^ WE ARE
DOOMED
RECLAIMING CONSERVATIVE PESSIMISM
JOHN
by
DERBYSHIRE
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page iv
Black Sparrow Books: Excerpt from “Patriotic Poem” from Emerald Ice: Selected Poems
1962–1987 by Diane Wakoski, copyright © 1988 by Diane Wakoski. Reprinted by
permission of Black Sparrow Books, an imprint of David R. Godine, Publisher.
The Overlook Press: Excerpt from “There Are Bad Times Just Around the
Corner” from The Lyrics of Noël Coward by Noël Coward, copyright © 1965 by
Noël Coward. Reprinted by permission of The Overlook Press, New York, NY.
978-0-307-40958-4
1 3 5 7 9 10 8 6 4 2
First Edition
www.CrownForum.com
To purchase a copy of
We Are Doomed
visit one of these online retailers:
Amazon
Barnes & Noble
Borders
IndieBound
Powell’s Books
Random House
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page vii
CONTENTS
1. A Call to Pessimism 1
Acknowledgments 263
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page 1
1
6
A CALL TO PESSIMISM
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page 2
2 WE ARE DOOMED
This book is about what we have done to ourselves, to our society and
culture. It’s about the hopelessness of any project to save the situation
based on current conservatism, perverted as it has been by smiley-face
schemes of human improvement. It’s about composing ourselves to a
true view of humanity and human affairs, so that we can get through
our individual destinies usefully and with maximum peace of mind in
the dark age to come, preserving as much as can be preserved. Who
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page 3
A Call to Pessimism 3
knows? Once back in touch with truth, we might even see a revival of
real conservatism: self-support, patriotism, limited government, feder-
alism . . . though of course, I don’t hold out much hope.
Please be clear about the scope of the pessimism I urge on you.
Don’t mistake my thesis for any of those tabloid Chicken Little prog-
nostications about particular economic, ecological, military, or cos-
mic misfortunes we may be able to science our way out of.
Have we reached Peak Oil? I don’t know. (Neither, so far as I can
gather from some extensive reading in this area, does anyone else.)
Will global warming melt the polar ice caps? Sorry, I have no clue.
Are suitcase nuclear weapons secreted in our cities awaiting a word of
command from some terrorist mastermind or malevolent dictator?
I really couldn’t say. Shall we fall to some plague, some runaway
particle-physics experiment, some asteroid strike or other celestial
mishap? Or will human nature itself disappear into a “singularity”
around the middle of this century, as futurologist Ray Kurzweil pre-
dicts? Beats my pair of jacks.
My book is not primarily about any of those things, though speak-
ing as a constitutional pessimist, I’d lay odds that one or other of
them is lurking just round the historical corner. Things are bad and
getting worse, any fool can see that, but I pin my dark banner to no
one particular prediction. Despair should be large and general, not
petty and particular.
Nor does my scope extend beyond this human state and this
earthly life. Possibly there are other states and other lives. Though
no longer an adherent of any religion, I maintain an open mind on
these issues. They are in any case outside the purview of this book.
I’m writing about the communal arrangements of a particular social
mammal on a particular planet. Believe what you like about matters
beyond that; this book isn’t concerned with them.
That’s all very well, you may say, but isn’t pessimism enervating? If
all is for the worst for us in this, the worst of all possible worlds, why
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page 4
4 WE ARE DOOMED
Arnold was a witty and sociable man who loved sport and com-
panionship. He worked hard at useful employment, was happily mar-
ried to the same lady for thirty-seven years, and was a loving father to
his six children.
Enervating? Not at all: Pessimism is bracing, like foul weather.
(Arnold and I were both raised in England.)
It also makes you a better person. Consider the optimist Jean-
Jacques Rousseau, who believed human beings to be innately good
and who laid the philosophical foundations for progressive, “child-
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page 5
A Call to Pessimism 5
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page 6
6 WE ARE DOOMED
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page 7
A Call to Pessimism 7
self,” as they tend to say. Sure, you can sit in your study and intro-
spect, or buy a shelf of philosophy courses from the Teaching Com-
pany. For sheer insight into the living world, though—including the
human world—nothing can beat the kind of scientist who started out
with a bug collection at age eleven and never lost his enthusiasm for
the teeming, chaotic, cruel, convoluted, fantastically interconnected
world of nature. Edward O. Wilson, whom I shall surely be quoting
before I get through with this book, is a star example; another is of
course Charles Darwin.
Annie Dillard came to nature somewhat later than that, but she
struck a true note in her Pulitzer Prize–winning 1974 book about the
Blue Ridge Mountains of western Virginia, Pilgrim at Tinker Creek.
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page 8
8 WE ARE DOOMED
had, there were always bears, wolves, and crop failures to remind
them of the biological facts.
If they had known more, they would have had an even darker
view. If, for example, those Tidewater Anglicans had known that the
diseases that swept away their loved ones in hecatombs were not
signs of God’s displeasure at our fallen state, but the blind actions of
unthinking microbes and viruses, devoid of any personal interest in
humanity, they would have reached conclusions about nature very
close to Annie Dillard’s.
