9 Introduction 9 Buckling g Resistance 9 Buckling Curves 9 Design Procedure 9 Comparison of BS5950 and EC3 9 Example E l Compression C i Member M b
Introduction
C Compression i members b (columns ( l and d struts) t t ) subject bj t to t Axial compression only No bending In practice, practice real columns are subject to Eccentricities of axial loads Transverse forces Compression members must be checked for Section resistance Buckling g resistance
Stocky y Columns
The characteristics of stocky columns are:
Slender Columns
Slender columns present a quasi buckling behaviour Euler critical stress
2E f cr = 2 = Lcr i
where, is the columns slenderness i is the radius of gyration Lcr is the buckling length
Lcr
Buckling of Strut
f cr = f y , = 1
2E fy = 2 1
1 = E f = 93.9 y
= 235 f y
Where, 1 is equal to 86 for steel Grade S275 76 for steel Grade S355
10
N Ed N b , Rd
Compression buckling resistance Nb,Rd: For Class 1, 2 & 3
N b , Rd N b , Rd
Af y = M1 Aeff f y = M1
For F Cl Class 4
M1 = 1.00, , in NA to SS EN 1993-1
11
Buckling g Curves
=0
Non-dimensional slenderness
12
Buckling g Curves
Column C l strength t th is i defined d fi d by b a reduction factor applied to the yield strength fy
The European p buckling g curves p plot Reduction factor versus Non-dimensional slenderness ratio, p factor, , For different imperfection
13
i 1 Aeff f y N cr
2 EI
Lcr
2
14
Reduction Factor
The curves, the reduction factor, can be expressed mathematically as:
=
1 1. 0
+ 2
= 0.5(1 + ( 0.2) + )
Where,
15
Imperfection p Factor
Imperfection factor a depends on : the shape of the column cross-section the direction of buckling (y or z axis) the fabrication process (hot-rolled, welded or coldformed) Imperfection factors given in Table 6.1
Table 6.1: Imperfection factors for buckling curves
a0 0.13
a 0.21
b 0.34
c 0.49
d 0.76
16
17
18
19
20
21
7. Select appropriate buckling curve and determine imperfection factor 8. Calculate buckling reduction factor
22
N b , Rd
Af y = M1 Aeff f y = M1
N b , Rd
10. Check
N Ed N b , Rd
23
Af y
M0
24
EC 3
Where, pc is the compressive strength, strength pc is based on strut curve, slenderness & design strength py pcs is the value of pc for a reduced slenderness of Aeff Ag Ag is the gross cross-section area of the section Aeff is the effective cross-section area
1 .0
2 = 0,51 + 0,2 +
Af y N cr
L = cr i
1 1
25
6.0m
26
Section Properties p
BS 5950
Try 254 x 254 x 89 UC. D = 260.4 mm B = 255.9mm d = 200.3 mm t = 10.5 mm T = 17.3 mm rx = 11.2 cm ry = 6.52 cm Ag = 114 cm2
Eurocode 3
Try 254 x 254 x 89 UC. h = 260.4 mm b = 255.9 mm tw = 10.5 mm tf = 17.3 mm r = 12.7 mm d= 200.3mm iy = 11.2 cm iz = 6.52 cm A = 114 cm2 E = 210000 N/mm2
27
Cross-Section Classification
BS 5950
For steel grade S275, T = 17.3 17 3 mm > 16mm py = 265 N/mm2 (Table 9 ) Cross sectional classification:
= 275 / p y = 275 / 265 = 1.02
Eurocode 3
For S275 Steel, since nominal thickness t = 17.3 17 3 mm t 40mm yield strength fy = 265 N/mm2 (EN 10025)
= 235 / f y = 235 / 265 = 0.942
(Table 11)
Outstand element of compression flange (rolled section), b/T = 7.41 < 9 Class 1 Plastic Flange is class 1 Plastic.
28
Cross-Section Classification
BS 5950
Web (axial compression), Since d/t = 19.40 19 40 40 Class 3 semisemi compact Web is class 3 semi-compact. Section is Class 3.
Eurocode 3
Web subject to compression, cw = d = 200.3 mm
cw 200.3 = = 19.08 10.5 tw
Web W b is i class l 1 under d compression. i Section is class 1. P ti l factors Partial f t for f resistance: it M0 = 1.0 M1 = 1.0 10
29
Section Resistance
BS 5950
No cross-sectional resistance.
E Eurocode d 3
Cross-sectional resistance: Th design The d i resistance i of f the h cross-section i for f uniform compression is,
N c , Rd = N c , Rd = Af y
M0
Af fy
M0
30
Member Buckling g
BS 5950
Effective length of the pin-ended column: LEY = 6000 mm Compressive Strength: y-y axis(the minimum axis) Slenderness ratio, y = Table bl 23 Thickness < 40 mm F rolled For ll d H-section H ti buckling b kli about b t y-y axis i strut curve (c)
LEy ry = 6000 = 92.0 6.52(10)
Eurocode 3
Member buckling resistance: Buckling length, Effective length = Lcr = 6000 mm Flexural buckling resistance: Th resistance The it to t flexural fl l buckling b kli about b t the th axis with the smallest is the critical case. The design buckling resistance is, Af y N b , Rd = (Class 1, 2 & 3)
M1
1
+
2
but 1.0
2
]
31
Member Buckling g
BS 5950 Eurocode 3
L 1 = cr N cr i 1 1 = 93.9 = 93.9 0.942 = 88.5
Af y
L 1
6000 1
Pc = Agpc = 11.4 x 136.96 = 1549.98 kN The ultimate load that can be imposed on the column 1549.98 KN.
