Anda di halaman 1dari 106

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 1 OF 106 PIPENET VISION TRANSIENT MODULE CHAPTER 6 SPRAY OPTION EXAMPLES

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

1.

Introduction

At this stage, it is assumed that the reader is familiar with the basic concepts of the PIPENET VISION Transient Module. If this is not the case, please ensure that Chapter 1 of the Training Manual for the Transient Module (entitled Basic Concepts) is mastered before continuing with this chapter. This chapter contains the following sections. Section 2, entitled Basic Concepts For Modelling Fire Water Systems, is not for inputting models into PIPENET VISION, but contains a discussion of how to perform transient analysis of firewater systems. Dialog boxes are included for illustration purposes only. Section 3 contains the main example of this chapter of the training manual. This section contains a step-by step guide to entering the network into the Transient Module, and also a discussion. Firewater systems, especially offshore systems, have three specific potential surge problems, all of which are discussed in this section: Pump start up without the deluge system working (an example of which is a weekly test procedure). Fire pump and deluge system start up. Monitor valve closure. Section 4 is based on a real example. It is not essential to input the network as part of the training course. The network is included mainly to illustrate how a real system could be set up.

2.

Basic Concepts For Modelling Fire Water Systems Preamble and Discussion

This section, which is concerned with the basic concepts of modelling firewater systems using the PIPENET VISION Transient Module, does not include the exact sequence for inputting data into the Transient module. The dialog boxes are shown for illustration purposes only. This section is intended for reading only. Section 3 of this chapter contains a network that is to be input. This section is for general discussion and NOT FOR INPUT TO PIPENET.

2.1. Pump Priming With no System Working


Generally one should strive to input the simplest network that would adequately represent the real system. Consider the network below. In the network, the riser pipe normally has a check valve, which is followed by the ringmain proper. This ringmain will contain stationary water, which is kept pressurised either by a jockey pump or with a connection to a seawater system.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 2 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

In this network, it would be conservative to treat the check valve as a dead end. It is considered to be conservative because the piping system beyond the check valve will have some capacity to absorb and reduce the pressure surge. That functionality is ignored. However, this approach is a simple way of modelling a complex problem. The water after the check valve will be stationary when the pump priming is complete. The water that moves up the riser pipe will hammer against stationary water downstream of the check valve. This process is somewhat like water hammering against a dead end. The way that the system works is described below. The fire pump is selected to generate a pressure of say 14 barg at LAT (Lowest Astronomical Tide) level. However, when the firewater pump starts, the pressure downstream is very small, because the air-release valve will be open, and that would try to maintain a pressure of around 0 barg. Consequently, the pump will experience little resistance to flow, and so the water level will rise relatively quickly. When the water level reaches the air-release valve, this valve closes quickly. The water will, therefore, be brought to a sudden halt. The water in the firewater ringmain is stationary, and the water rising in the riser pipe will hammer against it. Rapid stopping of water is similar to rapid valve closure, which is capable of producing a very large pressure surge.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 3 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

In general, there is merit in looking for simple engineering solutions. In this case, there is a simple solution that is used by the engineering community. At the top of the riser pipe, close to the check valve, a suitably sized overboard dump valve is installed. When the riser pipe is fully primed, water will return to the sea through this valve. This valve would be closed at an appropriate speed, after the riser pipe is primed. Thus, the hammering effect of the water in the riser pipe being brought to a sudden and rapid stop is avoided. It is important that this overboard dump valve is correctly sized. In this section, we shall learn how to predict the pressure surges that can arise when there is no overboard dump valve. We also learn the merits of using an overboard dump valve, and how to optimise the selection of the size of this valve. The key aspects of the model we propose to use for this simulation are shown later in this document.

2.2

Examples of Properties Windows that are Specific to This Model

In this section, we consider only the properties windows that are specific to the network we are modelling. It is assumed that the reader is familiar with basic concepts such as dialog boxes and properties windows, which are necessary for setting up a model.

2.2.1 Inlet Pipe


The dialog box for the pipe is shown below. This pipe represents a number of aspects that need to be modelled. The negative elevation is the height of the pump discharge below the LAT level. It can also be used to represent the friction loss in items such as the filter and stilling tube upstream of the pump. In PIPENET VISION, there must be at least one elastic pipe in a system so that an estimate of the required time step can be obtained.

2.2.2 Two-node Caisson Type 1


The dialog box for the two-node caisson type 1 is shown below. The caisson represents a partially filled pipe. In this case, it is the riser pipe that has water level at LAT. It also has an

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 4 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

air-release valve that is deemed to open as soon as the fire pump starts. Please note that the caisson model has an in-built non-return valve at its end.

As mentioned earlier, the two-node caisson has a built-in air release valve and a check valve. Most of the items are self-explanatory. However, there are three items that need explanation. The Initial Fluid Depth represents the LAT level. It is important to understand that this depth is defined in terms of the length along the caisson, rather than height change. For this reason, if the caisson elevation is less than the caisson length then the caisson is not vertical, and the initial depth has to be adjusted accordingly: Initial depth = (LAT level above pump) x (caisson length) / (caisson elevation) The diameter of the air-release valve is input as Valve Diameter. The coefficient of discharge of the valve represents the efficiency of the air-release valve, and a perfectly efficient valve has a coefficient of 1. Node 6 is used for specifying the position of the air-release valve. Let us assume that the pump starts running at 1 second, and the air release valve starts to open at 1 second and takes 0.1 seconds to open. A typical specification would be as follows.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 5 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

2.2.3 Fire Pump Run Up Time


Let us suppose that the pump runs up in 10 seconds, starting at 1 second. In this case, the dialog box for the specification at the information node is as shown below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 6 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

2.2.4 Specifications at the Input and Output Nodes of the System


The input node has a specification on 0 barg, as this node corresponds to the surface of the sea (which is at atmospheric pressure).

The output node is given a flow-rate specification of 0 m3/hr. It is important to explain why the second specification is given in this manner. The caisson consists of the volume from the output of the pump to the input of the non-return valve. As the pump runs up, the water level rises rapidly, the reason being because there is virtually no back pressure (as the air-release valve is open). When the water reaches the non-return valve, the momentum of the water is quite large. At this time, the water downstream of the non-return valve is stationary. We assume that the air-release valve closes at the same time as the water level reaches the nonreturn valve. Therefore, the water is brought to a stop virtually instantaneously, which can produce a large pressure surge.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 7 OF 106 The following graph illustrates what could be expected.

