Dynamic seals
Shock absorbers from FOX
Cushioned
Greater comfort
for motorboats
Brewed
Exclusive solutions
for the perfect aroma
Sealed
The squareness
of a circle: PRW1
Trialled
Simmerrings
put to the test
Freudenberg Group
www.simrit.com
Editorial
As you were able to gather from the previous editions of Simrit insight, in many industrial markets today
Simrit is a development partner much sought by you, our customers. Your wishes and requirements re-
garding products and materials are very different from industry to industry and are becoming increasing-
ly more specific. In order to be available in the future to customers of other industries as a competent de-
velopment partner without losing the focus in our core markets, we have established three new sales
areas this year that are thus specially oriented to the specific customer wishes and requirements of energy
Dr. Jan Gupta,
technology, aerospace and medical technology.
Simrit Europe
In the last half-year, Simrit was confronted with heavy cost rises by our raw material and energy suppli-
ers. We were able to absorb an essential part of these costs by increasing our productivity and relocat-
ing manufacture where it was correct to do so. However we couldn’t avoid a price increase for you, our
customer. Unfortunately, on the basis of discussions currently taking place, we don’t see any easing up
for the coming year in the cost prices for oil, carbon black or energy. This is one of the drawbacks of glo-
balisation sought by everyone or of the growth of markets such as China and India and the associated
scarcity of resources. Today, it is still too early to conclusively assess the development for 2009. Nonethe-
less, let us jointly try to find alternative solutions on time (e.g., new materials) for your applications, in or-
der to counteract the raw materials price development. Use and actively call on the competences of Sim-
rit as concerns materials development, CO2 reduction and design knowledge by means of new,
innovative approaches to solutions in order to reduce the divide between raw materials price increases
and market prices. You can find some successful examples in this edition of Simrit insight.
With this current edition, I hope that we can present to you an interesting mix of projects, products and
materials from a wide variety of industries in which Simrit is active as a sealing specialist. At the same
time, it is especially important to us that the mirror is held up to us by you again and again and that we
get feedback regarding improvements to our magazine. For that reason, in this edition we are starting a
reader survey. We would be happy to receive feedback from you.
Thank you for the trust in Simrit that you have shown for years.
In addition, I wish you and your company a successful 2008.
Imprint
Simrit® insight is the magazine for Simrit customers. Publisher: Freudenberg Simrit GmbH & Co KG, 69465 Weinheim, Germany Responsible: Michael Littig Phone: +49 (0) 6201-805433
E-mail: michael.littig@simrit.de. Project Management: Waldemar Panek E-mail: waldemar.panek@simrit.de Co-operation: Katharina Bergman, Dr. Rolf-Wyland Heldt, Vera Böhner, Steve Bar-
rot, Philipp Frey, Mechthild Mohr, Matthias Arnold and Dr. Meike Rinnbauer Internet: www.simrit.com Editorial & design: Frank Trurnit & Partner Verlag GmbH. Reprinting or reproduction only
with the permission of the publisher. Pictures: Simrit; Honeywell (Page 5), Fox Racing Shox (Page 6/7), Hansgrohe AG (Page 9/right), Volvo Penta (Page 10/11), Thermoplan (Page12/13).
Contents
News 04|05
TechDay
at Honeywell
Application 08|09
Wellbeing with 2-
component technology
Application 10|11
The means for
`good vibrations´
Application 12|13
From customer
relations to aroma
Product 14
Haldex announces
`Supplier of the Year´
Haldex Brakes, manufacturers of optimally and, as a technology
pneumatic disc brakes and brake leader, continue to be Haldex’s
Give us your opinion components for heavy-duty utility preferred partner in developing
vehicles, have awarded Simrit new products.
Quality and customer relations are core with the title of ‘Supplier of the
principles of Simrit. Whoever wants to Year’. Haldex purchase custom-
maintain quality must continually put it to developed sealing components
the test. We want to know how we can from Simrit. The products are
tailor our customer magazine ‘Simrit in- manufactured at Simrit’s Kufstein
sight’ even better to your wishes and location, where expertise in this
needs. In this issue you will find a questi- application area has been built
onnaire which we kindly ask you to fill in up. The award from Haldex rec-
and fax back to us. Simrit will select a ognises the first-class product
winner of the prize, a mountainbike from quality of zero ppm and on-time
Corratec – model Xvert with FOX suspen- delivery rate of 99 per cent. In
sion fork – from the first 200 questi- parallel to this, the price-to-per-
onnaires received. We want to ensure formance ratio was improved for
Jonas Hansson of Simrit with the
that Simrit insight continues to be not only the customer. Overall Simrit ful- ranking list of seal suppliers for
long on words, but also long on topics. filled the four criteria of quality, Haldex. Simrit are clearly number 1
deliverability, value and service in this ranking.
