This paper was prepared for presentation at the 2006 SPE Technical Symposium of Saudi
Arabia Section held in Dhahran, Saudi Arabia, 21-23 May 2006.
Copyright 2006 Society of Petroleum Engineers This paper was selected for presentation by the Technical Symposium Program Committee following review of information contained in full manuscript submitted by the author(s). Contents of the paper, as presented, have not been reviewed by the Society of Petroleum Engineers and are subject to correction by the author(s). The material, as presented, does not necessarily reflect any position of the Society of Petroleum Engineers, its officers, or members.
Abstract This paper on ERD wells focuses on nearly all important aspects of drilling ERD wells. Various case studies have also been taken while discussing various aspects so as to signify the practical experience of ERD wells. The latest technology for drilling ERD wells has been taken up. This paper will discuss the planning of ERD wells, the latest technology for ERD wells, the consideration of drill pipes and drilling fluid design for ERD wells, completion of ERD wells, well control and fishing and workover tools for ERD wells. At the end, suggestions have been given so as to get better results for ERD wells.
Introduction As we drill into deeper harsh areas, the use of efficient and effective technology becomes a necessity not only due to drill the areas successfully, but also to be in accordance with the stringent environmental conditions. ERD wells have been successful in not only delivering excellent results but also minimize environmental effects. ERD wells are those wells where the wellbore is kicked off from the vertical near the surface, inclination is built to allow sufficient horizontal displacement from the surface to reach the target zone some distance away, and the angle is again built to near horizontal.(Figure 1) The wellbore is then extended horizontally into the reservoir. In other terms, a well is defined as extended reach if it has a stepout ratio (horizontal displacement divided by TVD at total depth) of 1 or more. The use of extended-reach wells results in less surface disturbance because fewer wells are needed and surface sites have a smaller footprint. ERD wells employ both directional and horizontal drilling techniques so as to achieve greater horizontal departures. ERD wells not only provide solutions for restricted reservoir production but also help us to eliminate additional platforms. Though, ERD wells are considered to be more risky than conventional wells, but with the use of effective technology and personnel experience far better results can be obtained when compared to conventional wells.
Planning of ERD wells Planning for ERD wells is driven by economical, environmental and technical objectives. In general extended reach drill string design involves: Determining expected loads Selecting drill string components Verifying each components condition Monitoring conditions during drilling Economic issues in drill string planning include availability, logistics and cost. Rig and logistics issues include storage space, accuracy of load indicators, pump pressure/volume capacity, and top drive output torque. Hole issues include hole cleaning, hole stability, hydraulics, casing wear, and directional objectives. Environmental conditions should also be taken into consideration while planning for ERD wells. We can take the example of Wytch Farm extended reach drilling by British Petroleum which has created a new milestone by drilling and completion of an ERD well with an horizontal displacement of 35,196 ft. the Wytch Farm oil field had three main oil fields out of which the Sherwood reservoir was the most productive one. The development plan had to be carefully carried out because not only the area was a tourist spot but also the plan had to adhere to the stringent environmental regulations. Initially, it was planned to have an artificial island and simple directional wells. Instead, ERD wells were chosen because it would better protect the environment and would also cut the costs by half. There is a need to create a multi functional team so as to identify the risks associated with the well and the tools and practices to manage them. Extensive training of all the personnel is a must along with close cooperation for smooth working relationship. A study of successfully drilled ERD wells in the past is also necessary. We can take the example of the Hibernia ERD well for getting a view of their planning process. In 2002, the Hibernia Management and Development Company (HMDC), led by ExxonMobil Canada drilled and completed a 31,000ft MD well with a horizontal departure and vertical depth that has exceeded the present day industry ERD envelope. HMDC created multi functional teams so as to look
SPE106346 Planning and Identifying the Best Technologies for Extended Reach Wells Adit Gupta, University of Petroleum & Energy Studies, India 2 Adit Gupta after different aspects of drilling the ERD well. Different workshops were held so as to effectively train the personnels in drilling the ERD well. These workshops were divided into eight focus areas: casing and cementing operations, directional, formation evaluation, downhole tools, open/cased hole wireline logging, drilling fluids and solids control, completions and rig operations. The team of HMDC also initiated specialized research projects in areas of hole cleaning and shale stability. Similarly, BP conducted more than 300 meetings to plan their ERD well at the Wytch Farm. ADCO drilled their ERD well with a MD of 18,478ft and a HD of 13,780ft.With the help of excellent planning, ADCO was able to beat the learning curve in extended reach wells.