L 1
6000 1
32
Member Buckling g
BS 5950
Table 6.2,
Eurocode 3
h 260.4 = = 1.018 < 1.2, t f = 17.3mm 100mm & S 275 steel b 255.9
buckling curve about major axis (y-y) to consider is b. buckling curve about minor axis (z-z) to consider is c. Table 6.1, For buckling curve b imperfection factor = 0.34 For buckling curve c imperfection factor = 0.49 Buckling about major axis (y-y),
y = 0.5 1 + ( y 0.2) + y 2
= 0.5 1 + 0.34(0.605 0.2) + 0.605 2 = 0.75 1 1 y = = = 0.84 < 1.00 2 2 2 2 0.75 + 0.75 0.605 y + y y
33
Member Buckling g
BS 5950 Eurocode 3
Buckling about minor axis (z-z
z = 0 .5 1 + ( z 0 .2 ) + z 2
= 0.5 1 + 0.49 (1.04 0.2) + 1.04 2 = 1.25 1 1 z = = = 0.51 < 1.00 2 2 2 2 1.25 + 1.25 1.04 z + z z
The ultimate load that can be imposed on the column l 1585 1585.84 84 KN. KN
34
35
36
Introduction
Sl d structural t t l elements l t Slender loaded in a stiff plane tend to fail by y buckling g in a more flexible plane (out-of-plane buckling) Clamp at root
Unloaded ii position
38
Plan
9 End Supports Twisting and lateral deflection prevented. Free to rotate both in the plane of the web and on plan. plan
39
Cross-section of the free end of the cantilever that undergoes LTB when subjected to MAJOR axis moment
40
41
Being g free to move, , the compression p elements would tend to move laterally (the same lateral movement if the beam is subjected to minor axis moment).
However, , the tension flange g and web are reluctant to move, , creating resistance to lateral movement. As such, the crosssection twists when it deflects, with the tension flange and web dragging behind. behind
42
minor axis (z-z axis) bending CHS, SHS, circular or square bar fully laterally restrained beams
LT < 0.2 for welded sections LT < 0.4 for hot rolled sections
43
Buckling g Resistance
Ch Checks k should h ld b be carried i d out t on all ll unrestrained t i d segments t of f beams (between the points where individual lateral restraint exists). )
44
Buckling g Resistance
Diagram of lateral torsional buckling on an I-section beam under load from cross-beam
Lateral restraint
Lateral restraint
Lateral restraint
45
46
Buckling g Resistance
Each segment between intermediate lateral restraints or between the end supports of a member subject to major axis bending should be verified against lateral torsional buckling using the following:
M Ed 1.0 M b , Rd
Where, MEd is the bending moment design effect. Mc,Rd is the design lateral torsional buckling resistance of a cross-section
47
Buckling g Resistance
Eurocode 3 design approach for lateral torsional buckling is analogous l t to th the column l buckling b kli The design buckling resistance moment, moment Mb,Rd of a laterally unrestrained beam should be taken as :
Wyf y M b,Rd = LT M1
where h , LT is i the th reduction d ti f t for factor f LTB Wy is the appropriate section modulus Wy = Wpl,y for Class 1 and 2 cross cross-sections sections l Wy = Wel,y for Class 3 cross-sections Wy = Weff,y for Class 4 cross-sections For stocky beams, LT = 1.0 (LT = 0.2 or 0.4)
48
LT =
1 LT +
2 LT
2 LT
1.0 10
LT = W y f y / M cr
0.2 is a limiting value
aLT is an imperfection factor from Table 6.3 Mcr is the elastic critical moment for LTB
50
51
LT
0.2
Non-dimensional slenderness LT
52
LT =
1 LT +
2 LT
2 LT
1.0 2 1 / LT
Equation (6.57)
LT ,0 = 0.4 (rolled sections, hot finished and cold formed hollow sections) = 0.2 0 2 (welded sections) = 0.75 (rolled sections, hot finished and cold formed hollow sections) = 1.00 (welded sections)
53
LTB Curves & Imperfection p Factors Rolled Sections or Equivalent Welded Sections
Recommended values for lateral torsional buckling curves for general cross-section (using equation 6.57)
Table 6.5: Recommended lateral torsional buckling curves for cross-sections Cross-section Rolled I-sections Welded I-sections Limits h/b 2 h/b > 2 h/b 2 h/b > 2 Buckling curve b c c d
54
LTB Curves & Imperfection p Factors Rolled Sections or Equivalent Welded Sections
In NA to SS EN 1993-1-1: 2010, Table 6.5 should be replaced with the following table: Cross-section