TechDay at Honeywell
More than 20 specialists from the fields of development/de-
sign, purchasing and testing were interested listeners during
the Simrit TechDay at the home automation specialist, Hon-
eywell. Florian Türck from O-ring Materials Development
and Mike Neubacher from Diaphragm Product Development
demonstrated the potentials of their two product groups for
the heating and sanitary areas. “For a long time now, it has
not been enough to just put a seal in a valve. Instead, it’s im-
portant that special regulations for the use of drinking water
be observed and additional functions such as reduced fric-
tion be offered,” say Purchaser Horst Högenauer and Uwe
Pfeiffer, Development Director at Honeywell. In addition, in-
telligent solutions such as 2-component technology and nan-
otechnology should provide for optimised workflows and re-
duced costs for the customer. Talks on the two topics just
mentioned were therefore a particular wish of Honeywell.
Thus it was not surprising that the talk by Dr. Rolf Heldt on
the topic of 2-component technology and the presentation
by Dr. Birger Lange on the topic of nanotechnology, divided
into the areas of friction reduction and disinfection, were
found to be especially interesting.
Making tools … not toys … FOX de- knowledge is what separates it from and made 35 design changes to en-
signs, tests and manufactures high- every other suspension company. hance quality and increase efficiency.
performance, engineering-driven shock Employing approximately 500 employ- FOX’s suspension is an integral part of
absorbers that have equipped vehicles ees, who are never satisfied with “good most extreme sports vehicles, as the
and racers in every extreme sport. Its enough,” the company has a dedicated ability of shock absorbers to take in
team of engineers performs rigorous Continuous Improvement Team that con- energy allows for a smoother, more
tests with racers year round, collecting stantly strategizes to gain manufactur- controlled ride. This increased control
data about performance and product ing efficiency. In 2007 alone, FOX im- improves rider comfort and perform-
robustness. FOX’s application of this proved 91 manufacturing processes ance, which, in turn, allows riders to
push their abilities to the limits. As a re- caused by dirt mixing with the oil inside
sult, FOX-equipped vehicles and racers the shock absorber. At the time, boots
have stood atop podiums in every sport were placed over the shock absorber to
its vehicles compete in – from the sands reduce contamination. While this did
of Baja to the dunes of Dakar. offer some protection, time still had to
be spent removing the dirt from the oil.
Keepin´ the Dirt Out To prevent contamination in the new
In 2000, FOX was planning to enter the FOX shock, Simrit created a customised
front suspension mountain bike fork internal sealing concept for FOX, called
market. Committed to superior perform- the “Samurai Seal.” This unique seal
ance, the company wanted to enter the was created using special materials
market with a quality, robust product and design techniques that meet the
that addressed design challenges and sealing requirements for all of FOX’s ap-
FOX supply
ensured rider comfort and control. plications. The dual-function exclusion shock absorbers
One of the challenges in shock absorb- and pressure seal works to keep out for all kinds of
er design is contamination, which is contamination, while containing the racing machines.
For many people today wellbeing starts Hard, yet soft to form a single work piece as an end
in the bathroom. With headquarters in The respective ring setting defines product. In the case of the adjustment
the small city of Schiltach in Germany’s where the water should flow and where ring in the shower head the (grey) ther-
Black Forest, the global sanitary tech- it shouldn’t flow, hence where it should moplastic material is the support materi-
nology firm Hansgrohe AG supplies in- be ‘sealed’ in the truest sense of the al and the (transparent green) liquid sili-
novative design solutions with its high- word. Depending on the number of pos- cone is the soft part.
