http://www.food-info.net/uk/qa/qa-fi45.htm
4-,
"olyo#yethylene$%& stearate Stearic acid is a fatty acid! See note belo' this table! "olyo#yethylene $()& stearate Stearic acid is a fatty acid! See note belo' this table!
E4-*
E4-+
"olyo#yethylene-*)-sorbitan Lauric acid is a fatty acid! See note belo' this monolaurate table! "olyo#yethylene-*)-sorbitan Oleic acid is a fatty acid! See note belo' this mono-oleate table! "olyo#yethylene-*)-sorbitan "almitic acid is a fatty acid! See note belo' this monopalmitate table! "olyo#yethylene-*)-sorbitan Stearic acid is a fatty acid! See note belo' this monostearate table! "olyo#yethylene-*)-sorbitan Stearic acid is a fatty acid! See note belo' this tristearate table! +elatin ,rom animal bones! Since the -SE crisis mainly from por , but other animal bones are used! .alal gelatin is available in specialised shops! ,or fatty acids, see note belo' this table!
E4--
E4-4
E4-5
E4-.
44* $invalid&
E4/,
E4/*
/ono- and di-glycerides of fatty acids Esters of mono- and diglycerides Sugar esters of fatty acids Sugarglycerides
E4/+
E4/E4/4
,or fatty acids, see note belo' this table! Combination of sugar and fatty acids! ,or fatty acids, see note belo' this table! ,or fatty acids, see note belo' this table!
E4/5
"olyglycerol esters of fatty acids "ropyleneglycol esters of fatty acids /i#ture of glycerol- and propyleneglycol esters of lactic acid and fatty acids Esterified soy oil
E4//
4/0
Natrium2Calciumstearoyllactylate Stearyltartrate
/i#ture of lactic acid and stearic acid, a fatty acid! ,or fatty acids, see note belo' this table! /i#ture of tartaric acid and stearic acid, a fatty acid! ,or fatty acids, see note belo' this table! /i#ture of citric acid and stearic acid, a fatty acid! ,or fatty acids, see note belo' this table! ,rom animal bones! Since the -SE crisis mainly from por , but other animal bones are used! .alal gelatin is available in specialised shops!
E40-
404
Stearylcitrate
+elatine
54+
,rom animal bones! Since the -SE crisis mainly from por , but other animal bones are used! Stearic acid is a fatty acid! See note belo' this table! /ainly from yeast, also from sardines and meat!
E5/,-04
E.+.-*1
E.-,-43
5nosinic acid and inosinates /ainly from meat and fish, also made 'ith bacteria!
.-., .-/
,rom malt $barley&, sometimes also from heating mil sugar! /ainly from gelatine $see ((6 above&, also synthetically! /ade by bees, but does not contain insects! Natural polymer derived from certain species of lice from 5ndia! 5nsects get trapped in the resin! 7 'a# from sheep! 5t is e#creted by the s in of the sheep and e#tracted from the 'ool! 8erived from proteins, including animal protein and hair! /ade from mil sugar ,rom beef $bile& ,rom chic en eggs
E.4,
+lycin
E1,* E1,4
1*-
Lanolin
1+,-*6
Cystein en cystin
,atty acids 2ats" whether from plant or animal ori in" consist of lycerol and enerally - fatty acids. 2ats can en3ymatically be split in fatty acids and lycerol. !he fatty acids can be purified and reconnected to lycerol as mono- di- of tri lycerides % lycerol with *" + or - fatty acids respectively). &any additives consist of these semi-natural fats" which act as emulsifiers. !hese semi-natural fats are de raded and metabolise din the body" 4ust like normal fat. 5hemically the fatty acids from animal or plant ori in are identical. !herefore the ori in is of no importance for the function in the food. 6roducers thus normally choose the cheapest oils to make these fats. !his is enerally some ve etable oil. (owever" animal fats can not be e#cluded. 7nfortunately it is not possible to distin uish animal and ve etable fatty acids in the final product. 8nly the producer can provide information on the ori in. $s there is a risk for animal fats" 'ews" &uslims" (indus and ve ans should avoid these products" unless the ori in is mentioned by the producer. Other common ingredients of animal origin : 5asein and caseinate :elatin $ protein from cow9s milk 2rom animal bones. ;ince the <;E crisis mainly from pork" but other animal bones are used. (alal and kosher elatin is available in specialised shops. ;u ar from cow9s milk 2rom fish" seals and soy. $ fraction of milk" see also here.