Limits
h/b 2
Buckling curve
b c d d
Rolled I- and H- sections, and hot-finished hollow sections Angles (for moments in the major principal plane) l ) and d other th hot-rolled h t ll d sections ti Welded sections and cold-formed hollow sections ti
h/b 2
c d
55
Comparison p of Curves
9 Comparison p between g general curves and curves for rolled, , hot-finished and cold-formed sections
LT
Reduction factor
0.4
Non-dimensional slenderness
LT , 0
56
Non-Dimensional Slenderness
Calculate lateral torsional buckling slenderness:
LT =
Wy f y M cr
57
Effect of Slenderness
Stocky St k b beams (LT <0,4) 0 4) unaffected by lateral torsional buckling g Slender beams(LT > 1.2) resistance close to theoretical elastic critical moment Mcr. Intermediate slenderness adversely affected by inelasticity and geometric i imperfections. f ti
M Mpl
1,0
Stocky y
0
Intermediate
1,0
Slender
LT= M pl
Mcr
58
Mcr =
Includes:
EI l
2
z w 2 cr z
L GI EI
2 cr 2
T z
0 .5
Lateral flexural stiffness EIz T i l and Torsional d warping i stiffness iff GIt and d EIw where, G = shear modulus, IT = torsional constant, constant Iw = warping constant, Iz = minor axis second moment of area Lcr = buckling length of the beam
59
Mcr = C1
EI l
2
z w 2 cr z
L GI EI
2 cr 2
T z
0.5
60
The elastic critical moment for a beam under uniform bending moment is
M cr =
EI z GI t 1 +
2 EI w
L2 GI t
The elastic critical moment (mid-span moment) for a beam with t a central ce t point po t load o d is s
M cr
2 EI w 4,24 EI z GI t 1 + 2 = L L GI t
M
9 which is increased from the basic (uniform moment) case by a factor C1=4.24/ = 1.365
61
= 1.0 corresponds to the most severe case loading condition of constant bending moment)
C1 1.0
(C1
62
where is the ratio of the end moments ( (defined in the following g table) )
63
64
C1 = 1.88 1.4+0.522
65
66
67
LT =
Wy f y M cr
68
M Ed M b, Rd
1.0
69
fy M1
Mb = PbSx Mb = PbZx
but LT 1,0 10
2 LT = 0,51 + LT LT 0,2 + LT
LT =
Wy f y M cr
70
BS 5950
Rigorous method Mb = PbSx 2 Mb = PbZx Mb = PbSx,eff Mb = PbZx,eff for Class 4 For rariable moment or unequal end d moment: t Mx Mb/mLT and Mx Mcx Where, Pb determined by LT = uv(w)0.5LE/ry or for Class 1 & f for Class Cl 3
2 EI z k I w (kL ) GI t M cr = C1 + 2 2 (kL ) k w I z EI z
2 2
71
6m
72
Section Classification
BS 5950
Section Classification (BS, Table 11): Flange: g Outstand element of compression flange, Rolled section. py = 265 N/mm2 (T<40mm, Table 9)
275 = py
275 = 265 = 1.02
EC 3
Section Classification (EC, Table 5.2): Flange: Stress distribution in parts (compressive positive) fy = 275 N/ N/mm2 (T<16mm) (T 16 )
=
235 fy
235 275
= 0.92
73
Member Properties p
BS 5950
Grade S275 Steel Section: 533x210x138 UB E = 205,000 N/mm2 py = 265 N/mm2 (T > 16 mm, Table 9) b/T = 4.53 d/t = 32.4 t = 14.7 14 7 mm T = 23.6 mm D = 549.1 mm Sx = 3610x103 mm3 Zx = 3140x103 mm3 Ix = 86100x104 mm4 ry = 46.8 mm
EC 3
Grade S275 Steel Section: 533x210x138 UB E = 210,000 N/mm2 py = 275 N/mm2 (T < 40mm, Table 3.1) cf/tf = 3.68 cw/tw = 32.41 tw = 14.7 14 7 mm tf = 23.6 mm h = 549.1 mm Wy,pl = 3610x103 mm3 Wy,el = 3140x103 mm3 Iy = 86100x104 mm4 iz = 46.8 mm
74
EC 3
Dead load = 40 kN/m Imposed load = 20 kN/m
w = 1.35(40 ) + 1.5(20 ) = 84 kN / m
M max
wl 2 = 8 2 ( 88)(6 ) = 8 = 396kNm
Vmax =
wl 2 (88)(6) = 2 = 264kNm
M max
wl 2 = 8 2 ( 84 )(6 ) = 8 = 378kNm
Vmax =
wl 2 (84)(6) = 2 = 252kNm
Mmax
Vmax
75
Section Classification
BS 5950
Web: Web of an I-, , H- or Box section, , neutral axis at mid-depth.
d = 32.4 80 = 80(1.02 ) = 81.6 t
EC 3
Web: parts (compressive ( p Stress distribution in p positive)
C w = 549.1 2(23.6 ) 2(12.7 ) = 476.5mm
76
EC 3
Elastic Critical Lateral Torsional Buckling Moment Determination:
M cr = C1
EI z I w
2
Lcr
Iz
Lcr GI T 2 EI z
2
1 2
LT = uv W
W = 1.0
u = 0.873 x = 25
L = E ry
= (1.132)
(6000)2
2
267 x10 (6000) (81000) 250 x10 + 4 2 4 ( ) 3860 x 10 210 , 000 3860 x 10
10 4
( (
) )
1 2
= 1007kNm
LT =
Wy f y M cr
= 0.99 LT , 0 = 0.4
Must M check h kf for LTB LTB.
