#n inde$endently incor$orated non$rofit foundation, governed %y an international %oard &ith the stated mission to' (Im$rove the care and outcomes of )idney disease $atients &orld&ide through $romoting coordination, colla%oration, and integration of initiatives to develo$ and im$lement clinical $ractice guidelines*+
Sharon M. Moe, MD, FASN, FAHA, FACP (Co-chair) United States Geoffrey A. B oc!, MD United States "or#e B. Cannata-And$a, MD, PhD S%ain Graha&e ". ' der, MB, BS, PhD, F(ACP A)stra ia Masaf)&i F)!a#a*a, MD, PhD, FASN "a%an +anda "or#etti, MD, PhD Bra,i Mar!)s -ette er, MD Ger&any Crai# B. .an#&an, MD United States Adeera .e/in, MD, F(CPC Canada
0i &an B. Dr1e!e, MD, F(CP (Co-chair) France A ison M. Mac.eod, MBChB, MD, F(CP United -in#do& .inda McCann, (D, CS(, .D United States Peter A. McC) o)#h, MD, MPH, FACC, FACP, FCCP, FAHA United States S)san M. 2tt, MD United States An#e a 3ee-Moon 4an#, MD, PhD, F(CP Hon# -on# "os5 (. 4eisin#er, MD, FACP +ene,)e a 6 United States Da/id C. 4hee er, MD, F(CP United -in#do&
-atrin Uh i#, MD, MS Pro7ect Director8 Director, G)ide ine De/e o%&ent (an7ani Moorthi, MD, MPH, MS Assistant Pro7ect Director A&y 'ar ey, BS Pro7ect Coordinator (e9ecca Persson, BA (esearch Assistant
Guideline Outline
Cha%ter ;< :ntrod)ction and Definition of C-D-MBD and the De/e o%&ent of the G)ide ine State&ents Cha%ter =< Methodo o#ica A%%roach Cha%ter >.;< Dia#nosis of C-D-MBD< Bioche&ica A9nor&a ities Cha%ter >.=< Dia#nosis of C-D-MBD< Bone Cha%ter >.>< Dia#nosis of C-D-MBD< +asc) ar Ca cification
Guideline Outline
Cha%ter ?.;< 0reat&ent of C-D-MBD 0ar#eted at .o*erin# Hi#h Ser)& Phos%hor)s and Maintainin# Ser)& Ca ci)& Cha%ter ?.=< 0reat&ent of A9nor&a P0H .e/e s in C-D-MBD Cha%ter ?.>< 0reat&ent of Bone *ith Bis%hos%honates, other 2steo%orosis Medications, and Gro*th Hor&one Cha%ter @< '/a )ation and 0reat&ent of -idney 0rans% ant Bone Disease Cha%ter A< S)&&ary and (esearch
Cha$ter .
:ntrod)ction and Definition of C-D-MBD and the De/e o%&ent of the G)ide ine State&ents
8e9uential Process for Guideline Develo$ment :irst 8te$s' &# Develop *ues ions and de+ine ou ,omes Pre$aratory 8te$s' '# "ondu, sys ema i, review $# -repare eviden,e pro+ile +or impor an ou ,omes Grading' .# /rade *uali y o+ eviden,e +or ea,h ou ,ome 0# 1an2 rela ive impor an,e o+ ea,h ou ,ome 3# /rade overall *uali y o+ eviden,e a,ross all ou ,omes )# Assess balan,e o+ bene+i s and harms 4# Assess balan,e o+ ne bene+i and ,os s 5# 6ormula e re,ommenda ion and grade s reng h 8u%se9uent 8te$s' &(# 7mplemen and evalua e
/1AD8 9M: '((0
-D:G2 'Cec)ti/e Co&&ittee and Board (e%resentati/es of Fi/e :nternationa G)ide ine De/e o%&ent Gro)%s 2r#ani,ationa , Sta!eho der, and P)9 ic (e/ie* A co&&ents s)9&itted at each %hase of the re/ie* %rocess are caref) y re/ie*ed and considered 9y the 4or! Gro)% %rior to %)9 ication of the fina #)ide ine
Cha$ter 6
"KD
9one urnover# os eo,al,in! 9one spe,i+i, al2aline phospha ase! "% erminal ,ross lin2s 9one minerali<a ion >densi y# D?A! *"@ ! *AS 9one urnover! minerali<a ion B s ru, ure# his ology
=essel s i++ness# pulse wave velo,i y! pulse pressure =essel > valve ,al,i+i,a ion# ? %ray! AS! "@! 89"@! MS"@! 7M@ =essel pa en,y# ,oronary angiogram! Doppler dupleE AS
Clinical Outcomes
Intervention
Treatment with Phos Binder A
Intervention
Treatment with Phos Binder B
Intervention
Treatment with Phos Binder C
8urrogate Outcome
Slowing of Calcification
8urrogate Outcome
Less Calcification
8urrogate Outcome
Slowing of Calcification
8urrogate Outcome
Slowing of Calcification
Clinical Outcome
Less CVD is!
