PARSHAPAGES.com www.parshapages.blogspot.com
PARSHAS V’ESCHANAN ואתחנן SELECTIONS
From Rabbi Baruch HaLevi Epstein
לְׁשֵם ּולְתִ ְפא ֶֶרת, ה' אֶ חָד ּוׁשְמֹו אֶ חָד,ל הַמְ יֻחָד-ֵ הִׁשְמִ יעָנּו א,ׁשָמֹור ְוזָכֹור ּבְדִ ּבּור אֶ חָד
.ְולִתְ ִהּלָה
As is well known, in the first presentation of the 10 Commandments, in Yisro, the verse states זכור את יום
השבתand in the second presentation in V’eschanan, the verse says שמור את יום השבת. According to the
order of the Torah, it would be proper to mention first זכורand afterwards שמור.
A simple answer would be that the author wants to write his name with the first letter of each stanza שלמה
הלוי. Thus, he placed the word שמורfirst in order to have the first letter of the line be a ש.
But this is difficult to comprehend that he would rearrange the proper order of the words just to spell out
one’s name. Further, the author could have arranged the wording of the stanza that a Shin would be
the first letter, such as שבת קודש בזכור ושמור בדבור אחד
In addition, another reason exists to precede זכור לשמור. It is the way of the world that when a gift is
given to a person and then the gift is lost, when the gift is given a second time, a warning is issued to
be more careful with the gift. Shabbos was a gift given by HaShem to the Jews (from His treasury).
Yet later the Shabbos was violated in public (by the “gatherer”). Thus, in the first set the verse using
the word זכור, as a way of a gift. And after the public “dismissal” of Shabbos, in the second
presentation, the verse uses שמורas a warning to now be careful with this gift.
However, one must say that the author had a proper reason for the order of the words, especially since the
Sheloh haKodesh stated that Lecha Dodi was written with Ruach haKodesh.
Therefore, Rabbi Epstein suggests that שמורproperly precedes זכורaccording to the medrash of Rabbi
Nechunyah ben haKanah (one of the great Tanaim) that is brought in Ramban in Parsha Yisro. He
mentions that a great secret exists in the concept of זכור ושמור, that the concept of זכירהis connected to
the day of Shabbos, and שמירהis connected to the night of Shabbos. The author relied on the great and
precious kabbalah for these concepts which are beyond most of us. But we can now provide a reason
that the author selected this song to be said at the beginning of Shabbos in order to have ( שמורconcept
of the night of Shabbos) precede ( זכורthe day of Shabbos).
PARSHAPAGES.com www.parshapages.blogspot.com
PARSHAS V’ESCHANAN ואתחנן SELECTIONS
From Rabbi Baruch HaLevi Epstein
ואף אתה אמור לו בהלכות בפסח אין מפטירין אחר הפסח אפיקומון
Why does the answer to the Chacham son specifically refer to this law of the Afikomon as opposed to
any other specific law of the Seder?
The last chapter of Pesachim (which brings the entire order of the Seder) concludes with the Mishneh
which states this aspect of the Seder, the Afikomon. And this is an advice to the father of the wise
son to learn with this son the entire set of laws up to the final detail, as stated in Devarim 6,24, that
the father should relate to the son all the Chukim (laws).
And to explain this wording, one should understand that it includes reference to two different time
periods: during the time of the Bais HaMikdash and when there is no Bais HaMikdash. Thus, this
phrase is understood that when the Bais HaMikdash was standing that after the meal, one should
conclude by eating the Korban Pesach; and in the time when there is no Bais HaMikdash, one should
conclude with the Afikomon (of matzah) which is in the place of the Korban Pesach. Thus, the
shortened version is to be read: Do not finish anything else after the Pesach (the korban in the time of
the Bais HaMikdash) (or) after the Afikomon (in the time of no Bais HaMikdash).
PARSHAPAGES.com www.parshapages.blogspot.com