77
EC 3
= 1
2 0.25
LT = uv W
= (0.873)(0.81)(128 ) 1.0 = 91
pb = 141 N / mm 2
]
]
LT =
=
M b = pb S x
LT + LT LT 1
2
1.0
1 .0
78
EC 3
m LT = 0.925
M1
(M1 = 1.0)
Mx
396kNm
79
Shear
BS 5950
Shear Check (BS, Clause 4.2.3): For rolled I-, H- and Channel sections, load parallet to web.
Av = t D
EC 3
Shear Check (EC, Clause 6.2.6): For rolled I and H sections, load parallel to web.
Av = A 2bt f + (t w + 2 r )t f hwt w
= (14.7)(549.1) = 8072mm 2
Pv = 0.6 p y Av
V pl , Rd
fy Av 3 =
M0
( M 1 = 1.0)
80
Shear
BS 5950
High or Low Shear :
0.6 Pv > Fv
0.6(1283 ) = 770 kN > 264 kN
EC 3
High or Low Shear Check :
0.5(V pll , Rd ) > Vmax
0.5(1342 ) = 671kN > 252 kN
No N reduction d ti of f Moment M t resistance it is i required. Shear Buckling Check: Shear buckling need not be considered provided hw 72 (for unstiffened web)
tw [549.1 2(23.6)] (0.92) 72 14.7 (1.0)
34 .14 66 .24
81
Moment
BS 5950
Moment Capacity : For Class 1 section:
EC 3
Bending Resistance Determination :
M c , y , Rd = W pl , y f y
( M 0 = 1.0)
M c = pySx
M0
= 396kNm
General(BS, Clause 4.2.5.1): Mc should h ld be b limited li it d to t 1.2p 1 2 yZ in i the th case of f a simply supported beam.
1.2 p y Z = 1.2(265)(3140 x103 )(10 6 )
= 999 kNm > M c = 957 kNm
82
Deflection
BS 5950
Deflection Check (BS, Table 8): Assuming beam is carrying plaster or other b i l finishes. brittle fi i h
Limit =
6000 L = 360 360 = 16.7 mm
4
EC 3
Deflection Check (Singgapor National Annex): Assuming beam is carrying plaster or other brittle finishes.
Limit =
L 360
6000 360 = 16.7 mm =
83
EC3
Lateral Torsional Buckling Resistance Determination For rolled section or equivalent welded section:
LT , 0 = 0.4 = 0.75
= 0.99
3.1 >
pb = 134 N / mm 2
Use buckling curve c (from Table 6.5) LT = 0.49 (from Table 6.3)
84
EC 3
LT = 0.5 1 + LT ( LT LT , 0 ) + LT 2
]
]
= 484 kNm
396kNm k
= 0.5 1 + 0.49(0.99 0.4 ) + 0.75(0.99) 2 = 1.01 1.0 1 LT = 1 2 2 LT + LT LT 2 LT 1.0 1 = 1 1.01 + 1.012 0.75(0.99) 2 2 (0.99)
= 0.65
1.0,1.02
M b , Rd = LT
Wy f y
M1
LTB Check is satisfied. R ll d section Rolled ti method th d gives i a less l conservative result.
85
86
Introduction
Members subject to combined bending and compression are also l known k as beam-columns. b l Members subject to axial load and moments should be checked for:
Section capacity (Strength) buckling capacity (Buckling-flexural and LTB ) Annex A A Annex B
For members subject to combined bending and tension, the effects of tension can be safely ignored in the check for buckling capacity.
87
88
Cross-Section Behaviour
No overall buckling Axial compression reduces moment resistance
Where, MN,Rd N Rd is the design plastic moment resistance reduced due to the presence of axial force NEd.