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

2.3

Overboard Dump Valve

The simple and cost-effective solution to the problem is to install an overboard dump valve. This valve would be held open until the caisson has been fully primed. Afterwards, the overboard dump valve will be closed. If the overboard dump valve is adequately sized, the pressure surge would be considerably reduced. It is important to mention the following. There is usually an optimal size for the overboard dump valve. Firstly, let us consider the case in which the overboard dump valve is too large. Air in the caisson would then escape at a faster rate, and water would rise up more quickly. So, at the time it reaches the valve, and the valve closes, a larger momentum would be brought to rest. Further, if the valve were too large, it would have to close more before it could begin reducing the flowrate (because a larger valve would have less resistance at a given a valve position). Therefore, for a given valve closure, the fluid would decelerate faster during the final moments of valve closure. The maximum pressure surge would then occur at the time of closure of the overboard dump valve. Now let us consider the case where the overboard dump valve is too small. In this case, water rises up the caisson rapidly. When it reaches the overboard dump valve, the water is suddenly decelerated, because the valve is too small to cope with the flowrate. This action gives rise to a

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 8 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

pressure surge. The maximum pressure surge in this case will usually be at the end of the priming stage of the caisson. It is clear from the graph above that the overboard dump valve, if installed, could start to close from a value above 9 seconds. Three typical graphs are shown. The difference between the graphs arises from the value of the valve coefficient, Cv, of the overboard dump valve. The three cases correspond to overboard dump valves that are under-sized, over-sized and correctly sized respectively.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 9 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 10 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

It is clear that the maximum pressure surge is less when the Cv value is 1000, in comparison to the case where the Cv is 250. The optimal value cannot be deduced simply by blindly increasing the valve size. In any case, from a cost point of view, the smallest valve that produces an acceptable pressure surge may be the best solution.

2.4

Modelling of Deluge Systems

When a deluge valve opens, what happens is extremely complex. As the valve opens, water from the firewater ringmain will begin to gush out. The water would then fill the deluge system, with the nozzles delivering water one by one until the whole system is primed. It is not possible to model this scenario rigorously. Instead, we model the deluge system by making an approximation. Suppose that the deluge system requires a pressure of P bar upstream of the deluge valve and delivers Q m3/hr when it reaches steady state. We can then approximate the deluge system by using an operating valve with a Cv value that is calculated as follows.

CV =

Q P

When the valve is fully open, it behaves like the real deluge system under steady-state conditions. The operation of the deluge valve would depend on the type of the valve, and is discussed below.

2.5

Modelling of Clack Open Deluge Valves

Clack opening deluge valves can cause pressure surges because of the way they operate, especially in the offshore industry. The sequence of events is typically as follows. When a fire is detected, a deluge valve is sent a signal to open. As it is operated by instrument air, it would open regardless of the water pressure in the firewater ringmain. As a consequence, the pressure in the firewater ringmain would generally collapse, if it were kept under pressure by a jockey pump. If the firewater ringmain is kept under pressure by a connection with the seawater system, it is conceivable that the ringmain would remain pressurised, depending on the capacity of the seawater system and the connecting lines. At the time a clack deluge valve receives a signal to open, the fire pump would generally not have been primed. As the elevation of the high points in the system is often more than 10 metres, the pressure at these high points would typically fall below the vapour pressure. Consequently, the water at the high points in the system would vaporise and form vapour cavities. When the fire pump has completed priming, and the firewater ringmain is repressurised, these cavities would collapse, potentially causing very large pressure surges. Pressure surges of the order of 80 to 100 bar are often encountered.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 11 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Typically, vacuum breaker valves are used to eliminate this problem. This solution is discussed later in this section. There are two ways of modelling the operation of a deluge system Simple Method The simple method of modelling this is to use a single virtual valve which represents the combined deluge valve and deluge system. The Cv of the virtual valve is calculated as described in the text below which is taken from section 2.4. Suppose that the deluge system requires a pressure of P bar upstream of the deluge valve and delivers Q m3/hr when it reaches steady state. We can then approximate the deluge system by using an operating valve with a Cv value that is calculated as follows.

CV =

Q P

When the valve is fully open, it behaves like the real deluge system under steady-state conditions.

This deluge valve represents both the deluge system and the deluge valve. It is a virtual valve with the value of its Cv representing the whole system. For this reason the downstream pressure must be set to 0 barg. If it is assumed that the deluge valve opens in 5 seconds, the operation of the deluge valve is defined by the following specification.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 12 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

This is a simple single valve approach. Two Valve Method: The simple method outlined above has one weakness. The real life system has a deluge valve followed by the deluge system. When the deluge valve opens the deluge system will gradually get filled with water and the nozzles will deliver water one by one. The back pressure downstream of the deluge valve will gradually increase as the deluge system gets filled. The resistance of the system will gradually increase as the back pressure increases. However, this is not taken into account by the simple method. In the simple method, the resistance of the system decreases with time. It relies on the fact that when the deluge system is fully flooded the Cv of the virtual valve will be the same as the Cv of the deluge valve and the deluge system combined, A more sophisticated way of modelling is by the use of two valves in series. The first valve represents the physical deluge valve. The second valve is a virtual valve which represents the deluge system. The physical deluge valve is quite easy to model. The data for its Cv and opening time are obtained from the vendor. The second valve which is the virtual valve representing the deluge system is modelled as follows. Suppose the inlet pressure and flowrate required by the deluge system are P and Q. Then the valve Cv* is calculated as follows.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 13 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Cv* = Q/ P Suppose the deluge system requires 10,000 lit/min at 9 bar then Cv* = 10000/3 = 3333.33 The second valve is input as a linear valve with Cv = 10 x Cv*. In the case above Cv = 10 x Cv* = 33333.33. Suppose the deluge system takes 30 seconds to fill up. Then this valve is closed from fully open position to 10% open in 30 seconds. Thus, the value of Cv of the value goes down from 33333.33 to 3333.33 in 30 seconds. It can be seen that initially the virtual valve offers very little pressure loss and in 30 seconds the pressure loss is the same as that of the real deluge system.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 14 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 15 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 16 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 17 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 18 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

2.6

Modelling Elastomeric (Pressure Regulating) Deluge Valves

Valves of this type normally require a minimum operating pressure in the firewater ringmain. For this reason, until the fire pumps have primed and the ringmain has sustained pressure, this type of deluge valve would not operate. The operation of these valves is modelled is similar to the way a clack deluge would be modelled. The main difference is that the valve is open only after the ringmain is pressurised. Consider the following case. Suppose that the caisson is fully primed at around 14 seconds. (Note that the exact time can be determined by outputting the results to a tabular output file.) So, we can open the deluge valve in 5 seconds, after 14 seconds into the simulation. The specification for this operation is shown below.

