attempt to. Having par- I first had the pleasure of meet- suggest anything of the sort, yet after
ticipated in three formal studies over ing Dr. Benson in 2004. To my looking at the numbers and reading
the past seven years, we at Bedside amazement he told me he had the formal report on this study, one
Harp® know that the effects of harp heard about Bedside Harp and the could walk away with such conclu-
therapy can be measured using strict, work we are doing. He went on to sions.
quantitative scientific methods. But confirm what I believed—that as Our experience in researching the
not always and never completely. we walk through our hospitals, effects of harp therapy in many ways
Indeed, given the nature of our work, playing in hallways, patient rooms, mirrors that of Dr. Benson. In 2002–
such methods too often fall short of ICU, PACU and the ER, we are, in 03 Bedside Harp and Robert Wood
capturing the full story of all that oc- fact, evoking the relaxation re- Johnson University Hospital Hamil-
curs when a patient is given a session sponse—that moment of healing ton partnered on a project that asked
of harp therapy. proven in countless studies of his, if a 20-minute harp therapy session
In an article some years ago, to aid one’s ability to return to a would reduce the stress levels of pa-
Wayne B. Jonas, MD acknowledged, state of wellness. I took the oppor- tients actively receiving chemother-
“We have to have deep respect for tunity to tell him that when a pa- apy. To minimize our variables, I
the many ways of knowing in the tient relaxed into our music, I sus- was the only one who played, choos-
world. Science, although it is a pow- pected that it did not take 11 to 18 ing a repertoire of well-known classi-
erful way of discovery, is just one minutes for the RR to kick in—it cal, pop, oldies and folk melodies. If
way of knowing. Spirituality and reli- seemed to me to occur fairly in- the patient indicated their fondness
gious explorations are other ways of stantly. Dr. Benson agreed that our for a particular tune or requested a
knowing. Those are important ave- healing tones could very well favorite song, I played in and out of
nues into the inner world.”2 speed things up. it throughout the session, cradling
Dr. Herbert Benson, Director That was the good news. him or her with the music.
Emeritus of Massachusetts General The bad news was revealed in We used the widely recognized
Hospital’s Benson-Henry Mind Body March 2006,3 when the results of a Spielberger State-Trait Anxiety In-
Institute, was one of the first Ameri- large and lengthy study of the ventory (STAI) to collect our data.
can physicians to investigate the power of prayer were published. The STAI requires that the patient
properties of spirituality as a healing Dr. Benson was one of the chief answer questions relating to his/her
We put out a call to our graduate and intern harp therapists to find out what happy songs they play. Here’s what they gave us:
Put Another Nickel In Happy Song Deep in the Heart of Texas Pop Goes the Weasel
(Music, Music, Music) Jump in the River of Joy Country Roads Music Box Dancer
I Want a Girl, Just Like the Girl I’ve Got a River of Life Good Morning Starshine Getting to Know You
that Married Dear Old Dad How Much is that Doggy in the Here Comes the Sun Happy Days (TV Theme Song)
Mares Eat Oats and Window Ob la di, Ob la da Happy Days are Here Again
Does Eat Oats High Hopes Under the Boardwalk Hello My Baby
You Are My Sunshine I’m A Believer Rhythm of the Rain Oh Susanna
Begin the Beguine Always Look on the Bright Magic Moment I’d Like to Teach the World
La Paloma Side of Life You and Me and Rain to Sing
La Cucaracha Tiptoe Through the Tulips on the Roof Sing, Sing a Song
Ah Marie Three Little Fishies Jamaican Farewell Frère Jacques
Ode to Joy American Pie Yellow Bird The Itsy Bitsy Spider
Morning (from the Peer Gynt suite) Red Robin Heart and Soul B-I-N-G-O
When Irish Eyes are Smiling Don’t Fence Me In I Whistle a Happy Tune Build me up, Buttercup
Beer Barrel Polka This Land is Your Land Puttin’ on the Ritz Take Me Out to the
She’s Too Fat for Me Don’t Sit Under the Apple Tree Waltzing Matilda Ballgame
That’s Amore (with anyone else but me) Bye, Bye Blackbird She’ll be Comin’ Round
Singin’ in the Rain Viva la Compagnie What a Wonderful World the Mountain
My Favorite Things Yellow Rose of Texas In the Mood Joy to the World