No allowance necessary if
89
90
91
92
M y , Ed M z , Ed + 1 M N , z , Rd M N , y , Rd
where
My
Type yp of Section
Mz
2 2
5n 1 2
N Ed and N pl , Rd = N pl , Rd M0
93
where a =
( A 2bt f ) A
0.5
M0
hwt w f y
for N Ed >
M0
where a =
( A 2bt f ) A
0.5 05
94
A 2bt a = 0.5 0 5 for hollow sections w A where A 2bt f aw = 0.5 for welded box sections A
M pl , z , Rd M N , z , Rd = M pl , z , Rd 1 0.5a f A 2ht a 0.5 for hollow sections = f A where A 2ht w a f = 0.5 for welded box sections A
95
M N , y , Rd = M pl , y , Rd (1 n 2 )
Reduced moment resistance about zz axis
M N , z , Rd = M pl , z , Rd (1 n 2 )
N Ed n= N pl , Rd
96
N Ed M y , Ed M z , Ed + + 1 N Rd M y , Rd M z , Rd
Where N Rd = Where,
Af y
M0
, M y , Rd =
Wel , y f y
M0
, M z , Rd =
Wel , z f y
M0
This check can also be used as a conservative approximation for Class 1 & 2 cross-sections where NRd, My,Rd and Mz,Rd are defined as follows:
N Rd =
Af y
M0
, M y , Rd =
W pl , y f y
M0
, M z , Rd =
W pl , z f y
M0
97
N Ed M y , Ed + N Ed eN y M z , Ed + N Ed eN z + + 1 N Rd M y , Rd M z , Rd
Where, , N Rd =
Aeff f y
M0
, M y , Rd =
Weff , y f y
M0
, M z , Rd =
Weff , z f y
M0
eN = shift in the relevant centroidal axis when the effective cross section is subjected to compression only.
98
My Mz Vz Vy
f yr = (1 ) f y
2VEd 1 where = V pl , Rd Av ( f y / 3 ) V pl , Rd =
2
M0
99
100
Interaction Equations q
Combinations of NEd and MEd As a proportion of corresponding member resistance, NRd and MRd NRd determined as for columns in axial compression MRd determined as for beams in bending Biaxial bending is also including in EC 3
101
Interaction Equations q
For Class 1, 2 & 3, both relationships must be satisfied: Biaxial bending g combined with flexural buckling g about major axis (y-y axis):
M y , Ed M z , Ed N Ed + k yy + k yz 1 N b , y , Rd M b , Rd M z , Rd
Eqn. (6.61)
Biaxial bending combined with flexural buckling about minor i axis i (z-z ( axis): i )
M y , Ed M z , Ed N Ed + k zy + k zz 1 N b , z , Rd M b , Rd M z , Rd
Eqn. (6.62)
102
103
Interaction Equations q
For Class 4, both relationships p must be satisfied: Biaxial bending combined with flexural buckling about major axis (y-y axis): M y , Ed + M y , Ed M z , Ed + M z , Ed N Ed + k yy + k yz 1 N b , y , Rd M b , Rd M z , Rd
Biaxial bending combined with flexural buckling about minor i axis i (z-z ( axis): i )
M y , Ed + M y , Ed M z , Ed + M z , Ed N Ed + k zy + k zz 1 N b , z , Rd M b , Rd M z , Rd
My,Ed, Mz,Ed = moments due to shift of the centroidal axis for class 4 sections.
M y,Ed = N Ed eN y , M z,Ed = N Ed eN z
104
105
k factors-Appendix B
Table B.1:Interaction factors kij for members not susceptible to torsional deformations
Interaction Type of factors sections Design assumptions elastic cross-sectional properties plastic cross-sectional properties class 3, class 4 class 1, class 2
kyy
I-sections RHS-sections
otherwise C my 1 + 0.8 N Ed N b , y , Rd
kyz kzy
0.6kzz 0.6kyy
N Ed C mz 1 + (2 0.6) z N b z Rd , , for z 1.0
otherwise
kzy
I-sections
kzz
otherwise C mz 1 + 1.4 N Ed N b , z , Rd
RHS-sections
For I- and H- sections and rectangular hollow sections under axial compression and uniaxial bending, kyz may be 0.
106
107
108
k Factors - Appendix pp B
k values as a function of cm Tables B1 & B2 Figures D2 D8 of SCI Concise Guide, e.g.
kyy for Class 1 & 2 Sections
N di Non-dimensional i l slenderness l d
109
Maximum values according to Annex B Class 1 & 2 1.8 cmy 0.6 kzz 0.6 kyy 2.4 cmz Class 3 1.6 cmy 1.0 kzz 0.8 kyy 1.6 cmz
110
EC3 Procedures
Determine Nb,y,Rd [6 3 1 1(3)] b Rd, Nb,z,Rd b Rd [6.3.1.1(3)] Mb,Rd [6.3.2.1(3)] Mcb,z,Rd [6.2.5] cb z Rd cmy , cmz , and cmLT based on shape of bending moment diagrams [Table B3] Select figure for k factors based on section type cross-section classification Determine k factors based on equivalent moment factor, cm non-dimensional di i l slenderness l d ratio i NEd / Nb,Rd [Table B1 or B2]
111
Verify for biaxial bending combined with flexural buckling about b t minor i axis i (6.3.3(4)) (6 3 3(4))
M y , Ed + M y , Ed M z , Ed + M z , Ed N Ed + k zy + k zz 1 N b , z , Rd M b , Rd M z , Rd
Eqn. (6.62)
112
113
Example 3: Buckling resistance of UC subjected to compression & moments P f Perform buckling b kli check h k on a steel t l column l using i 203 203x203x60 203 60 UC section ti Nc that is subjected to a compressive load of 380kN, linearly varying major My,1 & minor o axis a s moments o e s with the ee end d moments o e s be being g My, = 82.0kNm, 8 0 , y1 My,2 = 41.0kNm & Mz,1 = 35.4kNm, Mz,2 = 17.7kNm. The steel grade used is S275 and the effective length is Lcr,y = Lcr,z = L = 3.0m.
