i

Table of Contents
CRIMINAL LAW REVIEW BOOK I: REVISED PENAL CODE

Concept of Criminal Law

Theories 1. Magno v. Court of Appeals Enactment of Penal Statutes (Constitutional Limitations) 2. Romualdez v. COMELEC 3. Southern Hemisphere Engagement Network v. Anti-Terrorism Council 4. Estrada v. Sandiganbayan 5. People v. Dacuycuy 3 4 5 6 1

Characteristics of Criminal Law

Diplomatic Immunity 6. Minucher v. Court of Appeals 7. Liang v. People Retroactivity 8. People v. Lacson 9. Go v. Dimagiba Territoriality 10. US v. Bull 11. People v. Wong Cheng 12. US v. Look Chaw 13. People v. Lol-lo and Saraw 11 12 13 14 9 10 7 8

Article 3. Definition of a Felony

Dolo v. Culpa 14. People v. Ah Chong 15. People v. Oanis 15 16

ii

16. People v. Pugay 17. People v. Garcia 18. Garcia v. Court of Appeals 19. Manuel v. People 20. People v. Delim 21. Ivler v. San Pedro Mala in se v. Mala Prohibita 22. People v. Bayona 23. US v. Chico

17 18 19 20 21 22

23 24

Article 4. Criminal Liability

24. People v. Iligan 25. People v. Mananquil 26. Quinto v. Andres 27. People v. Quianzon 28. Urbano v. IAC Impossible Crimes 29. Intod v. Court of Appeals 30. People v. Domasian 30 31 25 26 27 28 29

Article 6. Stages of a Felony

Subjective and Objective Phase of a Felony 31. US v. Eduave Rape 32. People v. Orita 33. People v. Campuhan Theft 34. Valenzuela v. People Robbery 35. People v. Lamahang 36. People v. Salvilla Murder 36 37 35 33 34 32

iii

37. Epifanio v. People 38. People v. SyPio 39. People v. Ravelo Homicide 40. People v. Kalalo Estafa 41. US v. Dominguez Bribery 42. Pozar v. Court of Appeals Arson 43. People v. Hernandez 44. US v. Valdes

38 39 40

41

42

43

44 45

Article 10. Offenses Not Subject to the Provisions of the RPC

45. Ladonga v. People 46. People v. Simon 46 47

Article 11. Justifying Circumstances

Unlawful Aggression 47. Manaban v. Court of Appeals 48. People v. Alconga 49. People v. Genosa Test of Real and Imminent Peril 50. Senoja v. People Reasonable Necessity 51. Razon v. People 52. Eslabon v. People 53. People v. Luague 54. People v. De La Cruz 55. People v. Jaurigue Sufficient Provocation 56. People v. Oriente Defense of Property 57 52 53 54 55 56 51 48 49 50

iv

57. People v. Apolinar 58. US v. Bumanglag 59. People v. Narvaez Self-defense in Libel 60. People v. Chua-Hiong 61. People v. Pelayo State of Necessity 62. Tan v. Standard Vacuum Oil Co. Fulfillment of Duty and Exercise of Right 63. People v. Oanis Lawful Order 64. People v. Beronilla 65. People v. Barroga

58 59 60

61 62

63

64

65 66

Article 12. Exempting Circumstances

Insanity/Imbecility 66. People v. Ambal 67. People v. Puno 68. People v. Dungo 69. People v. Taneo Minority 70. People v. Estopano 71. Llave v. People 72. Jarco Marketing v. Court of Appeals 73. Guevarra v. Almodovar 74. People v. Sarcia 75. People v. Mantalaba Irresistible Force/Uncontrollable Fear 76. US v. Caballeros 77. US v. Exaltacion Accident 78. Pomoy v. People Absolutory Causes 79 77 78 71 72 73 74 75 76 67 68 69 70

79. People v. Doria

80

Article 13. Mitigating Circumstances

Lack of Intention to Commit So Grave a Wrong 80. People v. Ural 81. People v. Callet Sufficient Provocation 82. People v. Leonor 83. People v. Espina Immediate Vindication of a Grave Offense 84. People v. Diokno 85. US v. Ampar 86. People v. Pajares Passion of Obfuscation 87. People v. Adlawan 88. US v. Hicks 89. US v. De La Cruz Illness 90. People v. Crisostomo 91. People v. Javier Analogous Circumstances 92. People v. Navasca 93. Canta v. People 93 94 91 92 88 89 90 85 86 87 83 84 81 82

Article 14. Aggravating Circumstances

R.A. No. 8294 94. People v. Ladjaalam 95. Celino v. Court of Appeals Insult to Public Authorities 96. People v. Rodil 97. People v. Tac-an Dwelling 98. People v. Sto. Tomas 99 97 98 95 96

vi

99. People v. Apduhan Nighttime 100.People v. Garcia Evident Premeditation 101.US v. Manalinde 102.People v. Discalsota Treachery 103.US v. Baluyot 104.People v. Escote 105.People v. Caratao 106.People v. Sitchon 107.People v. Ancheta Ignominy 108.People v. Alfanta 109.People v. Dizon

100

101

102 103

104 105 106 107 108

109 110

Article 17. Principals

Conspiracy 110.People v. Pelagio 111.People v. Federico 112.People v. Aguilos Principals by Inducement 113.US v. Indanan 114.People v. KiichiOmine Principals by Indispensable Cooperation 115.People v. Montealegre 116.US v. Lim Buanco 117.People v. Madali 116 117 118 114 115 111 112 113

Article 18. Accomplices

118.People v. Tamayo 119.People v. Realon 120.People v. Doctolero 119 120 121

vii

121.People v. Watimar

122

Article 19. Accessories

Profiting from the Effects of the Crime 122.Mendoza v. People 123.Taer v. Court of Appeals P.D. No. 1612 124.Dizon-Pamintuan v. People 125.Tan v. People Assisting the Principal to Escape 126.People v. Talingdan 127.Vino v. People 127 128 125 126 123 124

Article 48. Complex Crimes

Compound (DelitoCompuesto) 128.People v. Pincalin 129.People v. Toling 130.People v. Tabaco Complex Crime Proper (DelitoComplejo) 131.Enrile v. Salazar 132.People v. Valdez 133.People v. Garcia 134.People v. Alfeche 135.Batulanon v. People Continued Crime (DelitoContinuado) 136.People v. De Leon 137.Defensor-Santiago v. Garchitorena 138.Gamboa v. Court of Appeals 139. People v. Penas 140.People v. Madrigal-Gonzales 137 138 139 140 141 132 133 134 135 136 129 130 131

Indeterminate Sentence Law

141.People v. Bon 142

viii

142.People v. Simon

143

Extinction of Criminal Liability

Pardon and Amnesty 143.People v. Patriarca Prescription 144.Domingo v. Sandiganbayan 145.People v. Pacificador 146.Sermonia v. Court of Appeals 147.Romualdez v. Marcelo Probation Law 148.Llamado v. Court of Appeals 149.Bala v. Martinez 150.Salgado v. Court of Appeals 151.Francisco v. Court of Appeals 152.Moreno v. COMELEC 153.Colinares v. People 149 150 151 152 153 154 145 146 147 148 144

Articles 100-113. Civil Liability

Subsidiary Liability 154.Basilio v. Court of Appeals 155.PRBLI v. Mangawang Persons Civilly Liable for Felonies 156.Carpio v. Doroja What Civil Liability Includes 157.Heirs of Raymundo Castro v. Bustos Extinction of Civil Liability 158.People v. Bayotas 159 158 157 155 156

END