Examination Committee: Dr. Hany Maximos (Faculty) Dr. Amr Sweedan (Dept.) Dr. Bilal El-Ariss (Dept.)
Objectives
The Graduation Project is divided into two main phases, namely GPI and GPII. The three-dimensional (3D) analytical modeling of the 60-story building, load calculations and verifications of the analytical model were performed in GPI. Tasks and results of this phase are briefly presented in this report. The second phase of the project focus on designing different structural members of the high-rise building such as floor slabs, beams, columns, shear walls and foundations using latest analysis software and modern design codes.
Original Building
Design process
Requirements Specifications Conseptual Design Embodiment Design (Simulation Model) Detailed Design
Specification:
Building should be design according to: ACI 318-05 Code. IBC 2009/ASCE 7-05 for calculating the wind loads. Structural Analysis programs: CSI ETABS CSI SAFE PROKON
Requirement:
Plan area: 1750.2 m2
Total number of stories: 60 Typical Story height: 3.5 m Use of the building: residential building Used materials: normal and high strength material and reinforcing steel
Summary of GPI
Summary of GPI
30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0 Earthquake Load Wind Load EW
Hand Calculation
1200000 1000000 800000 600000 400000 200000 0
ETABS Results
Hand
ETABS Results
GPII Tasks
Verified three dimensional analytical model of a typical 60-story building, representing the modern tall buildings in the UAE.
Design different structural elements, including the complete design of suitable floor slab systems, such as solid slabs and flat slabs, at different story levels of the high-rise building using the SAFE and PROKON programs.
Optimized design of shear walls using the latest version of the ETABS program with different load combinations and different cross section sizes and reinforcement ratios to arrive at the most cost-effective design.
In GPII we have designed three types of slab systems 1- Flat Slab 2- Hollow Block Slab 3- Solid Slab
Flat Slab
Solid Slab
Design as a T-Section
Increasing the width of ribs Increasing the depth & number of blocks Increasing of the reinforcement
Solid Slabs
Wu=1.2WD+ 1.6WL == 16.98 kN/m2 Mu = 13.262 kN.m/m
Rn=[Mu/ (
= 2.62 = 0.0065
Flat slabs
Exporting three slabs:
The following three slabs are exported from ETABS to SAFE: Ground story slab.
The design process of flat slabs is started by determining the most optimum thickness of the slab.
The optimum thickness can be determined by selecting the slab thickness and verifying the deflection
Example :Ground story After extracting the maximum positive and negative moment, each is divided by the strip width to get the bending moment per unit length and calculate the corresponding reinforcement
Strip No. S1x S2y S3y Strip No. S1x Strip No. S1x S2y S3y
+M/width 123.3
As Strip No. S1x S2y S3y -M/width 240.9 150.1 49.2 As = bd 2410 1457.64 463.46 Amesh 1188.2 1188.2 1188.2 Amesh 1221.8 269.44 ---Additional Reinf. 616 412 ----
Vc1 =
fc' bod 6
Vc2 =
fc' b d d o 2) b 12
o
Vc3 =
fc' b d o 3
Best Alternative
Flat Slabs Hollow Block Slabs
Decision Based on
Efficiency/ Construction
Cost
- The choice of the slab system for the 60stor building is based on the cost and performance - The hollow block slab system is more expensive than flat slabs. Moreover, flat slabs are much easier in construction, and therefore the flat slabs are selected.