Determine design strength and section classification as per Example BC-1.
My,1= 82.0kNm My,2= 41.0kNm Mz,1= 35.4kNm
Mz,1 L
Mz, z 2= 17.7kNm
Segment Length
Segment length for y-y buckling Lcr,y = 3.0m Segment length for z-z buckling Lcr,z = 3.0m Segment length for LTB Lcr,z = 3.0m 3 0m
My,2 Mz,2 Nc
114
h 209.6 209 6 = = 1.02 < 1.2 & b 205.8 t f = 14.2mm < 100mm
Use buckling curve b = 0.34
2 y = 0.5[1 + ( y 0.2) + y ] = 0.607 1 y = = 0.931 0 931 2 2 y + y y
a0
b
0.34
0.13 0.21
0.49 0.76
N b , y , Rd = y
Af y
M1
115
z =
z =
1 z +
2 z 2 z
= 0.744 0 744
a0
b
0.34
0.13 0.21
0.49 0.76
N b , z , Rd = z
Af y
M1
116
L2 cr GI T + M cr = C1 2 2 Lcr I z EI z 05 0.5 2 * 210000 * 2060 * 10 4 0.197 * 1012 30002 * 81000 * (47.2 * 10 4 ) 6 * 10 = 1700kNm = 2.70 * + 2 4 2 4 * 210000 * (2060 * 10 ) 3000 2060 * 10
2 EI z I w
0.5
41.0 C1 = 1.88 1.40 + 0.52 2 = 2.71 82.0 Since C1 2.70, Use C1 = 2.70
Limits
Buckling curve a b
b
0.34
c
0.49
d
0.76
LT =
Wy f y M cr
W pl , y f y M cr
Imperfection factor LT
LT =
1 LT +
2 LT
2 LT
= 0.971
M b , Rd = LT
Wy f y
M1
117
M1
my =
118
Ned My,Ed Mz,Ed Nb,y,Rd Nb,z,Rd Mb,Rd Mz,Rd kyy kyz kzy kzz (kN) (kNm) (kNm) (kN) (kN) (kNm) (kNm) 380 82.0 82 0 35.4 35 4 1956 1563 175 83.8 83 8 0 0.415 415 0 0.566 566 0 0.892 892 0 0.943 943
M y , Ed M z , Ed N Ed 380 82.0 35.4 + k yy + k yz = + 0.415 * + 0.566 * = 0.628 1 N b , y , Rd M b , Rd M z , Rd 1956 175 83 8 83.8 M y , Ed M z , Ed N Ed 380 82.0 35.4 + k zy + k zz = + 0.892 + 0.943 = 1.06 > 1 N b , z , Rd M b , Rd M z , Rd 1563 175 83 8 83.8
119
120
Plate Girder
9 Shear Sh buckling b kli 9 Initial Sizing 9 Web Design 9 Comparison p of BS 5950 and EC 3 9 Tension Field Action 9 Example Plate Girder
121
Plate Girder
3 plates, fillet welded to form I-section A
End post
load
Flange
Transverse T stiffeners
W b Web
122
123
h t
w w
31
where =
235 fy
124
Initial Sizing g
1) ) span p to depth p ratio: Recommended span-to-depth ratios for plate girders in buildings
Application p y pp beams with Simply-supported concrete deck (composite or noncomposite) Continuous beams with concrete deck Simply-supported p y pp crane g girders Span-to-depth ratio 12-20
15 20 15-20 10-15
Deeper girder is preferred for heavier loads and smaller deflections and a shallower girder is preferred for lighter loads.
125
Initial Sizing g
2) ) Flange g area An initial flange area may be established on the assumption that bending moment is carried by flanges alone: Af = Mmax/hwfy Wh Where, Af Mmax hw fy
is the area of each flange is the maximum bending moment is the height of the web is the flange yield strength
126
Initial Sizing g
3) ) flange g width The flange width bf will usually in the range h/5> bf > h/3 Where, h is the clear depth between flanges.