%>hey" wheypowder and cheese may not be halal when the animal that provided the rennet to clot the milk" is not slau htered accordin to Islamic rules. 8nly the producer can provide the information on the status of these products.)
Overvie' of additives and ingredients that are often mentioned as being from animal origin: E*,* ?iboflavin %lactoflavin) @ellow food colour. It can be isolated from milk" but commercially produced from micro-or anisms. Isolation from milk is too e#pensive. 6repared from charcoal from burned wood. 5an be obtained from burned animals" but this is no lon er done.
E*5-
5arbon
E*.*
5antha#anthin
5olour prepared from mushrooms or synthetically from carotene. (istorically it was also prepared from shrimp waste or flamin feathers. ;ynthetic canta#anthin is cheaper and has hi her purity. &ade by bacterial fermentation on su ar waste %molasses). It is not present in milk. $ll fermented products %dairy and nondairy) contain lactic acid as the result of bacterial fermentation. 5ommercially only prepared from su ar. 2rom ve etable oils. $lso in animal %fish) oils but these oils are too e#pensive. 2ish oils are" however" used as a source in food supplements" but not in foods" due to the stron flavour. ;ee E+/, above.
E+/,
!ocopherols %vitamin E)
Aicotinic acid %vitamin <-) 2rom yeast. 6roduction from liver is too e#pensive. :lycerol 6art of animal and ve etable fat. 5ommercially made synthetically from petroleum.
E4/.
6oly lycerolpolyricinoleate ;ynthetic ve etable fat. 5ommercially only made from su ar by bacterial fermentation or from seaweed. !heoretically from any protein" but that is too e#pensive. ;ynthetic. 5an be isolated from urine" but too complicated and e#pensive.
E.+,-5 :lutamates.
E1+/b 7reum
Bitamin <*+
5ommercially only made by bacterial fermentation. Isolation from meat is too e#pensive" due to the very low concentrations.
Which E-numbers are halal and haram ? Which E-numbers are allo'ed by 5slam ? Which products contain ethanol and are haram ?
!hese three questions are related and are discussed here combined.
,orbidden additives
!he list of really prohibited E-numbers is very shortC E*+, and E1,4 as these are made of or contain insects. E1,* is made by insects" like honey" but does not contain insects and thus is enerally considered halal. $ll other E-numbers are basically permitted and also widely used in Islamic countries. (owever" this does not mean that all additives are always halal. In many additives fatty acids are used in the production. $nd it is a matter of concern for many &uslims where these come from. If these are from plant ori in" they are halal" if they are from animal ori in they may be halal or haram" dependin on the animal" see also below. 5hemically they are identical" from the chemical composition it can not be determined whether animal or ve etable fat has been used. 8nly the producer and/or in redient supplier is able to provide this information. $nother complication is that additives can be listed by their chemical name or by their %E-) number. In the E7 the producer has to provide the name or the number or both. 8utside the E7 many countries use the same numberin system" but enerally without the E" and in other countries only the chemical names are used. !he list of additives that may be of animal ori in" or may contain fatty acids that may have been derived from animal ori in" can be found here. In that list also the chemical name is provided.