Cost in Millions AED
60.00 50.00 40.00 30.00 20.00 10.00 0.00 Floor slabs cost Hollow block slab
Stairs
Design of stairs using hand calculations
Wu = 16.08kN/m2 Wu X 0.3 load of each stair = 16.08 X 0.3 = 4.824 kN/m
STEP 2: Determine As
As= bd = 0.003521*300*195= 206 mm2
Stairs
[ use 3 bars#10]
Stairs
Reinforcement distribution
3#10 /step
3#10 /step
Beams
Design of hidden beam Design of edge beam Design of connecting beam
B1
Connecting beams
Beams
Design of hidden beam using hand calculations
(M max) = (Wu x L2)/8 =168.44 (KN.m)
Beams
Design of hidden beam using Prokon
Beam deflection
Beams
Slab Load: Dead load from slab = 48.03 kN/m Live load from slab = 8.5 kN/m Beam own weight Edge beam cross section hb= 620 mm O.W Beam= bw hb c = ((0.250.24) + (0.81 0.38)) (25) = 9.195 kN/m) Wall own weight O.W wall = bw hw = 0.25 2.88 10 = 7.2 (KN/m) Effective Length bw + 6t= 0.25+ (60.38)=2.53 bw + L / 12=0.25 +(6.7/12)=0.81m bw + b0= 0.25+ 4= 4.25 m
Beams
Design of edge beam using Prokon
Long-term deflection
Moment x-x
Beams
Reinforcement distribution
Reinforcement distribution
Beams
Design of connecting beams
Greater than 2
Beams
Design of connecting beams using ETABs & Prokon
Beams
Design of connecting beams using ETABs & Prokon
Level Beams No. B1_1 Reinforcement ground story levels B1_2 Reinforcement B1_3 Reinforcement B2_1 Reinforcement 17th story levels B2_2 Reinforcement B2_3 Reinforcement B3_1 Reinforcement 36th story levels B3_2 Reinforcement B3_3 Reinforcement 625mm 625mm 750mm 625mm 625mm 750mm 625mm 625mm Flange Width 750mm Bending Moment M=1270.42 KN.m 8 T 25 M=1660.9 KN.m 10 T 25 M=1537.34 KN.m 9 T 25 M=763.82 KN.m 5 T 25 M=895.1 KN.m 6 T 25 M=767.92 KN.m 5 T 25 M=760.1 KN.m 5 T 25 M=820.9 KN.m 5 T 25 M=679.5 KN.m 4 T 25 Shear Force V=865.2 (KN) 4 T 8@ 120 mm V= 1047.6 (KN) 4 T 10 @ 150 mm V= 1072.71 (KN) 4 T 10@ 120 mm V= 620.4 (KN) 4 T 8@ 150 mm V= 716.71 (KN) 4 T 8@ 120 mm V= 619.9 (KN) 4 T 8@ 150 mm V= 630.37 (KN) 4 T 8@ 150 mm V= 637.1 (KN) 4 T 8@ 150 mm V= 564.4 (KN) 4 T 8@ 200 mm
Shear Walls
Design shear walls using ETABs
Shear Walls
Design process
o Define pier section. o Pier section data. o Section designer. o Assign pier section. o Assign general Reinforcing pier section. o Start design of section.
Shear Walls
General reinforcing Pier Section
Shear Walls
Optimization
As(min) = (0.25/100) Ag
Level
Columns
Design columns using ETABs
Columns name No. of columns Columns dimension Col(1-20) 8 (1000x300) Col(2-20) 4 (1500x400) Col(2-40) 4 (1500x300)
Columns
Columns reinforcement detail
Columns
Check safety of columns
If columns un-safe:
Increase columns dimension Increase concrete strength
Design of Foundation
Using Safe program 709 piles have been distributed among the raft area.
Foundation Results
Point loads representation due to applied loads.
Foundation Results
Deformed shape.
Foundation Results
Strip # 1 in X-direction Strip # 2 in Y-direction Strip # 3 in Y-direction
Foundation Reinforcement
Reinforcement detailing for the raft foundation
Cost Estimate
Beams
Beams (cost) = width length depth number of stories cost of one m3
Columns
Columns (cost) = width length height number of stories cost of one m3
Cost Estimate
Shear Walls
Shear walls (cost) = thickness length height number of stories cost of one m3
Floor slab
Flat slab (cost) =thickness net area cost of one m3 number of stories
Cost Estimate
Stairs
Stairs (cost) = Area Stairs thickness Factor (1.2) number of stories cost of one m3 = [(3 m 7 m)0.23 m1.2 60 stories 2500 (Dhs/ m3)]2= 1,738,800 AED
Excavation
Excavations (cost) = Depth Area Raft cost of one m3 = 11 m 1750.2 m2 50 (Dhs/m3) = 962,610 AED
Plain Concrete
Raft Foundation
Foundations
Concrete Plan(cost)= Area Raft Thickness Cost of one m3 = (1750.2) m2 0.4 m 700 (Dhs/ m3)= 490,056 AED Raft foundation(cost)= Area Raft Thickness Cost of one m3 = (1750.2) m2 3.2 m 2200 (Dhs/m3) = 12,321,408AED
170,969,819
AED
Pile Foundation
Piles foundation (cost)= Number of piles length of pile Cost of one meter = 709 piles 25 m 2800 (Dhs/m) = 49,630,000 AED
Cost Estimate
Final cost estimate of structural system
Cost in Million (AED) 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
Project Management
Conclusion
The analytical model and modern design provisions have been employed in the second phase of the project (GPII) to fully design different structural members of the 60-story high-rise building.