127
Initial Sizing g
4) ) Proportioning p g of flanges g The required q flange g area Af and flange g width bf are now known. Generally proportion flanges to remain non-slender. Class 3 slenderness limit (outstand flange): cf/tf < 14 Class 2 slenderness limit (outstand flange): cf/tf < 10 cf is i the h flange fl outstand d width id h tf is the flange thickness 05 = (235/fy)0.5
128
Initial Sizing g
4) ) Proportioning p g of flanges g An initial flange g area may y be established on the assumption p that bending moment is carried by flanges alone, then:
M Rd = A f fy
M0
hw M Ed
or
A f = 2b f t f
M Ed M0 f yhw
129
Web Design g
5) ) Proportioning p g of web Web depth p is known. Generally y also p proportion p webs to remain non-slender. Class 3 slenderness limit (web in bending): cw/tw < 124 Class 2 slenderness limit (web in bending): cw/tw < 83 cw is the flange outstand width tw is i the h flange fl thickness hi k = (235/fy)0.5
130
Web Design g
6) Optimum depth Define terms:
= ratio of web depth/thickness = hw/tw Af =area of f one flange fl Wpl = plastic modulus based on the flanges only = Afhw=MRd/fy Af = Wpl/hw Aw = area of web = hwtw = hw2/ A = total area = Af+Aw=2 Wpl/hw+ hw2/
dh w
=0
hw = W pl
3
or hw = 3
M Ed
fy
131
Web Design g
7) Minimum thickness of web To prevent the compression flange buckling in the plane of the web, the following criterion should be met:
hw E k f yf t AW A fc
The value of the factor k should be taken as follows: k=0 0.3, 3 where plastic hinge rotation is utilized k=0.4, where the plastic moment resistance is utilized k=0.55, 0.55, where the elastic moment resistance is utilized
132
Web Design g
Stocky webs: For unstiffened
hw 72 tw
Slender webs (beyond the above limits, for unstiffened or stiffened webs):
For o st stiffened e ed
hw 31 k tw
Vb , Rd = Vbw, Rd + Vbf , Rd
f yw hw t w
3 M 1
Failure by yielding
V pl , Rd = Av ( f y / 3 )
M0
133
Web Design g
Where, Where Vbw,Rd is the design resistance contribution from the web Vbf,Rd is i th the design d i resistance i t contribution t ib ti from f the th flanges
Vbw, Rd = w
f yw hw t w 3 M 1
Reduction factor for the shear buckling
Vbf , Rd = w
b f t f f yf c M 1
M 1 Ed M f , Rd
134
F webs For b with ith transverse t stiffeners tiff at t supports t only; l Or for webs with intermediate transverse or longit dinal stiffeners or both; longitudinal The factor w should be obtained from Table 5.1 or Figure 5.2:
135
1.076
Figure 5.2: shear buckling factor w 1 Rigid end post 2 Non-rigid end post 3 Range of recommended
136
End Supports pp
Figure 5.1 shows various end supports for girders:
137
Web Slenderness
The web slenderness w may be taken as: a) transverse trans erse stiffeners at supports s pports only: onl :
w =
h 86.4t
In which k is the minimum shear buckling coefficient for the web panel.
Shear buckling coefficient k: k = 5.34 + 4.00(hw/a)2 when a/hw 1 k = 5.34 5 34 + 4 4.00(h 00(hw/a)2 when a/hw 1 a = transverse stiffener spacing; hw = web height
138
Flange g Contribution
When the flange resistance is not completely utilized for moment (MEd < Mf,Rd), the flange contribution should be obtained as:
Vbf , Rd = w b f t f f yf c M 1
2
M 1 Ed M f , Rd
(5.8)
bf and bt are taken for the flange which provides the least axial resistance, and bf 15tf on each side of the web. Mf,Rd is the bending resistance of the section consisting of the effective area of the flanges only.
M f , Rd = M f ,k
M0
2 1.6b f t f f yf c = a 0.25 + 2 th w f yw
139
Shear-Bending g Interaction
Shear-bending interaction for webs susceptible to shear buckling:
For MEd < Mf,Rd Equation (5.8) For MEd > Mf,Rd f Rd when VEd Vbw,Rd/2 then Mc,Rd = Mpl (or Mel) when h VEd > Vbw,Rd/2 then th moment t capacity it reduced d d according to Eq. 7.1. for info only
140
141
BS 5950 Sh Shear buckling b kli check h k when h d/t > 70 for a rolled section d/t > 62 f for a weld ld section ti
f yw hw t w 3 M 1
f yw hw t w
3 M 1
w f yw = hw t w 3 M1
Similar to qw
142
w =
hw 37.4t k
(5.6)
Assumed the stiffener spacing is equal to web depth, and Steel Grade S275,
so
a/hw = 1
k = 5.34 + 4.00(hw/a)
(A.5)
w =
hw 37.4t k
hw 37.4t 9.34
1 hw 105.66 t
143
144
180
0.6275=165
g end host TFA EC3 rigid qw (2000) TFA EC3 non-rigid end post TFA qcr (1990 & 2000) No TFA 71 61 55 7 55.7 28
80 87.7
100
114
150 200 250 300
146
147
Tension Compression
148
149
(a)
C A 6m
990kN E
990kN D
42kN/m B
6m Loading
6m
(b)
1368kN
1318kN
1116kN 126kN
1611kNm 7452kNm
7641kNm
151
Girder Section
k=0.4 as plastic rotation is not utilized. If the flanges resist the bending moment, moment Aw=Acf. Assuming the thickness of the flange is larger than 16mm, then the yield strength fyf 265N/mm2. The critical hw/t ratio f=265N/mm is given by:
hw E AW 210000 k = 0.4 1 = 317 t f yf A fc 265 The e optimum opt u dept depth hw is sg given e by:
6 317 7642 10 hw = 3 =3 = 2090mm f yf 265 Then the thickness of web, tw, is given as
M Ed
hw
Girder Section
Assuming the flange is Class 2. The maximum flange outstand c f = 10t f = 10 0.924 t f = 9.24t f Where, = 235 275 = 0.924 Use s=tw, so the flange width bf = 2cf+2s+tw=18.48tf+24mm, the fl flange area: Af = (18.48tf+24) tf F From another th equation ti
t f = 26.6mm b f = 515.6mm
use a 28500mm plate.