tech taps and showers for individua- sible settings, five or even more seals
alised bathroom atmospheres. must be positioned in the shower head. Joint learning process
This wellbeing starts with the shower This is where Simrit come in with their The joint learning by the engineers and
head, with the so-called adjustment ring materials expertise. The cooperation be- technicians at Hansgrohe and the mate-
being an important comfort element. tween Hansgrohe and Simrit began rials and process technology specialists
This ring is attached as a rotating ele- nearly 15 years ago. Initially the seals at Simrit which lasted nearly 15 years is
ment around the spray nozzle. Turning were manually positioned in the adjust- still far from being over, despite what
the ring produces various sprays: nor- ment ring and it was primarily the liquid has been achieved up to the present. At
mal, soft or pulsating massage sprays. silicone expertise from Simrit that was first single-cavity moulds were used,
Many other spray variants are also called for. Today much more than that is only to give way after a short time to
possible. involved: the expertise in materials and multi-cavity moulds for pure silicone
process technologies possessed by Sim- parts. Today we have reached the stage
rit for so-called two-component compos- of using self-adhering liquid silicone for
ite parts provides a key contribution to complex two-component composite
the competitiveness of Hansgrohe in the parts. The spray insert was placed in
world market for sanitary technology. the shower head manually many years
The two-component technology holds ago, but in the next step of improve-
great potential for economisation as it ment of the production process this op-
combines numerous individual steps in eration was automated. A short while
design, development and production. later all silicone parts could be formed
With this technology two components, simultaneously in one and the same in-
usually one hard material such as a jection moulding process. For this the
thermoplastic material and one soft ma- overall part had to be 2-component-ca-
Planning and monitoring play key roles in the terial such as liquid silicone, are proc- pable; i.e. after injection of the liquid
cooperation between Hansgrohe and Simrit. essed in an injection moulding process silicone all seals had to be filled in suc-
In brief
+ Simrit have been
concentrating on
the versatile mate-
● Two-component technology ● Simrit’s materials expertise facilitates meet- rial liquid silicone
places high demands on mate- ing of approval criteria in the rubber (LSR) for
rial and process technologies sanitary area over twenty
years.
● Joint learning by technology
partners Hansgrohe and Simrit Do you have any questions or
suggestions? Your contact is
● Low-cost manufacture through
rolf.heldt@freudenberg-ds.com
simplified assembly
cession. The redesign, however, could complicated seal assembly process is puter. Through the use of FEM and
not negatively affect the function or the eliminated. Seals cannot be lost or in- mould flow analyses such as are stand-
parts to be installed later. A filling simu- correctly installed. The number of parts ard at Simrit, the probability that after
lation enabled an initial (positive) as- used is greatly reduced. All this trans- moulds are made functional parts can
sessment to be made, confirming that lates into faster production and consid- be produced with them is greater.
the part could actually be manufactured erably lower costs. Not least important are the special ap-
in the planned manner. The complex manufacturing process for proval requirements applicable in the
products made from hard and soft com- sanitary industry for the materials used.
Simulation and analysis posite parts in one piece necessitate the Certain approval criteria must be met
on the computer use of state-of-the-art computing technol- both for thermoplastic and for elastomer
The advantages of using two-compo- ogy; i.e. the behaviour of the planned materials. Simrit are ideal partners for
nent composite parts are obvious. The part must first be simulated on the com- solving these problems as well.
Modern recreational skippers want both power engines generate stronger vibra- board. With software simulations the
performance and comfort. The boat tions, one must develop better and more vibrations, smoothness of running and
should have a strong acceleration and novel mounts to dampen these vibra- maximum deformation can be mod-
a brisk cruising speed, but at the same tions sufficiently and keep the boat run- elled precisely in a quasi-dry run. The
time it should run smoothly. This repre- ning smoothly even when driven to the results of the simulations formed the ba-
sents a typical conflict of objectives. extreme. sis for discussions regarding further op-
Among the world’s leading manufactur- timisation. The vision of a calm skipper
ers of ship engines, Volvo Penta are fa- Extensive simulations hand and a simultaneously high accel-
miliar with these requirements and take To find an optimum solution for these eration of the Volvo Penta engines
the high demands of their customers se- conflicting goals Volvo Penta got the vi- slowly became technical reality. After a
riously. Because, for starters, higher- bration specialists from Simrit on few simulation runs the way in which
A catalogue product
served as the basis for
the customised solution.
