Susan Ginsburg
Susan -
Thanks. I think you and Janice covered the ground very well. It is not surprising that the manifest would read one
date, btit the flight took off the next day since the FBI obtained the manifests in advance of the flights taking off.
One further point (that I would have to check the FBI documents to confirm) is that the name al Hazmi set off
alarm bells in the FBI for obvious reasons and specifically because they had that name on their security directive
list created after 9-1 1 of individuals not allowed to fly or depart without FBI clearance. I believe the FBI
documents, state that they did check to see whether there was any connection between the al Hazmi on the flight
and the hijacker, and satisfied themselves there was not.
~ Tom
— Original Message —
From: Susan Ginsburg
To: "
Sent: Sunday, April 11,2004 12:55 PM
Subject: FW: Manifest Raises Questions About Saudi Flights After 9/1 1
Tom,
Thanks.
Susan
I just spoke to Susan regarding your email about 45 minutes ago. In an effort to expedite an answer for you,
and because Tom is currently on a flight himself and unreachable, I've cross referenced the Flocco article
against Tom's summary memo on the Saudi flights and the original flight manifests. Walt helped me too.
Here's what I found: >•
[e
1. Flocco says there were 4 flights. There were actually 6. Flocco's dates for the flights are inaccurate as
well.
2. The date of the Lexington, KY flight was Sept. 16, not 15.
3 Both individuals listed in the Flocco article were on this Lexington flight. There is no evidence that the al
Hazmi listed in the article is in anyway connected to the hijacker Nawaf al Hazmi. (Flocco doesn't
4/11/2004
.1 Confidential Page 2 of4
Source
'There is a report that one chartered flight of Saudis flew from Tampa, Florida to Lexington, Kentucky on
September 13, 2001 at 4:30 p.m. "Phantom Flight from Florida," Tampa Tribune, October 5,2001. The
article relates that a Saudi Prince and his security detail told the Prince's father and his father's security
detail (which included several off-duty Lexington police officers) that he had flown to Kentucky from
Florida on September 13, 2001 in order to board the September 16, 2001 flight that departed the U.S.
from Lexington. However, the FBI found no FAA documentation of any flight from Florida to Lexington
\r to September 14, 2001. Moreover, according to the FBI, Lexington Airport Police Chief of Police
Scott Lanter told the FBI that no planes took off or landed in Lexington until the FAA lifted flight
\. Perhaps most significantly, according to the FBIJ \s that the young Prince told
there because his father had specifically advised him not to drive for fear the son would be in danger of
he did so. RFBI04017295 (Bates 10); RFBI03009447 (Bates 4). We are attempting to get the FBI
interview reports related to this incident. We continue to investigate whether it is possible the Tampa
airport reopened before the Saudi Prince's alleged flight on September 13, 2001, at 4:30 p.m.
6. As to Flocco's assertions about who may have provided the okay for these flights, that's still under
Commission investigation.
Janice
Original Message—
From: Susan Ginsburg
Sent: Tuesday, April 06, 2004 2:57 PM
To: Janice Kephart-Roberts
Subject: FW: Manifest Raises Questions About Saudi Flights After 9/11
Let1 s try to reach him to get his comment, unless you can give it for him.
4/11/2004
Personal Privacy _ „ _.
Page 3 of 4
Subject: RE: Manifest Raises Questions About Saudi Flights After 9/11
Tom has gone on vacation for a week. He is on his way to Palm Beach FL. We could reach
him there later today. Let us know. S
—Original Message—
From: Philip Zelikow
Sent: Tuesday, April 06, 2004 9:51 AM
To: Tom Eldridge
Cc: Team 5; Front Office; Christine Healey
Subject: FW: Manifest Raises Questions About Saudi Flights After 9/11
Tom -
Any comment? The story doesn't seem so convincing on the surface ...
\Z
—briglnal Message—
From;! I
Sent; Tuesday, April 06. 2004 12:19 AM
T O ! " 1
Subject: Manifest Raises Questions About Saudi Flights After 9/11
by Tom Flocco
WASHINGTON - April 4, 2004 - Posted 13:45 ET -- TomFlocco.com -
A copy of a previously unpublished manifest, obtained late Thursday night and dated
September 15,2001, provides evidence of a private Boeing-727 Saudi flight from
Lexington, Kentucky to London. But the names on the manifest raise serious questions
about FBI policies and procedures related to witness identification, criminal
investigations and obstruction of justice.
Ahmad A. M. Alhazmi, 20, (Saudi passport no. B805019) is listed on the manifest with
Prince Sultan bin Fahad bin Salman bin Abdulaziz, 19, (Saudi passport no. 406 A), son
of Saudi defense minister Crown Prince Abdullah bin Abdulaziz.