,atty acids
2ats" whether from plant or animal ori in" consist of lycerol and enerally - fatty acids. 2ats can be split in fatty acids and lycerol %the same reaction also takes place in the intestine when fats are di ested). !he fatty acids can be purified and reconnected to lycerol as mono- di- of tri lycerides % lycerol with *" + or - fatty acids respectively). &any additives consist of these semi-natural fats" which act as emulsifiers. !hese semi-natural fats are de raded and metabolised in the body" 4ust as normal fat. 5hemically the fatty acids from animal or plant ori in are identical. !herefore the ori in is of no importance for the function in the food. 6roducers thus normally choose the cheapest oils to make these fats. !his is enerally some ve etable oil" which makes the additives halal. (owever" animal fats can not be e#cluded and thus the same additive may be sometimes haram.
8iscussion
In the Islamic world there are several additional discussions on additives containin fatty acids. (ere we will mention the two points of issue" but" unless there is a reement amon Islamic scholars" we do not further elaborate on the ar uments of all parties concerned. !he first issue is the presence of animal fatty acids. If this fatty acid ori inates from pork" it is enerally considered haram. If it is from other animals" it is enerally considered halal. (owever" there is a discussion whether animal fat from other animals as pi s" is halal when the animal is not slau htered in the prescribed Islamic way. !he second issue is whether the presence of fatty acids ori inally derived from pork" makes the additives haram. !he final additive" as present in the products" is not present in pork %it is not a
natural component) and thus is not by definition haram. !he first issue limits the use of many additives and/or complicates the matter for many &uslims" the second discussion actually makes it easier for many &uslims to choose products.
E*,/ E**, E*+, E*++ E*+E*+4 E*+/ E*+0 E*+1 E*-* E*-+ E*-E*4, E*4* E*4+ E*5,a-d E*5* E*5E*54 E*55 E*.,a E*.,b E*.,c E*.,d E*.,e
>ello' *+ Sunset >ello' ,C, Carmine, Cochineal 79orubine 7maranth "onceau (= Erythrosine =ed *+ 7llura =ed 7C "atent -lue ; 5ndigotine -rilliant -lue ,C, Chlorophylls Copper comple#es of chlorophyll +reen S Caramel -rilliant blac -N Carbon -ro'n ,A -ro'n .< 7lfa-, -eta- and +amma- Carotene 7nnatto, -i#in, Norbi#in -ell pepper $"apri a& e#tract Lycopene -eta-apo-%?-carotenal
>ello' colour, a9o dye >ello' colour, a9o dye =ed colour, natural =ed colour, a9o dye =ed colour, a9o dye =ed colour, a9o dye =ed colour, synthetic =ed colour, synthetic =ed colour, a9o dye -lue colour, synthetic -lue colour, synthetic -lue colour, synthetic +reen colour, natural +reen colour, synthetic +reen colour, synthetic -ro'n colour -lac colour, a9o dye Natural blac colour -ro'n colour, a9o dye -ro'n colour, a9o dye Natural orange-yello' colour Natural yello' colour Natural orange colour Natural red colour Natural orange-yello' colour
E*.,f E*.*a E*.*b E*.*c E*.*d E*.*e E*.*f E*.* E*.*h E*.+ E*.E*/, E*/* E*/+ E*/E*/4 E*/5 E*0, *0*
Ethyl ester of beta-apo-%?-carotenic acid ,lavo#anthin Lutein Crypto#anthin =ubi#anthin ;iola#anthin =hodo#anthin Cantha#anthin Citrana#anthin -eetroot e#tract 7nthocyanins Calcium carbonate <itanium dio#ide 5ron o#ides 7luminium Silver +old Lithol =ubine -A <annins
Natural orange-yello' colour Natural, yello' colour Natural, yello' colour Natural, yello' colour Natural, yello' colour Natural, yello' colour Natural, yello' colour Natural, orange colour Natural, yello' colour Natural red colour Natural red-purple colours White colour White colour Natural red-bro'n colour /etal $colour& /etal $colour& /etal $colour& =ed colour, a9o dye >ello'-'hite colour and flavour