It should be noted that if elastomeric valves are used for deluge valves and ordinary valves are used for monitors, there might be problems. The operation of the monitors could result in cavity formation, and subsequent cavity collapse when the monitors operate. It may not be sufficient to choose elastomeric valves for the deluge systems only.

2.7

Modelling Systems Using Jockey Pumps

Suppose that the jockey pump is intended to maintain a pressure of 7 barg at its connection point. In this case, it could be modelled in the following manner.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 19 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Valve is initially open, but closes

The operation of the jockey pump is modelled by supplying the following specifications.

The specification at Node 5 would be obtained using a constant time function, with the value of 7 barg. The reason why the valve has to close is as follows. The pressure upstream of the valve is 7 barg. If the valve were left open then the flow through the valve would adjust itself in order to maintain the pressure.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 20 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

On the other hand, what would happen in practice is the following. The capacity of the jockey would be so small that its contribution to the flowrate through the deluge valve would be negligible. Therefore, if the valve were left open it would not reflect reality. An alternative approach would be to input the curve for the jockey pump and add a non-return valve downstream of the jockey pump.

2.8

Modelling Systems with Connection to Seawater Systems

Connection to seawater system

In this case, the valve represents the restriction in the connecting line. As the valve is left open, water will flow into the firewater ringmain. For two reasons, it is important to ensure that there is sufficient restriction in the connecting line. The first reason is that, if there is unrestricted flow from the seawater system, the pressure in the seawater system could drop to unacceptably low levels. A less obvious problem that is sometimes observed is the following. The firewater system normally works at a higher pressure than the seawater system. Suppose that there is an unrestricted and large flowrate from the seawater system to the firewater system when a deluge valve has opened, but the firewater pump has not primed the caisson. When the firewater pump primes the firewater ringmain, it will stop the flowrate from the seawater system into the firewater system. This process will happen instantaneously, and is similar to instantaneous valve closure, and can result in a pressure surge.

2.9

Vacuum Breaker Valves

It was suggested that installing vacuum breaker valves or air release valves at the high points in the system was one way of controlling pressure surges that arise from cavity separation. The scenario is as follows. The clack open deluge valve receives a signal to open, and opens because it is actuated by instrument air or some other means. At the same time, the fire pump receives a signal to start. However, it takes time for the fire pump to prime the caisson and, during that time, it is not possible to maintain the pressure in the ringmain. Hence, vacuum pressures would develop in the higher parts of the system, which could lead to cavity formation.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 21 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Vacuum breakers or air release valves are often used to counter this cavity formation. Basically, before the fire pump has primed, it allows air to enter the system quickly, so that the pressure at the higher levels of the ringmain remain close to atmospheric pressure. When the pump has primed the system, the air release valve (which is a much smaller valve), allows the air to exit relatively slowly. It is important that the air release valve is small; otherwise, water can move up the riser pipe very quickly, which can result in a surge (when water reaches the air release valve, and closes it).
Vacuum breaker

2.10 Monitor and Deluge Valve Closure


Both operations are treated as normal valve-closure events.

2.10.1

Effect of Line Packing

In the above sections, we considered pump priming with no system working, under the conservative assumption that water downstream of the check valve was completely stationary. This treatment made it behave like a dead end. In some cases, it might be important to consider the ringmain. If it is made of a more flexible material, such as GRP, and if long lines

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 22 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

such as bridge connections between platforms are used, they will have a mitigating effect against pressure surges.

2.10.2

Effect of Bleed Valves

Line packing could have a detrimental effect under certain circumstances. A pressure significantly higher than that with a closed head can be trapped in the ringmain. Installing a bleed valve in the ringmain (to allow the excess fluid to escape) can alleviate this problem.

3. 3.1

The Simulation Examples Introduction

Please note that the actual model input begins in section 3.2 below. This section 3.1. is a pre-amble. Firewater systems, especially those found on offshore platforms, are generally quite susceptible to surge problems. All fire protection systems on process plants are susceptible to pressure surges, not just offshore platforms. Therefore, considerable care must be taken when designing such systems. Here, a simple offshore firewater system is considered, and a few cases (which might be of general interest) are studied. There are three scenarios that are known to potentially cause problems, and these scenarios comprehensively cover the cases that normally occur in firewater systems. Pump start-up with no system running (which is often the case during pump start-up for weekly test purposes). Pump start-up with system(s) running. Problems can be caused by cavity separation. When the cavity collapses, very large pressure surges can occur. Valve closure during normal running.

Please use the Spray Option in the Transient Module for these simulations.

Spray Option

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 23 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

3.2

Case 1: Pump Start-up With no System Running

This scenario is often called the pump-priming scenario. The network and the data associated with it are shown below. In this scenario, there can be a particularly dangerous pressure surges. The pressure surge can potentially occur because of the following reason. The riser pipe normally has an air-release valve to prevent air from becoming entrained in the firewater ringmain. In this scenario, no monitor or deluge system is running, since we are considering a test start-up of the pump situation. When the pump starts, the air in the riser pipe escapes through the air-release valve, and the water rises up very quickly indeed. When the air is completely expelled, the water that has been moving fast encounters a non-return valve with stationary water locked downstream, bringing the water to a stop almost instantaneously. This can be a source of very dangerous pressure surges. Furthermore, this pressure surge travels back and hits the pump impeller with full force, as there is no check valve in between. The engineering solution to this problem is very simple; namely, installing an overboard dump valve just upstream of the non-return valve. This valve is held open during pump start up. After the end of the priming of the riser pipe, this valve is slowly closed. So the fire pump reaches an equilibrium pressure with the stationary water downstream of the non-return valve over a period of time, rather than stopping almost instantaneously. This approach can be used to bring the pressure surge down to a manageable level. We now compare the results from the following two cases. Pump start-up without an overboard dump valve. Pump start-up with an overboard dump valve of Cv = 50000 and 10000 (Lit/min, bar).