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page 9
A Call to Pessimism 9
TWILIGHT IN AMERICA
But hold on there! (I hear you cry) What about Ronald Reagan?
Wasn’t he the very epitome of modern conservatism? And didn’t he
present a cheerful face to the world, scoff at his predecessor’s diagno-
sis of “malaise,” and proclaim Morning in America?
Again, this is to confuse a sunny disposition with a well-thought-
out conviction that earthly affairs cannot be much improved by the
hand of man—most certainly not by the hand of government.
Reagan, like Matthew Arnold, was a cheerful and busy fellow, but
the good he did in government, he did chiefly with a pessimist’s re-
straint. He did not follow the 1983 bombing of a U.S. barracks in
Lebanon by invading and occupying that country with the dream of
turning it into a constitutional democracy, as a smiley-face world-
improver would have done; he pulled out. He did not, like his liberal
predecessor, chide his countrymen for their “inordinate fear of com-
munism”; he shared that gloomy fear, speaking of the Soviet Union
in frank, dark terms, not as a regrettable but correctable error on the
part of well-meaning reformers—Emersonian Transcendentalists
who had taken a wrong turn on the road to Walden Pond—but as an
“evil empire.”
A very rough index of an American president’s faith in plans for
social or international uplift is his willingness to veto legislation.
There are many variables in play here—most obviously, whether
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page 10
10 WE ARE DOOMED
president and Congress are of the same party—but veto counts offer
at least an approximate clue about presidential skepticism toward po-
litical schemes for human uplift.
Ronald Reagan’s annualized rate of vetoes across his term of of-
fice was 10, the same as William Howard Taft’s. This puts Reagan
and Taft at ninth in the rankings. Just below them at tenth stand
McKinley, Coolidge, and Hoover, with 9 vetoes per annum apiece.
Above, in eighth place, are Teddy Roosevelt and Benjamin Harrison
with 11. Above them stand Grant with 12 vetoes per annum, Eisen-
hower with 23, and fourth-ranked Gerry Ford with 27. Republicans
all! Reagan noted in his diary entry for July 9, 1987: “Every pen I
look at is a veto pen to me.”
(It is true that the top three scorers here are all Democrats: Tru-
man with 32, FDR with 52, and Grover Cleveland with an astound-
ing average of 73 vetoes per annum. These were all very special cases,
though—notably Cleveland, a fine classical-conservative liberal—
“libertarian,” we would say nowadays—and every conservative
Republican’s favorite Democrat. George W. Bush’s score was a
wretchedly hypercompassionate 1.5—12 vetoes in eight years.)
A pessimistic president knows that, as the great Calvin Coolidge
told his father, “it is much more important to kill bad bills than to
pass good ones.” Most of what legislators legislate and executives ex-
ecute is foolish, counterproductive, or downright wicked, so the less
they do the better.
Coolidge is, in fact, a key figure here: a great pessimist and a great
conservative, from sound New England Calvinist/Congregationalist
roots—a backcountry pre-Transcendentalist in spirit, in spite of
having been born shortly after Emerson’s sixty-ninth birthday.
Coolidge’s mature philosophical outlook was formed by the charis-
matic Amherst teacher C. E. Garman, an orthodox New England
Congregationalist: “a cheerful, happy man” according to his class-
mate Clarence Sargent, who nonetheless taught a stern philosophy of
service and integrity.
Historian Paul Johnson, who made a close study of Coolidge, de-
scribed him thus: “A constitutionally suspicious man, and not one to
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page 11
A Call to Pessimism 11
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page 12
12 WE ARE DOOMED
didn’t try very hard, recognizing early that the public would be
happy to have its taxes cut as long as its programs weren’t
touched.
CHILDREN OF WRATH
Back in the late 1960s, when the sectarian problems of Northern Ire-
land were heating up, the British home secretary (roughly equivalent
to a U.S. attorney general) went over to the province to pour oil on
the troubled waters.
This home secretary was a fellow named James Callaghan. A
cheerful, back-slapping type, Callaghan was nicknamed “Sunny Jim.”
If anyone could do the oil-pouring business, Sunny Jim surely could.
As part of his tour, Callaghan had a meeting with the fiercely sec-
tarian Unionist (which is to say, Protestant, and in fact Presbyterian-
www.CrownForum.com
Derb_9780307409584_5p_all_r1.qxp 8/3/09 2:12 PM Page 13
A Call to Pessimism 13
Abandon hope, then, all ye who enter here; or, if you must cling to
sunny anticipations, place the objects of your hope in some place
other than the one you and I currently inhabit; for this is a darkling
plain, a vale of tears. Happy talk and wishful thinking are for chil-
dren, fools, and leftists. We are conservatives. We know better. At
any rate, we used to.
Let us then explore the badlands of current society and culture,
whose soil has been turned to dust by the poisonous optimism of
fools. Where to begin? Perhaps in the deepest depths of self-deceiving
happy-talk folly, where dwell the smiliest smiley faces of all, those
who promote the great modern ideological cult of Diversity.
www.CrownForum.com
To purchase a copy of
We Are Doomed
visit one of these online retailers:
Amazon
Barnes & Noble
Borders
IndieBound
Powell’s Books
Random House
www.CrownForum.com