"otassium sorbate Calcium sorbate -en9oic acid Sodium ben9oate 2 -en9oic acid sodium salt "otassium ben9oate 2 -en9oic acid potassium salt Calcium ben9oate 2 -en9oic acid calcium salt Ethyl (-hydro#yben9oate Ethyl (-hydro#yben9oate sodium salt "ropyl (-hydro#yben9oate Sodium salt of E*6B /ethyl (-hydro#yben9oate
Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative Natural preservative Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative
Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative from ben9oic acid Synthetic preservative from ben9oic acid Natural preservative Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservativeC bleach Synthetic preservativeC anti o#idant Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative
E+*1
E++-
Sodium metabisulphite
"otassium metabisulphite "otassium sulphite Calcium sulphite Calcium hydrogen sulphite "otassium hydrogen sulphite -iphenyl *-hydro#ybiphenyl
E+-+ E+-E+-4 E+-5 +-. +-/ +-0 E+-1 +4, E+4+ E+41 E+5, E+5* E+5+ E+., E+.* E+.+ E+.E+/, E+0, E+0* E+0+ E+0E+04
Sodium biphenyl-*-yl o#ide *-$<hia9ol-(-yl&ben9imida9ole Nisin "imaracin ,ormic acid Sodium formate Calcium formate .e#amine ,ormaldehyde 8imethylcarbonate "otassium nitrite Sodium nitrite Sodium nitraite "otassium nitrate 7cetic acid "otassium acetate Sodium acetate Calcium acetate Lactic acid "ropionic acid Sodium propionate Calcium propionate "otassium propionate -oric acid
Synthetic preservative Synthetic preservative Natural antibiotic Natural antibiotic Natural acid, preservative Natural salt, preservative Natural salt, preservative Synthetic preservative "reservative Synthetic preservative Natural salt, preservative Natural salt, preservative Natural salt, preservative Natural salt, preservative Natural acid, preservative "reservative, natural salt "reservative, natural salt "reservative, natural salt Natural acid Natural acid Natural salt Natural salt Natural salt Natural acid
E-,0
gamma-<ocopherol
E-,1
delta- <ocopherol
"ropyl gallate Octyl gallate 8odecyl gallate <hiodipropionic acid +uaiac +um Erythorbic acid Sodium erythorbate
-*1 E-+, E-+* E-++ E-+5 E-+. E-+/ E--, E--* E--+ E--E--4 E--5 E--. E--/ E--0 E--1 E-4, E-4* -4E-5, E-5* E-5+ E-5E-54 E-55
-utylhydro#inon -utylated hydro#yanisole -utylated hydro#ytoluene Lecithin Sodium lactate "otassium lactate Calcium lactate Citric acid Sodium citrates "otassium citrates /ono, di, and <ri- Calcium citrate L-$D&- tartaric acid mono2di Sodium L-$D&- tartrate mono"otassium L-$D&- tartrate "otassium sodium L-$D&- tartrate "hosphoric acid Sodium orthophosphates "otassium orthophosphates Calcium orthophosphates /agnesium orthophosphates Sodium malate "otassium malate Calcium malate meta tartaric acid Calcium tartarate 7dipic acid
Synthetic anti-o#idant Synthetic anti-o#idant Synthetic anti-o#idant Natural emulsifier Sodium salt of lactic acid "otassium salt of lactic acid Calcium salt of lactic acid 7cidity regulators 7cidity regulators 7cidity regulators 7cidity regulators Natural acid Salt of tartaric acid Salt of tartaric acid Salt of tartaric acid -uffers -uffers -uffers -uffers -uffers Sodium salt of malic acid "otassium salt of malic acid Calcium salt of malic acid Natural acid Natural preservative Natural acid
Sodium adipate "otassium adipate Succinic acid Sodium fumarate 6,(-.eptonolactone Nicotinic acid tri7mmonium citrate 7mmonium ferric citrate Calcium disodium ethylenediamine
7cidity regulator 7cidity regulator Natural acid 7cidity regulator Synthetic acid - vitamin, colour protector Synthetic salt of citric acid Synthetic salt of citric acid SeEuestrant, chelating substance Synthetic stabiliser
-0.
