Race, Trust, and Tuskegee: Professional Ethics, Broken Trust and Health Disparities
Prepared and presented by Marc Imhotep Cray, M.D.
Based upon data provided by the AMA Race, Trust Speakers Kit
The information presented in these slides and the companion notes, from which this presentation was created, are meant to serve as a continuation of the dissemination of evidence-based information on Physician Ethics, Trust, and Health Disparities.
This presentation is a part of the IVMS Sharping Professionalism Learning | Teaching Series
To explain why African Americans tend to mistrust the medical profession (and this mistrust is not unfounded) To emphasize why the medical profession needs to demonstrate its trustworthiness. Some initial ideas...
2
Fewer eye examinations in DM, B-blockers after MI, and follow-up after hosp. for mental illness (Schneider 02)
3
Due to Coverage?
Schneider et al. (2001,2002) found that among Medicare recipients in managed care health plans, African Americans were less likely than whites to receive:
Breast cancer screenings 62.9% vs. 70.9% (P<.001) Eye examinations for diabetes patients 43.6% vs. 50.4% (P=.02) -blocker medication after myocardial infarction 64.1% vs. 73.8% (P<.005) Follow-up after hospitalization for mental illness 33.2% vs. 54.0% (P<.001) Influenza vaccinations 46.1% vs. 67.7% (AD 21.6%; 95% CI 18.2% to 25.0%)
Transplantation Disparities
Median Waiting Time (in Months) to Kidney Transplant By Race
Year
1988
1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994
Black Recipients
20.1
21.4 24.9 26.7 29.8 34.9 39.7
White Recipients
11.3
12.7 13.3 14.1 16.0 18.7 20.1
Difference
8.8
8.7 11.6 13.7 13.8 16.2 19.6
Source of Data for 1998 HHS OIG Report: Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network (OPTN), 1997 OPTN/SR AR 1988-1996. UNOS; DOT/HRSA/DHHS. 5
The Washington Post, the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation and Harvard University Racial Attitudes Survey (April 2001)
Unfair Treatment
25% of White physicians 29% of Physicians overall 33% of Asian physicians 52% of Latino physicians 77% of African American physicians
believe that the health care system treats people unfairly based on their racial or ethnic background very or somewhat often.
The Kaiser Family Foundation National Survey of Physicians (March 2002)
7
Most whites (70%-76%) believe that African Americans and Latinos receive the same quality of care as they do.
68% of whites, 75% of Latinos, 80% of African Americans say racism is a problem in health care
56% of Latinos, 64% of African Americans believe they receive lower quality health care than whites
Results of a Kaiser Family Foundation survey conducted in 1999 of 3,884 whites, 8 African Americans, and Latinos. (Lillie-Blanton et al. 2000)
Fueling Disparities
Patient-Level Variables Patient preferences, mistrust, comfort level Seeking treatment (or not) Adherence to treatment (or not) Effectiveness of treatment Healthcare Systems-Level Factors Language barriers Availability and access to health care Ability to navigate clinical bureaucracies Lack of insurance, differences in insurance Managed care limitations Care Process-Level Variables Bias, prejudice, stereotyping, clinical uncertainty Decisions made with limited time and information Effect of patient response on physician
Institute of Medicine Report (2002) Unequal Treatment: Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care 9
Importance of Trust
Intrinsic value of trust in the Patient-Physician Relationship
The physician-patient relationship often reflects [intimate bonds] and contains strong elements of transference, particularly during times of critical illness when patients are vulnerable and frightened. (Mechanic 1996)
Instrumental Value of Trust in Health Care Trust predicts a patients loyalty to their physician. (Thom 1999, Safran 2001, Keating 2002)
Higher levels of trust between patients and their physicians are correlated with positive health outcomes. (Thom 1999, Safran 1998)
10
Declining Trust
Eroding trust means that the health care system must work to maintain not only trust in physicians, but trust in the health care system overall. Harris and Associates Poll (1998) USA Today/CNN/Gallup Poll (2002)
Teachers Clergymen or priests Doctors Scientists Judges Professors Police officers Ordinary man or woman (The) President Business leaders Members of Congress Journalists Trade union leaders
86% 85% 83% 79% 79% 77% 75% 71% 54% 49% 46% 43% 37%
Teachers Military officers Police officers Protestant ministers Doctors Catholic priests Government officials Lawyers CEOs of large corporations Managers of HMOs
84% 73% 71% 68% 66% 45% 26% 25% 23% 20%
11
Lower patient and physician satisfaction Increased disenrollment Increased demand by patients for referrals and diagnostic tests Poorer patient adherence to treatment recommendations Increased litigation Possibly lower health status
Thom and Campbell 1997, Safran et al. 1998
12
13
Trust:
Trust is important in reducing anxiety, increasing a patients sense of being cared for, which in turn may improve the patients sense of well-being and improve functioning. (Thom and Campbell 1997)
Side query: What might be the economic cost of losing the placebo effect?