In general, it is preferable to use a model that is as simple as possible, but that realistically represents the system. In this case, we use a model that is considerably simplified. The dry riser pipe is modelled using a two-node caisson type 1 model. This model has a built-in airrelease valve. Also, it has two flow nodes and one information node, and the information node represents the position of the air-release valve. Although the user can define how the valve opens, PIPNET VISION will automatically close the valve when the water reaches it. For simulating pump start up, omit the part of the network beyond the dry riser pipe. This part of the system has stationary water, and so can be modelled using a zero flow-rate specification. For the scenario that does not include the overboard dump valve, the network is as shown below. Upstream of the pump, there is a pipe that represents items such as the filter, a stilling tube upstream of the pump, and the static head of the sea. Furthermore, at least one elastic pipe is needed in a network in order to enable the PIPENET VISION Transient Module to calculate the time step.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 24 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Information node, which models the operation of the air-release valve

Caisson, which models the dry riser pipe

Pipe, which represents the depth of the sea and losses Fire pump

3.2.1 Main Input Steps


The main input steps are shown below. It is assumed that the reader is now familiar with PIPENET VISION input, and so does not require much help with in this area.

3.2.2 Transient Module Network Options


These options can be displayed using either Options | Module options with the Windows Menu Style, or Init | Module options with the PIPENET VISION Menu Style. For the remainder of this document, all specified menu options relate to the Windows Menu Style.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 25 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

3.2.3 Units
Length Diameter Velocity Temperature Density Viscosity Time Mass Mass rate Torque m mm m/s Celcius kg/m3 Pa.s seconds kg kg/s Nm Inertia Force Volume Surface tension Thermal conductivity Heat capacity Youngs modulus Pressure Flow type Flow rate kg.m2 N litres N/m W/(m.K) J/(kg.K) GPa barg Volumetric lit/min

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 26 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 27 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

3.2.4 Fluid Data

3.2.5 Pipe Types


Use the Copper/Nickel (90/10) 20 Bar g pipe schedule, as is illustrated below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 28 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

3.2.6 Pump Data


It is important to note that the pressure (or head) specified in the pump-performance curve is the differential pressure across the pump impeller. The reason is because the depth of fluid on the discharge side of the impeller varies, and the riser is not always primed. The static head acting on the discharge side of the impeller will change with time, as the water level downstream of the pump changes. Pump curves that show the pressure at the discharge flange, as sometimes used in offshore applications, must be corrected for this purpose, and the differential pressure across the impeller must be input. The pump curve to be used is shown below. Flow rate (lit/min) 0 15000 25000 35000 Pressure (bar) 20.5 18.5 16.5 14.0

The run-up time for the fire pump is assumed to be 10 seconds. In simulation terms, the pump

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 29 OF 106 starts at 1 second and completes its run-up at 11 seconds.

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Open the Library Menu and select the pump input data option (Libraries | Pumps Coeffs. Unknown).

The relevant dialog box for inputting the pump data into the library is shown below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 30 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Please note that, for a satisfactory simulation, a flow rate of 0 lit/min must be present in one of the data points, because the fire pump starts from a standstill state. So, unless 0 lit/min flowrate is one of the data points, PIPENET VISION has to extrapolate the pump curve, and this process can lead to misleading results.

3.2.7 Generating the Schematic and Inputting the Attribute Data


Firstly, draw the network as shown on the schematic below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 31 OF 106 The dialog box entering the pump into the network is as follows.

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

3.2.8 Caisson Data


In this example, a two-node caisson type 1 is used to model the dry riser pipe. The details of the riser pipe are as follows. Length Diameter Elevation C factor Initial depth Valve diameter Valve coefficient = 26 m, = 600 mm, = 17 m, = 140, = 7.647 m (=5 x 26 / 17), = 100 mm, = 1.0.

The relevant dialog box is shown below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 32 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

3.2.9 Pipe Data


The pipe upstream of the pump has the following properties. Diameter Length Elevation C factor = 600 mm, = 10 m, = -10 m, = 140.

The properties window dialog box is shown below.

3.2.10 Specifications (Boundary Conditions)


The inlet node is assumed to be at a pressure 0 bar G, as it is at sea level. The corresponding dialog box is as follows.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 33 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The outlet node is assumed to have a flowrate of 0 m/hr, since we are assuming that water in the ringmain is stationary, and so acts like a dead end.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 34 OF 106 The dialog box for this specification is shown below.

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The pump is assumed to run up linearly in 10 seconds, starting 1 second into the simulation. (It is usually a good idea to start an event like this at a time other than 0 seconds, as it gives us the opportunity to observe the initial steady-state solution.) The dialog box for this specification is shown below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 35 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

It is assumed that the air-release valve at the top of the caisson starts to open as soon as the pump starts to run up, and is fully open within 0.1 seconds. The dialog box is shown below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 36 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

3.2.11 Selection of Graphical Output


The graphs of all variables with time for the pipe, pump, and caisson can be selected using a Data Window (via View | Data window | Result Graphs), and is indicated below.

In a similar manner, graphical results can be selected for other components.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 37 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

3.2.12 Simulation Time


In an earlier section, we set the simulation time to be 30 seconds (using Options | Module options).

Simulation time

The graphical output time step (in Calculation | Options | Output) is chosen to be 0.1 seconds, and this setting is shown in the following dialog box, along with the names of the output files. As the simulation is performed for 30 seconds, there are to be 300 points on each graph.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 38 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

3.2.13 Results
After the simulation has been run (using either the Calculate Button or Calculation | Go), the graphical results can be viewed as follows. Firstly, open the graph viewer (using either the Graph Viewer Button or Output | Graphs), then click on the prompt next to the directory tree, to reveal the available graph data (for the pump, pipe, and caisson).

To plot the position of the fluid surface in the two-node caisson, click on the prompt next to All variables of two-node caisson 1, and tick the box next to Position of fluid surface of two-node caisson 1, as indicated below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 39 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

After a title has been added (by typing text in the Title Field) and the legend has been removed (by un-ticking the box named Show Legend), the graph is as follows.

A graph of the inlet pressure of the caisson can be plotted by un-ticking the current box and ticking the box named Inlet pressure of two node caisson 1, as indicated below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 40 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The graph is as follows. Note that, to change the axis position for the graph, click on Inlet pressure of two-node caisson 1, click on the Axis Tab below, and then select the appropriate position from the pull-down menu.