+ In brief
Automatic coffee machines for commer- and special standardised coffee shops company cars with ‘CH’ on the licence
cial use are complex machines with so- such as Starbucks. The coffee machine plates. Just like their competitors, the en-
phisticated mechanics and electronics. specialists Thermoplan grew with Star- gineers and technicians from Weggis
They are designed for global hotel em- bucks. Each of the 13,500 Starbucks only build a few parts themselves. They
pires such as Hilton, fast-food chains outlets currently in operation has at least are responsible for the overall conceptu-
one automatic coffee machine from the alisation of the automatic coffee ma-
company headquartered in the central chine, but there are specialised suppli-
Swiss town of Weggis, and this cooper- ers for the individual parts.
ation with Starbucks has just been ex-
tended. A new generation of machines Food-grade materials
called ‘Mastrena’ was developed for the Simrit is the main parts supplier in the
coffee shop chain. Of course, Thermop- area of seals for Thermoplan. We are
Special valve
lan are not without competitors in this lu- currently in the planning phase in terms
with a magnet
inside which crative high-tech market. The Swiss do of the cooperation for the ‘Mastrena’
acts as position not have to go far to find them as nearly machine project mentioned above. In
sensor. all other market participants also drive the predecessor ‘Tiger’ project we have
been delivering critical seal parts that The sealing components in (com-
mercial) coffee machines must all
nearly all had to be composed of materi- be approved for use with food.
als that were FDA- and NSF-approved, Simrit score points with Thermo-
i.e. approved for the food industry, for plan through their great variety
several years. Most seal parts that Simrit of materials.
developed for Thermoplan’s Tiger project
are customer-specific. The Thermoblock
seal is a good example. The element us getting the go-ahead from Thermop-
must safely seal the entire pouring spout. lan,’ says Steve Barrot, engineer at Sim-
Dead space is not permitted and the as- rit and technical consultant for the Ther-
sembly must likewise be simple. Simrit moplan project. Design of the gear
use the material 70 EPDM 281 because keeps the vibrations as low as possible
the sealing component comes in contact and simultaneously ensures that the
with steam and cleaning agents for the ‘grain size’ of the ground product re-
machine as well as with milk. The use of mains constant. Except for some
conventional vulcanisation processes of- O-rings, all elements that Simrit supply
ten fails to meet the food standards (pri- for the automatic coffee machines from
marily defined in the US through the FDA Thermoplan are custom-made. The
regulations). Thus the component, which range extends from simple seals for a that the vulcanisation temperature is as
seals the support element for the coffee non-return valve and a slide ring seal for low as possible because otherwise the
pods and is made from silicone, must be installation without dead space all the magnetisation is eliminated. ‘The mag-
vulcanised on the metal grid, but for rea- way to a high-performance poly- net must be handled very carefully in as-
sons of FDA conformance only have a urethane machine leg and a complicat- sembly as well,’ explains Steve Barrot.
mechanical, not a chemical, bond. ed valve with an integrated magnet and With this sealing component, as with the
fulfilling special requirements. seal for the coffee pod holder, no chemi-
Customised parts The machine leg was designed in poly- cal bonding is allowed. The material
Commercial automatic coffee machines urethane because a leg made from the EPDM 281 is used for this sealing com-
such as the Tiger model naturally have elastomer NBR, as is otherwise usual, ponent.
integrated electric coffee mills. For this often leaves ugly marks on the support
Simrit designed a decoupled gear for surface when the machine is moved. The sealing components in (commercial)
the mill drive. ‘Our parts resist the hot coffee machines must all be approved
and humid environment arising in the Doing without chemical bonding for use with food. Simrit score points
machine during brewing of the coffee When valves are sealed using magnets with Thermoplan through their great
particularly well and this contributed to it must be ensured during manufacture variety of material.
In brief
+
● Thermoplan develop commercial with their wide range of materials as
coffee machines for large coffee many seals come in contact with both
shop and restaurant chains. One of steam and cleaning agents.
their major customers is Starbucks.
If users of hydraulic components have to cisely coordinated product programme from Simrit will be demonstrated in the
redesign the installation spaces for the for sealing components and guides for following. The application diversity re-
sealing system accordingly when they hydraulic cylinders. The choice of compo- sults from changing the material alone;
change the application field and the envi- nents is greatly facilitated and enables the sealing component dimensions re-
ronmental conditions, that takes up a lower-cost cylinder constructions (see Sim- main unchanged. In general such materi-
great deal of time and even more money. rit insight 1/2007). Using the example of al alternatives are available for many se-
Simrit show how this can be done more the PRW1 double wiper with integrated ries. For the PRW1 many non-standard
easily and economically. The solution is pressure relief function for the installation wipers and hence expensive reconstruc-
standardisation of the installation spaces space DIN-ISO 6195 type A, the varia- tion efforts are unnecessary because the
in accordance with DIN-ISO and a pre- bility of the standardised product range installation space can be retained.