The name Alhazmi and its ties to laundered Riggs Bank cashiers checks may become
a subject of interest when National Security Advisor Condoteezza Rice testifies later
this week-especially since young Ahmad Alhazmi has the same last name as Nawaf
Alhazmi, one of the terrorists identified as an alleged hijacker of American Airlines flight
77. FidLStPry
4/11/2004
Page 4 of4
vyww,tuesdayschildren,org
4/11/2004
fo.com - Manifest Raises Questions About Saudi Flights After 9/11 Page 1 of 10
Download Free The name Alhazmi and its ties to laundered Riggs Bank cashiers checks
may become a subject of interest when National Security Advisor
Top Referrers Condoleezza Rice testifies later this week—especially since young
Ahmad Alhazmi has the same last name as Nawaf Alhazmi, one of the
rense.com terrorists identified as an alleged hijacker of American Airlines flight
77.
whatreallyhappen..
Options
davidicke.com
blackboxvoting The White House had originally asserted that flights evacuating Saudis Printer Friendly
from the United States after 9/11 never existed, but author Craig Unger- Page
democrats.com -who has written a book about clandestine Bush-Saudi relationships--
S Send to a
scoop.co.nz
obtained flight manifest lists which were drawn up by the Saudi Friend
embassy.
legitgov.org
Besides the Alhazmi list, three other manifests confirm a total of four
democratic separate Saudi flights leaving the United States on September 15,
underground
IjS, 22 and 24, 2001, after the World Trade Center and Pentagon
H<1 10
http://tomflocco.com/modules.pnp ?name=News&file=article&sid=53 4/6/2004
co.com - Manifest Raises Questions About Saudi Flights After 9/11 Page 2 of 10
jr world
attacks. Unger, author of "House of Bush / House of Saud: The Secret
newsmakingnews Relationship Between the World's Two Most Powerful Dynasties," has
now posted all four manifests online.
serendipity
(http://www.houseofbush.com/files.php)
prorev.com
Alhazmi's associates received continued payments of $3,500. per month"""7
t-,-
home.t-online.de from Princess Haifa Al-Faisal, wife of Saudi Crown Prince Bandar bin /
Sultan who is Ambassador to the United States, according to sources I
stallman.org
familiar with the financial evidence. (Newsweek, 11-22-2002)
thepowerhour.com
Both Saudis visited President Bush's Texas ranch in late August, 2002-
before this news broke—but Americans will never hear Mr.
Hot Sites
Bush publicly discuss the contents of their conversations, or Bandar and
Lost Your Job? Haifa's signed checks made out to terrorist associates through his
Outsource Congress
uncle's Riggs Bank. 9/11 Commission Chairman Thomas Kean
Lost Your Money? negotiated away the important opportunity for personal,
Solari.com public presidential testimony under oath in exchange for Condoleezza
Rice's public testimony.
Lost Your Vote?
Black Box Voting
Interestingly, Kean stumbled slightly this morning when Meet the Press
Lost Your Country? host Tim Russert asked him why Bush and Vice-President Cheney were
Quality Of Life testifying together, and why former President Clinton and Vice-
President Gore were not being offered the same opportunity.
Lost a Friend on
911?
Cooperative Bush and Cheney will not be under oath, allowing joint corroboration
Research of each other's testimony on-the-spot regarding their actions during the
key two hour time-line of the actual attacks—thus avoiding possible
Lost Legal Rights? future perjury charges and/or impeachment proceedings.
A Matter of Justice
When Roemer asked "why the Saudis were allowed to leave the
country, who was on the planes, how many, and why the decision was
made," Clarke said the government "feared for their lives...some of
them were bin Laden family members, and the Saudi embassy requested
their evacuation."
During testimony Clarke told Roemer "I refused to approve the [Saudi]
request. I passed it on to [FBI Asst. Director] Dale Watson and the -^-
f%ht was approved....! don't think they were ever interviewed Minis
country." Only transcripts and/or video would negate Clarke's
assertion.
Clarke only mentioned one flight. And it is not known whether the
counter-terrorism chief was kept in the dark about the other flights, as
Roemer did not mention the now-public manifests. The commission^-'
has not revealed publicly whether it knows about Ahmad Alhazmi^alid
Prince Sultan bin Fahad, fueling speculation that an investigation of the
young Alhazmi may have been suppressed by the FBI or commission
executive director Philip Zelikow who controls the inner-workings of
the panel's probe.
There are indications that young Ahmad Alhazmi, along with Saudi
prince Sultan bin Fahad, and one other young man on the Lexington to~~"~?