An overlay plot of the water level in the riser pipe and the pressure at the inlet of the riser pipe can be obtained by ensuring that the two relevant boxes are ticked. Note that the legend has

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 41 OF 106 been included in the following graph.

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The default output from tabular results are shown below:


PRESSURE EXTREMA ---------------Maximum pressure is 60.7555 bar G on two-node caisson 1 at the inlet at time 11.01739 seconds Minimum pressure is -40.4428 bar G on pipe 1 at the outlet at time 9.400000 seconds

MAXIMUM/MINIMUM PRESSURE -----------------------Inlet max. pressure bar G Inlet min. pressure bar G Outlet max. pressure bar G Outlet min. pressure bar G Middle max. pressure bar G Middle min. pressure bar G

Component

Time seconds

Time seconds

Time seconds

Time seconds

Time seconds

Time seconds

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------PIPE 1 0.000E+00 0.00E+00 --------------------

0.000E+00 0.00E+00

0.424E+02 0.94E+01

-.404E+02 0.94E+01

0.591E+02 0.11E+02

-.404E+02 0.94E+01

PUMP 1 0.424E+02 0.94E+01 --------------------

-.404E+02 0.94E+01

0.608E+02 0.11E+02

-.260E+02 0.94E+01

CAPI 1

0.608E+02 0.11E+02

-.260E+02 0.94E+01

0.591E+02 0.11E+02

-.276E+02 0.94E+01

-.101E+01 0.00E+00

-.101E+01 0.00E+00

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 42 OF 106 Vapour Cavity Option

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

As can be seen in the above graph and tabular results, there are large negative pressures at the inlet of the caisson. Therefore, it is clear that the system exhibits cavity formation. We address this problem by selecting the vapour-cavitation option (Options | Module options), and running the calculation again.

Select the vapourcavitation option

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 43 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The resulting graph is shown below. Note that labels and arrows have been added to the graph (using Annotations | Labels | Create and Annotations | Arrows | Create respectively).

PRESSURE EXTREMA ---------------Maximum pressure is 60.0162 bar G on two-node caisson 1 at the inlet at time 10.49565 seconds Minimum pressure is -0.977000 bar G on pipe 1 at the outlet at time 9.391304 seconds

MAXIMUM/MINIMUM PRESSURE -----------------------Inlet max. pressure bar G Inlet min. pressure bar G Outlet max. pressure bar G Outlet min. pressure bar G Middle max. pressure bar G Middle min. pressure bar G

Component

Time seconds

Time seconds

Time seconds

Time seconds

Time seconds

Time seconds

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------PIPE 1 0.000E+00 0.00E+00 --------------------

0.000E+00 0.00E+00

0.424E+02 0.94E+01

-.977E+00 0.94E+01

0.584E+02 0.10E+02

-.977E+00 0.94E+01

PUMP 1 0.424E+02 0.94E+01 --------------------

-.977E+00 0.94E+01

0.600E+02 0.10E+02

0.806E+00 0.24E+01

CAPI 1

0.600E+02 0.10E+02

0.806E+00 0.24E+01

0.584E+02 0.10E+02

0.000E+00 0.00E+00

-.101E+01 0.00E+00

-.101E+01 0.00E+00

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 44 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

In both cases, the maximum pressure in the caisson (as can be seen in the Properties Window for the caisson, or in the output file) is approximately 60 bar G. As the maximum surge takes place before cavitation occurs, this value is the same in both cases. Therefore, this maximum value is unaffected by whether or not cavitation is modelled. The minimum pressure is equal to the vapour pressure when Vapour Cavitation option is selected. As mentioned earlier, the simple engineering solution to this problem is to install an overboard dump valve between the riser pipe and the non-return valve.

3.3

Case 2: Including an Over Board Dump Valve

The modified network is shown below.


Overboard dump valve

For the following reason, the value of Cv for the overboard dump valve needs to be relatively high. The water rises very quickly in the dry riser pipe as the pump speeds up. So, unless the overboard dump line and the valve are large enough, the water will decelerate as it tries to pass through them, which itself could create a surge. To illustrate this point, we try the following two values for the valve coefficient. Cv = 50,000 (lit./min, bar),

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 45 OF 106 Cv = 10,000 (lit/min, bar).

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

In both cases, the outlet pressure of the valve is set to 0 bar G, as the flow through the valve will be dumped overboard, and so will be open to the atmosphere. The zero flow-rate specification at the top of the caisson must be removed, as illustrated in the following figure.
Remove the output specification

It can be seen from the graph of the previous simulation that the riser pipe is primed in less than 11 seconds. It would, therefore, seem sensible to start closing the overboard dump valve from 12 seconds, with a closure time of 5 seconds. The dialog box for this procedure is shown below.

As an exercise, place an overlap in time between priming and the valve beginning to close; in other words, begin closing the over board dump valve from, say, 10 seconds.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 46 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The behaviour when Cv = 50,000 is shown below.

In this case, the maximum pressure is at the inlet of the two-node caisson and has the value 21.27 bar G.
PRESSURE EXTREMA ---------------Maximum pressure is 21.2697 bar G on two-node caisson 1 at the inlet at time 17.00000 seconds Minimum pressure is 0.00000 bar G on pipe 1 at the inlet at time 0.000000 seconds

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 47 OF 106 The behaviour with a coefficient of 10,000 is shown below.

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The maximum pressure observed at the two-node caisson outlet (taken from the browser output) is 32.92 bar G.
PRESSURE EXTREMA ---------------Maximum pressure is 32.9223 bar G on two-node caisson 1 at the outlet at time 10.58261 seconds Minimum pressure is -0.977000 bar G on pipe 1 at the outlet at time 10.60870 seconds