14
Trust can be disconfirmed at any time. Although patients discount small lapses because they appreciate that doctors, like others, can have good and bad days, a serious failure to be responsive when needed can shatter even the strongest of relationships. (Mechanic 1996)
15
Interpersonal and Institutional trust are related: Beginning a relationship with a new physician requires some level of institutional trust. Institutional trust can be cultivated by building on existing trust between patients and physicians.
16
African Americans are less trusting of the organ donation system. (Yuen 1998, Siminoff 1999) African Americans have less trust in the health care system in general. (Gamble 1997, Freedman 1998, Minniefield 2001) African Americans have profound mistrust of medical research. (Freedman 1998, Freimuth 2001, Shavers 2001, CorbieSmith 1999 and 2002)
18
Extreme Mistrust
The government introduced drugs into African American communities.
Physicians withdraw life-support to African Americans for financial/racial reasons over medical reasons.
Gamble 1997, Freedman 1998, Freimuth 2001
The Tuskegee Study (USPHS Study of Untreated Syphilis in the Negro Male) involved deliberate infection with Syphilis.
(Gamble 1997, Freimuth 2001)
20
21
For many blacks, the Tuskegee Study became a symbol of their mistreatment by the medical establishment, a metaphor for deceit, conspiracy, malpractice, and neglect, if not outright racial genocide. (Jones 1991) 81% know something about the USPHS Study at Tuskegee (Shavers 2001)
23
Untreated Syphilis
It was difficult to hold the interest of the group of Negroes in Macon County unless some treatment was given Dr. R. Vonderlehr, 1968. (Brandt 1978) In interviews with four survivors: (Department of Health, Education
and Welfare, 1973 - in Reverby 2000)
The USPHS ensured that the subjects did not receive treatment from other sources. (Brandt 1978)
While the men did not get treated for syphilis, they did get good medical carecare they would not have received otherwise because of their socioeconomic status. (As perceived
by Nurse Rivers in Hammonds, 1994)
25
Contemporary Experience
The legacy of the Tuskegee Study endures, in part, because the racism and disrespect for black lives that it entailed mirror black peoples contemporary experiences with medicine. (Blendon et al
1995)
Negative experiences cited by African American and Latino focus groups (Thom and Campbell 1997)
lack of respect lack of privacy deaths of friends or relatives due to what was perceived to be poor medical care
African American patients rate their visits with physicians as less participatory than whites. (Cooper-Patrick et al. 1999)
26
How can the profession build trust that has been breached?
27
The End
Special thanks to the AMA for providing the kit that made this presentational possible
Bibliography and Reading List (Word, 33KB)
Credits: This information was originally presented, in part, by Dr. Matthew Wynia MD, MPH at a June 2002 meeting of the American Medical Association's Medical Student Section. The meeting was hosted by the AMA Minority Affairs Consortium. Development of the ideas contained within this presentation was done in collaboration with Dr. Elizabeth Jacobs, MD in preparation for a paper on the relationship between physician professionalism, patient trust, medical ethics, and health disparities.
See: National Institutes of Health Presentation to Council of Public Representatives (PPT, 92.5KB) 24 Pages, focus on Race, Trust and Health Research
29
Eliminating Health Disparities Patient-centered communication Ethical Force Program initiative to develop tools for assessment and learning Focus area: trust A physician's professional responsibility, patient trust, and racial/ethnic disparities in healthcare. Race, trust speakers kit Race, trust, and tuskegee: Professional ethics, broken trust and health disparities Trust and disparities teaching resources Films, books and articles to be used for teaching about ethics and health disparities. What you can do Ways you can take action to address health disparities.
30