The exceptional nature of the produc- make maintaining the required, very placement of the inserts with a position-
tion process – in particular, the preci- tight dimensional tolerances more diffi- al accuracy of a few hundredths of
sion cutting process – allows sealing cult, both upon removal from the tool a millimeter within the profile cross
lips with chamfer angles of less than and also during the later precision cut- section.
30° and without radii on the tips of the ting of the sealing lips. For that reason, Precision profiles made of PU are also
lips. Such sealing lips are required, for with sealing profiles micro-cables, usual- used in machine tools. Here, they have
example, on sealing profiles for rodless ly made of steel wire, are also always to protect, among other things, sensitive
pneumatic cylinders, where they are embedded in the PU with the aid of a linear measurement systems, high-grade
used for sealing (compressed air 6 to 8 bonding system. The bonding strength slideway guides and precise spindle
bar) of the longitudinal slit in the bore. obtained reliably prevents unwanted ax- drives against penetration of metal
This use also makes the highest de- ial creeping in the cylinder with later shavings or grinding dust. Due to the
mands regarding dimensional toleranc- use or springing of the sealing profiles, special hydrolysis-resistant Simrit materi-
es and surface quality. The precision over the entire service life, in fact. The als the profiles offer long term resist-
also ensures that the pressure in the cyl- design process used at Simrit allows ance to cooling lubricants.
inder barrel does not drop over a long-
er period of time. Leakage along the slit
In brief
– especially at the tips of the lips, where
the sealing profile has to simultaneously
act in combination with the aluminium ● PU precision profiles meet the ● The profiles are
+
highest expectations regard- used in automation
profile and the piston seals – is reliably
ing dimensional tolerances and materials handling
prevented. At the same time, the sealing and surface quality. technology as well as in the
profiles in the area of the slit take over area of machine tools and
● The materials offer long term
the function of the counter-surface for in other areas of mechanical
resistance to cooling lubricants.
the PU piston seals. Today, this system is engineering.
Optimum friction
partnership
An ideal interplay between elastomer seal,
mating surface and lubricant reduces wear.
Through this the costs of service and mainte-
nance are also reduced and the lifetime ex-
tended. Simrit hence always design their seal-
ing elements with these overall
interdependencies in mind.
are thereby flattened (erosion or wear). only to a moderate increase in the lubri-
Depending on the composition, the cant temperature, the generated heat
elastomer contains more or less abra- must be suitably dissipated. Depending
sive fillers which result in wear of the on the lubricant film thickness, the coef-
mating surface (e.g. contact surface of ficients of friction can increase with in-
a moving seal). With unfavourable ma- creasing speed.
terial pairs and a high surface pressure,
the surfaces adhere to each other (ad- Interactions between the elastomer
hesion) and mechanical interlocking re- and the lubricant
sults, thereby increasing wear. Dry fric- The basis for the chemical and thermal
tion occurs, for example, if no lubricant stability of elastomers is the selection of
is used or if the lubricant fails. Mixed a suitable base polymer. Due to rising
friction can occur in the case of insuffi- operating temperatures and greater life-
cient lubrication or at the start of motion time requirements, synthetic lubricants
of lubricated friction pairs. In this case, with higher additive contents are increas-
the sliding surfaces contact each other ingly being used. This can result in chem-
only at specific points. The frictional ical reactions between the elastomer and
force is lower for both mixed friction the lubricant or operating media, lead-
and fluid friction than for dry friction. ing to surface decomposition or changes
Wear, however, is higher than for pure in the properties of the material, among
fluid friction. This condition is avoided other things. The consequence of this for
wherever possible in continuous opera- dynamic seals can be dry wear of the
tion, although occasionally without suc- elastomer at the sealing edge, leading to
cess. If static and sliding friction alter- insufficient lubrication. The resultant in-
nate periodically, a so-called stick-slip crease in friction causes the temperature
effect is occurring. This transition is un- at the sealing edge to increase. This can
desirable and is sometimes accompa- lead to damage of the elastomer net-
nied by noise, e.g. squeaking. Depend- work and hence to a reduction in life-
ing on the temperature and speed, time. Simrit have a multitude of different
elastomers have a greater or lesser ten- friction and wear test benches available
dency towards stick-slip. for simulating translational and rotation-
Fluid friction occurs when a continuous al motions. Effects occurring in this con-
lubricant film forms between the sliding nection, including the ‘stick-slip’ effect,
The phrase ‘smooth running’ is used if surfaces. Typical lubricants are oils and run-in behaviour, adhesion effects and
the complete contact surface has bro- water, but also gases. The sliding sur- friction behaviour, can be modelled over
ken free. This run-in process is charac- faces are completely separated from a wide range of temperatures and
terised by a lower coefficient of friction one another. The friction which arises is speeds. This allows for precise materials
than the starting value. caused by the fact that the lubricant characterisation as well as determination
With dry friction, the sliding surfaces molecules slide past each other. In or- of the interactions between the seal and
contact each other. Surface protrusions der for the arising shear forces to lead the lubricant.