The graphical result for the pressure at the outlet of the caisson is shown below. It can be seen that the above maximum pressure is not shown in the graph. This is because the pressure surge has a very sharp spike. The graphical output of 0.01 sec is not good enough to show the actual peak. This is why it is always a good idea to check the maximum value in the tabular output.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 48 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The difference that the valve size makes is remarkable. The maximum pressure in the two cases arises for different reasons. In the case with the large overboard dump valve, the maximum pressure is essentially caused by the closed head pressure of the pump. On the other hand with the smaller valve, the maximum pressure is caused by the fact that water rises very fast up the big diameter caisson and is not able to go out through the valve fast enough. The water has to decelerate and this results in the pressure surge. We have illustrated a procedure of obtaining the optimal size of the valve. In the example below, we shall use an overboard dump valve with a Cv of 50,000 (lit/min, bar). Another Interesting Observation: The above two examples show that as the size of the overboard dump valve increases the pressure surge decreases. It would be interesting to see what would happen if the value of Cv was increased to 200,000 (lit/min, bar). Results with Cv = 200,000
PRESSURE EXTREMA ---------------Maximum pressure is 23.2770 bar G on two-node caisson 1 at the outlet at time 16.99130 seconds Minimum pressure is -0.712943 bar G on pipe 1 at the outlet

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 49 OF 106


at time 17.01739 seconds

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Results with Cv = 100,000


PRESSURE EXTREMA ---------------Maximum pressure is 21.2697 bar G on two-node caisson 1 at the inlet at time 17.00000 seconds Minimum pressure is 0.00000 bar G on pipe 1 at the inlet at time 0.000000 seconds

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 50 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Rather surprisingly the maximum pressure with Cv = 200,000 is higher than that with Cv = 100,000. In order to understand the reason for this we must look at the flowrate through the overboard dump valve in both cases.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 51 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The reason for the difference is as follows. When the Cv is 200,000 the valve has to close considerably before the flowrate starts to decrease. On the other hand, with the smaller valve the flowrate starts decreasing much earlier. Therefore, the rate at which the momentum changes with the larger valve is higher. That in turn leads to a bigger pressure surge with the large valve. In actual fact, although both the valves take 5 seconds to close, the effective valve closure time is much shorter in the case of the large valve.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 52 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

3.4

Case 3: Pump Start up With a Deluge System Operating

Preamble and general data: In this scenario, we assume that the deluge valve starts to open after 1 second and takes 5 seconds to fully open. The pump start up is the same as in the priming scenario above. The pump runs up in 10 seconds, starting at 1 second into the simulation. We will use a simulation time of 120 seconds in the following simulations. The data where not specified will in general be the same as that in sections 3.2 and 3.3. of this chapter.
Helideck Monitors

Jockey pump Two valve Deluge System model

Overboard dump valve

Caisson

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 53 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The riser pipe has the same data as before, and is modelled by the caisson model. The pump performance curve is the same as in the previous sections 3.1. and 3.2. The data is shown below. Pump Curve:

Caisson Data:

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 54 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Overboard Dump Valve:

The Network: Remember to input the network in the same sequence as shown in the schematic diagram below, as it will be easier to input the attributes later.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 55 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The piping data is shown below. Pipe label 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Length (m) 10 22 26 46 32 24 25 10 25 5 5 5 46 Elevation (m) -10 3 0 0 0 0 15 0 -15 0 0 0 0 Diameter (mm) 600 600 500 500 500 500 250 250 250 250 250 250 500

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 56 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The pipe type is the same as used in the priming scenario; namely, Copper-Nickel (90/10) 20 Bar g. In this scenario, we ignore all of the fittings. The operation of the pump and overboard dump valve are the same as in the priming scenario. Note: Pipe 13 is used in a later simulation in which the caisson is replaced by a pipe. 3.4.1. Single Valve Approach for Modelling Systems with Clack Shut Valves:

Modelling the Deluge System: A virtual equivalent valve has been used to replace the whole of the deluge system, including the deluge valve. (Although there are no nozzles in the Transient Module, the formula for a valve is the same as that for a nozzle.) The Cv value of this virtual valve is equivalent to the whole of the deluge system, and may be calculated as

Cv =

Q P

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 57 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

where Q is the required flowrate and P is the required pressure at the inlet of the deluge system including the deluge valve. The data for the virtual equivalent valve and the monitors are shown below. Item Valve Label Deluge System 4 Virtual equivalent valve Helideck monitors 2,3 Equivalent CV (lit/min, bar) 8000

1200

The above data is input to the network, even though it is not necessary to operate all of them in the scenarios below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 58 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The Jockey Pump: The ringmain system is assumed to be kept under a pressure of 7 bar G in its quiescent state by a jockey pump. This situation is modelled by a valve with its inlet pressure set to 7 bar G. The valve is open initially, but closes as soon as the simulation starts, and before any other event takes place in the system. This valve is given a nominal Cv value of 500 (lit/min, Bar). It is open at time 0 seconds, and is fully closed at 0.5 seconds. The sole purpose of this valve is to set the initial pressure to 7 bar G. For this reason, the value of Cv does not actually matter, provided that the valve is kept open momentarily to begin with, and the initial pressure in the ringmain works out to 7 bar G.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 59 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 60 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The deluge valve starts to open at 1 second and takes 5 seconds to fully open. The monitor valves remain closed throughout this simulation. The Data Window below shows which results are available for graphical presentation.

Please be aware that calculations of this type can be very slow.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 61 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The cavity volume and the pressure at the top of the ringmain (in Pipe 8) are shown below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 62 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The maximum pressure at the outlet of Pipe 11 is approximately 80.4 bar G. 3.4.2. Two Valve Model for Systems with Clack Shut Deluge Valves: The basic data is the same as it is for the Single Valve Model. The deluge system is modelled differently. In order to be consistent with the single valve model the Cv of the 8,000 (lit/min, bar), the following values are used. Cv of the actual deluge valve Cv of the virtual valve representing the deluge system = = 17,500 (lit/min, bar) 9,000 (lit/min, bar)

If two valves are placed in series the combined Cv is calculated by using, 1/ Cv 2 = 1/Cv12 + 1/Cv22

In this case we can see the following, 1/ Cv 2 = 1/90002 + 1/175002

From this it can be calculated that Cv = 8003. The overall Cv therefore is the same in cases 3.4.1 and 3.4.2.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 63 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 64 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 65 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 66 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 67 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PRESSURE EXTREMA ---------------Maximum pressure is 135.943 bar G on pipe 7 10.00 metres from the inlet of the pipe at time 16.68996 seconds Minimum pressure is -0.977000 bar G on pipe 8 at the outlet at time 1.567686 seconds

3.5

Case 4: Vacuum Breaker Included

In this case we revert back to the single valve model and include a vacuum breaker at the top of the helideck riser.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 68 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Vacuum breaker

In order to reduce this pressure surge, we introduce a vacuum breaker (combined air-release and vacuum breaker valve).