153
Girder Section
Overall depth: h = hw + 2t f = 2090 + 2 28 = 2146mm Use h=2000mm hw = h 2t f = 2000 2 28 = 1944mm Actual web slenderness:
hw 1944 = = 243 tw 8 Maximum hw/t ratio:
hw E =k t f yf Aw 210000 1944 8 = 0.4 = 321 > 243 Acf 265 500 28
154
Girder Section
Plastic moment of resistance of the flanges:
M pl , Rd
fy
155
Web Design g
An arrangement for the stiffeners is set out as following. The design strength of web fyw is 275kN/m; the design strength of flange fyf is 265kN/m.
1200 1600 3 2000 3
II
III
Intermediate stiffener
stiffener arrangement
156
Web Design g
1) Panel I Web contribution Intermediate stiffener is 1.2m from the support, so a=1.2m.
a 1200 = = 0.62 < 1.0 hw 1944
157
Web Design g
Determine the normalized web slenderness ratio w
w =
As w > 1.08
3 M 1
158
Web Design g
Flange contribution
1.6b f t 2 f yf f c = a 0.25 + 2 t h f w w yw
2 1 . 6 500 28 265 = 1200 0.25 + = 325mm 2 8 1944 275
M Ed
M f , Rd = M pl , Rd = 7316 kNm
The shear resistance contribution from the flanges:
Vbf , Rd M bf t 2 f f yf Ed = 1 c M 1 M f , Rd
2
159
Web Design g
Verification for shear resistance
Vb , Rd = Vbw , Rd + Vbf , Rd
f yw hw t w 3 M 1
1 275 1944 8 10 3 3 M 1 2469kN
ok!
= 1432 + 304
= 1736
160
Web Design g
2) Panel II Wen contribution
VEd = 1368 - 1.2 42 = 1318kN (at the edge of panel II, x=1.2m)
161
Web Design g
Determine the normalized web slenderness ratio w
hw 1944 = = 2.04 w = 37.4t k 37.4 0.924 8 11.88
A As
w > 1.08
w =
1.37 = 0 .5 0.7 + w
3 M 1
= 0.5
162
Web Design g
Flange contribution
c = 325mm
M Ed
f yw hw t w 3 M 1
= 1474
2469 kN
ok! k!
163
Web Design g
3) Panel III
164
Stiffener Design g
1) Rigid end post The design will be made using twin stiffener end post, as shown following. The end post is designed to be rigid.
200 e 1200 a
19 944
tend
tend=12
hw
146 tw=8
146
300 bend
165
Stiffener Design g
The following criteria must be fulfill:
e 0.1hw = 0.1 1.944 m = 0.1944 m
t end
= 300
12 (double sided)
Stiffener Design g
2) Intermediate stiffeners The axial a ial force from the tension field action can usually s all occur occ r in the first intermediate stiffener near support, where the shear force is the maximum. The axial force Nst,ten is given by:
N st ,ten = VEd
t w hw
f yw 3 M 1
VEd is determined at 0.5hw from the stiffener with the higher shear force.
167
Stiffener Design g
The parameter of plate slenderness w is calculated assuming the stiffener is removed, removed thus a=1200+1600=2800. =1200+1600=2800
hw 1944 = = 0.69 a 2800
N st ,ten = 1358
The minimum stiffness requirement for all but two panels either side of the central stiffener is given by the case a < 2hw
168
Stiffener Design g
design on the least value of a:
3 3 hw t 1944 3 83 6 4 I s = 1.5 2 = 1.5 = 3 . 93 10 mm 1200 2 a
Use a 12mm thick plate, then the total breath of the stiffener lst is g given by: y
6 12 3 . 92 10 b=3 = 157.7 mm 12
Use lst=160mm.
169
Stiffener Design g
Strength check: Effective area:
l st 160 = = 13.3 > 14 = 12.9 t s 12 l st ,eff = 14t = 14 0.924 12 = 155 mm
The axial force that can be carried by the stiffener NRd is given as fy 275 3 N Rd = Aeff = 5590 10 0 = 1537 537 kN ff , st t M0 1 .0
170
Stiffener Design g
Buckling check: Effective length: l = 0.75h = 0.75 1944 = 1458mm Effective area second moment:
e w
I eff ,st =
ieff , st =
ieff , st 1
lcr
171
Stiffener Design g
=
1
+ 2
= 0.99
172