Clinical Outcome
Less CVD Events
Clinical Outcome
Less CVD Events
7llus ra ion o+ prin,iples ou lined in AsersF /uide +or a Surroga e 8nd -oin @rial 9u,her et al. :AMA &555! '4' C4D# ))&%))4
High for randomized trial Moderate for quasirandomized trial Low for observational study
Final grade for quality of evidence for an outcomec High Moderate Low Very low
"
Moderate %he true effect is li&ely to be close to the estimate of the effect" but there is a possibility that it is substantially different$ Low Very low %he true effect may be substantially different from the estimate of the effect$ %he estimate of effect is very uncertain" and often will be far from the truth$
Guyatt G/, et al. M= >>2' .743, 677?
# $
Most people in your situation would want the recommended course of action and only a small proportion would not$
%he ma ority of people in )ifferent choices will %he recommendation is your situation would be appropriate for li&ely to require debate want the recommended different patients$ *ach and involvement of course of action" but patient needs help to sta&eholders before many would not$ arrive at a policy can be management decision determined$ consistent with her or his values and preferences$
)*e *ig*er t*e quality of evidence+ t*e more li,ely a strong recommendation (arranted)*e more variability in values and preferences+ or t*e more uncertainty in values and preferences+ t*e more li,ely a (ea, recommendation (arranted-
)*e *ig*er t*e costs of an intervention1t*at is+ t*e more resources consumed1t*e less li,ely a strong recommendation (arrantedGuyatt G/, et al. M= >>2' .743, 677?
Strengt* +trong
'evel 2
#ea&
/rading Op ions# &A! &9! &"! &D! 'A! '9! '"! 'D! or Gno gradedH
Cha$ter >*.
-is) of all-cause mortality associated &ith com%inations of %aseline serum $hos$horus and calcium categories %y PT/ level !from DOPP8"
%hos%hor)s, e/ery A-;= &onths8 and for P0H, 9ased on 9ase ine e/e and C-D %ro#ression.
D :n C-D sta#e ?< for ser)& ca ci)& and %hos%hor)s, e/ery >-A &onths8 and for P0H, e/ery A-;= &onths. D :n C-D sta#es @, inc )din# @D< for ser)& ca ci)& and %hos%hor)s, e/ery ;-> &onths8 and for P0H, e/ery >-A &onths.
assess&ents
(;C).
Cha$ter >*6
Prevalance of ty$es of %one disease as determined %y %one %io$sy in $atients &ith CKD-M D
Cha$ter >*>
Cha$ter 4*.
0reat&ent of C-D-MBD 0ar#eted at .o*erin# Hi#h Ser)& Phos%hor)s and Maintainin# Ser)& Ca ci)&
Cha$ter 4*6
0reat&ent of A9nor&a P0H .e/e s in C-D-MBD
:t is reasona9 e to correct these a9nor&a ities *ith any or a of the fo o*in#< red)cin# dietary %hos%hate inta!e and ad&inisterin# %hos%hate 9inders, ca ci)& s)%% e&ents, andGor nati/e /ita&in D (not #raded).
4e s)##est that &ar!ed chan#es in P0H e/e s in either direction *ithin this ran#e %ro&%t an initiation or chan#e in thera%y to a/oid %ro#ression to e/e s o)tside of this ran#e (=C).