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 69 OF 106 The graphical output is as follows.

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The maximum pressure at the outlet to Pipe 11 is approximately 20.8 bar G.

3.6

Case 5:

Simulations with Elastomeric Deluge Valves:

Here again there is not one single way of modelling the systems. It depends on what types model are preferred and what data is available. There is one important point to bear in mind from a design point of view. The major advantages of using Elastomeric deluge valves are the following. They avoid interaction between deluge systems and reduce water usage. They help is reducing pressure surges because they do not allow the ringmain to drain when a deluge valve opens.

However, it is essential to remember that there are other significant users in ringmains such as monitors. They can also allow the ringmain to drain and cause unbalanced flow between users. It is important to consider their operation as well. We will not consider their operation in this section because they are similar to the way clack shut deluge valves in previous sections. 3.6.1. Simple Two Valve Method:

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 70 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

This is similar to the two valve model for clack shut deluge valve. The main difference is that the deluge valve opening is delayed, on the assumption that it will not operate until the firewater pump begins pressurising the ringmain. The network is the same. However, the operation of the valve is delayed. The first valve represents the deluge valve and the second valve is a virtual valve representing the deluge system. We assume that the deluge system takes 25 seconds to fill up. In order to model the behaviour during the time the deluge system fills, the virtual valve is given a Cv which is 10 times the Cv of the fully filled deluge system and it is closed to 10% of its fully open position over 25 seconds.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 71 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 72 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 73 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Maximum pressure is 15.9136 bar G on two-node caisson 1 at the inlet at time 39.16594 seconds Minimum pressure is 0.00000 bar G on pipe 1 at the inlet at time 0.000000 seconds

3.6.2. Addition of a Regulating Valve to the Two Valve Method: An elastomeric valve is essentially a downstream pressure regulating valve. So, it can be modelled as shown in the following schematic.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 74 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 75 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 76 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

3.7. Case 6:

Valve Closure Scenarios

The final scenarios that we consider relate to valve closure. It is assumed that the system is working with the fire pump running, and with the riser pipe fully primed. The caisson is unnecessarily complex and, for this reason, a pipe is used in place of the caisson. For the new pipe, the length is 26 metres, the elevation is 17 metres, and the diameter is 600 millimetres. We assume that the pump continues to run at full speed. We remove the overboard dump valve, since it is permanently closed during this scenario. We also remove the valve representing the jockey pump, as the fire pump is fully operational during this scenario. As mentioned above, we choose the value of Cv to be 50,000 (lit/min, bar) for the overboard dump valve. We require the results for the deluge valve and monitors to be shown (when they close).

3.7.1.

Monitor Closure Case

The first case we consider is the closure of the monitor valves. We assume that they both close in 2 seconds, starting simultaneously at 2 seconds. The modified network is shown below.

The caisson is replaced by a pipe

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 77 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The pipe that replaces the caisson has the following properties.

The specification for one of the monitor valves is shown below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 78 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

In this case, we assume that the deluge valve is closed. So, please note the following diagram and dialog box (which illustrate that the deluge valve is kept closed).

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 79 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Please note that, in this case, the pump will be running at full speed when the monitor valves close. The following diagram and dialog box indicate the input.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 80 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The graph below depicts the upstream pressure and the valve position for one of the monitors.

The maximum pressure in the network arises from Pipe 13, with a value around 21.0 bar G, and occurs after about 4.0 seconds.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 81 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Out of interest, we can look at the outlet pressure of the pump and the monitor valve position.

3.7.2.

Deluge Valve Closure

The final case we consider is that of the closure of the deluge system. As the flowrate here is larger, we consider a longer valve closure time of 5 seconds, starting at 2 seconds. Naturally, the monitor valves remain open throughout with this scenario. Apart from the fact that the monitor valves are closed, the system is shown in Case 4.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 82 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Deluge valve closing

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 83 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 84 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Graphical results for the valve are shown below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 85 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The maximum pressure, which is once again in Pipe 13, has a value around 19.9 bar G and it occurs at 7.13 seconds.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 86 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

3.8. Summary
Surge analysis of firewater systems is one of the most complex applications of PIPENET VISION. In fact, we believe that some of the capabilities of PIPENET VISION are unique in this respect. We began by stating that the following three types of scenario are normally considered for surge analysis of firewater systems. Pump start-up with no system running (which is often the case during pump start-up for weekly test purposes). Pump start-up with system(s) running, in which problems can be caused by cavity separation (and when this cavity collapses, very large pressure surges can arise). Valve closure during normal running.

By the end of this training course, you should have a basic understanding of how to run the above scenarios. The golden rules that you should follow are the following: Keep your system as simple as possible. Try to reduce the number of pipes to less than 50. Input the network in stages - do not try to input a large network in one attempt. Avoid short pipes.

4. 4.1

Monitor Closure Case: Real Offshore Firewater System (For Information Only, Not for Input) The Network

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 87 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

4.2

The Data

4.2.1 Transient Options


The following module options are used. Simulation time: Design rules: Default: C-factor: Cavitation: Pressure model: 30 seconds, NFPA 96/2001, 150, Vapour cavitation only, Hazen Williams.

Default values are used for the remaining parameters.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 88 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

4.2.2 Units
The units for the system are tabulated below.

Item
Length Diameter Pressure Velocities Flowrate Type Flowrate Density Viscosity Bulk Modulus Volume Time Force Mass Temperature Torque Inertia

Unit m mm Bar G m/s volume m3/hr kg/m3 Pa.s G Pa litres s N kg C Nm kg.m2

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 89 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

4.2.3 Fluid Data

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 90 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

4.2.4

Pipe Schedules

The following data is used to create a new pipe schedule in the library. Name: Youngs Modulus: Roughness: Poisson Ratio: PN20 GRE PIPE, 10 GPa, 0.0457 mm, 0.4. Internal Bore (mm) 38 81.8 105.2 159 208.8 262.9 313.7 344.4 393.7 1000 External Bore (mm) 49 89 115.6 166.8 218.8 274.9 327.9 360.2 411.5 1060

Nominal Bore (mm) 40 80 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 900

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 91 OF 106 The dialog box for entering the pipe schedule is shown below.

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 92 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

After the schedule library has been created, it needs to be accessed, as follows.