Technology for ERD wells 1. Rotary steerable systems: Rotary steerable drilling is the technology that enables full three dimensional drilling control to be performed while drilling with continuous drillstring rotation from surface and thus no slide drilling is necessary. A special BHA component known as rotary steering device is necessary to perform the above-mentioned task. (Figure 2)Rotary steerable systems offer the following advantages over the slide drilling: Fewer trips are required when using RSS. RSS uses fixed cutter bits unlike the other systems, which used tricone bits for directional control reasons. The longer life of fixed cutter bits results in more footage per bit and thus fewer trips for bit change. Continuous rotation at higher speeds results in very efficient hole cleaning. RSS can drill nearly all the required section trajectories using a single BHA design. Reduced tripping activity can be measured by comparing the footage drilled vs. the total amount of pipe tripped over the course of the project. Drilling with RSS results in a more in-gauge hole than drilling with other systems. Thus, this results in lower volumes of drilled cuttings waste and lower drilling fluid losses. Thus, RSS offers an environmental benefit, which is a major reason of concern in ERD drilling. Better ROP can be achieved with RSS due to less effect of torque and drag. (T/D analysis is taken up in later sections of this paper). This can be understood with the help of the following example. It was found that it was practically impossible to drill the ERD well at the Wytch Farm with the help of slide drilling. In slide drilling, the mud motor must be oriented and maintained in a particular direction. This orientation is achieved through a combination of rotating the drillstring several revolutions and working the pipe to turn it to the desired direction. At 8km or more, the pipe may need 15 to 20turns at surface just to turn the tool once downhole.it is difficult to maintain such high- generated torques at the lower end of the drillstring. Such difficulties are not encountered in RSS. Also, in wells with high drag, the drillstring cannot be lowered smoothly and continuously, which prevents the motor from operating at optimal conditions unlike RSS. Continuous pipe rotation, smoother trajectory due to less effect of torque and drag results in reduce stuck pipe and lost in hole (LIH) incidents. A study showed that RSS had LIH rate 15% less than the conventional systems. Thus the following advantages were realized in RSS: Improved ROP, reducing drilling time. Improved hole cleaning. Reduced torque and drag. More environmental friendly.
2. Casing Floatation: As stated earlier that overcoming torque and drag is one of the major challenges in an ERD well. This becomes one of the major hurdles when completing a well to a departure beyond 8000m. The ERD well drilled at the Wytch Farm showed that running the 9-5/8in. became increasingly difficult with greater departures. It was analyzed that drag would be to run the casing even with full weight from the traveling block. Casing floatation was the method, which can get the casing to the total depth. In casing floatation, casing is not filled as each joint is run into the wellbore, as is done in typical casing operations. The goal is to have the casing close to neutrally buoyant, so it becomes virtually weightless in the mud, and drag is minimal. In a long extended-reach section, an entire air-filled casing string can become positively buoyant and resist being pushed farther into the well. Thus, partial casing floatation was taken up and the casing string was divided into two sections; the upper section filled with mud and the lower section filled with air. Thus, double floatation collars were used. The section filled with mud is in the vertical section of the well and provides weight to help push the lower, buoyant casing into the well. BP completed three of its wells with casing floatation namely M08, M09 and M11. Thus, casing floatation proved to be an important technology for ERD wells.
3. Solid Expandable Tubular Technology: Drilling and completion of ERD wells is considered as a difficult task due to the many problems associated with ERD wells like high torque and drag, hole cleaning and hole stability. Solid Expandable Tubular (SET) Technology has two important advantages in ERD wells: Favorable drillstring casing geometry is possible which can reduce the tendency for drillstring lockup. Use of Larger drilling tubular is possible ERD wells extend up to large horizontal distances, which require running additional casing strings. SET is useful in these cases.
3 Planning and Identifying best technologies for ERD wells
In SET, the casing is being cold worked to expand it to the required size downhole. Many other technical aspects are taken care of, as cold working is an unstable process for the tubular. Expansion process (Figure 3): the launcher assembly (launcher + expansion cone) is connected to the liner to be expanded and is run through the rotary table. The required length of the expandable casing is then connected and is run in the wellbore which is followed by running the drillstring concentrically into the liner till it is latched into the expansion cone with the help of a safety thread connection. When the dart gets seated, pressure is exerted below the expansion cone. Expansion is initiated with hydraulic pressure from the drillstring. The expansion process is verified by decrease in the hook load. The progress of the cone through the tubular deforms the steel past its elastic yield limit into its plastic deformation region, but not its ultimate yield strength. Expansions of over 25percent, based on the diameter of the pipe, have been accomplished. SET are very useful in transversing severely depleted zone especially when the zone lies in an abnormal pressurized environment. Thus, vertical wells can easily be completed with the conventional casing systems, but for long ERD wells, in some cases, SET become the only option. 4. Near-Bit Reamers: Near-bit reamers are concentric reaming tools that can be run anywhere in the BHA to increase the hole diameter. This tool can be run either above or below the motor and logging-while-drilling tools.