-0/ -00
4,0 E4*, E4** E4*+ E4*E4*4 E4*5 E4*. E4*/ E4*0 E4+, E4+* E4++ 4-, E4-* E4-+ E4-E4-4 E4-5 E4-. E44, 44* E44+ E45,
,urcelleran Locust bean gum Oat +um +uar +um <ragacanth +um 7rabic Fanthan gum Aaraya gum <ara gum +ellan gum Sorbitol /annitol +lycerol "olyo#yethylene$%& stearate "olyo#yethylene $()& stearate "olyo#yethylene-*)-sorbitan monolaurate "olyo#yethylene-*)-sorbitan mono-oleate "olyo#yethylene-*)-sorbitan monopalmitate "olyo#yethylene-*)-sorbitan monostearate "olyo#yethylene-*)-sorbitan tristearate "ectin +elatin $no longer valid& 7mmonium phosphatides 8i- and polyphosphates
Natural thic ening agent Natural thic ening agent Natural thic ening agent Natural thic ening agent Natural thic ening agent Natural thic ening agent Natural thic ening agent Natural thic ening agent Natural thic ening agent Natural thic ening agent Natural sugar alcohol Natural sugar alcohol Natural alcohol
Synthetic emulsifier Synthetic emulsifier Synthetic emulsifier Synthetic emulsifier Synthetic emulsifier Synthetic emulsifier Natural thic ening agent Natural thic ening agent Synthetic emulsifier Salt of phosphoric acid
Salt of phosphoric acid Salt of phosphoric acid Natural fibre, thic ening agent Semi-synthetic thic ening agent Semi-synthetic thic ening agent Semi-synthetic thic ening agent Semi-synthetic thic ening agent Semi-synthetic thic ening agent Semi-synthetic thic ening agent Semi-synthetic emulsifiers Semi-synthetic emulsifiers Semi-synthetic emulsifiers Semi-synthetic emulsifiers Semi-synthetic emulsifiers Semi-synthetic emulsifiers Semi-synthetic emulsifiers Semi-synthetic emulsifiers Semi-synthetic emulsifiers
4.+
Ethyl cellulose
E4.-
.ydro#ypropyl cellulose
E4.4
.ydro#ypropylmethyl cellulose
E4.5
/ethylethyl cellulose
E4..
Carbo#ymethyl cellulose
,atty acid salts /ono- and di-glycerides of fatty acids Esters of mono- and diglycerides Sugar esters of fatty acids Sugarglycerides "olyglycerol esters of fatty acids "olyglycerol polyricinoleate "ropyleneglycol esters of fatty acids /i#ture of glycerol- and propyleneglycol esters of lactic acid and fatty acids Esterified soy oil 8ioctyl sodium sulphosuccinate Sodium stearoyl lactate Calcium stearoyl lactate
Stearyl tartrate Stearyl citrate =enamed as ((6 "ropylene glycol Sorbitane mono stearate Sorbitane tri stearate Sorbitane mono laurate Sorbitane mono oleate Sorbitane mono palmitate
solvent Semi-synthetic emulsifier Semi-synthetic emulsifier Semi-synthetic emulsifier Semi-synthetic emulsifier Semi-synthetic emulsifier
E5*5 E5*. E5*/ 5*0 E5+, E5+* E5+E5+4 E5+5 E5+. E5+/ E5+0 E5+1 E5-, E5-5 E5-. 5-/ E5-0 5-1 54, E54* 54+ 54544 545 54.