4.2.5

Pump Library

The pump data is tabulated below. Flow Rate (m/hour) 0 625 1000 1500 2000 Pressure (bar G) 17.4 15.86 14.1 11.94 9.4

The minimum and the maximum flow rates are 0 m/hour and 2000 m/hour respectively. After the following pump data is entered, PIPENET VISION will produce the performance curve. The library files are saved with the extension .SLF.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 93 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

4.2.6

Pipe Data

The pipe type is PN20 GRE PIPE. Pipe Label 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Diameter Length (mm) (m) 200 6.7 100 400 200 150 400 400 2 7.297 6.378 1 18.649 34.026 Elevation (m) 3.1 0 0 3 0.1 0 0 C-factor 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 Fittings 45 deg elbow x 2 90 deg elbow x 6 90 deg elbow x 5 90 deg elbow x 2 Tee x1 90 deg elbow x 3 Tee x2 45 deg elbow x 2 Tee x2 Butterfly valve x1 45 deg elbow x 1 90 deg elbow x 1

400

4.589

-0.8

150

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 94 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011 Butterfly valve x1 Tee x1 Butterfly valve x1 Tee x1 90 deg elbow x 3 Butterfly valve x1 90 deg elbow x 6 Tee x 1 Tee x1 90 deg elbow x 6 45 deg elbow x 2 Tee x 1 Long radius elbow x1 90 deg elbow x 2 45 deg elbow x 5 Tee x 4 Butterfly valve x3 90 deg elbow x 1 Tee x 2 90 deg elbow x 4 45 deg elbow x 1 Tee x 1 Butterfly valve x1 90 deg elbow x 6 90 deg elbow x 1 45 deg elbow x 5 Tee x 1 90 deg elbow x 7 Tee x 3 Butterfly valve x 3 Tee x 2 90 deg elbow x 1 Tee x 1 Butterfly valve x 1 Tee x 1 90 deg elbow x 5 Tee x 1 Butterfly valve x 1 90 deg elbow x 4 45 deg elbow x 4 90 deg elbow x 2

9 10 11

400 400 200

9.297 3.162 8.639

0 0 4.355

150 150 150

12 13 14 15

150 100 200 150

13.857 11.342 8.392 27.527

5.006 11.342 4.355 14.649

150 150 150 150

16

400

33.5

0.8

150

17 18

400 200

3.35 18.111

0 4.103

150 150

19 20 21 22 23 24 25

150 100 400 100 400 900 400

5.331 17.239 24.786 47.79 1.14 20 26.15

3.966 10.04 11.11 17 0 -16 2.006

150 150 150 150 150 150 150

26 27

400 400

3.31 42.71

0 -2.006

150 150

28 29 30

400 400 150

1.763 25.41 71.36

0 0 22.36

150 150 150

31 32 33 34

150 250 100 400

2.494 24.12 2 10.87

2.494 1.92 -0.8 0

150 150 150 150

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 95 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011 45 deg elbow x 5 Tee x 4 Butterfly valve x3 90 deg elbow x 2 45 deg elbow x 5 Tee x 4 Butterfly valve x3 90 deg elbow x 5 Tee x 1 Swing Check valve x 1 Butterfly valve x 1

35

400

8.38

150

36 37 38

350 200 400

36.5 1 15.997

30.5 0.1 4.317

150 150 150

The pipe data can be entered only after the schematic has been drawn. The attributes of the pipes are input either through the Properties Window or through the Data Window.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 96 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

To add fittings to the pipes, select the Fittings Tab at the bottom of the Properties Window.

Note that fittings can be input only through the Fittings Tab.

4.2.7

Valves Data

In this network, six operating valves are used to represent six deluge systems. The details of each valve are shown below (including the flow coefficient). Valve Label 1 2 3 4 5 6 Opening Profile Linear Linear Linear Linear Linear Linear Flow Coefficient (m/h, Bar G) 123.27 82.4 18.97 149.8 145 37.9

The properties of Valve 1 are shown below.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 97 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The pump type must be assigned:

4.2.8

Vacuum Breakers

There are five vacuum breakers in the network, and all have the same attributes.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 98 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The attributes for the above vacuum breaker can be copied and pasted for the other vacuum breakers. 4.2.9. Inlet/Outlet Specifications The following pressure specifications apply. Node label 32 45 4 10 6 48 39 Specification Type Pressure Pressure Pressure Pressure Pressure Pressure Pressure Time Function Constant Constant Constant Constant Constant Constant Constant Values 0 Bar G 0 Bar G 0 Bar G 0 Bar G 0 Bar G 0 Bar G 5.5 Bar G

A zero flow is set at the outlets of all of the vacuum breakers. Node Label 52 53 54 55 56 Specification Type Flowrate Flowrate Flowrate Flowrate Flowrate Time Function Constant Constant Constant Constant Constant Values 0 m/h 0 m/h 0 m/h 0 m/h 0 m/h

The pump is operating continuously, and the specification at its information node is as follows.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 99 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Only Valves 3 and 6 are operating valves, and Valve 5 is actuated by a control system. The remaining three valves are closed. Valve 6 closes in 5 seconds, starting from the fifth second.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 100 OF 106 Valve 3 closes in 3 seconds, beginning after one second.

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Valve 5 is actuated by a control system, the details of which are provided below. Node 47 is taken as the reference node, and a pressure sensor is connected to it. The physical output from the sensor is converted into a digital signal by the transfer function. Then, it is processed in the PID controller, and the signal from the PID controller passes through a transfer function, before activating the valve.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 101 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

An enlarged view has been provided below to clearly show the control system.

Pressure control valve

The attributes of the transfer function that is located after the sensor are as follows.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 102 OF 106 The attributes for the PID controller are illustrated below.

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

The following attributes apply to the transfer function that connects the PID controller to the operating valve.

4.4

The Calculation

The system is now complete, but before the calculation is run, it is necessary to select the graphical output for the valves, control system, and pumps. The graphical result can be selected either directly from the schematic (by right-clicking the appropriate component and selecting the graphical results) or through the Data Window.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 103 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Select the graphical results that are required

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 104 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

4.4.1 Calculation Options

4.5

The Results

A selection of graphical results now follows. Please note that the figures in this section were not created using the latest version of the PIPENET VISION Graph Viewer.

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 105 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

PIPENET VISION TRAINING MANUAL PAGE 106 OF 106

TRANSIENT: CHAPTER 6 REVISION 2.1, FEB 2011

Anda mungkin juga menyukai