London evacuation flight, were among a select few to fly on September \, 2001, two days after
I The special Saudi flighthas been termed the "phantom flight from
^Florida,.)' since Atlanta Federal Aviation_Administration spokesman'
ud "It's not in our logs./^didn't occur."yBut the Tampa
rribune'Tmultiple sources indicate that very high strings were pulled,
raising more questions about the identities of the young Alhazmi and
Prince.
Hopsicker said local police collected all the hijacker flight training files
from Hilliard's Huffman Aviation School the day after the attacks--
detailing information that would have confirmed or denied the flight
capabilities of the hijackers and sources of their funding support.
Just five days before the attacks on September 7, Governor Bush signed
executive order No. 01-261, declaring the authority "to order members
of the Florida National Guard into active service...to support law
enforcement and emergency management in the the event of civil
disturbances or natural disasters..."
No one knows where the President's brother went with the FBI officials
and the hijacker flight training evidence, fueling speculation that both
Hijacked bank
Questions also remain regarding the web of money transfers from
Princess Haifa, Prince Bandar and the daughter of late King Faisal,
some of which reached Nawaf Alhazmi and fellow terrorist Khalid
Almihdar.
Cashiers checks were sent to Majeda Ibrahin Dweikat, who signed them
over to her friend Manal Ahmed Bagader, wife of Omar al-Bayoumi
who met and befriended Alhazmi and Almihdar when they arrived in
the U.S.
All this, at a time when the White House was receiving "frantic" threat
warnings about "planes used as weapons" that would "set your hair on
fire," according to Commissioner Jamie Gorelick and other panel
members.
Houston's Baker & Botts, the family law firm of Bush 41 Secretary of
State James Baker that is defending Saudi Arabia's defense minister,
Crown Prince Abdullah, against the 9-11 families regarding the
financing of terrorism in America, produced "stacks of affidavits and
blackboxvoting The White House had originally asserted that flights evacuating Saudis Printer Friendly
from the United States after 9/11 never existed, but author Craig Unger- Page
democrats.com -who has written a book about clandestine Bush-Saudi relationships--
S Send to a
obtained flight manifest lists which were drawn up by the Saudi Friend
scoop.co.nz
embassy.
legitgov.org
Besides the Alhazmi list, three other manifests confirm a total of Jour
democratic separate Saudi flights leaving the United States on September 15;
underground
16i/2/ and 24, 2001, after the World Trade Center and Pentagon
When Roemer asked "why the Saudis were allowed to leave the
country, who was on the planes, how many, and why the decision was
made," Clarke said the government "feared for their lives...some of
them were bin Laden family members, and the Saudi embassy requested
their evacuation."
During testimony Clarke told Roemer "I refused to approve the [Saudi]
request. I passed it on to [FBI Asst. Director] Dale Watson and the
flight was approved....! don't think they were ever interviewed in this
country." Only transcripts and/or video would negate Clarke's
assertion.
Clarke only mentioned one flight. And it is not known whether the
counter-terrorism chief was kept in the dark about the other flights, as
Roemer did not mention the now-public manifests. The commission
has not revealed publicly whether it knows about Ahmad Alhazmi and
Prince Sultan bin Fahad, fueling speculation that an investigation of the
young Alhazmi may have been suppressed by the FBI or commission
executive director Philip Zelikow who controls the inner-workings of
the panel's probe.
There are indications that young Ahmad Alhazmi, along with Saudi
prince Sultan bin Fahad, and one other young man on the Lexington to
London evacuation flight, were^arnnri^a^select few tn flyjjn^September M(
13, 2001. two davs-after the attacks, when all planes over U.S. air space
were grounded—save a few emergency medical and body-part transplant
flights, one of which was forced to use a helicopter to comply with the
flight ban.
The special Saudi flight has been termed the "phantom flight from
Florida," since Atlanta Federal Aviation Administration spokesman
Chris White said "It's not in our logs...it didn't occur." But the Tampa
Tribune's multiple sources indicate that very high strings were pulled, .
raising more questions about the identities of the young Alhazmi and "
Prince.
LPrivate investi gator \r\d former Tampa police department homicide and
internal affairs officer Dan Grossi said he was told that clearance for the
flight came from the White House. This may confirm Richard Clarke's
recent testimony that "most likely it was the White House Chief of
Staffs office" who gave the order.
Grossi said the prince's family [Crown Prince Abdullah bin Abdulaziz]
pulled a favor from former President Bush—the only indication that it
was Bush 41 who first contacted Bush 43 to get the three men out of
Florida. All this, according to the Tampa Tribune.
Grossi and Perez said they saw "several private 747s parked on the
tarmac with foreign flags on the tails and Arabic lettering on the sides,"
helping to confirm the authenticity of the Saudi embassy manifests.
This, at a time when all U.S. air space was locked down by the United
States military under federal orders.