5. Thrusters: Thrusters generate weight-on-bit by using drilling fluid hydraulics. The pump-open behavior of thrusters decouples the lower part of the bottom hole assembly from the remainder of the drillstring, and in so doing provides a constant, controllable weight-on-bit (WOB) that dampens out axial vibrations and shocks. 6. Measurement-While-Drilling (MWD): effective logging is also a major task in ERD wells. MWD stands out to be the best technology for ERD wells. MWD is the evaluation of physical properties, usually including pressure, temperature and wellbore trajectory in three-dimensional space, while extending a wellbore. The measurements are made downhole, stored in solid-state memory for some time and later transmitted to the surface.
Torque and Drag
Drilling shallow ERD horizontal wells in which the ratio of displacement to TD is greater than 3:1 poses difficulties in maintaining enough weight to push the drillstring towards ultimate TVD. If the drag forces are large, then more weight is needed. Drag forces are much higher when the drillstring is not rotating, which occurs when tripping the string in at the beginning of a bit run and when directional drilling with a positive displacement motor (PDM) or steerable motor. The
sliding friction factor, f s usually is in the range of 0.30 to 0.50. When the drillstring is rotated, the drag forces are greatly reduced and the friction factor is between 0.03 and 0.07. The reduction in drag forces during rotation eliminates the problem of moving the bit to the bottom of the ERD wells. This is the main reason for the popularity of rotary steerable systems. When the drillstring is rotating, torque is seen at the surface. This torque is a function of the tool joints in the drill string and stabilizer blades in the BHA. Many techniques like use of mechanical tools, mud lubricants and drill collars for extra weight have been used for reduction of torque and drag, but all these techniques have their side effects. Use of smaller diameter drill pipe may be used in the deeper, high angle sections of ERD wells to reduce torque, drag and equivalent circulation density (ECD). Hole cleaning in high angle boreholes can reduce torque and drag losses.
Consideration of Drill pipes and Drilling fluids for ERD wells 1. Drill Pipes Till now, ERD wells were drilled with either 5- in. or 6-5/8 in. or a combination of both. But sue to the problems, which arises due to the above drill pipes, the industry is now turning to 5-7/8 in. drill pipes. The hydraulic performance of 5-1/2in.drill pipe becomes a major limitation in ERD wells resulting in poor cuttings removal, slow penetration rates and diminished control over well trajectory. The 6-5/8in.drill pipe is difficult to handle and requires more physical space on the rig. The 5-7/8in. pipe also provides 16% more ID flow area than 5- 1/2 in. pipe. Moreover, it is found that pressure losses are reduced upto 28% with the 5-7/8in. pipes. 2. Drilling Fluids The following factors should be considered while making a choice of drilling fluids for the ERD wells: ECD management Hole cleaning Torque and drag Borehole stability Lost circulation Moreover, due to the stringent environmental conditions, the industry is going on for the development of more efficient water-based muds, in conjunction with some suitable lubricants, so as to replace the invert emulsion muds Invert emulsion muds had been the priority for drilling wells due to their greater lubricity and for preserving hole stability. Moreover, low torque and drag and ECD have been experienced by the use of invert emulsion muds. Thus, invert emulsion muds prove to be a good choice for ERD wells, but due to the environmental regulations, then have been now replaced by the water based muds. The most suitable water based muds currently available for ERD drilling, when shale inhibition is required, are potassium based, non dispersed, polymer muds containing glycol or silicates. When inhibition is not required, low solids polymer
4 Adit Gupta
formulations or mixed metal silicates may be used. These muds are highly effective in ERD drilling Silicate drilling fluids exhibit remarkable shale stabilizing properties, resulting in gauge hole and the formation of firm, discrete cuttings when drilling reactive shales. Silicate muds are low solids polymer systems formulated in seawater or monovaleny brines with the addition of a soluble silicate complex for inhibition. Glycol enhanced water based mud systems offer the advantages of enhanced shale inhibition, improved filter cake quality, reduced fluid loss and reduced dilution rates. Development of better water based muds for ERD wells will take place in the near future.