?.=.?. (Contin)ed)
,e recommend that, in $atients &ith hy$ercalcemia, calcitriol or another vitamin D sterol %e reduced or sto$$ed %'B&* ,e suggest that, in $atients &ith hy$er$hos$hatemia, calcitriol or another vitamin D sterol %e reduced or sto$$ed %(D&* ,e suggest that, in $atients &ith hy$ocalcemia, calcimimetics %e reduced or sto$$ed de$ending on severity, concomitant medications, and clinical signs and sym$toms %(D&*
Cha$ter 4*>
0reat&ent of Bone *ith Bis%hos%honates, other 2steo%orosis Medications, and Gro*th Hor&one
Cha$ter 5
'/a )ation and 0reat&ent of -idney 0rans% ant Bone Disease
:n C-D %atients recei/in# treat&ents for C-DE MBD, or in *ho& 9ioche&ica a9nor&a ities are identified, it is reasona9 e to increase the freB)ency of &eas)re&ents to &onitor for efficacy and side-effects (not #raded). :t is reasona9 e to &ana#e these a9nor&a ities as for %atients *ith C-D sta#es >E@ (not #raded) (see Cha%ters ?.; and ?.=).
-esearch -ecommendations
De/e o% a ris!-stratification too 9ased on C-DMBD co&%onents and e/a )ate its %redicti/e acc)racy for c inica o)tco&es in %atients *ith C-D sta#es >-@, @D, and >-@0. Deter&ine if, in %atients *ith C-D-MBD, a sin# e &eas)re&ent of BMD (&eas)red 9y DFA or BC0) and seria chan#es in BMD %redict fract)res. Deter&ine if the %resence or a9sence of /asc) arG/a /) ar ca cification in %atients *ith C-DMBD is an a%%ro%riate stratification and se ection too to identify indi/id)a s *ho &ay 9enefit fro& s%ecific inter/entions.
-esearch -ecommendations
Deter&ine if the effect of an intensi/e C-D-MBD treat&ent a%%roach (e.#., %rotoco -dri/en co&9ination thera%y to achie/e s%ecific ser)& %hos%hor)s and P0H tar#ets) /s. a ess intensi/e treat&ent a%%roach (e.#., %rotoco -dri/en co&9ination thera%y a o*in# hi#her ser)& %hos%hor)s and P0H tar#ets) /s. standard care i&%ro/es c inica o)tco&es in %atients *ith C-D sta#es >@D. Deter&ine if treatin# do*n to nor&a ser)& %hos%hor)s e/e s (as co&%ared to %hos%hor)s e/e s of @.@-A.@ &#Gd.) *ith the )se of co&9inations of different %hos%hate 9inders and other a%%roaches i&%ro/es c inica o)tco&es in %atients *ith C-D sta#es ?-@D and ?-@0.
-esearch -ecommendations
Deter&ine if treat&ent to a o*er /s. a hi#her ser)& P0H tar#et i&%ro/es or *orsens c inica o)tco&es in %atients *ith C-D sta#es >-@, C-D sta#e @D, and C-D sta#es >-@0. Deter&ine if treat&ent *ith /ita&in D (er#oca cifero or cho eca cifero ) or ca cidio K=@(2H)DL, co&%ared to ca citrio or /ita&in D ana o#s, i&%ro/es c inica o)tco&es in %atients *ith C-D sta#es >-@, C-D sta#e @D, and C-D sta#es ;-@0. Deter&ine *hich %hos%hate 9inders and other ser)& %hos%hor)sE o*erin# treat&ents are a9 e to i&%ro/e s)r/i/a in %atients *ith C-D sta#es >-@D and C-D sta#es >-@0.
-esearch -ecommendations
Deter&ine if treat&ent *ith 9is%hos%honates, teri%aratide, or ra oCifene red)ces fract)res or /asc) ar ca cification in %atients *ith C-D sta#es >-@D and C-D sta#es ;-@0. Deter&ine if strate#ies to re/erse adyna&ic 9one disease 9y &eas)res s)ch as endo#eno)s sti&) ation of P0H secretion (e.#., )sin# o*ca ci)& dia ysate) or eCo#eno)s teri%aratide ad&inistration i&%act c inica o)tco&es in %atients *ith C-D sta#es ?-@D or C-D sta#es ;-@0, co&%ared to % ace9o.
M)estions