"otassium sulphate Calcium sulphate 7mmonium sulphate /agnesium sulphate 7luminium sulphate 7luminium sodium sulphate 7luminium ammonium sulphate Sodium hydro#ide "otassium hydro#ide Calcium hydro#ide 7mmonium hydro#ide /agnesium hydro#ide Calcium o#ide /agnesium o#ide Sodium ferrocyanide "otassium ferrocyanide ,errohe#acyanomanganate Calcium ferrocyanide Sodium thiosulphate 8icalcium pyrophosphate $no' E(3)& Sodium aluminium phosphate Edible bone phosphate Sodium calcium polyphosphate Calcium polyphosphates 7mmonium polyphosphates /agnesium pyrophosphate
Salt substitude ,irming agent Stabiliser 8ietary supplement Clarification agent 7cidity regulator Stabiliser -ase, colour solvent -ase ,irming agent -ase -ase 7l ali 7nti ca ing agent, al ali 7nti ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent 7nti-ca ing agent 7nti-ca ing agen 7nti-o#idant =aising agent =aising agent 7nti ca ing agent Emulsifier Emulsifier Emulsifier Emulsifier
55, E55* E55+ E55E554 E555 E55. 55/ E550 E551 E5/, 5/* 5/+ 5/E5/4 E5/5 E5/. E5// E5/0 E5/1 E505
Sodium silicates Silicium dio#ide Calcium silicate /agnesium silicate 7luminium sodium silicate 7luminium potassium silicate 7luminium calcium silicate Ginc silicate -entonite Aaolin Stearic acid 7mmonium stearate /agnesium stearate 7luminium stearate +luconic acid 8-glucono-6, 3-lactone Sodium gluconate "otassium gluconate Calcium gluconate ,erro gluconate ,erro lactate
7nti-ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent 7nti ca ing agent SeEuestrant SeEuestrant SeEuestrant SeEuestrant ,irming agent, seEuestrant Colour and nutrient Nutrient
E.+, E.+* E.++ E.+E.+4 E.+5 E.+. E.+/ E.+0 E.+1 E.-, E.-* E.-+ E.-E.-4 E.-5 .-. .-/ E.4,
+lutamic acid /ono sodium glutamate /ono potassium glutamate Calcium glutamate 7mmonium glutamate /agnesium glutamate +uanylic acid Sodium guanylate 8i-potassium guanylate Calcium guanylate 5nosinic acid Sodium inosinate 8i-potassium inosinate Calcium inosinate Calcium ribonucleotides 8i-sodium ribonucleotides /altol Ethylmaltol +lycine and sodium glycinate
,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer ,lavour enhancer Nutrient
,lour bleaching agent -leaching agent and preservative -read enhancer -uffer
1+0 1-, E1-0 E1-1 E14, E14* E14+ E14E144 E140 E141 E13) E136 E13* E134 E13( E133 E130 E131 E1B* E1.5 E1.. E1./ E111
-en9oylpero#ide Calciumpero#ide 7rgon .elium 8ichlorodifluormethane Nitrogen Nitrous o#ides -utane, isobutane "ropane O#ygen .ydrogen 7cesulfame A 7spartame Cyclamates 5somalt Sacharine Sucralose <haumatine Neohesperidin Salt of aspartame-acesulfame /altitol Lactitol Fylitol @uillaia e#tract
-read enhancer -read enhancer "ropellant "ropellant "ropellant, anti-free9e "ropellant "ropellant "ropellant "ropellant "ropellant "ropellant S'eetener S'eetener S'eetener S'eetener S'eetener S'eetener S'eetener S'eetener S'eetener S'eetener S'eetener S'eetener ,oaming agent
7cetylated di-starch glycerol .ydro#ypropylstarch .ydro#ypropyl-di-starchglycerol .ydro#ypropyl-di-starchphosphate Starch sodium octenyl succinate
<hic ening agent <hic ening agent <hic ening agent <hic ening agent <hic ening agent