FR V FR V FR V
Fluid h
Adhesive layer Fluid
Adhesive Layer
Metal Metal Metal
Schematic illustration of friction: the friction “Mixed” friction involves point contact of the Fluid friction occurs when a continuous lubri-
force is the greatest in dry or static friction. sliding surfaces. This can occur, e.g., if lubrica- cant film forms between the sliding surfaces.
tion is insufficient.
Lubricants have to be adapted precisely to gear wheels and bearings as well as to Simmerrings and other
sealing components. Otherwise failure is predestined. Practically all lubricant and oil manufacturers can
test their lubricants on Simrit’s test benches.
In the selection of a suitable material part, conflicting requirements with a means of changes in hardness, vol-
for a Simmerring, apart from the tem- lubricant formula. In view of the high ume, tensile strength and elongation at
perature range in which the sealing costs of such a development the possi- fracture before and after immersion,
component should be used, the liquid bility of incompatibility between seal the seal manufacturer can make use of
or gas-forming media the material will and lubricant only being discovered at its lengthy experience to draw conclu-
come into contact with must always be the end must be avoided. Tests accom- sions about expected interactions or
considered. These media affect the panying development are hence indis- material suitability. Exceeding the fol-
swelling behaviour or shrinkage and pensable. lowing limits often signals detrimental
the chemical stability of an elastomer interactions:
and thereby the performance capabili- Defined limits for interactions Change in hardness from +/– 5 Shore
ties of a sealing component. Lubricant An initial indication of the compatibili- A change in volume from –2% to +5%
manufacturers face special challenges ty of an elastomer with a lubricant is Maximum change in tensile strength of
in the development of new lubricants. gained through a static immersion test –50% Maximum change in elongation
They must meet a large number of, in in accordance with DIN 51517. By at fracture of –60%.
Whether in a cold
chamber (left) or other
endurance tests, Sim-
merrings must with-
stand a lot even before
they are ready for
mass production.
In brief
In the selection of the
material for a Simmer-
● The compatibility of lubricants with only be determined using additional ring the substances that
sealing components such as Simmer- dynamic tests. it comes into contact
rings must be tested. with are decisive.
● Practically all lubricant manufacturers
● Static immersion tests in accordance have their products tested for compat-
with DIN 51517 provide preliminary ibility with the sealing components in
indications of compatibility. Simrit’s testing laboratories prior to
market introduction.
● The compatibility of modern gear
and engine oils with Simmerrings
Do you have any questions or
and other sealing components can
suggestions? Your contact is
matthias.arnold@freudenberg-ds.com.
A greener performance
“Stihl products are often used in the natural
environment. Our new, environmentally compatible
components allow ecological use with optimum
performance. Simrit has contributed significantly to
this success with innovative seal design and unique
test options. Thereby reliably ensuring our technology
as well as our environmental commitment.”
1. How do you evaluate the magazine simrit insight? 5. How thoroughly do you read simrit insight?
very positively – very negatively Completely ➀
a) Overall impression ➀ ➁ ➂ ➃ ➄ Partially ➁
b) Selection of topics ➀ ➁ ➂ ➃ ➄ Only glance through ➂
c) Practical relevance ➀ ➁ ➂ ➃ ➄ Read only headings ➃
d) Current relevance ➀ ➁ ➂ ➃ ➄ Don’t read at all, but keep ➄
e) Intelligibility ➀ ➁ ➂ ➃ ➄ Put it away immediately ➅
f) Length of articles ➀ ➁ ➂ ➃ ➄
g) Ratio image/text ➀ ➁ ➂ ➃ ➄ 6.a Which sources of information do you use to inform yourself about
h) Graphic design/ ➀ ➁ ➂ ➃ ➄ Simrit (Internet, brochures, catalogues, etc.)?
selection of images