Well Control Gas kick is one of the most dangerous situations which can cause a blowout of the well. ERD wells are more prone to kicks and lost circulation due to the large distances upto, which they are drilled. Though, ERD wells have some advantages when the well takes a kick because gas migration rates are slower. Gas migrates at a rapid rate when the inclination is 45 and its migration rate decreases as the well becomes horizontal. As long as the kick is in the horizontal section, the shut in casing pressure (SICP) and shut in drill pipe pressure (SIDPP) are about the same because hydrostatic pressure on both sides of the U-tube is the same. The following well control procedures should be taken in ERD wells. 1. Drillers method should be used to control the well. The drillers method uses the old mud to circulate out the influx and requires two circulations to kill the well. The first circulation displaces the influx with old mud from the pits, and the second circulation replaces the old mud with the new kill mud. The kil weight mud will take a long time to get prepared for the long ERD wells, which could worsen the conditions. So, drillers method is the most preferable method. 2. Start circulating at a high rate for a short time to remove gas from the horizontal section of the wellbore.
Fishing and Workover tools 1. Coiled tubing casing patches: this technology is an external casing patch system. The tool is a high pressure hydraulically actuated dual packer expansion device. After the two rubber seals are actuated, high- pressure fluid is pumped between the seals. The pressure is increased and expands the patch first elastically then plastically with approximately 5,000 psi hydraulic pressure. The pressure on the seals is controlled to ensure that the seal is maintained until full contact with outer tubing/casing is achieved. As the pressure continues to increase, the outer tubing is elastically strained until the predetermined and preset final swage pressure is achieved. The pressure is then
bled off, and the seals are retracted by use of a 1500 psi retract cycle. Other conventional fishing tools are also used like: Junk baskets Junk mils Wireline spears Overshots Suggestions The following suggestions have been given keeping in mind the logging, drilling and completion aspects of ERD wells. 1. Swell Packers: Solid Expandable tubular technology is one of the main technologies used in ERD wells. This technology can be complimented with the use of swellable packers. Swellable packers can be easily customized to suit a variety of completion scenarios. Moreover, they are less costly than the mechanical packers. Also, swellable packers can eliminate cement jobs in many cases, particularly where the cement is being used to achieve zonal isolation. 2. Offset Stabilizers: the use of offset stabilizers allows better rotary steerable operations. The new stabilizer drills a curved path by using an offset stabilizer to achieve the desired well trajectory. Orientation of the control stabilizer is maintained by an eccentric mass, which hangs to the low side of the hole. The new offset stabilizer accurately geosteers as per the target requirements. The new stabilizer requires a hole inclination in excess of 45 to maintain orientation of mass. The new offset stabilizer offers the following advantages: Improves ROP Elimination of bit trip Ability to geosteer along the extended section Thus, due to these advantages, the offset stabilizer proves to be an important technology for ERD wells. 3. Through Bit Logging: ERD wells are considered to be more difficult to work on in comparison to the conventional wells. Loggins is one of the operations, which might prove a difficult task in some of the ERD wells. Through bit logging technology can be an efficient logging technlology for difficult ERD wells. Through bit logging is a method for data acquisition using the drill string and bit as a conduit to the well bore. In this new system, the logging tools are conveyed via the drillstring and pass into the open hole through a specially designed bit, with formation evaluation data being acquired with either wireline or memory tools, unlike LWD where tripping drill pipe out of the well is necessary. Thus, rig time can be saved. Thus, TBL offers the following advantages: Reduced operation risk Security of data acquisition Rig time savings Continuos wireline quality data
5 Planning and Identifying best technologies for ERD wells
Figure 1: Extended Reach Well, Courtsey: BP Exploration, Shlumberger
Figure 2: Configuration of Rotary Steerable Systems, Courtsey: World Oil
Figure 3: Expansion process for Solid Expandable Tubulars
6 Adit Gupta
References:
1. Applied Drilling Engineering SPE Textbook 2. Schlumberger- Oilfield Glossary 3. Schlumberger Case Study- Extended Reach Drilling at Wytch Farm 4. Schlumberger Case Study- Extended Reach Drilling at Xiang 5. Drilling Contractor-July/August-2003- Rotary Steerable Drilling Technology matures 6. World Oil-May 2005- A swell idea simplifies completions 7. SPE paper- Record Extended Reach Drilling at Hibernia 8. SPE paper 91854- Understanding Toque and Drag: Best practices and lessons learned from the Captain field Extended Reach Wells 9. SPE/IADC paper 72290- Drilling Fluid Management for Extended Reach Drilling 10. SPE/IADC paper 92256-Application of Through Bit Logging in difficult wells, Offshore North Sea 11. IADC paper- Next Generation Drill Pipe for Extended Reach, Deepwater and Ultra-deep Drilling